Latest / Braver New Worlds / Healing, Reparations and “Becoming a Good Relative” with Hilary Giovale
Transcript
- Nathan Young: Hello and welcome to another episode of Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. I think a lot of us remember 2020 when COVID mixed with the murder of George Floyd and the outcry that ensued, it forced a lot of us to look at our own connection to racism and privilege and culpability in some new, uncomfortable ways. And for some of us this was like a very welcome awakening. For some of us this was very uncomfortable. And for others it was like just they weren't even gonna approach it It definitely brought out a lot in our world and it was, a big awakening for a lot of us, I think. And it was definitely uncomfortable for me. I was always starting to kinda question a lot of my own beliefs and my own thoughts and always wanted to do the right thing in those regards and was h felt like I had a lot to learn and a lot to figure it out. And it was just a very weird time in my life to try and sort out everything that was happening in the world. Meanwhile other people had it worse than me And I was just relatively comfortable sitting at home with pandemic going on all around us. it was just a strange, strange moment in my life of just very isolated as we're going through all that too. But it was very interesting awakening in a lot of different ways. and I'd be lying if I said today that I feel like I've got it all figured out or anything like that. Definitely have my own set of questions and shortcomings and frustrations and things I still feel like I need to learn about and work on vis vis just understanding racial equity and privilege in the world and the lives of other people outside of myself. And how all these systematic aspects of living life in America are part of the problem. theoretically these are things that have helped to elevate me in this intern as well. And so yeah, these are all still questions I'm wrestling with, even if they aren't the type of thing that's all over the news or all over our social media feeds these days, at least relative to where they were in 2020. but I think about it a lot. And so this is the reason why I was very interested and excited to hear from Hilary Giovale about a book that she had written and she was interested in being on the show here. And like I said early in the interview, I get a lot of requests and very few of them are like, yeah, let's I I want to talk. Let's do this. So when she reached out very much was like, yep, let's do it. I want to talk. so Hilary Giovale, she is the author of Becoming a Good Relative, Calling White Settlers Towards Truth, Healing and Repair. it's very much like revisiting that conversation of how are we as white people supposed to be addressing a lot of the racial concerns and injustice that's happened in America that's paved the way for a lot of us to live the way that we are living here. And her work starts with a question that I think a lot of us encounter in different ways is what can we do with a history we inherited, but didn't personally create. How do we acknowledge the systems and harms that shaped our lives without getting stuck in shame, defensiveness, or feeling like there's nothing that we can do? And she offers a lot of different ideas for ways that we can address this both within ourselves and as a society. And a lot of times those two things go hand in hand too, right? And it was interesting for me because this isn't a conversation I've had out loud for quite a few years. it's happened in comment sections and things like that. But it was great to be able to like just talk to a person about it in the way that we talked about it here. And we get into a lot of different threads in this conversation too. We talk about our own ancestry, as well as questions about like land and memory and reparations. And we even get into philanthropy and what it can mean to actually practice repair in our own lives. And it was especially interested in how Hilary reframed the ways that we might have our defensive reactions and maybe think about those or doorways into curiosity and trying to sort out what might actually be going on there. So it's a little preview of what we're gonna talk about, but you don't need to keep hearing it from me. Let's just jump right into it. So here is my conversation with Hilary Giovale. Hilary Giovale, welcome to the podcast. Hilary Giovale: Thank you so much for having me, Nathan. Nathan Young: Well, as I like to start all these episodes, I'd just have the person that's on here with me to just introduce themselves real quick to the audience at home. Hilary Giovale: Yeah, I'd be happy to. I am a white American settler. I live on indigenous land, and the traditional stewards of this land are Hopi, Havasupai, Dine, Apache, Pueblo, and other nations as well. And it is colonially known as Flagstaff, Arizona. So I live up in the mountains at 7,000 feet elevation and Where I live, we sit in the footprint of a sacred mountain. And she is revered by all of the indigenous nations of this place. And she is known to be a being of kinship and a grandmother. And so I always like to acknowledge her. She is sitting over my left shoulder today, and she is a big part of this conversation that we're gonna have today. Nathan Young: Yeah, definitely. And yeah, I appreciate you reaching out 'cause when you start a podcast, you get people that reach out to you sometimes and most of the time you're like, nah. But when I got your emails like, yeah, yeah, let's well I'd like to talk to this person, bring her on. So I appreciate you reaching out. Hilary Giovale: Thank you so much for your interest. Nathan Young: Yeah. And then also so you recently published a book, right? Or is it about to be published? What's the status on the book? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, it was first published in the fall of twenty twenty-four and then in the spring of twenty-six, just a couple months ago, I published the second edition. So it has been Nathan Young: Okay. Hilary Giovale: out in the world for almost two years, but the second edition is newer and it's been a pretty phenomenal process having this body of work that took so many years to just date and birth and now it's out running away running around on its own and finding its way into people's hands and so it's been great. Nathan Young: Yeah. And what is the title of the book? Can you like just tell us like, you know, what's the title and just brief line about the book so people for sub context? