Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Struggling
Transcript
- Lucas: So today's question comes from a listener named Priya. She's a marketing manager at a mid-size retail chain — around 800 employees — and she says the company just reported a 12 percent revenue decline last quarter. They've already done one small layoff round, and everyone's nervous. But she's been there three years, her responsibilities have doubled, and she thinks she's underpaid by about 15 grand. She wants to know: how do I ask for a raise when the company is clearly struggling? Luna: Oof, that's a tough spot. I think most people's instinct would be to wait it out, keep your head down, and hope things improve. But Priya might be right that waiting costs her real money. Lucas: Yeah, the instinct to freeze is strong, but I actually think this can be the right time — if you frame it correctly. The key is to shift from a 'past performance' case to a 'future value' case. Normally when you ask for a raise, you say 'look at all the great things I did last year.' But in a downturn, the company doesn't care as much about what you did yesterday — they care about what you can do to help them survive and recover. Luna: So you're saying she should basically pitch herself as a cost-effective solution to a problem they already know they have. Lucas: Exactly. Let me give you a concrete example. Priya could say something like: 'I know the company is focused on stabilizing revenue this year. I've already identified three quick-win marketing campaigns that could bring in an incremental half a million in sales over the next six months with almost no additional budget. I'd like to lead those, and I want to align my compensation with the impact I'm driving.' That's not a demand — it's a business proposition. Luna: But what if her manager just says 'we don't have the budget, everyone's taking a freeze'? That's the most common pushback. Lucas: Then she needs to get specific about what 'no budget' actually means. Most companies have a compensation pool that's separate from operating budget — it's usually a percentage of payroll, set annually. Even in a freeze, there's almost always some flexibility for retention cases. The question is whether Priya qualifies as a retention risk. If her replacement would cost 20 to 30 percent of her salary in recruiting and training — and that's a conservative estimate for a marketing manager — then giving her a 10 percent raise is actually cheaper than losing her. Luna: That's a really smart frame. So she's not asking for a favor — she's pointing out that paying her more is the financially prudent move. But what about the loyalty argument? Some people feel like you shouldn't cash in when the company is bleeding. Lucas: I think loyalty is a dangerous trap in these situations. Companies don't hesitate to lay people off when the numbers don't work. Priya's responsibility to herself and her family outweighs any sense of moral obligation to accept less than she's worth. That said, she shouldn't lead with 'I deserve this because I've been loyal.' That's a weak argument. She should lead with data about her impact and the cost of replacing her. Luna: What about mentioning another offer? I know conventional wisdom says you should never bluff, but if she actually has one, does it work in a downturn? Lucas: It's risky. In a growing company, a competing offer can accelerate things. In a struggling company, it might backfire. If they're already looking for ways to cut costs, an offer could make them think 'great, we don't have to pay severance.' So I'd say only mention it if you're genuinely ready to leave, and only if you're sure they can't afford to lose you. Otherwise, it's better to keep the focus on your internal value. Luna: So Priya should go in with that future-value script, and also have a number in mind. But what if they say 'come back in six months when things are better'? Lucas: That's a brush-off. She should counter by asking for a specific performance milestone and a specific review date. Like 'let's agree that if I hit the three campaigns I mentioned and generate that half-million in revenue by Q3, we revisit comp in October.' That turns a vague promise into a concrete commitment. And she should get it in writing — an email is fine, but something that documents the agreement. Luna: I love that. It also gives her a timeline to evaluate whether the company is actually serious about recovery. If October comes and they still say no, she has her answer and can start looking. Lucas: Right. And that brings up something important: timing. Priya should check when her company's fiscal year ends and when budgets are typically set. Most companies finalize comp plans in the fall for the next calendar year. If she's in a retail chain, their fiscal year might end in January. So July or August is actually a sweet spot to start the conversation — early enough to influence the budget, late enough to have recent results to show. Luna: You know, this episode is a good example of why we keep Office Hours ad-free. We're not sponsored by anyone trying to sell you a negotiation course or a resume service. We just want to give you practical, honest advice you can use. If that's valuable to you and you'd like to support it, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just an option if it feels right. Lucas: Yeah, we really believe in keeping this space free from commercial agendas. So if you're finding these conversations useful, that link is there if you want to chip in. Now, back to Priya's situation — there's one more angle I want to touch on. Luna: What's that? Lucas: The psychological side. Priya needs to go in expecting that her manager might be defensive or stressed. A struggling company means everyone is under pressure, and a compensation request can feel like an added burden. So she should lead with empathy: 'I know this is a tough time, and I'm fully committed to helping us turn things around. That's exactly why I want to have this conversation — so I can focus on the work without distraction.' That disarms the defensiveness. Luna: That's a good point. It's not just about the numbers — it's about the relationship. If she frames it as 'I'm on your side, help me stay on your side,' that's much harder to reject than 'pay me or I leave.' Lucas: Exactly. And one more tactical thing: she should rehearse the conversation out loud. I know it sounds silly, but most people freeze when they get pushback. If she practices saying 'I understand the budget constraints, but let me share the math on what it would cost to replace me versus adjust my comp,' she'll be much more confident. Luna: Alright, let me try to summarize what we've covered for Priya and anyone else in a similar boat. One: build a future-value case tied to a specific revenue or cost-saving target. Two: get a written commitment with a timeline if they say not now. Three: time your request around budget cycles. Four: lead with empathy. Five: practice your responses to common objections. Lucas: That's a solid checklist. And if she does all that and still gets a no, she'll have clarity — and a strong case for her next job interview when she's ready to move. Sometimes the best outcome of a tough negotiation isn't the raise, it's the information you get about where you stand. Luna: Well said. Good luck, Priya, and let us know how it goes. We'll be back next time with another question from the inbox. Lucas: Until then, keep asking the hard questions.