Latest / Consumerpedia / 33 - Auto Insurance Based on How You Drive in Real Time. Good Choice or Not?
Transcript
- 0:02Auto insurance companies, baser premium on a host of factors,
- 0:05the vehicle, your age, gender marital status education,
- 0:09occupation, zip code, and driving record.
- 0:12Sometimes credit scores and other factors.
- 0:14You'll never know about are used in the calculation.
- 0:17What if the insurance company offered, you a way to lower your
- 0:19premiums, by installing technology, in your vehicle that
- 0:22monitors how, when, and where you drive, would you be willing
- 0:25to give up some of your privacy to see your insurance bill, drop
- 0:28by 30, or 80%, millions of drivers have already signed up
- 0:32for these telematic programs and millions more say they'd be
- 0:36willing to do it. If offered, I'm her wife's mom.
- 0:38The consumer, man, a contributing editor at
- 0:40checkbook. Dot-org, welcome to Consumer PDF
- 0:43at checkbook, dot-org where the nonprofit that helps consumers
- 0:47select Services, avoid trouble and save money because we don't
- 0:51accept any advertising or take money from any business.
- 0:53We recommend you can rely on checkbook, dot-org to be
- 0:56completely independent and objective now, Is the host of
- 1:00consumer PDF, America's consumer expert, the consumer, man.
- 1:04Her twice bomb, in this episode. We're going to talk about
- 1:07telematic data collection. How it works, how it can get
- 1:10things wrong. And whether you should even
- 1:13consider trading, your privacy for lower insurance rates, Our
- 1:16Guest is Michael too long. He's with the consumer
- 1:18Federation of America is campaign for Fair auto
- 1:21insurance. He joins us from the nation's
- 1:23capital. Hi there, Michael, thank you
- 1:25very much. I'm really excited to be here so
- 1:27let's make sure we understand it.
- 1:29Exactly what telematics is and how it works.
- 1:32Run us through the process telematics.
- 1:34Also calls usage, based Insurance.
- 1:37Its insurance policies or programs that insurance
- 1:39companies, use to capture data on people's driving behavior and
- 1:44they use that to calculate your insurance premium and ensure.
- 1:47They either plug the device into your car or they put an app on
- 1:50your phone and collects information about your driving
- 1:53and then the company uses that information about your driving
- 1:56to calculate your premium. These programs they were
- 1:58originally based on GPS Progressive started the first
- 2:02telematics program, they called it snapshot, all the way back in
- 2:05the late 1990s, it gradually grew and other companies going
- 2:09again, following suit and over the past 20 years, all the
- 2:12largest Auto insurers, have adopted them.
- 2:14And there's a bunch of different kinds of devices that they use.
- 2:17They can use mobile apps. They can use like these
- 2:20Bluetooth assists which are like these plug in devices, that
- 2:23collect driving information and send it to a smartphone that
- 2:26then analyzes that they conclude a various.
- 2:29Vices and more, and more of these new cars are being sold
- 2:33with these a devices installed, even if consumers decide not to
- 2:36use them. And the data collected allows
- 2:39insurers to get more information about someone's a driving
- 2:41behavior. And their habits.
- 2:43Theoretically, this is supposed to benefit consumers and improve
- 2:46pricing, because insurers would ideally use that data to
- 2:50determine how risky someone is to ensure and price the premium
- 2:53appropriately. But in practice, there's a lot
- 2:55of concerns both about privacy and what companies do with that
- 2:59information and They increase costs for consumers and that's
- 3:02one of the main things CFA is working on.
- 3:04So what sort of data do these devices whether installed in the
- 3:08vehicle or there's an app on your phone, what sort of data is
- 3:11the insurance company collecting on you?
- 3:13They collect data on your driving behavior and habits.
- 3:16And first off a disclaimer, there is a lot of different
- 3:18insurance companies. Most of the largest ones have
- 3:20their own telematics programs. So what follows is a general
- 3:24information but the kind of information that they usually
- 3:26collect on you is breaking whether you I'm on the brakes,
- 3:30the time of day, or the time of night that you drive, whether
- 3:33you're driving like the morning, the afternoon, the evening, the
- 3:36dead of night, how much you drive and the form of like miles
- 3:39traveled acceleration, whether you accelerate quickly or
- 3:43whether you don't accelerate very much your speed, how fast
- 3:46you drive, whether you're driving over the speed limit
- 3:49cornering. Which basically means like
- 3:50whether you make sharp turns around corners, how often you
- 3:53make, these turns and phone use. Whether you use your phone while
- 3:57driving. Do they also look at where you
- 4:00Drive. Yes.
