Latest / Women's Health / 1.13.25
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: Welcome to Women's Health Corner for RADIOI. As a reminder,
- 0:06RADIOI is a reading service intended for people who are
- 0:09blind or have other disabilities that make it difficult to
- 0:13read printed material. The health material presented in this program
- 0:17is provided for your interests and information. It is not
- 0:21intended for the diagnosis or treatment of individuals. Please see
- 0:25your doctor or healthcare provider for that and any other
- 0:29health related concerns you may have. Your reader is Mary.
- 0:33Today I will be reading various articles from different publications.
- 0:39The first article is a lengthy article in Prevention Magazine,
- 0:43October twenty twenty four. Come as you are. We all
- 0:49deserve quality healthcare, but people in bigger bodies are often
- 0:54shut out. That's why some providers have worked out a
- 0:58new approach that aims to treat the person actually sitting
- 1:02in their exam room, rather than the one they would
- 1:05be if only they lost weight. This article is written
- 1:10by Bethany Berkshire, PhD. When Jacqueline Gill, PhD began trying
- 1:19to get pregnant at thirty three, all anyone wanted to
- 1:22talk about was her weight. Though she describes herself as fat,
- 1:27her doctors had never commented on her size, likely because
- 1:31she was essentially healthy. My blood pressure was always low
- 1:36and I never had high cholesterol, says Gil, a professor
- 1:39of ecology at the University of Maine in Orano. But
- 1:44when she had difficulty conceiving and started seeing a parade
- 1:48of specialists, things changed. Every time I would go in
- 1:52for an appointment, I was told, lose as much weight
- 1:55as you can for a year and then come back.
- 1:59Says that. Now for three year old, and try she did,
- 2:03I would yo yo diet, lose some weight, and then
- 2:06bounce back and weigh even more. Her gynecologist suspected that
- 2:12Gill's trouble conceiving had to do with polycystic ovarian syndrome PCOS.
- 2:19This condition may affect fertility and can also lead to
- 2:23weight gain. Also, a previous doctor had diagnosed her with adenomiosis,
- 2:30a condition in which the tissue lining the uterus grows
- 2:34into the muscular wall of the organ instead of remaining inside,
- 2:39causing heavy, painful periods and a thickened uterine lining. But
- 2:44Gil had never been told it was merely written in
- 2:48her chart. Her obgyn then treated her for her suspected PCOS,
- 2:55but the adenomiosis went untreated for three years, she says
- 3:00as the focus was all on the need for her
- 3:04to lose weight. This situation isn't uncommon, says Emily Jungheim, MD,
- 3:12a reproductive endocrinologist and infertility specialist at Northwestern University in
- 3:18Chicago and a board member of the American Board of
- 3:21Obstetrics and Gynecology. But while many doctors counsel weight loss
- 3:27before they will help a woman in a larger body
- 3:29to become pregnant, there's not much data to back up
- 3:33that recommendation. Weight laws doesn't necessarily translate into better outcomes,
- 3:39says doctor Jungheim. It also takes time to lose significant weight,
- 3:45during which the person is growing older. Age overall is
- 3:50always going to be the biggest factor in this picture,
- 3:53says doctor Jungheim. Other important issues whether someone is ovulating regularly,
- 4:00whether their fallopian tubes and uterus are healthy, and whether
- 4:04their partner or donor is producing enough viable sperm. When
- 4:10she was around thirty six, gil learned about her adenomiosis
- 4:15and was referred to a fertility specialist who said, it
- 4:20would be unethical for me to treat you because of
- 4:23your BMI, but if you lost ten pounds, and I
- 4:27knew you were putting in an effort, then I would reconsider.
- 4:32It was the first time Gil says that anyone had
- 4:35truly thrown my fat in my face. Aware the time
- 4:41wasn't on her side, she tried to tell the doctor
- 4:44about her adinomiosis, arguing that treating this might increase her odds.
- 4:50The doctor dismissed her completely, and Gil left the office
- 4:54in tears. My doctors weren't willing to talk about options
- 4:59because they just saw me as a fat person, she says. Finally,
- 5:05when Gil was thirty seven, her primary care provider referred
- 5:09her to another OBGYN. He listened to me. He never
- 5:14once blamed me, she says. He told her that she
- 5:17had never had p COS and immediately started fertility treatments.
- 5:23After two heartbreaking years of no success, she needed a hysterectomy.
