Latest / Newcomer Pod / VC Twitter Ghostwriters (w/Logan Bartlett)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. So what kind of salad?
- 0:12Hey, it's Eric newcomer, welcome to dead cat.
- 0:15Tom do it on? Is here, we've got Logan,
- 0:17Bartlett VC. But more importantly a rival.
- 0:21Podcaster, what your Cartoon Avatar?
- 0:25I also profiled him a while ago. Sting is it a zero-sum game?
- 0:30It's a rising tide lifts All Ships here.
- 0:32That's true. But I used to promotion, to t.j.
- 0:34to have enemies than friends, right?
- 0:35I mean, I feel like few, you know what cartoon avatars is
- 0:38your enemy. It's very clear what our enemy
- 0:40can be, you're going after the wrong and wrong to be see how
- 0:43we're competitors in both the. We would like to be a foil to
- 0:46all in know. Yeah, exactly the modestly
- 0:50successful like, you know, up-and-coming, VC, trying to get
- 0:54by versus the self-proclaimed billionaires that are all
- 0:57navel-gazing, which one makes it better for Oh, I don't know.
- 1:00We can say at this podcast currently there is zero people
- 1:03that appeared in Elon Musk text messages so far as I can tell.
- 1:06Yeah, yeah, exactly. How long have you been at
- 1:09cartoon avatars, by the way, beginning of February.
- 1:12So originally actually, I give those guys a lot of credit in
- 1:15the impetus for doing it. And so it was last fall probably
- 1:21a year ago that the market was super crazy and I was seeing the
- 1:24success that they were having. And obviously they do a good job
- 1:26with one type of content, right? And one I mean, they all had
- 1:30different voices but so you're saying all in all in.
- 1:33Yeah. And so I thought, originally
- 1:35that I could be a foil to that in some ways and so it was
- 1:39actually, like originally trying to recreate elements of what
- 1:41they did, but maybe a little bit more relatable to the non
- 1:45billionaire class, but the format has evolved.
- 1:48Originally, I to other people doing it with me.
- 1:50Well, you at Nikita, who now has like, viral apps success.
- 1:53Right. What's it called?
- 1:54It's crazy. Yes, what you have gas?
- 1:58Is it doing well? That was number one on the app.
- 2:00Yeah, it's like a dating type thing or to be honest, I do not
- 2:04know there's bad blood x. No, no, guys, host you're done.
- 2:09No, I'm trying to get him to come back on.
- 2:11We're still buddies. But what actually happened was,
- 2:13he was starting this company and he got distracted with, you
- 2:16know, actually doing his day job.
- 2:17So it kind of evolved to just me and then just me plus sack
- 2:20Weinberg. And so we've been in our current
- 2:22iteration ish, probably since April, I would say.
- 2:25So I don't know how you score it.
- 2:27Yeah. All right.
- 2:28Well, we're here today. This is a fun episode, so I want
- 2:31to just sort of shoot the shit but Insider wrote, what would
- 2:35you call it? Like an explosive story
- 2:37headline. I made two hundred thousand
- 2:40dollars last year. Ghost.
- 2:41Writing tweets for Superstar VCS, it takes me 5 hours a week.
- 2:46Here's how I found my clients and built a booming side, hustle
- 2:49from scratch and it's basically sort of adds told to story of
- 2:54someone they claim they got like a hundred thousand dollars.
- 3:00River Tweed storming like a big funding round.
- 3:02I mean, just a ton of money and it's definitely traveling the VC
- 3:06world because, you know, it fits into this whole sort of, I don't
- 3:09know, VC's as content, marketers as sort of celebrities thing VC
- 3:14says influencers. Right?
- 3:15Right. I mean, it was like a big story
- 3:17three or four years ago in your an influencer, right?
- 3:19That's right. Yeah.
- 3:20Logan understands this I'm just trying to subtly shape people
- 3:23into my World Views one Twitter post at a time.
- 3:26Yeah you know it was interesting people have been poking around
- 3:28at this story for a little while.
- 3:29I'll add a Washington Post reporter reach out to me like
- 3:32three months ago and they were like I heard, you're someone, I
- 3:35should talk to about this and about specifically the paid for
- 3:39tweets issue. I couldn't tell like what their
- 3:42angle was if they were trying to get me to say that I pay for
- 3:45tweets or something. Yeah.
- 3:47And so I got on the phone with her and I was like, listen, if
- 3:50someone saying that, let's be very clear.
- 3:53No, I am not doing that, I'll hundred percent.
- 3:56If you're going to run that, I am going to like, get on a bully
- 3:58pulpit and call you Al Her, you're gonna see me go fake news
- 4:01on. This, was that the claim that
- 4:03they came out? No, no, just like, oh, you're
- 4:06one of those annoying, VCS on Twitter and you might be a great
- 4:08person to enter that. We was more like you would have
- 4:11an opinion about this. I think was her angle, but I was
- 4:14immediately, like, if someone is selling my name, like the
- 4:17originality is of my tweets. I will come for them, right?
- 4:20So, I immediately got defensive because I knew that this article
- 4:24one. Listen, it's logical that people
- 4:27are doing this right in a very high level.
- 4:29Hey, Is there a opportunity in Arbitrage that exists from very
- 4:34well paid people that maybe don't have a lot of time or
- 4:38don't have a lot of creativity to come up with stuff like this
- 4:41and then very creative people that have lots of time and don't
- 4:45have a lot of money. Like is there an Arbitrage
- 4:47opportunity that exists there? Yes, my criticism with this
- 4:50article is not that. It's not happening because I
- 4:54have to think it is right. You know.
- 4:56I don't want to undermine Business Insider's reporting.
- 4:58It seems like they have And stamps and, you know, wire
- 5:01receipts and all that. There were enough little details
- 5:04in this story that just like, didn't ring true to me that I'm
- 5:09not, and we can go through and talk about some of the specific
- 5:12one. Like, yeah, let's deconstruct
- 5:13it. By the way, I had nothing to do
- 5:14with this story. So I feel confident in being
- 5:17able to read this article, I'll leave commentary.
- 5:20That's critical to you guys. Well, to be fair like insiders
- 5:23defense, right? It's an As Told to, right?
- 5:26It's a zoo. So like a bit, you know, Insider
- 5:28validated the Is identity, right?
- 5:31They validated some form of wire, receipts.
- 5:33And so I think there's enough of a story there or that, that
- 5:37alone is interesting, right? This whole thing is interesting,
- 5:39just from like a palace Intrigue and you know, whenever we can
- 5:42talk about all the different things so before we get into
- 5:45the, did it happen? Exactly like this article lays
- 5:48out, I just want to touch on why there would be demand for this
- 5:53in the first place like Logan. I've written a story about you
- 5:56which I called a Twitter trolls take on the future of investing.
- 5:59So your son. Who's very clearly in a sort of
- 6:03Envy speak, even laid out to your El.
- 6:05Psy like tweeting and podcasting is important to be seized right
- 6:10now. But yeah, explain that to our
- 6:12audience. Why would there even be a market
- 6:13for like, who cares would have EC tweets?
- 6:16So I think we talked a little bit about this in that article
- 6:19that you did. But once upon a time, let's say
- 6:22early 2000. BC was very much a cottage
- 6:25industry where VC's controlled capital and Founders came to
- 6:29them. Them looking for access to that
- 6:32Capital, right? And diligence process has lasted
- 6:35a long time and entrepreneurs had to jump through hoops.
- 6:39And ultimately it was only a handful of mostly white men that
- 6:42sort of controlled the purse strings of, who got funded, and
- 6:45who didn't write. And then over the course of the
- 6:48last 20 years, I sort of call that like the broadcast
- 6:50television days is those were the days in which you know, your
- 6:54only job is a VC was to be broadly appealing.
- 6:58So as not to be Two ended not be eliminated from this little boys
- 7:02club cottage industry, right? And really you needed to suck up
- 7:05to the other, VCS more than anything because you're great
- 7:08deal flow from them, it was sort of protected you just wanted a
- 7:12generic good brand, you know, I mean there was still sort of a
- 7:16you want to be, you know, you want to have a little bit of
- 7:19spiciness because it's not banking, you know, it's Venture
- 7:22but yeah, yeah. But even still like sure, you
- 7:25hear stories of Sequoia and Kleiner duking it out for like
- 7:27Google and stuff. But like for the Most part it
- 7:30was much more collegial and how it operated.
- 7:33And then I sort of Market 2008. Ish, post-financial crisis
- 7:38happens to coincide with the Andreessen Horowitz coming up.
- 7:41Fred Wilson was vlogging in a meaningful way, right?
- 7:43Like all these Twitter was kind of proliferating as a medium.
- 7:47This is the cable television. Yeah.
- 7:49Cable. We're broadcasting cable, right?
- 7:52Where there's some level of personalization that exists,
- 7:55right? And so, like, you have funds
- 7:57that starts focusing on. Oh, we're a growth only.
- 7:59Find Ray like once upon a time that was not a thing.
- 8:02But now we're going to only do growth.
- 8:03There were only going to do fintech or we're only going to
- 8:05do Healthcare right and VC started to.
