Latest / The Big Nerd Gaming Podcast / Control Resonant, Marvel's Wolverine, Chrono Trigger + Our Top 5 Games We Played in September
Transcript
- Westen: What is up, everybody, and welcome to the Big Nerd Gaming Podcast. We're back. We've had busy lives, lots going on. So we're back. You know, the the schedule isn't as consistent as we like. We're doing our best here. We're we're grown-ass men, damn it. So just deal with it. I'm your host. My name is Weston. First off, we have a man who finally decided to play. The number two greatest game of all time, according to Bignerd Gaming dot com. It's David. What's up, David? David: It's going good. Glad to finally get this podcast going where people are no longer sick, no tech issues. Ready to go, ready to rumble. Westen: Yeah, until until my four year old comes down the stairs at some point during this podcast. She's she's a little squirrely tonight, so I don't know. We're we're hoping for the best. David: Yeah. Westen: And finally we have a man who's just just saw another Kingdom Hearts related release. I'm sure he's ready to slop it up. Yeah, slop up that Kingdom Hearts. Yeah, keep remixing the same bullshit. I'll keep buying it. It's Andrew. Andrew: You're darn right I'm gonna buy it on another platform. I've gotten over my new case of the mnemonic plague or whatever the hell they're calling this new thing and and you know what, we're clear, we're good, the Patriots gotta win and we've got Kingdom Hearts. It's all we need. Westen: my god. There's nothing there's nothing worse than a Boston fan. Yeah. That's the grossest shit I've ever heard. David: Ugh, disgusting. Patriots and Kingdom Hearts? Like, what next? Ugh. Andrew: Yes, yes. This is America's podcast, baby. David: god. Westen: This is awful. All right, let's let's please move on. let's let's talk about video games. Any anything but football right now for me. so we have David, I as I teased, recently played Chrono Trigger for the first time. How old are you, David? David: Yeah. All on all on stream. Shameless plug. Yeah. Yep. Don't don't forget. Amazing stream. Westen: Yes, don't forget David streams. How David: I'm just the best, most entertaining person ever. And I'm just also an amazing gamer. I'm a God gamer. So if you if you want to see the best gameplay, the funniest jokes. Handsomest guy, turn it turn into the the link will be down below. But yeah, I played Corona Trigger. Westen: It's no better way to showcase your gameplay skills than kicking off with Chrono Trigger, that's for sure. But David: I yeah, I not well I'll get into it, but not exactly the most in depth gameplay system. I Westen: Mm-hmm. David: did well I'll j'll go to that. I'll jump to that eventually, but yeah, this is all gonna be pretty much spoiler free. I do implore you, like Andrew here, if you were like me and have not played the game and you like RPGs at all, it is very, very much worth your time. I am done with the game now completely. It took me like four to five hours to 100% the game. So that's all endings. So it was 30 hours for my blind playthrough. And then new game plus, I used a guide for the endings and achievements. And I had a lot of fun. I would argue that the game has close to zero flaws, like true flaws. There are some things I think I would have preferred to have been done differently, but overall I don't sit here and think there was like a mistake or something I truly disliked. I mean the music, the art, the overall pacing of the game is I think phenomenal. the action turn based combat is it's simple. I think there's an interesting wrinkle there with like positioning mattering. I wish it kind of mattered more. And overall, I think the combat, there's a couple bosses that give you a little bit of trouble. Cause there's some wrinkles in terms of like some enemies, you know, in terms of like maybe you damage them with physical damage and then they become resistant to it. So then you have to hit them with magic and you kind of go back and forth. So some enemies have some wrinkles to them. But overall, the combat's not that difficult. I wouldn't call it difficult at all. It's pretty easy. I maybe died. I don't know, four or five times. so I I do wish there was more depth in that aspect. But for a game that is 30 plus years old, there are just so many design decisions that I wouldn't expect from a game like that. In terms of it's pretty approachable. it's player friendly in terms of XP not being exclusive to active party members. There's forgiving checkpoints and save points. There's no random encounters. you don't have to grind XP at all to progress. But in the story, it's not anything revolutionary, but there's little twists and turns that kind of keep you going along. I enjoy exploring the world, even though I got lost a good amount of times, which is pretty typical for those games. But especially at the beginning of the game, I was blown away. By how much my choices mattered, like little interactions. I found it, you know, a couple hours later, like punish me. That it's like things I didn't do, like there's a cat I didn't rescue, and it's like they bring it up later, and it's like, you're a bad person for not getting this cat. I'm like, What how was I supposed to know? But Andrew: Fuck cats. David: so little yeah, little things like that. I think my biggest critique overall. Is it's more of a product of the games of that time, is the lack of like player feedback. And what I mean by that is there were multiple times I was doing the correct thing, but not how the game wanted me to do it. And the game doesn't communicate well. So then it kind of leaves you wondering, am I doing the wrong thing? Am I supposed to do something different? Am I supposed to be somewhere else? So there was a couple moments there where I was just like, I end up Googling, like, Am I doing the right thing? And it turns out, like, I was only supposed to interact with the cat once and then it follows you, versus interact with it twice, then it runs away. And it's like it there's no feedback to be like, you're not supposed to do that. So at the end of the day. I think I give Chrono Trigger like a 9 out of 10. Maybe even a 10 out of 10 if I view it from like the lens that the game is 30 years old. But at the same time, this is kind of a different thought process, is I don't think it sniffs my top 25 favorite games. I don't think it's close. I really enjoyed my time. And I don't think that's the game's fault. I think the issue is. Like normally when you beat a game you really like, you think about it for like days, maybe a week. It's really stuck in your head. And you think about the ending, the characters, the choices you made that you didn't make, But with this, instead of pondering my own thoughts and enjoyment, I'm comparing my enjoyment to everyone else's. Which is strange. It's it's not really like. a validation thing and I didn't go into the game expecting that I'm gonna have like a new favorite game of all time. And I also didn't go into it thinking like the game can't possibly be this like this good. It can't be like one of the best games of all time that people say it is. But I'm more left wondering if I'd played this game completely blind, like with no knowledge of like how people felt about the game, would I still like the game? Is like, am I being inherently biased, like influenced from just knowing that the game exists and like is one of the best games of all time? So is that fair to the game? Probably not. But I think it's kind of the nature of playing something so beloved. But yeah, you can also like there's something Westen: It can go both ways though, right? Like you could David: you like s people generally hate and you go into it expecting to hate it. But Westen: Well, no, I'm I'm saying like, you know, there's so much hype that it's tough to live up to the hype. So it it can go both ways. I haven't played Chrono Trigger in like 20 years and I'm afraid to. So I mean it's it's nice to see that you enjoyed it, playing it for the first time that that long into the future. Cause it's like I, you know, I know what some of the limitations were back then. But yeah, when you when you played it however many years ago, like, man, it's it's like you said, it was crazy. It was so ahead of its time in so many ways. And it's almost cra it's always been crazy to me that it took so long for the genre to kind of fully catch up to a lot of the things that Chrono Trigger did. Like, you know, you go through the PS1 era and like there's not a lot of JRPGs without random encounters. There's and and the PS1 era, like honestly, the grinding near the end of games got like 10 times worse than it ever was in the Super Nintendo era for the most part. Like it it's it's it's almost like the genre request for a while, and then like more modern games have really like picked up on more of Kroner Trigger's influences. It said I I feel like a lot of the things it did made a lot of sense, but it just took a while for the genre to catch up. But I'm glad to see you liked it. It said it has a lot of heart, I feel like like this it you know, it's it's not David: yeah. I mean there's Westen: deep, but it's just it's just everything comes together so well. And it's just, you know, you could tell a lot of very passionate people made it. A lot of very talented people. Andrew: I appreciate like what I'm hearing from you about the idea that like it is ahead of its time and that it's like, okay, some of these more like and not not that it's entirely not opaque, but some of the improvements that it makes on that genre at that time, like actually would incline me towards going back to it. A lot of those old games, like I've I'd I've loved what I've played of Final Fantasy, but I wasn't big into the series when I was younger. And I made the mistake when the the six pixel remasters dropped. Of like being like, I'll go back to Final Fantasy One and I'll start with Final Fantasy One and I'll play it all the way forward, which I know like Weston hates that system of going through a series anyway. And it definitely like you you get tired as you go through, but like starting with Final Fantasy I was such a mistake and it totally took the wind out of my sails. And I was like, I guess I'll just play like Final Fantas Final Fantasy 15 or 7 remake instead, because like one was just I bounced off so fast from how like how it was structured and how opaque it was and how like what a pain in the ass it was. But like knowing that a game i is at least somewhat more approachable in that era like inclines me so much more to go back. David: Yeah. I mean it's definitely Westen: Yeah. David: aged extremely well. I mean, I started at one. I'd say if you were someone that is more what's the word I'm looking for susceptible susceptible to like games not aging well in terms of like playing older games and they're kind of just a lot more outdated in some of the mechanics and overall game design, this game holds up really, really well. It may not be Besides, I would say the art and the music, which are absolute top tier, everything else is just a perfect package. Westen: Yeah, I I'm I might have to finally, especially now with my Steam Deck or whatever else, like I might have to finally play it David: Yeah. Westen: again eventually. And