- 5:29The adhesions from the adenomiosis were so extensive that her
- 5:34bowel was perforated during surgery. Her obgyn also saw extensive endometriosis.
- 5:43After five years and tens of thousands of dollars paid
- 5:47to doctors, she was sicker than she had been to
- 5:51begin with, and her dreams of pregnancy were dashed. Was
- 5:56Gil's size a complicating factor in her becoming pregnant? Possibly?
- 6:02Was it the only one? Far from it? And that's
- 6:06the issue with a health care system that puts so
- 6:10much emphasis on weight, When everything becomes about the number
- 6:14on the scale, other factors that may be more easily
- 6:18modified or overlooked or downplayed. If Gil had been given
- 6:22a chance earlier to understand her diagnosis and all her options,
- 6:27things might have turned out much better, she thinks. But
- 6:30she'll never know. The year's long focus on her body
- 6:34weight above all, she says, robbed her of the opportunity
- 6:38to find out the toll it takes. A doctor's office
- 6:46can be a harrowing place. You're in a skippy gown,
- 6:50feeling powerless and sometimes sick, and it only gets worse
- 6:55if you're a large person. You can feel shamed or
- 6:59you might get scolded for your weight, even though the
- 7:02reason you came to the doctor had nothing to do
- 7:05with your size. A twenty twenty one survey of nearly
- 7:09fourteen thousand people across six countries, including the US, showed
- 7:14the two thirds of people who had experienced weight stigma
- 7:19felt stigmatized by their medical providers and A study earlier
- 7:23this year found that between thirteen percent and forty eight
- 7:28percent of second year medical residents displayed some anti fat bias.
- 7:34The degree of that bias varied by medical specialty. Urologists, anesthesiologists,
- 7:41and orthopedic surgeons had the highest apparent disregard for people
- 7:45in larger bodies, while family practitioners, pediatricians, and psychiatrists had
- 7:52the lowest. Previous research found that doctors spent less time
- 7:57with larger patients and were more likely to rate those
- 8:00visits a waste of time. Patients are in no way
- 8:06inured to their doctor's biases, says Sean Fhalon, PhD, and
- 8:11author of the study earlier this year and a professor
- 8:15of health services at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota.
- 8:19Their provider might say something, or their body language might
- 8:24betray of feeling that they don't have high hopes for you,
- 8:27he says, And like Gil, people often report their providers
- 8:33blame a lot of things on weight, he says, when
- 8:36in fact, there are other causes for the issues they
- 8:40are there to address. Even the physical setup of a
- 8:44medical space can make a heavy person feel self conscious.
- 8:48MRI machines, for instance, can make people feel claustrophobic, but
- 8:53for those who are bigger, there are additional concerns. The
- 8:57first MRI that Tigris Osborne had was in a machine
- 9:01sized appropriately for her larger body, but when Osbourne, the
- 9:06executive director of the National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance
- 9:11in AAFA, went for a later scan on a different machine,
- 9:16it was clear that she wouldn't fit in its narrow opening.
- 9:22I could hear two technicians outside the MRI, she recalls,
- 9:26one said just push her a little harder. The comment
- 9:30wasn't aimed at Osborne, but it felt bad. The biggest issue, though,
- 9:36notes Blake Lawrence, PhD, a psychology researcher at Curtin University
- 9:42in Perth, Australia, is that people who experience weight stigma
- 9:46at the doctor's office are less likely to go back.
- 9:51Some may feel that if they already know that the
- 9:54doctor is going to say eat less, move more, there's
- 9:59no re reason to show up for the lecture. If
- 10:03they have health issues related to their obesity, or even
- 10:06health issues completely unrelated to their obesity, Often they can
- 10:11go untreated for long periods of time and have really
- 10:15significant health consequences long term says Lawrence, health care that
- 10:23fits all among patients and practitioners. There is a growing
- 10:28movement to promote weight neutral health care, sometimes called weight
- 10:33inclusive health care, which attempts to address the biases that
- 10:37can be a barrier to treatment for people in larger bodies.
- 10:41Emily Gordon, MD, a primary care physician and an assistant
- 10:46professor of medicine at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School in Newark,
- 10:51began to think differently about weight in her office when
- 10:54she started practicing addiction medicine. One of the important philosophy
- 11:00in addiction medicine is harm reduction, which is reducing negative
- 11:05consequences associated with a certain behavior. She says she realized
- 11:11that people who use drugs often avoided going to the
- 11:15doctor for the same reasons people in larger bodies did.
