Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] Adobe Deep Dive Analysis: Stock Is Priced Like Zero Growth?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive, where we take all the complex
- 0:03research, all the data, and we boil it down into the insights
- 0:06you actually need. Today we're tackling a
- 0:09fascinating 1A giant in the software world, Adobe ticker
- 0:15ADBE. And this is such an important
- 0:17story right now because Adobe isn't just, you know, some big
- 0:20software company. It's historically one of the
- 0:22most resilient, most profitable franchises in all of tech.
- 0:26You have to remember they pulled off what seemed impossible about
- 0:30a decade ago under their CEO Shantanu Narayan.
- 0:33Oh, that pivot was legendary. From selling, you know, software
- 0:36in a box to a subscription model sauces.
- 0:39It was a master class. And here we go again.
- 0:41It feels like history is rhyming.
- 0:43Now they're facing another massive challenge, another
- 0:45inflection point with generative AI.
- 0:47It threatens the very core of what they do.
- 0:50It really does. But here's the paradox, and this
- 0:52is really the core of what we're unpacking today.
- 0:54The company itself is a financial fortress.
- 0:56The margins, the cash flow, they're incredible.
- 1:00But the market is treating the stock like the whole business
- 1:02model is about to fall apart. That is the disconnect.
- 1:05I mean, look at the numbers, the stock's trading at APE multiple
- 1:08of what, around 20.7 times earnings?
- 1:10Historically. Historically it's five year
- 1:13average has been way up there between 35 and 45 times
- 1:17earnings. So this this massive derating of
- 1:19the stock? It's like the market is saying
- 1:21Adobe is done growing. Exactly.
- 1:23It's being priced like a mature utility with, you know, a kept
- 1:27value. The bear case is basically
- 1:29pricing in 0 long term growth. So that's our mission for this
- 1:33deep dive. We're going to use the absolute
- 1:35latest financials. We've got the Q4 and full fiscal
- 1:38year 2025 results right here. And we're going to combine that
- 1:41with a deep look at their AI strategy to really test that
- 1:44pessimistic view. Is the market right or has it
- 1:47just fundamentally mispriced? One of the highest quality
- 1:49compounders in the entire tech sector.
- 1:52Let's find out. And to really get it, you have
- 1:54to start with the foundation they've built.
- 1:55It's it's nearly unbreakable. You really do.
- 1:58To understand why the valuation seems so off, you have to
- 2:01appreciate the just the sheer quality and durability of this
- 2:05business and it all goes back to that strategic shift a decade
- 2:08ago. Let's talk about that for a
- 2:09second. That cloud transformation.
- 2:11I remember at the time people were furious.
- 2:14Oh, there's panic. Going from buying Photoshop once
- 2:17for say 1000 bucks and owning it forever to suddenly being forced
- 2:22onto a monthly subscription. It felt like a cash grab.
- 2:26A huge risk it. Did.
- 2:28But man, did it pay off. That shift to the Sauce model
- 2:32means that today, over 95 percent, 95% of Adobe's revenue
- 2:36is recurring. What's?
- 2:37The bedrock. It is it, it gives them this
- 2:40incredible visibility into their future cash flows.
- 2:43Management knows with a pretty high degree of certainty what
- 2:46they're going to earn not just next quarter, but a year from
- 2:48now. Customers are locked in.
- 2:50And that predictability lets them do something really
- 2:53powerful financially, something called negative working capital.
- 2:57For anyone who hasn't heard that term, can you breakdown why
- 2:59that's such a huge advantage? It's really the hallmark of an
- 3:02elite subscription business. It's actually a simple concept.
- 3:05So working capital is just the difference between your current
- 3:08assets and your liabilities. Most companies have positive
- 3:11working capital. Right.
- 3:11They spend money on stuff before they get paid for it.
- 3:13Yeah. Exactly.
- 3:15They build inventory, they provide a service, then they
- 3:17send an invoice. Adobe's is negative, and that's
- 3:20because customers, whether you're a photographer paying 50
- 3:23bucks a month or Hollywood studio paying millions, they pay
- 3:27upfront for their subscriptions. They get the cash before they
- 3:31even deliver the full service. That's it.
- 3:33Adobe is basically using billions of dollars of their
- 3:36customers cash to fund their own operations, their R&D, their
- 3:40buybacks. It's like getting an enormous
- 3:43interest free loan from your entire customer base.
