Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Electric Reliability Edge: Renault vs. Citroën
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. We have pulled together a a
- 0:14really significant amount of research today and it all
- 0:16details this massive foundational shift happening
- 0:20across the French automotive sector.
- 0:23It's all focused on the big transition, the 1-2 electric
- 0:26vehicles. Exactly.
- 0:27And this isn't just about, you know, launching a few new EVs.
- 0:30We're talking about a complete structural overhaul.
- 0:33That's right. Our mission today is to give you
- 0:35a clear, comprehensive summary of what these sources are
- 0:38telling us and to, you know, cut through some of the corporate
- 0:41rhetoric. OK, so where do we start?
- 0:43We need to understand the architecture behind this shift,
- 0:46so first Ampere, which is Group Reno's new EV and software
- 0:50company, and then we have to zero in on the data.
- 0:52Hard numbers. Hard numbers on reliability and
- 0:55a detailed comparison of how the new Renault EVs stack up against
- 0:59the new offerings from Citroen. So we're looking at the
- 1:01blueprints for the future here. We'll dive into Ampere, it's
- 1:04platforms, and then we'll put the key models head to head.
- 1:07Right, three O 5 and the Megane E tech versus the Citroen EC3
- 1:12and the EC4X. The goal is for you to walk away
- 1:14from this really understanding the the distinct philosophies
- 1:19that are driving these two major French players in this new
- 1:22electric era and. What's fascinating is that they
- 1:24are making fundamentally different choices about what
- 1:27makes a good EV. The data shows those choices are
- 1:29already impacting quality. OK, so let's start at the top of
- 1:33this organizational earthquake ampere.
- 1:36It's much more than just a rebranded department inside
- 1:38Renault, isn't it? Oh.
- 1:39Absolutely. It was spun off as part of the
- 1:41Revolution plan. So for the listener, what is
- 1:44Ampere's true function? How is it supposed to behave
- 1:46differently? Well, officially, Ampere is
- 1:49categorized as an electric and software company.
- 1:52It was formally separated from the rest of Group Renault in
- 1:55November 2023. And the official line.
- 1:58The official line was that the group aimed to create the first
- 2:02pure EV and software player born from an OEM disruption.
- 2:06OEM disruption, that phrase it, it sounds a bit like aggressive
- 2:10corporate spin doesn't. It it does.
- 2:12I mean, how can a manufacturer with 100 year history truly act
- 2:16like a pure EV startup? Where's the proof?
- 2:19That's a fair challenge, and the evidence really lies in two
- 2:22major areas, technological autonomy and industrial focus.
- 2:27OK, so break that down. Technologically, they're
- 2:30building their own dedicated EV platforms and this is crucial,
- 2:34developing their own software stack.
- 2:36Which controls everything from battery management to the
- 2:39infotainment. Exactly.
- 2:41And industrially, Ampere operates as an autonomous
- 2:44business unit. It manages its own supply
- 2:46chains, its own production schedules.
- 2:48I remember the IPO was cancelled though.
- 2:50It was the plans were cancelled in January 2024.
- 2:54They cited, you know, challenging equity market
- 2:56conditions, but it still functions as an independent
- 2:59unit. So the structure was still
- 3:01attractive enough for outside money.
- 3:02Yep, it secured external investment, notably from
- 3:05Mitsubishi, which committed up to €200 million in League 2023.
- 3:10This really solidified Amperes role as an alliance asset, not
- 3:14just a Renault project. That is a key distinction.
- 3:16So it's not just a solo French venture.
- 3:18If Ampere is the structure, what are the actual tools they're
- 3:21using to build these cars? They're built on 2 core
- 3:24dedicated EV architectures. We know them as the Empire
- 3:26Platforms. OK, first you have Ampire Small.
- 3:29This was formerly the CMFBEV platform.
- 3:32It's designed purely for volume and affordability in the compact
- 3:37market. Oh, this is for cars like the
- 3:38new Run O 5. Exactly.
- 3:39The run O 5E tech, the new Run O four, and alliance products like
- 3:43the upcoming Nissan Micra EV. It's all about mass market
- 3:46accessibility. And the larger platform?
- 3:49It's amper arm medium, which used to be known as CMFEV.
