Latest / Film And Whiskey / How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000) / Calumet Farms Citation 16-year Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In the Millennium year of 2000, director Ron Howard and star Jim
- 0:04Carrey gave the world a satirical look at modern
- 0:07Christmas through the lens of an old classic.
- 0:11In 2024, we try a bourbon that Brad, Are you ready for this?
- 0:15Oh, I'm ready. Is a real work horse.
- 0:23The film is How The Grinch Stole Christmas.
- 0:25The whiskey is Calumet Farms citation.
- 0:29And we'll review them both this is.
- 0:32The Film and Whiskey Podcast Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:54Podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:57glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:00I'm Brad G and today I am setting the over under on Bob's
- 1:05score for this movie at 4.5. I guess it'd be 4.75 since we're
- 1:12allowed to go in half increments.
- 1:13Hey you can go whatever you want when you set the over under.
- 1:16That's that that that is true. I'm going to set it at 4.75
- 1:20folks. So if you want to take betting,
- 1:22we are now on draftkings.com each episode.
- 1:26Actually, you can just Venmo us your bet.
- 1:29Yes, there you go. We directly said odds.
- 1:32Of course, of course. So Brad, at the beginning of
- 1:35every episode, I say the phrase we review a classic movie and a
- 1:39glass of whiskey. Has that word been doing more
- 1:46heavy lifting that it is today? Because we are looking at not
- 1:50the actually classic 1960s short The Grinch.
- 1:55We're looking at Ron Howard's. I I mean, like, I don't know
- 2:00what the word is. I don't want to call it
- 2:01abominable, but I want to call it like sensory overwhelming
- 2:08experience. The the year 2000s, the Grinch.
- 2:13Did you need to go see your therapist after you saw this
- 2:15movie, Bob? Man, I'll tell you what dude,
- 2:17Let's just let's set the stage here a little bit.
- 2:19I have been dreading this for weeks, Brad, because I remember
- 2:23this movie being like a little too much, even when I was a kid.
- 2:27But because you're a kid and and I grew up on in an era of
- 2:30Nickelodeon where everybody was slimming each other and
- 2:33everything else. I just see little little 10 year
- 2:36old Bob sitting with his arms crossed like his leg crossed
- 2:41over the other tapping. Yes, yes, like it was a little
- 2:46much. I mean, I can't say you're
- 2:50wrong. I would like to say that you're
- 2:52wrong, but. Your little sisters are over
- 2:56there. Like, wow, Grinch, what a great
- 2:57movie. And you're just like ruining
- 2:59everybody's Christmas. Let let me let me get to my
- 3:03point more quickly than I intended to.
- 3:05I know I can be long winded, Brad.
- 3:07I think this is actually a really important historical
- 3:09document because I don't know that that future generations
- 3:13will be aware of like what it was like to consume media as
- 3:18children of the 90s. Like what were we being fed our
- 3:21media diet and Nickelodeon stuff?
- 3:24It was just there was so much overwhelming sensory experience.
- 3:30Everything was tangible. Everything was about getting
- 3:32slimed and the like, garish, really bright visual colors.
- 3:37And you know, I think this is like, this is born out of 1990s
- 3:44overbearing entertainment like this.
- 3:47This is just as related to Nickelodeon as it is to like
- 3:51that crappy Godzilla remake that we've been referencing from the
- 3:54late 90s. It is the culmination of 1/2
- 3:58decade of visual and auditory assaults on the senses.
- 4:04And I think that it's kind of like I want to put it in the
- 4:07museum, you know what I mean? Yeah, no, I was going to say if
- 4:10you want a shorter version than having to watch this movie, go
- 4:14on YouTube and just look up the old Sonic the Hedgehog ads for
- 4:19Sega and like, to me those are like peak 90s ridiculousness.
- 4:27Like I like, I, I, I look back on those.
- 4:29I'm like, what? What did they think that they
- 4:32were doing? Like, why?
- 4:34Like, how did that attract people?
- 4:37But I I mean it did. I guess we spent money on these
- 4:40things. We obviously spent money on How
- 4:42the Grinch Stole Christmas Bob, because this was the was it the
- 4:45highest grossing movie of 2000? Yeah, so we've been going on
- 4:48domestic gross for every movie we've reviewed this season.
- 4:51Oh, and by the way, if this is your first episode, welcome into
- 4:53film and whiskey. We usually talk about Better
- 4:56Movies TM. That's our that's our slogan.
- 4:59You you do know that if there's somebody new to this episode,
- 5:03it's probably because they like. Love this movie and I am so, so
- 5:07sorry for what's about to happen.
- 5:08Your first words to them are, we usually do better films than
- 5:13this one, The one that got your favorite movie?
- 5:16Yeah. So this season we are looking at
- 5:19high grossing films. So usually it's the highest
- 5:22grossing film from each year from 1988 to 2019.
- 5:26We have landed in the year 2000 where we are actually doing the
- 5:29highest grossing domestic film. I think it was only like sixth
- 5:32highest grossing worldwide. But people in America ate this
- 5:36up. And Brad, you're you're
- 5:38absolutely right, man. I think that if there's if this
- 5:41is really a spiritual cousin to any form of media, it's not even
- 5:45just like the TV and movies of the late 90s.
- 5:48It's the commercials. Yes.
- 5:50Yeah. And.
- 5:51And I think that like one of the most generous things I can say
- 5:54about this movie is that everything's intentional.
- 5:58Like I don't think they decided, like, I think it would look cool
- 6:01if we did this and then they just made a movie where every
- 6:04single shot is a Dutch angle. Like it's doing this on purpose.
- 6:08And if I'm putting on my thinking cap, I think it's
- 6:11because Ron Howard, a very good director, was trying on purpose
- 6:17to mimic the advertisements and commercials of the late 90s to
- 6:21help under score the point of his movie, which is anti
- 6:25commercialism. Like it, It makes sense why he
- 6:28chose to do it. He definitely made choices.
- 6:31The question is were those choices the appropriate choices
- 6:35and did they work? And Brad, I am very excited to
- 6:39hear your thoughts on that today.
- 6:41But before we get into that, it's time for our first segment
- 6:44of the day, which we call Brad explains.
- 6:47Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 6:50ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and hear your take with
- 6:54this little segment that we call.
- 6:55Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 6:58podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 7:01has just seen often for the first time.
- 7:05The $1,000,000 question Right now, Brad, Is this your first
- 7:08time with Ron Howard's Grinch? It is not.
- 7:11No. I I did not see it as a child,
- 7:14as you would have imagined. I in fact, I never even watched
- 7:19Nickelodeon. I don't know if I've ever seen
- 7:21an actual episode of of Slime Time.
- 7:24What? What was that show?
- 7:25Called Slime Time Live. Yeah, yeah.
- 7:27Yeah, never once saw a single episode of that.
- 7:31I did, however, watch this, probably in my college years.
- 7:36Oh, what am? I out of man.
- 7:38I I just want to spend the whole episode hearing about that,
- 7:41'cause that seems like if there's any age to get
- 7:44introduced to this movie, that's like the worst possible age,
- 7:48'cause you're not like, you're not old enough to have your own
- 7:50kids yet, but you weren't. You have no nostalgia for it,
- 7:53you know what I mean? Like I'm.
- 7:56Fascinated. I think it.
- 7:57I think it actually hit well in the college years because we're
- 8:01all kind of idiots when we're in college and we think that stupid
- 8:05stuff is funny. And so I remember walking away
- 8:08from it thinking like, Oh yeah, like that was pretty funny.
- 8:12I think that was my take away, like B minus maybe AC plus that
- 8:18was kind of funny. Jim Carrey is a is a unique
- 8:22talent that that probably would have been my take away.
- 8:26About four or five years later, I had a friend who it's like one
- 8:30of his favorite movies of all time.
- 8:33And so I watched it with him and enjoyed how much he enjoyed the
- 8:36film. And then I watched it for this
- 8:38viewing, Bob. You're such a good friend.
- 8:42I dude, I love my friends. I am very kind to them.
- 8:46Especially you, Bob. I was going to say in terms of
- 8:49Jim Carrey movies that Brad things are not that great.
- 8:53It does blow my mind that you gave Eternal Sunshine a 2 1/2
- 8:57out of 10 and are primed to give this movie a much higher score.
- 9:01Oh. My gosh dude.
