Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The Long Island Serial Killer Archives: Rex Heuermann And The 20/20 Special
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the program. It's
- 0:04been about two months now since Rex Ewerman was arrested
- 0:08and charged in the murder of three of the four
- 0:11Gilgo Beach murder victims. And since that time, we've learned
- 0:15a lot more about how the authorities were able to
- 0:19track down Rex Ewerman and bring him into custody. And
- 0:22in today's episode, we're gonna talk a little bit more
- 0:25about how they were able to find Rex Ewerman and
- 0:28what evidence led them there. Today's article is from ABC
- 0:32News and the headline the Long Island serial Killer. How
- 0:37cell phones and a pizza box led to a suspect
- 0:40in three cases. This article was authored by Samantha Wanderer
- 0:45and Christina Corbin. Sarah Carnes was sitting in her Times
- 0:50Square hotel room when she says she received a phone
- 0:53call from a block number. She said the voice on
- 0:56the other line, an unknown mal caller, who was calm
- 0:59and matter of fact, revealed personal details about her friend,
- 1:03Maureen Brainerd Barnes, who vanished days earlier in July two
- 1:08thousand and seven, while working as an escort in New
- 1:11York City. I just saw her, Carnes recalls the man
- 1:15saying she's at a whorehouse in Queens. Well, we know
- 1:19that Rex Youwerman has called family members of his victims before,
- 1:23so that certainly tracks exactly sixteen years after the chilling
- 1:28phone call. Carnes said she believes that mystery voice was
- 1:32that of Rex Ewerman, a married father of two and
- 1:36New York architect who is charged in the murders of
- 1:39three other women. He is the prime suspect in the
- 1:42death of twenty five year old Brainerd Barnes. According to
- 1:46the investigators, Huerman has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
- 1:52That was him, Carnes said of the caller in an
- 1:54exclusive twenty twenty interview following Huerman's arrest on July thirteenth. Hwerman,
- 2:00fifty nine, is charged in the killings of Melissa bartholemy
- 2:04Megan Waterman, and amberln Costello, who were working as escorts
- 2:09on Craigslist when they disappeared. And as we all know,
- 2:13all of these women that we know about anyway, we're
- 2:16also doing the same thing. And when you're trying to
- 2:19build a profile or a pattern, those are the sorts
- 2:23of things that you look for, and when you look
- 2:26at all of these missing women, there are so many
- 2:29similarities that they share that it's very, very difficult for
- 2:33me anyway to look at anyone besides Rex Ewerman, at
- 2:36least until we know about the forensic testing. Once all
- 2:39the DNA comes back and we can rule them out,
- 2:42that's one thing, But as of now, there's nobody else
- 2:45even on the radar when it comes to these murders.
- 2:49The badly decomposed remains of those women, as well as
- 2:52those of Brainerd Barnes, was found in twenty ten near
- 2:57Gilgo Beach on New York's Long Island, what police described
- 3:01as the work of a serial killer. Well, you don't
- 3:04have to be you know, Anne Burgess to figure out
- 3:07that this was a serial killer. And imagine the audacity
- 3:10of James Burke and his investigators throughout this whole entire
- 3:13thing at the beginning, to just treat this like it
- 3:16didn't matter, sweep it under the rug, don't chase down
- 3:19any leads. And because of their ineptitude, how many other
- 3:22women were hurt. That's a question that's going to have
- 3:25to be asked at some point. Carnes, who reported the
- 3:29phone call to police at the time, said she made
- 3:32the connection after hearing Huerman's voice in a now viral
- 3:35interview on YouTube about his work as an architect. I
- 3:40remember rewinding it and playing it over and over again,
- 3:43Carnes said. And I'm sure that's a voice that gets
- 3:46burned into your mind. Somebody calls you and says that
- 3:49about your missing friend. Pretty sure that's a voice that
- 3:52you will never forget. The investigation into the Long Island
- 3:56serial killer focused on cell phones used from the beginning.
