Latest / GeekWire / Voices from the Amazon walkout
Transcript
- 0:01Emily Cunningham: We are here because we want to build a better
- 0:04Emily Cunningham: Amazon. Who wants to build a better Amazon?
- 0:10Todd Bishop: Hundreds of Amazon employees walked out of the office in
- 0:13Todd Bishop: Seattle this week, gathering in between the company's headquarters towers
- 0:17Todd Bishop: while holding signs, participating in chants and listening to speakers
- 0:21Todd Bishop: urge the tech giant to do better.
- 0:24Speaker 2: Let's make our voices heard by Andy Jassy and the S-
- 0:27Speaker 2: team. This is our world.
- 0:28Crowd: This is our world.
- 0:28Speaker 2: This is our company.
- 0:28Amazon employee: This is our company.
- 0:36Speaker 2: I'm so proud of all of us. Yes.
- 0:39Todd Bishop: It was part of a global walkout that organizers said
- 0:42Todd Bishop: drew participation from more than 2, 000 Amazon employees worldwide.
- 0:46Todd Bishop: So why did they walk out and what do they
- 0:49Todd Bishop: hope to accomplish? On this episode of the GeekWire Podcast,
- 0:52Todd Bishop: we hear from Amazon employees in the crowd and speakers
- 0:55Todd Bishop: at the podium. We explain the company's perspective and we
- 0:59Todd Bishop: put the walkout in the larger context of tectonic shifts
- 1:03Todd Bishop: taking place in the tech industry. Welcome to GeekWire. I'm
- 1:12Todd Bishop: GeekWire co- founder Todd Bishop, and I'm here with Kurt
- 1:14Todd Bishop: Schlosser, GeekWire reporter. It's great to see you, Kurt.
- 1:17Kurt Schlosser: Hi Todd, good to be back.
- 1:19Todd Bishop: You had some adventures this week. You went down to
- 1:21Todd Bishop: the Amazon campus, and when you've been in the past
- 1:25Todd Bishop: to try and find Amazon employees to talk with just
- 1:28Todd Bishop: randomly approaching people on the street, it's often difficult to
- 1:31Todd Bishop: get Amazon employees to talk. This time was very different.
- 1:36Todd Bishop: In some ways, at least, certain Amazon employees had a
- 1:39Todd Bishop: lot to say. This was the walkout that had been planned,
- 1:43Todd Bishop: a demonstration urging the company to take boulder action on
- 1:47Todd Bishop: the climate, and also to reconsider its return to office policies.
- 1:51Todd Bishop: Give us a sense for what you saw and heard
- 1:53Todd Bishop: down at Amazon HQ outside the S pheres this week.
- 1:57Kurt Schlosser: Yeah, Todd, there was quite a bit of talking. There
- 2:00Kurt Schlosser: was chanting, there was some clapping, yelling, a lot of
- 2:04Kurt Schlosser: fired up people. We estimated a few hundred walked out
- 2:08Kurt Schlosser: at the noontime hour on the plaza there by the
- 2:11Kurt Schlosser: spheres next to the Day 1 headquarters tower. Sun came
- 2:15Kurt Schlosser: out and people were distracted from getting lunch for a
- 2:18Kurt Schlosser: minute to listen to a variety of speakers, and to
- 2:22Kurt Schlosser: waive signs and air their grievances about these topics that
- 2:25Kurt Schlosser: they think upper management is ignoring, chiefly the return to
- 2:30Kurt Schlosser: work policy that started May 1st where employees are required
- 2:33Kurt Schlosser: to be back in the office three days a week at
- 2:36Kurt Schlosser: least, and their concerns about Amazon falling short of its
- 2:39Kurt Schlosser: climate pledge initiatives. So it was a twofold protest and
- 2:44Kurt Schlosser: lasted about an hour, and then people presumably went back
- 2:48Kurt Schlosser: into the office where they didn't want to be.
- 2:52Todd Bishop: I know people are accustomed to Amazon w arehouse employees increasingly
- 2:56Todd Bishop: speaking out against the company, but to me, this was
- 3:00Todd Bishop: notable in part, because corporate and tech employees, historically at least,
- 3:05Todd Bishop: have not been as outspoken on these issues. And it
- 3:08Todd Bishop: reflects the change that we've seen over the past six
- 3:11Todd Bishop: months to a year as the economy has turned and
- 3:15Todd Bishop: companies have started to cut back. Now, one of the
- 3:18Todd Bishop: employee groups that organized this particular protest, Amazon Employees for
- 3:22Todd Bishop: Climate Justice, actually goes back a number of years and
- 3:26Todd Bishop: has been pushing the company in a variety of ways
- 3:28Todd Bishop: over that timeframe. But the other organization which is focused
- 3:32Todd Bishop: on remote work is relatively new and grassroots, and I
- 3:36Todd Bishop: thought it was interesting. One of the speakers that you
- 3:39Todd Bishop: heard from was an Amazon employee who started the internal
- 3:42Todd Bishop: Slack channel that created this groundswell of opposition to the
- 3:48Todd Bishop: Return to Office policy.
