Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 204 - Bitcoin, Energy and the Reality of Building a Free City | Dušan Matuška
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 204 of the Free Cities podcast. Yes, hello. Welcome,
- 0:38welcome, welcome indeed. This week's show, well, I'm catching up with an old friend,
- 0:43Dushan Matuska. He's the co-founder of Amity Age. He's a Bitcoin educator and someone who's
- 0:51been part of this podcast almost since from the very beginning. We last sat down together in San
- 0:58Salvador back in 2023, just before he moved to Prospera. Back then we were talking about
- 1:05Bitcoin education, free cities and building alternatives to the system you want to leave
- 1:12behind. How things change. Three years on, I wanted to know how things had actually worked out.
- 1:18We sat down in Prospera itself and quite a lot has happened. Dushan is now traveling the world,
- 1:25training Bitcoin educators whilst the Bitcoin mining side of his company Amity Age has taken
- 1:32him from Paraguay to Ethiopia and now on to Alberta in Canada. Those moves in the mining space
- 1:40have not been all straightforward. Cheap electricity is one thing. Being able to rely on people
- 1:47supplying it. Yeah, well, that's another. We talk about what happens when the terms change or someone
- 1:52decides to switch you off his response has been to move further into the energy business
- 1:59buying the actual infrastructure needed to produce power themselves which is amazing we get into gas
- 2:06wells engines bitcoin mining and the growing demand for ai data centers uh oh look out a lot of people
- 2:14don't seem to like ai data centers i get quite carried away in this conversation to be honest
- 2:19the mining part I'm talking about because I've always wanted to work in Bitcoin mining. It's been
- 2:25a dream for years. Outdoor work, engineering, building things with your hands. Sounds like a
- 2:31pretty good life to me but it's not all Bitcoin talk. We come back to Prospera. Of course Dushan's
- 2:38been running a company there for several years now and he's pretty candid about what works and
- 2:43what still needs improving that includes making the bitcoin education center that he runs financially
- 2:50sustainable which a lot of bitcoin companies struggle with making their projects sustainable
- 2:55for a number of reasons that we go into we also talk about attracting small businesses how do you
- 3:00do that and overcoming the suspicion surrounding prospera on the island of roatan interesting on
- 3:08that there's a story about a basketball court they helped renovate that rather neatly
- 3:13illustrates that last point i'll leave him to tell you that one in the actual conversation right
- 3:20before we get into the words a few news updates as i said i'm doing news every week now because
- 3:27there's more and more news it appears in the free cities world first prospera because there's an
- 3:33opening for dialogue in its dispute with the honduran government in a report updated on the
- 3:4013th of this month the honduran newspaper el heraldo says that the government's chief legal
- 3:46representative is willing to hear prosper's proposals for resolving their differences
- 3:52sounds good he also says the government must enforce the supreme court's 2024 ruling
- 3:58against the legal framework under which prosper was established prosper has proposed a dialogue
- 4:05process first to clarify which rules apply to its investment and then to look for an amicable
- 4:12resolution that protects investment and property acquired in good faith so this is an opening for
- 4:19dialogue rather than a settlement the report doesn't establish that negotiations have begun
- 4:24or that either side has agreed a way forward for the people living and running businesses there
- 4:29the practical question is still the same which rules can they rely on when they make plans for
- 4:35the future and it's something to keep in mind as you listen to duchan describe his experience on
- 4:41the ground in prospera next a follow-up to the themes in my conversation with gareth ike episode
- 4:49196 the panopticon is already here was a very popular one that one over 4 000 watches on youtube
- 4:56now which is good for our channel a colorado woman is suing flock and a police officer after
- 5:04she says number plate tracking records were used to wrongly accuse her of stealing a package you all know what flock is flock are these cameras that are appearing everywhere causing a lot of problems in the community pointing at people daily lives
- 5:18and recording everything they're doing in this particular case in colorado her summons was later
- 5:23voided flock says its cameras accurately located her vehicle and that interpreting the evidence was
- 5:30the police's responsibility obviously those are disputed allegations rather than a court finding
- 5:36but the case raises a useful question if a system records your movements correctly and those records
- 5:43help produce a false accusation against you who's accountable i don't know i don't like
- 5:50cameras anyway get rid of them go on okay last news item and it's a bitcoin one we've got a lot
- 5:56of bitcoin listeners probably more this week as well because of dushan and it's worth mentioning
- 6:01the latest ledger hardware wallet hack in inverted commas story because it follows
- 6:08well a few very difficult months for hardware wallet security in general if you don't know what
- 6:14a hardware wallet is it's what we call a signing device which holds your private key to your bitcoin
- 6:23wallet and you can take it with you and you can use it to sign transactions i think a lot of people
- 6:29think a hardware wallet actually contains your bitcoin it's not all it does is sign your
- 6:33transactions basically using your private key but it means that your private key never makes its way
- 6:39onto the internet it sits inside the device now the most recent hack with one of these devices
- 6:46happened at source a reseller basically installed some nefarious hardware inside devices and then
- 6:54sold them to people that's how crazy it's getting people ledger says that all the confirmed cases
- 7:01in the theft reported on the 9th of october involved devices sold through a company called
- 7:06cryptobilis which is a reseller in southeast asia although i have heard that a few people have
- 7:12noticed the same problem in europe but i can't i can't qualify that i just saw it on twitter
- 7:18separately researchers who've examined modified ledger nano x's that's what it's called have
- 7:25have documented extra electronics hidden inside the device these read the recovery words as they
- 7:31appear on the screen and then send them out over a mobile network it's insane a modified wallet
- 7:37therefore can still pass its genuine device check because the original security chip is in there
- 7:44Now, lesson here, well, firstly, don't buy from resellers.
- 7:49If you're going to buy a hardware wallet, which many people do and many people should do,
- 7:55because it is actually a very good way to hold your Bitcoin in self-custody,
- 7:59but buy directly from the person who creates the wallet.
- 8:04Now, this particular hack comes after July's cold card incident,
- 8:09where a software flaw weakened the way that affected wallets generated their private seeds.
- 8:16Coincart says attackers reconstructed the corresponding private keys and stole funds
- 8:21without even remotely accessing the devices.
- 8:24Fixed firmware prevents that problem in future seed generation,
- 8:28but it doesn't repair an existing affected seed.
- 8:32Then in August, Trezor, another hardware wallet company,
- 8:36probably one of the stalwarts the one that people always think right this is these are the goats
- 8:41these are the guys that really know what they're doing they had a breach in their shipping provider
- 8:46so their shipping provider exposed customers names addresses and contact details they didn't
- 8:52but the provider who was sending their devices out did in september another separate breach
- 8:58and its email provider allowed attackers to send phishing messages through treasure's own
- 9:03newsletter account so those treasure incidents involved customer information and communications
- 9:09they were nothing to do with breaches of wallets or their private keys the point is there are
- 9:15several different problems here how your keys are generated whether someone has altered the device
- 9:21before it reaches you and what happens to the personal information you hand over when you buy
- 9:27it and i think that's a rather more useful conversation than simply saying hardware wallets
- 9:32are safe or hardware wallets are unsafe it's a gray area here's my two sats if you're holding
- 9:38your own bitcoin top tier would be multi-vendor multi-sig two of three three of five whatever
- 9:47you want multi-sig means you use well i'll go from the start multi-vendor means you use different
- 9:53hardware wallets say you do a two of three that's three different vendors hardware wallets
- 9:59then you do a multi-sig so if you want to sign a transaction two out of those three need to sign
- 10:07together so if one of them gets compromised you're good even if two of them if two of them
- 10:13get compromised you're possibly still good unless it's the same person but we're not expecting
- 10:19hardware wallets to get compromised in all honesty but if you want to do the top tier way you do multi and you do multi but if you never done multi before pay attention to this
- 10:33don't forget something called your descriptor file it's a crucial new element that you have
- 10:39to take into account if you're going from a single signature wallet a normal wallet like a trezor
- 10:44whatever and you're going up to multi-sig there's something new that you have to look after it's
- 10:49It's called the descriptor file.
- 10:51The rule of thumb is in single SIG, you must back up the seed, obviously.
- 10:55That's your backup.
- 10:56In multi-SIG, you must back up the seed and the descriptor file.
- 11:00That helps put all the keys together.
- 11:03Just as important.
- 11:05Tier two for me would be a single hardware wallet that you trust.
- 11:09Pick one that you really trust.
- 11:12And then add a dice-generated six or more word passphrase.
- 11:17very annoying if you want to sign with your wallet a lot but it adds huge amounts of entropy a pass
- 11:24phrase is basically a 25th word or a 13th word depending how many words there are in your seed
- 11:32and it can be whatever you want but you can also generate six words space them apart by a space
- 11:40and then you're adding six words of entropy on top of your seed phrase that means if you
- 11:47if if your original seed phrases are compromised as in the cold card hack they've still got to crack
- 11:54your passphrase anyway if you're generating your own seeds and people are doing it now much more
- 11:59with dice it's doable and it's quite easy just find a dice indexed passphrase word list and do
- 12:08it yourself and whatever you do try not to include your mind in what you're doing throw dice read off
- 12:15the numbers throw dice read off the numbers don't do anything human because in the future an AI will
- 12:22probably know what you did you've got a plan for that future where AI knows bloody everything
- 12:28anyway that's enough of the Bitcoin stuff it's just been so much of it recently I thought I
- 12:32probably should mention uh to people that listen to this pod the Bitcoiners amongst you will
- 12:37already know this but there might be one or two of you that that are bitcoin adjacent it's good to
- 12:42keep up on these kind of things right time to thank the people supporting the show through value for
- 12:47value our top five this week are anon anon who'd have thunk it number one shadrach number two
- 12:52christopher albanese number three matthias number four and great grand man number five thank you
- 12:59all five of you and everyone else just because you didn't make it into the top five doesn't mean i
- 13:03don't love you here's some messages uh od says quality conversations very interesting and
- 13:10thoughtful much appreciated timothy thank you od episode 203 my conversation with rafael lima that
- 13:17was last week got a lot of comments on that and on and on went straight to the question in the title
- 13:22leave it he said justin bianchi wrote move where you're treated best and great grand man said great
- 13:28conversation uh episode 197 with dominic frisby frisby hypno said great guest i didn't know
- 13:36well that's an unusual one frisby's very well known especially in the bitcoin space
- 13:41but it's always lovely to hear people discovering someone new through the show
- 13:45finally rev hodl episode 202 with patrick hibbert proof of 40 hours per week on onlyboosts.social
- 13:54okay if 40 hours per week's your vibe I want to know you yeah I love the 40 hours per week guys
- 14:00that is I don't know whether it's tongue-in-cheek or not I don't care I probably do do 40 hours per
- 14:07week but it's essentially saying that that should be what you do how much how many hours of podcasts
- 14:12you should listen to uh every week so a full working week I probably do do that to be honest
- 14:18because I listen to them at night as I fall asleep and they sometimes they just stay on all night
- 14:22words wafting into my brain god knows what i know about random things just because i learned it while
- 14:28i was asleep anyway if you'd like to support the show you can send a boost or a stream
- 14:33sats through an app like fountain leave me a message as well i you know i always enjoy hearing
- 14:39from you lot now i've got some news of my own after this week's convo with dushan guess what
- 14:46He asked me to become a show sponsor, as therefore Amity Age are joining the podcast as a new sponsor.
- 14:52And I'm very, very pleased to welcome them.
- 14:55As I said earlier, Dushan's one of my first guests.
- 14:58And I followed what the team have been building over the years, bumped into them at conferences, watched their work grow well beyond the Bitcoin Education Center in Prospera.
- 15:08What I like is that the teaching and the building go together.
- 15:12So Dushan's helping people understand Bitcoin while the mining part of the business are doing
- 15:17the practical work of running the infrastructure behind it.
- 15:20And as you'll hear today, he's quite open about the things that haven't worked as well
- 15:24as the things that have.
- 15:26That's a great fit for the show.
- 15:27As far as I'm concerned, I want to hear from people who are putting their ideas into practice
- 15:32and can tell us what they learned along the way let say So a warm welcome to the amity age team and thank you for supporting the podcast watching them grow into a formidable worldwide bitcoin
- 15:44mining company has been quite something to behold their next step in their evolution is in alberta
- 15:50canada and i've got to say alberta isn't ottawa it's canada's most pro-energy province i know
- 15:57Canada might raise a few eyebrows amongst you but Alberta has an established energy industry,
- 16:04a competitive electricity market and a provincial government actively encouraging natural gas
- 16:09powered centres. Those are practical reasons for choosing it. Amity Age's plan is to actually own
- 16:15the wells and power generation reducing their dependence on an outside energy supplier.
