Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Margin, Membership, and Mounting Risk: Unpacking Q4 2025 with Farrar, Miller and Bauer
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trico with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04I'm back with Steve, Todd and Dennis.
- 0:07Guys, how you doing today?
- 0:09Miller: Doing well, doing well,
- 0:11Treichel: doing good.
- 0:12Steve, that, Steve, that nods gonna come through good on YouTube.
- 0:15Not so much on the, on the, uh, on the podcast, but, uh, but
- 0:20podcaster, Steve's doing well.
- 0:21He's nodding.
- 0:22So all, all is good.
- 0:24We got Dennis hanging out in, uh, Arizona, and I asked him if he saw
- 0:28Kyler Murray on a plane to Minnesota.
- 0:30I was hoping I could announce that today's podcast is being recorded on the beginning
- 0:35of the Kyler Murray era, but, uh, not yet.
- 0:38Not yet.
- 0:38But we're not here to talk about football.
- 0:40We're here to talk about the fourth quarter data, the fourth quarter
- 0:44reports that have come out from NCUA.
- 0:46This has gotten to be one that we do every quarter.
- 0:49That is always kind of fun, where we look at.
- 0:52What the numbers are showing, what the numbers are not showing.
- 0:56And guys let's, uh, what, it's been a few months since you were on the
- 1:00show, so let's, uh, let's start with Steve, uh, short, uh, summary of, of,
- 1:05uh, your background, uh, in credit.
- 1:09Farrar: Uh, background, I'm gonna be broken into three separate, uh, parts.
- 1:12The first part was in the field as a NCO, A examiner and problem
- 1:17case officer for roughly 15 years.
- 1:20And in that, the lot of enjoyable work working with the credit unions and
- 1:24conservatorships and turning turnarounds.
- 1:28Then, uh, when you went to the central office, I followed you
- 1:31there and worked remotely in the division of risk management and
- 1:35highly involved in, in the, uh.
- 1:38We came to the accounting for the N-C-O-S-A-F in the training of problem
- 1:42case officers, which was most enjoyable.
- 1:45And, uh, towards the end of that career, I ended up as the vice president of the CLF.
- 1:50So I did that.
- 1:51And then, you know, we've been doing this for a while now and post-retirement and
- 1:55the consulting and, and part of what I did do a, a fairly short stint as, uh.
- 2:00A chief financial officer for a conservatorship into a
- 2:03conservatorship in Manhattan.
- 2:06And, uh, then we've enjoyed what we've been doing to help the
- 2:09credit unions doing this for, well, we have almost five years Mark.
- 2:12I
- 2:12Treichel: think we're into the sixth year of consulting.
- 2:14Steve and I and Todd you're like right behind that.
- 2:17So let's pivot to, let's pivot to Todd.
- 2:20Miller: Well, I spent 34 years with NCUA.
- 2:23I can kind of break my career into three pieces like Steve were.
- 2:27The first third of it, I was an examiner and a problem case officer
- 2:31in the western western region.
- 2:33Went through a few recessions then, so the PCO side of the career was
- 2:38very busy and active back then.
- 2:40For the first decade of 2000, I spent it as a capital market
- 2:44specialist in the western region.
- 2:47Did a lot of teaching on capital market issues.
- 2:50Occasionally would help seed with a problem case class here and there.
- 2:54And then the last third of my career.
- 2:57From 2010 basically to 2021.
- 3:00When I retired, I was a director of special actions in the western region
- 3:04dealing with problem credit union, supervising problem case officer,
- 3:07regional capital market specialist, regional lending specialist.
- 3:11Very enjoyable career.
- 3:13There was some things not fun when you had to close or liquidate a credit union.
- 3:17There was a lot of fun when you could actually see a credit union
- 3:21go from troubled status back to that Camel three, two did a lot of
- 3:27conservatorships over my career.
- 3:29I did return two of them to the members.
- 3:30So that always kind of a, a chip on my shoulder.
- 3:34Some people at NCUA, they keep souvenirs from credit unions that have failed.
- 3:38You don't find any failed credit union stuff in my house, but I do have stuff
- 3:41in my house from the, um, credit unions that went into conservatorship and
- 3:45were returned to their members all, in all a very enjoyable 34 years at NCUA.
- 3:51I enjoyed almost every bit of my career.
- 3:53Spent a lot of that working with Steve.
- 3:55The first third of it.
- 3:57I retired in June of 2021 and I don't know, it was late August, early September.
- 4:01Mark gave me a call and I told my wife, yep, there's gonna be a job
- 4:05offer here out of dinner tonight.
- 4:07And so I've been helping Mark since late 2021.
- 4:10So when we get into the late 2026, I'll hit the five year mark with you.
- 4:15Treichel: There you go.
- 4:16There you go.
- 4:16Yeah.
- 4:17That was a trip out to see Dave Matthews at the Gorge, I believe,
- 4:20and we made the pit stop there.
- 4:23Caught up with Steve and Todd and Dennis.
- 4:25Bauer: Yeah, I'm a short timer with Mark.
- 4:27I've been with Mark for about a little bit over a year now.
- 4:30But I spent, uh, 38 years in the credit union industry.
- 4:35Um, most of it was with a credit union actually.
- 4:37Um, um, 32 years at Ideal Credit Union in St.
- 4:41Paul, Minnesota.
- 4:41I was, uh, retired in.
- 4:44In September of 24 as their Chief Financial officer and
- 4:47executive vice president.
- 4:49But I started my career with NCUA back in 1986, and that's where
- 4:53Mark and I got to know each other.
- 4:54We started about the same time in Minnesota traveled up and down, uh, the
- 4:58state of Minnesota examining credits up on the Iron Range and all over.
- 5:02So we had a good time those six years.
- 5:04But that's where I, I, started my career and.
- 5:07Up to no credit union.
- 5:07So I had enjoyed my time with NCA, but thoroughly enjoyed working as the,
- 5:12um, uh, working at the credit union.
- 5:14I started when the credit union was about a hundred million in assets
- 5:18and I stayed there for 32 years.
- 5:20And when I, when I left, we were about a 1.1
- 5:23billion in assets.
- 5:25And that was mainly organic growth.
- 5:27We had a couple small mergers during that time.
- 5:29So it was, it was sort of neat to go through, uh, go through that
- 5:33time, um, with that credit union.
- 5:34And I enjoy working with Mark here.
- 5:36The last year sort of kept me ke, it's kept me engaged, uh, in the credit
- 5:40union world, so I appreciate that.