- 9:03Easily higher than the eternal sunshine.
- 9:05I need new friends. All right, Brad, So this was not
- 9:09your first time seeing the movie, folks.
- 9:11It's the Grinch. I don't really know what there
- 9:13is to spoil here, but spoiler alert, Brad's going to break
- 9:15down the plot of the movie. You have one minute on the
- 9:18clock, Brad, and go. All right, so imagine the 1950s
- 9:25Grinch. But instead, the Grinch wants to
- 9:29bone one of the main Who's in Whoville?
- 9:34And like, that's all you really need to know, folks.
- 9:37That's the kind of movie we're watching.
- 9:40The end. Is that a good?
- 9:41Yeah, absolutely. This is just like a deeply mean,
- 9:47ugly, horny movie. And when I say ugly, like, it is
- 9:52visually very ugly movie, but it's also just like it truly
- 9:57does embody like the late 90s and the early 2000s in terms of
- 10:01what we put on screen. Like the values that we A
- 10:05pretended to have but B actually had like the objectification of
- 10:09women, the like, the weird, violent like children.
- 10:16Like, it's just a really great encapsulation of pre 911.
- 10:23But post late 90s I don't. I'd like this.
- 10:27This might be the most important movie of the last five years.
- 10:31We've talked about Brad. Baba, I feel like you're just
- 10:33going to continue to compliment how, like unique to its era this
- 10:40film is to like cushion the 2.5 you're going to give it at the
- 10:44end. Of the what if I end up talking
- 10:46myself into like this Is an absurdist masterpiece 8.5 out of
- 10:5110. Bob, let's be really honest.
- 10:54This is an absurd absurdist masterpiece.
- 10:57I mean, it's absurd. I don't.
- 10:58I don't. Know if it makes it a good
- 10:59movie. But.
- 11:01It like it's a masterpiece of what Ron Howard is setting out
- 11:05to do. Yeah, OK, let's, let's talk a
- 11:07little bit about Ron Howard as a director.
- 11:09I have gone on my soapbox many times for Ron Howard because I
- 11:12think that like Clint Eastwood and like Steven Spielberg, he he
- 11:17often champions the everyman, but his direction is the most
- 11:22kind of muted of the three of them.
- 11:24Like, you can't really. There's not as much of A
- 11:26directorial signature as, you know, like Spielberg.
- 11:29You can always tell when you're watching a Spielberg movie.
- 11:32Every once in a while, Ron Howard will do something that is
- 11:35just way outside of his wheelhouse.
- 11:37Like, this is the guy that made multiple Da Vinci Code movies.
- 11:42And you forget like, oh, he made those Da Vinci Code movies.
- 11:45That doesn't seem like a Ron Howard movie.
- 11:47And then you remember, Oh yeah, he made like one of the worst
- 11:50Star Wars movies ever. That was also Ron Howard.
- 11:53So he just, every now and then he's like, I'm gonna test the
- 11:56waters elsewhere and it almost never works out for my guy.
- 12:00Which? Which Star Wars movie did he
- 12:02make? He did solo.
- 12:04Oh, that. That was Ron Howard.
- 12:06Well, that, I mean that's he only gets half credit for that
- 12:08'cause it was like almost made and then they pulled the
- 12:11directors off of it and Ron Howard was brought in to like
- 12:13try to salvage it. So you know, like, I don't blame
- 12:16him for that one. He did not unsalvageable.
- 12:20I as a Star Wars fan, I will tell you I've never seen Solo.
- 12:24It's just, it's not even, like, bad, bad.
- 12:26It's just like the most boring and forgettable move As you're
- 12:29watching it, you're like, Oh yeah, I forgot, this is about
- 12:32Han Solo, right? Like, like, every, every scene.
- 12:36Anyway, all that to say, Brad, I like one of my boldest claims
- 12:39today is going to be, I think this is like the most directing
- 12:44Ron Howard has ever done in a movie.
- 12:46Like, he's really trying for an aesthetic here.
- 12:49I don't know what you would even call what he's trying to go for
- 12:53here, but it's very obvious that he is making big choices.
- 12:58I I think that what he's going for is trying to turn a
- 13:05children's like animated cartoon book into a message of morality
- 13:14that wasn't in the original book and it and it becomes something
- 13:19vastly different. Now here's the thing, Bob.
- 13:22Do you feel like the consumeristic urge that has
- 13:26dominated Christmas is good? I I I do not.
- 13:30I will go on record and say no. So what's your problem with this
- 13:34movie then, man, he's he's just, he's on your side.
- 13:37He's on your team, Bob. That's it, man.
- 13:39That's that's how movies work, right?
- 13:40Like, that's it. If we agree with the central
- 13:42message of the movie, then the movie must be good.
- 13:45Yeah, that we just did an episode, Brad, about the
- 13:47Christian movie industrial complex.
- 13:50And every single Christian movie is.
- 13:52Is good based on our criteria and logic, yeah.
- 13:56So I I think I wanted to point that out to say like both of us
- 14:01agree with the underlying message of this film.
- 14:03Like like we're not going to sit here and lambast him for trying
- 14:08to make a movie about, hey, like the spirit of Christmas is
- 14:10probably something other than buying a million gifts.
- 14:14Like what? Like one of my favorite scenes
- 14:16of the film is when Cindy Lou who has the giant thing of
- 14:20Christmas presents near the start of the film and and he
- 14:23pulls out the one from the middle to see her face which is
- 14:25a great little like frame within A-frame.
- 14:28And and she just really quietly goes, I don't know if this is
- 14:33what Christmas is all about, Daddy.
- 14:36And it's the most sweet, precious little moment of the
- 14:40film. And it might be one of the only
- 14:42quiet moments of the film. And I loved it.
- 14:45Yeah. And so, man, I think, Brad, how
- 14:48I'd like the first half of this episode to go is because we're
- 14:51already diving into kind of the analysis part of it.
- 14:56My two big problems with this movie are interrelated.
- 14:58The first one is the difficulties of adapting a story
- 15:03that is meant to be short into an almost two hour movie and and
- 15:08the, you know, the additions that they have to make to fill
- 15:11out the runtime and whether those are successful or not.
- 15:14And then B, as a result of that, I feel like the, the underlying
- 15:21message of the movie is kind of similar, but the
- 15:23characterization is completely different.
- 15:25Like the who's in the short film are completely different than
- 15:29the who's in this movie. And I think they're trying to
- 15:31kind of update it for, you know, quote UN quote modern times.
- 15:34But I I do feel like it kind of undermines the point of the
- 15:37movie, the way that they portray these characters.
- 15:39So I don't know if you're OK with it.
- 15:41Let's kind of just go through both of those points.
- 15:45And I want to start with an episode we released multiple
- 15:49Christmases ago where we had a debate about which short
- 15:53animated film was better for Christmas time, Charlie Brown,
- 15:56Christmas or The Grinch. What an episode.
- 15:59Now you have very famously said, A, that you love Charlie Brown
- 16:02Christmas, and B, the Grinch has never really worked for you, the
- 16:05original Grinch cartoon and and part of your reasoning, as I
- 16:09recall, was that you just don't really like the the animation
- 16:13style of Doctor Seuss. Which is not.
- 16:17Totally. Just don't.
- 16:18Just don't. Like is a very very light
- 16:22encapsulation of the hatred. Really.
- 16:25It's that bad. Oh, I I think it is one of the
- 16:28most hideous animation styles I've ever seen in my life.
- 16:32Interesting. OK.
- 16:33I didn't realize it was that. I thought it was more just like,
- 16:35yeah, I don't care for it, you know?
- 16:36Oh no, I like and and I'm not the animators for the Christmas
- 16:43special. I I'm not blaming them.
- 16:45I hate Doctor Seuss's art style. Got it.
- 16:48Period. I think it's horrendous.
- 16:50The animators did a great job of of mimicking it and putting it
- 16:54to screen. I think it's terrible.
- 16:57OK. All right.
- 16:59We got that out off your chest. We're good.
- 17:01We could move past that. I I do want to ask, though.
- 17:05So you don't really care for that special, but like, I mean
- 17:10you have a good grasp on the way that it's told and the
- 17:13underlying message of it. Yeah.
- 17:16What do you think about the way that they quote UN quote fleshed
- 17:22out the story for the two hour version like because to me,
- 17:26Brad, when I think about this story like it is, it is a
- 17:29parable. That almost the same way that
- 17:31Charlie Brown Christmas is like a parable.
