Latest / Raising Men / Healing Cultural Shame and Reconnecting with our Sons with Dr. Adam McCormick
Transcript
- 0:00again
- 0:00whether it's on a college campus or in a youth prison
- 0:02when things get heavy
- 0:02we start talking about trauma or heavy stuff
- 0:05you know loss
- 0:05grief that sort of stuff
- 0:07it's so interesting how
- 0:09how funny the room gets initially
- 0:11and I always catch it and I always say
- 0:12you guys notice that we're
- 0:13we're we all including me sometimes we
- 0:16you know somebody shared something really heavy
- 0:18and we felt the need there to make a joke
- 0:20to disarm a little bit you know
- 0:22um it's just one of those many examples with boys where
- 0:25you know we
- 0:26we don't even real I mean I
- 0:27I could give you 100 with my son
- 0:28and in things that I've done
- 0:30where I've just kind of
- 0:31tried to rush him through an emotion
- 0:32talk him out of an emotion
- 0:34get get
- 0:34get him through it as fast as he can
- 0:36without even realizing
- 0:38and I'm a social worker yeah
- 0:40yeah you're trained
- 0:41you're you're really aware of this stuff
- 0:43how are we normal mortals supposed to deal with it
- 0:54welcome back to raising men
- 0:55today on the Raising Men podcast
- 0:57we're joined by the author of
- 0:59The Cost of becoming a boy
- 1:02a groundbreaking book at how
- 1:05cultural expectations of masculinity
- 1:08systematically train boys to disconnect from their own
- 1:14emotional lives he's a professor
- 1:16of social work at Saint Edwards University
- 1:19with over 25 years of experience
- 1:22working with boys in foster care
- 1:25schools and juvenile detention settings
- 1:28his name is Doctor Adam Mccormick
- 1:31Adam welcome to raising men
- 1:34thank you so much Sean
- 1:35I'm really excited to to be here
- 1:37well it's
- 1:38it's a real pleasure to have you and
- 1:39and your work just absolutely speaks to the heart of
- 1:43of what I'm trying to do um
- 1:46in this entire
- 1:49uh in
- 1:49in this entire project and so let's dive right in now
- 1:52one of the things you write about is
- 1:53how boyhood
- 1:55itself seems to operate as a form of cultural trauma
- 2:01which trains boys to kind of
- 2:03abandon traits like vulnerability and tenderness
- 2:07and help seeking just so that they can belong
- 2:10so tell me about that or how does that come about
- 2:13and how does this
- 2:14this kind of early emotional self erasure show up in
- 2:19in the everyday lives of young men
- 2:22yeah uh
- 2:23it's a great question uh
- 2:25and I call it the the
- 2:26the great setup here and for
- 2:29for so many boys we're
- 2:31we're kind of
- 2:31raised to reject those things in our society that have
- 2:34that have just been been feminized right
- 2:37um and
- 2:39and for a lot of the boys that I work with and
- 2:41and I include myself in this
- 2:42I grew up with a very very just
- 2:44just kind of hyper um masculine
- 2:48very emotionally immature
- 2:51rough hard father
- 2:54um but also my culture was very much uh
- 2:56that way as as well
- 2:58so not to just kind of
- 2:59reject everything that's kind of been feminized
- 3:01but to to have this almost disdain or hatred uh
- 3:05for it now
- 3:05the problem with that what I
- 3:06you know certainly
- 3:07what I've Learned over the course of 25 years
- 3:09working with survivors of childhood trauma
- 3:11is a lot of the things in our culture
- 3:13a lot of the things in our society
- 3:14that we have just kind of feminized
- 3:16that these boys are are
- 3:17are really policed into or trained into rejecting
- 3:21are the are the
- 3:22are the very things that you
- 3:23fundamentally need to be a happy and healthy person
- 3:27especially in in childhood
- 3:28we think about emotional expression
- 3:30we have to grow up in an environment where we can
- 3:32fully feel and safely express the full range of our
- 3:36our emotions we talk about connection relationships
- 3:40uh to express a need if we're
- 3:42if we're struggling in in any sort of way um excitement
- 3:46joy sometimes for for
- 3:47for boys I think about this when I would go read to my
- 3:50my uh
- 3:51kids uh
- 3:51classes when they were little
- 3:52in kindergarten and preschool
- 3:55go read a book to the class
- 3:56and they used to always like when I would come
- 3:57because I would do the voices and uh
- 3:59you know the little boys in the class
- 4:01they're just their hands are up
- 4:02they're talking over you
- 4:03they're showing you their artwork on the wall
- 4:05they're so proud of it those same boys
- 4:07by the time that they're in 5th or sixth grade
- 4:09you don't see any of that anymore
- 4:11so even the just the
- 4:12the excitement the joy
- 4:13the curiosity you know
- 4:15these are just
- 4:16the fundamental things that we need to be happy
- 4:18and healthy human beings
- 4:19but especially in childhood
- 4:21and then when we think about young people
- 4:23who experience the wounds of trauma
- 4:24which is kind of where my work focuses on relationships
- 4:28emotional expression asking for help
- 4:30support connection
- 4:32these are the only things that
- 4:33could ever heal those wounds
- 4:35or counterbalance the stress of those events
- 4:37and for so many boys they're just kind of policed into
- 4:41forced
- 4:41into disconnecting from those parts of themselves
- 4:45man what a vicious cycle
- 4:46I suspect and
- 4:48I mean the
- 4:48the way that you frame that story is so clear to me
- 4:53when I look back at my own kind of childhood experience
- 4:56I mean I remember a specific instance
- 5:00where it felt like the light in my eyes that
- 5:04that you're talking about
- 5:05that innocence faded
- 5:07I had a teacher in school that specifically kind of
- 5:11shamed me for that kind of joyous
- 5:15reveling activity and and literally
- 5:20the switch flipped in my brain
- 5:22and made it to where I felt shame for that and
- 5:26and took it away for years
- 5:28and I almost didn't get it back
- 5:31I don't know if I ever got it back really
- 5:33um certainly as I become older
- 5:35as I become my own as I've had my own kids
- 5:38I start to I
- 5:39I I'm
- 5:40I feel differently about it
