Latest / No Way Out / Why Ukraine Adapts Faster: Revolution in Military Affairs & the Real OODA Loop | Fred Stein
Transcript
- 0:00Fred Stein: Normally, generally usually, uh RMAs consist of an uh and they don't have to start with a technological advance, but they generally do.
- 0:10Fred Stein: But then they have to be boistered or linked with a doctrinal uh change and a organizational change.
- 0:19Fred Stein: And when I look at the Ukraine, uh it's harder to look at it at Israel and even harder to look at Iran.
- 0:27Fred Stein: But when you look at the Ukraine, uh they've done some interesting organizational changes that seem to have allowed them to leverage the technology changes uh and and the doctrinal changes required.
- 0:40Fred Stein: And so I think the the question I've been struggling with is why is that so hard for the U.S.
- 0:46John R. Boyd: Well you have maxed entropy and maxed what?
- 0:48John R. Boyd: This order, which is that is called what?
- 0:50John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 0:53John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then there is no way out.
- 0:56John R. Boyd: We want to get a matchup between our actions and our situation to a deal with.
- 1:06John R. Boyd: We have a mismatch, we can't cope, right?
- 1:08John R. Boyd: And there is no way out.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh uh, you joined us about six months ago.
- 1:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: At that time, you identified something.
- 1:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You said that uh let me make sure I get this quote right.
- 1:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You haven't been able to break the code on Ukraine situation.
- 1:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is about six months ago, and I think you're coming around to this, and we may want to talk about that.
- 1:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we have Fred Stein, uh, Colonel Fred Stein with us again on No Way Out.
- 1:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think uh what's happened all this last six months uh globally in the war over in Europe and in Ukraine, uh, what's happening in every you name it, from cognitive warfare to the acceleration of artificial intelligence.
- 1:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have one of the uh creators, authors of network-centric warfare.
- 1:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think this is probably the most overlooked book in the world.
- 1:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is the foundation, in my opinion, to what many organizations understand as agile.
- 1:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Last time Fred was here, we had a conversation about the the linear oodaloop.
- 2:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, we just before we started recording, we start talking about how we think doctrine got the OODA loop wrong.
- 2:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the OODA loop, had we had it correct back then, we would be so much further than we are today when it comes to artificial intelligence, teamwork, leadership, warfare.
- 2:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and Fred, welcome back to the show, man.
- 2:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How you doing?
- 2:20Fred Stein: I'm well, I'm well, thanks.
- 2:21Fred Stein: Just returned from my, and this is an age comment, 60th high school reunion, which is a interesting few of the classmates were there.
- 2:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I I I I don't know, I don't know how to comment to that.
- 2:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'd uh if I was a comedian, I would say something, but I'm like six you said sixty, not six.
- 2:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Six six zero, yeah.
- 2:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 2:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Wow.
- 2:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 2:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Wow, fantastic.
- 2:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, thanks for being here again.
- 2:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know you're uh dialing in from uh you're you're down in Texas, right?
- 2:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, near right near Austin, a place called Georgetown, my wife's home.
- 2:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That place is booming too, right?
- 2:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got a lot of growth over there.
- 2:56Fred Stein: Yeah, yeah, Georgetown.
- 2:57Fred Stein: It was 5,000 when we got married in 1971, and it's over 100,000 now.
- 3:03Fred Stein: But the good news is it has good golf courses, so it's okay.
- 3:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Perfect for you, right?
- 3:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 3:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's talk about the uh evolution of network-centric warfare, you know, going back many years and then bringing it forward to today.
- 3:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh you gave me some slides, I can share those with the audience if we want to.
- 3:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just just kind of steer me around on where you want to go today.
- 3:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll have a conversation and I'll I'll uh either amplify or challenge you on things as we go.
- 3:29Fred Stein: Yeah, I think that's a great idea.
- 3:30Fred Stein: So I think the first thing that I've been thinking about or rethinking about, and and I gave a class I I teach at the senior university of lifelong learners in Georgetown.
- 3:41Fred Stein: And I gave a series of classes on revolution in military affairs, and I became more and more convinced that we are in one when we combine artificial intelligence, uh, quantum computing, and and drones, which I which I would suggest is merely a delivery vehicle.
- 4:02Fred Stein: Okay.
- 4:02Fred Stein: But but as the drones then are informed by artificial intelligence and our and the algorithms are potentially done by by uh quantum computing.
- 4:10Fred Stein: And so the first thing I think that interests me is how are we doing in the basic question of what happens in a revolution military affairs.
- 4:21Fred Stein: Normally, generally usually, uh RMAs consist of an uh, and they don't have to start with a technological advance, but they generally do.
- 4:33Fred Stein: But then they have to be boistered or linked with a doctrinal uh change and a organizational change.
- 4:42Fred Stein: And when I look at the Ukraine, uh it's harder to look at it at Israel and even harder to look at Iran.
- 4:49Fred Stein: But when you look at the Ukraine, uh they've done some interesting organizational changes that seem to have allowed them to leverage the technology changes uh and and the doctrinal changes required.
- 5:03Fred Stein: And so I think the the question I've been struggling with is why is that so hard for the U.S.
- 5:08Fred Stein: I went back and uh I don't have a slide on this, but I'm gonna do that.
- 5:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, can I can I share a thought here?
- 5:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because the last time you were on here, and we we were talking about the 70s when the F-14 and you know, we were talking about the uh Og9 radar uh for six years or five years, these aviators are flying around with this bubble, this situational awareness that that uh no one else had.
- 5:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And our doctrine, I think, if I remember correctly, took about six years to catch up to the technology.
- 5:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that the same thing you're talking about right now?
- 5:35Fred Stein: Is is Yeah, exactly.
- 5:37Fred Stein: I think I think doctrine, and I'm gonna conclude just because it's easier.
- 5:44Fred Stein: When I say doctrine, doctrine leads to the development of tactics, techniques, and procedures, uh, although it's a lesser form of it, if you will.
- 5:52Fred Stein: But until you get the TTP's tactics and techniques and procedures and doctrine aligned with the new technology and organizations.
- 6:03Fred Stein: Uh and the larger the countries are and the more complex the their their their services are, the harder they seem to be able to be in challenged to do this.
- 6:16Fred Stein: Uh uh the last time I was in MITRE Corporation before I retired completely, I took part in NIE's uh the series of experimentations down at Fort Bliss.
- 6:27Fred Stein: And they cost a good deal of money, and they actually found a lot of stuff, but very, very little ever got into the systems.
- 6:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 6:38Fred Stein: Uh and I don't know where we are in that today.
- 6:42Fred Stein: I I don't know if we're continuing how I'm I'm worried about how we introduce these new forms of of uh of technologies.
- 6:51Fred Stein: Experiment, and when I say experimentations, uh gosh, what I'm really talking about is is the ones we used to do in college or high school, i.e., you have a hypothesis, you have a no hypothesis, you conduct the experiment under as rigid conditions as you can, and then you find out what happened.
- 7:11Fred Stein: Then you can move to introducing them into exercises, Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, you know, whatever.
- 7:17Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 7:18Fred Stein: But how do we do the experimentation uh quickly enough?
- 7:22Fred Stein: And then I took a look at at the at the interesting situations in the Ukraine, how they are moving so quickly and how they've uh how they've seeming to broke the uh the bind between testers and acquis and acquirers.
- 7:37Fred Stein: And I don't mean to pick on acquirers or testers, but somehow the acquisition process and the testing process seems to be at odds often with rapid technological innovation, much less doctrinal or organizational changes.
