Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Appropriate Objects for Meditation
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the deepening, your practice
- 0:03podcast, with George Hoss. For more information.
- 0:07Visit www.fema.gov group dot-org.
- 0:11That's www.mit.edu gr oup dot-org.
- 0:20So welcome, everybody. This is deepening your practice.
- 0:23Keep it in your practice is intended as an intermediate or
- 0:26advanced class. And what that really means is,
- 0:28I'm not going to be offering basic meditation.
- 0:31Instruction. I expect you all ready to know
- 0:33that. That being said, if you find
- 0:36that I'm talking about something and you don't understand what
- 0:38I'm talking about. Please feel free to ask whatever
- 0:41questions you want. I'm happy to answer any
- 0:43questions. I'm just not going to cover the
- 0:46basics. We have been talking about the
- 0:49manual of insight, which is a new translation by The vipassana
- 0:53Meta Foundation of Maha. See Shadows or text on how to do
- 0:58Karnataka samadhi. Karnataka samadhi is a poly word
- 1:04that means momentary concentration, Insight samadhi
- 1:10Meditation, which is a concentration oriented
- 1:13meditation would be a practice for a first, you develop
- 1:16concentration, and then you go. To incite in Karnataka samadhi,
- 1:20you start with Insight practice and through practicing Insight,
- 1:25develop concentration, the practice was really designed for
- 1:29householders. So it seems like an appropriate
- 1:32practice to instruct in. We talked about some of the
- 1:37basics, around this purification of mind and purification of
- 1:43conduct. And we've been talking for the
- 1:46last few weeks about out Ultimate Reality versus
- 1:51conceptual reality. And what we really mean by that
- 1:56is that you're aware of the sensing experience, which is the
- 2:00Ultimate Reality and then you're aware of what you make the
- 2:04sensing experience into which is the conceptual reality.
- 2:08Can you be with the experience of sensing before you actually
- 2:15make it into something? And then, can you be aware of
- 2:18the Mind state that that operates between the sensing and
- 2:22the making the Seeing into something that affects the
- 2:26interpretation of the sensing experience or what you make it
- 2:30into. A reading from the section of
- 2:34the book. That's called two kinds of
- 2:37insight. We're talking about appropriate
- 2:39objects for meditation. So when you come to meditation,
- 2:46you come for a lot of different reasons.
- 2:48Mostly people come in the west because of suffering, often they
- 2:52come because they've tried other avenues to address the suffering
- 2:56and they find that they're still suffering.
- 2:58And so they're looking for a remedy to ooh, that this this
- 3:04text is really talking about Enlightenment as the end goal
- 3:10and what you may notice in your practice as you begin.
- 3:12And I said deepens, that that initial release from stress that
- 3:18you were seeking is easily obtained and maybe in the
- 3:21distance is happiness. And then you pursue your
- 3:26practice, and you find that, you can come pretty easily into a
- 3:30place of happiness. And then in the distance, from
- 3:34the from conventional happiness is freedom.
- 3:40You discover early that simply relieving stress isn't going to
- 3:44be enough to be satisfying and then you go for happiness and
- 3:49you find your happiness. But then you realize also that
- 3:52that's unlikely to be enough. And then, as you move in the
- 3:57direction of Freedom, when you do find Freedom, you realize
- 4:03that that will be enough, that's kind of the energy that I think
- 4:06propels people in on the path. But in the beginning, it simply
- 4:13that desire to relieve suffering.
- 4:16And then as you get more into the meditation practices that
- 4:21you do, you find that if there was some path or some math, that
- 4:28might be useful, this isn't everybody's approach in.
- 4:31There are a lot of different Maps.
- 4:33The the map that Maha see typically uses the 16 stages of
- 4:38insight which is a terawatt, a map.
- 4:42Based on the four foundations before path model of Liberation,
- 4:46which is based on the eradication of the ten Fetters.
- 4:52Maja C is really talking about how to develop your practice so
- 4:56that you can pursue the path to liberation.
- 5:02There are two kinds of insight, empirical and inferential
- 5:06knowledge. That is cut cultivated by
- 5:08empirically meditating on mental.
- 5:10And physical phenomena is called empirical inside.
- 5:14One could be clearly aware of the unique characteristics and
- 5:17impermanence of phenomena, Vaya empirical Insight.
- 5:22Insight meditators should develop empirical Insight from
- 5:24the beginning up to the peak Insight knowledge of adaptation
- 5:28or another word for that would be liberation. every empirical
- 5:35Insight, when it matures is followed by inferential Insight
- 5:38that extrapolates to phenomena that are not directly
- 5:42experienced from Insight based on experiential phenomenon, So,
- 5:48what we're talking about here is the difference between the
- 5:54sensing experience and what you make the sensing experience into
- 5:59that. You, you, you have awareness of
- 6:01the sensing experience and then it's made into something.
