Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / TÜV Report 2026: Reliability and Performance of Electric Vehicles
Transcript
- 0:10Hello everyone, and welcome back to The Deep Dive.
- 0:12Today we are tackling a subject that I feel like has been the
- 0:15centerpiece of every awkward dinner party conversation for
- 0:19the last five years. It's the debate that just won't
- 0:23die. It really is the perennial
- 0:25question. It really is.
- 0:26You know how it goes. You're at a BBQ, someone points
- 0:28at a Tesla or a pole star parked on the street, and suddenly
- 0:31everyone's an engineer. Oh yeah, one side is saying that
- 0:35thing is a ticking time bomb. The battery will cost 30 grand
- 0:38to replace next week and the other side is saying no, it's a
- 0:41spaceship. It'll run for 1,000,000 miles
- 0:44with 0 maintenance. Exactly.
- 0:46It is always been a discussion driven by, you know, tribalism.
- 0:50It's been hype versus fear, marketing versus anecdotes.
- 0:55Right, my cousin's neighbors EV died in a car wash versus my EV
- 0:59drove to Mars and back. But today we are firing the
- 1:02anecdotes. We're done with feelings.
- 1:04We're going to look at cold, hard, massive data.
- 1:06Which is my favorite kind of Dick.
- 1:08We are diving into the Two Report 2026.
- 1:11Now for our listeners who might not be obsessed with German
- 1:14bureaucracy, can you set the stage?
- 1:17What is this report and why should we care about it more
- 1:20than, say, a Reddit thread? Well, this report is basically
- 1:23the heavyweight champion of car reliability studies in Germany.
- 1:27The law is very, very strict. Every single car on the road has
- 1:31to undergo a rigorous technical inspection every two years just
- 1:35to make sure it's safe to drive. And this is all conducted by to
- 1:38sue the Technical Inspection Association, so they.
- 1:40Aren't just like glancing at the tires?
- 1:42Oh. No, no, they are putting the car
- 1:44on a list, shaking the suspension, testing the brakes
- 1:46on a dynamometer, checking every single light.
- 1:49It is thorough, right? And this report, which is
- 1:51published on November 20, 2025, it compiles the results of 9.5
- 1:56million of these inspections. 9.5 million OK that is a sample
- 2:00size I can respect and it. Covers inspections from July
- 2:022024 to June 2025. So this is the most current
- 2:06comprehensive snapshot of vehicle health on the planet.
- 2:09And the reason we're doing this deep dive today is because
- 2:11there's a twist this year, a major milestone.
- 2:15That's right, for the very first time, enough electric vehicles
- 2:18have been on the road for enough years to generate statistically
- 2:22robust data. We have solid numbers on 18
- 2:26different popular EV models. So we aren't just guessing
- 2:30anymore. We.
- 2:30Aren't guessing anymore. And spoiler alert for everyone
- 2:33listening, the results are absolutely wild.
- 2:36We have some EVs that are graduating at the top of the
- 2:38class, you know, straight A students.
- 2:41And we have some very famous, best selling electric cars that
- 2:44are, well, let's just say they're sitting in the corner
- 2:47wearing a dunce cap. It is a massive wake up call for
- 2:49the industry it is and for anyone looking to buy a used
- 2:52car. So our mission today is simple
- 2:55and clear. We're going to strip away the
- 2:56noise and tell you the truth about whether used electric cars
- 2:59are actually reliable. But before we get to the
- 3:01specific winners and losers, we need to understand the playing
- 3:04field. When A2 inspects these 9.5
- 3:07million cars, what actually counts as a failure?
- 3:10OK. So they're looking for what they
- 3:12classify as significant failures or FF.
- 3:15This isn't about, you know, a rattle in the dashboard or a cup
- 3:18holder that sticks. So if my Bluetooth doesn't
- 3:20connect, I still pass. You still pass.
- 3:23A significant failure is a defect serious enough that the
- 3:26car is considered unsafe to be on public roads.
- 3:28Got it. If you get an SF rating, you do
- 3:31not get your inspection sticker. You are not Rd. legal until you
- 3:34go to a mechanic, fix the problem and then come back for a
- 3:37retest. OK.
- 3:38So we're talking about safety critical stuff, brakes, steering
- 3:42lights, that kind of thing. Precisely.
- 3:44And the report breaks everything down by the age of the car, two
- 3:47to three years old, four to five, all the way up to 10.
