Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / Trapped by the Win: How to Keep the Gains and Take the Exit with Ashley Romiti
Transcript
- 0:00What if a third of everything you build disappeared
- 0:02on the way out the door? For millions of Americans,
- 0:05the plan worked. They bought the property, they
- 0:08held it for decades, and and it appreciated into
- 0:10to real wealth. Individual investors, not Wall
- 0:13Street, own 70% of America's small rental properties.
- 0:17That's 15.9 million properties held by regular
- 0:20people. But the day they go to cash out, the
- 0:23bill arrives in layers. Federal capital gains
- 0:26up to 20%. depreciation recapture at a maximum
- 0:30rate of 25%, net investment income tax, and state
- 0:35taxes on top. So the wind becomes a trap, and
- 0:38people decide to stay on those properties that
- 0:40they become exhausted by rather than deal with
- 0:42the taxes. But what if the bill was never actually
- 0:46mandatory? Today I'll be joined by Ashley Remitti.
- 0:49She personally underwrote more than $500 million
- 0:52in commercial real estate transactions before
- 0:54founding GCA 1031. where she now helps retiring
- 0:58landlords engineer their exit out of active management
- 1:01and into passive income. So today we get into
- 1:04what selling really costs, the 100-year-old
- 1:07provision in the tax code that defers the entire
- 1:09bill, the two deadlines that wreck exits with
- 1:12no forgiveness whatsoever, and how to trade the
- 1:15tenants and the repair calls for income that
- 1:17arrives without you. So stay tuned because the
- 1:20toll at your exit is optional, but only if you
- 1:22learn the rules before you sell. Welcome back
- 1:44to Escape the Clock, the show where we highlight
- 1:46strategies and approaches for achieving financial
- 1:47freedom and having the option not to work. I'm
- 1:50your host, Daniel C. Rodgers. If you've been following
- 1:52the show, you'll have heard from many experts
- 1:55on how putting earnings into assets that pay
- 1:57us back is a proven path towards financial independence.
- 2:00And for millions of people, the asset of choice
- 2:03is property. Individual investors, not corporations,
- 2:06not Wall Street, own 70% of America's small
- 2:09rental properties. That's 15.9 million properties
- 2:12held by regular people. And it worked. Decades
- 2:16of appreciation have turned those holdings into
- 2:18serious wealth. Americans age 60 and over now
- 2:22control roughly $19 trillion in housing wealth,
- 2:25nearly 40% of all real estate assets in the
- 2:28country. That's the win. Here's the trap. The
- 2:31moment you go to cash in the winnings, the bill
- 2:33arrives. Capital gains, depreciation recapture,
- 2:37state taxes, decades of gains. and the exit can
- 2:41claim a powerful cut of all of it. So it's natural
- 2:44to delay. Don't sell, keep the property, which
- 2:47means keeping the tenants, the repair calls,
- 2:50the work. True financial freedom is one where
- 2:52the W-2 income is optional and the alternate
- 2:54income sources are passive. So why do so many
- 2:57let themselves get handcuffed by the escape?
- 2:59Is there no way to escape the bill pushing people
- 3:02back from the exit? The good news is that there
- 3:04is a solution. And for more than 100 years, the
- 3:07tax code has said something most of us were never
- 3:09told. If you reposition instead of sell, you
- 3:12owe nothing today and maybe a lot less, if anything,
- 3:15in the future. There's a mechanism available
- 3:17to all those millions of property owners. Today's
- 3:20guest has spent her career on exactly that mechanism.
- 3:23Ashley Romiti started out as an investment property
- 3:26agent. where she personally underwrote more than
- 3:28$500 million in real estate transactions, rent
- 3:31rolls, debt structures, operating expenses, and
- 3:34exit assumptions, deal by deal. In nearly 15
- 3:37years in commercial real estate, she saw the
- 3:39same story on repeat. Longtime owners with appreciated
- 3:42properties, growing management fatigue, and no
- 3:45idea where the real exits were. so she founded
- 3:48gca 1031 where as president she helps retiring
- 3:52landlords and long-term property owners transition
- 3:54out of active management using 1031 exchanges
- 3:57and Delaware Statutory Trusts. Ashley, welcome
- 4:01to Escape The Clock. Thank you. You spent years
- 4:04underwriting hundreds of million dollars in deals
- 4:07helping people get into real estate what did
- 4:09you keep seeing and all these owners sitting
- 4:12across from you that convinced you that the real
- 4:14problem was actually getting out Well, so when
- 4:17I started my career, I was early 20s and what
- 4:21my position was initially, I kind of fell into
- 4:24this side and I tell the story because, you know,
- 4:26we don't always plan our path, but I was working
- 4:28with retail real estate investors and local property
- 4:31owners here in Orange County and trying to help
- 4:34them reposition, right? We have more retiring
- 4:37landlords. today than we did back then. But it
- 4:39was always that transition of they owned maybe
- 4:42multifamily or retail and they didn't know what
- 4:44to do. And so from the start of my career, my
- 4:47role and my goal was in helping these investors
- 4:49find that retirement strategy. And it's changed
- 4:52over the last decade, 15 years from going from
- 4:55primarily recommending. net lease properties.