- 6:05Have you noticed that you're hearing me speak in English and
- 6:11that if you're conditioned understand English that you've
- 6:13Associated a lot of meaning to the different things that I'm
- 6:16saying, But have you also been aware of the vibratory sound
- 6:22that that's being communicated in?
- 6:25I am I'm speaking in sound so that you're sensing capacity.
- 6:31First is for the sound, the vibration.
- 6:37In the inner ear, there's a thing called a cochlea, which
- 6:42has a lot of little fight filaments in it, that vibrate,
- 6:49depending on the frequency and that translates into an
- 6:52electrical energy that's in the brain.
- 6:56Decodes. If you're conditioned, you can
- 7:00recognize the pattern of that and make it into a word.
- 7:04And then depending on how you've been conditioned to associate,
- 7:07meaning to that word, you associate, that meaning that's
- 7:10inferential the associated meaning, whereas the empirical
- 7:14understanding of the sensing experiences is the mechanics of
- 7:19sensing, is that making sense? Okay.
- 7:32Initially. For the recognition of the
- 7:36pattern. However, inside that is
- 7:48inferential rather than empirical is on the is unable to
- 7:52experience the unique characteristics of phenomena.
- 7:56It is not necessary to deliberately develop inferential
- 7:59Insight since it always arises by itself following every
- 8:03mature, empirical Insight. So from here on I will only
- 8:06explain objects of empirical in sight.
- 8:15It is not necessary in some sense to pay attention to the
- 8:20content of experience when you're meditating.
- 8:24The maybe another way to say, it's important to pay attention
- 8:28to the function of it, but not necessarily the content of it.
- 8:32This is seeing experience, this is hearing experience, this is
- 8:36feeling experience and they come together and form a concept of
- 8:41what's happening in the moment. And and while that can be useful
- 8:46and engaging in terms of conceptual reality, what we're
- 8:51attempting to do in meditation is not pay attention to But pay
- 8:55attention to the empirical experience of sensing.
- 9:00So when we begin to talk about what actually is important to
- 9:04pay attention to in meditation and how you can easily get
- 9:09caught up in the conceptual reality, which won't bear the
- 9:13fruit of practice, that is described in the text and also
- 9:19is going to take you down the path to liberation.
- 9:25Paying attention, are you in the experience of sensing or even
- 9:29the experience of thinking, or are you in the experience of
- 9:33meditating or in the experience of thinking?
- 9:38In order to develop true, Insight knowledge, starting with
- 9:41knowledge that discerns body and mind when showed observe
- 9:44ultimate mental and physical, phenomena phenomena, and not
- 9:48conceptual objects in addition, among ultimate mental and
- 9:53physical phenomena, only those that are mundane should be taken
- 9:57as objects of Insight Meditation, and not those that
- 10:00are super mundane. The reason for this as the
- 10:03vasudha, Maga says ordinary people cannot observe
- 10:06supramundane phenomena that they have not yet realized. so, it is
- 10:21hard to recognize for instance, what the characteristics of a
- 10:24liberated mind are, is if you're not enlightened, And we can get
- 10:29caught up in the idea that would, that's what we should be
- 10:32focusing on. That's what we should be looking
- 10:34for. But actually, if you haven't had
- 10:37that experience, then you can't detect it anyway.
- 10:41And so it's not productive and what it leads to is being caught
- 10:45up in thinking Shinzen my teacher can come and go from the
- 10:53Euro tour, the cessation experience.
- 10:55And when I asked him about it, he tells me to look for
- 11:00something and that just focusing on that will lead to the
- 11:04cessation experience. But I can't detect the thing
- 11:08that he's talking about. So it isn't too helpful
- 11:12instruction. So in the beginning of practice,
- 11:16what's useful And as you move forward in practice to really be
- 11:22focusing on the things that you can already experience.
- 11:26And I think shins and used to say that when you come to
- 11:33practice and you're just beginning, your resolution is
- 11:37not very good, you can't see clearly the things that you need
- 11:41to be able to look at. But as you practice the
- 11:44resolution increases, it's like changing the lens on a
- 11:51microscope first. It's at a high level.
