Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bad Therapists (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. As some of you long time listeners will know,
- 0:04one of my favorite things to do on this podcast is to read these case
- 0:09studies about therapists who broke ethical codes and were punished because of that. In
- 0:16these case studies, therapists will do all sorts of bad things and then they
- 0:20get punished. And why would I want to read about that. I mean,
- 0:24I'm a therapist. Wouldn't it make me afraid? Why do I enjoy
- 0:27this so much? Well? I think I like to read these case studies
- 0:31because, on one hand, it helps me to feel less anxious, because
- 0:36when you read about the behaviors in these case studies, you realize that in
- 0:40order to be punished in this profession, you really have to do something pretty
- 0:43obviously wrong. And a lot of therapists, and I know this to be
- 0:48true because it particularly around students and novice therapists, they're all terrified of breaking
- 0:54ethical codes and laws. One of the most common symptoms after taking ethics classes.
- 1:00All the students are just terrified of being a therapist because they're just like,
- 1:04there's so many rules and I don't really understand, and you're telling me
- 1:07that to be a therapist, I could I could get punished and do something
- 1:11wrong. And what I always tell them is, well, let's actually look
- 1:15at the cases where people actually get punished, because the things that they're doing
- 1:19are pretty obvious. And so I think, on one hand, when I
- 1:23read these cases, it's like, oh, to be punished at this job,
- 1:26you really have to go off the rails. And it relieves my anxiety
- 1:32to read about these cases. Another reason why I like to read these cases
- 1:36is because it's a good justice story. It's sort of like forensic files.
- 1:41I guess that's what it is. These cases are sort of like the forensic
- 1:44files of my profession. All right, let's get into it. So this
- 1:48first case is of a sexual relationship with a client, and I want to
- 1:52tell people out there that there could be some triggers in here if you've been
- 1:56traumatized in this way. So you want to be real careful about this first
- 1:59case I talk about. Okay, So in this first and by the way,
- 2:02all these case studies are from my malpractice insurance, which is CNA or
- 2:08HBSO, and they send out these briefs, these case studies as a way
- 2:15of informing us, look, stay away from this behavior because this will happen
- 2:19to you, all right. So the clinician that was insured by my malpractice
- 2:23insurance was a substance abuse counselor in this case. And this man owned and
- 2:30was the executive director of a private counseling practice. So this is an owner
- 2:35and the executive director of a counseling practice, maybe a little agency, probably
- 2:39a little substance abuse counseling agency, and he was a substance abuse counselor.
- 2:46The client was a forty year old female and recently convicted of several criminal offenses,
- 2:52including drug possession, and she was on probation in order to participate in
- 2:57substance abuse treatment. So again for your all, female, recently convicted,
- 3:01probation ordered to participate in substitbuse treatment. Okay. So when treatment began,
- 3:07the insured counselor, the drug counselor, was assigned to evaluate and treat the
- 3:13client and the weekly fee, and the weekly fee was fifty dollars. After
- 3:16about two months of treatment, the client told the counselor that she was unable
- 3:21to afford the fee. The counselor essentially intimated that she would have to have
- 3:25sex with him to pay for the services. So let's just pause here for
- 3:31a second and really imagine the psychopathy involved in this. This is a counselor
- 3:38someone who supposedly is in it to help people, to get people back on
- 3:44their feet, to help people recover, and charge money for it. A
- 3:51woman is down on her luck. She's been convicted, she's ordered to go
- 3:54to substance abuse treatment. She's presumably trying to get clean, and after two
- 4:00months of treatment, she's like, you know, I can't I can't afford
- 4:02this, and he says, well, I guess you're just gonna have sex.
- 4:06You're just gonna have to have sex with me in order to pay.
- 4:10Now. I don't know. They didn't go into detail, but it's there's
- 4:12a pretty good likelihood that the woman was thinking, well, if I don't
- 4:16have sex with him, that I won't get treatment, and if I don't
- 4:19get treatment, I'm in violation of my probation and I might have to go
- 4:25back to detention. I don't know if that's the case, but it seems
- 4:28like it's possible. So they began having sex at the office at the end
- 4:32of every session. So just imagine this one. The woman shows up for
- 4:35therapy and or for canceling drug and alcohol counseling, and they do their regular
- 4:43session and at the end of the session, they have sex every single time
- 4:46as payment for the service. And then that relationship evolved into a full blown
- 4:55sexual relationship that was not connected to the drug and alcoholic and this went on
- 5:00for several months. After several months, the client reported the counselor's conduct to
- 5:05a case manager at the probation office and the Department of Corrections filed a complaint
- 5:12on behalf of her with the state and an investigation happened. They pulled the
- 5:16records. They also pulled all of the counselor's phone records, and here's what
- 5:23they decided to do. They permanently revoked the counselor's license in the interest of
- 5:28protecting the public. So they permanently took away his license, meaning that he
- 5:32could never get his license back. And this is one of the most severe
- 5:35things that a department, a state department, will do. And they also
- 5:41found in this case that the costs associated with defending him exceeded the policy limits.
- 5:46So all insurance policies have a limit to how much they will pay out
- 5:53to defend you. And this malpractice, so malpractice does two things. People
- 5:58usually associate malpractice with a settlement, you know, like a surgeon makes a
- 6:03mistake and then the family sues the surgeon for five million dollars or something.
- 6:09So there are two costs associated with that. One is the five million dollars
- 6:13if they're found liable, and the other cost is for all the lawyers,
- 6:16because most people don't have one hundred thousand dollars or more laying around to pay
- 6:20for all the lawyer's costs. And so usually these malpractice suits will or the
- 6:25malpractice insurance will cover the lawyer's costs a percentage or in some sort of policy
- 6:31around that, and also the settlement cost. And so the costs associated with
- 6:36just defending the counselor exceeded the policy limits. And so what this means is
- 6:41that the councilor probably had to pay out a pocket to pay for the extra
- 6:45fees associated with defending himself. And so, yeah, he has a permanent
- 6:49revocation of his license now for me, And that was all they did to
- 6:55him For me, though, I think he should have been criminally charged.
- 6:59To do something like this should be a crime. In some states it is
- 7:03a crime. I don't know if for drug and alcohol counselors. But and
- 7:06I'm not a super expert on this, so I shouldn't speak out of my
- 7:10butt. But the point is, I think this person should be locked up
- 7:13based on the information that I have before me. Maybe there's some circumstances,
- 7:16but come on, to have sex with the client one, that's not okay.