- 11:19We're doing a disservice to people by making this a
- 11:22scary place, she says to doctor Gordon. Harm reduction means
- 11:28treating the patient in front of her, not the patient
- 11:32she might have if they say, stopped using drugs or
- 11:37lost weight. We can meet people where they are, she says.
- 11:42If a patient with a larger body comes to her
- 11:44with diabetes, she treats the diabetes. This can include suggesting
- 11:50lifestyle modifications like more movement, avoiding specific foods, or using
- 11:56a medication to control blood sugar, and while that may
- 12:00or may not result in weight loss, there's no reason
- 12:03to frame it as an intervention aimed at weight loss,
- 12:07doctor Gordon notes. Lisa Erlinger, MD, a clinical professor of
- 12:14family medicine at the University of Washington School of Medicine
- 12:18in Seattle, had a similar epiphany when working with people
- 12:22with eating disorders. She found that extreme food restriction was
- 12:27classified as an eating disorder for people in small bodies,
- 12:32but people in larger bodies would be put on equally
- 12:35extreme diets. We encourage an obsession with calories, timing, and
- 12:41types of food, she says. All those are disruptive physically, physiologically, socially,
- 12:51and mental health wise. Doctor Erlinger is now on the
- 12:55advisory Board of Medical Students for Size Inclusivity and is
- 13:00the president of the newly formed Association for Weight and
- 13:04Size Inclusive Medicine. When someone gets weight inclusive care, that
- 13:09doesn't mean they can't try to lose weight if they want,
- 13:12she says. The point is to provide access to compassionate
- 13:17non stigmatizing care that is supported by unbiased research. What
- 13:24does that look like in practice? It begins before an
- 13:27appointment even starts. The environment should be size friendly, doctor
- 13:32Rlinger explains, the chairs should be comfortable and the robe
- 13:36should fit. The visit itself shouldn't begin with a weigh
- 13:40in most of the time, Doctor Rlinger says a doctor
- 13:44doesn't need the number on this scale. There aren't many
- 13:48times that the number is important in delivering care. She explains.
- 13:53If it is like for a weight based medication, or
- 13:56because someone thinks they're losing or gaining weight and we
- 14:00might want to get two data points, then we'll talk
- 14:03about it together, a different approach. Of course, the reason
- 14:10many doctors bring up weight is not to shame a patient.
- 14:14They are trained to report the facts, and there are
- 14:17correlations between weight and health associations between body size and
- 14:22type two diabetes and some fertility issues. For example, a
- 14:27high weight could also impact some cases of osteoarthritis. But
- 14:32being informed that they carry a lot of weight as
- 14:35if they might not realize it is frustrating to many
- 14:39larger patients. Most people with obesity know that they have
- 14:43a weight problem, says Lawrence. They are not blind to
- 14:47that in many, if not most cases, they have already
- 14:51tried a host of methods to drop pounds. Losing a
- 14:55considerable amount of weight and keeping it off is incredibly
- 14:59difficult to do. Research shows that in people who lose
- 15:04a significant amount of weight, about eighty percent of it
- 15:08is regained within five years. That's one of the reasons
- 15:15weight neutral practitioners don't raise the subject. If the patient
- 15:20brings it up. I'm willing to talk about it, of course,
- 15:23doctor Gordon says, but if I don't believe it's impacting
- 15:26their physical health, I might let them know that it
- 15:29is not an emergency to lose weight. If a patient
- 15:33wants to lose weight, doctor Erlinger works with them carefully.
- 15:37Even with the latest interventions like GLP one drugs, weight
- 15:43loss usually doesn't last. Finding show that people regain two
- 15:48thirds of the weight they lost within a year of
- 15:51stopping these medications. The goal is to help patients not
- 15:56feel singled out and judged as weights. Stigma itself causes
- 16:01health problems. Research has shown that people who experience weight
- 16:08stigma are more likely to have depression, anxiety, and chronic stress.
- 16:15The ongoing chronic level of stress associated with the stigma
- 16:19has a negative impact on their health markers, says Lawrence.