- 3:46It's an incredible financial engine.
- 3:47Very few businesses have that kind of advantage.
- 3:50And that predictable flood of cash is then channelled into
- 3:53what Adobe calls it's RE strategic clouds.
- 3:57This is the structure of the Empire.
- 3:58Right. So first you've got the most
- 4:00famous one, the Creative Cloud or CC.
- 4:02This is the crown jewel. Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere
- 4:06Pro, all the big names. All of them.
- 4:08And the strategy here has evolved.
- 4:10It's not just about selling tools anymore, It's about
- 4:12becoming a full creativity platform.
- 4:15That means collaboration features, integrating their
- 4:17stock photo library, and now of course, embedding generative AI
- 4:21right into the workflow. They want to own the whole
- 4:24process from the first idea to the final product.
- 4:27From idea to asset. Then you have the workhorse, the
- 4:30Document Cloud DC. Acrobat and Adobe Sign.
- 4:34Not as glamorous, but hugely profitable.
- 4:37And absolutely critical to how modern businesses run.
- 4:39And that's the genius of it. It's a utility.
- 4:42It's all about digitizing paper, legal contracts, HR forms,
- 4:46finance approvals, E signatures. And once a big company builds
- 4:50its internal processes around Adobe Sign.
- 4:52The cost of switching is enormous.
- 4:53It's not just a software cost, it's a process and compliance
- 4:56cost. It's incredibly sticky.
- 4:58It's its own kind of Moat. And that brings us to the third
- 5:00pillar, the experience cloud, or EC, the enterprise brain.
- 5:05This is their suite for marketers.
- 5:06You've got Analytics, Marketo for marketing automation,
- 5:09Magento for e-commerce. So this is designed to be the
- 5:12what the operating system for the chief marketing officer.
- 5:14That's the perfect way to put it.
- 5:15Think about the whole workflow. A marketing team uses Creative
- 5:19Cloud to design A campaign. They use document cloud for the
- 5:23contracts with an agency. But Experience Cloud is what
- 5:27connects that creative work to well to the customer.
- 5:31Delivery, Measurement, Personalization.
- 5:33All of it. So they link creation with
- 5:35measurement and that's something a competitor like Salesforce
- 5:37just can't do because they don't own that creative front end.
- 5:41It's a very powerful end to end story.
- 5:43Which brings us back to that market skepticism, The big fears
- 5:46that generative AI tools like Mid Journey can just replicate
- 5:50the features, making the Moat worthless.
- 5:52But you argue the mote isn't about features.
- 5:54Not primarily. It's defined by two things that
- 5:57are much harder to copy, file format standardization and
- 6:00workflow entrenchment. OK, break that down.
- 6:02File format standardization. Think about a professional
- 6:04design agency. Their entire world revolves
- 6:08around the dot PSD file, the Photoshop file.
- 6:11It's not just an image, it's got hundreds of layers, edits,
- 6:14masks, all this complex data. If a new AI tool comes along and
- 6:18it can't open that PSD file and render every single layer
- 6:22perfectly, I mean 100% perfectly, it's useless.
- 6:26It cannot be used in a professional collaborative
- 6:29workflow. The PSD file is the universal
- 6:32language of professional design. And the workflow part is the
- 6:34human element, the muscle memory.
- 6:36It's the cognitive switching cost, and it is massive.
- 6:40A video editor who has spent 20 years learning every keyboard
- 6:44shortcut in Premiere Pro. Their productivity would plummet
- 6:48if they had to switch. You'd have to retrain everyone,
- 6:50rewrite all your standard operating procedures.
- 6:52For a busy agency on a deadline, that's just not going to happen.
- 6:55That lock in is a much stronger Moat than any single line of.
- 6:59Code and you see that durability reflected in their
- 7:01profitability, which is just elite.
- 7:05These numbers should command a much higher valuation than 20
- 7:08times earnings. Objectively, yes, the gross
- 7:10margin is consistently around 88 to 89.
- 7:12Percent, which is just absurd. So for every dollar they bring
- 7:15in, $0.88 is left after the cost of providing the service.
- 7:18It's the definition of operating leverage in the software.
- 7:21The cost to serve one more customer is basically 0.
- 7:24And they maintain that discipline further down the
- 7:26income statement too, even with all the heavy investment in AI.
