Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep7: GRD035: Should I Aim for a Zero Percent Tax Rate in Retirement?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:29You, a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:33each side of the debate to your own personal situation to decide
- 0:36what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go.
- 0:39Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 0:44Hey Ed, you like zero calorie soda?
- 0:46Yeah, I actually have a vitamin water, zero vitamin water.
- 0:50I love that stuff.
- 0:51I like it too.
- 0:52You ever have a Paycheck though with zero dollars in it?
- 0:55No.
- 0:55All right, so that's not so good, right?
- 0:57I can see already.
- 0:58I don't even think, can that be called a paycheck?
- 1:00Well, that's a good question.
- 1:02A no paycheck.
- 1:03That's called an intern.
- 1:05Ooh, you're going to rub some interns the wrong way with that one.
- 1:10All right.
- 1:10Well, I think even with those two examples, we can
- 1:13see sometimes zero is good.
- 1:15Sometimes zero, not so good.
- 1:17So Ed kind of leads us into today's topic of discussion.
- 1:22Zero percent, more specifically, should people aim for a zero
- 1:26percent tax rate in retirement?
- 1:29That sounds fantastic, and I always tell people tax free is fantastic.
- 1:34You want to have zero percent, but if you do the planning, it may not
- 1:38be the best course of action because you may be leaving a lot of tax
- 1:43savings on the table if you only stop planning or so once you hit zero.
- 1:49All right, so.
- 1:50First, before we get into good, bad, and different.
- 1:53How do we get to zero?
- 1:54Like what, what would, what are the ways that someone can pay
- 1:57zero percent tax in retirement Ed?
- 1:59Assuming they have income, right?
- 2:01That's what we're assuming.
- 2:02Yes, we'll assume they have income.
- 2:03It would be zero if they have zero income.
- 2:05They don't have to file a return.
- 2:06It is always an easy way to not pay taxes to have no income.
- 2:09Yes.
- 2:09Yeah.
- 2:10See, nobody ever comes up with that strategy.
- 2:12And you heard it here on the great retirement debate.
- 2:15That's right.
- 2:15Have no income.
- 2:16There you go.
- 2:16Done.
- 2:17Zero taxpayer.
- 2:17But you could have, you know, they have large, uh, Standard deductions
- 2:22now, uh, certain income is exempt.
- 2:24So you could actually end up with zero percent.
- 2:27It depends on how you invest and what level of income you're in.
- 2:32So maybe, like, things like municipal bonds.
- 2:34Right.
- 2:340 percent taxes.
- 2:36Uh, you have, let's say, Roth IRAs.
- 2:39Right.
- 2:39More places you can shield.
- 2:40You could have a 0 percent tax rate.
- 2:42Uh, could be possibly, uh, through the use of certain loans from life
- 2:47insurance or even really any asset.
- 2:49A loan is going to be received tax free.
- 2:52Even taxable assets that are covered, say, by the standard deduction.
- 2:55Yup, yup.
- 2:56And then ultimately you can have up to that standard deduction
- 2:58amount of income tax free per year.
- 3:00Plus, for a lot of retirees, if they have minimal to no other income, their
- 3:05Social Security can be tax free as well.
- 3:07And even capital gains can be, uh, tax free, zero percent
- 3:10in certain circumstances.
- 3:11That's right.
- 3:12If you're in either the 10 or the 12 percent ordinary income tax bracket,
- 3:15then your long term capital gains rate is zero percent, which applies
- 3:19both to your, uh, capital gains as well as to qualify dividends.
- 3:23But the question is, should you stop there and think, this is great.
- 3:26Right, is it great?
- 3:27If you get to that point where everything is in one of those areas, and you are
- 3:30paying a 0 percent tax rate, Is it good?
- 3:33Generally, no.
- 3:34Especially if you have a lot more built up income, say in
- 3:38a retirement account, an IRA.
- 3:40The key to tax planning is getting this money out at the lowest rates.
- 3:43Now, zero is the lowest rate, but there are other low rates that you want to
- 3:48take advantage of every year you can.
- 3:50Yeah, I think you're hitting on something there, Ed, which is, you know, zero
- 3:53percent may be good in theory, like it sounds great, but zero percent for that
- 4:00One year might mean that you either, either you or your heirs have to pay
- 4:05a lot more than zero and a lot more than they otherwise would later on.