- 7:20To coerce a client because they're in a position where they can't pay for
- 7:27services. That's just I mean, how is that not a crime? It's
- 7:31just blackmail? I don't know anyway. So in this brief, in this
- 7:39case provided by my malpractice insurance, they talk about different percentages. So what
- 7:46they find here is that thirty two percent of all professional liability claims, according
- 7:50to them, involve allegations of sexual and romantic interactions or relationships with current clients,
- 7:57partners of clients, or family members of clients. So let's just pause
- 8:01and think about this for a second. So of all liability claims, meaning
- 8:05that when someone claims damage or malpractice of a ensured counselor of some kinds,
- 8:13so you have drug and alcohol counselors, marriage family therapist, licensed professional counselors,
- 8:18psychologists, this kind of thing of all the claims involves sexual misconduct of
- 8:24some sort, either having sex with clients or partners of clients or family members
- 8:31of clients. So again, when students in my university takes ethics class and
- 8:39they're paranoid about, like, you know, one of the things that interns
- 8:43novice therapists will be real paranoid about. It's like, what if a client
- 8:46gives me a gift? You know, what if my client gives me like
- 8:50a five dollars Starbucks card, what do I do? You know if I
- 8:54broken some kind of law. And I'm always like, well, maybe,
- 8:58but you're not going to get punished for it. I mean, just because
- 9:01in my profession we're not supposed to take essentially tips from clients, we're not
- 9:07supposed to take gifts. It sets up an expectation there that we just don't
- 9:11want to involve ourselves in. But in a pinch or in some special circumstances,
- 9:16accepting gifts is actually the ethical thing to do. For example, the
- 9:20example I always give is I was working with this family in home family therapy
- 9:24and they were rural Mexican immigrants and were in a pretty unsafe situation and they
- 9:35were having trouble with one of their kids, and I went into the home
- 9:39to help out, and I did a lot of helping them just understand how
- 9:43to navigate society in a lot of ways. And I spent a lot of
- 9:48time with the parents, just bonding with them. And then one day they
- 9:52said again, and the therapy was free to them because I was paid for
- 9:56by the government. And one day they brought me some tamales. And if
- 10:01you ever had tomalus like homemade tomala tomales, it's just like they're just so
- 10:07good. So they give me this, you know, aluminum foil wrapped a
- 10:13whole bunch. I think it was like a dozen or something warm tomali's.
- 10:16And I'm like, oh, because normally what I'll say is, oh,
- 10:20no, thank you. I don't because when I would do in home therapy,
- 10:22a lot of times people felt like they had to give me things.
- 10:24They'd be like, Oh, don't worry about me. I'm okay, I'm
- 10:26at work, it's fine, And they give me these tomalus, And in
- 10:31this split second, I'm thinking, Okay, normally i'd say no, but
- 10:35this family, the look in their eyes and what they're telling me is they
- 10:41appreciate me a lot, and they don't have anything to give me because they're
- 10:46so disenfranchised, they're so poor, they're so marginalized, and they just want
- 10:52to give me something. And they made me food, right, they didn't
- 10:58spend money on me, and I thought I could give the gift to them
- 11:03by accepting this gift, and so I accepted it and felt really, you
- 11:09know, really warmed my heart that they would do that. I mean,
- 11:11this is I don't know, twenty years ago. I still remember it.
- 11:15And I also ate the crap out of those Tomorrow's because there because they were
- 11:20good, and I told them, you know, and I said, you
- 11:26know, but they'll give me anymore because it's usually not a custom of therapy.
- 11:30But thank you so much, and I really have That's all I've been
- 11:33eating. At the time, twenty years ago, I didn't have a lot
- 11:37of money to spend on any kind of food, and so just having anything
- 11:41homemade and good was quite a treat for me. I mean, I can
- 11:48still see them in my mind's eye, twenty year old Tomorrow's. Anyway,
- 11:54so I'll have students that will be going to ethics class and they'll and they're
- 11:58told that they can't apt gifts, which is you know generally true, and
- 12:03they're paranoid about going to prison if they accept a five gift card from a
- 12:07client around Christmas time. And what I'll tell them is like, okay,
- 12:13let me give you put this in perspective. A third of all professional liability
- 12:18claims are when people have sex with their clients or a partner of a client,
- 12:22or a family member of a client. So accepting a five dollars gift
- 12:26card from your client is a far cry from having sex with your clients.
- 12:33So I think you're okay. Now, maybe there's a problem there, and
- 12:35let's talk about it. For sure. There's a way to communicate to people
- 12:39about not accepting gift cards and this sort of thing. But you know,
- 12:43the ethics police aren't going to lock you up anytime soon, okay. So
- 12:46let's go on to another case here. This is the second case. This
- 12:50is a case of bad boundaries. The insured clinician was a marriage family therapist
- 12:56from what I can tell, twenty five years of experience and working at an
- 13:00agency. So again, a marriage of family therapist like myself, twenty five
- 13:03years into the profession like myself, and working at an agency, which is
- 13:09not like myself. The therapist was treating two children for acting out because they
- 13:15started acting out and you know, having bad behaviors because their father had died.
- 13:20So the mother, the widow, brought the two children in because the
- 13:26father died and the children were acting out quote unquote. So the family comes
- 13:31in, the mother comes in with the kids and which and they didn't give
- 13:35the ages of the kids, but I'm guessing they're you know, pre teen,
- 13:39And as is customary, the intake forms were completed by the mother.
- 13:45So normally in therapy when you bring in children, the parents are the one
- 13:48consenting the treatment and they're the ones filling out all the forms. Okay,
- 13:54So and on those forms, the children were the only ones listed as clients.
- 13:58This is a portant for later, So the two children were identified as
- 14:03clients and the mother was not identified as a client. All right, So
- 14:09they do three years of therapy, and during these three years, the children
- 14:15were sent that the children were seen together by the therapist, sometimes they were
- 14:18seen separately by the therapist sometimes, and the mother was always present at these
- 14:24sessions. So again this is pretty normal too. And I'm guessing actually,
- 14:28if the mother was always present, the children are probably pretty young. I'm
- 14:31guessing the kids were like four and six or something like this, because if
- 14:37a kid's ten, usually the parent isn't always present, but if you're counseling
- 14:41a four year old, usually the parent is always present. Okay, so
- 14:48three years of therapy, sometimes both the kids are together, sometimes it's just
- 14:52one of the kids, but the mother is always there in the session with
- 14:56the therapist, and some meetings are with the other by herself. And from
- 15:03the records, it was clear that the therapist did not consider the mother to
- 15:07be a client. So let me pause here and maybe this would be helpful
- 15:11to clinicians out there, and hopefully you know all this stuff. But so,
- 15:16we have two types of people that we talk to professionally as clinicians.
- 15:20One our clients and two our collateral contacts. So what I always quiz my
- 15:26novice clinicians on is what is a client? What is the definition of a
- 15:30client, and what is the definition of a collateral contact. So collateral contact
- 15:35is someone that you talk to that will give you information about your client,
- 15:41or someone in connection with your client that you need to talk to facilitate treatment.
- 15:48And there's a variety of people you could talk to. The clients physician,
- 15:52or the client's psychiatrist, or the client's roommate. If there's a suicide
- 15:58contract, you need to do where you need to read each out to the
- 16:00roommate to make sure that the roommate is involved in the suicide prevention plan if
- 16:04the client wants your roommate to be involved. So, these are people connected
- 16:10to the client that you would talk to. And what I always quiz people
- 16:12on, particularly in situations like this where a mother brings in the kids,
- 16:17how do you determine if the mother is a client or a collateral contact.
- 16:21This is important to determine for a variety of ethical reasons, which we'll get
- 16:26into you later with this case, and I get a lot of blank stares.
- 16:30Now I don't get a lot of blank stares anymore because I quiz them
- 16:32periodically about this. But the answer is, clients are the people that you're
- 16:36treating. And there's a lot of different nuances legally and ethically to this,
- 16:40but generally speaking, at its core, clients are people that we treat.
