Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Insurance Podcast #9 - Phil Anderson
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors. This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, Zurich Australia Limited, ABN 9200 010 195 AFSL 232 510 and is limited to publicly available information. Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor. Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:30Thank you.
- 0:50Each episode features real conversations with the people who live and breathe this work every day, uncovering the lessons, processes, and the stories that help advisors lift confidence, capability, and client outcomes. Whether you write two policies a year or 200, this podcast is here to help you deliver better protection, build stronger businesses, and ultimately serve more Australians. Let's jump in.
- 1:13Zurich is proud to be supporting this episode. Experience Zurich and OnePath advisor portals with new and improved digital capabilities and an enhanced range of self-service functionality, helping make your business more efficient, saving you time and removing complexity. It's everything you need in one place. Partner with us today.
- 1:36A real treat today with me is Mr. Phil Anderson, the GM of Policy Advocacy and Standards with the FAAA. Welcome, Phil.
- 1:46Hi, Ben. It's good to be here. Thank you very much, mate. I'm really, really happy to have you here. Mate, your voice is one that as a financial advisor, I sort of relate it back to like the familiar uncle, right? You've been around for as long as I have in the industry, mate, and it's always been wonderful to have you on our side. But can you give me a quick sort of background of how you got here, what your journey has been in advice?
- 2:10Well, my career started in the Navy, actually. I did a commerce degree through the Navy, started work as an accountant. In 1994, I went to work for AMP, and that was my first career.
- 2:25real financial services role. But I spent 10 years at AMP, ended up working in risk and compliance. I then went to work in the MLC advice business, running the risk and compliance function for the advice business there. Spent a bit of time doing the same thing at CFS. And then in 2011, I went to work for the AFA.
- 2:48And I was away from there for a little stint in 15 and 16, but back in 17, and I've been there in that world ever since. So, yeah, it's quite a long time in the professional association space, but particularly in the policy and advocacy role. Yeah. Can I ask, what actually is that policy and advocacy role? What do you do day to day?
- 3:14Well, I would say that the key objective that we have is to try and achieve a better regulatory regime for our members, one where they can be the best that they can be, to be as efficient as they can be, to deliver as much value to their clients as they can. So that sounds like a very noble purpose, but it's a really difficult exercise, you
- 3:38So the way you achieve it is building relationships with politicians, with regulators, with other bodies that are influential in this. And then we have to frame a policy objective, a broad policy program. We have a policy platform.
- 3:57So that's being proactive. Being reactive, we are reacting to all of the consultations that impact our sector. And we've seen that through the very recent three papers related to CSLR, super switching and lead generation.
- 4:15So we have to pull together papers to argue our case to get the government to listen to what we think is the most important thing to do and do our very best to achieve that outcome. So it's a difficult exercise, but it's all about...
- 4:33playing with an agenda, having a very clear plan and working with as many key stakeholders as you possibly can to try and achieve that outcome. That's quite the task, right? And like if I just think about the life insurance world, one of my presentations that I do sort of talks about the changing legislation over the last six, seven years. And I think there's been three a year or something along those lines, everything from, you know,
- 4:59Putting members' interests first, protecting your super, all that stuff. It's quite consistent. One question I'm almost embarrassed to ask about this because I think my Australian civics is maybe not enough to speed. But when you say government and when you say policy advocacy and whatnot, there's Treasury, there's ASIC, APRA.
- 5:18local members, House, Senate, and probably some other stuff that I should probably know, but I don't. How does all that work together? So who are you engaging with? Yeah, what's the process look like?
- 5:30Right. And we're on timer here as well. It's a really, really good question. Yeah. So there's many different layers here. So you've got what is politics? What's the parliament? You have the government. You have the opposition. You have the crossbench. You also have structures within the parliament. So you have the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services. You have the Senate Economics Committee, and that's the committee that runs...