- 7:29That's the amazing part. Their operating margin on a non
- 7:33GAAP basis is over 45%. Now it's important we say non
- 7:37GAAP here. GAAP margins include things like
- 7:40stock based compensation. Non cash expenses.
- 7:43Exactly. For a mature tech company like
- 7:46Adobe, non GAAP is often a cleaner.
- 7:48Look at the core cash generating power of the business to
- 7:51maintain a 45% margin while spending billions on AI compute
- 7:56power. That shows incredible pricing
- 7:58power and operational discipline.
- 8:00And the final number of the result of all that is just a
- 8:02fire hose of cash. A massive of one.
- 8:04The free cash flow is estimated to be around $9.74 billion for
- 8:08fiscal year 2025. And that's the war chest.
- 8:12That's what funds the buybacks, pays for acquisitions and
- 8:14protects them from any macro storm.
- 8:16OK, So that's the foundation, a high quality cash gushing
- 8:19business. Now let's look at the reality on
- 8:21the ground. If the market thinks this is a 0
- 8:23growth story, the latest data should show that, right?
- 8:26It should, but it doesn't. They released their Q42025
- 8:30results on December 10th and they really flew in the face of
- 8:33that bearish narrow. It was a classic beat and raise
- 8:35quarter. It really was.
- 8:37The market was whispering about weakness from the Gen.
- 8:40AI threat, but the numbers were strong.
- 8:42Total revenue for the quarter hit $6.19 billion.
- 8:45The consensus was looking for $6.11 billion.
- 8:48And that's 10% year over year growth.
- 8:50Let's just pause on that 10% growth for a company of this
- 8:54scale. It's not the 20% growth of the
- 8:57past, but it is absolutely not 0.
- 8:59Not even close. It shows that yes, the law of
- 9:01large numbers applies, but they are still finding ways to grow
- 9:04the top line at a double digit rate.
- 9:07And earnings were strong too. Non GAAP EPS was $5.50, beating
- 9:11the estimate of $5.40. And they did it without
- 9:13sacrificing profitability, which again points to that pricing
- 9:17power. That's the key.
- 9:18That 45.6% operating margin in Q4 proves they are managing the
- 9:23higher cost of AI. They're not having to slash
- 9:25prices to compete. They can hold that premium
- 9:27because what they offer is still essential for professionals.
- 9:30So let's dive into the segments. Digital media first.
- 9:32This is the core engine, the part the bears think is most at
- 9:35risk. Right.
- 9:36So digital media revenue was $4.62 billion, up 11% year over
- 9:41year, but the number you have to watch for any subscription
- 9:44business is annualized recurring revenue ARR.
- 9:47The leading indicator. It is.
- 9:49Total digital media ARR grew to $19.20 billion.
- 9:55That's an increase increase of 11.5% from the year before.
- 9:58So if professionals were fleeing to cheaper AI tools, that number
- 10:03should be flat or even going down.
- 10:05This number directly contradicts that thesis.
- 10:07It completely refutes it, it shows the workflow lock in is
- 10:10real, and what's more, the adoption of their own AI Firefly
- 10:13features like generative fill and Photoshop is actually a net
- 10:16positive. Of keeping people in the
- 10:17ecosystem. It's keeping them and it's
- 10:19encouraging them to upgrade to higher priced plans to get more
- 10:22of what they call generative credits.
- 10:24So AI is making the subscription more available, not obsolete.
- 10:27What about the document cloud, the sleeper segment that always
- 10:29seems to over deliver? It continues to be the quiet
- 10:32superstar. It consistently grows faster
- 10:34than the rest of the company, often up in that 1718% range.
- 10:37And the driver there is expanding beyond just creative.
- 10:40Exactly, it's about targeting every knowledge worker and the
- 10:43big new feature is the Acrobat AI assistant.
- 10:47Imagine you're a lawyer looking at a 300 page contract.
- 10:50With this you can just chat with the PDF, ask it to summarize the
- 10:54key risks, find specific clauses.
- 10:57It turns a static document into a dynamic database.
- 11:00That's a huge productivity boost.
- 11:02It's massive and it justifies the license for employees who
- 11:05would never ever open Photoshop. It's a whole new Ave. for
- 11:09growth. And finally, the digital
- 11:11experience cloud enterprise piece growth was a little slower
- 11:14there at 9%. Which is pretty typical for big
- 11:18enterprise sales cycles. But these customers are
- 11:20incredibly sticky. Once they're in, they're in.
