Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / The HR Crisis Behind Workplace Wellbeing
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tons more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:46Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work, and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:10Ok then, why is it still seen as unprofessional to cry at work?
- 1:17When the UK Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, teared up during Prime Minister's question times recently, it wasn't her policy that made the headlines, it was her emotion.
- 1:29The backlash was mixed, loud, swift and revealing.
- 1:35It left many of us wondering, including myself, why is it still not ok to show emotion at work?
- 1:44And maybe even more importantly, what's the cost of pretending we're all fine all of the time?
- 1:51My guest today is Dr Jo Burrell, a clinical psychologist, former NHS frontline practitioner and now a specialist in something you've probably never heard of but absolutely should, HR Supervision.
- 2:06That's right, she works with the people who hold the emotional weight of entire organisations, the ones expected to be the calm in the storm, the trusted go-to, the fixers.
- 2:19But Jo's latest survey of nearly 1,500 HR professionals reveals a worrying truth.
- 2:27HR is struggling.
- 2:29High workloads, poor leadership, toxic cultures, lack of recognition, emotional exhaustion.
- 2:35Now you might say, well that's just like everyone else, but they're the ones being asked to design the wellbeing strategy for the rest of us.
- 2:44Now overlay that with a recent study from Oxford University tracking over 46,000 UK employees and I'm afraid it gets worse.
- 2:54It found that most workplace wellbeing initiatives, stuff like mindfulness apps, resilience workshops, stress coaching, they actually deliver no meaningful improvement in mental health or job satisfaction.
- 3:07Some even cause more problems.
- 3:10If the people who create wellbeing programs are being burned out and the programs themselves aren't working, then something my friends is seriously broken.
- 3:20In this episode, we're going to pull back the curtain on the personal, emotional and ethical toll of being the fixer.
- 3:28We unpack the flaws in current wellbeing strategies and we ask what real human-centred support looks like, not just for HR, but for everyone.
- 3:39Welcome to the show, Jo.
- 3:40Thank you so much for having me.
- 3:42It's great to be here.
- 3:43Really cool to have you.
- 3:45HR as a department and as a bunch of people comes up a fair amount in this series of podcasts, but I think it's going to be a really interesting conversation today to hear about some of the struggles within that department, not just from a structural perspective, but what's actually going on inside.
- 4:03So I'm fascinated to hear that.
- 4:05Before we dive into that sort of stuff, Jo, would you mind just giving my audience a better introduction to you and what you're doing today?
- 4:14Sure.
- 4:15So, as you said, I'm a clinical psychologist by background and that means I spent most of my career working in the NHS in mental health services as a clinician and a leader.
- 4:27Around 12 years ago, I set up a business called Ultimate Resilience alongside my business partner, Dr. Felicity Baker, who's also a clinical psychologist.
- 4:36And we set up our business because we were finding in our clinics in the NHS that we were seeing lots of people whose difficulties had their origin at work.
- 4:47So they were coming with significant symptoms of depression, anxiety, maybe even trauma, certainly workplace stress.
- 4:56And the source of their difficulties was at work.
- 4:59And the sort of business model, the delivery model in the NHS is such that you can't really go into organisations and tackle that source.
- 5:07And so we were really interested in doing that, really, because actually, if you can tackle the problem at source, then you're preventing potentially thousands and thousands of people turning up in NHS services with significant mental health problems.
- 5:22So we've been delivering resilience training and coaching for the last 10 years or so, really aimed at that, preventing the worst effects of stress, preventing the build-up of stress and that becoming then more serious mental health problems.
- 5:44And then we became particularly interested in HR professionals and their mental wellbeing around the time of the pandemic, because we found that this was a function which typically came to us to commission our services and weren't necessarily utilising them.
- 6:04But suddenly during the pandemic, they were starting to ask for help for themselves.
- 6:09And we became very interested in why that was happening.
- 6:13I'm sure we'll talk about what happened next later on.
- 6:17But yeah, that's how we started to become interested in specifically the mental wellbeing of HR professionals.
- 6:26And yet we absolutely will get into that today.
- 6:29But I also think, personally, you are a very well-known thought leader and advocate on these topics.
- 6:38You've recently picked up HR's Most Influencing Person type award, which is fantastic.
- 6:44Tell us a little bit about that.
- 6:45So that's HR Magazine's HR Most Influential Thinker list.
- 6:50So they have two lists.
- 6:51They have a practitioner list and a thinker list.
- 6:53So I was named on that list for the first time this year.
- 6:57And actually, my business partner Felicity was named on that list last year.
- 7:02So between us, we've picked up 2024 and 2025.
- 7:06And it's different from a lot of other awards because it's peer-nominated, though it's not one of those awards where you have to pay to be...
- 7:14I was going to say, you buy it.
- 7:16Yeah.
- 7:18And so, I mean, I don't know who nominated me.
- 7:22And then, you know, the nominations are kind of analysed by a professional company, you know, who do that kind of thing.
- 7:30So I feel very honoured to have received that award, actually, because I know that it is you know, a set of awards that are, you know, have a lot of kudos and credibility.
- 7:44And, you know, it's a sign that the work that we're doing is being heard.
- 7:50Yeah.
- 7:50Yeah, it's great.
