Latest / The Dokkcast / Can You Be a Surgeon and Have a Family? Orthopaedic Surgeon Cat Malik Explains
Transcript
- 0:06Nara: Lovely! So thank you so much Kat for joining me today. It's lovely to meet you and it's lovely to have you on our Dokkast. Welcome! Tell me a little bit about yourself, what you're doing, who you are, introduce yourself to the audience and we'll go from there.
- 0:22Cat: Well thank you for having me. My name's Kat, I'm a post CCT Fellow in Trauma and Orthopaedics, currently doing my first fellowship in foot and ankle surgery with an interest also in lower limb trauma. I've actually been an orthopaedic surgeon for twelve years. I had three children during my training so I've taken the rather scenic route to get to where I am. But that's been a very important part of my life juggling family life and being a doctor.
- 0:50I remember when I was younger and people still say things like this today that you can't be a woman in surgery with a family and be a surgeon and it's just such nonsense. You can definitely juggle both and actually I recently spoke to someone who said that working mums are the most organised people that they'd ever met.
- 1:10Nara: Yeah, a 100%. I could not agree with that more. For those of us who are not in the medical specialty, tell us a little bit about what an orthopaedic surgeon does. Cause they kind of think orthopaedics, you know, they, they don't necessarily know where that overlaps with anything else to do with joints or bones or tissues, etcetera. What, what, what, what is an orthopaedic surgeon?
- 1:33And then second follow-up question to that is why orthopaedics for you?
- 1:40Cat: Orthopaedics is treating mostly bone and joint conditions. That things like arthritis, we treat a lot of tendon and muscle problems sometimes and then trauma. So I do a lot of broken bones, ligament injuries around the foot and ankle that sort of thing. And then why an orthopaedic surgeon? I'll say what I said in my interview when I got the job which was I really like power tools and if I wasn't an orthopaedic surgeon I'd have probably ended up being something like a carpenter or a joiner.
- 2:15I really like putting things together and building things. I find it very satisfying and it's like mechano with people. And then on a more personal side I really enjoy meeting people interacting with my patients and it's it's not all about surgery and as a surgeon I think a lot of us forget that there's a lot of conditions that we see that actually you really want to try and avoid operations for people and it's trying to educate your patients and motivate and empower them to treating them with things such as physiotherapy and take control of their own recovery really.
- 2:53Nara: Yeah, giving them that agency. And when did you know that that was it for you? Because actually I think it's one of those questions that we get a lot and I, you know, and, and we're kindred spirits in some ways, because I'm an ENT surgeon and exactly, you know, we've got very clear reasons as to how we landed in that spot. I think it's very rare that you go to medical school and think I am going to be an orthopaedic surgeon. What was your journey to that point like?
- 3:19Yeah, what were the things that you thought? And in some ways there'll be, there'll be people watching this in medical school thinking, I don't know what I want to do. And, it's a really nice way of hearing from others who've been through that journey and their decision pathway.
- 3:36Cat: Yeah, that's a really good point. So in medical school I absolutely did not know what I wanted to do. In hindsight I have always been a surgeon and I think I'd have never ended up being anything else now that I know my personality as I do. And then at med school in my last year I had a special study module in max fat surgery and it was the most mind blowing thing I'd ever seen. I remember watching them do a fibula free flap graft for jaw cancer which is where you take out the bone, the muscle and the skin in part of the leg and you put it in their face to replace the bit of bone with the cancer in.
- 4:13And I can't even describe it, when they plumbed in the artery and then the blood was coming out of the vein at the other end I was like wow this is really cool surgery, this is phenomenal. And then I rearranged a second study module in the same department because I enjoyed it so much. And at that point I wanted to be a max vac surgeon and you have to do both dentistry and medicine. So at the end of my second year of medical training, my foundation year two, I applied for surgical training and for dentistry. But then I got offered my job for surgery before they'd even announced the interview dates to do dentistry.