- 8:09I think the Andreessen Horowitz folks did a good job of like
- 8:12pulling back the veil a little bit in terms of how the industry
- 8:17operated and you know Ben Horowitz was leading with rap
- 8:20posts at the beginning of his article right and there was just
- 8:23a little bit more personality that existed there.
- 8:26We've had Parker Conrad on the show before and he obviously has
- 8:29specific a feelings about Andreessen Horowitz.
- 8:31But his line that stuck with me is that they're basically a
- 8:34media company with an investment arm attached to it.
- 8:37Yeah. Parker's the fucking best I had
- 8:39him on and he went in but you had a great.
- 8:41Yeah he went into depth about Andreessen Horowitz was an
- 8:44interesting that episode first. He was our first guests, what
- 8:48great job interviewing him. And for some reason he decided
- 8:50to go like full Hit Em Up On David Sachs and then were we
- 8:53sort of warmed him up. He was a little Paranoid on ours
- 8:56and then he was like, okay nothing bad happened to me when
- 8:59I did that. And, you know, you got an even.
- 9:01That's right. You prime the pump for?
- 9:03Yeah, exactly. You were my opening act, okay?
- 9:05Then the next era post-2020 is the streaming are.
- 9:08Then the next day, right now, as capital got abundant right?
- 9:11Like you sort of got your infinite choice of what type of
- 9:15capital you wanted. And if you wanted a fintech,
- 9:17only early stage fund, that was backed by whatever former has
- 9:22bananas. It's Avatar.
- 9:24We are what? Yeah, yeah, you got all your
- 9:26choices, right. And so we enter the Cartoon
- 9:29Network are A Avicii, the Cartoon Network area.
- 9:32I say it's sort of tick-tock personalization, where
- 9:34everything you like, have your option of like any personalized
- 9:37feed of capital provider and I think that has been true.
- 9:41Now with the pullback may be less, and we'll do they that
- 9:44after that's sort of the next logical.
- 9:46So, but going into the bubble and I think this like insiders
- 9:50story about paying for tweets is sort of, you know, it's
- 9:54reflecting a period that might be ending or might continue, but
- 9:58sort of at least until the And of, like last year in the first
- 10:01quarter of this year, this was the streaming Wars idea was like
- 10:04very much the mood. Yeah.
- 10:07Where everyone was just trying to cut through the noise, right?
- 10:10And I said this, Eric when I was talking to you about this, in
- 10:12the thing we did is like it's better to be Donald Trump than
- 10:15it is to be Jeb, Bush and Venture.
- 10:18And it's kind of like this that, you know, even comparing
- 10:20anything to Donald Trump is polarizing, but we don't live in
- 10:23a ranked Choice world of venture capital.
- 10:25It's like to be second is to be a loser, right?
- 10:28And the same thing. As in the primary process where
- 10:31if you're going through primaries right?
- 10:33You want to appeal deeply to as big of a subset of the
- 10:36population as you can but it's much better to appeal very
- 10:40deeply to a smaller group than it is to be milquetoast or like
- 10:45broadly, kind of rice and likable to a broader group,
- 10:48right? Are you willing to be mean
- 10:50enough? Do you have the hatred in your
- 10:52heart? And not like, no.
- 10:53I'm being sincere though. I mean I feel like there is
- 10:55almost an incentive to be like Keith and really like fighting
- 10:58with people on Twitter. Do you always adhere to your own
- 11:01principle on this or like are you intentionally alienating
- 11:03subsets of people go to I don't push to the outer end a
- 11:07polarization right for sure. Like that's just not my
- 11:09personality but I have pushed the outer end of certain types
- 11:14of content. For example like I think I was
- 11:17fucking around on Twitter and playing more of a Stephen
- 11:20Colbert, ish parody personality. We first interacted you tweeted
- 11:26a joke like a fake email or something I was sort of Due to
- 11:29your account and I was like the scold who is like, you know,
- 11:33half the people consuming this don't realize it's fake and like
- 11:37that was back in the days where I was like, oh chase down dumb
- 11:39shit on Twitter or whatever I think you might I forget if you
- 11:42deleted that or not you were sort of now.
- 11:44I didn't delete it. And no, come on because I got
- 11:47scolded by are no Dumber. Come on.
- 11:49That was like with there are some I mean you want the parody
- 11:53be to be obvious to a certain percentage of people, right?
- 11:56Or I don't know this week and yeah that's all day.
- 11:58Like how many people need to know?
- 11:59It's Joke for it. To make sense.
- 12:01Yeah. And like who you're appealing to
- 12:03and not. But to some extent, there's this
- 12:04element of people feeling like they're on the end on the joke
- 12:07and then when it goes outside the bubble of the people that
- 12:09are in on the joke, it actually makes the joke better to those.
- 12:12People that role that side right wing troll type but it's very
- 12:15mean-spirited. That idea that you're happy
- 12:17about it. Let's zoom in towards the
- 12:18article and we can debate the higher level stuff after way and
- 12:21tries. You know, like you're saying.
- 12:23I think the article capture is a specific point in time.
- 12:25Maybe one that is ending, but it's absolutely something that I
- 12:29imagined. CCS recognized at a certain
- 12:31point, which is like, oh shit, I'm getting attention for this.
- 12:34I've developed a personality and this may actually have
- 12:37Downstream effects, beneficial Downstream effects towards deal
- 12:40flow. And, you know, it seems like
- 12:43it's just feeding my ego like from the outside if you wouldn't
- 12:45think about how it could potentially help you in your,
- 12:48you know, actual day job, you would think, oh, this is just
- 12:50narcissism and that, you know, the base horrible Instinct that
- 12:53fuels all of the bullshit on Twitter, but it sounds like
- 12:56you're saying that there's, you know, real Financial upside to
- 12:59it. We should you get everyone to
- 13:00remember, you exist? I mean, as a newsletter writer
- 13:02it's like if you like everybody returns my texts and emails,
- 13:06whenever I publish and like similarly I think when you're
- 13:09tweeting a lot, people are thinking about you more, and you
- 13:11can feel the inbound come at you.
- 13:13And so I can imagine from the VCR perspective, it's a lot.
- 13:16Like the me, I should go look at like the actual report because I
- 13:18referenced it too many times so I should get my facts right on
- 13:21this. But there were some study done
- 13:23right about like people that were shown a list of names of
- 13:27people like six weeks before, Anna.
- 13:29Election. And then when the election came
- 13:32to be, they didn't know any of the candidates.
- 13:34But just based on the familiarity of having seen those
- 13:36names before, they're like proclivity to pick those
- 13:40candidates. And so it's hard to know right?
- 13:43What you don't see is the negative of it particularly as
- 13:45you pick a more polarizing view of stuff, right?
- 13:48And you're like joking around and I've gotten yelled at online
- 13:51before you don't see how many people are kind of like fuck
- 13:53this guy right but the advantage of just name recognition and
- 13:57people knowing you exist in the world.
- 13:59Olds. I've seen it be super
- 14:01advantageous for me and just cutting through the noise at an
- 14:04incremental level. I mean, who am I right?
- 14:07I'm 34 years old, Finance, background liberal arts school.
- 14:11Major have never been an operator like have had a decent
- 14:14investing career experience. But like you know, why would
- 14:16anyone want to work with me versus?
- 14:19I don't know. X other person that has had
- 14:21infinitely more success and infinite more like operating
- 14:24experience or whatever, right? And if people feel like they
- 14:27know me a little bit more and they feel like there's a little
- 14:29bit bit more personality there. I've seen it be effective,
- 14:32right? And so, I don't know how much to
- 14:34actually attribute it to this. It's one of these like brand
- 14:37marketing, how do you even come up with Roi or anything?
- 14:39But I can tell you anecdotally. It's been impactful.
- 14:42I mean it's funny Logan that like why VCS and journalists are
- 14:45at each other's throat. A lot on Twitter when there's
- 14:48actually very similar impulses and downstream effects to being
- 14:52obnoxious on Twitter, that maybe that's the reason why they don't
- 14:55get along. Because in the same way that
- 14:56capital is a commodity facts are ultimately a Aditi.
- 15:00Right? We're just trying to gather
- 15:01facts from people inside companies and when it comes down
- 15:03to it through the internet, it's all compressed through the same
- 15:06pipes. And so a big story that comes
- 15:08out through insider versus the information versus even the
- 15:12Washington Post. I think the New York Times is
- 15:14maybe the one that's slightly different, but by and large, you
- 15:16know, when you push these things through the same place, it's all
- 15:19the same. And so you kind of got to figure
- 15:21how can I get these people that have the information to want, to
- 15:23talk to me, and the outlet, or this tactic that certain
- 15:27journalists take, which is to be a personality.
- 15:29He on Twitter, which I had. By the way, don't necessarily
- 15:31agree with, but this is not an episode about journalists that
- 15:34was a long subtweet of Ryan Mac by the way, but and you are.
- 15:39But anyway, I don't tweet that much and I should, sometimes I
- 15:42should pay somebody. My question is, I mean, do you
- 15:44know, I like to offer my services to journalists, by the
- 15:46way, I can be your Ghostwriter number.