- 7:52And it's nice for me over the years to look at that list and see the number of people that have come on and taken time out to chat to me about some stuff.
- 7:59So it's wonderful.
- 8:00Fantastic.
- 8:01Congratulations.
- 8:02Absolutely fantastic.
- 8:04Where to start?
- 8:05Well, I mentioned right at the top of the introduction, the whole Rachel Reeves thing.
- 8:11And actually, you did a LinkedIn post, drawing attention to that very issue.
- 8:18And I guess that's a good enough place to start as any.
- 8:20What made you write that post?
- 8:23What was behind it for you?
- 8:25Well, I think it kind of, it wrangled me, you know, for the response.
- 8:31I saw what was going on in the media.
- 8:33And I suppose it sort of touched on something that concerns me greatly, which is that I think we live in a very name-blame-shame kind of culture.
- 8:43And the media sort of exacerbates that often, not always.
- 8:47It depends on what kind of media outlet we're talking about.
- 8:49But they settle on things that they know are going to incite strong feeling and can often be critical before they are compassionate or understanding.
- 8:59And so what happened was, you know, within minutes, we were seeing, you know, pictures of a woman in distress and critical headlines and suggestions that she should leave, you know, that she should be leaving her job because she was displaying a human emotion.
- 9:19That was the majority of the conversation afterwards.
- 9:22I mean, I remember listening to the radio and every sort of pundit was like, well, when's she going?
- 9:26Clearly it's too much.
- 9:28Yes, absolutely.
- 9:30And, you know, as a clinical psychologist who's worked with people and their emotions the whole of my career, I just felt like, you know, that's really rubbish.
- 9:40And, you know, so what if she cried?
- 9:44Yeah.
- 9:45But I suppose it also spoke to something for me about women in leadership roles and the different ways in which, you know, men and women express themselves and the ways in which we've been socialised.
- 9:57And all of those sorts of things.
- 9:59So it felt like an attack on her as a woman, as well as an attack on her as a human being who experiences emotions just like everyone else.
- 10:07You think it exposed some, I'm going to say, and they're not hidden, but some real truths about culture and the expectations of what professionalism still means today in the workplace.
- 10:22Absolutely.
- 10:23And I think those expectations and those kind of stereotypes hurt everyone, not just women.
- 10:30You know, the sort of stereotypical kind of template that leaders, you know, are expected to fit into is someone who's very stoic, you know, someone who stays strong and calm and copes regardless of what happens, who, you know, who's decisive, who's, you know, can't be confused.
- 10:54You can't have a wobble.
- 10:56You know, can't have an off day.
- 11:00And I don't think that template, that stereotype serves anyone really.
- 11:05But I think it's informed by male stereotypes and it's informed by the expectations that are placed on men, which are that you shouldn't show any emotions unless they are aggression-related emotions.
- 11:21It almost sounds prehistoric still, doesn't it?
- 11:23It does feel a bit weird.
- 11:26But as somebody who sits, listens, dives into, explores emotions with people on a regular professional basis, I mean, that's such a wonderfully complex, interesting topic.
- 11:41But yet it seems like a taboo when it comes to the workplace.
- 11:47Why do you think we still have such a problem talking about dealing with, facing into emotions in the workplace?
- 11:55I think because we, particularly those sorts of emotions like sadness and grief and that kind of thing, I think that they have very negative connotations to us in our culture.
- 12:07And I'd be interested, you know, sort of just struck me talking about it, I'd be interested to know about, you know, whether there are other cultures across the globe where expressing sadness is seen as a strength.
- 12:20The ability to cry is seen as a strength because I think we automatically in this culture feel that it's a weakness to show that we're sad or to show other types of emotions, even things like anxiety, you know, to show that we're stressed, to show that we're anxious, to show that we're down.
- 12:39And I think that expectation is there both outside and in work, but it's kind of magnified in work because it's overlaid with these expectations of professionalism and professionalism is associated with holding it together and keep it going and being on your A game all the time and, you know, that kind of stuff.
- 13:02So these two things are sort of conflated, aren't they?
- 13:06And like I say, I don't think it serves anyone, doesn't serve individuals and it doesn't serve organisations either because if we're busy trying to kind of control our emotions and, you know, repress them, then that just comes out in all sorts of other ways.
- 13:24You know, one of the articles that I contributed to, I talked about, you know, on the back of that post, I talked about how, you know, if we're, you know, repressing those feelings, then it can lead to fracture and conflict and tensions between people.
- 13:41So it's not useful to the wider organisation, let alone the individual.
- 13:47No, it isn't.
- 13:48And I think this thing about professionalism almost results in this feeling of depersonalisation.
- 13:57So, you know, to be professional, you've got to park your emotions.
- 14:01Why?
- 14:01Why leave the very, very best part, the defining part of you at the door when it comes to that sort of stuff?
- 14:08Why not lean into it?
- 14:10I mean, I think it's, I find it really interesting, particularly in some of the rooms that I work in with groups where the topics can get emotional.
- 14:20People show emotion because they're human.
- 14:24But it's really interesting to see the reaction of people in the room when those things happen.
- 14:29There is such a mix in the room.
- 14:31People who have real empathy and want to understand and help.
