Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Attachment vs Non-Attachment
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org. That's www.a.
- 0:12Me ta GR oup dot-org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:22love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It's January, 19th 2023, 7:35 p.m.
- 0:28Pacific time. And I thought today we would
- 0:32talk about attachment and non-attachment one of my
- 0:36favorite topics from quite a long time ago.
- 0:40I used to teach a course called attachment not attachment to
- 0:42introduce attachment Theory to the idea of not attaching it
- 0:50meditation. They really do mean quite
- 0:52different things. I think though that we sometimes
- 0:57can find ourselves thinking that not engaging.
- 1:03We're detached mode is actually what the Tera vaada Buddhism and
- 1:11meditation is teaching us. I think that comes from the idea
- 1:14that a lot of us who find meditation find it because we
- 1:20are suffering and we want a way out of suffering. and a lot of
- 1:26people who come to meditation in the West, Come because the
- 1:34sources of suffering in their lives.
- 1:37They've identified as difficult interpersonal relationships.
- 1:41And so they're looking for a way to either make their
- 1:45relationships work better or simply not need them so they can
- 1:49move through the world without depending on them.
- 1:53There's a kind of romantic notion about being a cave Yogi
- 1:59and retiring to a cave somewhere and living completely
- 2:03independently. And the idea that meditation
- 2:06could be that vehicle that would allow that to happen.
- 2:13When we were traveling in Myanmar, I asked if there was
- 2:16some caves that we could go and see, I wanted to see what these
- 2:22cave monasteries were like. And so we went to a few of them.
- 2:28Was quite different than I thought wasn't high in the
- 2:31mountains. It was actually next to a
- 2:33village. It wasn't isolated Yogi's.
- 2:38It was like a war and meditation cells dug into the side of a
- 2:45hill. And outside of that, there was a
- 2:49monastery that actually had a couple of hundred monks in it,
- 2:52that supported the people who stayed in the caves and there
- 2:56was a Constant social activity. There wasn't the kind of
- 3:00isolation that I had in my cartoon world dreamed up.
- 3:12In attachment theory, of course, we're talking about making these
- 3:15connections with other people, that feel safe that are actually
- 3:19supportive of us. So that we are emotionally
- 3:21regulated enough and nurtured enough that we can then pursue
- 3:26exploration and derive the meaningfulness of life from That
- 3:33exploration and then have a social network where we can
- 3:37share that experience the experiences of our exploration
- 3:41in. And non-attachment in the
- 3:45Buddhist sense, has a micro. And the macro understanding, I
- 3:53think in the micro sense, all of the sensing experiences arise in
- 3:58pass and we fixate them or attached to them briefly which
- 4:04creates the experience of conceptual reality from Ultimate
- 4:09Reality. And we simply have a light touch
- 4:13which is allows them to come and go without grabbing onto them.
- 4:18Grab is the word that Dan Brown used to use, to describe this,
- 4:23our attention grabs onto a sensing experience, and then we
- 4:26don't want to let it go. And so we resist letting it go
- 4:30and that's the origin of suffering, or we Fixate
- 4:37something. And then we have an aversive
- 4:39reaction to the experience that we attempt to push it away.
- 4:42So the grab is that we don't want it.
- 4:48So that's at the macro level in the in the just the flow of
- 4:54sensing experiences arising and passing where you can push into
- 4:58a flow state with that, they're just coming and going or you can
- 5:01find that you're grabbing onto Pleasant Sensations, resisting
- 5:06unpleasant, Sensations ignoring uninteresting, Sensations.
- 5:15And it's easy to think that in not attaching in the way that we
- 5:19talk about in terms of experience, that that also
- 5:23applies to relationships. We want to get to a place where
- 5:27we don't actually have to attach into relationships.
- 5:32And an attachment theory. Of course, what we understand is
- 5:34that we live in these human bodies, which are designed
- 5:37through Evolution to require complex social interactions.
- 5:45We have these bundles of neurons in the brain which are only in
- 5:51Species that have complex, social interactions.
- 5:56That actually the attachment system causes us to seek
- 6:00proximity to people that we think are safe and who will
- 6:05protect us. And that the one, the attachment
- 6:08mechanism goes off. The only thing that really
- 6:11settles, it is this connection to other people and that it
- 6:16continues to get more and more distressing until we actually
- 6:19find that connection and can settle into it.
