Latest / I Don't Have Enough FAITH to Be an ATHEIST / Why Didn't God Create a Universe Where Everyone Believed?
Transcript
- 0:01[Speaker 0] Does truth exist?
- 0:03[Speaker 1] Because you have faith, does that make this
- 0:04[Speaker 1] book true?
- 0:05[Speaker 0] Does God exist? So when someone says
- 0:08[Speaker 1] there is no truth, if you apply the
- 0:10[Speaker 1] claim to itself, what should you say? Is
- 0:13[Speaker 1] that true? They don't think Christianity is true.
- 0:18[Speaker 1] They're talked out of it. You know why
- 0:20[Speaker 1] they're talked out of it? Because they've never
- 0:23[Speaker 1] been talked into it.
- 0:24[Speaker 0] Cross examining skeptical and atheistic views. Welcome to
- 0:29[Speaker 0] cross examine with doctor Frank Turek.
- 0:32[Speaker 2] Ladies and gentlemen, last week on this podcast,
- 0:35[Speaker 2] we were tackling a question from John about
- 0:38[Speaker 2] Romans chapter nine. And there's much in Romans
- 0:42[Speaker 2] chapter nine that many Calvinists try and say,
- 0:45[Speaker 2] well, man doesn't really have free choice. God
- 0:48[Speaker 2] makes all the choices. He God has mercy
- 0:50[Speaker 2] on whom he wants to have mercy and
- 0:52[Speaker 2] compassion on whom he wants to have compassion
- 0:55[Speaker 2] and hard and pharaohs heart. Who are you
- 0:58[Speaker 2] to talk back to God and all this?
- 1:01[Speaker 2] And a lot of Christians go, Oh, man,
- 1:03[Speaker 2] that really seems like we don't have any
- 1:05[Speaker 2] free will and God makes all the choose
- 1:06[Speaker 2] and does all the choices. And now we
- 1:09[Speaker 2] can't recant. We can't recant. We can't we
- 1:12[Speaker 2] don't want to recant. We can't go back
- 1:14[Speaker 2] and go through everything we did for the
- 1:17[Speaker 2] past forty five minutes in the last program.
- 1:22[Speaker 2] That's forty five minutes long. So I'm just
- 1:24[Speaker 2] going to pick it up where we left
- 1:26[Speaker 2] off with a very kind of brief summary.
- 1:29[Speaker 2] We were talking about Romans chapter nine, and
- 1:31[Speaker 2] I tried to make the case that Romans
- 1:33[Speaker 2] chapter nine is not talking about the election
- 1:36[Speaker 2] of individuals to salvation. It's talking about the
- 1:40[Speaker 2] election of the nation of Israel. So we
- 1:44[Speaker 2] went through that case and we also pointed
- 1:47[Speaker 2] out that several places in the scriptures it
- 1:50[Speaker 2] talks about that God doesn't want anybody to
- 1:54[Speaker 2] be lost. He wants all to be saved.
- 1:56[Speaker 2] And so we ask the question, if God
- 1:59[Speaker 2] wants all to be saved and the Calvinists
- 2:02[Speaker 2] are right, that God does all the saving,
- 2:05[Speaker 2] then why isn't everyone saved? That would appear
- 2:08[Speaker 2] to be a contradiction. And I think it's
- 2:11[Speaker 2] not a contradiction because Calvinists are interpreting the
- 2:15[Speaker 2] passages wrongly. And we went through some reasons
- 2:21[Speaker 2] why in the last in the last show,
- 2:25[Speaker 2] we're going to pick it up here. In
- 2:28[Speaker 2] fact, I want to point out that when
- 2:30[Speaker 2] we go toward the end of Romans chapter
- 2:33[Speaker 2] nine, Paul says this in verse thirty. What
- 2:37[Speaker 2] then shall we say that the Gentiles who
- 2:40[Speaker 2] did not pursue righteousness have obtained it? A
- 2:43[Speaker 2] righteousness that is by as if it were
- 2:53[Speaker 2] by as if it were by works. He's
- 2:58[Speaker 2] pointing out again, the issue is the Israelites
- 3:02[Speaker 2] didn't have faith. And if the Calvinists are
- 3:05[Speaker 2] right, it would make absolutely no sense for
- 3:09[Speaker 2] Paul to say here that, well, the reason
- 3:15[Speaker 2] that Israel isn't saved is because they went
- 3:20[Speaker 2] about it by works when if they had
- 3:22[Speaker 2] gone about it by faith, they would have
- 3:24[Speaker 2] had faith because God had given them that
- 3:29[Speaker 2] faith. Well, why didn't God just give him
- 3:31[Speaker 2] the faith then? If God gives us faith,
- 3:35[Speaker 2] why is he lambasting or at least scolding
- 3:38[Speaker 2] Israel? In fact, why did he do it
- 3:40[Speaker 2] throughout the old testament? If God just gives
- 3:43[Speaker 2] people
- 3:43[Speaker 0] faith, why does he, why is he saying
- 3:48[Speaker 0] you guys don't have faith? Get it, repent
- 3:50[Speaker 0] and believe
- 3:52[Speaker 2] because human beings have a free choice. That's
- 3:54[Speaker 2] why. And then in chapter ten, Paul says,
- 4:00[Speaker 2] Brothers, my heart's desire and prayer to God
- 4:03[Speaker 2] for the Israelites is that they may be
- 4:05[Speaker 2] saved. See, Paul wants them to be saved.