- 16:24This is arguably one of the most important problems facing
- 16:28many people with obesity a weight inclusive future. It's easy
- 16:36to imagine that Gil's fertility journey might have been easier
- 16:40had she encouraged, encountered more size friendly providers. I hope
- 16:45women who have a larger body recognize that there are
- 16:48fertility doctors out there who can help them through this
- 16:52and be their cheerleaders rather than their antagonists, says doctor Jungheim.
- 16:58Such a practitioner could have helped Gil feel empowered rather
- 17:02than hopeless and ashamed. Gil has seen that play out
- 17:07in the care she's received since her Risks directed me.
- 17:11After having switched doctors for her general care. The big
- 17:15transition was to just being seen as a human being,
- 17:19she says. Her doctor never says phrases like weight neutral,
- 17:24but she doesn't have to. It's clear in how she
- 17:27treats Gil. As more doctors adopt a weight neutral or
- 17:32weight inclusive approach, patients options are expanding. More of doctor
- 17:38Rlinger's colleagues are now respecting when a patient declines to
- 17:42be weighed, for instance, and some patients are so relieved
- 17:47not to be shamed by their doctor that they cry
- 17:50during their visits with her. So many people have not
- 17:53had access to the care they deserve, she says, Listening
- 17:58to and honoring a patients preference is at the heart
- 18:02of patient centered care. Be your own advocate when you
- 18:10need to work with the healthcare provider you have. Here's
- 18:14how to advocate for yourself even while wearing a skimp
- 18:18be gown. Call ahead. Ask whether the office offers weight
- 18:24neutral care and has gowns and blood pressure cuffs that
- 18:28fit larger bodies, advises Reagan Chastain, BCPA, a speaker and
- 18:35patient advocate, an author of the substack Weight and Healthcare Decline.
- 18:42The weigh in no rule says you must be weighed
- 18:45at the doctor's office. Doctor Rlinger says your provider might
- 18:50try to insist on it, but it's rarely required. Bring
- 18:56back up. A friend or family member can give you
- 18:59support and improve provider behavior simply by being there. They
- 19:04can go with you to the appointment with a plan
- 19:07for how you or they might intervene if the conversation
- 19:11begins to feel shaming, Ask pointed questions and set boundaries.
- 19:18Chastain offers printable cards for appointments that include helpful questions
- 19:24like do thin people get this health issue? What do
- 19:28you recommend for them? You can also request that weight
- 19:33or dieting not be the topic of your visit, ask
- 19:37the doctor to stick to the issue you have come about,
- 19:43and Next, this gives a listing how to find a
- 19:47weight neutral doctor How to find a weight neutral doc.
- 19:52Some organizations offer databases of health care providers that meet
- 19:57their weight neutral standards. The Weight Neutral Provider's Lead List
- 20:04started by singer Mary Lambert. This crowdsourced Google sheet allows
- 20:10anyone to recommend a healthcare provider with whom they've had
- 20:14a good experience. Organized by state, the list includes nearly
- 20:19seven hundred primary care providers and nearly eight hundred specialists
- 20:24in the US. The online address is naa FA dot org.
- 20:32Click on learn. The next is Health at Every Size
- 20:38healthcare Provider listing. The Association for Size Diversity and Health
- 20:44as DAH lists more than one hundred seventy five vetted providers.
- 20:51Its online address is as DAH dot org slash listing.
- 21:00The next is BEAR. This recommendation engine aggregates size friendly
- 21:06providers and includes helpful information on which ones are currently
- 21:11accepting new patients and taking insurance. Its online address is
- 21:18bare Health spelled b A R E H E A
- 21:23l t H dot co and the Non diet Provider's List.