- 5:41and I feel like that's a lot more protected and
- 5:45and I view my own mission in my life
- 5:50for both of my kids I have a son and a daughter and
- 5:54but particularly for my son
- 5:56that that fire within his eyes is
- 5:59is there it's blazing
- 6:02and I wanna keep it blazing for as long as I can and
- 6:07but the world is coming for it
- 6:08it feels like right and and
- 6:11and so and I think we
- 6:14we you know you
- 6:15you you write
- 6:17um so well that
- 6:20that we're and I'll just quote you to yourself
- 6:23we're living in a moment which
- 6:24in which boys and men
- 6:25are facing unprecedented rates of depression suicide
- 6:30school disengagement loneliness addiction
- 6:33relational instability and violence
- 6:36and I mean
- 6:37when you look at it that starkly
- 6:39and you look at the data
- 6:40you just can't look away from it
- 6:41it is like a car crash is sitting there
- 6:45and you never even knew it was there
- 6:46you just kind of drove around it
- 6:47and you didn't even pay attention
- 6:49and now it it
- 6:51I mean and
- 6:51and if you and if you look at it
- 6:53it becomes so obvious but it also
- 6:56there's sort of a deeper cultural issue here
- 6:59where it feels to me like
- 7:01in every other aspect of our culture
- 7:03we seem to quote
- 7:05make space for all the nuances of experience and
- 7:09and you know
- 7:09take time to understand the deeper issues
- 7:12driving the behavior and all of that stuff every
- 7:15you know everywhere we don't
- 7:16we don't blame the victim
- 7:17we we try to understand what the root causes are
- 7:20and all of that and that's the right thing to do
- 7:23but then when it comes to our boys
- 7:25we're happy to to blame the victim
- 7:27and that seems to me to be disastrous
- 7:33and I think your book is starting
- 7:35you know trying to drive right to the heart of that and
- 7:38and so what you know
- 7:40how are you attempting to crack that nut
- 7:43in a way that is productive
- 7:45as opposed to kind of uh
- 7:47you know counterproductive
- 7:48yeah that's a great question um
- 7:50you know we have to
- 7:51we have to start to learn to walk and chew gum
- 7:53at the same time like we can
- 7:55we can do the things that we need to do in society
- 7:58to hold boys and young men accountable
- 8:00to understand you know
- 8:01hurt people often times are gonna grow up to
- 8:03to to hurt people
- 8:04and we can absolutely hold folks accountable boys
- 8:09young men grown men accountable for their
- 8:11their behaviors at the same time
- 8:14we have to do a better uh
- 8:15job of of recognizing
- 8:17especially in boyhood that this
- 8:18this is this is rooted in
- 8:20in a wound I mean
- 8:21your example there where
- 8:22where you were talking about the educator who
- 8:25you know who they
- 8:26they shamed you into this
- 8:27this moment right
- 8:28and and everything that I
- 8:29I talk about when a boy disconnects from his
- 8:32his his emotions
- 8:33when he disconnects from that excitement or that joy
- 8:36when he disconnects from you know
- 8:39all of these human parts of himself
- 8:41it's really really important that
- 8:43that we recognize that disconnection right
- 8:46as being rooted in in shame and whether we're
- 8:50we're overly harsh and entirely focused on behaviors
- 8:53and just kind of have these punitive
- 8:57you know rigid behaviorally based responses to boys
- 9:00you know we're gonna suspend you
- 9:01we're gonna expel you you're gonna get in trouble right
- 9:03or um
- 9:06you know whether we
- 9:07you know we just
- 9:07just completely shame you
- 9:09without really acknowledging the wounds that are
- 9:13that are being experienced here
- 9:15that's just not going to work
- 9:16you will you know
- 9:17I've worked with survivors
- 9:18of childhood trauma for 25 years
- 9:20one thing Sean
- 9:20I have never seen in 25 years is a
- 9:24a a kid
- 9:24or an adult who has been shamed out of something
- 9:28that they were shamed into
- 9:29into in
- 9:30in the first place that just
- 9:31it just human behavior does not work that way
- 9:33child development does not work yeah
- 9:36when you say it like that
- 9:37it's obvious it's not gonna work
- 9:38yeah right
- 9:39I mean of course it doesn't work
- 9:40it it's
- 9:41I've never been that like
- 9:43I mean yeah
- 9:44I've never been shamed out of
- 9:45out of anything I've been shamed into either
- 9:48and and so
- 9:49and in fact what it
- 9:51what it does is
- 9:51drive me to look for alternatives to that environment
- 9:55and then of course
- 9:56I'm gonna find now on social media and the internet
- 9:59and I'm gonna find a Miriam of
- 10:02of people that are just waiting with open arms
- 10:05to bring me in and then
- 10:08you know start their grift on me and
- 10:10and so like
- 10:12we're just driving our sons into the arms of people
- 10:16that they're not there to help them
- 10:18they're
- 10:18not there to help them adapt and thrive in our culture
- 10:21they're there to stoke grievance and to make
- 10:25get money and power and and whatever else
- 10:27and social influence out of
- 10:30creating an audience of folks that are agreed and
- 10:33and so and that's
- 10:35that's the last place we want our boys
- 10:37yeah I mean
- 10:38there's an entire ecosystem that are just masterful
- 10:42I mean 10 steps ahead at weaponizing the shame uh
- 10:45and the loneliness of of
- 10:47of boys yeah
- 10:48and we have got to as a society
- 10:49as parents as educators
- 10:51as teachers we have got to do something different
- 10:53to recognize that shame very
- 10:55you know I
- 10:56when I run my groups
- 10:57and it doesn't matter if I'm in a youth prison
- 10:58if I'm in a foster care program
- 11:00if I'm with the students on my college campus
- 11:02here at Saint Edwards or anywhere else
- 11:05when I when I
- 11:06we start talking about shame
- 11:07and this is an emotion that so many of these boys
- 11:10and so many of these young men are absolutely ruled by
- 11:13with no language for it no understanding for it
- 11:17but we start talking about shame
- 11:18for most of them it is
- 11:20it is it becomes so evident right away that
- 11:23despite the fact that they are just ruled
