Latest / StarQuest Media / Benedict XVI on Aliens and the Vatican UFO Claims
Transcript
- 0:00Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is brought to you by the StarQuest Production Network and is made possible by our many generous patrons.
- 0:07Dom Bettinelli: If you'd like to support the podcast, please visit givemysterious.
- 0:11Dom Bettinelli: fm.
- 0:12Dom Bettinelli: You're listening to episode 443 of Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World, where we look at mysteries from the twin perspectives of faith and reason.
- 0:22Dom Bettinelli: In this episode, we're talking about Pope Benedict XVI's Letter on Acts.
- 0:26Dom Bettinelli: Adam, original sin, and aliens.
- 0:29Dom Bettinelli: I'm Dom Bettinelli and joining me today is Jimmy Akin.
- 0:33Dom Bettinelli: Hey Jimmy!
- 0:33Jimmy Akin: Haddy
- 0:34Jimmy Akin: Dom
- 0:35Dom Bettinelli: And folks, be sure to stick around for the end of the episode.
- 0:37Dom Bettinelli: We'll have your feedback on our recent episode number 432 on the Shepherd of Hermos.
- 0:43Dom Bettinelli: But first, in 2014, former Pope Benedict XVI
- 0:48Dom Bettinelli: wrote a private letter about Adam and Eve, original sin, and the possibility of intelligent aliens.
- 0:55Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy recently covered that letter on his other show, the Jimmy Akin
- 0:59Dom Bettinelli: Podcast, and in this episode, we're bringing that coverage to Mysterious World, but we're also adding something new.
- 1:06Dom Bettinelli: For years, some people have claimed that the Vatican has proof that extraterrestrials exist
- 1:11Dom Bettinelli: and that it's quietly preparing the world for the announcement.
- 1:14Dom Bettinelli: Benedict's letter has a bearing on those claims.
- 1:17Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:18Dom Bettinelli: what did Benedict say about aliens?
- 1:20Dom Bettinelli: Was he in a position to know if the
- 1:22Dom Bettinelli: Vatican had proof of them?
- 1:24Dom Bettinelli: And what does his letter mean for the claims that the Vatican is hiding something?
- 1:29Dom Bettinelli: That's what we'll be talking about on this episode of Jimmy Akin
- 1:33Dom Bettinelli: 's Mysterious World.
- 1:34Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:35Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, this episode is going to be a little different from our usual format.
- 1:39Dom Bettinelli: What are we doing today?
- 1:41Jimmy Akin: Well, uh, this is a crossover episode.
- 1:44Jimmy Akin: On my other show, the Jimmy Akin Podcast, I recently did an episode
- 1:49Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:49Jimmy Akin: a letter that Pope Benedict XVI
- 1:51Jimmy Akin: wrote in twenty
- 1:52Jimmy Akin: fourteen to an Italian philosopher of science named Paolo Musso.
- 1:56Jimmy Akin: He wrote it after he'd resigned the papacy and in it
- 2:00Jimmy Akin: Benedict answered four questions that Mousseau had put to him.
- 2:04Jimmy Akin: Those questions dealt with human origins, uh with original sin, and with the possibility of intelligent life on other planets, and all of those are mysterious world topics.
- 2:15Jimmy Akin: We've talked about aliens in religion before
- 2:18Jimmy Akin: in episode 55.
- 2:20Jimmy Akin: I've also thought about doing a whole Mysterious World episode on polygynism, the idea that
- 2:26Jimmy Akin: humanity descends from more than one original couple, so if you'd be interested in such an episode, let me know.
- 2:33Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 2:33Jimmy Akin: in any event, I decided that what Benedict said would be of interest to both audiences, and that's why we're
- 2:40Jimmy Akin: uh
- 2:40Jimmy Akin: presenting that
- 2:41Jimmy Akin: podcast episode on his letter
- 2:44Jimmy Akin: here in full.
- 2:46Dom Bettinelli: Some of our listeners may already be familiar with the podcast episode.
- 2:50Dom Bettinelli: Is there anything new for them in this one?
- 2:52Jimmy Akin: Yes, there is.
- 2:53Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 2:54Jimmy Akin: after the episode on the letter, we'll have a brand new segment that's just for Mysterious World.
- 3:00Jimmy Akin: It deals with what Benedict's letter means for the broader discussion of UFOs or UAPs, and in particular
- 3:08Jimmy Akin: Four claims that the Vatican has proof of extraterrestrial contact and that extraterrestrials exist
- 3:16Jimmy Akin: For anybody who's already uh seen the podcast
- 3:19Jimmy Akin: from the Jimmy Akin podcast, we'll have a link in the show notes that goes straight to the place where the new segment begins.
- 3:27Jimmy Akin: For everybody else, the episode on the letter comes first
- 3:30Jimmy Akin: because the new segment
- 3:32Jimmy Akin: builds on what Benedict says in the letter
- 3:35Dom Bettinelli: Then let's turn to the letter itself.
- 3:37Dom Bettinelli: Here's your original episode on that from the Jimmy Akin
- 3:42Dom Bettinelli: podcast.
- 3:46Jimmy Akin: A 2014 letter from former Pope Benedict XVI
- 3:50Jimmy Akin: has been making the rounds online.
- 3:52Jimmy Akin: He answers some questions about Adam and Eve, original sin, and
- 3:58Jimmy Akin: intelligent aliens.
- 3:59Jimmy Akin: But what he says is gonna make some folks angry.
- 4:04Jimmy Akin: So
- 4:04Jimmy Akin: is the letter real
- 4:06Jimmy Akin: and what does he say?
- 4:07Jimmy Akin: Let's get into it.
- 4:18Jimmy Akin: Hi
- 4:19Jimmy Akin: to folks, we're in our third year of the podcast now, and you can help me keep making it for years to come
- 4:25Jimmy Akin: and get early access to new episodes by going to patreon.
- 4:29Jimmy Akin: com slash JimmyAken
- 4:31Jimmy Akin: Podcast.
- 4:32Jimmy Akin: Recently on X
- 4:33Jimmy Akin: , science fiction author Patrick Abbott posted a 2014 letter that had been written by former Pope Benedict XVI.
- 4:41Jimmy Akin: He also carboned me saying
- 4:43Jimmy Akin: open
- 4:43Jimmy Akin: Jimmy Akin would be interested in this.
- 4:46Jimmy Akin: Indeed, I was interested, and I thanked him for calling it to my attention.
- 4:51Jimmy Akin: Of course, the first question to ask about anything like this is
- 4:55Jimmy Akin: whether or not it's real.
- 4:57Jimmy Akin: It would be easy.
- 4:58Jimmy Akin: for anyone in the world to use a word processor to write a fake letter that says some things that folks won't like, attribute it to Benedict, post it online, and then sit back and watch the sparks fly.
- 5:11Jimmy Akin: So
- 5:12Jimmy Akin: my first job was to see if the letter was even real or not.
- 5:16Jimmy Akin: That meant looking at the people and circumstances connected with the letter.
- 5:21Jimmy Akin: According to the images of it, the letter was written on june sixth,
- 5:25Jimmy Akin: twenty
- 5:26Jimmy Akin: fourteen.
- 5:27Jimmy Akin: That would put it in the period after he resigned the papacy, which he did in February of twenty thirteen, fifteen months earlier.
- 5:36Jimmy Akin: We know that Benedict continued to write after he resigned.
- 5:40Jimmy Akin: In fact, in 2023, a book collecting his post-resignation essays was published titled
- 5:46Jimmy Akin: What Is Christianity?
- 5:48Jimmy Akin: The Last Writings.
- 5:50Jimmy Akin: We also know that he wrote letters, and several of them have been published.
- 5:54Jimmy Akin: Letters he wrote after the resignation that have been published
- 5:58Jimmy Akin: include one from February 2014
- 6:01Jimmy Akin: to the journalist Andrea
- 6:02Jimmy Akin: Tornielli.
- 6:04Jimmy Akin: One from August 21, 2014, to Monsignor Nicola
- 6:08Jimmy Akin: Bucks.
- 6:09Jimmy Akin: One from November 9th, and another from November 23rd of 2017 to Cardinal Walter Branmuler.
- 6:17Jimmy Akin: and won from February 7th of 2018
- 6:20Jimmy Akin: to Monsignor Dario Vegano, who is not the same guy as the nutty former archbishop that became a seat of a contest.
- 6:29Jimmy Akin: In any event, there's nothing implausible in principle with the idea of Benedict writing post-resignation letters.
- 6:35Jimmy Akin: One of the things about this letter is that it's written on a special letterhead.
- 6:40Jimmy Akin: At the top left of the page, it says
- 6:43Jimmy Akin: Benedictus Decimus, Papa
- 6:45Jimmy Akin: Emeritus, or Benedict XVI, Pope Emeritus.
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: On the top right, just above the date, it says Città del Vaticano, or Vatican City.
- 6:57Jimmy Akin: Well, after his resignation, Benedict lived in a monastery in Vatican City, so.
- 7:01Jimmy Akin: that fits.
- 7:03Jimmy Akin: And if he was gonna be writing letters, it would be a good idea to get new letterhead that made it clear he was no longer Pope, and thus that the letter contained purely his private opinions.
- 7:14Jimmy Akin: So
- 7:14Jimmy Akin: that would make sense
- 7:15Jimmy Akin: too.
- 7:16Jimmy Akin: We also see how he signed himself at the end of the letter, which was as Benedetto Sedici, or Benedict XVI.
- 7:24Jimmy Akin: And the good news is that when other letters Benedict wrote were published, some of them were published along with images.
- 7:33Jimmy Akin: That lets us compare the images of this letter with them
- 7:37Jimmy Akin: When we look at the August 2014 letter to Monsignor
- 7:41Jimmy Akin: Bucks, written just two months after the one we're interested in, we see that it has the same letterhead
- 7:49Jimmy Akin: saying
- 7:49Jimmy Akin: Benedict XVI, Pope Emeritus
- 7:52Jimmy Akin: on the left, and Vatican City over the date.
- 7:55Jimmy Akin: When we look at the first page of the twenty
- 7:58Jimmy Akin: eighteen letter to Monsignor Vigano
- 8:01Jimmy Akin: ,
- 8:01Jimmy Akin: we see the same letterhead
- 8:03Jimmy Akin: with Benedict the Sixteenth, Pope Emeritus
- 8:05Jimmy Akin: on the left, and Vatican City on the right.
- 8:08Jimmy Akin: And when we look at the second page, we see that he's also signed himself Benedict the Sixteenth.
- 8:15Jimmy Akin: So
- 8:15Jimmy Akin: all that matches.
- 8:17Jimmy Akin: Of course, this doesn't prove that the letter is authentic.
- 8:20Jimmy Akin: Any document examiner
- 8:22Jimmy Akin: will tell you that you can't establish authenticity by looking at photographs.
- 8:26Jimmy Akin: You have to have the
- 8:28Jimmy Akin: original documents to examine.
- 8:30Jimmy Akin: Someone could have
- 8:32Jimmy Akin: learned about Benedict's letterhead, had a fake batch printed up, and then faked his signature.
- 8:38Jimmy Akin: but we're at least seeing points that are consistent with his known post
- 8:43Jimmy Akin: resignation letters.
- 8:45Jimmy Akin: Now, the letter we're interested in is in Italian, and that's not a problem.
- 8:50Jimmy Akin: We know that Benedict was fluent in Italian.
- 8:53Jimmy Akin: But
- 8:53Jimmy Akin: he was a native German speaker
- 8:55Jimmy Akin: and that left traces in his Italian.
- 8:58Jimmy Akin: I won't go into the details on this
- 9:01Jimmy Akin: because they're really technical.
- 9:02Jimmy Akin: But the letter contains spellings, words, and phrases that suggest it was written by a native German speaker rather than a native Italian speaker.
- 9:12Jimmy Akin: So that checks out.
- 9:14Jimmy Akin: The person the letter was written to
- 9:16Jimmy Akin: is Paolo
- 9:17Jimmy Akin: Musso.
- 9:18Jimmy Akin: He's also the man who released the letter to the public.
- 9:22Jimmy Akin: Musso
- 9:23Jimmy Akin: is a professor and philosopher of science at the University of Insubria
- 9:28Jimmy Akin: and a visiting epistemology professor at a Catholic University in Lima, Peru.
- 9:34Jimmy Akin: He's a member of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence Committee of the International Academy of Astronautics.
- 9:41Jimmy Akin: He wrote a prize-winning essay for a contest sponsored by Oxford University, and he's a twenty
- 9:46Jimmy Akin: seventeen Oxford Fellow.
- 9:48Jimmy Akin: He's quite academically respectable
- 9:51Jimmy Akin: as a result, and he would have a lot to lose if he went around publishing fake letters from the former Pope.
- 9:58Jimmy Akin: That's a notable mark of credibility.
- 10:01Jimmy Akin: A further mark of credibility is the way he released the letter.
- 10:05Jimmy Akin: He didn't just put it on X or his blog or something.
- 10:09Jimmy Akin: In February of 2021, he published a book titled La
- 10:14Jimmy Akin: Vita Extraterrestre, or Extraterrestrial Life.
- 10:18Jimmy Akin: which is a university textbook
- 10:21Jimmy Akin: and contains the letter as an appendix.
- 10:23Jimmy Akin: And it says right on the cover of the book, Con
- 10:26Jimmy Akin: una
- 10:27Jimmy Akin: lettera inedita di Benedetto
- 10:30Jimmy Akin: Sedici.
- 10:31Jimmy Akin: or
- 10:31Jimmy Akin: with an unpublished letter of Benedict the 16th.
- 10:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 10:36Jimmy Akin: they're not trying to hide this.
- 10:37Jimmy Akin: They're putting it right up front.
- 10:39Jimmy Akin: The book was published by Edizione
- 10:42Jimmy Akin: Studium, which is a Catholic academic publisher in Rome
- 10:46Jimmy Akin: that was co-founded by the future Pope Paul VI.
- 10:51Jimmy Akin: and that publishes intellectual titles on the intersection of theology, philosophy, history, and education.
- 10:59Jimmy Akin: So
- 10:59Jimmy Akin: they
- 11:00Jimmy Akin: would have a lot to lose if they went around publishing fake letters by the former Pope, too.
- 11:07Jimmy Akin: Further, the University of Insubria
- 11:09Jimmy Akin: held the presentation of the book, which they also advertised as containing an unpublished letter from Benedict
- 11:16Jimmy Akin: So
- 11:16Jimmy Akin: their reputation was on the line
- 11:18Jimmy Akin: too.
- 11:19Jimmy Akin: And in 2021, Musso
- 11:22Jimmy Akin: gave a presentation at the International Academy of Astronautics about his interaction with Benedict.
- 11:29Jimmy Akin: In the abstract of his presentation, he said, the discovery of other civilizations in the universe would clearly have deep religious implications.
- 11:38Jimmy Akin: Despite this, when I started getting involved in SETI, only very few theologians had seriously reflected about the subject, while there was no official position of the Catholic Church as such, whose attitude could be summarized as
- 11:51Jimmy Akin: wait and
- 11:52Jimmy Akin: see.
- 11:52Jimmy Akin: So
- 11:53Jimmy Akin: one day I wrote to Pope Emeritus
- 11:55Jimmy Akin: Benedict XVI
- 11:56Jimmy Akin: asking for his opinion about some theological issues related with extraterrestrial intelligent life.
- 12:03Jimmy Akin: First of all, of course, whether it can exist
- 12:06Jimmy Akin: from a Christian point of view.
- 12:08Jimmy Akin: On june sixth, twenty
- 12:10Jimmy Akin: fourteen, he sent me a reply letter with some very interesting and open minded
- 12:14Jimmy Akin: considerations, but, being strictly personal,
- 12:17Jimmy Akin: So far I used it only as a reference point for my reflections, without discussing it in public.
- 12:24Jimmy Akin: However, when at the beginning of 2021
- 12:27Jimmy Akin: I decided to publish a university textbook about extraterrestrial life and its culture.
- 12:32Jimmy Akin: cultural implications, I asked him to authorize me to include the letter as an appendix, which he did.
- 12:39Jimmy Akin: So
- 12:40Jimmy Akin: now I finally have the opportunity to present and discuss this historical document
- 12:44Jimmy Akin: where
- 12:45Jimmy Akin: For the first time in history, a pope, although no longer in office, has taken an open position to the possible existence of other intelligent species besides humanity
- 12:55Jimmy Akin: So
- 12:56Jimmy Akin: Musso was given academic talks about the letter.