- 16:21That doesn't remove political risk of course but it does give them a huge amount of control
- 16:26over how the business operates. In Alberta, like many places, limited pipeline capacity
- 16:33leaves a lot of gas stranded. The Bitcoiners will know what that means, or at least sold at a steep
- 16:39discount. And for AmityAge, of course, that's their huge opportunity. The team are actually acquiring
- 16:45wells, land and infrastructure. They're buying stuff. That means producing their own gas, generating
- 16:50their own electricity and mining Bitcoin themselves with plans to power AI data centers,
- 16:56of course, as well. For me, well, this is taking self-sovereignty to the next level,
- 17:01owning the energy behind the money. I love that. They have 70 megawatts of client demand
- 17:07lined up and they're looking for accredited investors to help build this next chapter.
- 17:13That's where you come in. But it's not for the faint-hearted guys. This is for serious people.
- 17:17mining is a serious business it needs serious investors 500k upwards is what they're looking
- 17:23for but i happen to know there's quite a few of you out there quietly bawling in the real world
- 17:29who listen to this show so if you're looking to invest in something like this www.amityage.com
- 17:36forward slash free cities or follow the link in the description tell them we sent you please
- 17:42and listen to this conversation with dushan if you want to understand what kind of a company they
- 17:47are and what kind of a guy he is he runs the company right and one more thank you before
- 17:53we go to the show it has to be our lead sponsor who've been with us for so long veritas villages
- 17:58taking more control over the essentials of your life is something we talk about a lot on this show
- 18:03veritas are putting that idea into practice through their freedom oriented communities in panama
- 18:09costa rica and nicaragua their september update included a lovely milestone in coronado panama
- 18:16Sarah and Jason received the keys to their new home marking the community's first key handover
- 18:22that's a new community there construction and infrastructure work are continuing but it's great
- 18:27to see those plans becoming homes over at Playa Pacifica that's the beachside one in Nicaragua
- 18:34the community pool is now under construction they've also shared a video following the local
- 18:38sea turtle conservation work from protecting the eggs to releasing the hatchlings into the ocean
- 18:44If you're curious about what's available, they've now got an interactive lot plan that you can explore on the different home sites, look at the property details and check availability across all four communities.
- 18:58These communities are designed, of course, for people who value privacy, independence and like minded neighbours with opportunities to generate power, grow food and rely less on outside systems.
- 19:10and you can use bitcoin too including to buy your property bitcoiners and it looks like we might be
- 19:17heading into a ball run if everyone i know is correct so it might be time to spend some of
- 19:23that bitcoin on a plan b property or a plan a anyway whether you're considering a permanent move
- 19:27a second home visit veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities and have a conversation with
- 19:34their lovely team and don't forget tell them we sent you right let's get into this but before we
- 19:41do and finally remember that it's come up a few times in the in the show when i was a kid on the
- 19:49news they always used to do and finally at the end of the news it was to kind of soften the blow a bit
- 19:54of all the bad news and it disappeared i don't know why so i'm bringing it back a few people have
- 20:01let's bring it back we're gonna do and finally from now on screw all the eggheads and finally
- 20:08sark has a rather unusual way of helping pay its residents prescription bills that's right ladies
- 20:16and gentlemen sheep racing back in july more than 2 000 people attended the island's sheep racing
- 20:23weekend over the past 10 years the event has raised more than 300 000 pounds towards subsidized
- 20:31prescriptions for islanders this year's program even included the in quotes lamborghini steaks
- 20:39and that's steaks as in s-t-e-a-k-s a day out with your neighbors and help with the chemist's bill not
- 20:50bad for a field full of sheep. Did that sound like and finally? I like that anyway let's get
- 20:57back to Prospera and get into it just sit back relax after you've and finalied and enjoy my
- 21:04conversation with Dushan Matuska. So Dushan, I had a quick, I got my clanker to check out what
- 21:23we spoke about the last time we spoke. Do you remember? We were in El Salvador. Yes. About
- 21:28three years ago very true yes um you you were there back in the early days of the podcast
- 21:35and i have bumped into you a few times since i see you a lot at bt prague things like that you know
- 21:40but this is the first time we've actually got to sit down so this should be a fair bit to talk
- 21:46about oh yeah i'll remind you what we spoke about because i got i got a list here um it was
- 21:53essentially bitcoin parallel nipolis or parallel polis prospera and exit from the state where he
- 22:00was then you spoke in san salvador just before he flew to ruatan preparing to move to prospera
- 22:07was that right so it was just before you moved it pretty much i think it was 22 or 23 well there
- 22:12you go that's that's uh parallel polis you found co-founded the bratoslava version free cities he
- 22:20thought free cities and bitcoin naturally fit together uh prosper political risk because that
- 22:26was all going on then all the all the trouble with the government oh yeah democracy strongly
- 22:30skeptical we'll see if any of these have changed aml skeptical um yeah then there's some stuff
- 22:38about kyc aml and kyc he argued that centralized collection of financial and personal information
- 22:45creates enormous risk, which it does.
- 22:48It materialized very heavily in France.
- 22:51Yes.
- 22:51Freedom of movement.
- 22:53This became a big section of the conversation.
- 22:55You discussed lockdowns, vaccine restrictions,
- 22:58personal carbon allowances, CBDCs,
- 23:00and the much greater difficulty of voting with your feet.
- 23:03It's funny, the whole COVID thing was much closer back then.
- 23:08Yeah.
- 23:08I feel so distant right now.
- 23:10We were talking about it.
- 23:10I think everyone was talking about it quite a lot.
- 23:13Can you remind me of a year we did it?
- 23:15uh 2023 23 okay yeah so it was i mean you know the world had opened up for for a fair amount but
- 23:24it was still fresh in people's minds you know um bitcoin has protest probably one of the strongest
- 23:30conceptual sections of the interview both of you contrasted street protest with building a parallel
- 23:36reality doosan described bitcoin as effectively ignoring the legacy system rather than fighting
- 23:43it we all are probably still there why prosper excited him you discussed 3d printed construction
- 23:49drones and biotech companies using prosper to experiment more rapidly for him this was evidence
- 23:55that governance competition could produce technological experimentation his closing answer
- 24:00given a fully funded one year sabbatical he said he would travel around the world educating people
- 24:07about bitcoin oh i remember back then i had this little gimmick at the end of each show
- 24:11and I used to ask every guest if you had a fully funded one year sabbatical what would you do with
- 24:18it maybe I should bring that back that was quite cool I don't know I just remember I just kind of
- 24:22you said you would basically travel around the world educating people about bitcoin which is
- 24:27what you do right yeah I'm still doing that I'm fulfilling my dream since sport time 23
- 24:32he described the larger mission as separating money and state well that's interesting because
- 24:38one of the things i think this is actually one of the reasons why i stopped asking that question
- 24:43at the end because most people i was speaking to was already was already doing that thing and i
- 24:49kept getting the same answer the same that the answer was well um you know i am i've chosen to
- 24:56do this this is like being on a sabbatical so and and you're exactly that i mean you literally
- 25:01correct me if i'm wrong but in those 23 4 5 so three years ago in those three years you've spent
- 25:07your time traveling around the world educating people about bitcoin very true and actually
- 25:12interestingly enough uh the academy that i'm mostly traveling around the world to teach bitcoin
- 25:17we started in 2024 so after we had the podcast together so it materialized and we did it in
- 25:2325 countries so far and i'm flying to zambia nigeria lebanon and argentina soon to do that
- 25:29what is that then so it's called a bitcoin educators academy and um it's a three-day
- 25:35intense programs that helps bitcoiners passionate for education to teach them soft skill of teaching
- 25:43so that's that's the main thing we're doing now and that that's your that's your doosh and that's
- 25:48your thing yeah that's mth what's that oh mth because i know at mth you you hadn't started
- 25:54when we spoke but did since um so mth as a company started 2021 so i had it when we spoke but this this program the BEA we call it Bitcoin Educators Academy didn start it till 2024
- 26:07Right.
- 26:08Because I started this pod here
- 26:11and some of my first interviews
- 26:13were at the Bitcoin Center.
- 26:14I spoke to Zuzel Ramos.
- 26:16Do you remember?
- 26:17Ariana told me yesterday
- 26:18that you've mistaken her for Zuzel.
- 26:21I did.
- 26:22I was at the bar
- 26:22and she was serving drinks
- 26:24and I went,
- 26:25I know you from somewhere.
- 26:27And then I had to go and look back through the old episodes.
- 26:30But I hope, I mean, I thought she did look like her.
- 26:33Is that true?
- 26:34They kind of resemble each other.
- 26:36Right, okay, okay, right.
- 26:38Right, so Bitcoin Education Academy is an offshoot of Amity Age?
- 26:46It's a project underneath.
- 26:49It's called Educators Academy.
- 26:51Educators.
- 26:52Yeah, Educators Academy.
- 26:55It's basically our educational project,
- 26:56the flagship project we do for education.
- 26:59We didn't want to recreate the wheel of,
- 27:02like there are so many interesting, you know,
- 27:04Bitcoin curriculums and diplomas.
- 27:08We didn't want to do another one and just compete on it in front,
- 27:11but we wanted to do something else.
- 27:12So we can discuss that further.
- 27:14Sure, we will.
- 27:15And is that bigger or smaller than AmityAge?
- 27:19That's kind of the same thing.
- 27:22It's basically a product.
- 27:23So AmityAge, we build data centers,
- 27:26We built power plants now in Canada.
- 27:28So MTH is growing and getting bigger.
- 27:31And from the education side of things, the main thing is the Educators Academy.
- 27:35But then we do like the data center business.
- 27:37That's what really makes money for us.
- 27:39And I got a feeling at the time you were looking into Paraguay.
- 27:44And I would imagine now you've gone full hard send into Paraguay, have you?
- 27:49That's interesting.
- 27:50We can discuss that.
- 27:51We set up the data centers in Paraguay and then we went out of Paraguay.
- 27:55Oh, right.
- 27:56So it started and it's ended since we started talking.
- 28:00All right.
- 28:00We'll talk about that.
- 28:01That's interesting because I've spoken to a couple of people about Paraguay.
- 28:04And it's like the it place at the moment for so many reasons for people, it seems.
- 28:09And one of the topics was always that they've got so much hydropower.
- 28:13That is still true.
- 28:14But the government and the power companies are messing it up.
- 28:17So so many miners left Paraguay.
- 28:19Is that right?
- 28:20Okay.
- 28:21Oh, shit.
- 28:21Well, where should we start then?
- 28:22Why don't we start with Bitcoin Educators Academy then?
- 28:27So you basically, is it a bit like what happened in El Salvador with my first Bitcoin?
- 28:33You create a curriculum and then you basically just export it around the world.
- 28:36Pretty much.
- 28:37It's not fully open source as a Bitcoin diploma, as my first Bitcoin, because it requires a teacher to know what they teach.
- 28:44So we cannot just open it up.
- 28:47We are getting new teachers in, but we need to train them over time to be able to deliver it.
- 28:51So we want to keep the same level of quality no matter where we go.
- 28:54And we are right now two trainers delivering it.
- 28:57So my friend is doing it in Asia now, and I'll be traveling to Africa.
- 29:01So all the knowledge that we teach there, people can take it and use it wherever they want.
- 29:05So there's no strings attached.
- 29:07But it's not like, here's a book, follow the book with your students, and you're going to get good results.
- 29:12So when it comes to soft skills, it is much more difficult.
- 29:16It needs a proper teacher.
- 29:17And did you say three days?
- 29:19Three days, yeah.
- 29:20Run me through it, roughly speaking.
- 29:23What are the main points you hit?
- 29:24It's always nice to know.
- 29:25What would be 101 on Bitcoin these days?
- 29:28So the three days focus on how to become a better educator.
- 29:32So it's not about like learning what is Bitcoin,
- 29:34but learning how to communicate Bitcoin properly.
- 29:37So we focus on how to handle objections,
- 29:40how to not be this firehose of facts and figures,
- 29:43how to listen more, how to do public speaking.
- 29:46So the first day is very heavy on speaking skills
- 29:49and communication skills.
- 29:50Then we go into how to handle Bitcoin myths,
- 29:53how to use analogies,
- 29:54how to structure presentations
- 29:56so people get inspired to change their beliefs.
- 30:00So it's very focused on the delivery part of education.
- 30:06And what are the, you said there, handling objections.
- 30:09What are the current objections to Bitcoin?
- 30:11It's funny, I almost feel like three years ago,
- 30:15there was so many.
- 30:17I think we were probably in the thick of the environmental objections probably at that particular time.
- 30:21That's still on the plate all the time.
- 30:24Right. Okay.