- 4:07[Speaker 2] That's why he's taken this three chapter detour
- 4:11[Speaker 2] in the book of Romans. First two of
- 4:14[Speaker 2] chapter ten says, for I can righteousness that
- 4:22[Speaker 2] comes from God and sought to establish their
- 4:25[Speaker 2] own. They did not submit to God's righteousness.
- 4:30[Speaker 2] Christ is the end end of the law
- 4:32[Speaker 2] so that there may be righteousness for everyone
- 4:35[Speaker 2] who is chosen by God. No, for everyone
- 4:37[Speaker 2] who believes. Why didn't they believe? Because they
- 4:41[Speaker 2] did not submit to God's righteousness, not because
- 4:43[Speaker 2] God didn't choose them. In fact, the whole
- 4:46[Speaker 2] point of Romans nine is God did choose
- 4:48[Speaker 2] them to be the nation through which he
- 4:51[Speaker 2] was gonna save the world, but individuals still
- 4:55[Speaker 2] needed to trust in Jesus. In fact, that's
- 5:00[Speaker 2] why Paul is going on and on about
- 5:01[Speaker 0] you got to you got
- 5:02[Speaker 2] to come to God by faith, not by
- 5:04[Speaker 2] works. So the kind of election Romans nine
- 5:08[Speaker 2] is talking about is the election of the
- 5:10[Speaker 2] nation of Israel, not the election of individuals
- 5:12[Speaker 2] to salvation. And then last week, we went
- 5:15[Speaker 2] through the knowledge that Moses had of the
- 5:18[Speaker 2] Egyptian culture and religious practices. That's where the
- 5:21[Speaker 2] hardening of the heart comes from, Because if
- 5:25[Speaker 2] you harden Pharaoh's heart, it meant he wasn't
- 5:27[Speaker 2] going to make it in the afterlife because
- 5:29[Speaker 2] his heart was going to be heavier than
- 5:30[Speaker 2] a feather. Heavier than a feather. And that
- 5:33[Speaker 2] meant his heart was going to be devoured
- 5:33[Speaker 2] by the demon goddess Ammit. And then we
- 5:38[Speaker 2] pointed out in chapter eleven that the clincher
- 5:42[Speaker 2] here is when Paul says in Romans eleven
- 5:45[Speaker 2] twenty eight, as far as the gospel is
- 5:48[Speaker 2] concerned, they meaning Israel are enemies on your
- 5:51[Speaker 2] account. But as far as election is concerned,
- 5:53[Speaker 2] they are loved on account of the patriarchs.
- 5:55[Speaker 2] So he's bifurcating. He's separating the gospel from
- 5:58[Speaker 2] election. You can't do that if this election
- 6:02[Speaker 2] is to the gospel. It's obviously not to
- 6:04[Speaker 2] the gospel. It's the election of the nation
- 6:06[Speaker 2] of Israel to bring forth the nation through
- 6:09[Speaker 2] whom God was going to save the whole
- 6:11[Speaker 2] world. And then we went through the passages
- 6:15[Speaker 2] in Ephesians pointing out that predestined doesn't mean
- 6:19[Speaker 2] you don't have a choice. It essentially means
- 6:21[Speaker 2] that once you make the choice, once you
- 6:24[Speaker 2] believe, once you're in Christ, you're guaranteed to
- 6:27[Speaker 2] be glorified. We also dealt with some passages
- 6:31[Speaker 2] in John Chapter six, and there was an
- 6:33[Speaker 2] entire debate on John six forty four between
- 6:37[Speaker 2] Layton Flowers and James White. We'll put that
- 6:39[Speaker 2] in the show notes. And this is about
- 6:42[Speaker 2] the place we ended last week where we
- 6:47[Speaker 2] said even if God is electing people to
- 6:50[Speaker 2] salvation, it really is unavoidable because any universe
- 6:57[Speaker 2] God elects to create, he knows the outcome,
- 7:00[Speaker 2] but he's not doing it against our free
- 7:03[Speaker 2] choice. He's doing it in accord with our
- 7:05[Speaker 2] free choice. In fact, that's what first Peter
- 7:08[Speaker 2] chapter one says. The very first and second
- 7:10[Speaker 2] verse says this, Peter, an apostle of Jesus
- 7:14[Speaker 2] Christ to God's elect, strangers in the world
- 7:18[Speaker 2] scattered throughout Pontius, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithina.
- 7:25[Speaker 2] Here's the key phrase. Who have been chosen
- 7:28[Speaker 2] according to the foreknowledge of God the Father
- 7:32[Speaker 2] through the sanctifying work of the Spirit for
- 7:34[Speaker 2] obedience to Jesus Christ and sprinkling by his
- 7:39[Speaker 2] blood chosen according to the foreknowledge of God.
- 7:43[Speaker 2] Now, the Bible is written from our perspective.
- 7:45[Speaker 2] It's foreknowledge from our perspective, but it's just
- 7:49[Speaker 2] knowledge to God's perspective. God doesn't have to
- 7:52[Speaker 2] look down the corridor of time and go,
- 7:54[Speaker 2] gee, I wonder. Let me see what those
- 7:55[Speaker 2] guys are gonna do. He already knows. He
- 7:58[Speaker 2] knows all things. He's he's infinite, which means
- 8:02[Speaker 2] he knows everything there is to know, including
- 8:05[Speaker 2] what you're gonna do. Oh, but I don't
- 8:08[Speaker 2] have free will. No. You have free will
- 8:10[Speaker 2] to do what you're gonna do. God just
- 8:11[Speaker 2] knows how you're freely gonna do what you're
- 8:13[Speaker 2] gonna do. He knows the free choices you're
- 8:15[Speaker 2] gonna make. You still have free will. Just
- 8:20[Speaker 2] because God knows what you're freely going to
- 8:22[Speaker 2] do doesn't mean you don't have free will.