- 5:41Treichel: Yeah.
- 5:42Yeah.
- 5:42This is fun.
- 5:42This is a lot of fun and I like these quarterly reports where
- 5:45you guys dive into the data and tell me what's kind of going on.
- 5:47So with that, what's going on?
- 5:49Where do you want, where, what topic what trend do you guys want
- 5:52start with and who wants to start?
- 5:54Miller: You know, these guys are like keeping their mouth shut.
- 5:56I'll open mine.
- 5:57Treichel: Okay.
- 5:58Miller: Maybe just give a little background context about 2025.
- 6:03You know, we've had a lot of volatile years with COVID.
- 6:06This massive influx of deposits, um, from all the government assistance.
- 6:12Then we had this inflation, spreading.
- 6:15Kind of had a hard time dealing with that.
- 6:17Um, a lot of long-term investments underwater and stuff.
- 6:202024 last year, things kind of normalized and I would say 2025 is
- 6:25a little bit more of normalization.
- 6:27Unemployment was fairly stable through most of 2025.
- 6:31There's some ups and downs in different FTEs and a lot of
- 6:34variations in different states.
- 6:36The yield curve, while it's still inverted at the short end, in
- 6:40general, most interest rates fell about a hundred basis points.
- 6:44Throughout 2025.
- 6:45So it gave credit unions a chance to, um, catch their breath and get caught
- 6:49back up on that net interest margin.
- 6:53Some other just interesting things that went on, and I think that this
- 6:56will come out later on the podcast.
- 6:59Even though inflation is down, inflation is still faster than wage growth.
- 7:03So savings rates across the country have been dropping.
- 7:08They were just a little over 5% in the quarters at the end of 2024.
- 7:13By the end of 2025, the national savings rates down to 3.6%.
- 7:18People that are being a little bit challenged, but all in
- 7:20all, 2025 was kind of a year.
- 7:23Let people catch their breath and still catch up from all those years of
- 7:27volatility than that whip song that got with COVID inflation and everything else.
- 7:33Farrar: Yeah,
- 7:34Bauer: Go ahead, Todd.
- 7:34Todd.
- 7:34Todd brought up interest rates and that.
- 7:36The interest rates have come down and it's interesting to see what's going on in
- 7:40the, um, credit union's deposit portfolio.
- 7:43Right.
- 7:43We saw a huge runup of.
- 7:45CDs in 2023 and 2024.
- 7:49Um, well that's beginning to shift a little bit as
- 7:51interest rates, um, come down.
- 7:53There's not much of a advantage on that short-term end now
- 7:57as, as there was in the past.
- 7:59So you see, that there's a been a huge acceleration of, of, uh, CD
- 8:04growth and a lot of that growth is now going into non maturity deposits.
- 8:09Let me see here.
- 8:09I got my notes here on, on growth.
- 8:12Yeah, for, um, the, for the, uh, for the, um, year end 2025, let's
- 8:20see, share drafts were up 8.3%.
- 8:23And in 2024, that was at 2.93%.
- 8:27And the, the largest increase in deposits was in money
- 8:30markets this past year at 9.38%,
- 8:34and at the end of the year, 2024, that was 2.37
- 8:38and CD growth, um, still fairly strong.
- 8:41For 2024, it was at 7% roughly.
- 8:44And in the year of 2024 it was around 14%.
- 8:49So you're starting to see that, uh, decel rate.
- 8:51So, so, right.
- 8:52So, and I think most of those CDs that are maturing are short-term CDs.
- 8:57So I think I read somewhere 80% of the CDs are gonna be coming due in the next year.
- 9:03Gonna be coming due here in 2026.
- 9:06There'll be an the pricing will be key as to, to try to keep those
- 9:09margins try to keep those margins up.
- 9:11So I think we're starting to see, uh, the, the, we, we started to
- 9:15see the cost of funds rate drop, but that's sort of slowing down.
- 9:19Um, and also with the yield on assets as well, that's still that's
- 9:23still up, but the growth that of, of that increase has slowed.
- 9:26So I think we're probably at the top of the net interest margin at the top of the
- 9:30net interest margin peak here in, in 2025.
- 9:34So, be interesting to see next year, 2026, what type of pressures
- 9:38are put on that interest margin?
- 9:41Miller: I'm gonna throw another little piece out there.
- 9:43So NCUA with their call reports are, they also do a chart pack.
- 9:48There's like 42 graphs in there and they have it going back for 10 years.
- 9:53But something that the industry have to think about is where did
- 9:56tomorrow's members come from?
- 9:58So, well, deposit growth last year was a little over 5%.
- 10:03And I always question these numbers because of how credit unions fill things
- 10:07in and that's their membership numbers.
- 10:08But membership only grew 2% last year.
- 10:11It's the lowest level in probably a decade.
- 10:14And what does that mean for credit union long term and when you can't
- 10:19generate new membership growth or membership growth is getting very low.
- 10:25Just something that industry to think about.
- 10:27Where's tomorrow's members gonna come?
- 10:29Farrar: Yeah, and I think that lower growth is, is the result of this
- 10:32increased competition that we keep talking about and hearing about.
- 10:36And so there is, uh, it's very competitive for bringing people in.
- 10:42And, and you always know that, you know, people don't tend to leave
- 10:47their primary financial institution until they become angry about
- 10:51something or, or feel mistreated.
- 10:53But, you know, they're, they're real rate conscious and it's easy to move money.
- 10:58And there's really great marketing out there, done by a lot of these, uh, really,
- 11:04uh, institutions that you, that you see that are, uh, on a lot of the advertising.
- 11:09Treichel: Well, and, and along those lines when you say that, I'm thinking of
- 11:12the different generations and the makeup.
- 11:15The makeup of.
- 11:16Credit unions and boomers who don't borrow, but have
- 11:19a lot of, a lot of deposits.
- 11:22Uh, and as you get younger, you know, we've talked a little bit and may talk
- 11:25about a little bit more here about, what it takes to get the younger
- 11:28people involved in credit unions.
- 11:29There is a podcast I did a couple months back with, uh, Dan Preso, Bolden Lane.
- 11:34I'll link it in the show notes, but, uh, where we talked a lot
- 11:37about the different generational.
- 11:39Challenges that credit unions are facing.
- 11:41I think we talked about it maybe a little bit on the crews that we did with, uh,
- 11:46with the QS crews that we did as well.
- 11:48But specifically on, on any more on deposits or any more on growth
- 11:53that you guys want chat about.