- 12:59Jimmy Akin: He also gave press interviews about it.
- 13:01Jimmy Akin: With Musso's reputation
- 13:03Jimmy Akin: the reputation of the Catholic academic publisher, the reputation of the university, and the reputation of the scientific association all wrapped up in this.
- 13:13Jimmy Akin: If
- 13:13Jimmy Akin: it turned out that the letter was fake, then it would severely damage all of them
- 13:19Jimmy Akin: and would absolutely destroy Musso
- 13:22Jimmy Akin: 's academic career.
- 13:23Jimmy Akin: I mean, even a tenured professor would be stripped of tenure, fired, and be unemployable at any other academic institution for that.
- 13:32Jimmy Akin: Even plagiarism
- 13:33Jimmy Akin: or using someone's words and ideas without crediting them
- 13:37Jimmy Akin: can get professors fired.
- 13:38Jimmy Akin: In fact, professors have been fired for that.
- 13:41Jimmy Akin: Putting
- 13:41Jimmy Akin: words into someone's mouth by publishing a forged letter from them, let alone one
- 13:47Jimmy Akin: by the Pope and especially in Italy, would be absolutely career-shreding.
- 13:52Jimmy Akin: We thus have very strong motives for credibility in favor of the letter.
- 13:57Jimmy Akin: Finally, the book was released in February of 2021, near the beginning of the year.
- 14:03Jimmy Akin: And
- 14:03Jimmy Akin: at that time, Benedict was still alive.
- 14:07Jimmy Akin: He did not die until December of 2022.
- 14:12Jimmy Akin: At the end of the year, almost two years later.
- 14:16Jimmy Akin: So the textbook came out
- 14:18Jimmy Akin: during Benedict's lifetime
- 14:20Jimmy Akin: And Musso
- 14:21Jimmy Akin: was claiming not only that he had written the letter in 2014, but that he also had a second communication with Benedict in which he authorized him to include the letter as an appendix.
- 14:32Jimmy Akin: And
- 14:33Jimmy Akin: with that letter appearing in a university textbook being published, especially during Benedict's lifetime.
- 14:41Jimmy Akin: Then
- 14:41Jimmy Akin: if it were fake, we would expect either Benedict himself, his personal secretary, or someone from the Vatican to start yelling that the letter was fake.
- 14:53Jimmy Akin: And they didn't
- 14:54Jimmy Akin: not in Benedict's lifetime, and not in any of the years since then.
- 14:59Jimmy Akin: I thus consider it morally certain that the letter is genuine, and we're safe in proceeding on that basis.
- 15:07Jimmy Akin: Another question we should look at is what authority the letter has.
- 15:11Jimmy Akin: The short answer is
- 15:12Jimmy Akin: it doesn't have any authority.
- 15:14Jimmy Akin: When Benedict resigned the papacy, he resigned the authoritative teaching role that he had as Pope.
- 15:20Jimmy Akin: As a result, the letter is not a church document.
- 15:23Jimmy Akin: It falls into the same category as Benedict's other private writings, like all the books and articles that he published before becoming Pope.
- 15:32Jimmy Akin: However, that doesn't mean that the letter is without value
- 15:35Jimmy Akin: any more than it means that all of Benedict's writings from before he was Pope
- 15:40Jimmy Akin: were without value.
- 15:41Jimmy Akin: Not only is it valuable because of Joseph Ratzinger
- 15:45Jimmy Akin: 's razor-sharp theological mind, he also
- 15:48Jimmy Akin: occupied the two positions that established the bounds of permitted Catholic opinion in any given generation.
- 15:56Jimmy Akin: namely
- 15:57Jimmy Akin: the Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and the Papacy itself.
- 16:03Jimmy Akin: Now, I'm not talking here about something that one of those two figures might say,
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: off
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: the top of their head in an interview or something.
- 16:11Jimmy Akin: Even popes
- 16:12Jimmy Akin: and CDF prefects can't express themselves badly when they're speaking spontaneously.
- 16:17Jimmy Akin: But
- 16:18Jimmy Akin: if they express themselves in writing, then they've had time to consider what they're going to say and their responsibilities for teaching Catholic doctrine.
- 16:27Jimmy Akin: mean that we should at least start by assuming
- 16:31Jimmy Akin: that
- 16:32Jimmy Akin: what they have written is a permitted Catholic opinion.
- 16:36Jimmy Akin: As I point out in my book
- 16:38Jimmy Akin: Teaching with
- 16:39Jimmy Akin: Authority
- 16:40Jimmy Akin: Members of the magisterium may express theological opinions, and these
- 16:45Jimmy Akin: generally may be presumed legitimate
- 16:48Jimmy Akin: Bishops in communion with the Pope
- 16:50Jimmy Akin: are commissioned to teach the faith, and are guided by the Holy Spirit.
- 16:54Jimmy Akin: One could not seriously maintain that theological opinions expressed by bishops and the Pope
- 16:59Jimmy Akin: should be presumed illegitimate.
- 17:02Jimmy Akin: Of course, that presumption can be defeated.
- 17:05Jimmy Akin: There are bishops who hold theological views that should have stopped them from being appointed, or who have gone off the rails since their appointment.
- 17:13Jimmy Akin: But there are two bishops in particular
- 17:16Jimmy Akin: whose theological opinions carry a stronger presumption of legitimacy.
- 17:21Jimmy Akin: As I also point out
- 17:23Jimmy Akin: ,
- 17:23Jimmy Akin: Two bishops deserve special attention in this regard, the Pope himself and the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
- 17:31Jimmy Akin: These are the bishops most responsible for protecting the faith of Christians, and their views carry a stronger presumption of orthodoxy.
- 17:39Jimmy Akin: The Pope is the vicar of Christ, empowered by the Holy Spirit to confirm his brother bishops in the faith, and the head of the CDF is the chief doctrinal watchdog for the church.
- 17:50Jimmy Akin: If you can't presume that these men's views are orthodox, who can you?
- 17:55Jimmy Akin: The presumption also applies to works they produced prior to entering
- 17:59Jimmy Akin: these offices.
- 18:00Jimmy Akin: If a man were known to be fundamentally unorthodox, the College of Cardinals wouldn't have elected him Pope, and if a man's theological judgment was fundamentally unsound, the Pope wouldn't appoint him to head the CDF.
- 18:13Jimmy Akin: Now, you could still say that this doesn't apply to a specific Pope
- 18:17Jimmy Akin: or a specific head of the CDF.
- 18:20Jimmy Akin: You could say that they were mistakenly appointed or that they'd gone off the rails.
- 18:25Jimmy Akin: But that does not apply to Joseph Ratzinger, either when he was the head of the CDF
- 18:31Jimmy Akin: or when he was Pope
- 18:33Jimmy Akin: or afterward
- 18:34Jimmy Akin: We can therefore look to what Benedict wrote as an indicator of what permitted Catholic opinion is.
- 18:41Jimmy Akin: You could
- 18:42Jimmy Akin: overcome that presumption in theory, perhaps on a specific point.
- 18:47Jimmy Akin: but he was not only Orthodox, but also the greatest theological mind of his generation of churchmen.
- 18:53Jimmy Akin: We're thus on very safe ground taking his writings as a very solid indicator of what opinions Catholics are.
- 19:00Jimmy Akin: permitted to hold.
- 19:02Jimmy Akin: As Professor Musso
- 19:03Jimmy Akin: says in his textbook, Extraterrestrial Life, the fact remains that this is the opinion of the greatest theologian of our time and one of the greatest of all time, who
- 19:15Jimmy Akin: besides being Pope, was also the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith
- 19:20Jimmy Akin: for almost twenty four years.
- 19:22Jimmy Akin: I would therefore say that, whatever one thinks of him, he deserves to be listened to with the utmost attention.
- 19:30Jimmy Akin: And I
- 19:31Jimmy Akin: definitely agree with that.
- 19:33Jimmy Akin: So,
- 19:34Jimmy Akin: pew, with all that as background, let's take a look at the letter.
- 19:39Jimmy Akin: In Extraterrestrial Life, Professor Musso
- 19:42Jimmy Akin: gives us a little more background on how he received the letter from Benedict.
- 19:46Jimmy Akin: He writes
- 19:47Jimmy Akin: The letter reproduced here, with the explicit authorization of His Holiness, was written by Pope Emeritus
- 19:53Jimmy Akin: Benedict the Sixteenth on june sixth, twenty
- 19:56Jimmy Akin: fourteen, in reply to a letter of mine
- 19:59Jimmy Akin: of March twenty second
- 20:01Jimmy Akin: in which I put to him some questions on important theological matters, all connected in one way or another with the problem of extraterrestrial life.
- 20:10Jimmy Akin: So
- 20:11Jimmy Akin: Musso
- 20:11Jimmy Akin: wrote Benedict on March 22nd, 2014, and Benedict wrote back on June 6th.
- 20:18Jimmy Akin: And as we'll see, not all of the questions he asked the former Pope were directly connected with extraterrestrial life.
- 20:26Jimmy Akin: Some of them were only indirectly related to the question
- 20:30Jimmy Akin: and concerned human origins.
- 20:33Jimmy Akin: Mousseau
- 20:34Jimmy Akin: also gives some additional detail a bit earlier in the book, writing.
- 20:37Jimmy Akin: .
- 20:38Jimmy Akin: .
- 20:38Jimmy Akin: Since the questions involved were very tough, there was no point in asking advice from just any theologian.
- 20:45Jimmy Akin: I wanted only the best, all the more
- 20:48Jimmy Akin: since it was very easy to identify who that
- 20:51Jimmy Akin: was.
- 20:52Jimmy Akin: Working out how to reach him, on the other hand, was very difficult.
- 20:56Jimmy Akin: But at last, in 2014, the right opportunity came, thanks to Monsignor Guido Marini.
- 21:02Jimmy Akin: master of pontifical liturgical celebrations, who kindly acted as go-between, delivering to Benedict the Sixteenth
- 21:09Jimmy Akin: a letter of mine
- 21:10Jimmy Akin: in which I asked his opinion on a few but burning questions
- 21:15Jimmy Akin: His reply, dated june sixth, twenty
- 21:18Jimmy Akin: fourteen, reached me exactly a month after he had received mine, a very short time
- 21:23Jimmy Akin: considering the massive work he still had even as emeritus
- 21:27Jimmy Akin: a year after his resignation.
- 21:29Jimmy Akin: I remember being particularly struck by the very carefully prepared packet
- 21:34Jimmy Akin: and by the fact that he had sent it to me
- 21:37Jimmy Akin: not by ordinary mail, but by the Vatican diplomatic courier.
- 21:42Jimmy Akin: That
- 21:42Jimmy Akin: may seem a trifle, but it immediately gave me the distinct impression, later duly confirmed by the text, that he had understood how important the matter was to me, and therefore wanted to be sure that his reply reached me without mishap.
- 21:57Jimmy Akin: And
- 21:58Jimmy Akin: that was reasonable, because the Italian mail system has a reputation for mishaps.
- 22:04Jimmy Akin: The Vatican Post Office has a reputation for being much better, and the diplomatic couriers are better yet.
- 22:10Jimmy Akin: Unfortunately, Professor Musso
- 22:13Jimmy Akin: does not reproduce the text of his
- 22:15Jimmy Akin: letter in the book, and I really wish he had, so that we could clearly see both sides of the conversation.
- 22:22Jimmy Akin: However, from Benedict's reply, we can tell that Professor Musso asked him four questions, and from how Benedict answers, we can tell something about what the questions were.
- 22:32Jimmy Akin: Also, in the textbook, Professor Musso
- 22:35Jimmy Akin: summarizes them.
- 22:36Jimmy Akin: He says, My first question was whether the origin of humanity from a single couple, as the Bible narrates it, should be taken literally.
- 22:44Jimmy Akin: The thesis of monogenism, or not the thesis of polygenism.
- 22:49Jimmy Akin: I'll explain more about this in a bit, but for now we can say that the first question dealt with polygenism
- 22:56Jimmy Akin: Musso
- 22:57Jimmy Akin: continues, my second question went straight for the big target, namely
- 23:01Jimmy Akin: nothing less than the correct interpretation of the nature of original sin.
- 23:06Jimmy Akin: So
- 23:07Jimmy Akin: the second question was about original sin.
- 23:09Jimmy Akin: These first two questions were thus about human origins rather than directly about extraterrestrial life, but that's going to change with the third question.
- 23:19Jimmy Akin: Unfortunately, we have a bit of a difficulty here
- 23:21Jimmy Akin: because in his reply Benedict combined his answers to the third and fourth questions.
- 23:27Jimmy Akin: That means that they were closely related, but it also means that it's at least a little harder to pull them apart.
- 23:33Jimmy Akin: Professor Musso
- 23:35Jimmy Akin: also doesn't clearly distinguish them in his textbook.
- 23:38Jimmy Akin: Instead, he says, Finally, here is the question most eagerly awaited.
- 23:43Jimmy Akin: whether the existence of other intelligent species in the universe is admissible for the Christian faith.
- 23:50Jimmy Akin: Now
- 23:51Jimmy Akin: in Benedict's reply to questions
- 23:53Jimmy Akin: three and four, he
- 23:54Jimmy Akin: It clearly addresses the subject of extraterrestrial life first
- 23:58Jimmy Akin: before pivoting to another subject.
- 24:00Jimmy Akin: So
- 24:01Jimmy Akin: based on what both Benedict and Musso
- 24:04Jimmy Akin: say, we can tell that the third question was about extraterrestrial life.
- 24:09Jimmy Akin: And the subject Benedict pivots
- 24:11Jimmy Akin: to is the role of Christ and its cosmic implications.
- 24:15Jimmy Akin: Since Benedict
- 24:16Jimmy Akin: combined this answer with the one about alien life, the most natural read of this would be that the fourth question was about Christ and aliens.
- 24:24Jimmy Akin: I'm relying on inference rather than a direct statement for this, but that is the most logical inference given the facts we have
- 24:32Jimmy Akin: I thus think that we can conclude that the four questions were about polygym,
- 24:37Jimmy Akin: original sin, extraterrestrial life, and Christ and aliens.
- 24:42Jimmy Akin: Now, each of these are controversial subjects in some circles, and no matter what you say on them, you're gonna make some folks mad.
- 24:51Jimmy Akin: That's definitely true of what we're going to see Benedict say.
- 24:55Jimmy Akin: It will definitely make some people mad.
- 24:59Jimmy Akin: But it doesn't make me mad.
- 25:01Jimmy Akin: I would have predicted what he says.
- 25:03Jimmy Akin: In fact, I've been pointing out the same possibilities for years.
- 25:06Jimmy Akin: I was surprised, though, that Benedict expresses a few things as
- 25:10Jimmy Akin: definitely as he does, and he expressed at least one thing more definitely than I would have.
- 25:16Jimmy Akin: But to explain that, we need to read the letter.
- 25:20Jimmy Akin: Benedict begins by saying, Dear Professor, the questions that you put to me in your letter, which arrived on May 8th, are difficult and are now in a new phase of study and interpretation
- 25:32Jimmy Akin: Just as the problem of geocentrism could be clarified only in a new context of the vision of the world
- 25:39Jimmy Akin: and in a new understanding of the literary genres of scripture,
- 25:43Jimmy Akin: So
- 25:43Jimmy Akin: also
- 25:43Jimmy Akin: the questions proposed by you are in a phase of maturation, which, at the moment, does not yet permit complete answers.
- 25:51Jimmy Akin: Only with this reservation can I give first annotations on the problems.
- 25:56Jimmy Akin: Now, let's go over that bit by bit.
- 25:58Jimmy Akin: The first thing Benedict says
- 26:00Jimmy Akin: is that the questions you put to me, that is, on the four subjects we just covered, are difficult.
- 26:06Jimmy Akin: That means they don't have easy answers.
- 26:09Jimmy Akin: So right there, that should put certain people on notice of where we're going.
- 26:15Jimmy Akin: If someone thinks that these issues have easy answers, like, of course
- 26:20Jimmy Akin: polygym is
- 26:21Jimmy Akin: impossible, or
- 26:23Jimmy Akin: of course
- 26:23Jimmy Akin: church teaching on original sin is fully clear with no questions left to answer, or
- 26:29Jimmy Akin: Of course there are no intelligent aliens.