- 3:50Plus today we're mostly focusing on that two to three years old
- 3:54bracket because that's where most of the modern EVs are right
- 3:57now, right? So before we zoom in on the
- 3:59electrics, what's the general vibe of the car market?
- 4:03Are cars getting better? Because I feel like I'm seeing a
- 4:05lot of clunkers out there lately.
- 4:07Your eyes are not deceiving you. The general trend is actually
- 4:11quite concerning. Across all 9.5 million cars, and
- 4:16the average age of a car in this study is 10.6 years.
- 4:20The average rate of significant failures is 21.5%.
- 4:24Wait. Wait, let me process that One in
- 4:26five cars that drives into the inspection station fails.
- 4:30Yes, they are deemed unsafe to drive.
- 4:33And what's more, that rate increased by nearly a full
- 4:36percentage point compared to the previous year.
- 4:38That feels. Like a move in the wrong
- 4:40direction. Why is that happening?
- 4:41It's. Largely economic, you know,
- 4:43inflation, cost of living. People are squeezed.
- 4:46The car fleet is getting older and owners are delaying
- 4:49maintenance. They hear a squeak in the brakes
- 4:51or a clunk in the suspension. And you just turn up the radio
- 4:53and. Turn up the radio exactly
- 4:54because they can't afford the repair bill, but eventually the
- 4:57inspection forces their hand. I think we've all been there.
- 5:00If I can't hear it, it's not broken.
- 5:02OK, I have to ask this before we get to the E VS just for
- 5:05context, who won? If I want the absolute most
- 5:08reliable car on the road, broadly speaking, in that young
- 5:12two to three-year old category, what am I buying?
- 5:15You might want to sit down for this.
- 5:16It wasn't a Mercedes, it wasn't a Porsche, and it wasn't an EV.
- 5:20The overall winner was the Mazda 2.
- 5:23The Mazda 2, The little hatchback.
- 5:25The very same. Specifically the classic hybrid
- 5:28version. It had the lowest defect rate of
- 5:30any car in the entire study. That is fascinating.
- 5:33It just goes to show that established, you know, mature
- 5:36technology is still incredibly strong.
- 5:38Exactly. Mazda's been building cars like
- 5:41that for decades. They've ironed out all the
- 5:42kinks, right? But now let's get to the main
- 5:44event. The question on the outline Do
- 5:47electric vehicles breakdown more than gas cars?
- 5:49Drum roll please the. Short answer is no.
- 5:52The data is very clear on this. If you look at the averages,
- 5:55electric vehicles match and in many cases actually exceed
- 5:59internal combustion engines in terms of reliability.
- 6:02OK, let that sink in for a second.
- 6:04Despite all the headlines about battery degradation or range
- 6:06anxiety, mechanically they are just as good.
- 6:10But, and this is a huge but, the things that fail on them are not
- 6:15what you might expect, right? I feel like everyone worries
- 6:17about the battery dying. Oh no, I'll have to replace the
- 6:19battery pack that. Is the common fear.
- 6:22But the data shows the high voltage batteries and the
- 6:25electric motors are actually rock solid.
- 6:27They are not the problem. So the heart of the car is fine.
- 6:29What's breaking? The skeleton.
- 6:32The failures are concentrated in three specific areas, lighting,
- 6:36brakes and chassis suspension. Lighting.
- 6:39Really. That seems kind of mundane.
- 6:41Lighting is actually the number one cause of failure for all
- 6:44vehicles, not just EVs. It's usually simple things,
- 6:47misaligned headlights, blown bulbs, or complicated LED
- 6:50matrices that glitch out OK, but the brakes and suspension?
- 6:55That is where the EV story gets really, really interesting.
- 6:58I want to dig into that. There's a quote in the report
- 7:00from Jurgen Vols at Tube Suit that I thought was perfect, he
- 7:05said chassis, brakes and lights require constant maintenance
- 7:10regardless of the power source. It's the truth, and EV is still
- 7:14a car. It still has to deal with
- 7:16gravity and friction, and in some ways being an electric car
- 7:19makes life much harder for those mechanical parts.
- 7:22How so? Walk us through the physics
- 7:23here. We'll take the chassis in
- 7:25suspension. EV batteries are incredibly
- 7:28heavy. We're talking about adding 405
- 7:30hundred, maybe 600 kilograms to the weight of a comparable gas
- 7:33car. That's like driving around with
- 7:34a grand piano and a couple of concert pianists in the back
- 7:37seat all the time. It's a great way to put it.