- 5:57The Senate estimates process is where some of the regulators get challenged. The committees will also run inquiries. So you'll be working with inquiries. So you're working with many different elements. Then you talk about the government itself. And the key department that we work with is Treasury. So the Corporations Act, ASIC, APRA, they all operate under the sphere of Treasury. Yeah.
- 6:26But in other areas, we're working with other departments. So if we're talking about AML-CTF, that sits in the Department of Home Affairs. So, you know, AUSTRAC is under that sphere. If you're talking about the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, that's under the Attorney General's Department. So there can be multiple government departments and there are multiple agencies underneath that or regulators underneath that.
- 6:54So sometimes it's a complex picture and it differs depending upon what our point of advocacy is. So we'll be dealing with very different people when we talk about AML-CTF reforms as to when we're talking about the CSLR. And even CSLR versus DBFO, we're talking about different teams within Treasury. Wow. How big is your contact list in your phone?
- 7:20Um, so if you, okay, so more departments that I can think of on top of that, you have changing personalities, right? So you've got turnover of staff. I imagine that presents a challenge and you've got changing of ministers and whatnot. Um, does your focus have to shift every time there's an election? Do you have to form new relationships with new people, take them on the journey of education, advocacy and whatnot? Um, yeah.
- 7:46Yes. So if you've got an election that leads to a change of government, then things fundamentally change. But hopefully the shadow minister becomes the minister and you have already built a strong relationship with that shadow minister so you can transition over. Yeah.
- 8:03And look, that was the case when Stephen Jones took over. He'd been the shadow minister for a while. So in 2022, when the ALP got elected, he became the minister. But we'd had a relationship with him for a period of time. So it wasn't as though there was a sudden break and you had to commence again.
- 8:22Look, in other situations, like Stephen Jones retired in the early part of last year and didn't stand beyond the election. So we're there thinking, well, who is our new minister going to be? And we have to then leverage around that and build a new relationship with a new minister.
- 8:43Yeah, we had Luke Howarth as the shadow minister until the election last year. We got Pat Conahan as the shadow minister. And then there was further restructuring in the coalition. And now we've got Kevin Hogan. So you just need to be flexible. You need to...
- 9:02not just work with one particular person in politics. You need to have relationships with others. You need to not just be focused on who your direct minister or shadow minister is, but the people around them. So when we talk about the coalition, it's not just about Kevin Hogan. It's
- 9:22It's the shadow treasurer, Tim Wilson. We're always thinking about the connections in Parliament and you need to have that flexibility to have a relationship with a broader group of people such that you're not just reliant upon a one-to-one relationship. When there's that level of turnover or changes and whatnot, you need to know everybody to a certain extent. Right.
- 9:45Is that why the FAAA, so again, card-carrying member, love it. Is that why there's such a push there for the FAAA members to get in contact with their local government members?
- 9:59That's one of the reasons, but another reason, another really important reason is that whilst it's fantastic to have good relationships with the people who are in the decision-making roles, politics is not as simple as that. It's not a, the boss says this, so we're going to do this. They have this concept of the party room. They have backbencher committees. So there are processes that the political parties work through
- 10:28And they engage quite actively with other members of the party. So we want to have a number of people in the parliament who understand the value of financial advice. They understand the key issues in achieving a better regulatory regime. And when it comes to discussion within the party room, they can speak on our behalf.
- 10:50So that's why it's really important to have influence more broad than just a few people in the parliament. You want as many people in the parliament to understand how important financial advice is to Australians as a whole, but particularly to the constituents in their electorate. Yep. And if they have an ongoing relationship with an advice ambassador –
- 11:13or they may have ongoing relationships with more than one advisor in their electorate. If they have a relationship where they will reach out to that person and say, hey, John, or hey, Jenny, this thing has come up in the parliament. Tell me, what does it mean?
- 11:30What does it mean to you? What does it mean to your clients? We want them to have the ability to go to people and ask those questions. We want a higher level of education about financial advice across the parliament. And that's why we've built the Advice Ambassadors Program.
