Latest / This is Oregon / S1E4: How to Parent Digital Kids
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to This Is Oregon,
- 0:04podcast where we take you inside research happening at the University of Oregon
- 0:09and show you how it applies to your daily life.
- 0:11I'm Sherri Buri McDonald, your host for this episode.
- 0:15My guest is Jen Doty, associate professor at the University
- 0:18of Oregon's Department of Counseling Psychology and Human Services.
- 0:23She's an expert on youth and technology, and we'll be talking about how parents
- 0:27can help their kids safely navigate online spaces like social media.
- 0:32Thanks for joining us, Jen.
- 0:34Yeah, happy to be here. Great.
- 0:36Would you mind quickly introducing yourself to our listeners?
- 0:39Yeah, absolutely.
- 0:40You mentioned a little bit about the department I'm with.
- 0:44I'm also affiliated with the University of Oregon Prevention Science Institute
- 0:48and The Ballmer Institute for Children’s Behavioral Health.
- 0:52And I was trained in family science, and I got a postdoc in adolescent health.
- 0:58So families and teens is kind of my thing.
- 1:00And I've been focusing on technology
- 1:05and parent child relationships to promote adolescent well-being.
- 1:09So I think about that as kind of two sides of a coin when it comes to technology.
- 1:15I'm trying to reach parents via technology,
- 1:18but I'm also trying to help them with technology in their own homes
- 1:22and with what their kids are doing with technology.
- 1:25So, Jen, we've seen the headlines about cyber bullying and the Surgeon General's
- 1:29call for a warning label on social media to protect kids well-being.
- 1:33How big of a problem is this?
- 1:36Well, this might actually surprise you.
- 1:38The research actually shows it doesn't show a correlation
- 1:44or an association between screen time and teens’ mental health.
- 1:50So I think part of what's happening here
- 1:53is that for some kids, it might be a problem.
- 1:57And for others it can actually be a help.
- 1:59And so the way that algorithms work,
- 2:02they tend to magnify whatever's going on in the kiddos life.
- 2:05So if you would imagine a kiddo who comes home from school one day
- 2:10and they've had a great day, they were at school
- 2:14and they did great on their math test, and then they had fun
- 2:18with their friends at lunch, and they were talking and and socializing.
- 2:22And then they got word that they made
- 2:26the basketball team and, and they're they're on cloud nine, right?
- 2:31They get online a little bit.
- 2:33They complement things.
- 2:34They are bit creative online because they're feeling great.
- 2:38Now imagine another kid who went to school and they had a terrible day.
- 2:44They did terrible on that same math math test.
- 2:47There were kids giving them nasty looks at lunch, and then after school,
- 2:51they found out that they didn't get the part in the play that they wanted,
- 2:55so they might go home and get on social media
- 2:58and they might be attracted to kind of darker material.
- 3:01And then the algorithm feeds them that and they go down a rabbit hole.
- 3:05There was a huge research study by Orben et al.
- 3:09and they found that among over 80,000 students,
- 3:13that screen time wasn't related to life satisfaction.
- 3:17It didn't have a relationship on average.
- 3:20But what they did find is that there were subgroups that were at risk.
- 3:25Girls 11 to 13 during that age,
- 3:29if they were using a lot of social media and screen time.
- 3:32A year later, they reported lower life satisfaction
- 3:35and boys about ages 14 to 15, and then both sexes
- 3:41at like the transition out of high school into college.
- 3:45So it's those transition times that they might be vulnerable.
- 3:49And also subgroups of, you know, kids who are exposed to a lot of racism
- 3:54or kids who are doing a lot of social comparison.
- 3:57That might be at higher risk, but not necessarily everyone.
- 4:01Interesting.
- 4:02Well, we know that many families
- 4:04struggle with issues around screen time and social media.
- 4:08What's the big picture?
- 4:09How much time are kids spending on screens?
- 4:12Yeah, I love asking this question in groups of parents
- 4:16because almost always it matches the research.
- 4:19Parents are underreporting what kids are saying they're spending online.