- 26:31Jimmy Akin: Well, then Benedict is going to disagree with you.
- 26:35Jimmy Akin: Those easy answers are precisely the kinds of things that Benedict is going to reject.
- 26:41Jimmy Akin: That's why he says these are difficult
- 26:43Jimmy Akin: questions.
- 26:44Jimmy Akin: He also says that they are now in a new phase of study.
- 26:48Jimmy Akin: meaning that they are currently being studied by theologians and churchmen in an attempt to find the difficult answers that these questions have.
- 26:56Jimmy Akin: He also says that these questions are in a new phase of interpretation
- 27:01Jimmy Akin: Meaning that they raise the issue of how certain things are interpreted and whether they need to be interpreted in a new way
- 27:09Jimmy Akin: That's confirmed by what he says next
- 27:11Jimmy Akin: when he invokes the problem of geocentrism, or the view that the Earth is at the center of the universe.
- 27:17Jimmy Akin: The description of it as a problem
- 27:20Jimmy Akin: envisions it as an intellectual issue that needed to be solved
- 27:24Jimmy Akin: and one that did not have a clear and obvious answer at first.
- 27:29Jimmy Akin: He says that the problem of geocentrism could be clarified only in a new context of the vision of the world.
- 27:36Jimmy Akin: That's a reference to the understanding of the world that was suggested by scientific discoveries that changed our understanding of how the universe is structured.
- 27:46Jimmy Akin: He also says that geocentrism could only be clarified in the context of a new understanding of the literary genres of Scripture.
- 27:54Jimmy Akin: That's a reference to how the scientific discoveries made theologians and churchmen rethink what the biblical texts are actually trying to teach, which turns out to be theological matters rather than scientific matters.
- 28:07Jimmy Akin: The Bible wants to teach that God made and sustains the world, but it does not want to give a scientific account of how God
- 28:16Jimmy Akin: made the world
- 28:18Jimmy Akin: or how
- 28:18Jimmy Akin: precisely it operates.
- 28:21Jimmy Akin: It took thus
- 28:22Jimmy Akin: both scientific discoveries
- 28:24Jimmy Akin: and discoveries about the proper interpretation of scripture
- 28:27Jimmy Akin: to ultimately solve the problem of geocentrism.
- 28:30Jimmy Akin: And this, by the way, is a statement that will not please the handful of fringe authors who hold that the church teaches geocentrism.
- 28:40Jimmy Akin: because that
- 28:40Jimmy Akin: is plainly in conflict with what Benedict and previous popes like John Paul II
- 28:46Jimmy Akin: have said on the subject.
- 28:48Jimmy Akin: In parallel to this historical controversy
- 28:51Jimmy Akin: involving science and faith, Benedict then says, So
- 28:55Jimmy Akin: also the questions proposed by you are in a phase of maturation, which
- 28:59Jimmy Akin: at the moment
- 29:01Jimmy Akin: Does not yet permit complete answers.
- 29:03Jimmy Akin: So, according to Benedict, we need to be patient.
- 29:07Jimmy Akin: Just as it took careful studies of both science and scripture to clarify the question of geocentrism
- 29:13Jimmy Akin: It'll take the same thing to clarify the questions of polygynyism, original sin, and extraterrestrial life.
- 29:20Jimmy Akin: Because
- 29:21Jimmy Akin: the
- 29:22Jimmy Akin: new contexts provided
- 29:24Jimmy Akin: by
- 29:25Jimmy Akin: scientific and scriptural discoveries in our age
- 29:27Jimmy Akin: aren't complete, we cannot yet give complete answers to these questions.
- 29:33Jimmy Akin: Benedict thus concludes the introduction to his letter by saying
- 29:37Jimmy Akin: Only with this reservation can I give first annotations to the problems.
- 29:43Jimmy Akin: The letter thus
- 29:44Jimmy Akin: only offers
- 29:45Jimmy Akin: first
- 29:46Jimmy Akin: annotations
- 29:47Jimmy Akin: or first notes
- 29:48Jimmy Akin: on the questions of polygenism, original sin, and extraterrestrial life.
- 29:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 29:54Jimmy Akin: now
- 29:55Jimmy Akin: let's look at the notes he has to offer
- 29:58Jimmy Akin: The term polygenism comes from Greek roots.
- 30:01Jimmy Akin: Polos
- 30:02Jimmy Akin: means many
- 30:03Jimmy Akin: and genos
- 30:04Jimmy Akin: means birth or origin.
- 30:06Jimmy Akin: So according to its roots, polygenism means origin
- 30:09Jimmy Akin: for many.
- 30:10Jimmy Akin: In the history of thought, this term has been used in more than one way, but in contemporary Catholic discourse it refers to the idea that humanity is descended from more than one original couple
- 30:23Jimmy Akin: Either Adam and Eve were two people that were part of a broader group of people, or Adam and Eve were symbols of a broader group of people.
- 30:32Jimmy Akin: The alternative to polygynism is monogenism.
- 30:35Jimmy Akin: Manos
- 30:36Jimmy Akin: means only, alone, unique, or one.
- 30:41Jimmy Akin: And genos means birth or origin.
- 30:43Jimmy Akin: So
- 30:44Jimmy Akin: monogenism means origin
- 30:46Jimmy Akin: from one
- 30:47Jimmy Akin: couple alone.
- 30:49Jimmy Akin: The idea
- 30:50Jimmy Akin: of biological evolution began to become common in the late 1700s, almost a century before Darwin.
- 30:57Jimmy Akin: And it led
- 30:58Jimmy Akin: to a discussion of whether mankind's origin
- 31:01Jimmy Akin: should be explained in terms of monogenism or polygenism.
- 31:05Jimmy Akin: In 1950, Pope Pius XII
- 31:07Jimmy Akin: published an encyclical called Humanae Generis, in which he stated
- 31:12Jimmy Akin: The Magisterium of the Church does not forbid that the doctrine of evolutionism, insofar namely as it inquires into the origin of the human body
- 31:21Jimmy Akin: as arising from matter already existing and living,
- 31:24Jimmy Akin: for the Catholic faith
- 31:26Jimmy Akin: commands us to hold that souls are created immediately by God, be treated, according to the present state of the human disciplines and of sacred theology, by investigations and disputations of men skilled in both fields.
- 31:40Jimmy Akin: So
- 31:40Jimmy Akin: the magisterium does not forbid that the concept of evolution be discussed as it applies to the origin
- 31:49Jimmy Akin: of the human body
- 31:51Jimmy Akin: Pius XII
- 31:52Jimmy Akin: had no problem with the idea of evolution of other life forms.
- 31:56Jimmy Akin: It was the biological evolution of the human body that he was concerned with.
- 32:01Jimmy Akin: and in nineteen fifty he was quite tentative about it, though in nineteen
- 32:05Jimmy Akin: ninety six Pope John Paul II
- 32:07Jimmy Akin: announced that discoveries in a variety of fields in the previous half century
- 32:12Jimmy Akin: had given the idea of human evolution a secure footing.
- 32:15Jimmy Akin: While Pius XII
- 32:18Jimmy Akin: had been open to evolution as applied to the human body, he went on to say.
- 32:24Jimmy Akin: But when it is a question of another conjectural opinion, namely of that which they call polygym,
- 32:30Jimmy Akin: then the sons of the church by no means enjoy a liberty of this kind.
- 32:34Jimmy Akin: for the Christian faithful cannot embrace that opinion, whose holders assert
- 32:39Jimmy Akin: either
- 32:40Jimmy Akin: that after Adam, true men existed on this earth who did not take their origin by natural generation from him
- 32:47Jimmy Akin: as
- 32:47Jimmy Akin: from
- 32:47Jimmy Akin: the first
- 32:48Jimmy Akin: parent of all, or that Adam signifies a certain multitude of first parents, since it in no way appears how an opinion of this kind can be reconciled with those things
- 33:00Jimmy Akin: which the sources of revealed truth and the acts of the magisterium of the Church
- 33:05Jimmy Akin: set forth concerning original sin, which proceeds from a sin truly committed by one Adam, and which, transfused into all by generation
- 33:14Jimmy Akin: is in each one as his own.
- 33:17Jimmy Akin: Now, some people, including a variety of apologists, have treated this as a statement that the Catholic faith requires the rejection of polygenism, that it's just false.
- 33:28Jimmy Akin: But that's not what Pius XII
- 33:31Jimmy Akin: is doing here.
- 33:32Jimmy Akin: Papal encyclicals are written very carefully, and they have to be read very carefully
- 33:37Jimmy Akin: What many miss is that there is a difference between doctrinal statements and regulatory statements.
- 33:45Jimmy Akin: There's a difference between saying that something is false and saying that you're not allowed to discuss and advocate it.
- 33:52Jimmy Akin: Saying something is false is doctrinal language, while saying that you're not allowed to advocate it is regulatory language.
- 34:01Jimmy Akin: And what Pius XII
- 34:03Jimmy Akin: uses here is regulatory language
- 34:06Jimmy Akin: He says that the magisterium of the church does not forbid that the idea of the evolution of the human body be treated or discussed.
- 34:15Jimmy Akin: by
- 34:16Jimmy Akin: investigations and disputations of men skilled in both the human disciplines, or natural science, and sacred theology.
- 34:24Jimmy Akin: In other words, the magisterium lets scientists and theologians investigate and debate about the idea of human evolution.
- 34:32Jimmy Akin: That's a regulation of what people
- 34:35Jimmy Akin: can do, not
- 34:37Jimmy Akin: a teaching that evolution is either true or that it's false.
- 34:42Jimmy Akin: He then says that when it comes to polygenism, Catholics by no means
- 34:47Jimmy Akin: enjoy a liberty
- 34:49Jimmy Akin: of this kind.
- 34:50Jimmy Akin: Again, that's regulatory language.
- 34:52Jimmy Akin: He's saying that you don't have the liberty
- 34:55Jimmy Akin: to discuss and debate polygynyism the way you do the biological evolution of the human body.
- 35:00Jimmy Akin: Pope Pius then tells us why people didn't have this liberty, saying that Christians can't advocate the idea
- 35:08Jimmy Akin: that some people weren't descended from Adam or that Adam was a symbol of a larger group of people
- 35:14Jimmy Akin: since
- 35:15Jimmy Akin: or because
- 35:17Jimmy Akin: It in no way appears how an opinion of this kind can be reconciled with those things which the sources of revealed truth
- 35:24Jimmy Akin: and the acts of the magisterium of the church
- 35:26Jimmy Akin: set forth concerning original sin.
- 35:29Jimmy Akin: In other words, Catholics didn't have the liberty to freely debate polygym
- 35:34Jimmy Akin: because
- 35:34Jimmy Akin: it wasn't clear how it could be squared with the doctrine of original sin.
- 35:38Jimmy Akin: What this statement had the effect of doing
- 35:41Jimmy Akin: was refocusing the discussion on original sin itself.
- 35:46Jimmy Akin: Humanae generis came out in 1950, so in the 1950s, theologians started discussing
- 35:53Jimmy Akin: whether you could.
- 35:55Jimmy Akin: harmonize original sin
- 35:57Jimmy Akin: with the idea of there being more than two original humans, and they ended up proposing several ways.
- 36:03Jimmy Akin: As a result, by the 1960s, the Vatican newspaper itself,
- 36:09Jimmy Akin: L'Eservatore
- 36:10Jimmy Akin: Romano, was publishing articles saying, well.
- 36:14Jimmy Akin: Here are ways you could square original sin with polygenism.
- 36:18Jimmy Akin: And the magisterium started treating polygynyism as something that could be discussed and debated.
- 36:25Jimmy Akin: Unlike most folks, I've made a careful study of that history.
- 36:28Jimmy Akin: In fact, I actually wrote a book about it
- 36:30Jimmy Akin: and even obtained an imprimatur for the book, though I haven't published it.
- 36:35Jimmy Akin: If you'd like me to publish it, let me know in the comments.
- 36:38Jimmy Akin: Also, I've thought about devoting an episode of Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World to the question of polygenism, so if you'd like me to make one, let me know
- 36:46Jimmy Akin: In any event, the magisterium began treating polygym as
- 36:50Jimmy Akin: a legitimate subject of discussion.
- 36:52Jimmy Akin: It wasn't saying that polygenism is true, but it was allowing people to debate it.
- 36:58Jimmy Akin: An example of that is seen in the publication in 2004 of a document by the International Theological Commission called Communion and Stewardship.
- 37:08Jimmy Akin: The International Theological Commission is a theological advisory body run by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, now the Decastery for the Doctrine of the Faith.
- 37:18Jimmy Akin: Its job is to write theological position papers that may be of use to the DDF and to theologians more broadly, and you can see how they handled issues related to Polygynism in communion and stewardship.
- 37:31Jimmy Akin: They stated,
- 37:32Jimmy Akin: Every individual human being, as well as the whole human community, are created in the image of God, in its original unity, of which Adam
- 37:43Jimmy Akin: is the symbol
- 37:45Jimmy Akin: The human race is made in the image of the Divine Trinity.
- 37:49Jimmy Akin: Willed by God, it makes its way through the vicissitudes of human history towards a perfect communion, also willed by God, but yet to be fully realized.
- 37:59Jimmy Akin: The important
- 38:00Jimmy Akin: part of that statement is that Adam is the symbol of the original unity of the human race.
- 38:07Jimmy Akin: Now
- 38:08Jimmy Akin: That doesn't mean that Adam is only a symbol.
- 38:11Jimmy Akin: He could also be a historical individual.
- 38:14Jimmy Akin: The text doesn't settle that question.
- 38:16Jimmy Akin: And that's the point.
- 38:18Jimmy Akin: It
- 38:18Jimmy Akin: doesn't settle the question of whether or not Adam is a historical individual who also happens to be a symbol of mankind's original unity.
- 38:28Jimmy Akin: but it does understand him as a symbol.
- 38:31Jimmy Akin: And they're not challenging the scientific understanding of how mankind arose.
- 38:36Jimmy Akin: Elsewhere in the document they say
- 38:39Jimmy Akin: While the story of human origins is complex and subject to revision, physical anthropology and molecular biology
- 38:47Jimmy Akin: combined to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa
- 38:52Jimmy Akin: about 150,000 years ago
- 38:55Jimmy Akin: in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage.
- 38:59Jimmy Akin: So
- 38:59Jimmy Akin: the ITC says there is a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa
- 39:07Jimmy Akin: about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population.
- 39:13Jimmy Akin: The fact that the text doesn't settle the historical individual question is made clear later in the document
- 39:20Jimmy Akin: where it says
- 39:21Jimmy Akin: Catholic theology affirms that the emergence of the first members of the human species, whether as
- 39:29Jimmy Akin: individuals
- 39:31Jimmy Akin: or in populations
- 39:33Jimmy Akin: ,
- 39:33Jimmy Akin: represents an event that is not susceptible of a purely natural explanation
- 39:38Jimmy Akin: and which can appropriately be attributed to divine intervention
- 39:42Jimmy Akin: The important
- 39:43Jimmy Akin: part of that is where it describes the emergence of the first members of the human species
- 39:49Jimmy Akin: either
- 39:51Jimmy Akin: as
- 39:51Jimmy Akin: individuals
- 39:53Jimmy Akin: or
- 39:53Jimmy Akin: in
- 39:54Jimmy Akin: populations.
- 39:56Jimmy Akin: So
- 39:56Jimmy Akin: the ITC is open to both the idea that the first humans were either individuals, Adam and Eve, or a broader population.
- 40:06Jimmy Akin: In other words, they're open to both monogenism and polygynyism.
- 40:11Jimmy Akin: Now, the International Theological Commission is not an organ of the magisterium.
- 40:16Jimmy Akin: It's an advisory commission that works for the magisterium.
- 40:20Jimmy Akin: And it's only allowed to publish its documents
- 40:24Jimmy Akin: on the
- 40:24Jimmy Akin: condition
- 40:26Jimmy Akin: that the magisterium doesn't have a problem with what they say.
- 40:29Jimmy Akin: That's in the ITC's operating rules.