- 4:01At least some of the companies do and this is an interesting
- 4:03thing that we'll get into later, some of the companies.
- 4:06Look at your location where you drive, although they also most
- 4:09of them claim that they don't use this information to
- 4:12calculate your insurance premium and they don't use sell it to
- 4:15advertisers. But again, there aren't really a
- 4:18lot of safeguards for consumers. Most states don't have good
- 4:22regulation of telematics programs.
- 4:24They don't have specific in-depth, either laws or
- 4:27bulletins detailing. What they need to do to protect
- 4:29Consumers, so there's all sorts of possibilities for abuse.
- 4:33So if I opt into this program, if my insurance company offers
- 4:36it, I say yes I want lower rates.
- 4:38Hopefully based on you tracking how I drive and where I drive,
- 4:42Etc, do they make it clear? What factors?
- 4:44They're collecting and how that information is scored by their
- 4:47algorithms. It's a bit unclear.
- 4:49There are some behaviors that are almost universally
- 4:51collected, we and Consumer Reports.
- 4:54Have each look to the largest insurance companies and their
- 4:56programs like Allstate, which calls the program Drive Wise Guy
- 4:59Code. Drive, easy.
- 5:01And we found that most of the insurance companies collected
- 5:04information about hard braking, and when you drive, almost all
- 5:07of them, collect data on a phone use, most of them collect data
- 5:11on how much you drive, and a lot of them collect information on
- 5:14your speeding, but there are other behaviors.
- 5:16They look at as well. For example, Geico also looks
- 5:19the type of Road you drive on because they think that impacts
- 5:22your driving as well. Whether the road is a good road
- 5:24or a low-quality one, they also look at the weather in which
- 5:27you're driving and on the website It's companies usually
- 5:30have these very nice sort of pages about how this program
- 5:34will save you money and they list some of the factors that go
- 5:36into their programs. Like for instance, you go to a
- 5:39website and look at a tell Max program, it will say this
- 5:41program evaluates you based on say you're breaking how much you
- 5:45drive and the time of day or night that you drive, but we
- 5:48strongly suspect that the companies are collecting other
- 5:51driving information as well, even if they aren't disclosing
- 5:54this. And when it comes to the actual
- 5:56input of what happens, what weight each sort of driving
- 5:59behavior, As the company's clam up and there's no transparency
- 6:03at all. They don't make the weight to
- 6:05every Factor public. They don't say like for
- 6:08instance, about twenty percent of your premium in this cow, is
- 6:11due to like how fast you drive, and there's been some cases
- 6:15where Drive easy has rated customers on driving smoothness
- 6:18and like how quickly they're going around corners, but they
- 6:21don't elaborate further. And whenever we've tried to get
- 6:24more transparency about the factors that go into telematics
- 6:27programs and how much each factor otters like on a
- 6:30percentage basis. The companies have pushed back
- 6:33and said that would hurt competition and it would ruin
- 6:35everything and we don't want to do that and there's no real time
- 6:38feedback is there if I'm driving along.
- 6:40It doesn't tell me. Hey you're breaking too hard or
- 6:43you're starting to faster or anything like that.
- 6:45I don't get any real time feedback from these things to
- 6:47it. In some cases you do some of the
- 6:50apps are devices. Programs, do it, for example.
- 6:52All states driveway as well, this isn't quite real time
- 6:54feedback, but they give you feedback.
- 6:56After each trip about you're driving and you can also see
- 6:59Like how much you use your phone behind the wheel, Farmers their
- 7:03program is called signal and it allows people to review their
- 7:06driving behavior and will sometimes offer suggestions on
- 7:09how to save money. For example, it will suggest
- 7:12that you try to avoid driving during like peak times of the
- 7:15day like rush hour or to drive less and they also have like
- 7:19different time periods as well. Usually, each of these programs
- 7:22has like a set period where you drive and then they start look
- 7:26at your driving behavior and then calculate your premium, for
- 7:28example, travel, Has a program intelligent.
- 7:31I've where they collect information on your driving
- 7:33behavior for a 90 days before they determine your premium.
- 7:36One of the big points that these companies emphasize is that safe
- 7:39driving supposed to save you money but bad driving will cause
- 7:43your premium to go up. So, is it possible that if I opt
- 7:46into this program and the algorithm decides that I'm a bad
- 7:49driver? I could wind up paying more than
- 7:51if I just got the normal policy without the telematics.