- 30:25But I think we have come a long way in three years.
- 30:28I think there are a number of ideas which were just starting to surface three years ago,
- 30:35like even the fact that Bitcoin mining is a massive net positive.
- 30:39That wasn't even generally, or the reasons why that is true weren't generally known.
- 30:44but maybe you knew it but your average person out there didn't acknowledge the you know balancing of
- 30:49the of the network and and you know buyer of last resort and all that kind of stuff
- 30:54what are the current ones that or even some potentials you can see coming up soon
- 31:00so the ones that really went off are like oh nobody will implement it like the companies will
- 31:06not touch it and we saw over the last few years the treasury companies integrating it and so that objection is kind of off the table The ones that that are still there is definitely the environmental one uh people still not understanding how it balances the grid how it
- 31:20reduces the methane so this is actually what we're doing canada we're reducing the methane from
- 31:25flared gas turning it into electrons and bitcoin right um we are traveling to multiple countries
- 31:33as i said we did in 23 countries and every country has a different context and culture
- 31:37and different objections. So for example we are pretty surprised in Indonesia one of the major
- 31:42objections that people are getting the educators are getting is that bitcoin is haram. And I was
- 31:47like what do you mean haram? It's like oh no Islam doesn't allow that. So I was like I've never heard
- 31:52that because we never educated in a Islamic country right. But this was very important for
- 31:56the educators to have a solid argument to dismantle it. So that was something very important for them.
- 32:04The general thing is like Bitcoin has no intrinsic value.
- 32:08And then we teach the educators to better ask the person like what they think is intrinsic value.
- 32:15Like what does it mean?
- 32:16So just to define the terms first and then you can have a conversation.
- 32:20Because some people are like immediately fighting it.
- 32:22But if you define properly what intrinsic value is, you can agree that Bitcoin does not have an intrinsic value.
- 32:29Because it doesn't produce cash flow.
- 32:30And from financial terms, that is what intrinsic value requires.
- 32:33So then you can switch the communication to the utility of Bitcoin and usage of Bitcoin.
- 32:39So these are kind of the nuances that we're doing there.
- 32:42What's the haram argument then? I've never heard that one.
- 32:45Why is Bitcoin not haram?
- 32:47So by people saying that, they're like, the main argument is that you shouldn't make profit on it.
- 32:56As in like when you can't lend money out in haram.
- 32:59Yes, so there is something in regards of lending, credit, making profit that is the haram part.
- 33:07I'm not professional on that.
- 33:09I'm not like a...
- 33:10Can I guess what the comeback is?
- 33:13That when Bitcoin increases in value, it's not a zero-sum thing.
- 33:19There's no loser of money.
- 33:20Whereas if you're lending money out, you're basically taking back more than you lent out.
- 33:26So there's that, because I think under Haram Ideas, that's not allowed you.
- 33:31You're not allowed to lend money and take interest, basically.
- 33:33Yes, that's kind of my argument.
- 33:35But that is zero sum.
- 33:36That means someone loses money.
- 33:38The person who's paying you interest loses money.
- 33:39But when everyone's price goes up.
- 33:41I would even disagree with that, because if somebody is getting a loan,
- 33:46they suddenly value the amount you give them plus the interest that they will pay more.
- 33:52And they want to do a business to earn more than the interest.
- 33:55and then pay you back. So for them, it's a voluntary exchange. So for me personally,
- 33:59and I think for humanity in general, credit system is a great thing. I think even in Bitcoin
- 34:06standard, there will be credit. The problem is when you're loaning more than you have,
- 34:11and you're pretending you have it all covered, and you don't. It's like fractional reserve banking.
- 34:15So that's actually the argument that we are bringing to these discussions. Like, okay,
- 34:19let's look at the banking as it is today in every major bank in the world. And let's look at if that
- 34:25is haram or not and suddenly you know there are some rules that people like yeah that's okay
- 34:30because it's the government and so on and you know it's good to bring the the legacy system in and
- 34:35like look very closely on it under the same microscope right so i get it so the educators
- 34:41program is about creating new teachers of bitcoin and what do they do after that go out and create
- 34:47their own i don't know yeah they they create their own uh consultation services they go to schools
- 34:53and teach. They create their own podcasts, YouTube channels, newsletters, magazines. So each and every
- 35:00one of them is different. And the principles we're teaching are applicable across multiple platforms
- 35:05that they are using. Wow. And what do you say? 23 countries? Yes. Bloody hell. How do you work
- 35:14that out? Do you just connect with Bitcoiners in each country and then just use that as a way in?
- 35:18Pretty much, pretty much. And yeah, I connected with them on conferences and I tell them what we do. And they're like, hey, we want this for our community. And then we just figure out the details. It's a paid program. And we want to keep it that way. Because I have a saying that if people don't pay, they don't pay attention. So I believe that if people at least pay something, suddenly their focus is 10x, the amount that they would be like, oh, it's a free program. So they would just come and go and not focus on it.
- 35:45So we are getting also some grants for it so that helps us to sustain it.
- 35:49But otherwise, it's a paid program by participants.
- 35:51So we cover our cost, we make a profit on it, and we can sustain it.
- 35:55And your most eye-opening places you've been where you were surprised about how receptive people were or something?
- 36:02I don't know.
- 36:03I was very surprised by India.
- 36:05We did it in September last year.
- 36:07And the amount of knowledgeable Bitcoiners and super passionate and engaged Bitcoiners was phenomenal.
- 36:14There was a conference called BitPlebs.
- 36:16It was a small one, maybe 200 people.
- 36:20But the quality of discussions I had were pretty unmatched Like extremely passionate educators there wanting to get deeper very knowledgeable So I was like wow So we did a Bitcoin mining academy
- 36:33That's something that we're doing as well. It's a project we started last year. And back
- 36:37to back, we did it with the educators academy. So it was like a six days of heavy training
- 36:41with it. So I was pretty exhausted.
- 36:42Right. Training people how to set up a mining operation.
- 36:45How to understand mining better and how to become a mining consultant. So how to understand
- 36:50not only the machine itself, but how to calculate efficiency, profitability, how to choose a
- 36:56site, how to choose a country, what to look at, how to deal with customs, suppliers.
- 37:01So kind of like the broader picture of the whole mining ecosystem so that they can advise
- 37:06some people.
- 37:07They can say, oh, don't go here because these are the reasons or just this is better for
- 37:10you.
- 37:11So that's kind of the, again, three day mining academy, very heavy and morning 8am to 6pm.
- 37:18And what's the mining landscape like these days then?
- 37:22Sounds like Paraguay is a no-go for miners now, which is a bit of a shame.
- 37:26Yeah, it is a bit of a shame.
- 37:27Do you want to go in?
- 37:28Give us the mining landscape and then just go into why Paraguay has taken a hit.
- 37:32So mining landscape.
- 37:34Europe is pretty dead on mining.
- 37:36Some Nordic countries still trying, but there are so many regulations.
- 37:39There are socialists up there.
- 37:40So it's very difficult.
- 37:42In order for you to be profitable, you need to do something called district heating.
- 37:45So you need to use your heat from the miners to heat houses, warehouses.
- 37:49So then it kind of makes sense.
- 37:51And people are doing that?
- 37:52People are doing that.
- 37:53Yeah, yeah.
- 37:53There are large companies doing that.
- 37:54There is a company that's heating 5,000 houses in Finland.
- 37:57So it's a really great...
- 37:59With a mining farm or a mining operation.
- 38:02Yes.
- 38:03Wow.
- 38:03But that's quite a lot of extra infrastructure, right?
- 38:06Not that much, to be honest.
- 38:07Because if you have hydro-cooled miners, the output is hot water.
- 38:12Hot water.
- 38:12And you either cool it down and run it back.
- 38:15or you just supply it to the district heating company,
- 38:18they're very happily buy it from you
- 38:20because they pay less to you
- 38:21than they would otherwise spend for heating it up.
- 38:24And you're getting suddenly paid like an extra revenue
- 38:28besides the Bitcoin you're mining.
- 38:30So it's a very win-win cooperation.
- 38:32Wow.
- 38:34Where else then?
- 38:35So Africa, we are right now in Ethiopia.
- 38:37So we have two data centers in Ethiopia,
- 38:40which are not going the best.
- 38:42There are a lot of hurdles.
- 38:43the governmental entities are fighting each other and we are kind of in between as hostages so
- 38:49actually I just finished the call right now with our with our local partner that we are
- 38:53you know figuring out what to do because for a few weeks we are offline
- 38:56and we just can't mind there so it's rough in Ethiopia. Are you when you say you set up in
- 39:02Ethiopia are you taking the same miners from Paraguay shipping them over there setting them
- 39:08is that how it works or do you just get a whole new setup? We did both so we moved about
- 39:13600 miners from Paraguay to Ethiopia. We sold about 700 in Paraguay and then we're getting new
- 39:21ones to Ethiopia. So we have about almost 3,000 miners in Ethiopia now. But it's not going well?
- 39:27Currently no. Currently no. There are also curtailments because of the El Nino, which
- 39:32decreased the level of water in the dams. So they are curtailed us to just 23% of the whole power.
- 39:39And for a miner, 23% is not sustainable.
- 39:43And is your business model looking for hydro?
- 39:47Is that the main business model for someone like yourself?
- 39:49Honestly, not now.
- 39:51Because with hydro, the power plants are pretty centralized.
- 39:55And if there is any volatility in the water levels, you might get cut off like that.
- 39:59So our main thing that we are doing right now, we are basically getting vertically integrated.
- 40:04We are owning the land.
- 40:06We're owning the gas underneath.
- 40:08We're owning the pipelines, gas wells, and the power generation.
- 40:13So we are becoming a power company and creating our own power.
- 40:17So we're turning the stranded molecules of gas into electrons and into bits and bytes.
- 40:22But you mean, but you still have to find someone who's already extracting.
- 40:28What is it?
- 40:28What is the, what are they extracting to begin with?
- 40:31So it's, there are gas wells, oil and gas.
- 40:33Oil companies have gas as a side business.
- 40:37and sometimes they even give you gas for free
- 40:39because they need to pay extra royalties on it
- 40:42and getting rid of the gas
- 40:44because their main focus is oil
- 40:45and just gas comes out with that.
- 40:47So they're very happy to give it to you
- 40:49and you take care of it.
- 40:51You kind of lower their burden
- 40:52and you have free gas.
- 40:55That's one way.
- 40:56The other is buying out the gas well.
- 40:58So integrating everything into a one pipeline system
- 41:02and then you own all the assets for that.
- 41:05So suddenly nobody can turn you off
- 41:07you are fully responsible so if you some if you mess up something it's your own fault and you can
- 41:11solve it but but suddenly you're you cut out all the middlemen in a way that can mess it up for you
- 41:18so you have all the responsibility on your shoulders which for me i like it much more because
- 41:25if i mess up i know it's my fault and i need to fix that but if the agency tells you hey sorry
- 41:30you know um we cannot give you power it's pretty impossible that's amazing so you're now at the
- 41:36where you're buying gas wells for yourself.
- 41:38Yes, we might be actually
- 41:40acquiring an oil and gas company in upcoming weeks.
- 41:43Wow.
- 41:43That's amazing, dude.
- 41:45I mean, you're a bona fide large-scale miner now, right?
- 41:50Yep.
- 41:51I would still call it a medium-sized
- 41:53because for me, large-scales are like the big public traded companies,
- 41:56but we are slowly getting there.
- 41:58And I was just buying gas engines for a million dollars last week.
- 42:03So we are going heavy.
- 42:06I am genuinely happy for you, mate, because that's so cool.
- 42:10So, wow. And that's Canada. That's where you're doing that?
- 42:14Alberta. I think it's the only province that makes sense to do mining.
- 42:18All the other provinces are pretty socialist, and they don't like mining very much.
- 42:23But Alberta is very based. There's a lot of competent people.
- 42:27Oil and gas is established there for decades.
- 42:30And government actually heavily supports that.
- 42:33And the reason for it is they cannot export gas south to US.
- 42:37They cannot export it to the West to build some gas ports.
- 42:43So they are very happy to use the gas in-house.
- 42:46So they're opening their doors to miners.
- 42:49And not only miners, but AI data centers.
- 42:51So a few weeks ago, Meta announced a $13 billion project there,
- 42:55a huge AI data center in Alberta.
- 42:58And main source of power is gas.
- 43:02It is trended.
- 43:03It's huge amounts of gas.
- 43:05and this can monetize the economy.
- 43:07Well, is stranded gas they're running the data center of?
- 43:10The big one, not on a stranded.
- 43:12That would not be enough.
- 43:13So they run it in a pipeline gas.