- 4:59So your triple net properties with have limited
- 5:01landlord responsibility into a structure known
- 5:03as a DST. And as you mentioned, right, there's
- 5:06a ton of people retiring. We are seeing that
- 5:08the DST structure is becoming more favorable
- 5:11in a lot of ways, which I'll cover, but it's
- 5:13just been a transition over the years and talking
- 5:16to investors, hearing their pain points and trying
- 5:18to help them solve this huge tax problem. When
- 5:22a landlord is finally deciding to sell a property
- 5:24they've owned for, let's just say like 20 years.
- 5:27start with the fundamentals a little bit what
- 5:28is the tax bill that eventually is waiting for
- 5:32them assuming there's been appreciation and things
- 5:34that they might see and why does it become such
- 5:36a shock to so many people When you think about
- 5:39selling, people understand that there's capital
- 5:41gains. Capital gains is typically going to be
- 5:43one of the larger taxes that you're paying. Highest
- 5:46earners are looking at 20% on federal. You have
- 5:49state capital gains, varies by state, but here
- 5:52in California, we're at 13.3%. What shocks investors
- 5:56the most is probably the depreciation recapture,
- 5:59which is in addition to federal and state, and
- 6:02then also what's known as net investment income
- 6:04tax. i work nationwide so it varies by state
- 6:07but like for example here in california i'm working
- 6:10with a client and they're looking at paying 37
- 6:12in taxes at the end of the day that's a lot of
- 6:15the appreciation that's just eaten away and they're
- 6:18not getting that long-term benefit and all that
- 6:20work that they put in so it ranges typically
- 6:22from 30 to 40 percent of the gain in the property
- 6:26Yeah, hopefully people caught that 30 to 40%.
- 6:29You know, for us real estate people who have
- 6:31actually taken the journey here, we understand
- 6:34the enticement that is depreciation. For someone
- 6:37who hasn't taken that leap yet, can you talk
- 6:41about what depreciation is, why that's such a
- 6:44powerful strategy, and why the IRS charges what
- 6:47they do for the recapture? Yeah. So depreciation
- 6:50is essentially if you buy a property on your
- 6:53taxes, you get to write off the wear and tear
- 6:55of the property. So it varies whether it's a
- 6:58commercial or multifamily. So commercials, 39
- 7:01year schedule, multifamily is 27 and a half year.
- 7:04So essentially what that means that every year
- 7:06you get some deductions to identify that the
- 7:08property does have that wear and tear. When you
- 7:11go to sell it, the depreciation recapture is
- 7:1425%. So essentially they're saying, okay, you've
- 7:16gotten all these deductions over the year. we're
- 7:19going to take back 25% of that, which can be
- 7:22a substantial amount when you're looking at the
- 7:24sale and how much equity you're going to walk
- 7:26away with. Yeah. And you also mentioned the net
- 7:29investment income, which I think a lot of people
- 7:31miss. So can you talk about how states tax and
- 7:35also the net investment income tax stacking on
- 7:38top of this federal bill? So I think all these
- 7:41percentages are kind of like piling on each other.
- 7:44Yeah, you're going to see every layer. Most people
- 7:46are going to be familiar. They're just going
- 7:47to say capital gains. But as mentioned, at the
- 7:50end of the day, you could be looking upwards
- 7:51of 30 to 40%. And so it really does layer up.
- 7:55I tell investors, make sure before you do any
- 7:57sort of cash out or before you sell a property.
- 8:00No, a lot of people don't do tax planning before
- 8:02the sale. And that's always my biggest recommendation
- 8:05is you have spent decades building this equity,
- 8:08building this portfolio. Make sure you understand
- 8:11the full tax consequences on the sale. Because
- 8:13that could wipe out all your hard work. So if
- 8:16someone were going to do the sell and they're
- 8:19excited about that, maybe this is part of their
- 8:21early retirement. It's appreciated really well.
- 8:23And let's say they've done depreciation and they
- 8:26have a 30% recapture owed back to the IRS. And
- 8:30then they have, let's say, some state taxes from
- 8:33some deductions and that investment income taxes.
- 8:35And let's say they end up around something like
- 8:3740%. What are happening to folks at this point
- 8:40that is making them actually bulk away? Is it
- 8:43that total bill is just too much for people?
- 8:45They're just too exhausted by the idea they're
- 8:47going to lose that much money? Is the reason
- 8:49they end up staying with the property? Is it
- 8:51purely a tax part or is there more to it than
- 8:53that? Well, I mean, a lot of investors aren't
- 8:56familiar with what their options are. They might
- 8:58be familiar with the 1031, which is the tax deferred
- 9:01exchange. Like, for example, the clients that
- 9:03I work with. They don't understand that there
- 9:05are passive structures that are available. So
- 9:07they hold onto the property simply because they
- 9:10don't know what else to do with it. And they
- 9:12don't want to pay that 40%. Then you have clients
- 9:14who say, I'm just going to take the hit because
- 9:17I don't want to manage anymore. Again, they don't
- 9:19always know what the real options are. And that's
- 9:22where the education, because the market is changing
- 9:25and there's more opportunities coming out every
- 9:27year. Yeah. I imagine if I was that client right
- 9:30now and I saw that bill, I'd be like, okay, I
- 9:32don't want to give that much up. And we would
- 9:34start talking about options and 1031 exchange
- 9:37would naturally come up. And to do that, it would
- 9:39require me as an investor to identify a replacement
- 9:43property. I think within like 45 days of the
- 9:45sale to complete. But let's go through the 1031
- 9:49exchange for those who aren't completely aware
- 9:51of it. I do think that could be a lot of the
- 9:54reasons people decide to kind of stay in the
- 9:56real estate game instead of cashing out completely,
- 9:59because that is such a powerful strategy. So
- 10:01what's happening kind of step by step from the
- 10:04day their property is closing when they decide
- 10:06to take that approach? 1031 exchange or tax deferred
- 10:09exchange is a tax code IRC 1031. It's been around
- 10:13for, you said, over 100 years. And what it is,
- 10:16it allows investors to buy and sell real estate,
- 10:18all deferring the taxes. It's important to note
- 10:20it's all those taxes, including depreciation
- 10:23recapture. But it's a pretty straightforward
- 10:25process if you're doing a traditional exchange.