- 7:54Yes, unfortunately, it's a very possible.
- 7:57They have somewhat different valuations of what.
- 7:59Exactly is bad driving but they usually look at the following
- 8:02behaviors phone use in the car which is honestly makes quite a
- 8:06bit of sense because that's distracted driving and that
- 8:09increases your likelihood of getting into a crash speeding or
- 8:12driving too fast, hard braking, they think that if you slam on
- 8:16the brakes or brake hard that you're less likely to be paying
- 8:18attention, making sharp turns and accelerating really fast.
- 8:22But there are also some things to consider like for instance,
- 8:25if someone is say living in a city or an urban area and and
- 8:29they may have to put on the brakes more often and so they
- 8:32could get dinged for that as a result of, they're just driving
- 8:35in a place where there's a lot more traffic and they need to
- 8:37keep accelerating and then stopping and then accelerating
- 8:40and stopping. So there is a lot of things to
- 8:42consider and we're a little bit concerned about that.
- 8:45You mentioned cell phones, a couple of times and that is a
- 8:47key thing. If you're using your cell phone
- 8:49texting, whatever while you're driving, that's a problem.
- 8:51But what if I'm in my car and my wife says, to me, I want to
- 8:54drive to Costco today. You sit in the passenger seat
- 8:57and I'm using my cellphone as the telematics.
- 8:59I am in my car going to know. It's me in the passenger seat.
- 9:02Not driving. The telematics systems are
- 9:04supposed to know when you're the driver and when you're the
- 9:06passenger, but they don't always.
- 9:08And actually if you go online, there have been a bunch of cases
- 9:12and angry consumerist pointing out instances where the app
- 9:15thought they were a driver when they were really a passenger
- 9:17either. Because they were in someone
- 9:19else's car or because say like their spouse was using their
- 9:22phone traveler says, for instance, that it's app and tell
- 9:25a drive does its best to determine whether or not you're
- 9:28the driver of the vehicle. And if you're a passenger on the
- 9:30app record you as a driver, you have 10 days to change that
- 9:33information USAA their program is called safe pilot.
- 9:37And one of the things that they touted actually online is that
- 9:41there are programs supposed to be very good at telling whether
- 9:43you are a driver or a passenger and it gives you the option to
- 9:46select that after a drive. But they can't always tell
- 9:49whether you're driving your own car, whether you're a passenger,
- 9:51whether you're riding in someone else's car.
- 9:53So they may ding you for sloppy driving that isn't yours.
- 9:57And most of the programs will allow you to Recategorize a
- 10:00drive or dispute a mistake, but some of them require you to call
- 10:04customer service and go through that area, which can be quite a
- 10:07pain. When we talk about insurance
- 10:09companies, there's always a concern based on past history of
- 10:13using information to discriminate against certain
- 10:15classes of individuals. Is it possible to use any of
- 10:18this data collected by these telematic devices to
- 10:21discriminate against people? Maybe lower-income minorities,
- 10:24people live in certain zip codes or where they drive.
- 10:26Is there any problem? Potential problem with that?
- 10:29Oh, yeah. Yes, unfortunately, CFA has been
- 10:31working on this for a while. Auto insurers, have
- 10:33traditionally used a lot of non-driving related factors to
- 10:37discriminate against people, and charge them, unfairly High
- 10:40premiums. They include someone's credit
- 10:41history, their education level their job, their zip code,
- 10:46whether they own a home, and whether they're married and
- 10:48other gender. And we found that these factors
- 10:51result in people paying a lot more for auto insurance.
- 10:53For example, if someone has a perfect driving record.
- 10:56But poor credit, we've done studies in a bunch of states and
- 10:59we found Found that oftentimes they wind up paying twice as
- 11:02much for auto insurance compared to someone who has excellent
- 11:05credit and this holds true, even if like, in both cases, the
- 11:08driver has a perfect driving record with no tickets, no
- 11:11crashes, no claims. And one of the supposed benefits
- 11:14of telematics is that it's supposed to move away from
- 11:17those. Harmful factors that are not
- 11:19really connected to risk, and that lead to people paying more,
- 11:22but we think that companies could use telematics along with
- 11:25those factors to unfairly discriminated against people.