- 4:24And so Common Sense Media, right after the right towards
- 4:27the end of the pandemic, 2021 did a huge national survey
- 4:31and they found that tweens these are the 8 to 12 year olds,
- 4:35they're spending over five hours a day on screens,
- 4:39and then teenagers are spending over eight hours a day on screens.
- 4:45So that’s a lot.
- 4:46And that includes things like you know, listening to music and stuff,
- 4:49but it doesn't include, like, doing homework online.
- 4:52So that's like screens for entertainment.
- 4:55A lot of influence, a lot of time that they're spending on these screens.
- 4:59So that number seems huge.
- 5:00At least a third of a teen's day.
- 5:02What are they doing on the screens?
- 5:04Yeah.
- 5:05That's a that's another good question actually.
- 5:07We know from the Pew Institute that kids
- 5:10say they get mostly positive, benefits from being online.
- 5:15Nearly three quarters, three out of four say
- 5:18that they're making connections and that there are connecting with friends online.
- 5:22So that's a positive thing.
- 5:24And they're being creative.
- 5:26Their creativity is coming out and they're also getting support when they need it.
- 5:31We also know that there's some kids who are having problems.
- 5:35One out of three say that the drama gets kind of overwhelming sometimes.
- 5:39We know about two thirds, 66%
- 5:42or so are witnessing harassment online, and nearly three out of
- 5:47four are exposed to mature content during their teen years.
- 5:51Okay.
- 5:52Well, as parents or guardians, it's easy to feel out of touch
- 5:56with the apps or social media platforms our kids are using.
- 5:59What message do you have for us?
- 6:01What is our role in helping our kids establish healthy relationships
- 6:05with this technology?
- 6:07Yeah.
- 6:07And I, I will say here that
- 6:11I got into this research
- 6:13because I am a mom and my kids were struggling
- 6:17with screens and social media and cyberbullying and all of the things.
- 6:22So I am right there with you all.
- 6:24And I, I have to say,
- 6:28kids will always be like ten steps ahead of us
- 6:32when it comes to technology, but they need their parents.
- 6:35And parents play such a vital role in modeling
- 6:39social relationships and emotional regulation.
- 6:43So it's so important that we're talking to our kids.
- 6:45And I have my favorite framework is by a colleague of mine, Joy Gabrielli.
- 6:51And it's the Tech Parenting Framework.
- 6:53It's an acronym T stands for talk to your kids about what they're doing online.
- 6:59Strike a tone of curiosity and just get them talking about,
- 7:04you know what they're doing, what they like about being online.
- 7:07Also, E educate them about risks.
- 7:10So let them know that there are people trying to advertise to them and,
- 7:15help them be aware, you know, have a conversation about maybe
- 7:18some mature content they've seen and talk about your family's values.
- 7:23C is co-use of media.
- 7:26So sharing experiences together online playing together
- 7:30online play is a huge way that people learn and that kids learn.
- 7:34And so you know getting on Snapchat and playing with those funny filters,
- 7:40you know
- 7:40could be one way to use media together, sitting down and watching memes together,
- 7:45watching YouTube videos will give parents
- 7:48an opportunity to have teaching moments
- 7:51and talk about, gosh, what did you think about that scene?
- 7:55And do you think that's realistic?
- 7:57And and again, striking that tone of curiosity
- 8:00and listening to what kids are saying and, and a lot of times
- 8:03kids will have some pretty amazing insights when we do that.
- 8:07And then H is establish house rules.
- 8:10And, we'll talk a little bit more in depth, I think about that.
- 8:14But the idea is that we're collaborating with our kids and,
- 8:18and having open conversations about what do we want our rules to be.
- 8:22Yeah, those are great tips, but help us out here.
- 8:25Your grade schooler is asking for a smartphone.
- 8:28She says you need to be in touch about afterschool pickups and getting her
- 8:32to dance class and piano lessons, and it kind of makes sense.
- 8:36Plus, all of her friends have one.
- 8:38What do you do?
- 8:40That's a good question.
- 8:41And that is like such the famous line from kids, right.
- 8:45Like everybody has one.