- 11:25governed by this this emotion
- 11:28they have no idea
- 11:29they have no capacity to tolerate that
- 11:32that shame to recognize where it comes from
- 11:35and so if
- 11:36if you know any
- 11:37any one of us
- 11:38just like you said if
- 11:39if if
- 11:39if we have this this emotion of shame
- 11:43and we're not taught and modeled how to tolerate that
- 11:47shame and pride
- 11:48we're always going to turn it outward in some other way
- 11:51I'm gonna blame everybody else
- 11:53for what's going on in my life
- 11:55I'm gonna shut down entirely
- 11:57and disconnect from the people that can
- 11:59that I can connect with that
- 12:00that can help me that can love me
- 12:02there's all sorts there's a host of things
- 12:05you know you
- 12:05I I was talking to my students in class the other day
- 12:07about um
- 12:08the strategic control skill of gaslighting
- 12:11we hear a lot about in our society well
- 12:12we we talk a lot about gaslighting
- 12:14nobody ever talks about you know how
- 12:16where does somebody get that
- 12:18you don't just wake up one morning
- 12:20you know
- 12:20just knowing how to turn somebody's lived exist
- 12:24reality upside down that is
- 12:27that that comes from this inability to tolerate shame
- 12:30it's an evolution that kind of grows into this
- 12:33you know this really unhealthy relationship dynamic of
- 12:36of gaslighting where I'm
- 12:37where I'm effectively just taking all of my shame in
- 12:40in turning it towards you um
- 12:42but what we don't seem to have any curiosity at all for
- 12:47for the wounds that
- 12:49that behavior are rooted in so many other behaviors
- 12:51that they're that they're rooted in in in boys
- 12:54let me let me see if I can restate
- 12:57something I'm hearing from you
- 12:58and see if you agree with it
- 13:00it seems to me that what you're saying is that we have
- 13:04like a fundamental human need
- 13:08like atavistic limbic system
- 13:11um
- 13:11cone of the barbarian brain need to avoid feeling shame
- 13:17and then
- 13:18our culture has figured out how to weaponize that
- 13:21in order to get what it wants out of us in
- 13:26in both like sort of positive ways
- 13:29but also negative ways yeah
- 13:31and
- 13:32and that's probably bad
- 13:35and and I want
- 13:36so I want to ask you this question
- 13:37and this is kind of a hobby horse of mine
- 13:39is there ever an appropriate use of shame
- 13:44absolutely shame if
- 13:46but if there's
- 13:47another thing I've Learned
- 13:47in working with survivors of childhood trauma
- 13:49shame keeps us safer than any other emotion
- 13:51it gets a bad rap but
- 13:52you know for good reason right
- 13:53like we don't want to have shame outside of
- 13:55kind of the do or die relationships
- 13:57where we need it yeah
- 13:58you know but um
- 13:59there's a a brilliant author
- 14:01Gabor mate and he has this
- 14:02what he refers to as a traumatic tension
- 14:04and the tension is
- 14:04between our two most fundamental needs in childhood
- 14:07the first of course
- 14:07is attachment and the second is to be authentic right
- 14:12or to live in alignment with who we were made to be
- 14:14our authentic self but there's
- 14:16there's often times this huge tension between the two
- 14:20and in order to belong whether it's with our parents
- 14:22our family later on in cult
- 14:24you know with our peers teammates
- 14:26classmates
- 14:27uh in order to
- 14:28to secure and maintain or to stay connected
- 14:32we have to disconnect from these
- 14:34these authentic authentic parts of
- 14:38of of of of ourselves right
- 14:40and and and in that disconnection
- 14:42you know
- 14:42trauma really at its core is a disconnection from
- 14:46from our most authentic self now shame is the emotion
- 14:49you know if I grew up with a father who was just just
- 14:54just me he was a rager
- 14:55he was an alcoholic he was I mean he was he was awful
- 14:59yeah imagine if I'm a kid Sean and I
- 15:02I see that he's awful and I tell him
- 15:05you're being awful right now or I'm sad or I'm scared
- 15:08you know he would have rather I be a
- 15:10I was a tender sensitive kind of kid one of those
- 15:12you know really just timid
- 15:14timid sensitive boys yeah
- 15:16he would have preferred I be a serial killer
- 15:18than be a timid sensitive kid
- 15:19imagine if I'm fearful in front of him or I'm scared
- 15:23or I'm emotionally vulnerable in front of him
- 15:26if I show if I express that to him
- 15:27I'm gonna get my clock cleaned right
- 15:29shame is the emotion that says you can't be this right
- 15:32you that that emotion that you're feeling is not okay
- 15:35there's something wrong with it and then over time
- 15:38if it's persistent in your childhood
- 15:40then it's not just
- 15:41there's something wrong with that emotion
- 15:42there's something wrong with that need
- 15:44there's something wrong with setting that boundary
- 15:46it becomes there's something inherently wrong with you
- 15:49right with me here
- 15:51and then so that shame kind of wears out its welcome
- 15:53it follows us into every relationship
- 15:55every interaction every encounter that we have here
- 15:58so you know
- 15:59shame gets a bad there is a
- 16:01there is a good reason
- 16:03that we have the emotional capacity for shame
- 16:05and for for
- 16:06for some men and some boys
- 16:08that shame kept them safe in the moments where they
- 16:12you know you can't be setting boundaries
- 16:14you can't be authentically who you are
- 16:16because you're gonna lose your sense of safety
- 16:19or worse you're gonna lose your sense of belonging
- 16:21or attachment to the people you need to be attached to
- 16:26so basically what you're saying here is that
- 16:28is that shame is a reaction to feeling unsafe
- 16:33and that
- 16:35it is a symptom of being in an unsafe environment
- 16:38and one of the
- 16:41one of the kind of tenants of healthy masculinity is
- 16:47in my in my view is our whole goal
- 16:51our whole job is to create a safe environment
- 16:55which means that if you're creating an environment
- 16:57where people are feeling shame
- 16:58then you
- 16:59by definition failed in creating that safe environment