- 4:00According to investigators, the victims, known as the gilg for
- 4:05posted advertisements on Craigslist and then used their own cell
- 4:08phones to connect with clients. And in this day and age,
- 4:12if you're going to use your cell phone and think
- 4:14you're going to get away with crimes, breaking news, you're not.
- 4:18They're gonna hit you with all kinds of warrants. You're
- 4:20gonna get blasted with a geofense warrant probably, and lord
- 4:24knows what else. So all of these people who think
- 4:27they're smooth, who think that if they turn their cell
- 4:30phone off, I'm looking at you, Brian Kohberger, that you're
- 4:33gonna get away with it, well, breaking news, you're not,
- 4:37the police claimed. The killer meanwhile, use separate burner phones
- 4:41to contact each victim and in doing so, gave them
- 4:44their first clue. So when he was riding around with
- 4:48the Burner phone in his pocket, he was also riding
- 4:51around with the phones of his victims. This is according
- 4:55to the police report and the bell warrant that came
- 4:59out previously, And we now know that him driving around
- 5:03with those cell phones and those cell phones pinging off
- 5:06of those towers was a vital building block in this investigation. Remember,
- 5:12all of that digital information is used as foundation, so
- 5:17they use it as a foundation to build their case on.
- 5:19And when they're talking about Ewermen here, well it's not
- 5:22only digital. They also found the DNA at the scene.
- 5:25So when you tie all of that together and you
- 5:28look at the totality of the evidence, it is all
- 5:31bad for a Rex Ewermen and Mark by words, his
- 5:35team and him. They're going to attack the process, not
- 5:38the evidence that's been compiled. We had cell site hits
- 5:42in two areas in Massapeka Park and also in midtown Manhattan.
- 5:46Suffey County Police Commissioner Rodney Harrison told ABC News the
- 5:51authorities claimed the killer also used the cell phone of
- 5:54one of his victims, Melissa Bartholemy to make a series
- 5:58of taunting calls to her family in Buffalo, New York,
- 6:01in the summer of two thousand and nine. Those calls
- 6:04allegedly pined from towers near New York's Penn Station and
- 6:08other areas of Manhattan, and with that location being so busy,
- 6:13it was very hard for them to pinpoint who was
- 6:16making these phone calls. But after a while, with all
- 6:19of the evidence that they have compiled over the years,
- 6:22they were able to build this profile, and that profile
- 6:25led them directly to rex Ewermen. But if he didn't
- 6:29have those burner phones on him, and he wasn't traveling
- 6:31around with those burner phones, it would have been a
- 6:34lot more difficult for the authorities to pin this on him.
- 6:38I'm watching your sister, rot the killer said to Bartholemy's
- 6:41younger sister, according to multiple sources with knowledge of the
- 6:45phone calls. Knowing about those phone calls, and if rex
- 6:49Ewerman's the man they're saying that he is, you could
- 6:52take this fool up to the Empire State Building and
- 6:54shove his fat ass off for all I care, Because
- 6:57anybody who's that demented doesn't deserve to share any air
- 7:01with the rest of us, and that even includes being
- 7:04in prison. Why should the taxpayers be on the hook
- 7:07for somebody like Rex youwer Men if he is convicted,
- 7:10instead of him sitting around forever in a jail cell
- 7:13on the dime of the New York State taxpayer. How
- 7:16about we get a helicopter and just find the volcano,
- 7:20and if we're really feeling industrious, we could have a
- 7:22Glain Maxwell drive that helicopter and crash that bitch right
- 7:26into the volcano and get a two for one. It
- 7:30wasn't until twenty twenty one that investigators, including the FBI,
- 7:34said they were able to use advanced phone analytics to
- 7:37hone in on an area of Massapeka Park, some seventeen
- 7:41miles from Gilgo Beach, where they believe the killer likely lived.
- 7:46There was a little bit of what we called a
- 7:48box where our potential suspect was making these phone calls
- 7:52to our sex workers, Harrison said. The next breakthrough in
- 7:55the case came in the form of an old clue
- 7:58that police revisited. In March of twenty twenty two. A
- 8:03witness reported seeing a dark green Chevy Avalanche parked outside
- 8:07of the home of Amberlin Costello in Babylon, New York,
- 8:11the day before she disappeared in September of twenty ten.