and so that's one of the nice things about said the I think S N E S era and even like Final Fantasy, you know, I played through Final Fantasy eight and nine, or at least partly through them recently, in terms of eight. But it's like, man, you forget how much better the pacing is of the stories in those older RPGs too. Cause I mean, there's just a little bit less side bullshit and It the stories just tend to be a little more focused. So they they weren't going for 90 hundred hour experiences back then too much. So it's fun to watch and error it's fun to play. And and yeah, I mean, I think I hate replaying a series all from the start just because I'm guaranteed to burn out. But Andrew: Yeah. Westen: it's also like like I liked wrestling for a time and like I tried to watch all the WrestleMania's, and like the first nine kind Andrew: Yeah. Westen: of suck, you know, and then So it's like you need you need that like logic like you know, if you're gonna play all the Final Fantasies, like you're probably good to start with six 'cause there's just a lot of games. Like I mean, four and five, they're good, but I don't think they're essential. David: Four and five are very good. I if you I I think if you enjoy yeah, I would say one through three, even though I enjoyed one through three. I think one through three are a lot easier to skip. I think four and five still have their merits. Westen: But then you're playing a lot of fucking games. So David: Y yeah, I n six is very g yeah, six is definitely the best of four and five. and six is some people's favorite Final Fantasy, so Westen: It it I believe it is our our friend Paul's, if I recall his rankings correctly. So yeah. David: Six is mine, but I've also only played one through six and sixteen, so or Westen: Well, that would that would check out then. So whether any other g whether David: Yeah. I love sixteen. Andrew: Sixteen slapped. Sixteen slapped. Westen: sixteen is sixteen's underrated. Sixteen's underrated. Andrew: It is. Westen: It had it's it had a few flaws, especially with the difficulty curve in the second half, but just getting so easy. But man, there's some cool shit there. any other games you want to talk about this week, David? David: Not really. I'll touch on them when we get to our top five games of the month at the end. Just just some quick thoughts. Westen: Okay, I'll go next. I have well, I have some games I'll I'll just talk about more when we do our top five at the end. So I'm gonna focus on probably the most interesting game I've I've played recently and I'm still in the middle of it, and that is Control Resident. been a slight bit divisive from what I've seen from reviews, like overall strong, not quite reaching the review heights of past remedy games, which kind of makes sense. You know, they took some big swings, right? Like that was the big thing with control resonance. Like I felt like there was, I think even on this podcast, I I thought there was a little bit of risk attached to the game. I saw a clip, a few clips. I was like, I don't know if the combat looks as good as I would hope, given the focus. But it's still Remedy. They're still really talented. and with that talent, like they're taking those big risks that can sometimes really pay off. And I think the risks mostly paid off, but there's there's a few things. I will say my first, I don't know. five, six hours of the game were really not positive. Like I was not vibing with the game whatsoever. the combat never gets super deep, but it is especially simple early on. And enemies, I mean they hit decently hard, but they just take a lot of damage. And fights took a long time to get through for and when you considered the quality of the combat, it was not a good length. Like you know, if I'm fighting a long fight neo three, I'm I'm having a good time. Like that's part of the appeal. These were long fights that I was just not enjoying that much. the open world, like art direction-wise, is incredible. Early on, it's kind of annoying. It's just it's really hard to go from point A to point B. You have to like go all these crazy roundabout ways. And early on, you're missing like two of the key movement abilities. So it's just you really have to, it's really hard. It's a weird map. It's really weird to navigate. It takes some time to adjust to. But as you get those movement abilities and as the combat picks up a little bit and enemies feel a little less spongy and you have a few less options, I'm starting to vibe with it a fair bit. It's just like the combat's still a little too long, but it's it's impactful, it's it's pretty intense, has a lot going on. Like there's these big enemies, and as long as the big enemies are on the screen, smaller enemies will continue to spawn. So you kind of have to focus more on the big enemies, but it keeps It keeps the fights chaotic start to finish. Like you don't get to that point where it's just clean up and it's just like, this is like kind of a minute and a half of just easy bullshit. Like fights are pretty intense start to finish. There's a lot going on. I mean, you can use your platforming. You have like a double jump, a double dash, and then another jump you can add on. You can kind of float in the air when you're doing combat in air. You have a few ranged abilities, you have a few stationary abilities, like you you get just enough and it it's it's intense, it's interesting. It and the RPG elements are just addictive enough where the combat just it works. It's definitely not perfect, but it works. But I'm just like really vi I mean, just it's a remedy game. So it's just the atmosphere is I'm really vibing with. Like it's just a lot of cool stuff going on. Story's not that great, and the lead character is boring as hell. Like it's really funny that we go from a female character to a male character, right? And nobody says a word about that. But like significantly less Andrew: Thoughts. Westen: interesting character. For sure. Andrew: That like drives me nuts actually, because I I will admit in the non like incel freak way, I'm the type of person that doesn't like any sort of I don't care which direction it goes in, like a race swap or a gender swap for a character like drives me nuts because I hate change as a person. and so this that's actually what's kept me from jumping into control to immediately is that like we've gone from gun-based combat to like melee-based combat. And that it's Dylan instead of Jesse. And I fucking loved Jesse. She's awesome. She's such a great character with such a cool story. Why would you swap her out for her brother who was in a cage the entire first game? What are we doing? So that I've I've heard some positive things about Dylan on Twitter, so I don't know. David: Andrew hates men, confirmed. Andrew hates men. Andrew: But yikes, that that's that puts me off to hear that somebody I trust that much is like Dylan sucks. Because like, Westen: It Dylan is so I mean, look, he's like locked in a cage his whole life. So, like, yeah, it makes sense. He's Andrew: Yeah. Westen: boring as hell. Like, and and and Jesse was way cooler. So, yeah, it's like it's a huge downgrade. And and the story, I just had one moment I was kind of into, but for the most part, it's just a lot of lore dumping. And I just it's it's not doing much to hook me, besides there was like one small element, but it's already kind of gone away. So David: How far in are you? Westen: I have no idea. I probably I feel like I'm probably halfway-ish, but who knows? I think I I wanna say I probably David: Okay. How much have you played then? Like Westen: I wish I had accurate hour counts, but I I leave my Xbox on all the time. Yeah. So David: Well yeah, I know, yeah. Being a dad, yeah, yeah, yeah. Westen: I I would guess like 20 hours, but who knows? But it's I've been focusing on like Andrew: Shame. Westen: I took a day or two off for it for Galactic Racer and I was right back to it. Like all of a sudden, like I got a little break and I was back to resident. But it's the open world, I think, is actually really starting to get to me because once you The the navigation abilities are not as cool as they look in the trailers. Like there's, you know, you have that wall walking, you know, like you kind of think that's what the whole world's gonna be. It's very David: Mm-hmm. Westen: limited where you can do that. And and there's like a ability where you can grapple onto buildings. Once again, you can only do that in very specific spots. This isn't like Spider-Man where you just have, or like even Assassin's Creed, where you just have a lot of flexibility with how you move. But the open world is just, I don't know, there's a there's a lot on there and it's It's like very easy to just explore and organically discover like useful resources, useful upgrades. the structure is very addictive. So each each zone you're in, as you do side activities, you level up the zone, which also is what levels up your character. So it's not like a traditional XP system. So if you're someone that likes the hundred percent games, this game really will probably sink into you in that way. Like I have enough self-control where, you know, I'm I'm probably going 85%, 80%. But you know, if you like to do that stuff, it it's structured in a really interesting way. the art direction, that in orbitals are the top art direction game this year. And honestly, I'm I'm leaning resident for being best art direction this year. Cause there's just they just keep doing cool shit. it's Remedy, so they got a couple, I've already had a couple cool music moments. it's neat. it's really it it's it's unlike. I mean, they took big swings, right? And I think as someone who plays video games all the time. You know, sometimes you just enjoy that. You're like, they're doing some weird shit, especially from a triple A perspective. Like you respect that. So I can see how people don't like the game. I said I was one of them for however many hours, but I'm I'm actually pretty into it now. Like it's it's rising my ranks. I think it's in my top five right now. I actually my session today, we were originally gonna record two days ago. My session playing today upped it one rank in my top five. for this month. So David: Mm. Westen: yeah. So you'll see at the end. There's a little tease for you. Like, subscribe, share as well. But yeah, Andrew: Ha ha ha. Westen: it's it's really interesting. I'm really liking it. Dude, I know. It's it's helpless. It's it's I wasn't David: You forgot to do it earlier. It's too late now. I was good. Yeah. Andrew: You work it in where you can. Westen: built to promote podcasts. David: Horrible YouTubers. the inf I I see a lot of people comparing it to infamous. Is that a valid comparison? Westen: Infamous, I feel like had a lot more f I mean, you do have some cool flexibility with the movement. Like just like I said, you have you can kind of float for a while, you dash, you got some stuff, but Infamous the movement felt more free. and I mean the combat the combat is just the is so it's good. It's just odd how long it is. Like it's just battles are They're intense, but they can be a slight slog at times. It is a a bit repetitive. I d I feel like Infamous's combat was better, its movement was better. And I mean, I mean, I don't