- 3:53If empire. Small is about volume, medium is
- 3:55about performance, range and integrating higher levels of
- 3:59tack. So that's for things like the
- 4:00Megane E tech and the Nissan Aria.
- 4:02Precisely, and the decision to have these dedicated platforms
- 4:05means 0 compromises. You know none of the issues you
- 4:08get with platforms that also have to fit engines and fuel
- 4:10tanks. And all of this converges at one
- 4:12major site. Do I?
- 4:14Absolutely do I is the industrial epicenter Group.
- 4:16Bruno invested a massive of 550 million are all to convert this
- 4:20place into a flexible 100% EV production line.
- 4:24And it's up and running now. Since May 2023, it's already
- 4:29manufacturing six different electric models for four brands,
- 4:32Renault, Alpine, Nissan and Mitsubishi.
- 4:36It's the real world proof that the Ampere Blueprint is working
- 4:39at scale. OK, now before we praise Ampere
- 4:42too much, we have to look backward for a moment.
- 4:45French manufacturers, Renault, Citron, Peugeot, they have this
- 4:49incredible legacy of innovation. Oh.
- 4:51Absolutely pioneers of front wheel drive.
- 4:54Incredible suspension systems. But when you talk about
- 4:56reliability, especially in say the UK market, there's, there's
- 5:00a certain reputation. What is that historical context?
- 5:03The. Historical context is essential
- 5:05for you to understand what's happening now.
- 5:07French cars were famous for prioritizing comfort and, you
- 5:10know, unique design. They were often first with new
- 5:13tech. They were, but this result in
- 5:15what you could call a double edged sort of innovation, which
- 5:17means it means they sometimes rush complexity.
- 5:19Historically they got a lot of criticism for their electrical
- 5:22systems, buggy infotainment, complex sensors that failed
- 5:26prematurely, and mechanically they had known issues with
- 5:28specific components like timing belts or turbochargers.
- 5:32Especially when you compare them to say, a super reliable
- 5:36Japanese engine. So the perception was you bought
- 5:38a French car for style and comfort and you accepted a trade
- 5:42off in that long term durability.
- 5:44Less dependable than a Toyota, but cheaper than a German
- 5:47premium. Precisely.
- 5:48And that brings us to the present.
- 5:50The critical question is whether that old reputation is still
- 5:53relevant in the EV world. And the sources suggest.
- 5:57What the sources suggest that the move to ease ease with their
- 6:00simpler mechanics gives these French manufacturers A profound
- 6:03fresh chance to reset those reliability standards.
- 6:06Because they aren't worrying about timing belts anymore.
- 6:09Exactly. The complexity shifts from all
- 6:11those moving mechanical parts to software and battery management.
- 6:14They're now refining electronic systems on dedicated platforms
- 6:17like Amp R If they can nail that, the old criticisms become
- 6:21obsolete. This is where we see the payoff
- 6:24of that Ampere strategy. Then we have specific
- 6:26reliability data comparing the two streams, Rano with Ampere's
- 6:30Focus and Citroen. What does the TV Report 2025
- 6:34tell us? The data strongly suggests that
- 6:36Renault's new electric models are achieving superior
- 6:39reliability scores compared to Citroen's.
- 6:42We can actually quantify this by looking at defect rates after
- 6:45three years of ownership. Give us the hard numbers, OK?
- 6:48The Renault 5E tech, even though it's new, is tracking a low
- 6:52defect rate of 7.5%. The Megaine E tech is even lower
- 6:56down at 6.8%. And the citrate EC3.
- 6:59That sits at a medium defect rate of 9.2%.
- 7:02Wow, So that gap, especially for the Megaine, that suggests a
- 7:07pretty significant quality difference.
- 7:09It does. A difference of 2.4 percentage
- 7:11points is notable. So why the gap?
- 7:13What's the reason? The primary reason cited in the
- 7:15analysis is platform choice, and this is crucial for you to
- 7:18understand. Renault is using the dedicated
- 7:20EV platforms. NPR.
- 7:22And Citroen. Citroen is still relies heavily
- 7:24on the CMP platform, which is a mixed platform.