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, it's the title is Becoming a Good Relative and the subtitle is Calling White Settlers Toward Truth, Healing and Repair. And there are stories behind both of those titles. I didn't really even choose those titles per se. They were kind of gestated and prompted by some of my readers. And so it's been a really collaborative project to bring this forward and and You know, that process what yielded those titles. Nathan Young: Cool. Well, and I think this is such a great conversation. I'm really looking forward to this conversation. Part of the reason is because I know, as a white person that is like descended from settlers that came from Europe and we sort of know that we've had this effect on this land and that there has been there are people that lived here before we and did and they are not here at the same numbers and like their culture has been for the large part has been erased. And yeah, and I think even Outside the notion of respecting Native American or indigenous groups that are here. I think just like there's a lot of us that are trying to just be good white people or good people like that acknowledge our privilege and understand what that means in the world and just be working towards some equity in our world, whether that's along race or other things of privilege. But it's difficult, right? I think there's a lot of times we struggle to wonder or like are we doing a good enough job? Or are we, you know, what parts of the conversation are we allowed to engage in and where is it like not our place or where are we allowed to ask questions or what's appropriate as far as like asking questions or asking for work or help from people that have been in some of these groups that have gotten the less lucrative end of history. And so I get the impression that's a lot of what you talk about. Is that right? Hilary Giovale: That's right, yeah. and I have also been facilitating groups and teaching classes for years, primarily for people of European descent who are white identified, and then sometimes with people of mixed European descent who may be BIPOC identified. And I think When you're at the beginning or near the beginning stages of this learning curve, it can be easy to be really uncertain about where do I plug in, who do I talk to, what things is it okay for me to say or ask, and what things aren't okay. And what I've discovered along the way is that there's a whole body of work that white people can do with each other and for each other and in community together to help bring us along this trajectory. And we don't have to rely, I think we need to take our guidance from communities of color and we need to heed and pay attention to what they are asking us to do. But the asks have been very consistent across the board, I would say, and it's a matter then of us coming together as white folks and figuring out how to put those requests into action. So there's a lot that we can do. and yeah, the book is a lot about that Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Hilary Giovale: and also the other work that I do is about that. Nathan Young: Okay. Well, it's so I know it's gonna be kind of a big question, but I do want to give kind of some insight into like what your work and like how how it goes and everything. So to the degree that like maybe you could offer us some insight into, you know, a thesis or your process or how you like to encourage white people to interact with these issues and and sort of explore them for themselves. Can you give us a kind of like broad view of that to get a to just to kind of get us started here? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, absolutely. I always tend to start with a story because this is a very personal exploration for me. And the way it started was that when I was 40 years old, I found a book of family genealogy that had been written by my great uncle in the 90s. And up until that time, I had been totally unaware at how early my ancestors immigrated to this continent. And so on my father's side, they came from the Scottish Highlands in 1739. And then that Nathan Young: wow. Hilary Giovale: book that I was reading tracked all of the generations since then. And so over the course of one evening, I found out that they had come In the 1700s, landed in North Carolina, received land grants and enslaved people. And through as the generations went on, it was this path of, you know, receiving land that had been stolen and and that was, you know, only available through the profound suffering of indigenous people who were being pushed off that land. And And then, of course, several generations of owning other human beings and buying and selling them. And so over the course of that evening, it kind of felt like I had been handed my life assignment on a platter. And it wasn't one that I was looking Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: for. It wasn't one that I really even had ever heard anything about. I didn't understand it. But I knew as Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: soon as I read that, that this was the assignment. And so the work that has come out of that discovery over that evening is one that is very relational. It's based in storytelling, it's based in grieving the past and the harms that have happened through colonization and the harms of whiteness, the harms of white supremacy, and also the way that whiteness shortchanges those of us who identify as white because it was only that identity was only made up for the purpose of consolidating wealth and power. it's not actually who we originally Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: were. And so there are many facets of it, but I would say overall it's a body of work that is based in healing. It's not about shaming people. It's not about making people wrong. It's not about self-flagellation, but it is about healing and moving through difficult material in order to heal. Nathan Young: Okay. Well tell us more about that healing piece, 'cause I think that's really interesting. that stood out to me in the materials that you sent me over to read before our conversation too. Hilary Giovale: Yeah, you know, it's easy sometimes, I think, when we look at the way our society is set up. We've got a very hierarchical setup where, you know, it appears there are people at the top who are winning the game, and then the majority of people are in the middle or at the bottom and they are not winning the game, right? But I think what I have come to see over time is that This system of colonialism, of taking things that don't belong to us, of pushing people off their land, of cutting them off from their culture and their language, is one in which no one really wins. Even those of us who find ourselves at the top of that hierarchy, we're not winning. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: for me, the healing is about recognizing that and then about recalibrating ourselves Toward a path of right action and right relationship. because that for me is what real healing is about. and seeing our mutual interdependence and our interrelation and the fact that we all need each other. So it has been a lot of shifting worldviews for me and and learning new ways of being and new ways of thinking. And that's where I've ended up ultimately through that process. Nathan Young: Yeah. it's interesting 'cause I think one of the things that released even through my own sort of healing journey and sort of learning about these things for myself, there was this initial piece where I had to catch myself being like, I didn't do that. That wasn't you know, that what I why is why am I being held responsible for this or this was a me or like even recognizing like the privileges I do have, vis-a-vis like privileges I maybe I don't have too, right? And Want to be like, well, my life's hard too. But there was a lot of one, like kind of getting past that though, it was like quite redemptive to just sort of like deal with the reality of it. And it wasn't necessarily all about like I am this bad person per se. It's just sort of recognized, like, this is the history that it's been. but also just like you said, too, Yeah, that's gonna come back around for all of us. Like it's sort of built into a system of oppression that we're all living in. And for right now, I'm like a somewhat benefactor of that system of oppression in some ways and not in others. And but like that system of oppression is also just finding ways to carve off the benefits for me as we go as well, and kind of pit me against people that even have less privilege than I do. And that's sort of how that system of oppression works, right? Hilary Giovale: That's right. It's all about divide and conquer. That's those are the roots. When you go back Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Hilary Giovale: and you look at how whiteness was engineered and written into law in this country, it has always been about divide and conquer. and once I feel like once a critical mass of of us begin to realize that, like the gig is up. