Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Born vs. ID.3: The Rivalry of Heart and Brain
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to the deep dive everyone.
- 0:12Our mission today is to explore this really fascinating case of,
- 0:17well, automotive split personality.
- 0:19Oh yeah, it's a crazy one, right?
- 0:21We're. Pulling from some European car
- 0:23reviews and a really detailed YouTube comparison to see how
- 0:26like one single vehicle can essentially live 2 completely
- 0:31different lives. Two totally different lives.
- 0:33Exactly. So to kick us off, just imagine
- 0:35you're at a restaurant, right? You order two dishes from the
- 0:38very same kitchen made with, you know, identical base
- 0:40ingredients. OK, I'm with you.
- 0:42But when they arrive at your Table, 1 is this spicy,
- 0:45avant-garde masterpiece, and the other is just your favorite
- 0:48reliable comfort food. Which is a perfect analogy for
- 0:51what's happening right now with two electric hatchbacks, the
- 0:55Cooper Born and the Volkswagen ID .3 Neo.
- 0:59Exactly. I mean, underneath the sheet
- 1:00metal, these two cars are basically mechanical twins.
- 1:03Yeah, they both sit on Volkswagen's MEB platform.
- 1:06Right. And for those unfamiliar, you
- 1:08can think of that platform like a giant motorized skateboard
- 1:11that different car bodies can just, you know, snap right onto.
- 1:14Snap right onto yeah and they share the the exact same rear
- 1:18wheel drive systems and carbon copy battery packs too.
- 1:20Yep, giving you both the 58 and 79 kWh options.
- 1:25And with that larger battery, you can hit DC fast charging
- 1:29speeds up to 183 kilowatts. Which is pretty fast.
- 1:33It really is. In the real world, that means
- 1:34you can grab an 80% charge in about the time it takes to get
- 1:38lunch, though sitting at a charging station can still get a
- 1:41bit tedious if the nearby coffee shop happens to be closed.
- 1:44Oh definitely. There's nothing worse than a
- 1:46closed Lowe's coffee shop when you're stuck charging, but you
- 1:49know that shared skateboard chassis is what makes this whole
- 1:52thing so fascinating. How so?
- 1:54Well, by using one unified industrial foundation,
- 1:57Volkswagen is basically proving that you can tune the exact same
- 2:00raw materials to produce 2 wildly different emotional
- 2:03experiences. Wow.
- 2:05Yeah, so they save money on the invisible parts to invest
- 2:07heavily in how the car actually makes you feel.
- 2:10Exactly. It's a master class in modern
- 2:12manufacturing. But I mean, if the hardware is
- 2:15identical, how did the engineers actually managed to make them
- 2:18feel so radically different from the driver's seat?
- 2:20It really comes down to this idea of brain versus heart.
- 2:24OK, so the ID .3 neo is the brain obviously.
- 2:27Right. Totally the brain.
- 2:28It's designed to be clean, mature and just hyper efficient.
- 2:32Like the software managing the electric motor is programmed to
- 2:36ease into the power, keeping your morning coffee perfectly
- 2:39level. Yeah, it doesn't spill.
- 2:41Plus you get this massive 12.9 inch touchscreen.
- 2:44Super intuitive controls and a beautifully quiet cabin that
- 2:49practically just disappears under you on the highway.
- 2:52Which is fantastic for a daily commute, sure, Yeah, but if I'm
- 2:56buying an electric hot hatch, I don't want the car to just
- 2:59disappear. You know, right?
- 3:00You want to feel it. Exactly.
- 3:01I want to feel the drive, and that's where the Cooper steps in
- 3:04as the heart. So they didn't change the
- 3:06physical motors. No, they didn't.
- 3:08Instead, they just changed the software, telling those motors
- 3:10how to behave. Yeah, the Cooper's throttle
- 3:12mapping dumps that torque immediately, so you really feel
- 3:16it in your chest. And they tweaked the steering
- 3:18ratios so it reacts way faster to your inputs.
- 3:21And you see that whole attitude reflected in the design, too.
- 3:23It intentionally sacrifices some of that soft, quiet smoothness
- 3:27for pure aggression. Oh, definitely.
- 3:29You've got that sharper lower nose, intricate copper details
- 3:33all over the place, and those deeply bolstered bucket seats.
- 3:37And it all peaks with the Bournes VZ version.
- 3:40Right, The VZ packs 326 horsepower and hits 62 mph in
- 3:44just 5.6 seconds. Which is incredibly quick.
- 3:47It is, and to handle that they swap in a much stiffer sport
- 3:51suspension. Though I have to say, feeling
- 3:53every single inch of the road can get a bit tiring on your
- 3:56lower back if the road surface is really.
- 3:58Rough. Oh for sure, your back will feel
- 3:59it on a bad Rd., but the Volkswagen aims for that
- 4:02universal usability, while the Cupra uses the software and
- 4:06suspension tuning to really chase that edge in dynamic
- 4:09response. So the Cupra gives you a stiffer
- 4:11ride, sharper software, aggressive styling, but
- 4:14underneath it is still that identical battery and motor.
- 4:17Yep, same exact core. Which makes the price gap
- 4:20incredibly hard to ignore. The ID point 3 is clearly the
- 4:23value play here. It starts much cheaper, around
- 4:25£30,800 or €33,995. Meanwhile the Cupra demands
- 4:33pretty noticeable premium, starting up near €39,990.00.
- 4:39So I have to ask you, why pay more?
- 4:42Just take a second to really think about that.
- 4:44Yeah, it's a well, it's a tough question to answer on paper, I
- 4:47bet, because when you buy the Cupra, you really aren't paying
- 4:50for better hardware or more range.
- 4:53You were paying for an identity. The ID .3 is the rational, easy
- 4:56to justify daily driver. Exactly.
- 4:58It is the smart choice, but the Born is for buyers who just
- 5:01refused to let logic win every single time.
- 5:04You want an EV that makes you smile when you walk up to it in
- 5:06the marking lot. Exactly.
- 5:07That so it's the spicy avant-garde dish versus the
- 5:10comfort food. But you know, here's where it
- 5:12gets really interesting to think about for the future.
- 5:14What's that? Well, if car makers can engineer
- 5:172 completely different souls out of identical batteries and
- 5:20motors today, what does that mean for the future of cars?
- 5:22Right. If we we connect this to the
- 5:24bigger picture, it raises an incredible possibility.
- 5:27Like what? As cars become more digital and
- 5:30software to find, will we eventually just be downloading
- 5:33new personalities for our vehicles overnight?
- 5:35Oh man, like you could drive the comfortable ID .3 on a Monday
- 5:39and then just download the aggressive Cooper born
- 5:43suspension and throttle tuning for the weekend.
- 5:45Yeah, exactly. It's like a restaurant where the
- 5:47menu changes from comfort food to a spicy masterpiece just by
- 5:51pushing a button on your app. That is a wild thought.
- 5:53Now that is really something to chew on.
- 5:55Well, thank you for joining us on this deep dive, everyone.
- 5:57Thanks for listening.