- 8:16But the problem was James Burke and the rest of
- 8:19the crooked cops in Suffolk County at the time pushed
- 8:23all of this under the rug. They didn't care. All
- 8:26they cared about was James Burke getting out from underneath
- 8:29the FBI investigation that he found himself under. And in
- 8:32their mind, these women were nothing more than just prostitutes,
- 8:36so who cares about an investigation. The witness told police
- 8:39that Costello met with a client that same day, someone
- 8:43the witness described as a white male, approximately sixty four
- 8:47to six six in height and in his mid forties,
- 8:50with dark, bushy hair and big oval style nineteen seventies
- 8:55tye eyeglasses. According to core documents in the case, seems
- 8:59like if that fits your min huh almost to a t.
- 9:03And then you go back to the avalanche that they
- 9:05found and add that up with all of the other
- 9:07circumstantial evidence, and what you have here, folks, is a
- 9:11tight ass case. And Rex youwer Men and his legal
- 9:14team they understand that. Again, pay very close attention to
- 9:18who attacks the process, and almost to a person, the
- 9:22people that opt for that strategy are people that don't
- 9:26have any evidence of their own innocence. And before anybody
- 9:29even starts with the whole oh you're innocent until proven guilty,
- 9:32come on, who believes that you better have some evidence
- 9:35to back up what you have to say. You can't
- 9:37just show up and be like, well, but it wasn't me,
- 9:40I'm heading home. Okay, where are your phone records? Who
- 9:42were you with? Can they corroborate your story? So when
- 9:46I say evidence, that's what I'm talking about. Providing basic
- 9:49evidence about the things that you say you were doing.
- 9:52You have to be able to back that up. So
- 9:54that's what I mean when I say you better have
- 9:56some evidence as a defendant. Last year, investators were able
- 10:01to determine that Hewermen, who lived in Massapeka Park and
- 10:04fit that physical description, owned a Chevy Avalanche. In twenty ten,
- 10:10we were able to capture, we were able to seize
- 10:13that Chevy Avalanche, pursue into a search warrant, and were
- 10:16certainly going to analyze that, Suffolk County District Attorney Ray
- 10:20Tierney said at a press conference the afternoon after Hewerman's arrest.
- 10:25Once authorities established hewer Men as a suspect. They conducted
- 10:29surveillance on his daily life, issuing three hundred subpoenas and
- 10:33search warrants to collect potential evidence. In January twenty twenty three,
- 10:39an undercover team watched from security cameras as Hewerman allegedly
- 10:44tossed a pizza box into a trash can outside of
- 10:47a midtown Manhattan office. The team retrieved the box, which
- 10:52contained a partial piece of pizza crust that was later
- 10:56tested for DNA. It proved to be a ninety nine
- 11:00nine point nine to six match to the hair found
- 11:02on one of the victims at Gilgo Beach, according to authorities.
- 11:07Michael Brown, Huerman's attorney, scoffed at reporters who asked about
- 11:11the alleged physical evidence following Huerman's court appearance on July
- 11:16fourteenth in Riverhead, New York. I didn't see any evidence,
- 11:20did you, Brown said, claiming the government's case against his
- 11:23client is very circumstantial. This guy is out to lunch. Circumstantial.
- 11:29Huh okay, I guess can you explain the hairs on
- 11:33the victims? Can you explain the other circumstantial evidence that
- 11:36all ties up in the totality to look like your
- 11:39client is guilty. Can you explain any of that? Please?