- 14:36And those are almost repulsed by the idea of someone being that human in the room.
- 14:43Yes.
- 14:43Fascinating stuff, really.
- 14:45Yes, absolutely.
- 14:46And I think actually, I was thinking about how there's also another thing going on, which is that it feels to me like in the workplace that we're increasingly expected to act as if we are a kind of mechanistic function within the workplace, just like your sort of conveyor belt.
- 15:08Yeah.
- 15:09We just churn out work.
- 15:12And that dehumanises us, obviously.
- 15:17And that if that conveyor belt breaks down, all you've got to do is sort of put a bit of oil on it and it'll start back up again.
- 15:26And actually, we are, as human beings, so much more complex and nuanced than that.
- 15:33And as you're implying, actually, why don't we lean into that and embrace that?
- 15:38But also, if you want the best out of your people, that is not to treat them like machines.
- 15:45It's to acknowledge and recognise that they are human beings and that they, as human beings, one of the defining features of being a human being is that we experience emotion.
- 15:55Yeah.
- 15:55I think it's really interesting.
- 15:56I really think it's interesting because it goes up and down the chain in the room.
- 16:01I'll often get sort of, if you like, managers and that sort of fraternity go, the leaders need to understand our emotions better.
- 16:09They need to understand and have some empathy.
- 16:12But at the same time, then that group of people expect the leaders to never make a mistake, to be bang on it the whole time and know everything about everything.
- 16:20And so we're all kind of in this horrible soup of misunderstanding and misconception and need and want.
- 16:28It's just a really interesting thing.
- 16:30I'm really interested in your thought, though, and that's something for me to go away and think about what other cultures hold up this stuff as being, you know, pillars of their culture.
- 16:44It's good to share this stuff.
- 16:45It's fantastic to show this level of emotion.
- 16:47I don't know.
- 16:48But it does ask another question for me is, in your work, where do you think we need to pay attention to try and reframe this use of emotion as a human strength and a part of our difference?
- 17:08Where do you think we need to start that reframing process?
- 17:12I mean, everywhere.
- 17:13You know, we talk about culture, don't we?
- 17:15And how important culture is.
- 17:18And it's really at the heart of that, isn't it?
- 17:21That we create cultures in which we recognise and acknowledge humans as humans.
- 17:29And that we create environments in which we can, you know, be our authentic selves.
- 17:34And, you know, sometimes I feel like that sort of idea of the authentic self is a bit of a sort of trope, isn't it?
- 17:41And it happened.
- 17:43And the reality of being human, and this speaks to the complexity that I was talking about earlier.
- 17:48You know, the reality of being a human being is that we are actually playing, we are in roles, aren't we?
- 17:53We are stepping into different roles in different, you know, environments, different situations in our lives.
- 17:59So we, who the authentic person is in the midst of all of those roles that we are kind of putting on, is a puzzling question.
- 18:10I'm playing when I'm a parent, when I'm a granddaughter, when I'm a, you know, when I'm a, you know, a community leader, when I'm a psychologist, when I'm at a party, when I'm a, you know.
- 18:22So yeah, so I think that notion of the authentic self is kind of thorny, isn't it?
- 18:28I think it is that it comes back to what I was saying before about acknowledging and recognising that the human being part of the organisation isn't exactly that, it's human, it's not a machine.
- 18:41And there feels like, it feels to me there's an increasing trend to kind of push us into acting as if we are robots, you know, as if we are machines.
- 18:51And that just denies, it denies everything about our uniqueness, you know, as a species.
- 18:59I think you're 100% right on the authentic trope, because you might not like me in my, if I'm being really authentic in a certain situation.
- 19:09And actually that could be very unhelpful in some situations.
- 19:11So I think it's interesting.
- 19:13This emotional intelligence stuff, a lot of the work that I try and do and associates that I work with try and do around helping people have more effective cultures is absolutely trying to tune into the human nature of all of this stuff.
- 19:27That's not making excuses for things, it's just trying to elicit the best response from somebody and by putting them in an environment where they feel safe and confident and trusted, you know?
- 19:37Yes, yes, yes, exactly.
- 19:39And where they can build trust.
- 19:40Because of course, if you put people in a situation when they feel under threat, they don't perform at their best.
- 19:45That's the bottom line, isn't it?
- 19:47Absolutely.
- 19:47And that's a great link actually, Jo, under pressure, under threat.
- 19:54Because let's turn our attention to really, I think the meat and bones of this conversation today in having a look under the bonnet at HR.
- 20:04I mean, you've just got the results of your big survey.
- 20:10What's it said?
- 20:11Why have you got to the conclusion that HR is struggling?
- 20:14What are the headlines?
- 20:15So as you said, we had 1,421 respondents to our survey.
- 20:22Beautiful.
- 20:23We designed it so that it kind of really delved into mental health presentations like depression, anxiety, burnout, psychological well-being.
- 20:34And we actually use clinical measures for some of those because we've experienced in using those kind of questionnaires and measures within our clinical work.
- 20:44And so what we found was pretty shocking, actually.
- 20:49I mean, it chimed with what we were hearing.
- 20:52But of course, you never know whether when you do a piece of research, whether what you're going to reveal is going to be consistent with what you're hearing out there amongst people.