- 16:45So let's look at another profession. Let's look at dentistry. Okay, So
- 16:51if my mom brings me in to the dentist and I'm the one who has
- 16:56the cavity, and the dentist proceeds to treat the cavity on my tooth,
- 17:03but my mom is always there. Is the mom a patient of the dentist.
- 17:07No, I am the patient and my mother is a collateral contact.
- 17:11My mother is connected to me, and the dentist might have to talk to
- 17:15my mother about like making sure I brush my teeth and that kind of thing.
- 17:18But I am definitely the patient and the mother is definitely not the patient.
- 17:23Also, let's say, in that same scenario, let's take it a
- 17:26little ridiculous where the dentistic notices, as my mother is smiling, that my
- 17:33mom also has a cavity on her front tooth. Does the dentist just push
- 17:41my mom into a chair and pull out her tooth. No, the dentist
- 17:44says, huh, I notice you might have something on your tooth. Do
- 17:48you want me to help you with that? And then my mother could say
- 17:53yes or no. And if my mother says no, then the dentist says,
- 17:57well, I recommend you have that looked at. But okay, So
- 18:00at that point the dentist was asking, do you want to be a patient
- 18:04of mine or not? I'm recommending that you allow me to investigate, but
- 18:08you have to consent to that first. It makes total sense, right,
- 18:12Dentists don't walk down the street, see cavities or signs of dental decay and
- 18:18just push people down and perform oral surgery on them in the middle of the
- 18:22street against their will. Well, therapists also, therapists do not provide therapy
- 18:29to people without their consent. We do not push people down and provide therapy
- 18:33to them. Okay, so when the mother comes in, we have to
- 18:38determine is that mother a clateral contact someone that I'm not treating, or is
- 18:45it someone that I'm treating, or is it someone that I think I should
- 18:48treat. And as a family therapist, I always try to work with the
- 18:52mothers in situations like this. I can do so much more good if I
- 18:57can help the mother, because the mother's going to be with the kid all
- 19:02the time and I'm only going to be with the kids an hour a week,
- 19:04and especially with young kids, it's really slow going with stuff like this.
- 19:11I can do stuff, for sure, but how accelerated would it be
- 19:15if I could also involve the mother not only in the sessions like this family
- 19:18was dealing with grief the father had died. Imagine if I had the kids
- 19:22and the mother sitting down playing a game and grieving in a four year old
- 19:27way, and the mother was there, and then the mother learns how to
- 19:30do that and can translate that into behaviors and help for the kids at home.
- 19:36And when I meet with the mother alone, which this therapist did,
- 19:38I could actually help the mother not only grieve the loss of her husband,
- 19:42but I could also help her and how to parent the kids as they go
- 19:45through this grief. But not every clinician operates that way. Some people don't
- 19:51want to work with the mother, They just want to work with the kids.
- 19:53I don't recommend that in most situations, but it's a judgment call,
- 19:57and there there you go. Now, sometimes mothers in this situation don't want
- 20:03to you know, I'll offer it up. This never happened to me,
- 20:07by the way, but you know, I understand that it could happen where
- 20:10I'd be like, So, I'm a family therapist, and i'd I'm glad
- 20:15you brought your kids in for me to evaluate and to help, and I
- 20:19really want to involve you in this treatment, and I really want to involve
- 20:22you in the overall evaluation and assessment and help, meaning that I want to
- 20:29help you help the kids, and in order to do that, you have
- 20:33to consent to being a client as well. Not only do you have to
- 20:37consent to me treating your kids, because again, these kids are younger,
- 20:38so they don't necessarily consent or officially to treatment or not. I still recommend
- 20:44that you try to get children's consent to treat them, even though you don't
- 20:47legally have to in my area. But I would say that you know you're
- 20:53you're bringing in your kids, and you're consenting to me treating your kids,
- 20:57but i'd love it if you would also to me helping you sometimes. Now
- 21:02I understand we're really focusing on the kids, but I want to occasionally check
- 21:06in with you, and in order for me to help you out, you
- 21:07have to consent to treatment. Otherwise you're just a collateral contact, meaning I
- 21:12can basically only get information from you, and I can. I can inform
- 21:18you about what's happening in therapy, because you have that right since these are
- 21:21you know, children, But I can't help you. I can't. I
- 21:26can't really get into things with you because that's that's treatment and an order for
- 21:30treatment to happen, you have to consent to treatment, and you have to
- 21:33also sign in the datted line. When I bring it to people on that
- 21:37way, one hundred percent of time parents would say okay, yeah, that
- 21:41sounds good. So in this situation, we have a therapist who did meet
- 21:47with the mother, not only with the kids, but also alone. So
- 21:52if if some of the sessions were with the mother by them, you know,
- 21:56alone, we have to assume that treatment was happening there, and that
- 22:03would be a good treatment. You're empathizing with the mom, You're talking about
- 22:07parenting with the mom. You're problem solving, you're allowing the mom to talk
- 22:11about our grief. You're helping the mother heal from a variety of things.
- 22:15You're helping the mother deal with the frustration of a variety of things going on.
- 22:18This is three years of therapy, so there's probably a lot there that's
- 22:22good treatment. But the therapist did not consider the mother to be a client
- 22:27and thus did not get any of the consent forms signed or anything like that,
- 22:32and didn't write anything in the progress notes indicating that the mother was a
- 22:36client. This happens all the time in my profession. Of marriage and family
- 22:41therapy, and it drives me bonkers, and even to the point where some
- 22:48agencies, if not many agencies actually in my area, prevent my students,
- 22:53my interns, from actually getting consent from the mother in a situation like that.
- 23:00So I can only speculate as to why they do this. But what
- 23:04they do is, you know these on site these you know, my interns,
- 23:07they intern in the community and so at the community mental health agencies,
- 23:11and these agencies have this policy that when a mother brings their kid in that
- 23:15therapists are prevented from actually asking the mother. Look, I'm a family therapist,
- 23:21do you consent to being client too? Now, as I said,
- 23:25that is the superior form of therapy. Every expert agrees that at least that
- 23:29should be on the table. And in order for that to be formalized in
- 23:34an ethical and legal way, you have to have the mother sign a consent
- 23:40form saying that they consent and you put that in the file. Well,
- 23:42a lot of these agencies don't allow that to happen. They don't allow you
- 23:47to treat them mother. They say, no, you have to treat just
- 23:49the kids. And there's various reasons. I think because of funding and the
- 23:53way the system pays for sessions, and just the culture of anti family therapy.