- 10:27Whereas let's say you own a four unit apartment
- 10:31building. Prior to closing escrow on that, you're
- 10:34going to open an account with what's known as
- 10:35a qualified intermediary. They're essentially
- 10:38your 1031 escrow. They're going to hold the funds.
- 10:40The property you sell is known as the relinquished
- 10:42property. So you sell the relinquished property
- 10:44funds. Say you sell for a million dollars or
- 10:47you net a million dollars from the sale. Funds
- 10:49go from escrow to the qualified intermediary.
- 10:51On the date of that sale starts your clock. So
- 10:53you have 45 days to identify your replacement
- 10:56properties. There's a few different rules. on
- 10:59how you're gonna identify, but you wanna identify
- 11:02a few properties in those 45 days, if not close
- 11:05on them. On day 45, if you haven't closed, you're
- 11:08gonna send an ID sheet to your qualified intermediary,
- 11:11outlines what you might buy. And then from there,
- 11:13you have six months from your closing date to
- 11:16then close on the properties. So, and those timelines
- 11:18are one of the most critical aspects to consider
- 11:21because there is no forgiveness. If your day
- 11:24is on July 4th, make sure you're closing before
- 11:26then because you do not get extensions. Yeah,
- 11:29the tax code has not been proven to be very forgiving.
- 11:31No, I say never assume that you can do it on
- 11:36the weekend. If your ID day is on a Sunday, figure
- 11:38it out by Friday. If you miss these dates, you
- 11:41will be faced with paying taxes. Let me see if
- 11:45I kind of got the workflow right. So when you
- 11:47decide to take this route, you're going to go
- 11:50into an escrow in a qualified intermediary where
- 11:53you're not going to be able to touch that money.
- 11:54at all during that period you need to find a
- 11:57like-kind property within ideally close within
- 12:0045 day window otherwise you'll have to follow
- 12:03the form you mentioned let's talk about the like
- 12:05-kind piece though you mentioned an example i
- 12:08think an apartment building how similar does
- 12:12the property need to be from the property you
- 12:14had could it be any type of real estate could
- 12:17you go from like a single family home into some
- 12:21other type where does that line hit people yeah
- 12:25that's a great question and something that i
- 12:27think is misunderstood a lot so like kind just
- 12:31means for investment or business so if you own
- 12:34a single family home you can go trade into a
- 12:37multi-family if you own land you can go buy
- 12:39a retail center what matters is what they use
- 12:42for And then there's some alternatives, mineral
- 12:45and oil rights, DSTs, right? There's a lot of
- 12:48structures that qualify as like kind, but what's
- 12:51important to note is what's the use. So investment
- 12:53or business use. Can we talk about the Delaware
- 12:57Statutory Trust and how it lets landlords trade
- 13:01rental houses for a slice of institutional real
- 13:04estate without triggering the tax bill? Sure.
- 13:07Into the bread and butter of what I love to do.
- 13:10So DST or Delaware Statutory Trust is essentially
- 13:13a trust that holds real estate and it qualifies
- 13:16for the 1031 exchange. And that's the most important
- 13:19aspect that investors need to understand is it
- 13:22is an avenue where you can trade from the active
- 13:25management of owning your real estate and trade
- 13:28into a property that's much larger typically.
- 13:31Typically what we see in what's known as a DST
- 13:33are going to be institutional quality assets.
- 13:36So the trust is going to hold maybe a portfolio
- 13:39of industrial properties or a newly built 300
- 13:42unit apartment building in a major metro area.
- 13:47portfolios of net lease properties these are
- 13:49going to be much larger assets that you and i
- 13:52typically wouldn't be able to go out and buy
- 13:54on our own and so the way that it's structured
- 13:56is that an investor can sell let's say a million
- 13:59dollar single family home and reinvest into multiple
- 14:04of these dsts so they get to build a passive
- 14:07portfolio and the goal is really meet your exchange
- 14:10goals meet your investment goals and diversify
- 14:14right Let's mitigate risk and get into some solid
- 14:17assets that can perform over the next five to
- 14:20seven years. DSTs are growing. Offerings raised
- 14:24more than $8.41 billion in investor equity in
- 14:292025, which was a 49% increase over the $5.6
- 14:33billion that it raised in 2024. So this seems
- 14:36to be definitely growing. So what kinds of properties
- 14:40are actually sitting inside these trusts, though,
- 14:41and who is actually managing them? The properties
- 14:45in the trust can vary. Usually it's going to
- 14:47be dependent on the asset classes at the time,
- 14:49right? So right now, a lot of what we're seeing
- 14:51are going to be multifamily. Multifamily historically
- 14:54and probably in the future will always be a majority
- 14:56of these assets are constant in need and in demand
- 15:00for housing. Right now we're seeing industrial.
