Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Trump, Reputation Risk, and NCUA’s New Rule
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trekel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I'm flying solo and we'll be discussing N NCAA's proposed
- 0:07rule to eliminate reputation risk.
- 0:10A little bit of background previously, NCA.
- 0:13Chairman had come out with a press release that they were going to
- 0:16be getting rid of reputation risk.
- 0:18Then they sent out an email to all CEOs from the office of examination
- 0:24of insurance indicating they were getting rid of all risk ratings.
- 0:28And then October 20th, just yesterday, they came out, with a proposed rulemaking
- 0:33to take further action to solidify removal of use of reputation risk.
- 0:38And I'm gonna walk through what that proposed rule goes into and then give
- 0:42you a little bit of my take on what it means and what it does not mean.
- 0:46Alright.
- 0:47As I stated, NCOA is is proposing a rule that says we will be a.
- 0:53Creating the elimination of reputation risk.
- 0:55They're formally proposing to codify the removal of reputation
- 0:59risk from its supervisory program.
- 1:01Examiners will no longer be able to cite and rep, cite it in reports, use it in
- 1:06ratings or base supervisory actions on it.
- 1:08So they've already done that.
- 1:10They're codifying it.
- 1:11Codifying.
- 1:11What does that mean?
- 1:12That means they're putting it in regulation.
- 1:14To me the biggest corollary here would be succession planning, which they had.
- 1:21Previously not handled, and then they handled it via a letter to credit unions.
- 1:26And then under the Harper LED board, they put it out as a proposal to a regulation,
- 1:31and then they approve that regulation.
- 1:33So once it's codified, once it's in the regulations or the regs,
- 1:39as we like to say, it takes a board action to unwind that.
- 1:44My instinct is that the Trump administration is asking all the banking
- 1:48re regulators to codify this so that bell has been wrong, and it would
- 1:53have to be UNR at the politician and board po board level at any agency.
- 1:59Instead of someone coming in and saying, Hey, we're gonna change this policy.
- 2:03And having it done at a staff level makes it harder to take it out.
- 2:07That's what codifying does.
- 2:09Alright.
- 2:09Number two, why reputation, according to NCUA, reputation risk is problematic.
- 2:14It's subjective and hard to measure.
- 2:17I'll give 'em that Leads to examiner.
- 2:20Inconsistency on unpredictability and potential bias.
- 2:25I think that's a stretch.
- 2:26It distracts both examiners and credit unions from
- 2:28managing real measurable risks.
- 2:31I'm not sure I agree with that either.
- 2:32Let's go back to it's subjective and hard to measure.
- 2:35Sure.
- 2:36So is unsafe and unsound.
- 2:37And I'm gonna get into a proposal.
- 2:40On another podcast on another day in another week, about the federal
- 2:44regulators and other agencies coming out with a proposed definition of safe
- 2:48and sound, which I believe NCOA would probably follow if they get to that.
- 2:51But what's safe and sound?
- 2:52What is safe and sound?
- 2:54What's beauty?
- 2:55What's reputation risk?
- 2:56Yes, they're all subjective and hard to measure, but reputation risk is not the
- 3:00only hard to measure thing that NCOA and other regulators have to deal with.
- 3:04They're doing this.
- 3:06Because they think reputation risk was misused in the
- 3:09past, and I'll get into that.
- 3:11So in the proposal, there is explicit reference to political reasons.
- 3:15The proposed rule is clear that NCA cannot act for political reasons.
- 3:20Now, if you asked every employee at NCA, if they believe they could
- 3:25not act for political reasons, they would say, of course not.
- 3:27We don't act for political reasons, doesn't get it into
- 3:30unconscious bias and all that, but.
- 3:34Do do NCA staff believe they do that?
- 3:36I would bet dollars to donuts that, that they don't believe they do it.
- 3:41Examiners cannot pressure a credit union to deny or close accounts
- 3:44based on political beefs or lawful or unpopular activities.
- 3:48I would bet again that's never happened at in any NCA examinations.
- 3:53There were situations in other.
- 3:56Types of financial institutions where this was alleged as having
- 4:00happened recently, and then under President Trump's first term.
- 4:05So there is an alignment here with the White House.
- 4:08And again, we have a board of one at NCUA one Republican and they're trying
- 4:12to carry the water of the White House 'cause that's what they do, right?
- 4:15No, no criticism here.
- 4:16It's just the reality of agencies are.
- 4:20Going to move in the direction of whoever's in the White House.
- 4:23So the proposal directly aligns with President Trump.
- 4:27President Trump's executive order.
- 4:301, 4 3, 3, 1.
- 4:32Guaranteeing fair banking for all Americans.
- 4:35The goal is to prevent regulators from using reputation risk as a pretext
- 4:39to cut off lawful financial services.
- 4:43Now, in the past there was operation choke point where allegedly.
- 4:48Individuals who had gun stores were not, had their accounts closed.
- 4:52And then there was the pillow guy I can't think of his name who
- 4:55had his his businesses allegedly shut down for the wrong reasons.
- 5:00And again, I'm not going into the facts of whether that happened or that
- 5:02didn't happen, but that's the argument.
- 5:06Now there are allegations of politically driven account closures.
- 5:11President Trump has argued that banks and credit unions have closed accounts
- 5:15of Republicans and conservative groups citing reputation risk.
- 5:18I don't think he's actually named credit unions.
- 5:21So let me clarify that.
- 5:22I believe he's said that banks have not credit unions.
- 5:25Now, whether proven or not, the perception was that lawful, but disfavored groups.