- 6:24So the way that I like to think about it is that we want to be
- 6:27able to fully engage in the experience of the present moment
- 6:30which includes fully engaging into connection with other
- 6:34people. At the same time.
- 6:36We don't want to cling to it and cause ourselves to suffer from
- 6:41it. When you're establishing your
- 6:46social network, one of the things to pay attention to is
- 6:50how useful people are to you, in terms of your capacity to
- 6:55regulate and how useful they are to in terms of supporting your
- 7:00exploration. You have a kind of fuzzy
- 7:06romantic idea about the utility of relationships.
- 7:11I think that we're supposed to love people.
- 7:16That are close to us. And that is the main motivation.
- 7:23But I like to cleave apart love and care.
- 7:25We need to take care of people so that they're in good shape to
- 7:29take care of us. And they need to take care of
- 7:31us. So that the support that we get
- 7:34from interpersonal relationships, actually, is
- 7:37useful to the kind of exploration that we want to do.
- 7:45Human babies are, of course, completely dependent on the care
- 7:48that they received to survive. And if they don't receive enough
- 7:52care for the right kind of care, there's actually a Fail-Safe
- 7:56mechanism and, and shuts them down.
- 7:59They don't survive. If they have the right kind of
- 8:04care or enough care, they do grow.
- 8:10And develop, we've all all of us, sitting here have grown and
- 8:14developed throughout our lives. By receiving the necessary care
- 8:21coming from the people that we've been able to put around
- 8:24ourselves and through our own contributions.
- 8:32We are born, we are dependent on care.
- 8:35The care that we give creates the experience with the
- 8:38expectation of what we can expect from ourselves and from
- 8:42the world. And that's the model that we
- 8:46take forward representation of that early experience of care
- 8:51into the world, what we're capable of.
- 8:55But we could expect from other people.
- 8:59Insecure relationships. And according to attachment
- 9:03Theory, the expectation is that you can take care of yourself
- 9:09and the expectation for the world is that there.
- 9:11The world is filled with people who will be happy to engage in
- 9:15relationship with you and share that caring exchange.
- 9:20If you grow up to be dismissing, the ordinary conscious
- 9:26experience of self is that your this was fantastic, a person.
- 9:32And everybody else is not quite up to.
- 9:37It doesn't quite measure up if you would peel away that
- 9:42surface, what you would find is that at the core of, this is
- 9:46this terrible sadness, that nothing that they did, as
- 9:50children was enough to get an adequate response from their
- 9:55caregivers. So there was a terrible sadness
- 9:59at the core of that, which they then Late, the sense of self to
- 10:04avoid touching into. In childhood of course the
- 10:11experience is that there's nothing I can do.
- 10:13I'm not good enough to get the care that I need but as you get
- 10:18older, you flip it. And then becomes I'm this
- 10:22wonderful person but you're not up to taking care of me.
- 10:30So everybody else is the value diminished in that?
- 10:36In terms of exploration because the specific people have a
- 10:40tendency to transact. The care that they want, they
- 10:44pursue things that provide them with the resources that they can
- 10:47then use to transact, the kind of care that they want to
- 10:51receive. It's not reciprocal, it's not
- 10:54collaborative. Secure people tend to
- 10:59collaborate, they recognize that they have an agenda that the
- 11:03other person has an agenda and they collaborate with the people
- 11:07in their lives so that each person can reach a successful
- 11:15conclusion with the agenda that they have.
- 11:18But in dismissing adults really, the dismissing persons adult,
- 11:24the dismissing persons agenda is the only one that matters and
- 11:29the other person degenerate even though they provide care doesn't
- 11:34preoccupied adults think of themselves as inadequate to take
- 11:38care of themselves. They think of everybody else is
- 11:41capable that really their mission in life is to latch on
- 11:46to somebody else who can take care of Because they're, they're
- 11:50unable to do that. this comes from a childhood, where the care
- 11:56that was provided was inconsistent in the child,
- 11:59couldn't predict how they would ask, or what they would have to
- 12:03do in order to get the care that they needed was all always
- 12:07dependent on the state that the caregiver was in, And then
- 12:13disorganized people see themselves as incapable really,
- 12:17of getting the care that they need or undeserving of getting
- 12:21the care that they need. But they see other people as
- 12:24perpetrators as people who will harm them.