- 11:55And then you get more and more into the subtleties of
- 11:58experience more and more directly in touch with what the
- 12:02sensing experience is like and that's really all you need to
- 12:07do. You don't need to conceptualize
- 12:10or spend time exploring. So maybe in the perfect world
- 12:15there would be perfect understanding and perfect
- 12:18practice but an Perfect world. It's definitely more productive
- 12:24to focus on practice than it is on understanding the concepts of
- 12:31this. Super mundane would we refer to
- 12:35experience that's available to people who have been
- 12:38enlightened. The Illusions can only be
- 12:43eradicated by observing mundane phenomena not by observing super
- 12:47mundane ones. For example, of a person wants
- 12:49to level the ground, they must resume remove places that are
- 12:53too high and fill in places that are too low doing.
- 12:56So serves the purpose of leveling the ground, but if the
- 12:59ground is already leveled doing so serves, no purpose.
- 13:04Among mundane phenomenon, beginners cannot meditate on
- 13:08highest John on neither perception, nor non-perception
- 13:13it is. So extremely subtle.
- 13:15Even the venerable shariputra was unable to observe, observe
- 13:19it directly. So although they are mundane
- 13:21Sublime types of Consciousness experience with the attainment
- 13:25of Jonna cannot be observed. If one has not attained Jonna
- 13:31when I first started practicing machines and used to describe
- 13:36the conversations that people had about Advanced states of
- 13:40meditation as state and V, really, what was being driven
- 13:46was this, this mines desire for entertainment or the mines
- 13:51desire to for social ranking in within the group If you haven't
- 13:59had that John experience, then you can't observe the quality of
- 14:03the Mind as it transforms. The sensing experience into the
- 14:08thing that you've You make it into is everybody aware that the
- 14:15sensory experience in the thing that you make it into our
- 14:18different? Not the same thing.
- 14:24One of the things I, when I look around the room, the walls are
- 14:28solid. The ceiling, the solid, the
- 14:29florist solid, everything is in Focus.
- 14:31Everything is detailed. And as I move my head around the
- 14:36room, it looks like a solid world, but this is not the
- 14:41sensing experience. This is the thing that my mind
- 14:43has made the sensing experience into and it can make it in many
- 14:48different ways. If I do a lot of meta and I look
- 14:53around the room, everybody seems beautiful.
- 14:59And if I'm angry, everyone seems dangerous, if I'm sleepy, it's
- 15:05hard, even to, to have much experience of people the sensing
- 15:13experience. And then the thing you make it
- 15:15into, we want to really in this practice of focusing on the
- 15:20mundane push into the sensing experience, and let the rest of
- 15:25it just happened without too much attention.
- 15:29Tension. In the case of sensual phenomena
- 15:51one should only note the obvious mental and physical phenomena.
- 15:55One should not note vague objects by imagining them based
- 15:59on scriptures. Confirm this point to the suti
- 16:02Maga says, even among distinct mundane objects.
- 16:05One should make effort to contemplate objects that are
- 16:08obvious and easy to observe. I think that in some sense this
- 16:16talks about striving or this need to speed up.
- 16:23Where are you at? What can you easily?
- 16:26Observe? You don't need to to observe
- 16:28everything. You just need to observe enough
- 16:32of what's happening so that to get into a rhythm of obvious and
- 16:36easy as a. It's a good idea to it cools out
- 16:40the intensity of striving or craving that can arise in your
- 16:44practice. Because that making sense.
- 17:10I think what happens is that in the beginning, the the urgency
- 17:16is to relieve the suffering and so you apply practice and it and
- 17:20it's good at that but stress is easy for meditating mind to
- 17:26address. and so, once you find the the way into resolving
- 17:33stress, you I think what arises is a sense that that isn't
- 17:40enough that that Simply Having a life where you're able to
- 17:44resolve stress isn't enough to be satisfying and in a deep way,
- 17:51what is the Deep Way in a way that allows you to be happy?
- 17:59So then happiness arises on the horizon and and you move in the
- 18:04direction of Happiness. What makes you happy for me?
- 18:08It was the ability to express myself authentically in the
- 18:14moment as I experienced it in relationship to my own
- 18:19experience internally. And also with other people, When
- 18:26you depending on your conditioning, that will be
- 18:30easier. Not easy.
- 18:32If you've been held and adored and cherished as a child and
- 18:39encouraged to explore what's meaningful to them, that it
- 18:42should come pretty easily for you that those all of those
- 18:47spontaneous authentic Expressions were received by the
- 18:52people that were taking care of you.
- 18:55So you learned in, he's in that, but if that wasn't what happened
- 18:59to you, then you've learned to restrict it and to present
- 19:03something inauthentic in order to get the care that you needed.
- 19:07And to unwind that will push you into the sadness of having to
- 19:11have been inauthentic and also into the terror of Abandonment
- 19:17if you are authentic. But if you can come through that
- 19:21enough that you actually begin to express, Your authenticity.
