Latest / The Vegan Report / The Shocking Reason Why Veterinarians Eat Their Patients. With Dr. Heath | Ep. 12
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're
- 0:11not sure where to start, then this podcast is for you.
- 0:15Every week, let yourself fall in love with passionate animal rights leaders who will
- 0:21inspire you to find your voice, your own special contribution to the animal rights movement.
- 0:29However small or big it is.
- 0:32Today, we are going to talk about veterinarians.
- 0:37And let me start by telling you a personal story.
- 0:41Weeks ago, I was a devet.
- 0:43My old cat had some health problems, so here I was for an exam.
- 0:47And as I was patiently waiting to meet the good doctor, a lady came in with her cat and
- 0:55she looked visibly upset.
- 0:57And she basically started yelling at the receptionist.
- 1:00Now here's what I understood from the situation.
- 1:04A provincial law forbidding the surgical procedure of declawing was going to take into effect
- 1:11at the end of the day.
- 1:13And this woman was dead set on declawing her cat before the deadline.
- 1:19And she was upset because no clinic could find time to welcome her as a client.
- 1:25Now I felt very uneasy about that interaction for a number of reasons.
- 1:31One of them being that it reminded me of an old question I had.
- 1:36How come vets are not vegan?
- 1:39They are the ones who understand the best animals.
- 1:43So why are they not greater allies in the cause of animal rights?
- 1:48Why are they performing cruel and unnecessary surgeries like declawing in the first place?
- 1:56To discuss this topic, I have with me Dr. Heath from the organization Our Honor.
- 2:03And Our Honor is a vegan organization which works closely with and for animal health care
- 2:10professionals.
- 2:12Let me read one of their mission statement.
- 2:14We empower and support veterinarians, veterinary students, and animal professionals who face
- 2:22bullying and retaliation for trying to create more ethical systems while working for the
- 2:29best interest of others no matter their species.
- 2:33So Dr. welcome to the podcast.
- 2:37Thank you so much for having me.
- 2:38And that's a heartbreaking story and that kind of shows the bullying that we face not
- 2:45only from our colleagues but from clients who want us to participate in animal harm.
- 2:51And that's kind of an example a lot of veterinarians and veterinarians associations use to oppose
- 2:58declaw bans.
- 2:59They say well clients will tell us that they're going to euthanize their cat who's scratching
- 3:07because, you know, they don't want a cat who will scratch their furniture or scratch themselves.
- 3:16And it's really heartbreaking because we have now decades of research showing that countries
- 3:22that have banned declawing across the world have successfully protected cats, clients,
- 3:28and veterinarians.
- 3:30And these are like old antiquated arguments.
- 3:33We should not be being bullied into committing harm against animals.
- 3:40And you know that's what we're allowing to happen.
- 3:43And it's just tragic and heartbreaking.
- 3:45Well, as we are on the topic, what is declawing?
- 3:49Because at first I believed the surgery to be about removing claws.
- 3:55And actually it's about removing the bone.
- 3:59And it's much more, you know, horrible and radical than we think.
- 4:05So can you explain what is declawing?
- 4:07Yeah, it's amputation of the first digit of the claw.
- 4:14So it's de-knuckling.
- 4:16And we've found that a lot of cats after they're declawed will resort to biting.
- 4:24You know, a lot of people say, well, I'm immunocompromised.
- 4:28I can't be scratched by my cat.
- 4:30And then they declaw their cat and then their cat bites them.
- 4:33Or they're upset that their cat is scratching their furniture, so they declaw them.
- 4:38And then the cat doesn't use the litter box after that because the pain in the claws and
- 4:43they associate the litter box and the scratching the litter box with pain.
- 4:47So they start peeing outside the litter box.
- 4:49And then as a shelter veterinarian, I saw many cats relinquished to the shelter after
- 4:54a declaw because of these effects.
- 4:57And so one of our honor campaigns is to support declaw bans as well.
- 5:02And sadly, like our biggest opponent is the veterinary medical associations who are opposing
- 5:08these declaw bans.
- 5:10Why?
- 5:11They're giving all of the old reasons that, oh, if we ban declawing, then people will
- 5:20relinquish their cats to the shelter when they scratch or if they're immunocompromised.
- 5:26One veterinary association used this sad story of this older man with a medical condition
- 5:32and his cat was playfully scratching him.
- 5:35And their only option was to either euthanize the cat or declaw the cat.
- 5:40And it's like, that is not the only option.
- 5:42And if he was to declaw the cat, then the cat starts biting him.
- 5:48And that's another huge problem that's created.
- 5:51So the answer is not to mutilate and cause harm to our patients.
- 5:55Just to look for other alternatives.
- 5:57And we always find when animal protection laws are put in place, people then value animals
- 6:04more and they're not viewed as just accessories that can be mutilated and manipulated to suit
- 6:13our needs.
- 6:14We're instilling these are individuals that need to be protected for their own and need
- 6:21their own interests protected.
- 6:23Like any other human patient in the healthcare sector.
- 6:28So I'm very curious about your journey to becoming this vegan activist.
- 6:34How did you discover veganism?
- 6:37How did you decide to become vegan?
- 6:39And how did that show itself in your vet practice?
- 6:43Well, all my life animals were my close friends, but ironically, I grew up in a rural area,
- 6:50an ag community.
- 6:51I was involved in 4-H and my neighbors raised cattle, sheep, pigs and goats for slaughter
- 6:58and raised pigs in 4-H to go to slaughter.
- 7:03So I was very familiar with that.
- 7:05But at a young age, I also got my hands on some PETA material.
- 7:10I tried going vegetarian when I was 10.
- 7:13My parents really gave me a hard time for it because I was really a small skinny kid
- 7:17anyway.
- 7:18They were really worried that I was going to be really unhealthy.
- 7:22And so I kind of went away from the dietary stuff, but I was involved.