- 21:03Anyway, so what we found was 44% met the threshold for clinical symptoms of depression.
- 21:11And that is two and a half times higher than the general population.
- 21:16Wow.
- 21:16That's a rate two and a half times higher than the general population.
- 21:19And 38% had clinically significant levels of anxiety.
- 21:26And that is one and a half times higher than the general population.
- 21:3163% were very likely experiencing burnout.
- 21:36And a further 15% were at risk of burnout.
- 21:4267% were in the category for low well-being.
- 21:4742% were considering leaving the profession.
- 21:5287% felt that support for their mental well-being at work was insufficient to some degree.
- 22:01So what we have is a picture of a group of people who are struggling really quite significantly, but where there isn't a matching degree of support for them.
- 22:16You know, actually what we know, and again, I'll go back to the anecdotal, but you know, I was at an event a year or so ago, and I was chatting to an HR professional about, you know, well-being in HR.
- 22:29And she said, oh, you know, we've got a coaching service in our organisation, but like, I never think that it's something for me, you know, that it's a service for me.
- 22:40So they put themselves at the back of the queue, you know, I think that's one of the issues.
- 22:46And, but, you know, there is, I don't think the kind of right services available for them either, because they're doing a very specific job.
- 22:55But yeah, so this picture reveals, you know, very high rates of distress, low rates of support.
- 23:05And what we found actually in terms of support, and I think this was a really, really interesting finding.
- 23:12We found that of those people who were experiencing good levels of support, people who said, yes, I feel very well supported at work, and that was only 13% of our respondents.
- 23:23Amongst those people, they were far less likely to be experiencing mental health difficulties.
- 23:29They were far less likely to be thinking about leaving the profession, and they were far less likely to have taken time off sick in the previous year due to stress or anything mental health related.
- 23:41So what that tells us is that support is a hugely important ingredient in protecting individuals, but also the business, because of course, those are costs to the business, aren't they?
- 23:53If people are suffering with their mental health, if they're thinking about leaving or actively leaving, and if they're off sick.
- 23:59The associated costs of turnover or retention, whichever way you want to look at it, retraining, I mean, they're some of the biggest people costs that businesses experience.
- 24:11And to get the distortion or the inflation of those costs based on some of these statistics, that's an awful lot of money.
- 24:18It's an awful lot of profit threatening the P&Ls of a lot of businesses there in the numbers that you're saying.
- 24:25Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 24:26The theory behind the survey, Jo, were you just trying to get a sort of state of the nation with regards to this HR population?
- 24:35Is that what was behind it?
- 24:37Yeah, so I was saying earlier that we noticed this kind of uptick in the numbers of HR professionals who were coming to us asking for some support and help.
- 24:47And that was a shift in what we'd seen before.
- 24:49We'd never really seen that before.
- 24:50And as clinical psychologists, we train in research methods.
- 24:55So the first thing we do is go and look at the evidence, what data's out there.
- 24:59So we sought to find what data, have a look to see what data was out there about the mental wellbeing of HR professionals.
- 25:07And actually what happens if you put into Google HR wellbeing or HR mental health, what you get is lots of information for HR professionals about how they can look after other people's mental health and wellbeing.
- 25:19Nothing about them and their mental health.
- 25:22And there was nothing, from what we could gather.
- 25:25So we just thought, well, let's do a survey ourselves.
- 25:29And this survey that we're talking about today is the second iteration of that.
- 25:33So we did the first one in 2023 and we had a hundred respondents.
- 25:37So it was a much smaller scale.
- 25:38It was a bit of a pilot.
- 25:39We were just trying it out.
- 25:41But what it revealed was very similar data, very similar figures to what we've got this time.
- 25:47So it felt like it was shining a spotlight on a problem that was probably much bigger.
- 25:54And it certainly was revealing something that it felt had been sort of hidden.
- 25:58And we hear this all the time, since we've been focusing much more on HR professionals, we just hear it all the time that people just feel they've not felt confident or they fear the consequences of speaking up and saying, I'm struggling.
- 26:15It has been a very hidden problem.
- 26:18And I think that also that, you know, they're the people you go to for help.
- 26:22They're not the people that we expect to have the problems.
- 26:25I think this is the question I wanted to ask really, Jo, is I think the stark thing in those numbers is not just the headline numbers, but their disproportionate effect versus the rest of the population.
- 26:35That's really interesting.
- 26:38But without wanting to sound like an idiot, why is it so significant that this particular group of people are struggling to that degree?
- 26:49What's your insight into that?
- 26:52Well, I mean, I think there are lots of factors.
- 26:55I could talk to you for the rest of the day, just to make it a question.
- 26:59But I think what we have is a profession that has seen a real broadening of its remit.
- 27:08I think that they've been at the eye of the storm when it comes to the pandemic.
- 27:13So let's start there.
- 27:14Yeah.
- 27:15They were like the key workers.
- 27:18They were the frontline workers.
- 27:20And we don't think about them and how they were, all the stuff that was in their laps during the pandemic.
- 27:26We think about NHS workers and supermarket staff and public transport workers and that kind of thing.
- 27:32We don't think about HR professionals.
- 27:34So again, an example of how their experiences are hidden.