- 11:55Miller: Growth was pretty slow and balanced last year.
- 11:58Um, share growth was a little bit ahead to loan growth, so we did get to
- 12:02see a lot of credits they were paying back, borrowed money, um, that helped
- 12:05their net interest margins again.
- 12:08But, you know, all the growth numbers were in single digits last year.
- 12:12Maybe Steve will tell us about banks.
- 12:14He usually digs into the bank numbers when we do this podcast, but I actually
- 12:18believe the banks probably grew a little bit slower than credit Union did even.
- 12:22They weren't growing very fast last year either.
- 12:25Farrar: Yeah.
- 12:25The community bank growth rate was, was pretty low for 25.
- 12:30It was, it was basically 0.96%.
- 12:33Wow.
- 12:34And, uh, just up, I mean, down about half from what it was the year before.
- 12:38So, so the community banks are, are seeing slower growth and also so
- 12:45Treichel: interesting.
- 12:46So we kind of, uh.
- 12:49Started with the discussion on deposits, which would, when I think
- 12:51deposits, I think, uh, obviously you think growth, but you think liquidity.
- 12:55Let's go back to the beginning of the camel.
- 12:57Let's talk about, uh, any camel, excuse me, capital.
- 13:01Any capital trends that you highlighted when you reviewed
- 13:04this, that you want chat about?
- 13:06Bauer: One, one thing I noticed, I mean, when you look at net worth
- 13:09year over year, it's up from 11.2,
- 13:11I think at the end of quarter or end of 24.
- 13:14It's sitting at 11.28.
- 13:17However, at the end of the third quarter, it was at 11.35.
- 13:21So we saw a slight down a downward movement in, in that,
- 13:26um, in the, uh, net worth ratio.
- 13:30That, you know, right.
- 13:31We had a little Right.
- 13:32That might be a little bit smaller amount of earnings.
- 13:35Right.
- 13:35So, so in effect you know, asset growth, even though it's been somewhat muted, five
- 13:40percent's not bad, but obviously equity growth isn't keeping, didn't keep up with
- 13:45it in the, in this last, uh, last quarter.
- 13:47So I don't know if that's a trend or if, um, if that is just related to.
- 13:54Year end, uh, cleaning up some of the balance sheet.
- 13:56But I just, I did notice that a little, little slight downward movement
- 14:00in the, the net worth ratio which, part of it might be related to.
- 14:05DLL is a little bit elevated, right?
- 14:07They're sitting at 61 basis points, which is a little bit higher than average.
- 14:11So I think we'll probably talk about that in a bit, but that might be part of it.
- 14:14And then, right, the, and we talked about, I think this at the, in our last
- 14:18podcast, we continue to see an a trend upward in the non-interest expense.
- 14:22So that might be putting pressure a little bit on earnings, which then,
- 14:26not making enough earnings to keep up with that asset growth cause that
- 14:29net worth ratio to slip a little bit.
- 14:33Miller: On the positive side, there's only 59 credit unions that are not
- 14:36well capitalized in the whole us.
- 14:38So, you know, you got that regulatory well-capitalized number at 7%.
- 14:43There's only 59 credit unions out of 4,000 that are below that 7% ratio.
- 14:48So.
- 14:49Well, NCUA has laid off 27% of their staff, or 25% or whatever the number is.
- 14:55They haven't publicly disclosed how many people have actually
- 14:59left in the last year and a half.
- 15:01The credit unions are in good shape for the moment.
- 15:05NCUA can catch their breath a little bit.
- 15:07There is a lot of capital out there now, competitively, should capital ratios
- 15:12be higher, you can make an argument.
- 15:14Maybe they should be higher.
- 15:17Overall from a regulatory standpoint, credit unions are in pretty good
- 15:21shape right now in terms of capital.
- 15:23They're still recovering from, those unrealized losses in those
- 15:28investment portfolios that go all the way back to the COVID years,
- 15:32but that's getting better too.
- 15:34Gap net worth and went up almost 200 basis points in the last couple of years.
- 15:39So that's a positive there.
- 15:42Later on we'll talk about some credit union.
- 15:45To undo all the good that's come about with that, but we'll save
- 15:49that for later in the podcast.
- 15:50For the moment though, as an industry, the credit union capital
- 15:54wise are looking pretty good.
- 15:55Treichel: Looking very strong.
- 15:56Steve, any any thoughts to throw in on capital before we pivot?
- 16:00Farrar: Yeah, if you compare capital back against the community banks who are
- 16:04sitting, they're very similar right now.
- 16:06'cause their core, uh, capital ratio is 11.05.
- 16:09It, theirs did increase, but you would expect that 'cause
- 16:12they had slower asset growth.
- 16:15Treichel: Makes sense.
- 16:16Makes sense.
- 16:18So let's pivot to asset quality.
- 16:20And you know, Todd, you mentioned part of assets is, is the
- 16:25investments side of things.
- 16:27And, and, uh, you know, I went back and kind of looked at what
- 16:29we chatted about last time.
- 16:30You, you talked a little bit about people going longer in
- 16:34the three to five year bucket.
- 16:36Which if my numbers look right, that investment category has gone up 17%.
- 16:40So let, let's start with that.
- 16:42People undoing, the rates have gone down.
- 16:44They're recovering some of their gap equity but they're starting to go long.
- 16:48And Todd, any, what do you got on that?
- 16:52Miller: Well, like I said, you know, the yield curve has come
- 16:54down, but it's basically flat.
- 16:56Then you sit here and look at COVID years.
- 16:59Credit unions went long.
- 17:00Banks went long too.
- 17:01Some of 'em failed because they went long on investments during this time
- 17:05period, a lot of credit unions did.
- 17:07So now they ended up with investment portfolios that are underwater for a long
- 17:11period of time, and they're illiquid.
- 17:14You can borrow against them, but they're basically illiquid.
- 17:17So now we're in a similar environment, so rates have come down a little bit.
- 17:21The yield curve is flat.
- 17:23Then dollars of investments in that, over five years, over 10 years,
- 17:28over three years, every one of those categories, dollars a grid.
- 17:33And there's like no spread between, you know, going out from three years to 10
- 17:39years, and you just wonder why they're making bets that rates are gonna fall.
- 17:43What if rates don't fall?
- 17:45You know, there's like 11 basis points between a five
- 17:48and a seven year investment.
- 17:49There's only like 14 basis points between a three and a 10 year investment.
- 17:54Why are you going out 10 years?