- 19:28And you find people that like that and are delighted by that,
- 19:33then you can come into a place of easy happiness.
- 19:39But I think that if you come into a place of easy happiness,
- 19:42you'll discover that that isn't enough.
- 19:48And that in the distance, you'll see freedom.
- 19:53And then you'll move in the direction of freedom.
- 19:55And then if you can get freedom, I think what you'll find is that
- 19:59it is enough, And that sense of striving, that may have driven
- 20:04you in your life, even in happiness is, is relieved.
- 20:09But from a place of stress, to see all the way to Freedom is
- 20:13probably not possible. But from happiness, you can see
- 20:19it. And I think if you look at the
- 20:22zoo kind of a bell curve of people who come to practice at
- 20:25one end of the bell curve is people who hardly function and
- 20:29suffer greatly in are really just trying to get engaged in
- 20:33being alive. And then everybody in the middle
- 20:35of the bell, curve is so in engaged and just the
- 20:38conventional realities of our culture that they don't see a
- 20:42need for practice. And then you get onto the other
- 20:46end of the curve and people have done very well in the world and
- 20:50Very well and find that they're still, not fulfilled, still not
- 20:55happy. And so you have that two ends of
- 20:59the bell curve that come to practice in the West.
- 21:04Very different motivations. One end is trying to get into
- 21:07the game and the other one is played the game, really well.
- 21:09And it still didn't provide that sense of we're humans, and and
- 21:17we like to have a sense of meaning.
- 21:20What does our life mean? What does our actions in the
- 21:24world mean? Do you find that you go to a job
- 21:29that doesn't provide meaning for you?
- 21:31And so it's hard to get yourself to go.
- 21:35It's maybe you have a family and a child and so you think that
- 21:40you do that in order to to take care of the child, and that
- 21:44provides the meaning that's necessary for you to, to do
- 21:47those other things. But if you haven't found meaning
- 21:51Then a lot of those things that we are required to do, in our
- 21:55culture are going to be hard to do. they all I guess the freedom
- 22:07that I'm talking about would be able to drop into cessation or
- 22:12neuro to whenever you want to and then fully manifest the
- 22:15sense of self and then when you don't need it simply drop off
- 22:19into Cessation. Again that would be the ultimate
- 22:23freedoms that you can just come and go from solid to flowing to
- 22:28solid whenever you wanted. If you touch into neuro tour
- 22:35cessation as you come out of it. There's this huge blast of I
- 22:40like to call it Limitless compassion.
- 22:46Have you noticed? Not having that capacity that
- 22:51compassion can somehow be hard to come by.
- 22:56Imagine if you could have a limitless amount of it whenever
- 22:59you wanted and have that would free you up to be
- 23:04extraordinarily generous in terms of your distribution of
- 23:08it. You know, I like to.
- 23:12Talk about it. As you know we work really hard
- 23:15to eke out a few drops of compassion and then we can get
- 23:18very stingy around the distribution of it because it's
- 23:21so hard to come by. But then could you imagine
- 23:25turning on a fire hydrant and jamming a box under it and just
- 23:28having the compassion fly everywhere uninterrupted?
- 23:34That would be the difference between free and not free.
- 23:56Can you be free to be happy or unhappy?
- 24:02So it isn't the sort of clinging or Desiring to be one thing or
- 24:06another. How good are you at losing
- 24:15things might be another way to talk about it.
- 24:19Can you Go all in. Fully engage knowing that
- 24:28nothing lasts and that you're going to lose it.
- 24:30And then when the time comes to lose it, can you just let it go?
- 24:33Or do you find that? There's some clinging that
- 24:35comes? Do you find that your aversive
- 24:38to going all-in because you know, you're going to have to
- 24:40lose it and you don't want to suffer that.
- 24:45So what you do is you restrict your going all-in, you lose it.
- 24:49Anyway this is this is the kind of delusion that we get into.
- 24:53We don't want to engage fully because we're going to lose it
- 24:57and we all at some level know that we're going to lose it.
- 25:00Nothing is permanent. You've figured that out already,
- 25:03right? When I was in Myanmar this last
- 25:13trip and I should preface this by saying in Myanmar the life
- 25:20expectancy of a male is 64 and the life expectancy of a female
- 25:25of 66, minus 64 I found over and over again.
- 25:30I was the oldest person. And it was disconcerting and
- 25:35increasingly disconcerting because in a culture where there
- 25:39are people who are older than you, are you have this natural
- 25:42sense that you could live longer and it just comes to you look
- 25:47around and there are a lot of people who are older than you
- 25:49which means that you're likely to live longer but when you're
- 25:52in a place where you're always the oldest person and everyone's
- 25:57quite a bit younger than you, it begins to Dawn on you.