- 15:48Your tweets should be good at tweeting but he doesn't have the
- 15:51followers to back it up. Or you don't know why I need to
- 15:54go through other outlets? So journalists come to me.
- 15:56I will go straight your tweets. I will complain about the New
- 15:59York Times. Stealing your stories.
- 16:00I can write those tweets. I can write sweet about 0 as we
- 16:04previously reported, and then linking to a story that you
- 16:07didn't write. I can do those.
- 16:08Yeah, anyway, I'm sure there's a Chinese menu of snarky
- 16:11journalist tweets dying. Just go to the soundboard and
- 16:14play the hits of all these things.
- 16:15Easy, what's the like pricing on?
- 16:18Like the I feel like the thing that's hardest to believe on the
- 16:21Insiders Dory is just like how much, you know, two hundred
- 16:23thousand last year at go straight in I mean I all the
- 16:27time, can we just get to the story?
- 16:28Then you want to just read it? We are talking about this area,
- 16:30what you want to read this, okay?
- 16:32I was going to read some paragraphs read, Summit, read
- 16:34some of it. Okay?
- 16:35So this is just the top here. Ghost writing tweets or venture
- 16:38capitalist? Is my side hustle.
- 16:40It's like the opening for Goodfellas.
- 16:41I like that last year. I made two hundred thousand, so
- 16:43there's your number are if some VCS will pay you per tweet, I've
- 16:46done a hundred thousand threads to announce a big funding round.
- 16:49I've also done a hundred dollar tweets, other VCS pay you per
- 16:52month for 5,000 to 10,000. All right, ten original tweets,
- 16:55a month and the rate goes up quickly from there.
- 16:58So like this is right now the financial Or to buy these
- 17:00numbers. Logan did they sound right to
- 17:01you from what you've seen in the community.
- 17:03So we're usually they use a hundred thousand dollars for a
- 17:06funding round announcement. That's what it sounds like a
- 17:09thread. Yeah, I don't know.
- 17:11I like hard for me to say it's one of these things like with
- 17:13brand Marketing in general, how do you attribute, what anything
- 17:16is worth? And so, is it possible that
- 17:19people would be willing to pay for something like this?
- 17:21Yeah. Totally.
- 17:22I guess it's totally possible where it sort of broke down for
- 17:25me is the way this person talks about it.
- 17:27It makes it seem like it's this very liquid.
- 17:29Good Market of like, you know, that there's some up work like
- 17:32site in which people are bidding jobs and, you know, okay, I'll
- 17:36do this versus that and like this is my card rate for that
- 17:40kind of thing versus not. And I would think 125 250
- 17:44clients across all of these different jobs.
- 17:47Like I would think I would have some idea that this is like
- 17:50going on or who this person you know that like people are doing
- 17:53this in Mass. It wouldn't surprise me.
- 17:56Hey, if an associate at a venture firm we're like, right?
- 17:59Some tweets, right? Like that's definitely
- 18:01happening. It wouldn't surprise me if there
- 18:03was like some comedian or some journalists who was like built a
- 18:07relationship. Hey, Eric and I have a
- 18:09relationship and so Eric's writing and occasional like
- 18:12thought piece for me on Twitter fright.
- 18:14But like this liquid Market of all these different jobs that
- 18:17are going on to the point that like the person's able to
- 18:19consistently Bill five hours a week and two hundred thousand
- 18:23dollars a year. That's where we're my bullshit
- 18:25meter on. This was like that just doesn't
- 18:27feel right to me, right? Or I'm totally obviated from
- 18:31this going on, which it would seem like something that I would
- 18:33be aware of, right? If it would seem if there's any
- 18:36person that I think I would be on a short list of people, that
- 18:38should know this is going on and I didn't know this was going on.
- 18:41Everywhere is like podcasting you must get in your DMs all the
- 18:44time. Like people are like I can build
- 18:46your podcast like the distribution or there are all
- 18:49these Hustlers around content products that promise they can
- 18:54do great stuff for you. But yeah this is what we don't
- 18:56hear a chat about you. Do here like meme accounts often
- 18:59I think Talk about how people DM them, like draft, tweet ideas
- 19:03for them to send out, right? I mean there's a level, like you
- 19:05get people who just like pitch, you like Logan style tweets, not
- 19:09random people, but buddies buddies, do all the time.
- 19:12Probably have three friends. One in particular who will be
- 19:16like, send me an idea and be like, hey, this is funny.
- 19:19I can't say this, but is there something we can do about this
- 19:23yzn? Would you pay me a hundred
- 19:24thousand for it or yeah. What is there, what he said?
- 19:29It to me, and he's like, what's all this in?
- 19:31Kind friendship bullshit, that I've been getting from you of
- 19:34like us brainstorming ideas. You know, why aren't I getting
- 19:37hundreds of thousands of dollars from you out of it?
- 19:39So, I do feel bad, sometimes my friends will say something
- 19:42clever and a text threatened. It's like, oh yeah, that's a
- 19:44good idea. Like then he tweeted out you're
- 19:47like oh, what a genius, you are. I don't know.
- 19:49I'm probably sort of higher on the level of like, want my
- 19:53authentic ideas of my Twitter, then some, I don't know if they
- 19:56send me want to keep going through like the things that
- 19:59This article said, but I do think it's an interesting thing
- 20:03of like the desire for authenticity that exists here.
- 20:07It would feel for some reason like a bait and switch, right?
- 20:10It's the Twitter Persona of the VCU were following wasn't
- 20:13actually written by the person right there, right?
- 20:16That would. But like we don't hold Trevor
- 20:19Noah to the same. You know.
- 20:21Like if you're like me started, do like people delude themselves
- 20:24on, they think of actors, is having said, the line, you know,
- 20:27like as actors it being there. R quote even though like
- 20:30somebody else wrote it? Yeah, sure.
- 20:32Or like a speechwriter. No one's like oh like Obama
- 20:35wrote. This great speech.
- 20:36Everyone like is a comfortable with the fact that Jon Favreau
- 20:39probably wrote like all of the words and Obama just read it but
- 20:42for some reason this would feel very inauthentic and I'm not
- 20:45totally sure what that is and why I would feel that way about
- 20:49it. Like, why some things we accept
- 20:51like, okay, there's going to be a full team, working and
- 20:53writing, and all that versus other things were kind of like
- 20:56it. Maybe it's because it's an
- 20:57ancillary part of the job rather than a Part of the job.
- 21:00And so we kind of just feels dirtier that way.
- 21:03If you're just like grifting on your side part of your job, I
- 21:06don't know. That feels like a little
- 21:08weirder, but well, I think it also depends on how much of a
- 21:10specifically identifiable character.
- 21:12You have built as your Twitter presence that people would pay
- 21:16attention, whether it feels authentic or not, right?
- 21:18Because Trump, we know, while he was on Twitter and I don't have
- 21:21any idea with truth social, it was always like, oh, he didn't
- 21:23write this one. Various people like in his orbit
- 21:26that would write things for him. Whereas, you know, at this point
- 21:28is like, who that isn't feel like a Keith for boy.
- 21:30I don't know. Didn't have like the, you know,
- 21:32the particular bitchiness that he's so good at but that's like
- 21:35weird. Trump would have the ones that
- 21:36are obviously, like he's right. And then the ones that were
- 21:39like, didn't look anything like his.
- 21:41But there I mean that almost speaks to, you know, he's style
- 21:44really came through but his fans don't hate.
- 21:46It is the thing, right? I mean like it's different
- 21:48because people, you know, are clearly fixated on him but when
- 21:52there were a couple of tweets that were like clearly not
- 21:54written by him, people would be like that.
- 21:56Well that's just Trump being Trump, you know like if there
- 21:58were a couple of I don't know. Good example, in the VC world
- 22:00would be who are the top 10 right off the Dome, big hitters
- 22:05of VC, Twitter and your mind Logan.
- 22:08Let's go right now. Well, I think Andreessen right
- 22:12there now he's just changes the status now but whenever he comes
- 22:15back you know, I don't know. I mean there was like a four
- 22:18week period where it felt like every week there was some new
- 22:22topic about it was all related to his tweeting.
- 22:24So I would be hard-pressed to not read him high on the list.
- 22:27Absolutely. I mean Keith obviously We've
- 22:29referenced he has and that is one of the main ones out there.
- 22:34His brand is just saying, no, yeah, violation.
- 22:39He gets into fights with random people.
- 22:41Probably most of them are bought saying, I know more about this
- 22:44topic than you'll know about anything your whole life or
- 22:46whatever. Yeah, yeah, I love it.
- 22:48I love it. Yeah, he's excellent.
- 22:49Honestly, I've talked to him about that.
- 22:51We did interview on the podcast with him and one of the things
- 22:53he said was like a lot of the stuff he learned, it was like PR
- 22:57stuff. He employed at Square.
- 23:00Of Psych. Hey, and this is just a
- 23:02statement about the social apps as well as Humanity probably use
- 23:06like engaging in good. Faith discussion is just such a
- 23:09losing battle. I'm saying wrong saying, wrong
- 23:12or late? You're a moron right?