- 7:26It supports both combustion engines and electric
- 7:29powertrains. And that mixed platform
- 7:30introduces problems. Think of it this way.
- 7:33The CMP platform is fundamentally A chassis designed
- 7:37for an old school car. It has to make space for an
- 7:40engine, a gearbox, a fuel tank. So when you put an electric
- 7:43drivetrain into it, you're adapting, not designing from
- 7:46scratch, which forces compromises exactly in battery
- 7:49placement, wiring, thermal management.
- 7:51The sources say this shared architecture leads to more
- 7:54hybrid related faults and complexity compared to Renault's
- 7:57clean sheet design. So that's why we see these
- 8:00electronic niggles coming up in the Citron feedback.
- 8:02That's the theory. The most common criticisms for
- 8:05Citroen relate to buggy infotainment and invasive ADAS
- 8:09systems. The driver assistance stuff.
- 8:12Integrating those complex features is just harder on an
- 8:14adaptive platform. Renault with Ampere's software
- 8:17Focus, seems to have a smoother integration.
- 8:20OK, let's translate this into actual cars.
- 8:22The listener might be looking at the entry level segment, the
- 8:25retro tech forward Renault 5 versus the budget focused
- 8:29practical Citroen EC3. What's the core trade off the.
- 8:32Fundamental trade off is refinement and style versus,
- 8:35well, absolute affordability. The EC3 is the budget winner
- 8:38hands down. What are the numbers the?
- 8:40EC3 starts significantly lower, around 18,192.
- 8:44After typical discounts. The R5 starts closer to
- 8:47$21,051.00. That's a £3000 difference.
- 8:51A substantial barrier. So if the Citroen is cheaper,
- 8:54where does does the Renault justify its premium?
- 8:56Primarily inefficiency and technology.
- 8:58They're claimed ranges are similar, 192 miles for the R5 to
- 9:02101 for the EC3, but the R5 includes a heat pump as
- 9:06standard. Which the EC3 lacks.
- 9:08Why is that a big deal? In cold climate, the heat pump
- 9:11radically improves efficiency. It means the Renault's real
- 9:14world range loss in winter will be far less dramatic than the
- 9:17Citrons. It's a key long term efficiency
- 9:20win. And the interior?
- 9:22This is where that Ampere and Google partnership shows up,
- 9:24isn't it? It really does.
- 9:25The Riddle 5 feels like a technology product.
- 9:28It has a high quality stack dashboard and its infotainment
- 9:31runs the Google Automotive OS natively.
- 9:33Meaning seamless Google Maps and Assistant.
- 9:36Right. It's slick, responsive, and cuts
- 9:38down on distraction. The EC3's interior is
- 9:40comfortable, the seats are soft, but the materials are tougher.
- 9:43And the tech is it's functional but basic.
- 9:46What about that classic French car trade off between style and
- 9:49interior space? It's still there.
- 9:52The R5 has a slightly larger boot, 326 liters, but because of
- 9:56its styling, the rear seats are reportedly very tight for
- 9:59adults. The EC3, with its taller, boxier
- 10:02design, has superior rear leg room and an upright seating
- 10:06position. It's just better for carrying
- 10:08passengers. It's boot is a bit smaller at
- 10:10310 liters, but very usable. Than to drive.
- 10:13The R5 is sporty, agile, eager in the corners, but that comes
- 10:17with a firmer ride. You will feel the bumps.
- 10:20And the EC3. The complete opposite.
- 10:22It's soft suspension is designed for plush urban comfort.
- 10:25It glides over speed bumps, but push it hard and it leans.
- 10:29The choice is really eager agility versus soft cushioning.
- 10:32OK, let's move up to the family size segment.
- 10:34We've got the Megane E Tech hatchback versus the unique
- 10:37Citroen EC4X saloon. On paper, the Megane seems
- 10:41technically superior across the board.
- 10:43Technically, it is. The Megane is a product that amp
- 10:45our medium platform designed for serious performance.
- 10:48It has 217 horsepower, a longer range of 280 miles and faster
- 10:52charging. And the EC4X.
- 10:54It's much more reserved, 134 horsepower, 241 miles of range,
- 10:58and slower charging. The Mcgame just delivers more
- 11:01power, more range and less downtime.