- 26:02Or at least it did to me. It began to dawn on me that I'm
- 26:05old and in this country I'm as old as most people get, there's
- 26:09no after this moment and it undermines that sense of false
- 26:15security that this is just going to go on.
- 26:18And it's it's confrontive after a while in a way that I rarely
- 26:24have that here. How was that for you since
- 26:29That's your old. The moment is gone.
- 27:33Very often the oldest Newsroom, you're right?
- 27:42It's quite anyway. I noticed and I think you've
- 27:46probably heard me comment on it many times while I was there
- 27:50because it was so startling. To be in Myanmar for a month and
- 27:56maybe see five people that are older than you, it was kind of
- 28:00alarming. You don't want to go all in
- 28:06because you know that you're going to lose it and so your
- 28:08reserve yourself from going all-in and you lose it anyway
- 28:14but then you don't get to have the experience of it, right?
- 28:18So that the thing that you've lost by not going all-in is the
- 28:22only thing that you can prevent from losing which would be to
- 28:25have the experience of it. So you really do want to to be
- 28:30free to then go all in knowing full well that it will be lost
- 28:36in. There's nothing that you can do
- 28:37about that. So then you're free to say the
- 28:41thing that you need to say to engage to express all of those
- 28:47things that you're talking about.
- 28:48The kindness that is And you when you get into that place
- 28:54where you really understand this at a deep level, you know, that
- 28:58there's nothing that you could reserve any way that if you
- 29:02don't use the kindness in the moment that you could have used
- 29:05it, the moment will be over and you won't ever be able to use
- 29:09the kindness in that moment. Anyway, So that the illusion
- 29:14that you can preserve something by withholding is actually not
- 29:18even true. You don't get to use it later.
- 29:21There's no keeping it. The moment is over and anything
- 29:25that you could have done in that moment is also lost.
- 29:40Since everything's gone. Why not?
- 29:43Just be apathetic and what's the point in going all-in?
- 29:48If you go all in, you have the experience of it and if you
- 29:51don't go all in the then you have the experience but you've
- 29:54been the nest off. Ultimately, you're gone.
- 30:02But you can hold yourself back from going all-in because of
- 30:09fear of losing. And once you get it or you can
- 30:12be like yeah. So here we're at this fork in
- 30:18One Direction is nihilism. Nothing matters because nothing
- 30:21lasts. And certainly you can go do
- 30:25that. I don't recommend that you go do
- 30:28that but it's certainly a possibility of doing and then
- 30:32what is the quality of the present moment in that?
- 30:37Path. And then what is the quality of
- 30:41the present moment? Which is the thing that we do
- 30:43have only if you go into the path of Engagement and I would I
- 30:48would argue that the quality of the present moment in an Engaged
- 30:51life. For me is preferable to one that
- 30:55is disengage and right.
- 31:37How did drug addiction work? For those of you who tried it?
- 31:53I guess my experience of it is that it becomes so painful.
- 31:58So, unbearably painful. That.
- 32:06That really I just wanted to kill myself.
- 32:08I think that's where that ends up at least it did for me.
- 32:17So I'm going to give you some instructions on focusing on
- 32:21mundane phenomenon in a traditional or kind of
- 32:26conventional way of instructing in Maja see Karnataka samadhi or
- 32:32noting practice. You would simply let your
- 32:35attention be drawn to wherever it's drawn and then know that
- 32:39that's where your attention is and then soak in an attempt to
- 32:42have the sensing experience of it.
- 32:45What are the things the neuroscientist taught us?
- 32:47Is that the sensing experience, almost all of the time is
- 32:51already decided by the time it enters Consciousness.
- 32:53So you know, it the empirical understanding of it and it also
- 32:57already has the inferential attached or you, you explore
- 33:03into the quality of the Ultimate Reality and the conventional
- 33:08reality is already been associated with it.
- 33:10It's very hard to in a, in a householders practices.
- 33:15Is coming into a meditation center to divide them so maybe
- 33:18don't try to do that. In a traditional way of noting
- 33:24that Maha see instructed, you just note, everything that
- 33:26you're doing everything that's happening that your attention is
- 33:30drawn to. And remember, it's sort of
- 33:32obvious and easy is what we're going for in terms of this, I
- 33:37like to talk about this in a see hear feel modality that shins
- 33:42and developed, because you don't have to fret about what to label
- 33:48it, what to label the experience it's divided into these Broad
- 33:52categories, which are obvious and easy.
- 33:55That's one of the things that I really like about it.