- 23:14Is like, how does someone come back from that, right?
- 23:17So he's like, I just kind of learned, that's the better way
- 23:20of approaching these, which is just like a such a thing in of
- 23:23America and realpolitik. Yeah, Because we all kind of
- 23:30know where morons and so when you call them out is that
- 23:32because we often haven't spent the time to fully understand
- 23:35what we're writing that when someone's like no you're just
- 23:37wrong. You're like, oh shit, I probably
- 23:39am. So it's a smart move on his part
- 23:41and then you want to come back though because your job is
- 23:44rooted, in fact, right? In like actually having
- 23:47substance to back things up and then you're coming back with
- 23:49like no Keith. Here's the three rings and
- 23:52you're wrong and at that point you've already lost, you know
- 23:54and he like does it poop emoji and you know whatever right now
- 23:57you're done right, we've moved on.
- 23:59Yeah it does. Matter.
- 24:00Okay, so we got Keith, we got and reason.
- 24:02Gosh, who else does a really good job?
- 24:04I mean, I feel like Jai you know, it's a different style,
- 24:06Josh Wolf, I think is always actually posting interesting
- 24:09kind of substantive stuff. Yeah out there and I have a lot
- 24:12of respect for Josh. I mean I love my occasional
- 24:14podcast co-host is Zach Weinberg who has battled Keith quite a
- 24:18bit but he's always an entertaining personality
- 24:21tweeting. I mean Steve it's axes.
- 24:23Bigger house acts duh though. It's mostly like let's let
- 24:26Russia and behold the whole world sort of hold Thing.
- 24:29Yeah, in calacanis probably, you know, I don't know if you call
- 24:32him a VC or whatever you call them, the calacanis, it's
- 24:35always, you know, like him. So sure.
- 24:37He give you see that's a compliment.
- 24:39I mean, Paul G blocked me for a long time, but when he tweets,
- 24:42it's still. Is you Tweeting his hologram?
- 24:46Yeah. And Balaji 2008.
- 24:47I mean, navall is sort of falling off, right?
- 24:50Or like, I don't see this. Yeah sweetie.
- 24:52Yeah. I mean he's like tweeting like
- 24:54cones of now like he's like the Buddha or something.
- 24:58I haven't seen him to eat as much.
- 24:59I Just always try to reply to the Vol when he would say
- 25:01something and he came up to me at a party one time and we had
- 25:05never met before. And now we just like reply with,
- 25:07you know, he would say the most important thing in life is the
- 25:11decision of where you live. And I said, like, no Vols wife
- 25:14reading this like, you know, shaking my head or something,
- 25:16right? And he came up to me one time at
- 25:18a party, and he has so many followers, and get so many
- 25:20replies, right? And so, I just thought I was,
- 25:22like, some random ass and just like, making myself, laugh.
- 25:25And he came up to me and he was like, you motherfucker, he's
- 25:28like, I've wanted to block you So many times, I got the thought
- 25:31of blocking you so many times and then every third time you'll
- 25:34really make me laugh. And so I like convince myself
- 25:37that I should and I was like, oh thanks snowball.
- 25:39I appreciate that. Now that he was prolific, I
- 25:42think the thing is it Ebbs and flows, right?
- 25:45Like Twitter in general is a medium just kind of Ebbs and
- 25:47flows and that's one of the things I found is like in
- 25:50tweeting. I've sort of you're not as hot
- 25:52as you were. Yeah, I'm now sort of focus on
- 25:54the podcasting thing because you sort of figure out a form factor
- 25:58that works and then your Come because of that form factor or
- 26:02style, right? And there's really only two ways
- 26:04to grow in a meaningful way. On Twitter, it's like jokes and
- 26:07shit posts or like threads. Those are some really only two
- 26:10more Scoops, but sir, we are your way.
- 26:12Yeah, it's a lot of it does. I mean, that's all I have.
- 26:17I mean, I have more newsletter subscribers and Twitter
- 26:20followers, which speaks to which medium, yeah, more successful
- 26:23on. Yeah.
- 26:24But the thing is, once you get to a certain level, it's kind of
- 26:27like you start to box yourself in In to that's what people want
- 26:30from you, right? And I always think of the
- 26:32Wedding Crasher scene where it's like make me a bicycle clown and
- 26:35it's like whenever I would deviate from something they'd be
- 26:37like, you know to give me the bicycle like side doing the
- 26:40subduing, the insights pain, right?
- 26:43Funny man. That's not why I came here,
- 26:45right? So, I do think Twitter, like,
- 26:47people add them flow with their, like interests and do Ian and
- 26:51Founders fund. He used to fight so much if you
- 26:53like his Twitter is mellowed out.
- 26:55I think people just get busy and distracted with other stuff like
- 26:57delians running a company and you.
- 26:59Whatever, but I mean CM lesson does his screenshot, sorry.
- 27:02I'm still going through my list of who's the real a lot of men,
- 27:06obviously, but on the article thing though, it's an
- 27:09interesting confirmation bias of, I think, people just want to
- 27:12believe this to be true. And again, the story itself is
- 27:16interesting enough. One of the quotes in, there was
- 27:18most VCS, who are playing the content game, employ a bunch of
- 27:21writers. I know people who make almost
- 27:23seven figures doing this. And again, I think I would know
- 27:27if that were the case. Like I think if were people
- 27:29making seven figures writing and not to say it's not happening.
- 27:33I don't want to again, this is an Insider saying.
- 27:35This is whoever the person is that saying it, I just find it
- 27:38really hard to believe but I don't know.
- 27:39I mean there's a lot of capital in the ecosystem, right?
- 27:42Well I love the idea of the Griff that a writer would have
- 27:44here in claim. You know, we got a whole writers
- 27:47room of people Keith. We're going to pump up some
- 27:49treats for you and then they come back to them like a day
- 27:51later with this a narrative violation, just throw that bomb
- 27:55into the mix and see what happens.
- 27:56But it's sad thing. Obviously is it's not even like
- 27:58the big It's probably like the more boring accounts that want
- 28:02like that's the thing. If you're willing to pay someone
- 28:04because you think oh you pay people for the best information
- 28:08than the type of person who has terrible taste.
- 28:10And, you know, is going to like be happy with like, really Bland
- 28:13tweets. Well, that's how it gets.
- 28:15I think to the point we're saying about authenticity here
- 28:17because I think the people that are pure posters that you know
- 28:19the ones that you know, Logan was mentioning here are the ones
- 28:23who it is their core being it is the way they view the world that
- 28:25their brain functions in, you know, tweets that get
- 28:28engagement. Aunt.
- 28:29And it's why I'm assuming that this person that was interviewed
- 28:32here for the article is probably doing second or third-tier
- 28:35things which kind of defeats the whole purpose of it.
- 28:37Because if we can't you know, if we're going to guess that it's
- 28:39not famous people. Then what are they really
- 28:41gaining from it right? Like what do they actually know
- 28:44what deal flow all the stuff about being a public personas?
- 28:46They can get more, you know, to benefit their Core Business.
- 28:49It's not even really there which is why it's kind of just like,
- 28:52you know, like the Overflow of money in the space and people
- 28:56just being absurdly wealthy, just trickles down to it, you
- 28:58know, a writer here or there. About Sequoia.
- 29:00I mean, rule of has 92 thousand Twitter followers, hard to
- 29:04believe. It's Sequoia, retweeted me
- 29:06there. Sequoia corporate account.
- 29:08Retweeted me one time. They have 631 thousand
- 29:11followers. Nothing happened.
- 29:14It was like a mini injury sanur by far.
- 29:16I think corporate accounts are hard just in general.
- 29:18Like, people follow those like passively right rather than but
- 29:22them in Andresen had by far, the biggest follower count and I
- 29:26assume people are just following it for General information about
- 29:32deals and stuff like that. Not for like actual engagement,
- 29:35right? People don't engage with a
- 29:37corporate. That's why you see like
- 29:39occasionally when Wendy's goes off the, you know, whatever and
- 29:42like some of these Brands start flapping back it is super
- 29:44entertaining but people don't follow corporate accounts for
- 29:47the actual information. I think one of the things that's
- 29:49interesting though is that dichotomy that would exist from
- 29:52like building this Persona online in such a way that is
- 29:56incongruous with your own. Personality or style, right?
- 30:00And I felt that a little bit where I was playing this cold
- 30:04bearish VC voice, and then people would beat me and they
- 30:10would be like, I think some people would expect me to be in
- 30:14character. Right.
- 30:15You know, whatever or like, be funnier than I was in person or
- 30:19something, right? I don't know if you guys have
- 30:21ever been around comedians but like some of the funniest people
- 30:23I've ever met in my life, like you meet them and they're not
- 30:26actually like funny on a day-to-day.
- 30:27Like some are good, some are Insufferable where they're
- 30:30always like trying to make jokes.
- 30:32It can go either way. I know.