- 17:33It's just a very short. It's not supposed to have a lot
- 17:35of context. You're not supposed to know why
- 17:38the Grinch hates the who's. He just does.
- 17:40He's a guy who hates the who's and the who's love Christmas and
- 17:45to give him the back story that they give him in this movie and
- 17:48and all the things they flesh out, it's like you tried to make
- 17:54the impact of the parable better by giving it more context, but
- 17:59in doing so you actually rob it of all of its power.
- 18:02Jesus's parables in the New Testament, you know, my guy knew
- 18:06what he was doing. If those, if those parables
- 18:09were, you know, multiple chapters long, they would lack
- 18:12the rhetorical power. So like, I guess just just on
- 18:16like a rhetoric level, Brad, like did they ruin it here?
- 18:20Honestly, Bob, my curiosity is so obviously your opinion is
- 18:26that yes, they did ruin it. I guess I'll speak to that
- 18:30point. I don't think that they ruin
- 18:34necessarily the moral of the story with most of the
- 18:37characterization. Like I, I I honestly kind of
- 18:41like the idea of the Grinch being a part of the society and
- 18:47then being rejected because of his skin color and his just
- 18:53robust facial hair. If, if we can put it that way,
- 18:58like none of that bothers me. I think that the only
- 19:00characterization that just feels so far out of left field is how
- 19:07deeply what What's her name? Martha May something.
- 19:13Oh, yeah, yeah. Christine Baranski.
- 19:16Wants to have sex with the grin. I mean, like, bad dude like.
- 19:19So bad. It's so weird.
- 19:24And like if they literally just fully cut that piece out of the
- 19:27story, or like not even cut it out of the story.
- 19:30It's just poorly directed. Like, I I like that he thought
- 19:34that this girl was cute. Like that is so relatable to be
- 19:38somewhat of a loser in your class, at least self perceived
- 19:42that way and think that the cute girl in the class might ever
- 19:46like you like that. Like that's a classic storyline
- 19:49that we can all relate to. It gets weird when they become
- 19:53adults and I and I think that a different director might have
- 19:56done a better job with it, but it it's that's the primary point
- 20:01for me that kind of muddles the entire message of the original
- 20:07Grinch. Yeah, the way I see it, they add
- 20:102 crucial things to fill out the runtime, #1 is they they try to
- 20:18answer the question of like why does the Grinch hate Christmas
- 20:21slash the who's and the 2nd is like they try to they try to add
- 20:28context to the who's themselves. So like instead of in the
- 20:32original version. Like, they are not really caught
- 20:34up in consumerism in this version.
- 20:37They have to overcome their own consumerism.
- 20:40Like that's their obstacle to overcome.
- 20:42And it's I I think they both have their own flaws.
- 20:45But the biggest flaw of the movie for me is like those two
- 20:49stories are kind of happening separate from each other.
- 20:52So like the Grinch hates Christmas, but only as an
- 20:56extension of the who's loving it.
- 20:58Like, he doesn't really hate Christmas so much as he hates
- 21:00the who's. And he had a really traumatic
- 21:03experience happen to him around Christmas.
- 21:07But when they have this flashback and they show that the
- 21:10Grinch was, like, absolutely bullied and humiliated by grown
- 21:14women and children and then forced into exile as a small
- 21:18child, Like, what is actually happening there has nothing to
- 21:22do with the consumeristic attitude of the who's.
- 21:25It's like the Who's are awful, awful people, and their
- 21:28consumerism is only one facet of how they're awful.
- 21:31And so the end of the movie attempts to fix this by them
- 21:35overcoming their consumeristic impulses.
- 21:39But like, they don't fix anything else.
- 21:41Like, they're still racist. They're still like, they're just
- 21:44horrible, horrible people. And I think that's like, that's
- 21:49the thing that pisses me off, is like, it tries to manipulate you
- 21:52into thinking like, oh, they've overcome this one thing.
- 21:55So now we can, like, cheer for them.
- 21:57Absolutely not. Like I want.
- 22:00I want the Grinch to go Django Unchained on this entire
- 22:05village. I would like to see an absolute
- 22:08bloodbath at the end of this movie, because those people
- 22:10deserve it more than anyone else.
- 22:14How the Grinch stole Christmas Django Edition I.
- 22:18Don't know man, am I like am I far off in my assessment here?
- 22:21I feel like they they tried to patch up a whole host of awful
- 22:27sinful things these people do by like having them fix one sinful
- 22:30thing they do. Sure, I I think that the the
- 22:34problem here is that Ron took things.
- 22:38He allowed it to go too far. It is Ron's fault.
- 22:41It's all Ron's fault. It is Ron's fault.
- 22:44Like he and I say that because he is the one who chose the the
- 22:50general timbre of the film. Like like the the sound and the
- 22:55the garishness that we talked about earlier.
- 22:58Everything is so over the top in order to portray Americans
- 23:03ridiculous consumption habits. But he never pulls the reins in
- 23:09on any other elements of it. And so I think that you end up
- 23:13with the Grinch being the most over the top Grinch you will
- 23:16ever see in your life, and the who's being the most over the
- 23:18top who's and the storyline being the most over the top
- 23:22storyline. Yeah.
- 23:23And it undermines exactly what they're trying to say, 'cause
- 23:25like, you know, even if we, if we grant him that, like, the way
- 23:30he's shooting this movie is supposed to be a reflection of
- 23:33the commercialism of the 90s or whatever.
- 23:35It's not like they stopped doing it at any point in the movie.
- 23:38Like the movie is a giant commercial based on the way they
- 23:42shot it. So I'm with you, man.
- 23:44Like it. It does like it.
- 23:45It seems like it's trying to make points, but then it's
- 23:47undermining its own points. Also it it undermines it in a
- 23:51very simple way, like that isn't even done over the top.
- 23:54Like at this point the movie's calmed down some.
- 23:57But like the whole point of the movie is like we don't need
- 24:00presence, we just need each other, right?
- 24:02Kindness, human human goodness and and decency.
- 24:07But but they still get the presence at the end of the
- 24:09movie. So this brings me like the the.
- 24:12Go ahead, go ahead. No, I was just going to say like
- 24:15they still end up with the thing that they.
- 24:19Should not they fix nothing about themselves?
- 24:21These people suck. Here's the curiosity for me.
- 24:27This is this is more general Bob.
- 24:29A few, not even a few weeks ago. Last week we watched The Phantom
- 24:33Menace and I I specifically remember you saying, man, why
- 24:37didn't they just give us a a 10 minute background on Qui Gon
- 24:40Jinn or Obi Wan or Darth Maul. And here we have one of your
- 24:45favorite movies, the The Grinch getting a little bit of
- 24:49background and and it is not your cup of tea.
- 24:52It is not So what's so? So what gives?
- 24:54How? How do we reconcile these two
- 24:57two things, Bob? It's a good question, Brad, and
- 24:59I think the real answer is that I am just not a consistent
- 25:01person. But my my actual answer is going
- 25:05to be like I really do just think this story is a 30 minute
- 25:11story. Like if you read the book to
- 25:14your child, it will take you about 30 minutes.
- 25:16If you watch the 30 minute version, it takes you guess how
- 25:20long 30 minutes to get through it.
- 25:21It's a perfectly told story in 30 minutes and trying to stretch
- 25:26it out to two hours is just a it's a bad idea.
- 25:29Like they they made another Grinch movie and I think 2018,
- 25:32an animated one with Benedict Cumberbatch voicing the Grinch.
- 25:37And it's also not good because like guess what, you are just
- 25:41padding the runtime when even if it's an hour and a half long,
- 25:45you're putting an hour of filler into this story.
- 25:48So like I wanted more Qui Gon because I feel like The Phantom
- 25:52Menace is a 2 hour story, you know, actually 2 hour plus,
- 25:57right? But like, it needs to be filled
- 25:59out even more because it's being told on this big canvas, whereas
- 26:02the Grinch is like it is intended to be a very simple
- 26:05story and it doesn't need the context that they're trying to,
- 26:09like, force on to it. Now I I will say Bob in in
- 26:14defense of my boy Ronnie. This is an hour and 4040 hour
- 26:18and 44 minute movie. And I I looked when the credits
- 26:23came up and it was at an hour and 38 minutes, sure.