- 4:54And I thought well, I don't really want to decline the surgery offer in case I don't get the dentist you want and I have to do the two years of surgical training anyway. So I accepted that and withdrew my dentistry application and thought well I'll just reapply in two years time. And my first job was orthopaedics which I really enjoyed and I sort of decided maybe that's what I wanted to do. And then one of the other trainees wanted to swap jobs with me. They wanted to do a bit more general surgery, which like intestines and stuff.
- 5:32And they offer me a swap to more orthopaedics. And at that point I was toying with the idea of doing orthopaedics. So I was like, great. Yeah, I'll swap that job. Had an absolutely fabulous job.
- 5:44I met the man that's now my husband I decided didn't want to do anything else apart from orthopaedics and that's how it went. So that's basically I had a job in orthopaedics, I absolutely loved it and decided I never wanted to do anything else again.
- 5:58Nara: Yeah. And that's a really interesting path because it actually reinforces how important those moments, experiential moments, I. E. What you experienced, how that attachment makes you feel to some degree. And it's about feeling valued, contributing to the team, because I don't know if you felt this way, but when you're quite junior as a, as a doctor and a surgeon, it's easy to not feel very relevant perhaps.
- 6:28Know everyone feels, do you agree with that statement? I don't want to No, put words in your
- 6:32Cat: no, I completely agree. My first orthopaedic attachment as a core surgical trainee was in a department where you were treated very well as a core surgical trainee and we were very much valued and taught very well. So I was taught to operate and I wasn't doing what a lot of junior doctors at that stage do, which is a lot of ward work which is very necessary and very important but it's not what you love. The sort of surgery and the patient interaction is what I find to be the best thing and without a doubt if I hadn't been in that department with those people and hadn't had that experience, I don't think I would be thinking oh this is something I want to do for the rest of my life.
- 7:19Nara: Yeah, I think that's a really important point and one of the challenges now as you know, and you're sort of coming definitely at the other end of your training, and we'll be looking for that consultant post very, very soon is how do we make sure as consultants and trainers that we keep advocating for the trainees? Because there is so much work to be done and a lot of that work may be administrative and maybe a little bit more run of the mill. And exactly as you say, surgeons are operating, whether you are a trainee surgeon or a consultator at any stage of your career. So it requires a high level of engagement. There are, sort of stereotypes about orthopaedic surgeons, which I think if you're in the business of medicine and surgery, you know about it.
- 8:12Tell us a bit about that. How did, how did that kind of not necessarily play into your decision making, but how do you feel And, about and by the way, we all, every surgical specialty has a bit of that, don't they? But orthopedics, maybe maybe more than others. Do you agree with that?
- 8:28Cat: Yeah, there's definitely a reputation of orthopaedics and so historically orthopaedic surgeons were big blokes normally, you know, rugby players, that sort of thing. And there's a sort of I don't want to say joke, like knuckle draggers. So very strong and not very clever. Orthopaedics has got this reputation of people who like to bash things with a hammer, which is not untrue. But actually I think if you feel you need to be strong to do orthopaedics then you're doing it wrong.
- 9:02Nara: I
- 9:04Cat: know five foot female hip surgeons who can do the job perfectly well if you get your technique correct. And I think it's really important to dispel those myths about any specialty actually, particularly in orthopaedics where historically it's been very male dominated and probably quite aggressive. Actually it shouldn't be like that and it's not like that anymore.
- 9:31Nara: Yeah. And, and when you say it's not like that anymore, do you think that that change, is it just the times and everything changes with the times or what do you think has changed? And, and it sounds like it's changed for the better. What do you think has played into that? And part of the sort of the nugget of that question in there is how do we make surgery an attractive specialty in general?
- 9:58Because actually, by the way, that's declining people who are coming out of medical school and going towards surgery, getting less, women particularly. So what do you feel were the drivers behind that positive change and how do we learn from that, both in orthopedics and other specialties?