know. It's I I guess I can slightly see it, but I I feel like it's just I honestly feel like it's the open world kind of feels like control, like the original control. Like you're navigating David: Mm. Westen: the map and it's kind of twisty and confusing. It's it's maybe not quite as bad here. and the combat is not gun based. You know, anymore. It's melee based, but you still a couple the movement abilities are the same. So it it feels like an open world evolution of control, weirdly, even though honestly, control is like the weirdly best comparison, I guess, even though it's a very different game. It's it's its own thing. It really is. I don't think there's much quite like David: And they are the same name. Westen: it. Yes, yeah. There's not much quite like it, including the game that came before it. So it it's it's Andrew: That kind of the case with Alan Wake and Alan Wake too though, where like they like they do build in a the remedy builds in an interesting way where like there's a lot of the original DNA in a game and it like it's the same characters or the same story, but like it's a big evolution from like one to another in a main series installment. Westen: That's that's fair. The one the one thing that's different is it's so long apart. So it makes a little more s it's kinda like the the max pain from Rockstar that's like has the max pain vibes but isn't quite, you know, the remedy max pain. I mean control what I think was twenty nineteen, like I mean, yeah, that's a fair bit of years away, but not that many. So that that's what's crazy is that they made such a big swing within like a relatively short time frame. But yeah. I I agree. That's that's not the worst comparison either. All right. let's see what let's see what weeb shit Andrew's got on deck. What what'd you play this week? Andrew: There's no weave shit this week, unfortunately. I haven't gotten around to Kingdom Hearts, so I can't make that the thing that I talk about. Westen: Weak. Andrew: I considered it. I considered changing it all up between Tuesday when we try or Monday when we tried to record initially and today, but I'm not gonna do it. I actually did take a page out of you guys' book from the last two episodes, and I think one of each of you did a a roundup for the last two, so I'm gonna do a roundup a little bit. So as to not hog the time, I'm gonna leave Star Wars Zero Company till our our rankings. but just to kind of shout that out, like I know Weston had talked might have been two episodes ago, and just kind of touched on it briefly and said that he was super, like, not super into it, like it wasn't bad, but it just wasn't thrilling him. I'm actually way more up on this game than than Weston was. That might have something to do with the fact that I've never really been into turn-based tactical games. And so maybe this this was kind of a being in the Star Wars universe and just being a solid, very spog standard, kind of approachable version of that, like kind of kind of hooked me. I'm I'm loving that game. I'm probably about halfway through it. So that I'll j discuss that a little bit more later. But the two that I want to bring to the table are Wolverine and Runescape Dragon Wilds. We'll start with with Wolverine. I know we're we're a little bit behind the curve on that one that I feel like that that had its moment in the sun very briefly and and went away, but I finally just finished it this weekend. I started it maybe a week after everybody else got into it when it dropped. And I'm I'm higher on it than a lot of people were, I think. I didn't love it. It has a ton of flaws, and we can get into that. But I, you know, I found it to be pretty, pretty interesting. I I thought it was as far as Insomnia combat goes, it's it's in line with the Spider Man games, might even be a little bit better actually. I think especially I was shocked 'cause the first session that I had with it, I played maybe six or seven chapters, probably a third of the game. And I came away, I the first thing that I said on Twitter and Blue Sky was like, hey, the the combat here is is fun and it's dumb fun, but it's fun. and the the further I got into the story and into the game and the more abilities I unlocked, the more that I thought that the combat progressed. It's still nothing in intensively deep, incredibly deep. but the way that all the powers kind of worked together, the the enemy variety, like every you you fight across the game, like probably three different groups or factions of enemies that each have a variety of different types and they all kind of bring something different to the table and force you to approach them a little bit differently. And the abilities what I loved about it was it really it feels like a Wolverine game. I don't get hate for the like because people loved in Spider-Man IGN being like, you feel like Spider-Man, but like you feel like Wolverine. It's like, hey, like it make it the game wants you to engage in the way that Wolverine would engage. You need to be in the thick of the combat. Like you can't be dodging around. spending an amount of time running around trying to kind of switch between. Like you need to be in the thick of it to get certain abilities off, off of certain attacks that will kind of recharge your healing factor and and and keep you kind of getting your rage meter up so that you can get these kind of critical move kills that are flashy and fun and exciting and it kind of keeps the rage meter up and it keeps you In the thick of the combat. And I liked that. It w i every boss or every fight arena like felt like a good time. It got kind of samey by the end, but it wasn't until the last hour or two that I really started to feel that way. And the boss fights I thought were great. some of them have gotten some hate. The Sentinel major boss got some hate, but the the last the final boss battle was incredible. The mid game boss, Lady Death Strike, not giving anything away that was in the trailers, like was incredibly intense. Like that felt like a like s a Sekiro level boss fight. Like those game like the that game it had had its moments and and it has its flaws. the open world segments, I know they're not open world, but kind of the the more the more open sections where you get to explore and kind of do a little bit of investigating as Wolverine, they suck. They're terrible. I know the the fart gas, like the kind of the the the pathing system that kind of leads you from one objective to the next got people really annoyed on social media, and I get that. I'm not a gamer who who cares about like the yellow paint thing, it doesn't bother me. but what I found interesting is I think a lot of the people who got on this game about that didn't really understand it, or I I might have I maybe have a different take on it, that I don't think it was because Insomniac thinks you're dumb and needs to tell you where to go next. I think they knew that they had a very uninteractable, very straight line mission design. And they wanted to keep you as on rails as humanly possible. If they could just give you that slight nudge in a direction, because the moment you look to your left or to your right, you wander over there, you wander over here looking for something else. Can I go over there? Can I climb that? Can I jump on this? Can I move this? Can I attack this? you realize how much of this world is just fucking set dressing. Like there is nothing interactable. There is nothing to do with the Nightmare Door challenge mode missions. There's like probably like 20 of them throughout the game similar to the challenges Spider-Man can do around New York in the Spider-Man games. And they're fucking horrible. In particular, the the parkour ones are fucking nightmarish. They're so bad. and so I think that like they have a really good arena based action character action game on their hands with a d a pretty good X-Men story, and that's it. Like if you're going into it for anything other than that, I would suggest you avoid it or get it on a deep sale. If you're a a Marvel fan, if you're an X-Men fan, I'd say pick it up. I think it's a r I think it's a perfectly serviceable game. I'd give it a high seven, a low eight. which I know that's you know the critics were kind of mid seven. Like I I think it's it's better than mid. It's just above mid, just below like good, a good game. You know what mean? So I liked it well enough. Westen: The critics are always right. That's the thing that people keep forgetting, is they're just always right. Like I but honestly, Andrew: Ha ha ha. Westen: honestly though, like for video games, like if you look at open crit I always say this, if you look at open critic for a game, yeah, I you know, and actually pretty soon on the blog, I I should be back to writing soon. One of my first articles is gonna be my biggest disagreements with game critics this year. And it's this year I think I have a few more than most, but like it's pretty rare for me to have like a map, like, man, they're putting this game in the mid eights and I think it sucks. Like David: Yeah. Westen: It's Andrew: I will say that I think the critics and the community, especially the community, but definitely the critics, I think they gave this game a harder time because they have Spider-Man to compare it to. I think that like it's a step down as far as an Insomniac game goes. I think it's still a good game. If another studio David: Yeah, I mean it very well could be Andrew: that Marvel had handed it to had made this, people would be like, this is great. It's a step down for Insomniac. David: Yeah, there's definitely was an expectation thing. it yeah, in in terms of reviews, I'm just so tired of people nitpicking outliers. It's like I think I saw what the Hellraiser game came out today, and I think it sits around like a seventy four Metacritic. And people, there was like five, there was like a four and a half, I think, from Game Informer, and like a six from IGN, and people are like, wow, they're so hard on the game. It's like these this review's trash. I'm like Have you guys never played a game that was like an eight or a nine critically, and you were maybe two points above that or below that? Like it happens all the time. Andrew: It happens. David: I just I'm so tired of like there can be outliers. That's why it's an average. Yeah, yes. And and Westen: Yeah. You want them. I mean I mean there's defin there's there's definitely some reviewers where you can just see that they're like trying to be contrarian to get the clicks, but it's rare. David: Yeah. And I think i it's Westen: I think overall people give their authentic opinions and you want a wide range. Yeah. It's like it's like p David: Yeah, and this I Yeah and this idea that things are paid off or like I'm so Westen: No, that's just lazy. Andrew: That's the dumbest. David: people just shut up. Like Westen: Well the those people will will watch their favorite streamer. Not not talking about you, David, but you know, they'll watch it they'll watch a streamer. David: Yeah. And but these are also somewhat like level headed people. Westen: That's crazy. 