- 11:23And the big new product here is Gen.
- 11:25Studio. What is that?
- 11:26It's an AI first platform for creating marketing content at a
- 11:30huge scale, and it's doing incredibly well.
- 11:33It's already surpassed $1 billion in annual recurring
- 11:35revenue. A billion in ARR for brand new
- 11:38enterprise product is a massive win.
- 11:40It is. It proves enterprises see the
- 11:42value in that end to end platform.
- 11:44They don't want five different vendors, they want one
- 11:47integrated, legally safe system. Genstudio gives them that.
- 11:51So when the market is this pessimistic, I always look at
- 11:53what management is doing with its own money.
- 11:55That's the real signal of conviction.
- 11:57And their actions could not be clearer.
- 11:58They see the stock price, you know, bouncing around in that
- 12:01320, three, $150.00 range in Q4 and they think it's a bargain.
- 12:06How do we know? Two things.
- 12:07First, record operating cash flow in Q4 of $3.16 billion.
- 12:11They are flush with cash. Second, they use that cash to
- 12:15aggressively buy back their own stock.
- 12:18How aggressive are we talking? They repurchase about 7.2
- 12:21million shares in Q4. To put that in perspective, in
- 12:24Q4 of the prior year, it was 4.6 million.
- 12:27So that's a huge acceleration. And they have authorization for
- 12:30more. A lot more.
- 12:32A $25 billion share repurchase program that runs through 2028.
- 12:36This is management screaming from the rooftops that they
- 12:39believe their stock is cheap. And their forward guidance for
- 12:42fiscal year 26 seems to back up this story of steady,
- 12:45predictable growth. It does.
- 12:47They're guiding for revenue between 25.9 and $26.1 billion.
- 12:52That's about 910% growth. Again, the law of large numbers,
- 12:57but the key number in that guidance.
- 12:59Let me guess. ARRARR, they're targeting over
- 13:0210% total AR growth. So even with all the headwinds,
- 13:06all the competition, they believe they can keep growing
- 13:08the recurring revenue base faster than the global economy.
- 13:11The data just doesn't line up with a 0 growth valuation.
- 13:15All right, let's pivot and focus entirely on that AI threat.
- 13:17I mean, this is the source of all the fear, right?
- 13:20How does a premium company like Adobe compete with tools like
- 13:23Mid Journey that can make amazing images for next to
- 13:25nothing? They knew they they couldn't
- 13:27just build another image generator, they had to build
- 13:29something different, something that solved the biggest problem
- 13:32for big companies using AI. Which is the legal risk?
- 13:35The legal exposure, exactly. And that's the whole idea behind
- 13:38Firefly and what we're calling the ethical AI Moat.
- 13:41OK, explain that. What's the difference?
- 13:43Well, when models like Mid Journey or Stable Diffusion were
- 13:46trained, they basically scraped the entire Internet that
- 13:49includes a lot of copyrighted material.
- 13:51So if a company uses an image from one of those, they could
- 13:54get sued later for copyright infringement.
- 13:56And for a Fortune 500 company that's a non starter.
- 13:59The risk is just too high. Firefly on the other hand, was
- 14:03trained on a completely clean data set.
- 14:06It was all Adobe stock images, openly licensed content and
- 14:10public domain stuff. They know exactly where all the
- 14:12training data came from. They have the receipts for
- 14:14everything and because of that they can offer something the
- 14:17others can't, IP indemnification.
- 14:20Meaning if a company like Nike uses a Firefly image in an ad
- 14:23and gets sued, Adobe steps in and takes the heat.
- 14:26Adobe covers the legal costs and any damages for a big
- 14:30enterprise. That commercial safety is a
- 14:32massive BDB Moat. The value proposition is no
- 14:35longer make me a pretty picture, it's make me a legally safe
- 14:38picture that's worth paying a premium.
- 14:40For But running these AI models is incredibly expensive.
- 14:43All that computing power, How do they monetize it without just
- 14:46crushing their margins? With a very clever system they
- 14:49created the Generative Credit system.
- 14:52It's basically a usage based model layered on top of the flat
- 14:56subscription fee. So how does it work?
- 14:58Every subscription plan comes with a certain number of credits
- 15:01per month. You use these credits for AI
- 15:04tasks like generative fill, but if you're a heavy user like a
- 15:07design agency, you'll burn through those credits pretty
- 15:10fast. And then you have to buy more.