- 26:27So this is very nearly a 90 minute film, yeah.
- 26:31And and I will still say 60 minutes.
- 26:33Too long, Brad. You you were you would prefer
- 26:36the 38 minutes I. Sure would.
- 26:38Where no one's horny like, very, very importantly, the.
- 26:43Joke's on you. That's the 38 minutes, the R
- 26:48rated version, just the horny parts.
- 26:52OK. So I want to talk a little bit
- 26:53about the, the second part of what I was saying, which is like
- 26:56the the characterizations changing.
- 26:59And Brad, you know, I do think that at the end of the day, the
- 27:02message is Christmas isn't about consumerism.
- 27:06Like we we reached that conclusion when we were talking
- 27:08about Charlie Brown. Like they both kind of say the
- 27:10same thing. But what I really love about the
- 27:12original Grinch is that the way they get to that point is that
- 27:18if you really think about the Grinch, it's that he's been
- 27:21misunderstanding them the whole time.
- 27:24Like, he thinks like he he, you know, he's looking down at
- 27:27Whoville and he's like, I can't stand all the noise from their
- 27:30toys. And I I just hate that they're
- 27:32making all this cacophony. So what am I going to do?
- 27:34I'm going to go steal it all from them because in his mind,
- 27:37he's thinking they make lots of noise with this.
- 27:40So they must love these things. And I hate when they gather
- 27:42around and sing. I just hate it.
- 27:44I'm going to take it all away from them and then they'll be
- 27:46sad. And the big reveal is like
- 27:50presents are fine, but they never cared about the presents
- 27:53to begin with. And it's when he hears them
- 27:55singing in the absence of their stuff that he has a change of
- 28:00heart. It's a really beautiful story.
- 28:02And so, like it's anti consumerist, but it's anti
- 28:05consumerist because the Grinch misunderstood them.
- 28:09Whereas in this movie they freaking suck.
- 28:12And he's right about them the whole time.
- 28:14And so his his plan to to get back at them is to steal all
- 28:18their stuff. But it's more of a revenge story
- 28:20than anything. And so at the end of the movie,
- 28:23like they, I guess they have a change of heart, but they decide
- 28:27like, we don't want to be sucky anymore, so let's embrace the
- 28:31spirit of being together. But it completely changes the
- 28:35calculus of the Grinch needing to have a change of heart.
- 28:39Like he had a change of heart in the first one because he had
- 28:42fundamentally misunderstood them to begin with.
- 28:45And in this movie, they're the ones misunderstanding the
- 28:47Grinch. And I just don't feel like it
- 28:50sticks that landing. Like it tries to arrive at the
- 28:53same place, but it completely flips the characterization of
- 28:57the who's and the Grinch to try to do it.
- 28:59And I just don't feel like it works as well.
- 29:02And I I'd like to hear your thoughts because you're a guy
- 29:04that doesn't like the Grinch anyway, so it probably doesn't
- 29:06matter to you. But like, I mean, do you do you
- 29:09know what I'm getting at here? Oh 100% can can I get Biblical
- 29:13here for a second Bob? Like the the essence of being a
- 29:19Christian in a lot of ways is summed up by Jesus when he talks
- 29:23about like the world will know you Christians by the love that
- 29:29you have for one another And and this is in the middle of a
- 29:32passage where he's talking about like leaving them and and
- 29:36darkness and suffering. And the implication is when
- 29:40things are really terrible and life is insanely difficult,
- 29:44which as we all know, happens a lot, you will be known by the
- 29:49love that you have for one another.
- 29:51And I think that's kind of what the original Grinch is getting
- 29:54at, right? Like when things are really bad,
- 29:56when you're suffering, quote UN quote, and it's a children's
- 29:59story, so suffering equals losing your toys.
- 30:04What do we, what do we recognize?
- 30:06Oh wow, they actually love each other.
- 30:07And it's the recognizing of that that converts the Grinch, if
- 30:13you, if you'll allow the metaphor to continue in this
- 30:16one, Ron recognizes like one or two elements of that and is
- 30:23like, but also I hate commercialism and we're just
- 30:27going to focus on that like we're just going to focus on the
- 30:31consumerism and and how much I hate that.
- 30:35And it's been so in his face for about 20 years now.
- 30:39Like 80s and 90s are not known for their subdued nature.
- 30:46And so it would make sense that he would want to mock the last
- 30:5120 years by making the most ridiculous version of it
- 30:56possible. And so I I I think that's why to
- 31:00me, Bob, I almost just consider them completely separate films.
- 31:04And well, and I, you know, I'm, I'm glad you said that, 'cause
- 31:07you kind of have to. Like you can't, you can't think
- 31:10of them the same because they are two completely different
- 31:12movies that are trying to make. Like I said, they're trying to
- 31:16make the same point, but they're really not.
- 31:17They're making two completely separate points from each other
- 31:19as well. Brad, I know Before we go any
- 31:21further, I don't, I won't talk about the old Grinch anymore
- 31:24because you've provided a good segue out of it.
- 31:26But I have to say, what I love about the old Grinch is that we
- 31:31don't even know what the Grinch's relationship is with
- 31:34Whoville. Like, we don't know if they've
- 31:36ever seen him before. He just hates them.
- 31:39He just lives on a mountain and hates these people and their
- 31:42first exposure to him may be him stealing their stuff.
- 31:48It would explain why Cindy Lou, who doesn't recognize him and
- 31:51thinks that he's Santa Claus and buys all buys into all his lies.
- 31:55Because they are such a naive and welcoming people.
- 31:59And when this dude has his change of heart after seeing
- 32:03them singing around their tree and he speeds down the mountain,
- 32:07it's so crudely animated, 'cause they're like standing in a
- 32:09circle and they they open the circle up for the Grinch to come
- 32:12in, but they animate it like the people are like a hinge door and
- 32:15they just like swing open and let him in.
- 32:18It's such a great picture of like who these people are.
- 32:22They they never cared about the toys, they never cared about the
- 32:26stuff. The at their core they're like a
- 32:29beautiful, welcoming people. And the moment that he turns and
- 32:34comes to them, they welcome him with open arms, and they let him
- 32:37carve the freaking roast beast. And in this movie, like, the
- 32:40Grinch comes riding into town. And the only reason that they
- 32:43welcome him is because they're like, he's doing to us what
- 32:47we've been doing to him for 50 years.
- 32:49Like, look what we have wrought. And then they're like, maybe we
- 32:52shouldn't suck so much. And again, like, that's an
- 32:56effective way to tell a story. It is not the Grinch.
- 32:59This thing is an abomination to grinches everywhere.
- 33:02Burn. Bob, I am gonna take the How the
- 33:07Grinch Stole Christmas to the finals of our bracket at the end
- 33:10of the. Year just so I can burn it.
- 33:13No, just so that it lives on forever and is never burnt.
- 33:19All right, Brad, we, we have done all the analysis on this
- 33:21movie and we haven't talked about performances at all, but I
- 33:24think this is a good place for us to stop.
- 33:26Let's drink some whiskey. We'll come back and we'll talk
- 33:28about Ronnie and Jimmy and all the people involved in this
- 33:31movie. What do you say?
- 33:33Let's get to it, man. Although I'm not sure if there's
- 33:35anybody else involved that Jim Carrey.
- 33:45All right, everybody, today we are drinking Calumet 16 year
- 33:50Citation. Now, Bob, I I don't know a ton
- 33:55about Calumet Farms, but I do know that they have a special
- 33:59limited release series that that honestly comes out pretty
- 34:03sporadically and they they're naming them these special
- 34:07releases after the the different Triple Crown winners.
- 34:12Is that correct? Yeah, I don't.
- 34:14I I don't remember if it's actually just Triple Crown
- 34:16winners or if it's just like famous race horses.
- 34:18But you know, Citation is one of the most legendary horses to
- 34:22ever win the Triple Crown. If you drive through Lexington,
- 34:26like there is a Citation Road or Citation Blvd.
- 34:30I'm getting nerdy now Brad. But anyway, Calumet Farms, Brad,
- 34:33we had a listener right into us and in fact it was our friend
- 34:36Wes who provided these Calumet samples to us to correct us on
- 34:42what we know or don't know about Calumet.