- 7:55Fred Stein: So those are my initial thoughts uh going in.
- 7:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now that's consistent.
- 8:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here, you know, we had the Defense Innovation Unit stand up, uh, which to me is really just a brokerage.
- 8:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not an innovation unit.
- 8:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It its purpose in my mind was to accelerate acquisitions, and it's doing a pretty decent job in that.
- 8:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we're yeah, I've been out of the active duty side or that that that world for a while, so I can't really speak to what's happening today.
- 8:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But um I the lessons are clear going back to 20, 30 years ago on organizational agility.
- 8:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, the cycles have to overlap, right?
- 8:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and uh I want to bring something up that you just shared.
- 8:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um in testing today, testing can be happening in actual wartime scenarios.
- 8:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's there's you don't have to create any conditions for it.
- 8:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You could just put it in a scenario now, right?
- 8:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so I know I or I understand some of that is happening uh globally, that some of these new technologies are not necessarily being tested, you know, back at some range in the US, but they're actually being tested uh uh globally at the at the moment.
- 8:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh the landscape has completely changed.
- 8:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um it and and and I think you you kind of warned and and talked about this you know when you wrote about network-centric warfare years ago.
- 9:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh as far as having an expert in the room, uh I I believe, and I may be wrong, is you you saw this coming.
- 9:13Fred Stein: Yeah, I'm afraid we did.
- 9:15Fred Stein: Uh again, the conditions for an RMA is a the technology, and and there's no reason to believe that the U.S.
- 9:22Fred Stein: and its allies uh can't develop technologies as well or better than any country.
- 9:29Fred Stein: Agreed.
- 9:30Fred Stein: Where we seem to have we really be challenged is is do we recognize the use of it?
- 9:36Fred Stein: Give me a I'll give a real quick historical example.
- 9:39Fred Stein: The machine gun was first introduced into combat, as I understand it, against the dervishes in Africa by the British.
- 9:49Fred Stein: The British decided that that weapon was so inhumane that it should not be used against Europeans.
- 9:59Fred Stein: The Germans took the same technology, developed a very similar machine gun.
- 10:05Fred Stein: They were all water cooled at the time and very heavy, put them in units down to platoon or company level, and the British and the French took a year to figure that out.
- 10:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh wow.
- 10:17Fred Stein: And so I just thought it was a fascinating example of a technology that the British proved in Africa, and Craig Churchill said it was inhumane also to use against the the brave, and they were brave dervishers who would who would uh who would rush the machine guns and get cut down.
- 10:35Fred Stein: Uh and yet we ended up with British and and and and French, the first battle of the Somme, with what, 16,000 British killed in a couple of hours with infillet machine gun fire.
- 10:48Fred Stein: So the doctrine and the and the and the organization, they didn't have the organization to put the machine guns where it was supposed to be, and they didn't have the doctrine of how to use them.
- 10:58Fred Stein: I think we're struggling now with doctrine and organizations as the weapons, and I'll I'll I'll make the platform the drone, but but but the drone is now enhanced significantly by AI.
- 11:14Fred Stein: Whether we're in an algorithmic-based warfare or a data-centric-based warfare, I'm not so sure.
- 11:21Fred Stein: When we ran into NCW, people would say when you said that, you took the man out of the loop.
- 11:26Fred Stein: We never intended to.
- 11:28Fred Stein: That was never our intention.
- 11:29Fred Stein: But but certainly data-centric and uh an algorithmic uh warfare seem to move push us even further away.
- 11:38Fred Stein: And so I'm concerned that we have have developed the right experiments and the right idea of how do you modify that organization and the doctrine uh to take these new technologies.
- 11:53Fred Stein: Because I am convinced that the RMA that we're currently living through is a combination of uh drones and AI, probably a little early on quantum computing.
- 12:04Fred Stein: That's has showed a lot of problems for a lot of years, has kind of under underproduced.
- 12:10Fred Stein: So I'm not going to add that one necessarily.
- 12:12Fred Stein: Uh, but but algorithmic warfare, if you will, which is it which I believe is becoming an interesting buzzword.
- 12:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can I share a couple thoughts here?
- 12:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the context in the last few weeks, we've seen uh Newt Gingrich, we've seen others be assigned to uh Project Meridian.
- 12:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um we're seeing a lot of changes.
- 12:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're going from artificial intelligence to superintelligence.
- 12:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so building on what you're sharing right now, one of the and and you know, I have friends that are working in Shield AI, I get to meet with these guys from time to time.
- 12:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh reinforcement learning, these this new capability, um, this vertical launch capability.
- 12:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um here's here's something that I'm I'm noticing is uh we're dealing with closed systems and open systems and treating them as the same, right?
- 12:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so to me, EM theory from fighter aviation from what we got from John Boyd is a closed system approach.
- 13:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can program the heck out of that, and you should be able to beat any pilot, piloted aircraft with a drone if if you if you do things properly, right?
- 13:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because it's a closed dog fighting to me is kind of a closed system uh once you take the human out of it.
- 13:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um but that's not the same loop we're gonna talk about when we're talking about reinforcement learning, um you know, active inference, uh deep learning.
- 13:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: These things look more like the real OODA loop.
- 13:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think what what and this is my view is people get fixated that, hey, this linear large language model that we want to scale scales, you know, you just build more and more of them and you scale, it scales that way.
- 13:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not how open systems work.
- 13:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, they're they're um they're nonlinear.
- 13:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what I'm trying to say is our military, um, even though a lot of us went through JPME and wicked problems and starting to understand complex adaptive systems, I think you know, you guys had a good grasp on this years ago, again, going 20, 30 years ago, and saying we kind of need to know the difference here because if we're going to fight a war in in that domain of complexity, uh, where human the mind is critical in this, we have to understand the difference between a complicated system and a complex system.
- 14:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we can't just run around trying to peanut butter spread one approach to these things.
- 14:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that's kind of what I think we're doing with the podcast is saying this this understanding, doctrinal understanding of John Boyd's Utoloop, this linear four-step approach, is insufficient for what we need to do in this type of world, right?
- 14:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think, again, going back to what you guys wrote years ago and what you're talking about now, is our leaders in the military, again, my my opinion, don't have a full grasp on this.
- 14:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And therefore, I think the right decision, and and you may challenge me on this, is to go outside the system and find people that are actually understanding, you know, learning how to use uh reinforcement learning, um uh active inference, and bring that into the military because we can't do it from within.
- 15:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um anyway, I just want to share that my thoughts with you there.
- 15:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that there's a there's a um there might be a reason why we have to go outside the system, which goes back to your uh often adapted and fully exploited by someone other than the nation.
- 15:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you you can't determine the character of a nature nature of a system from within, you have to go outside.
- 15:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what we're doing right now, and I think it's a good move.
- 15:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, but we have to get outside the system to understand how this war is gonna or the uh RMAs are going to um uh evolve.
- 15:34Fred Stein: Yeah, I certainly think the same.
- 15:35Fred Stein: So when I've asked the question or when I thought about the question of complexity versus uh uh versus complex and complicated, I the easiest way I try to understand it is if I if I have a if I have a complicated problem, I can define that as a problem that I can deconstruct or if we go back to our our times in elementary school and we diagrammed a sentence.
- 16:08Fred Stein: And we diagram the sentence in in in terms of the subject and predicate, verbs, etc.