- 30:33But I even have like some of the people I interact with that are
- 30:35like the funniest people. I know are like, have a very
- 30:38dark, they're like, very quiet. And they have like, very like
- 30:41dark witty, quips that are going on in their head and then they
- 30:44like, say it very subtly, but it doesn't come across right like
- 30:47in the same way. And I think that's interesting
- 30:49of if you're building this public Persona around something,
- 30:51that is an authentic to who you are, and then people meet you,
- 30:55right? And it's like, wait, hang on,
- 30:57that's not what I thought. I was getting right and so
- 31:01that's an interesting thing as well.
- 31:03It's like to what end eventually you have to meet these people in
- 31:05person are diamonds just like, hey, I took your money.
- 31:08You need to get your jokes per minute up when we're hanging
- 31:11out. Yeah, exactly.
- 31:12He's, like, this isn't, you know, this isn't what I signed
- 31:15up for Matt. You're like, over here, trying
- 31:17to talk to me about, like, hack payback and efficiency metrics
- 31:20is like, but I need some memes out of you.
- 31:22Yeah, I thought that board meeting was to be way more
- 31:25fucking like pithy than just asking me about.
- 31:28Let's write your own goals. Can we get to the part of the
- 31:30story that I found interesting? Because you know it no.
- 31:32Okay, yeah, no go. Yeah yeah I know.
- 31:34I'm just kidding. Okay, here's this part.
- 31:36Everyone involved in Tech at a global scale has a political
- 31:39project. Most of them are open border
- 31:41guys, they want to be the immigration reform drum because
- 31:45they need to hire Engineers. A lot of my clients are
- 31:48interested in Tech policy and National Security.
- 31:51China, deterrence missile defense, the government
- 31:53procurement process. I can help them sound like their
- 31:55knowledgeable and In The Weeds on this stuff, man, I hope he's
- 31:58not charging a ton for. Sometimes tweets about policy
- 32:01arguments can get pretty close to what you'd call an op-ed.
- 32:04So this is weird to me this part of it because it's trying to
- 32:08graft a political low like a business rationale on to
- 32:13political tweets and I just don't agree that that's the
- 32:16case. I honestly think all these guys,
- 32:18you know, the all in people any of the other people, have you
- 32:20mentioned so far that are tweeting about politics and, you
- 32:22know, all the fucking day long, think they do it?
- 32:25Because they really think their political opinions are
- 32:27interesting and they want to get it out there.
- 32:29Right, it's not even good for business or they just can't help
- 32:31themselves. Like yeah, honestly, what
- 32:34prolific interesting person. This figure whoever this is must
- 32:38be that they're like five hours a week, right?
- 32:42Five hours a week for 200 Grand a year.
- 32:44They're waiting in 25 to 50 VC's in boxes that come up with
- 32:49tweets. They have their own burner phone
- 32:51to do this, which is just hilarious.
- 32:52That like that was a part of the article.
- 32:54It's like I have my own CRM. My own burner phone a thick what
- 32:57in the world, why do you need your own?
- 32:59Like the chat apps work pretty well across different platforms
- 33:01like an Excel sheet where I don't think you need a personal
- 33:04CRM for this, but it feels like they just this person must be
- 33:08amazingly intelligent to be able to just talk in someone else's
- 33:12voice. Let alone, one person, but 25 to
- 33:1550 people and then come up with funny jokes, as well as, like
- 33:19immigration policy threads, and be able to craft all that back
- 33:23to like the voice that this individual wants to have all
- 33:26while being a founder of another company that Are spending, you
- 33:30know the vast majority of their time doing.
- 33:32I don't know. It felt like to me there was
- 33:34like cobbled together a bunch of interesting truths here
- 33:38probably, and they decided to just like, you know, maybe this
- 33:43is five different people that they turned it into the
- 33:45amalgamation of one or something.
- 33:47It just feels like they try to jam too many things into one.
- 33:51Like, here's what I'm doing, right?
- 33:53And make too many different points.
- 33:54When any of these points could have been interesting on their
- 33:56own. It does feel like this needed to
- 33:58be a real person. Like a named person, I don't
- 34:02know. I find it a little hard to
- 34:04believe. They have a process here at
- 34:06Insider where they do try to verify these things and I'm sure
- 34:09went through that process. I think what they're trying to
- 34:11get at why the story was popular, is that it does seem to
- 34:13be that there are like, we talked about, ulterior motives
- 34:16to being a Twitter personality to presence.
- 34:18And whether you can do it yourself, ready to hire someone
- 34:20to do it. I do think there's a sense, the
- 34:23Twitter's, like, dying or like, I don't know, do you feel like
- 34:26Twitter is like decaying? I think that keeps coming up in
- 34:28the Our station right heel on buying it.
- 34:30The like it's not just the markets gotten worse, but it
- 34:33feels like Twitter, the experience or is that too?
- 34:37Or just always heard of Bleak on there.
- 34:39I don't know. I mean honestly it feels like it
- 34:43feels like people that have increased new levels of fame or
- 34:47new levels of notoriety or celebrity then look around at
- 34:51their like Twitter presence and they're like, what is good?
- 34:55Like all these people are attacking me and it's like,
- 34:57well, you are Weighing in on global events across the world
- 35:01and you do have millions of followers and so like your
- 35:04experience may be has changed because of how your profile has
- 35:08been raised and how your profile has gone up.
- 35:10Not anything inherent de like Twitter, the app and so to some
- 35:14extent Twitter gets all this criticism of the experience.
- 35:18Right? From people, whose experience
- 35:20has noticeably changed because they're far richer and far more
- 35:24famous and weighing in on issues that they didn't in the past.
- 35:28And so, If that's what's always funny to me.
- 35:30When he lands like, oh, how many people their replies are all
- 35:34Bots when they post something, right?
- 35:36And he's like, everyone only gets bot replies in crypto spam.
- 35:39And I'm like, dude, like you're the most followed person on a
- 35:42platform, right? Yeah.
- 35:44It's not represent experience is different than my experience on
- 35:47the platform and so I don't know if Twitter is actually dying.
- 35:51I mean I do think that all these new form factors that are coming
- 35:53out are interesting and like should be explored and be that
- 35:56you know whatever Tick-Tock or reels or YouTube I mean you're
- 35:58paying someone and Been wanting to say this and you're paying
- 36:01red point. Is someone to create tick-tocks,
- 36:04right? I mean, can you talk about that?
- 36:05Yeah, well, that's, you know, whatever that's not his entirety
- 36:08of his job. But yeah, we shot a Seer, we
- 36:10hired from he was at looker. That's all I see, you know?
- 36:13Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 36:14He comes on him. He's a producer, I see him on my
- 36:17tic tocs, you know, he's a producer for my podcast as well.
- 36:20And then he does a bunch of internal stuff with other than
- 36:22sand in content with our portfolio companies at a bunch
- 36:25of different things. But yes, that is some one I
- 36:28guess to be very clear that we Was what Drew us to hiring him?
- 36:31Was that he was creative and good at content.
- 36:34And I guess this is an interesting thing that kind of
- 36:35dovetails back to the overall thing.
- 36:37We're talking about is I found when we were trying to produce
- 36:40content or get our name out there more and more inevitably,
- 36:44it always falls to the bottom of investors priorities to do this
- 36:48stuff. Like, it's always, hey, you have
- 36:50a list of 15 things and this is the 16th and you never get to
- 36:54it, right? It's like unless you're willing
- 36:56to bump it up to the 4th or 3rd or whatever thing.
- 36:59Never going to get to it versus talking to the next founder,
- 37:02whatever. And so in talking to one of the
- 37:05thought process and bringing over shy because hey, he's
- 37:08funny, interesting creative and he's going to be a kind of a
- 37:10Swiss Army knives that can do a bunch of different stuff for us.
- 37:13But then to having someone that wakes up everyday kind of
- 37:15thinking about content in some way shape or form, he's
- 37:18launching a podcast here in the next couple weeks or like a
- 37:20YouTube series thing. And just having someone that
- 37:23like his thinking, about that every day, but all that's to
- 37:26say, like, the more important thing was in trying to Get my
- 37:29co-workers to produce content. It was never a priority.
- 37:33It's a priority at a strategic meeting and we're like, oh, this
- 37:35should be a priority. And so, we talked about it,
- 37:37right? And then like one person or two
- 37:39people goes and executes on it when everyone else is like, oh I
- 37:42forgot about that priority, right?
- 37:44And so that was one of the things for it, which I think
- 37:46ties back to why you would pay someone else that would make it
- 37:49a priority for them, right? Yeah.
- 37:51Has there ever been significant blowback?
- 37:52Do you think they're VCS who have lost out on deals because
- 37:55they were so committed to tweeting about their Fierce
- 37:58commitment to Borders that you know, there was some like
- 38:01potential startup Founders that were like a fucked.
- 38:03This guy. I don't want this guy on my
- 38:05board because he's going to you know, it's a funny story.
- 38:07I mean this is like related to your question less heft than
- 38:10open borders, but we had a joke, Rashad made this video about VC,
- 38:14six months ago versus VC's now. And the joke was how fickle VCS
- 38:18are in their advice. That was the joke, but one of
- 38:21the comments of six months ago were like, hey, you need to hire
- 38:24as many people as you can, and let's blitzscale our marketing
- 38:27department and then it like cuts To VCS now.