- 43:15So you have a great quality constant input of gas.
- 43:19We as miners, since our data centers
- 43:21don't need to be that high-end as AI data center,
- 43:24we can go to more remote locations.
- 43:26We can put up Starlink.
- 43:27Our uptime can be 95% and we are extremely happy with that.
- 43:31For AI, you need to go 99, 99.5 and above.
- 43:35all it's funny because when when when i just before i started this podcast four years ago
- 43:41whatever i was trying to i i've always wanted to work in mining and by that i mean bitcoin mining
- 43:48but not because it's bitcoin necessarily but obviously it is but because i love working with
- 43:53my hands and and i just looked at the whole mining scene and thought what an amazing job
- 43:58oh yeah you basically spend your life looking around the world for the right location you go
- 44:02out there you wreck it you're driving around in four-wheel drives you're doing all this stuff then
- 44:06you actually get to build it yeah with your hands and then you get all the electronics and the
- 44:10technical stuff and it's like this is my dream job and i did reach out to a load of miners you know
- 44:15but you know you really they wanted it was mainly happening in america all the stranded stuff was
- 44:20mainly happening in america i even contacted some oil companies in the uk because we've got our
- 44:25offshore oil rigs oh no yeah but no chance they they didn't they didn't even want to talk or when
- 44:32i thought it through the actual implications of putting miners on offshore rigs is completely
- 44:37different from what you guys do which is basically set up a hut next door yeah you know it's not like
- 44:43out at sea it's not built on the side of something so the insurance implications are completely
- 44:47different easier yeah but i can hire you one day maybe no it's still my dream job i think if you're
- 44:53a guy and you like bitcoin and you like the outdoors i think it's the perfect job 100% yeah
- 45:01Yeah, I'm super, I'm genuinely happy for you, mate.
- 45:04In the last few months, I got so excited about gas engines and the whole engineering around it.
- 45:08Man, like you wouldn't believe, like, I love to work with my hands.
- 45:12I used to do when I was a kid, I was always locked in my dad's garage and building planes and ships and like a bunch of stuff from wood.
- 45:19And now with the mining, and especially with the gas mining, like you're suddenly seeing the engines.
- 45:24Our partner is flying tomorrow to look and inspect like 10 megawatts of engines that we might be acquiring.
- 45:30and the whole, you know, just seeing the engines.
- 45:34You probably read Atlas Shracht, right?
- 45:36Yeah, yeah.
- 45:36And like the engine was like the big thing in the book, right?
- 45:40And right now I'm rereading Atlas again for the third time
- 45:42and just reading about an engine and everything that it implies.
- 45:46It just makes me so excited
- 45:47because it's like the human ingenuity in a physical form, right?
- 45:51Like you're turning these molecules
- 45:52into sustainable rotational movement and then electricity.
- 45:56It's fascinating, like what humanity is capable of doing
- 45:59and building so just seeing the engines i'm right now learning all about that about gas oil so i'm
- 46:05just going down the rabbit holes of this i'm watching landman which is the series i know you
- 46:10know i love it i love it and i'm just watching the the episodes and suddenly there's some
- 46:17lingo i don't know i just stop it i go on google i clawed it out and i'm like man this is so
- 46:22fascinating so i totally agree also it's it's you know the kind of people you you meet in the oil
- 46:29gas world are solid guys, you know, and that's my dream.
- 46:35You know, that's the place I want to be.
- 46:38What I was thinking was, if you buy a whole well of gas well,
- 46:42does it all go into Bitcoin mining or are you buying the tankers now
- 46:46so you can actually sell it as well sell off the other stuff or the exit We go all the way to Bitcoin mining And the good thing about owning the assets the energy assets is that right now the price of gas in Alberta is pretty low And
- 46:59it's been like that for some time. There are some expectations that the price will increase,
- 47:05nobody knows when, but if it does, and if for any reason at that moment, it's much better to sell it
- 47:10to the pipeline, we can suddenly decide to just build the compressor and put it to the pipeline
- 47:16for a while and then get back to mining or we can sell electricity to the grid. So right now,
- 47:22if you own these assets, you are basically hedged against the volatility of Bitcoin because you know
- 47:27that people still need electricity, they still need the gas, so you can then choose what's the
- 47:31best option for you. So it's much better than just building the data center for Bitcoin, connecting
- 47:37from the grid and if something happens you disconnect and you're waiting because you don't
- 47:41on the generation asset, right?
- 47:43So this is kind of the play
- 47:45we are playing for upcoming decade.
- 47:47There are some opportunities
- 47:49in upcoming year or two
- 47:50for solar mining as well
- 47:52when the battery storage gets better
- 47:54and it's already on track
- 47:55of getting cheaper and more efficient.
- 47:58And so we, in Alberta,
- 47:59Calgary especially is the most sunny city
- 48:02in whole Canada.
- 48:03So deploying some solar farms
- 48:06for mining would make sense.
- 48:08Not right now.
- 48:09Right now the best play is the gas,
- 48:10but the solar might open up in some time.
- 48:13And do you pull the gas out,
- 48:15store it on site in big tanks
- 48:17and then use it
- 48:18or do you just use it as it comes out of the ground?
- 48:20As it comes out, it goes directly.
- 48:22You need to check the quality
- 48:23if there's no H2S
- 48:25so you just need to make the gas
- 48:27to a good condition
- 48:29so the gas engines are not stressed
- 48:31or messing up.
- 48:33But yeah, you basically take the molecule
- 48:36just treat it a bit
- 48:38run into the engine
- 48:39it spins, create electricity, and here's your Bitcoin.
- 48:42Shit.
- 48:42And what about partners?
- 48:44Have you got, do you know a bunch of guys who come from the oil and gas world?
- 48:49And now you're working, because it's not, you know, the Bitcoin side of it is probably
- 48:54the simple side, isn't it?
- 48:56Yes.
- 48:57That's very true.
- 48:58Yeah, the oil and gas is like the tough part.
- 49:00So we partnered up with a couple of local partners, engineers that were running sites
- 49:05for decades and they have extremely good knowledge of oil and gas because that was not our
- 49:11our knowledge we used to when we started mining in Slovakia we used to use a biogas so it was
- 49:17kind of similar but it was created from different processes than from the earth but the engines were
- 49:22similar um but yes we knew that we don't have that knowledge we want to partner with somebody very
- 49:28knowledgeable so right now we are building the team and the partners we already have are like
- 49:32like extremely knowledgeable people.
- 49:34Like the amount of competency I met in Calgary,
- 49:38like in Alberta in general, is tremendous.
- 49:41I'm getting so excited for people who know what they're doing.
- 49:44They are delivering.
- 49:46They keep their words.
- 49:47They're just like, they're doers, builders, engineers.
- 49:50It gets me so excited for humanity.
- 49:52It sounds like you're juxtaposing that
- 49:55against what happens in Central America.
- 49:57Well, yes, yes.
- 49:59Well, you've spent a lot of time here recently, haven't you?
- 50:01I did.
- 50:02Yeah. I just thought of another question. God, I'm asking so many questions about mining.
- 50:10What was I going to say? Oh, yeah. So you're doing the teaching alongside this.
- 50:17Yes.
- 50:17That seems like quite a lot of work.
- 50:21It's a lot. I mean, I'm traveling a lot. I'm trying to minimize it. That's why I have other trainers in the process that can take over my work.
- 50:28So I don't need to visit every single country myself.
- 50:31And that's why I'm also building a team in Canada that's capable of doing things.
- 50:35So my colleague moved there right now with his family for at least three months.
- 50:39And we just had a call today in the morning.
- 50:41And he's the one on the ground with our partners.
- 50:44Yesterday, we were wrecking new miners, like one megawatt of S21s and plugging them in.
- 50:50So he's the guy on the ground, extremely knowledgeable.
- 50:54He has skills from deploying sites in Norway, hydro-cooled sites.
- 50:58So yeah, I mean, really, I cannot make this alone.
- 51:02It's not possible.
- 51:03So I love to have competent people on the team.
- 51:06That was a question I was going to ask.
- 51:08What do the local guys up in Calgary make of what you're doing with the gas?
- 51:12Sorry, what?
- 51:13The local guys you're working with up in Calgary.
- 51:15What do they make of the fact that you're mining Bitcoin?
- 51:18Does it make sense to them?
- 51:20Yeah, yeah, it does.
- 51:21We met a couple of people who, I would say, older generations from like oil and gas, 40, 50 years.
- 51:26and they already understand the play
- 51:28because they understand that selling the gas to pipeline
- 51:31doesn't even make them enough to cover their costs.
- 51:34So it's like, it's kind of painful.
- 51:36They don't know what to do with the gas.
- 51:37And suddenly when mining comes in,
- 51:39like that revenue makes sense for them.
- 51:42So we can buy it for much more
- 51:43than the pipeline would give them
- 51:45and offset that gas directly locally,
- 51:49even without piping it.
- 51:51So they would probably,
- 51:52they would need to build a pipeline to connect,
- 51:54by compressors.
- 51:57And with us, they don't need to do that
- 51:58because they just consume the gas locally on site So few of them are pretty skeptical because they had some bad experiences with Bitcoiners and miners in the past that were just coming going leaving
- 52:11But that's why it really is important to build the long-term relationships. And when we told
- 52:15them like, look, we're not here for a day or a week or a year. We want to acquire the assets.
- 52:22We want to be here long-term. We want to play the long-term game. They're like, wow, this is the
- 52:26approach that we appreciate and we want to work with you yeah sure buying thing i used to whenever
- 52:31when i was looking into it years ago the main things that used to come up were the difficulty
- 52:37in getting miners and the volatility of the price causing you to have to make all these weird hedges
- 52:42against the price of what you're actually mining is that got any better well there's an interesting
- 52:50situation now. A lot of big publicly traded miners are switching slowly to AI because they have the
- 52:57capital for it and there is much more revenue in it. But it's super complicated. It's like next level
- 53:02thing. And the benefit for us is that they're disconnecting their miners that they had. So
- 53:08suddenly the good quality secondhand miners getting cheaper and suddenly the difficulty
- 53:15even is dropping. So it's more profitable to mine Bitcoin, right? So since January, the difficulty
- 53:20dropped by like 15%, which is great. This was never the case. It was always going up, even though
- 53:26the price was dropping because all these big guys had contracts they need to fill out. So they were
- 53:30wrecking the miners as much as possible. What is happening now, the big producers of the miners
- 53:36that are also producing GPUs and AI hardware, they don't have a lot of buyers for the new miners. So
- 53:42They're willing to enter joint venture agreements with us,
- 53:46bring the hardware, we do a profit split,
- 53:48so we have a pipeline of more than 100 megawatts
- 53:51of mining hardware that the guys are like,
- 53:54hey guys, we want to work with you,
- 53:56just prepare the racks, prepare the power plants,
- 53:59we will bring the miners.
- 54:00So right now our main play is how to get as much funding as possible
- 54:04so we fulfill these contracts
- 54:06and we can buy the gas engines, buy the power plants,
- 54:09all of that, build it out and wreck those miners.
- 54:13So we are investing into long-term infrastructure
- 54:15and they have the short-term infrastructure,
- 54:17which are the miners that will take maybe three to six years to operate
- 54:22and then you need to replace them, right?
- 54:24And they're all still coming out of China though.
- 54:25Is anyone else making miners now?
- 54:28There was a company that was a US company,
- 54:31but they actually pivoted heavily from miners to AI right now.
- 54:35So it's pretty difficult to build those anywhere else.
- 54:38So yeah, still Taiwan, China, main factories for the miners.
- 54:43We better talk about AI then.
- 54:44Why is AI more profitable?
- 54:46Literally just hosting servers for AI companies more profitable than mining Bitcoin.
- 54:52One reason is that you see what's happening with AI.
- 54:55It's booming.
- 54:55Everybody wants to get the new models out.
- 54:58So you need a lot of inference.
- 55:00You need a lot of hardware to calculate real time when you put something into cloud.
- 55:05It's happening in the cloud, in the data centers.
- 55:08and you need hardware and almost 100% uptime for that. And the companies who are fighting right now
- 55:17to become the best ones are heavily paying on it. So they have VC money from selling their stocks
- 55:24and they're heavily deploying that into making sure that they win this race. So the revenue is
- 55:30there. You need to have an offtaker, meaning a client that puts their machines there, their AI
- 55:35hardware or is willing to do the computations with Bitcoin you don't need it because Bitcoin
- 55:40is your client right so anytime you plug miner in Bitcoin is there and will pay you so that is the
- 55:45very easy part in AI you don't have that if you buy the hardware you plug it in suddenly you're
- 55:51like okay who's my customer who's going to pay me for that that's that's rough to do it and since
- 55:56there are so many more risks involved the prices are much higher as well I think it will plateau
- 56:02in a way or maybe there will come a correction. So that's why we are slightly hesitant to play
- 56:08AI game but we have two sides in Canada that are extremely AI ready that we can build out because
- 56:14they are sitting on a 100 megawatt pipeline connection, 100 megawatt grid connection and on the
- 56:19fastest fiber backbone of the whole Canada. So you need a special occasions for AI data centers to
- 56:25really be used by these companies. So you cannot go too much trendy, too much you know remote.