- 3:49Kurt Schlosser: The event was the Climate Groups event, at least that's
- 3:53Kurt Schlosser: what I was told. And then the remote group joined
- 3:57Kurt Schlosser: on when they became such a force within Amazon with
- 4:01Kurt Schlosser: this internal Slack channel that attracted some 33,000 employees.
- 4:06Todd Bishop: Here's an extended clip from the employee who created the
- 4:09Todd Bishop: Slack channel, Pamela Hayter, that puts the Return to Office
- 4:12Todd Bishop: controversy into broader perspective.
- 4:15Pamela Hayter: Back in February of this year, Andy Jassy, Amazon CEO,
- 4:18Pamela Hayter: announced that this may Amazon's policy of allowing individual directors
- 4:24Pamela Hayter: to determine remote work, would come to an end. I
- 4:30Pamela Hayter: remember when I first read that announcement, my heart just
- 4:33Pamela Hayter: dropped, because I knew immediately the negative impact that this
- 4:38Pamela Hayter: would have on my family. Working from home had allowed
- 4:43Pamela Hayter: me the opportunity to be with my family more than
- 4:47Pamela Hayter: I had ever had before. A little bit of a
- 4:49Pamela Hayter: secret, I am a workaholic, a true trait of an
- 4:53Pamela Hayter: Amazonian, and I'm sure a lot of you out there
- 4:55Pamela Hayter: can relate. So, before the pandemic, I rarely found myself
- 5:01Pamela Hayter: having time to spend with my family. I either was
- 5:04Pamela Hayter: in meetings at all hours of the day, I was
- 5:07Pamela Hayter: stuck in hours long traffic getting to the office, I
- 5:11Pamela Hayter: would spend eight plus hours at that set office, only
- 5:15Pamela Hayter: to then yet again be stuck in more hours long
- 5:17Pamela Hayter: traffic on the way home. So, the time that I
- 5:20Pamela Hayter: spent at home was laughable at best, team, I got
- 5:23Pamela Hayter: to tell you. And believe me when I say, my
- 5:26Pamela Hayter: family felt that. But at the time, I didn't know
- 5:31Pamela Hayter: that there was a different world that was possible, so
- 5:34Pamela Hayter: we just did what we thought we had to do.
- 5:37Pamela Hayter: But when I think back on that time, it makes
- 5:40Pamela Hayter: me really sad, because now standing here today in front
- 5:43Pamela Hayter: of you, I realize that it doesn't have to be
- 5:46Pamela Hayter: that way. We don't have to spend hours of our
- 5:50Pamela Hayter: lives in traffic, hours of our lives at an office
- 5:53Pamela Hayter: building. We can be productive, customer obsessed, we can do
- 5:59Pamela Hayter: our good work, we can make a difference, and it
- 6:01Pamela Hayter: does not have to be in an office building.
- 6:05Kurt Schlosser: This employee, Pamela Hayter, who's been at Amazon for eight
- 6:08Kurt Schlosser: years, called the Slack Channel the largest concrete expression of
- 6:11Kurt Schlosser: employee dissatisfaction in our entire company history, during her speech
- 6:16Kurt Schlosser: to the crowd.
- 6:17Todd Bishop: Historic. History being made on Slack.
- 6:21Kurt Schlosser: Trying to think what was the largest before that? 200
- 6:24Kurt Schlosser: people angry about a lack of poop bags at the dog park?
- 6:30Todd Bishop: To the point of us laughing about this, Kurt, it
- 6:32Todd Bishop: can come off as somewhat petty, but in fact, the
- 6:36Todd Bishop: remote work group positioned this as an issue of equity
- 6:40Todd Bishop: and of fairness. Some of the norms that were created
- 6:45Todd Bishop: during the pandemic, created more of a level playing field
- 6:47Todd Bishop: for people with disabilities, others who have extenuating circumstances who
- 6:52Todd Bishop: might not be able to make it into the office
- 6:54Todd Bishop: on a regular basis in the same way or with
- 6:56Todd Bishop: the same ease as some of their colleagues. And so,
- 7:00Todd Bishop: in a lot of ways, these are substantive issues being
- 7:02Todd Bishop: discussed here, not just for the company and the industry, but
- 7:06Todd Bishop: for individuals who have to grapple with this new policy
- 7:09Todd Bishop: that, as you said, went into effect on May 1st.