- 8:47And there is some research that shows
- 8:51that if kids are the only ones without,
- 8:54for example, social
- 8:55media or a smartphone, when they, you know, get into middle school
- 8:59that there is a social deficit, that that can happen there.
- 9:02And so, I really I don't want to tell parents what to do.
- 9:08Every family has different values around this.
- 9:10Every family has kids at different maturity levels.
- 9:13And so I would encourage a couple of principles.
- 9:17One is really think about development
- 9:20and the how old your kids are.
- 9:23And I like to think about okay,
- 9:26what would be appropriate in an in-person situation.
- 9:29For example, you have an eight year old.
- 9:32Would you let them wander around Grand Central Station by themselves?
- 9:38Probably not. Right.
- 9:39But if you have a teenager and you give them some coaching,
- 9:44they'll probably be okay
- 9:46navigating Grand Central Station even for the first time on their own.
- 9:50So so using that, like what would be okay for my kids in
- 9:54person is a good way to judge what will be okay for them online.
- 9:58The thing that I also think about is with that social deficit, well,
- 10:03if there's a whole community that decides to kind of reduce harm
- 10:07by holding off as long as possible with all these phones,
- 10:10then you get rid of that problem of, oh, well, everybody has one.
- 10:14Right.
- 10:15And so I would encourage families and communities and PTAs,
- 10:19or PTOs, to come together
- 10:22and talk about as a community, like, how long can we wait?
- 10:26To give our kids phones because, then
- 10:29we won't be leaving out just a few kids if everyone does that together.
- 10:32Once you say yes to a smartphone, it only gets more complicated, right?
- 10:36Right. But let's say you have three children.
- 10:39One in fifth grade, one in eighth grade and one in 10th grade.
- 10:43How can you set up
- 10:44rules and expectations for each child given their developmental differences?
- 10:49Yeah, that's that's such a great question.
- 10:51And and again, I think tailoring to your kids maturity
- 10:54level is absolutely key.
- 10:57Fifth graders a lot of them aren't on social media.
- 11:00But what we have been hearing,
- 11:01from schools and from families and parents, is that a lot of
- 11:05these kids are in group chats and they're often not monitored by adults.
- 11:09So you get an entire fifth grade on a group chat
- 11:13and you can have a lot of drama go down right.
- 11:15Some pictures that are inappropriate.
- 11:16And then you've got principals calling the entire grade level all the parents.
- 11:21And it's a lot of work for the schools.
- 11:23It's a it's a big hassle for all the kids who are exposed to whatever
- 11:27drama went down.
- 11:28And so I think just being aware that if kids
- 11:32do have access to technology, it should be highly monitored.
- 11:36But again, if you can wait, the longer you can wait, I think often
- 11:40the better at this age.
- 11:43And I, I always have parents asking me, for software.
- 11:47Like what software can take care of this problem for me.
- 11:51And there are a lot of good softwares out there.
- 11:54Microsoft Family has free software that you can program in when kids
- 11:58have time to go online, how much time
- 12:01they can restrict certain apps.
- 12:04Apple parental controls are also out there.
- 12:06Disney Circle is another one.
- 12:08I have seen kids completely dismantle Disney Circle.
- 12:11So again, kids can usually get around some of these controls.
- 12:15Bark is another one that some families really like
- 12:19because it protects especially like teens privacy.
- 12:23But then it flags parents if there's, you know, some concerning
- 12:27content on there like about cyber bullying or substance abuse.
- 12:32I would say
- 12:32though that because kids can get around this technology,
- 12:36it can backfire and kids can kind of go underground.
- 12:39And really what we want is we want that active conversation.
- 12:43And some of our research is mixed around this, that
- 12:47when there's too much restriction and technology controls going on,
- 12:52that those might actually be the kids who tend to have more problems.
- 12:56And we even see that longitudinally.
- 12:58So I would say really, if you can lean into the conversations
- 13:03and the modeling and the talking about it
- 13:06more than trying to control them with technology.
- 13:11Our own research has shown
- 13:13that talking, with kids about technology, having those active conversations
- 13:19and establishing house rules and making sure everybody knows what those are,
- 13:23has been shown to reduce cyberbullying and risky online behaviors.