- 7:40Now imagine taking a corner at speed with that grand piano.
- 7:43The stress on the control arms, the bushings, the axe.
- 7:46It is immense. If the manufacturer didn't
- 7:48reinforce those parts specifically for that weight,
- 7:51they wear out much, much faster. Gravity is the enemy here.
- 7:54Gravity is the enemy of the suspension, but for the brakes,
- 7:57the enemy is, well, it's efficiency.
- 8:00This is what we call the EV brake paradox.
- 8:03I love a good paradox. Explain this one.
- 8:05OK, so electric cards use recuperation or regenerative
- 8:08braking. When you lift your foot off the
- 8:10accelerator, the electric motor reverses and acts like a
- 8:14generator. It slows the car down.
- 8:17And sends electricity back into the battery.
- 8:19Exactly, which is a great feature.
- 8:21One pedal driving is awesome. I barely touch the brake pedal
- 8:25in my EV. And that is exactly the problem.
- 8:27Because you aren't using the physical friction brakes, the
- 8:30iron discs never get hot. They never get scrubbed by the
- 8:34pads, so they sit there cold and damp and they rust.
- 8:38They corrode. So the car fails the safety
- 8:40inspection not because the brakes are worn out, because
- 8:44they're rusty. Exactly.
- 8:45The calipers can even seize up from lack of use.
- 8:48You end up with what look like zombie brakes.
- 8:50They are physically there, but they've sort of rotted from the
- 8:52inside out. That is wild.
- 8:54The car fails because the driver was driving too efficiently.
- 8:57In a nutshell, yes. OK, so we know the general
- 9:00trends. Gravity hurts the suspension.
- 9:03Efficiency hurts the brakes. But surely some car companies
- 9:07have figured this out better than others.
- 9:09Let's name names. Who are the winners?
- 9:12Who is the model student of the EV world according to this 2026
- 9:17report? If you're looking for the star
- 9:18pupil, you look no further than the Mini Cooper SE.
- 9:22The Electric Mini. Yes, it was ranked as a
- 9:24technical model student. It had very few defects in those
- 9:27critical areas, Chassis, brakes, lighting.
- 9:30It seems BMW, who owns Mini, really did their homework on
- 9:34tuning the suspension for the extra weight.
- 9:36That is great to hear because Matey's are supposed to be fun
- 9:38to drive. You don't want the wheels
- 9:39wobbling. Who else did well?
- 9:41The Fiat 500. This one was fascinating.
- 9:43It absolutely dominated the mini car category.
- 9:46And I mean the size category, not the brand.
- 9:47Oh really? It beat out all the gas powered
- 9:49equivalents. Oh wow, so the electric Fiat is
- 9:52more reliable than the gas Fiat? According to this data, yes, it
- 9:55had a significant failure rate of only 4.2%.
- 9:59And for context, remind us what the average is.
- 10:02The average for that 2-3 year group across all cars is closer
- 10:05to 5 or 6%. And remember, the overall
- 10:08average for all ages is over 20%, so 4.2% is excellent.
- 10:12And the Fiat is pretty much the definitive City car, right?
- 10:15It is. The report explicitly mentions
- 10:18it as ideal for urban driving. They noted it's particularly
- 10:21perfect for Italy, which I think implies it handles cobblestones
- 10:24and potholes without falling apart.
- 10:26That's a good sign. OK, so many in Fiat win the
- 10:28small car game, but what if I have a family I can't fit?
- 10:32Two kids in the golden retriever in a Fiat 500.
- 10:34Then you look at the Audi Q4 E Tron.
- 10:37This was a standout performer in the SUV category.
- 10:40It climbed to 8th place overall among all fuel types in the two
- 10:44to three-year age bracket. 8th place overall is huge for a
- 10:47heavy. EV it is, and what's more
- 10:49impressive is the mileage. The average Audi Q4 in the study
- 10:52had about 42,000 kilometers on the clock.
- 10:54That's significantly higher than the Fiat or the Mini.
- 10:57So it's being driven hard. It's a workhorse.
- 10:59It is, and Despite that higher mileage and the heavier weight
- 11:02of an SUV, it only had a 4.0% failure rate.