- 38:30And it's like, do you really need a marketing department,
- 38:33right? And the joke wasn't like, about
- 38:36the role of marketing. The joke was like, how fickle
- 38:39BCS were in their advice. But I'll tell you, there's a lot
- 38:44of humorless people on the internet and one CEO.
- 38:47In particular, got very fired up about that and was like, I would
- 38:51never work with a DC that is so, flippant about the roles of
- 38:56layoffs and all that. And Then it got set around
- 39:00internally and then you know whatever it got the original
- 39:04your enemies within red Point. Used it to knife you like
- 39:07however yeah exactly. So I this is my I announced my
- 39:10departure from Red Boy you know. But the original tweet got like
- 39:12two thousand likes and then this one person got 60 or whatever
- 39:16trying to clap back at us. But you know what like 60 likes
- 39:20and 15 replies saying. I'm never going to work with
- 39:23this firm again or I'll never have them on my list.
- 39:26It does feel like a big Deal in the grand scheme of things.
- 39:30And so to some extent, like, I actually respect Founders Fund
- 39:32in a meaningful Way for their ability to say, hey, we're not
- 39:35going to appeal to everyone, and we're going to tell a lot of
- 39:37people to fuck off, but we're going to try to feel deeply to
- 39:40some subset of this. And so we've had that experience
- 39:42here in the last couple months, and it had to be a conversation
- 39:44internally about like, hey, our jokes worth people, disliking
- 39:49us. Because that sort of, even if
- 39:51you have a 90% approval rating and you reach 100,000 people,
- 39:55that means 10,000. People are going to dislike you,
- 39:57right? And back him seem like, Lot when
- 39:59they're yelling at you online. Well, this is C.
- 40:01This is where it gets to be Crossover with journalists again
- 40:04because I think it's the same calculation journalists have of
- 40:06like. All right I can make this joke
- 40:08or I can make fun of Facebook in this particular way and it could
- 40:11piss off some number of people. I'm I willing to accept that in
- 40:15order to get the other people that might be more inclined to
- 40:17follow me or like me relief things to me like let me see
- 40:20what that trade-off is. So it's all flattened through.
- 40:22The same medium people are so much meaner journalists have
- 40:26such thicker skin than BCS do like you guys get roasted like
- 40:30all the time with people angry at you for doing your job,
- 40:33right? Like you doing your job,
- 40:35involves people getting mad at you more often than not like
- 40:38breaking a scoop you know, Eric broke some Scoops today and I
- 40:41was like fuck man. Come like come on, really like
- 40:45did you really have to do that, right?
- 40:46About one of our portfolio companies and so you're doing
- 40:49your job is like, actually annoying people at times.
- 40:52And people can be very vitriolic to reporters about stuff, right?
- 40:56And all the fake news and, you know, whatever all the
- 40:58animosity. I don't feel too bad for
- 41:00reporters. First of all, we're out there.
- 41:02Like I was going to say. Also, you have to keep in mind
- 41:04that we make a lot of money, you know, that's the thing that's so
- 41:07wealthy. And so it's like you're willing
- 41:09to accept some of the slings and arrows in order to get that 78
- 41:12figure. Well, yeah, and you all have
- 41:14verified check marks on Twitter and you get to, you know,
- 41:18whatever, all those like Met Ball Galas and stuff.
- 41:20I do the most invigorating is definitely for all the VCS to be
- 41:24like the real Elites are the reporters, you know?
- 41:27It's like not the people who make a bazillion In dollars.
- 41:29It's the fucking reporters. Who are the real Elites?
- 41:33It is a funny though. I mean baked not to say I feel
- 41:35badly for reporters. It's more of contrast of like
- 41:39how sensitive VCS can be about stuff isn't right.
- 41:42And at the end of the day we get paid very well to do a pretty
- 41:47fun job. I do think it's a very San
- 41:49Francisco thing or I mean like Wall Street Finance.
- 41:53I mean, I feel like people while do complain about getting
- 41:56attacked. I don't think there is like
- 41:58surprise. I do think part of it is that VC
- 42:01works so well in that you can always add somebody else to
- 42:05around. So there's just such an
- 42:07incentive in that business to be nice to everybody in a way that
- 42:11feels great. Like I, yeah, it's nice to be in
- 42:13a business where people can be nice and then it makes people
- 42:17shocked when people aren't and they're like why it works?
- 42:19So well when you're I wonder how much I mean 21 like a lot of
- 42:22people in Tech at large, right? We're probably more introverted
- 42:27and not like, you know, Didn't have the popularity, Sports
- 42:32thing through high school and college and all of that stuff,
- 42:36right? And so there's some like, hey
- 42:38now I've made it. And so when people now I'm cool,
- 42:41right? And by my childhood, people were
- 42:44mean, and there were these Meathead bullies, but now I'm
- 42:47not that, and so when there's criticism coming it's like wait,
- 42:51hang on, I'm past that point, right?
- 42:53Like this is bringing back memories of my middle school and
- 42:56I don't like that, right? And so I think part of it is Is
- 42:59made, but it's a trauma to this box.
- 43:01Yeah. Yeah.
- 43:02It's like hang on, hang on. Like and you do not put me in
- 43:05that Locker again, I told Tommy Greene if he ever did that and
- 43:09then the other one I think that's interesting is like there
- 43:12is this inherent optimism and now I mean it's kind of
- 43:15counterbalance with some level of like broad-based mule ISM
- 43:18that I think also exist. But the like the tenant of BC
- 43:22and technology is like optimism ever believing in the future and
- 43:27all that. And so when people start poking
- 43:30and prodding that, I think there's an inherent
- 43:32defensiveness that comes out and also it's a lot easier to sound
- 43:37a cynic than it is to sound an octopus.
- 43:39Right? And so I think people just over
- 43:41correct on those things and it comes off in a vitriolic, kind
- 43:45of way. Did you ever concluding thought
- 43:47on this Tom? And then I did want to talk
- 43:49about the market for 10 minutes? No, I think we should all, you
- 43:53know, keep fighting on Twitter. I think it's clearly doing good
- 43:56for all of our personal Brands I want to Rate my offer to
- 44:00journalists, I don't have a lot of followers but that's because,
- 44:03you know, I'm very concerned about my personal brand, but I
- 44:06can build up other people's and I would like to just put my
- 44:09skills out there to someone. If you are a journalist, you
- 44:11don't think you're getting the gauge me.
- 44:12Think you should get, you want to get into fights with people.
- 44:15I can offer those tweets reach out to me.
- 44:17My dams are open, Tom has the weirdest.
- 44:19I'm gonna link to some of the Tom tweets that are like jokes
- 44:22on, like streaming platform, wants to be the New Yorker, you
- 44:25know, you don't need to appeal, broadly to everyone, Tom.
- 44:29You have a very sophisticated palate that, like, keep us what
- 44:31I like, you know, it's a small but extremely high influence
- 44:36audience of people? I think that's right.
- 44:38Either I think make the time not to psychoanalyze you but to do
- 44:41it but I really do. You make you make joke that
- 44:44there were a lot like I like them because they rely on
- 44:47knowing like your voice and so if you know your voice and your
- 44:51sensibility, it's like rorty, like no lever.
- 44:54But like nobody your buddy, laughs.
- 44:58Maybe less It's like, do you know what my hope is that it
- 45:01Burrows into your brain and then like a couple of hours later
- 45:04you're like oh yeah, I guess that was kind of funny and then
- 45:07and then you move on with your day.
- 45:08I keep making content for the unwashed masses but Tom that the
- 45:13real caviar Taste of humor, right?
- 45:15He's not only sell out like you back to the broadcast Cable
- 45:18model. I mean, you're kind of you're
- 45:19out there doing CBS sitcoms, you know?
- 45:21That's right. That's right.
- 45:23Popularity. Our podcast has a dead cat.
- 45:25Like, definitely. There we got a couple people
- 45:27were like a dead cat like Like, how dare you invoke that image?
- 45:31Like, it's terrible for SEO. But yeah, yeah.
- 45:35But it weeds out the people who are concerned about that.
- 45:37All right, let's go through our serious PC.
- 45:38So naturally we're going to spend 90% of time talking about
- 45:42Twitter and 10%. But like, I mean I have course I
- 45:46actually don't remember which of these companies you'd invested
- 45:48in earlier but you know I just wrote about like a hundred
- 45:50million dollar series 175 million series a of 500 million
- 45:56series C, all happening recently.
- 45:57And just as Idea that like yep I don't know.
- 46:01Series a bcc'd. People are willing to go
- 46:04aggressive. The growth stage funds are like
- 46:06diving in whereas growth is still super hard.
- 46:10You're more of a growth investor I mean yeah I don't know where
- 46:14we grow that desus or like yeah, you've been tempted to go early.
- 46:18Oh yeah, funny enough, I guess. Timing-wise were reporting this
- 46:22on what a Friday. And last night I got together
- 46:25with a bunch of our limited partners and so I had to pull
- 46:27together a bunch of Data and, you know, kind of collect my
- 46:32thoughts. Unstuff, right.