- 33:59If you were sitting there and trying to figure out more subtle
- 34:03distinction or to create a name, that was specific to the action
- 34:08that you were undertaking, it's easy to get engaged in thinking
- 34:11and then pulled out of the, the actual exploration of empirical
- 34:17sensing rather than Into the conceptual.
- 34:24So the C label refers to all visual phenomenon.
- 34:29So most of the time when we're doing vapp Asana, our eyes are
- 34:33closed and so we're talking about internal visual
- 34:36experience. So most people experience a
- 34:39mental screen where imagery is projected onto it related to
- 34:45memory planning and fantasy. It's somewhere around the eyes
- 34:51shins and and I don't know where he gets these numbers will.
- 34:54That 70 percent of people are auditorially inclined in 30% or
- 34:58visually inclined. So, if you're really heavily
- 35:01auditory in your internal experience, maybe you don't
- 35:04notice the usual stuff so much, but you can sensitize yourself
- 35:09to it. In addition to the mental
- 35:11screen, there's a way of knowing how the body is currently
- 35:15positioned in visual thinking. It's called proprioceptive
- 35:18sense. It's a kind of feedback between
- 35:21sensation in the body and a visual.
- 35:24Presentation of that there is the body's location in the
- 35:28current environment in visual thinking.
- 35:30So if you look out and then close your eyes, you'll often
- 35:34notice an afterimage of where the body is located in that.
- 35:38That internal imagery is often available.
- 35:42There's an image reaction to local sensation.
- 35:45So you feel something in the foot and the mind generates an
- 35:47image of the foot or any other part of the body, and then,
- 35:51there's often an image reaction to exterior sound, so you hear a
- 35:55sound and there's a visual response to it any of these.
- 35:59And if you decided, if you found that you were sleeping, you
- 36:02wanted to open your eyes to energize.
- 36:05The Practice ending external visual experience.
- 36:08All of that is the category of see pretty clear.
- 36:14If you hear something in the outside world or you hear the
- 36:18internal auditory thinking of the mind that's auditory
- 36:22experience and the label for that is here.
- 36:26And if you're have any felt sense of the body either related
- 36:30to gravity temperature, respiration circulation,
- 36:33digestion, the interaction with the world or emotion in the
- 36:37body, then that would be the category of feel.
- 36:40So there's three categories. If your attention is drawn to a
- 36:45visual experience, its see, space know that you're in see
- 36:50space. And then see if you can detect
- 36:52the sensing experience. If it's auditory That's here.
- 36:59See if you can detect what the quality of the sensing
- 37:02experiences and then it's in the body and he felt sense in the
- 37:06body. That's feel in a noting
- 37:09practice, you can also label. So noting is simply to know
- 37:12where your attention is and soak in and labeling is to create the
- 37:16word that corresponds. So the three labels are see hear
- 37:19or feel if you want to do that. It's it can be useful because
- 37:24it's a concentration booster. So your attention is drawn to a
- 37:29visual experience, you know, that it's visual you soak into
- 37:32the sensing experience. And then you generate the word
- 37:35see in auditory thinking space for most people that auditory
- 37:39thinking spaces inside the head between the ears are actually at
- 37:42the ears. Same for here.
- 37:44No. Need to label the label and and
- 37:47if it's in the body, feel that making sense those instructions.
- 37:54Then what we're going to do is a double noting.
- 37:57So what is the quality of the sensing experience?
- 38:00This is the second Foundation or second pasture of mindfulness.
- 38:05The Pali word for that is vade know it's often translated in
- 38:09English as feeling tone. So, first note, for sensory
- 38:13Clarity then note, what is the quality of the sensing
- 38:16experiences, it Pleasant unpleasant, or neutral?
- 38:19Most sensing experience as it turns out is neutral.
- 38:26Hearing is often neutral in this.
- 38:27The sound is loud or sharp. Seeing is often neutralness.
- 38:31The it's bright feeling in the body.
- 38:36Not always neutral. But And then after some minutes
- 38:42of meditating on double noting will triple note, this is the
- 38:46quality of Mind. Are you wanting what it is?
- 38:49That's happening. I'm sorry.
- 38:51Are you not craving a version unconsciousness?
- 38:55Here we go. Craving is wanting something
- 38:58that isn't so that you're in the experience of the present moment
- 39:02and you notice that the mind is inclining toward things that are
- 39:05not happening. That would be craving.
- 39:10You're in the experience of the present moment.
- 39:12You don't want what's in the the present moment that would be a
- 39:15version or you notice that you get caught up in thinking.