- 40:32Jimmy Akin: They have to submit
- 40:34Jimmy Akin: their conclusions to the Pope and to the DDF, and they only get to publish them
- 40:39Jimmy Akin: on the condition that the Holy See
- 40:41Jimmy Akin: does not have
- 40:43Jimmy Akin: any
- 40:44Jimmy Akin: difficulty
- 40:45Jimmy Akin: with them.
- 40:46Jimmy Akin: Well, in 2004, the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith was Joseph Ratzinger.
- 40:52Jimmy Akin: He was also the head of the International Theological Commission itself, and so in the preliminary note for communion and stewardship, we read.
- 41:02Jimmy Akin: The present text was approved in forma
- 41:04Jimmy Akin: specifica
- 41:05Jimmy Akin: by the written ballots of the International Theological Commission.
- 41:09Jimmy Akin: It was then submitted to Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, the President of the Commission.
- 41:14Jimmy Akin: who
- 41:15Jimmy Akin: has given his permission
- 41:17Jimmy Akin: for its publication.
- 41:18Jimmy Akin: So Joseph Ratzinger
- 41:20Jimmy Akin: himself approved this document for publication, indicating that the Holy See
- 41:24Jimmy Akin: did not have
- 41:26Jimmy Akin: any
- 41:26Jimmy Akin: difficulty with it, even though it was open to both monogenism and polygenism.
- 41:33Jimmy Akin: And it isn't just him.
- 41:35Jimmy Akin: I also have
- 41:36Jimmy Akin: statements from other
- 41:38Jimmy Akin: heads of the CDF, like Cardinal Gerhard Muller
- 41:41Jimmy Akin: and Cardinal Luis Ladaria, also
- 41:45Jimmy Akin: indicating openness to polygianism.
- 41:47Jimmy Akin: So
- 41:48Jimmy Akin: with CDF prefects like Ratzinger, Muller, and Lidaria
- 41:53Jimmy Akin: being open to polygynism, it's not a surprise when we read Benedict's answer to Musso's first question
- 42:00Jimmy Akin: Benedict writes, to
- 42:02Jimmy Akin: question
- 42:02Jimmy Akin: one.
- 42:03Jimmy Akin: The question of monogenism and polygenism, only
- 42:06Jimmy Akin: one couple or a small group, was discussed extensively in the 1950s.
- 42:11Jimmy Akin: After the Second Vatican Council theological interest moved to other areas, as far as I know, the discussion has not been pursued any further.
- 42:20Jimmy Akin: At that time, polygynyism was not excluded absolutely.
- 42:24Jimmy Akin: It remains fundamental, however, that there exists only one human race
- 42:29Jimmy Akin: and that all men are men
- 42:31Jimmy Akin: in the same sense
- 42:32Jimmy Akin: A fundamental intention of the doctrine of the One Adam is precisely this
- 42:37Jimmy Akin: the defense of the unity of the human being, and thus the defense of the equal dignity and of the metaphysical
- 42:45Jimmy Akin: fraternity of all men.
- 42:47Jimmy Akin: So
- 42:47Jimmy Akin: Benedict notes that the question of monogenism and polygynis, only one couple or a small group, was discussed extensively in the 1950s.
- 42:57Jimmy Akin: but that after the Second Vatican Council, theological interest moved to other areas.
- 43:02Jimmy Akin: The important thing he says for this question
- 43:04Jimmy Akin: is that at that time, polygynism
- 43:07Jimmy Akin: was
- 43:08Jimmy Akin: not
- 43:08Jimmy Akin: excluded
- 43:10Jimmy Akin: absolutely.
- 43:11Jimmy Akin: In other words, as a result of the discussion that followed the 1950 publication of Humanae Generis, polygynyism was not excluded absolutely.
- 43:20Jimmy Akin: So
- 43:20Jimmy Akin: both it and monogenism have been subsequently discussed, as illustrated by Cardinal Ratzinger's approval of communion and stewardship in 2004, and in statements by Cardinals Muller and La
- 43:32Jimmy Akin: Daria
- 43:33Jimmy Akin: However, Benedict sets bounds on this question, stating that it remains fundamental that there exists only
- 43:40Jimmy Akin: one
- 43:41Jimmy Akin: human race, and that all
- 43:43Jimmy Akin: men are men
- 43:45Jimmy Akin: in the same sense.
- 43:47Jimmy Akin: That's a reference to some of the older discussions of polygenism.
- 43:51Jimmy Akin: In the 19th century, the concept was sometimes used by racists to claim that the different races
- 43:58Jimmy Akin: had
- 43:58Jimmy Akin: different origins.
- 43:59Jimmy Akin: For example, there was a white Adam and Eve, a black Adam and Eve, an Asian Adam and Eve, and that all the races were not all equally human
- 44:10Jimmy Akin: That's why Benedict stresses that there exists only
- 44:14Jimmy Akin: one
- 44:15Jimmy Akin: human race
- 44:16Jimmy Akin: and that all men
- 44:18Jimmy Akin: are men
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: in
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: the same sense.
- 44:21Jimmy Akin: So
- 44:22Jimmy Akin: whether you think there was one original human couple or not, there's just one human race
- 44:28Jimmy Akin: and we're all equal, meaning
- 44:31Jimmy Akin: Love your neighbor as yourself requires all of us to love our fellow human beings equally.
- 44:38Jimmy Akin: You can't downgrade or exclude certain people, certainly not on cosmetic differences
- 44:45Jimmy Akin: Benedict thus concludes that a fundamental intention of the doctrine of the One Adam is precisely this, the defense
- 44:54Jimmy Akin: of the unity of the human being, and thus the defense of the equal dignity and of the metaphysical fraternity of all men.
- 45:03Jimmy Akin: And
- 45:04Jimmy Akin: as long as that's maintained, it would be possible to hold that there were more than just two first parents, as Benedict says that polygenism is not excluded absolutely
- 45:16Jimmy Akin: The second question Musso
- 45:18Jimmy Akin: asked was about original sin, and I really wish we knew how he posed it.
- 45:23Jimmy Akin: Benedict has said a good bit about original sin, especially before he was Pope.
- 45:28Jimmy Akin: And
- 45:29Jimmy Akin: this question has multiple aspects, but without knowing exactly which ones
- 45:34Jimmy Akin: Musso
- 45:34Jimmy Akin: asked about, it's harder to know exactly what Benedict is responding to here.
- 45:40Jimmy Akin: Nevertheless, here's what he writes.
- 45:43Jimmy Akin: To
- 45:43Jimmy Akin: question two.
- 45:44Jimmy Akin: The discussion of the second problem posed by you has only just begun.
- 45:49Jimmy Akin: I think that the thesis of His Most Reverend Excellency, Archbishop Leonard
- 45:55Jimmy Akin: Archbishop of Brussels
- 45:56Jimmy Akin: shows the right path.
- 45:58Jimmy Akin: Original sin is not a simple empirical act on a certain date and in a certain empirical place.
- 46:05Jimmy Akin: This fundamental fact precedes empirical history and determines it.
- 46:10Jimmy Akin: How to define such a meta-empirical fact is all still to be discussed.
- 46:15Jimmy Akin: I think that Archbishop Leonard
- 46:17Jimmy Akin: could answer these questions better.
- 46:20Jimmy Akin: André
- 46:20Jimmy Akin: Joseph
- 46:21Jimmy Akin: Leonard
- 46:22Jimmy Akin: was the Archbishop of Brussels and the Primate of Belgium until his retirement in 2015.
- 46:28Jimmy Akin: He's still alive
- 46:29Jimmy Akin: and he's known as a theological conservative.
- 46:32Jimmy Akin: In fact, one of his nicknames
- 46:34Jimmy Akin: is the Belgian Ratzinger.
- 46:36Jimmy Akin: And he's also known for his writings about original sin.
- 46:40Jimmy Akin: He discusses this in his apologetics book, The Reasons for Believing.
- 46:45Jimmy Akin: And we'll come back to that.
- 46:47Jimmy Akin: But for the moment, note that Benedict says that the discussion of the problem of original sin
- 46:53Jimmy Akin: has
- 46:53Jimmy Akin: only
- 46:54Jimmy Akin: just begun.
- 46:55Jimmy Akin: meaning that there is a lot of work yet to do on this question and how it is to be understood.
- 47:02Jimmy Akin: He then says that the thesis of Archbishop Leonard shows the right path
- 47:07Jimmy Akin: That means that he thinks what Archbishop Leonard has proposed is fundamentally in the right direction.
- 47:14Jimmy Akin: It doesn't mean that everything the Archbishop has proposed is accurate.
- 47:19Jimmy Akin: but that Benedict thinks that his fundamental proposal is good.
- 47:23Jimmy Akin: Benedict then identifies the particular element of Leonard
- 47:27Jimmy Akin: 's proposal that he thinks is good.
- 47:29Jimmy Akin: It's the idea that original sin
- 47:32Jimmy Akin: is not a simply empirical act on a certain date and in a certain empirical place.
- 47:39Jimmy Akin: This means that original sin should not be conceived of
- 47:43Jimmy Akin: as an event that occurred in a specific time and place, like
- 47:48Jimmy Akin: say.
- 47:49Jimmy Akin: At 3.
- 47:49Jimmy Akin: 06 p.
- 47:50Jimmy Akin: m.
- 47:51Jimmy Akin: on Tuesday, November 1st, 4004 BC, on the proleptic Julian calendar, just outside Basra, Iraq.
- 48:00Jimmy Akin: Instead, Archbishop Leonard proposes, between the world before the sin of Adam and the world after the first sin, there is a qualitative discontinuity.
- 48:11Jimmy Akin: One must therefore
- 48:12Jimmy Akin: not picture the original fall as taking place inside the present world.
- 48:17Jimmy Akin: The sin
- 48:18Jimmy Akin: of Adam is precisely
- 48:20Jimmy Akin: at the origin of the present condition of man
- 48:23Jimmy Akin: and of the world, insofar as they are infected by evil.
- 48:26Jimmy Akin: So, according to Archbishop Leonard, one must not picture the original fall as taking place inside the present world.
- 48:36Jimmy Akin: He proposes that
- 48:37Jimmy Akin: Adam and his sin
- 48:39Jimmy Akin: are not to be situated inside our universe
- 48:43Jimmy Akin: with the physical and biological laws that we presently know it to have.
- 48:47Jimmy Akin: Instead, he says, our hypothesis amounts to placing Adam and Eve in a real
- 48:53Jimmy Akin: preternatural world.
- 48:55Jimmy Akin: but
- 48:56Jimmy Akin: one not coinciding with the present universe, somewhat
- 49:00Jimmy Akin: as we situate the risen new Adam and the glorified New
- 49:03Jimmy Akin: Eve in a real
- 49:05Jimmy Akin: new world, but not one
- 49:07Jimmy Akin: overlapping our cosmos.
- 49:10Jimmy Akin: and
- 49:10Jimmy Akin: that
- 49:11Jimmy Akin: the consequence of the sin of Adam
- 49:13Jimmy Akin: is
- 49:14Jimmy Akin: then
- 49:14Jimmy Akin: precisely
- 49:15Jimmy Akin: that
- 49:16Jimmy Akin: the whole of the preternatural universe falls and becomes
- 49:20Jimmy Akin: from the initial Big Bang until today
- 49:23Jimmy Akin: this universe as we know it, handed over to the irreversibility of time
- 49:29Jimmy Akin: and to the laws of life and death
- 49:31Jimmy Akin: of a nature abandoned to its own resources.
- 49:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 49:35Jimmy Akin: the consequence of the sin
- 49:37Jimmy Akin: of Adam is that the whole universe falls and becomes, from the initial Big Bang
- 49:43Jimmy Akin: until today, this universe such as we know it
- 49:47Jimmy Akin: This is similar to a proposal made by Cardinal Hans Erz von
- 49:51Jimmy Akin: Balthasar.
- 49:52Jimmy Akin: In his book, A Theological Anthropology, he proposed that the fall of man might have had effects both
- 49:59Jimmy Akin: before and after it took place.
- 50:02Jimmy Akin: He writes, a metaphysical point at which this human decision occurs is therefore theoretically necessary, but is not historically demonstrable
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: One might, however, raise the question of whether this point does not exist
- 50:18Jimmy Akin: above the whole temporal unfolding of the material cosmogonic process.
- 50:23Jimmy Akin: He then appeals to a proposal made by Gregory of Nyssa, according to whom God, foreseeing human agency, gave man his biological, sexual
- 50:34Jimmy Akin: concupiscence.
- 50:36Jimmy Akin: This would mean that man's negative decision flowed into the process of hominization
- 50:41Jimmy Akin: which preceded it in time.
- 50:44Jimmy Akin: In other words, Saint Gregory of Nyssa
- 50:46Jimmy Akin: proposed that because God
- 50:48Jimmy Akin: foresaw human sin, he built sinful tendencies like biological or sexual concupiscence.
- 50:55Jimmy Akin: into
- 50:55Jimmy Akin: human nature
- 50:56Jimmy Akin: so that man's sin, his negative decision, affected the course of human development
- 51:02Jimmy Akin: which preceded it in time.
- 51:05Jimmy Akin: For von
- 51:05Jimmy Akin: Balthazar, the sin of Adam is thus a transhistorical event that determined the shape of human history
- 51:12Jimmy Akin: both before and after it.
- 51:14Jimmy Akin: Both von
- 51:15Jimmy Akin: Balthazar and Leonard propose that Adam's sin
- 51:18Jimmy Akin: affected the course of universal history.
- 51:21Jimmy Akin: What's different
- 51:23Jimmy Akin: is that Leonard puts Adam in a real but preternatural world that existed
- 51:28Jimmy Akin: before our universe, while von
- 51:30Jimmy Akin: Balthasar keeps him in our universe.
- 51:33Jimmy Akin: Of the two, Benedict proposes Leonard's idea, saying that it strikes him as showing the right path.
- 51:40Jimmy Akin: That doesn't mean he rejects von
- 51:42Jimmy Akin: Baltazar's similar proposal, but it does mean that he thinks Leonard is on the right track.
- 51:47Jimmy Akin: And he definitely agrees with the idea that Adam's sin
- 51:51Jimmy Akin: was a transhistorical event
- 51:53Jimmy Akin: saying
- 51:54Jimmy Akin: this
- 51:54Jimmy Akin: fundamental fact precedes
- 51:57Jimmy Akin: empirical history
- 51:59Jimmy Akin: and determines it.
- 52:01Jimmy Akin: However, he acknowledges that
- 52:03Jimmy Akin: precisely how we should understand this is an open question
- 52:07Jimmy Akin: saying
- 52:08Jimmy Akin: that how to define such a meta-empirical fact is all still to be discussed.
- 52:13Jimmy Akin: And he concludes by saying, I think that Archbishop Leonard
- 52:17Jimmy Akin: could answer these questions better
- 52:19Jimmy Akin: Which reminds me of a moment from the Star Trek episode Devil in the Dark where Mr.
- 52:24Jimmy Akin: Spock says,
- 52:25Audio clip: Mr.
- 52:26Audio clip: Scott has far more knowledge of nuclear reactors than I do.
- 52:29Jimmy Akin: Always nice to see geniuses
- 52:31Jimmy Akin: having the humility to acknowledge that someone else still has greater expertise in particular areas.
- 52:38Jimmy Akin: In any event, Benedict at least provisionally supports the idea that original sin should not be understood as a normal historical
- 52:45Jimmy Akin: event.
- 52:46Jimmy Akin: but as one that took place in a different way and that determined the course of the whole of human history
- 52:54Jimmy Akin: Now we come to what Benedict said about aliens, and this will very much displease those who hold that alien life.
- 53:02Jimmy Akin: must be impossible, and therefore
- 53:05Jimmy Akin: all aliens
- 53:06Jimmy Akin: must really be demons in disguise.
- 53:10Jimmy Akin: Benedict writes
- 53:11Jimmy Akin: to questions three and four
- 53:13Jimmy Akin: These problems too
- 53:15Jimmy Akin: were discussed intensely in the 1950s.
- 53:18Jimmy Akin: The great English writer and theologian C.
- 53:20Jimmy Akin: S.
- 53:20Jimmy Akin: Lewis wrote a novel, or perhaps a trilogy of novels, on this theme
- 53:25Jimmy Akin: I personally think that, as long as nothing serious is known about traces of life on other planets, there is not much sense in discussing the problem.
- 53:34Jimmy Akin: C.
- 53:34Jimmy Akin: S.