- 11:04But the Citroen plays the space card with that huge.
- 11:07Boot it does 510 liters. But here's the practicality
- 11:11reality. It's a saloon.
- 11:13The opening is restrictive. You can fit suitcases, sure, but
- 11:16getting bulky everyday family junk in and out is a hassle.
- 11:20A. Stroller or a big weekly shop?
- 11:22Exactly. The Magain's 440 liter boot is
- 11:24smaller, but because it's a hatchback, the access is wide
- 11:27open and much more usable for daily life.
- 11:30And Citroen signature is comfort.
- 11:32How do they achieve that in the EC4X?
- 11:34They do it with their Progressive Hydraulic Cushions
- 11:36suspension system combined with Advanced Comfort seats.
- 11:40It's a sophisticated system that soaks up bumps and cracks in the
- 11:42road. To isolate you from the road
- 11:44surface, yes. The Magain, by contrast, is
- 11:47firmer, better handling, more stable at speed, but you feel
- 11:50every lump and bump. Any downsides to the Citroen's
- 11:53comfort focus? The surprising trade off is that
- 11:55sources noted it suffers from more wind and road noise than
- 11:59the Magan, which suggests Renault may have invested more
- 12:03in soundproofing. Let's get to this critical
- 12:06financial nugget we found despite the Magon being the
- 12:09better car on paper, more power, better tech, higher list price,
- 12:13it can actually be cheaper to finance monthly.
- 12:17How is that possible? This insight connects all the
- 12:20dots right back to Ampere's success.
- 12:23We're looking at PCP figures, Personal contract purchase, OK
- 12:26PCP payments are based on the list price minus deposit and
- 12:30crucially, the guaranteed minimum future value or GMFE.
- 12:34Which is the manufacturer's prediction of what the car will
- 12:36be worth in three or four years. Exactly.
- 12:38And when Sample figures showed the Magon at around 446 miles a
- 12:42month versus 526 miters for the EC4X, it reveals something
- 12:46important. What's that?
- 12:48It shows that the finance houses have significantly more
- 12:50confidence in the Mcgahn's long term resale value.
- 12:53They are betting it's dedicated platform, superior tech and
- 12:56better reliability will make it worth more in the used market
- 12:59than the compromise base Citroen.
- 13:01That is the ultimate vote of confidence in the Ampere
- 13:03strategy. The market believes the Renault
- 13:06Tempere platform is building better long term assets.
- 13:09So as a final analysis, the historical issues of French
- 13:13reliability, often tied to over complex innovations, seem to be
- 13:17shifting in the EV era. Dedicated platforms like Ampyr
- 13:21are allowing Renault to build a competitive and reliable
- 13:23foundation. Meanwhile, Citroen is doubling
- 13:26down on its signature strength, absolute low cost, comfort and
- 13:30practicality, even if it means using older platforms and
- 13:34dealing with a few more software glitches.
- 13:36So the choice for you is now highly segmented.
- 13:38Do you prioritize the technological agility and future
- 13:41proof design of a run out? Or do you prioritize low entry
- 13:44cost, supreme comfort and passenger friendly practicality
- 13:48of a Citroen? It's a choice between the Google
- 13:50powered agility of the Megane and the the happy bum focus of
- 13:54the EC4X. That's a good way to put it.
- 13:55We can leave you with this final thought that brings our entire
- 13:58deep dive into focus. The structural shift to
- 14:02dedicated EV platforms has demonstrably stabilized French
- 14:05quality, particularly for Renault and Ampere, Now that the
- 14:09mechanical complexity is simplified with a combination of
- 14:12increased efficiency and native EV design.
- 14:15Finally, allow these French players to close and maybe even
- 14:18eliminate the perceived reliability gap that has
- 14:20historically existed between them and the famously dependable
- 14:24Japanese manufacturers. That really is the billion
- 14:26dollar question for the next decade.
- 14:28It is. We appreciate you spending this
- 14:30time with us on Dee Dive, extracting these insights
- 14:33directly from the source material.
- 14:34If you found this analysis helful and appreciate this clear
- 14:38summarybased approach, please be sure to follow the channel for
- 14:41more curated knowledge.