- 4:09Or you might have gotten to zero by prepaying your taxes to a
- 4:15much, uh, too high degree, right?
- 4:18You might have prepaid in the form of Roth conversions way too much earlier in life.
- 4:23You might have prepaid in the form of, uh, or even things like municipal bond
- 4:27interest, you know, municipal bonds.
- 4:29Municipalities know there's a special tax rate associated with their interest.
- 4:34And so a typical municipal bond will pay less in interest than a comparably
- 4:39rated and duration corporate bond.
- 4:42Why?
- 4:42Well, because they know that there's a tax benefit attached to it.
- 4:44That's what you pay.
- 4:45That's right.
- 4:46So to that extent, right, if you're in municipal bonds, you would
- 4:49expect a lower level of interest.
- 4:52And it varies from time to time, depending upon what yields are,
- 4:56what market conditions are.
- 4:57But oftentimes, if you're not someone who's in the highest, or at least one
- 5:02of the highest tax brackets, you're usually better off taking a bond where
- 5:07you have more gross interest, whereas paying a higher yield, in other words,
- 5:12where you're getting more income taxable, and then exactly a taxable bond, and
- 5:15then paying the income tax on it.
- 5:170 percent is great, but sometimes it's better to have, you know, a
- 5:22lot of of a bigger number than it is to have all of a smaller number.
- 5:27Right.
- 5:27And it also depends how much you have stockpiled.
- 5:30Because if you're only putting a little in at a time, that means the rest of
- 5:34your assets are growing and growing.
- 5:36And if they're in taxable accounts, like an IRA, for example, the taxes
- 5:40are going to, are going to explode.
- 5:42Yeah.
- 5:42I mean, so let's talk about why this is even a question to begin with,
- 5:45because I think it's fair that there are, there are some people who really
- 5:49believe that this is the best way to go.
- 5:51Right, where, uh, you know, either for their own accounts or either
- 5:54even professionals out there who, um, who support the idea that retirees
- 5:59should aim towards having a 0%, uh, you know, tax rate in retirement.
- 6:04And the thought behind it effectively is if you have a 0 percent retirement,
- 6:08you have some predictability over what your taxes look like.
- 6:11It's all yours.
- 6:12Uh, you don't have to worry anymore about, you know, what will this happen?
- 6:15What will that happen?
- 6:16There's a, there's a, a peace of mind and it's fair.
- 6:19Like we, it.
- 6:19You know, but that's generally you're looking at one year.
- 6:23Well, but even, even if you want, right, if you want to get to the extreme, right?
- 6:27How do you get to 0 percent forever?
- 6:28Well, if you had, you might have a million dollars in your
- 6:31401k, convert it all today.
- 6:33You never have to worry about taxes on it in the future, right?
- 6:35You get down to 0%.
- 6:37So the, the.
- 6:38The challenge I have, again, with, with that philosophy, um, you know,
- 6:42and I, I totally agree that we should take into consideration people's,
- 6:46uh, comfort levels with things and, you know, what makes them feel good.
- 6:51It's okay.
- 6:51Sometimes it's okay to do things that aren't the best dollars and cents
- 6:54wise, if it makes you feel comfortable.
- 6:56But it's also fair to say that we should be careful about doing
- 7:01things that are blatantly, uh, not in our financial best interest.
- 7:07Long term.
- 7:08Yeah.
- 7:08Long term.
- 7:09Exactly.
- 7:09And to the beneficiaries.
- 7:11Sure.
- 7:11Yeah.
- 7:12If that's important to you.
- 7:13Yeah.
- 7:13Sometimes people say, well, I'm going to leave my kids Roth money.
- 7:15It'll be the best thing for them.
- 7:16Well, maybe, but maybe they would have been better off getting traditional
- 7:20IRA money plus a lot more money in your bank account because they're
- 7:23in a lower tax rate than you.
- 7:25Right.
- 7:25Right?
- 7:26Ultimately, that 0 percent tax rate.
- 7:29The question is, how much did it cost you to get there already, or how
- 7:32much would it cost you in the future by not using up today's low rates?