- 27:37But a lot of stuff landed on their plates during the pandemic.
- 27:41And then from then on, there's been really no let up.
- 27:46We've had a cost of living crisis.
- 27:47We had obviously all the hybrid working stuff and they've got policies and procedures that they've got to bring in.
- 27:52We've had the great resignation.
- 27:54We've had new employment law on the horizon.
- 27:58And so there's this huge range of issues, pressures that are around and this kind of gradually broadening remit.
- 28:07And it's not necessarily a bad thing that this is a profession that's become much more professionalized.
- 28:14It was essentially an admin role some years back and it's become more professionalized.
- 28:19And like I said, I don't think that's a bad thing because this is a group of people who now have much more influence and are often being the voice of the people within the organization.
- 28:34Although there again is one of the other challenges.
- 28:36There's a conflict.
- 28:38They've walked this kind of very delicate tightrope between the concerns and needs of the organization and those of the people.
- 28:46And I think that throws up all sorts of ethical dilemmas for them.
- 28:50Oh, for sure.
- 28:51I think that point about the growing remit is interesting as well because it feels, in lots of the conversations we've had on this podcast, some of the issue must come down to this department in transition that it feels like HR is in.
- 29:09A certain degree of certainty must be being put at risk within that department because remit changes.
- 29:18One day you're supposed to be hard-nosed policies and benefits and I'm holding out the next you're supposed to be there to look after somebody who's having an emotional breakdown.
- 29:27The role is changed.
- 29:29Cultures often defaulted to HR when that's ridiculous.
- 29:34That is not a thing that should be defaulted to anybody.
- 29:37So there is quite a lot of turmoil in the background, as well as the obvious front-facing things, isn't there?
- 29:42Yes, absolutely.
- 29:45And I think that there's a big emotional toll.
- 29:48I think that there is an increasing expectation that the workplace picks up and deals with the distress of the workforce and that there's an increasing degree of distress amongst workforces because we're living in very uncertain times, in very frightening times at the moment.
- 30:06And so certainly mental health issues are on the increase and HR professionals, what I hear from them is they are the first port of call when someone's got an issue, whether it's domestic abuse, whether it's someone who's suicidal, whether it's someone who's got terminal cancer.
- 30:28They are the first port of call and they may not be going on and doing a piece of counselling work with that individual.
- 30:35But even just having a conversation with someone who's going through that type of thing is a distressing thing to experience.
- 30:42Of course, it's an emotional conversation and this must be where your work comes in.
- 30:49So tell us about HR Supervision.
- 30:54What is it?
- 30:55What's involved?
- 30:56What's it trying to help with?
- 30:59Clue us in.
- 31:00Sure.
- 31:02So Supervision is something that I have delivered and received all the way through my career as a clinician.
- 31:09So when I trained as a clinical psychologist, I trained as part of that core training, I trained in the skills of supervision.
- 31:16And the model in my profession is that you train in that approach because then it becomes a self-sustaining system of support of personal and professional development.
- 31:28I'm ready once I qualify to supervise people who are coming up behind me and the people who are ahead of me are supervising me.
- 31:35So it's a brilliant system.
- 31:37It's completely self-sustaining.
- 31:39It operates at no cost to your organisation because you're supervising each other often.
- 31:43I mean, sometimes there are costs because you have to get external supervisors in, but generally speaking, it's a great system.
- 31:50And I looked at HR.
- 31:51We looked at HR when we started to uncover this degree of distress that was going on.
- 31:57And we said, where's their source of support?
- 32:01Why have they not got this kind of system of support that we've had through our careers that has served this incredibly important function?
- 32:11You know, it's a personal and professional development tool, system.
- 32:16And it's called that because it's there to develop you in your professional skills, your technical skills, but it's also there for you personally.
- 32:25And so, you know, if I had a particularly tricky session with a client, you know, when I was doing therapy work, I had supervision there to talk about the impact of that on me, what it felt like, you know, about the distress, how difficult it was.
- 32:39I could also talk about how I might work with that person going forwards, you know, the sort of tools and techniques that I might need.
- 32:48And the fact that I could have that conversation in work, in work time, meant that I could process that emotional impact.
- 32:56I could put it to bed and I could go home at the end of the day, knowing that, you know, I dealt with it.
- 33:02And actually, that meant that my free time was there for me to recuperate, to rest, relax, and, you know, it can then help me to be ready to perform at my best when I go back to work the next day.
- 33:15And we just thought, you know, this is so lacking in HR.
- 33:21So we're trained supervisors.
- 33:24This is what we're going to deliver.
- 33:26Love it.
- 33:27Love it.
- 33:28What, Jo, in all of that work, are some of the most common things that you're having to deal with?
- 33:36Things that perhaps now echoed in the results of your survey?
- 33:42Well, I think that the, generally, the sort of motivating factor that brings people to us is around their people's well-being.
- 33:50So people who are kind of, know they're on the road to burnout, you know, potentially, or who are, you know, struggling and they're noticing the signs.
- 33:59So that tends to be the sort of, the thing that brings them to us.
- 34:05Although we're working with both individuals and teams, and I would say it's, in that case, it's the individuals who are motivated by that.