- 5:30We're being punished.
- 5:31Again, that's the perception, and in making this rule,
- 5:35they're saying it's the reality.
- 5:37Now, some generic examples of at-risk groups, political campaigns
- 5:40or advocacy groups, faith-based nonprofit, nonprofits with controversial
- 5:45positions, lawful politically sensitive industries like firearms, as I
- 5:49mentioned, payday lending or marijuana.
- 5:52So those are, that they highlight as.
- 5:55Being impacted for reputation, risk, citations, and examinations.
- 6:01The there's a focus on there.
- 6:04They want examiners to focus on real risks instead, so that's credit risk,
- 6:09liquidity, risk, interest rate risk, cybersecurity, operational mis risks
- 6:14are measurable and belong exams, as opposed to reputation risk, which
- 6:18do not according to this proposal.
- 6:20Again, reputation risk adds little value to safety and soundness.
- 6:23Oversight according to the proposed rule.
- 6:26Now, credit unions the other takeaway from the rule is that credit unions
- 6:30know their members best management, not regulators should decide how
- 6:34member perception affects strategies.
- 6:36Examiners are not equipped to measure public opinion or member trust.
- 6:40I would agree with that.
- 6:43Prohibited Exam Pro.
- 6:44So what are the prohibited examiner actions under the proposed rule?
- 6:48Under this rule, examiners cannot require a credit union to close accounts,
- 6:52cannot discourage offering services, cannot terminate vendor or third party
- 6:57contracts, cannot pressure credit unions to avoid lawful businesses.
- 7:01Again, if you ask.
- 7:02Your examiner, do you do any of these, those things?
- 7:04Have you ever done any of those things in your 10, 20, 30 years?
- 7:08As an examiner, they would say no, wouldn't even contemplate it.
- 7:10But this codifies it again, it puts it in the law.
- 7:14So there's a broad definition of adverse action which includes exam, downgrades,
- 7:20negative feedback, denial of applications, or even informal supervisory pressure.
- 7:24Any examiner action designed to punish or steer a credit union based on reputation.
- 7:29Is off limits.
- 7:31Now.
- 7:32What about state regulators?
- 7:33What's the context as it relates to state regulators?
- 7:36State examiners may still apply a reputation risk if they choose, but N
- 7:40two a examiners must not participate or enforce in that discussion or that
- 7:46being brought up in an examination where it's a joint examination where
- 7:50NCOA is there, or if NCOA in your state does solo examinations, they
- 7:54won't touch that, because again this.
- 7:57Proposed rule.
- 7:57When final we'll make it we'll make it a a third rail, if you will.
- 8:04So it's a wide scope of doing business with in the proposal.
- 8:09It goes beyond accounts.
- 8:10It covers vendor contracts, employ employment decisions,
- 8:13and even charitable giving.
- 8:15It ensures that there are no back doors, ways for regulators to influence.
- 8:20Credit union relationships?
- 8:21That would be the goal.
- 8:22'cause there are no absolutes in life, but that's their goal.
- 8:26So it's already in effect because on September 25th, NCOA told staff
- 8:30and credit unions that reputational risk would no longer be used.
- 8:34The rule simply cements that policy into law.
- 8:37And again, why into law?
- 8:39Why codify it?
- 8:40Because it has to be changed by the NCA Board going forward, again, presuming
- 8:45that it's approved by the board and since it was proposed by a board of
- 8:48one, you can bet your bottom dollar that it will be approved by a board of one.
- 8:53Or if Trump puts new board members in it will be voted on that, I
- 8:56guess theoretically the one way.
- 8:58It wouldn't happen, would be if somehow the Supreme Court would decide that
- 9:02Otsuka and Harper need to come back before it was voted on in, in its final form.
- 9:07If they did come back after they put it in place, theoretically you could have
- 9:11the two Dems then unwind that rule.
- 9:14So what are the expected.
- 9:16Benefits greater objectivity and consistency in exams, more clarity
- 9:21for credit unions, managing examiner expectations, and it protects credit
- 9:26unions from being dragged into political or cultural disputes.
- 9:29Again, those are the expected benefits from the author.
- 9:32You could argue that just by proposing this, they're getting pulled into
- 9:35the political disputes again, and depending on which side of the aisle
- 9:39you're on, or if you're not in the aisle and you're in the middle.
- 9:43No new compliance costs since reputation risk was already discontinued.
- 9:47This rule creates no new burden.
- 9:49So that's funny.
- 9:50They discontinued it in September.
- 9:52They propose a rule in October and say, since we discontinued it in policy
- 9:55in September, there are no costs.
- 9:57That's a tricky way of avoiding some of the.
- 10:00How much does this cost and is it a major rule?
- 10:03And all those kind of nuances tied to regulation making.
- 10:07So instead it reduces uncertainty and increases predictability is what it.
- 10:12Here's the thing.
- 10:13The NCA proposal directly addresses a headline issue.
- 10:16President Trump has said that reputation risk was used as a pretext
- 10:20to shut down Republican accounts.
- 10:22Whether you buy into that narrative or not, this rule is designed to make
- 10:26sure examiners cannot get involved and those kind of politically.
- 10:30Driven decisions, and I guarantee you they don't want to.
- 10:34That's it, that's the take on this proposed rule.
- 10:37And as it gets finalized, as more come up, comes out on it, I will have follow ups.
- 10:42I will have a separate short podcast on the elimination of all the risk areas
- 10:46and more to come on that down the road.
- 10:48As always, I appreciate you listening.
- 10:50I appreci appreciate you watching.
- 10:52This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.