- 17:56That little bit of yield you gain is not worth putting that much interest
- 18:01rate risk on your books or a decade.
- 18:04It makes no sense to me.
- 18:06The risk for the risk is, is high and the reward is low,
- 18:09is what I'm hearing you say.
- 18:10I'm sure there's a whole bunch of investment brokers out there
- 18:13that will tell me, Hey, I don't know what I'm talking about.
- 18:15But you know, I know I fixed a lot of problem credit unions in my career where
- 18:20they made mistakes just similar to this and it just seems to not make sense to me.
- 18:25Now, maybe there's a credit union out there where their
- 18:27loan to share rates are always.
- 18:2920% where they could maybe make an argument that some of it.
- 18:33But realistically, you know, credit unions over a billion
- 18:36dollars are 78% of the industry.
- 18:40So this is big credit unions making bets to make those dollars move.
- 18:44This isn't little credit unions, this is big credit unions doing.
- 18:48Maybe some of them will be our clients a couple years down the road,
- 18:52Treichel: so there is that.
- 18:54Yeah.
- 18:54Yeah.
- 18:55Investments, uh, in going along Dennis, Steve, anything you
- 18:58wanna add to that before we pivot into the other asset categories?
- 19:02Bauer: No.
- 19:03And, and, and, and maybe this will segue into the loan, but right when you look at.
- 19:07If you're looking at, we're going longer in the investment portfolio, you look
- 19:10at where loan growth has occurred and it's in mortgages and commercial, so
- 19:13it tend to be a little bit longer.
- 19:15So you're sort of, doubling up there of extending your
- 19:18balance sheet, uh, duration.
- 19:19So
- 19:20Treichel: that's a good point.
- 19:21Bauer: Yeah.
- 19:22Treichel: Steve, anything on investments?
- 19:24Anything compare to banks?
- 19:26Farrar: Uh, I have nothing to add.
- 19:27Treichel: Nothing to add.
- 19:28All right.
- 19:28Let's pivot into the other asset quality, uh, conundrums.
- 19:32Or positivities, whatever they might be.
- 19:34Loan delinquency.
- 19:35Dennis, you talked a little bit about charge offs.
- 19:37Talked a little bit about PLL.
- 19:39What's, uh, what's, what are the numbers showing on loans, gentlemen?
- 19:44Bauer: What I saw for like delinquency.
- 19:47That has crept up a bit.
- 19:50Particularly if you look at real estate, I think that's where the, the biggest
- 19:54category where you, where I saw, uh, an increase in delinquency that was up 10
- 20:00basis points from year end, uh, 2024.
- 20:04Um, but it's interesting, right?
- 20:05I think at the end of 2024, delinquency rose quite a bit.
- 20:08And then in that first quarter of.
- 20:10Of last year, it, it came down nicely, but now it's back up to where it was
- 20:14at the end of, or a little bit, even beyond where it was in, in 2024.
- 20:18But it, you know, it looked like it was real estate related.
- 20:20I don't know if Steve or if Todd saw anything different, but that's where
- 20:24I sort of, saw that, that, where that, uh, delinquency really picked up.
- 20:29Miller: I've got every category on the call report in a little chart right here.
- 20:33Bauer: Alright.
- 20:33Treichel: Alright.
- 20:33Let's
- 20:33Miller: hear it.
- 20:34Let's hear it went out just about everywhere.
- 20:36But I'm gonna throw one other thing out there too, because
- 20:38this is kind of a red flag.
- 20:40So I mentioned NCUA has their little chart package that has
- 20:44a decade of numbers in it.
- 20:47This is the first time in a decade where delinquency for the
- 20:51whole industry has been over 1%.
- 20:53Mic
- 20:54Treichel: drop.
- 20:54That's a big no, that's a
- 20:55Miller: powerful stat.
- 20:57Yes.
- 20:58So within the credit unions, you know, what you see is, so commercial
- 21:03loans have been growing delinquency in those commercial categories
- 21:07have went up pretty significantly.
- 21:10Especially with the construction and development piece, the non-owner occupied
- 21:14commercial real estate, that delinquency jumped almost 25 basis points last year.
- 21:20Farm operating loans, which there's not a lot of in credit union, their
- 21:23delinquency is really skyrocketed.
- 21:26Student loan delinquency has shot up govern.
- 21:30Most credit unions have.
- 21:30Um.
- 21:31Non-government guaranteed student loans that have went up.
- 21:34Unsecured delinquency is actually stayed kind of stable.
- 21:38Car loans have stayed really stable.
- 21:39You would think that would be a troubled category.
- 21:42But we talk about loan growth.
- 21:44Auto loans actually shrank in the credit union industry in 2025, and
- 21:49I don't know if I've ever seen that in my career where the dollars of
- 21:51auto loans actually didn't go up.
- 21:54Of course new vehicles are, I just bought one here recently.
- 21:58They're a lot of money.
- 22:00I think people say there's trucks out there that are a hundred thousand
- 22:02dollars now, which is kind of crazy.
- 22:05So a lot of the areas, the real estate delinquency is jumped up
- 22:09primarily like primary residence.
- 22:11That hasn't moved much.
- 22:12It only went from 79 to 88 basis points.
- 22:16Real estate second longs those HELOCs, they're.
- 22:20Delinquencies only one up nine basis points.
- 22:23It's at about 0.89.
- 22:25This other residential real estate, though, kind of non-owner occupied that
- 22:29shot up from 62 basis points to 141.
- 22:33Bauer: Is that honest?
- 22:34Miller: That's not a big chunk of the real estate right though.
- 22:37But it's so they're not commercial loans, but they're one to four
- 22:40family dwellings or single things that are not on or occupied.
- 22:44Say those,
- 22:44Treichel: say those numbers again.
- 22:4561 to 61 basis points
- 22:48Miller: to 141 basis points to 1.41.
- 22:52So you see these little segments of the industry and you know, prior
- 22:57to the old, under the old business loan rule, those probably would've
- 23:01been called commercial loans.
- 23:02Treichel: Right?
- 23:02Miller: And they're not anymore.
- 23:04Treichel: Right?
- 23:05Miller: Some of that's probably undeveloped property too.
- 23:07You know, there it's just bare land is probably in that category somewhere too.
- 23:12But.
- 23:14You just see things kind of wearing away at the edges, and I think it kind of
- 23:21goes back, you know, I'm not gonna throw out all the statistics, but you look
- 23:24at unemployment across the 50 states.