- 7:27I was an equestrian and I was involved in a lot of horse advocacy stuff like pregnant
- 7:32mare urine, raising awareness about the PMU foals.
- 7:36And this is urine that's collected to make the drug Premarin for menopausal women.
- 7:41I was also fascinated by the hunt sobs, which are the direct action activists who will
- 7:48sabotage these fox hunts.
- 7:51And I'm like, that's great.
- 7:52Why are you doing it?
- 7:53I'm like, yeah, it's fun to ride a horse and jump over fences.
- 7:56Why are you now killing foxes?
- 7:58Like it makes no sense.
- 8:00And now I don't ride horses anymore, but I'm not necessarily opposed to it.
- 8:03I am an advocate against horse racing.
- 8:06I'm an advocate against breeding and selling horses.
- 8:10Not necessarily opposed to people rescuing horses and riding them with their best interests
- 8:16in mind, not for ego stroking and all of that.
- 8:21But that's a kind of a nuanced discussion.
- 8:23And then I really, after I kind of went to vet school, paid off my student loan debt,
- 8:30became more involved in advocacy around the California fur ban and really opening my eyes
- 8:38to animal agriculture stuff and the advocacy surrounding that and realizing, oh, veterinarians
- 8:45really need to get involved in this.
- 8:47Things are changing at a rapid pace.
- 8:49I think we're really starting to address animal agriculture in a real significant way now
- 8:55and veterinarians need to get involved in this.
- 8:57And then of course, ventilation shut down, which is the practice of sealing up barns,
- 9:04pumping in heat and steam and waiting for the animals inside to die really came to light
- 9:09during 2020 and the COVID-19 outbreak that shut down slaughterhouses.
- 9:16And that's when I realized veterinarians play a key role in addressing these issues.
- 9:24And then I faced a great deal of backlash and retaliation from the industry when they
- 9:29realized I posed a real threat to them.
- 9:34I'm very professional person.
- 9:36I haven't been involved in any crazy, radical, extreme stuff.
- 9:41I merely worked on legislation and they portrayed me as this radical activist.
- 9:48They made memes about me saying, beware, Dr. Heath means nothing good for our profession.
- 9:53They sent out emails to my veterinary colleagues in California warning them about me.
- 9:59I was kicked out of veterinary Facebook groups.
- 10:01Emails have been written about me by the industry saying I'm a militant vegan with a streak
- 10:08of zealotry.
- 10:09I was banned from attending the AVMA's Humane Ending Symposium, even though I'm an 11-year
- 10:16member of the AVMA.
- 10:17So it was crazy to realize how threatened they were by a veterinarian speaking out.
- 10:26And then I unpacked all of the reasons why the veterinary profession wasn't supportive
- 10:33of animal rights.
- 10:34And that's a whole other journey.
- 10:38Well that's the next question I had for you.
- 10:42Why are not vets the greatest allies of vegans?
- 10:46But first, about that backlash, were also your colleagues involved in your cancellation?
- 10:53Because it is a cancellation.
- 10:55People that you know, who knew that you were not this extremist that you were portrayed
- 11:02to be.
- 11:03Could you count on their support or did they just turn against you?
- 11:09It was really kind of nuts how my classmates who knew me had turned on me.
- 11:18And they knew like my intentions and my background and everything.
- 11:22But it's like a pack mentality, a group think.
- 11:28And they believed the story that was told about me that I was basically going to...
- 11:37The original thing that happened was my colleagues were reaching out to me saying, you're posting
- 11:43all of these things against animal agriculture.
- 11:45You really should shadow a livestock veterinarian.
- 11:48And I studied animal science at UC Davis.
- 11:50I'm a former 4-H-er.
- 11:52I thought, well, I know what I'm talking about, but sure, I'm down to shadow livestock vet.
- 11:59And so I posted on a veterinary Facebook group that I was looking to shadow livestock veterinarian
- 12:03to understand.
- 12:05And then they were like, look, she's posting stuff from this extremist group on my public
- 12:11Facebook page.
- 12:12And they said I was going to go undercover and secretly record people to use against
- 12:17them.
- 12:18And it's like, if I was going to go undercover, do you think I would really post publicly
- 12:22on my public Facebook page things that are so critical of animal agriculture?
- 12:28So it was just crazy, but it's amazing how the motivated reasoning and how people will
- 12:35believe and how threatened they are by it.
- 12:38So yeah.
- 12:39And it goes back to the question of why aren't veterinarians supportive of animal rights
- 12:44and veganism?
- 12:46And I want to ask why more vegans aren't becoming veterinarians.
- 12:51And it's because we don't want to see animals suffer.
- 12:54We don't want to euthanize animals.
- 12:56We don't.
- 12:57And I think a lot of us self-select against entering the profession.
- 13:01But there's active gatekeeping against veterinarians who are vegan and animal rights activists,
- 13:06because there's a producer and a research veterinarian on every veterinary admissions
- 13:14board making sure that their interests are protected.
- 13:18And the animal rights philosophy is viewed as so antithetical to veterinary medicine.
- 13:25We're taught in school that if animals were to get rights, that would mean that we could
- 13:31be sued for a lot more money than we can be sued for now.
- 13:36That would increase the cost of our malpractice insurance.
- 13:39That would increase the cost of medical care.
- 13:42So that would ultimately harm animals.
- 13:45And of course, it also threatens animal experimentation.
- 13:48Many people are still supportive of animal experimentation viewing that as beneficial
- 13:54to human beings.
- 13:58People want to ride horses.
- 13:59People want to eat meat.
- 14:00So this threatens that whole thing.
- 14:03And veterinarians are viewed as playing a key role in sustaining animal agriculture.
- 14:08So these are all the reasons.
- 14:10But they're all things that we need to dismantle and kind of deconstruct all of these belief
- 14:19systems and rebuild a food system that is more healthy and sustainable and good for
- 14:27everybody.
