Latest / In God We Trusted / Is Christianity Compatible with Communism?
Transcript
- 0:02[music]
- 0:11Welcome to In God We Trusted. I'm your
- 0:12host, Will. I'm here alongside Sam. Sam,
- 0:14what are we talking about today?
- 0:15>> Today, we're going to be talking about
- 0:17the commies.
- 0:18>> I hear report cards we handed out today.
- 0:21What were your grades?
- 0:23>> Uh uh uh.
- 0:25>> Quit Stalin and answer your father.
- 0:28>> [laughter]
- 0:29>> No, we're going to be talking about
- 0:31communism and why it doesn't work. How
- 0:34what the Bible has to say about it. How
- 0:36we got to a place uh in our culture
- 0:39where it influences far more than we
- 0:42think it does. Cuz it's like you look
- 0:43and we're like, "Oh, we're not
- 0:44communists. We still have private
- 0:46property." But even the roots of where
- 0:48communism comes from, the the Marxist
- 0:51ideology, it's very prevalent in our in
- 0:54our culture and our college campuses.
- 0:57And so I want to to hit dead on for
- 1:01Christians who are watching and for
- 1:02other people like why does it not work?
- 1:05Why does the Bible stand absolutely
- 1:08diametrically opposed to the
- 1:11foundational principles of communism?
- 1:13Like that's what we're going to talk
- 1:14about.
- 1:14>> Yeah. Because it's interesting because
- 1:15it's not like, hey, communism just
- 1:18doesn't work. But philosophically with
- 1:21the Bible, even flirting with communism
- 1:23is not an option.
- 1:24>> That's correct. Like the Bible
- 1:26absolutely comes and says no. Like you
- 1:29may not go there. There's a a great
- 1:31quote by Martin Luther King Jr. and he
- 1:33says this. Communism and Christianity
- 1:36are at bottom incompatible.
- 1:39>> Absolutely right. One cannot be a true
- 1:42Christian and a true communist
- 1:44simultaneously. How then is communism
- 1:47irreconcilable with Christianity? They
- 1:49represent diametrically opposed ways of
- 1:51looking at the world. Spoton. We must
- 1:54try to understand communism, but we can
- 1:57never accept it and be true Christians.
- 2:00Which is a statement that's even more
- 2:01bold than what I would say. I would say
- 2:03you could be a really misguided
- 2:05communist and still go to heaven and
- 2:06have a relationship with Jesus. You're
- 2:08just wrong.
- 2:10>> He's saying we cannot accept it and be
- 2:12true Christians. That's that's a that's
- 2:14a strong cup of coffee right there. Like
- 2:17that's a strong statement. But I think
- 2:19in principle he's right. like communism
- 2:23is the antithesis of what the Bible
- 2:26teaches. All right. So, where do we
- 2:27begin with all this?
- 2:28>> Well, I think a good place to start is
- 2:30to to recognize that the motives are are
- 2:33noble. Like, what is it that a
- 2:36communist, somebody who is drawn to
- 2:39Marxism or communism, what is it that
- 2:41they want? Quality, everyone being okay.
- 2:44Yeah. Level standards of living, that
- 2:46kind of thing.
- 2:46>> There there you look at it and it's
- 2:48like, man, I I don't like oppression. I
- 2:51don't like suffering. I don't like the
- 2:52exploitation of the poor and the
- 2:54marginalized. And so what I want to do
- 2:56is to bring about a system that compels
- 3:00equality, that absolutely requires
- 3:02everybody to lay down their personal
- 3:04possessions, to lay down everything that
- 3:07they have, everything. There's no
- 3:09private property ownership. There's none
- 3:11of that. And we're going to distribute
- 3:12it equally. And you're it's like, oh,
- 3:15sharing. Well, I I learned in preschool
- 3:17that that's a really good thing.
- 3:20caring.
- 3:20>> That's right. So, why would a Christian
- 3:23not want that? And so, this is where
- 3:25communism has a fatal flaw. There's
- 3:27there's two things in in my opinion that
- 3:30cause communism to have a fatal flaw.
- 3:32One, you have to deny God. Every single
- 3:36communist regime that's ever been tried
- 3:38in the history of our planet requires
- 3:41the abolition of religion. Markx, when
- 3:44he wrote the Communist Manifesto,
- 3:46required the abolition of religion. And
- 3:48why would that be? Because if you're
- 3:50establishing a communist state where the
- 3:53government reigns supreme over
- 3:54everything and it determines it's over
- 3:56the family, it's over children, it's
- 3:58over the church, it's over everything.
- 4:02You cannot have a competing higher
- 4:04power. So if you're going to have a
- 4:06church, it's a church that bows the knee
- 4:08to the dear communist leader and says,
- 4:10"We'll affirm everything you teach." And
- 4:12in all these things like you stand
- 4:14against them. There's a reason in last
- 4:16century more than 100 million people
- 4:18were killed by communist regimes. But
- 4:21like let's let's jump in. According to
- 4:24Markx who wrote the communist manifesto
- 4:26kind of gave birth to this whole thing.
- 4:29Listen to what he says. It's a very
- 4:30famous statement. He says religion is
- 4:32the sigh of the oppressed creature. So
- 4:35what is he saying there? It's like it's
- 4:38religion is the way that people that are
- 4:40being exploited find some hope and they
- 4:42just okay I'll continue on in my
- 4:45exploitation because I have this hope of
- 4:47heaven to come and maybe someday my
- 4:49sufferings will be worthy of all this
- 4:52and so I'm just going to continue to
- 4:54endure the pain because I believe
- 4:56something better is coming. And he's
- 4:58like religion it's just the sigh of the
- 5:00oppressed creature the heart of a
- 5:02heartless world the soul of soulless
- 5:04conditions. It is the opium of the
- 5:07people. It keeps them asleep. It keeps
- 5:10them drugged up to where they don't
- 5:12realize how bad they have it. It keeps
- 5:14them from from revolution and
- 5:16overthrowing the tyrannical powers that
- 5:18are oppressing him. And so Markx is
- 5:20coming along and he's like religion is
- 5:22the problem.
- 5:23>> Yeah.
- 5:23>> He says in his writings, communism
- 5:27begins where atheism begins.