- 8:24[Speaker 2] We unpack this more, in the last program,
- 8:28[Speaker 2] so you got to go back and listen
- 8:29[Speaker 2] to the last program. And for people to
- 8:33[Speaker 2] say that, well, you're negating the sovereignty of
- 8:37[Speaker 2] God if you give people free will. I
- 8:40[Speaker 2] think that's absolute nonsense. In fact, I think
- 8:43[Speaker 2] God is so sovereign that he can get
- 8:46[Speaker 2] his will done through our free will. If
- 8:49[Speaker 2] you're saying in order for God to remain
- 8:51[Speaker 2] sovereign, he can't give other creatures free will.
- 8:54[Speaker 2] That's not a very sovereign God. You're saying
- 8:56[Speaker 2] there's something God can't do that's logically possible.
- 9:00[Speaker 2] Why can't he sovereignly give us free will?
- 9:05[Speaker 2] Suppose he sovereignly decides to do that. Who
- 9:09[Speaker 2] are you to say he can't? Apparently, that's
- 9:12[Speaker 2] what he's done because you can't have love
- 9:16[Speaker 2] without free will. In fact, we'll unpack that
- 9:18[Speaker 2] more in a minute. To say that God
- 9:21[Speaker 2] must be a puppet master, that he has
- 9:24[Speaker 2] to make all the choices for us to
- 9:27[Speaker 2] get his will done, I think, is to
- 9:30[Speaker 2] diminish the power and the glory of God.
- 9:34[Speaker 2] I mean, Layton Flowers has a analogy here.
- 9:37[Speaker 2] He says, who is the more glorious chess
- 9:39[Speaker 2] master? The one who can beat you no
- 9:42[Speaker 2] matter what you do, no matter what move
- 9:44[Speaker 2] you make, or the one that has to
- 9:46[Speaker 2] tell you where to move in order to
- 9:49[Speaker 2] beat you. Obviously, the more glorious chess master
- 9:54[Speaker 2] is the one who can allow you to
- 9:56[Speaker 2] make any move you want, and he's still
- 9:58[Speaker 2] gonna win. Not the guy who says in
- 10:01[Speaker 2] order for me to
- 10:01[Speaker 0] beat you, I've got to I've got to
- 10:02[Speaker 0] basically move the pieces for you. That wouldn't
- 10:06[Speaker 0] be very glorious.
- 10:07[Speaker 2] Or imagine a football team. What's a more
- 10:09[Speaker 2] glorious football team? The one that beats you
- 10:11[Speaker 2] no matter what place you run or the
- 10:14[Speaker 2] one that in order to beat you takes
- 10:16[Speaker 2] your free will away by telling you what
- 10:18[Speaker 2] plays to run so they can be ready
- 10:20[Speaker 2] and stop them. Obviously, the more glorious football
- 10:24[Speaker 2] team is the one that can give you
- 10:26[Speaker 2] all the freedom you want and still beat
- 10:29[Speaker 2] you down, still win.
- 10:34[Speaker 0] That brings more glory to God, not that
- 10:37[Speaker 0] he has to control everything and take free
- 10:39[Speaker 0] will away from you. God is so sovereign
- 10:43[Speaker 0] that
- 10:43[Speaker 2] he can get his will done through our
- 10:46[Speaker 2] free will. So, yes, God elected to create
- 10:51[Speaker 2] this universe. And in that sense, he predestined
- 10:54[Speaker 2] the outcome. He guaranteed the outcome. It's guaranteed.
- 10:58[Speaker 2] Why? Because he knew what we do, but
- 11:00[Speaker 2] he did it in accord with our free
- 11:01[Speaker 2] will, not against our free will. Billy Graham
- 11:05[Speaker 2] freely chose to follow Jesus. So far, Richard
- 11:09[Speaker 2] Dawkins has freely chose to reject Jesus. Both
- 11:13[Speaker 2] are freely doing what they're doing. And yet
- 11:18[Speaker 2] both God always knew what they would do.
- 11:21[Speaker 2] He always knew Billy Graham would believe, and
- 11:22[Speaker 2] he always knew Richard Dawkins wouldn't, at least
- 11:25[Speaker 2] at this point. Who knows? Maybe Richard Dawkins
- 11:26[Speaker 2] will come around. He's speaking a lot more
- 11:28[Speaker 2] favorably about Christianity lately. You never know.
- 11:34[Speaker 0] Now, you might say, well, I got to
- 11:37[Speaker 2] point out one other passage here. We've already
- 11:39[Speaker 2] in the last podcast, we talked about some
- 11:42[Speaker 2] passages that talk about how God wants everyone
- 11:44[Speaker 2] to be saved. We talk about Ezekiel eighteen
- 11:46[Speaker 2] thirty two for I take no pleasure in
- 11:48[Speaker 2] the death of anyone declares the Lord, repent
- 11:50[Speaker 2] and live. Second Peter three nine says the
- 11:53[Speaker 2] Lord is slack, not concerning his promises. Some
- 11:56[Speaker 2] count slackness, but his long suffering toward us.