- 7:37I guess a different way to say this would be, a low income tax
- 7:41year is a terrible thing thing to waste from a planning perspective.
- 7:44Tell me, uh, I've heard it before, but I like when you say it.
- 7:47Tell me what you say to a, an accountant who's so proud of themselves, Jeff, I
- 7:51got my clients a zero percent tax rate.
- 7:54How do you like that?
- 7:55I'm so sorry for the bad advice.
- 7:57That's really what it comes down to.
- 7:58And what do they say?
- 7:59What?
- 8:00Yeah.
- 8:00You know.
- 8:00I'm a hero.
- 8:02Unfortunately, and look, you're a CPA, Ed.
- 8:04I know.
- 8:04You're a CPA.
- 8:05It, it, it pains, I know both of us to say that, you know, many
- 8:10of, uh, many persons of our ilk.
- 8:12So to speak are too focused on the here and now they're looking at today's tax
- 8:17return and saying How do we keep that number lower when really what the focus
- 8:21should be on is how to keep the total amount of taxes That someone pays over
- 8:26their lifetime as low as possible, which often means spreading out out income
- 8:32and paying at least a little bit, but you know, some amount, but hopefully
- 8:36a little bit in each year rather than nothing in some but an outsized tax
- 8:41bill in other years to get it there.
- 8:43The outsized tax bill is the big surprise and that could be the big
- 8:46hit and it could be at a higher rate.
- 8:48It will be at a higher rate, Even if rates don't go up, because it'll push you
- 8:52into a higher bracket for that one year.
- 8:55Because you only get one crack at the apple, rather than use, where you
- 8:58said, you know, you spread it over many years, that's the way to do it.
- 9:02I think we, uh, we all, we all understand what you're saying, Ed,
- 9:05which is, you know, effectively, if you have these opportunities, you
- 9:08want a little bit each, look, I'll give you another analogy, Ed, right?
- 9:12You're supposed to eat 2, 000 or 2, 500 calories in a day.
- 9:15That's a standard thing, right?
- 9:17You want it all in one meal or you want it spread out throughout the day, right?
- 9:21Right.
- 9:21It'd be very difficult to eat all that.
- 9:22You know, I thought you were gonna go.
- 9:24I get it only on Saturday night.
- 9:26You know, I'm gonna take, you know, I don't know, 20, 000 calories on Saturday.
- 9:30There you go.
- 9:30You could take it to an extreme, right?
- 9:32Yeah, yeah, you need to spread it out.
- 9:34And, and, uh, Ultimately, right, by, um, by, by doing that on the tax return, you
- 9:39know, we have a progressive tax system.
- 9:41That's really why this, this matters.
- 9:44Right.
- 9:44If we had a flat tax system, as is the case in some other areas of the
- 9:48world, and even some states have a flat tax, then it wouldn't matter as much
- 9:52because effectively, whether you took the income today or you took it in the
- 9:54future, you'd be paying the same rate.
- 9:56But in our system, if you have a million dollars of income today, you'll pay
- 10:01more than if you had 100, 000 of income.
- 10:04Each year over 10 years.
- 10:06Yes.
- 10:07I always tell people the same exact thing.
- 10:10Exactly.
- 10:10That you'll always pay less tax the more years you spread it out.
- 10:15All right.
- 10:15So conceptually, if we agree that going to a 0 percent tax rate is is is not the
- 10:20best and or is not the aim that people should be, you know, not not what people
- 10:24should be aiming for in retirement.
- 10:27And we're saying that you should try and spread it out.
- 10:30How do you like what?
- 10:31What's one or two things that listeners should keep in mind
- 10:34as they're trying to spread out.
- 10:36Like how do you actually do that in, in, in reality?
- 10:38Well, you have to do a projection and this is best done.
- 10:42For example, with Roth conversions, this is best done probably November,
- 10:46December, after you have a good idea of what your income is.
- 10:50The reason I said with Roth conversions, because no longer
- 10:53can you undo a Roth conversion.
- 10:55So I have people, I, I tell people to think about it, but don't, don't, Pull
- 11:00the trigger on a Roth conversion until maybe first week in December when you,
- 11:04when you know better what it's going to cost after you get your capital
- 11:07gain distributions and all of that, maybe bonuses, things that come in.