- 5:31He says the abolition of religion as the
- 5:35elucory happiness of the people. What
- 5:36does that mean? What does what an
- 5:38arrogant statement? [laughter]
- 5:40>> The abolition. Notice what he's not
- 5:41saying. He's not saying, "Hey, the the
- 5:43abandonment of religion, we're going to
- 5:45we're going to invite people to walk
- 5:46away from religion." What's he say?
- 5:48>> We're going to take it away.
- 5:49>> Abolition of religion is the elucory
- 5:52happiness of the people. And it's the
- 5:54it's the demand for their real
- 5:56happiness. In other words, everything
- 5:58that they're putting all their faith and
- 6:00hope in, it's all a mirage. It's all
- 6:02elucory. It's like it's like they're
- 6:03drugged. They don't know what they're
- 6:05missing. We're going to take it away
- 6:07forcibly so that they can experience
- 6:10real happiness. Like, and you look at
- 6:12history because Marx didn't have the
- 6:14crystal ball to see what his ideas would
- 6:17impose on the world. But how much
- 6:19happiness did communism impose on the
- 6:21world? Not much. A lot of death. Lot of
- 6:23death. Lot of starvation. Lot of
- 6:25cruelty. lot of goologs, a lot of
- 6:28families being torn apart, a lot of
- 6:29churches being burned down, a lot of
- 6:31priests being murdered. Like there's not
- 6:33a lot of happiness that comes out of
- 6:35communism because it abolishes religion.
- 6:38The exact opposite is true, right? And
- 6:41so anything that has a birth certificate
- 6:43that says you have to get rid of
- 6:46religion obviously is counter to
- 6:48Christian belief like by definition,
- 6:52right? You have the first commandment.
- 6:54You shall have no other gods before me.
- 6:56That's what sets Christians apart and
- 6:58capable of fighting for liberty, right?
- 7:00Because it's it's like the apostles
- 7:02after the crucifixion and resurrection
- 7:04when they're walking around in Jerusalem
- 7:05and the leaders are like, "We have to
- 7:07silence these people, threaten them with
- 7:09death." And what do they say? We must
- 7:12obey God rather than men, right? Because
- 7:15there's a higher power. You shall have
- 7:17no other gods before me. There's no
- 7:19government that reigns higher than me.
- 7:22Like you cannot have that,
- 7:25>> right?
- 7:25>> Yeah.
- 7:25>> And so that's a biblical principle.
- 7:28Psalm 14:1 says, "The fool in his heart
- 7:30says there is no God." Like that's just
- 7:32naturally foolish to be an atheist.
- 7:35Everybody instinctively knows there has
- 7:37to be a designer. Everybody in their
- 7:39heart realizes and knows that there's
- 7:42something just that's beyond what the
- 7:44material world is. And the Bible
- 7:46straight up comes out and calls it a
- 7:48fool that would believe that. And then
- 7:51beyond that, like everything about
- 7:54experience in history shows that this is
- 7:56a really bad idea. But going back to
- 8:00what Markx was teaching and this
- 8:02influenced what would come with the
- 8:03Bolevik revolution and the revolution
- 8:05that came to China to impose communism.
- 8:08He says this, "The doctrine of
- 8:10Christianity is an idea that has
- 8:13justified the most revolting
- 8:15oppression."
- 8:16>> Like pot calling the kettle black. Like,
- 8:20but what is what does he point to?
- 8:22Christianity is an idea that has
- 8:24justified the most revoling oppression.
- 8:26Is he right?
- 8:28Christianity, you go through history,
- 8:30there are seasons of the church when
- 8:32they walk away from authentic gospel
- 8:36biblical ethics.
- 8:38where they use religion to justify
- 8:40atrocities. Uh if you look at at like
- 8:44you go back through the the ages where
- 8:46if you had any differing opinions, you
- 8:48could be burned on the stake or or
- 8:49things like that, they would point to
- 8:51that and be like, look, you cannot have
- 8:54religion as the basis for liberty
- 8:56because it's it's it's awful. It
- 8:58oppresses people. And then he says this
- 9:01on the other side. If you have authentic
- 9:03Christianity, people who genuinely
- 9:05believe in the gospel, not the
- 9:07oppressive state, right? Listen to what
- 9:09he says about them. He says, "The social
- 9:10principles
- 9:12>> of Christianity preach cowardice,
- 9:14self-contempt, abasement, submission,
- 9:17humility." In a word, all the qualities
- 9:20of the rabble. So what's he what is he
- 9:23saying? Like Christians are worthless
- 9:24because they're too nice. Yeah.
- 9:26>> They're too humble.
- 9:27>> They don't stand up for themselves.
- 9:28>> That's right. they they'll take offense
- 9:30without retaliation. And we need
- 9:33revolutionaries that are going to take
- 9:35it and and rip it away from those that
- 9:37have it. We need people to stand up, to
- 9:39get angry, to march, to overthrow. And
- 9:43he's like, the Christians on one hand,
- 9:45they're so oppressive, right? The ones
- 9:47that have power. On the other hand, the
- 9:49ones that genuinely believe it, they're
- 9:51worthless. They act like cowards. They
- 9:53allow people to exploit them. which if
- 9:56you're somebody that's in the middle of
- 9:57exploitation and you look around at your
- 9:59Christian neighbor that is just praying
- 10:01for his enemies and showing kindness
- 10:03like you can understand why this would
- 10:05be appealing, right?
- 10:06>> Yeah.
- 10:06>> We can go through church history and be
- 10:08like, "Oh, I don't want that. I don't
- 10:09like that. Definitely don't want to live
- 10:11under a theocracy." Look how gross
- 10:13humanity can be when they do things, you
- 10:15know, pushing their own agenda in the
- 10:17name of God. Awful stuff happens. And
- 10:20vice versa, like when Christians are
- 10:22like, "Look at our culture now. the
- 10:24slide that we've had where so many
- 10:26leaders in the church have been like, "I
- 10:28don't want to offend anyone. You know,
- 10:29I'm not going to say anything hard." And
- 10:30the churches just drift off into
- 10:32irrelevance, right? Because they're too
- 10:34worried about being nice. Well, that's
- 10:36not authentically what the church is
- 10:38supposed to be. But Marx is looking at
- 10:40the worst of both ends, saying, "It's
- 10:42awful. Get rid of it."