- 34:45So last week I called Calumet Farms a non distilling producer,
- 34:48which is true. I said that they were sourcing
- 34:50their whiskey from Western Spirits which I don't know very
- 34:53much about and Wes corrected me to say that Western Spirits is
- 34:58also a non distilling producer. So this is actually Barton
- 35:02Whiskey that is being aged at a warehouse owned by Western
- 35:07Spirits and Calumet is just a brand that Western Spirits puts
- 35:12out. So sure fine this is still a non
- 35:16distilling producer that is giving us what we now know to be
- 35:19Barton Juice. So Brad, this particular whiskey
- 35:22is a 16 year old from their single rack, Black Label.
- 35:28We talked about this a little bit last week.
- 35:29They pull all these whiskeys from one rack in the Rick house.
- 35:33They say that it is the optimal conditions.
- 35:36I think they're they're never more than like 19 barrels in a
- 35:39blend and this is the oldest one we've had by a lot.
- 35:42Brad, this is 16 years old. I'm a little worried, 'cause
- 35:45even last week at 14 years old, I think that thing was
- 35:48approaching being over oaked. Yeah, that I've not found many
- 35:5612 plus bourbons that survive. The oaking.
- 36:02The oaking. That sounds like a horror movie.
- 36:05The the opening. All right, we are We're sitting
- 36:10at 106 proof. Today we are at 74% corn, 18%
- 36:16rye, 8% malted barley. Brad, let's freaking drink this
- 36:20thing. What are you picking up on the
- 36:21nose? This is a really pleasant nose.
- 36:25It it doesn't stand out in any powerful ways, but it gives me
- 36:29some really nice vanilla. There's caramel it, it's very
- 36:33like a like a rich cream cheese and there's a little bit of like
- 36:38a sweet mint going on that I that I I really like.
- 36:41It's very pleasant. I give it an 8 out of 10 here on
- 36:44the nose. I'm really close to you because
- 36:47I actually think your notes are right on.
- 36:48But that minty note, I think sometimes tips into smelling
- 36:53like straight ethanol, almost like rubbing alcohol.
- 36:57And so I can't tell from moment to moment.
- 36:58Like, is this just really herbaceous or is it, like,
- 37:01chemically almost? And so that's the only thing is,
- 37:05I'm, I'm a little wary of this alcohol note.
- 37:08Like, is it going to really kick me in the mouth when I take a
- 37:10sip here? It's pleasant.
- 37:12I'm going to give it a 7.5 on the nose.
- 37:15Yeah, I was. I don't think it's the Mint note
- 37:17that's giving you that. I think it's the ethanol.
- 37:19Yes, thank you. Just just a little correction on
- 37:24the pallet here. The first note that I have is,
- 37:28wow, that's oaky. Like there is a lot of oak going
- 37:33on here. Once you kind of push past that
- 37:36with the 2nd and 3rd sip, there's some cocoa powder.
- 37:39The vanilla continues through. I got like a nice like Raisin
- 37:44type of vibe. It's got a little bit of a
- 37:46coffee, ground coffee smell to it.
- 37:51I came down a little bit on the pallet.
- 37:53I'll give it a 7 out of 10 here. It's it's good product.
- 37:59It should be like 12 or 13 years, not 16.
- 38:02Brad, I'm in a very interesting position right now because you
- 38:05sound like Bob Book right now. You sound like a guy who, I'm
- 38:11not saying you're lying about your position or even couching
- 38:13it in nice things, but you're like, you know, if you think
- 38:16about this and I'm going to be the Brad G here because you said
- 38:20the words, hey, once you push past the first sip and give it a
- 38:24second and third sip, it gets better.
- 38:26Brad G would look me in the eye and say Bob, you shouldn't have
- 38:29to give it 3 sips to think that it's a good whiskey.
- 38:32Yeah, that's true. So.
- 38:34I'm going to be the Brad G here, so it's too oaky.
- 38:37It just is. And that first sip, dude, like,
- 38:40it was the front of my palate. And then you said, Oh yeah, it's
- 38:42on the front of your palate. And I was like, OK, hopefully I
- 38:45will push through this all the way through oak, oak, oak.
- 38:48And it's like you get just the faintest glimmer of sweetness.
- 38:54And then it is swallowed up once again by just straight, woody
- 38:58notes. It's it's certainly something,
- 39:02man. I'm sure there are people out
- 39:03here who love their whiskey to taste like this.
- 39:06This is just not, you know, I like my decadent rich whiskeys.
- 39:10This is not that, man. I'm going to give it a 5 1/2 on
- 39:14the taste. Wow.
- 39:16Yeah, I well, I'll, I'll just go on to the finish.
- 39:20For the finish, I'm at a 7 1/2 I I think that the oak continues
- 39:24through very strong as you said. I get a little bit of black
- 39:28pepper, a little bit of leather. It has some some of those kind
- 39:31of classic bourbon finishing notes that you would have from a
- 39:35more heavily oaked W7 and a half decent finish on a on a decent
- 39:43whiskey. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2
- 39:45too, and I'm going to, you know, I'm going to pull a Bob book.
- 39:48Now, when we were at the New York Whiskey competition, Brad,
- 39:54we got one sip to judge these things.
- 39:56That's it. I mean, like if you really
- 39:57wanted to take a second sip, you would.
- 40:00But we're drinking like 100 samples a day.
- 40:02So you're you're pretty much taking your notes based off of 1
- 40:04sip. You are absolutely correct in
- 40:07that the 2nd and 3rd sip on this are significantly better, much
- 40:10more caramel, much more brown sugar here.
- 40:13And that's going to bump my finish score up a little bit.
- 40:16Because when I think about like a finish, I'm I'm thinking about
- 40:18the lasting impact of the whiskey.
- 40:20And I include like a second sip in that I yeah, I'm going to
- 40:24give it a 7 1/2 here, but my balance score I can't pin down
- 40:28dude, because this is like, this was a wild ride.
- 40:32Yeah, I I I think that it's a wild ride and not in a great
- 40:37way. So I'm going to put my balance
- 40:40score at a 7 out of 10 there. There's a little bit of
- 40:43complexity here, enough for me to enjoy it.
- 40:46It's just so heavily oaked that I I can't go any higher than A7.
- 40:52Man, I just. I want to use this in like an
- 40:55Infinity bottle. I feel like this could give so
- 40:57much character to a bigger bottle of whiskey.
- 41:01Like you add these two oz and it's like a cheat code to just
- 41:04making your stuff more complex. But it almost reminds me of you
- 41:08know how they make poor man's Pappy where you blend Weller
- 41:11Antique and Weller 12 year and we've always said the antique is
- 41:16like all the flavor and the 12 year is all the spice and
- 41:19character. This is like that.
- 41:22This is like the Weller 12 of the Calumet we've had so far,
- 41:25Brad. Yeah, I'm going to give it a 6
- 41:291/2 on balance and I don't even know what this costs.
- 41:33Brad, what do you what's the value on this?
- 41:35Baba, I'm seeing it for $150.00 online and that's the only one I
- 41:43can see it's. At this point it is a very hard
- 41:46to find bourbon. Yeah, I'm seeing a review from
- 41:49back in 2022 when it came out at 138 dollars then.
- 41:54So it doesn't seem like it's been marked up that much.
- 41:56It was just expensive to begin with.
- 41:58Yep. I don't think this is a poorly
- 42:01made whiskey. Like, I think this is a really
- 42:03great example of a 16 year old bourbon.
- 42:06I just don't like 16 year old bourbon now like it's sourced.
- 42:12It's from a premium brand. Everything's always going to be
- 42:14expensive. Like, I I don't know, Brad, that
- 42:17I think $138 is actually exorbitant for this.
- 42:20Do you? Triple digits is tough.
- 42:25Man, like, I wouldn't pay for this, 'cause I don't like it.
- 42:28But if this is what you're looking for, I don't think this
- 42:32is like gouging people. Like if this was called Weller
- 42:3716, it would, you know, it'd be on the secondary market for
- 42:41$400.00. You know what I mean?
- 42:44Yeah. I think that this is like a 70
- 42:48to $90.00 whiskey. I think 110 isn't gouging.
- 42:52I think anything much above that is.
- 42:54All right, so let's say 90 is where it should be, so that
- 42:59they're charging like at least $4050 more than it should be.
- 43:02I'm still going to give this like a six out of 10 on value.
- 43:05I don't like it, but I don't think.
- 43:06I think you could do worse. I think there's much, much
- 43:10poorer decisions you can make in terms of value on whiskeys.