- 23:59It just drives me nuts. But anyway, so that's what this therapist
- 24:03did. The therapist saw the mother, but did not consider the mothers to
- 24:07be a client, didn't have the mother sign any papers. Okay, So
- 24:11at some point the mother and the therapist entered into some sort of business relationship,
- 24:18so they didn't talk about it in the case, but some sort of
- 24:22business relationship. So typical things would be like maybe the mother is a financial
- 24:29guru and the therapist is like, oh, you know, I could use
- 24:33some help with my finances, and the mother's like, well, I could
- 24:34help you with that, and so they or the mother was a real estate
- 24:38agent and the therapists like, oh, you know, I'm actually trying to
- 24:41sell my house. Maybe you could help me or something like this. Okay,
- 24:45so this is a pretty big no no under most circumstances. You can
- 24:51get away with some instances of this under very limited circumstances. A lot of
- 24:56buttoning up has to be done around, a lot of consultation, a lot
- 24:59of oversight really, but generally speaking, this is just not something that we
- 25:04do as therapist. And if you don't know, the reason why is because
- 25:10of the following reason why. I'll get into here. So the mother and
- 25:14therapist entered into some sort of business relationship, and over several months, the
- 25:18business relationship got bad. The two started to conflict about their business relationship,
- 25:25not their client therapist relationship. The mother believed that the therapist owed her money,
- 25:30and the mother made several attempts to collect the money from the therapist.
- 25:37The therapist refused to pay the mother for a variety of reasons, and their
- 25:41relationship became hostile. So in this business relationship, the mother's like, hey,
- 25:45you owe me money, therapist, and the therapists like, no,
- 25:48I do not owe you money, okay. So under normal circumstances, you'd
- 25:52be like, well, let's take it to civil court, let's work this
- 25:56out, let's see what we can do. But now you're inness situation where
- 26:00you're in business with a client of yours, or you're in business with a
- 26:04therapist of yours, and it's been three years of therapy, okay. So
- 26:11at this point, the therapist actually refused to allow the mother to attend therapy
- 26:18because of the hostility between them. So just imagine this, the therapists like,
- 26:22okay, because our business relationship has gone bad and we now hate each
- 26:27other, you are completely not allowed to come to therapy with your kids.
- 26:34And if you want me to treat your kids, fine, but you're not
- 26:37allowed in session because of this other thing. It happened outside of therapy in
- 26:41this business relationship. Okay. So obviously at this point, the mother files
- 26:48a complaint with the state licensing board and also a professional malpractice lawsuit. So,
- 26:56if you don't know, there are two major things you can do as
- 26:59a client against a clinician. One is, as you can report them to
- 27:03the state licensing board, which can take licenses away. So if you don't
- 27:08know this, as with a driver's license, you know, let's let's just
- 27:12do driver's license for a second. Okay, So you apply for a driver's
- 27:17license, you have to pass a test and demonstrate blah blah blah, and
- 27:21you pay the fee and you get your license, and if you break some
- 27:26sort of law like speeding or something, then they can impose some kind of
- 27:33sanction against you, some kind of fee, and in extreme cases, they
- 27:37can actually take your license away such that you can no longer drive legally.
- 27:41Well, the same is true about a license to practice. I have a
- 27:45license as well to practice, and if I do something wrong and the state
- 27:52decides to punish me, they can punish me in a variety of ways.
- 27:55And they can also take my license away or they can you know, temporarily
- 27:59take my license away, where they could take it away and then say you
- 28:02have to do these things to get it back. Okay, So that's the
- 28:06first thing that the mother did that she complained with the state licensing board.
- 28:10The second thing you can do as a client is you can sue the therapist
- 28:15the clinician for damages. Essentially, you can say you owe me money because
- 28:21of what you did to me, you know, like it's I don't know,
- 28:23some sort of legal term there. And the reasons that the mother filed
- 28:29the complaint was because of abandonment and breaking professional boundaries. So abandonment meaning that
- 28:36the therapist was like, you can't come to therapy anymore because of what happened.
- 28:40You know, I'm not going to be your therapist anymore, and the
- 28:42client felt abandoned and also breaking professional boundaries by engaging in this outside relationship.
- 28:49Okay, So the allegations against the against the counselor against the therapist included abandonment,
- 28:56client neglect, failure to obtain client it's consent for change of family to
- 29:02individual therapy, failure to maintain professional standards, and entering into a non professional
- 29:07relationship with a client. The licensing board obtained the client file. Obviously,
- 29:14they obtained the therapist personal cell phone records, which a licensing board can do,
- 29:19and they also the licensing board also interviewed the therapist co workers to find
- 29:26out about her. I guess the findings from the licensing board was that the
- 29:33file. So when I say file, if you're not a clinician, whenever
- 29:37you go to a physician, whenever you go to psychiatrist, whenever you go
- 29:41to a therapist that's licensed by the way, they have to keep a file
- 29:47on you. They have to keep notes on everything that happened. Essentially,
- 29:52sometimes the notes are pretty brief and not very detailed, and sometimes they can
- 29:57be very detailed. But there's a client file. There's a record of you
- 30:02as a client, and there's a record of every meeting and maybe even every
- 30:07telephone call. So what the finding was was, you know, the state
- 30:11licensey boarders reviewing the file and they're like, whoa, this is really incomplete.
- 30:15The file doesn't have enough in here, and the file is insufficient,
- 30:22and the file failed to meet professional documentation standards. This is really common whenever
- 30:30therapists get complained against and the file is pulled or the file is pulled into
- 30:34court somehow, I would say half the time, maybe more, it's found
- 30:41that these therapists have insufficient records. Keeping records in documentation is a pretty complicated
- 30:48thing, and graduate schools do not spend enough time on this. We're getting
- 30:53a little better because there's all these online services. Because you know, in
- 30:59the past you just had to write it by hand or type it out or
- 31:03something. Right, Well, today a lot of clinicians actually use these online
- 31:07services where you post all of your progress notes to a website essentially, and
- 31:14it's encrypted and it's hip A compliant this kind of thing. But and these
- 31:18services will actually walk you through the process. They'll say, Okay, you
- 31:23know right, make sure you write about this, make sure you're write about
- 31:26that. It's sort of like when you do Turbo tax online or h and
- 31:30R block online or something. You don't have to be a tax expert because
- 31:34the website kind of walks you through it, and some of these websites do
- 31:38that, but some of them don't. Anyway, so a lot of people
- 31:42are having insufficient records because it's a pretty complicated thing. And it took me
- 31:48years, really to figure out all the nuances to the ethics and the laws
- 31:55that really influence what we're supposed to be writing and what we're not supposed to
- 31:59be writing. Essentially, I had to read and learn a lot of cases
- 32:04in which people were sued for various different reasons, and there's just so many
- 32:08things to think about, and so we just don't spend enough time. There's
- 32:13barely any class time spent for counselors and therapists on this topic. And you
- 32:21have a lot of people who just have no idea what they're doing. And
- 32:24then even if they kind of do know what they're doing, after a couple
- 32:29decades of practice, a lot of people just kind of drift, because of
- 32:32laziness or something ignorance, to this mode where they barely keep any records.
- 32:38So anyway, this person was found to have an incomplete file, which doesn't
- 32:43surprise me now. What they also found the licensee board was that even though
- 32:49the counselor thought that the mother was not a client. The license cy Board
- 32:52says the mother was indeed a client because the therapist was treating the mother.
- 32:59Remember we're talking about all those individual sessions, and they're like, whether or
- 33:05not you knew what or not, therapist, that mother was your client because
- 33:08you were treating them. And of course consent was never obtained from the mother
- 33:13because the therapist didn't know to do that. And it's such a simple step.