- 46:34Just sound intelligent and I don't know if that worked but I
- 46:38did collect thoughts and it's interesting, right?
- 46:41I will say that what we've seen at the series B series C, stage
- 46:48is like, definitely a pullback in terms of valuations.
- 46:51So this was kind of a proprietary analysis that we had
- 46:54internally, and I'm going to give you the broad Strokes of
- 46:56it, but the deals that we care about Eight, which is a very at
- 47:00the moment in time and a very qualitative assessment, but
- 47:03we've been doing it for six years or whatever, right.
- 47:06And we saw a step up between 2020 and 2021 of it went from
- 47:13like do the math on it. I guess it went from 255 million
- 47:16to just under 600 million for series bees for the average
- 47:20price of deals, you care about correct the median.
- 47:23But yeah and so it was like a 2X step up in the revenue.
- 47:26Multiple of that went from 32. Times to a hundred and fifty
- 47:30three times. Right?
- 47:32Right. And the room also increased by
- 47:34much more than the valuation. Correct.
- 47:36And so what was happening was at the scale of these companies
- 47:39went from five million down to two million.
- 47:41And so, people were both going earlier in these companies and
- 47:45paying more, right? And so obviously that's how the
- 47:48multiple of those up in such a meaningful way.
- 47:50Now, since in 2022, we've seen it falls at 595 is down to 39 T
- 47:56fish and the multiples. I'm from 153 to 110.
- 48:01So it's fallen off but not at the level before all this was
- 48:05going on, right? If you go back to 2019 or even
- 48:082020, we're talking like 25 to 35 times, right?
- 48:11These like sort of the and you can justify that because these
- 48:14companies are growing to 2/3 x. And so hey like when you compare
- 48:18that to the public market how does that make sense?
- 48:20Well you know the public market companies are growing 60% right
- 48:23versus these companies are going to hundred percent, right?
- 48:25So you could justify at reeling number being fire.
- 48:29As a multiple. So we've seen it correct.
- 48:31But there is this like stickiness in some of these
- 48:35prices and then there's all this dry powder sitting on the
- 48:38sidelines, right? And so I don't know how it's
- 48:41going to flow through and there's these two things that
- 48:44are kind of at odds or tension with one another right now,
- 48:47we're one is valuations have gotten hammered in the public
- 48:50markets, right? To is, we're starting to see the
- 48:52macro, flow-through of, you know, softening and sales cycles
- 48:56and Pipeline and all that in the public markets.
- 48:59Where I have some data that I can talk to on that.
- 49:01So we're starting to see all that stuff happening, right?
- 49:03Then the tension on the other side, is all this fucking money,
- 49:06right? And you have six, eight, ten
- 49:08billion dollar funds sitting there.
- 49:10And so I'm not really sure how those two things are going to
- 49:13play out and how long it's going to take to play out.
- 49:16And so I think to the things that you reported on today Eric
- 49:20what I think is bright, I don't want to speak about any of the
- 49:22portfolio companies that I wish you hadn't preempted funding
- 49:25news on. But in general, I think what
- 49:27we're seeing is Is some of these groups that previously were
- 49:32willing to invest two hundred million dollars at a two billion
- 49:35dollar valuation right now, they're saying, hey you know
- 49:39what, let's go put in 20 million dollars at a 200 million dollar
- 49:43valuation and let's do it in 10 companies, right?
- 49:46And so you're seeing all these people say, Hey, fuck it.
- 49:49We don't really care if it's 150 or 200 or 250, or 300, much
- 49:53better than that 2 billion. We were paying before and so,
- 49:56while it's crazy on a multiple basis, Right, because it might
- 49:59be, you know, Infinity time, they might not have Revenue, at
- 50:03least the low absolute valuation.
- 50:06Gives you upside that if this grows into a two billion dollar
- 50:09company, the big like, question that I've had that is hard to
- 50:12answer. But do you think series a rounds
- 50:14were actually like were mispriced and the just the
- 50:18likelihood of getting from series data series?
- 50:20See was so high that people were giving too much of a discount.
- 50:25Its series a, I mean, John courteous who's leaving tiger I
- 50:29You could almost argue his new fund is on that premise.
- 50:32It's like very like going to be series 8 is series beef, series,
- 50:36C focused. I think like the idea that like
- 50:39preference is actually a really valuable thing and like you
- 50:42don't necessarily lose your money and like an early stage
- 50:45investment. So there's more downside
- 50:47protection than is, I don't know.
- 50:49Do you think there is a chance that series a prices were too
- 50:53low relative to series C and D? If you look at the run up that
- 50:56existed from like, let's go back to 2012, Calls to today rate.
- 51:00Like I think I'm not gonna get this numbers exactly right.
- 51:03But like series bees went up by 4X and series sees what up by
- 51:08six acts and series a is went up by two x, right?
- 51:11And so, like the absolute, the valuation increase of these
- 51:14things were not linear between the two, right?
- 51:17They didn't expand at a comparable rate.
- 51:19Now, why was that the case? Well, series A's?
- 51:22I think, Founders probably had a little bit more price discipline
- 51:25and desire to pick board members and you know, not to price.
- 51:29Mais the myth of a benchmark. Insisting, you keep to price
- 51:34discipline held harder than the late State.
- 51:36Yeah. And I think there's more truth
- 51:38to it at the earlier stage then as you get to the later stages
- 51:41of these valuations. And so you've seen the
- 51:44correction, I think when we were sort of pouring through our
- 51:46data, you know that B's and C's or down in some cases 50, 60, 70
- 51:53percent, right in different situations.
- 51:55And I think it might take a while for all that back.
- 51:59Lee flow through and to see it in a broad-based way versus the
- 52:01series Azor down 20-30 percent, right?
- 52:05And they didn't go up the same way that the B's and C's did so
- 52:08they're not going down the same way.
- 52:10And so, I guess the question is like, was it mispriced may be
- 52:15right? I think it requires a lot more
- 52:17work to invest in a series, a company.
- 52:19It's not nearly the dollars aren't as scalable because, hey,
- 52:23you know, it takes about as much time to do a 30 million dollar
- 52:27check as it does to do five million.
- 52:29Check in a lot of cases and then to you actually need to work
- 52:32with these companies in a way of like, helping them hire, and
- 52:34recruit and all that. I know that well, that's been
- 52:36the real challenge that this series a investors have to keep
- 52:39working. And then tiger comes in and is
- 52:41like, here's a bunch of money, but we're not going to do
- 52:42anything. Good luck.
- 52:43And so it's then still the poor series.
- 52:46A investor that has, like, keep the company together, that's the
- 52:49smartest thing. A lot of these hedge funds are
- 52:51doing now, is they're looking at, like, the companies and
- 52:53saying, not just the validation of, do they have a good
- 52:56investor? That's already there.
- 52:57But also do they have a good? Board member who's going to be a
- 53:00steward for the capital and make sure they don't drive it off the
- 53:03cliff, right? And so, they're kind of looking
- 53:05at it being like, well, you know, that person's legit.
- 53:08And so I'll just trust them, like, they'll be my proxy for
- 53:12all decisions, right? And then they get to be a little
- 53:14price insensitive about is it 100 post or 200 posts, right?
- 53:19Which seems like a really meaningful amount, but if you're
- 53:22a hedge fund, who's crossing over into privates and you're
- 53:25ultimately trying to move three, four billion.
- 53:29There's five billion dollars in the next three or four years
- 53:31like you don't really care. It's either gonna work or it's
- 53:34not last question on this. I think there's one view that
- 53:38like everybody was slow in the first like, what eight months to
- 53:41a year nine months to a year and then they're like, finally
- 53:45really come back from vacation. And like you said there, I have
- 53:47all this dry powder and they're like, fuck it.
- 53:49We need to do deals this. What people pay me for.
- 53:52And so, they're doing them, but it's still sort of irrational
- 53:55because it's going to be more brutal ahead than Hind or this
- 54:00is sort of the beginning of a comeback story in startup
- 54:04investing. I mean, do you have a view
- 54:07either way of whether this is sort of like sort of weird
- 54:10incentives based on people's jobs or if it's the actual
- 54:13reflection that the market is going to start to turn around?
- 54:17Yeah, I mean, I guess I'll take a cop out and say, hey, I think
- 54:20it's some of both. I will say, there are perverse
- 54:22incentives that and I had a high level, I believe in the trends
- 54:26that are going on in blah, blah, blah.
- 54:27Let me give you all my life. LP speak of what they tax.
- 54:31Good on it, right? Yeah.
- 54:32These tectonic shifts that are happening or inevitable and it's
- 54:35going to create lots of equity value and all that right Bubba.
- 54:37Yeah, I think one thing we're seeing is there's definitely
- 54:40Supply. I think it's not a demand
- 54:41problem that exists like I think there's feces still willing to
- 54:45be very irrational in their investing and I think there's a
- 54:47lot of perverse incentives that exist there.
- 54:50Where people are like hey you know, my job's not the time, the
- 54:53markets, right? I'm using air quotes, right?