- 14:28And I think veterinarians will play a key role.
- 14:30But we have to kind of deconstruct the biases that we've been taught.
- 14:37Well, I'm shocked.
- 14:39I'm simply shocked.
- 14:41And I'm still thinking about the part where you said they filter out vegans from the vet
- 14:48profession.
- 14:50What?
- 14:51This is crazy.
- 14:54Why aren't we talking about this more?
- 14:56Well, I am talking about it.
- 15:00But yeah, I mean, I learned back in 2008 when I was applying for vet school, I talked to
- 15:06somebody about it and they're like, you really should keep the whole vegetarian.
- 15:12I wasn't vegan at the time.
- 15:13I was vegetarian.
- 15:15Keep that quiet.
- 15:16Just keep in mind, people may be threatened by that.
- 15:19So I kind of keep it under wraps.
- 15:21And another vet student recently told me she was outspoken about being vegan when she was
- 15:27interviewing because she's like, I want to be accepted.
- 15:30And that's the whole fitting in versus belonging thing.
- 15:33She wanted to belong where she went.
- 15:35And luckily, there's a new progressive school that opened up.
- 15:39And that's a little bit more forward thinking.
- 15:43But she said in her interview that she was vegan.
- 15:46And they argued with her.
- 15:47They're like, what about spaying and neutering?
- 15:49And she explained how spaying and neutering is consistent with veganism because it's for
- 15:54the animal's best interest to prevent overpopulation.
- 15:58And they let her in.
- 15:59But it's like, you have to know your stuff and you have to be able to communicate it
- 16:03in the right way.
- 16:06And every vet student's always reach out to me.
- 16:09The first semester of veterinary school, there's this class on welfare versus animal rights.
- 16:15And it's always like an ag person coming in explaining the difference between animal
- 16:19welfare and animal rights and how we're a profession that supports animal welfare for
- 16:24these reasons.
- 16:25I remember even in school, they said how the Humane Society of the United States isn't
- 16:31actually about animal shelters.
- 16:33It's a wealthy organization that secretly wants to give animals rights.
- 16:39And they talked about how the Harvard Animal Law Clinic and the Yale Animal Law Clinic
- 16:45was a threat to our profession in all of these ways.
- 16:49And I was skeptical at the time.
- 16:53And I was just kind of rolling my eyes.
- 16:55But I didn't have the language to fight back.
- 16:59And I'm kind of thinking, I don't know if you saw the Barbie movie.
- 17:04It's like, spoiler alert to anybody who hasn't seen it.
- 17:07But like, Penn goes back to the real world and then comes back to Barbie land and brings
- 17:11the patriarchy to Barbie land.
- 17:15And it's like the Barbies just eat it up.
- 17:17And it's like, why did the Barbies just go along with this?
- 17:22And it's like, because they were naive, they're sitting ducks, they didn't have the immunity
- 17:27to it.
- 17:28So they just ate it up.
- 17:29And that's what best students are.
- 17:31We're just like sitting ducks.
- 17:34We're not taught in how to refute those sorts of arguments that are perpetuated by animal
- 17:40ag.
- 17:41We're just kind of like indoctrinated into it.
- 17:47So you're faced with all that backlash.
- 17:50And knowing what you know, I guess there was a moment when you could have just backed away
- 17:57and just go silent and stop creating waves.
- 18:01Why did you decide to pursue your denunciation of this industry to the point of creating
- 18:08our honor?
- 18:09So why did you make that choice?
- 18:11And where did you find the strength to make that choice?
- 18:15It was so helpful to have some veterinary colleagues who were really supportive of me
- 18:20and to have Glenn Greenwald write a story about you and have me on his show.
- 18:27And that was huge.
- 18:30And then it's like, OK, this is a real, people really care about this.
- 18:34This is a big deal.
- 18:36And then luckily had somebody give me a lot of money to start our honors.
- 18:42And sometimes all the everything, all the stars are aligning in the right direction.
- 18:49But it's like if I didn't have the support of some colleagues, if I didn't have Glenn
- 18:53Greenwald, if I didn't have somebody willing to financially back me, I wouldn't have been
- 18:59able to do it.
- 19:00And I think it's happened to a lot of people who did have to quietly go away because they
- 19:07had none of that support.
- 19:10And I don't have kids.
- 19:12I'm not married.
- 19:13I am very I'm also I have all my student loan debt paid off, which is rare for people.
- 19:21So I have a lot of privilege that and I'm like, I'm going to take advantage of all the
- 19:25privilege that I was given.
- 19:27So, you know, yeah, that makes you that makes you a powerful opponent.
- 19:33And for those of you who don't know, Glenn Greenwald is a award winning journalist.
- 19:38He's the one who break to the Snowden story, so about mass surveillance and stuff like
- 19:45that.
- 19:46So, yeah, you got the funding.
- 19:48You decide to start our honor.
- 19:51What was the first cause, the first fight that you decided to lead with your organization?
- 19:58This was our advocacy around ventilation shut down and raising awareness about the mass
- 20:03killing of animals via heat stroke.
- 20:06The American Veterinary Medical Association condones this practice in constrained circumstances.
- 20:14And we were still finding out more and more about how that came about.
- 20:19We're doing a lot of FOIA requests to discover all the conversations that were had about
- 20:26allowing this practice in the first place.
- 20:28And we're really finding that the guidelines on depopulation were really started kind of
- 20:34after the first avian influenza outbreak when veterans didn't know what to do.
- 20:41All of these birds are getting sick.
- 20:44It probably does make the most sense to try to stop the spread of the disease and stop
- 20:50animal suffering by ending the lives of birds.
- 20:54But they were going about it in a haphazard way, throwing birds in wood chippers.
- 21:00Nobody really knew what they're doing.
- 21:02And so they're like, okay, good intentions.
- 21:04Let's figure out as veterinarians what's the best way to do this.