- 15:03So that includes, you know, the small bay industrial
- 15:05or the big box industrial with corporate tenants.
- 15:08You see the big box. So the dollar stores, the
- 15:11Amazons. The goal with what type of real estate
- 15:14is in the DST is you want solid core assets that
- 15:18have the fundamentals to perform for the next
- 15:22five to 10 years, which is the general hold period.
- 15:24Because when the IRS approved DSTs back in 2004,
- 15:29they put some restrictions. And so because of
- 15:32those restrictions, you're going to really see
- 15:34those core stable assets in the DSTs, not so
- 15:37much value add. Historically, maybe you would
- 15:40have seen office, no more office, the pandemic,
- 15:42some self-storage, and you can diversify. You
- 15:45can go to multiple different asset classes. People
- 15:48are probably used to a certain type of income
- 15:49before they were to go into a trust like this.
- 15:52Once they decide to take a DST route, what type
- 15:55of income should they expect? And also, should
- 16:00they expect to be giving up control and liquidity?
- 16:03And is there any gotchas that people should avoid
- 16:06when it comes to what they might be used to from
- 16:10the kind of income they were getting from their
- 16:12rentals to moving into this trust? Yeah. So first
- 16:16we'll talk about the income. So, and we need
- 16:19to look at specific offerings to be able to really
- 16:21narrow down. But generally speaking, the offerings
- 16:24today will yield anywhere from like four, four
- 16:26and a quarter to on the higher end, you'll see
- 16:28offerings like five and a half, 6%. It's all
- 16:31dependent on the asset that's in there, right?
- 16:33A lot of times cashflow is going to be directly
- 16:35related to the asset and risk, but that four
- 16:38to 6% is a broad range of what investors could
- 16:41expect. That can be good or bad. Here in California,
- 16:44the average return on equity, given the appreciation
- 16:47we've had on single family homes, multifamily
- 16:50is around 2%. So it's great when I talk to people
- 16:53in California, I say, you're going to be in a
- 16:55good position. Other parts of the country, they
- 16:57might be getting 6% or 8%. And so what they're
- 17:01trading at that point is that passive structure,
- 17:03being able to get rid of tenant calls, maintenance,
- 17:06all the insurance changing. But with whichever
- 17:09side you fall on, we talk about the highlights.
- 17:12You said, what are they giving up? Well, they're
- 17:14going to give up control of the property, which
- 17:16means once you invest, it is considered an illiquid
- 17:20investment. So you're going to be in the deal
- 17:21for five to seven years. There's some variations
- 17:24that I'll talk with clients. This one might be
- 17:27projected for 10. This one's for five. But that
- 17:29five to seven, five to 10 year in the deal, even
- 17:32if someone passes away, their heirs are in the
- 17:34deal. And so that's a big. challenge for investors
- 17:37who have spent decades building their portfolio.
- 17:40But I will tell you, most of the time, investors,
- 17:42once they get that passive income, they're pretty
- 17:45happy with giving up the control. You underwrote
- 17:48more than $500 million in real estate before
- 17:51founding GCA 1031. And so I'd love to get your
- 17:56overall impressions of DST because it has, like
- 18:02I mentioned, has grown quite a bit. As the end
- 18:04of last year, there's 50 active sponsors offering
- 18:0789 dst programs in the market why do you think
- 18:11dst investing is growing so fast especially right
- 18:14now I mean, hate really is because of who owns
- 18:19the real estate in the United States. A lot of
- 18:21the real estate, you quoted it earlier, but is
- 18:24held, I think 40% is held by baby boomers. They're
- 18:27ready to get out. They're ready to just get the
- 18:29passive income. And that is what's contributing
- 18:31to this change. It's also, DSTs are a really
- 18:34good tool for estate planning, right? If you
- 18:36have four kids in a $2 million property and you
- 18:40pass away, Every kid is going to be in a different
- 18:42financial position, have a different perspective.
- 18:44So having them agree and keep that relationship
- 18:47upon your passing, that can cause anxiety where
- 18:50with the DSTs, you've got $2 million, $500,000
- 18:54or $2 million for kids. You can allocate $500
- 18:57,000 to each child and it's a very easy transition
- 19:00in comparison to a lot of the real estate direct
- 19:03ownership. So that are some of the major contributors
- 19:06to why the industry is growing. Your other question
- 19:09on underwriting. So yeah, I spent almost a decade
- 19:12working on the commercial side, underwriting
- 19:15deals, representing buyers and sellers, consulting
- 19:17with investment firms and family offices. And
- 19:20the one thing I caution investors is I'm a huge
- 19:24advocate of DSTs, but the underwriting, there
- 19:26is no guidance on how it has to be underwritten.
- 19:29It's really up to the sponsor. And so with the
- 19:32good deals, underwriting is solid, right? What
- 19:35we're seeing distributed to investors makes sense
- 19:38based on their purchase price, the projections
- 19:40and rental growth, the reserves account, right?