- 54:55But I like my job is to give Adam Newman like three hundred
- 54:57million dollars. Yeah, my job is not to assess,
- 55:01you know, valuation. My job is to assess, you know,
- 55:04Trends and entrepreneurs, right? And so I'm not going to get too
- 55:08hung up on the price of all this.
- 55:09And so I think there's a lot of people that have that philosophy
- 55:12right now. I think what you're seeing is,
- 55:14there's a supply problem that so many companies, raise so much
- 55:17money over the course of the last two years that the great
- 55:20companies out there like hey, why would I go out there now and
- 55:24get jerked around potentially on valuation, or have to take it
- 55:26down round or whatever? Why would I go out and do that?
- 55:28That when I have capital for the next six years sitting on my
- 55:31balance sheet. And so I think the reason we're
- 55:34seeing I don't know how much VCS have actually found religion on
- 55:38like hey the public markets are impacting the multiples that we
- 55:41should be willing to pay and therefore what these outcomes
- 55:43can be versus they're just not getting in the swings at the
- 55:47plate that they got over the course a lot.
- 55:49And so I think it's going to take a bunch of the businesses
- 55:52that actually need Capital to go back out and start fundraising
- 55:56and they can't just sit on the sidelines to really figure Which
- 55:59one of those two things is going to play out.
- 56:00And to be honest, it's going to be both, right?
- 56:02There's going to be V sees that have found total religion and
- 56:06understand exactly where multiples are trading and going
- 56:08to be very disciplined about this stuff.
- 56:09And there's going to be VC's that say, Hey, you know our jobs
- 56:12to we raised by billion dollars and so we're invest five billion
- 56:16dollars. How many deals have you done
- 56:18personally, this year as a fund, we've done one this entire year.
- 56:23What I've done? Oh my god.
- 56:25Wow. Alright boys.
- 56:25Early stage. Sorry.
- 56:26Sorry, that's the growth team. Red pointer.
- 56:28Least age. I don't know.
- 56:29They've done more. But we've done one this entire
- 56:32year. It was done in January and we've
- 56:34done. That's the only one we've done.
- 56:35Is that an eyesore? Well, 12 months.
- 56:37Yeah. Acuity MD, it was technically a
- 56:39series. It was a big series as your life
- 56:41is just tweeting. Going back to her room.
- 56:42No wonder. You're like Europe.
- 56:44I kind of resent. Well, hey, come on.
- 56:47That's not that's not fair. I podcast and tweet a so, right?
- 56:49Yeah yeah. Do you help me send you Ilan
- 56:52like text like what have you done this week?
- 56:54Yeah, yeah I get that. I get that.
- 56:56Sometimes I know they wish I It more of their money, just
- 57:00unscrew Pious lead to the Twitter round.
- 57:02Just sort of sent money over that.
- 57:03That's true. I got right?
- 57:05Let me in on that baby. Yeah.
- 57:07Only 4 billion or bust? Yeah, so no.
- 57:09But it's interesting, right? I mean it is the last 12 months
- 57:12I think as a fund we're probably at the point that we've only
- 57:15done one. That's the only deal we've done
- 57:16even in the last 12 months, let alone this calendar year right
- 57:19now. We're still looking at a bunch
- 57:20of stuff and we're still chasing things around but it's really
- 57:23that supply problem. And then a little bit of this
- 57:25Market disk location pricing thing that were I don't know,
- 57:28We've been a little more attuned to, or at least a little more
- 57:31focused on than others have. Hmm.
- 57:33Well, we ended and quite a height in place.
- 57:35I feel like in this conversation after the beginning.
- 57:37Yeah, I do think a real, you shitpost.
- 57:39The real you is, is the the one with the financials.
- 57:42I'm sorry to say, well, I mean, and that's why it's so
- 57:45incongruous that I have all these writers writing, all this
- 57:48stuff to me and then and then I like go down this Rabbit Hole of
- 57:51like multiples and Sass and financials and all that.
- 57:53And they're like, what the fuck? Like, can you make a joke,
- 57:57right? Well, but Ability to, you know,
- 57:59have facility with these financials makes the monies that
- 58:02you can employ the writers that keep your Twitter account
- 58:05cracked. Yeah, I know it's a sort of
- 58:06circular flywheel. It's really capitalism and its
- 58:09purest form right there. So right.
- 58:12Yeah. Just trickle it down
- 58:13actualization. Yeah, yeah, it, but it all works
- 58:16together. Well, I'm glad we entered in
- 58:17this place Logan and we should plug your podcast.
- 58:20Yeah. So this is much more in depth
- 58:22into all this stuff. It's nice to be a guest rather
- 58:24than a host. So I appreciate you guys.
- 58:26Yeah, you guys driving this Italy?
- 58:28Is it? You're like I have thoughts to,
- 58:30you know, I have expert. Yeah.
- 58:32Ask other people what they think?
- 58:34Yeah. Yeah.
- 58:35I have two on my podcast. I ask that a non sequiturs that
- 58:38just like double back to my own opinion.
- 58:40It's like much more. You know, we're you guys ask, it
- 58:42doesn't feel like you're projecting here.
- 58:44Logan. Is there something that you want
- 58:45to be talking about? Yeah, a lot of that on the show.
- 58:48Yeah, so I do I've cartoon avatars.
- 58:49You do it once a week and yeah, it the format changes.
- 58:53We have people on, it's not dissimilar.
- 58:54You guys in some ways. You guys brought down, web,
- 58:57three basically, right? I mean, you just Right.
- 58:59You said there was nothing there and yeah correct.
- 59:02Yeah, which is another funny thing because we have people in
- 59:04our team at Red point that invest in weatherbury and people
- 59:07are like, wait, isn't that guy like the - web three guy,
- 59:10doesn't? That doesn't mean work with you,
- 59:12right? See, but this gets back to like
- 59:14the idea between like contents and actual business.
- 59:17You're like, if to understand anti web, three stuff does
- 59:19really well right now. Exactly, exactly play that
- 59:21market gives. That's right.
- 59:24I actually just when people, whatever people say, aren't you.
- 59:26The web three guy just show the spikes and listener.
- 59:28Bishop and ever and I'm like, yes, no, I'm the market guy.
- 59:32That's what I mean. Yeah.
- 59:34Are you guys going to have Sam lesson back on to redeem
- 59:36himself? Is that, you know, I like it,
- 59:40right? Like it was.
- 59:41Yeah. It was hard to listen to, I
- 59:43mean, yeah, I know, I know likes him.
- 59:45I like his tweets but he came off terribly and he also can
- 59:48just be so petty, like, on some of the I listened, he wanted to
- 59:53do it. Exactly like, hey, this is
- 59:54terrible. You know, I really I was
- 59:57embarrassed because, like, I, you know, Sensibly, I'm supposed
- 59:59to be the moderator of that and I I was just sort of sitting
- 1:00:02back like arms crossed laughing the whole time and I kind of
- 1:00:05forgot what my role in doing something like that.
- 1:00:08Was you see? I'm just kept interrupting like
- 1:00:10he, like I mean Zack is very good.
- 1:00:13Is he like a what's his status with the show?
- 1:00:15Is he a co-host? Or is he just sort of a he won't
- 1:00:18be called a co-host. The guy does a million things.
- 1:00:21It's actually pretty impressive, how busy he is and so trying to
- 1:00:23pin him down regularly as a pain in the ass, but he know think he
- 1:00:27comes on regularly, At this point and I can get them
- 1:00:30probably every other episode. So I get something quasi
- 1:00:34co-host. Yeah, we have a co-host who
- 1:00:36drops off in the middle of episodes to take calls about the
- 1:00:39justice department. So we can empathize.
- 1:00:42Everyone can relate right here, we are.
- 1:00:44We're on that content grind, and other people are like, trying to
- 1:00:47do their job. Everyone's like, now you hear
- 1:00:50why? I have the time to do this.
- 1:00:52It's a penguin. So it you dumb one deal in the
- 1:00:54last year. I'm like, yeah, that's right.
- 1:00:56That's a yeah. Now, you know why I'm the And
- 1:00:59with the schedule available for Zach and not the other way
- 1:01:01around. All right.
- 1:01:02Well anyway we I look forward to.
- 1:01:04It's the same lesson Zak part 2. It's like the Gore Vidal Norman
- 1:01:07mailer fight of our time. So no honestly I think the best
- 1:01:11analogy is the first Trump Biden debate where I was I was the
- 1:01:15moderator to sort of who was that, was that Chris Wallace?
- 1:01:18Who was it? That got steamrolled.
- 1:01:19That wasn't very good. Yeah, I think so.
- 1:01:22I'm glad I remember more the Hillary, the more Hillary by
- 1:01:24debates. They like I'm not the puppet,
- 1:01:26you're the puppet. That's basically where that one
- 1:01:27ended up but I'll listen. And either way cool thanks guys
- 1:01:30this is fun alright thanks a bunch.
- 1:01:32Thanks Logan. Goodbye.
- 1:01:46Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:01:49Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:01:46Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:01:49Goodbye.