- 34:13When it's teams, it's often the, you know, the team manager who's realizing that actually the content of what people are dealing with is distressing and difficult, is having an emotional impact.
- 34:25But interestingly, and so that's where we start, but interestingly, while we will probably spend some time supporting someone to build, to address that set of issues around potential, you know, looming burnout or, you know, that kind of thing.
- 34:41So we're thinking about setting boundaries and, and, you know, doing all sorts of things that, you know, we can put in place to protect people and their well-being.
- 34:49What we are going on then to talk about is some of those things that contribute to the the challenging nature of the job.
- 34:58So the tricky conversations, you know, I mean, I just took two supervision sessions yesterday and both of them were about having a tricky conversation with someone.
- 35:08In one case, it was having a tricky conversation with the CEO of this company that I work in.
- 35:14The other was having a tricky conversation with an employee.
- 35:18So it was, how do I approach this?
- 35:20What do I say?
- 35:22What's going on here in the dynamic?
- 35:24So I thought we're kind of bringing our psychological skills and we're helping people to sort of unpick that, you know, that interpersonal challenge, which I think is a big source of the stress and difficulty that's, you know, around in HR.
- 35:40So we're just, we're walking alongside, we're giving space to reflect, we're giving space to problem solve.
- 35:47And I think we're also work so busy nowadays and HR is absolutely no exception.
- 35:53In fact, 50% of our respondents said workload was their biggest source of stress.
- 35:59You know, we're all so busy nowadays that we really lack that space to reflect and to think through and to problem solve.
- 36:07And that's what HR supervision becomes.
- 36:11So it starts, you know, how do we look after you and protect your wellbeing?
- 36:15And then it moves on to the kind of interpersonal challenges that people are facing.
- 36:20Ethical dilemmas is another one, you know, space just to think through, what should I do in this situation?
- 36:25There's no real right answer, but let's think together so that we can confidently go forward and say, that probably is the right way forward here.
- 36:34I think it's fascinating because there's lots of differences and parallels with some of the more generalised challenges that I see in my work about difficult conversations and building trust and having an effective confrontation and all those sorts of bits and pieces.
- 36:50But this is now wrapped up in internal people issues, ethical issues, and also carrying multiple emotional loads of other people when you're dealing with these things.
- 37:00And this supervision thing, in my head at least, certainly feels like a far more targeted, intentional mentoring and coaching programme where someone's really got to find, still got to find the solutions ultimately for themselves, but they're getting a strong steer and support from you.
- 37:20Absolutely.
- 37:21And I think that is the job of the supervisor.
- 37:23Like I said, it's to walk alongside and to kind of facilitate.
- 37:28And I think we're using lots of coaching techniques and skills.
- 37:32We're using mentoring, techniques and skills.
- 37:36I think we're using some ingredients of counselling too because of the fact that we're bringing some emotional stuff.
- 37:42I spoke to someone last week who was experiencing something personal that was impacting on their work.
- 37:48And we talked about that and how difficult and painful that was and what the impact was and how they might go forwards with it and how they might function at work despite that difficult thing.
- 38:00There's some elements of counselling in there too.
- 38:03But that's what it's meant to be.
- 38:06Supervision is meant to be a place where you can talk about yourself and you can bring yourself, going back to the conversation about the authentic self and your emotions.
- 38:15It goes back to that too, doesn't it?
- 38:16I think that's all about that safe space.
- 38:18And not underestimating the benefit and power of time to reflect.
- 38:24With workload and everything else you've mentioned, it is often, that's the bit that goes missing.
- 38:30The ability to try and do that emotional intelligence, rationalising of what's actually happening rather than just living in the frenzied moment and just constantly reacting to everything, which is just draining us of all sorts of energy and causing lots of problems.
- 38:45I think it's fascinating.
- 38:46And you've mentioned the wellbeing word quite a lot.
- 38:50And I think this is another fascinating area, a whole other episode, I'm sure.
- 38:55But I referenced the Oxford University sort of research centre piece of research that basically sort of said that a lot of these wellbeing, I can't even use the word strategies.
- 39:06Let's just say activities are not doing anything.
- 39:11And in some cases, actually causing problems.
- 39:14I wonder if that's what you're seeing, that the issues that are coming through, there's a more systemic problem here.
- 39:22There's a lot of performative, superficial perks and stuff associated with wellbeing, which is why I think wellbeing gets a bad rap in a lot of cases.
- 39:32And I tried to find alternative research studies to give a counter view.
- 39:38And there's not lots, to be fair.
- 39:40I mean, the bits I could find were the usual suspects of Deloitte and Harvard Business Review, who all seem to point to, look, wellbeing is important, but actually the movement comes from more systemic, strategic issues to address within workplace design, job design, leadership behaviour, cultural environment.
- 40:02I'm fascinated to get your thought on this as somebody who's right inside what's going on right now.
- 40:07Yeah, it's fascinating for me coming from a healthcare background.
- 40:12You know, I worked in the NHS for well over 20 years.
- 40:15And when we started working in the workplace setting, I have to say I was extremely shocked at how behind.
- 40:27So, you know, that sounds really bad.
- 40:31You know, how ill-informed workplaces were about how you support people's health and wellbeing, how you address it when it's in crisis, how you prevent health and wellbeing issues from developing in the first place.