- 10:44>> Yeah. And the appeal of communism is
- 10:45like, "I don't want to be a doormat."
- 10:47>> Like, I don't want to be exploited. I
- 10:49don't want to just be like, "Okay, do
- 10:51whatever you want to me. I'll take it."
- 10:53it comes to you and says no like there's
- 10:55a better purpose and a better life which
- 10:57is the appealing part it doesn't satisfy
- 10:59that it can't cash that check
- 11:02>> sense
- 11:03>> but it's understandable so so both of
- 11:05these views like you take Christianity
- 11:07and and whatever form of government
- 11:09you're living in and you put it up
- 11:10against communism both of them come with
- 11:13the the prospect of a utopian future
- 11:16right
- 11:17>> one of them says this world is broken
- 11:20right everybody around you has a fallen
- 11:22nation nature like we're all suffering
- 11:25together. We're in a world where there's
- 11:26death. We're in a world where there's
- 11:28tears. We're in a world where there's
- 11:29pain. But there's a hope of something
- 11:31better coming. Christ is going to redeem
- 11:33this. So press on. Endure. Do the right
- 11:36thing. Try to bring heaven to earth here
- 11:38while you can. But recognize this world
- 11:41is fallen. One of the the death nails of
- 11:44of communism is it denies that. If
- 11:47communism comes along and says, "Well,
- 11:50human nature isn't universally fallen."
- 11:52The problem is us victims, we are the
- 11:56righteous ones. If we had authority, we
- 11:59would be way better than those evil
- 12:01people over there because, you know, the
- 12:03fall or the fallen nature isn't
- 12:04universal. So, we righteous will
- 12:07overthrow them and then we're worthy of
- 12:09being able to be trusted with power.
- 12:11We're the good guys, remember? And how
- 12:13does that work out every single time,
- 12:15guys? That's up.
- 12:17>> They're not good guys,
- 12:19>> right? They're not. They end up being
- 12:21absolutely malicious. They end up
- 12:23killing people. They end up storing all
- 12:25the money for themselves. There's no
- 12:26sharing. There's mass starvations and
- 12:29murders and genocides that happen under
- 12:31communist leadership because all people
- 12:34are fallen and you can't trust anyone
- 12:36with power. And the foolishness of
- 12:38communism is to say, you know what, I
- 12:39really don't trust those people in
- 12:41power. So my solution is to take all
- 12:44power on an even bigger scale and make a
- 12:46bigger government and give it to that
- 12:48guy because he'll be nice to me. He'll
- 12:50he'll follow the rules. And it's like,
- 12:52are you crazy? So your problem is a
- 12:55government that exploits you. And your
- 12:57answer is I'm going to take all power
- 12:59and give it to that guy, all my
- 13:01possessions, all my wealth, all my
- 13:04everything because he'll do me good. And
- 13:07what inevitably
- 13:09that does not work out because human
- 13:12nature is fallen.
- 13:14>> Yeah. The classic line absolute power
- 13:16corrupts absolutely.
- 13:17>> That's the reason why that exists
- 13:19because we've seen it play out
- 13:20historically. It's not just like oh this
- 13:22is a novel concept. It's like no give
- 13:23someone power and see what happens.
- 13:25>> Yeah. So the reason why like the reason
- 13:27why the American form of government is
- 13:29so brilliant is what does it recognize?
- 13:31>> That no one person can be trusted.
- 13:32>> Oh my goodness. We got to separate this
- 13:34as much as we can because humanity
- 13:36cannot be trusted with power. So, we're
- 13:38going to have three different branches,
- 13:39three different roles. We're going to
- 13:41have checks and balances and separations
- 13:43of powers. And there's going to be, you
- 13:45know, a limit to how long they can
- 13:47serve. There'll be terms before
- 13:48elections because we cannot let them run
- 13:51away with power because if they get the
- 13:52opportunity, they absolutely will. So
- 13:55all through our foundation of
- 13:57government, you want to know that one of
- 13:59the number one things that our founders
- 14:01were looking to impose when they wrote
- 14:02the constitution is how do we restrain
- 14:05power- hungry people because all people
- 14:07when they get power become hungry for
- 14:09more. They will exploit. Communism is so
- 14:12foolish because it's like no no they'll
- 14:15be good. We'll give them all the stuff.
- 14:16We'll give them all the keys and power.
- 14:18And the Bible comes along and says all
- 14:20have sinned and fall short of the glory
- 14:22of God. Blood out.
- 14:24Don't give that guy power because he's
- 14:26fallen short. Don't give me power cuz
- 14:27I'm fallen too. Don't give King David
- 14:29power. Don't give anyone that kind of
- 14:31exclusive power except for God who who
- 14:33earns it, deserves it, and is good with
- 14:35it. Jeremiah 17:9, the heart is
- 14:37deceitful above all things. So, I
- 14:39shouldn't just follow my heart
- 14:42and it's beyond cure on your own. Like,
- 14:45the Bible comes when it speaks of human
- 14:48nature and it's not nice. It's not nice.
- 14:52And every time that people try to deny
- 14:54that reality, you know what? I'm just
- 14:55going to live with my windows and doors
- 14:57open and I'm going to leave my keys in
- 14:59my car and I'm not going to lock my
- 15:01locker at school. Like, there's a reason
- 15:03why we have passwords on our computers
- 15:05and codes to get in everything. Why is
- 15:07that? Because deep in our heart, we know
- 15:11human beings are faulty. You don't have
- 15:13to train a kid to be to to steal, to
- 15:15want, to be selfish. You have to train
- 15:18them to be generous because human nature
- 15:20is all about self. Right?
- 15:23>> So, so number one, communism comes and
- 15:25says you can't believe in God. It will
- 15:28overthrow and oppress religion. Two, it
- 15:31denies the basic fundamentals of the
- 15:33biblical story, which is that humanity
- 15:35is fallen and the only chance of a
- 15:37utopia is going to be in in another
- 15:39remade world. This world is broken.