'Cause as I said, I mean how many streamers do they watch that have like sponsored streams? And it's like, this is dumb. David: I mean in general s people are just too tribalistic when it comes to r reviews and especially games that they're interested in. It's just the nature of the beast. But going Andrew: I will say the one area where the critics get it wrong on this game is that it's ten times better than fucking mixtape. Westen: I think David: it's backwards crap no It's backwards It's it's one podcast Andrew: No, no! I didn't know you had it out for this. No! Westen: Ha ha. David: without mixed state mentioned. We gotta go to zero. Andrew: I didn't know you actually had Westen: He Andrew: it for this episode, no. Westen: he was so ready. He was so ready. David: I had it. Zero podcasts Andrew: Yeah. David: with podcasts w without Westen: That's crazy. David: mixed inventions. God Westen: That's crazy. I can't believe that's real. It was so immediate. He had it like in hand the entire pot. He had to wait thirty minutes. David: I I heard I it's like it's like a trigger word. No, it's these guys didn't know I I just pulled out a whiteboard because it just kept getting mentioned and I was just like we gotta but There you go. Westen: The last thing I'll say before you move on to Rootscape is it is crazy that you kind of mentioned this at the start. It had its moment in the sun, like for two seconds. I literally, I mean, there's a lot I still want to play this year, and it's just a lot of long games, and I just don't have the time. I'm gonna have to make hard cuts this year in terms of what I play. And man, I really might not play Wolverine by year's end, which is crazy to me being an insomniac game. And then I said I'm sure it's a perfectly fine game. It's just like you get to a point last few months where it's like, I if I'm gonna play this, I want it to be potential top ten. Andrew: Yeah. Westen: And it just doesn't even feel like that for me. Andrew: No, it it it probably won't fall there for you. It might be a good palate cleanser if you've got the time, but if it if not, I don't know. I g you could get into it next year and not have missed this year. Like it's not gonna be in the game of the David: Yeah. I mean we Andrew: year just gonna David: We at the beginning of the year had it penciled in as a game of the year contender until like the previews came out. Yeah, until the previews, Westen: Yeah. I took it off. I took it off. Yeah. Andrew: Did it? David: yeah, I took it off too. I know I didn't finish my list, but it came Westen: Yeah, you didn't. You did not. David: out too late. But I I have two questions. Is one was about their portrayal of Logan. As I've heard he's kind of lovey-dovey, definitely more heartwarming than like compared to the movies or the comics, which I know Logan definitely has, or Wolverine definitely has his touching moments. And then also you talked about how the trail is kind of almost necessary to keep players like it's a linear game and focused on the path. in progressing through the story, but like if the game is so linear, I mean, wouldn't the game already propel you forward through that? Like why do you need, there's not so much exploring and you can't really explore 'cause you said, you know, a lot of it's set dressing. Like, why do you need like a guide like that if it should just be propelling you forward already? Andrew: Yes, well I'll get to that. I'm gonna get to the f the second one first. I think so A, it's I I actually agree with you, they probably could have condensed certain areas down and made it more streamlined and directly straight through. there were plenty of times where I was kind of frustrated with like, here's an investigation section where you're gonna look walk around an area that is like not large, but mid-sized, and it's like it has you walking around a pretty big area for what it is, but there's just nothing to interact with or do. You're just kind of like trying to find a scent and pick it up. straight line. so they probably should have condensed it down more. But I think honestly, I think that they had a lot more planned for this game, probably more larger explorable areas, but the budget ballooned down the stretch. And I think once the leak hit, I think Sony was like, fucking rush this thing out. Let's just get it out and move on. People are not up on what this game is going to be and they're not going like it's it's not hitting. You're spending way too much money. Just get it out. And I think they had to pare it down a little bit and didn't pare it down enough. and then as for Logan, I it's interesting because I I think he definit this is one of the softer versions of Logan that they've ever that that has ever been put to screen. But I don't think it's totally out of character. I think Sabretooth is out of character. I think making him like his whole thing that he's angry at Logan because he loves him so much and misses him so much is a total mischaracterization. I think all the other characters are incredibly well characterized. I think the villain, I won't spoil anything. I think it's pretty clear once you pick the game up who the fucking villain is. but he gives an incredible performance. He's such a bastard. He's so good down the stretch. and I think Logan, it's it's there are some cartoons in particular, X-Men, I don't know if it's X-Men Evolution, where he's a professor at Xavier's school and he's he's pretty, you know, good with all the young kids and kind of loving on them and like kind of like an the drunk uncle figure that like does love them and care about them but is a little gruff and rough around the edges. I think this works. It's definitely one of the softer, more warm approaches. But it's actually I'd say this game is a love story. like a as odd as that sounds for a beat up action care character action game, it's it's a love story with him and and Gene Gray. And I think that like having a more tender hearted Logan. No, God no. I fucking hate that that David: I thought you're gonna say between Sabretooth and Wolverine. I'm kidding, I'm drilling. That that was some Andrew: that yeah, there's some scene there is some cringe ass writing, but the I think the characterizations are fairly good mostly. And then to get to the real surprise of my year, I was excited when I heard that this game got announced. It was initially a PC game that was eventually gonna come to consoles, was Runescape Dragon Wilds. my a little bit of a small lore drop, I was not a huge MMO kid growing up, but I had you know I dabbled a little bit. Problem for me was that I was all my friends played RuneScape and I was obsessed with wanting to play RuneScape, despite how ugly it was and how goofy, you know, like it wasn't like this amazing, but to me, like as a kid, you're looking at it and you're like, my god, I don't want to pay for World of Warcraft. And RuneScape is this awesome, big, bombastic fantasy RPG game with that you play with your friends, and it's so it sounds amazing. Of course, like many mothers in the early 2000s era, my mother saw one. Or two ridiculous, sad news stories, and decided that RuneScape was match.com for pedophiles. And so I was not allowed to play RuneScape for a very long time. And so shout out mom. I know she watches every episode. so I I eventually was allowed to make an account that she I would I could play when she was sitting in the room with me. and then I started to kind of like I'd sneak on when I wasn't allowed to or when I At a friend's house. So I play, I have a good memory of RuneScape, but didn't play it endlessly as a kid. and this game, when I saw it, I was like, that's what that's the game that I thought RuneScape was when I was a kid, if that makes sense. Like the grandiosity of the adventure, that just the this grand scope, like RPG that you play in a co-op and you go fight dragons with your friends. Like, that's what I thought RuneScape was when I was little. And this game is that. I was excited for it when it was announced. And when it finally came to console last month, holy shit, dude, it's so good. It may be my favorite survival crafting game of all time. I think it's better than Minecraft. I think it's I it is unbelievable. The progression system is so beautifully interwoven between all the skills. It has a lot of the classic runescape skills, fishing, artisanship. Cooking, all farming, all these different things that kind of feed into your adventure. So you don't just go kill goblins and dragons and go questing with your friends. You gotta farm, you gotta make food that's gonna give you different buffs and and different heals. you have to learn potion craft, you have to build a house, you have to go fishing and get, you know, a lot of the fishing like these different skills, they impact your magic skills, they impact your your agility. They all kind of feed into each other in this magical fucking way where no matter what you are doing at any given time you feel like you're being rewarded A with new abilities, new skills, new parts of the game to explore and to go new things to go do. And like you're when you are going off to do your farming in a lot of these types of games, I feel like you go farm and you're like, this is the farming and it's segmented off. This is the fishing and it's segmented off. The cooking kind of you know, interacts with all those things in a lot of games, but like they feel so segmented. When you're doing one thing, you don't think you're progressing in another thing. In this game, it's not like that. Every skill that you are leveling up and engaging with makes you feel like it's connected to the other parts of your adventure. And it all fuels this the great moments where, okay, we've spent two hours hunting, fishing, gathering, building our houses, getting new items, building new armor. And then you and your three or four or five friends, depending on how your how your server is set up, get to go and go on a quest and you get to go fight a dragon. And like in the first area, it's very simple. It's kind of a grassy, you know, medieval fantasy world. But as you go, you end up in an undead land. You end up in this big desert. Like we've we've we've put in, my group of friends has put in almost a hundred hours each on this game this month. It's disgusting how much we have been playing it. It's so addictive. And the quests get better and better. In the the undead area and the the the Umbral Sands Desert and the there's like this great castle kind of fort that you assault later in the game. The quests get really good. Like there's some puzzles you have to solve around the map that are persistent. There's mini bosses you have to fight to get certain items that will allow you to unlock the tower where you go fight the area boss, like the it's normally a dragon. that is kind of us laying siege to the area as you progress towards this final endgame raid where you fight, you know, the queen of all the dragons, essentially. And it just it fucking hits on every level, dude. It's such a fantastic experience. It is a sleeper contender for like my game of the year. Like like not just like my multiplayer game of the year, which it has on fucking lock, by the way. It is a sleeper contender for my game of the year. It is so addictive, so satisfying, so fun. It's unbelievable. David: I it Westen: Honestly, if it wasn't just, you know, the MMO time sink element, I you might have sold me on trying it at least, but