- 33:17I always talk about this with my trainees because because so let me back
- 33:23up. So one of the things that happens is you know, a mother
- 33:28will show up, and whenever you're meeting a new client, there's a lot
- 33:30of tension because you don't know who you're going to be talking to. There's
- 33:34a wide variety of the sort of people who show up in your office.
- 33:37You don't know what situation there, and you don't know how desperate they're going
- 33:40to be. And to be honest, you're trying to make them like you
- 33:44because you either for self esteem reasons or even just for your bottom line.
- 33:49This is your living. You're essentially you're like a restaurant and someone's coming into
- 33:52your restaurant. You want to please them. Because you want them to choose
- 33:55you as their service provider, right, And so there can be a fair
- 34:01amount of anxiety, particularly from novice clinicians, and the mother brings in the
- 34:07kids, and the mother's like, okay, there's all these problems, you
- 34:09know, acting out. That was the problem that the kids had, and
- 34:12so you know the kids are acting out, and so you want to spend
- 34:15a lot of time as a therapist really listening to the mom. You're like,
- 34:17go, okay, I'm listening. And it takes a real professional to
- 34:23pause the mom and say, Okay, I just want to talk about something
- 34:27for a second. Now, I'm a family you know, And then you
- 34:30go into your whole spiel where you take control, where you're saying, I'm
- 34:32a family therapist and here's my approach, and I recommend that you engage in
- 34:36therapy as well. How do you feel about that? You might have it
- 34:38back and forth in this Okay, you know, here's here's what I can
- 34:42do, and you have to be pretty good on your toes and you have
- 34:45to be pretty good at describing what we do. And again with that topic,
- 34:50therapists get no education. Therapists get zero education about how to talk about
- 34:55their profession how to talk about their service, and clinicians can, especially novice
- 35:00clinicians, can just be terrible when they're asked a question like what are you
- 35:07doing? You know, Like sometimes they'll get a client that'll just be like,
- 35:10what are you doing to me? You know, a client will just
- 35:13ask that question, and the therapist they just don't know what to say.
- 35:16And then what will happen is the therapist will be like, I hate that
- 35:20client. And then they come to me and they're like, eye, this
- 35:22client that keeps questioning me about what I'm doing, and I'm really it really
- 35:25pisses me off, and I'm like, well, what question do they ask
- 35:28there? Like, well, they keep confronting me on what I'm doing a
- 35:31therapy and you know, calling me out and asking me why I'm doing what
- 35:35I'm doing it, and it's just a bunch of crap. And I'm like,
- 35:37well, what do you say now? Of course I get it,
- 35:40because these trainees of mine, these supervises of mine, have never been trained
- 35:46on how to answer that question. And so in this instance, when you're
- 35:52having to take control of the session and actually talk with the mother about the
- 35:57bigger picture of treatment, you have to know how to have that conversation.
- 36:00You have to be pretty good on your toes. You have to understand the
- 36:02profession. You have to know if the mother's like, well, wait a
- 36:07second, I don't want treatment, you have to know how to respond to
- 36:08that in a convincing way or in a way that allows flexibility anyway. And
- 36:14so a lot of people they just they just avoid it, and there's like,
- 36:19well, I don't want to bother the mother. I don't want to
- 36:21bother Well, how is it bothering the mother to give her a service that
- 36:24she wants? And like I said, when I give my spiel to the
- 36:29parents, they always agree. I've never had a parent say no. And
- 36:31what I also say is, imagine if you go through this process with the
- 36:37parents and they're like, no, I don't want treatment. Well, wouldn't
- 36:39that be good to know in the beginning. Wouldn't you want to know that
- 36:43right from the start that the parents like, absolutely not, I do not
- 36:45want to be a client. Then you can just be like, Okay,
- 36:47well I gave up my best shot, and I guess I'm just you know,
- 36:52I guess the parent is a collateral contact and I'll have minimal contact with
- 36:54the parents. Okay, well, you know they told me it's something that
- 36:58you want to know anyway, So because the therapist did not do because I'm
- 37:02guessing that if we went back in time while this therapist was treating this family
- 37:07for three years and we asked the therapist, Hey, what are you doing
- 37:09with the mom and the therapist well, you know, I'm meeting with the
- 37:12mom alone sometimes, Well what are you talking about. Well, we're talking
- 37:15about parenting, we're talking about her the grief of the loss of her husband,
- 37:17and we're talking about the stress she's going on. Okay, so you're
- 37:21talking about all those things. That sounds like therapy to me? Is that
- 37:23therapy? And the therapist might say, well yeah, I mean I'm trying
- 37:27to help the mom and trying to help her out. Okay, have you
- 37:30obtained consent to treatment from the mother? Well no, I haven't. Well
- 37:35why, well because she brought the kids, and you know, the kids
- 37:37are the clients. I'm like, okay, the kids are the clients.
- 37:40But it also sounds like the mom as a client. Well, you know
- 37:44I talk with the mom about the kids. Well okay, but you're still
- 37:47talking with the mom and you're helping the mom right, Yeah, I'm helping
- 37:52the mom. Are you helping her professionally? Well, what do you mean,
- 37:54Well, are you a clinician helping someone? Yes, I'm clinician.
- 38:00That's treatment, my friend. And so you need to get consent before you
- 38:05engage in that. So you need to have them agree and on the dotted
- 38:08line that they are a client. And the fact that you're treating someone without
- 38:12getting their consent is akin to a dentist pushing someone down and performing a procedure
- 38:17on someone's mouth without getting their consent. That's what's happening, and that's how
- 38:22the courts will see it, and that's how the courts saw it, and
- 38:25that's how the licensing board saw in this instance. Okay, can you tell
- 38:30I've talked a lot about this over the years with my trainees, and it's
- 38:35because there's so much confusion and these agencies are telling my trainees the exact opposite.
- 38:43By the way, anyway, so not all the agencies, but some.
- 38:47Okay, So the Lycey Board was like, Okay, your file wasn'tcomplete,
- 38:53the mother was a client, and you didn't get consent, and the
- 39:00discipline from the licensing board was eighty hours of ethics training. That's a lot
- 39:05of training, by the way, eighty hours. That's like, I don't
- 39:08know, it's it's probably what ten it's probably like fifteen days, fifteen full
- 39:15days of classes anyway. And also to practice under supervision buying approved supervisor in
- 39:22marriage of family therapy for two years. So this is a really common disciplinary
- 39:28action by a licensing board is ethics training and practice under supervision. Now this
- 39:34thing I actually will tell people to help to calm them down, because,
- 39:39as I was saying earlier, a lot of novice clinicians are paranoid and just
- 39:44terrified of breaking some ethical code or breaking some law. And what I tell
- 39:51them is, you know the things I've been telling them, but I also
- 39:53say, but also sleep well at night knowing that the very worst that you're
- 40:00probably capable of. You know, obviously don't have sex with a client.
- 40:04But if you're going to do something bad, like perform treatment on someone that
- 40:07hasn't consented to it and engage in a relationship outside of therapy, you know,
- 40:14remember this is the case where the mom and the therapist had a business
- 40:17relationship. So even if you do something as stupid as that, the only
- 40:22thing that'll happen to you is eighty hours of ethics training and you're you have
- 40:29to practice under supervision, which actually could be pretty cool because you probably get
- 40:35to hire your own supervisor in that situation, so you could actually hire someone
- 40:38that. Now it costs money. It's probably going to cost a lot of
- 40:42money, and the ethics training is going to cost money and time. But
- 40:45that's great. You get it. You get ethics training, you get supervision.