- 10:14Cat: I think a lot of it is a change in culture in the workplace environment, not just in medicine and surgery, but the idea that we don't accept bullying behaviour anymore. People who deliberately belittle people and make their life difficult and mock them is not accepted anymore. And there's been some great work done through the Royal College of Surgeons through recent years, particularly on bullying and orthopaedics because that was quite a notorious area. And then I think the overall change in culture and I think more women in surgery has made a difference and I don't want to make sort of gender stereotypes but I think in large the attitude of women can be quite different to men. And I think having a more varied workforce with more personalities makes a big difference to that.
- 11:07Historically people tend to employ people like themselves because they feel comfortable with them. So you end up with a lot of people with the same background and the same opinions who will back each other up in the same way and actually having a much more diverse department means that people will challenge you when you act or say in ways that they're not comfortable with and I think really important.
- 11:30Nara: Yeah, 100%. And I think it would be, you know, remiss of us, certainly of me, if I didn't bring up the point that obviously it's two female surgeons talking to each other, which is great. You know, one of the things that still to some degree saddens me is that when you look back in 'ninety two, which was, you know, before I started med school, but certainly sort of going into that arena, you know, female surgeons were less than 3%. And at this point in time, I think it was last done in 'twenty three, was only up to just around fourteen percent. So it's still a long way to go.
- 12:04If we're going at this rate, it's going to take us like, you know, another twenty five years to get anywhere near parity. What has your journey been like in terms of choosing surgery? You know, as a woman and, and positives, negatives, and importantly learnings and how, how was, how was that for you? And now that you're sort of obviously a very senior trainee about to, you know, get into a consultant substantive position, how do you look back on that?
- 12:37Cat: I have to say, I don't know if I've just been very lucky with the people that I've had interactions with in the departments I've been in or whether I'm just not that observant and people have made comments that I've not picked up on. And actually I don't always read people very well so it's quite possible people have made disparaging comments that I have just not noticed and let go. It's weird you say that because when I first started surgical training apparently anaesthetist made a comment about me during an operation and I was busy operating and was completely oblivious to this. But the surgeon, the consultant I was with made them come and apologise to me afterwards, even though I hadn't actually heard what they said. But I was really touched by that, that they'd heard someone say something that they thought was inappropriate.
- 13:25And they said, first of all, that's not on, but also you must go and apologise. And I think a lot of it is other people standing up for you moments like that are not just about gender but in race and all that sort of thing as well that when you hear something that's inappropriate that you will stand up for the people around you and not just let it happen.
- 13:45Nara: Yeah, there's something very strong about that because it actually sends a signal and that person who would have made that comment is not going to make that comment again. They probably are not going to have a personality transplant and they may think it, but at least they're not going to be saying it. And, and, and I think one is obviously just what people say and think, and that comes with it. And then there's the cold, harsh reality of actually saying, I also would like a family and all the other, time pools and commitments that come with that. Talk us through a little bit around how that journey was for you.
- 14:24You know, three kids is, is quite a nice number of kids, right? That that's a busy, busy household. You know, and, yeah, tell us a bit about that and how, you know, the highs and lows and to be honest, you know, advice, you know, it's one of the things I certainly remember at medical school, I asked someone, you know, what do you want to do? And we're talking about this and she said, I'm not gonna be a surgeon because I want to have a family. And I remember being so shocked that this was, they'd cut themselves off even before we, you know, got anywhere, nip, scalpel.
- 14:54So yeah, so how has that been for you? What worked? What didn't work? What were the pain points? I'm there were many and what advice do you think you'd give to someone else coming through?
- 15:06Cat: So I'd always known I wanted a family and that I wanted to have children so that that was an easy decision. And a lot of people think that you can plan these things and decide when it's going to happen and sometimes you just need to get on with things and let things happen. And I'd actually wanted to have children much earlier but haven't met the right person. And I should probably declare both my parents are actually surgeons. So my mum is a now retired O and G consultant and she said to me Cat look get yourself a registrar number first because then you've got job security and although I wanted to have kids earlier that's how it ended up happening And she was completely right.