- 23:27You look at earnings in the chart, map across the 50 states.
- 23:31There's a lot of places where there's huge disparities in performance.
- 23:35And you see this with the banks too, Steve.
- 23:37You know, if you look at those.
- 23:39Regional levels.
- 23:40The numbers are very different from region to region, so we
- 23:44have parts of the US that.
- 23:46Are doing really well and other parts that are not doing as well.
- 23:50And you know, I suspect if we actually pulled this at a state level or regional
- 23:54level, that you would find that a lot of these delinquency increases are probably
- 24:00isolated in, you know, a small number of places, maybe a quarter of the US.
- 24:06Which is kind of interesting 'cause you go back and look at, our experiences
- 24:10dealing with troubled credits, and I'm sure you saw this mark as a DSA and a PCO
- 24:15and regional director recessions in places where performance deteriorate all tended
- 24:22to be regionalized at different times.
- 24:25You know, and when I was a PCO, we had a time period, Montana
- 24:29and Alaska kind of sucked.
- 24:31And then they got better.
- 24:32And then it was Southern California where had issues.
- 24:34And then it was Northern California that had issues not
- 24:37related to Southern California.
- 24:39And we had a period of time, we had issues in Hawaii.
- 24:42And then of course the last recession, the sand stakes.
- 24:45You know, it was really five or six states that got get really, really
- 24:48hard compared to the rest of the us.
- 24:51And I suspect you're getting some of that with these delinquency increases here.
- 24:55If we really dug into it.
- 24:58There's probably very much regional aspects to that
- 25:01underneath the national numbers.
- 25:03Treichel: Yeah.
- 25:03If, if we duck and, and again, 1.4,
- 25:05one a hundred forty one basis points is the average delinquency on that category.
- 25:10If we looked at the granular data going out 1, 2, 3 standard deviations there's
- 25:15probably a handful of institutions, um, that are materially impacting
- 25:20that number without getting into, I, I haven't looked at those numbers, but
- 25:23that would be an interesting deep dive.
- 25:27Miller: I said the credit union's over 1 billion and you know, there's 439
- 25:31of them and there's 21 in the ones credit unions that are over 10 billion.
- 25:36You know, those credit unions account for about 79% of the
- 25:40total credit union's assets.
- 25:43And when you see numbers like this jump, it's probably someone in one of
- 25:48those two categories or maybe four or five credit unions in that category.
- 25:52Treichel: Yep.
- 25:53Miller: In that four hundred and fifty, four hundred sixty credit
- 25:57unions, it's probably just a handful of credit unions in that four 60 that are
- 26:02actually moving some of these numbers.
- 26:04Because I noticed, like with our own clients, most of them, their
- 26:09delinquencies were pretty stable in 2025.
- 26:12They didn't move very much so.
- 26:14You know, we, we might have a client here and there that did see some delinquency
- 26:18rise, but for most of our clients that we deal with personally, their delinquency
- 26:22and charge off numbers were really stable from 24 to 2025, but nationally.
- 26:28You're seeing some red flags out there.
- 26:30Treichel: Well, and, and I'm gonna take this opportunity, since you brought
- 26:33up ones to say, Hey, NCA, if you're listening, when are you going to tell the
- 26:39world that ones is or may be going away?
- 26:42You've told your staff but you haven't technically told uh uh, the.
- 26:47The stakeholders.
- 26:49Uh, let's, uh, let's get on that.
- 26:51Uh, as soon as you can.
- 26:52Maybe there's, uh, good reasons for not telling them.
- 26:54I can think of a couple that might be contemplated as potentially good
- 26:58reasons, but, but there really are no good reasons because the world
- 27:01of Credit Union deserves to know.
- 27:03And while it only impacts as a few of the large credit
- 27:06unions, that does trickle down.
- 27:08So.
- 27:08Alright, I'll, I'll get off my soapbox on, on NCAAs.
- 27:11Um, needing to communicate better, uh, Steve, any thoughts from a bank
- 27:16perspective or in general on this?
- 27:18Farrar: You can see the similarities they're having that in delinquency across
- 27:22the industry for community banks and great is double what it was in 2022, so
- 27:29that's why people are worried about it.
- 27:30But I always look more specifically is delinquency is an issue that we have
- 27:36to deal with in terms of collections and all that, but where it really
- 27:39becomes a problem is in losses.
- 27:42And, um, you know, the, our, the loss ratio, I didn't notice anything for
- 27:48sign in our industry, but the credit union loss percentages much higher
- 27:54than it is in the community banks.
- 27:56Their loss, uh, net charge off for loans was 0.21
- 28:01for 2025, and, and it stayed below 0.2
- 28:05the last couple of years and, and our, the credit union industry is 0.78.
- 28:11So that reflects in the provision for a loss expense.
- 28:15And that's a little bit of a competitive disadvantage that
- 28:19the credit unions probably have.
- 28:22And Todd did notice that that regionality is huge when you look
- 28:26at the community bank data that their losses are, are just so much
- 28:31higher in that San Francisco region compared to every, every other region.
- 28:36It's just way out almost outta bounds.
- 28:39Treichel: Interesting.
- 28:40Well, and some of that, if you were to talk to individual credit unions, if
- 28:44you're talk to low income, designated credit unions or some of that higher
- 28:50delinquency, uh, and loss ratio.
- 28:53Loss ratio specifically would be, would be tied to theoretically
- 28:57serving people of modest means.
- 28:59Right.
- 28:59In some instances it's loan quality.
- 29:01But some, but it's.
- 29:03Credit union's owned by the owners.
- 29:05So maybe they're making broader decisions on their loans potentially.
- 29:09Uh, but that gap is more than what that would tend to.
- 29:13Miller: I think that's part of it, mark, to be honest with you, that is part
- 29:16of it, that part of the tax exemption.
- 29:19You know, you go back prior to the last recession in 2008, and my numbers
- 29:24are probably kind of foggy, but.
- 29:27I don't remember.
- 29:28Like 1% charge off being something that bothered me back then.
- 29:32Treichel: Yeah, exactly.
- 29:34No, it's a great point.
- 29:36When, when, when numbers double, but the number was so low and when those are not
- 29:41numbers that scare any of us is from a risk perspective, but the, it's the trend.
- 29:46It's more the, the trend and the velocity of the change maybe.
- 29:50Miller: Yeah.
- 29:51And.
- 29:52Like last year, the, all the numbers were fairly stable with inflation.
- 29:56Interest rates came down a little bit.