- 12:27And so they have a tendency to withdraw, from social
- 12:31interaction. But these become views that are
- 12:36fixed. We talked about that in
- 12:40understanding the nature of how we experience things.
- 12:43You can create a view that gets quite fixed and then you think
- 12:47that that's actually how it is. So we're talking about here than
- 12:53in the non-attachment side of things is that this is a view
- 12:58that's been formed by conditioning.
- 13:01We need to begin to penetrate into the The experience that
- 13:06formed these views and then stop clinging to them, stop grabbing
- 13:11onto them and allowing them to open up so that we can see,
- 13:16clearly what actually is happening now, in the present
- 13:20moment that making sense. Until we do this through a
- 13:27different meditation practices for seeing how we make things.
- 13:32So you have the capacity to sense the object that can be
- 13:37sensed by that capacity. When there's contact, a
- 13:41consciousness of that sensory experience arises, it's
- 13:46evaluated for urgency. Does it need immediate
- 13:48attention? Does it not matter whether we
- 13:51get to it? Is there time for pleasant
- 13:54experience, then? The process of it is ordered.
- 14:02As a particular sensing experience gets the top of the
- 14:05queue, it's compared to perceptual compared to the
- 14:10perceptual database. And if there's a previously
- 14:16experienced, Sensing experience in the database that map's
- 14:22closely to the current one, the meaning attaches to the
- 14:27undifferentiated sensing experience.
- 14:29So attaches is what we when we say attached or non-attachment
- 14:34Buddhism. What we mean is that the raw
- 14:38undifferentiated unpick sated sensing experiences attached
- 14:42with meaning and becomes a representation of conceptual
- 14:47reality In that process of conceptual reality is also the
- 14:54intention that we might take in the action that we might take.
- 14:57And if we do take an action, what result there is from taking
- 15:02the action. As we begin to see the
- 15:11conditioning. And one of the reasons I like
- 15:14attachment theory is because it describes patterns of
- 15:18conditioning that are recognizable.
- 15:21When we begin to do the meditation work of trying to
- 15:24decode this, the whole experience of self and world.
- 15:32In the beginning, can be quite daunting to try and decode
- 15:35understand what's actually happening.
- 15:40But if you have these patterns these that you can begin to
- 15:44recognize, it actually is like a key to a map that unfolds in a
- 15:54way that makes it easier to see. One of the reasons I talked
- 15:59about working with attachment conditioning as Polly Maneri
- 16:04practices for westerners, it helps us explore the things that
- 16:11we need to see in terms of the nature of this Human Condition,
- 16:15where we create a sense of self and world through our perception
- 16:21of it. And that we can create it any
- 16:26different ways. And that everybody is creating a
- 16:29sense of self and world through their perception, their
- 16:34conditioning. Because everybody's conditioning
- 16:37is different. We just create different
- 16:40experiences of even if we're in the same room experiencing the
- 16:45same thing at the same time, because our conditioning is
- 16:50different. We create a different sense of
- 16:52what's actually. Happening.
- 16:59In opening up the attachment conditioning.
- 17:01Of course we see how to unfix eight things.
- 17:05How to detach from the old working models and to see more
- 17:12clearly what's actually happening in the present moment.
- 17:22So we look at it. First, in terms of the pasta
- 17:30decider, breaking things up. This is how I make the
- 17:35experience of the world. How closely does it match?
- 17:39Actually what's happening the Pali word that I like?
- 17:42This is Todrick. Naughty which means a constant
- 17:46checking You're constantly evaluating the way that you've
- 17:50created conceptual Reality by comparing it to the Ultimate
- 17:55Reality to make sure that the way that you've created the
- 17:58experience of the present moment is a reflection of what's
- 18:02actually happening in the present moment and not wildly
- 18:06distorted. The thing about content
- 18:11attachment conditioning is it's very stable over a most people's
- 18:17life time in the views that it creates are very compelling,
- 18:20very convincing. So part of this process is to
- 18:27understand, actually what happened to us and how we use
- 18:32that as a basis were forming, our experience of the present
- 18:36moment and re-evaluating. The rigidity of some of these
- 18:44views or viewpoints. Adding to this experience of the
- 18:56present moment and what's happening now.