- 15:54There's no stress about having to reapply for jobs once you've got a training number. You're fully protected in your job. I had the opportunity to work part time with no questions asked whatsoever. I have to say I had a very supportive training programme director who when I said I wanted to work 50% after my first child was born, which is the lowest you can do and retain your training post, said that's fine, you know it's going to take your training longer, I don't need to tell you that, you can do And then I had colleagues in other rotations who had children and wanted to be part time and they were like oh no you can only do 80% that's the only option and they had a real fight trying to find that work life balance whereas I was sort of allowed to carve my own path and I was very well supported in that actually. And it is shocking what some people say to you.
- 16:52I sometimes teach students surgical skills to students and I remember one female surgeon who was a junior trainee saying oh my goodness I can't believe you're a surgeon and you've got children and I was like yeah it's totally normal what's the issue? She's like I didn't think it was possible and I asked her why I? And she said oh well one of our lecturers at university said that you can't have a family as a woman and have children and was like oh were they a surgeon? She went no what were they? They were GP and I was like well how on earth would they know whether you can be a surgeon and have a family?
- 17:29And I have to say I think I think my job being a surgeon in a hospital is much better than my colleagues who are GPs. Being a GP at the moment is an extremely hard job.
- 17:44Nara: Really hard to get humbled from every which way at the minute.
- 17:47Cat: Absolutely they're ridiculously overworked and you have to know everything about everything and everyone only wants to complain about you. Whereas I turn up and do my job and then I go home and I have very little work to do at home because I do it all at work. I have great colleagues and I think the pressure from the hospital is less than it is in a GP surgery and I think I probably work less hours than my colleagues in GP. So actually I think someone saying don't be a surgeon because you can't have the work life balance is total rubbish. If you're organised you can do absolutely whatever you want to do.
- 18:28Nara: Yeah. And there's definitely a piece around, the osmotic effect. So, we had, you know, if we have a really, really good role model, certainly ENT, we had a very good role model as a female surgeon in a particular subset of ENT. And then you found a lot of other women went into that subspecialty with an ENT. So the role modelling piece absolutely works.
- 18:52And I think that visibility absolutely works, and you can, and you can, you can advocate for that. But it is hard, right? When they are, particularly when they're quite small, obviously it all comes with challenges throughout that. And obviously this is about you, but no man or woman is an island and, and there definitely is a piece around that support system around you. You know, your partner, your, you know, friends, family, etcetera.
- 19:25How did you manage to kind of work that? Because of course, you know, you've got to pull in your army, right? You've got to pull in as much as you can and there's a piece around actually admitting that we can't do it all, all of the time and neither were we meant to.
- 19:41Cat: Yeah and it's different for every family and every individual about what you've got available. So for us basically my first daughter didn't sleep and she went for a phase where she woke up every twenty minutes for like a year and a half. Oh wow!
- 20:00Nara: And the worst of a pause.
- 20:02Cat: I'll be honest she's still, God bless her, she's still terrible at sleeping but now she's 10. But so my parents live far away so good for holidays, no use for day to day stuff. But my husband was very supportive and is and always has been a really involved and active dad. So between us we would you know we'd have a plan and we'd take it in turns over who would look after the kids when they wake up at night, would get to have a lion on which day. So it was very even and we very much worked as a team with our childcare.
- 20:38When the kids were all little we had a nanny and we're very lucky to be in the financial position where we could do that because actually paying her salary and her tax was more than I earned. Actually it's
- 20:55Nara: very I recognise much my this degree very well.
- 20:58Cat: Yeah I spoke to my parents about this and they said oh yes when you were little we had to take out a loan to pay for a nanny knowing that we'd be able to pay it back once you started school and we were consultants. So we were able to scrape things together but we you know, my salary entirely went on childcare for sort of four years probably.