- 19:42There's a lot of factors, but I can't speak to
- 19:45every DST offering because every sponsor underwrites
- 19:49it differently. And that's where it's very important
- 19:52to work with someone who understands the real
- 19:54estate and the underwriting. How do these work
- 19:57in these structures? And are there red flags
- 20:00that people should be looking for with any sponsors
- 20:03where they're trying to understand, okay, I should
- 20:05just walk away from this deal? Essentially, when
- 20:08you come into a DST, you're buying in at a premium.
- 20:11So typically fees can range anywhere from 8%
- 20:14to 12%. And the biggest red flag is, right, I've
- 20:18looked at deals that have 20% plus fees. That's
- 20:21a red flag, right? the fees are important to
- 20:23understand because people want to know what the
- 20:25premium is but when we're underwriting the deal
- 20:28what's very important is understanding what's
- 20:30the exit viability for that offering meaning
- 20:33if you're coming in at a let's call it a 10 premium
- 20:36on a deal what's the likelihood that that deal
- 20:40is going to not only overcome that premium you
- 20:42come in at but also deliver appreciation on the
- 20:44back end so the red flag is if you see fees that
- 20:48are really high and there's Because if you look
- 20:51across the different offerings, it's pretty consistent
- 20:54on what we see, right? It's not going to vary.
- 20:57Some deals are more difficult to acquire. So
- 21:00the upfront fees, the real estate fees are higher.
- 21:03Some broker dealers charge more. It's just there's
- 21:05slight variations. But I'd say the fees can be
- 21:08overcome as long as the deal is good. One of
- 21:10the biggest red flags I see is if I see like
- 21:12a... a leveraged single tenant deal that has
- 21:15really high fees. Because if you understand how
- 21:18net lease structures work, you don't get a lot
- 21:20of appreciation. And then if you have a huge
- 21:22fee load, what I want for clients is capital
- 21:25preservation. So that fee load is very important
- 21:28to look at when we're understanding what's the
- 21:31likelihood that if you invest $100,000 today,
- 21:33you're going to have $100,000 when you leave,
- 21:36hopefully more. But that's another conversation
- 21:38on what's an appreciating asset. People listening
- 21:42to this are very much thinking about their financial
- 21:45freedom and how to get to a point where they
- 21:48don't have to work if they don't want to and
- 21:50they can enjoy their lives as quickly as possible.
- 21:53And 1031 exchanges are powerful. Now, hopefully,
- 21:56you know, think about DST as another possibility
- 21:58and figuring out how to keep that alternate income
- 22:01source as passive as possible. But there was
- 22:04this report back in 2020 that showed that approximately
- 22:0780% of investors who complete a 1031 exchange
- 22:10only ever do it once. They do it one time. They
- 22:13never do it again. And deferring is not the same
- 22:16as erasing. You can push it down a little bit,
- 22:19but you're still dealing with it at some point.
- 22:21And you had mentioned a state earlier. I think
- 22:23that's great. I think it's important for people
- 22:25to understand that at some point, deferring could
- 22:27mean potentially inheriting. I know there's a
- 22:30step up in basis that occurs at death. Maybe
- 22:33we can just talk about that for those who aren't
- 22:35aware of that. And just to have a whole picture
- 22:39of how the DST or the 1031 exchanges could help
- 22:42folks when it comes down to deciding when to
- 22:45hold on and when to let go of real estate. Yeah.
- 22:48So the step up in basis essentially is the year
- 22:50you pass the properties reassessed. So it's a
- 22:53good way where you're not going to owe all of
- 22:56those capital gains. What you're going to be
- 22:57looking at from that point is estate taxes. And
- 23:00that's a conversation with the estate planner.
- 23:02And it's true. A lot of investors will actually
- 23:04find they don't do exchanges because they're
- 23:07in a hold position. A lot of investors buy real
- 23:09estate just to hold, might do one exchange. And
- 23:12then investors that cash out, I mean, there's
- 23:14a lot of different reasons as to why they might
- 23:16cash out. But when it comes to estate planning,
- 23:19I would say rather than ever going and just paying
- 23:22the taxes, understanding what the DST does, it's
- 23:25new. I'd say in the last few years, it's really
- 23:27grown and it's going to continue to be a solution.
- 23:30So I would assume you said that was from 2020.
- 23:33DSTs were small. I think it was $5 billion back
- 23:35then, $4 billion. We've already doubled. I think
- 23:38over the next few years, it's going to double
- 23:39and triple because you have more sophisticated
- 23:42companies coming in. I mean, BlackRock just came
- 23:45out with a DST. So as this education comes out,
- 23:49more investors are going to, I think, go against
- 23:52paying the taxes and look into something like
- 23:54a DST. When should someone just pay the taxes?
- 23:58Is there still a scenario where that would be
- 24:00the right answer for them? For some of the clients
- 24:03that I've had pay taxes, one, the tax bill wasn't
- 24:05going to have a huge impact. That's one consideration.
- 24:09DSTs are illiquid. So if all of your funds are
- 24:12going into a DST, we have to think of, can all
- 24:15of your funds be tied up for the next five to
- 24:17seven years? If you need some liquidity in your
- 24:19bank, if you're going to need some cash over
- 24:21the next few years, we need to talk about having
- 24:23some of that pulled out. And it hurts to pay
- 24:25taxes, but it's going to be even worse if down
- 24:27the line you need some money and it's all tied
- 24:29up. Another scenario, I mean, we could go through
- 24:31different ones, but like if your basis is really
- 24:33high, right, you need to calculate how much in
- 24:37capital gains and other taxes are you going to
- 24:39pay? And what is that investment scenario look
- 24:43like paying taxes and reinvesting versus doing
- 24:46the DST? And then another factor is how much
- 24:49risk does someone want to take? If someone is
- 24:51willing to go and take more risk with their cash
- 24:54proceeds, and that's the stage that they're at.