- 15:12You either buy more credit packs or you upgrade to a more
- 15:14expensive subscription plan that comes with more credits.
- 15:17It's a brilliant way to directly link revenue to AI usage.
- 15:21It pays for the high compute costs and it incentivizes users
- 15:24to upgrade. So that's the defense.
- 15:27But they also went on offense in late 2025, buying SEM Rush for
- 15:30$1.9 billion in cash. SEM Rush is an SEO company.
- 15:35It seems like an odd fit. At first glance, maybe, but it's
- 15:38actually a visionary move to future proof their experience
- 15:40cloud. It's all about where the world
- 15:42of search is going. We're moving from SEO search
- 15:44engine optimization to something new, Geo generative engine
- 15:49optimization. Think about it, people aren't
- 15:51just typing keywords into Google anymore.
- 15:54They're asking complex questions to AI chat bots like ChatGPT or
- 15:58Perplexity. And those chat bots synthesize
- 16:01answers from all over the web. Exactly.
- 16:03So for a brand, the new challenge isn't just ranking on
- 16:06Google, it's making sure your content is what the AI chat bots
- 16:10find trust and use to create their answers.
- 16:13So SEM Rush gives them the data to figure out how to do that.
- 16:16It gives them the intelligence layer.
- 16:17SEM Rush can see what questions people are asking the AI's and
- 16:21this This allows Adobe to offer a complete end to end workflow
- 16:24for enterprise marketing the entire content supply chain.
- 16:28Walk me through that chain. Okay, step one, some rush tells
- 16:31you what topics are trending and what questions people are
- 16:33asking. Step 2 you use Creative Clarity
- 16:36and Firefly to instantly create all the legally saved content
- 16:39you need for those topics. Step three, you use Experience
- 16:42Cloud to publish and measure the results.
- 16:44It closes the loop. Completely from idea to
- 16:47analysis, it's a hugely powerful story for an enterprise CMO.
- 16:52And that $1.9 billion all cash deal was easy for them to
- 16:55swallow with their what, nearly $8 billion cash pile?
- 16:59A real power move. OK.
- 17:01So the strategy looks solid, but we have to talk about the risks.
- 17:05The market isn't pessimistic for no reason, and these risks are
- 17:08real. They are.
- 17:10We've got regulatory issues, serious competition, and some
- 17:13governance questions. Let's start with the big one,
- 17:16the DOJ lawsuit. This one could directly hit that
- 17:19recurring revenue stream. It could.
- 17:20The Department of Justice sued them in June 2024.
- 17:23The allegation is that Adobe is trapping consumers in their
- 17:27subscription plans using deceptive design or dark
- 17:30patterns. Is about how hard it is to
- 17:31cancel right and those surprise termination.
- 17:33Fees. That's the core of it, the
- 17:35annual full paid monthly plan. People don't realize that if
- 17:37they cancel early, they get hit with a fee for 50% of the rest
- 17:41of the contract. The DOJ says that isn't
- 17:43disclosed clearly and the cancellation process is amazed.
- 17:46So what's the risk here? What's the worst case outcome?
- 17:48A settlement could force them to implement a simple Click to
- 17:51cancel button. No more phone calls, no more
- 17:54chat bots, Just one click. And if you remove that fiction.
- 17:57You could see a short term spike in churn.
- 18:00That friction. Honestly it's a retention tool
- 18:02if you take it away. That beautiful, stable ARR
- 18:05growth could take a temporary hit.
- 18:07It's a real, quantifiable risk. Then there's the other lawsuit,
- 18:11the securities class action over the failed Figma deal.
- 18:15This one is more about trust and management.
- 18:17It is the lawsuit claims that management basically misled
- 18:20investors. They were publicly calling Figma
- 18:23just a little point product, while internally documents
- 18:26apparently show they saw Figma as an existential threat and.
- 18:30The proof was the price they were willing to pay, $20
- 18:32billion. 50 times Figma's revenue.
- 18:35When that price was announced, the stock cratered 17% because
- 18:38the market suddenly saw how scared Adobe really was.
- 18:41What's the lasting damage from something like that?
- 18:43It just puts a question mark over management's credibility
- 18:47and they come out and say don't worry about this new competitor.
- 18:50Investors are now going to be a little more skeptical.
- 18:52It adds fuel to the bear case. OK, let's talk direct
- 18:57competitors. The Canva factory is huge.