- 21:22Nara: Yeah. And I think that's the thing, isn't it? You've got to invest in yourself, in your career as a So, team and going to now that you're coming out to the other end with CCT, what, what, what's your hopes and dreams in terms of what you want your consultant life to look like? And by the way, for those who are sort of untrained in the whole UK sort of post graduate medical training system, of course, you go through these foundation year core higher surgical training, and then you become a consultant. And for years, until you were a consultant, which by the way, it may have been in your early forties, by the time you've done a and taken time out and had children, you were called a junior doctor, which kind of, we know other, you know, no other, professional field are you called a junior anything when you're as highly trained as, as that with twenty some years of experience behind you, but yes, but what does it look like for Cat as to, you know, this is what I'd like to be when I'm, you know, a consultant surgeon?
- 22:17So
- 22:20Cat: my ideal place of work would be a relatively busy hospital. You know I like to keep myself busy but I think the most important thing is actually the culture of the department and I've said this to other places before like I commute quite far from my present job and actually I've always commuted quite far and I think it is absolutely worth it for working somewhere with the right culture. And I've worked in some places where honestly if an ambulance took me there I would crawl to another hospital they were so terrible. So I'd be very picky when I eventually come to applying for consultant jobs and I know that's a little bit of an arrogant thing to say but I think for the rest of your working life I would, I think it's very important about the not just the doctors but the whole hospital so the management structure there, how you're treated as a human being and as an employee is really important. Do find a lot of people still make gender assumptions about things when you're a consultant.
- 23:29I don't know if you saw last week but the Royal College published an article about the number of female surgeons in private practice. And I don't know if it's right or wrong but I don't necessarily read that and see it as a gender issue. I've got no interest in private practice. I enjoy spending time with my children and my family and I've got hobbies that I want to carry on with and no amount of money is going to make me give that up.
- 23:58Nara: And
- 23:59Cat: a lot of my colleagues assume as well that once you're a consultant you're interested in private practice and actually I'm interested in having a job that I enjoy and a family life that I enjoy and that's important for me is having that balance. I don't want a job that I hate and I don't want to go home and be miserable.
- 24:19Nara: Yeah 100% and actually as you say it's as with everything in medicine it's about people you know, And who you're working is that conducive to your, growth and happiness in terms of professional fulfillment? Cause by the way, we give so much more at work than what we're paid to do and has, and have always done. Nobody goes into medicine. I hope you agree with this statement for the money, know, you're,
- 24:45Cat: you're not here.
- 24:46Nara: Yeah. You know, and, and actually, which brings us to the, to the last topic, which is essentially the role of social media and, and medicine or rather where those two overlap. There's so much out there and I'm sure you get asked as well. I certainly do on a daily basis about some of the stuff people read online And they get so much quote unquote advice, online. As you know, UDOC was set up in order to give verified sound information that you can trust, and taking out all the other noise that surrounds.
- 25:23So what's your thoughts on the role of, social media in serving that information piece, both to within medicinesurgery, but also how we interact with the public and people looking just for information or actually looking for advice.
- 25:42Cat: Yeah, I think finding information that's real and that you can trust through social media can be really difficult. And certainly I get a lot of patients saying oh I've seen this and like I'm afraid that's total nonsense. And I also see I see a lot of fake ads so companies advertising things even claiming that they've been authorised by this medical society or whatever. I read that I think this is total nonsense as well. And our patients read that and think it's a reliable source and it's not.
- 26:17So I think finding true and reliable information is really difficult. And we and our patients don't necessarily know what you can trust.
- 26:30Nara: Yes. Yeah. Trust is a really important word, isn't it? And it's very, very difficult because a lot of what's out there is sort of almost financially fiscally driven. So people are looking for the clicks, they're looking for the eyeballs.