- 15:42That's a reality. And anytime you try to
- 15:44say, you know what, I think the utopia
- 15:46is coming if only this guy gets into
- 15:48power. If this Republican or this
- 15:50Democrat gets it, then humanity will be
- 15:52singing kumbaya. You're a fool if you
- 15:54believe that.
- 15:55>> Like you just are. Humanity's fallen. No
- 15:59one can be trusted with unchecked power.
- 16:01Like no one. And then we get to the next
- 16:03one. Like the Bible comes and says you
- 16:06are and should be allowed to own private
- 16:09property.
- 16:10>> What communism? If you go back to Markx,
- 16:14he says, "The theory of communism may be
- 16:16summed up in a single sentence, the
- 16:18abolition of private property." So
- 16:21that's it. Like he's coming to take away
- 16:22your god to make you happy.
- 16:25>> Yeah.
- 16:25>> And he's coming to take away all of your
- 16:27property and to to communize it to make
- 16:29it all community property, all
- 16:31businesses, your house, your land, your
- 16:33everything. It belongs to all the state,
- 16:36the people, right? And he and they're
- 16:39going to be good to you with it. that
- 16:40nobody we'll all share. It'll be
- 16:42wonderful. You won't have to worry about
- 16:43jobs anymore. And it's like no, the
- 16:47Bible comes along and like even in the
- 16:50ten commandments, the commandment that
- 16:51says you shall not steal
- 16:53>> means I have stuff that can be stolen,
- 16:55>> which means it's yours. Yeah.
- 16:56>> Right. You have property. Yeah.
- 16:58>> So the Bible comes and says you shall
- 17:00eat and the state shall not steal. The
- 17:02people shall not steal. You have stuff,
- 17:04right, that you're entitled to. In Acts
- 17:075:4 it says when Ananas is being
- 17:12condemned for lying about his generosity
- 17:16they say didn't it belong to you before
- 17:18it was sold. So like even in Acts when
- 17:20the early church is sharing everything
- 17:22in common which is where communists go
- 17:25oh see Christianity they they shared
- 17:27everything.
- 17:28>> Yeah. Voluntarily not at the end of a
- 17:30barrel of a gun.
- 17:31>> Yeah.
- 17:31>> Right. like they were so overwhelmed
- 17:34with the love of Christ that they made
- 17:36the decision that I'm going to give to
- 17:39the poor. I'm going to share these
- 17:41things in common. I'm going to do this
- 17:42with one another because I want to care
- 17:44for my brothers and sisters. It wasn't
- 17:46saying, "Oh, Herod, we trust you so
- 17:49much. We want you to take all of our
- 17:50money and we'll trust you to divvy it
- 17:52up." Like they they would never have
- 17:54done that ever. Ever. Ever. Ever because
- 17:57they knew. What would Herod do with it?
- 18:00>> Selfish things. selfish things. He'd
- 18:02reward his friends. He would and he
- 18:03would exploit the very people they were
- 18:05trying to help.
- 18:06>> Right? It doesn't work. Every time
- 18:08government gets involved with these
- 18:10things and takes ownership of things, it
- 18:13doesn't work. Even the Bible's
- 18:15commandment. So that there's a
- 18:16commandment against stealing. There's
- 18:17also a commandment against coveting.
- 18:19>> Oh yeah.
- 18:20>> So how does that work?
- 18:21>> Don't desire what someone else has.
- 18:23>> Yeah. Don't desire your neighbor's
- 18:24goods. Don't desire your neighbor's
- 18:26wife. Well, what does that mean? And
- 18:28that means that the wife is exclusively
- 18:30belonging to that guy. The husband is
- 18:31exclusively belonging to that wife.
- 18:33Their stuff exclusively belongs to them.
- 18:36So the Bible comes and says there are
- 18:38absolutely property rights. And it's all
- 18:40over the place that there are property
- 18:42rights. You look at the laws of Jubilee.
- 18:44Everybody had their own property. They
- 18:45got to keep their own property. In fact,
- 18:47even if they sold it, it eventually went
- 18:49back to their future generations because
- 18:51that property belonged to them.
- 18:54Communism comes and says, "You have
- 18:55nothing.
- 18:56>> Not anymore." the state will take it
- 18:58all, which is just absolutely crazy to
- 19:00me.
- 19:01>> All right, so flat out, number one,
- 19:04communism rejects God.
- 19:06>> Anti-Bible because
- 19:07>> requires it.
- 19:08>> God is a God of the Bible. Two, we have
- 19:10the whole idea of human nature.
- 19:12>> Like the Bible comes to says, "No,
- 19:14everyone is fallen. Sin has entered in
- 19:15this world. No one's above it. No one
- 19:17can be around it. That each of us has a
- 19:19fallen nature, can't be trusted to a
- 19:21certain degree." And three, the Bible
- 19:23again makes it clear that like we own
- 19:25things. Like there's things that God has
- 19:27given you. He's a good God who gives you
- 19:29good gifts and has blessed you with
- 19:31things that are yours. Have the right to
- 19:33do things. [clears throat]
- 19:34>> All right. So, what's number four?
- 19:35Number four is the one that I think is
- 19:38most prevalent in our culture in the
- 19:41West, especially today, and that is the
- 19:44the class struggle. The idea like
- 19:47dividing up people into different
- 19:48categories and being like, "Hey, they're
- 19:50oppressed. They're the oppressors, okay?
- 19:52Hate each other now. And then cobbling
- 19:55together people for the sake of of
- 19:57acrewing power. And it's been so evident
- 20:00in the last couple of decades. And it's
- 20:02really ripped our country apart. It's
- 20:04ripping Europe apart. All of these
- 20:06places
- 20:07that come to the table in the
- 20:09discussion. And here's here's the thing.