- 29:59You know, now bonds are flying through the sky.
- 30:02That creates volatility and uncertainty.
- 30:04So who know, who knows where things are gonna go and like I
- 30:09said, there's always been this.
- 30:11Geographical differentiations, parts of the country doing really well,
- 30:15parts of the country not doing so well.
- 30:18I think that will probably always be there and it'll be just interesting
- 30:21to see how that plays out.
- 30:23But I do think for NCUA where they've had these cuts in staff, they're gonna
- 30:28have to be paying attention to loan quality, loan quality loan quality
- 30:32loan quality, and concentration risk because it's loan losses that
- 30:37cause losses to the insurance fund.
- 30:40With their scarce resources.
- 30:41That's the one thing they absolutely need to be paying attention to is
- 30:45asset quality in the crane industry
- 30:48Treichel: and with their, and when they're done with that, they
- 30:50might wanna look at asset quality.
- 30:52All right, let's pivot to, let's see, we did the C, we did the A, uh, we sort
- 30:57of did the LI think that leaves the E.
- 30:58We've, we've talked about it a little bit.
- 31:01What are we seeing in the earnings arena, gentlemen?
- 31:04Bauer: Compared to 2024.
- 31:05ROA was up 16 basis points, very strong.
- 31:10Fueled by net interest margin.
- 31:12That was up 27 basis points, so right, that, that contributed to the bottom line.
- 31:19If you compare it to Q3 2025, things are changing a bit.
- 31:24Actually ROA is down.
- 31:27Roughly three basis points from 79 to 82.
- 31:32And as I mentioned, it seems like margin, net interest margins possibly have peaked.
- 31:37That was only up one basis point if you compare year end to quarter
- 31:41three compared to 27, so right.
- 31:44So that's slowed down.
- 31:45PLL is roughly the same.
- 31:47Non-interest income is flat, not really any changes, and we still continue to see
- 31:52a little bit of an up upt uptick in on operating expenses that was only up two
- 31:58basis points for the quarter over quarter, and it was up 10 basis year over year.
- 32:03So, right?
- 32:03I think so.
- 32:05So I think that that acceleration of net interest margin is, is basically done.
- 32:10And that, that, that's depending upon how we manage, uh, how credit unions
- 32:13manage that non-interest expense.
- 32:16Um, and then the loan quality will really determine power leg.
- 32:21First part of, of this year.
- 32:22It'd be interesting to see what, what plays out
- 32:26Miller: part of the whole net interest margin is.
- 32:29You know, you talked about earlier they've been whip saw with inflation
- 32:34deposits, this, that rising interest rates, interest rates falling, but
- 32:39like last year they're still playing catch up because loan yields went up.
- 32:43They were able to bring cost to funds down a little bit.
- 32:45That's what helped that net interest margin is they're still playing catch
- 32:49up on those yield, uh, loan yields.
- 32:52Investment yields were up a little bit too.
- 32:54Um.
- 32:56But the last thing that Dennis mentioned, the operating expenses,
- 33:00that's a challenging one.
- 33:03So we've got 1, 2, 3, almost four years.
- 33:06We're operating expense numbers relative to assets have increased.
- 33:10And yes, there's been some massive inflation in there and, but we've also
- 33:16had some years where there's been a fair amount of growth in there too.
- 33:20Well actually not really.
- 33:23Asset growth, 5 4, 2 5.
- 33:26That operating expense number going up though is.
- 33:30It would make me nervous if I was still working at nc.
- 33:33Right.
- 33:34Treichel: And it's been at least 6% for three straight years.
- 33:37The, yeah.
- 33:37Operating expenses which, um, I, I wonder when the last time that happened was.
- 33:41Bauer: Yeah, it's, I think a lot of it's re related to wage inflation.
- 33:44We talked maybe a little bit about this in the last podcast, but Right.
- 33:48The last two years, 2024 and 2025 salaries and benefits went up roughly 8% each year.
- 33:56Whereas asset growth is.
- 33:58Been a lot lower than that.
- 33:59So that's gonna push up, right?
- 34:01That's just gonna push that ratio up.
- 34:02But 8% right?
- 34:03That.
- 34:04I didn't go back to years prior to that to see if that, that, that seemed a
- 34:08little bit, that seemed a little bit high compared to historical numbers, but Right.
- 34:13I think it's a little bit of a catch up because of, in, of inflation that went
- 34:16on, um, from, you know, 2021 to 2023 trying to maintain and retain, uh, staff.
- 34:22So that might be a big, might be a big piece of it.
- 34:25It's nice to see that.
- 34:26It's starting to slow down the rate of operating expense growth.
- 34:30Hopefully that that's peaked.
- 34:32Um, but that Right, that was a contributing factor to uh, yeah,
- 34:35to that obviously to the increase in overall operating expenses
- 34:39Miller: that kinda led the way in 2024.
- 34:41But I actually just brought up that whole income statement for 2025 in front of me.
- 34:47It's virtually every category went up 8%.
- 34:51Farrar: Yeah.
- 34:52Yeah.
- 34:53Miller: In back to your employee compensation benefit only went up 11.2.
- 34:57It was one of the lower growing ones.
- 35:00Dollar wise it was a big one.
- 35:01'cause dollar wise, it's what, a third of mm-hmm.
- 35:04Almost 50% of the total expenses, operating expenses, it's almost
- 35:09half of it is employee compensation.
- 35:11Um, so that half went up 7% and the other half went up.
- 35:16Mm-hmm.
- 35:16Most of the categories went up close to 8% last year too.
- 35:20So it's a little bit of everything.
- 35:22But yes, wages and compensation.
- 35:26You know, as Dennis brought up, that's half of operating expenses, so it's
- 35:30a big number and it's hard, bigger,
- 35:34Farrar: it's
- 35:34Miller: hard
- 35:34Farrar: to
- 35:35Miller: control that when inflation is growing, you know.
- 35:38But if we go back and just look at staffing for members, I'm sure I
- 35:43have that here in my notes somewhere.
- 35:44I do.
- 35:46Members to full-time employees has stayed relatively stable.
- 35:50Actually went down a little bit in 2025, so
- 35:54Bauer: yeah.
- 35:54Could it could go back to what the other expenses, you know, mark, you
- 35:57were talking about membership growth and credit unions staying relevant.
- 36:01So, right.
- 36:02Part of the challenge is in this digital world, is to invest in
- 36:06your infrastructure, your your ai, your, your digital presence.
- 36:10So.