- 53:34Jimmy Akin: Lewis would have disagreed with the idea that he was a theologian, but he did write the famous space trilogy of books that deal with how extraterrestrial life could be understood from a Christian perspective.
- 53:47Jimmy Akin: In particular, he deals with races that have not fallen into sin
- 53:51Jimmy Akin: in Out of the Silent Planet and in Paralandra, which deal with intelligent races on Mars and Venus, respectively.
- 53:58Jimmy Akin: Here, Benedict says that when it comes to intelligent aliens, these problems
- 54:03Jimmy Akin: too
- 54:04Jimmy Akin: were discussed intensely in the 1950s in theological circles.
- 54:08Jimmy Akin: And
- 54:08Jimmy Akin: he doesn't say that theologians concluded that aliens are impossible
- 54:13Jimmy Akin: or that they must all be demons.
- 54:15Jimmy Akin: Still less does he say that the church has mandated such views.
- 54:20Jimmy Akin: Instead, he says that he personally thinks that there's not much sense in discussing the problem at the moment, and he gives a specific reason.
- 54:29Jimmy Akin: The reason
- 54:30Jimmy Akin: he thinks that the subject
- 54:32Jimmy Akin: doesn't presently need much discussion
- 54:35Jimmy Akin: is that nothing
- 54:36Jimmy Akin: serious is known about life on other planets.
- 54:41Jimmy Akin: So
- 54:41Jimmy Akin: got that?
- 54:42Jimmy Akin: Nothing serious is
- 54:45Jimmy Akin: known
- 54:46Jimmy Akin: about
- 54:46Jimmy Akin: life on other planets.
- 54:48Jimmy Akin: In other words, we
- 54:51Jimmy Akin: don't know
- 54:52Jimmy Akin: one
- 54:53Jimmy Akin: way or another, whether it exists, which is what I've been saying for years.
- 54:57Jimmy Akin: And what Benedict says definitely won't please those who falsely claim that the church teaches that there can be no intelligent alien life.
- 55:06Jimmy Akin: Sometimes they claim that the catechism requires this idea, but guess what?
- 55:12Jimmy Akin: The greatest theological mind of our generation of churchmen, the former Pope
- 55:17Jimmy Akin: And
- 55:17Jimmy Akin: the very man
- 55:19Jimmy Akin: who oversaw the writing of the catechism
- 55:22Jimmy Akin: disagrees.
- 55:24Jimmy Akin: He says, we don't know if alien life exists or not.
- 55:28Jimmy Akin: And we don't.
- 55:30Jimmy Akin: The church does not have a teaching on this, one way or the other, and science hasn't yet established whether aliens exist.
- 55:38Jimmy Akin: That means that Benedict held the view that it is possible that intelligent aliens do exist, and that we need to wait and see if we ever get solid evidence that they do
- 55:50Jimmy Akin: It seems that Benedict's personal thought that it isn't worth discussing this issue much is not shared by everyone.
- 55:57Jimmy Akin: I get
- 55:58Jimmy Akin: tons of questions about intelligent aliens
- 56:01Jimmy Akin: and
- 56:02Jimmy Akin: While I always point out that I don't even know if aliens exist, I do my best to answer them.
- 56:08Jimmy Akin: And I do think that there's value in these discussions because it's something people wonder about
- 56:14Jimmy Akin: and we don't want
- 56:15Jimmy Akin: people
- 56:15Jimmy Akin: thinking that the Christian faith will somehow be threatened if we ever get solid evidence of aliens.
- 56:21Jimmy Akin: In fact, we know right now that there are some strange things going on in the skies.
- 56:27Jimmy Akin: Even those who think it's all demons
- 56:29Jimmy Akin: acknowledge that.
- 56:30Jimmy Akin: And the US government programs looking at UFOs or UAPs
- 56:34Jimmy Akin: acknowledge that they don't know what all the things they're seeing
- 56:38Jimmy Akin: are.
- 56:39Jimmy Akin: They might be purely terrestrial.
- 56:41Jimmy Akin: Or they might not.
- 56:43Jimmy Akin: And this is something that became more prominent in the public mind since Benedict wrote his letter in 2014.
- 56:51Jimmy Akin: It wasn't until 2017 that the New York Times published an article about the government's UAP efforts and the UAP videos that have been released.
- 57:02Jimmy Akin: I thus think it's a good idea for people to be thinking about this subject in advance, so that if one day we ever do
- 57:09Jimmy Akin: get evidence for aliens, people won't think that this somehow disproves the Christian faith.
- 57:15Jimmy Akin: But
- 57:16Jimmy Akin: for a theologian like Benedict, who doesn't regularly answer questions from the general public
- 57:21Jimmy Akin: and who was writing back in 2014.
- 57:24Jimmy Akin: I can see how this wouldn't be the highest priority, especially since we can't reach any firm conclusions until such time as we have some specific aliens to consider.
- 57:36Jimmy Akin: In his answers to questions three and four, Benedict then pivots to a new subject.
- 57:41Jimmy Akin: Having discussed the possibility of intelligent aliens, he says, one
- 57:46Jimmy Akin: thing is certain.
- 57:47Jimmy Akin: The apostolic letters of the New Testament tell us clearly that the triumph of Christ embraces the entire cosmos.
- 57:55Jimmy Akin: 1
- 57:55Jimmy Akin: Peter 3 22, Ephesians 1 20 and 21, Colossians 1 15, and following
- 58:03Jimmy Akin: In the 1950s, Father Jean Danielou
- 58:06Jimmy Akin: wrote a small book on the vision of the fathers regarding the cosmic victory of Christ, the angels, and their mission.
- 58:13Jimmy Akin: Let's take a look at the passages that Benedict cites.
- 58:17Jimmy Akin: They include 1 Peter 3.
- 58:18Jimmy Akin: 22, which says, Jesus Christ has gone into heaven and is at the right hand of God.
- 58:25Jimmy Akin: with
- 58:25Jimmy Akin: angels, authorities, and powers having been subjected to him.
- 58:30Jimmy Akin: Ephesians 1, 20 and 21
- 58:32Jimmy Akin: says
- 58:33Jimmy Akin: God worked
- 58:34Jimmy Akin: in Christ when he raised him
- 58:36Jimmy Akin: from the dead
- 58:37Jimmy Akin: and seated him at his
- 58:38Jimmy Akin: right hand in the heavenly places, far above all rule and authority
- 58:43Jimmy Akin: and power
- 58:43Jimmy Akin: and dominion.
- 58:45Jimmy Akin: and above every name that is named, not only in this age, but also in the one to come.
- 58:51Jimmy Akin: And in Colossians 1, starting at verse 15, Paul says,
- 58:55Jimmy Akin: Christ is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation, for by him
- 59:00Jimmy Akin: all things were created, in heaven and on earth, visible and invisible.
- 59:05Jimmy Akin: whether thrones or dominions
- 59:07Jimmy Akin: or rulers or authorities.
- 59:09Jimmy Akin: All things were created through him
- 59:12Jimmy Akin: and for him.
- 59:13Jimmy Akin: For in him
- 59:14Jimmy Akin: all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell,
- 59:17Jimmy Akin: and through him
- 59:18Jimmy Akin: to reconcile to himself all things, whether on earth or in heaven, making
- 59:24Jimmy Akin: peace by the blood of his
- 59:25Jimmy Akin: cross
- 59:26Jimmy Akin: These passages certainly speak of the cosmic significance of Christ's triumph, since he is at the right hand of God, with angels, authorities, and powers having been subjected to him
- 59:39Jimmy Akin: Since he is seated at his
- 59:41Jimmy Akin: right hand in the heavenly places, far above all rule and authority
- 59:45Jimmy Akin: and power and dominion.
- 59:47Jimmy Akin: And since all things were created through him
- 59:50Jimmy Akin: and for him, and he reconciled to himself
- 59:54Jimmy Akin: all things, whether on earth or in heaven, by his
- 59:58Jimmy Akin: cross
- 59:59Jimmy Akin: Benedict thus says that it is certain that the apostolic letters of the New Testament tell us clearly that the triumph of Christ embraces the entire cosmos.
- 1:00:09Jimmy Akin: What this doesn't do
- 1:00:11Jimmy Akin: is answer all the questions we might have about the implications
- 1:00:15Jimmy Akin: of this cosmic triumph, like
- 1:00:18Jimmy Akin: whether there are aliens
- 1:00:20Jimmy Akin: in
- 1:00:21Jimmy Akin: whether they're fallen
- 1:00:22Jimmy Akin: creatures like we are, and
- 1:00:24Jimmy Akin: whether God chose
- 1:00:26Jimmy Akin: to save them, and
- 1:00:27Jimmy Akin: whether he chose
- 1:00:29Jimmy Akin: to save them through the death of Jesus here on earth
- 1:00:33Jimmy Akin: It
- 1:00:33Jimmy Akin: might mean those things, but there are other possibilities as well.
- 1:00:38Jimmy Akin: Benedict also recommends another book at this point, saying, in the 1950s, Father Jean
- 1:00:44Jimmy Akin: Danielou wrote a small book on the vision of the fathers regarding
- 1:00:47Jimmy Akin: regarding the cosmic victory of Christ.
- 1:00:49Jimmy Akin: That book has been published in English as The Angels and Their Mission, and in it Father Danielu
- 1:00:56Jimmy Akin: presents Christ's ascension after the crucifixion
- 1:00:59Jimmy Akin: as the decisive act that restores
- 1:01:02Jimmy Akin: mankind to the fellowship of the angels.
- 1:01:04Jimmy Akin: It thus deals with the cosmic implications of Christ's victory
- 1:01:09Jimmy Akin: Benedict closes his letter by writing, I hope that these hints can be a first help for your reflections.
- 1:01:15Jimmy Akin: Yours in the Lord, Benedict XVI.
- 1:01:19Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:01:19Jimmy Akin: he presents his responses only as hints
- 1:01:23Jimmy Akin: that can be a first
- 1:01:25Jimmy Akin: help in considering these questions.
- 1:01:27Jimmy Akin: They're not definitive answers, and in fact Benedict didn't try to settle almost anything in his letter.
- 1:01:34Jimmy Akin: He did say that it's certain that Christ's triumph has cosmic significance, but
- 1:01:38Jimmy Akin: But otherwise, he only expressed openness on these questions.
- 1:01:42Jimmy Akin: On polygenism, he said that it has not been excluded absolutely, meaning both monogenism and polygenism are possible.
- 1:01:50Jimmy Akin: On Original Sin
- 1:01:52Jimmy Akin: he said that discussion of it has only just begun, and he recommended the proposal of Archbishop Leonard
- 1:01:59Jimmy Akin: that it be understood as a transhistorical choice that shaped the history of the world.
- 1:02:04Jimmy Akin: On
- 1:02:05Jimmy Akin: extraterrestrial intelligence, he said, we don't know if there is life on other planets or not, and he recommended the works of C.
- 1:02:12Jimmy Akin: S.
- 1:02:13Jimmy Akin: Lewis.
- 1:02:14Jimmy Akin: And on Christ and Aliens, he said that Christ Triumph definitely has cosmic significance
- 1:02:19Jimmy Akin: and recommended a book by Father Jean Daniel.
- 1:02:22Jimmy Akin: but he did not go into all of the implications of Christ's triumph for any other intelligent creatures that might exist.
- 1:02:29Jimmy Akin: In each of these, Benedict thus held a position of openness.
- 1:02:34Jimmy Akin: which is exactly what I would have predicted based on my knowledge of Benedict's thought
- 1:02:39Jimmy Akin: and of church teaching.
- 1:02:41Jimmy Akin: I was a little surprised that he supported the trans
- 1:02:44Jimmy Akin: historical understanding of original
- 1:02:45Jimmy Akin: sin as strongly as he did
- 1:02:47Jimmy Akin: And I personally would have gone into the range of possible implications that Christ's victory may or may not have for other races, a little more.
- 1:02:57Jimmy Akin: But Benedict landed where I expected, however much that may
- 1:03:02Jimmy Akin: displease certain folks.
- 1:03:04Dom Bettinelli: We'd like to take a moment to thank our patrons who make this show possible, including
- 1:03:08Dom Bettinelli: Dina C.
- 1:03:09Dom Bettinelli: Martin P. Deborah
- 1:03:11Dom Bettinelli: F. Leslie H,
- 1:03:12Dom Bettinelli: and Bruce E. Their generous
- 1:03:14Dom Bettinelli: donations at givemysterious.fm
- 1:03:17Dom Bettinelli: make it possible
- 1:03:18Dom Bettinelli: for us to continue Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World
- 1:03:21Dom Bettinelli: and all the shows at StarQuest.
- 1:03:23Dom Bettinelli: More than 90% of our financial support comes from individual donors like you
- 1:03:28Dom Bettinelli: and you can join them by visiting givemysterious.
- 1:03:32Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 1:03:34Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is also brought to you by Father Dwight Longnecker.
- 1:03:39Dom Bettinelli: Father Longnecker reminds the Jimmy Akin's
- 1:03:41Dom Bettinelli: Mysterious World audience that one of the most mysterious of mysteries is coming up
- 1:03:46Dom Bettinelli: And
- 1:03:46Dom Bettinelli: that is the mystery of Christ's nativity, otherwise known as Christmas.
- 1:03:50Dom Bettinelli: The Magi, along with the shepherds, are the mysterious strangers who come to visit the stable boy of Bethlehem
- 1:03:57Dom Bettinelli: In his two
- 1:03:58Dom Bettinelli: Christmas books, Father Longnecker
- 1:04:00Dom Bettinelli: explores the mystery of the Magi
- 1:04:02Dom Bettinelli: and the secret of the Bethlehem Shepherds.
- 1:04:04Dom Bettinelli: These books will deepen your understanding of Christmas and are perfect to wrap up and put beneath the tree
- 1:04:10Dom Bettinelli: To cut through all the mystery and get down to the history, check out Father Longnecker's Substacked
- 1:04:16Dom Bettinelli: website.
- 1:04:17Dom Bettinelli: Go to dweltlongnecker.
- 1:04:20Dom Bettinelli: com to read his blog, browse his books, and be in touch
- 1:04:24Dom Bettinelli: And
- 1:04:25Dom Bettinelli: by
- 1:04:25Dom Bettinelli: Gravetending Solutions.
- 1:04:27Dom Bettinelli: Gravetending is a professional service and apostolate that brings peace of mind to families.
- 1:04:33Dom Bettinelli: By caring for established grave
- 1:04:35Dom Bettinelli: sites, distance and physical limitations can create barriers to maintaining a loved one's
- 1:04:40Dom Bettinelli: Final resting place.
- 1:04:42Dom Bettinelli: From planting graveside gardens to cleaning headstones, a grave
- 1:04:45Dom Bettinelli: tending professional provides a way for their clients to continue to care for and honor their loved ones.
- 1:04:51Dom Bettinelli: If you're interested in learning more about grave
- 1:04:53Dom Bettinelli: tending
- 1:04:54Dom Bettinelli: Either as a client or as someone who'd like to enter the profession, please visit gravetending solutions.
- 1:05:00Dom Bettinelli: com
- 1:05:05Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:05:05Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy in his letter, Benedict told Paolo Musso that nothing serious is known about life on other planets
- 1:05:12Dom Bettinelli: What does that mean for the wider discussion of UFOs or UAPs?
- 1:05:17Jimmy Akin: Well, it has some important implications.
- 1:05:20Jimmy Akin: For years, some folks have claimed that the Vatican has proof.
- 1:05:24Jimmy Akin: that extraterrestrial intelligence exists.
- 1:05:26Jimmy Akin: According to these claims, uh the Vatican knows about aliens
- 1:05:30Jimmy Akin: and it has been keeping that knowledge from the public.
- 1:05:34Jimmy Akin: It isn't hard to understand why claims like this are popular.
- 1:05:37Jimmy Akin: You know, for one thing, it's exciting to think that the Vatican might be sitting on proof of aliens.
- 1:05:43Jimmy Akin: Oh, for another, the Vatican is an old institution with lots of archives
- 1:05:47Jimmy Akin: and people love to attribute all kinds of secret things to it.
- 1:05:52Jimmy Akin: You know, we looked at examples of
- 1:05:54Jimmy Akin: things like that before, like in episode one hundred forty seven on the Vatican Secret Archives and the Chronovisor in episode two
- 1:06:01Jimmy Akin: ninety nine.