- 20:11their their kindness is actually used
- 20:13against them
- 20:14>> because and this this is why it's so
- 20:17confusing honestly
- 20:18>> is if you come to me and you're like hey
- 20:20this particular group is being
- 20:22marginalized
- 20:23my immediate response is what do what do
- 20:27I have to do like let me help I I want
- 20:29to help like how can I get them to not
- 20:31feel that way or to not be that way but
- 20:34what ends up happening is is you want to
- 20:36enter into the story and it's like no no
- 20:37no no we're we're keeping the story
- 20:40going and you see that with what is
- 20:42called intersectionality that you find
- 20:43all over campuses. Uh we're going to
- 20:45talk about this in a in a future
- 20:47episode, but the idea of critical theory
- 20:49that comes along and it it was
- 20:51introduced into America in the early
- 20:531900s, but it became critical theory,
- 20:56which is the power structures are
- 20:59destroying these particular groups. So,
- 21:02we need to destroy the power structure.
- 21:05We need to tear down the government and
- 21:07redistribute. which by the way is Markx
- 21:09did that with economics right the have
- 21:11nots should rebel and overthrow the
- 21:13halves you know and and overthrow it
- 21:15well now it it became not just about
- 21:17that but these communists come together
- 21:19in the early 20th century and they're
- 21:22like okay the great depression happened
- 21:24like we should be having this revolution
- 21:26why are they not revoling why are they
- 21:28not overthrowing the rich and they were
- 21:30like we've got to come up with more
- 21:31reasons for them to be unhappy and so
- 21:33you you had critical race theory come
- 21:35out of that and critical feminist theory
- 21:37and all sorts of theory, you know, queer
- 21:40theory and this that and the other
- 21:41theory. And what did it do is it came
- 21:43along and said, "The power structures
- 21:45are keeping you down. They're out to get
- 21:48you. They are the enemy. Divide
- 21:51everybody up in a million different
- 21:53slices of whatever are you are what's
- 21:55your race? Well, that determines whether
- 21:58you're a good guy or a bad guy. What's
- 21:59your gender? Oh, that determines where
- 22:01you are. What's your sexuality? What's
- 22:03your wealth? What's your what language
- 22:06do you speak?" And I mean,
- 22:06intersectionality divides everybody up
- 22:09in dozens of different ways. And then it
- 22:12it sets them against each other, right?
- 22:16And it's worked brilliantly to cobble
- 22:19together people for political
- 22:23manipulation.
- 22:23>> Yeah. Outrage is the thing that sells.
- 22:26>> It's all over. And and the tragedy of
- 22:28that is now everything is a grievance.
- 22:32>> Everything is a grievance. And it takes
- 22:35away from instances where the real McCoy
- 22:37exists. If there's now because
- 22:39everything's an injustice all the time
- 22:41everywhere. People walk around, you
- 22:43know, terrified to say anything or, you
- 22:45know, because you might be your
- 22:48privilege might be showing or whatever.
- 22:50And so what does it do? And it builds a
- 22:52quiet resentment of this is ridiculous.
- 22:56This is ridicul. And then the real
- 22:58injustices start getting overlooked.
- 23:01>> Yeah. Yeah, it's the boy who cried wolf.
- 23:02100%. 100%. And it's a terrible thing to
- 23:05happen, right? So, what begins by
- 23:08exploiting people to be like, I want to
- 23:10help. I'm in. I'll support this and I'll
- 23:12support that and I'll support this. And
- 23:13they acrewue power and power and power.
- 23:16And the whole point was a Marxist
- 23:17strategy that says, let's go after the
- 23:19marginalized,
- 23:21cobble them together and overthrow the
- 23:24powerful. And then they start imposing
- 23:26things like you know for example if you
- 23:30look at the black community they are
- 23:32like family oriented social values
- 23:35conservatives but you look at the
- 23:37organization black lives matter which is
- 23:39a communist organization by the way.
- 23:41What's one of their main goals? The
- 23:43abolition of the family to get rid of
- 23:46the nuclear family. Like that's one of
- 23:48their goals.
- 23:50How much more ungodly can you get? Yet
- 23:53nobody knows that. You just hear black
- 23:55lives matter. Well, I want black lives
- 23:57to matter. I I absolutely What do I have
- 23:59to do? And so all this is manipulated.
- 24:02You see it in all sorts of things. You
- 24:04see it in the movements of the LGBTQ
- 24:07agenda, which on the basis of people
- 24:09wanting to help and wanting people to
- 24:11feel safe and loved and everything else,
- 24:14it got absolutely insane. And people out
- 24:17of the goodness of their heart were
- 24:18like, "Okay." Until they realized that
- 24:20this was all a power play. This was all
- 24:22political. This was all to to exploit.
- 24:26So what does the Bible have to say about
- 24:28that? Because I would say that the
- 24:29reason why this intersectionality and
- 24:32cultural Marxism is so appealing
- 24:35is because men want that.
- 24:37>> Yeah.
- 24:38>> Good. Like people genuinely want people
- 24:40to feel safe and so they come up with
- 24:42this counterfeit compassion.
- 24:45But the Bible comes along in in
- 24:46Galatians 3:28 and it says, "Look, there
- 24:49is neither Jew nor Greek. Yeah, there's
- 24:52dividing lines. There's no identifying
- 24:54things. There's no like, hey, I'm this
- 24:55and you're that. So, we're against
- 24:57>> That's right. And in Christ, those
- 24:59dividing lines have to go away. There is
- 25:01no slave or free. You're all under me.
- 25:04You There is no male or female. All are
- 25:07one in Christ Jesus. Galatians tells us
- 25:10in 1 Timothy 6-10,
- 25:13it warns of greed. It warns of class
- 25:15envy. It talks about how the love of
- 25:17money is the root of all kinds of evil.
- 25:20Like what does that like? If you have
- 25:21it, I want it. And if I'm going to I'm
- 25:23going to covet and I'm going to tear you
- 25:24down. Nothing good comes from that. So
- 25:27what the Bible comes along and says is
- 25:29look, you're all fallen.
- 25:31>> Yeah.
- 25:31>> You're all suffering the broken nature
- 25:34of the world. You should be able to
- 25:36relate to one another because you all
- 25:38belong to me. You know, if you want to
- 25:40know there's two things and
- 25:41sociologists, psychologists will tell
- 25:43you this. If you want to know things
- 25:45that really bring people together like
- 25:47in strong powerful ways, one is common
- 25:51suffering, right? Like people go through
- 25:54a tornado that tears down their city.