- 11:43None of that circumstantial. The hunt for the killer began
- 11:47with the disappearance of Shannon Gilbert, a twenty three year
- 11:50old escort from Jersey City, New Jersey, who disappeared on
- 11:54May one, twenty ten, from Oak Beach, a gated community
- 11:59on the south shore of Long Island. The police search
- 12:03to find Gilbert led to the discovery of four sets
- 12:06of human remains dumped in thick bramble along Ocean Parkway
- 12:11at Gilgo Beach in December of twenty ten. The women,
- 12:16three of them wrapped in camouflage burlap, were all bound
- 12:20in a similar fashion and placed approximately five hundred feet
- 12:23apart from one another. Gilbert's body was not among the
- 12:27first fore found in Gilgo Beach. The search, consisting of
- 12:32canine and marine units, expanded to the surrounding area with
- 12:36the assistance of the FBI. And it's crazy to think
- 12:40that if it wasn't for the Shannon Gilbert tragedy, lord
- 12:44knows when and if we would have ever found any
- 12:47of these other women. So Shannon Gilbert, while her story
- 12:51is obviously sad as hell for her family, it's also bittersweet, right,
- 12:57because there is a little bit of silver lining you
- 12:59can take out of this if you're Shannon Gilbert's family,
- 13:04and Lord knows, that's a family that could use some
- 13:06silver lining, folks. Gilbert's skeletal remains were found in a
- 13:11marsh in Oak Beach in December twenty eleven. The Suffolk
- 13:15County Medical Examiner ruled her cause of death as undetermined,
- 13:19and police said that they believed her death was an accident,
- 13:23with some investigators theorizing Gilbert drowned in the marsh. And
- 13:28for me, when you look at the whole profile of
- 13:30Shannon Gilbert and you know about the medical history, the
- 13:34mental breaks and stuff like that, I think the most
- 13:37likely scenario here is she had a mental break that
- 13:41led to this. Now I'm certainly willing to see evidence
- 13:44of the contrary, but so far from the evidence that
- 13:48I have seen, it's my opinion that she had some
- 13:51kind of medical episode, meaning a mental break of some sort,
- 13:55and it led to this. The Gilbert family, however, maintained
- 14:00that foul play was to blame for her death. In
- 14:03twenty fifteen, the family retained forensic pathologist doctor Michael Bawden
- 14:08to conduct an independent autopsy. His report concluded that Gilbert's
- 14:12death was likely homicide. Six more sets of remains were
- 14:17found along Ocean Parkway. The skull, hands and forearm of
- 14:22Jessica Taylor twenty whose torso was found in Manorville in
- 14:26two thousand and three, skull, foot hands of Valerie mac
- 14:30twenty four, torso found in Manerville in two thousand, skeletal
- 14:34remains of an unidentified male dressed in women's clothing, unidentified
- 14:39female toddler, and the bones of a woman believed to
- 14:42be her mother, and the skull linked to a torso
- 14:45found in nineteen ninety six on Fire Island, identified in
- 14:49August twenty twenty three as thirty four year old Karen Vergata.
- 14:54To this day, authorities do not know if the deaths
- 14:57are the work of one or more killers, and I've
- 15:00said from the beginning, I think it's one person. Now
- 15:04I am open to evidence, obviously, as I remain agnostic,
- 15:08but it certainly seems to me that this is the
- 15:10work of one person, and that one person is likely
- 15:14rex Ewerman. The investigation into the remaining bodies is still continuing,
- 15:19Tierney said, while rex Euerman's attorney declined to comment when
- 15:23asked if his client was involved in the death of
- 15:26Maureen Brainer Barnes and others found the Long Ocean Parkway.
- 15:30He tells ABC News in part, in a court of law,
- 15:33what's required is evidence and proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 15:37We look forward to defending this case in a court
- 15:40of law. For Sarah Carnes, the pain of losing her
- 15:43friend is as raw today as it was nearly two
- 15:47decades ago. Every time I talk about it, it doesn't
- 15:50get any easier, Carnes said. She said these bright blue eyes.
- 15:54She was very outgoing, very outspoken, And now, two months
- 15:58after rex Ywerman's arrest, Sarah Karnes and others are hoping
- 16:03that the right man has been captured and that their
- 16:05friends and loved ones get the justice that they deserve.
- 16:09All Right, folks, that's gonna do it for this one.
- 16:11All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 16:14be found in the description box.