- 21:31Dietitian Christy Harrison m p h r D has compiled
- 21:36a list including mainly nutritionists, dietitians and therapists who are
- 21:43non diet focused for those who are in recovery from
- 21:47disordered eating, and the online address for that is Christy
- 21:53Harrison dot com. Is an article in the Natural Fixes
- 22:03category Ease Your Allergies. These holistic remedies may provide relief
- 22:10from seasonal symptoms, written by Madeline Has for people with
- 22:17seasonal allergies, Sniffling and sneezing are just the tip of
- 22:21the drippy, itchy iceberg and symptoms can range from mildly
- 22:26annoying to truly debilitating. Seasonal allergies, also known as hay fever,
- 22:33are allergic reactions to airborne allergens like pollen and mold spores,
- 22:39says Katie Marx Cogan, MD, an allergist at Clear Allergy
- 22:44in Culver City, California. Normally harmless, certain allergens can prompt
- 22:50an immune response in some people, leading to itchy, watery eyes, sneezing,
- 22:56runny nose, congestion, coughing, and shortness of breath. Seasonal allergies
- 23:03work similarly to food and animal fur allergies, says doctor
- 23:07Marx Cogan. When an allergic person comes in contact with
- 23:12the allergen, antibodies trigger the release of histamine, a chemical
- 23:17that cues vexing allergy symptoms. Antihistamines are the most common
- 23:22treatment for seasonal allergy. When choosing an antihistamine, avoid benadryl,
- 23:29an older formulation that is more likely to cause side
- 23:33effects like drowsiness. Doctor Marx Cogan advises newer antihistamines like
- 23:39Xertec and zyzol or steroid nasal sprays like floonaise are
- 23:46better options for treating symptoms as they have fewer side effects.
- 23:51But if you want to find relief before resorting to medication,
- 23:55here are some natural fixes. Doctor Marx Cogan recommends nasal irrigation.
- 24:03This technique involves rinsing the nose and the sinus cavity
- 24:08to remove pollen and bold spores that can trigger allergic reactions.
- 24:13Nette pots and tools such as bulb syringes and squeeze
- 24:18bottles are available at most pharmacies and either come with
- 24:23a salt baking soda powder to be mixed into water,
- 24:27or are pre filled with a solution. Dissolve the solution
- 24:32packet in distilled or previously boiled tapwater warmed to about
- 24:37body temperature. Then tilt your head sideways over a sink
- 24:42and pour water into one nostril while taking in deep
- 24:46breaths through your mouth. The water should come out your
- 24:50other nostril. When you're done, carefully blow your nose, then
- 24:55repeat starting with the other nostril. Warm showers. Taking a
- 25:04warm shower and can rinse off pollen trapped on your
- 25:08skin or in your hair, and can open up your
- 25:11airways to make breathing more comfortable. During pollen's season, Having
- 25:17a quick rinse after spending time outside can help keep
- 25:21an allergic reaction from starting minimize exposure. The best way
- 25:27to deal with seasonal allergies is to prevent the symptoms
- 25:31in the first place. Checking pollen counts via weather dot
- 25:36com and spending time indoors with windows shut when they're
- 25:40high and using Heppa air filters are some ways to
- 25:45avoid allergens When to see a doctor. If allergy symptoms
- 25:52interfere with their daily life and over the counter treatments
- 25:56don't work, it's time to turn to an allergist. The
- 26:00doctor can perform a test to determine exactly what you're
- 26:04allergic to and suggest medication or other treatments. And next,
- 26:13I'm going to read a research report from the Women's
- 26:16Health Advisor newsletter published by wild Cornell Medicine Iris Kant
- 26:20Women's Health Center. This issue is dated December twenty twenty four.
- 26:27New drug can extend lives of people with h e
- 26:32R two positive breast cancer. A new drug, trastuzumab de
- 26:40ruxtacan t d x D, has shown promising results in
- 26:46treating advanced HR two positive breast cancer that has spread
- 26:52to the brain, according to findings from the Destiny Breast
- 26:56twelve study, which were published in September in the journal
- 27:01Nature Medicine. The research included over five hundred patients with
- 27:07and without brain metastases from seventy eight cancer centers in
- 27:12Western Europe, Japan, Australia, and the United States. The results
- 27:19showed that on average, patients including those with brain metastases,
- 27:25survived over seventeen months without any progression of the cancer.
- 27:31More than sixty percent of patients survived twelve months without
- 27:36further tumor growth. The researchers detected regression of the brain
- 27:42metastases in over seventy percent of the participants and ninety
- 27:48percent of all patients were alive one year after the
- 27:52start of treatment. These findings offer hope for better treatment
- 27:57options for her two positive breast cancer patients, who typically
- 28:03face poor prognosis once the cancer spreads to the brain.
- 28:11And this concludes the Women's Health Corner for today. Your
- 28:14reader has been Mary. If you have any questions, comments,
- 28:18or suggestions concerning this program, please call us in our
- 28:22Lexington studios at eight five nine four two two six
- 28:27three nine zero. And now please stay tuned to Radio
- 28:31I for the continuation of our local broadcast. Thank you
- 28:35for listening, and have a healthy and happy day.