- 16:14Fred Stein: And we had this little diagram and the diagram flowed out, and everything eventually related back to each other.
- 16:21Fred Stein: No matter how big it was, we could track it down.
- 16:24Fred Stein: When we have a complex system, we start doing that the same way, but before we finish the diagramming of the sentence or the deconstruction, the relationships between the items have changed.
- 16:40Fred Stein: So we're in a constant state of flux of the verbs and the adjectives and the pronouns, et cetera, as they change.
- 16:48Fred Stein: And therefore, we are we are both frustrated, annoyed, uh, and and we can't seem to get our hands around it, and that causes a great deal of frustration.
- 16:59Fred Stein: That also complicates experimentation because experimentation is, as I said, based upon a hypothesis and a no hypothesis.
- 17:06Fred Stein: And so I think we have to be appreciative that we're in a complex environment and we are not going to be able to understand the changing relationships between, if you will, the nodes and the links.
- 17:21Fred Stein: We're just gonna have to live with those.
- 17:23Fred Stein: If we take an example from the Ukraine, as I understand it, and and I give want to give credit, this came from my Wall Street Journal article on 26th September, so I want to be sure I credit them with it uh on the opinion page.
- 17:36Fred Stein: But they talked, they went and talked apparently to the uh individual, the major in charge of the drone warfare in in uh Ukraine.
- 17:45Fred Stein: What was interesting was he he made the claim, whether whether he whether he was being totally honest, I don't know, that 2.5% of the army was accounting for about 30% of the casualties.
- 17:59Fred Stein: And that those 2.5% had very little, if any, military background.
- 18:04Fred Stein: Wow.
- 18:05Fred Stein: I'm not again suggesting that that we go completely that way, but it was an interesting comment uh in it.
- 18:13Fred Stein: And I think somewhere in the latter part of the uh somewhere in the latter part of the of the stuff I sent you, I actually, and and again I want to give credit to Wall Street Journal, I don't want to not do that.
- 18:25Fred Stein: Uh but uh the the major there had yeah, 2.5% of the Ukraine forces makes up this organization that is in charge of both uh of executing on the drone warfare.
- 18:42Fred Stein: Now, I don't know that that number is everybody who's involved in the development of the drone warfare.
- 18:48Fred Stein: But he was the successful grain trader, for instance, uh and which is of course a high volume, uh high-paced occupation.
- 18:57Fred Stein: I traded grain on the open market, but I I know option trading is is is for so we may need to look at people from that kind of background to see what else they can bring to the military uh in in this development process, whether it's the Navy Project Overwatch or the uh uh the the Marine Corps dominant uh dynamics or whatever service is going into it.
- 19:23Fred Stein: Now, it is easier in the Ukraine because it's smaller and they're at war and it's critical.
- 19:28Fred Stein: Yep.
- 19:28Fred Stein: Uh and and uh we're not at war well, we're at various wars, but we're not we're not fighting for our very existence.
- 19:36Fred Stein: And and we have huge organizations.
- 19:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so we have different I'll rephrase that.
- 19:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have different constraints, right?
- 19:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's what's happening right there.
- 19:47Fred Stein: Exactly right.
- 19:47Fred Stein: Yeah, so I I don't want to say you can you can pick up the the Ukraine and and say, gosh, do that, you know.
- 19:54Fred Stein: Uh but it is interesting that they and and they have been successful.
- 19:59Fred Stein: I mean, I I never thought the Ukraine was actually going to lose immediately as many did, but I have been impressed with the ability they've held off uh the the the the Russia.
- 20:09Fred Stein: I mean, when you think that the trench line in the Ukraine, trench is a bad term, strong point, the strong point line in the Ukraine is longer than the strong point line in World War I.
- 20:21Fred Stein: Wow.
- 20:22Fred Stein: There are more kilometers defended in the Ukraine than there were from the from the sea to the Alps in World War I.
- 20:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you you avoided using the term uh trench, uh, but uh you you go back to uh uh you know second generation warfare.
- 20:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um it's kind of what it looks like combined with uh uh you know uh advanced drones and things like that.
- 20:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And one of the things that uh I think it was in your notes, and I want to go back to the the acceleration of technology.
- 20:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I think you had in there Ukraine updates drone software every two weeks.
- 20:56Speaker 3: Right.
- 20:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and it takes NATO 15 to 20 months to revise doctrine, right?
- 21:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so that's the pace of change we're competing, not competing against, but that's the in the environment at the moment.
- 21:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and I think that came from General Petraeus recently.
- 21:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He he pointed out, and General Petraeus has been on the show.
- 21:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh just just those numbers are staggering.
- 21:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Two weeks to update something, uh, you're learning faster on the battlefield.
- 21:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This goes back to the Tomcat, right?
- 21:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We bring the Tomcat in and we get this radar, we don't know what to do with it.
- 21:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It takes six years for us to figure out how to put distributed capability uh in the fleet.
- 21:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, there's no time for that.
- 21:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our doctrine could actually kill us now, right?
- 21:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could it could it could damage what we do.
- 21:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um but it's just fascinating to see some of those numbers that uh I think it's from that Wall Street uh journal piece.
- 21:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not sure where that came from.
- 21:46Fred Stein: Yeah, and and you know the other quote I thought was was interesting, kind of on the open system, and again, I'm assuming the quote's accurate.
- 21:53Fred Stein: I'm reading from the article.
- 21:55Fred Stein: Uh Ukraine is a symphony that's being perfected.
- 21:59Fred Stein: And our partners, we're teaching the notes.
- 22:03Fred Stein: We can give them the symphony, but they can't appreciate it because they're looking for the best drones or notes, if you will.
- 22:09Fred Stein: By the time those drones run off the the time those drones run off the Western battlefield, it's already been replaced.
- 22:18Fred Stein: Uh and and the one you've got up now is kind of how it works.
- 22:22Fred Stein: I was fascinated that that they and and again you got to take the article at face value, but it they claim at least that all is too inclusive a term, I think.
- 22:34Fred Stein: But obviously a large, large percentage of their drones are actually sending back information over whatever classified system they have, uh and all of it is visible, and and when something is is then attacked, and there's obviously more than one attack at all, you record it in a Google-like fashion and an Uber-like approach to drive the drones.
- 22:57Fred Stein: Again, I thought this was an interesting uh uh this was an interesting explanation.
- 23:02Fred Stein: And then the final bullet on this slide is the delegation of uh of authority, never responsibility, but the delegation of authority.
- 23:12Fred Stein: But I I I they they seem to claim they have achieved a high visibility of their own weapon systems, and they've married it more successfully to enemy situations.
- 23:27Fred Stein: Uh now again, they're dealing with individual or squad-like soldiers, it's a different issue.
- 23:32Fred Stein: But we always had trouble with silos of intelligence sharing information, either because of technological restrictions in the silos and or security restrictions.
- 23:44Fred Stein: Uh real quick story there, and then I'll let you talk.
- 23:47Fred Stein: Uh we had the ability to see wooden-framed uh aircraft invading from North Korea with the radar that was used for artillery, was used for Mortar, Q 3738s, I think they were.
- 24:04Fred Stein: But we we really didn't understand how to use that.
- 24:09Fred Stein: We tried to marry that to other kinds of technology, other kinds of uh detectors, and one of them, one group, I won't say who, but one group said, no, we can't share that with you.
- 24:20Fred Stein: Our engagement loops are too tight.
- 24:23Fred Stein: And I said, I'm not trying to interfere with your engagement loops, I just want the information.