- 21:09But I think there was some complacency of like, this is good enough.
- 21:14And we found the National Pork Board, which is under the USDA.
- 21:19This is the pork checkoff program, the pork, the other white meat advertising campaign.
- 21:26Veterinarian who was part of the Pork Board played a key role in creating the guidelines
- 21:31on depopulation for pigs.
- 21:34And so the AVMA was very defensive about the fact that we were criticizing this document.
- 21:44And after the realities of ventilation shut down and the footage of how horrible it was
- 21:50for the pigs and the pigs screaming for hours, well, this wasn't acceptable.
- 21:55But we also found that the reason it got in the guidelines in the first place was an industry
- 22:01funded study performed at an industry funded public university.
- 22:07The Prestige Department of Fultry Science, named after Prestige Farms, was used as the
- 22:12basis for putting this method in the guidelines.
- 22:17And then the USDA has a cooperative agreement with the AVMA.
- 22:22So that if methods used are listed in the guidelines, the USDA gives our taxpayer dollars,
- 22:31public funds back to those producers who have kind of created the conditions that necessitate
- 22:39the atrocity of mass killing of animals via heat stroke in the first place.
- 22:43And it's like a really dangerous feedback loop.
- 22:47It's kind of like recently, Bill Sack, the Ag Secretary, just increased indemnity payments
- 22:54to cattle producers because of climate change, because cows are being lost in the heat of
- 23:02climate change.
- 23:03But obviously, climate change is perpetuated by cows in the first place.
- 23:08So we're just having this dangerous feedback loop of enabling producers to continue practices
- 23:15that cause emergency situations and then necessitate the cruelest killing methods.
- 23:21So that was our first advocacy efforts, and we really have gained a lot of media attention.
- 23:27And I've been barred from attending the AVMA's Humane Ending Symposium, the legislative fly-in.
- 23:33But it's like, okay, every time they keep pushing back, we get more media attention.
- 23:42And now it'll be interesting to see what happens at the next conventions.
- 23:47I have been allowed to continue to go to conventions since then.
- 23:51I felt like at the last convention, I was treated a little bit better.
- 23:55So I think change is coming.
- 23:56I think they're really realizing they are definitely in the wrong here.
- 24:00Yes, that's what I want to hear because this is so dark.
- 24:06What a dark problem.
- 24:08And it just brings in me feelings of despair a bit because it's like a conspiracy.
- 24:15You have the vet associations, and then you have the government and the private industry,
- 24:21and they're all talking to each other and helping each other while the animals are just
- 24:28in the worst possible pain.
- 24:31And I had a representative animal partisan, which is this organization that sues the
- 24:38animal industry when there is proof of animal abuse.
- 24:43And he was telling me how the FBI, even the FBI was in bed with the animal industry and
- 24:51participating in conferences organized by the farm industry.
- 24:56So I wonder, do you feel safe about what you're doing?
- 25:03Do you feel like you could be in danger from doing all of what you're doing and becoming
- 25:10the target of an institution like the FBI?
- 25:13Well, I haven't done anything, even bordering on illegal.
- 25:20But there have been weird things that have happened where I'm wondering if I'm being
- 25:25surveilled.
- 25:26I wonder if there's a campaign to smear me.
- 25:33A lot of things I can't explain and can't really talk about.
- 25:37So it is weird.
- 25:39I'm lucky I live in a really secure building.
- 25:42But yeah, there have been some really weird things that have happened.
- 25:47I'm kind of open.
- 25:48I'm an adventurous person.
- 25:50I'm down for whatever plot twist they're going to throw at me.
- 25:55So I don't know.
- 25:56I'm just the perfect person for them to try to do whatever they want to do because I'm
- 26:02just like, yeah, the FBI, let's do something crazy.
- 26:07You're always scared you're going to get assassinated or something.
- 26:11But what are you going to do?
- 26:14The worst thing anybody could do is get you to not be able to talk.
- 26:19And I'd rather them try to murder me than me feel like I can't use my voice.
- 26:27Those are intimidation techniques.
- 26:28I don't think that they will go as far as that.
- 26:31But they want to frighten you.
- 26:34Frame me for something.
- 26:35Who knows?
- 26:36Yeah.
- 26:37Well, hopefully nothing happens.
- 26:40And thankfully, you can think of those situations and misadventures as just another chapter
- 26:47in the book, the bestseller book that you're going to write one day.
- 26:52So yeah, let's put a positive spin to this story.
- 26:58Have you stopped fighting for that horrible ventilation mass murder thing that happened?
- 27:06Is that behind you or is it still current affair?
- 27:11Yeah, it's still ongoing because our next threat is African swine fever.
- 27:16Ventilation shutdown was used in the avian influenza outbreak that's died down.
- 27:20Now African swine fever is an emerging threat.
- 27:23They still don't have any plan in place to use anything better than ventilation shutdown.
- 27:30We're getting more and more FOIA documents about the conversations around this.
- 27:35And we'll see how it goes.
- 27:39It's kind of out of the media right now, so nobody's really talking about it.
- 27:43But we're still working on it, even though it's not an active news story.
- 27:48So stay tuned for that.
- 27:50And on this issue, can people do something in particular to advance that fight?
- 27:57Yeah, if you want to stay involved and get in touch, go to vavsd.org.
- 28:04That's veterinarians against ventilation shutdown.org.
- 28:07And you can sign on to our petition.
- 28:08Even if you're not a veterinarian, at least you'll sign on to our petition and get our
- 28:12newsletters and stuff.
- 28:13And also ourhonor.org, sign up for our newsletter there.
- 28:18Follow us on social media to stay appraised of what's going on.
- 28:22And we'll kind of let you know.
- 28:25Every Friday we do a FOIA Friday where we kind of highlight the most, the best FOIA
- 28:31document that we've received recently.
- 28:33So stay tuned for that on social media too.