- 11:45Okay. So I've got those emails and I maybe shouldn't have been as proactive in responding to them as I should be. So I think I might. Thank you. So there you go. One more ambassador for you. So that's policy setting, right? That's in the government. Can you please just talk a little bit more and help me understand the Treasury, so the rule setting specifically with ASIC, APRA, and the engagement on things like, again, specifically for life insurance, things like LIF,
- 12:14How does that work? And how, as a member of the FAAA, am I helping? Or what should I expect?
- 12:22Right, and so this is not simple either. Fraud, question, sorry. So if we look at the law, you know, what we talk about is the law. First of all, we've got the legislation, which is decided by the parliament. The parliament votes to pass a piece of legislation. The Corporations Act, any changes to the Corporations Act, go through that. Underneath that, you've then got regulations, which the minister can set,
- 12:47there's a process that gets ratified by the Governor-General and the Parliament has the ability to disallow it. And there's a certain period under which they can disallow regulations that are set by the Minister. And then underneath that, there are legislative instruments. Now, certain regulators have the capacity to set their own legislative instruments, and ASIC certainly does,
- 13:14And then underneath that, you've got regulatory guidance. So, you know, some of the most important regulatory guidance that we face is Regulatory Guide 175, which sets the rules around – well, when I say it sets the rules, it sets ASIC's expectation around how they expect things like the best interest duty to be complied with. And then, you know, other regulators have – like AUSTRAC has its rules –
- 13:42which the CEO of Austrac can set, and then it has guidance, which is how they expect people to implement it. Okay. So there are multiple levels, and you talk about LIF, for example. Perfect, because that's what I wanted to ask. And this is one thing that most people don't understand. Yeah. When the LIF legislation was put through,
- 14:05the legislation actually sets up the ability for ASIC to set the caps. So the law doesn't actually set the caps. The law sets the provisions around which ASIC sets the caps and some of the other detail related to that. So it's how it fits into the conflicted REM provisions.
- 14:27You've then got regulations that define some of the elements to it, but the actual caps are set in an ASIC legislative instrument. So arguably, ASIC could change those without government intervention.
- 14:43Okay, so quick question as a follow-up. Why aren't we talking or what – I'm guessing we are, but what can we do? What should we expect around that? Because from a life insurance framework, the changing market, what we're seeing, effectively, the sustainability of the life insurance market has been negatively impacted by 60-20.
- 15:0580-20 would see a growth in the life insurance market and more Australians covered. How do we go about it? Yeah. So, Ben, I think I might have set up that as a misleading question because there is no way that ASIC is just going to go on their own and change the lift caps. You go back to the history of it.
- 15:2660-20 was first set out by Josh Reidenberg in June of 2015. It was endorsed by Kelly O'Dwide when she became the minister later in 2015. Can I just ask quickly, how did 60-20 come about? Where's the 60 number come from?
- 15:46So the actual decision came out of the minister's office, Josh Frydenberg, in the months leading up to June of 2015. It was his decision that it would be, at that point, it would be a 60% cap, 20% ongoing, and it was supposed to be a three-year clawback. Right.
- 16:07Kelly O'Dwyer in November of 2015 kept the 60-20 but reduced the claw back from three years to two years. Just to follow up on that, when we look at the mental health review, when we look at other components, there are evidence-based decisions about why certain things are being done. Again, what was the evidence or foundation for a 60% decision? The answer that I can give to that is please ask Mr Frydenberg. Okay.
- 16:37I can't tell you, I can't give you an answer to that question. We were told that was what it was going to be. Yeah. And that was what it became. I understand that some of the speculation is it looked neat to halve the commissions. And the maximums around that time, around 120, was to bring it back to 60. And look, Ben...
- 17:05This whole focus on commissions in life insurance didn't start in 2015. It started back in 2011. So it was really at the end of the journey that that was the number that was defined. There's a long history of things that happened in the meantime. No crystal ball, not expecting accuracy on this, but do you think there's scope at some point in the next little bit? I know the
- 17:30There's a lot of distraction with First Shield and Guardian and we're not viewed in the most positive light. But again, going from 60-20 to 80-20 would result in a better outcome for the average Australian. Is there, do you think, hope for that happening anytime soon or...?