I just I know I'm not gonna have the time. So there's no point. But Andrew: Yeah, it's it's tough. Westen: it you know you know the fantasy life, I it is a game I played, I think it was last year, and there's all these like different RPG elements, but they just didn't feel coherent, like it didn't feel like all the work was really rewarded in a in a way that I enjoyed, like where doing this really helped me with my combat as much as I'd like, et cetera. And so it's appealing that I that's what I like. I like when all the systems really work together in that way and like everything you do feels meaningful. So that that is definitely appealing sounding. I I spent a little time on RuneScape back in the day, but not much. But you know. David: Yeah. I've never played RuneScape. But I'm curious, so are you at Andrew: If you've never played it and you like this sort of thing, go ahead. David: Are you at endgame? Andrew: Almost. So we we have gone a lot slower than it looks like a lot of people have online. A lot of people you could pro like if you really like fucking nose to the grindstone, just try to get, you know, the equipment you need to move on to the area boss and then the next area. Like you could beat this game in I think the the developers said like twenty hours. I think that's a stretch. Maybe thirty, I think, if you really like push it. Westen: Huh? That's Andrew: but like I said, we've gone slow. I am in the final area because I ran ahead a little bit with my buddies. We we got a a dedicated server for it, that's live all the time. So we play When the other guys aren't on, which I think has added to the ability to kind of keep the game alive, which is often a problem when you're at our age with, you know, a group of friends that you've had your whole life. Everyone's on a different schedule. It's hard to keep up. so having a hosted server has helped with that. But no, so I'm in the final area before the final area boss, and then the raid. my buddies are one boss behind me. So we I would say by the end of this month we'll have beaten the game. And even that, I'm amped to say that like I watched When they released next year's year two roadmap. The content that Jagex plans on adding to this game, it started out you go from the original Runescape Continent to this. There's this new continent that's been discovered, and and the first kind of party that landed there had some problems with fighting dragons, and they need your help. So you go, your group goes and sets up camp and tries to help defeat the dragons. Next year, there's gonna be this whole plot line with gnomes and elves who are in like a civil war. And they're gonna add a bunch of new areas throughout the months next year. And the year two roadmap looks even better than this year's content. Like the wor the world art that they've released looks fantastic. They're adding new skills from the OG RuneScape, they're adding just a ton of new equipment. Like this game, I think, is gonna get a lot of service. So if you like a live service game that you can keep up with, like a destiny, like a Runescape, like a World of Warcraft, I think you're gonna be very happy with what they have at so far said that they're gonna roll out. Like if it if it keeps on with this quality, this is a game I can see my again, this is childhood friends, people I've known since I was, you know, five, six, seven years old that I still game with. And like we are all like hooked. We will be playing this for years to come if it continues like this. It's it's awesome. But yeah, we're almost we're almost done with what they have now. David: So what you're saying, is this more survival game versus MMO? Cause what you where do you cause you say you 'cause you say beat the game, and Andrew: Yes, for one hundred percent it's it's more a survival, it's more like a minecraft. David: I'm like, okay. So is there like a post Andrew: Yeah, it's it's much more like a Minecraft. David: game? Like what like what do you do when you beat the game? Or is it just that's kind of it? Like is was there like a post game Andrew: So all of the David: or raids that you can repeat for better gear? Like what's yeah. Andrew: You can repeat everything. all the area bosses, all the area mini bosses, all the puzzles reset on an in on the in-game calendar. I think it's about five in-game days, which the in-game game days are quick. They're a couple hours max, to get through five, and everything resets. So you can redo the end game raid, which people there's people online who have redone that already, I think, enough times to get the full set of dragon armor. Like there's there's a lot of really cool shit you can you can keep playing. I can see it having the longevity and then like If you're addicted to the base building, building your house, which you know, me and my buddies totally are, like when we're done with the game it's just gonna be like let's go gather resources and build a huge castle. Like there's there's enough of that stuff to keep you going. Westen: Yeah, it's it's David: yeah, I mean it sounds fun. Westen: interesting how you talk about this potentially David: I am a sucker for MMOs. Westen: being your game of the year. Cause I'm thinking about this too, 'cause like I'm starting to sort of think about A, the game awards predictions I'm gonna have, and B, you I'm looking at my own top ten where it's like, okay, a lot of these games might be here. Maybe not. There there is a late rush of games coming, but I feel like this is gonna be a year with a lot of weird top tens. Like you're not gonna you know, you're you're gonna see a lot of top tens with games Nobody has any almost any matches. Like maybe you have one match, two matches with someone that's played a bunch of games too. And I think we're headed to maybe the most unpredictable Game Awards, like game of the year nominations in a while. Cause I feel like there's a a David: Yeah. I think there's like three locks. Westen: there's a lot of games that I thought were gonna be in like the eighty nine ninety range and ended up in like the eighty four, eighty five range. And it's like which ones are gonna break through. I don't know. Like control resident, great example. I was pretty confident that would be a game of the year. Game this year. It's it's sitting at 83 and open critic, that's probably not gonna do it. So, but what David: Yeah. Westen: takes its place? There's there's like is mugenics, is Mina. Point is it's a weird year for games, and it I feel like in some bad ways, but in in good ways too. There it it's like the triple A games that we expected to really Andrew: Yeah. Westen: like knock it out of the park haven't quite reached the heights, which has been the case in recent years. Like those a lot of those triple A games have come and delivered exactly what you wanted. This Andrew: Mm-hmm. Westen: year they've been like really good, but maybe not quite on that level. And it's opening things up for some different weirder things to kind of potentially David: Yeah. I'd say like Westen: break through. David: some of the smaller triple A games. smaller air quotes. Like I mean obviously like Capcom is still like Pragmata, but like Andrew: Mm-hmm. David: that's not like some huge budget triple A, you know. It was also a low it was like a fifty dollar game, you know, stuff like that. Pragmata, Onimusha. and then of course there's lots of indies that have really stepped it up. Yeah, Zero Company, like there's a lot of these, like not Westen: On a move I mean Galactic Racers up there now. Like that's it's Andrew: Mm-hmm. Yep. David: full price you know, seventy dollar full price games that didn't have like insane budgets that I think really picked up the slack for like the two hundred plus million dollar triple A Andrew: Mm-hmm. David: big budget games. Westen: with that we'll get to our top five games we played in September, our monthly segment. And a couple of those games might be referenced here in the in the coming moments. So David, what was your top five games you played in September? David: So my top five this month, a little weird, because I've been sick a bunch. And NFL started and baseball playoffs and hockey, so sports, being sick. But I've been kind of portable this month, is a lot of Switch stuff. I've been still playing through three houses, trying to get through it so I can play Fortunes Weave. Game's great. Love Fire Emblem. Say I am over halfway through now. I've done The DLC, which I did like after Westen: Is this your number five? David: Yeah. Well, yeah, I guess it's five. I don't know. It's it's hard because I talked about it last month. So I'll have it a number five, sure. Westen: That's fine, it's it's still your game you played. Yeah, so David: Yeah. Actually, no. I'll have a number three. So I jumped I jumped the gun. But so now that will be number three. Then I'll go to five. five is gonna be Westen: Jesus Christ. David: Yeah. Westen: This is all r this is a ranking sin. Okay, I'm disgusted. David: I'm sorry I wasn't thinking. I just I know it's funny. I have I have like some I have Westen: This is terrible. Yeah, any order, that's what this is all about. Let's just list five games. David: Alright, just just bully me. Just is I have no Westen: When it comes to raking, I I get passionate. All right. Go ahead. Sorry. Start with five. David: I have notes. That's the funny thing. And I have it in order, but I just for some reason just jumped out of order. So that's number three. Westen: Cool. David: Number five. I'm gonna put orbitals. Wes and I have played probably three, four hours. I mean the game Westen: Yes. David: has i ish. It's we've been sick, he's been busy, he's playing too many other better games, so and the game's the game's fun. Westen: True. It's David: Is it a masterpiece? No. the game has the sauce. I mean, the loading screens, the menus, the music. It the style is just off the charts. I mean, even like we booted up the game and I was just like in the main menu and like the party screen. And it's just like the art style is just insane. If it if this game is not nominated for like best art direction, it I don't know what we're doing anymore. I understand it's not the biggest game, but Man, like it is I don't think I've ever pla Westen: No, it has to be. It it is absolutely insane if it's not. David: yeah, I don't think I've ever played a game that there's such a delta between like the visuals and the gameplay in terms of like the visuals just like selling me on the game. I don't think the visuals of a game and art style have ever sold me on a game so much. But gameplay's fine. Yeah. Westen: It's it's exactly it. And that's and that's exactly why I'm having a hard time with it. Is and like when I'm when we're playing, we're like holy like we're just constantly holy shit on the animations, everything they're doing, and then we just start playing it, and I'm like, man, it's just so mediocre. Like the the the game really centers on its ship elements, and the ship elements are just so mid. Both the navigation and the shooting is so bad. And yeah, and David: Yeah. And there's not the story is completely whatever. there's not really like side activities. Westen: The gamepla there's a couple moments. There there's a yeah, the side activities are are