- 1:06:02Jimmy Akin: So the idea that the Vatican has a secret file on aliens, you
- 1:06:06Jimmy Akin: fits right in with that kind of
- 1:06:08Jimmy Akin: Paradigm.
- 1:06:10Dom Bettinelli: One of the places these claims show up is in a field known as exopolitics.
- 1:06:15Dom Bettinelli: What is exopolitics?
- 1:06:17Jimmy Akin: Well, it's a term that has come up in the last few years
- 1:06:21Jimmy Akin: since
- 1:06:21Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:06:22Jimmy Akin: around two
- 1:06:23Jimmy Akin: thousand
- 1:06:23Jimmy Akin: five.
- 1:06:24Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:06:24Jimmy Akin: the Greek word exo
- 1:06:26Jimmy Akin: means outside
- 1:06:27Jimmy Akin: and politic means
- 1:06:29Jimmy Akin: politics, so
- 1:06:30Jimmy Akin: exopolitics is supposed to be the politics of the extraterrestrial, or how
- 1:06:37Jimmy Akin: human political governments deal with beings from outside our world.
- 1:06:43Jimmy Akin: One of the key people associated with exopolitics is named Michael Sala, and he writes on the subject at his website, exopolitics.
- 1:06:53Jimmy Akin: org.
- 1:06:53Jimmy Akin: Uh he's written a number of pieces there about the Vatican and extraterrestrials, and in May of 2025, just after the election of Pope Leo XIV, he published a piece titled
- 1:07:05Jimmy Akin: Pope Leo XIV
- 1:07:07Jimmy Akin: and Vatican will
- 1:07:09Jimmy Akin: lead official extraterrestrial disclosure.
- 1:07:13Jimmy Akin: The piece says
- 1:07:14Dom Bettinelli: Leo XIV, the first American Pope, will play a key role in an official announcement of extraterrestrial life and the launch of a Star Trek
- 1:07:23Dom Bettinelli: future during the Trump administration.
- 1:07:25Dom Bettinelli: The election of Pope Leo XIV
- 1:07:27Dom Bettinelli: was a tacit acknowledgement that White Hats and an Earth Alliance associated with the Trump administration
- 1:07:33Dom Bettinelli: have defeated the globalist deep state in an undeclared secret war
- 1:07:38Dom Bettinelli: The Vatican has subsequently signaled its intention to collaborate with the Victors, the Trump administration, in a future official announcement regarding the discovery of extraterrestrial life through an American Pope.
- 1:07:50Dom Bettinelli: This Exopolitics Today podcast examines the historic role played by the Vatican in studying and covering up evidence
- 1:07:59Dom Bettinelli: of extraterrestrial life
- 1:08:00Dom Bettinelli: dating back to 1933
- 1:08:03Dom Bettinelli: with the discovery of a crashed flying saucer
- 1:08:05Dom Bettinelli: in northern Italy
- 1:08:07Dom Bettinelli: Special focus is placed on the book Exo Vaticana Petrus Romanus, Project Lucifer, and the Vatican's Astonishing Plan for the Arrival of an Alien Savior.
- 1:08:17Dom Bettinelli: which predicted that extraterrestrial disclosure would occur under Pope Francis.
- 1:08:23Dom Bettinelli: It is proposed by Dr.
- 1:08:24Dom Bettinelli: Michael Salah that even though the Vatican laid the groundwork for such an announcement,
- 1:08:28Dom Bettinelli: Prior to Pope Francis coming to power in twenty
- 1:08:31Dom Bettinelli: thirteen, the Deep State blocked the announcement.
- 1:08:34Dom Bettinelli: With the recent defeat of the Deep State, the pathway is clear for the Vatican
- 1:08:38Dom Bettinelli: and US to collaborate in making such an announcement
- 1:08:42Dom Bettinelli: The
- 1:08:42Dom Bettinelli: extensive information in Exo Vaticana
- 1:08:45Dom Bettinelli: provides a framework for understanding key issues and what to expect with the Vatican's involvement in extraterrestrial disclosure.
- 1:08:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:08:53Jimmy Akin: Sila
- 1:08:54Jimmy Akin: holds that the Vatican has been studying and covering up extraterrestrial life since 1933.
- 1:09:01Jimmy Akin: He also holds that the Vatican intends to make an official announcement about it through Leo XIV, the American Pope.
- 1:09:09Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:09:10Jimmy Akin: he refers to a twenty
- 1:09:12Jimmy Akin: thirteen book by the writers Chris Putnam and Thomas Horn.
- 1:09:17Dom Bettinelli: Sulla
- 1:09:17Dom Bettinelli: mentioned a crashed flying saucer that was supposedly discovered in northern Italy in nineteen
- 1:09:22Dom Bettinelli: thirty three.
- 1:09:23Dom Bettinelli: What's that about?
- 1:09:24Jimmy Akin: Uh that's what's known as the Magenta
- 1:09:27Jimmy Akin: UFO crash.
- 1:09:28Jimmy Akin: Uh Magenta
- 1:09:29Jimmy Akin: is a town outside of Milan.
- 1:09:31Jimmy Akin: And according to the story, an unidentified craft came down in that area in 1933, and the government of the Italian dictator Benito Mussolini
- 1:09:41Jimmy Akin: recovered it and kept it secret
- 1:09:43Jimmy Akin: The story rests on a set of papers that were mailed anonymously to an Italian ufologist named Roberto Pinotti, beginning in 1996.
- 1:09:54Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:09:54Jimmy Akin: the case got a lot more attention though in 2023
- 1:09:58Jimmy Akin: when a former intelligence officer named David Grush made claims about it.
- 1:10:03Jimmy Akin: That year, Grush went public with the claim that the U.
- 1:10:05Jimmy Akin: S.
- 1:10:06Jimmy Akin: government had a secret program for retrieving crashed
- 1:10:09Jimmy Akin: UFOs
- 1:10:10Dom Bettinelli: Grush also said things about the Vatican in a 2023
- 1:10:14Dom Bettinelli: interview with News Nation journalist Ross Coulthardt.
- 1:10:17Dom Bettinelli: What did he say?
- 1:10:18Jimmy Akin: Coulthard asked him whether the Vatican knows about non-human intelligence, and a NewsNation
- 1:10:25Jimmy Akin: article from 2026
- 1:10:27Jimmy Akin: recounts the exchange.
- 1:10:30Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:10:30Dom Bettinelli: let me be very clear about this, News Nations Ross Coulthard asked Grush during an exclusive interview in 2023.
- 1:10:38Dom Bettinelli: You're saying that the Catholic Church, the Vatican, they know about the existence of non-human intelligence on this planet?
- 1:10:45Dom Bettinelli: Certainly, Grush replied.
- 1:10:48Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:10:48Jimmy Akin: Grush claimed that the Vatican knows that non-human intelligence exists, and
- 1:10:54Jimmy Akin: he's not talking about angels here.
- 1:10:56Jimmy Akin: And he connected uh
- 1:10:59Jimmy Akin: the Vatican with the Magenta
- 1:11:01Jimmy Akin: case.
- 1:11:01Jimmy Akin: Here's how a 2023 article reports his remarks.
- 1:11:06Dom Bettinelli: 1933 was the first recovery in Europe
- 1:11:09Dom Bettinelli: in Magenta, Italy, he told NewsNation on Sunday.
- 1:11:13Dom Bettinelli: They recovered a partially intact vehicle
- 1:11:15Dom Bettinelli: and the Italian government moved it to a secure air base
- 1:11:19Dom Bettinelli: in Italy until around nineteen forty four to forty
- 1:11:22Dom Bettinelli: five.
- 1:11:23Dom Bettinelli: The former intelligence official added about the alleged post
- 1:11:26Dom Bettinelli: war
- 1:11:27Dom Bettinelli: mission in question.
- 1:11:28Dom Bettinelli: The Pope back
- 1:11:29Dom Bettinelli: channeled that and told the Americans what the Italians had, and we ended up scooping it.
- 1:11:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:11:35Jimmy Akin: Grush's claim is that the Pope told the Americans about the craft
- 1:11:40Jimmy Akin: and that the United States then took possession of it.
- 1:11:43Jimmy Akin: The Pope at the end of World War II was Pius XII, who reigned from 1939 to 1958.
- 1:11:50Jimmy Akin: Now, it's important to know
- 1:11:52Jimmy Akin: that this is partitioned from some of the other things that Gresh claims, like things he was directly involved in.
- 1:11:59Jimmy Akin: When it comes to the Magenta
- 1:12:01Jimmy Akin: UFO crash story, Gresh didn't claim to have seen any of this for himself.
- 1:12:06Jimmy Akin: He said he was relying on what other people had told him
- 1:12:09Jimmy Akin: and that
- 1:12:10Jimmy Akin: the supporting documents and data were classified
- 1:12:13Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:12:14Jimmy Akin: he could be right about the stuff that he claimed to be involved in personally
- 1:12:18Jimmy Akin: and completely wrong
- 1:12:20Jimmy Akin: about what people told him regarding the magenta
- 1:12:23Jimmy Akin: case.
- 1:12:23Jimmy Akin: I've done some research on that case, and there's a lot more to say about it, so I might may devote a future episode to it.
- 1:12:31Dom Bettinelli: Salah also mentioned a book by Putnam and Horn
- 1:12:35Dom Bettinelli: which deals with what's sometimes called controlled disclosure.
- 1:12:38Dom Bettinelli: What does that mean?
- 1:12:40Jimmy Akin: The idea of controlled disclosure is that the authorities know aliens exist, but they don't want to spring this on the public all at once
- 1:12:48Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:12:49Jimmy Akin: people would panic and freak out.
- 1:12:51Jimmy Akin: So, according to this idea, they're gradually preparing people for an eventual
- 1:12:56Jimmy Akin: announcement.
- 1:12:57Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:12:58Jimmy Akin: some
- 1:12:58Jimmy Akin: people claim that the Vatican is doing that.
- 1:13:01Jimmy Akin: That was the argument in the
- 1:13:04Jimmy Akin: uh Putnam and Horn
- 1:13:05Jimmy Akin: book, which is titled
- 1:13:07Jimmy Akin: Exo
- 1:13:08Jimmy Akin: Vaticana
- 1:13:09Jimmy Akin: Petrus
- 1:13:10Jimmy Akin: Romanos, Project Lucifer and the Vatican's astonishing
- 1:13:14Jimmy Akin: plan
- 1:13:15Jimmy Akin: for the arrival of an
- 1:13:17Jimmy Akin: alien
- 1:13:18Jimmy Akin: saviour.
- 1:13:19Jimmy Akin: And according to Sala, it predicted that disclosure would happen under Pope Francis.
- 1:13:26Jimmy Akin: People who think that the Vatican is preparing for disclosure
- 1:13:30Jimmy Akin: often point
- 1:13:31Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:13:32Jimmy Akin: statements made by, for example, Vatican astronomers, and the astronomers
- 1:13:37Jimmy Akin: never say
- 1:13:39Jimmy Akin: things that confirm what the exopolitics authors claim.
- 1:13:43Jimmy Akin: They
- 1:13:43Jimmy Akin: always say general things about what the implications
- 1:13:48Jimmy Akin: might be
- 1:13:48Jimmy Akin: if what aliens exist.
- 1:13:50Jimmy Akin: You
- 1:13:50Jimmy Akin: like, you know, the Christian faith would be just fine.
- 1:13:54Jimmy Akin: Then the aliens would just be other children of God, whether they're good children or bad children.
- 1:13:59Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:14:00Jimmy Akin: but exopolitics authors
- 1:14:02Jimmy Akin: sees
- 1:14:03Jimmy Akin: on every statement like that as
- 1:14:05Jimmy Akin: proof that the Vatican knows extraterrestrials exist and this is all part of the
- 1:14:11Jimmy Akin: controlled disclosure process
- 1:14:14Jimmy Akin: Well, in the summer of 2014, Salah claimed that Pope Francis
- 1:14:21Jimmy Akin: was just
- 1:14:22Jimmy Akin: about to make a statement on the subject.
- 1:14:25Jimmy Akin: He wrote.
- 1:14:26Dom Bettinelli: Pope Francis is reportedly preparing a major world statement about extraterrestrial life and its theological implications.
- 1:14:34Dom Bettinelli: Rosanna Ubinel from Voxy News
- 1:14:36Dom Bettinelli: Today reported that due to advances in scientific detection methods for the discovery of extraterrestrial life, Pope Francis wants to be ready with a statement about first
- 1:14:46Dom Bettinelli: contact.
- 1:14:47Dom Bettinelli: Ubinel reports that details have yet to be officially announced, but that the Vatican's interest in extraterrestrial life is well documented through recent astrobiology conferences the Vatican Observatory has sponsored or participated in.
- 1:15:01Dom Bettinelli: Father Guy Consulmano, a Jesuit astronomer and one of the leading Catholic proponents
- 1:15:07Dom Bettinelli: for preparing for the scientific discovery of extraterrestrial life.
- 1:15:10Dom Bettinelli: on july eighteenth, won the Carl Sagan
- 1:15:13Dom Bettinelli: Science Medal from the American Astronomical Society.
- 1:15:16Dom Bettinelli: Pope Francis, a fellow Jesuit, regularly consults with Consulmagno and other leading Vatican astronomers
- 1:15:23Dom Bettinelli: about scientific issues.
- 1:15:25Dom Bettinelli: It is likely that Pope Francis is preparing an Erby et Orbi speech, Latin for
- 1:15:30Dom Bettinelli: to the city of Rome and the World, about first contact with extraterrestrial life.
- 1:15:36Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:15:36Jimmy Akin: in July of 2014, Salah expected Pope Francis to make a major statement about first contact with extraterrestrials, and needless to say, that didn't happen.
- 1:15:49Jimmy Akin: Which is what happens every
- 1:15:51Jimmy Akin: time.
- 1:15:54Jimmy Akin: To
- 1:15:54Jimmy Akin: every prediction
- 1:15:56Jimmy Akin: by
- 1:15:57Jimmy Akin: exopolitics authors.
- 1:15:59Jimmy Akin: Personally, I find their claim, them
- 1:16:02Jimmy Akin: and their claims
- 1:16:03Jimmy Akin: really
- 1:16:04Jimmy Akin: annoying
- 1:16:05Jimmy Akin: Because they proceed from
- 1:16:07Jimmy Akin: a sensationalistic
- 1:16:09Jimmy Akin: and fundamentally incorrect appraisal of reality, and they are just
- 1:16:15Jimmy Akin: always wrong.
- 1:16:17Dom Bettinelli: Now
- 1:16:18Dom Bettinelli: Benedict wrote his letter to Paulo
- 1:16:20Dom Bettinelli: Musso on june sixth of that same year, twenty fourteen.
- 1:16:24Dom Bettinelli: How does what he said bear on these claims?
- 1:16:27Jimmy Akin: Well it clashes with them.
- 1:16:29Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:16:29Jimmy Akin: as we saw, Benedict told Musso
- 1:16:32Jimmy Akin: I personally think that
- 1:16:33Jimmy Akin: as long as nothing
- 1:16:35Jimmy Akin: serious is known about traces of life on other planets, there is not much sense in discussing the problem.
- 1:16:41Jimmy Akin: In other words, Benedict
- 1:16:42Jimmy Akin: said that
- 1:16:43Jimmy Akin: nothing
- 1:16:44Jimmy Akin: serious is known.
- 1:16:46Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:16:46Jimmy Akin: whether there is intelligent life on other planets.
- 1:16:50Jimmy Akin: But if Benedict had known that the Vatican had proof of extraterrestrial intelligence.
- 1:16:57Jimmy Akin: He wouldn't have said that.
- 1:16:59Jimmy Akin: And Benedict was in a position to know.
- 1:17:03Dom Bettinelli: Benedict served as Pope from 2005
- 1:17:05Dom Bettinelli: until his resignation in 2013.
- 1:17:08Dom Bettinelli: Wouldn't the Pope be told if the Vatican had evidence of aliens?
- 1:17:11Jimmy Akin: Yeah, he kind of would have been told.
- 1:17:14Jimmy Akin: Uh now
- 1:17:14Jimmy Akin: there's an argument to be made that not every American president would be told about it by his staff
- 1:17:20Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:17:21Jimmy Akin: Presidents come and go.