- 43:14Yeah, yes, I would agree with that.
- 43:20I'll give it a 3 1/2. I I just, I don't think this is
- 43:26a good value at 140 bucks. Man that's a lot of money.
- 43:30And you could go buy so many other whiskeys.
- 43:36Like so many other whiskeys, Bob.
- 43:38That is like 7 bottles of Rebel 100 tell me you could get.
- 43:44So drunk. All right, man, I am coming out
- 43:48to a 33 out of 50, which is higher than I thought.
- 43:51But again, I think this is a pretty well made whiskey, so I'm
- 43:54OK with it. Where are you at?
- 43:57Would you, would you guess that we're at the exact same score?
- 44:03I I want that to be exactly how we shake out on this movie, too,
- 44:06Brad. Yes, All right.
- 44:07Now, would you recommend This is the question?
- 44:10If you're not paying for it I like I would say it is worth a
- 44:15pour. Maybe if you could find a pour
- 44:19for like 1520 bucks and like you know what you're getting into,
- 44:24I'd say sure. Maybe try this, I I would not
- 44:28recommend a bottle. What do you think this would go
- 44:30well with? Like if we're food pairing?
- 44:32Because, you know, like Lagavulin goes really well to
- 44:35steak because we've been talking about this because like, the
- 44:38steak almost takes away the salinity of the Lagavulin, yes,
- 44:43but you get the smoke a little bit too.
- 44:45So like this, I don't like. I don't know this would go well
- 44:48with a steak, but it definitely like you couldn't drink this
- 44:50with like fish or chicken. It's too oaky, like it needs
- 44:53something with a ton of flavour. I don't think it's a dessert
- 44:57bourbon. Like it's got to be beef, right?
- 45:00No, it's not beef. This has to go with like an
- 45:04insanely long smoked pulled pork.
- 45:08Like a like a brisket maybe. I I think that this this has to
- 45:13go with just the juiciest pulled pork you've ever had in your
- 45:17that. Makes sense because of so
- 45:18there's so much oak like it have to be something smoked.
- 45:22Yeah. All right.
- 45:22Well, there you go folks. Get yourself a brisket and a
- 45:25bottle of Calumet 16. Brad, let's get back into
- 45:28talking about the Grinch. What do you say?
- 45:30Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 45:37That was Calumet 16 year citation of whiskey.
- 45:41That will just cost you too much money, Bob.
- 45:44Yep. You know it's not going to cost
- 45:47you any money at all. What's that, Brad?
- 45:502 facts and a falsehood, Brad. Is going to try to stump your
- 45:55ball. 2 all right And what is wrong?
- 46:012 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 46:05the podcast where Brad presents me with three items as fact
- 46:09about the making of this movie, one of which he has just
- 46:12completely made-up and I have to guess which one that is.
- 46:16Brad, I am sitting at 9:00 and 4:00 on the season.
- 46:19You're rocking it, man. Now one of those losses is is
- 46:24doubled because Noah could tell or was it Noah?
- 46:27I think it was Noah. Somebody steered me wrong, they
- 46:30done me wrong, and I took on an extra L So the numbers don't add
- 46:33up to the number of episodes in our season, but that's because
- 46:37we have crazy rules. What's the?
- 46:40What's the line in? Whose Line is It Anyways?
- 46:43The the games are made-up and the points don't matter.
- 46:45Yeah, the points don't matter. That's that's all 100% what this
- 46:48is, man. All right, hit me with the 2
- 46:50facts and a falsehood, Brad. Fact #1.
- 46:53Jim Carrey was suggested for the title role by Audrey Geisel, the
- 46:57widow of Doctor Seuss, who controlled the rights to the
- 46:59book. She also suggested Jack
- 47:02Nicholson, Dustin Hoffman and Robin Williams.
- 47:05Fact #2, Jim Carrey would often smoke in order to cope with the
- 47:09stress caused by the intense makeup process.
- 47:11However, his as his suit was covered in yak hair, he had to
- 47:15use a very long cigarette holder in order to avoid a potential
- 47:19fire hazard. Fact #3, the role of Max the dog
- 47:24was auditioned for by 47 different pooches with the
- 47:28winning the the final winning dog being Chip, a mixed breed 3
- 47:33year old puppy. These are good, man.
- 47:36I actually have no idea. So fact number one is
- 47:41interesting because I read enough about the making of the
- 47:44movie that I know that when they first started pitching the
- 47:49rights to the story, Doctor Seuss's widow stipulated like it
- 47:56has to be somebody on the level of a Jack Nicholson or a Dustin
- 48:01Hoffman. In terms of like, I don't know
- 48:03what the term is, you know, popularity, purchasing power.
- 48:06Right, she she was greedy, is what you're saying.
- 48:10No, she just, well, I guess so. But like, you know, I think this
- 48:14movie is very much like the weird 2000 commercialized
- 48:18version of, like, Tim Burton's Batman.
- 48:20So it kind of makes sense that, like, you'd want Jack Nicholson
- 48:23to be the star, like the way that he was the Joker.
- 48:25She wanted somebody to be the Grinch.
- 48:28Now, does that mean that she actually suggested Jack
- 48:30Nicholson? I don't know.
- 48:32Or did the person who wrote that IMDb thing understand exactly
- 48:36what she was saying? I don't know.
- 48:39Fact #2 sounds funny just because I could like the Grinch
- 48:42with a long cigarette holder. Just seems like the that seems
- 48:45like the perfect thing to put in the Grinch's hand with those
- 48:48long fingers and stuff. Fact #3, I just don't care.
- 48:52Like I don't care how many pooches they auditioned, so that
- 48:54could be made-up. I truly do not care.
- 48:58Screw the dog, yeah. Forget that dog.
- 49:03Forget that dog. Come on, man.
- 49:05Max is a very cute dog. Yep.
- 49:08Hey, can I tell you something else?
- 49:09Yeah, Max is probably dead by now.
- 49:12Yeah, he probably. Is that dog's dead?
- 49:13All right, so fact #1. That was that man.
- 49:20Chew, I'm gonna say fact number one is the falsehood just on
- 49:27that technicality, but I think I'm wrong.
- 49:30You are in fact wrong. Which one was it?
- 49:35It was #3 was the falsehood. Yeah, see, here's the thing.
- 49:39I don't care. That's that's what I need to do
- 49:43more often, right? Falsehoods that you just don't
- 49:45give a rip about. Like, I actually, I really like
- 49:48dogs. I I just like, you know?
- 49:51Convince me, Bob. How it like how am I ever to
- 49:54care about like the number of dogs that they what.
- 49:57So what was false about it? Did you just make it completely
- 49:59up or? There was a fact on IMDb about
- 50:05there being like 3 different dogs that played Max and I think
- 50:10that they were mixed breed, but like that there was nothing
- 50:13about the name of the dog or how many different dogs auditioned
- 50:17or anything like that. I didn't even think about the
- 50:19possibility that there was more than one dog.
- 50:21It's like the Olsen twins on Full House.
- 50:24Yeah, I thought about that when I wrote the fact I was like, I
- 50:27feel like if I write something about there being multiple dogs,
- 50:30you're going to sniff that out more than if I just say there
- 50:33was one. I would sniff it out.
- 50:35Yeah, See what I did there? All right, man, you've got me at
- 50:389:00 and 5:00 on the season now. Still got a little bit of
- 50:41cushion, but things are getting dicey here.
- 50:44Brad, let's talk not about the dog in the movie, but let's talk
- 50:48about The Grinch himself, Jim Carrey.
- 50:51Here's the thing, man. You could write the article
- 50:53about this movie that's like, oh, the Grinch is such a relic
- 50:57of its time, like Bob Book said, and it's because of this crazy,
- 51:01unhinged performance by Jim Carrey.
- 51:04I actually think Jim Carrey's performance makes so much sense
- 51:08in the context of this movie and in fact is less crazy and wild
- 51:13than the filmmaking going on around him.
- 51:16Like it seems like a very grounded performance and he's
- 51:20under so much make up that you have to go that big or else it
- 51:24would seem like a really flat performance.
- 51:27The fact that he's able to emote and move around as much as he
- 51:30is, it's kind of a minor miracle.
- 51:33Like I think it's a really, really good performance.
- 51:36Brad. I'm 100% with you, man.