very mediocre as well. A a couple like the base gameplay has its moments where it's like, we're actually like truly cooperating, or hey, this is like this puzzle. You know, it's it's like it takes two in split fix where you you get all these different abilities and then they just put you in an area and it's your job to figure out how to move forward with like a navigational challenge. So the co-op element, you know, you talk, you figure it out. And there's a couple, there's been a couple moments where it's like, we're really collaborating. And and there's plenty where I'm like, it's it's fine. I I don't know. It's just it the style, I I feel like open critic wise, this one got a little bit it's at an eighty two. I I just think with the gameplay where it's at, it really shouldn't even be that high. But the style is incredible. The style is David: Yeah. Yeah. Westen: really it's said that and control resident, easily my top two favorites for art direction this year. David: Yeah. I also think it's hard. Like this genre is there's not that many games. It's really just the the haze light games. And then this now, and they're I think there's gonna be more coming up, but you're comparing orbitals Westen: There there's definitely more coming. David: to like those three Titans, and it's kind of it's odd. It's it's that's tough, that's tough going. But and it's also Westen: Right. Right. Yeah, no, it's it's tough shoes to live in. David: it's also just very short. I think we're halfway. The game's like six hours long. I saw on how long to beat. Yeah, it's Westen: We feel like we barely played it too. David: and we're like halfway and the game's like six hours long on how long to beat. And there comes a point, like I'm not one to be like the whole value, you know, proposition of like, how can you pay fifty bucks for a six hour game? But like There is kind of like a point where it's kinda like, I wish there was more meat on the bones. Because I feel like we're gonna get to the end and be like, that's it. So Westen: Right. It'll probably happen like two more sessions and we'll be like, okay, that's it. But David: Yeah. But Westen: yeah, I I one thing I will shout out, I like that it seems to be pretty interchangeable with what role you perform, like it lets you choose. You know, so with it takes two in split fiction, you're kinda it whatever character you are that you're stuck into whatever role they pick. And when I played a way out a long time ago with my wife, like we got stuck at a point and I remember thinking, like, Maybe it would have gone better if I was able to choose what action each time and we can like go to her strengths more. You know, 'cause like with this kind of game, you're more likely to play it with someone who maybe doesn't play a lot of games. So I like that feature. Love the style, music, incredible. Like so good. And that is what completely carries it. So anyway, go ahead. David: Yeah. I actually I actually think that's a a downside. Because I think like what makes like something like split fiction unique, or like it takes two, is you can play like let's say you know split fiction, you can play as what Zoe and get one experience, and then you can play with like another friend and play as Mio and get a completely different experience because there's completely different gameplay elements. In orbitals, it doesn't matter, like it's completely interchangeable, like You know, you're the the female character can use the gravity gun or the male character can. So there's I feel like if I do another playthrough with another friend, my playthrough is gonna be like very close to the same thing, which I kinda also limits but it yeah, but it's harder to like what how what am I supposed to remember, you know, Westen: I mean you could switch it up, but yeah, it's little harder. Like yeah. Yeah. David: what gun I used at this part? It's just not I think especially when the game is six hours long, like I would Westen: Right. Yeah. No, there's David: I kind of wanted more like I wanted to play another playthrough with a friend and now I'm a little less inclined 'cause it's kind of gonna be the same thing. So Yeah, I know, you don't care. So yeah. Westen: Yeah. As someone who never replays games, it's not something I think about, but but it's fair. But that's fair for for those who will. David: so that's number five. number four. No, no, no, no. Westen: All right. Now number two. Okay, number four. That will do number four. David: number four, I've come back to Kirby Air Riders. yeah, Westen: Okay. David: is We didn't talk about this on the podcast before because we hadn't had the podcast going. I love Kirby Air Ride. Kirby Air is one of my f favorite games ever. Is it one of the best games ever? Hell no. But I love it so much. And Air Riders was just such a love letter to the original. And I've been going back. I've, you know, I I've done they do these events, you know, for there's like cosmetics and stuff, and it gets back and there there's like some twists on the gameplay in terms of like, you know, the events that happen I've been going back, but I've really besides the events, I've also just been playing again. And the game just is fun. It makes me feel warm and fuzzy. I don't know how to explain it. It's just a game that I love. It just makes me happy. It's simple enough. If you have any attachment to Kirby Air Ride on the GameCube and you have a Switch 2. you owe yourself to get the game. It is just I don't know. It's just a hug in a game. It just makes me happy. So I'll Westen: It sounds awful. David: always be going back and playing it. It just get out of here with the lack of Andrew: I was gonna say I know he's gonna hate that whole explanation. David: Yeah, I know, just a hug, just Westen: Fuck. David: a hug. But that's number four. Three was three houses. You might realize I don't even have five. I only have four. Westen: Jesus Christ. David: Number number two slash number one is Chrono Trigger. This is just I didn't even play five games. So wait wait, you Westen: Yeah. That's tough. Honestly, this is Andrew: It gets two slots. David: know what? Sorry. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. I this is just a disaster. I'm gonna keep this in. I played Westen: my god, holy shit. David: Star Wars Galactic Racer. I have played about four Westen: No that that came out in October. David: to five hours. Westen: No, that came out in October. That doesn't count. David: fine. we're not counting. What the podcast has been delayed. Andrew: Ha ha. David: my whatever. We'll we'll keep it in. Alright, well we'll talk about it. Westen: man. My ranks would be different if I was including October games. So sorry. Although games David: Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Westen: I although Control Resident I played in September, but my opinion has changed from my October. So is that I don't David: Woo. Westen: know. You know, it's kind of complicated, right? But all right. I'll I'll do my top five. I'm gonna start with my number three. Yeah, yeah. Number David: Yeah, then so number one's chronic trigger. So very we already talked about that a bunch. Westen: two and number one, because I'm not counting Galactic Racer. all right. I'm gonna start my number three. Maybe actually I can't. I can't do it. I'm not starting with my number three. But my number five is a battle of games. I'm not that into. the orbitals missed the cut. So Fire Emblem Fortune's Weave is here at number five. Honestly, I played six games in in September, so that's why it's here. I it's a very slow start. It is a very slow start. And man, fire I I don't know, man. Turnbase. Turn based RPG combat, I really think a lot of it's mediocre. I I really don't think fire lump combat's that good. This is no mugenics. This is certainly I you would at least agree mugenics is a lot better, combat wise, right? Like it's just way more interesting. David: I don't know, it's just different. I also didn't play as much Megenix as you did. I'll definitely probably go back Westen: Man, David: to it next year. Westen: it's just I think the I've talked about this before, but these fire emblem games and a lot of these turn-based RPGs, it's just like annoying movement where you go to the edge of the map and you wait for them to do something stupid, and it's just it's a lot of bullshit baiting and just very simplistic. you know, I mean there's different abilities, but it's just not that deep. And there's a luck element, which is fine, but I mean I turned off the permadeath because although they have the rewind ability, so it's you don't David: no wonder why you hate it. Westen: Yeah, I mean but that's the point. The whole challenge of the game is to like not let any it's not actually to win battles, it's to make sure your guys don't die. Like more so than winning the fights, which I David: Well, yeah, I mean they go hand in hand. I mean I think the games are with the rewind stuff now. I I I started Fire Emblem with the older games. I much prefer I think the difficulty I think the games are so much easier now. I mean, for better or for worse. But Westen: Yeah, they're definitely easier. David: for me, I think like I I'm playing three houses on whatever hard mode and classic and I'm still kind of breezing through. And I've heard from my friends who are big fire and yeah, Westen: Yeah, fortunes we've so far, same. David: I hear Fortune's Weave is kind of the same as they give you they're very generous with the rewinds. So it's kinda like I can see how the combat maybe, for lack of better words, is kinda getting dumbed down. Westen: I what I love about Mugenix is it's just it's so and and said this I had the same problem as Zero Company. I just feel like there's a a very conservative movement style that's like the best way to play and it's not a the most fun way to play. Like with mugenics, there's all these crazy movement abilities where you you're like churn one, you're flanking or going behind enemy lines and doing all sorts of crazy shit. And with these games it's just slow methodical movement. Tends to be the best way to play. And it's just it's kind of a boring way to play. So I did just unlock like the persona elements. They're not introduced well. I think I think maybe as I play more and adjust to it, that might. That's the whole reason I decided to play this game, because I I knew I was kind of out on fire emblem combat, but I was hoping the stuff around it would help more. So now that I've got to that point, once I adjust to it, we'll see. David: So you're still in your first part one with whatever character you chose? Westen: Yeah, I basic I basically got through the first whatever six, seven hours that are just truly boring. And I just got to that point. So we'll we'll see what happens. number four, I have Mortal Shell two. I don't know if I'm gonna finish this game. I really like the combat. I really love it. Like the parry system is so fun, lots of fun enemy attack patterns, like it's punishing, but it's got just enough forgiveness that I enjoy, although I have reached a point that's getting pretty hard. Boss design is pretty mediocre. I just hate the world design. It's it's this twisty, sort of like old school Souls like map design within an open world, which sounds