- 17:45So I would not want people to give up hope, but I wouldn't want them to be overly ambitious that it's going to happen anytime soon. You rightly mentioned Shield and First Guardian, but I would make the point that I do think both the political set and the media appreciate that this is about a group of rogue advisors and that the...
- 18:11fault here is much broader than just financial advice. So I actually think we are in a much better position from a reputational perspective coming out of the Shield and First Guardian crisis than we were coming out of the Royal Commission, where the view was that it was reflective of the broader profession. So they're viewed as outliers. We're not getting painted with the same brush.
- 18:34I think so, and I think that probably helps to mitigate the sense that Shield and First Guardian will stop any positive reform. However, what we also need to be appreciative of is that our minister has a very broad portfolio of...
- 18:53He's only going to be able to commit a certain amount of time and resources to dealing with financial advice. And he has a lot on his plate when you think about Shield and First Guardian. So Shield and First Guardian is going to delay DBFO. And DBFO is the next big priority. That's important. It doesn't deliver an increase in commission rates, but it will hopefully make it more efficient to provide advice.
- 19:20But then what happens after that? What are the next things that get done? We need to see the code of ethics fixed. And I think risk advisors have every incentive to get a more workable standard three in the code of ethics. We want changes to the CPD standard. Nine hours of ethics and professionalism is excessive.
- 19:41We want changes in a number of places, including fixing those lift caps. But this will depend upon where it is in the priority list. Before you know it, we get to a point where we get to the next election and we see what happens then. But I don't see it happening in this term of government. I think that there is a continuing change.
- 20:05element of concern about the role that commissions play because certain elements of society see them as automatically negative. I see it very differently, but I think we've got to work hard to make sure that politicians appreciate that they have an important role to play and they actually work in the interests of clients.
- 20:29So this is why we've got to have broad policy programs. We've got to be working with all levels of government, and it's an ongoing effort to build momentum and achieve change over time. I'll ask specifically about something in a second, but I just want to ask, is there appreciation for the current standing of life insurance? Yeah.
- 20:55So we've gone from a large amount of new business to not much new business. We've got a decreasing number of lives insured. We've got increasing premium pressures that flows through to things like NDIS and whatnot. Is there an appreciation of the government level that there's a cliff coming if we don't do something about it?
- 21:13So I do think there is an awareness, and the message is being repeated regularly, but I'm not sure that it is currently at the top of their list of priorities. Yeah. So I do think that, and communicating about this is really challenging. The last thing that we actually want to do is to reduce the confidence that policyholders have in the policies they hold. Mm-hmm.
- 21:41But we do need to be able to put forward a case for why reform is essential. And, you know, there are many warning signs that we're all aware of at the moment that necessitate a close look at what's going on. We do have regulator intervention from time to time, and we have regulator statements. But when it comes to LIF, that needs to be a government decision, and it's not going to be something that's solved by ASIC or APRA. Okay. Okay.
- 22:10Where does best interest duty fit in all of this? Because I've got to worry that with current upfront discounts built into life insurance policies, that at the five-year mark or some other mark like that, the existing policy for a client is so far out of the market that…
- 22:30that I'm effectively forced to at least look at rewriting it. It's the opposite of what I want to do, but with best interest duty, doing the right thing by the clients, I sort of have to do it. There seems to be a conflict there.
- 22:42Well, there's a huge, huge conflict. You know, we go from the reasons for Lyft being to combat the expectation or the assumption that churn is happening. Clearly, the fear was it was happening more regularly than it actually was and that it couldn't be addressed by other means. But 10 years ago, churn was the concern. Was the word, the buzzword. And now what we're doing is we have a market practice that encourages it.