- 13:28And sexting behaviors.
- 13:30So I would recommend leaning into those types
- 13:34of parenting, practices at this at this age.
- 13:38And really, as they move on to older ages.
- 13:41Those are great ideas, especially for the grade schoolers.
- 13:44Now for the eighth grader, how does your approach change with middle schoolers?
- 13:49Yeah, that's a great question.
- 13:51I think about a metaphor that I use a lot and that is driving.
- 13:56And with kids who are getting the vehicle,
- 14:00they have a training period with driver's ed,
- 14:02and they get time where they're monitored
- 14:04and they get coached and trained on how to use that technology.
- 14:08And I really think we should be doing the same thing
- 14:11with phones, that kids have a period of time
- 14:14where they get some training and some coaching from, from parents
- 14:19and maybe some digital citizenship in the schools.
- 14:22And then they they kind of learn in a more controlled environment.
- 14:28Right?
- 14:28There's a lot of folks saying, wait until eighth grade
- 14:32to give kids social media or smartphones.
- 14:36I don't know if that's realistic for all families.
- 14:39Some people are even saying wait until age 14 or or 16.
- 14:44Because guys in particular struggle at that age of 14 or 15.
- 14:49But, every family I think has to make their own decision.
- 14:53But whenever you do give kids a phone, I would say
- 14:56strongly suggest kind of some training and monitoring
- 15:00so that, you know, that they're using it in a responsible way.
- 15:03And then another question I get a lot from parents is like what's
- 15:07appropriate content for my kids?
- 15:10And there's so much adult content available to kids.
- 15:13If parents have a question, a great place to go is Common Sense Media.
- 15:19And there's reviews of all sorts of media,
- 15:23movies and TV shows and games
- 15:27from experts and also from parents.
- 15:30And there's good articles about media parenting for parents.
- 15:33So there's just a wealth of information there.
- 15:36And parents can, can go there to kind of figure out
- 15:39if something is appropriate for a middle schooler.
- 15:42So moving on.
- 15:43How about sophomore in high school?
- 15:45Does your approach change with that?
- 15:47Kids need to be ready to manage this stuff on their own,
- 15:50and if parents clamp down for too long, then kids don't have a chance
- 15:54to learn from their own mistakes.
- 15:56And my colleague, Pam Wisniewski,
- 15:59she showed that teens that had a little bit more autonomy,
- 16:04they were more likely to learn from their own mistakes online.
- 16:09And that's some powerful learning, right?
- 16:12So having those experience experiences to be a little bit more independent
- 16:16and to learn from your own mistakes before you leave the house.
- 16:20So if you do crash and burn a little bit, you can have that conversation
- 16:23and have support from parents or caregivers.
- 16:26So important.
- 16:27What are some resources to help families set up their house rules?
- 16:31You mentioned earlier the importance of setting house rules.
- 16:35Yeah, I think this is so important to be kind of
- 16:38a collaborative process and to sit down with kids, kind of make it a fun night.
- 16:41And a great tool that we recommend is the American Academy of Pediatrics.
- 16:46They have an interactive website that is called the Family Media Plan.
- 16:51So you can just Google that.
- 16:52And so you put in your family members, you're
- 16:56the parents, the caregivers, the kids and the different ages.
- 17:00And they give developmental suggestions in nine different areas.
- 17:04So, for example, you could work on the area of media balance.
- 17:08You could work on the area of practicing kindness and empathy.
- 17:13You could work on the area of having screen screen free time
- 17:17in your day as a family.
- 17:20And I really recommend that it's not parents
- 17:24kind of telling kids, this is what we want you to do,
- 17:26but really parents kind of reflecting and modeling to kids.
- 17:30Gosh, I sometimes am on my phone and paying attention to my phone
- 17:35instead of paying attention to you guys, and I really want to change that.
- 17:39And and here's
- 17:40this website and, and gosh, you know, are there things you want to work on too?
- 17:44And then sitting down and doing that together, like
- 17:47let the kids tell you like, hey,
- 17:49yeah, mom, I do think you should work on this right.