- 51:39And. And can I take a second just to
- 51:41extol the virtues of practical effects like this is a hell of a
- 51:47costume. Oh my gosh.
- 51:49Very famously drove Jim Carrey insane.
- 51:53The costume director who put him into it every day nearly quit
- 51:56because Carrie was so difficult to work with.
- 51:58Like, like, it's almost legendary how terrible of a
- 52:01costume it was to get on. But I'll tell you what, man.
- 52:04I don't know if I've ever seen a better, just ridiculous costume
- 52:10that looks perfect. And and The thing is, like the
- 52:16way they shoot this movie, I hate, like, I hate
- 52:18cinematography. Brad.
- 52:20Like it's just, it's ugly. There's like sometimes there's a
- 52:22weird fog filter on top of everything.
- 52:24Everything's at an angle. The angles themselves, they
- 52:28reveal too much of the sets a lot of times.
- 52:30So it doesn't look like a real town.
- 52:32It looks like a set. And even with all that going on
- 52:36around him, like I never was looking at Jim Carrey's costume
- 52:40going like that's a costume. Like it is.
- 52:43It's one of the best costumes I've ever seen.
- 52:45It's like, incredible. And and the performance
- 52:48underneath it is spectacular. And it's because Carrie is such
- 52:53a brilliant comedian and he knows like, like there are
- 52:58moments in the asinine ridiculousness of his
- 53:02performance. There's moments where he draws
- 53:05it in and he almost like he often uses his body in a very
- 53:10big wide fashion. When he's engaging with the
- 53:13who's and he like it's almost like he's trying to get big for
- 53:16a bear and like scare them right and but when he's on his own in
- 53:21The Cave on the top of the mountain, like the scene where
- 53:25he's putting together his schedule, he's he's drawn in on
- 53:29himself. He's inwardly focused and and
- 53:32like Carrie, just has a talent for this type of comedy that I
- 53:39don't know if anybody else has. I will say like that that part
- 53:43of the movie was the worst part for me.
- 53:45Like the first half of this movie, for many reasons, was
- 53:50like unwatchable. Like once the actual plot kicks
- 53:53in and he's like, I'm going to steal Christmas, the movie gets
- 53:55a lot better. But it if there was one scene
- 53:57that I could do without, it's that one where he's just in his
- 54:00cave chomping on a glass and basically doing like his version
- 54:05of Robin Williams riffing in Aladdin.
- 54:10You know, like there's like multiple points in Aladdin where
- 54:12it's like, I don't think they could actually cut around all of
- 54:16this improv. So they just kind of left it all
- 54:18in there and animated it. That's kind of what this feels
- 54:20like. It just goes on for way too
- 54:22long. But I like overall, I think this
- 54:25performance is a huge success. I do want to ask you about his
- 54:29voice because, you know, very famously in the original it was
- 54:32voiced by Boris Karloff, one of the great voices.
- 54:36And in this movie, Jim Carrey's like, you can tell he's kind of
- 54:39trying to pay homage to that voice, but he's more doing like
- 54:44funny Sean Connery. Like, there's a lot of, there's
- 54:46a lot of Sean Connery here and it's it is also a choice.
- 54:52Yeah, I I think it's fine. That, like his voice, never
- 54:55bothered me. I think it fits with the
- 54:59character that he's trying to create.
- 55:02I think it would have bothered me in a more or in a less crazy
- 55:06movie. Yes.
- 55:07But like, you got to pick your battles, honestly.
- 55:11Yeah, like if it was a very accurate live action readaption
- 55:16of the animated film, but it had that voice.
- 55:20It yes, it would not fit, it would be over the top.
- 55:24But what? What is over the top anymore,
- 55:27Bob? No.
- 55:27There is there is no top. If you find it.
- 55:32Brad, I don't want to spoil. Actually I do.
- 55:34I'm going to spoil my let's make it a double here because I don't
- 55:38want to wait until we get to that segment to come back to
- 55:40this. I I do think that I saw a lot of
- 55:46Burt Lars, Cowardly Lion in his performance, like from the
- 55:52extent of the makeup and the heaviness of the costume, but
- 55:56also like just the way he moves like you.
- 55:59I really do think Carrie was probably watching The Wizard of
- 56:02Oz to try to get some pointers for how to act underneath all
- 56:05this makeup. And you can draw a through line
- 56:09from the Cowardly Lion to the Grinch.
- 56:11There's a lot of voice similarities, there's a lot of
- 56:13movement similarities. I didn't know if that was
- 56:16something you picked up on. Like, you and I are very
- 56:18famously not the world's biggest Wizard of Oz guys, and we
- 56:22haven't talked about that movie since, I don't know, season one
- 56:24or two. But I like, I kept thinking,
- 56:28like, what does this remind me of?
- 56:29And it hit me halfway through the movie like it's the Cowardly
- 56:31Lion, and then I couldn't get it out of my head the rest of the
- 56:33time. Yeah, that did not enter my
- 56:36consciousness. I haven't thought about The
- 56:39Wizard of Oz probably since we reviewed it.
- 56:43But you're. Yeah, I I think you're 100%
- 56:46correct. Like what?
- 56:47Like when I think back on The Wizard of Oz, there is.
- 56:51Yeah, yeah. If he didn't watch it, I would
- 56:54be surprised. Boom.
- 56:55I did it. I nailed it.
- 56:56You. You.
- 56:57Did it, man, you're doing great. Is there anything else in this
- 57:00movie worth talking about, Brad? I think the little girl's great,
- 57:06Taylor Momsen. Momsen Yeah.
- 57:09Yeah, I I think Cindy Lou, who is really well done.
- 57:14I think that if the notes for Christine Baranski were just be
- 57:17as horny as possible, then she does a great job.
- 57:21I don't know if I like the performance.
- 57:24I definitely don't like the character.
- 57:26Yeah, I mean, I don't really think she's asked to do anything
- 57:28except be horny. So she's she's fine.
- 57:30So the the mayor of this Whoville town is played by
- 57:33Jeffrey Tambor, very famous comedian and I could not
- 57:37recognize him under the makeup and the buck teeth, but he.
- 57:41Looks no idea that that was him. He.
- 57:43Looks. He.
- 57:45Looks like somebody else. And I couldn't place it.
- 57:48And I was thinking like, oh, this guy looks familiar.
- 57:51But then I saw Jeffrey Tambor and I'm like, no, no, that's not
- 57:53who I'm thinking of. Like, even when confronted with
- 57:55the reality of who it was, it like, I guess it it speaks to
- 57:59the effectiveness of this makeup because I thought he was being
- 58:02played by somebody else than he actually was.
- 58:06This makeup is weird sometimes, Brad, because it's really good
- 58:09on Jeffrey Tambor. It's incredible on Jim Carrey.
- 58:13And then you've got different stages of it.
- 58:15Like with the little kids, they don't put as much makeup on
- 58:17them. There's like the nose, but
- 58:18that's about it. There's not as much prosthetics.
- 58:22Christine Baranski barely has any.
- 58:24But then you've got like, Molly Shannon playing the mom.
- 58:28And every time she tries to like, say, the letter M, she
- 58:32can't close her lips over the teeth.
- 58:34And so, like, there there are points where the makeup is
- 58:36really distracting. And I kind of wish that they had
- 58:39been like, you know what? We are maximizing everything
- 58:43else about this movie. Like, do we really need to force
- 58:46this poor woman to try to speak through these teeth?
- 58:48You know what I mean? This is not my let's make it a
- 58:52double. But as you're saying that all I
- 58:54could think about was Remy Malik.
- 58:58But keep me in Rhapsody teeth. Yes, yes.
- 59:03They must have been taking notes for Bohemian Rhapsody from How
- 59:07the Grinch Stole Christmas like, oh, this is exactly what we're
- 59:10going for here. All right, Brad.
- 59:13Like I think we've both established there's not going to
- 59:15ask you. One one question about the
- 59:17script. Sure, what I At the end of the
- 59:23movie, you find out that the mayor isn't actually married to
- 59:28Christine Baranski. Yeah, I don't really.
- 59:31So here's the thing after. What was up with that?
- 59:34After the whole movie, they make it seem like they're married.
- 59:38After the Grinch rides into town and and the dad, like, stops the
- 59:42sleigh, I I'm not going to lie dude, I just completely zoned
- 59:47out. I don't remember a thing about
- 59:49the end of this movie, except that, like, Anthony Hopkins is
- 59:52narrating, right? Oh.