- 28:37And of course, all of those links will be available in the description.
- 28:42Another fight you're leading is against the EATS Act.
- 28:46Now what is this about?
- 28:48What is the EATS Act?
- 28:49And why is it bad?
- 28:51This is the industry's way to overturn Proposition 12.
- 28:56And we also supported Proposition 12.
- 28:59We helped get over 400 veterinarians to sign on to an amicus brief in support of Prop 12.
- 29:05What is Prop 12?
- 29:06This is the ballot measure passed in California by 63% of California voters.
- 29:13And it gives animals minimum cage space requirements.
- 29:17So the flesh of animals and eggs of animals sold in California have to come from animals
- 29:25who have met minimum requirements.
- 29:28And all of the other industry groups were kind of accepted this, were fine with this,
- 29:33except the pork industry.
- 29:34Of course, they are literally the most ruthless, powerful, and abusive industry on the planet.
- 29:42So of course, they fought back.
- 29:46The National Pork Producers Council fought it all the way to the Supreme Court.
- 29:50It was a huge battle in the Supreme Court.
- 29:53Amicus briefs back and forth.
- 29:55We helped write one and we helped get a bunch of veterinarians to sign on to counter the
- 30:00American Association of Swine Veterinarians amicus brief that opposed Prop 12.
- 30:06They wanted to keep pigs confined to gestation crates.
- 30:10And these are crates.
- 30:11Other pigs are housed in for 114 days of their pregnancy, two and a half foot by seven and
- 30:16a half foot stalls where they're unable to turn around.
- 30:21And the pigs are kept in these, then they go to ferroin crates, and then they go back
- 30:25to gestation crates.
- 30:27And that's how they spend their whole lives.
- 30:29And they're cold usually after four pregnancies, but sometimes they go through as many as 14
- 30:34pregnancies, you know, just being confined in this way.
- 30:38It's absolutely cruel and horrifying.
- 30:41And so Prop 12 is one way to stop that because it requires that the flesh of pigs sold in
- 30:49California come from mothers who were given at least 24 square feet.
- 30:55But yeah, it was fought.
- 30:56And luckily the Supreme Court upheld Prop 12.
- 31:00But now the EATS Act is a way to overturn that, saying that a state doesn't have, shouldn't
- 31:09have the right to dictate production practices in another state.
- 31:14So we are getting veterinarians to sign on.
- 31:19The American Veterinary Medical Association hasn't really taken a stand on it.
- 31:22We want to tell legislators, veterinarians are opposed to the EATS Act.
- 31:28This threatens animal health and protection, and it threatens food safety too.
- 31:33So we are encouraging people to sign on.
- 31:35And they can go to rhonor.org and find our blog post about it and sign on there and find
- 31:42all the information about why we are opposing the EATS Act.
- 31:47And I guess people can go and encourage their vet, their personal vet, to sign that petition.
- 31:55That's what we would love for people to do is go on social media, tag your veterinarian
- 32:00in our content, email your veterinarian and tell them about this stuff.
- 32:06And if they know that their clients really care about this, I think they'll start to
- 32:11pay attention.
- 32:12Hopefully then they'll tell their state veterinary medical associations, like, hey, a lot of
- 32:18my clients are talking about this.
- 32:20Let's take action.
- 32:22Because our reputation as caring advocates for animals is really being destroyed by the
- 32:27positions taken by the state VMAs and by the American Veterinary Medical Association.
- 32:31It's like when the public finds out we're opposed to declaw bans, we support gestation
- 32:38crates and we support mass killing of animals via heat stroke.
- 32:42That's just not a good look.
- 32:44It doesn't kind of help our authority when it comes to animal welfare.
- 32:50I wish you could create a vegan certification for vets, because as a vegan, I would be influenced
- 32:59by that certification.
- 33:00I would think, I want a vegan vet who shares my beliefs for at least is in line with the
- 33:06vegan cause.
- 33:08And I would 100% go to that vet instead of another random vet who doesn't.
- 33:14Yeah.
- 33:15But I think the problem is all of us vets, we don't want more clients.
- 33:21We're all so busy that we don't want to put our names out there anyway, because we just
- 33:26want to take care of the people that we take care of now.
- 33:29But it's a huge issue.
- 33:31There's not enough veterinarians to take care of all of the animals.
- 33:34It's hard to get an appointment at the vet.
- 33:37But yeah, I imagine one day, imagine if every veterinary office had a bunch of vegan material,
- 33:44animal rights material on the TV screen.
- 33:47There was information about the harms of animal agriculture.
- 33:51And it's like, you care about your dog and then realizing that other animals are just
- 33:56like your dog or your cat.
- 33:59And you're hearing about veganism and animal rights from your veterinarian.
- 34:04That will be huge.
- 34:06And if veterinarians are supportive of animal protection legislation, that would be huge.
- 34:13Because I think the biggest barrier is to passing animal protection legislation is these
- 34:18VMAs who squash all of the legislation that's put forward because legislators look to them
- 34:25as like, oh, they're the experts in this.
- 34:27So let's do what they want to do.
- 34:30And we kill a lot of really important legislation.
- 34:35And that's why your work is so important.
- 34:37So again, thank you for doing what you are doing.
- 34:41Another cause you are pursuing is that of the carbon dioxide gas chambers, which is
- 34:49one more sadistic way of torturing animals out there.
- 34:55So could you tell us about that?
- 34:57Yeah.
- 34:58So a new method was kind of implemented since the 1990s to kill pigs.
- 35:06It's a faster, more efficient way of killing pigs, but not necessarily a higher welfare
- 35:12way.
- 35:13And now 113.5 million pigs in the United States are killed using carbon dioxide gas chambers.
- 35:21And Raven Deerbrook and activists place cameras inside of a slaughterhouse.
- 35:26Gondola, like to see what actually happens to the pigs inside.