- 11:05So that really debunks the the idea that high mileage EV's are
- 11:09risky. Completely, it proves that if
- 11:11you engineer the car correctly to handle the weight, a heavy
- 11:15high mileage EV can be incredibly reliable.
- 11:18The Renault Twingo ZE also performed well.
- 11:20So it's not just the luxury brands, OK.
- 11:23So we have our heroes, the Mini, the Fiat, the Audi.
- 11:27But we promised the truth. And the truth is, not everyone
- 11:31passed with flying colors. In fact, some very popular cars
- 11:34did well, remarkably poorly. Yes, we have to talk about the
- 11:39Tesla shock. Let's RIP the Band-Aid off Who
- 11:41is at the bottom of the list. The Tesla model.
- 11:43Y the best selling car in the world.
- 11:45The very same in the category of cars aged 2 to three years, the
- 11:49Tesla Model Y ranked in the absolute last position.
- 11:52Last place out of how many models?
- 11:54Out of 111 models evaluated in that age group, it was dead
- 11:57last. Wow, what?
- 11:58What were the numbers? It had a staggering 17.3%
- 12:02significant failure rate. 17.3% Wait.
- 12:05Compare that to the Audi Q4 we just praised.
- 12:06The Audi was at 4.0%, the Tesla's at 17.3%.
- 12:10That is more than four times the failure rate that.
- 12:12Is a massive gap. We're not talking about
- 12:14statistical margin of error here.
- 12:16That is a chasm. It is significant and the Tesla
- 12:19Model 3 didn't fare much better. It was also among the Schluse
- 12:24Lichter, which is the German term they use.
- 12:26It means the tail lights or the bottom of the pack.
- 12:29The Skoda ENIAC was also down there in the bottom 3.
- 12:32OK, we need to understand why Tesla is known for tech, for
- 12:37software, for superchargers. Why are their cars physically
- 12:41failing inspections so early? It comes back to the specific
- 12:45mechanical stress points we talked about.
- 12:47The suspension is the big one. The control arms and axle
- 12:50suspensions just seem to struggle with the vehicle
- 12:53weight. On the Tesla's, the inspectors
- 12:55are finding worn out bushings and joints that just shouldn't
- 12:58be worn out after only three years.
- 12:59So the suspension is literally buckling under the pressure.
- 13:02In a sense, yeah, the components are wearing out prematurely.
- 13:05But the other big issue, and this goes back to our paradox,
- 13:07is the brakes. Tesla has very aggressive
- 13:11regenerative braking. Right, they are the kings of 1
- 13:13pedal driving. Which means Tesla drivers use
- 13:15their friction brakes less than almost anyone else, so the rest
- 13:19issues on the brake discs are severe.
- 13:21It seems like a cruel irony. The car is so good at being an
- 13:24EV that it fails at being a car. That is a perfect way to put it
- 13:28and they also had some issues with fog lights and lighting
- 13:31alignment. But the suspension and brakes,
- 13:33those are the expensive problems.
- 13:35This. Really highlights that
- 13:36reliability isn't just about gas versus EV, it's model versus
- 13:40model. That is the key take away.
- 13:42You cannot generalize. You have the Audi Q4 at the top
- 13:45and the Tesla Model Y at the bottom.
- 13:47Both are electric. SU VS 1 is engineered in a way
- 13:50that passes inspection easily. The other is struggling with its
- 13:53own weight and braking systems. So let's pivot to the practical
- 13:56side. What does this mean for our
- 13:58listeners? Say I'm in the market for a used
- 14:00car in 2026. I want an EV.
- 14:03What does this report tell me? Well, the good news is that the
- 14:05market is maturing. The report showed there are .8%
- 14:08more EV models with low failure rates than the previous year.
- 14:12The manufacturers are learning and I.
- 14:13Assume this data impacts prices. Hugely, we expect use EV prices
- 14:17to drop in 2026 as supply increases, and this report
- 14:20basically serves as a shopping guide.
- 14:22It helps you distinguish between the safe bets and the risky
- 14:25ones. It gives you bargaining power.
- 14:27Exactly. If you really want to use Model
- 14:29Y because you love the software, you can buy one.
- 14:32But you take this report to the seller and say hey look at this,
- 14:36the suspension is a known weak point.
- 14:38I need $2000 off the price so I can replace the control arms.
- 14:43That is super actionable advice. Now what if I already own an EV?