- 24:27Fred Stein: And yet they didn't want to give the information.
- 24:31Fred Stein: They seemed to think that the sharing of the information was going to impact their sensor-to-shooter looping, which is which was a missile thing and had to be quite quick.
- 24:39Fred Stein: I don't know where we are in the ability to do that.
- 24:42Fred Stein: It appears, again, only from this article, that the Ukraine seems to have broken down those silos of intelligence, and then their AARs seem to be effective, i.e., they know what they hit.
- 24:54Fred Stein: Now you're using predominantly, I think, first-person drones, I think.
- 24:58Fred Stein: Uh but increasingly those drones are AI driven.
- 25:02Fred Stein: Your thoughts.
- 25:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 25:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, uh so I I'll build on that here in a moment, but I want to take a look at that last sentence on that on that page we have right there, and ask you ask you this.
- 25:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, when in the in when you guys are writing network-centric warfare, you knew that we needed to push information to the decision makers, those that are actually doing the work or those that are closest on the battlefield.
- 25:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, that's what you just described, that's what I heard you describe just now.
- 25:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it's going on in Ukraine.
- 25:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's you have no choice but to do that.
- 25:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and an enabler for that is technology.
- 25:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think if I remember the way I was introduced to NCW Network Centric Warfare, everybody talked about the technology and not what you do with the information and interactions, right?
- 25:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's where we got we we kind of lost our way uh back back then with NCWs.
- 25:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everybody got fixated on the technology.
- 25:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um what matters here is the process of pushing that information to the warfighter.
- 25:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Technology is accelerating that.
- 26:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm gonna use an example right now.
- 26:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the last few weeks and months, we're we're learning more about Grok bots and um Claude and things like that.
- 26:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're taking the same approach, and I promise you this network-centric warfare, the things that you guys wrote about, the way we talk about Agile, the way we talk about things in the flow system, apply to these systems as well.
- 26:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um going back to a opera the 2.5% causing three, 30% of the uh casualties, uh, and they don't have a military background.
- 26:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's assume that they're flying drones or they're connected in some way of that.
- 26:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um they may be a little siloed at the moment, where their job is to focus on that one thing they're flying or the set of drones they're flying or controlling.
- 26:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, but as technology accelerates and we you can start applying these bots that have interactions, that that information is gonna be shared rapidly across.
- 26:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and and you're gonna start building up individual orientations that understand the bigger picture, right?
- 26:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's what's happening today.
- 27:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh again, I'm I'm not in the military, not holding a clearance, not running around asking questions.
- 27:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I could read things, but this is what you set out years ago and suggested we ought to be doing, and we failed at it, in my opinion.
- 27:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and now we're seeing this happen in in Ukraine where um uh you know, more access to technology, better use of it by the warfighter, uh, by people that may not have military experience but may know technology is game-changing.
- 27:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so AI is a big piece of that.
- 27:34Fred Stein: Yeah, I think I think there are two interesting areas that one, and and again, I'm like you, I'm out of the military for years now and and don't have any class fight, don't want to have any classified with you.
- 27:46Fred Stein: Uh but it's clear that the censor to shoot a loop, for instance, uh in the Iran current conflict has been pretty good.
- 27:56Fred Stein: Uh we seem to pick up on boats leaving uh harbor sort of thing, uh small boats trying to attack, lay mines, and so forth.
- 28:04Fred Stein: Uh we are operating in a contested environment.
- 28:07Fred Stein: Uh uh we're obviously using a lot of our fairly expensive uh munitions.
- 28:12Fred Stein: Uh we're trying to reduce that with drones.
- 28:15Fred Stein: I don't know what our kill rates are.
- 28:17Fred Stein: Uh they used to be very high, 90-95%.
- 28:19Fred Stein: I think they're lower now.
- 28:22Fred Stein: Uh that's probably because uh the Iranians are receiving assistance from various countries, probably in the EW area or poofing areas.
- 28:31Fred Stein: Uh that, of course, is what you see.
- 28:33Fred Stein: We we saw in the Ukraine uh the Russians uh putting the fiber optics on the tail of their uh their drones so that the uh so they couldn't be jammed.
- 28:43Fred Stein: Uh we even heard that the Russians were using uh horses to draw uh carts uh because the AI wouldn't recognize it as a weapon system.
- 28:53Fred Stein: Uh it does go off tremendous heat signatures, so I'm not sure that really works, but but it is interesting.
- 29:00Fred Stein: The question is, I think in my mind, as this uh as this complex system continues to develop, uh we know AI is capable of semi-autonomous, even to autonomous actions.
- 29:15Fred Stein: Uh and so it it matches X signatures, heat signatures, or IR signatures or visual signatures, and and can can attack the target with or without uh man uh man in the loop.
- 29:29Fred Stein: We see that obviously in some of our own systems today, which don't have time to have man in the loop.
- 29:34Fred Stein: But in the Ukraine, they seem to have developed a way, at least again according to this article, where they record all this footage.
- 29:41Fred Stein: Now, it's terabytes or huge, you know, pega, I mean huge amounts of data are being collected.
- 29:47Fred Stein: Somehow that's got to be uh got to be looked through.
- 29:50Fred Stein: But that's I think where we get the the idea that that uh and I'm still not sure that data-centric algorithmic warfare is the right way to state it, but algorithms are clearly playing an increased role in it.
- 30:04Fred Stein: Uh people would say they didn't see W, the network was at the center of it.
- 30:08Fred Stein: I always felt the network was was that there were, as you recall, sensor networks, information networks, decision networks.
- 30:16Fred Stein: Uh, but we did not have at that time the mathematics, the algorithms, or the tremendous uh data systems where where you ask a question of uh, you know, what what diet should I go on to uh to lose pounds at my age, sort of thing, and you get it right out of uh Claude or Gork or whatever those.
- 30:36unknown: Yeah.
- 30:36Fred Stein: So it it is it is clearly changing the way we we think about uh things on it.
- 30:41Fred Stein: But I I I do think that that we've got to be able to do the doctrine organization piece as well.
- 30:48Fred Stein: It's not just technology, as you point out with the uh with the story about the radar.
- 30:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I know you have some uh like case uh studies from the past.
- 30:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can we share some of those on how these connect?
- 31:00Fred Stein: Yeah, yeah.
- 31:00Fred Stein: So uh the the two there were three countries that developed carriers during World War II.
- 31:08Fred Stein: The British actually had the first carrier, but once again, they like the machine gun, they they didn't figure it out.
- 31:15Fred Stein: Uh arguably the the Japanese and the Americans got it right.
- 31:20Fred Stein: Uh, but carriers were the paradigm shift.
- 31:23Fred Stein: I mean, uh before World War II, at least in some camps, the battleship was still the key uh weapon uh from Jutland in World War I uh forward.
- 31:33Fred Stein: Uh and and the Yakamoto got got sunk on its way to Okinawa, which is gonna prove by the way, they were gonna beach that and use it as a uh as an artillery piece.
- 31:43Fred Stein: Uh but but the extension of range for both engagement and reconnaissance made the carrier what it was then and and still is today, with some questions, I suppose, today.
- 31:57Fred Stein: But that whole idea that that where did the experiments take place, uh did you armor the deck of it?
- 32:03Fred Stein: There were lots of technological, you had to get a restraining wire, you know, to capture the the aircraft.
- 32:09Fred Stein: I mean, uh they they truly are revolutionary devices.