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: Is going to be shattered and we're not no one's going to be able to keep us separate anymore once once more and more and more of us come online in that realization. And this thing you mentioned, Nathan, about wanting to distance yourself from the reality of Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: the painful things that have happened, that's very common. And it's so common Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: that I feel It's almost like a script that many of us internalized Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: in our upbringing it through our culture, even if no one ever explicitly told us that. Many of us have internalized that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: kind of reaction. and it's not unusual to hear that. It's very common. and I actually think that kind of reaction, as you described, can be a doorway. into unpacking that and going, Nathan Young: Mm. Hilary Giovale: hmm, where did that come from? who told me that? Where did I, how did I absorb Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: that message? Right. and once you get curious about things, then all kinds of things become possible that weren't possible before. So a lot of my journey has been about Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Hilary Giovale: that kind of having the initial reaction and then getting curious about that reaction and then working with it until it becomes something different. Nathan Young: Yeah. that was part of the revelation for me too, was like, well, like if I didn't do it and I feel like that wasn't necessarily me, like why am I so resistant to, exploring this and seeing what this is all about too, right? Yeah. Hilary Giovale: Yep. Yeah. That's right. Yep. Nathan Young: I'm curious to hear more about your journey then, because okay, it's like you had this revelation, you found this family journal one night, and you had you know, learned so much about the history of your family. How did you get from that place to where you are now to where like you're writing a book and you're helping people wrestle with this question in their own lives? Hilary Giovale: Yeah. Well, you know, it's a pretty incredible story because around that time, I mean, I still I walk in the woods around Flex staff many, many times a week, right? So I'm always spending time with the trees and on the land. And shortly after I learned all that information, I heard this kind of like whisper coming to me in the trees. I felt like Someone was tapping me on the shoulder and there was a nudge coming through saying, You're going to write a book about this. And I wasn't a writer at the time. And I was terrified. I mean, I had no idea how to talk about these things at all. And that was back in 2016. So it was 10 years ago that started. And around that time, I received a Dilogoon reading from a friend of mine Who is a priestess named Yeye Luisah Teish. And she practices in the Yoruba tradition. And she did a divination for me. And I hadn't mentioned anything about the book or any of this, but she did a divination and she rolled these cowrie shells, and the ancestors started speaking to her. And they said, she has written a book. And so Yeye Teish said to me, They're telling me about a book that you've written. And I said, No, I haven't never written a book. and she said, Well, they're telling me that the book has already been written and you just need to get out of the way. And so that was a very Nathan Young: Hm. Okay. Hilary Giovale: otherworldly and auspicious. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: you know, I could never have planned or imagined such a thing happening. But Yeye Teish Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: is an author of She's published many wonderful books and she was very gracious and she helped me get started. And she listened to all of my reasons that I could never do such a thing and then said, Well, you're you're gonna do it though. You're gonna do it because it came through in an Nathan Young: wow, okay. Hilary Giovale: ancestral. And so she gave me, I Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: would say, the structure and the accountability and also helped me find the courage to to get started. And I'm grateful, so grateful to her always for that. So that's how it Nathan Young: Okay. Hilary Giovale: started. And then it became a whole it was like living with a pregnancy or a spirit or like an entity who was walking with me for years that was just guiding and helping me understand what needed to be done next. It was very intuitively guided. Nathan Young: Okay, interesting. Yeah, it's at that point it just sort of seemed ordained like you had to do it. There was no way around it anymore. Hilary Giovale: Yeah. Yep. Well, and also I'm Nathan Young: Yes, Hilary Giovale: telling you all of the I'm sharing the more spiritual or intuitive aspects of the beginning of that. But then the more logical or thinking side of me also said to myself, I'm the ninth generation since this first immigrant in seventeen thirty-nine from the Scottish Highlands. And Our no generation of our family has been able to actively look at this legacy yet. No one has discussed it. It has not been worked with, it has not been spoken of openly. And so I realized there's some reason that this landed with me. And it's because I'm part of the generation that's supposed to start working with it. And so it felt like a logical thing that assignment came to me. and then, you know, I began speaking with my children about it right off the bat. And I mean, it will be part of our family story from here on out. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I think that piece is so fascinating too, because I think probably for a lot of Americans, it's just like the detachment from history and the detachment from sort of our lineage of who we are because yeah, you're describing the situation of, you know, realizing your family came here or your ancestors came here in the seventeen eighties from Scottish Highlands. I know my family history. My father's side are German immigrants and my mother's side are Scandinavian immigrants and they both went to North Dakota, Minnesota area in the eighteen eighties and eighteen nineties. And that's like that was a big that was the wave of immigration at that time. It was like, you know, the Civil War was ended, America opened back up. I only recently looked into this and was like, what was going on there? But yeah, like the Civil War ended, America had opened back up. But also this was the era when basically like the last Plains Indian tribes or plain Native American tribes were subdued to make that land safe Hilary Giovale: Yes. Nathan Young: to settle. and so like the call was made to to Europe, especially like the German and Scandinavians. I mean, I know exactly this is where sort of my understanding of like the history is a little bit fuzzy, but I think those were probably seen as like the kind of immigrants they wanted and like, yo, come here and move out to that area out there and populate out there. And that was when my ancestors came. And so I'm fourth or fifth generation American. I mean, it was like my great grandfather's parents moved here. But I think it's sort of fascinating because I don't know like after that, right? Or before that. My last name's young. I know that Used to be Hyung is like the J U N G, which is a very common last name in Germany. but I don't know what the conditions were of my ancestors in like Germany and Scandinavia that led to them coming here. And I don't know if they were like doing well for themselves or if they were like marginalized in those communities. And within this like whole immigration discussion that we're having in our country right now. I think about that a lot. Like what would it like, how would we be thinking about it differently if we were to trace our own family roots back to like what brought our ancestors here? And like what was their journey like? And, you know, is there some sort of a relation to the people coming from places like El Salvador now that like we'd find some coinciding circumstances or reasons there too. So I don't know, I guess I'm just kinda riffing now, so I don't know. What do you think? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, yeah. I mean this has been a particularly interesting study for me too, because I have got German ancestors as well as much older Scandinavian generations and then Irish and Scottish. And when you look at what was going on in different parts of Europe, before this whole mass wave of European immigrants started coming over here, there were very many things that were happening in Europe that were meant to dispossess people of their land, to impoverish them, to force them into cities where there was not enough housing and not enough jobs, to strip them of their cultural and linguistic practices, to shame them as being backwards and barbaric and uncouth and ultimately to disenfranchise them so much that there was almost no option but to leave. and then when you look at the playbook of what happened to indigenous people through the process of colonization here, I see very, very many many similarities between what was happening in Europe It was almost like in Europe, our ancestors were the testing ground for these techniques. And then once these techniques were imported over here, they became much faster, much more intense, and more brutal. And so, you know, like I'm thinking about what you mentioned about the the Plains Indian Wars. I have a good friend who lives close to the wounded knee massacre site. And my understanding is that massacre was kind of like The definitive, I mean, the people had been so, so disenfranchised and so harmed by that point. It was like there was nothing to do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: but to go onto these reservations being established by the federal government and just try to survive. Like keep your head down and try to survive, you know? And Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Hilary Giovale: and yeah, once you start putting the pieces together, both what was going on in Europe and then what was happening over here. For me, I see this arc of amnesia. It's almost like we've had to forget. We've had to forget what happened to our people and then what our people did as a result of that. We've had to forget Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: and we've had to kind of anesthetize ourselves in order to go on with business as usual. And I think Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, Hilary Giovale: The opportunity that's opening for us now is to stop going on with business as usual and to actually look at it Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: and to begin thinking, how could we write the next chapter of this story in a different way? You know? because these these things have been playing out for many centuries now. Nathan Young: Yeah. That that is interesting. That even that that connection you brought between like wounded knee there and sort of people getting put in the reservation. Just as you said that, I sort of like had this like pang of a yeah, obviously I've never been anything even remotely like that, but just sort of a fill a familiarity of just like fuck like I don't have any other choice. Yeah, like what like of what the people were thinking, like, I just don't like this is the this is probably the a resignation there and a sort of loss of hope of just like, well, this is like I'm just gonna do this 'cause I don't I can't I don't have any fight left or we don't have the ability to fight this anymore. So yeah, and I think a lot of us have sort of dealt with that resignation on different levels. again, nothing remotely like that, but even just like, you know, when you when you realize that you're out of options and you have to go with something that doesn't work for you. So that was interesting just to feel that for myself here too. Hilary Giovale: Right. I was at a gathering recently in the Scottish Highlands that was hosted by people from Ireland and Scotland. And it was a chance for people of the Irish and Scottish diaspora to come home and reunite with people who still live there. Nathan Young: just in Hilary Giovale: And it was interesting to Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: realize how much Not only those of us who left, obviously we we lost our culture, we lost our life ways, we lost our language, we lost so much, but Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: still the people there too feel like they lost something because we left. So there was this kind of Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Hilary Giovale: incredible reunion hundreds of years later, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm Hilary Giovale: and and this recognition that we all lost when this big rupture happened of people being forced off their land and it gives me Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: hope that maybe we can start coming back together and rebuilding those bridges and those relationships. Nathan Young: You may have noticed that one of the recurring themes of this podcast is that the world as it is isn't the only world that's possible. And the people I talk with on here are often exploring different ways of leading, working, building community and creating change in the world here too. And you also may have noticed that we have a few problems in our world. Things aren't the way that a lot of us would like them. And many of the guests I've had