- 24:57that's very different than my 85 year old clients
- 24:59who are they just don't want to pay taxes so
- 25:01every client is different and it's just understanding
- 25:04their position and helping them make that decision
- 25:07that's best for them yeah so it sounds like you
- 25:09know doing the calculations to find out one what
- 25:12your income needs look like what different possible
- 25:15tax bills look like with timelines to them because
- 25:17they do like you said become a liquid you can
- 25:20defer things you might be able to defer a tax
- 25:23bill to a better period of your life. Maybe you
- 25:25could even get that step up in basis and pay
- 25:28less taxes. But, you know, that depends on this
- 25:31person and their longevity and things like that.
- 25:33And the risk tolerance, like how risky is these
- 25:36plans? So, yeah, a few different pieces there.
- 25:39But it sounds like with the right conversation,
- 25:41people can make the right decision. There's lots
- 25:43of options available for them. So for someone
- 25:45who is listening right now. who let's say owns
- 25:47a rental and they're hoping to get out in the
- 25:50next five years, what would you say to them?
- 25:53How would you start to help them? The first thing
- 25:56I tell investors is to get your property valued
- 25:58and look at your tax return. Find out what you're
- 26:01truly earning on the property. A lot of investors
- 26:04are earning far less than what they think they're
- 26:06rental. So the first step is getting an understanding
- 26:08of the value of the property, return on equity,
- 26:11and have a conversation with your CPA to understand
- 26:14what the tax implications will be on a sale.
- 26:16And then where I work with investors, for example,
- 26:19is we look at the different exit options. DSTs
- 26:21are 95% a good option. opportunity zone funds
- 26:25which could be a whole different conversation
- 26:27those are coming back next year that could be
- 26:30an option buying direct property bringing in
- 26:32property management going into a net lease so
- 26:34if you put time in your property people spend
- 26:37so much time building their portfolio take that
- 26:40same time on exiting the portfolio bring that
- 26:42advisory group together to make sure you're making
- 26:45the best decisions because there's different
- 26:47options there's dsts we didn't even get to chance
- 26:49but 721 dsts So plan. Don't just sell because
- 26:53someone called you and said your property's worth
- 26:56X, Y, and Z. I hear that too often. Well, thank
- 27:00you so much, Ashley, for coming on the show and
- 27:02helping demystify so much of this. There is a
- 27:05lot here. Like you mentioned, we didn't even
- 27:07get into 721s. I'm sure we could go a lot deeper.
- 27:10How could listeners connect with you and even
- 27:12learn more about this? Sure. Yeah. So my website,
- 27:15gca1031.com. I love working with investors.
- 27:19Give me a call. Start the conversation early.
- 27:21That's my biggest piece of advice. Well, thanks
- 27:24again for coming on the show and wishing you
- 27:26all the best. Thank you. Every plan you've ever
- 27:39built has two halves, getting in and getting
- 27:42out. Think about how much time you spent on that
- 27:44first half. Figuring out the goals, choosing
- 27:46the investments, comparing offers, finding the
- 27:49fees, researching reviews, running numbers again
- 27:52and again. It's a lot of effort. And we do that
- 27:55because we understand it's costly to miss the
- 27:57details when it comes to how we use our money.
- 27:59But now think about how much time you spent on
- 28:01the second half. Because for most, the answer
- 28:04is none. No effort at all. The time comes to
- 28:07cash in and clicking that sell button is just
- 28:09easier because we need the money for that next
- 28:11thing. But it's that delayed pain that wakes
- 28:15us up to the mistake of not planning the exit.
- 28:18Because the taxes, they don't arrive all at once.
- 28:21They can arrive in layers and they arrive later.
- 28:24So we build the plans to accumulate, but rarely
- 28:27do we build the plans to decumulate. I know because
- 28:30I did this myself. I had done the research and
- 28:33calculated how much I needed in retirement accounts
- 28:35to be done with work. I opted into the employer
- 28:38-offered retirement plans whenever they were
- 28:40available. Taking the full match plus contributing
- 28:42whatever else made sense to help just push me
- 28:44to that goal. And I rolled my 401k balances out
- 28:48of my IRA every time I left a job so that I could
- 28:51keep rebalancing and optimizing to get the most
- 28:53out of my positions. I had a goal, I was doing
- 28:56what I was supposed to do, and I was watching
- 28:58that number tick up. Yet I made one major mistake
- 29:02right off the bat. With all that planning, when
- 29:05it came down to it and I was asked, do I want
- 29:07to contribute to a traditional or a Roth? I chose
- 29:11the traditional and actually made sense to me
- 29:13at the time. I was thinking about what I needed
- 29:15at that moment. I saw the immediate tax savings
- 29:18sitting right there in front of me. But what
- 29:20I did is I neglected what it would cost me when
- 29:22I exited work with that account decades later.