- 32:12Fred Stein: And of course, you had to develop aircraft, you know, with with these sort of ranges and so forth.
- 32:17Fred Stein: But the Japanese America carriers clearly changed the whole paradigm of war, particularly in the Pacific, if not war in general.
- 32:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's something interesting about this too.
- 32:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In World War II, uh the Japanese kind of had a fixed set of uh number of carriers.
- 32:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They just couldn't produce them.
- 32:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and that's something else that we we had an advantage on, is our ability to mass-produce.
- 32:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Did I can't remember if you have that uh in this uh case study at all?
- 32:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh just our ability to produce outproduce stuff.
- 32:43Fred Stein: Yeah, I I don't, but you're absolutely right.
- 32:45Fred Stein: When when you when you take a look at the Battle of Okinawa, the last major battle, uh there were 20 or 30 carriers.
- 32:54Fred Stein: I mean, we produce carriers at a rate unimaginable.
- 32:57Fred Stein: Now the Japanese knew this.
- 32:59Fred Stein: The Japanese knew that in a long war they couldn't outproduce the United States.
- 33:02Fred Stein: Uh they were actually aware of that very early.
- 33:04Fred Stein: Whether they should have shifted their production more to more to carriers, and and carriers require aircraft, but more carriers require pilots.
- 33:13Fred Stein: Pilot ship trained.
- 33:15Fred Stein: Uh unless it's a one-way mission, differ different, different uh proposition.
- 33:19Fred Stein: Uh but yeah, I I think they just they they knew they were going to be outproduced.
- 33:24Fred Stein: Uh I think that was pretty clear early.
- 33:26Fred Stein: Uh but when you look at Okinawa, uh I mean we had more carriers there than than uh in one in one fleet.
- 33:34Fred Stein: It wasn't even our only fleet.
- 33:36Fred Stein: A huge, huge thing.
- 33:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, it's a it's a good parallel to what's happening here.
- 33:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So many other lessons to pull aside, and I'll go back to the pilots thing.
- 33:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you know, the the the fact that we rotated pilots back to train other pilots is is huge because that information or the knowledge transfer is is is essential in in warfare.
- 33:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I this goes back to the the point about Ukraine.
- 33:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh that knowledge or information transfer is critical too.
- 34:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, how how fast can we move the information around a system?
- 34:05Fred Stein: Yeah, and and I think uh I think you're using the right term, which is why I'm a little concerned with the concept of data.
- 34:11Fred Stein: Uh data is useless unless it's combined with with uh with experience to produce information.
- 34:19Fred Stein: So you've you've got to have information, not just data.
- 34:22Fred Stein: Now, if you're sending time or location data to a drone, that's fine.
- 34:29Fred Stein: But somewhere, the hue somewhere you've got to get it into information.
- 34:34Fred Stein: And the one you the the slide you're showing now sort of goes back to how long ago new technology chariots were a big deal in in the first battles, the first major carrier uh chariot battles, cannot carry a chariot battle in Egypt with each side.
- 34:52Fred Stein: And each side, the Babylonians or the Assyrians and the Egyptians had different chariots, by the way.
- 34:57Fred Stein: They were constructed differently, uh, they looked different, and they had different capabilities, even though they were both drawn by horses that had people on them.
- 35:05Fred Stein: They saw them differently.
- 35:06Fred Stein: Uh the longbow uh stirrups is one that sort of gets gets a short shift, but without stirrups, you really don't control horses.
- 35:14Fred Stein: Uh so all of these new technologies required new organizations.
- 35:19Fred Stein: Uh uh does a tank require infantry backup sort of thing.
- 35:24Fred Stein: Uh but this was just an example of those areas.
- 35:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you also have this one here.
- 35:31Fred Stein: Yeah, so this one again talks that if you don't understand the technology, if you haven't integrated it into how you fight.
- 35:38Fred Stein: Now that's a good question because how you fight may be dictated by the technologies.
- 35:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There you go.
- 35:46Fred Stein: And and I think we have trouble making that so doctrine is is key.
- 35:50Fred Stein: The Russians once said the American doctrine is so good because we don't have any.
- 35:55Fred Stein: Uh not quite sure that's absolutely true.
- 35:58Fred Stein: Uh but but at the tactical, at the tactical level, the employment of the weapons has to be has to be understood.
- 36:06Fred Stein: I think, again, that's a lesson we can take, not wholesale, but unless we take from the Ukraine.
- 36:11Fred Stein: Uh uh the the coordinated attack to Britzkrieg, uh which was really the combination of what?
- 36:18Fred Stein: It was a combination of radios light enough and powerful enough to put in aircraft, ground units that could communicate for air-to-ground support, tanks that could communicate with infantry and artillery.
- 36:30Fred Stein: That's what made Britzkrieg work.
- 36:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's add one more thing.
- 36:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Methamphetamine.
- 36:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's uh uh that's something that isn't in our books, but uh we we discovered recently that um so a high flow state, which is you can't sustain, um, you you need some recovery.
- 36:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's just like a flight deck of an aircraft carrier.
- 36:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can't fly off it all for five days in a row.
- 36:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You just can't do that.
- 36:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have to recover.
- 36:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Humans are we humans are are are I would hate to call it the long poland attempt, but we're a critical note in there that uh we need rest, right?
- 36:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's something that uh uh methamphetamines didn't really provide to the uh Germans.
- 37:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but I want to throw that in there because we've had a guest on here that that wrote about that and was um an interesting piece.
- 37:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 37:10Fred Stein: It w it was very real, but all the way from Poland on.
- 37:13Fred Stein: And then of course we've done that in special forces of Vietnam.
- 37:15Fred Stein: I'm using using stimulation drugs of whatever type.
- 37:19Fred Stein: The the Germans, of course, ended up using some that became very addictive and very harmful to their forces.
- 37:24Fred Stein: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 37:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you brought up something here that kind of makes me think about Iran.
- 37:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and that is maybe Iran doesn't have the technological advantage that we do.
- 37:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't need it.
- 37:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um we they can't produce the things we can do, they can't do it.
- 37:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But they have another advantage, and that that is our one of our weaknesses, I would say, is our um dependence on high-tech, right?
- 37:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So buying a Pac-3, uh buying SM6s, you know, all these things cost a lot of money.
- 37:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh a T Lamp costs a lot of money, but you know, inexpensive um ballistic missiles, um, hidden in mountains, uh, building, you know, having many years to build up that capability, uh, you don't need to have a in I'm gonna say in parody, in technological parity.
- 38:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um you don't have to have that parity in technology to be able to compete in this environment, right?
- 38:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 38:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I I think the two examples of that.
- 38:20Fred Stein: Uh and again, I don't know this for fact, but I've been told that the Iranians were particularly interested in a exercise that the U.S.
- 38:30Fred Stein: Navy ran some years ago where a retired admiral uh used small ships to overwhelm uh some American uh ships on it.
- 38:40Fred Stein: And and the story goes, the story goes, I wasn't present, that the exercise was actually stopped because it was too effective.
- 38:48Fred Stein: Now, whether or not they got that lesson or not, I don't know.
- 38:52Fred Stein: It's a very real lesson.
- 38:54Fred Stein: Uh and it it it talks about operational level.
- 38:59Fred Stein: The the slide you got up there is sort of an arms that there's a tactical level war where we're actually using the weapons as best we can, the new weapons.
- 39:06Fred Stein: There's also the operational level, which says I'm analyzing my enemy from a from a from an intelligence perspective.