on here have had on specifically for the ideas they have to share about what could make our world a better place. and this all gets back to the kind of work that I do too. This connection of leadership and social change. Very much part of the work I do. I work with leaders to help them own and share their own bold vision for a better world. Sometimes this means helping someone find the message in the heart of a talk they're giving or an overall message they're sharing about who they are and the kind of work they're doing. Sometimes it means helping an organization tell a clearer and more compelling story about the work they're doing and the change they're trying to make. And sometimes this even means helping my clients understand what it means to be courageous And applying that courage to the message they wanna share. Right now I do this primarily through coaching and consulting with leaders specifically, but also with some small organizations. I'm also developing a set of tools and training models around an idea I call narrative leadership, which is a framework for understanding how the stories we tell shape what we believe is possible and our ability to make these stories real. And I'll be sharing much more about this work here soon. So if any of this sounds interesting, it sounds like something that you could use help with for your either for yourself or for your organization, I'd love to hear from you. I'd love to see if we could work together. you can start by visiting my website which is storyculture consulting dot com or finding me on social media and all the channels. It's Nathan Cody Young on all of them. There are ways you can message me either through social media, through the website. So get in touch with me that way. And of course keep listening here. I plan to roll out some pieces of this here very soon. So as more and more of that comes together, you're all gonna be the first to hear about it. So thanks so much for listening to my little commercial here, And now let's get back to the episode. well it's funny too, like again as we were thinking about this, I was thinking about wasn't there a series of like revolutions in Germany in the eighteen seventies also, right? So when I think of the context of my ancestors, I think there was quite a bit of upheaval. So I'm curious to know more about some of the work that you've done around this. I mean, it sounds like you do some facilitations, some teaching, you share this work. I mean, how does that usually go? And who's coming to you wanting to work on this in their life? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, I would say most of the people who come are white identified women. And often they are anywhere between their 20s and all the way up into their 70s or 80s sometimes. But a lot of them are kind of in the middle age range. it comes through a variety of channels. So There is one class, one curriculum that I co-developed with a friend of mine. It's called Rekindling Ancestral Memory, where we start with everyone building an ancestor altar and working with their ancestors and asking for help. And honoring the Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Hilary Giovale: ancestors who were connected to the land and the ancestors who were living in equitable and balanced ways, because we all descend from those people at some point, even if we have to go very far back. Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: so we start with that, and then we move into ancestral storytelling within the community, and then we move into ritualized apology and forgiveness because. this feeling of knowing that your ancestors stole land or enslaved people or took part in a massacre or whatever is very, very heavy. So we work through a ritualized form of apology and forgiveness. And then finally we move into making personal reparations plans. And that's a very beautiful process that anyone can participate in. And I will share a guide with you for the show notes if anyone wants to take a look at that and begin that Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: process of making a personal reparations plan. but that's one example of a class, but many of the classes pull Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: on one or more of those themes. So more recently I've been teaching European lineage repair. So we're talking about how to go back and find the remnants of ancestral cultures and languages and songs and begin rebuilding a different sense of identity that goes beyond whiteness. sometimes I teach classes on reparative philanthropy and the redistribution of wealth and resources and power to communities that have been marginalized. And so they all kind of intersect and take different areas of focus but That's typically the type of stuff I'm working with people. Nathan Young: Okay. I'm curious about so many things there too. with regards the lineage thing, I'm curious if you've ever encountered people like yeah, we actually did the DNA tests or the family trees and we were shocked how much my mom's side of the family was actually ninety-nine percent Scandinavian, which I don't know how common that is. And my father's side is ninety-seven percent German, Swiss or something like that. but I know a lot of other people, their lineages are much more diverse and even the last couple of generations could be completely different lineages too. I mean I'm curious when you do that sort of lineage work for people that come from those diverse backgrounds, is there a different way you go about it or a different way that to address it, or is that present anything Hilary Giovale: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: unique or is it kind of the same and you're just going down different channels? Hilary Giovale: Yeah, we usually recommend that people start by setting up a place in their home to honor the ancestors and asking, where do you want me to start? and then sometimes things will happen. Like in my case, I literally had books fall off of shelves in front of me that told me we want you to connect Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: with these Celtic ancestors, you know? and so that's one approach. And then the other approach I would say is really listening intuitively and starting with the thread or the family line that feels most accessible to you in the moment and beginning where there's the least resistance and starting there. And that's that's valuable because there's a lot of resistance that goes along with this work. There are a thousand reasons to stop doing it, to get too busy to do it, to lose interest, etcetera. And so we need to like have the pathway into it be as easy as possible. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's interesting too, as you say that I'm like reflecting for myself and just imagining connecting with my ancestors and German peasants don't sound like the most mythically fascinating ancestors to connect with the same way that Celtics would or from other parts of the world even. But I guess yeah, that's probably just a little bit of a bias there too, of what to expect from, who your ancestors are and how you would connect with them, right? I don't know. Hilary Giovale: Well, and you know what? I I have felt that too. And that's actually there's a term that I developed that's in my book called ancestral avoidance. And it's a phenomenon that I see Nathan Young: Mm. Hilary Giovale: all the time where it's very common to feel, my people weren't interesting and they had nothing to offer and they were just peasants Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: and they you know, it's very common. I've been through that too. And actually since you mentioned Nathan Young: Okay. Hilary Giovale: German and Scandinavian ancestors, I want to recommend for anyone of that background, there are these free online gatherings that are hosted by a group in the Twin Cities called Healing Roots Community. And there are study Nathan Young: Mm. Hilary Giovale: groups available for people of Nordic and Germanic and English descent, I go to them and I love them. They're taught by a wonderful elder and Nathan Young: cool. Hilary Giovale: You know, we we study all kinds of seasonal traditions and what can still be gleaned and found about their ritual practices and planting and harvesting and governance and all kinds of things. And so, and it's a really great thing to do that in community with others. so we can Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: explore our questions together and our misgivings and our doubts and and also our Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: wins, celebrate our wins of when we're able to feel Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: connected. So I'll share that that link as well to that organization. I just love them. Nathan Young: Yeah, that sounds fascinating and so they're like twin cities, Minneapolis area, Minnesota. Hilary Giovale: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. But anyone can take part 'cause it's just on Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: Zoom. Nathan Young: Okay. Well, it's funny too, 'cause then like that sort of that brings up for me like a second layer too. There's a sort of like a double separation too, because then my family moved to that area of the what is now the United States, like North Dakota, Minnesota, and now I'm in San Diego. my parents left that area and they brought me here. So I know even when I go back to visit family back there, there is a strange kinship I feel. And I know there were parts of North Dakota that spoke German up until pretty recently. So there is some Hilary Giovale: Right. Nathan Young: ancestry alive up there that's not the same that I'm sort of separated again too. And I think that's the story for a lot of people in America where like even though their ancestors Hilary Giovale: Yes. Nathan Young: might have come to a certain part of America and they might have some kinship with that area still, but they're separated again. So yeah, that's fascinating. Hilary Giovale: Right, yes. Yeah, one time I was in a conversation with an indigenous elder and teacher, and he said to me, Why don't you settlers just go ahead and settle down already? And he said, He described Nathan Young: Ha ha Hilary Giovale: the phenomenon that you're talking about. we're all our families are spread out all over the country. We move every generation, sometimes Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: multiple times within every generation. And his Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: point was if you're gonna come over here and settle on this land, find Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: a spot and commit to it. And so I really love that point that he raised because I feel like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: that is important. and one of the reasons that I'm committed is staying in Flagstaff. I've lived here for over 30 years and I wanna continue because it's that longevity with place that helps build the capacity for Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: this kind of work too. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Totally. Yeah. That's so interesting. I always wondered if there was a sort of like to what degree that was a strange like wanderlust that's been imbued in our genetics as being American and all descended from people that came from somewhere else, or to what degree that's like economic pressures also that did that. But it's a really interesting point because I think about this on a couple levels. One is like Yeah, I'm in San Diego, obviously, and there's so many ways I look around and I see both on one hand, the way the sort of natural area land here's been abused, the biggest one. I'm a big nature fan, and so I look at the eucalyptus trees everywhere. The eucalyptus aren't supposed to be here. this land has not been stewarded in an appropriate way. We brought in new eucalyptus trees to create shade and lumber and stuff, and it's done a number on the natural environment here that hasn't been good. And it's sort of like Yeah, see a lot of ways the land isn't being stewarded here because we're just not invested in the actual soil and land the same way. But also even on a more petty urban scale, just the way this neighborhood I'm in right now, I'm this neighborhood called South Park in San Diego. And it's gone through so many other places in the world, neighborhoods in America, has gone through successive waves of gentrification, and each new wave that comes through just doesn't really know about or even think to like sort of respect what was there before. And even on just the dumbest, whitest level, there used to be a really cool neighborhood coffee shop right here that's not there anymore. More and yeah, these new people live in the neighborhood, they don't really get that, right? And and yeah, but if Hilary Giovale: Right. Nathan Young: you sort of expand that out of just the way the land has been stewarded and communities have been stewarded over the years from all throughout America, that's an ongoing story. Hilary Giovale: Right. It sure is, yeah. And I mean, I have the benefit of living very close to the largest reservation in this country, the Navajo Nation, as well as Hopi Land. and I think by being so close to those communities and by being in relationships with people of those communities, I've come to see the real I think we in white culture can take a lot of our cues from indigenous peoples. And how they relate to place and family and land and water. And I think they have a lot to teach us because they've been here much longer than we have. and also they know how to how to do things that our ancestors forgot for whatever reason, you know? So I think there are ways that we Nathan Young: Mm, mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Hilary Giovale: can approach these things with being respectful and reciprocal and not appropriative, but really following their lead, in how to approach land. Nathan Young: Yeah, definitely. So I'm also curious to ask you about so the personal reparations and the la reparative philanthropy. I'm very curious about that. And so like philanthropy's been a big topic on this podcast too, and just how do we fund the important work that we want to do. but so I'm kind of curious to hear a little bit more about both of them. maybe we could start with the personal reparations. Like we'll put a link to that tool that you mentioned here in the show notes. But can you tell us a little bit about what that is and like what that looks like? Hilary