- 11:58[Speaker 2] In other words, he's patient with us, not
- 12:00[Speaker 2] willing that any should perish, but that all
- 12:03[Speaker 2] should come to repentance. Well, I also mentioned
- 12:07[Speaker 2] first Timothy two. I'm going to read an
- 12:10[Speaker 2] expanded section of first Timothy two, a few
- 12:12[Speaker 2] more verses than what I read last time
- 12:14[Speaker 2] because I think it's, provides more context. Here's
- 12:19[Speaker 2] how First Timothy two starts. I urge then,
- 12:22[Speaker 2] first of all, that petitions, prayers, intercession, and
- 12:26[Speaker 2] Thanksgiving be made for all people, for kings
- 12:29[Speaker 2] and all those in authority that we may
- 12:32[Speaker 2] live peaceful and quiet lives in all godliness
- 12:35[Speaker 2] and holiness. Let me stop right there, ladies
- 12:37[Speaker 2] and gentlemen. That applies to our country right
- 12:39[Speaker 0] now. Okay. We're just coming out of
- 12:43[Speaker 2] a Republican convention. In fact, as I'm recording
- 12:46[Speaker 2] this and recording this on Thursday, July eighteenth.
- 12:50[Speaker 2] So it hasn't ended yet. As you're listening
- 12:53[Speaker 2] to this, I haven't heard President Trump's, address.
- 12:56[Speaker 2] I don't know how it ultimately turned out.
- 13:00[Speaker 2] And I don't know that Biden's out of
- 13:02[Speaker 2] the race yet. If you're listening to this
- 13:03[Speaker 2] on Tuesday, sources are saying he's out already.
- 13:07[Speaker 2] In any event, this is a time of
- 13:09[Speaker 2] upheaval, quite obviously. President Trump was almost murdered
- 13:13[Speaker 2] last week, And there are all sorts of
- 13:15[Speaker 2] questions. We did a podcast on it last
- 13:18[Speaker 2] week. Regardless of all that, we all ought
- 13:21[Speaker 2] to be praying for anybody involved. All of
- 13:24[Speaker 2] our leaders Trump, Biden, Harris, anybody in the
- 13:31[Speaker 2] Senate and in the Congress, any of our
- 13:33[Speaker 2] governors and state and local officials. We ought
- 13:36[Speaker 0] to be praying for everyone. Why? That we
- 13:40[Speaker 0] may live peaceful and quiet lives in all
- 13:42[Speaker 0] godliness and holiness. A good government is conducive
- 13:46[Speaker 0] to that. And we should we should we
- 13:51[Speaker 0] should pray for everybody, not just so we
- 13:54[Speaker 0] can live peaceful and quiet lives, but because
- 13:56[Speaker 0] we care about people and want them to
- 13:58[Speaker 2] know the truth and want us to lead
- 14:00[Speaker 2] lead us well. Anyway, the next verse says
- 14:03[Speaker 2] this. This is good that you're praying for
- 14:05[Speaker 2] these people and please is God, our savior,
- 14:07[Speaker 2] who wants all people to be saved and
- 14:10[Speaker 2] to come to a knowledge of the truth.
- 14:14[Speaker 2] For there is one God and one mediator
- 14:18[Speaker 2] between God and man, the man Christ Jesus
- 14:21[Speaker 2] who gave himself as a ransom for all
- 14:24[Speaker 2] people doesn't say he gave us gave himself
- 14:28[Speaker 2] as a ransom for just some gave himself
- 14:31[Speaker 2] as a ransom for all people. Now, not
- 14:34[Speaker 2] all people accept the ransom, but God has
- 14:38[Speaker 2] provided it. You know, this is one of
- 14:41[Speaker 2] the problems with the Calvinistic view. You know,
- 14:43[Speaker 2] the Calvinistic tulip. You've probably heard the tulip
- 14:46[Speaker 2] acronym, you know, t total depravity. You unconditional
- 14:49[Speaker 2] election. Well, the L is limited atonement that
- 14:52[Speaker 2] God only died for some people. This isn't
- 14:55[Speaker 2] what this verse says. God died for all
- 14:57[Speaker 2] people. He gave himself as a ransom for
- 14:59[Speaker 2] all people. In fact, probably the most famous
- 15:04[Speaker 2] verse in the Bible for God so loved
- 15:07[Speaker 2] the world that he gave his one and
- 15:09[Speaker 2] only son that whoever believes in him shall
- 15:11[Speaker 2] not perish but have eternal life doesn't say
- 15:13[Speaker 2] for God so loved the elect. He loved
- 15:17[Speaker 2] the world. And that's important because it tells
- 15:22[Speaker 2] you something about the nature of God.
- 15:25[Speaker 0] So, if God wants all to be saved,
- 15:28[Speaker 0] then why aren't all why why isn't everyone
- 15:30[Speaker 0] saved? And the answer is free will. Now,
- 15:33[Speaker 0] you might ask, well, why aren't more saved?
- 15:39[Speaker 2] Why couldn't God have created a universe where
- 15:41[Speaker 2] everyone believed? Well, that's logically possible, but it's
- 15:47[Speaker 2] probably not actually achievable with free creatures because
- 15:52[Speaker 2] even an all powerful God can't force free
- 15:56[Speaker 2] creatures to do what he wants, because that
- 15:57[Speaker 2] would be a contradiction. When we say God
- 16:00[Speaker 2] is all powerful, what we mean is God
- 16:03[Speaker 2] can do whatever is logically possible. But even
- 16:05[Speaker 2] God can't do logically impossible things like he
- 16:10[Speaker 2] can't create a square circle. Doesn't exist. Can't
- 16:13[Speaker 2] create a married bachelor. Doesn't exist. I know
- 16:16[Speaker 2] some guys try, but no. Can't create a
- 16:19[Speaker 2] five sided triangle. Doesn't exist. Can't create an
- 16:22[Speaker 2] honest politician. Yeah. There are some things that
- 16:26[Speaker 2] are just too hard for God. Okay? In
- 16:28[Speaker 2] fact, you can do some things that God
- 16:30[Speaker 2] can't do. What can you do? Well, you
- 16:32[Speaker 2] can. You can lie. God can't lie. If
- 16:34[Speaker 2] he could lie, he wouldn't be the
- 16:35[Speaker 0] standard of truth. God, you can go
- 16:38[Speaker 2] out of existence. God can't. God can, or
- 16:43[Speaker 2] you can change. God can't. What's he going
- 16:44[Speaker 2] to change from? He's already a perfect being.