- 39:15Fred Stein: I know my restrictions.
- 39:16Fred Stein: How can I, what can I do?
- 39:19Fred Stein: Uh operating small boats out of caves that are only present when they leave the cave makes the targeting of them difficult, either whether whether they're laying mines or shooting short-range missiles at tankers.
- 39:31Fred Stein: Uh clearly that's an asymmetrical use of modern warfare.
- 39:36Fred Stein: Those could be drones in the future.
- 39:39Fred Stein: I think they're actually manned uh boats now and they're actually firing things.
- 39:43Fred Stein: Now they do have to uncover, and that's their that's the engagement period that we're looking for.
- 39:48Fred Stein: But an example on the bottom one, I happen to have thought the Mongolian was some of the finest uh armies in the world, people don't study them enough.
- 39:59Fred Stein: They would spend a year or two scouting out the pasture lands that they were going to use the next year because they traveled on horses.
- 40:06Fred Stein: And if you don't have pastures, you don't have fodder.
- 40:09Fred Stein: You don't have fodder, you've got starving horses.
- 40:12Fred Stein: Kind of the same thing.
- 40:13Fred Stein: We've got a situation now.
- 40:15Fred Stein: Uh you got weapons, you can't produce them in time.
- 40:18Fred Stein: So, what is the operational level?
- 40:20Fred Stein: What is the linkage of the battles?
- 40:23Fred Stein: And I'll give one other quick historical example and then it go.
- 40:27Fred Stein: But I was a student at Army War College, I studied under J.
- 40:30Fred Stein: Luboss, who was since passed wonderful historian.
- 40:33Fred Stein: And I was at the uh I was at uh in the Civil War Battle of Fredericksburg, uh the South was getting uh its way, the North was attacking uphill, what was successful, very unsuccessful.
- 40:47Fred Stein: But allegedly uh at that stage, Lee said, I'm looking across a Rappahannock and I'm detail and I'm figuring out the next battle, which would have been Antietam.
- 40:58Fred Stein: So he was thinking in time and space beyond that one.
- 41:01Fred Stein: So an operational level war or a series of campaigns.
- 41:05Fred Stein: And have we, and I'm not being not being difficult with any administration or any group, but have we thought through the series of battles in terms of a campaign?
- 41:16Fred Stein: Enemy always gets a boat.
- 41:18Fred Stein: Uh, that's got to be then linked to these new technologies, because I think we're in a cycle where technology can change so quickly that it impacts tactics and impacts operational levels at a greater speed of command.
- 41:31Fred Stein: And I'll leave it with this, because speed of command said you're trying to get inside your enemy's UDLU.
- 41:36Fred Stein: In fact, the the appropriate podcast, obviously.
- 41:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, that's huge.
- 41:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh years ago, uh so just some background.
- 41:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I worked um as a map chief and a deputy combat uh plans division chief in the Air Force.
- 41:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm a Navy guy, right?
- 41:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I got to go through all that training.
- 41:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh for those of you who are not familiar, uh airspace schema maneuver, which includes cyberspace for you know what is happening over in Iran, how do you coordinate all the air aircraft, the the weapons that are above the ground, anything that's flying a couple hundred feet off the ground and higher?
- 42:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you do that?
- 42:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that was my job, right?
- 42:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I had to understand weapons.
- 42:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I had to go through integrated air and missile defense, Aegis weapons.
- 42:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I went up to Dahlgren um and spent a week and a half up there.
- 42:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so what I learned back then uh are are the uh things that I'm seeing now uh that that I knew back then.
- 42:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, okay, I I knew how to do that, I knew how to set some of these things up, but nobody wanted to do it.
- 42:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now you have to do it.
- 42:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm not gonna get into specifics.
- 42:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then in and then PACOM, same thing, uh setting up resilience uh capability over there.
- 42:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we fight uh Pacific battle with accelerated technology?
- 42:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you know, um uh how do you do that?
- 42:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and and I'm not gonna say that that drove a lot of the uh way the Marine Corps fights now, uh, because I don't want anything to do with that, by the way.
- 42:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but you you you do have to look at how do we fight in the future given what we have today.
- 42:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have to anticipate it, you can't predict it, right?
- 42:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um uh but but where I'm where I'm going with this is the the the war that the wars that we're seeing today, um people that I worked with, we were looking at how to fight like that with some type of asymmetry to get out of our box, right?
- 43:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I hate to say this being a Navy guy, but do we still need carriers?
- 43:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know, right?
- 43:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I mean you got to challenge all assumptions, and those things are damn expensive.
- 43:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you lose one, um that that's pretty significant, right?
- 43:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: E and and um uh just the reports we're hearing out of um what's going on in and around Iran and the number of aircraft carriers.
- 43:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I mean, I live here in Virginia Beach.
- 43:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, my neighbors come back, and these are the guys that are flying in these missions, right?
- 43:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um there there's a lot of things that we can't talk about here, uh, but I want to make sure our our listeners understand that uh uh you know, Fred's experience and my experience, um I I think we were pushing for a deeper understanding.
- 43:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Understanding by our military to see uh hate to say it, but see around corners, to understand that it's not just this mission, but it's the next mission as well, and it how it fits in a bigger, bigger campaign.
- 44:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's hard as hell to do.
- 44:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It really is.
- 44:16Fred Stein: Yeah, I I would I would sort of end with this.
- 44:18Fred Stein: The the strength of our militaries, I think, has always been our exceptional training facilities, uh, whether it's National Training Center in Barstow or JRTC Joint Training Center in Louisiana, or the one in in uh for the Army, the one in uh in in uh Germany, or whether it's Top Gun or or any other.
- 44:41Fred Stein: Those are the places that I hope, and I don't visit them anymore.
- 44:46Fred Stein: I used to visit the NTC regularly, those are the areas where I would hope the innovation loop for material, doctrine, and leadership, or at least material and doctrine, take place.
- 45:00Fred Stein: I'll end it with this.
- 45:02Fred Stein: Uh, and it's not meant to be critical of anybody, but leadership does matter.
- 45:07Fred Stein: And and so if you don't have a hero or somebody who can who can get this thing through, whether it's any one of those RMAs we're showing, there's always a hero in those things.
- 45:18Fred Stein: It was uh uh uh uh uh Admiral Art Sabrowski's clearly was a hero for NCW.
- 45:25Fred Stein: Well-respected carrier pilot, uh F-18 pilot, uh, you know, had all the credentials.
- 45:31Fred Stein: Uh you need those in each of the services.
- 45:34Fred Stein: Uh at the same time, as we suggested, the development of some of the technology may be better left, or at least in coordination with people not in the military.
- 45:45Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 45:45Fred Stein: And and then, as you say, the adjustment of the acquisition and testing community.
- 45:50Fred Stein: You can't just willy-nilly add something to an aircraft.
- 45:53Fred Stein: Bryce, you know that.
- 45:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep, yep.
- 45:55Fred Stein: Your flight.
- 45:56Fred Stein: It's a big deal.
- 45:56Fred Stein: And it should be a big deal.
- 45:57Fred Stein: If you screw it up, somebody dies.
- 45:59Fred Stein: Uh so you've got to have rigorous testing of the are they gonna, oh, I'm gonna add this widgigit to the to the F-35.
- 46:06Fred Stein: Well, maybe not.
- 46:07Fred Stein: Yeah, I mean, not such a good idea.
- 46:08Fred Stein: Uh and so there's got to be that, but we can't have those things standing in the way all the time.