- 40:49It's not the end of the world. It's not like someone comes and
- 40:52locks you up in prison. Okay, So even when you do something as
- 40:55stupid as what this therapist did, it's the punishment still isn't that bad.
- 41:00So you know, novice therapists out there, try not to worry too much.
- 41:06Do your job, learn the ethics, consult all the time, make
- 41:10sure you're buttoned up with your records, make sure that you obtained consent,
- 41:15and have those conversations with your clients, and go to ethics training. Have
- 41:21good mentors, have good experts in your corner. But also know that if
- 41:24you make a pretty big mistake, the punishment usually isn't dire. It's not
- 41:30going to ruin your life. This person was absolutely allowed to continue treating people
- 41:36and their life probably didn't change that much after the situation was settled. So
- 41:42with the licensing boards findings, the insurance determined that the therapist had only a
- 41:46ten percent chance of winning the civil lawsuits. So remember the mother both filed
- 41:52the complaint with the state and did a civil suit, you know, sued
- 41:58the therapist for images, and because the licensing board hearing was first, and
- 42:04so the licensing board and that usually that's the way it goes. Usually the
- 42:07civil suit will wait until the licensing board, at least from my understanding,
- 42:10and the licensing board found that the therapist was guilty essentially that's not the words
- 42:16they used, but that they were negligent. And so the malpractice insurance,
- 42:22my malpractice insurance which was shared by this therapist, looked at the situation was
- 42:28like, oh boy, you know, given the fact that the licensing board
- 42:32decided against our client, the therapist, chances are the civil suit is also
- 42:37going to go against our client, and we have a we only have a
- 42:42ten percent chance of winning this case, and so we're going to settle.
- 42:45So they decided to settle, and they found that the total expense to the
- 42:52settlement and for the lawyers for the settlement was one hundred and seventy eight thousand
- 42:55dollars, So the mother probably sued the therapist for like one hundred and fifty
- 43:00thousand dollars or something and got that money. And the cost to defend the
- 43:06therapist for the board complaint, the lawyer's fees was thirteen thousand dollars, so
- 43:12rough estimate, I'm just guessing here, one hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
- 43:15The malpractice insurance had to pay one hundred fifty thousand dollars to the mother,
- 43:19and they had to pay about fifty thousand dollars and lawyers fees for the state
- 43:24board complaint and for the settlement. Okay, So obviously there are many recommendations
- 43:30here to be made, and my malpractice and myself provide these recommendations. One
- 43:36is always consult have a mentor have experts. Whenever you're doing things along these
- 43:42lines, you need to consult with someone, and don't just consult with anybody.
- 43:46Consult with an experts. I see a lot of clinicians online on Facebook
- 43:52consulting with each other, consulting with non experts, and this is not a
- 43:57good idea. It's the blind leading the blind. Do not just look to
- 44:01someone and some people. I've seen people online make egregious claims about what is
- 44:08ethical and what is not. In fact, on the majority, I would
- 44:14say that half of all the ideas rattling around in clinicians heads are in error.
- 44:21There's so much misinformation out there, and I've seen it all, and
- 44:24it changes by state to state, changes by profession. It's pretty it's pretty
- 44:29complicated. So you need to actually have in your corner or on your speed
- 44:32dial someone who you know to be an expert. Now, what constitutes an
- 44:37expert? Now, some might say, well, what constitute an expert?
- 44:39Is a professor right of ethics? Not always. I know professors of ethics,
- 44:45you know, people who teach ethics classes to be sometimes terrible experts and
- 44:52terrible guidance guides when it comes through the ethical codes. I've seen that a
- 45:00lot in my travels. I've seen some professors who are excellent experts. So
- 45:05how can the average clinician determine? Well, here's here's my little here's my
- 45:08little shortcut to determining a good expert from a bad expert. Good experts have
- 45:15case law. Good experts have contact or have read actual cases that went to
- 45:22the board or went to court, because this is where the things get determined,
- 45:29not amongst ourselves. There's a lot of ideas among clinicians, like there's
- 45:34this idea. One common example in my field is that when we get subpoenaed.
- 45:39So let's say that there's a divorce, for example, and you're say
- 45:45you're treating the wife and there's your wife, the wife is getting divorced from
- 45:51her husband, and the husband's lawyer. Subpoena is you to come to court
- 45:55and to testify. And you're like, I don't want to do that.
- 45:58You know the husband, the husband. I don't even know the husband.
- 46:00I'm treating the wife and the husband's lawyer is subpoena? Is subpoena in me,
- 46:07I don't want to do that. Well, And I remember hearing this
- 46:10early in my career and believing it was that unless the subpoena comes from a
- 46:15judge, you don't have to go and so you can just ignore it.
- 46:19This is not true. You can't ignore any subpoena. You have to respond
- 46:22to all subpoenas. Now you can get out of it. There's various different
- 46:25ways to get out of it. I won't go into all the details.
- 46:29But that's just one of those things that among lay clinicians or clinicians that are
- 46:35lay experts on the law and ethics, they will rattle they'll have these ideas
- 46:37that will just permeate through the culture. You know. It's just like all
- 46:42the weird ideas that people have in society, like flat earth for example.
- 46:47You know, it's there's all these ideas that just kind of rattle around and
- 46:51echo around in certain little pockets. And clinicians are really bad about this.
- 46:57And the fact is is that there's very few people that actually go to court.
- 47:01Now why is that, Well, because we rarely get sued, we
- 47:05rarely have complaints waged against us. It's pretty rare for a clinician to have
- 47:08any kind of thing like this happen. And so very few of us actually
- 47:13have contact with what actually happens in courts and in boardrooms, in licensing boardrooms.