- 19:08Often, when we come out of the, the childhood experience, if
- 19:11there isn't a need to normalize what happens, we think of it as
- 19:17normal. So we call this process of
- 19:24establishing a coherent Narrative of what your early
- 19:28experiences would like. When we remain in the family
- 19:34System, since the conduct of the caregivers over Generations is
- 19:41usually pretty stable. What your, it's hard to get a
- 19:47contrast that would allow you to see things.
- 19:52In a perspective other than the view of the family system. so,
- 20:03one of the things is this exchange with people, There
- 20:07isn't really a way to change the past, but there is a way to
- 20:11change the relationship to the past, in the present moment,
- 20:15which changes the meaning of the past, which is something that we
- 20:20can do. To understand it differently
- 20:25that when we make those sense of the world.
- 20:28Now, we make it in a different fashion than we did without that
- 20:33understanding. One of the paradigms of
- 20:38difficult childhood experiences is the good parent, bad child,
- 20:43the child needs to some, the experiences that happen and feel
- 20:49a sense of safety in the person that's taking care of them, if
- 20:52they can't make sense of it. Then they take on the
- 20:59responsibility for why it went wrong.
- 21:04So that they can preserve the image of the good parent.
- 21:07So part of this process is to actually see things clearly from
- 21:11the adult perspective. Maybe the parenting wasn't so
- 21:17good, maybe the child wasn't so bad.
- 21:20You could let go of one side of the other of it, I think letting
- 21:24go of both sides is pretty good. Then you can begin to reflect
- 21:29with a sense of compassion, on the conditions that the
- 21:34caregivers must have grown up. And in order to behave in the
- 21:38way that they did with you and your childhood circumstance, if
- 21:46you have children, one of the things that you notice about it,
- 21:49I think is that it's quite stressful to have children.
- 21:52It's quite demanding children. Need a lot of care, and it's a
- 21:56kind of ceaseless demand that comes from younger children for
- 22:03care. And often when it's novel,
- 22:07particularly with first children who don't have anything in the
- 22:10database. That would tell you what to do
- 22:13in response to how the children are behaving.
- 22:18But you might have an example of how your caregiver interacted
- 22:21with you. The Mind flips it and you become
- 22:24your caregiver, your you, your child becomes you.
- 22:30And and that's how you respond way that it carries generation
- 22:35to generation in family systems and so you could reflect
- 22:39backwards and open that up. To see things clearly to
- 22:48understand that the effects of conditioning.
- 22:55To understand that while your caregivers may not have attended
- 23:00to these difficulties and changed it in the process of you
- 23:05examining it and opening up to it.
- 23:08You are changing it here that it doesn't continue down.
- 23:13Generation after generation. Tatran conditioning is very
- 23:18stable. You're likely or you have a 70%
- 23:24chance of having the same attachment strategy as your
- 23:27great-grandmother, an 85 percent chance of having the same
- 23:32attachment strategy as your parent your primary caregiver.
- 23:40So in this investigation of the attachment conditioning, we can
- 23:43begin to, then see the elements that we need to investigate in
- 23:48order to understand the nature of the human condition.
- 23:51In classic Enlightenment perspective that all the skills
- 23:56training that happens, when you have these easy signposts to
- 24:02track, Opens up the meditation capacity.
- 24:07Then once you resolve the attachment conditioning, if you
- 24:10have something to resolve, you can then focus on a deeper
- 24:16understanding of the nature of The Human Condition.
- 24:21And that is that we take in the sensing data.
- 24:25We compare it to our perceptual database and we create a version
- 24:29of reality. Part of this inside, of course,
- 24:33is that you can create almost any version of reality depending
- 24:38on the circumstances that you're in.
- 24:40You want to recognize when the mind is distorted by a view.
- 24:44And when it's not distorted by a view, and whether the
- 24:48representation that you're creating out of the experience
- 24:51of just being here is actually reflective of what's Happening.
- 24:58and then, in seeing that, Opening to the possibility of
- 25:07touching into the sacredness of this life.
- 25:19This is a conundrum for me, for a long time.