- 17:03is that would you agree with that
- 17:04oh absolutely
- 17:06without question I mean in
- 17:07in in teaching the capacity to tolerate those
- 17:09you know I the
- 17:11the solutions here really
- 17:12I don't think are that that
- 17:14that difficult and
- 17:15I mean it's
- 17:16I think it's a little bit tougher
- 17:17obviously now in our culture
- 17:18in our society where boys are so disconnected and
- 17:21and they don't have access to
- 17:23you know many of the
- 17:25the things that were built into childhood
- 17:27that would have
- 17:28that would have allowed you to connect with that uh
- 17:31authentic self I was watching um
- 17:33a couple months back
- 17:33I was watching Stranger Things with my kids
- 17:35and if you're not familiar with the the
- 17:36the the show
- 17:37I mean everybody's
- 17:38I guess watch Stranger Things but um uh
- 17:41you know it's just this band of
- 17:43of kiddos that are just running around town
- 17:45in the 1980s you know
- 17:47it's what these big
- 17:48big and my
- 17:48and my daughter kind of made a joke and she said dad
- 17:50what in the 1980s
- 17:51did you guys basically
- 17:52just run around town on your bikes and
- 17:54and uh
- 17:55you know get into trouble
- 17:57and I I said well
- 17:58you know it kind of
- 18:00yeah you kind of did
- 18:01you had your pack of friends and you
- 18:03and you you went to the rec center
- 18:04in the community pool in the neighborhood
- 18:06in this friend's house and that friend's house and and
- 18:08and and you had all of this
- 18:10this opportunity for connection and exploration and and
- 18:13and play and curiosity uh and
- 18:15and for many of us you know
- 18:17we still had hardships
- 18:18and I remember my band of friends
- 18:19you know we had fathers who were alcoholics
- 18:21and there was domestic violence and there was all that
- 18:23but but built into our society
- 18:26or play and curiosity in so much connection that's
- 18:31you know
- 18:31and those are the things that kind of counterbalance or
- 18:34or you know the
- 18:34the stressors of life um
- 18:37in the wounds of trauma that's
- 18:38that's how you heal
- 18:39that's how you regulate those sorts of things
- 18:41so for a lot of boys now
- 18:42given that they are so disconnected
- 18:45I saw a statistic here in Texas
- 18:47teenage boys in Texas spend less time playing outdoors
- 18:50than Texas state inmates do
- 18:52um wow
- 18:53a lot of those structures in society
- 18:55that have historically been built in
- 18:58they're gone they're lost for them
- 19:00so now we're seeing all of these really maladaptive
- 19:03but perfectly understandable
- 19:05and explainable ways that boys are
- 19:07are adapting to
- 19:09to this culture that's an interesting headline
- 19:12and I mean
- 19:12it seems like it's that
- 19:14that seems really bad um
- 19:17but you know
- 19:19I mean is it
- 19:20does that
- 19:20is it impossible to develop those sorts of bonds in
- 19:25inside activities or online activities or
- 19:28you know what's the problem with that
- 19:29I mean I think I agree that there is a problem
- 19:32but how do we name that
- 19:34yeah yeah
- 19:35you know I think it's a little bit tougher
- 19:37at the same time I
- 19:37I get it for you know
- 19:38a lot of groups of young people that
- 19:40I think
- 19:40those online connections that they have are really
- 19:42really important for them
- 19:44but I you know it's I
- 19:45I don't I often times think of like online um uh
- 19:51engagement is kind of artificial intimacy in
- 19:53in many ways it's not the same as
- 19:56you know being in
- 19:57in relationship with with
- 19:59with your friends and your teachers
- 20:00and your peers and mentors and coaches and all
- 20:02all of that sort of stuff
- 20:03so
- 20:04no I mean I
- 20:05I think I think they have to have that connection and
- 20:08and and
- 20:08you know we
- 20:09we heal the wounds of of adversity and trauma
- 20:12and hurt and pain and shame in the context of
- 20:16we heal those relationally
- 20:17we know that the only thing that can counterbalance
- 20:19the effects of those things
- 20:20are relationships connection
- 20:21I call it small t therapy
- 20:23um those are just those little interactions that you
- 20:26that you get throughout the day with your peers
- 20:28and your friends and your coaches and your teachers
- 20:31I I think about Covid right
- 20:32these are the things that kids lost
- 20:33and it was no wonder that right away
- 20:36when we were locked down and shut down
- 20:37almost every kid or especially teenager
- 20:39adolescent was anxious and depressed
- 20:41we lost the thing that we needed most
- 20:44I remember getting emails from my students who are
- 20:46you know freshman
- 20:47sophomores in college oh Adam
- 20:49I would kill to be back in class right now sometimes
- 20:51isn't that crazy yeah
- 20:53sometimes from students who never even came to class
- 20:55that was kind of the point
- 20:55we missed the yeah
- 20:57the thing that we needed the most
- 20:58these little interactions are so healing
- 21:01for our nervous systems
- 21:02so regulating for our nervous systems in
- 21:05in what we what we're seeing in the data right now is
- 21:07boys simply are not getting those
- 21:08those interactions and those connections
- 21:12is it is it the case that
- 21:13I mean is it boys specifically aren't getting them
- 21:16and that's the problem or is it that boys specifically
- 21:20they need them more than girls and
- 21:21and that's the problem because
- 21:24I mean girls aren't experiencing this in the same way
- 21:29and and they have
- 21:30I mean girls have challenges
- 21:32no question but they're different and
- 21:34and so they they come out on the data in different ways
- 21:37why is this uniquely pernicious for boys
- 21:41yeah I mean I and
- 21:42and I think we're seeing a
- 21:43a a loneliness crisis in many ways for
- 21:45for for all kids
- 21:47boys girls
- 21:47you know all
- 21:48all kids I think it
- 21:49it the data suggests
- 21:50it's a little bit more pronounced with
- 21:52with boys the
- 21:53the issue often times with
- 21:54with the difference between boys and girls