- 16:46[Speaker 2] Any change would necessitate a move from perfection
- 16:49[Speaker 2] to imperfection
- 16:52[Speaker 0] so God can't force free creatures to do
- 16:56[Speaker 0] what he wants. But he can create a
- 17:00[Speaker 0] world of free creatures where some
- 17:04[Speaker 2] of them believe freely and some of them
- 17:06[Speaker 2] don't. And that's the world God chose to
- 17:08[Speaker 2] create. Is God obligated not to create because
- 17:11[Speaker 2] some people he creates don't believe? Are those
- 17:15[Speaker 2] non believers given veto power over God's creation?
- 17:18[Speaker 2] I don't think so. Why does that make
- 17:20[Speaker 2] any sense? The people who don't believe freely
- 17:23[Speaker 2] don't believe again. If you take free will
- 17:27[Speaker 2] away, you're you're you're creating all sorts of
- 17:31[Speaker 2] problems. In fact, here are some of the
- 17:34[Speaker 2] problems. Well, before I do it, before I
- 17:36[Speaker 2] get there, let me just point out this.
- 17:38[Speaker 2] What God actually did. He created a world
- 17:40[Speaker 2] of free creatures where the maximum number
- 17:43[Speaker 0] of people believe in the minimum number of
- 17:46[Speaker 0] people don't believe. And he
- 17:49[Speaker 2] knew that before he created this universe, he
- 17:51[Speaker 2] knew some would believe in some wouldn't. And
- 17:55[Speaker 2] so that's the universe we have. And people
- 17:59[Speaker 2] are freely believing and freely rejecting. God wants
- 18:04[Speaker 2] all of them to believe, but some of
- 18:06[Speaker 2] them don't because they have free will. Now,
- 18:08[Speaker 2] what are the stakes of believing in this
- 18:11[Speaker 2] hard five point Calvinism? What are the implications?
- 18:14[Speaker 2] Well, my coauthor, Doctor. Norman Geiser, who dealt
- 18:17[Speaker 2] in this manner quite a bit, in fact,
- 18:18[Speaker 2] he wrote a book on it called Chosen
- 18:21[Speaker 2] But Free, a great book to get if
- 18:23[Speaker 2] you want to get into this in much
- 18:24[Speaker 2] more detail, Pointed out that he's had several
- 18:28[Speaker 2] people come to him who were just depressed
- 18:31[Speaker 2] with fatalism, Even pastors. There's been pastors he's
- 18:35[Speaker 2] known that one pastor is about to give
- 18:38[Speaker 2] up being a pastor until he read chosen
- 18:41[Speaker 2] but free and he said just just liberated
- 18:43[Speaker 2] my mind.
- 18:45[Speaker 0] Because I really thought, you know, what? Why
- 18:46[Speaker 0] am
- 18:46[Speaker 2] I even doing evangelism? I mean, what if
- 18:48[Speaker 2] God is pulling all the strings? What's the
- 18:50[Speaker 2] point? Yeah, exactly. No, this doesn't necessarily prove
- 18:54[Speaker 2] Calvinism's fault. It's just a real big negative
- 18:58[Speaker 2] implication of it. Well, actually, I might say
- 19:03[Speaker 2] that the real hard for five point Calvinism,
- 19:05[Speaker 2] if true, would be impossible to prove why.
- 19:08[Speaker 2] Because if God makes all our choices for
- 19:10[Speaker 2] us, then he's making the choice for what
- 19:15[Speaker 2] we believe. If he's making the choice for
- 19:18[Speaker 2] what we believe, that would mean that some
- 19:21[Speaker 2] people are believing false things and God is
- 19:25[Speaker 2] giving them those false thoughts. So now God
- 19:28[Speaker 2] is a deceiver. So how can we trust
- 19:31[Speaker 2] a deceiver at all? So this is a
- 19:35[Speaker 2] problem if God is giving us
- 19:37[Speaker 0] all our thoughts. Now, to be fair, one
- 19:40[Speaker 2] of the great five point Calvinists was RC
- 19:42[Speaker 2] Sproul. And I love RC Sproul. I mean,
- 19:44[Speaker 2] he passed away six, seven years ago. He
- 19:46[Speaker 2] was a great teacher. And what he said,
- 19:50[Speaker 2] he basically said, we do have free will
- 19:52[Speaker 2] to make certain choices, but not the the
- 19:55[Speaker 2] free will to choose God. So Doctor. Sproul's
- 20:01[Speaker 2] position appeared to be less deterministic than, say,
- 20:03[Speaker 2] the materialistic atheists who say that, you know,
- 20:06[Speaker 2] we're just like moist robots. They will say
- 20:09[Speaker 2] that God gave or they will say that
- 20:11[Speaker 2] physics gave us all our thoughts where maybe
- 20:13[Speaker 2] the hard five point Calvinist will say, God
- 20:15[Speaker 2] gave us all our thoughts. But Sproul is
- 20:18[Speaker 2] kind of taking a middle position saying, no,
- 20:19[Speaker 2] no, no. You know, we still have the
- 20:22[Speaker 2] free will to make some choices, just not
- 20:26[Speaker 2] the choice to choose Jesus. Now, that would
- 20:29[Speaker 2] appear to me to be really kind of
- 20:31[Speaker 2] arbitrary. Why would God give us the free
- 20:34[Speaker 2] will to make choices that aren't as momentous?