- 17:52And, when kids participate in that process,
- 17:55they're more likely to have buy in, and then you can print those
- 17:59and put them in a, in a place where you can all see them,
- 18:02and then when something does happen
- 18:05that, you know, somebody is crossing a line,
- 18:08you can go back to those rules in that conversation and, and talk
- 18:12about it and, and maybe reevaluate, like, do we want to add some rules?
- 18:17Do we want to take away some rules?
- 18:18But then it becomes an ongoing tool for conversation.
- 18:23What are the signs that a child's technology use is a problem,
- 18:26and what should parents do about it?
- 18:28Yeah.
- 18:29I'm so glad that you asked this question because, there are a subset of kiddos
- 18:34who are really kind of struggling, and I hear the word addiction
- 18:39a lot in reference to kids technology, you know, technology use.
- 18:43But the honest truth is, most of them wouldn't
- 18:46meet any kind of like diagnostic criteria for addiction.
- 18:51But there are some signs that parents can look for
- 18:54to see if there might be some a sign of problematic internet use
- 18:58that could lead to addiction down the road.
- 19:00And so some of those are one.
- 19:03If digital media is getting in the way of everyday activities,
- 19:09if it's interfering with things that kids need to do, for example, their homework,
- 19:13getting to bed on time, they're, you know, scrolling at night and then falling
- 19:17asleep the next day in math, that that is a sign that maybe it's an issue.
- 19:23And then the second, kind of screening
- 19:26tool is, if if kids are engaging
- 19:30in excessive effort to be online, for example,
- 19:34you know, let's say their parents
- 19:35take away their phone at night and plug it in in a central location,
- 19:39and parents find a kiddo up in the middle of the night in the office,
- 19:44you know, playing video games.
- 19:45That's excessive effort to to be online, you know, and that could be a problem.
- 19:49If they're craving digital media, even when they're away from it, like,
- 19:53let's say, you know, family goes out to a baseball game and the kiddo,
- 19:58like, keeps talking about social media or they're in class
- 20:02and they can't concentrate because they're thinking about
- 20:04what is going on in an online drama situation.
- 20:08You know, then that could also be a warning sign,
- 20:12if they're spending more time than they meant to quite a bit,
- 20:16they lose track of time.
- 20:17That could be a sign.
- 20:19And then if parents see that they're losing, like real life, face
- 20:23to face relationships, with friends and family and, you know, holding up
- 20:28and playing video games a lot, that's also a sign that might be concerning.
- 20:33And so if parents start to see these patterns,
- 20:35they might want to talk to a school social worker.
- 20:38They might want to talk to their pediatrician
- 20:42and and voice their concerns and get some support.
- 20:45Because it could be a sign of this problematic internet
- 20:49use pattern that could lead to addiction down the road.
- 20:53To sum up, what do you hope listeners take away from our conversation?
- 20:56The word that I always highlight is balance.
- 20:59And so that is,
- 21:01you know, balance between technology and other activities in kids lives.
- 21:06That is balance in terms of giving kids
- 21:09more access and more responsibility that matches their development
- 21:13in their maturity.
- 21:14And then it's also building those relationships.
- 21:18And so
- 21:19I can't emphasize enough
- 21:21how important, face to face relationships are.
- 21:26And, and parents and caregivers, what a critical role you play,
- 21:30even if kids are ahead of you developmentally when it comes
- 21:33to technology, socially, they they have a lot to learn.
- 21:37And they learn that in our face to face relationships with each other.
- 21:40We appreciate all the great ideas and resources you've shared.
- 21:44Links to those resources will be available in the episode description.
- 21:48Thank you for joining me on the podcast, Jen.
- 21:50Oh, absolutely a pleasure.
- 21:51Thank you for having me.
- 21:53This is Oregon is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 21:57For more of the latest University of Oregon research and news,
- 22:01visit news.uoregon.edu
- 22:04or find us on your favorite social media platform
- 22:07using the handle @uoregon.
- 22:10Thanks for listening and Go Ducks!