- 25:21I tend to be science-oriented, I grew up in a household where my
- 25:28parents were educated. By father was a medical doctor,
- 25:32so rooted in science. My mother was a nurse who turd
- 25:38in science. Fair, little sense of the spirit
- 25:43in the household. I grew up and it was not really
- 25:46a discussion not religious I came home in fourth grade with a
- 25:51form that that one of the lines on it was what is your family's
- 25:57religion? so I said to my mother what's
- 26:02our religion She thought about it for a minute and she said,
- 26:06oh, put Protestant. Which was the full extent of our
- 26:12religious training. Christian.
- 26:21George, do you think it might be somewhat natural that someone
- 26:26moving into secure attachment? If they haven't had any kind of
- 26:30spiritual sense that that would accompany, that some kind of
- 26:34growing spiritual sense, or do you think that that's not
- 26:37necessarily the case? if you change your mind about,
- 26:48Other people being reliable and other people being capable of
- 26:53taking care of you and other people being worth.
- 26:57You're interested in care and you begin to take care of them.
- 27:03And see the value in that. And at the same time, you begin
- 27:07to practice. I think that they can work very
- 27:13well together. You don't know that you need to
- 27:16do the first part in order to have them the Mind open to A
- 27:27sense of interest in the service of the community of bodhichitta
- 27:32is a, is a word that means the heart breaks open.
- 27:35And what I notice about people who practice, and develop
- 27:39insight into the nature of this is, there's a natural tendency
- 27:44to move more in the direction of service to the community.
- 27:51This natural outcome of the practice say that again, that
- 27:56would be related to like Buddhist practice, but not
- 27:59necessarily shifts in attachment.
- 28:05I notice in people who don't do attachment work, that that
- 28:10opening of the heart in that interest in being of service to
- 28:13the community, the whole planet Community happens without
- 28:20resolving the attachment conditioning.
- 28:23The difficulties in interpersonal, relationships,
- 28:26that insecure organized or disorganized attachment the
- 28:33interference. That happen are still happening,
- 28:37even though there is that interest in the community.
- 28:40I think that one of the things that happens in practices that
- 28:47those barriers are those boundaries that appear so solid
- 28:55that keep us as separate from everything, begin to come apart
- 28:59and you see yourself more as part of this whole thing rather
- 29:05than as these individuals that are separate from each other.
- 29:11There's also as the compassion. Peace arises, the loving
- 29:15kindness peace, arises more of a sense of softness and more of a
- 29:24sense of acceptance of other people.
- 29:27Doesn't mean you you without doing the attachment work with
- 29:30that end without really understanding how relationships
- 29:34are supposed to function that you're any better at it.
- 29:40I do think that the heart does open, there is a feeling of
- 29:46capacity for experiencing other people's suffering with out
- 29:53needing to reflexively turn it away.
- 30:01I think the practice is harder if you don't have support.
- 30:08And so in the beginning, focusing on really making
- 30:16relationships functional and putting around yourself a
- 30:20network of people who support you actually makes the practice
- 30:27focus more on Liberation easier to do because you have the
- 30:30support that you need to do it. And that it's harder to do when
- 30:34you don't have that support. I don't think that the idea that
- 30:39you can withdraw from everyone and be an island unto yourself
- 30:44is actually a good platform for the practice.
- 30:50It's too difficult. If you get knocked sideways to
- 30:53write yourself, it takes a long time in comparison to how fast
- 30:58you could do it. If you were in a social network
- 31:01that was supportive. And I think that we talk about
- 31:06it of having community and having sung, and having that
- 31:10kind of support. But I also noticed that it it is
- 31:18hard to get to work very well in certain communities, I know and
- 31:26it against the stream where we were for a long time.
- 31:32So many of the people that were there, or coming out of the
- 31:35addiction community, and did not function that well and
- 31:40relationship. So that there's a lot of
- 31:42difficulty around that, you know, a wonderful community of
- 31:51support and an interest in being supportive and developing.
- 31:57But at the same time, but difficulty. so in the attachment
- 32:08world, what we talk about is attachment as a positive thing
- 32:12where we connect to other people and form functioning
- 32:17relationships that support us in our capacity to explore support
- 32:25for our capacity to explore. We can use that as the energy to
- 32:31go into practice deeply and understanding attachment and
- 32:37non-attachment in. The micro version of it in
- 32:44meditation, is that we attach to things to create, the experience
- 32:49of solid is of the conceptual reality.