- 25:56Look, watch what the city does. They'll
- 25:59just come together in love and they'll
- 26:00meet each other's needs. My parents
- 26:02experienced this when a hurricane
- 26:04destroyed their house. You look at how
- 26:06the military will put people through
- 26:07boot camp and man, when they suffer
- 26:09together, they're willing to die for
- 26:10each other after that. That's why
- 26:12fraternities do stupid things like
- 26:14hazing because when you suffer with your
- 26:16pledge class, you'll be like, "All
- 26:17right, you're my friends. These are my
- 26:18brothers now.
- 26:19>> We've brothers. We've been through it
- 26:21together." So, common suffering. What
- 26:24does intersectionality say? The premise
- 26:26of intersectionality is you can't relate
- 26:28to me. You can't speak on this. Go away.
- 26:31You there's nothing we have in common.
- 26:33That's of the devil, man. That is
- 26:35absolutely of the devil. It will it will
- 26:38100% keep any joining any brotherhood
- 26:42anything that lays down the weapons and
- 26:44moves forward like the Martin Luther
- 26:46King model brilliant and beautiful right
- 26:50the model that we have today which is
- 26:52just saturated with all this Marxism and
- 26:54envy and hatred and division it's doomed
- 26:57to failure it's doomed to really ugly
- 27:00things so one thing that brings people
- 27:02together is to run in common suffering
- 27:05like I know what it's to be betrayed. I
- 27:07know what it's like to have family
- 27:08members that are sick and die. I know
- 27:10what it's like.
- 27:11>> I can empathize with you.
- 27:13>> Empathy. You can't empathize if you tell
- 27:15me I have no part in your story.
- 27:16>> You're not allowed to speak into my
- 27:18suffering.
- 27:18>> That's right. So, take your privilege
- 27:20and go away. Like, tell me that and it's
- 27:22like, okay, we're done. Like,
- 27:23>> we can co coexist,
- 27:26>> but it's going to be from a distance.
- 27:28>> We'll never relate. We'll never We'll
- 27:30never be brothers. That's gross. Like,
- 27:33stop. We need to stop doing that and
- 27:35tolerating that. But the other one is,
- 27:36okay, there's things that cause you to
- 27:38suffer together that brings you
- 27:40together. The recognition that we all
- 27:43suffer in a broken world with common
- 27:45sufferings. The other one is to run
- 27:48under a common banner to look at Christ
- 27:51or or you know the Florida Gators or
- 27:53what whatever whoever you I know whoever
- 27:56you root for whatever is your cause.
- 27:58Like for a Christian obviously the chief
- 27:59supreme cause is Christ. But I can
- 28:02relate to anybody anywhere in the world
- 28:05who's an authentic Christian because we
- 28:07know the goodness of Jesus, right? It
- 28:09brings us together regardless if we
- 28:10share any other interest. You're you're
- 28:12my brother immediately.
- 28:14>> Yeah. We always have that one thing.
- 28:15>> That's right. What does all the Marxism
- 28:18say? It says those people have none of
- 28:21your interests in mind. They there's
- 28:24there's no compromising. They just need
- 28:27to be defeated.
- 28:28>> Yeah. There's no common ground ever.
- 28:29Don't try to look for it. Don't try to
- 28:30find it cuz it's not there.
- 28:32>> So you play that out. Where does it
- 28:34ultimately end? You I mean you know
- 28:36where it ends, where it's always end.
- 28:39Genocide, bloodshed, revolution, misery
- 28:43for everyone, and starvation. And it's
- 28:46not going to end well for the poor. I
- 28:47promise that
- 28:49it always ends badly. And so this is
- 28:51again, we'll go back to Martin Luther
- 28:53King Jr. who says this, "The Communist
- 28:54Manifesto might express a concern for
- 28:56the poor and oppressed, but it expresses
- 28:59no greater concern than manifesto of
- 29:01Jesus." With this as its opening
- 29:03sentence, the first line he ever
- 29:05preached, "The spirit of the Lord is
- 29:07upon me because he has anointed me to
- 29:09preach the gospel, the good news to the
- 29:12poor. He has sent me to heal the
- 29:14brokenhearted, to preach deliverance to
- 29:16the captives, and the recovering of
- 29:18sight to the blind, to set at liberty
- 29:20them that are bruised, to proclaim the
- 29:23acceptable year of our Lord. So what
- 29:27he's saying is the real McCoy that
- 29:30transforms people to care for the the
- 29:32disadvantaged is the gospel.
- 29:34>> Yeah.
- 29:35>> The counterfeit is communism and Marxism
- 29:39that just trains people to devour one
- 29:41another. And we as a church, as
- 29:44seminaries, as colleges, we've got to
- 29:46get more bold at calling it evil. I
- 29:49believe it's demonic, honestly. So,
- 29:52that's number four. That's a big one
- 29:53today.
- 29:53>> All right. So, that's number four. And
- 29:55five and six, we've kind of talked all
- 29:56throughout, but what's number five?
- 29:57>> Yeah. So, number five, I would say, is
- 29:59the state controlling everything, right?
- 30:02Versus the the biblical authority
- 30:04structure. Like we've talked about this
- 30:06before in other episodes, but if you
- 30:08look at the way God creates the
- 30:10different institutions as creation's
- 30:11unfolding, you know, he is alone. Then
- 30:14he creates Adam and Eve. He sets
- 30:17marriage apart. Then the family comes
- 30:19along. There's commerce structures.
- 30:21Eventually, governments are given. But I
- 30:24think the order in which he that the
- 30:26world comes about also expresses the
- 30:28authority structure that he wants. He
- 30:30reigns, right?
- 30:31>> Yeah. He's God. Then Adam and Eve,
- 30:33marriage becomes the next most important
- 30:35institution. Then the family, then the
- 30:37community and the church and the
- 30:39worshiping
- 30:41world, right? Then the government comes
- 30:43along, right, after the flood. And I
- 30:46think that actually is a good model for
- 30:48how God wants the world to operate.
- 30:50What's the most fundamental building
- 30:52block of a civilization? It's marriage,
- 30:54right? Then it's the home. And then it's
- 30:56the church and the community. And the
- 30:58government exists to serve all of those.
- 31:01Communism does what?
- 31:03>> Birds it
- 31:04>> one. It says, "God, you go away."