- 40:46And I'm not blaming them for that because actually what happened was a pandemic happened.
- 40:51And, you know, it became suddenly the job of workplaces to really focus on this much more.
- 40:59They weren't really thinking about it before that because the NHS was dealing with it or someone else was dealing with it.
- 41:05But suddenly it became something, you know, a central thing that they had to be offering to their employees.
- 41:14And so, you know, they are on the back foot and they're learning.
- 41:21And I think that's what I've seen really is that I think what happens first of all, when you're presented with a problem and you don't really know what to do with it, is you go, oh, what's out there already?
- 41:32What are other people doing?
- 41:34And you go, oh, well, then I'll do that.
- 41:36So there's been a lot of that going on.
- 41:39There is, yeah.
- 41:39There's been a lot of picking up the latest thing because it looks shiny and it's, you know, it's been marketed really in a really slick fashion.
- 41:48There's been a lot of that going on.
- 41:50There's been a lot of grabbing for stuff because we just need to find a solution as quickly as possible.
- 41:56And, you know, we know that that doesn't work.
- 41:59It doesn't work.
- 42:01And so, although when that research came out from Oxford, that, you know, although lots of people were saying, well, this proves that well-being initiatives just don't work at all.
- 42:12I felt that, you know, that's not the right outcome.
- 42:15That's not the right conclusion.
- 42:17The right conclusion is that, you know, is actually we've not, the technology is not advanced enough.
- 42:24You know, we're not thinking in a, particularly in a more strategic way about how we address these issues.
- 42:31And certainly one of their conclusions is that actually initiatives that are targeted at a more systemic level are more effective.
- 42:39And so, you know, that gives us some answers already, doesn't it?
- 42:42You know?
- 42:43I think it does.
- 42:44I mean, there are parallels in the Engage for Success survey that's been done post-pandemic on a number of occasions looking at the, much like your survey actually, in that where people felt safe, in a good place, supported, well-being was taken seriously, their likelihood to remain much higher, their engagement much higher, issues of stress burnout much lower.
- 43:12But I think I am in your, I'm in your court here because I think we've almost come full circle in this conversation.
- 43:20The conversation we had about emotions and why we don't touch that, it's a bit difficult.
- 43:25And then you come into the well-being stuff.
- 43:27Well, there's a quick bolt on, there's a quick kind of plaster I can kind of take here, rub my hands of it.
- 43:32I've given you some well-being stuff, get on with it.
- 43:35Why on earth is that going to help someone in their emotional state?
- 43:39It's support and understanding, I think that's required in these situations.
- 43:43And as we learn from lots of these conversations, there are so many unique nuances and differences between people.
- 43:49Why would we think an app is going to solve the world when it comes to this stuff?
- 43:53I don't know.
- 43:55It seems a bit daft to me.
- 43:58I don't like to sort of leave these podcast episodes on sort of niggie notes of this is rubbish or what.
- 44:05I try and think about where do we go and what practical steps can people take?
- 44:12And from all the things that you've ended up dealing with in all of your career and certainly where your focus is now, where do you think organisations can start to think about the root cause of some of these things rather than plaster on the things that we see?
- 44:29Where can they start to reduce the emotional burden?
- 44:32And we're talking about HR, so let's focus in on that, on this HR group.
- 44:36Where do we start with that?
- 44:38In terms of looking after HR, do you mean?
- 44:40Yeah, I think trying to reduce that emotional burden.
- 44:42Is that even possible?
- 44:44Well, I think we have to acknowledge it first.
- 44:47Yeah.
- 44:47I think that's one of the problems that HR professionals face is that it's not been acknowledged.
- 44:55And so if it's not acknowledged, then they feel like they have no voice, they have no permission to say this is a problem for me.
- 45:02I'm struggling here.
- 45:04And if organisations are able to acknowledge it and say, we recognise that your job comes with a load of emotional labour.
- 45:11If they're able to acknowledge and recognise that, then sort of automatically something else has to follow on, doesn't it?
- 45:19If we're acknowledging that your job comes with that emotional labour and actually the existence of supervision for me in my career did exactly that.
- 45:29Yeah.
- 45:29Presence of it said to me, you know, your job's going to have an impact on you.
- 45:35And therefore, here's a thing that's going to support you with that.
- 45:38And so that's what we need to see in organisations is that, first of all, that acknowledgement and recognition.
- 45:46This is a reality of doing this job.
- 45:49Therefore, what are we going to do about it?
- 45:51That leads to a solution, doesn't it?
- 45:54I think that's right.
- 45:55I think that combination of acknowledgement, understanding, but the support mechanisms behind there to find different, better, suitable, relevant ways forward.
- 46:09Interesting.
- 46:10I can't help but not hide from the fact that, or hide from the fact that other departments are going to say, yeah, well, what about us?
- 46:16And I think this is what's really interesting.
- 46:18I don't think what we're saying, I hope not what we're saying here today is, by the way, HR are the only people that need looking after HR.
- 46:25I've got all the problems.
- 46:26We're just sort of really honing in the emotional toll specific to this particular profession.
- 46:34It's not to say that other parts of the organization aren't feeling similar things and that they're somehow less important.