- 14:48Maybe I have a Tesla or a Skoda, or just any EV with regenerative
- 14:52braking. How do I make sure I pass my
- 14:54next inspection? There is actually a term for
- 14:57what you need to do. It's called break hygiene.
- 15:00Break hygiene sounds like something my dentist would tell
- 15:03me about. It's similar.
- 15:04You have to brush your teeth to keep them clean.
- 15:06You have to use your brakes to keep them clean.
- 15:08So how do I do that? Do I just tap them at a
- 15:09stoplight? No, you need heat and friction.
- 15:12The advice is once in a while, maybe once a week or every two
- 15:15weeks. Find a safe, empty stretch of
- 15:18Rd., make sure nobody's behind you, get up to speed and then
- 15:22brake hard. Like emergency stop hard.
- 15:24Firmly hard enough that the car realizes, oh, the electric motor
- 15:29can't handle this alone and engages the physical hydraulic
- 15:33brakes. You want to hear that?
- 15:34Grind for a second that scrubs the rust off the discs.
- 15:38So, ironically, to maintain your car, you have to drive it a
- 15:42little aggressively sometimes, correct?
- 15:44Use it or lose it and what? About the suspension, can I do
- 15:47anything to save my control arms?
- 15:49You can't really change physics, the weight is the weight.
- 15:53But you should be proactive. Don't wait for the two year
- 15:55inspection. If you hear a clunk going over a
- 15:58speed bump, or if the steering feels a little loose, get it
- 16:00checked immediately. Right, because a loose part puts
- 16:03stress on other parts and suddenly a small repair becomes
- 16:06a big repair. Exactly.
- 16:07The general trend of the report showed people skipping
- 16:10maintenance even though an EV has fewer moving parts, No oil
- 16:14changes, no spark plugs, the parts it does have are under
- 16:17higher stress. Skipping a check up on an EV is
- 16:20a bad idea. It's a shift in mindset.
- 16:22We used to worry about the engine blowing up, Now we need
- 16:24to worry about the car holding itself up.
- 16:26That's the new reality. The propulsion is solved.
- 16:29The structural integrity is the new frontier.
- 16:32This. Has been such an eye opener.
- 16:34I went into this thinking we'd be talking about battery
- 16:36chemistry and instead we're talking about rusty iron and
- 16:39heavy axles. It's always the things you don't
- 16:41expect. So let's summarize for everyone
- 16:43listening. The deep dive take away today is
- 16:46that electric vehicles are proving to be just as reliable,
- 16:49if not more so, than compelling cars.
- 16:53The technology works, but, and it's a big but, you have to pick
- 16:57the right model. And you have to understand the
- 17:00specific needs of that machine. The biggest threat to your
- 17:04electric car isn't the battery dying, it's the rust on your
- 17:06brakes because you didn't use them enough.
- 17:09Which leads me to a thought I want to leave you all with
- 17:11today. We've spent the last 10 years
- 17:13obsessed with battery technology, squeezing every last
- 17:16electron out of the chemistry. But hearing this, I have to
- 17:19wonder, is it time to reinvent the mechanical brake that's.
- 17:22A fascinating question. If the friction brake is barely
- 17:25used, why are we still using big heavy iron discs that rust?
- 17:31Maybe the electric age needs a completely new way to stop.
- 17:34Maybe sealed drum brakes or new materials that don't corrode.
- 17:37It's a great point. The rest of the cars from the
- 17:3921st century, the brakes are from the 19th.
- 17:43It feels like a mismatch. Something to Mull over as you
- 17:46drive home. Now, before we sign off, we want
- 17:49to take a serious moment to say a huge thank you to you, the
- 17:52listener. Yes, thank you.
- 17:53We know how busy life is. You have work, family, friends
- 17:57and about a million other podcasts and videos fighting for
- 18:00your attention. The fact that you chose to spend
- 18:03these 15 minutes with us trying to understand the world a little
- 18:06better, that really means a lot to us.
- 18:08It does. We love digging into these
- 18:10reports and finding the truth in the numbers, but it only matters
- 18:13because you are here to listen to it.
- 18:14So. Thank you for your time, your
- 18:16curiosity, and your trust. We don't take it for granted.
- 18:19We appreciate you. Until next time, keep learning,
- 18:22keep asking questions, and if you drive an EV, go find an
- 18:26empty road and stomp on those brakes.
- 18:27Drive safe everyone, goodbye.