- 20:37[Speaker 2] Certainly not the most momentous choice we could
- 20:39[Speaker 2] ever make, whether or not to follow Jesus.
- 20:41[Speaker 2] Why would he give us free will to
- 20:43[Speaker 2] do the more trivial choices but not the
- 20:46[Speaker 2] ultimate choice? That doesn't seem to make sense.
- 20:51[Speaker 2] And in fact, here's the problem. It makes
- 20:56[Speaker 2] God, Calvinism does this hard five point Calvinism,
- 20:59[Speaker 2] the author of evil. Because if God is
- 21:04[Speaker 2] giving us is making all our choices, if
- 21:07[Speaker 2] we don't really have free will, then God
- 21:12[Speaker 2] is the one making those choices for us.
- 21:14[Speaker 2] And some of the choices we make are
- 21:16[Speaker 2] evil. Many years ago, Doctor. Geissler debated a
- 21:21[Speaker 2] another Dallas Seminary professor when Doctor. Geissler was
- 21:24[Speaker 2] there in the 1980s, a man by the
- 21:26[Speaker 2] name of John Gerstner and John Gerstner was
- 21:28[Speaker 2] a big follower of of Jonathan Edwards, who
- 21:31[Speaker 2] was also a five point Calvinist, as I
- 21:33[Speaker 2] understand it anyway. And Geissler and Gerstner were
- 21:36[Speaker 2] having this debate on five point Calvinism. And
- 21:39[Speaker 2] at one point, Geissler asked Gerstner this question,
- 21:43[Speaker 2] does man have free will? And Gerstner said,
- 21:46[Speaker 2] yes, man has free will to do what
- 21:50[Speaker 2] he desires, but God gives him the desire
- 21:53[Speaker 2] of his heart. So Geisler said, well, who
- 21:56[Speaker 2] gave Adam the desire to sin? And Gerstner
- 22:00[Speaker 2] said, mystery. And Geisler said, contradiction.
- 22:05[Speaker 0] Why? Why do you punt to mystery when
- 22:09[Speaker 0] you get back to
- 22:10[Speaker 2] the choice of Adam? Because to say that
- 22:14[Speaker 2] God gave Adam the desire to sin would
- 22:16[Speaker 2] make God the author of evil. That's why
- 22:18[Speaker 2] Gerstner tried to avoid it by saying it's
- 22:20[Speaker 2] a mystery. No, either gave him the choice
- 22:23[Speaker 2] or not. If he did give him the
- 22:26[Speaker 2] choice, then God is the author of evil.
- 22:28[Speaker 2] If he didn't give him the choice, then
- 22:29[Speaker 2] Calvinism is false.
- 22:34[Speaker 0] So which is it
- 22:37[Speaker 2] now? The problem here is, is that when
- 22:41[Speaker 2] you make God the author of evil, you
- 22:43[Speaker 2] make him more like Allah.
- 22:44[Speaker 0] Now, let me be clear
- 22:45[Speaker 2] on something here. Ladies and gentlemen, I don't
- 22:47[Speaker 2] want to impugn all Calvinists with this because
- 22:53[Speaker 2] just because this might be true, what I'm
- 22:56[Speaker 2] saying doesn't mean that everybody realizes it. I
- 23:00[Speaker 2] mean, I discover new things all the time,
- 23:03[Speaker 2] and I didn't know that a previous belief
- 23:05[Speaker 2] I had led to this other belief. And
- 23:08[Speaker 2] if I had, maybe I'd reevaluate the first
- 23:11[Speaker 2] belief. So just because this might be news
- 23:14[Speaker 2] to you, or this might be news to
- 23:18[Speaker 2] you if in fact my reason is correct
- 23:21[Speaker 2] here doesn't mean that you knew this because
- 23:26[Speaker 2] look, we obviously, if it's news to you,
- 23:29[Speaker 2] you didn't know it. I learned stuff all
- 23:31[Speaker 2] the time.
- 23:31[Speaker 0] I didn't realize those two beliefs were connected.
- 23:35[Speaker 0] The problem is, I think these are connected.
- 23:37[Speaker 2] I think that if hard five point Calvinism
- 23:39[Speaker 2] is true, that God makes choices, particularly when
- 23:42[Speaker 2] it comes to salvation, then God is the
- 23:45[Speaker 2] author of evil because he then, against
- 23:48[Speaker 0] the free will
- 23:49[Speaker 2] of the individual, sends people made in
- 23:52[Speaker 0] his image to hell against their will. That
- 23:56[Speaker 0] would appear to
- 23:57[Speaker 2] me to be evil. You don't have, a
- 24:01[Speaker 2] free choice, and yet God is punishing you.
- 24:06[Speaker 2] Now, think think about it this way, ladies
- 24:07[Speaker 2] and gentlemen. If we deny that we have
- 24:09[Speaker 2] free will, then there's no basis for moral
- 24:11[Speaker 2] accountability. I mean, how can people be held
- 24:13[Speaker 2] morally responsible for their, say, chemical reactions or
- 24:20[Speaker 2] for a thought that God gave them an
- 24:23[Speaker 2] evil thought that they went ahead and did
- 24:26[Speaker 2] that they had no choice to do otherwise.