- 23:11So how crazy is it that we put LIF in place to reduce the prospect of it and then we've got upfront premium discounting to encourage people to do it? And, yes, you do have an issue. Look, I don't think it's simple and I think it does draw upon the best interest, Judy, because you've got more than just pricing as a factor in it. You know, we've got issues around legacy products and whether you should hold on to legacy products.
- 23:38We've also got the challenges that come with deterioration in health and disclosure obligations. So you can't underplay the significance of the other factors that might count against putting someone in a new policy.
- 23:55But ultimately, yes, in terms of pricing, you have an incentive to do it. What I would say is the best interest duty doesn't apply to you at night. You don't have to think about your clients at nighttime. It applies when you give advice. So when you give advice, you need to comply with the best interest duty. So if you are not...
- 24:17If you're not giving advice to clients, then there's no ongoing obligation. But if you meet with them and do a review of their policies or they come to you and say, I've got this crazy premium increase, what should I do? Then you do need to take it into account and you need to be prepared to talk to them about these are all the issues that would influence whether we would recommend you change.
- 24:43Yeah. So it's a balancing act and it's a difficult one. Yeah. Is that the solution then? Maybe get everybody in parliament to get a TPD policy and they can see firsthand the 40% increases coming through.
- 24:56That's one strategy, Ben. Okay, so speaking of changes and reviews and whatnot, mental health. That's a big one at the moment. What do you see as the ideal situation? So we have ballooning mental health costs associated with TPD. I think that the stat that everybody's talking about is quite terrifying, the 730% increase in mental health claims for, I think it's blokes between the age of 30 and 40 or something like that.
- 25:25And we have markets overseas that have a limited coverage of mental health. And we have certain insurers that in the past have given us options. I think TAL had an income protection policy where you could exclude mental health. And now I think one of the TPD components is looking at that as well. What's happening with mental health and life insurance and government?
- 25:47So I think that mental health particularly, obviously, it plays an important role in TPD, but also in income protection. It is the spotlight now. It is the thing that is challenging the sustainability of products. You know, we had the income protection and the APRA intervention in that space.
- 26:07That's what five years ago. Now we've got it again. We've got it again with TPD. And we've, I think, had comments this week from APRA to say that the industry needs to sort out what's happening in the TPD space. And that is largely to do with mental health.
- 26:24I think that we've got a range of factors here that are at play. You know, whatever happens is only going to change the new book. It's not going to change the existing book. So change because of guaranteed renewable nature of policies is going to happen gradually.
- 26:43But I think it forces a change of policy design. I think we're starting to see new policies in policy designs in the marketplace. And I think this will be a continuing focus. I do think that mental health could become...
- 27:01an optional element of cover, but I think also, and probably more importantly, is the benefits that are paid on mental health events. So, you know, whether it's a lower amount or it's paid in, um,
- 27:16In a series of payments, all of those things have to be in play. Now, we've had recently consultation over the life insurance code, which seems to, it prevents the use of blanket mental health exclusions. So there's a range of factors that are in play. But this is a really big focus for Cali and the life insurers. And I think we can expect to see ongoing change of policy terms and conditions as a result in policy design. Yeah.
- 27:45They've got to fix it. They've got to fix it because the policies need to be sustainable. And one of the things that I would highlight is that, you know, one of the real bad consequences of constant premium increases is advisors have to work so hard to hold clients in their existing policies. Their effort goes into finding solutions for them, you know, whether that's reducing the level of cover or changing the,
- 28:13the wait period or benefit period. You know, all of these things you're forced to do rather than go out there and talk to new clients about new policies. So the problems play on themselves and we need to get a more sustainable, stable process.
- 28:33pricing outcome in order to ensure that advisors are not focused so much on their existing clients and can focus more on new clients. Then we get more new lives into the pools, the pools become more sustainable. I think with a lot of risk advisors, so myself has included, a majority of the referrals I'm getting from financial planners are large existing clients. The clients come to them and said, mate, I can't manage this. And the financial advisors just said, I don't know what to do. Can you please take over this? And so, you know,
- 29:03But I guess that sort of goes to the other component, right? So you've got the sustainability. And just touching on distribution, the $700 million question, how do we get 14,000 advisors back into life insurance?