- 21:56when it comes to this moment of
- 21:58of when when they're in crisis
- 22:00maybe they're having some depression
- 22:01they're having some anxiety
- 22:03they're experiencing some traumatic stress
- 22:05how we respond to that um
- 22:08and recognize that is
- 22:09is entirely different and oftentimes we
- 22:12you know we
- 22:12we see data that um
- 22:14you know suggests uh
- 22:15so we'll take college age young men uh
- 22:17we know college age
- 22:18young men are seven times more likely to
- 22:21to lose their life to suicide than
- 22:23than than college age young women but
- 22:25but also at the same time
- 22:26far less likely to be diagnosed with depression
- 22:29well depression in boys and young men
- 22:31uh boys and young men are taught to kind of
- 22:33externalize behavior it's gonna come out as anger
- 22:35aggression irritability
- 22:37shut down the
- 22:37not the classic things that parents or teachers
- 22:40or educators would be looking at to
- 22:42to to explain that a
- 22:44that a kid is depressed so at the same time
- 22:48we know that boys are oftentimes socialized
- 22:50as part of what you know
- 22:51what I was talking about earlier
- 22:52to disconnect from those most human parts right
- 22:55you're disconnected from the parts of yourself
- 22:57that would tell you you're in crisis
- 22:59that would tell you that you need help
- 23:01and then even if you were to recognize that
- 23:03to be able to ask for that help
- 23:06for many boys is the most shameful thing imaginable
- 23:09that's this is an admission that I'm weak
- 23:10that I can't do this on their own
- 23:11that there's something wrong with me
- 23:13in some sort of way
- 23:14so not only am I not recognizing that I'm in crisis
- 23:17but people around me are not recognizing that I'm
- 23:19in crisis
- 23:21even if I do recognize that
- 23:23it's really really hard for me to ask for help right
- 23:26and so what we need to do as a society
- 23:28when we're seeing boys acting out anger
- 23:31aggression irritability
- 23:32they can't you know
- 23:34can't focus in the classroom
- 23:36substance use in school you know
- 23:38in adolescence you know
- 23:40risky behavior that sort of stuff
- 23:41we have to start thinking about those as
- 23:43as as warning signs that this is
- 23:46this is a young person that's
- 23:48that's in distress not somebody who's just
- 23:50just acting out here we don't see those as wounds
- 23:52we don't see those as mental health issues
- 23:55but if you understand the ways that boys are
- 23:57are socialized taught to externalize what's
- 23:59what's happening inside of them
- 24:01very quickly it becomes evident uh aggression
- 24:04irritability um
- 24:06risk taking behavior those are
- 24:08those are cues that this is a
- 24:10this is a kid that's in distress
- 24:13yeah so let's talk about what to do with that
- 24:16and you mention okay
- 24:17well as a culture
- 24:18we should recognize all of this stuff
- 24:20but that's a little bit like
- 24:22you know peeing into a fire hose
- 24:24um
- 24:24what can we do as a tactical matter with our own boys
- 24:30are there you know
- 24:31concrete skill building habits that we can
- 24:34that we can do for ourselves or for them
- 24:37what can we implement at home today
- 24:39to create an environment where our sons don't have to
- 24:42don't feel like they have to erase themselves
- 24:44so many things and and
- 24:45and the great part of this is is
- 24:47is is all of these are things that anyone of us can do
- 24:49and and when I it it
- 24:50when I write the book you know
- 24:52every time I I share a story
- 24:54I try to share more stories from teachers
- 24:55coaches parents
- 24:56you don't have to be a skilled clinician
- 24:58or a social worker or a therapist to do this stuff
- 25:01yeah one of the things is
- 25:02is and I encourage any parent
- 25:04and any teacher
- 25:05to do this with the boys that you're working with
- 25:07is just initiate a conversation on what what
- 25:09what they've Learned
- 25:10or what they know about what it means to be a boy
- 25:12um you know will will
- 25:15they'll get the man up conversation
- 25:17perhaps throughout life or they'll get those messages
- 25:19but nobody teaches them what it means to be a boy
- 25:22or to be a man what are the pressures
- 25:23what are the struggles
- 25:24what are the things that have been kind of
- 25:25normalized for you and and
- 25:27and more importantly how have you kind of
- 25:29internalized that or interpreted those sorts of things
- 25:32most boys
- 25:32will never have that conversation in their life
- 25:35and as you have those conversations
- 25:36there are some some very tangible
- 25:38easy things that that we can do that are really
- 25:40really important setting
- 25:42the conditions
- 25:43of these conversations are sometimes as important
- 25:46or even more important than what we
- 25:47what we say right
- 25:48the content of these conversations
- 25:50I find this with my son
- 25:51I just had an example not too long ago
- 25:53where we were having a big
- 25:54serious talk about something
- 25:55as he's transitioning into college
- 25:57we sit down at the dinner table
- 25:59face to face from one another and
- 26:00and we'd kind of I'd kind of scheduled this with him
- 26:03boy he was not going there
- 26:06it it
- 26:06it it was just
- 26:08you know close
- 26:09close ended answers he just wasn't having it
- 26:12yeah he's not conditioned for that
- 26:14he's not socialized that so I try again about
- 26:16about two weeks later when we're driving in the car
- 26:18and we're shoulder to shoulder to one another
- 26:21and I start asking some of this
- 26:22and I initiate that same conversation
- 26:24and I'm just driving in circles because he's just has
- 26:27he's just opening up and he's sharing so much and
- 26:29and it's very clear that he really
- 26:30really is enjoying and needing this conversation
- 26:32and I thought as as I was doing that
- 26:35of so many of the meaningful
- 26:37important conversations that he and I have had
- 26:39over the years
- 26:40you know it's been shoulder to shoulder on a video game