- 35:31This is the only killing method that USDA inspectors can't observe when the pigs are
- 35:38dying and what happens to them.
- 35:40And she saw that the pigs are screaming, are scrambling for far too long minutes.
- 35:48And I talked to Dr. Temple Grandin about this.
- 35:51And she said she wanted to do a similar study where she placed cameras inside the gondolas
- 35:56to see what happens.
- 35:57And the company killed her study.
- 36:01And her solution is that we need to breed pigs who respond better to carbon dioxide.
- 36:08I argue that how do we know?
- 36:12And that's kind of disturbing because a lot of people react differently to pain and suffering.
- 36:20And just because a pig is standing there doesn't necessarily mean that they're not suffering.
- 36:25Just because they're not going berserk, scrambling and screaming doesn't mean they're not suffering.
- 36:30She argues that, well, we can tell because we've done studies that show that some pigs
- 36:37will voluntarily put their head in lower carbon dioxide chambers to get a bit of food.
- 36:43But that just tells me that that line of pigs is more highly food motivated and willing
- 36:48to withstand some suffering in order to get food.
- 36:51Doesn't necessarily say that they're not suffering.
- 36:53So people always say, well, what's the better way then?
- 36:57And the truth is there's really not a good feasible alternative.
- 37:03We used to use electrocution or captive bolt guns.
- 37:07And that requires pigs to line up single file, which they don't want to do at the pace that
- 37:12is required for modern slaughter needs.
- 37:17And that requires use of prods to prod them, which is bad.
- 37:23There are mixtures of gases that can be used, like mixtures of argon and nitrogen.
- 37:29So we'd have to reconfigure gas chambers.
- 37:31But instead of spending all this effort reconfiguring things, we should really be asking, are we
- 37:40solving the wrong problem here?
- 37:43Instead of solving the problem of how do we kill pigs with less suffering, how do we get
- 37:49our nutrient needs met without having to kill pigs?
- 37:53That's the question that we should be asking, I think.
- 37:56So let's just scale down this animal agriculture and get slaughter free methods of food production
- 38:03implemented instead.
- 38:05Well, I mean, where is the historical sensitivity?
- 38:09I mean, we're talking about gas chambers.
- 38:12Is there no one who's offended by that?
- 38:14I feel like we're just recreating gas chambers from concentration camps and using pigs instead
- 38:21of humans.
- 38:22I mean, sorry for my language, but what the fuck is that situation about?
- 38:31It's frightening.
- 38:32And there's this brilliant essay written about the moral vulnerabilities in medical culture
- 38:39and how future doctors are sort of groomed to commit mass atrocities.
- 38:47There's so many structures in place.
- 38:49So this medical student, Alessandra Coliani at Johns Hopkins, sort of examines the harm
- 38:54caused by doctors throughout history.
- 38:58Human doctors participated in torture at Guantanamo Bay, mercy killings at Hurricane Katrina,
- 39:03and of course, Nazi Germany.
- 39:06And she found that doctors were more likely to become members of the SS than the general
- 39:13population.
- 39:15And like, why is that?
- 39:16And it's because of all of the things in medical culture.
- 39:20We're kind of taught to kind of suck it up and we have to be tougher.
- 39:26We have to cause pain to heal.
- 39:29And we don't really examine all of the ways we become desensitized to harms.
- 39:36And we're looking for like the greater good.
- 39:39And the way that we're viewing animals as a benefit to human beings, we're kind of objectifying
- 39:47them just like Nazi doctors objectified people.
- 39:55And it's very much the same thing.
- 39:58And why we implemented gas chambers in the first place, why we implement ventilation
- 40:02shutdown, it's because the reality is like having somebody kill individually one by one,
- 40:09it's hard.
- 40:10There's a lot of turnover.
- 40:11There's a lot of moral distress.
- 40:12The best way is to like distance people from it.
- 40:15And the same reasons gas chambers were used in Nazi Germany are the same reasons gas chambers
- 40:20are being used on animals now.
- 40:23And we really need to examine that.
- 40:25But it's like, you can't really talk about that.
- 40:28But all of the detachment and everything that we are taught in medical culture is what leads
- 40:34us to become susceptible to committing these mass atrocities.
- 40:41I wholeheartedly agree.
- 40:44And it's fascinating how we can make parallels between the abuse and exploitation of humans
- 40:51and of animals.
- 40:52It proves the point that Darwin was making like a what 200 years ago, that the difference
- 40:59between humans and animals is a difference of degree.
- 41:02What can we do about these gas chambers?
- 41:06What is happening in the front of fighting against them?
- 41:11And how can we participate in the fight?
- 41:13Well, what we did is the AVMA is coming out with their new guidelines for humane slaughter.
- 41:22And we submitted comments on those guidelines.
- 41:25We don't know they're currently working on the draft.
- 41:28We don't know when it'll be out.
- 41:30But I encourage people to share clips of this gas chamber footage online, on social media.
- 41:39Whenever somebody talks about humanely raised pigs, ask them, how are the pigs killed?
- 41:46Are they killed like this?
- 41:47And show a little one minute clip of the pigs dying in the gas chamber.
- 41:50This is how 113.5 million pigs are killed.
- 41:53No matter how humanely they are raised on whatever farm, this is how they're killed.
- 42:00What are we doing here?
- 42:02So yeah, come to ourhonor.org.
- 42:06Sign up.
- 42:07Sign our petition.
- 42:09Sign our statement.
- 42:11And humainslaughter.org is our other website that we have for this.
- 42:15So you can look at all of the frequently asked questions.
- 42:20What are the alternatives?
- 42:21I go through the different alternatives that are available and the problems with all of
- 42:26those alternatives.
- 42:28So educate yourselves, educate other people, and share this content widely.
- 42:35And you have clips of that footage, but I think that you have six hours of footage of...
- 42:43It's actually...
- 42:44Oh my God, how many?