- 31:06>> Yeah. You don't exist anymore.
- 31:08>> You don't exist anymore.
- 31:10>> And now I'm going to determine the
- 31:11market. I'm going to determine the
- 31:13community. I'm going to regulate the
- 31:15church. I'm going to take over the
- 31:17family.
- 31:18>> And I'm going to speak to the home and
- 31:21the marriage. And it puts the government
- 31:23as the chief of all things, which is
- 31:26wildly crazy that anybody would want
- 31:29that. It is a it's it's a recipe for
- 31:31dictatorship and misery from the start.
- 31:34It takes away all liberty. But Romans 13
- 31:37comes and says, "Let every person be
- 31:38subject to the governing authorities."
- 31:40It doesn't promote totalitarianism,
- 31:43but it does say, "Hey, you have you have
- 31:45a responsibility
- 31:46to to submit to the king, right? Unless
- 31:50what? Unless the king's against God.
- 31:52>> And if the king is telling you there is
- 31:54no God and all of his policies are
- 31:55godly, what is a Christian called to do?
- 31:57>> We must obey God rather than man.
- 31:59>> That's right. And I would say that
- 32:01compels our rebellion. In Acts 5:29, we
- 32:05talked about this when the the members
- 32:07of the Sanhedrin were threatening Peter
- 32:08and John like, "Stop preaching in
- 32:10Jesus's name." They say, "We must obey
- 32:12God rather than men." Like and so what
- 32:16they say is like you can arrest us, you
- 32:17can kill us, you can do whatever, but
- 32:19I'm going to keep breaking the law
- 32:20because God has told me to.
- 32:22>> And so the Christian should have that,
- 32:24you know, unlike what Markx is saying
- 32:26where the Christians just like, "Oh, I
- 32:27just want to be nice. I don't want to
- 32:29rock the boat or make waves, you know, I
- 32:31just want to be seen as nice." Like John
- 32:33and Peter were not seen as nice,
- 32:35[laughter] you know, like they they were
- 32:37making people pretty mad. They were
- 32:39imprisoned a lot. They were bold for the
- 32:41faith. Paul everywhere he went, you read
- 32:44the book of Acts and it's like things
- 32:45are erupting and breaking out into riots
- 32:47everywhere beat up all the time. Yeah.
- 32:49>> Like this is not a what do I have to say
- 32:50to make everybody happy faith. It's just
- 32:53not like you're called to exalt God, to
- 32:57protect marriage, to protect the family,
- 32:59to promote good commerce and private
- 33:01property rights and protect people's
- 33:03stuff, right? All of that. And the
- 33:06government serves that. That's what the
- 33:08way we were set up like to secure the
- 33:10blessings of liberty, right? That's in
- 33:11our constitution. Governments are
- 33:13instituted among men to protect
- 33:16god-given rights. Hear that? It's at the
- 33:19bottom protecting what has already been
- 33:22given. And that's, you know, communism
- 33:25comes like Markx in his thing. Listen to
- 33:27what he says. The education of all
- 33:28children from the moment that they can
- 33:30get along without a mother's care shall
- 33:32be in state institutions.
- 33:35Do you hear that? Like, and that's
- 33:37exactly what you find in Soviet Russia.
- 33:40That's exactly what you find when China
- 33:42comes along, when Cuba comes along, all
- 33:44these communist regimes, North Korea
- 33:46today, like where the families like the
- 33:51government comes and just takes control
- 33:52of everything and in every place it's
- 33:54tried. It is unbearable for the people.
- 33:59It is a horrible, horrible philosophy
- 34:02and it should be dumped by anybody who's
- 34:06got these really simplistic, naive, oh,
- 34:09we'll just all share and get along. If
- 34:11you believe that, you're a fool. You're
- 34:12just a fool. Stop. Drop it. Walk away.
- 34:16It is toxic. It is proven itself toxic.
- 34:19We should not toy with it. So, that's
- 34:21five.
- 34:23[laughter]
- 34:24>> Where's the Tylenol?
- 34:24>> Yeah. The funny part about communism is
- 34:26like it's not that we haven't done it
- 34:27yet. It's not like the world hasn't seen
- 34:29its effects. It's like the only thing
- 34:30like in our modern world it's like no
- 34:32the hypothesis of science really
- 34:34matters. If we need to test something
- 34:36and if it succeeds it's great. If it
- 34:37fails it's bad.
- 34:38>> Well, it keeps failing. We keep being
- 34:40like let's try it again.
- 34:41>> Yeah. And it's crazy cuz like fascism
- 34:44has proven itself evil.
- 34:46>> Yeah.
- 34:46>> We've had experiments in the last
- 34:47century really bad. We don't want to go
- 34:49back there again. Right.
- 34:50>> Mhm. Communism has had more experiments
- 34:54that have failed and failed even worse
- 34:57with a higher death toll than fascism.
- 35:00And yet we treat we we teach our kids
- 35:02fascism is is awful. We need to avoid
- 35:04it. It's a it's a dirty word. And yet
- 35:06the universities, they keep flirting
- 35:09with Marxist ideology. And it's like
- 35:12they don't teach, you know, the 100red
- 35:13million death toll. They don't teach
- 35:15about the red terror campaign. They
- 35:17don't teach about the killing fields.
- 35:19They don't teach about the oppression in
- 35:21the way that Cuba fell off the map or
- 35:22when you see Venezuela go into a a
- 35:25really hardline socialist stance, how it
- 35:28people starve to death under that stuff.
- 35:30It wrecks people's lives. It has real
- 35:32implications. And as a Christian, if
- 35:34you're loving your neighbor as yourself,
- 35:35you should do whatever you can to
- 35:37prevent that from happening to them,
- 35:39which means standing against Marxism
- 35:42because it's a god-awful ideology. It's
- 35:45terrible.
- 35:46Not that I have a strong stance on it.
- 35:48Like I really do believe it's demonic.
- 35:50It really is. Christians should have
- 35:52nothing to do with that stuff. And
- 35:54number six, like the idea of forced
- 35:57redistribution. And this is one of the
- 35:59ones that I think for well-intentioned
- 36:01people is the most confusing because
- 36:03it's like why wouldn't you want to force
- 36:05the rich to take care of the poor?