- 32:52Then we let them go Moment by moment.
- 32:54So in each moment, fixating and releasing fixating rooms.
- 33:00In the micro sense. Sorry in the macro sense of
- 33:05that. I think it is a misunderstanding
- 33:12to say that we don't connect in relationships to anyone.
- 33:21It's actually the opposite. We want to be free to be in
- 33:24relationships but not have to cling to them.
- 33:31In relationships where you're committed, and you're
- 33:34supportive, and you keep your agreements with people.
- 33:42That is not necessarily clinging.
- 33:49Recognizing that All Things Come and Go including all
- 33:53relationships. But at the same time, be capable
- 33:57of supporting and putting the time energy and resources into
- 34:01relationships that are productive are not
- 34:05contradictory. You can have supportive
- 34:09relationship that are long-term, and at the same time, not cling
- 34:14to them. Understand the, the impermanent
- 34:18nature of everything, still value them and still try to keep
- 34:23them as long as you can. And then experience the loss.
- 34:31One of the things about impermanence is that because
- 34:33everything is lost, we need to get good at losing things that
- 34:37it doesn't create that clinging environment, that causes us to
- 34:42suffer from it. But still in each moment,
- 34:46there's a pop of sadness and when things come to an end,
- 34:50there's there's a lot of connections with there's a lot
- 34:54of sadness and we don't cling to the sadness.
- 34:59It's an energy that propels us into what's coming next, the
- 35:04replacement of what's lost, and if we do cling to it, it becomes
- 35:09an enervating energy. That prevents us from moving
- 35:12forward and connecting. They're all making sense.
- 35:24So I like that that back and forth.
- 35:27I think attachment Theory when we use it as a platform for
- 35:34developing our meditation practice, we can put together a
- 35:38social network that will support a deep practice support that our
- 35:44exploration in that. And then we can learn the true
- 35:49nature of The Human Condition. Which is that everything is
- 35:53impermanent that the self is not substantial and that we live in
- 35:58a body that will go through its process of birth to death.
- 36:05Not much to do about that, but we can't have traveling
- 36:09companions along the way as we go.
- 36:13And so, we can find meaning in that.
- 36:19So let's do some meditation practice.
- 36:26What do you think? Loving kindness or insight.
- 36:40No preference. All right.
- 36:50Let's do some insight practice. Now that go.
- 36:57Easy to do. Once you know that investigation
- 37:02of where your attention goes is really interesting because it's
- 37:05selecting the the little tokens that you make Sailfin world out
- 37:10of, you can get a real real sense of what you prefer.
- 37:15Which is an opening into the nature of your conditioning, how
- 37:19you hold self and world. So this Saturday is the third in
- 37:25the series of level one that we're currently in.
- 37:28So there's this Saturday in the following Saturday, we have a
- 37:32level-two starting few weeks after that we're actually going
- 37:37to do another level one in March.
- 37:41We're going to do an EU level 1 in April.
- 37:47We have the retreat starting in June and who tracked if you're
- 37:51interested in sitting for a few days, we've been talking about
- 38:00doing the retreat in Thailand for three weeks in November.
- 38:08So that seems to be coming together.
- 38:11Might be fun. Anyway, that stuff is on the
- 38:18website. Take a look, we have a new chat
- 38:20book out called secure strategies, or something like
- 38:28that, which is a dialogue about the nature of secure attachment,
- 38:34which people quite let have been liking quite a bit.
- 38:37So take a look at that if you're interested.
- 38:43Am I off to the call the class on a Donna basis?
- 38:46That means that I often teaching freely but I do hope that you'll
- 38:50make a donation. If you can there's a link on the
- 38:53website to do that, it supports me and also the work that met a
- 38:56group is doing. We really appreciate your
- 38:59practice Christian. George.
- 39:04I'm performing on violin tomorrow so send me some.
- 39:07Send me some good meta vibes. Okay, awesome.
- 39:12Record it. I'd like to hear it.
- 39:14All right. Wonderful.
- 39:20Fingers crossed. We'll see you soon.
- 39:26By now.