- 7:12Kurt Schlosser: Yeah, that's a good point. I spoke to a couple different
- 7:15Kurt Schlosser: employees who expressed that exact sentiment. And one said, I
- 7:18Kurt Schlosser: asked him, " How do you feel about coming in three
- 7:20Kurt Schlosser: days a week?" He said, " I'm coming in five days
- 7:22Kurt Schlosser: a week."
- 7:23Amazon employee: I can walk to work, but there aren't that many
- 7:25Amazon employee: people like me. And I also don't have to be
- 7:29Amazon employee: a caregiver, I don't have any dependents, so I'm in
- 7:34Amazon employee: a position where it's okay for me to come in
- 7:36Amazon employee: the office, but I think I'm in the minority, a
- 7:38Amazon employee: very vast minority.
- 7:39Kurt Schlosser: But he goes, " I'm out here for my colleagues who
- 7:42Kurt Schlosser: don't have that luxury, whether it's because they're a caregiver
- 7:46Kurt Schlosser: or they have a disability that has made working from
- 7:49Kurt Schlosser: home an easier prospect."
- 7:51Amazon employee: It really bothers me that I'm in a company that's
- 7:54Amazon employee: 70% men in corporate Amazon, it's 80% men at the
- 7:57Amazon employee: manager level. I just feel like the tech industry holds
- 8:01Amazon employee: so much of the wealth in this city and the
- 8:04Amazon employee: country that it's really important to me that it be
- 8:07Amazon employee: a more diverse and accessible line of work for everyone.
- 8:10Amazon employee: And seeing the teammates of mine who are immediately looking
- 8:14Amazon employee: for new jobs, because they are caregivers or they have
- 8:16Amazon employee: a health issue or they don't qualify for disability, but
- 8:19Amazon employee: they can't make it to the office for some other
- 8:21Amazon employee: reason, just makes me furious, and I want to see that change.
- 8:27Todd Bishop: In a video posted online by the company last month,
- 8:30Todd Bishop: Amazon CEO Andy Jassy is shown greeting employees individually as
- 8:34Todd Bishop: they walk into the company's headquarters before sharing his own
- 8:38Todd Bishop: perspective on the importance of returning to the office.
- 8:41Andy Jassy: Well, I'm really excited to have more of my teammates back in
- 8:44Andy Jassy: the office. I think we're pretty convinced that we're going
- 8:47Andy Jassy: to invent and collaborate better when we're in the office
- 8:49Andy Jassy: more together. I think the riffing that happens is really
- 8:51Andy Jassy: different. I think the ability to map out ideas in
- 8:55Andy Jassy: the whiteboard when you're done with the meeting, is different.
- 8:57Andy Jassy: Those serendipitous meetings happen a lot more when we're together,
- 8:59Andy Jassy: but I also think it's easier to be connected to
- 9:02Andy Jassy: one another and to understand the culture better when we're
- 9:04Andy Jassy: here together. And when you work with talented and inventive
- 9:08Andy Jassy: people like we do, it's also more fun to be
- 9:10Andy Jassy: together. So I'm excited to have everybody back.
- 9:12Todd Bishop: One more perspective on the return to office issue, we
- 9:15Todd Bishop: did hear from some readers, unaffiliated with Amazon, who criticized
- 9:19Todd Bishop: the walkout. They pointed out, for example, that for more
- 9:21Todd Bishop: than two years during the pandemic, Amazon's warehouse workers had
- 9:25Todd Bishop: no choice but to come to work, as the company
- 9:27Todd Bishop: dealt with huge demand from shoppers at home. After the
- 9:30Todd Bishop: break, Amazon and the planet.
- 9:37Todd Bishop: Climate issues were obviously key as well, and on their
- 9:41Todd Bishop: webpage encouraging employees to walk out, the organizer said that
- 9:45Todd Bishop: Amazon is severely under counting its carbon footprint, disproportionately polluting
- 9:50Todd Bishop: communities of color, increasing carbon emissions 40% since 2019, killing
- 9:55Todd Bishop: clean energy legislation. All of these things, a laundry list
- 9:59Todd Bishop: of things that the Amazon employees for Climate Justice say,
- 10:03Todd Bishop: really runs counter to the company's Climate Pledge.