- 36:11That, that might be fuel a some of the additional expense growth
- 36:15in, you know, operating expenses.
- 36:17Is that strategy or that of, of staying relevant so that,
- 36:21again, grow their membership?
- 36:24I think it's, it's maybe a piece of it as well.
- 36:26Miller: I think you're probably right, Dennis.
- 36:28'cause I suspect during the COVID years, a lot of that type of stuff didn't occur.
- 36:33So people were playing catch up here in the year since.
- 36:36It's interesting how we're three years out of that and you still see that
- 36:40event having an impact on what's going on across society in many ways yet
- 36:46Treichel: Many ways.
- 36:47For sure.
- 36:47For sure.
- 36:48Farrar: Yeah.
- 36:49The, uh, that 7% expense growth rate is basically what they
- 36:53have had in the community.
- 36:54Banks who are the Thera Unions were, were actually below the, uh,
- 36:59community banks and the rate of growth.
- 37:01An interesting thing that we had that when N two A had the, uh.
- 37:04The podcast on, what was it, Todd?
- 37:07The, where I submitted the question, which podcast was it that or webcast?
- 37:11NCA did,
- 37:12Miller: was there supervisory priorities?
- 37:14Farrar: Yeah.
- 37:14Yeah.
- 37:14And I'd, I'd submitted the question is, you know, what's NCO a's thought on, uh,
- 37:19credit union, putting their capital to work, work in terms of raising expenses
- 37:24as they try to increase technology and increase in the competition.
- 37:30They read the question, but the answer had nothing to do with
- 37:33the question that I'd asked.
- 37:35'cause I wanted to try and get them like more, you know, on the record is where
- 37:39do they stand on credit unions trying to put their capital to work to address
- 37:44the competition that they're facing or even other issues that they have.
- 37:48Treichel: Well, and, and sometimes, you know, having, having been
- 37:51in on those webinars, you know, it's a little bit like, um.
- 37:55It can, when you're on the other side with NCUA, it's a little bit like, uh,
- 37:59making sure planes don't collide and you've got, okay, this, this question
- 38:03we wanna make sure we've answer it and, and who are we gonna assign it to?
- 38:06And you got people, RA that one's for me.
- 38:07And I'm guessing what happens, Steve, is someone said, Hey,
- 38:10this is a good question.
- 38:12Why don't we have this person answer it?
- 38:13I haven't, I gotta go back and listen to it.
- 38:15But there was a mismatch between, uh, what they thought the question was and
- 38:19maybe the right person wasn't in the room.
- 38:22Farrar: Yeah, but we can throw it out to, you know, Todd and them as you know.
- 38:24Yeah.
- 38:25We we're hearing it from our clients is really, we we're trying
- 38:28to address this the competition issues, but they're not feeling
- 38:33support from nsu, their NCA examiner.
- 38:37Miller: I mean, we've got credit unions that are way, way north
- 38:40of 7% and you know, they're getting doors about earnings.
- 38:46They're getting doors about, Hey, we think you need more capital.
- 38:50Of course, they can't define what that number is.
- 38:53And this is, you know, the one client that we had, it, it's
- 38:56a very diversified client.
- 38:57They have like no concentration risk or anything, you know, and they're
- 39:01still cutting flack from NCUA about putting some of their capital to work.
- 39:06And we have another client that just got a door.
- 39:08It says, you may have too much liquidity.
- 39:11Not you have too much.
- 39:12You may have some I.
- 39:15And, you know, so it's kind of a nebulous thing.
- 39:17And you know, Steve texted me that capital question the day before and I said, oh,
- 39:22they're not gonna read that question.
- 39:24So they read it, but they didn't answer it.
- 39:25They didn't even read my question.
- 39:27So I can't remember what I sent in, but I always send one just to see if they'll
- 39:31read it or not, because you know, they can see your email that you register with.
- 39:35So they know who's asking these questions for the most part.
- 39:40Treichel: I I don't ask questions.
- 39:41I figure they'll, they'll, uh,
- 39:43Miller: you just need to come up with like a Mickey Mouse email or something.
- 39:47They don't know who you are,
- 39:50Bauer: I guess.
- 39:50Right?
- 39:50We, but we also gotta look at expenses in relation to income, so efficiency ratio.
- 39:54Right.
- 39:55So those look pretty stable.
- 39:57They've actually continued to drop, partly because that in
- 40:00net interest margin bumped up.
- 40:02But so you don't, I guess you'd be concerned if you saw operating expenses.
- 40:06Increasing and then also the efficiency ratio increasing.
- 40:09But we're not, not necessarily seeing that.
- 40:12So that's one thing I looked at a lot and at our credit unions just
- 40:15kind of income are we generating to be able to support those expenses.
- 40:18And overall it looks like credit unions have done that, uh,
- 40:20quite nicely this past year.
- 40:22Miller: Yeah.
- 40:22Yeah.
- 40:22The efficiency ratio hasn't actually moved at all.
- 40:26I mean, it moved a little bit.
- 40:2749.
- 40:27Bauer: Yeah.
- 40:28I came to, I show that it was at about 72% at the end of last year,
- 40:33and it's down to about 69, 70%.
- 40:36So it moved a little bit, didn't go up.
- 40:38So
- 40:39Farrar: that's what
- 40:39Bauer: I'm trying
- 40:39Farrar: to say.
- 40:39Miller: Yep.
- 40:40Farrar: Yeah.
- 40:41And in the year end we had, uh, a 11.7%
- 40:44of, uh, credit unions are unprofitable and
- 40:48Miller: uh, only 5% of banks are unprofitable.
- 40:51Farrar: Yeah.
- 40:515% of banks.
- 40:52Yeah,
- 40:53Miller: so I actually, you know, and that's another one that NCUA gives
- 40:57you a little 10 year history on, or No, I did a query on it myself.
- 41:02We have a hundred credit unions over a hundred million exactly
- 41:05that were negative earners in 2025, there's 500 credit unions.
- 41:09Lost money, but there was a hundred over a hundred million not lost money.
- 41:13And I thought that was kind of a interesting number.
- 41:16So you've got some large 17 credit unions over a billion dollars, lost money.
- 41:22You know, that's 5% of them.
- 41:25So that's like in line with the community banks.
- 41:28But 11% of the industry losing money, that's a fairly big number.
- 41:35Treichel: Yeah, those small ones that are losing that's probably
- 41:37where a lot of the mergers are.