- 56:31presumably the ai um trade will cycle back as well because it is it is bubble now it is a but
- 56:42i mean i'm not saying necessarily that's necessarily a bad thing very natural for it's very natural to
- 56:46be a bubble but it is a bubble yeah we saw it in the bitcoin price it was decreasing while the
- 56:51capital was moving and flowing out of bitcoin as the risk asset into the riskier asset ai so uh
- 56:58And there will be a correction, 100% sure.
- 57:01But the tools are useful that the guys are doing.
- 57:05It's not just like some vaporware.
- 57:06It's like I use it every day and it helps me tremendously.
- 57:09So there is value in it but there will be winners and losers And now I think in upcoming few years it will be determined Well you playing the trade mate You literally playing the correct trade You mining more at a cheaper price now
- 57:24And by the time it cycles back, you'll have the price of Bitcoin go up at that point, won't you?
- 57:31Yes, yes. No, but this is what I discovered when I looked into it originally, is you really need
- 57:39to know what you're doing to mine because of the price volatility and because of the cycles of you
- 57:45know the four-year cycle yes and what inevitably happens is people get wrecked because they get
- 57:51they get the cycle wrong it's like people that go and try and trade they get it wrong most of
- 57:56them lose money it's the same in mining you end up basically buying high and selling low you know
- 58:01you mine it mine it when it's expensive and then you you go out of business when it drops and you
- 58:06have to sell everything. Yeah, it happened to a lot of miners that I know as well. So it's not an
- 58:11easy business in this way, and it's very hard to predict. So we're also, I would say, in a risk
- 58:17environment. But we believe that this is the right play to go with. And that's why over the last five,
- 58:24six years that we've been mining, we're slowly getting into owning the whole infrastructure.
- 58:30And the engines, you can use them to create power for AI later. So that's an asset that can be
- 58:35easily sold and interestingly enough if you buy an engine and connect it on the on the gas that
- 58:42you package it and you have an offtaker either a bitcoin data center or anybody else the value of
- 58:48that engine can go three four times the purchase power so then you can leverage it you can
- 58:54collateralize it in the bank and you're getting more than you paid for it and then you have
- 58:59liquidity to buy new stuff. So the assets are very valuable once they are connected and there is a
- 59:06longer term contract of power production. So this is also a very interesting thing that I found out
- 59:11just kind of recently and that is helping us to finance everything as well. Yeah, it was the same
- 59:17with miners, wasn't it? When you're in the height of a bull run, you could sell miners for a massive
- 59:24profit i mean it's it's an obvious trade if you can do it because you're you're you know you if
- 59:31you know enough about bitcoin cycles and just what you know you've been in it a long time you get a
- 59:36sense when you're getting somewhere near a very big top yes and you just start if you you know
- 59:41you start selling if you own bitcoin and you want to cycle through it you sell a bit of it there or
- 59:46if you've got miners you can get rid of them there yeah it's it's an amazing thing i'm absolutely
- 59:51fascinated by the whole thing it is it's like a new industry that just sprung out of nowhere
- 59:56that is so aligned with market incentives and stuff that you can learn so much about the human
- 1:00:03condition from just watching how to do business in the most cutthroat business it's probably one
- 1:00:08of the most cutthroat businesses in the world it is because you see global competition instant
- 1:00:12like results from your mistake if you make a mistake it's instantly there for you oh yeah
- 1:00:17Or like you say, you plug in, you're making money.
- 1:00:20But that doesn't mean anything if you spent too much on the miner
- 1:00:23and the price of Bitcoin is too much.
- 1:00:24Yeah, you can get wrecked, yeah, 100%.
- 1:00:26Crazy, man. Awesome.
- 1:00:27So you're in Canada.
- 1:00:30I'm going to keep talking about mining for a bit because I love it.
- 1:00:33Are there any other hotspots around the world anymore?
- 1:00:37I know some guys who are deploying 100 megawatts in Bolivia,
- 1:00:42but Bolivia falls, in my mind, to a category of Ethiopia, Paraguay,
- 1:00:46and I don't want to play that game.
- 1:00:47And I don't want to do any weird deals behind the backs and like paying these guys.
- 1:00:52No, that's not how I want to do business.
- 1:00:56So we were offered to go to Kazakhstan as well, but it's super complicated, super centralized.
- 1:01:01You need to sell your Bitcoin to like a governmental approved entity.
- 1:01:07So a lot of uncertainties.
- 1:01:11And anytime I hear like, oh, you need to know the right people.
- 1:01:15I'm like, no, no, no.
- 1:01:16This is a huge red flag for me because the right people can change.
- 1:01:19And like, it's no.
- 1:01:21So honestly, U.S. Texas is still big.
- 1:01:25And right now the bigger miners got kind of messed up by a new legislation
- 1:01:30that is giving them some hard time.
- 1:01:32So we already see some of the Texas miners thinking of Canada as well
- 1:01:37and already moving there.
- 1:01:40I know in Wyoming there are some miners.
- 1:01:43So there are folks around.
- 1:01:44U.S. is still pretty big.
- 1:01:46I know some miners in Africa and other countries,
- 1:01:49but they are getting messed up as well.
- 1:01:52Basically the free world, I guess.
- 1:01:54Yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:56So hopefully that will stay.
- 1:01:57I don't know if the Western world will not go completely nuts.
- 1:02:02And what about Roatan and Prospera and all that?
- 1:02:05How much time do you spend here?
- 1:02:06Is it your base or are you all over the place?
- 1:02:09I don't think I ever have a base,
- 1:02:11or I would call Slovakia still my base
- 1:02:13because my family is there.
- 1:02:14I spend maybe six months of a year in Slovakia
- 1:02:18and the rest I keep Roatan and traveling.
- 1:02:20So in Roatan, I'm roughly four to six months of a year
- 1:02:24and the rest I'm doing the academies around the world.
- 1:02:27So it's one of my bases.
- 1:02:30is Roatan, which might decrease time-wise because of Canada. So I'm flying to Canada in a few days,
- 1:02:36my girlfriend's going to come there for the first time ever and I want to get her excited for it.
- 1:02:40She loves mountains, so I think she's going to love it and Calgary and the Rockies next to it is
- 1:02:45beautiful. So if everything goes well and if my main business is in Canada, I might spend much
- 1:02:51more time there. So then probably Roatan will decrease since you cannot do mining here. But I was
- 1:02:57speaking with Prospera that maybe we can help with some energy projects here. So maybe I can
- 1:03:04come back again more when we do some energy stuff here. So let's see.
- 1:03:08Well, someone needs to create energy here, don't they? Because there's a monopoly on the island at
- 1:03:12the moment. It is, it is. And honestly, the guy who's doing it here, he's a billionaire. So he's
- 1:03:18a self-made guy that was working as an engineer on oil rigs and he built pipelines. So he's really
- 1:03:26a guy who knows what he's doing.
- 1:03:29I think RECO, the local power company,
- 1:03:30is run extremely well.
- 1:03:33I think it's one of the best businesses
- 1:03:34or not the best business on Roatan.
- 1:03:38It is a monopoly, right?
- 1:03:39So he did his job.
- 1:03:41He invested capital.
- 1:03:42He can charge kind of whatever he wants
- 1:03:44and then it's up to people to either buy it
- 1:03:46or do something on their own.
- 1:03:47But there's not a lot of people
- 1:03:49who know what they're doing
- 1:03:50when it comes to energy.
- 1:03:51So definitely a other player
- 1:03:53would be helpful.
- 1:03:56So a healthy competition would work.
- 1:03:59So I believe Prospera can step in this game.
- 1:04:01And I think they are thinking heavily
- 1:04:04about doing something like that.
- 1:04:05You've been living here on and off
- 1:04:07for quite a long time now.
- 1:04:09So give me your opinion on what's going on.
- 1:04:12The timeline, how far they've got,
- 1:04:15what are the problems,
- 1:04:16what are the upside, downside?
- 1:04:18What do you think of Prospera?
- 1:04:21Obviously, you can be diplomatic if you want,
- 1:04:23but don't necessarily.
- 1:04:25I'm interested in understanding, because everyone that comes here has issues, obviously.
- 1:04:30The question is, are those issues relevant?
- 1:04:33Are they relevant?
- 1:04:35Like, obviously, complaining about the coffee shop, not too relevant.
- 1:04:38That's probably going to get sorted.
- 1:04:39But not being able to start a business because I can't do it, that's a problem.
- 1:04:44So what's your experience and what do you think the pros and cons of being here are?
- 1:04:49People are asking me this week about that, how is running a company in Prospera.
- 1:04:52and we've been running a Prospera company for four years now and used it in Ethiopia, used it in
- 1:05:00Paraguay, like many countries, and that worked brilliantly. So the infrastructure for
- 1:05:05setting up a company, and if your business even is abroad, is working brilliantly. So that's one
- 1:05:13part. Living here, so we had a Bitcoin center, right? And for us, it was more like a building,
- 1:05:19We did teaching around the island.
- 1:05:21We understood that people here are not ready for Bitcoin.
- 1:05:26A lot of them still need to solve their issues
- 1:05:28when it comes to just earning enough to save.
- 1:05:31So that is kind of like underlying issue
- 1:05:33before you ever get to Bitcoin.
- 1:05:34It's like, okay, store of value,
- 1:05:36but what if I don't have any value to store long-term?
- 1:05:38Then Bitcoin is not for me.
- 1:05:40So we did a couple of education for basic financial literacy,
- 1:05:45setting up your budgets, saving a little bit more.
- 1:05:48but it's a very long-term game, right?
- 1:05:51And the Bitcoin Center wasn't a very profitable business for us.
- 1:05:56So we couldn't figure out a proper business model
- 1:05:59that will sustain that.
- 1:06:00With Bitcoin Center, we got some business to our data centers,
- 1:06:03to our OTC services that we do on top of Bitcoin.
- 1:06:06So that kind of paid for itself.
- 1:06:08But when it comes to business and sustainability,
- 1:06:11we couldn't figure out a proper way
- 1:06:13how to make the Bitcoin center long-term sustainable, right?
- 1:06:18So there will be some restructuring right now.
- 1:06:20There'll be more like a business center in the building.
- 1:06:23It's going to be expanded.
- 1:06:24It's going to be rebuilt a little bit.
- 1:06:25So I'm pretty excited for that.
- 1:06:28And you're doing that as yourselves,
- 1:06:30or is that Prospera doing that?
- 1:06:31That's more Prospera doing that.
- 1:06:32Yeah, we will be partners in that
- 1:06:33and we'll take care of the Bitcoin part in it,
- 1:06:35but it will not be only Bitcoin center
- 1:06:38in that building anymore.
- 1:06:40Yeah, and talk to me about
- 1:06:43the problems you see here in things like that.
- 1:06:47I mean, obviously, in your case, it's a specialist thing.
- 1:06:51I mean, obviously, I don't know many Bitcoin centers
- 1:06:53that make money.
- 1:06:54I don't know.
- 1:06:55I mean, just thinking it through, let alone on Roatan.
- 1:06:58But like you say, it's more like it was a shop front
- 1:07:01and you were selling online, if you see what I mean.
- 1:07:03Like I know people with bookshops
- 1:07:04that sell all their books online,
- 1:07:06but they've still got a shop window, you know.
- 1:07:08Yes, it was very similar to that.
- 1:07:10It was very similar.
- 1:07:10And my background is in teaching,
- 1:07:12So I love doing the teaching in person and I did it in schools here.
- 1:07:16So I love what we are doing here and that will continue.
- 1:07:18That education part will still be on the island.
- 1:07:21Even though the Bitcoin center as a building will be reformed, we'll still continue that.
- 1:07:26The challenges I faced here, I think I realized it more when I was in Canada.
- 1:07:31And I saw that competency there of people that know what they do extremely proficient in their field keeping their words like the reliability and competency And I saw the contracts to
- 1:07:47I would globally call maybe Central America,
- 1:07:49where I had hard times to establishing
- 1:07:52proper contracts or proper agreements.
- 1:07:57With Prospera, so much better.
- 1:07:59Of course, I would say it's a bubble
- 1:08:01inside of Central America
- 1:08:03that works so much better.