- 29:26Every one of those dollars that went into that
- 29:28traditional account, that was pre-tax, untouched
- 29:31by the IRS. In essence, it's just an IOU to the
- 29:35government that I wasn't even accounting for
- 29:37anywhere in my plan. Eventually, I caught the
- 29:40mistake and I adjusted. I kept the traditional,
- 29:43but I also opened a Roth as well. This was a
- 29:46great pivot. At first, I was just balancing contributions
- 29:50between the two. Depending on what tax bracket
- 29:53I was in that year, I knew how much I should
- 29:55put into my traditional and then everything else
- 29:57into the Roth. Eventually, I was 100% Roth,
- 30:000% traditional. Now in my early retirement,
- 30:04my traditional has become a source of Roth rollovers
- 30:07and it was even a great one-time HSA contribution
- 30:11source. So I'm able to tap into it now and minimize
- 30:16that tax burden that's still going to come eventually
- 30:18down the line. So I'm now after tax heavy and
- 30:21pre-tax light. But imagine I hadn't made that
- 30:24pivot. I'd have hit my number at 42, opened my
- 30:28spreadsheet, looked at the total and felt like
- 30:30I'd won. I'd see the number I was working so
- 30:33hard for, but it wouldn't have been real. I'd
- 30:36only get to keep a percentage of that money because
- 30:38the rest belonged to the IRS. And it's a jarring
- 30:41mistake and an easy one to miss if we don't plan
- 30:44for that exit. This mistake is even more painful
- 30:47for the people that Ashley works with because
- 30:50they're investing in real estate and treating
- 30:51it as a source of cash flow and eventually looking
- 30:54to cash in on the appreciation as well. They
- 30:57bought a property, held it for, let's say, 20
- 30:59or 30 years. and then signed each line of the
- 31:03paperwork at the time to get it sold and for
- 31:05many real estate investors that delayed pain
- 31:08is far worse than my mistake because it can hit
- 31:11in layers federal capital gains are the part
- 31:13that most have thought about they consider that
- 31:15because it's common but sadly many stopped there
- 31:19to get the investment off the ground they might
- 31:22have used depreciation because it's a powerful
- 31:24tool but the mistake is thinking that it's a
- 31:26benefit You know, like the government's taking
- 31:28pity on us for the struggle that we're having
- 31:30trying to get our investment going. But just
- 31:33like that pre-tax IRA, it's a loan. And the
- 31:35IRS returns to take up to 25% of it, whether
- 31:39you ever claim the deduction or not. Then there's
- 31:42the net investment income tax. This one is sneaky
- 31:45because it's tied to your income and not the
- 31:48property itself. It's an extra 3.8% % that kicks
- 31:51in once your income for the year crosses $200
- 31:53,000 if you're filing single. or $250,000 if
- 31:57you're filing jointly. And those thresholds have
- 31:59not moved since 2013. And so here's the trap
- 32:03that people miss. That big sales spike on that
- 32:05real estate hits your income for that one year,
- 32:08and it can trigger that 3.8% % without even realizing
- 32:11it. So people who never come close to these numbers
- 32:15in a normal year can find themselves well over
- 32:17the line in the year that they sell. And don't
- 32:20forget state taxes. If you're in a place like
- 32:22California, You need to add another 13.3% % on
- 32:25top of all of that. So punch after punch until
- 32:29you might feel like you're on the ropes. And
- 32:31when it's all said and done, you might see 40
- 32:34% of your gains gone. And that is a hard pill
- 32:37to swallow. Decades of tenant calls, roof repairs,
- 32:41and vacancies, and the exit can take a third
- 32:43or more of what you earned. So it might not be
- 32:47a surprise that the people who get wind of this
- 32:49before closing decide not to exit at all. They
- 32:52just keep the property, including the tenant
- 32:54calls and the vacancies and all the other stuff
- 32:56that comes along with it. And it's a reasonable
- 32:58reaction when you don't know your options. They
- 33:01knew about selling and they knew about holding,
- 33:03but no one had ever told them there might be
- 33:05a third option. That third door has been sitting
- 33:08in the tax code since 1921. IRS section 1031,
- 33:13or more commonly known as the 1031 exchange.
- 33:17If you reposition into another qualifying investment
- 33:19and so selling, you can defer the entire bill,
- 33:22all of it, including the depreciation recapture.
- 33:27But it comes with two dates and no mercy. From
- 33:30the day your sale closes, you have 45 days to
- 33:33identify what you're buying and 180 days to close
- 33:36on it. And Ashley's warning was blunt here. If
- 33:39your deadline falls on a Sunday, get it done
- 33:41by Friday because there are no extensions and
- 33:44there is no appeal. A 1031 is a fine strategy
- 33:48if you're looking to reinvest. But on its own,
- 33:50it's not really a freedom strategy. You might
- 33:53find yourself in a new property with new problems,
- 33:56and all those painful tax concerns were just
- 33:59simply punted down the road. Luckily, there is
- 34:01a version that a lot of people miss. You can
- 34:04exchange into a Delaware Statutory Trust, or
- 34:07a DST. A DST is a structure that holds institutional
- 34:11real estate, and the IRS approved it as a valid
- 34:13replacement property back in 2004. Instead of
- 34:16exchanging into a property that you manage, You
- 34:19want to slice, let's say, a 300 unit apartment
- 34:22building and it's fully passive. So instead of
- 34:25a duplex that you have to drive to, you trade
- 34:28the keys for shares. You're giving up control
- 34:30and you're giving up liquidity for five to seven
- 34:33years. But what you get back is your time and
- 34:37you've eliminated the stress of all those taxes.