- 1:17:23Jimmy Akin: They're in office for a maximum of eight years and then they're gone.
- 1:17:26Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:17:27Jimmy Akin: you can see how
- 1:17:28Jimmy Akin: staffers who spend entire careers
- 1:17:31Jimmy Akin: in bureaucracy
- 1:17:33Jimmy Akin: Might decide not to tell a president they don't like, you know, like if they thought he'd do something crazy, like
- 1:17:39Jimmy Akin: tell the public and freak him
- 1:17:40Jimmy Akin: out
- 1:17:41Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:17:42Jimmy Akin: that doesn't apply to popes.
- 1:17:44Jimmy Akin: They can spend decades
- 1:17:46Jimmy Akin: in office.
- 1:17:47Jimmy Akin: They're expected to
- 1:17:49Jimmy Akin: remain in it for life, while lower
- 1:17:51Jimmy Akin: down
- 1:17:52Jimmy Akin: people only serve for limited terms.
- 1:17:54Jimmy Akin: And then there's that
- 1:17:55Jimmy Akin: You know that little fact that the Pope is supposed to be uh
- 1:18:00Jimmy Akin: the vicar of Christ himself
- 1:18:03Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:18:03Jimmy Akin: something like proof
- 1:18:05Jimmy Akin: valence
- 1:18:06Jimmy Akin: would be of enormous importance to the church, and the Pope would need to know about it, and so yes, he would be told.
- 1:18:14Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:18:14Jimmy Akin: in Benedict's case, it isn't just that he was Pope.
- 1:18:18Jimmy Akin: Before that, Joseph Ratzinger
- 1:18:21Jimmy Akin: headed the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith for more than 23
- 1:18:25Jimmy Akin: years.
- 1:18:25Jimmy Akin: The CDF is the Vatican office
- 1:18:28Jimmy Akin: that deals with doctrinal matters.
- 1:18:30Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:18:31Jimmy Akin: if aliens
- 1:18:32Jimmy Akin: ever had been discovered, they would have rushed the news over to the CDF.
- 1:18:38Jimmy Akin: So that the CDF could start working on a way to explain it to the faithful and deal with any implications it might have for the Christian faith
- 1:18:46Jimmy Akin: Thus, for that reason alone, the CDF, or the Holy Office as it used to be called, would have been informed immediately.
- 1:18:56Jimmy Akin: And thus
- 1:18:57Jimmy Akin: Joseph Ratzinger would have inherited that knowledge when he became its head.
- 1:19:03Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:19:04Jimmy Akin: There's another reason that he would have known, and that's
- 1:19:08Jimmy Akin: the fact that the Holy Office has been the keeper of certain highly important secret documents.
- 1:19:14Jimmy Akin: like
- 1:19:14Jimmy Akin: the third secret of Fatima that we discussed in episode
- 1:19:17Jimmy Akin: 64 and 65.
- 1:19:19Jimmy Akin: When the third secret
- 1:19:21Jimmy Akin: was published in the year 2000, the CDF explained
- 1:19:24Dom Bettinelli: The sealed envelope was initially in the custody of the Bishop of Leera.
- 1:19:29Dom Bettinelli: To ensure better protection for the secret, the envelope was placed in the secret
- 1:19:33Dom Bettinelli: archives of the Holy Office
- 1:19:34Dom Bettinelli: on four
- 1:19:35Dom Bettinelli: April nineteen fifty-seven, the Bishop of Lera
- 1:19:38Dom Bettinelli: informs Sicilucia
- 1:19:40Dom Bettinelli: of this.
- 1:19:40Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:19:41Jimmy Akin: for more than forty
- 1:19:42Jimmy Akin: years the third secret was kept in the archives of the Holy Office.
- 1:19:46Jimmy Akin: Ratzinger
- 1:19:47Jimmy Akin: thus spent more than two decades as the head of the office that kept sensitive material like the Third Secret.
- 1:19:54Jimmy Akin: And if the Vatican had proof of aliens and decided not to make it public, then because of the implications for the faith, it would have been kept at the
- 1:20:04Jimmy Akin: CDF
- 1:20:05Jimmy Akin: that, you know, held such documents.
- 1:20:08Jimmy Akin: and Ratzinger
- 1:20:09Jimmy Akin: thus would have known about it, because
- 1:20:11Jimmy Akin: if mankind is in contact with aliens, well you can never be sure what they're gonna do, and so the CDF would need
- 1:20:19Jimmy Akin: to be able to act at a moment's notice.
- 1:20:22Jimmy Akin: Thus, if the Vatican had proof of aliens, the head of that office would
- 1:20:28Jimmy Akin: be among the people who knew about it.
- 1:20:30Jimmy Akin: And then he became Pope.
- 1:20:32Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:20:33Jimmy Akin: if anyone was in a position to know whether the Vatican had proof of extraterrestrial intelligence, it was Joseph Ratzinger.
- 1:20:42Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:20:42Jimmy Akin: in 2014, after he'd held both positions, he said that nothing serious is known about life on other planets, and that's a serious mark against the credibility
- 1:20:55Jimmy Akin: of the claims that the Vatican has such proof.
- 1:20:58Dom Bettinelli: Some people might respond that Benedict was simply lying to Musso.
- 1:21:03Dom Bettinelli: What would you say to that?
- 1:21:05Jimmy Akin: Well, there are two problems with that idea.
- 1:21:07Jimmy Akin: The first one is
- 1:21:08Jimmy Akin: it doesn't fit Joseph Ratzinger.
- 1:21:11Jimmy Akin: If you think Ratzinger
- 1:21:12Jimmy Akin: would invent a falsehood for a correspondent on a question like this, then
- 1:21:17Jimmy Akin: You just don't know anything about Joseph Ratzinger.
- 1:21:20Jimmy Akin: Also, he didn't have to respond to Musso
- 1:21:23Jimmy Akin: in the first place.
- 1:21:24Jimmy Akin: If Benedict wanted to avoid the subject, he didn't have to lie.
- 1:21:27Jimmy Akin: He could have just not answered his letter
- 1:21:29Jimmy Akin: A s
- 1:21:30Jimmy Akin: the second problem
- 1:21:31Jimmy Akin: is that a
- 1:21:32Jimmy Akin: lie
- 1:21:33Jimmy Akin: wouldn't fit the conclusion that Benedict drew.
- 1:21:37Jimmy Akin: He said that, given our lack of knowledge, there isn't much sense in discussing the question intensively
- 1:21:43Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:21:44Jimmy Akin: suppose
- 1:21:45Jimmy Akin: the Vatican did know
- 1:21:47Jimmy Akin: that aliens exist and was in the process of managing a controlled disclosure.
- 1:21:52Jimmy Akin: Well, then Benedict would have said the opposite of what he did say.
- 1:21:56Jimmy Akin: He would have said that we need to be discussing this a lot
- 1:22:00Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:22:00Jimmy Akin: If we knew that aliens exist, well, then it would be urgent to devote attention to this question, and so he would be encouraging people to discuss this more
- 1:22:10Jimmy Akin: so they'd be ready whenever the disclosure happened.
- 1:22:13Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:22:13Jimmy Akin: Benedict's actions, like his, well, we really don't need to figure this out at this moment, attitude
- 1:22:20Jimmy Akin: is just
- 1:22:21Jimmy Akin: inconsistent with the claim that the Vatican knows aliens
- 1:22:26Jimmy Akin: exist.
- 1:22:27Jimmy Akin: As a result, the claims of the exopolitics authors
- 1:22:31Jimmy Akin: as
- 1:22:32Jimmy Akin: usual, don't fare
- 1:22:34Jimmy Akin: well.
- 1:22:35Jimmy Akin: Not the claim that the Vatican knows aliens exist, not the controlled disclosure claim
- 1:22:41Jimmy Akin: And not the magenta
- 1:22:43Jimmy Akin: UFO crash claim that Pius XII
- 1:22:45Jimmy Akin: supposedly played a role in.
- 1:22:48Dom Bettinelli: So Jimmy, what's your bottom line?
- 1:22:50Dom Bettinelli: The
- 1:22:50Jimmy Akin: Benedict the Sixteenth letter
- 1:22:53Jimmy Akin: from twenty
- 1:22:54Jimmy Akin: fourteen to Paolo Musso
- 1:22:55Jimmy Akin: is genuine.
- 1:22:56Jimmy Akin: It was published in a university textbook during Benedict's lifetime
- 1:23:00Jimmy Akin: with his permission
- 1:23:02Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:23:03Jimmy Akin: nobody
- 1:23:05Jimmy Akin: on his staff or at the Vatican
- 1:23:06Jimmy Akin: challenged it.
- 1:23:08Jimmy Akin: In the letter, Benedict took a position of openness on difficult questions.
- 1:23:12Jimmy Akin: He said that polygynism
- 1:23:14Jimmy Akin: had not been excluded
- 1:23:16Jimmy Akin: absolutely
- 1:23:17Jimmy Akin: He said that the discussion of it
- 1:23:19Jimmy Akin: of original sin had only just begun, and he pointed to the proposal of Archbishop Andre
- 1:23:26Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:23:26Jimmy Akin: Joseph Leonard of Brussels.
- 1:23:28Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:23:29Jimmy Akin: he said that nothing serious is known about life on other planets.
- 1:23:33Jimmy Akin: We don't know whether intelligent aliens exists, and Benedict didn't claim to know either.
- 1:23:39Jimmy Akin: That last
- 1:23:40Jimmy Akin: point has implications for the claim that the Vatican has proof of extraterrestrial intelligence, because Joseph Ratzinger
- 1:23:47Jimmy Akin: was in a position to know
- 1:23:49Jimmy Akin: as head of the CDF for more than twenty-three years.
- 1:23:53Jimmy Akin: and then
- 1:23:53Jimmy Akin: as Pope, and his conclusion
- 1:23:56Jimmy Akin: that there
- 1:23:57Jimmy Akin: isn't too much sense in discussing the question in depth
- 1:24:01Jimmy Akin: is the opposite of what we would expect
- 1:24:04Jimmy Akin: if the Vatican were preparing the world for disclosure.
- 1:24:08Jimmy Akin: By the way, if you haven't uh yet checked out the Jimmy
- 1:24:11Jimmy Akin: Akin podcast, please do so.
- 1:24:13Jimmy Akin: It's devoted to the mysteries of the Christian faith, so there's a lot of stuff you may find interesting.
- 1:24:19Jimmy Akin: You can find it wherever you get your podcasts and also on YouTube.
- 1:24:23Jimmy Akin: And you can support it
- 1:24:25Jimmy Akin: and get early access to new episodes by going to patreon.
- 1:24:28Jimmy Akin: com slash Jimmy
- 1:24:29Jimmy Akin: Aken
- 1:24:30Jimmy Akin: Podcast.
- 1:24:31Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:24:32Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, what further resources can we offer to the listeners and viewers?
- 1:24:35Jimmy Akin: We'll have links to Paolo Musso's book, La Vita Extraterrestre.
- 1:24:41Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:24:41Jimmy Akin: which contains uh Pope Benedict's letter as an appendix.
- 1:24:45Jimmy Akin: We'll also have links
- 1:24:47Jimmy Akin: a link to Chris Putnam and Thomas Horne's ridiculous book, Exo
- 1:24:52Jimmy Akin: Vaticana
- 1:24:53Jimmy Akin: Also
- 1:24:54Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:24:54Jimmy Akin: CDF document, The Message of Fatima, talking about the third secret, as well as
- 1:25:01Jimmy Akin: various uh
- 1:25:02Jimmy Akin: biographical and other notes uh from the Vatican website.
- 1:25:06Jimmy Akin: Also
- 1:25:07Jimmy Akin: Michael Salas, Pope Leo XIV
- 1:25:09Jimmy Akin: and Vatican
- 1:25:10Jimmy Akin: will
- 1:25:11Jimmy Akin: lead
- 1:25:12Jimmy Akin: official extraterrestrial disclosure.
- 1:25:14Jimmy Akin: We'll see how well that prediction fares in the future
- 1:25:19Jimmy Akin: as well
- 1:25:20Jimmy Akin: as his
- 1:25:20Jimmy Akin: previous 2014 statement about how Pope Francis was going to announce extraterrestrial life
- 1:25:27Jimmy Akin: and other
- 1:25:28Jimmy Akin: related resources.
- 1:25:32Spidermail bumper: Look out!
- 1:25:33Spidermail bumper: Here comes the spider
- 1:25:35Spidermail bumper: ghost
- 1:25:42Dom Bettinelli: And now we turn to our mysterious feedback brought to us by our feedback coordinator, Rob Leonardi.
- 1:25:47Dom Bettinelli: And this feedback is coming from our episode 432 on The Shepherd of Hermos.
- 1:25:53Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 1:25:53Dom Bettinelli: the first feedback comes from Woodkern
- 1:25:56Dom Bettinelli: on Spotify, who writes, I love history, writings of the church fathers, and everything in between.
- 1:26:02Dom Bettinelli: But some in the past haven't met my preconceived expectations, probably since I'm two
- 1:26:06Dom Bettinelli: millennia removed from the cultural context of the authors and audience.
- 1:26:10Dom Bettinelli: Thus, I wasn't sure what to expect of the Shepherd of Hermos.
- 1:26:14Dom Bettinelli: That said, I found this topic so fascinating that I may have to look around for a modern translation of the book to investigate further.
- 1:26:21Dom Bettinelli: Also, Jimmy, I really appreciate your nuanced and reasonable view on anthropogenic climate change.
- 1:26:27Dom Bettinelli: While I don't work in climate science, I'm a scientist, studying the effects of electromagnetic fields on electronics, conduc
- 1:26:34Dom Bettinelli: conductors, etc.
- 1:26:36Dom Bettinelli: and have seen far too much scientific tomfoolery in the last twenty two years, both intentional and honest mistakes
- 1:26:43Dom Bettinelli: Today's climate science strikes me as being incredibly muddied by a lot of both, with an extra helping of corruption due to the money involved.
- 1:26:51Dom Bettinelli: Thanks again, gentlemen.
- 1:26:52Dom Bettinelli: God bless.
- 1:26:54Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:26:54Jimmy Akin: thank you.
- 1:26:55Jimmy Akin: I try to uh
- 1:26:57Jimmy Akin: do what I can to
- 1:26:59Jimmy Akin: uh present interesting material on early Christian
- 1:27:02Jimmy Akin: literature like the shepherd of Hermas, and I try
- 1:27:05Jimmy Akin: to be fair and balanced in my treatments of every subject, including alleged anthropogenic climate science, on which
- 1:27:13Jimmy Akin: I
- 1:27:15Jimmy Akin: I'm open, but
- 1:27:18Jimmy Akin: also
- 1:27:19Jimmy Akin: don't buy every claim that comes down the pike.
- 1:27:23Dom Bettinelli: Catherine on Spotify writes, thanks
- 1:27:25Dom Bettinelli: for a great episode, Jimmy and Dom.
- 1:27:27Dom Bettinelli: I love this series on the lost scriptures and your discussion of the shepherd of Hermos
- 1:27:31Dom Bettinelli: was fascinating.
- 1:27:32Dom Bettinelli: I would also enjoy an episode on the Sibyline Books and Oracles.
- 1:27:36Dom Bettinelli: Thank you.
- 1:27:38Jimmy Akin: Thanks, and I'll have to see if I can prepare such an episode.
- 1:27:41Jimmy Akin: There's a lot of material there, but some of it is really interesting.
- 1:27:47Dom Bettinelli: I find this representation of the church personified as an old woman and the description of the church's age to be problematic.
- 1:27:55Dom Bettinelli: The description
- 1:27:56Dom Bettinelli: she was created before all things.
- 1:27:58Dom Bettinelli: fits a similar description to Jesus in the Creed, born of the Father before all ages.
- 1:28:03Dom Bettinelli: Jesus's timelessness is an intrinsic part of his
- 1:28:06Dom Bettinelli: place in the Trinity.
- 1:28:08Dom Bettinelli: This suggests a sort of quadrinity, which of course would be heresy.
- 1:28:12Dom Bettinelli: It stands to reason that first there is God and nothing, and then subsequently
- 1:28:16Dom Bettinelli: creation.
- 1:28:17Dom Bettinelli: There logically can't be anything before creation except God's divine essence.
- 1:28:22Dom Bettinelli: Maybe you could say that you have God, then the church, then everything else, but does this not already contradict Genesis one?