- 47:21And so when you're looking for an expert, find someone that has actually
- 47:23been there or frequently reads those cases, because there are plenty of people who
- 47:30think they're experts but don't have contact with the actual decision makers. Because that's
- 47:36ultimately what we're worried about. Right, what we're worried about is what does
- 47:39the licensing board think? What does the judge think? Because sometimes courts of
- 47:45law, particularly in civil suits, they adjudicate in some very weird ways that
- 47:49don't make sense to us as clinicians, but it makes sense to the courts,
- 47:53and so that's who we need to We at least need to know what's
- 47:55going on over there. Right, anyway, so you need to have an
- 48:00expert. Now, how do you find those people? Well, I don't
- 48:01know. Ask around. Sometimes if you talk with an ethics professor and you
- 48:07say, do you know anyone who actually works? Sometimes looking for a lawyer
- 48:15slash counselor those kinds of kinds of people can be great anyway. The other
- 48:20thing is obviously get trained in ethics and law. Go to trainings from actual
- 48:22people who know what they're talking about. Also clearly define who is considered the
- 48:28client. Also, be mindful of multiple relationships. Don't involve yourself in multiple
- 48:34relationship, meaning don't have business partnerships with your clients. And also know how
- 48:38to document well. My Malpractice actually found that five percent of licensing protection claims
- 48:45involved allegations regarding bad documentation. Five percent of the malpractice cases with my amount
- 48:53with my insurance, they said, involves bad documentation. So that's pretty high
- 49:00rate of bad documentation. All right, let's go on to another case,
- 49:04but first let's take a break. All right, This next case is about
- 49:10documentation. This should be a short one actually, Okay. So the insured
- 49:15clinician is a licensed mental health counselor, so licensed mental health counselor, and
- 49:22the client female fourteen years old, being treated for depression anxiety PTSD and associative
- 49:29identity disorder. For some reason, the client suddenly terminated and the client file
- 49:36a complaint with the state board. The client claimed that the counselor had been
- 49:40verbally abusive in a session. So we have a teenage client who suddenly terminates
- 49:49and then, you know, files a complaint with the licensing board saying my
- 49:53counselor was verbally abusive to me in a session. So in the case description
- 50:00they didn't go into detail, so I don't know if this was a valid
- 50:04complaint or not. But anyway, the state board investigated. They got the
- 50:09client file, of course, and what they found in the client file was
- 50:15that there were no progress notes and no discharge summary because remember that the clients
- 50:21suddenly terminated, there should be a discharge summary, a termination summary of some
- 50:23sort. The state board asked the counselor why, saying why don't you have
- 50:30any progress notes? Why is there no discharge summary? And the counselor said
- 50:35that she does not write progress notes and she does not generally complete former discharge
- 50:40summaries. So they're like, okay, So the experts look into this and
- 50:53they find that it is absolutely unethical for a counselor to not have progress notes
- 50:58detailing all the things that it needs to detail, and they didn't discipline the
- 51:04counselor for the verbal abuse. I'm guessing that they've found it was hard to
- 51:08figure out, you know, we have a counselor said client said situation,
- 51:14and they didn't know what to do, but they definitely knew that the counselor
- 51:17did not have proper documentation, which is a pretty slam dunk violation of the
- 51:23ethical codes. And the counselor was placed on probation for a year and required
- 51:29to complete continuing education on documentation and record keeping. So again they were punished,
- 51:36but pretty light punishment, right for someone just to not you know,
- 51:40as a policy I don't write progress notes for my clients. This is egregious
- 51:47and laughable. But understand, I mean, I could, I can see
- 51:52this happening. I've heard attitudes like this from counselors before, and they're caught
- 51:58red handed. And the only thing it happens is the counselor is placed on
- 52:02probation for a year, meaning that either that's like a temporary license. Well
- 52:09I don't know what probation means exactly. Usually what that means is, look,
- 52:15as long as you don't do anything bad for this year, then you're
- 52:17okay. But if you do anything bad in this year, then you're in
- 52:21double trouble. Usually that's what I mean. And also required to complete continuing
- 52:24education on documentation record keeping. The cost to my male practice insurance to defend
- 52:30this counselor with thirteen thousand dollars. Okay, So the recommendations obviously are have
- 52:38proper documentation not only for treatment purposes, but also to cover your ass CYA.
- 52:47As they say, when it comes to pass and you have a complaint
- 52:54filed against you, you have to present your file. That's the first thing
- 52:59that happens. And if you don't have a file, then you have no
- 53:01way of defending yourself. You have no way of defending your treatment at all.
- 53:06You have no way of defending the fact that you're even talking to the
- 53:08person. And in this in these progress notes, in this file, it
- 53:15needs to have the diagnosis and some general sense of a treatment plan and ongoing
- 53:21check ins and the progress notes around the treatment plan and response to treatment,
- 53:25any kind of consultations you had, assessment of client safety risks, the informed
- 53:31consent process, session notes, telephone calls with the client, discharge summaries,
- 53:37and so it so, it all needs to be in there. And again,
- 53:42not a lot of clinicians get trained enough on this. And the thing
- 53:47I'll say to if you're a clinician listening is it's up to you. You're
- 53:52going to get minimal education on this usually, but even if you get pretty
- 53:59good education on this, it's still up to you to determine a system.
- 54:01It's up to you to really take the bull by the horns and say I'm
- 54:05going to get good at knowing what to put in the file and knowing what
- 54:08not to and what I say what not to. Is you can get sued
- 54:13for not putting things in the file successfully, and you can be punished for
- 54:16putting too much in the file. And there are countless examples that I've worked
- 54:22with trainees and supervises on this, where there's court cases and it's all based
- 54:28on the fact that the clinician put too much detail in the client file.
- 54:31Let me just give you a random example. This isn't a real example,
- 54:35but so let's say that you have a client, twenty five year old woman,
- 54:39and she comes in and you and her have a pretty good relationship,
- 54:44and about six months into treatment, she starts talking about how she was sexually
- 54:47abused by her father, and you put in the session notes that she was
- 54:52sexually abused by her father. You just mentioned that the client discussed with me
- 54:57her traumatic history of being sexually abused by her father. And then, let's
- 55:01say a year later, the client and you have a falling out for some
- 55:07reason. The client just really doesn't like what you're doing and decides to complain
- 55:12against you and the client. The file is pulled and presented to the licensing
- 55:19board, and everyone's reading it, the lawyers and the board, and you
- 55:22know, everyone's reading the file, and the client sees and the file now
- 55:28that it says explicitly that you wrote that the client was sexually abused by her
- 55:35father, and she is incredibly shamed by this, not because she should be
- 55:39shamed to it, because there's a lot of stigma around stuff like that,
- 55:45and she has trements. She has a big problem with that information now being
- 55:50out there. The information is now being read by everybody. Now, in
- 55:53some circumstances, the client doesn't have any right at this point, because what
- 55:59are you going to do. But sometimes I've seen situations where a client will
- 56:04beyond the you know, sort of teeter tottering between suing the therapist or not
- 56:10now. Or let me give you another example. Let's say that there's a
- 56:15divorce, like I said, and the client, your your client says,
- 56:21actually I want the client file, and so you're, okay, here's the
- 56:23client file. And then the client submits the file to the court and the
- 56:30husband, you know, she's divorced in the husband and the husband's looking at
- 56:35the file and all the lawyers are looking at the file and it says in
- 56:38there that she was sexually abused by her dad. And now the dad or
- 56:43the husband is going to use that against her. You know, the husband's
- 56:46lawyers are going to say, oh, you were sexually abused by your dad,
- 56:51and you're crazy. That's why you don't you shouldn't get custody of the
- 56:54children. And now the wife your client is really angry at you for putting
- 57:00that in the file, for revealing too much information in the file, and
- 57:05then the wife the client decides to sue you for putting too much in the
- 57:08file. Now, it's hard for a client to win a case like this,
- 57:13but do you really want that to happen? And that's a risk,
- 57:16and you don't have to put that detail in the client in the file.
- 57:20You can put something like, we discuss the client's traumatic history. It's a
- 57:22safer statement to say. Now, sometimes you do want to put that detail,
- 57:27but sometimes you don't. My point is is that you need to understand
- 57:30all the different risks involved in what you put in the file. And it's
- 57:37pretty complicated, and in order to really do that, you have to learn
- 57:42a lot of different details and a lot of different possibilities, possibilities that probably
- 57:46don't occur to you as a clinician. At first. You have to hear
- 57:51about all these stories and oh okay, and every time you're writing a session
- 57:54note, you have to have all those things in your mind as you're writing
- 57:59everything down. I need to put enough in, but I shouldn't put too
- 58:02much in? And what is that? What do I need to put in?