- 24:29[Speaker 2] There's also no basis for reason why. Because
- 24:31[Speaker 2] reason depends on the ability to choose between
- 24:34[Speaker 2] at least one correct proposition and at least
- 24:37[Speaker 2] one incorrect proposition. So how could people engage
- 24:40[Speaker 2] in debate if all propositions are the result
- 24:43[Speaker 2] of deterministic matter in motion? Now, this, of
- 24:47[Speaker 2] course, isn't necessarily the Calvinist point
- 24:50[Speaker 0] of view, but it certainly is the deterministic
- 24:52[Speaker 0] point of view. And sometimes Calvinists do take
- 24:56[Speaker 0] this point
- 24:56[Speaker 2] of view. They will just say it's not
- 24:58[Speaker 2] determined by just matter in motion.
- 25:00[Speaker 0] It's determined by God giving you those choices.
- 25:03[Speaker 0] Well, why is God given me a choice
- 25:07[Speaker 0] that's either evil or false?
- 25:12[Speaker 2] And, of course, without free will, we would
- 25:15[Speaker 2] be forced to defend the absurd notion that
- 25:21[Speaker 2] the universe made itself. Well, you could say
- 25:23[Speaker 2] God had free will to make the universe
- 25:24[Speaker 2] okay. But then everything from cars to computers
- 25:27[Speaker 2] that we
- 25:27[Speaker 0] made was made by not our free choice.
- 25:34[Speaker 0] Now, if you want to say God did
- 25:35[Speaker 0] it all, okay, God's given us choices to
- 25:39[Speaker 0] do good things, but
- 25:39[Speaker 2] it also means he's given us choices. Or
- 25:42[Speaker 2] let me put
- 25:43[Speaker 0] it another way. He's making choices for us
- 25:45[Speaker 0] to do evil. This is this is
- 25:48[Speaker 2] a problem, ladies and gentlemen. Whether you're a
- 25:53[Speaker 2] determinist in the atheistic sense where just molecules
- 25:57[Speaker 2] bumping into one another are causing us to
- 25:59[Speaker 2] do things, or you're a hard five point
- 26:01[Speaker 2] Calvinist saying that God is causing us to
- 26:04[Speaker 2] do all these things. You've got a problem
- 26:07[Speaker 2] because you don't have moral responsibility either way.
- 26:12[Speaker 2] And it makes the author of all this
- 26:15[Speaker 2] doing evil himself. Of course, this would also
- 26:19[Speaker 2] make love a problem. I've heard some people
- 26:21[Speaker 2] say some Calvinists say, well, no, you you
- 26:25[Speaker 2] don't need free will to love. You just
- 26:27[Speaker 2] love your kids. That kind
- 26:28[Speaker 0] of thing. Well, there may be instances where
- 26:31[Speaker 0] you just love people because say
- 26:32[Speaker 2] they're your children, they're your family. But love
- 26:36[Speaker 2] is not merely a feeling. How can you
- 26:38[Speaker 2] love your enemies if love is
- 26:40[Speaker 0] a feeling? You can't because you don't feel
- 26:44[Speaker 0] good about your enemies. And how can you
- 26:47[Speaker 0] vow to love someone in marriage If love
- 26:52[Speaker 0] is merely a feeling? You can't you can't
- 26:55[Speaker 0] feel a certain way for
- 26:56[Speaker 2] the next fifty years. You can't say I'll
- 26:58[Speaker 2] never be tired. I'll never be hungry. I'll
- 27:00[Speaker 2] never get angry again. You can't. That would
- 27:03[Speaker 2] be like saying that when you're at the
- 27:05[Speaker 2] marriage altar to say, Oh, I love you.
- 27:07[Speaker 2] And it's all built on feelings. I'm gonna
- 27:10[Speaker 2] feel like I love you for the next
- 27:11[Speaker 2] fifty years. You can't do that. In fact,
- 27:15[Speaker 2] that's why you take a vow. Because love
- 27:19[Speaker 2] isn't based on feelings. Feelings may start a
- 27:23[Speaker 2] relationship, but feelings don't necessarily keep a relationship
- 27:26[Speaker 2] going. That's why you have a vow. You
- 27:29[Speaker 2] don't need a vow when you feel really
- 27:31[Speaker 2] good about the other person, when you're infatuated
- 27:33[Speaker 2] with the other person, and all you wanna
- 27:34[Speaker 2] do is be with the other person. You're
- 27:36[Speaker 2] all lovey dovey. You don't need a vow.
- 27:40[Speaker 2] You need a vow when you wake up
- 27:41[Speaker 2] ten years into the marriage and you look
- 27:43[Speaker 2] over at the person next to you and
- 27:45[Speaker 2] you go, you again. Why did it have
- 27:49[Speaker 2] to be you again? That's when you need
- 27:51[Speaker 2] a vow,
- 27:54[Speaker 0] And you need free will in order to
- 27:57[Speaker 0] carry out the vow. If you don't have
- 28:01[Speaker 0] free will, then how can
- 28:02[Speaker 2] you be held accountable for wanting to walk
- 28:03[Speaker 2] out of your marriage?