- 1:28:29Dom Bettinelli: It seems like all the subsequent visions are based on this part, so it would call into question the entirety of the book
- 1:28:35Dom Bettinelli: so it wouldn't even be a private revelation, just a false gospel.
- 1:28:39Dom Bettinelli: If an author's primary attestation is origin, that is as good as worthless.
- 1:28:44Dom Bettinelli: He's not a very credible source, although not anathematized as explicitly as the Orthodox have done to him,
- 1:28:50Dom Bettinelli: he is at least highly controversial as an authority.
- 1:28:53Dom Bettinelli: The confirmation of the name being rare
- 1:28:55Dom Bettinelli: while being built on only a string of assumptions about name prevalence
- 1:28:59Dom Bettinelli: misses the more important possibility of falf
- 1:29:02Dom Bettinelli: false authorship
- 1:29:03Dom Bettinelli: which was not all that uncommon.
- 1:29:05Dom Bettinelli: You could just take a name from an epistle and attribute your writing to it.
- 1:29:09Dom Bettinelli: What is the evidence that this is not the case outside of origin?
- 1:29:13Jimmy Akin: Okay, um
- 1:29:14Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:29:15Jimmy Akin: you're raising two issues here.
- 1:29:17Jimmy Akin: The first one is
- 1:29:18Jimmy Akin: does the
- 1:29:20Jimmy Akin: Shepherd of Hermas
- 1:29:21Jimmy Akin: teach heretical doctrine when it conceives of
- 1:29:24Jimmy Akin: the church as existing with God before the creation of the world.
- 1:29:29Jimmy Akin: And I understand your argument, but you're
- 1:29:32Jimmy Akin: you're applying a set of categories that are anachronistic.
- 1:29:36Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:29:37Jimmy Akin: you're using
- 1:29:39Jimmy Akin: post-doctrinal development categories
- 1:29:42Jimmy Akin: to analyze
- 1:29:43Jimmy Akin: literature
- 1:29:45Jimmy Akin: that came
- 1:29:46Jimmy Akin: before that doctrinal development occurred
- 1:29:49Jimmy Akin: and therefore has to be read in a different way.
- 1:29:54Jimmy Akin: You can declare anything
- 1:29:59Jimmy Akin: heretical
- 1:30:00Jimmy Akin: if you impose
- 1:30:02Jimmy Akin: later categories and apply them rigidly.
- 1:30:05Jimmy Akin: rather than trying to enter into the thought of the text
- 1:30:09Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:30:09Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:30:10Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:30:11Jimmy Akin: world of the mind that was in circulation at the time.
- 1:30:17Jimmy Akin: The
- 1:30:17Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:30:18Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:30:18Jimmy Akin: for example, um
- 1:30:21Jimmy Akin: the Gospel of John
- 1:30:22Jimmy Akin: uses the term
- 1:30:24Jimmy Akin: God
- 1:30:25Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:30:25Jimmy Akin: the Father
- 1:30:27Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:30:28Jimmy Akin: dys
- 1:30:29Jimmy Akin: d
- 1:30:29Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:30:30Jimmy Akin: it regularly distinguishes Jesus from
- 1:30:34Jimmy Akin: the Father
- 1:30:36Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:30:37Jimmy Akin: you
- 1:30:38Jimmy Akin: and if you impose
- 1:30:40Jimmy Akin: the wrong later categories on that
- 1:30:44Jimmy Akin: you could say, oh, it's denying that Jesus is God.
- 1:30:48Jimmy Akin: But that's clearly not true
- 1:30:49Jimmy Akin: because we have
- 1:30:50Jimmy Akin: passages like John
- 1:30:52Jimmy Akin: 1 and John
- 1:30:53Jimmy Akin: 20 that I and in the middle, you know, we have a reference as well
- 1:30:57Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 1:30:58Jimmy Akin: makes Jesus equal to God.
- 1:31:00Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:31:02Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:31:02Jimmy Akin: you could either portray the Gospel of John as heretical or non-heretical, depending on which passages you're paying attention to.
- 1:31:10Jimmy Akin: and which categorical framework you're fitting over them.
- 1:31:15Jimmy Akin: The Shepherd of Hermas
- 1:31:17Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:31:18Jimmy Akin: similarly before the development of the categories that you're talking about.
- 1:31:23Jimmy Akin: And therefore we have to say, well, how could
- 1:31:26Jimmy Akin: this be taken in an orthodox sense
- 1:31:29Jimmy Akin: rather than just declaring it to be heretical?
- 1:31:32Jimmy Akin: And one of the things that you will find in
- 1:31:36Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:31:37Jimmy Akin: both Old Testament and Christian literature
- 1:31:40Jimmy Akin: is a
- 1:31:41Jimmy Akin: reference to things
- 1:31:43Jimmy Akin: you'll find language depicting other things as existing before creation, like wisdom
- 1:31:50Jimmy Akin: You know, the wisdom in various Old Testament passages is depicted as a woman that existed with God before creation
- 1:31:59Jimmy Akin: and that
- 1:32:00Jimmy Akin: was used, he used his wisdom to create the world.
- 1:32:03Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:32:04Jimmy Akin: in the same way, and there's a whole separate question of how that relates to the second person of the Trinity, but just sticking with the language, wisdom is this woman.
- 1:32:14Jimmy Akin: that is pictured in the text as existing with God before creation and was used in making creation.
- 1:32:20Jimmy Akin: Well, in the shepherd
- 1:32:22Jimmy Akin: The church is pictured as this woman existing with God before creation
- 1:32:28Jimmy Akin: and for whom
- 1:32:29Jimmy Akin: everything is made.
- 1:32:31Jimmy Akin: But Hermes
- 1:32:32Jimmy Akin: knows perfectly well that uh the church doesn't exist without members.
- 1:32:37Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:32:38Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:32:38Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:32:39Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:32:40Jimmy Akin: the church did not exist in the sense that it exists today.
- 1:32:44Jimmy Akin: It would be m
- 1:32:46Jimmy Akin: logical to read Hermes
- 1:32:48Jimmy Akin: '
- 1:32:48Jimmy Akin: imagery thus
- 1:32:49Jimmy Akin: as
- 1:32:50Jimmy Akin: envisioning the woman of the church as an idea in God's mind.
- 1:32:56Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:32:57Jimmy Akin: he built the world for, and
- 1:33:00Jimmy Akin: thus it's the goal of the world, which is why
- 1:33:03Jimmy Akin: when the church is complete, the world ends.
- 1:33:06Jimmy Akin: This is analogous to wisdom
- 1:33:09Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:33:09Jimmy Akin: an idea in God's mind that he then uses to build the world.
- 1:33:13Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:33:14Jimmy Akin: you have wisdom as the beginning of the world.
- 1:33:18Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:33:18Jimmy Akin: the church as the goal of the world, but there's nothing heretical
- 1:33:24Jimmy Akin: about using this idea
- 1:33:26Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:33:28Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:33:28Jimmy Akin: God
- 1:33:29Jimmy Akin: having an idea that's depicted as a woman from
- 1:33:32Jimmy Akin: all eternity.
- 1:33:33Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:33:34Jimmy Akin: I I think you're misreading the gospel.
- 1:33:38Jimmy Akin: Sorry, you're misreading
- 1:33:39Jimmy Akin: Hermes
- 1:33:41Jimmy Akin: in thinking that it's a false gospel.
- 1:33:43Jimmy Akin: When it comes to origin, I mentioned he's the first
- 1:33:47Jimmy Akin: guy to
- 1:33:48Jimmy Akin: identify
- 1:33:50Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:33:50Jimmy Akin: the author of the shepherd of hermas
- 1:33:53Jimmy Akin: with the hermas
- 1:33:54Jimmy Akin: mentioned in
- 1:33:55Jimmy Akin: the book of romans, um
- 1:33:58Jimmy Akin: he's not the only guy
- 1:34:00Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:34:00Jimmy Akin: frankly, you're committing what's known as the genetic fallacy
- 1:34:04Jimmy Akin: if you're just judging a claim by its
- 1:34:09Jimmy Akin: Ironically, by its origin
- 1:34:12Jimmy Akin: historically, rather than by its merits.
- 1:34:15Jimmy Akin: And I didn't just accept origin
- 1:34:18Jimmy Akin: as
- 1:34:19Jimmy Akin: proof or confirmation
- 1:34:21Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 1:34:22Jimmy Akin: Hermes
- 1:34:23Jimmy Akin: the Hermes of Romans wrote this book.
- 1:34:25Jimmy Akin: I went into statistical arguments, the merits of the case.
- 1:34:30Jimmy Akin: to say
- 1:34:31Jimmy Akin: how likely is it that there would have been these two different guys named Hermas
- 1:34:36Jimmy Akin: in this generation of the Roman Church
- 1:34:38Jimmy Akin: if
- 1:34:39Jimmy Akin: One of them is not the author of uh this book.
- 1:34:42Jimmy Akin: And I concluded it's very unlikely.
- 1:34:45Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:34:46Jimmy Akin: I would set the genetic fallacy
- 1:34:48Jimmy Akin: aside and focus on the merits.
- 1:34:50Jimmy Akin: which
- 1:34:50Jimmy Akin: are not only from
- 1:34:52Jimmy Akin: origin
- 1:34:53Jimmy Akin: and the merits I think
- 1:34:54Jimmy Akin: are substantial in this case.
- 1:34:56Jimmy Akin: So I hope that's helpful
- 1:34:58Dom Bettinelli: Our next feedback comes from William Vauk, who wrote in with an email.
- 1:35:02Dom Bettinelli: I love the podcast.
- 1:35:03Dom Bettinelli: I really enjoy the Lost Scriptures episodes, including the most recent one on the Shepherd of Hermos.
- 1:35:09Dom Bettinelli: Honey Pronunciation Note
- 1:35:11Dom Bettinelli: Prophe
- 1:35:12Dom Bettinelli: prophecy, the noun is
- 1:35:14Dom Bettinelli: prophecy, while prophesy, the verb
- 1:35:17Dom Bettinelli: is prophesy.
- 1:35:18Dom Bettinelli: Not a dialect thing, just one of those old English noun-verb pairs.
- 1:35:22Dom Bettinelli: I thought you might want to know.
- 1:35:24Jimmy Akin: Yeah, people sometimes pick on my pronunciation of these words.
- 1:35:28Jimmy Akin: I am aware of the difference between the
- 1:35:31Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:35:32Jimmy Akin: the noun and the verb, but in my mind
- 1:35:36Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:35:37Jimmy Akin: Prophesy
- 1:35:39Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:35:40Jimmy Akin: not
- 1:35:41Jimmy Akin: identical as a verb, is not identical with every use of the verb, but with certain uses.
- 1:35:48Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:35:49Jimmy Akin: however
- 1:35:51Jimmy Akin: People have different accents, accents being pronunciation schemes, and uh
- 1:35:56Jimmy Akin: you say tomato, I say tomato, so let's not fight about it.
- 1:36:03Dom Bettinelli: All right, and now it's time to hear from you.
- 1:36:06Dom Bettinelli: What are your theories about whether the Vatican knows something about aliens?
- 1:36:10Dom Bettinelli: You can let us know by visiting SQPN.
- 1:36:13Dom Bettinelli: com or the Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World Facebook
- 1:36:16Dom Bettinelli: page
- 1:36:16Dom Bettinelli: Sending us an email to feedback at mysterious.
- 1:36:19Dom Bettinelli: fm, sending a tweet to at
- 1:36:22Dom Bettinelli: mys
- 1:36:22Dom Bettinelli: underscore world, visiting the StarQuest
- 1:36:25Dom Bettinelli: Discord community at sqpn.
- 1:36:27Dom Bettinelli: com slash discord.
- 1:36:29Dom Bettinelli: or calling our mysterious feedback line at 619-738-4515.
- 1:36:35Dom Bettinelli: That's 619-738-4515.
- 1:36:39Jimmy Akin: Thanks to Oasis
- 1:36:41Jimmy Akin: Studio 7 for the video work on this episode.
- 1:36:43Jimmy Akin: Check it out by going to my channel
- 1:36:45Jimmy Akin: youtube.
- 1:36:46Jimmy Akin: com slash Jimmy
- 1:36:47Jimmy Akin: Akin
- 1:36:48Jimmy Akin: and join my quest to f
- 1:36:50Jimmy Akin: Fight the algorithm and get good content in front of people
- 1:36:53Jimmy Akin: by liking, commenting, writing a review, sharing the podcast, uh
- 1:36:58Jimmy Akin: hyping it.
- 1:36:59Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:36:59Jimmy Akin: of course, subscribing.
- 1:37:01Jimmy Akin: We're trying to get to 200,000 subscribers right now, so uh
- 1:37:05Jimmy Akin: be sure and subscribe.
- 1:37:06Jimmy Akin: And when you do
- 1:37:08Jimmy Akin: Seal the bell notification in an envelope, deposit it in the archives of the Holy Office
- 1:37:15Jimmy Akin: until
- 1:37:16Jimmy Akin: it will never be opened
- 1:37:18Jimmy Akin: and will sit in the archives forever.
- 1:37:21Jimmy Akin: Unless it notifies you whenever I have a new episode.
- 1:37:26Dom Bettinelli: So Jimmy, what's our next episode going to be about?
- 1:37:29Jimmy Akin: Next week, uh, we're coming up to the anniversary
- 1:37:33Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:37:33Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:37:34Jimmy Akin: the JFK assassination.
- 1:37:35Jimmy Akin: So we're gonna be taking another look at it this year, and we're gonna be looking at a very interesting
- 1:37:41Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:37:42Jimmy Akin: set
- 1:37:43Jimmy Akin: of claims about
- 1:37:44Jimmy Akin: a plot to kill JFK
- 1:37:47Jimmy Akin: a few weeks before Dallas
- 1:37:50Jimmy Akin: in Chicago.
- 1:37:51Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:37:52Jimmy Akin: there are some interesting
- 1:37:55Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:37:55Jimmy Akin: there's some interesting testimony about
- 1:37:58Jimmy Akin: this plot, including from one
- 1:38:00Jimmy Akin: of JFK's own Secret Service agents.
- 1:38:04Dom Bettinelli: Very interesting.
- 1:38:06Dom Bettinelli: Folks, be sure to check out the Mysterious World bookstore at MysteriousWorldStore.
- 1:38:10Dom Bettinelli: com for links to all the books and videos that Jimmy mentions in the show.
- 1:38:14Dom Bettinelli: Check out our new designs for Mysterious World
- 1:38:17Dom Bettinelli: t-shirts, mugs, and more in our merchandise shop at sqpn.
- 1:38:22Dom Bettinelli: com slash merch.
- 1:38:23Dom Bettinelli: You'll find links to Jimmy's resources from our discussion on our show notes at mysterious.
- 1:38:28Dom Bettinelli: fm slash four four
- 1:38:30Dom Bettinelli: three.
- 1:38:30Dom Bettinelli: And remember, to help us continue to produce the podcast, please visit give mysterious.
- 1:38:39Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin
- 1:38:40Dom Bettinelli: 's Mysterious World is also brought to you in part by Rosary Army, featuring award-winning Catholic podcasts, rosary
- 1:38:47Dom Bettinelli: resources, videos.
- 1:38:48Dom Bettinelli: And the School of
- 1:38:49Dom Bettinelli: Mary online
- 1:38:50Dom Bettinelli: community prayer
- 1:38:51Dom Bettinelli: and learning platform.
- 1:38:53Dom Bettinelli: Learn how to make them, pray them, and give them away while growing in your faith at rosaryarmy.
- 1:38:59Dom Bettinelli: com and schoolofmary.
- 1:39:01Dom Bettinelli: com.
- 1:39:02Dom Bettinelli: And bye.
- 1:39:03Dom Bettinelli: The Grady
- 1:39:04Dom Bettinelli: Group, a Catholic company bringing financial clarity to their clients across the United States, using safe money options to produce reasonable rates of return for their clients.
- 1:39:14Dom Bettinelli: Find them at greedygroup.
- 1:39:17Dom Bettinelli: us
- 1:39:21Dom Bettinelli: Until next time, Jimmy
- 1:39:22Dom Bettinelli: Akin, thank you for exploring with us our mysterious world.
- 1:39:25Jimmy Akin: Thanks, Dom.
- 1:39:27Dom Bettinelli: And once again, I'm Dom Bettinelli.
- 1:39:29Dom Bettinelli: Thank you for listening to Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World on StarQuest