- 26:43I can remember a young man that I worked with
- 26:46in the foster care system
- 26:47and I had to to share some heavy
- 26:50heavy news with him
- 26:51that his little sister was being adopted without him
- 26:54and I knew that this this was gonna devastate this
- 26:56little guy because his little sister was his world
- 26:59and his last link to his family
- 27:01and so
- 27:02he and I both played video games quite frequently
- 27:06and so I had that conversation with him
- 27:08kind of shoulder to shoulder while and
- 27:10and in the I think the only reason that he was able to
- 27:13to regulate through that entire conversation
- 27:15not to suggest that it wasn't hard or heavy for him
- 27:18is because the conditions that were set there
- 27:20so even something as simple as
- 27:22kind of going shoulder to shoulder
- 27:23and then the last thing with boys is
- 27:25we have to
- 27:26focus a lot more on our capacity to stay with them
- 27:30as opposed to focusing so much on what we say to them
- 27:33we don't realize it and even some of us as parents
- 27:35and I certainly fall into this category
- 27:38we don't realize that we're often times
- 27:39socialized and trained to kind of
- 27:41rush a boy out of an emotion as fast as we can
- 27:43to talk him out of it
- 27:44to work him through it as fast as we can
- 27:46um well intended even
- 27:48you know the best parents can can
- 27:50can do this yeah
- 27:51we wanna
- 27:52just give them permission to feel what they're feeling
- 27:54whether it's shame pain
- 27:55hurt sad
- 27:55just stay with them during those really
- 27:57really difficult moments those really
- 27:59really heavy feelings and emotions
- 28:01um and in our capacity to stay with them is often times
- 28:05so much more important than
- 28:06than even what we say to them in those conversations
- 28:10yeah I
- 28:11I I
- 28:11I've told this story before um
- 28:15but my way of dealing with difficult emotions is
- 28:17through humor
- 28:19as it is with a lot of people
- 28:20I'll make you know
- 28:22dark humor black humor
- 28:24you know just like
- 28:25like I'll start making jokes about
- 28:27about stuff and um
- 28:32there was a time about so my son is 7 now
- 28:35this is back when he was maybe 4 or 3 even
- 28:39and he was upset about something
- 28:42and so my again
- 28:46my coping is my coping mechanism is humor
- 28:48and so you know
- 28:49my goal to to
- 28:50to keep him from being sad is to start making him laugh
- 28:55and he started getting frustrated with me and um
- 29:00he was like so I'm I'm
- 29:01I'm sitting there trying to make him laugh
- 29:03he's starting to laugh and he goes daddy stop
- 29:05and I go and I go what
- 29:06he goes just let me feel what I feel
- 29:11I was like brilliant
- 29:12oh my gosh
- 29:13and I I mean at
- 29:16at once I felt I don't shame about gosh I
- 29:20I'm not letting him feel what I feel
- 29:22I'm like this
- 29:23this is me training him to be like me in this way
- 29:28that isn't great
- 29:31but then I was also so proud of him that he was able to
- 29:34like even at that age
- 29:35like speak up and and
- 29:37and push back on me and go
- 29:39no man
- 29:40I mean this is
- 29:41I need to do I need to do this other thing
- 29:43and I you know
- 29:46I I mean
- 29:46I had that reaction I
- 29:47I and I was like
- 29:49you're you're so right about that man
- 29:51and I'm you know
- 29:53I'm sorry I will do better than that and uh
- 29:56and you know
- 29:57and and
- 29:57and I did and now he's
- 30:00you know
- 30:00he's able to process those things a little bit better
- 30:03that's that's wonderful
- 30:03I mean that's an emotionally mature brilliant
- 30:05brilliant kid and good for you for allowing him to
- 30:07I think he gets that from his mom
- 30:09I think hahaha to have that space
- 30:12but the reality is that the emotions of
- 30:14boys elicit a lot of emotions in us
- 30:16as parents I mean
- 30:16this is
- 30:16this is part of the reason why we don't go there
- 30:19um cause I have
- 30:20I have that same I have a
- 30:21I call it the um
- 30:22the entertainer the clown adapted
- 30:24the only emotions that I could feel as a child safely
- 30:26were anger and humor alright
- 30:28so no matter what the emotion is for me alright
- 30:31especially if it's a heavy moment right
- 30:32you're gonna get anger or humor out of me
- 30:35you know you know
- 30:36before I did a bunch of therapy and stuff like that um
- 30:39and I think when I run my groups in it
- 30:41in it you again
- 30:42whether it's on a college campus or in a youth prison
- 30:43when things get heavy
- 30:44we start talking about trauma or heavy stuff
- 30:46you know loss
- 30:47grief that sort of stuff
- 30:49it's so interesting how
- 30:50how funny the room gets initially
- 30:52and I always catch it and I always say
- 30:54you guys notice that we're
- 30:55we're we all
- 30:56including me sometimes we
- 30:58you know somebody shared something really heavy
- 31:00and we felt the need there to make a joke
- 31:02to disarm a little bit you know um
- 31:04uh and
- 31:05and that's that's entirely adaptive uh
- 31:07uh for us
- 31:08but it's just one of those many examples with boys
- 31:11where you know we
- 31:12we don't even real I mean
- 31:13I could give you 100 with my son
- 31:15and in things that I've done
- 31:16where I've just kind of
- 31:17tried to rush him through an emotion
- 31:19talk him out of an emotion get
- 31:20get get him through it as fast as he can
- 31:22without even realizing
- 31:24and I'm a social worker yeah
- 31:26yeah you're trained
- 31:27you're you're
- 31:28you're really aware of this stuff
- 31:30how are we normal mortals supposed to deal with it
- 31:33but I I mean I
- 31:34I'm not sure that those reactions
- 31:36or those reflexes are necessarily bad
- 31:38like I mean
- 31:39it's okay to to turn the relief valve a little bit
- 31:42as long as we don't leave it open right
- 31:44you know you gotta close it back down
- 31:46and then you still have to go through the emotion and
- 31:48and and process it
- 31:49I think and
- 31:50and you know
- 31:51let me ask you one other thing about
- 31:55I think part of like
- 31:57if I feel resistance towards the notion of