- 28:06[Speaker 0] God gave you the the desire to walk
- 28:09[Speaker 0] out
- 28:09[Speaker 2] of your marriage. Despite the fact he says
- 28:12[Speaker 2] don't do it. If the hard five point
- 28:15[Speaker 2] Calvinistic view is true that we don't have
- 28:18[Speaker 2] free will, This whole universe is a sham.
- 28:22[Speaker 2] We're just puppets to the puppet master. And
- 28:27[Speaker 2] this whole moral accountability, good and evil doesn't
- 28:31[Speaker 2] really exist. That's a really high price to
- 28:35[Speaker 2] pay. In fact, why would Jesus even need
- 28:39[Speaker 2] to come if no one ever really did
- 28:43[Speaker 2] evil?
- 28:46[Speaker 0] The whole reason that Christianity or that Jesus
- 28:51[Speaker 0] came was to save us from the problem
- 28:54[Speaker 0] of evil. If none of
- 28:57[Speaker 2] us ever did evil, there'd be no need
- 28:58[Speaker 2] for Jesus to come and save us. But
- 29:01[Speaker 2] we did do evil and we still do
- 29:03[Speaker 2] evil. That's why Jesus needed to come. And
- 29:06[Speaker 2] we did evil and do evil because we're
- 29:09[Speaker 2] corrupt, because our natures are bent that way
- 29:13[Speaker 2] and we make free choices to do evil.
- 29:19[Speaker 2] God doesn't make all the choices for us.
- 29:23[Speaker 0] So there
- 29:25[Speaker 2] are many other passages maybe
- 29:27[Speaker 0] we could talk about, but I think when
- 29:31[Speaker 0] you look
- 29:32[Speaker 2] at Romans nine, Ephesians one, John six, they
- 29:36[Speaker 2] don't do what the Calvinists think they do.
- 29:39[Speaker 2] We are chosen because God knows all things,
- 29:43[Speaker 2] but we're still free. He's chosen this world
- 29:48[Speaker 2] knowing what we would freely do. Yahweh is
- 29:51[Speaker 2] not Allah. He loves all and he wants
- 29:54[Speaker 2] all to be saved. For God so loved
- 29:59[Speaker 2] the world that he gave his one and
- 30:01[Speaker 2] only son that whoever believes in him shall
- 30:03[Speaker 2] not perish but have eternal life. That's true,
- 30:09[Speaker 2] ladies and gentlemen. Hard five point Calvinism isn't
- 30:13[Speaker 2] true, thankfully. Now we're going to investigate more
- 30:18[Speaker 2] of this, particularly the whole hardening of the
- 30:21[Speaker 2] heart motif that Moses talks about and Paul
- 30:26[Speaker 2] talks about when we go to Egypt this
- 30:29[Speaker 2] December. We're going to Egypt and Saudi Arabia
- 30:31[Speaker 2] to see the real Mount Sinai. And we're
- 30:34[Speaker 2] going to look at evidence for the exodus.
- 30:36[Speaker 2] We're going to see all the amazing sites
- 30:38[Speaker 2] in Egypt. We're going to see evidence for
- 30:41[Speaker 2] maybe even Joseph Moses, the Exodus. And then
- 30:45[Speaker 2] we're going to go and actually climb what
- 30:48[Speaker 2] we think is the real Mount Sinai in
- 30:50[Speaker 2] Saudi Arabia. Go to cross examine dot org,
- 30:53[Speaker 2] click on events. You'll see that trip there.
- 30:57[Speaker 2] We're only taking one bus. We're about half
- 31:00[Speaker 2] full right now. You don't want to miss
- 31:02[Speaker 2] this. It's going to be wonderful. A trip
- 31:05[Speaker 2] of a lifetime. And we're going to stay
- 31:07[Speaker 2] in the best places so you can enjoy
- 31:10[Speaker 2] yourself and rest when we're not out there
- 31:12[Speaker 2] seeing the amazing sights that very few people
- 31:15[Speaker 2] get to see. All right, friends. Great being
- 31:17[Speaker 2] with you. Oh, and by the way, don't
- 31:19[Speaker 2] forget the online course How to Convince People
- 31:23[Speaker 2] to be Pro Life with the great Scott
- 31:26[Speaker 2] Klusendorf. It starts August fifth, and, it's a
- 31:32[Speaker 2] course that will help you be better equipped
- 31:36[Speaker 2] to deal with the most divisive issue, one
- 31:38[Speaker 2] of the most divisive issues in our country,
- 31:40[Speaker 2] the issue of abortion. It starts again August
- 31:42[Speaker 2] fifth. And if you're part of the premium
- 31:44[Speaker 2] version, you're going to want to be a
- 31:47[Speaker 2] part of that because you're going to be
- 31:48[Speaker 2] able to ask questions of the great Scott
- 31:50[Speaker 2] Klusendorf on several Zoom sessions. Also want to
- 31:54[Speaker 2] mention this weekend, I'm going to be down
- 31:56[Speaker 2] in Palm Beach with my friend Charlie Kirk,
- 32:00[Speaker 2] my friend Seth Dillon, Eric Metaxas, Al Beth
- 32:04[Speaker 2] Stuckey, and many other speakers at the Believer's
- 32:07[Speaker 2] Summit put out put out by TP USA
- 32:11[Speaker 2] Faith. If you wanna be a part of
- 32:12[Speaker 2] that, and I hope you do, there's gonna
- 32:14[Speaker 2] be several thousand believers there in Palm Beach.
- 32:17[Speaker 2] Go to cross examine dot org. Click on
- 32:19[Speaker 2] events. You will see it there. And Lord
- 32:20[Speaker 2] willing I'll either see you there or I'll