- 10:06Jeff Bezos: Today we are announcing the Climate Pledge. The climate pledge
- 10:12Jeff Bezos: is to meet the goals of the Paris Agreement 10
- 10:16Jeff Bezos: years early. Amazon becomes the first signatory to the Climate
- 10:20Jeff Bezos: Pledge. We want to use our scale and our scope
- 10:23Jeff Bezos: to lead the way.
- 10:25Todd Bishop: Of course, the company says, they've been doing the best
- 10:27Todd Bishop: they can. It takes time to accomplish these things, and
- 10:30Todd Bishop: they remain on track according to Amazon to get to a
- 10:33Todd Bishop: 100% renewable energy by 2025, they continue investing substantially. So
- 10:38Todd Bishop: you've got both sides of this, but clearly this was
- 10:41Todd Bishop: a platform for the employees to air their views and
- 10:46Todd Bishop: to bring attention to these issues in a very public way.
- 10:49Kurt Schlosser: Yeah, the term greenwashing was thrown around quite a bit.
- 10:53Kurt Schlosser: It was on the banner behind the speaker's podium, and
- 10:55Kurt Schlosser: several employees used that term when speaking to me. A
- 10:59Kurt Schlosser: couple of them openly mocked the fact that Amazon has
- 11:03Kurt Schlosser: slapped the Climate Pledge name on the arena over at
- 11:07Kurt Schlosser: Seattle Center. They said that's nice for media purposes and
- 11:11Kurt Schlosser: for hand waving, but it does really nothing to get
- 11:14Kurt Schlosser: at the issues that they're concerned about.
- 11:16Amazon employee: It's frustrating, because Amazon made the Climate Pledge, which is net-
- 11:22Amazon employee: zero emissions by 2040, and they boast about it all
- 11:25Amazon employee: the time. I mean, we have the Climate Pledge Arena
- 11:27Amazon employee: blocks from here, and yet if you look at the
- 11:30Amazon employee: sustainability reports, our emissions are only going up. And on
- 11:35Amazon employee: top of that, there was this pledge called Shipment Zero,
- 11:38Amazon employee: which was 50% of shipments being zero carbon. And yet
- 11:43Amazon employee: last week they dropped that silently, and internally we learned
- 11:46Amazon employee: about that from a reporter, not from Andy Jassy or
- 11:49Amazon employee: from Worldwide Sustainability. And so, it's really frustrating to publicly
- 11:57Amazon employee: see Amazon say that they're going to do better about
- 12:01Amazon employee: the climate, and yet in reality, we're only going in
- 12:04Amazon employee: the wrong direction. That's frustrating.
- 12:07Todd Bishop: As you may have noticed, despite reassurances from organizers that
- 12:10Todd Bishop: they would be safe from any retribution, the employees Kurt
- 12:13Todd Bishop: spoke with were not comfortable sharing their names on the
- 12:16Todd Bishop: record. As he spoke with employees at the rally, Kurt
- 12:19Todd Bishop: asked several of them, " So, why are you still working here?"
- 12:22Amazon employee: Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, I joined Amazon
- 12:27Amazon employee: in 2019 with the Climate Pledge fresh. I was really
- 12:32Amazon employee: feeling great about it, and I feel fortunate that I
- 12:34Amazon employee: work with great colleagues, but absolutely, I mean, sometimes I
- 12:38Amazon employee: feel like I'm part of this greenwashing machine, and I'm
- 12:43Amazon employee: not part of something bigger. I've brought up sustainability in
- 12:47Amazon employee: meetings, and yet leadership doesn't see it as a priority.
- 12:50Amazon employee: And so, I feel like this is the only way
- 12:53Amazon employee: to get their ear and tell them that we're not
- 12:56Amazon employee: okay with this.
- 12:58Kurt Schlosser: These concerns that are being raised, do they ever make
- 13:00Kurt Schlosser: you wonder, " Why do I work at this place?"
- 13:03Amazon employee: I love my work at Amazon. I've never worked with
- 13:05Amazon employee: better, more capable people. This job is really suited to
- 13:10Amazon employee: what I care about, and I do want to fight
- 13:13Amazon employee: for it.
- 13:13Todd Bishop: But there is one last controversy to discuss. That's after
- 13:17Todd Bishop: the break.
- 13:21Todd Bishop: Kurt, I hate to go all Sean Spicer on you
- 13:24Todd Bishop: here, but I feel like we have to address and
- 13:26Todd Bishop: discuss the questions that came up over the size of
- 13:31Todd Bishop: this crowd. I was tempted in our discussions to just
- 13:35Todd Bishop: call it Bigley, but this was a crowd, you were
- 13:40Todd Bishop: there, and I was looking at the photos, and our
- 13:44Todd Bishop: estimate was 300 to 400 people. And the organizers said
- 13:50Todd Bishop: that about a 1, 000 pledged to walk out, and very
- 13:54Todd Bishop: well may have walked out, but they also contended that
- 13:57Todd Bishop: the bulk of those 1, 000 based on their count, were in
- 14:00Todd Bishop: that courtyard between the Amazon spheres and the Doppler building
- 14:05Todd Bishop: right next to the Day 1 Tower, which is the
- 14:07Todd Bishop: headquarters. I got to say, I don't think that was
- 14:11Todd Bishop: the case.