- 11:11So you're better off, uh, doing it at that point.
- 11:15And then you have a better idea what that conversion is going to cost by
- 11:19knowing how much of each lower graduated brackets, that's, uh, what you talked
- 11:24about, the per, the per Progressive tax system, their graduated rates, you
- 11:28get a certain amount of each bracket.
- 11:30You, I think you said it earlier, you never want to waste a bracket.
- 11:33I agree with that because you don't get it back again.
- 11:37If you only used, I don't know, 80 percent or just a part, forget about
- 11:41the percentage, a part of the 22 percent bracket or the 24 percent
- 11:45bracket, you left the rest on the table.
- 11:47You never get credit for that in a future year.
- 11:50You want to start using those brackets each year.
- 11:53So the more income you can throw in to max out whatever bracket you
- 11:58feel comfortable with, I think given these rates, uh, 12 percent, 22, 24
- 12:03percent, you could have hundreds of thousands of income, taxable income,
- 12:07and still be in a 24 percent bracket.
- 12:10Yeah, the way I like to think about it and explain it, and it's, This is much more
- 12:14at a 10, 000 foot view at a micro level.
- 12:17You may have to manage a little bit more specifically, but you basically
- 12:20want to look at your entire life, right?
- 12:24And you want your income to be as flat as possible over all the years.
- 12:28Like if you want to plot this on a chart, right?
- 12:29With, with ups and downs, well, some years your, your income is higher
- 12:33cause you've got a better year in business or some years are higher
- 12:36because interest rates are higher and you've got more interest from the bank
- 12:39or some years are, are higher because you had, uh, You know, um, some bonus
- 12:44that wanna spike and operations.
- 12:45Yeah.
- 12:45Right?
- 12:45Sure.
- 12:46But you want to take the other savings that you have and sort of mix it into
- 12:51those years and, and spot low points, if you will, and fill it in so that
- 12:56there are no more low points, so that your income looks as flat as possible.
- 13:00over your entire lifetime.
- 13:01Now, obviously, you've got to work at inflation and things like that, but
- 13:04that's, that's generally the idea.
- 13:05You want your income to be smooth.
- 13:07You don't want large peaks some years and large valleys in the other, because
- 13:12when you see that, if you look at a, you know, if you were to plot your income
- 13:15over the course of your lifetime, Any large value you have and large peak you
- 13:20have is probably an opportunity where had you equalized that income more over
- 13:25those two years or series of years, you would have paid cumulatively less tax.
- 13:30And again, this is an oversimplification tax rates change over time.
- 13:34There are certain things like Medicare Part B premiums, which
- 13:36only matter after a certain point.
- 13:39And only, you know, if you go over 1, Then you're over the cliff.
- 13:42So if you've gone over 1, you might as well go over by 50, 000
- 13:45because it can't hurt you anymore.
- 13:47But as a general statement, smoothing out income over lifetime helps
- 13:52to create that lowest lifetime tax bill, which has tax planners.
- 13:57We value more than anything else, right?
- 13:59So back to your 0%, you might get a 0%, but at some point it's going
- 14:04to be the top rate, 37 percent or whatever the future top rate is.
- 14:09And that will wipe away all the prior year's savings.
- 14:12Yeah.
- 14:12So ultimately I think we agree at 0 percent sounds nice, but the reality
- 14:18is for most individuals who are healthy earners, who accumulate significant
- 14:22amount of assets, 0 percent is not something you should strive for.
- 14:26Instead, focus on that lowest lifetime tax bill.
- 14:29Use up low rates while you have them, and take advantage of today's low
- 14:33tax rate environment while you can.
- 14:34That's right.
- 14:35And inflation, because that expands the brackets each year.
- 14:38Absolutely.
- 14:40All right.
- 14:40That's all the time we have for today.
- 14:41Ed, great discussion as always.
- 14:43We'll see you next time on the Great Retirement Debate.
- 14:46Jeffrey Levi is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 14:49This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 14:52not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal, or tax advice.
- 14:56Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information
- 14:58which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 15:01Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but its accuracy and
- 15:05completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 15:06The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 15:09and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.