- 32:01you know letting my boy process those emotions and feel
- 32:05be vulnerable and all the training him to be vulnerable
- 32:08what I start to worry about is that
- 32:15this becomes an excuse to misbehave and oh
- 32:20well you're
- 32:21you know you experienced this trauma
- 32:22and that's why you're doing X
- 32:24y and Z yeah
- 32:25and so it's okay
- 32:27and that so it's okay thing isn't true
- 32:30it's not okay to act out it's not okay to allow
- 32:35your trauma to get imposed on other people that that
- 32:39that that don't deserve it
- 32:41and so I mean
- 32:42what is
- 32:44what is the mechanism to prevent this from being
- 32:47a blame game yeah
- 32:48yeah and it
- 32:50in the I've had these conversations
- 32:51and I've had with all my kids
- 32:52not just not just my son
- 32:54but it's it's
- 32:55it's really helping them to
- 32:56to understand um
- 32:59these behaviors and where they come from
- 33:01as an explanation but never an excuse right
- 33:03like we
- 33:05one of the most trauma informed things we can do is
- 33:07hold folks accountable for their
- 33:08especially if the behavior is
- 33:09is harmful towards someone
- 33:10which we do know you know
- 33:11when we think about like intimate partner violence
- 33:13domestic violence you know
- 33:14some of those sorts of things
- 33:15that we do know that disproportionately
- 33:17it's men that are that are perpetrating those things
- 33:20right um
- 33:22from wounds of boyhood
- 33:23so making those distinctions between hey
- 33:26this is an explanation
- 33:27we can understand the origins of this
- 33:28we can understand maybe where this came from
- 33:32you were ashamed you were overwhelmed
- 33:34you were disregulated whatever it might be
- 33:36but that's not an excuse
- 33:37so we're still gonna have some accountability here but
- 33:40but the the
- 33:41you know in this
- 33:42in our society we don't
- 33:44we don't understand
- 33:45the first thing about accountability
- 33:47accountability is not just a consequence I
- 33:49I if you just give me a consequence for
- 33:52for a behavior and I don't understand why I did it
- 33:55where I came from
- 33:56if I don't understand the impact that it had on you
- 33:59the harm that it it
- 34:00it caused you if I don't understand
- 34:02you know if I don't have any curiosity
- 34:03about your inner experience
- 34:05and how my actions or behaviors harmed you
- 34:08I'm not being held account
- 34:09I'm getting I'm getting a consequence
- 34:11that's it
- 34:12and so we really have to better understand what is
- 34:16what is accountability at
- 34:17at the core of accountability is I
- 34:21I have to
- 34:23understand and be curious
- 34:25about the impact that my behavior had on you
- 34:28the harm that this behavior had
- 34:29why the why this was so hurtful
- 34:31why it would be so unfair to my teacher
- 34:32that I acted up in class uh
- 34:35whatever it might be uh
- 34:36and and
- 34:37and as I walk through this
- 34:38you're gonna you're gonna recognize really quickly
- 34:39a lot of these capacities
- 34:41to do this
- 34:41are capacities that we systematically kind of
- 34:44shame boys out of haha
- 34:45yeah and
- 34:46and then uh
- 34:47then then
- 34:49you know I have to offer an apology
- 34:50the apology is kind of a an early step in in
- 34:53in in accountability
- 34:55we kind of teach boys that it's
- 34:57it's the end so now I'm
- 34:58I have this shame for this behavior
- 35:01so I have to I have to be able to tolerate this shame
- 35:03meaning I have to I have to be okay with
- 35:06you know mom or dad or
- 35:08or a friend or a girlfriend
- 35:10or somebody is upset with me
- 35:12they're hurt by me
- 35:14right um
- 35:15so I have to I have to develop that capacity to
- 35:17to to tolerate that shame
- 35:19and understand how this behavior really
- 35:22really impacted you for me to repair that relationship
- 35:25so that I don't do this thing again right
- 35:27that's accountability
- 35:29we don't live in a society where we
- 35:31we we think we're holding folks accountable um
- 35:34by just divving out a consequence
- 35:36we're not I promise you
- 35:38I mean I see these
- 35:39the work that I do is in youth prisons
- 35:42where these kids are given
- 35:43kind of big consequences for their behaviors right
- 35:45or in foster care programs where they get
- 35:47they're given big consequences for their behaviors
- 35:50when in reality there's almost never accountability
- 35:53nobody is doing the repair work
- 35:55to recognize why this behavior
- 35:57where it came from why did I do it
- 36:00what is the impact that it had on somebody else
- 36:02how do I repair that relationship
- 36:03how do I develop the capacity to
- 36:05to tolerate that somebody I care about I've hurt them
- 36:09right or that
- 36:10that that relationship might change a little bit
- 36:13we're not teaching this stuff to boys
- 36:15we're not teaching this stuff to men
- 36:17yeah man
- 36:18I I wish we had this conversation yesterday
- 36:20I I had this experience last night um
- 36:23as I was talking to my my son at bedtime
- 36:26and he mentioned
- 36:28that he was involved in an incident at school
- 36:30where a bunch of kids vandalized the school
- 36:34and he mentioned this and
- 36:37and that he was one of the vandals
- 36:40and what happened was that they had you know
- 36:43boys will be boys kind of thing where you know
- 36:46they all got together
- 36:46and they wet a bunch of toilet paper
- 36:48and threw it on the walls
- 36:49and on the roof and stuff
- 36:50that was the vandalism the vandalism that happened
- 36:54so he and then he
- 36:55so he copped to this with me and then he asked me I
- 37:00I he asked me what was you know
- 37:03is he gonna have a punishment for me
- 37:05and I said well
- 37:06what's the school doing about it
- 37:07and he said he said well
- 37:09we're you know
- 37:10they're gonna have us clean up the bathroom and
- 37:13you know
- 37:14he mentioned all of these things and and I was like
- 37:17well that seems to me to be
- 37:20um
- 37:22that seems appropriate to me and it seems like
- 37:24I mean I don't think I need to impose any additional um