cool, but there's like no shortcuts, which is super annoying. So it's just like going from point A to point B. I mean, you do get fast travel points, but I just don't enjoy the exploration as much as I wish I did. And the dungeon design is truly awful. Like it is metaphor, re Fantasia levels of bad dungeon design. So if that gives you an idea. Very generic. Very extremely generic. Very similar dungeons all over the place. But man, the combat's good. The combat is really, really good. And that is carrying the experience for me. My number three is Fields of Mystria. It wasn't number two. I'm officially through one year of the game now. I think this is this is a me thing, but it really, it really I I might have talked about this in the last pod, but it really bothered me that the winner was like the same. With farm, like can still farm during the winter. I'm like even without a greenhouse or whatever, like just out in the fields, you're farming. I'm like, this sucks. Winter in these games should be all about like, you're gonna fish more, you're gonna mine more, like give me other things to do, like help me mix it up. So the lack of cool festivals too, and and I'm not that into the romance stuff. So, but it's it's still really strong. RPG elements, the whole formula, it's very well executed on. I'm still having a really good time with it, like I still pick it up. I'll play for half an hour. I just don't get as addicted to it now. the RPG elements slow down a lot once you get into the so once you get through three ish seasons. So pacing just isn't where it was. I'm still really enjoying it though. It's it's still one of the better cozy farming scenes I've played in a while. I just don't think it's gonna hit like all time or status like I thought it might. number two. David: Yeah. Are you into year two now? Westen: Yeah, I just got into year two. I'm like a week or so in. So David: Do you s is there any do you see any changes like from year two to year one or is it more of the same? Westen: No, I th I think the progression is very tied to your town rank, more so than time passing. So I'm very close to hitting level fifty, which I think level ninety nine is the max. So I'll be curious if there's David: Mm. Westen: one area. there's like a forest area that hasn't been unlocked. I'm curious if getting to level fifty finally unlocks that 'cause it's been kind of weird that I haven't been able to access that. number two is Control Residents that just upgraded it today. I I'm just I don't know, the more I play, the more I'm liking it. So We'll see where it goes, but I just kind of looking at my top 10. I I think I don't know if it'll stay there, but it's probably gonna be top five when I'm done if things keep going as they go. And my number one is Well Dweller. the newest game from Kyle Thompson. Fans bigger game, we knew I excited for this one. Kyle Thompson, man, he just knows how to make a Metroidvania. You know, so many Metroidvania's these days. The the developers didn't want to make a Metroidvania, they wanted to make an action 2D platformer game. And they're like, well, fuck, Metroidvania sell. So we'll make a Metroidvania. And then they don't know how to make a Metroidvania correctly. Just the balance, it's very open ended exploration. It does not guide you, kind of like like a hollow night, but like you read the map and it's pretty clear. You can figure out where you can try to go next. You can buy map markers. So you have to like earn the rewards coming or the exploration getting easier. But so I never did that stuff. I just explored, I found everything. Extremely, it's not an RPG, but it has a very rewarding upgrade system. They do a great it's it's very unique. I love the style, I love the music. Like Kyle Thompson's brother is the guy that makes the music, and he he does a great job. It's just kind of like sad chill vibes. It's it's introspective. I enjoy it. definitely combat upgrade over his last games. There's some really interesting mechanics. Like you have a matchstick that's like your bow and arrow. You can also like pogo jump off that. You sh you throw grenade things and then you hit them out of the air to hit enemies. There's there's just some interesting elements. and this game by far has his most clever boss design. So lots of cool stuff. if you love Metroidvania's, like this guy gets it more than anybody. And the combat and ever and the platforming are up to snuff too. Like, are they the top top of the genre? No, but they're very upper tier with the great Metroidvania elements. My only critique is this is like more of a dark fairy tale story, just didn't click with me. And you don't really expect a Metroidvania story to hit with you. That's not a big focus of the genre, but Crypt Custodian had like a story I was into, simple, but you know, I related to it. Islets, his game before that, was like a game about, you know, you unite this Metroidvania map. It's it's a game about connection. It was funny. I feel like from a writing and story perspective, this was the weakest of his three main games, but gameplay wise, the map, just the best he's done. He just keeps getting better. So yeah, that's David: Diffi yeah. Westen: go ahead. David: Difficulty wise, where where does it kind of fall in terms of like let's say, I don't know, like haul and it like silksong is like a ten. Westen: so this game ha it's it's definitely not there. Like it's probably in the seven to eight range, but I believe I I David: Mm-hmm. Westen: put it on hard difficulty. David: Okay. Westen: which I'm not sure if I don't remember Crypt Custodian have difficulty settings. So yeah, I mean so I David: I d Metroidvania is I'm trying to think what I don't even think like Ori had a difficulty setting. I think Westen: the Lost Crown did. I know that 'cause I played that game on hard. But yeah, there's a lot of a lot David: Mm-hmm. okay. Westen: of Metroidvanies that don't have that. So this one does have difficulty settings, which is great. I put it on hard, which was very good for me. It's enemies hit hard, but and there's some unique boss design, but they don't they don't last as long. Like you can win fights David: Mm-hmm. Westen: within a few minutes, so and and the attack patterns aren't like too all over the place. So Yeah, I mean, even on hard, I'd probably put it at like a seven. Like definitely a few moments to challenge me, but it's it's forgiving enough. It's it's it's it's honestly like I wouldn't hate if the bosses were a touch longer, but it's a really enjoyable balance in my opinion. But and now that there's difficulty settings, anyone should be able to enjoy it. David: How is the in terms of checkpoints and run backs is it punishing or Westen: Not not at all. Ky Kyle Thompson, that's David: Okay. Westen: one of my favorite parts about him. He's maybe this one might be a touch more punishing than Crypt Custodian, but not by much. David: Mm-hmm. Westen: And it's it's really not bad. Like the this genre, in my opinion, that's one of the biggest flaws in this genre, which I love. I love the genre. I think there's an obsession with longer run backs that I just don't think enhances the experience. Even like the Lost Crown had some like really long ones where I'm like, why? Why why do I have to go so long to backtrack or whatever? Whatever. It's like some of these games you're better off dying sometimes than than you know, progressing. Cause it's like this this is quicker. So not an issue here, man. Kyle Thompson, he knows what he's doing. So that's that's the thing about him. I just feel like he intrinsically understands what a Metroidvania is and he designs the game that way. So love it. It's a great game. It is definitely going to be in the mix for my game of the year, which so I mean it'll be the third straight game from a solo developer. All within like a five and a half year span that hits my top ten at the end of the year. So crazy, crazy achievement for a solo David: Okay. Westen: developer. Andrew, your top five. Andrew: Yes, sir. Okay, so first a couple honorable mentions as as we do every every episode. Lord of the Rings War in the North. I think that actually came out before September, but me and a couple of friends, none of whom all of whom like Lord of the Rings, and none of whom had had played the game, were like, this is finally our chance to hop into this game. I would I would be like those bastards, they've dropped it and so we haven't gone back, and so I haven't gone back solo, which I probably will do later in the year. I won't knock them too hard because then we got Dragon Wild, so we've got a co-op game we're playing as a group and we're enjoying it. And so I can't I can't fault them too hard. I was actually gonna put Wolverine in the Honorable Mentions, but it's it's it's now up the list because of the the you know, final half of the game really, really won me over, like I said. So we'll get there. but instead on the honorable mentions will be Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resync. I finished it last month and then went ahead and did the new story chapter that I know you had mentioned. Loving West End and I I couldn't agree more. the the World Without Gold added story chapter for the remaster is some of the best content in the entire game. it was killer. It was so good. It was some of the best naval battles, some of the best ground battles that you have in the entire game, in the entire Assassin's Creed series. which is I think extra promising given that I haven't liked a lot of the modern Assassin's Creed titles. So I think if if they put out more game more either remakes and remasters like this or more straight up titles that kinda blend old school and new school Assassin's Creed together in this way, I think Ubisoft could fix the series. I think they really could win everybody back going forward. Westen: Yeah. Dude, it's crazy how it's crazy how much better that's like I mean, not that it's not not all good, but it is crazy that the new stuff is the best stuff in the game. Like, that is wild. But I Andrew: Yeah, it's insane. I would not have expected it. Westen: I think they leaned I think they were able to lean into like their new formula. I I don't the original, I think it was not it wasn't as easy to kill guys, right? Like it wasn't as quick. Yeah, so I think they really lean they leaned into that with that. They they Andrew: Yes. Westen: made like some real ass like war. Like you feel like you're in war, like straight up in a way that yeah, Andrew: Yes. You're in a battle. A battle. Yeah, that's for real. Westen: like like you have those moments in the base game, but it just it takes it to another level with both the ship battles and the on foot battles. And like it has like an actual legit naval boss battle fight, which is kind of fucking cool. Like it's cool. Like it's it's Andrew: Yeah. Yeah. Westen: it's it's really impressive how good that was. Andrew: Yeah, it was killer. They crushed it. I w I would have put it on I would have put it up the list, but it's some other games won me over, but it no less deserving, frankly. number five, the game I didn't talk about yet is No More Room in Hell 2. I never played No More Room in Hell 1. I didn't know what the fuck that was. It was just a random pop-up on Game