- 26:43And so the more, I don't want to use the word extreme, but the more sort of out there that opinion is, the more it drives engagement. And that is probably inversely related to how trustworthy or verifiable it is. What do you do in terms of, getting involved? Cause you know, for a very long time, certainly initially when sort of Facebook and some of this social media interaction started, a lot of doctors, this is going back twenty years or more now, were like, this is just not our field. This is, this is, you know, a wild west out there.
- 27:14We're not engaging. I think those days quite rightly are long gone and people are engaging. What do you think is the best way to engage with it? If you're a medic or a doctor and what do you do? What have you found that's worked for you?
- 27:29Cat: Yeah so I mostly use from a medical point social media to get and give advice from other doctors, particularly the specialties who might be quite niche or finding contacts in other hospitals to try and make connections for patients or other people looking for advice. But like of the difficulties with social media is you can't always tell who it is that you're speaking to and whether they're legit. And it comes back to the trust issue really. And I do enjoy that so I've made contacts with people through social media that I find really useful in terms of advice for me and my patients and I've given advice to other people in the same way. But finding something that is you know it's reliable and so I'm in a couple of groups that are meant to be just doctors and you can feel it's a safe space sometimes for having a clinical discussion, and asking advice, but you can't do that on an open platform really.
- 28:37Nara: Yeah, yeah. A 100%. And how do you think people will look at what's out there? How do you think it's going evolve in the say next five years, ten years is probably a little bit too long time to look at it because, you know, people are getting more and more comfortable about getting that information and guidance online. You know, what will be our role as medics, as doctors, you know, will AI put us out of a chat GPT put us out of a job?
- 29:06Cat: Yeah. I think when I look at a lot of stuff online, I sometimes find it difficult to work out what is self promotion by the person posting it and what is information that's actually useful to me. In medicine a lot of people will post things and I look at it and think is this real or are you just promoting your own service or your own name? So sometimes finding things that are useful without a person's ego in there as well can be quite difficult.
- 29:42Nara: Definitely.
- 29:43Cat: I think in terms of the future AI is both a great benefit and a real threat at the same time in terms of what like we're talking about truth and trust that it does make it very difficult to know what's real and what isn't when you're watching videos and even posts that aren't even written by a person, they're written by a bot because they've seen that you've clicked on things similar to this before and then you read it and see the picture or the video and you think, hang on, this isn't real.
- 30:12Nara: Yes. Yeah. Yeah. I think that's going to be, that's going to be a real challenge. And, I don't know if you agree with the statement, but I feel it's medicine at its very heart.
- 30:21It's about humanity, right? It's allowing, and I always say it's the greatest privilege to look after people at their most vulnerable, you know, it's incumbent on us to be the best that we can be possibly because, know, they're in pain, they're in distress and, you know, and we are in that space where actually the vulnerability is at its most and, and that's a human thing, you know that's a trust thing.
- 30:53Cat: Of the best things about my job and actually one of my favourite things is not when people say oh you did a great operation' or anything like that it's when people say things like 'thank you for taking the time to listen to me'
- 31:03Nara: or
- 31:04Cat: you explain that in a way that no one's bothered to do before. It's those sort of comments that really make my day as the human interaction, not, not the bigger things that people think that it is.
- 31:15Nara: Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it? Cause they, they assume rightly that, that we, we have competence as, as surgeons. Is that, it is that kindness, which I know is slightly an overused word, when actually you feel it, particularly at moments of vulnerability, it's, it's sort of transforming. And that's, that's, that's wonderful. Beautiful.
- 31:37Thank you so much, Kat. I really, really enjoyed this and I loved, I loved talking to a fellow female surgeon because I think, yes, there's still not enough of us, but it's yet, not yet, but it is, you know, I think incumbent on us to sort of shape, shape the next, the next round, you know, and you know, how would that looks like, etcetera. And, and thank you for so much for letting us know how you see the social media evolution and yeah, and thank you for the time.
- 32:03Cat: Thank you for having me. It's been a really interesting conversation.
- 32:06Nara: Thank you, Kat.