- 14:12Kurt Schlosser: Yeah, it tightened up a bit when it finally got
- 14:15Kurt Schlosser: started, but there were a lot of people on the
- 14:18Kurt Schlosser: periphery like, " Hey, should I go get a salad or
- 14:22Kurt Schlosser: should I listen to these coworkers of mine talk about
- 14:26Kurt Schlosser: these issues?" I couldn't tell who was there for the
- 14:30Kurt Schlosser: rally and who was just passing by. Some people were
- 14:33Kurt Schlosser: up behind the podium at the dog park. Some were
- 14:36Kurt Schlosser: hidden in the trees, in the bushes that ring the
- 14:39Kurt Schlosser: spheres. Some were hiding behind their signs. Amazon has been
- 14:45Kurt Schlosser: known to dabble in facial recognition technology. I wonder about
- 14:49Kurt Schlosser: standing in that plaza and giving up your face for
- 14:54Kurt Schlosser: future uses.
- 14:56Todd Bishop: One would hope in an altruistic way that none of
- 14:59Todd Bishop: this would be used for retribution. And in fact, the
- 15:02Todd Bishop: groups reassured employees who were considering participating in the walkout
- 15:06Todd Bishop: that they were effectively legally protected as a form of
- 15:11Todd Bishop: demonstration and free speech to do this walkout, without fear
- 15:15Todd Bishop: of retribution. The crowd size intrigued me in part, because
- 15:20Todd Bishop: the size of the crowd is an indication of the
- 15:24Todd Bishop: momentum that's behind this movement. The organizer said, as we mentioned,
- 15:28Todd Bishop: that they had about 1, 000 people pledge to walk out
- 15:32Todd Bishop: in Seattle, and that's out of 2, 143 worldwide. They
- 15:36Todd Bishop: also noted anecdotally that some people walked out without pledging
- 15:39Todd Bishop: in advance to do it. And the pledges were interesting,
- 15:42Todd Bishop: because they wanted to reach a threshold of 1, 000
- 15:44Todd Bishop: people promising to walk out before they went ahead with
- 15:48Todd Bishop: it. For context, when you take that 1, 000 in Seattle
- 15:51Todd Bishop: or 2, 100 worldwide number, then that compares to 65,000
- 15:57Todd Bishop: corporate and tech workers in Seattle overall for Amazon, and about 350,
- 16:01Todd Bishop: 000 worldwide, so a relatively small fraction of Amazon's workforce.
- 16:07Kurt Schlosser: I would've been much busier if 50,000 people floated out
- 16:09Kurt Schlosser: of those buildings into the streets and turned the Return
- 16:13Kurt Schlosser: to Office, RTO rally into WTO style full on Seattle mayhem.
- 16:22Todd Bishop: We're not at that point yet with the Amazon employee
- 16:25Todd Bishop: base yet, at least.
- 16:27Kurt Schlosser: Yeah. I'm angry. I'm hungry. What do I do?
- 16:29Todd Bishop: I don't know that chant.
- 16:34Kurt Schlosser: You'll hear it at your local salad bar in South Lake Union.
- 16:39Todd Bishop: All right. Well, this was an interesting week in part,
- 16:43Todd Bishop: because I think it represented this tug of war, this
- 16:47Todd Bishop: change in the balance of power between employees and big
- 16:50Todd Bishop: tech companies. And that's in part because you've got the
- 16:54Todd Bishop: stock price tanking and layoffs happening, and this r eturn to
- 16:59Todd Bishop: office mandate all happening at the same time, and it's
- 17:03Todd Bishop: creating this really complex stew of emotions and motivations, and
- 17:08Todd Bishop: you're seeing tech employers and tech employees at odds more
- 17:13Todd Bishop: than they have been in the past. Thank you, Kurt.
- 17:15Kurt Schlosser: Thanks Todd.
- 17:16Todd Bishop: See the show notes for related links and stories, and
- 17:19Todd Bishop: be sure to subscribe, rate and review the show wherever
- 17:22Todd Bishop: you listen. We'll be back next week with a new
- 17:25Todd Bishop: episode of the GeekWire Podcast.