- 59:53Dude. And even that I'm hot take.
- 59:57I love Anthony Hopkins. My guy was mailing it in like he
- 1:00:01he wanted that check and he he did everything in one take and
- 1:00:04it was like OK but not the best. Yeah, and I mean he he recorded
- 1:00:09his lines in one day. Oh yeah, so.
- 1:00:12So it shows. Anyway, all that to say, I don't
- 1:00:17even remember this thing about the mayor that you're referring
- 1:00:19to. So, like, yeah, that through the
- 1:00:21whole movie, he's clearly got the hots for her.
- 1:00:24I don't remember thinking they were married, but then also
- 1:00:28apparently there's a reveal at the end that they weren't
- 1:00:31married. I don't know.
- 1:00:34Here's the thing, Brad, it's a it's a 30 minute movie that they
- 1:00:37stretched into an hour and a half.
- 1:00:40I think we are at a good place, Brad, to get into our last
- 1:00:43segment of the day, which we call, let's make it a double.
- 1:00:46We're near the end of the episode, so thanks for listening
- 1:00:49to the film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 1:00:52this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:00:54It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:00:57Let's make it a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:00:59movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:01:03feature. As I said, I'm going to pick The
- 1:01:05Wizard of Oz here because of the Cowardly Lion similarities, but
- 1:01:09also because, like The Wizard of Oz is not my favorite movie.
- 1:01:14It is a significantly better film than this, and it also is a
- 1:01:18really good example of how to film sets that are very fake and
- 1:01:24still make them seem like real places that our characters are
- 1:01:27in. Because one of the biggest
- 1:01:29downsides of this movie is that the crazy camera angles just
- 1:01:33completely ruin any chance of you thinking that these people
- 1:01:37are are anywhere but on a sound stage.
- 1:01:40So if you would like a better example, but also maintaining
- 1:01:44absolute wild craziness, I would say go watch The Wizard of Oz.
- 1:01:50I think I'm going to pick another movie from the 90s that
- 1:01:55is just a great example of the wild craziness of the 90s.
- 1:02:00I am going to pair this with the Arnold Schwarzenegger LED Jingle
- 1:02:05all the way. Dude, as a child of the 90s, I
- 1:02:10love this movie, a film my wife had never seen until we got
- 1:02:14married. And when we were decorating for
- 1:02:16Christmas one year, I was like, well, let's put this on in the
- 1:02:18background. She was not into this movie,
- 1:02:22dude. Like, I don't think she hated
- 1:02:24it, but she was just like, you. You watched this as a kid.
- 1:02:27You liked this as a kid. What's going on?
- 1:02:30Like, it's just one of those movies, you know?
- 1:02:335-6 year old Bob had much worse taste apparently than 10 year
- 1:02:39old How the Grinch Stole Christmas watching Bob.
- 1:02:42How much better would this movie have been if Arnold
- 1:02:45Schwarzenegger had been like the mayor or something, though?
- 1:02:47Oh. Bro if.
- 1:02:50If if the Grinch was played by Sylvester Stallone and the mare
- 1:02:55was played by Schwarzenegger, yes, I'm 100% in.
- 1:03:05All right, so there you have it. I said the Wizard of Oz.
- 1:03:07Brad said, Jingle all the way. Honestly, I think Brad wins this
- 1:03:10round. That's just such a deeply weird
- 1:03:13movie. I love it so much.
- 1:03:15Yep, I I thought it was a good match for this.
- 1:03:18All right, Brad, let's give this some scores.
- 1:03:20I'm gonna be honest with you. I was fully prepared to come in
- 1:03:25and give this movie a 2.5 out of 10 based on the first half.
- 1:03:29In fact, at the halfway point, I texted you an article I found,
- 1:03:34and I I don't know if I've ever agreed with more in an article
- 1:03:38than this review of the Grinch. And it was like a complete
- 1:03:40takedown of just what an abomination this movie is.
- 1:03:43I still agree with that. But I will also say that once
- 1:03:48this movie finds a plot, you kind of stop noticing how
- 1:03:52freaking weird everything else is.
- 1:03:54Like the the filmmaking gets more propulsive.
- 1:03:58There's like a rhythm to it. You're kind of used to the
- 1:04:02garishness of it. And so you kind of don't pay
- 1:04:04attention to that anymore, and you're just along for the actual
- 1:04:07Doctor Seuss written ride. And like I I kind of enjoyed the
- 1:04:13second-half of this movie, Brad. I didn't enjoy it enough to give
- 1:04:17it a really high score. But Brad, I I've been waffling
- 1:04:21between a four and a half and A5.
- 1:04:23And then you set and then you set the over 104 and a half
- 1:04:274.75. Exactly where it needed to be,
- 1:04:30baby. Do I know you or do I know?
- 1:04:33You and I'm 100% serious, dude. Like, we did not talk about
- 1:04:37this, this, These were the 2 scores that I was.
- 1:04:39Like is it a 5 or is it a four and a half?
- 1:04:43I'm gonna give it. Vegas has got nothing on me,
- 1:04:45baby. I'm gonna give it a 4 1/2 man.
- 1:04:47Like it. The ending is OK, but the first
- 1:04:50half is an abomination, yeah. No, I I'm not too far off from
- 1:04:54you, Bob. I think for me, I don't have as
- 1:04:57much angst about this movie because I really don't give a
- 1:05:00rip about the first one. That being said, this isn't a
- 1:05:05great movie, folks. There are some funny moments I
- 1:05:09for me, I'm with you that the scene of just Jim Carrey being
- 1:05:13Jim Carrey in the mountain by himself is is overwrought in a
- 1:05:17movie full of of going over the top.
- 1:05:21But it has some classic lines. When he talks about not being
- 1:05:26able to cancel on himself for dinner again, it's it's so
- 1:05:30funny, man. So I think there's more than
- 1:05:33enough here to enjoy. I wouldn't recommend watching it
- 1:05:37more than like twice a decade if you even if you're a big fan.
- 1:05:42I'm like, I I don't know if this movie is good for you if you
- 1:05:45want. To like, Are you saying like if
- 1:05:46you want to preserve the magic of the movie?
- 1:05:48Like you can't, you can't ruin it for yourself?
- 1:05:50Exactly. Got it.
- 1:05:52So I I'll give it a six, I'll, I'll give it a 5 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:05:59It's it's fine. It was OK.
- 1:06:01It made me chuckle a few times. Not a great movie.
- 1:06:04All right folks, that takes us to an average of just a 5 out of
- 1:06:0910. Brad I have a feeling it's going
- 1:06:11to be pretty difficult for anything to come out lower than
- 1:06:15this movie on the season. Yeah, yeah, I I can't see a
- 1:06:19world where this isn't the number 32 seed.
- 1:06:23Michael Bay and his Transformers movies are like Challenge
- 1:06:26accepted, baby, yeah. I yeah, I guess that's true.
- 1:06:31I mean, we have The Last Jedi. We have.
- 1:06:34Yeah. There's a lot to bring us down.
- 1:06:36All right. We're just starting starting
- 1:06:38early in 2000. Yeah, and we're going to
- 1:06:40continue this weird trend of like goofy monsters that we've
- 1:06:44been on with Jar Jar Binks and the Grinch.
- 1:06:47And we're going to roll into 2001 next week to look at what
- 1:06:51is apparently the Internet's favorite film of all time, the
- 1:06:54DreamWorks animated Oscar winning film Shrek.
- 1:07:00Hopefully that's not going to come out to a 5 out of 10
- 1:07:02because I don't know how many more of these I can take, Brad.
- 1:07:05So before we get out of here, let me say folks, we'd love to
- 1:07:08hear what you think of how the Grinch Stole Christmas.
- 1:07:10Are we out of our minds or did we score it too high?
- 1:07:13You can let us know at any of our social media accounts.
- 1:07:16Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok, YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:07:22Or jump into our Discord. We have a Discord server
- 1:07:25dedicated for you guys, our fans.
- 1:07:28We love getting on there, talking to you guys, discussing
- 1:07:31anything going on in our worlds. So if you want, you can join the
- 1:07:35conversation. There's a link at the end of
- 1:07:37every single. Join us next week for Shrek, but
- 1:07:41until then, I'm Bob book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:07:44And we'll see you next time.