- 46:43It's just, let's just have a look at this department and sort of, because they're at the heart of all of these things.
- 46:48And if this lot are burnt out, stressed, not coping, then the support that they give the rest of the organization is going to be, well, not very good.
- 46:58It's not going to be healthy itself, right?
- 47:01To quote someone who did a post recently on LinkedIn, they said, if HR are burning out, the whole organization's on fire.
- 47:10So I can't take credit for that quote, with a brilliant one.
- 47:15And that's it, you know, because HR are playing this job of holding everyone up, of looking after everyone, of holding everyone, of making sure everything runs the way that it needs to, right through from advertising and recruitment through to exiting, you know, they're there all the way along the life cycle of the employee, aren't they?
- 47:36So, and if they're struggling, then actually the ripple effect is massive.
- 47:42But to your point about, you know, wellbeing more broadly, like, you know, as I said earlier, workload came out as the top source of stress for our survey respondents.
- 47:53We know that's mirrored across the workforce.
- 47:57We know that workload is one of the, you know, is identified already as the top source of stress for people across the organization.
- 48:05So there are a load of things that can be done, right, across the organization that HR professionals could benefit from.
- 48:11I just think that HR are a particular case in point.
- 48:15I think they need something specific.
- 48:17I think the nature of their job, you know, a lot of what they're doing is confidential.
- 48:21Yeah, that comes with its own pressures and emotions, right?
- 48:24Exactly.
- 48:24It brings its own pressures and emotions, but it also means they can't really realistically be in a room with someone else receiving a wellbeing initiative.
- 48:32You know, that's not going to work.
- 48:34It doesn't feel comfortable.
- 48:35It doesn't feel right.
- 48:37So, you know, there's sort of boundaries, professional boundaries there that need to be maintained.
- 48:42And so I just think this is a group that needs something very specific.
- 48:46And so I think, and it needs to be tailored to them and their needs.
- 48:49But there are huge needs right across the organisation, absolutely, in terms of wellbeing.
- 48:57Jo, in an attempt to try and bring this episode to a positive close, I've come to the part of the show I call sticky notes.
- 49:06So this is where I'm looking for your absolute pearls of wisdom that we could fit on three little sticky notes and we'll put them on the Instagram channel.
- 49:14Thinking about if we could take the wellbeing of people more seriously at work, what would your three bits of advice be?
- 49:25I think my first bit of advice would be define wellbeing.
- 49:30Because...
- 49:30Great start.
- 49:33Because we actually don't have an agreed definition of wellbeing.
- 49:37So as an organisation, the onus is on you to define what you mean by wellbeing.
- 49:42Let's not just bandy about the word wellbeing because it doesn't really mean anything.
- 49:47Yeah.
- 49:47Be strategic.
- 49:48That's my second point.
- 49:50I mean, I just read today, literally, that the CIPD had done some research which found that 50% of organisations said that they had a wellbeing strategy.
- 50:00Now, I have to say, I do not believe that.
- 50:04Wow.
- 50:05I mean, like I say, I've been working in this area for about 12 years.
- 50:09I've worked with, I don't know, 150 organisations.
- 50:12I've met thousands.
- 50:14I'm on a panel, a judging panel for wellbeing awards.
- 50:18The number of organisations that have a substantive wellbeing strategy, not a plan, a strategy...
- 50:26Exactly.
- 50:27...is sparse.
- 50:28It's minimal.
- 50:30So really think about your strategy.
- 50:33So define wellbeing.
- 50:35Yeah.
- 50:36Be strategic and remember people are human.
- 50:39Really?
- 50:39Just that.
- 50:43I mean, the whole world would be better, Jo, if everybody kind of took stock and realised that at time to time.
- 50:50Listen, three fabulously simple but powerful sticky notes there.
- 50:56Thank you so much for taking time out of, I know, your very, very busy schedule to come and sit down and talk to us today.
- 51:03Really appreciate it.
- 51:04Before I let you go, Jo, if people would like to find out a bit more about you, a bit more about HR supervision, where can they find you?
- 51:11Where should they go?
- 51:13So our website is ultimateresilience.co.uk and you can download our HR Mental Wellbeing Report from there on the homepage.
- 51:21There's a button you can press and you can download it from there and you can learn about HR supervision on that website too.
- 51:28If you're interested in HR wellbeing, I'm talking about it a lot on LinkedIn.
- 51:33So you can come and follow me and join me on LinkedIn.
- 51:37I am Dr Jo Burrell on LinkedIn.
- 51:40So please, you know, come and say hello.
- 51:43Well, I'll put all those links in the show notes too.
- 51:46Jo, thank you so much for coming on.
- 51:48It's been an absolute delight to have you here.
- 51:50Thanks very much for your time.
- 51:51Thank you so much for having me.
- 51:53Okay, see you soon.
- 51:56Okay, that was Dr Jo Burrell and if you'd like to find out a bit more about her or any of the topics that we've talked about in today's episode, please check out the show notes.
- 52:09So that concludes today's episode.
- 52:12I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 52:23If you have, please like, comment and subscribe.
- 52:26It really helps.
- 52:28I'm Andy Goram and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 52:33Until next time, thanks for listening.