- 1:08:05but still there were a couple of issues.
- 1:08:07And one of them is, I think,
- 1:08:09Prospera is doing a lot of things on so many fronts.
- 1:08:11And it must be super challenging, you know,
- 1:08:14dealing with the government and solving that thing,
- 1:08:16then building the infrastructure
- 1:08:18and doing things on the mainland, right?
- 1:08:19So there's so many moving parts
- 1:08:22that sometimes, you know,
- 1:08:23things were not properly, you know,
- 1:08:26closed or agreed on and stuff like that.
- 1:08:29So I would put it more on the shoulders
- 1:08:34of doing a lot of things at the same time
- 1:08:37and still putting right people in the right seats.
- 1:08:40And that is a process that it takes more time.
- 1:08:42It is getting so much better,
- 1:08:44but there is still a process, right?
- 1:08:47On the broader Roatan, yeah,
- 1:08:49I had these issues of people, you know,
- 1:08:52not keeping their words or getting,
- 1:08:55like having a hard time to engage the community,
- 1:08:58making them care.
- 1:09:00I see a lot of people like kind of addicted
- 1:09:01to TikToks and phones a lot here.
- 1:09:03So to make them learn something and spend time learning, they're like, no, this is not for me.
- 1:09:10I already did my school.
- 1:09:11I don't need it anymore.
- 1:09:11So I don't want to, like, generalize it by a culture.
- 1:09:18But this was something I was experiencing myself for the first time.
- 1:09:21That could be island life as well.
- 1:09:22Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:09:23Islands don't inspire you to go out there and change the world.
- 1:09:27Yeah, and I should maybe learn a lot from them how to rest and chill and just be more chilled out.
- 1:09:32So that's maybe feedback to me as well.
- 1:09:35What do you think Prosper's biggest challenges are at the moment then?
- 1:09:38Because I haven't dug deep enough, but I don't know how many,
- 1:09:43I know they're getting new businesses for sure,
- 1:09:47but I think probably a lot of that is people digitizing here and stuff.
- 1:09:53Because what you don't see a lot of are small businesses arising.
- 1:09:58I'm just going to juxtapose it against Morazan, where you can start a business in your front room, and people are.
- 1:10:06There's lots of little businesses.
- 1:10:08The market is wide open for those kind of things.
- 1:10:10You don't get the sense that that's going on here.
- 1:10:13Yeah, I think one of the reasons Morazan is in a very dangerous neighborhood.
- 1:10:18So for them, the very proposition of moving to a place that is safe is a huge thing, right?
- 1:10:25I feel people coming to Roatan.
- 1:10:27Roatan is already a safe place.
- 1:10:30It's beautiful, so you can set up anywhere.
- 1:10:33I think the challenge of Prospera right now
- 1:10:35is to kind of getting all those required agreements
- 1:10:39and approvals by the government as well
- 1:10:41that are by the constitution.
- 1:10:43So that is taking longer than we all expected
- 1:10:45because the government changed in November.
- 1:10:48And we're like, okay, it's going to take a few months
- 1:10:50to replace people and then it's going to be there.
- 1:10:52And I know it's on track.
- 1:10:54I know it should be soon, but I don't know when the soon is.
- 1:10:56and this is kind of not helping to attract a lot of new investors and businesses and when the
- 1:11:03business come and want to be set up locally if it's somebody from let's say from Europe or US
- 1:11:08it's a different culture you need to get get used to how it works here right like the supply chain
- 1:11:14even the prices are kind of high on Rotten Rotten is not a cheap island right so it takes you time
- 1:11:20to just establish yourself so I think the businesses that would mostly thrive here would be
- 1:11:25local businesses from people that live here locally and they know all the conditions
- 1:11:29and they can get all the benefits of easy bureaucracy and ease of doing business inside
- 1:11:34of Prospera. But what I feel here like Prospera still misses density, misses a lot of people kind
- 1:11:41of staying, being here, which again, all of this and what I'm saying is being worked on. And I see
- 1:11:47it my first time because I am here, but it takes kind of longer than a lot of people would love to
- 1:11:51it to take, right?
- 1:11:53So, yeah, the challenge
- 1:11:55with the government to sort it out,
- 1:11:57I'm sure this year it will be done.
- 1:11:59And then I think a new flock of capital
- 1:12:02investors will come.
- 1:12:03And then just, yeah, increasing the density.
- 1:12:06There are projects coming up here,
- 1:12:07so Darien Village should help tremendously in that.
- 1:12:10Bring people in, you know, Duna is here.
- 1:12:13So, but you need, yeah,
- 1:12:16you cannot only rely on digital nomads
- 1:12:19or like people who live digitally
- 1:12:20because they come and go.
- 1:12:21If something like, oh, the sand flies are bothering me here,
- 1:12:24then I move somewhere else.
- 1:12:25Or some little thing bothers me, then I move out.
- 1:12:29If you focus on these people,
- 1:12:31I don't think you can build a sustainable city.
- 1:12:35I keep telling and I think that, again,
- 1:12:38it's going in the direction that Prospera should focus also on families.
- 1:12:43Somebody would already have a kid.
- 1:12:44And I love that Eric's new vision for St. John's Bay,
- 1:12:47as the place where we are right now,
- 1:12:49is to focus on young families where at least one of the parents is an entrepreneur And I think that super crucial but for that in order to attract them you need to resolve walkability you need to
- 1:13:00resolve access to groceries and like all of that things that my I think what would best help
- 1:13:08is to figure out the project where you bring let's say 10 families at the same time here
- 1:13:15and kind of screen them before. So they are like, let's say they love homeschooling.
- 1:13:21They are entrepreneurial. They love taking risks. They love to be in this environment.
- 1:13:26And if you properly screen them and offer them an incentive, like, hey, if you stay five years,
- 1:13:31you can buy this house for $100,000 that normally market value would be 400.
- 1:13:37You get it for 100,000. And in five years, you can, let's say, buy it back or something like that,
- 1:13:42or sell it later if you want.
- 1:13:44But committing for, let's say, five years
- 1:13:45and 10 families at the same time
- 1:13:48that ideally maybe you can do
- 1:13:49a little team building for them before
- 1:13:51so they know each other
- 1:13:52and they're kind of excited
- 1:13:53because their kids already play some games online
- 1:13:55and they're like, yeah, I want to meet you in real life.
- 1:13:58And if you bring it at the same time,
- 1:14:00I think that can create this substrate,
- 1:14:02this mycelium that will,
- 1:14:04based on that you can build everything.
- 1:14:05I saw over the last four years,
- 1:14:07families coming and leaving
- 1:14:08and they came here like, wow,
- 1:14:09I want to be here at least a year.
- 1:14:11and after a few months they left because they're like,
- 1:14:13I didn't find kind of my family's here.
- 1:14:16And I saw many of them coming, going.
- 1:14:17If all of them came at the same time, they would stay.
- 1:14:21And this is, I think, what would benefit tremendously
- 1:14:25is like bringing them at the same time,
- 1:14:26offering them a cheap place,
- 1:14:30like large enough for a family to grow,
- 1:14:33figure out some walkability, like a district for families.
- 1:14:36and yeah, I think that would be a tremendous value
- 1:14:42based on which you can build everything else.
- 1:14:45It's about getting the sort of population
- 1:14:50over a little hump, isn't it?
- 1:14:51Because it's like a catch-22.
- 1:14:53You can't, like a grocery store
- 1:14:55is not going to come in with no customers.
- 1:14:57Exactly.
- 1:14:58And you're right.
- 1:15:00I mean, maybe there needs to be a forcing function.
- 1:15:02Maybe.
- 1:15:03I love it.
- 1:15:04I spoke with Eric recently about this
- 1:15:06and he said that he wants to figure out some rent contracts based on revenue.
- 1:15:11So if there is low revenue, you don't pay a high rent.
- 1:15:15Because I know that Prospera has to make money.
- 1:15:18It's moral to make money and make profit.
- 1:15:20But if you bring in a business that was like, I love Prospera, I want to try it out.
- 1:15:25You bring them, you give them a rent that is kind of market rate, but maybe slightly lower.
- 1:15:30And, you know, they're not making money for something.
- 1:15:31And suddenly it starts to be like, I still have the vision, but I need to pay myself.
- 1:15:35I need to survive.
- 1:15:37And then it starts to be a struggle.
- 1:15:38But instead, if Prospera is willing to be like,
- 1:15:41okay, for us to build a density,
- 1:15:43we're willing to give you a rent
- 1:15:44that's really based on revenue.
- 1:15:45So if you're not making money,
- 1:15:47we'll not be charging you heavily
- 1:15:48and we are taking the risk side of this.
- 1:15:51I think that's a right play to go with.
- 1:15:54And I think if Prospera decides to go heavily this way,
- 1:15:58a lot more businesses would come,
- 1:15:59even the local ones that can wait longer
- 1:16:03for density to build.
- 1:16:04And then you're kind of deleting the catch-22 because, oh, the infrastructure here is here.
- 1:16:09So families can come, people stay longer, and then more businesses will justify.
- 1:16:13Prospera earns more because the revenues are higher.
- 1:16:16So I think this is a model that would be more suitable for Prospera right now.
- 1:16:23And again, I heard from Eric that they want to do it.
- 1:16:25So I think that's the right play to go with.
- 1:16:27My view would be whatever it takes to bring in small businesses.
- 1:16:33not necessarily i i don't know a huge amount about the other you know the businesses using
- 1:16:38the regulatory environment that's that's one thing it's the businesses on the ground the the
- 1:16:44corner shop the even the even a couple of bars a couple of restaurants you know stuff like that
- 1:16:51is is what this place obviously lacks obviously everyone would say that when they come in i mean
- 1:16:57there are other things and this and that and the other but and i haven't spent much time over the
- 1:17:01other side actually but um but yeah that's that's what it needs and it it feels like there's a
- 1:17:07there's a hump that you need to get over there's like a point of no return there's a there's a kind
- 1:17:13of like critical mass critical mass yeah there is and i think like i don't have um a rule book for
- 1:17:19it i don't have like the manual i don't know what prosper is trying multiple things um but yeah you
- 1:17:24need to iterate you need to like i try this doesn't work i iterate again again so 100 like
- 1:17:31if you want to build a city, you need people to like it here. You need people to have what they
- 1:17:35need here, right? School is great already. So that's, I would say, sorted. When families come,
- 1:17:40like the school is doing great and it's expanding. So if you bring your kids, you have a place to
- 1:17:45have them around. I love that Prospera built these little playgrounds for the kids,
- 1:17:50kind of a little park that you can walk around, you can spend some time. That's a great step.
- 1:17:55So all these amenities that not necessarily make money immediately or use some land to kind of
- 1:17:59bring in more infrastructure just to enjoy and have a good time But that is one thing that subjectively make people be like okay I feel good here I okay I sustain myself I can play some sports I can buy what I need I don need
- 1:18:12to travel too much. Internet is good. I can work from here. And once you have that, then it's very
- 1:18:18hard to say no to Roatan. You know, it's like, then the scent flies thing is a thing, you know,
- 1:18:23it's for newcomers who come. And I hate to see that even during the conference, when I see these
- 1:18:28red dots on people and I asked him like what about a safe out there like yeah it's it's crazy
- 1:18:32when you when you stay here longer after two three months your body get used to it and it doesn't
- 1:18:38bother you because your body develops some kind of antidote for it but for the newcomers
- 1:18:41everybody reacts differently but it's pretty annoying so kind of it's all it's also a
- 1:18:46a bump you need to sort somehow or some people just go through it because they're like yeah
- 1:18:51whatever I'm here for the vision for the business I will just make myself but if your kid is crying
- 1:18:57because their sand flies' bites are all over their body,
- 1:19:01you're like, you know, I don't know.
- 1:19:03Is that all over the island or is that just in some bays?
- 1:19:07Pretty much.
- 1:19:08Pretty much all over the island.
- 1:19:09It's actually in multiple islands in Caribbean too,
- 1:19:11so Puerto Rico has the same issue.
- 1:19:14You can sort it chemically,
- 1:19:15which is not the most good for the environment, I would say.
- 1:19:19Maybe there are some different things sorted out,
- 1:19:22But my solution was just to exposure strategy.
- 1:19:27So I got bitten many times.
- 1:19:29And then my body is like in 5, 10, 15 minutes, the bits are gone.
- 1:19:34And that's it.
- 1:19:34It's been annoying in the beginning, but I don't care about it anymore.
- 1:19:39But it takes time.
- 1:19:40And not so many people are willing to go over that.
- 1:19:43Especially if they're coming from one week or something.
- 1:19:46Do you think there's a bit of tension between the vision of the founders
- 1:19:51and the vision of the free market here?