- 46:15Fred Stein: And and I think that's our struggle right now.
- 46:17Fred Stein: I don't know how we're doing it.
- 46:19Fred Stein: I always remain optimistic, uh, but I am concerned on it and and appreciate you giving me a chance to talk about it.
- 46:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, hopefully I have a few more minutes with you, uh, if you don't mind.
- 46:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I so in the last few weeks, uh actually since 17 October, I think um Starlink, uh so uh that's been in the news recently.
- 46:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Ukraine's a little upset about that.
- 46:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um walk me through uh a dependency on an external agency or something else when you're fighting a war.
- 46:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, did you think through that years ago?
- 46:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like um, do you want to have uh do you want to rent time on some type of uh space capability when you're fighting a war?
- 46:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you want to own it?
- 46:53Fred Stein: Yeah, I think I think it's a great question.
- 46:55Fred Stein: Uh one of the discussions, and and I will add, whenever I had a discussion with Admiral Sabrowski, I left the room hoping I understood 20 or 30 percent of what he was trying to convey, because he was clearly at a uh at a level I was not.
- 47:11Fred Stein: But but during that during those discussions, uh do you want the U was it the U.S.
- 47:19Fred Stein: Army uh or Air Force or Navy's Space Command didn't exist in duty to put up all the satellites, or could you leverage a GPS uh constellation Starlink didn't exist in, but but others did.
- 47:34Fred Stein: Uh I think clearly we need dual technologies, and clearly uh industry profit-driven has shown the way of less expensive launch vehicles, recovery vehicles.
- 47:46Fred Stein: Nobody thought you could capture a missile until Elon Musk did it.
- 47:49Fred Stein: Whether you like Elon Musk or not, you have to admit that's a really, really crazy idea.
- 47:54Fred Stein: Uh and it takes visionaries like that.
- 47:57Fred Stein: Uh I I don't know how we uh I don't know how we break that down well enough.
- 48:03Fred Stein: Uh I'll I'll tell you one other thing.
- 48:05Fred Stein: I'm doing a partnership series here at my local senior university, and the last partnership I explored was uh was uh uh Henry Stimpson and George Marshall.
- 48:18Fred Stein: And that was a wonderful partnership that probably changed the course of World War II for the United States.
- 48:25Fred Stein: A bit of one bit of trivia, they never closed the door between the two offices in the newly built Pentagon between the Secretary of War and the Chief of Staff of the Army, or the Secretary of War and the Chief of Staff of the Army.
- 48:40Fred Stein: The door was always open.
- 48:42Fred Stein: It's an interesting thought.
- 48:45Fred Stein: I hope the doors remain open today.
- 48:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I've got something else for you.
- 48:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in the last few weeks, we've seen the Autonomous Warfare Command stand up.
- 48:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've seen uh like if we brought up Project Meridian.
- 48:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um based on what you just shared?
- 49:02Fred Stein: Yeah, they're they're they're new, and and I hope that during the setup or post the setup, and we have the Army Transformation Command here in Austin, I was going to speak to them years ago, and then COVID set in and I never got a chance.
- 49:18Fred Stein: I would like them to all go back to failures and understand why they didn't work as they proceed forward.
- 49:26Fred Stein: So, why did NIE for the Army fail?
- 49:30Fred Stein: Why were small companies almost bankrupt going there?
- 49:34Fred Stein: And why didn't we almost get nothing out of all those experimentations?
- 49:38Fred Stein: So we should look at our attempt to integrate technology quickly and to innovate quickly as we form these two organizations and do an AAR, an after-action review of what went wrong.
- 49:49Fred Stein: Be honest enough to say it went wrong, what happened?
- 49:52Fred Stein: We do that well in combat.
- 49:54Fred Stein: I don't think we do as well.
- 49:56Fred Stein: Uh future combat session, FCS, not a great success.
- 49:59Fred Stein: So we we have a plora, unfortunately, of failed projects, but we also have a plora of failed organizations like NIE, and I use that in the Army, uh, but others that that set out to do rapid innovation, set out to have small companies in in in their way, set out to and they didn't work.
- 50:20Fred Stein: Why didn't they work and what can we learn from them?
- 50:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's critical.
- 50:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I I have a prediction for you if you're ready for this.
- 50:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we're gonna see more organizations that are uh even even SpaceX and Claude and Anthropic and others.
- 50:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh anybody that specializes in an SI, uh superintelligence, uh they're starting to migrate towards or or learn about things that you have in network-centric warfare, what we've already written about, and this goes back to this the solid AARs.
- 50:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, why did we understanding what failed years ago is critical because people feel like they're discovering something new with the way agents are working together, so human agent teaming and agent-agent teaming, so superintelligence, it's not new.
- 51:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and that's what we're trying to say here is there's plenty of lessons to be learned from history and specifically the military, because we we've gone through this.
- 51:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we've we've uh we've had smart people looking at this for years.
- 51:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh just how do we uh you know, how do living systems engage with a changing environment or a competing environment?
- 51:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh other other organizations, agents, actants that have their own OODA loop.
- 51:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we that's all warfare is, in my opinion, is how do we how do we do that with the as the environment changes?
- 51:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think network-centric warfare, and I can't remember how old how old this book is in my hand, uh, but this goes back to the yeah.
- 51:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think somewhere around that period.
- 51:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 51:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Wow.
- 51:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um we we've been thinking about this for years, and I think um uh a lot of the bureaucracy, a lot of the systems, the behaviors, the the um we're talking bigger system behaviors or system um uh constraints.
- 52:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you know, sometimes it's not in the best interest for a company to pursue this type of thinking because they'll be obsolete next week, right?
- 52:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and I would argue that today's companies, if you're looking at what's happening with Claude and Grok bots, um, and you're not learning from what we just talked about and applying that type of thinking towards your organization, there's going to be a small company of five, maybe three people that are going to dominate your company of 400.
- 52:40Fred Stein: You think I'm it's coming.
- 52:41Fred Stein: Uh I'll give the audience one other book.
- 52:44Fred Stein: I think I recommended it before, and unfortunately I don't have the author's name because I can't pronounce it.
- 52:49Fred Stein: But Late L-I-N-K-E-D is an old book now.
- 52:53Fred Stein: It was written by a Hungarian mathematician whose name I cannot recall.
- 52:59Fred Stein: But what he did was attempt to understand the mathematics behind the emerging internet.
- 53:05Fred Stein: And he recognized that the value of the nodes or the distribution of the nodes was not a normal distribution.
- 53:11Fred Stein: It was a power law.
- 53:13Fred Stein: And I can't draw it, but it was a power law.
- 53:15Fred Stein: I would suggest that today the ability to map the nodes on networks and evaluate their worth, and I think their worth is is is equated to the number of connections that are made over a period of time.
- 53:34Fred Stein: So a super node gets more connections than a regular node.
- 53:37Fred Stein: That is important to understand in any organization, but particularly one driven by this.
- 53:45Fred Stein: If you if we are going to this book-like thing with a companion agent on my shoulder doing things all the time.
- 53:53Fred Stein: I've always thought that way.
- 54:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I agree.
- 54:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh there's a couple books on that from uh social physics too, from many.
- 54:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think actually Stanley McChrystal, Journal McCristol, wrote about that in his book, Team of Teams.
- 54:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh again, nothing is is is new here.
- 54:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is understanding complexity theory.
- 54:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think you guys had a good grasp on that years ago.
- 54:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh hey Fred, anything else you want to cover?