- 29:16Yeah, so $14,000 is a big ask. I don't think they're all actually authorized to provide life insurance advice. But we need to provide more incentive. We need to provide more encouragement. We also need to be very clear with advisors that you can't just ignore life insurance needs. You've got to deal with it or you've got to refer the client. That's a really important message. We can't just ignore the problem.
- 29:45We talked about increasing the lift caps. I think that would be one factor. I think we've got to convince young advisors why risk is a great place to work. This is not an easy thing to solve, but yeah, more incentive, more focus, more encouragement. And I think mentoring of the younger advisors by the more mature advisors can...
- 30:08They can learn so much. You know, there are so many of the skills that experienced advisors have in working with clients and getting clients to agree to make decisions that younger advisors can really benefit from.
- 30:24There's a range of things that can be done, but this will be one step at a time. Yeah. The super funds and the life insurers have talked about wanting to get – well, particularly the life insurers wanting to get their own teams of general advice providers. And is it qualified advisors, I think, was the term? We don't like that. No, that's why the face – yeah. Yeah.
- 30:47Unqualified advisors, yeah. They're now called the new class of advisor. Right. But these are not people providing general advice. They would be providing personal advice and they would need to comply with the best interest duty. So it is a...
- 31:04It is a genuine form of advice. But yes, the issue here is how can we get more people into this space through that pathway should the government ultimately legislate for it? And can we treat it as a pathway to become fully qualified advisors? And whether it's in the product providers or it's working for advisor businesses, I think it has broader application.
- 31:33Yeah, okay. And do you think that's the new version of the AMP Horizons? You reckon that's the way that we should be going? Yeah.
- 31:41Look, I think AMP Horizons had an important role to play in getting young advisors in and that was then... Yeah, the incubator for future advisors, yeah. And they could then take on orphaned clients and they had something to work with. So that had a role. This is probably a different role, but I do imagine that you could spend some time
- 32:04As a new class of advisor working for a life insurer servicing existing clients, you could go and work in a practice, you could do your qualifications, and then you could ultimately run your own business. Okay. Well, this has been absolutely brilliant. And thank you for allowing the sort of the quick fire really targeted questions there. Nice one to sort of finish with. 30,000 to 15,000 advisors, artificial intelligence, rising premiums. How do you feel? Are you optimistic about the future? Yeah.
- 32:34What happens next? Well, you certainly threw a few things in there. Look, yes, advisor numbers have fallen, but they have stabilised over recent years. The government's talking about more flexibility in the education standard, so hopefully we can get more new entrants coming in and we can start to rebuild the profession. Artificial intelligence, I think we can view this in two ways.
- 33:03One is it can significantly improve the efficiency of the office, right from preparing documents to recording meetings. I see it less as a threat, particularly in the risk space, because I think selling is not something that artificial intelligence is going to do. And I use the word selling, selling advice.
- 33:26and getting people to make decisions. I think that is still going to be largely a person-to-person activity. So I don't see it as so much of a threat. And I do think there are other opportunities through regulatory reform to make it easier to provide advice that we could see a continuing growth. Am I optimistic about the future?
- 33:47I think in the risk space, we probably have more challenges because of the product-related issues and the pricing increases and the really poor selling practices that come with upfront premium discounting. Yep. So I think risk has more challenges than investment and super. Yep.
- 34:08But I think it's still strong. Those risk specialist businesses that have specialized in this space are doing really well. And they are getting some fantastic referrals coming through to them. When you think about it, financial advice practices are focusing on high net wealth clients.
- 34:26They're referring people who are going to need significant premiums. So there are many dynamics that actually work in favour of the profession, and I think it will have a strong future. There are some things to get fixed in the meantime. Yeah, brilliant. All right, well, thanks so much for coming on, Phil. This has been an absolute pleasure. Cheers. Thank you, Ben. Thanks.