- 1:19:54Because it's something I thought of.
- 1:19:56I thought that,
- 1:19:58I know that those guys have got a big vision of here
- 1:20:02and the one on the mainland
- 1:20:03and all this kind of stuff.
- 1:20:04100%.
- 1:20:05And it feels like the free market isn't working here.
- 1:20:09And the reason I'm saying that is because
- 1:20:11I think everyone I speak to says,
- 1:20:14wouldn't it be nice
- 1:20:14if there was a little shack down on the beach?
- 1:20:16You know what I mean?
- 1:20:17Like, you know what I mean?
- 1:20:18So obviously that will be a good thing.
- 1:20:22You know, that's the free market talking, you know, or another or a better third space, a better place where you could just go that is open more or it's just, you know, not.
- 1:20:33It feels like there's gaps in the market that aren't being filled.
- 1:20:38So is that because why is that?
- 1:20:41i think we named it before and it's the a business will not set up a shack on the beach if there's not
- 1:20:48so many people that will visit that will just go and pay so we accept though that's a that's a
- 1:20:53pretty simple and cheap thing to do this is what i mean like i get the sense that probably the vision
- 1:20:59for prosper is a nice beach bar but actually what what's cheap like if you go to lots of central
- 1:21:06america they'll be like thatched huts cheap beers nice honest food ready to go and if you look at
- 1:21:13the actual um underlying cost of that it's not a lot is it really so that that way you don't need
- 1:21:20to be rammed full every night you just need one or two guys coming down there every you know and
- 1:21:25and you're you're covering your costs and making a bit of money you know but but i i get the sense
- 1:21:29the vision might be no we want a lovely you know something that costs a lot of money you know what
- 1:21:35Yes, yes, I agree with that.
- 1:21:37I think, and especially with Pristine Bay being kind of a very high-end resort,
- 1:21:41to maintain that level of quality in this environment,
- 1:21:45I think it's expensive and it takes a lot of energy and effort and commitments.
- 1:21:51So then Prospera needs to spend kind of a lot of money to maintain it.
- 1:21:56If you want to open something that's kind of just a few shacks,
- 1:22:00maybe Prospera doesn't want that to be there
- 1:22:02because that would kind of destroy the visuality.
- 1:22:05But then it's a gap between like,
- 1:22:07oh, then that little entrepreneur will not do it
- 1:22:09because he's disincentivized to do it
- 1:22:12because he doesn't have money to build it as beautiful.
- 1:22:16But also because say you're building a very high-end place,
- 1:22:24which you could argue Prosper is a high-end place,
- 1:22:26not necessarily like top of the pile.
- 1:22:28but with high-end places people expect the best and for example sand flies might not be on their
- 1:22:36list no but seriously you know if you if you're expecting the best if the regulatory environment's
- 1:22:42not super important to you you'll go somewhere where there aren't sand flies because there are
- 1:22:46so many lovely places you can live on the beach without sand flies yes so i you know it's a it's
- 1:22:52a very weird equilibrium
- 1:22:54and I sense
- 1:22:56there's a bit of tension between
- 1:22:58the sort of long term
- 1:23:00vision and what's actually
- 1:23:02evolving out
- 1:23:04of the free market in a decentralized
- 1:23:06way you know. I agree with that
- 1:23:08and I think a very like a good example
- 1:23:10for me for a business that
- 1:23:12found that
- 1:23:13merge between the quality
- 1:23:16and the roughness on the island
- 1:23:18it's Roatan Brewery
- 1:23:19I don't know if you've visited.
- 1:23:21I haven't, but I know all about it.
- 1:23:22You told me about it.
- 1:23:23You have to go there.
- 1:23:25It's not so far away from here.
- 1:23:28It's a place where you really,
- 1:23:29you don't expect that like high-end beauty
- 1:23:31and crispy clean thing
- 1:23:33because it's a brewery.
- 1:23:35It's in the middle of the jungle
- 1:23:36and it's rough.
- 1:23:38Wooden tables,
- 1:23:39kind of not everything super clean.
- 1:23:41But if you have it that way,
- 1:23:44you don't need to invest extremely heavily
- 1:23:46to kind of keep everything tidy.
- 1:23:48and then the guys like people are coming they have a good time the the food is great the the
- 1:23:54beer is great so they focus on like delivering good quality of the product while the place is
- 1:24:00kind of rough but they are super busy like that place is on fire they have cruise ships coming in
- 1:24:06they have the whole program the beer tours um so the guy one of the best entrepreneurs on the
- 1:24:12island i met ilias he's the founder of the brewery he's a greek canadian guy builder
- 1:24:18engineer, like extremely, extremely handyman. And he nailed it. He's a great businessman. And
- 1:24:25I think that's something that naturally converged the mixture between what Rotten has to offer,
- 1:24:32how it fits to the whole nature, the good ratio between the quality and the roughness of it.
- 1:24:39So that is, I think, what I see is working on the island pretty well. And places similar to that
- 1:24:45with the vibe are kind of booming.
- 1:24:50So I don't necessarily say that that's what Prospera should aim for.
- 1:24:54But yes, if Prospera wants to be very high in place,
- 1:24:57there will be challenges with the free market
- 1:24:58that maybe it's very hard to attract people, right?
- 1:25:01So I don't have a playbook for that.
- 1:25:03I suppose one of the ways of looking at it could be that
- 1:25:08Prospera is renowned for a lot of built upon the back
- 1:25:13of the fact that you have this regulatory autonomy here which is great for businesses but not as
- 1:25:19important for small businesses really yes i mean it's not that's not that's not going to attract
- 1:25:25them what's going to attract them is you know like enough people to make their business profitable
- 1:25:31and that in turn is a function of how much rent they pay how how much their building costs and
- 1:25:37how many people are here yes and those are things which are almost nothing to do with
- 1:25:41you know all this what makes what makes prosper unique like you say what makes the brewery unique
- 1:25:48is just it's a cracking business model that really works it could be anywhere it could be in prosper
- 1:25:53it could be up there in the hill or whatever it doesn't really matter what matters is the business
- 1:25:58i mean you know they've got obviously power here to to decide how much things cost yeah you know
- 1:26:05But it is. It's a very, very interesting and weird dynamic of opposing, sometimes it seems, forces, which are all trying to sort of work.
- 1:26:18Yes. One thing that also sadly is not helping, but it's hard to uproot it or outroot it is
- 1:26:26the socialists created a lot of marketing against prosper over time. And every time,
- 1:26:33like when I saw these documentaries, like all these billionaires are building their
- 1:26:37enclave on the island and all of it. So it's like a lot of people just fall into these agendas and
- 1:26:43fall into this marketing. It's very hard to show them that it's different. And people on the island,
- 1:26:48like we felt it with our education efforts when we were going around businesses and schools
- 1:26:54they are afraid of Prospera they are kind of seeing like oh they're going to steal our land
- 1:26:59of course but they don't have any proof of that but they just heard it and they're afraid and
- 1:27:02they don't want to like try it out and give it a try and it's very hard to break that cycle break
- 1:27:08that marketing cycle that the socialists did I think the only way to break that is that keep on
- 1:27:14ongoing and showing like, hey, we're not stealing anybody's land.
- 1:27:17We're offering a lot of opportunities.
- 1:27:19Crawfish Rock is the village next door.
- 1:27:21A lot of people are working here.
- 1:27:22I spoke with them. They're extremely happy.
- 1:27:24They're getting paid more than they would be getting paid anywhere else.
- 1:27:28Salary on time, you know.
- 1:27:31So but even if you tell these case studies, even if they tell their neighbors,
- 1:27:37their neighbors are like afraid or I know that some of them are paid by
- 1:27:42the previous government that it's tried to kind of keep it in place. So there's a lot of weird
- 1:27:50dynamics where there are still forces that they want that want Prospera not to succeed.
- 1:27:54And sadly, people don't have time to just look deeper or spend some time really researching that.
- 1:28:00So they just fall for the first information they got. And then it's kind of having a hard time to
- 1:28:06build something. So actually, one example from our case is that we renovated the only sport arena on
- 1:28:14the island. We crowdfunded $20,000 for it. That was the basketball. Yes. The Bitcoin arena. Exactly.
- 1:28:21Bitcoin arena. So if you go to a map and you put Bitcoin arena, you'll find it on Google Maps.
- 1:28:25It was in a very bad condition It was very rough Nobody cared about that So we spoke with the school with the coach they were like yes let do it uh and they said yeah municipality will not care because they don care about us
- 1:28:39for decades so we did that crowdfunding 20 000 fixed the bathrooms build the the cloak rooms
- 1:28:46repainted everything and we put a bitcoin logo in the middle of the court and suddenly after a few
- 1:28:51days they came to us like no the bitcoin logo needs to go who the the municipal yeah the
- 1:28:57municipality the lorota municipality and we're like guys like nobody said thank you for investing
- 1:29:03our own money and community bitcoiners donating and and doing all the work nobody said thank you
- 1:29:10for that the main topic was there is a bitcoin logo it needs to go away so they repainted that
- 1:29:16Did they?
- 1:29:16Yes.
- 1:29:17Yes, they repainted it.
- 1:29:18They actually did something.
- 1:29:21Crazy, right?
- 1:29:22And they sent the guy who actually, the guy who should have repainted it was like, guys, I like Bitcoin.
- 1:29:27I have Bitcoin on my own, but I was told that I need to repaint this.
- 1:29:30And I was trying to get meeting with the mayor, like, hey, what's going on?
- 1:29:34Like, are you against freedom?
- 1:29:37Are you, like, what's the issue?
- 1:29:38And the situation is like, there is some tension between them and Prospera.
- 1:29:43They feel like Prospera should pay them taxes.
- 1:29:46And it's not the case.
- 1:29:47Prosper is its own municipality.
- 1:29:50It's by its constitution.
- 1:29:51Well, the government should distribute the taxes.
- 1:29:53Yes, exactly.
- 1:29:54More to the point.
- 1:29:55Exactly.
- 1:29:55And the current government, or in general, Tegucigalpa, the main government,
- 1:30:01is taking a lot of money from Roatan in general, and it's been for decades like that,
- 1:30:05and not returning a lot of back.
- 1:30:07So people in Roatan are normally fed up with that.
- 1:30:11They're angry on that.
- 1:30:12But they should point their anger to the government and telling them,
- 1:30:15hey, keep the money we create here on the island.
- 1:30:18Don't take that much.
- 1:30:19So I think, my personal view is that municipalities
- 1:30:21should focus their attention to the government
- 1:30:25instead of telling Prospera,
- 1:30:26oh, you should pay taxes to us.
- 1:30:28And I asked actually one of their employees,
- 1:30:31like, so you're using the roads on the east as well?
- 1:30:34And she said, yeah.
- 1:30:35Are you paying taxes to that government?
- 1:30:37No.
- 1:30:38To that municipality?
- 1:30:38No.
- 1:30:39Then there's the same as with Prospera.
- 1:30:41It's its own kind of municipality.
- 1:30:43the businesses there are paying taxes to Prospera
- 1:30:47Prospera pays to the government
- 1:30:49but it's always their hate is towards Prospera
- 1:30:53and we felt it first hand
- 1:30:56when we interacted with some businesses
- 1:30:59then they were like
- 1:31:00I don't know I shouldn't accept Bitcoin
- 1:31:03because the municipality doesn't like it very much
- 1:31:05so it's very hard to operate an environment
- 1:31:09that doesn't want you
- 1:31:10But they are basically connecting Bitcoin with Prospera.
- 1:31:15They do a lot.
- 1:31:16Yes, yes.
- 1:31:17They said Bitcoin is Prospera.
- 1:31:18And we try to tell them, no, it's two different things.
- 1:31:21And you should look at them separately.
- 1:31:23And I think both of them are great for society and prosperity.
- 1:31:27But they put it into one basket.
- 1:31:29So it's very hard for us to do the education because they're like, yeah, Bitcoin is not good.
- 1:31:36And I try to have so many meetings with the mayor.
- 1:31:38they always like refused or rescheduled
- 1:31:41they cancelled the meeting
- 1:31:42so I want to have a discussion
- 1:31:44but they somehow don't want to have a discussion
- 1:31:47Are they political at the local level?
- 1:31:49Ah yes
- 1:31:49And what are they here?
- 1:31:51Well I don't think as far as I know
- 1:31:54again my own personal views
- 1:31:56I don't think they are with the national party
- 1:31:59that is right now in the power
- 1:32:02I think they are not directly Libre
- 1:32:04which are the socialists
- 1:32:05but I think it's the liberal party
- 1:32:07as far as I know
- 1:32:08but somehow there is tension and I don't see inside very clearly.