- 37:28any additional punishment to you
- 37:29so I think that's okay but why did you know
- 37:33what made you do this like what and
- 37:36and actually where I went with it was
- 37:38like what do you think the impact was of that
- 37:41you know who
- 37:42who would have to clean that up if it wasn't you
- 37:44well I guess it was the janitor well
- 37:47is that fair like
- 37:48is that you know
- 37:48this guy this janitor has a
- 37:51has a work has a job to do in the school
- 37:54and he's got to keep everything clean
- 37:56and he's got to do all this stuff
- 37:57and now he's got to deal with this
- 37:59all this extra mess
- 38:01you know that you guys put in there
- 38:02is that right is that fair
- 38:03and he's like no no
- 38:05it's not and but I didn't actually get to the bottom
- 38:09of what drove the behavior in the first place
- 38:12and I actually think I know the answer
- 38:14so I I
- 38:16it was you know
- 38:17a belonging he fight
- 38:19he had this group of kids and they're all like
- 38:22it's kind of a vicious cycle
- 38:23in the sense that they all want to feel belonging
- 38:25and here's some activity that everyone's doing
- 38:27and so I can feel belonging by engaging this activity
- 38:30and then
- 38:30to push back against the activity is the opposite
- 38:33of that and so I missed an opportunity there
- 38:37and the opportunity is not lost
- 38:38he's downstairs right now
- 38:39I can go I can go talk to him in a minute
- 38:43um I missed an opportunity there
- 38:45to actually get to the root of that
- 38:47and talk a little bit about the sense of belonging and
- 38:52and and why that felt so good and what he could
- 38:56what we could have done instead
- 38:58to actually
- 39:00experience that sense of belonging
- 39:02in a way that didn't have this negative repercussion
- 39:06yeah and that belonging
- 39:07and we forget this with boys and and
- 39:09and I understandably
- 39:10I get I get it too
- 39:11but belonging is our strongest drive in life
- 39:14because at one point in time
- 39:16we don't survive without it
- 39:17you know we
- 39:18you know he's at
- 39:19it sounds like he's at an age where
- 39:21you know a couple generations back
- 39:23not too long ago if he didn't get accepted by the pack
- 39:26he's a he's in a lot of trouble when it comes to his
- 39:29his belonging we don't want to forget that as well
- 39:32um yeah
- 39:33boys do all sorts of you know
- 39:34we all kids have this
- 39:36this our strongest drive in life is not just kids man
- 39:39I mean I think you and I have it too
- 39:41oh you bet
- 39:41it doesn't end right after childhood we
- 39:43we we
- 39:44we still have it um
- 39:46and often times we'll we'll disconnect from
- 39:49maybe sometimes even our moral compass
- 39:51in order to um
- 39:53you know to get that belonging
- 39:55and yeah I think just having that conversation to say
- 39:57you know and
- 39:58and we gotta equip boys too with that
- 39:59that moral compass and those moments to say hey
- 40:02for a lot of you guys you know
- 40:03especially as you become teenagers
- 40:04it's just gonna be these series of moments
- 40:06where your head
- 40:07and your heart are at odds with one another
- 40:09listen to your heart in those moments
- 40:10engage that moral compass
- 40:11remember your values um
- 40:14but that's that tension
- 40:15it's attachment and authenticity
- 40:17it's it's yeah
- 40:18it's brutal for boys yeah
- 40:21well I like to end these conversations with uh
- 40:23more or less the same question to everybody
- 40:25and I put everybody on the spot um
- 40:28but
- 40:28if there's one principle that every parent listening
- 40:32should live by that comes to mind for you when
- 40:35when raising their boys give me a
- 40:38give me one principle yeah
- 40:40yeah it is to remember that
- 40:41that no matter how old that boy with a teenager
- 40:44grown adult son
- 40:46they they were born with these capacities
- 40:48right to embrace the most human parts of themselves
- 40:51connection relationships
- 40:53emotional expression their needs
- 40:54their joys the
- 40:55all of those sorts of things right
- 40:57we boys in boyhood
- 40:59we disconnect from that authentic self not
- 41:02not out of choice often times out of necessity
- 41:05it doesn't leave us it doesn't disconnect from us
- 41:08we never want we never want to think that it's
- 41:11it's too late to do the work
- 41:12I think with boys and men especially
- 41:14we are so focused on growth and change
- 41:16and what do I need to fix
- 41:18and I I get all of that
- 41:20but for a lot of us you know
- 41:21as I think it is you started that story with your
- 41:23you know that educator who
- 41:24who really shamed you that the work is
- 41:27is to reconnect with that boy uh
- 41:29you know who was in that classroom that
- 41:32that out of necessity
- 41:34had to disconnect from your authentic self and and
- 41:38and with boys and men for a lot of us
- 41:41our work is not so much about growth and change
- 41:43and fixing anything
- 41:44uh
- 41:45it's not about what is wrong with these behaviors now
- 41:47it's a little bit more about what
- 41:48what might have been right
- 41:49or what purpose did they serve um
- 41:52back then um
- 41:53and these are these are wounds
- 41:54and with boys and I get it
- 41:55it's a little bit tougher
- 41:57but we have to recognize these as
- 41:59as wounds if we're gonna
- 42:00if we're gonna disrupt this cycle in any sort of way
- 42:04yeah I love that
- 42:06well this has been Doctor Adam Mccormick
- 42:08he's a professor of social work at Saint Olaf's
- 42:10University and the author of The Cost of becoming a Boy
- 42:15Adam's work is a powerful reminder
- 42:17that reframing our sons struggles
- 42:19from character flaws to survival strategies
- 42:23is where we can really begin to understand where
- 42:27they're coming from and where the healing can begin
- 42:30you can find Doctor Mccormick's background
- 42:32book links and additional resources LinkedIn
- 42:35the show notes thank you for listening to Raising Men
- 42:39and you are a great parent
- 42:49raising men is produced by Phil Hernandez
- 42:53this episode was edited by Ralph Tolentino