- 18:59It is Canva owns the easy to use, consumer friendly design
- 19:03space, and the threat is that they're moving upstream.
- 19:07Canva for Teams is targeting the same marketing departments that
- 19:10Adobe wants to sell more seats to.
- 19:12And they're even getting into document editing, which
- 19:15threatens the document cloud. They are and that Adobe's
- 19:18defense is Adobe Express, their own web-based competitor to
- 19:21Canva and it's getting traction. Adoption was up 84% in the
- 19:25education in small business markets.
- 19:27So they are fighting back. But it's a fight they have to.
- 19:30Have and it probably means more discounting and free tiers in
- 19:33that lower end of the market, which can put some pressure on
- 19:35average revenue per user. What about in video?
- 19:38Premiere Pro used to be the undisputed king.
- 19:40It's still dominant in Hollywood and big studios, but black magic
- 19:43designs Davinci Resolve is a serious threat.
- 19:46Because the base version is free.
- 19:48A very powerful professional grade version is completely
- 19:51free, so it's capturing the next generation, the Youtubers, the
- 19:55independent film makers. The pipeline of new users who
- 19:58grow up on Premiere Pro is getting smaller.
- 20:00It's a slow burn threat, but it's real.
- 20:03And finally, governance. There seems to be a conflict
- 20:06here. The company's buying back stock
- 20:08hand over fist, but what are the insiders doing with their
- 20:11personal money? It's a good question.
- 20:13The company led by the CFO is signaling massive conviction
- 20:16with the buybacks. But the CEO, Shantanu Narayan
- 20:20has sold about 172,000 shares since 2021.
- 20:24Now, to be fair, a lot of that is automatic sales to cover
- 20:28taxes on stock awards, right? A lot of it is, yes.
- 20:31But here's the yellow flag for an investor focused on
- 20:33governance. Even with the stock supposedly
- 20:36so cheap, there have been basically no open market
- 20:39purchases by any senior executives.
- 20:41If they really think it's trading at a huge discount, why
- 20:43aren't they buying more themselves?
- 20:45It's a fair question to ask. And there's one last risk
- 20:48related to AIA congressional inquiry.
- 20:51Yeah, the House Judiciary Committee started looking into
- 20:54AI censorship in March of 2025. They're asking if Adobe is
- 20:59tweaking its AI algorithms to reduce bias in a way that might
- 21:02actually suppress legal speech. It's a tightrope.
- 21:05To walk an incredibly fine line. Their whole enterprise mode is
- 21:08built on safety, but the creative community wants total
- 21:12freedom. Trying to please regulators and
- 21:14corporate clients at the same time is a major operational
- 21:18risk. All right.
- 21:18So we have this incredible business facing some very real
- 21:22headwinds. Let's put it all together and
- 21:23talk about valuation. What is this company actually
- 21:26worth? 1st, we have to remember why the
- 21:28valuation changed from 2015 to 2018.
- 21:31During that big cloud transition, Adobe was growing
- 21:34revenue over 20% a year. The market paid a huge premium
- 21:38for that growth. And now growth is in that 911%
- 21:41range, it's maturing. So the 40X PE multiple is gone.
- 21:44Should it be down at 20? X that's the billion dollar
- 21:47question. So we looked at it through the
- 21:48lens of a value investor like Warren Buffett.
- 21:50We focused on owner earnings, the real durable cash the
- 21:54business generates. And that means looking at two
- 21:56things, the quality of the business and the price you're
- 21:58paying for its cash flow. Exactly.
- 22:00For quality, the best metric is Return on invested capital, or
- 22:04ROIC. How much profit do they make for
- 22:07every dollar invested in the business?
- 22:09And Adobe's number is. It's a phenomenal 35.27%.
- 22:13Now you compare that to their cost of capital, their WACC,
- 22:16which is about 8%. So for every dollar they invest
- 22:19that cost them $0.08, they're generating over $0.35 in profit.
- 22:22That massive spread is the clearest sign you can get of a
- 22:26wide, durable Moat. This is an elite business, full
- 22:29stop. OK, so the quality is elite.
- 22:31What about the price? We use free cash flow as a proxy
- 22:34for owner earnings. That's about $9.74 billion a
- 22:38year. The whole company's market cap
- 22:39is around $144 billion, so you're paying about 16 times
- 22:43owner earnings. A business with a 35% ROIC
- 22:47growing at 10% for 16 times cash flow, That just that sounds
- 22:51cheap on its face. It's a massive discount to what
- 22:54a business of this quality would normally trade for.