- 1:32:14But one thing that also interests me and surprises me is that Crawfish Rock,
- 1:32:19you know, that the whole debate and a lot of hate to Prospera came because of the Crawfish Rock.
- 1:32:25Crawfish Rock has its own patronato, which is kind of the local little village government.
- 1:32:32The deal is that every two years there should be an election of that patronato.
- 1:32:37This one in Crawfish Road hasn't been elected for the last five years.
- 1:32:41A lot of people demanded, hey, we want a new election.
- 1:32:44That's what we should do.
- 1:32:45It's not like we want a patronato that is for Prospera.
- 1:32:48We just want a fair election.
- 1:32:50And the municipality of Roatan,
- 1:32:53they are the ones deciding that election to happen or not.
- 1:32:56They're kind of like not caring because something,
- 1:32:59again, I may be conspiring,
- 1:33:01but something works in their favor
- 1:33:03because the current patronato is very against Prospera.
- 1:33:06They are forbidding people to work for Prospera.
- 1:33:08There is really rough.
- 1:33:10If you speak to people in Crawfish Rock,
- 1:33:12they can tell you a bunch of deep stories
- 1:33:14about how Patronado is preventing them
- 1:33:18to choose where they can work,
- 1:33:20how they can live their lives,
- 1:33:22who they can sell their land to, their private land.
- 1:33:25So why there was no election for the last five years?
- 1:33:28But, I mean, that's obviously not working
- 1:33:30because people from Crawfish Rock work here, I know.
- 1:33:33Yes, yes, but there was a lot of threats being done.
- 1:33:35I know first hands from multiple people.
- 1:33:37So it 100 not supported by the Patronado And yeah That work itself out It rough That will obviously work itself out over time There obviously are some detractors in Crawfish Rock
- 1:33:53We know that.
- 1:33:54But as far as you can tell, it's a minority.
- 1:33:57It is.
- 1:33:58It is.
- 1:33:59And I just wanted to put on the table a couple of forces that doesn't help Prospera,
- 1:34:04although they want to do the best and they are doing their best.
- 1:34:07you're still finding the perception that is super hard to change and once people adopt some idea like
- 1:34:13that it's extremely difficult to uproot it and show them like no the reality is here so that is
- 1:34:20coming back to the original question what's the challenge i think this is a big challenge and it's
- 1:34:25very hard to resolve and i don't i don't have like the steps to do it but well do you know what
- 1:34:31That's an important lesson because, you know, for other people creating these kind of projects, PR should be something you think about from the word go.
- 1:34:43And actually, one of the conclusions that I know some of the companies I work with have come up with is that you keep quiet for the first amount of time.
- 1:34:52You don't publicize hugely what you're doing, but you take control right from the start.
- 1:34:58But really, you don't need to go on about it too much in the beginning.
- 1:35:01A lot of people like to present,
- 1:35:03ah, here we go, this is a new thing.
- 1:35:06But really, PR should be on your radar all the time.
- 1:35:12And being on it,
- 1:35:13I know Prosper are much more on it now.
- 1:35:16When something happens,
- 1:35:17they'll send a legal document to someone saying,
- 1:35:20this is incorrect, right?
- 1:35:21You've got five days to respond.
- 1:35:22If you don't, you're being sued.
- 1:35:23And of course, then they retract and stuff like that.
- 1:35:25But I think that should be a practice from the word go.
- 1:35:29So, you know.
- 1:35:30Should be and shouldn't in a way.
- 1:35:32Like, if you as a businessman, and I take Prospera as a business as well,
- 1:35:38if you are really forced to do PR, it's kind of like you would like your work
- 1:35:44and the proof of work to be your PR, right?
- 1:35:47That would be the ideal case.
- 1:35:48But sadly, we're operating in a way where you have to do the PR,
- 1:35:52which kind of defies the purpose in a way.
- 1:35:56in but prosper has to put has to put a fence around itself in a way you know like like here
- 1:36:04for example um when you know in beta district when you come in there's like a gate and you go
- 1:36:09through and blah blah blah you know that's a kind of necessary thing to do but that creates a terrible
- 1:36:15pr disaster if you're not careful yeah because if you're a local and you're driving along on your
- 1:36:21scooter and you see that i know what that would signal to me it's not inviting no no it is not
- 1:36:27inviting but you also need to do that as well you know because it's a different boundary it's a
- 1:36:32different jurisdiction in a way so yes exactly you have these things that doesn't help with the pr
- 1:36:37but you have to do it to be you know um compatible with with the law and with everything so how to
- 1:36:46bridge dead well the the the big the big um the winds that have happened the big winds that have
- 1:36:54happened have always been non-mainstream sort of journalists or inquirers coming here yes and
- 1:37:02honestly it's looking at it because it's true what you say you know the truth is in the pudding it's
- 1:37:08it it's a it what's going on here is productive more than it's not productive so it's like
- 1:37:13and and it's quite easy to see that and actually one of the things i mean i mentioned this in my
- 1:37:18talk at the conference but the a lot of these negative articles now are actually turning into
- 1:37:25positives for prosper because they are reporting on what's going on here yes and and and that's
- 1:37:32you know sure if you if you're a socialist and you read that you'll be like oh my god that's terrible
- 1:37:36but if you're not you'll look at that and go that's interesting that sounds like a quite an
- 1:37:40interesting thing because they're they're not necessarily spreading complete lies they are
- 1:37:46showing that this is um you know what what's happening here is a is an experiment in governance
- 1:37:51and experiment in regulatory powers and all this kind of stuff and and a lot of people tune into
- 1:37:57that and go yeah that sounds good so but i would still say that that being on top of your pr
- 1:38:03that's been the lesson for me because i've watched like you i've watched it for a number of years now
- 1:38:08and i even did some i i did a deep dive with the data and looked at what what the changes in
- 1:38:14positive versus negative articles were um over the years and it's getting better well now
- 1:38:20it's 50 in the but you need to define this western press and the spanish speaking
- 1:38:24western press is 50 50 now spanish speaking is almost zero to 100
- 1:38:30against like against yeah yeah yeah wow as in it's still all negative like if you look at
- 1:38:37Or it's still all negative?
- 1:38:38Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:38:39Wow, okay.
- 1:38:40You said opposite.
- 1:38:41No, no, no.
- 1:38:41I'd be surprised.
- 1:38:42No, but I think English speaking is doing all right.
- 1:38:49You know, it was teetering around 50-50,
- 1:38:51and then you get now if you look it depends which part of the year you look at or stuff you starting to get 65 to 35 in favor But if you go to Spanish speaking articles this is just Mike Lanker having a good deep dive on it
- 1:39:04So, you know, it's not in depth.
- 1:39:07It's just looking at the surface.
- 1:39:08But if you take Spanish speaking headlines and you look at it, it's mainly almost exclusively negative.
- 1:39:14Negative.
- 1:39:15Yeah.
- 1:39:16Yeah.
- 1:39:17That's rough.
- 1:39:18I don't know if it's because of potentially people being more socialist or they kind of are afraid of neocolonialism.
- 1:39:27No, no, it's the press. It's the journalists.
- 1:39:33So they must have some agenda then.
- 1:39:35Well, they did previously. They don't now.
- 1:39:38But everything I think that the Spanish-speaking world knows about Prospera, especially if you're talking about Central America,
- 1:39:46came from the former government who basically they did use prosper as a political punch box
- 1:39:53exactly bag it's easy it's obvious if you know anything about politics you know find an enemy if
- 1:39:58you can pick if you can pick something and then rally against it you can really you know get get
- 1:40:03people to join your team and that's basically one of the things because there's no reason to
- 1:40:08necessarily rally against prosper and i've got a feeling i had a conversation with a few years ago
- 1:40:15about how it even started and it was a silly little discrepancy that caused a bit of a riff
- 1:40:21and then someone in the government made it an issue and then they realized oh shit we can turn
- 1:40:27this into something and then it was just like every now and then let's bring out the prosper
- 1:40:31issue again and and generate yeah we're we're going to protect you from these evil colonizers
- 1:40:37who are going to steal your land all that stealing of the land stuff which if you if you just take
- 1:40:42five minutes to look even at how the whole place is set up you know it's not possible to go and
- 1:40:49steal land yes and in fact who the people that actually steal land is the government exactly
- 1:40:55they'll steal your land yes they'll if they want to build a pipeline through your back garden they'll
- 1:40:59be able to steal your land prosper can't steal your land you know so yeah i don't know just it
- 1:41:04does make me a bit angry but it is the reality of the world we live in and you know people do
- 1:41:11hear gossip
- 1:41:13and just stick with it
- 1:41:15and don't try and work it out.
- 1:41:17But I think over the long term
- 1:41:18it will sort itself out.
- 1:41:20I believe so.
- 1:41:20Like I'm a believer
- 1:41:21that the truth will win over time.
- 1:41:23It just takes longer
- 1:41:24than anybody expected
- 1:41:26in post-prow
- 1:41:27or maybe from the businesses
- 1:41:28that should have been resolved sooner.
- 1:41:31But yeah,
- 1:41:32you're fighting against
- 1:41:33all this propaganda
- 1:41:34that piled up over the last years.
- 1:41:37And, you know,
- 1:41:38the damage control
- 1:41:39is much harder to do
- 1:41:40then to create the damage.
- 1:41:42So that's the reality check we are at.
- 1:41:47And yeah, I think the best thing we can do
- 1:41:48is like keep on building,
- 1:41:49keep on figuring out,
- 1:41:51iterating what works, what doesn't work,
- 1:41:53how to make sure the free market,
- 1:41:55you know, goes in favor of the goals of Prospera as well,
- 1:41:59like how to integrate small businesses.
- 1:42:00And yeah, that's, I think, the only way how we can win.
- 1:42:05I think that's a good place to end, I think.
- 1:42:08Thank you, Dushan.
- 1:42:09lovely to see you again enjoyed last night thanks for your hosting a party last night for the bitcoin
- 1:42:15center that was cool i managed to get i was like an hour and a half i spent up there it's the only
- 1:42:19evening event i've been to because well i finished at six yesterday and i thought right i'm going to
- 1:42:24get up there so and it was great it was great to see everyone and just just it was great to just
- 1:42:28be able to play with a qr code oh yeah with a bitcoin wallet you know 100% really did you have
- 1:42:33a steak yesterday yes i did yeah of course perfect i had the buffet oh it's lovely um and and yeah
- 1:42:39and really good luck and i genuinely mean that especially if you end up with a power company
- 1:42:44here that would be absolutely the most awesome turn of events grand cycle that would be so cool
- 1:42:53man it would be so cool it would be but but it sounds like you're probably going to spend the
- 1:42:57next few years learning about how to run an energy company shit dude bring it back here
- 1:43:03do you know what I mean?
- 1:43:04I will work on that
- 1:43:05I mean
- 1:43:05I'm
- 1:43:06I loved my life
- 1:43:08here
- 1:43:08I'm a sailor
- 1:43:09for 22 years
- 1:43:10so just being around water
- 1:43:11I don't have that
- 1:43:12in Calgary
- 1:43:13in Canada
- 1:43:13there's just mountains
- 1:43:15which is amazing
- 1:43:15but
- 1:43:16my soul loves
- 1:43:17to be
- 1:43:18around water
- 1:43:19and doing some sailing
- 1:43:20so
- 1:43:21maybe I come through
- 1:43:22an angle of power
- 1:43:23or doing a sailing academy
- 1:43:24here
- 1:43:24oh yeah
- 1:43:25amen to that
- 1:43:27right
- 1:43:27thanks very much indeed
- 1:43:28really enjoyed you
- 1:43:29and good luck
- 1:43:30yeah
- 1:43:30thanks a lot
- 1:43:33right you made it to the end of the show so i'm gonna go ahead and assume that you got some value
- 1:43:41out of this episode if you want to help the show please follow or subscribe right now it takes only
- 1:43:49two seconds and it massively helps if you've got another 30 seconds well leave a review on apple
- 1:43:56podcasts or spotify honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners
- 1:44:03find us if you want more you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on fountain
- 1:44:09dot fm for the price of one coffee for a whole month or you can support the mission by streaming
- 1:44:16sats on any of the value for value platforms or use the bitcoin and fiat donation links in the
- 1:44:23show notes every contribution to the show makes a real difference believe me and one more thing
- 1:44:29if you know someone who'd love this episode share it directly with them that personal share beats
- 1:44:35every algorithm in the book. All the links, the community and the newsletter are in the show notes
- 1:44:41and jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions
- 1:44:48and more. That's the new Free Cities podcast website, freecities.fm.
- 1:44:54Have a good week and see you next time.
- 1:45:05Thank you.