- 41:39I was looking at merger data for some separate stuff, but every year,
- 41:43four to 5% of 'em are going away.
- 41:45And so if 11% are losing money, a lot of that four to 5% that goes
- 41:50away are coming from that 11%.
- 41:52Uh, especially when you look at the reasons they say why they're going away.
- 41:56Alright, so earnings.
- 41:57Any, any more things on, on the earnings?
- 41:59Uh.
- 42:00Topic?
- 42:02No.
- 42:02All right.
- 42:03So let any, anything you got on your notes that you wanted to
- 42:08talk about that we haven't hit?
- 42:10Farrar: I usually give just a quick update on both the insurance
- 42:12funds and they both did really good here in the end of the quarter.
- 42:16Um, you know, n two ways equity ratio in increased.
- 42:21And, um, and the bank went increased and so, so they're, they're both looking
- 42:25really good as far as the insurance funds and so that's always good news.
- 42:30Treichel: Very good.
- 42:31And Todd, any last words?
- 42:33Miller: Couple a LM things, you know, not long term assets
- 42:36in the credit union industry.
- 42:38They're going down just a few basis points every year.
- 42:41So there, there's no indication that interest rate risk is going
- 42:45up, it's actually staying stable or going down a little bit.
- 42:48And then last year, liquidity improved quite a bit.
- 42:51A lot of your wholesale funding was repaid.
- 42:55So try to have more capacity to borrow money and bring in
- 42:59non-member funds if they need to.
- 43:01So that side of things looked pretty decent as well.
- 43:04So small improvements in liquidity, interest rate risk wasn't going up.
- 43:09If I'm an MCUA person, I'm only gonna be worried about
- 43:12credit risk for the most part.
- 43:15Asset
- 43:15Farrar: quality, asset
- 43:16Treichel: Quality.
- 43:16Asset quality,
- 43:17Farrar: yeah.
- 43:17And camel ratings, uh, you know, it showed improvement.
- 43:20That improve, especially in terms of dollars.
- 43:22It's wasn't a big improvement, like the reduction in camel threes.
- 43:27There was, there was 155 billion reduction in assets, which means
- 43:31there may have been somebody who was pretty big that is no longer a three.
- 43:35Treichel: That'll cover some of their staff reductions and not
- 43:38having to go to do follow up so much.
- 43:41Dennis.
- 43:42Bauer: The only thing I wanted to point out is the allowance coverage
- 43:45of delinquency a little bit more back on asset quality, right?
- 43:48So that, so how much, how much do we have an allowance compared to delinquency?
- 43:52So at the at the end of third quarter of 2025, that was 140%.
- 43:58So a lot more coverage and allowance then and delinquency that dropped
- 44:03to 131% at the end of the year.
- 44:07So that just says that link Delinquency's going up, but the
- 44:10allowance isn't keeping pace.
- 44:12So really interesting to see how that transpires in this current year.
- 44:16If that, if if, I mean a lot of it depends on where that delinquency's happening.
- 44:20A lot of it was happening in the real estate portfolio,
- 44:22so maybe that that's fine.
- 44:24But it was, it was notable though that it was at 140% coverage at the end of Q3.
- 44:30It's only 131% at the end of.
- 44:33And at the end of last year it was 136%.
- 44:37So downward trend.
- 44:39So Cecil, right?
- 44:41So Cecil comes into play.
- 44:42See what kind of, um, impact that might have for provision.
- 44:46In 2020, in 2026,
- 44:48Farrar: and that number in the community banks is 153%.
- 44:52They've always had a, a bit more in their allowance than the credit union industry.
- 44:58Bauer: And Steve, do you have any trends from them, Steve, or
- 45:00is that just a point in time?
- 45:02Farrar: I just looked at this specific point in time and it's been
- 45:04pretty consistent at that level.
- 45:07Miller: The other thing though too, is when you got delinquency
- 45:10reporting the banks, they have.
- 45:1230 to 90.
- 45:13And then NCA has got zero to 60 and then mm-hmm.
- 45:17Over 60.
- 45:18So the delinquency numbers aren't exactly the same.
- 45:22Farrar: Yeah.
- 45:23Treichel: And when I hear coverage ratio, I think of a meeting I was in
- 45:26with Steve Farr and Dan Murphy, the former regional director when Steve
- 45:30and I worked for him on the West Coast.
- 45:32And he said, when you guys come in here and brief me,
- 45:35you say, this one's doing bad.
- 45:36This one's doing good.
- 45:38I wanna believe you, but I just look at their, this, the ratio of their
- 45:41delinquency to their allowance.
- 45:43And so we, we coined that the Murphy ratio back before we knew it was the cover.
- 45:48It might have been called the coverage ratio back then, but we had
- 45:50it, we, that was the Murphy ratio.
- 45:52So I always, I always think, so the Murphy ratio's not, not as good as it was.
- 45:56It's a trending in the wrong way.
- 45:57That's something we can watch going forward.
- 46:01All right guys, this was fun.
- 46:02I've got a Costco delivery coming in two minutes.
- 46:05So this worked out perfectly.
- 46:07Hopefully, uh, we'll get this uploaded by Tuesday for Tuesday's episode.
- 46:13Uh, hopefully by then I've got myself a new quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings.
- 46:17Uh,
- 46:18Miller: good luck.
- 46:18Treichel: Yeah.
- 46:19Yeah.
- 46:20Which Todd, by the way, if we get if we get, uh, Kyler.
- 46:25Bauer: Murray.
- 46:26Treichel: Murray he was picked first.
- 46:28The Bear's quarterback was picked first.
- 46:30The lion's quarterback was picked first, but not the Packers.
- 46:35All right.
- 46:36That's all I got.
- 46:37Miller: They developed theirs in-house, and they don't need a quarterback.
- 46:40Treichel: They need You're the quarterback farm.
- 46:42You guys always develop 'em.
- 46:43That's right.
- 46:44Yeah.
- 46:44Good comeback.
- 46:45All right.
- 46:46Asset quality.
- 46:47Asset quality.
- 46:47And develop your quarterbacks from within
- 46:51Miller: Green Bay.
- 46:51Find a defense.
- 46:53Treichel: Hey, you just signed a guy.
- 46:54We cut.
- 46:55So, he'll be good for you though.
- 46:56All right, guys, the listeners.
- 46:58Thanks for listening, watchers.
- 47:00Thanks for watching.
- 47:01Uh, guys, thanks for, uh, your wisdom.
- 47:03And this is Mark Rele signing off with flying colors.