- 22:56The pricing just doesn't seem to line up with the operational
- 22:58reality. You know, this kind of valuation
- 23:00disconnect, it's exactly the kind of thing we're trying to
- 23:03track on a macro level. It's actually a good moment to
- 23:05mention for any anyone listening who wants to track total market
- 23:08temperature, you can search and download the iOS app.
- 23:11Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store can give you some of
- 23:14that broader context. That's right.
- 23:16Having that macro view is critical.
- 23:17So let's take all this, the quality of the growth and run it
- 23:21through a conservative discounted cash flow model, A
- 23:24DCF to get an actual intrinsic value.
- 23:27And you were conservative with the assumptions here.
- 23:29Very. We used a WACC of 7.96% and for
- 23:33the terminal growth rate, that's the growth rate we assume for
- 23:36ever into the future we use just 3.0%, barely above long term
- 23:40global GDP. It's a very low bar.
- 23:42OK. So with those conservative
- 23:44numbers, what does the model say this stock is worth?
- 23:46The intrinsic value per share comes out to $626.51.
- 23:50Wow. OK, so the model says it's worth
- 23:53$626 and it's currently trading around $343.
- 23:57That implies an 82% upside. It's not a small mispricing.
- 24:00It's a chasm, but this is the most important part.
- 24:03We also ran a bear case scenario in the model.
- 24:06We wanted to see what the stock is worth if the bears are
- 24:08totally right. What did you assume for the bear
- 24:10case? We assumed 0 revenue growth for
- 24:13the next 5 years, 0 tiny 2% terminal growth rate as bad as
- 24:18it gets and even in that doomsday.
- 24:19Scenario the intrinsic value is. It's approximately 300.
- 24:22And $65 per share. So let me get this straight.
- 24:25The stock is currently trading at $343, which is below the
- 24:30theoretical value of the company.
- 24:32Even if it never grows again, that is the punchline.
- 24:35The current market price is pricing Adobe as if it is in
- 24:38permanent decline. Any growth at all, even the 5%
- 24:41they might get if churn ticks up, let alone the 10% they're
- 24:44guiding for, is pure upside. For an investor at today's
- 24:47price, that is a fascinating. Asymmetry.
- 24:50OK, let's wrap this up. Let's summarize the key
- 24:52takeaways from this deep dive on Adobe.
- 24:54I think there are four big ones. First, the whole story about AI
- 24:56killing Adobe just isn't supported by the data.
- 24:59They are growing at double digits and they found a smart
- 25:01way to monetize AI through generative credits.
- 25:04Second, their Moat. Is real, and it's not just about
- 25:07features. It's about that workflow lock in
- 25:10and critically for big companies, that IP
- 25:12indemnification. It's a business mode, not just a
- 25:15tech mode. 3rd the financial. Quality is just top tier.
- 25:19You've got 89% gross margins, 35% ROIC and a torrent of free
- 25:24cash flow that they are using to aggressively buy back their own
- 25:27stock and 4th. And most importantly, the
- 25:31valuation at 20 times earnings, it's being priced like a no
- 25:34growth utility that creates a huge margin of safety when you
- 25:38compare it to a conservative intrinsic value of over $600 a
- 25:41share, which brings us to our. Final thought for you, we know
- 25:45the DOJ lawsuit is a real risk. It could force that Click to
- 25:47cancel feature and that might hurt growth for a little while,
- 25:50but think about the price you're.
- 25:52Paying even if that risk happens, even if it knocks their
- 25:54growth rate down from 10% to say just 5% for a year or two, you
- 25:58are still buying the company today for less than its
- 26:00theoretical no growth value of $365.
- 26:03How much safer can an investment get?
- 26:05This company is just so much more robust than its stock price
- 26:08is giving it credit for. A great way to end it.
- 26:11And remember, all this analysis is based on public information
- 26:14and it's for educational purposes only.
- 26:16It is not investment advice. Please do your own due
- 26:18diligence. And if you want to hear more
- 26:21deep dives like this, you can join our Deep Value Club
- 26:23membership or subscribe to our channel Deep Value Investing on
- 26:27Apple or Spotify podcasts. We'll see you next time on the.
- 26:29DDAF.