- 36:08>> And I think they should, right? But it's
- 36:10the the question then becomes can you
- 36:12can you force it?
- 36:14>> Yeah. Because if you give that power
- 36:15away to where the church controls where
- 36:17property goes and who gets what, right?
- 36:20To that degree, you run into some
- 36:22problems. And so, what's the idea of
- 36:24biblical charity? Biblical charity, like
- 36:27Acts 2, we've talked about where they're
- 36:29sharing all things in common. What's the
- 36:31difference between that and communism?
- 36:33>> Voluntary.
- 36:34>> It's 100% voluntary, right? It's it's
- 36:37compelled from the heart.
- 36:39>> Yeah. Cheerful giver,
- 36:40>> right? 2 Corinthians 9 says this, "Each
- 36:43one must give as he's decided in his
- 36:46heart, not reluctantly or under
- 36:50compulsion." H for God loves a cheerful
- 36:54giver.
- 36:55>> Proverbs 14:31, "Whoever oppresses the
- 36:57poor shows contempt for their maker, but
- 36:59who whoever is kind to the needy honors
- 37:03God." Like this is a choice that's left
- 37:05to them. This is written by the king. He
- 37:07could have said, "Everyone give to the
- 37:09poor or you're or you die." He doesn't.
- 37:11What does he He compels them
- 37:15to give out of the goodness of their
- 37:17heart. And there's safety nets in
- 37:18society.
- 37:20>> But it's not, "All right, everyone,
- 37:21we're getting rid of all of your
- 37:22property. We're going to compel you to
- 37:24walk away. There's no incentive for you
- 37:25to work anymore. It's just all shared."
- 37:27Like, you'll never find that in the
- 37:29Bible. Acts two, it's all voluntary. And
- 37:32so I think when you walk through those
- 37:36six things, I don't know, you would
- 37:38never be able to convince me
- 37:41that the Bible that Christianity is even
- 37:44remotely
- 37:46aligned with communism for those at
- 37:48least those six reasons. And I think
- 37:51it's a really dangerous ideology that's
- 37:55subtly infused through so much of what
- 37:57we have today. this culture of envy and
- 38:00resentment and and bitterness that's
- 38:02built in where we divide everybody and
- 38:05it's it it's it's going to lead to bad
- 38:09places. But also
- 38:11why this is a a a challenge to the
- 38:15church, right? If people are running to
- 38:18the government because the poor are not
- 38:21being cared for.
- 38:22>> Yeah. Why aren't you?
- 38:24>> That's an indictment, isn't it?
- 38:25>> Yeah. Like what are what are you doing?
- 38:27If you hate communism so much, what are
- 38:29you doing for the poor, right? Like so
- 38:32you should be a cheerful giver. You the
- 38:34church could take care of poverty. The
- 38:37church could take care of hunger. We
- 38:38give, by the way, in real life. We give
- 38:40four to five times more than people that
- 38:44don't go to church. Like studies have
- 38:45been done. We are the most charitable
- 38:47people in our country. We could be more
- 38:50so.
- 38:52But communism is is not the answer.
- 38:55Every nation where communism tried is
- 38:57tried. Everyone has hurt the poor. The
- 39:01movement toward free market liberates
- 39:03the poor every time.
- 39:05>> Yeah. We're talking about this so
- 39:06blatantly because it's not just a theory
- 39:08or an idea that's just out there. It's
- 39:09like no, these are real things that have
- 39:12real effects on eternal souls.
- 39:15>> And we don't want that to happen.
- 39:17>> That's right. And so I mean at bottom I
- 39:21think the the reason why people
- 39:22entertain communism except for the
- 39:24people that want to use it to exploit
- 39:25for power
- 39:27>> is they want to see the marginalized
- 39:29helped.
- 39:29>> Yeah.
- 39:30>> Right. So do we. But the difference is
- 39:33one is an atheistic where where does an
- 39:36atheist find their utopia? There's going
- 39:38to come a day when you die. So if you
- 39:40get to find a utopia where's it got to
- 39:42be?
- 39:42>> Got to be here right now.
- 39:43>> It's got to be here. And it adds an
- 39:44urgency like oh my gosh my days are
- 39:46numbered. like I got to do something
- 39:48now. So, let's impose this really
- 39:49radical drastic thing that always
- 39:51results in a bad ending because I'm
- 39:53chasing my utopia now because I don't
- 39:55have a utopia to come. Where the
- 39:58Christian says, "What?" Like Jesus, one
- 40:00of the weirdest things that ever comes
- 40:02out of his mouth is when when Judas
- 40:05comes along and he's rebuking the lady
- 40:07who's anointing him for his burial and
- 40:10he says, "Whoa, this could have been
- 40:11sold and we could have given the money
- 40:13to the poor." And you're like, "That
- 40:14sounds that sounds noble. What does
- 40:16Jesus say? You'll always have the poor.
- 40:18You will always have the poor. Prophetic
- 40:20statement out of Jesus's mouth. You will
- 40:22never have utopia on this side of glory.
- 40:24Ever. Now, you can have flavors of
- 40:27heaven that come down and beautiful
- 40:29stories of of but you will always have
- 40:31the poor. Jesus has told you communism
- 40:33will fail, [laughter]
- 40:35right? But the Christian can live in
- 40:39this world with open hands. Why? It's
- 40:43not about this world. because we've got
- 40:44an inheritance to a far better kingdom
- 40:47to come. So this world doesn't own me.
- 40:49It doesn't define me. My treasure is not
- 40:51here. And therefore, I can live with
- 40:53open hands to bring a flavor of heaven
- 40:55down to help the poor, to help the
- 40:57marginalized. I can give my influence to
- 41:00give them a voice that don't have one.
- 41:02>> Like that is what changes cultures is
- 41:06when people genuinely live for the
- 41:07gospel. And that's what I want.
- 41:10Communism terrifies me. All right. So I
- 41:14think I think we'll close there and the
- 41:15bottom line don't be a commie
- 41:19[laughter]
- 41:19anyway. So thank you for watching. Join
- 41:21us [music] next time on In God We
- 41:23Trusted.
- 41:29[music]