- 58:05What should I exclude? It's very important to know that all the while.
- 58:09You don't want to be spending half an hour in every session note,
- 58:13right. I always tell my supervisees that if you're spending more than thirty seconds
- 58:19on a client a session note, you're doing something wrong. You should be
- 58:22able to write a session note very quickly. You should be able to just
- 58:27off the top of your head go blah blah blah blah boom, righte,
- 58:29you know, five ten sentences and you should be done. If you're spending
- 58:31a lot of time, you're wasting a lot of time. And so it
- 58:35takes a lot of practice. It takes a lot of practice. And it
- 58:37took me years to get practiced enough so that I could write my sessions really
- 58:43quick, my session notes really quick. Anyway, So those are three cases
- 58:50that I told you about. The first one the substance abuse counselor blackmailed client
- 59:00and having sex with him and had his license revoked permanently and was not sued.
- 59:07Apparently at least according to the case brief, the second counselor was a
- 59:14marriage family therapist who did not get consent from the mother and was and also
- 59:21engaged in a business relationship with the client and was sued in civil court and
- 59:27also had her well. She had eighty hours of ethics training and practiced under
- 59:34supervision. And then this third medal of counselor apparently was accused of being verbally
- 59:42abusive to a client. But then they found that there were no records,
- 59:46and then the counselor was placed on probation and required to complete education on how
- 59:52to do records. So that is that, and let me know what you
- 59:57think, and everyone out there, pleased take care of yourself. Well,
- 1:00:00actually, let me conclude with this. So if you're a clinician, I
- 1:00:07hope that this helped that to hear cases like this, to hear me ramble
- 1:00:10about this, you know, it's always a good idea to have this kind
- 1:00:13of reminders about the topics. And there are many more topics obviously, But
- 1:00:20if you're a client, you know a lot of people clients out there will
- 1:00:25say to me, well, I don't want to hear stories like this because
- 1:00:30I'm thinking about going to therapy, and I'm already worried about going to therapy,
- 1:00:35and if I hear about stories like this, it makes me not want
- 1:00:37to go to therapy because I'm worried that they're going to do something bad to
- 1:00:40me. Well, I'm here to tell you that the vast majority of clinicians
- 1:00:45do not do things like this. Or yeah, maybe they don't keep records,
- 1:00:50but you don't know about that, but they're they're not likely to have
- 1:00:52sex with you, and they're not likely to engage in a business relationship with
- 1:00:57you. These are pretty egregious behaviors, and this is why we have these
- 1:01:01write ups about them, is sort of these stark examples of terrible behavior that
- 1:01:06gets that gets called out. So the other thing I'll say is, let's
- 1:01:12say you engage in a relationship with a therapist and you start noticing some boundary
- 1:01:16violations. And I've you know, I've received emails from people for years,
- 1:01:21and a lot of you have reached out to me with your stories, some
- 1:01:24slightly egregious and some terribly egregious. It happens. And the thing I'll say
- 1:01:32is, at the first sign of something happening, you can always consult with
- 1:01:40another therapist about what's happening. You know, that's not a common practice,
- 1:01:45but I think it should be. You know, if if a therapist says,
- 1:01:52hey, you know, I was thinking about joining business with you,
- 1:01:55well, who should a client go to? I think going to another therapist
- 1:02:02or some other expert would be a good idea, some kind of resource around
- 1:02:07that, because how would a client know that that was going to be a
- 1:02:10risk to them if the therapist doesn't inform them or at the very least bring
- 1:02:16it up with your therapist and just say so, can you tell me all
- 1:02:22of the problems, are the risks involved and what's happening right here? Because
- 1:02:27if they if the clinician can't answer that question very well, then again it's
- 1:02:31a bad sign because there are a lot of situations as a marriage family therapist
- 1:02:37for me where I will absolutely answer those questions and fully I'll just go okay,
- 1:02:42good, I'm glad you asked. Well, the risks are this,
- 1:02:44and the pros and this and the cons are this, and here here are
- 1:02:46your rights, and here are my ethical responsibilities. And you can also always
- 1:02:52change therapists if something really concerning or you're even mildly concerned and you're just like
- 1:03:00gah, I think I want to try and every therapist you can always do
- 1:03:01that as well. So don't feel like if you start therapy and that you
- 1:03:08have to stick with that person forever, because you don't. You have the
- 1:03:13power usually depending on access to change and to say I don't really feel so
- 1:03:20the reason why I say, I'm not saying you should always jump ship at
- 1:03:22at every concern. But my point is that when people are like, well
- 1:03:28now I'm really scared to go to therapy, well, you know, give
- 1:03:30it a try and watch what happens, and monitor what happens. Make sure
- 1:03:36you're watching out for your own interests, make sure you're being treated well,
- 1:03:39make sure that your clinician has good answers to things, and then you know,
- 1:03:45proceed forward. And again, most therapists don't do anything like this.
- 1:03:50Most therapists, like I said, are terrified of taking a five dollars gift
- 1:03:53as some massive ethical violation, you know, from one client once a year,
- 1:04:00or they get one five dollar gift card for Starbucks from a client and
- 1:04:04they're just crapping their pants and I'm like, yeah, okay, let's talk
- 1:04:11about it. But I don't think it's anything that bad. So so that's
- 1:04:15what i'll say if you're a prospective client. The other thing I'll say here
- 1:04:19is that as a profession, if you're a professor or you're a supervisor,
- 1:04:23you're thinking about becoming a trainer of therapists, we really need to get more
- 1:04:28buttoned up about this sort of thing. There are a lot of buttoned up
- 1:04:30people for sure, for sure, and I feel like it's getting better over
- 1:04:34the years, but we have a long way to go, and we need
- 1:04:40to do what we can to make sure that we create a culture. It's
- 1:04:44really that it's really creating a culture of being buttoned up, which the profession
- 1:04:49doesn't really come from, particularly marriage of family therapy and counseling. The master's
- 1:04:54level professions come from a history and a culture of being pretty loose when it
- 1:05:00came to the law and the ethics. And it's getting better for sure than
- 1:05:04it was before. I mean, I'm old enough that I've been in the
- 1:05:06professional long time, and I remember when I first became a therapist in the
- 1:05:10nineties, things were real loose, Like there was a lot of just very
- 1:05:16loose behavior and loose education at the time. And in twenty five years there's
- 1:05:23been a lot more professionalization of these fields, and there's pros and cons that
- 1:05:28I think it's mostly pro, but then there's cons like we kind of lose
- 1:05:32the heart and the I don't know, the humanness of the profession. You
- 1:05:39know, when we become too buttoned up, then we were at risk of
- 1:05:44losing some of our humanity. Now I absolutely will contend that we can be
- 1:05:48extremely buttoned up for the protection of our clients, you know, for the
- 1:05:53protection of the public, while absolutely retaining our humanness because that's what clients need.
- 1:06:00All right, Well, let me know what you think, and everyone
- 1:06:02out there please take care of yourself because they deserve it. You really really do.