- 42:4716 hours of total footage.
- 42:4916, wow.
- 42:50Yeah, but there's some one minute clips that are easier to share on social media and Twitter
- 42:55and Instagram and Facebook.
- 43:00Okay.
- 43:02The next fight I want to talk about and that your organization is leading is that of...
- 43:07Well, I will read the point.
- 43:09We also urge the American Veterinary Medical Association to consider exploitation's role
- 43:16when setting sustainability policies.
- 43:21So you're highlighting the environmental impact of animal exploitation here.
- 43:28And I think it's a very interesting point.
- 43:30So could you expand on that?
- 43:32Yeah, for the first time, the AVMA at their convention brought up sustainability, but
- 43:39they're talking about the greening of veterinary practices, like use more recycling and things
- 43:45like that.
- 43:46And it's like, wait, there's this huge issue that we're not talking about.
- 43:52And Martha Smith Blackmore, she's a delegate, and she took to the stage and said, we really
- 43:59need to address the elephant in the room, which is animal agriculture.
- 44:04And somebody, a poultry veterinarian stood up and responded and says, they got really
- 44:10defensive and was like, if you think we're not taking this seriously, we are taking this
- 44:15seriously.
- 44:16And it's like, what they're doing is using dairy digesters, where now in California,
- 44:23many dairies get more money by selling low carbon fuel standard credits than they get
- 44:29by selling milk.
- 44:32And we're throwing how many gallons of milk away in schools.
- 44:3840% of the kids toss the milk cartons out in the trash without even drinking them.
- 44:45We've got 1.6 billion pounds of government cheese stored.
- 44:51And we're selling low carbon fuel standard credit using dairy digesters.
- 44:58And it's outrageous.
- 45:00Meanwhile, if we transition to plant-based nutrient production in place of beef and dairy,
- 45:08that would free up around 700 million acres of land in the United States.
- 45:14So veterinarians really have to take the lead in advocating for animals and advocating for
- 45:20a switch to slaughter free forms of nutrient production.
- 45:25Yeah, and I think that in terms of fighting for the environment and against climate change,
- 45:32this should be a priority because this is the top five, if not the number one reason
- 45:38for pollution out there and destruction of environments and so on.
- 45:45Exactly.
- 45:46Yeah.
- 45:47And our populations are growing.
- 45:51And animal agriculture is making this argument that in order to feed 10 billion people, we
- 45:56have to prioritize animal agriculture.
- 45:59It's like, no, we're not going to be able to feed the planet and have a healthy planet
- 46:04if we're eating this much in animal products.
- 46:08So we really have to switch to plant-based nutrition.
- 46:11Yeah.
- 46:12I hear a lot of farmers talk proudly about how they are feeding the world, feeding the
- 46:21country, feeding the community.
- 46:24And I want to say, Bill, you're feeding the people who can afford meat and you're destroying
- 46:31the environment and destroying those lands that should be used for plant-based diets,
- 46:38sources of nutrition in a better world.
- 46:42But here we are.
- 46:44Yeah.
- 46:45And now they're going into other countries, industrialized animal agriculture is going
- 46:50to Africa and the pharmaceutical companies are loving it because the biggest customer
- 46:55is animal agriculture.
- 46:57If you think we sell a lot of medications to humans, that's nothing in comparison to
- 47:01the antibiotics and vaccines that pharmaceutical companies sell to animals.
- 47:05And so now you have these whole new markets opening up and the growth in pharmaceuticals
- 47:10expected, all of the investments made there.
- 47:14And we really have to say, I think people in the pharmaceutical industry and in animal
- 47:22agriculture should really start to feel the pressure that an end is coming and investments
- 47:28really need to be made elsewhere, not in this antiquated model that causes so much harm.
- 47:35Yeah.
- 47:37The antibiotic era coming to an end, this is truly frightening and I had Catherine
- 47:45Besh, I don't remember which episode it was, but she's the founder of Animal Sanctuary
- 47:50in Vietnam and she was telling me how the animal industry was pushing dairy on the Vietnamese
- 47:58people.
- 47:59And in her time in Vietnam, she saw how the children were now eating lots of yogurt, lots
- 48:05of milk, and this is not even native to their culture in terms of feeding yourself.
- 48:15And yeah, it's fascinating and it's dangerous.
- 48:19And she was also telling me how Vietnam has the highest rate of antibiotic resistance
- 48:24in the world.
- 48:25So that's another problem.
- 48:27And I was considering Vietnam as a vacation spot.
- 48:31Now I don't.
- 48:33I'm sorry that I don't want to catch some bacteria and then I just know antibiotic will
- 48:40work on me.
- 48:41Yeah.
- 48:42Yeah.
- 48:43Yeah, it's frightening.
- 48:44It's food colonialism.
- 48:46I was arguing with somebody on Twitter who is telling me that New Zealand berries are
- 48:52the most humane and that I should drink New Zealand milk.
- 48:58And I'm like, I talked to a livestock vet from New Zealand and he was saying how you
- 49:03have a huge problem with resistance to dewormers.
- 49:08And I'm like, what do you think about that?
- 49:10He's like, oh, that happens.
- 49:11It's fine.
- 49:12It's not a big deal.
- 49:13It's like, oh, because you guys were misusing them.
- 49:17And the biodiversity loss in New Zealand is a huge threat and it's one of your national
- 49:24security risks.
- 49:25And this was caused by introduction of herbivores grazing on habitats.
- 49:32And now you had to introduce all of these antibiotics and all of these dewormers.
- 49:38And now there's resistance to these dewormers.
- 49:42That's threatening the biodiversity and the habitat destruction and habitat loss.
- 49:4890% of your wetlands are gone.
- 49:50And you're telling me like I should drink New Zealand milk instead of non animal based
- 49:56milk.
- 49:57Like, why?
- 49:58Like, what's the reason for doing that?