Giovale: Absolutely, yeah. Well, you know, if anyone has ever heard any kind of national or government dialogue about reparations, you will know that it immediately Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Hilary Giovale: goes to an basically an argument about how it's not feasible, it will never happen, it's too hard, etc. etc. Right. And so after observing that for a few years, I realized yeah, we really can't count on our government systems to get the ball rolling on this. And it doesn't Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: mean that we can't get the ball rolling because we as individuals Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: all I mean, not all, but most of us, if we've got the capacity to listen to this podcast, for example, we probably have the capacity Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: to start taking some reparative actions, you know? And so Personal reparations plans are really, they really come from your heart. They come from a process of looking inward and thinking about what really matters to me. And who are the communities surrounding me and what is impacting them? And so it's very place based, it's very personal, it comes from your heart. It doesn't come from a sense of guilt or shame. It's much more about Where can my passion and my assets of that could be time, that could be skills, that could be money, that could be land, whatever it is, where where do those things meet in creating the world that I want to see? And so one of the things I love as like a first step in a personal reparations plan is to Do some research and find out about an Indigenous led land tax program, either where you live or it could be somewhere else, if there isn't one where you live, and making a monthly recurring contribution so that the indigenous peoples of this continent are being resourced to do what they see and what they believe needs doing, and letting them have the autonomy and the sovereignty. Over how those funds are used. That's a really great first step. Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: Another great first step can be finding out if there is a BIPOC community near you that is working on some issue. So this could be immigration related stuff. It could be stuff rating relating to Black maternal health. It could be something relating to indigenous land rights. It could be You name it. There's as big as you can imagine. And reaching out and saying, How, if at all, can I help? Could I come attend a meeting? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: Do you need a meal cooked? Do you need some groceries purchased? etc. and often the entry into those types of situations is very quiet, very humble. This is not us coming in and saving the day and being white saviors and fixing all the problems. This is us showing up Nathan Young: Mm. yeah. Hilary Giovale: with small, small amounts to say and mostly to listen and just to really Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: listen for how we can be of service. and that can be the beginning Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: of beautiful, longstanding relationships that will completely change your life. So There are all kinds of injury points like that. And eventually I would say, I have this tool to share with listeners about making a plan, but eventually as you practice it over time, it becomes a life, a life way, a lifestyle, you know, and it comes totally Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Hilary Giovale: integrated into your way of being. And so and it brings An incredible amount of healing and joy and a sense of purpose that is very rewarding. So I would highly recommend that. Nathan Young: Yeah. I appreciate that because it is yeah, not always I think a lot of times the reparations thing is caught up with payments that need to be made or money. And not lot all of us have money, but maybe we do have a little bit extra time or maybe we do have some skills that we could contribute and being willing to offer those on the terms of the groups that we might want to help as opposed to us like yeah, being the saviors. I think that's a really interesting and valuable way to look at it. Hilary Giovale: Yeah, that's right. yeah, about letting our our gifts and our skills meet the need and finding that intersection wherever it is. Nathan Young: Yeah. the other thing you mentioned is the reparative philanthropy. And I think that's really interesting too because I think we talked about this on the phone about community centric fundraising and that's an idea that's been percolating in the nonprofit world. And there's a conversation happening in the nonprofit world to try and get away from thinking about Nonprover World is basically founded on the idea of charity and sort of saviorism and trying to change that conversation more over to justice and we're working towards collective justice here instead. and so I don't know, is that to what degree would you say maybe tell us a little bit more about like put reparative philanthropy and how you see that situation? Hilary Giovale: Yeah. Absolutely. I have come to recognize there are many forms of philanthropy and some forms of philanthropy happen without even one dollar being exchanged. Right. So there is a dimension of philanthropy that is much more about relationship and service and connection, interpersonal connections. And then there's a dimension of philanthropy that is all about money, right? And philanthropy, the institution of philanthropy, developed in the United States because there were all of these industrialist men who were underpaying their Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: workers and amassed these huge Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: fortunes Which then at the end of their lives they could give away and fund, you know, concert halls and museums and whatnot and kind of polish up their image by calling themselves philanthropists, right? And so philanthropy, Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Hilary Giovale: institutional philanthropy has a pretty tainted past and it's still tainted Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: because it's enabled by a broken system that Concentrates wealth into the hands of just a few while leaving most people without. Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: so for me, reparative philanthropy is really about it's about wealth redistribution. It is not charity, it Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Hilary Giovale: is not some kind of benevolent gift. it is literally about taking wealth that has been concentrated and flowing it out so that it can nourish people and projects and the land and the waters everywhere. And reparative philanthropy for me also is focused primarily on returning those resources to BIPOC led organizations. And because of my family's history with both receiving land grants and enslaving people, I tend to focus on indigenous led work and black led work both. And you know, often specifically in the places where my family was doing those things. And through reparative philanthropy you are finding a different way of doing everything. It's about reinventing the wheel in every way imaginable. So you're giving through trust-based lenses. You are not trying to control what people do. You are not making them jump through a bunch of administrative hoops in order to satisfy your curiosity. You are not trying to punish Nathan Young: Yes, Hilary Giovale: them when they don't do what you want. it goes on and on and on. It's much more relational. I hope it's something that will take off on a much bigger scale. And one organization to check out for anyone who's interested in this is the of project and they have been Nathan Young: Yeah. Hilary Giovale: really big kind of thought leaders in this area. So I want to encourage people to check them out too. Nathan Young: Cool. Well, Hilary, this has been great. I think this is probably a good good spot for us to to r to wrap things up here. We've been talking for close to an hour here, so this is this is great. so for people that just yeah, they want to know more about you, they wanna know more about your work and you know, how can they find you and also like remind us about that book again, the title of the book. Hilary Giovale: Yeah, sure. So I have a website that is goodrelative.com. And there's an events page on there. I try to keep that up to date with things that I'm doing. And there are also many resources available for all these topics we've been talking about. and there's a page for my book, which is called Becoming a Good Relative, Calling White Settlers Toward Truth, Healing and Repair. And all the income I receive from sales of that book go to the Decolonizing Wealth Project and Jubilee Justice. So it is an act of reparation to buy that book. and not only for the way the money flows, but also for the content within. And so yeah, if that's of interest to people, I encourage to them to check it out. And just know that there is a whole, even though political climate that we're in is very discouraging right now. There's a whole groundswell of people Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Hilary Giovale: doing this work that is just coming up from the grassroots. So I have a lot of hope because of that. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah, it is interesting to how this idea came out and it was so powerfully in the conversation for a little while, twenty twenty, twenty twenty one. It's kinda come and gone, but underneath it all, it's still there. It's still happening. Conversation's still happening, it's not going away. So appreciate you keeping keeping that fire lit too. Yeah. Hilary Giovale: Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: All right. Well Hilary Govale, thank you so much for joining us on the pod. Hilary Giovale: Yeah, thank you, Nathan. It's great to visit with you. Nathan Young: Yeah, thank you. Talk to you later. All right, thank you so much for Hilary Giovale for joining us on the show. I really appreciated this conversation, especially that shift from history and inherited responsibility more towards curiosity, relationship, and actually taking action. And I think that's a good way to put some of these ideals into practice. And one thing that came up for me is, as you heard, I talked about my own family history in this podcast a little bit too. And the conversation definitely got me curious about my own history. So I did a little quick research on my own family history. Didn't go too deep into it, but I just wanted to know a little bit more about what might have been going on. And I discovered that at least my father's side, the first member of the family, came over much earlier than I realized. It was in the eighteen sixties and he lived in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Came over as a single man, I think, as far as I can tell. And he worked on a riverboat on the Mississippi River there, where it is the border between Minnesota and Wisconsin, I presume. And then it was his son, my great-great-grandfather, that moved to North Dakota. And likely got a land grant that was being given out at the time for reasons we talked about in the episode. likely for the US government to solidify their own hold over that land that essentially annihilated the indigenous populations and pushed them off that land. And so my great-great-grandfather was able to acquire quite a bit of land via that land grant and somehow acquire quite a bit more from there. And that is where the family roots Started for me. And yeah, one of the other things I did too was looked into like what was going on in Germany and Scandinavia at the time And I sort of vaguely knew that there had been a revolution in Germany around 1850. And I'm sure that created a lot of like displacement. But also both those societies were going through industrialization. Rural populations were being pushed into cities and losing access to the land their families might have been on for generations. There were a lot of landless people suddenly floating around in both those parts of Europe. And so I'm presuming that my ancestors on some level might have been found themselves amongst those people. one of the things that I did see though too is that a lot of people that made the journey across from Europe to the United States, they would have actually had some means. They would have had enough money to be able to afford to cross the Atlantic Ocean and travel all the way to the part of the country where they were there. And they probably also had some connections in the part of the country that they ended up in the United States, in Minnesota, North Dakota. So maybe there's somebody that went there earlier and was writing back saying Hey, come on out. water's fine or The land is arable and whatever they said. so the people that came over, they weren't necessarily like the most marginalized folks in that regard, but yeah, they did see that maybe There was more of an opportunity for them in America than there was back home, and maybe they could create a new life for themselves out there, and they probably were making the journey more out of like aspiration than desperation. And again, I'm just generalizing here, speaking generally, based off 30 minutes of research. So not 100% sure how how correct my story is here. But it was interesting to me that I had not really known any of this in these terms prior to this conversation. I knew that there had been these like waves of immigration and I had kind of put two and two together as to why they were going up to North Dakota. And understood where it was in relation to the civil war and other things like that. But this is a little bit deeper than I had gone before in that situation. So it was interesting for me to have looked into that and gotten a little bit more clarity on just like my own family history. I know there's some documentation I could look into too and try and get a little a little bit more into it also. So I will thanks Hilary for the inspiration to look into that. And so if you want to learn more about Hilary's work, you can check out goodrelative.com. I'm very impressed that she got that URL. And we'll also link to her book, her upcoming events, and that guide that she mentioned for making a personal reparations plan I'll include that in the show notes as well. And so with that, thank you for listening to Braver New Worlds. If this conversation gave you something to think about it, Share it with someone else who might appreciate it, and I will see you next time. Thanks so much.