- 54:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know, I know we started a little late today.
- 54:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Floor's yours.
- 54:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything you want to look at?
- 54:37Fred Stein: No, I I think it's good.
- 54:38Fred Stein: And I do do appreciate the audience had to wait on it.
- 54:41Fred Stein: It was a bit of a bit of an issue with with with technology.
- 54:45Fred Stein: But I I guess I would simply end it that I remain optimistic but cautious.
- 54:50Fred Stein: And I would I would warn it's too strong a word, but I would I would advise if I had any power to advise the new organizations, be they at the uh at the very senior level or at the service level, go back and try to understand why other organizations like this didn't work so that at least you will make new mistakes and not maybe repeat the old ones.
- 55:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I tell you, one of the things that we're finding right now is focusing on the interaction of the agents, just like the interactions of the humans.
- 55:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's how you build high-performing teams.
- 55:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we know from the military.
- 55:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think many organizations look at it a little bit differently is let's build up these individual capabilities and let the emergence take over.
- 55:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let them, you know, they'll just magically fall into teams.
- 55:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh I I'd have to disagree with that.
- 55:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you actually have it's the quality of the interactions.
- 55:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think there's other many other words for it in technology, but in data science, it's it's you know, it's a context that matters for data, not just the data itself.
- 55:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so there's so again, so many lessons that we could pull from what you guys worked on years ago and bring it forward to today and say this is this this is useful.
- 55:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I am certain uh we're gonna see you back on here soon to talk about things because uh to be honest, uh, I wasn't expecting to hear back from you for about another till next year, but I think what's changed since we've had you on is just unbelievable, right?
- 56:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The acceleration.
- 56:12Fred Stein: That was my feeling.
- 56:13Fred Stein: And again, the the whole idea of of and whether it's data-centric algorithm-based warfare or not, it it still requires information.
- 56:21Fred Stein: You still require putting pieces together, and at least for the foreseeable time, you require a human in the loop.
- 56:27Fred Stein: He may have a companion agent as well.
- 56:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to throw, I want to twist it around a little bit.
- 56:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in sport, there's a lot of data that are driving how teams play, right?
- 56:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: With basketball or football when you make decisions.
- 56:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in fact, I've got a book back around here called Mathletics.
- 56:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Data-driven coaching, right?
- 56:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're going to go off the data.
- 56:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let me give you an example.
- 56:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Recently, coaches have said, hey, we're not going to take mid-range shots in basketball.
- 56:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And they're not necessarily saying that.
- 56:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're just saying that's probably not an optimal shot.
- 56:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, that pisses off people that go, well, that's all I teach is the mid-range shot.
- 57:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not to say you don't take it.
- 57:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's you give an intent, you give a principle of play, and you look at it holistically and say, given these other shots that might be available, which one are we going to take as a team?
- 57:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's the same thing that we're trying to say here is you if data-driven is how do we fight these things or these these, how do we compete in an environment where we have access to information?
- 57:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I'll tell you what, it forces you to change the way you train, coach, and lead, right?
- 57:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's no more about telling people how to do something, and this goes back to mission command, it's setting the constraints in the system so they can learn how to deal with the changing environment.
- 57:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think I think we've kind of lost the plot a little bit over the years.
- 57:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's one of the strengths of the military, is we really had that, at least in fighter aviation and special operations.
- 57:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me be clear about that.
- 57:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not everywhere.
- 57:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That this type of thinking has been around.
- 57:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We learned it, you know, it's it's not new, but this is this is how we believe living systems operate.
- 58:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and you need to challenge assumptions.
- 58:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if you're I'll I'm gonna throw some stupid things out there.
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're punting on fourth down all the time, is that the right decision?
- 58:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I don't know.
- 58:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The data will tell you that, right?
- 58:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you got to get away from I've done it this way my whole life, to looking at what the data are telling us.
- 58:20unknown: No.
- 58:20Fred Stein: And and I I guess I would end with this.
- 58:22Fred Stein: The it's complicated to understand what's happening in Iran today and classified, and it's complicated to understand what's happening in the Ukraine.
- 58:31Fred Stein: The exercise or the the thing I would look at with interest, and I I haven't seen nearly as much written about it, and it's maybe too classified as well, was a Venezuela takedown.
- 58:42Fred Stein: Yeah.
- 58:43Fred Stein: I thought the number of sensors, shooters, real agent, aircraft, uh, people, special agents, et cetera.
- 58:50Fred Stein: Absolutely extraordinary operation.
- 58:52Fred Stein: A lot had to go right for it to work.
- 58:54Fred Stein: It did work.
- 58:55Fred Stein: We we didn't lose some people, we got some people injured, and they performed heroically.
- 59:00Fred Stein: But it was a fascinating example of one that went went better than I think you could hardly ever expect an operation of that complexity to go.
- 59:09Fred Stein: Interesting one.
- 59:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, but it's context, right?
- 59:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Location, technology, advancement of forces, all kinds, it it it it context matters.
- 59:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, the context of Iran is different than the context of Venezuela.
- 59:21Fred Stein: We can't make it.
- 59:21Fred Stein: It's just it's just it's an interesting case study of a lot of stuff going well.
- 59:26Fred Stein: What made that go well?
- 59:28Fred Stein: Doesn't mean if you do it that elsewhere, it'll go well either.
- 59:31Fred Stein: Uh and again, I think our training centers, uh, and I would I would still like to have experimentation centers, but but maybe uh maybe you're right, and we're seeing that in in a in it if NATO and the U.S.
- 59:43Fred Stein: is taking advantage of the, and I think we are, I don't know, of of of the Ukraine forces, and we're certainly con we're certainly, I know, taking advantage of lessons learned on Iraq.
- 59:53Fred Stein: I don't know them, don't need to know.
- 59:55Fred Stein: Uh, but we're certainly learning from I would hope we're continuing to perform aggressive AARs.
- 1:00:02Fred Stein: But again, it's interesting to go back to that article in the Wall Street Journal.
- 1:00:06Fred Stein: A lot of the all that drone footage also constitutes AAR.
- 1:00:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:00:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:00:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep, 100%.
- 1:00:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I tell you what, Fred, I'm gonna keep you on here for a few minutes.
- 1:00:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we'll end it wrap up the podcast for uh now.
- 1:00:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But thanks again, uh, Colonel Fred Stein for being with us on No Way Out, network centric warfare, a lot of great uh lessons and in Fred's history.
- 1:00:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take a look at his work.
- 1:00:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh by the way, Fred, where can our our listeners find find you, connect with you?
- 1:00:34Fred Stein: Well, I hate to be willing, I don't have a Twitter or Facebook.
- 1:00:37Fred Stein: I just have an email.
- 1:00:38Fred Stein: I can put that email at the end if you want.
- 1:00:40Fred Stein: You can put the email.
- 1:00:42Fred Stein: That's the I I hate to say it.
- 1:00:43Fred Stein: I I I don't have a Twitter, I don't have a Facebook.
- 1:00:46Fred Stein: I don't have any though.
- 1:00:48Fred Stein: I I do use AI uh to get recipes and to help my golf game.
- 1:00:52Fred Stein: Uh so you know what more can I say?
- 1:00:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I'm gonna uh so we we use AI to cook around the house, which is awesome to get everything.
- 1:00:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Food's always good, and we're like, this is great.
- 1:01:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we hear you.
- 1:01:04John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:01:06John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple then.
- 1:01:08John R. Boyd: There is no layout.