- 50:00So doctor, tell me, is there a fight you want to talk about and that you're leading with
- 50:07your organization and I haven't asked you about?
- 50:12We are also addressing the harmful use of animals in medical school training, veterinary
- 50:18school training.
- 50:20People don't realize that veterinary students have to kill their patients often in veterinary
- 50:27school.
- 50:28The cadavers that students use to learn anatomy, they're often animals purchased from bioscience
- 50:38companies purposefully bred for that purpose.
- 50:42And there's an alternative.
- 50:44There's humane ethical alternatives, which are willed body programs.
- 50:50When our own dog, cat, horse, goat passes away, we can donate their body to veterinary school
- 50:56for veterinary students to learn on.
- 50:58We don't need to be purposefully breeding animals for veterinary students to learn on.
- 51:04But also like there are veterinary students who have to anesthetize a healthy animal,
- 51:11perform one or more surgeries on them, and then kill them before the animal is even allowed
- 51:15to wake up.
- 51:17And that is horrifying and against our ethics.
- 51:23And students are bullied into doing this, worrying that they're going to face a failing
- 51:28grade, worried that they're going to be ostracized.
- 51:31And the threats are really ramping up.
- 51:33I feel like the veterinary students are even more afraid now to speak up when it's very
- 51:39clear there's so much evidence against these sorts of training models when there's so many
- 51:44more alternatives.
- 51:46But the students are at the same time more fearful about speaking up.
- 51:50So we're going to put on some Know Your Rights trainings in the future for veterinary students.
- 51:54If there's any veterinary students out there, and you feel threatened and you feel like
- 51:59you can't speak up, reach out to us.
- 52:02Our honor wants to write to these schools and advocate for change in curriculum that
- 52:09requires less animal harm.
- 52:12We're going to come out with the numbers of how many animals are killed at each school
- 52:15and make a ranking of the most ethical to the least ethical veterinary schools.
- 52:22And there's going to be a lot more information coming out in that area.
- 52:27And that's a huge opportunity for change.
- 52:30And veterinary students shouldn't feel scared.
- 52:35Just know that animal law attorneys are wanting to take on some sort of case First Amendment
- 52:42attorneys.
- 52:44We have your back.
- 52:46There's a lot you can do and a lot of animals you can save.
- 52:50And some people say like, oh, what's the most ethical vet school to go to?
- 52:54And I encourage if you're bold, go to the worst ones.
- 52:57And because you're going to save more animals by changing the curriculum at the worst schools,
- 53:03like you could change, you can save thousands of animals by changing the curriculum, whereas
- 53:08you're not going to save any animals if you go to school that doesn't harm animals.
- 53:12So that's my philosophy.
- 53:15So stay tuned and follow us on social media to hear more about that.
- 53:21Why are they not suing the colleges?
- 53:24Because this is a traumatizing experience.
- 53:26I hear about lectures getting cancelled in colleges because they are insensitive.
- 53:34And then there's this horrible situation going on at your vet school department.
- 53:41I mean, if this is not a lawsuit, lawsuit material, then I don't know what it is.
- 53:49And it's it's against our oath.
- 53:51It's anti the three Rs, like the most welfarist basic.
- 53:56This isn't even animal rights stuff we're talking about here.
- 53:59This is like basic just adhering to the ethics of the veterinary profession.
- 54:03And Gary Francione, you know, back in the day did sue a lot of schools for this.
- 54:08And sadly, like there's been kind of silence lately, you know, and I feel like, you know,
- 54:16we really need to ramp that up again.
- 54:19More lawsuits.
- 54:20You know, there's so much potential here for change.
- 54:24I believe you.
- 54:25I believe you.
- 54:26And I hope people support your work.
- 54:30Did you have something to to add to the conversation, Dr. Hey, before we stop the conversation?
- 54:38That's it.
- 54:39Just if your vet student reach out, if you're not a vet or veterinarian, still reach out
- 54:43because we need help.
- 54:44We need volunteers.
- 54:46We need people to reach out to their vets and talk about these issues.
- 54:50And we have handouts that you can even give to your vet if you go in person.
- 54:53If you want a stack of them, email us and we'll mail you some so you can give to all
- 54:58the veterinary offices in your area.
- 55:00So please get involved and follow us on social media.
- 55:04Amazing.
- 55:05Thank you so much, doctor, for having taken the time to answer my questions.
- 55:11And thank you for your great work.
- 55:13This is such inspiring work.
- 55:15Those are the things I want to hear.
- 55:17And yeah, thank you.
- 55:19Thank you so much.
- 55:20Thank you for having me.
- 55:21It was fun.
- 55:23Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 55:25I hope Dr. Heath's message resonated with you.
- 55:30Please tell your friends about the show and why you love it so much.
- 55:34Let's inspire more people to take action.
- 55:38If you're listening to this on Apple Podcast, please consider leaving me a good review.
- 55:45And on that topic, I want to thank a certain John who has left me a five star review.
- 55:51He wrote, I'll stick to it as long as I can.
- 55:55I'm not vegan, but have been leaning that direction much farther now.
- 56:01Thank you so much, John, for being my very first review on Apple Podcast.
- 56:07The Vegan Report is also on YouTube.
- 56:10And a certain WIC entry left this comment on episode 10 about vegan conservatives.
- 56:18Lovely and insightful podcast as always.
- 56:21I always found it interesting that there aren't more conservative who are vegan.
- 56:26Regarding the more conservative ideals, it's interesting to hear conservatives talk about
- 56:31small government and being opposed to government handouts, but animal agriculture subsidies
- 56:37don't even register.
- 56:40Great episode.
- 56:41Well, great point, WIC entry.
- 56:43And thank you so much for your support and your kind words.
- 56:48Finally, you can always reach out to me on Instagram at veganreportpodcast.
- 56:55Thank you again for listening.
- 56:58Take care and see you next Tuesday for a new episode.