- 34:40Ashley outlined the tradeoffs and it's important
- 34:42to understand them before making this a part
- 34:44of your plan. These deals carry fees of 8% to
- 34:4812%. And she's seen some offerings north of 20%,
- 34:51which she straight up just called a red flag.
- 34:53So really ask about the fees, try to understand
- 34:55them. There's also no standardization and underwriting.
- 34:59So the quality you experience with these can
- 35:01vary by the sponsor. And there's quite a few
- 35:04sponsors nowadays. And once you're in, the money
- 35:07is locked up. So make sure you have all of your
- 35:09savings and liquidity things figured out before
- 35:12you start to move on one of these. And if you
- 35:14pass away, your errors are locked into it as
- 35:17well. I actually put the whole lesson in one
- 35:19sentence. People spend so much time building
- 35:22their portfolio, but rarely take the same time
- 35:24in exiting that portfolio. So here are the four
- 35:27steps to make sure the exit gets the same attention
- 35:29as the entrance did. It's the project put together
- 35:32for today's lesson. First, price your exit. Take
- 35:36every major asset that you own and write it down.
- 35:39What would it actually cost to convert it into
- 35:41money that you could spend? The traditional 401k,
- 35:44that taxable brokerage account, decades of gains
- 35:47on it, your company stock, rentals, whatever,
- 35:50just write them all down. Most people have never
- 35:53seen this number, and it's almost bigger than
- 35:55they might have guessed. You cannot plan around
- 35:58a cost that you haven't actually measured, so
- 36:00the first task in your project is to measure
- 36:01it. Second, calculate your return on equity,
- 36:05not your return on the purchase price. This is
- 36:08an important difference. So get the property
- 36:11valued and then pull the tax return. You might
- 36:14be surprised that you're earning less than what
- 36:16you think because if you bought a property for
- 36:18let's say $200,000 and it's worth a million
- 36:21today, your rent isn't returning a percentage
- 36:24of $200,000, it's returning a percentage of
- 36:27the million. So run this on everything that you
- 36:30own that has appreciated, including your house.
- 36:32You may be sitting on a lazy asset and calling
- 36:35it a good investment. Third, Learn the exits
- 36:39that already exist. The tax code is not a punishment.
- 36:42It's just a set of instructions. Section 1031
- 36:45exists to help you understand how it works. Take
- 36:48advantage of it. The step up in basis of death,
- 36:51which reassesses the property, can wipe out the
- 36:54deferred capital gains entirely for your heirs.
- 36:57Roth conversions in low years can be a really
- 37:00smart way to deal with those gains. Tax loss
- 37:03harvesting, charitable strategies. There are
- 37:05a lot of options here. You don't have to master
- 37:08them all. You just need to know which doors apply
- 37:10to what you own before the day that you actually
- 37:13need them. Fourth, build your exit team. Don't
- 37:17wait for closing when every good option is already
- 37:20gone. Find that CPA who can model the sale before
- 37:23it happens or an estate planner or an advisor
- 37:26who isn't compensated by keeping your money exactly
- 37:29where it is. Assemble them and make sure you
- 37:32to leverage that relationship early. while you
- 37:35still have a chance to act. Those four tasks
- 37:38are the start of a strong project to bulletproof
- 37:41the exit of every asset in your life. Imagine
- 37:44it's five years from now and you decided you're
- 37:46done. You make the call and decide to sell. Instead
- 37:49of a shock, you're enacting a plan that's been
- 37:51ready for years. You know the bill. You know
- 37:54which assets you're going to touch first and
- 37:55which to leave alone. You know what will convert
- 37:58cleanly and what doesn't. Nothing about the day
- 38:00will be a surprise because you priced it back
- 38:02when you still had every option available to
- 38:04you. And if there's one thing I want you to take
- 38:07away from today's conversation, let it be this.
- 38:10You don't get to spend your net worth. You get
- 38:13to spend what's left of it. So build the exit
- 38:16with the same care that you built the entrance.
- 38:18I'd love to hear from you. What would it actually
- 38:20cost you to turn your biggest asset into spendable
- 38:23money? Email me at contact at escapetheclock
- 38:25dot com or leave a comment wherever you listen.
- 38:28I'm Daniel C. Rodgers. Thanks for listening and
- 38:30best of luck pricing your exit and escaping the
- 38:32clock. I'll catch you next week. That's a wrap
- 38:36on this episode of Escape the Clock. Everything
- 38:38you've heard today is for educational purposes
- 38:39only. Designed to help you think, plan, and build
- 38:42a stronger financial program. Take what resonates,
- 38:45bring it into your Escape the Clock plan, and
- 38:47review it with a qualified professional before
- 38:48making any major moves. I'm Daniel C. Rodgers,
- 38:51a Wealth Management Certified Professional and
- 38:52your host. The book, the free planner, and the
- 38:55one-on-one time with me are all waiting for
- 38:56you at escapetheclock.com. If this episode
- 38:58was valuable, please leave a rating, share it
- 39:00with someone who needs to hear it. I'll catch
- 39:02you next week.