- 39:20That would be unconsciousness and then if you can just be in
- 39:24the experience of the present moment as it unfolds Moment by
- 39:27moment that would be Equanimity. So noting the third Foundation,
- 39:31I like to note wanting for craving, not wanting for a
- 39:36version. If I find that I've been caught
- 39:38up in thinking and lost the object of meditation, I'll say
- 39:41thinking, and come back. And if I'm able just to be in
- 39:45the quality of the experience of the present moment without
- 39:49needing to Go anywhere. I would call that piece.
- 39:54So we'll do a period, Then a triple noting.
- 39:58That instruction pretty clear. All right.
- 40:04And we will do that. Yeah.
- 40:14Well, unconsciousness is Being drawn into thinking.
- 40:22As long as you're aware that you're being drawn into thinking
- 40:24and don't go, you haven't gotten to the place of unconsciousness.
- 40:29It's after you've already lost the meditation in our in
- 40:31thinking, that you've become unconscious, which is after the
- 40:35fact. So then you recognize that,
- 40:38that's where you're there. And you just noted and come
- 40:40back. If you were still in the
- 40:43meditation knowing that you're being drawn into
- 40:46unconsciousness, you haven't crossed the line into
- 40:49unconsciousness. Deepen, your practice is moving
- 41:02to the Hill Street Center, so next week's class will be the
- 41:07last time, it's here. And then after that, it'll be on
- 41:10Tuesday night at the Hill Street Center.
- 41:13We will send out a notice about that if you're already on our
- 41:17email list, then you'll get it. And if you're not and you would
- 41:21like to be on our email list and get the notice about the
- 41:24upcoming classes. Has put your name email on here.
- 41:28Anybody wanted? And in Santa Monica, no, just
- 41:39just deepen your practice, just you just me.
- 41:46So, how was that? Mundane enough for you.
- 41:58Neutral. Peace.
- 42:08These gaps that we didn't have to retain as we practice to do
- 42:13come out of the game with each video.
- 42:17I don't know. There's two schools of thought.
- 42:20One is that you're already enlightened.
- 42:23There's just a lot of weeds in the way and the other is that
- 42:27you have to cultivate experience.
- 42:32The reason that I like to take my Massey is because it's, it's
- 42:36he teaches the progress of inside and that was pretty much
- 42:39what happened to me without me, knowing that, that was a map.
- 42:44And so it just, it's, I don't have to translate anything.
- 42:48It's pretty much just how it unfolded for me.
- 42:52But there are there. Lots of maps, you know, I
- 42:57haven't really ever found much in the Tibetan practices, but
- 43:00many people do that I haven't. Found much in the Zen practice
- 43:03is, but a lot of people do that. This practice is always, felt
- 43:09always made sense to me. And when I've tried the other
- 43:12ones, they didn't make the same quality of sentence.
- 43:15So, I guess that's also part of your conditioning that then
- 43:19Prime's you for this. How are we supposed to fight
- 43:27this technique of the daylight on?
- 43:28What are the bank? How do you apply to everyday
- 43:32life? So you become aware of the
- 43:36empirical quality of the sensing and what you make it into.
- 43:40That would be the And then you're aware as you get
- 43:44sensitive to this. The Mind state that filters the
- 43:48way that you make the sensing experience into something so
- 43:51that you can begin to calculate whether your perception of
- 43:54things is accurate or whether it's distorted.
- 44:06As a rule of thumb, I would say that when you're on your own or
- 44:09focused on some work that doesn't involve interaction with
- 44:12other people that you should push into the pasta and run a
- 44:16technique all day long. And when you're engaged with
- 44:21someone else, that you should be pushing A meta technique.
- 44:25The one that I liked the most for interacting with people is
- 44:29to say, may I be peaceful and then to say, may you be
- 44:33peaceful? May I be peaceful so you're
- 44:35going back and forth engaging in this inner and outer.
- 44:41In the city, putana, that one of the descriptions is to focus on
- 44:46the internal experience of self and then the external experience
- 44:51of other people. And then to notice the
- 44:53interaction between them. If you were to talk about this,
- 44:57just in terms of mine States, you'd have an awareness of the
- 45:01sensing experience and what you make it into, have an awareness
- 45:05of whether it was accurate or not, what you were making it
- 45:08into. You'd have an awareness that
- 45:10your mind state has an effect on somebody else in their mind.
- 45:13State has an effect on you. You'd have a an awareness that
- 45:18there's a emotional regulation, quality that happens in The
- 45:22Interchange of other people, or that your mindset can affect
- 45:25your internal, emotional experience.