Pass this past month that me and my friends decided to hop into. It's a roguelite zombie survival. Extraction shooter co-op game. It's an insane juggling of games. I know a lot of people are sick of zombie games, and I am too, but this game I like. It's a more grounded zombie game. I'm a big Walking Dead fan, like the original comic books and the early seasons of the show in particular. I like a more grounded zombie setting. I don't want to do a ton of parkour. I don't want special zombies that can do parkour and they turn green and they puke. It's like just give me a slow walking zombie. Let me you know, go hunt around for ammo and and do a couple little things and leave. Like that's I want a a spooky, horror realistic zombie survival game. And that was this. Like you drop in with your friends onto a you know different city or farm or industrial maps. you rummage around for supplies, and then you fight through, you know, waves of of kind of slow moving, meandering zombies that they throw more and more at you as you go. You do some objectives and you extract. You don't extract with your gear But when you extract successfully and you live, your characters level up and you get new abilities, you know, more carrying weight, more this, more that. And if your character dies and you don't have a certain item on you, you die permanently and you have to make a new character. And so me and my friends just enjoyed the shit out of that. It was it's a really good zombie survival game. If you got Game Pass, try it out. If you don't, I don't think it's an expensive title. So if you're looking for a fun zombie co-op experience with your friends and you like The Walking Dead, dude, fucking try this game. It's it's a good time for sure. So that's number five. number four, Wolverine. We talked about it. It's a good character action game. It's good. It's a good time. If you like Marvel, if you like Wolverine, play it. If you don't, and you don't play it till next year, or you never play it, you're not probably missing out. Like, you're not gonna go to the grave, you're not gonna be on your deathbed surrounded by your beautiful family going, God, I wish I played Wolverine by Insomniac. But like, it's a good game. If you played it, you're not gonna be on your deathbed going, fuck, I played Wolverine. Like, it's not that. Westen: Your your hipster older sister will be on your deathbed saying like you should have tried mixed ape and been more open to it though. Andrew: Yes, she will! Can can you even do a a half an episode on that chart? Westen: Still tr We're gonna have to chart it by minutes, not by episode. David: W I gotta add minus minus one podcast, like. man. This whiteboard's gonna get some use. Andrew: Two at two mentions this episode is is brutal. At number three, we've got Dusk Fade, which Weston hates to hear. But I'm telling you, go it's if you like old school PlayStation 2 collect a thon, you know, action games, you're look action platformers, you're gonna have a good time with Duskfade. It's a fun story, it's a good time. If you like Kingdom Hearts, that's kind of its big inspiration. If you like Spyro, if you like Jack and Daxter, it's a similar type of game. It's a good time. I'd like to see what these guys do going forward on like what their next game is. I think it will will be a little bit more technically improved, which I think that's the only pitfall here is that it's not technically horribly impressive, but the platforming is awesome and the boss battles are fun. Dusk Bade at number three. At number two, I did David: Did you finish it or Andrew: finish it. Yeah, I beat that one. and incredible. David: Okay. Andrew: It it it the final boss battle was actually like unreal. It was actually challenging. It was it was solid. Very solid experience. And number two, Star Wars Zero Company. I I'm really vibing with this game. I've not played a lot of strategy turn-based games with this grid system. I've never played XCOM or any of those games. So I don't know. Like I don't know if this is kind of bog standard, I don't know if it's great, I don't know if it's actually weak by c by those comparisons. I know Weston, you weren't super up on this game. it does one of my favorite things when it comes to Star Wars, which I love Star Wars. It does my favorite thing. It's not about the Jedi Sith conflict. Cause respectfully, that's the most boring part of Star Wars. Like we love I love the original movies, but outside of that, I'm done. I I've had enough Jedi. And there are some Jedi in this game, but it's not the main crux, is like the Jedi versus the Sith. Like, I'm so sick, I think, in just all media, of the like, it's the world-ending conflict. It's like this is the thing where if we don't do this, it's all over. We're all dead. It's all like the bad guys win. Ultimately forever, the dark has won, like it's over. Like this is a smaller scale story about a ragtag bunch, which I also love. I'm a big Guardians of the Galaxy fan. Like I love the Guardians, like I love a ragtag team, I love a space opera. I love how I played this. I know Weston had mentioned that it was more difficult for him because he played it on hard, and so he had to kind of make more simple decisions, like he had to play a kind of very conservative strategy style that wasn't as exciting. I'm playing on the moderate difficulty and I I have had a little bit more ability to kind of goof off and like be like, I'm gonna send this guy off on his own to go for this thing, or like to try to hit a flank or do this interesting, you know, I'm gonna send him out there. I'm gonna, you know, there's a Mandalorian that you recruit later on, and she can jetpack across the fucking battlefield and jump into the into the fray and blast people away and like that's super cool. I've had I've been able to kind of test different things out, try some different things, have some fun down the stretch. I'm probably about halfway through the game. I just had probably the best mission I've had was like you go in to get and you extract an item and the enemy finds out and you have to get to the extraction point and you have to go from one end of this big battlefield to the other while between every one of your turns, enemy like aircraft like strafe the map. And if you're not like on top of of like getting rid of enemies as you move, You need to be moving a certain amount forward at all times or you're gonna get your guys caught back and get killed. Like there's been some interesting kind of I very much expected every mission to play out the same and it hasn't. There's been some variety down the stretch. I'm liking it. I I think it's a really good time. It's got it's ha it has me considering playing more of this type of game in the future, which I think is also just that's always praiseworthy. Westen: Think I think putting it down to normal might have been better. I think you might be on to something there. I do think regardless, I'll still be disappointed with like the in between mission stuff for sure. the story and that it's been XCOM actually has like a whole little thing there, and Zero Company doesn't have much, and that's that David: Mm. Westen: was disappointing to me. And the story stuff, like there was some mass effect comparisons coming in. I I don't have not seen a a lick of that personally. But but yeah, I think normal would have helped Andrew: No disagree with that for sure so far. Maybe it changes. I do like the story, but David: Yeah. Westen: me a little bit. Andrew: I agree. It's such an interesting thing because with this list, like, I would say Wolverine benefited from me playing it on a difficulty up. Like I I played that on hard, and I found that that made the combat far more enjoyable. I found that playing this on normal has kept it enjoyable in a way that you're saying it doesn't on the higher difficulty. So it's that's it's tough when that's kind of David: Yeah. I I think Andrew: Cut. David: I think strategy games can sometimes the harder difficulty you go, the more it encourages you to play like Andrew: Boring. David: more carefully. And sometimes that means you're playing too safe. And sometimes it also like sometimes hard difficulty narrows the abilities that allows you to use because some are just too fun and not as good. It just encourages you Andrew: Yeah. David: to min-max more, which can sometimes lessen the experience. So I think games that balance that well, that's when hard really shines. Westen: But then f and then Fire Emblem on hard isn't hard enough. It's like I David: Yeah. Westen: legit when I start games, man, it is the biggest stress for me is figuring out what difficulty to play on. I probably Google David: Especially if you Westen: what difficulty to play on like almost every game that has difficulty settings. I'm trying to David: Yeah. Westen: figure it out because it's so such an important decision every time. Andrew: It is? It is. David: For me it's always it's less so choosing it's making it becomes more of an agonizing decision if you can't change the difficulty like mid play through. That's the biggest Andrew: Yup. Yup. Terrible. Westen: Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. David: thing. Westen: And that's I think what I'm stuck in with Fire Emblem because I was like, maybe when I realized how easy it was, I was like, maybe I should switch it back, but I don't th you can't do I don't think you can do the back to classic. So yeah. Anyway, what's your number one, Andrew? Andrew: It's Runescape Dragon Wilds. I mean, come on, was it did I gush about it enough? W Runescape Dragon Wilds is the greatest survival crafting game ever Westen: Had to be. Andrew: made that I've played so far, and I've played pretty much all the big ones. like Survive on Raft, Valheim, Minecraft, like d Arc. Like this is this is David: You play Valhant, 'cause I was about to say maybe we need to play Andrew: this is the one, man. This is the one that's just I've touched Valheim with some friends on Xbox. It's just not this game is just perfect as far as that goes, the progression Scaling is just too good. Westen: Man, that was fun. I you know, doing this podcast, it it got me inspired to write again too, because I mean I've been wanting to do it. but man, you know, the difficulty thing, man, that's an interesting topic. I feel like I want to dive David: Yeah. Westen: into that because that really is, man, just figuring out your difficulties so it's everything. It really is, but it's impossible to do because there's such a wide variety of skill sets. So you have multiple difficulties, which is stressful in its own way. So it's like, man, just Tough game developer decisions to make for sure. David: Yeah. Westen: I got there's no, there's not always a right answer. So anyway, that is it for this week. Hopefully we can get back on our normal schedule in the coming weeks, especially as get to end of year coverage. So the same with Big NerdGaming.com. Now that we're last quarter of the year, this is usually when I have a lot of stuff I'm pretty interested in writing about. So I think I'm gonna do a mailbag, then I'll be back to a lot of my end of year stuff, which is always fun. So appreciate you, Andrew and David, for joining us. We will see you all in a couple of weeks. David: Course.