- 45:28All of those things you can be aware of, and adjusting, if you
- 45:35get spun out by something, but being really aware of the Mind
- 45:40States comes from this because you send something, and then you
- 45:43make it into something, and between the sensing in the
- 45:46making is the Mind state. If the mind is angry, do you
- 45:50notice how the world is different?
- 45:52And if the mind is happy, The Samsung Experience could be very
- 45:56similar. So yes, all day long, running a
- 46:02technique, just in case. So this is deepening your
- 46:12practice. So I'm always advocating ways to
- 46:14deepen your practice. One way to do that is Retreat
- 46:17practice. If you haven't been on Retreat,
- 46:20I would suggest that you consider it ATS has a retreat
- 46:26coming up over Memorial Day weekend which is a four day
- 46:28Retreat out in Joshua Tree. I think.
- 46:31No and Vinny are teaching it so it's a basically to sitting
- 46:36dazed and to travel days that's how Retreats kind of go.
- 46:40If you haven't been on a retreat, may be assured.
- 46:42Retreat is a good way to go and get a taste of it.
- 46:44It's a, it's a for foundations Retreat.
- 46:46So they'll they'll be talking about the same pastures that I
- 46:54was talking about if you'd like to do a longer retreating you,
- 46:57don't mind traveling a little bit.
- 46:58I'm doing a retreat in New York starting Memorial Day weekend,
- 47:02and continuing for a week after I teach and met of apostle, a
- 47:06retreat. So that you come in in the first
- 47:09four days The Retreat will be met in the second.
- 47:12Four days will be the pasta. NE I find that if you really
- 47:16bring the Mind into a place of kindness that when you go into
- 47:20the of apassionata exploration, it's much easier to do and all
- 47:27of a lot of the difficulties that can come up for people in
- 47:30the first few days of a positive Retreat.
- 47:32Where there hasn't been met the practice don't come up because
- 47:36people have come into a place of kindness for themselves.
- 47:41I am also doing a summer retreat, in New York, and
- 47:44California up by Sequoia Park, at the seven circles Retreat.
- 47:48It's a week-long retreat. Again, will be the Met of
- 47:54apassionata format, but this is, I haven't taught a retreat there
- 48:01before, but it's supposed to be in the Redwoods and really quite
- 48:04beautiful. So, I'm I'm big on beautiful
- 48:07Retreat centers. I think it makes it easier to do
- 48:11walking meditation than in a parking lot, but I suppose you
- 48:14could do either this is a July third, through ninth You know, I
- 48:24think it probably is, but let me find out and you could get a, I
- 48:30think that you could get your own cabin there.
- 48:33There little cabins have time. Anyway, take a look at this.
- 48:38We have early bird specials for both of my Retreats.
- 48:41The one in New York. There's a 10% off until April
- 48:464th. And then this one is I don't
- 48:49know exactly. When anyway my website is meant
- 48:53to group dot-org. I put some flyers out there for
- 48:55this Retreat. Take a look if you want but I
- 48:59really do urge you to get on at least one week long residential
- 49:04Retreat this year so that you can get your practice and 80s is
- 49:08going to have an East coaster treat in August and I'm going to
- 49:13have a winter retreat in December and I think that that's
- 49:18all of the Retreats that are currently scheduled.
- 49:24I'm also an Ardent advocate of meditation centers including
- 49:28this one. One of the things about
- 49:32practicing meditation is that it can append a lot of your
- 49:36conditioning which can be difficult to manage.
- 49:39And it's useful to have people who are also meditating
- 49:44available to help you navigate this what better place to meet
- 49:49them than it a meditation center, right?
- 49:52Right? If there's no Meditation Center
- 49:54to come to, where would you meet somebody who was also
- 49:57meditating? Where would you find people to
- 49:58help you with your practice? So, it's important that we have
- 50:01these places. You may think that because we've
- 50:04been here for so long that we're in great financial shape.
- 50:09But I can assure you that the finances of meditation centers
- 50:12are always precarious and we rely on your individual acts of
- 50:17generosity. Each time you come, we've
- 50:19crunched the numbers. The Suggested donation here is
- 50:24$15 but it is an individual practice of generosity.
- 50:28So examine whether that feels generous or not, if you're well
- 50:33resource, maybe it doesn't and you want to give it a higher
- 50:36level, maybe that's just fine. Maybe it's too much and you need
- 50:40to give at a lower level, but each time you come consider
- 50:44giving so that we can keep the lights on and the doors open, if
- 50:49you would also be so kind as to put the chairs back and the
- 50:52cushion. The way that's also appreciated,
- 50:53and I'll see you next week here. Thanks.
- 50:52The way that's also appreciated, and I'll see you next week here.
- 50:55Thanks.