- 11:27For example, they could collect information A chinon say
- 11:30someone's location and use that to say, oh this person lives
- 11:34here and they also Drive in these certain areas and so they
- 11:37were low-income person. So we're going to discriminate
- 11:40against that most of the companies have an admitted to
- 11:43tracking people's locations, but we think they probably have that
- 11:46data and store with it and that there need to be protections
- 11:49against. It's being used.
- 11:51One of them, or example, actually, one of the most
- 11:54commonly used factors that the company's measure is with a time
- 11:57of day or the time of night, you drive.
- 11:59And at, First glance, that sounds quite reasonable.
- 12:01Because when you're driving at night, it's dark.
- 12:04People are tend to be more sleepy there, it's more risky to
- 12:07drive around. However, there's a problem of
- 12:10income because a lot of people who are lower-wage workers do
- 12:13not have control over their hours and so have to either get
- 12:16up very early and drive to work or stay up late and drive to
- 12:19work a lot. Fewer of them work jobs from
- 12:22like 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. and since they have to come in early
- 12:25or stay up late, they're more likely to be driving in the
- 12:27dark. So charging people More based on
- 12:30a, whether they drive at night, that may make a certain amount
- 12:33of sense, but it will also likely wind up costing
- 12:36lower-wage workers, because they're going to have to pay
- 12:38more even though there are usually earning less.
- 12:40You know, when it comes to telematics letting the
- 12:42insurance. Company collect information on
- 12:44your driving privacy is a top concern and we're going to talk
- 12:47to Michael about that. Next, this is consumer pedia
- 12:50powered by checkbook. Dot-org checkbook has ratings
- 12:54for auto insurance companies in these seven Metro areas, Boston,
- 12:58Chicago Philadelphia Fear Seattle, San Francisco,
- 13:02Minneapolis st. Paul and Washington, d.c. you'll
- 13:04also find ratings for auto repair shops, auto, body shops,
- 13:08and auto glass repair shops, advice on how to make these
- 13:11purchases are free to everyone, the checkbook, dot-org ratings
- 13:14of local services are available with a subscription.
- 13:17If you live in one of these seven areas and haven't joined
- 13:19checkbook. Yet check us out.
- 13:21Get your free 30-day subscription at checkbook,
- 13:24dot-org consumer PDF. And if you like what you've
- 13:27heard, we hope you'll become a supporter.
- 13:29By using the link at the bottom of the show notes to make a
- 13:32small contribution each month. Michael, the long is with the
- 13:36consumer Federation of America. Michael telematics is advertised
- 13:39as a way for safe drivers, to save money on their insurance,
- 13:42and that sounds good. But the insurance company can
- 13:44collect all sorts of data about where you drive, when you drive
- 13:48and that should raise some privacy concerns.
- 13:51Are you concerned about that? Oh yes.
- 13:53We are very, very concerned consumer Federation of America.
- 13:56We've been working on this privacy for many many years
- 13:59Worried about what exactly the auto insurers are going to do
- 14:02with all that data. And whether they're going to
- 14:05sell it, monetize it, try and use it for advertising and one
- 14:09of the major problems is that most states don't have specific
- 14:12laws or regulations governing telematics or having any privacy
- 14:16protections. For example, let's pick take
- 14:19Florida, which we looked at recently, they don't have any
- 14:21specific laws or regulations about telematics, they just have
- 14:24the insurance department and they look at it and they don't
- 14:28have any specific things. As there's are some states that
- 14:31are a little bit better. For example, a New York is
- 14:33somewhat better. They have some guidelines for
- 14:35regulating tell Max and protecting consumer privacy.
- 14:38Like they say companies, can't gather any data on related to
- 14:41Insurance rating or discounts and they can't use that data to
- 14:45harm policyholders. California has by far the
- 14:48strongest consumer protections. They only allow tell Max
- 14:51programs based on someone's mileage.
- 14:53How much they drive. And actually Elon Musk of all
- 14:57people actually through a Twitter tantrum about this.
- 14:59Several months ago, it's a long story.
- 15:01But basically, Tesla has moved into doing auto insurance in a
- 15:04few states with a heavy focus on telematics.
- 15:07And he got mad. That the California Department
- 15:10of Insurance was not bending, the rules for them.
- 15:12And allowing their tell Max program to use additional
- 15:14factors in relation to mileage and you went from there.
- 15:17So just to be clear because we're living in an age where
- 15:20data is capital. Not only can they know all about
- 15:23your driving, but they can also take all that data and monetize
- 15:26it by selling it to other companies or using it to Market
- 15:29you. Her or whatever?
- 15:30Correct. At this point in time.
- 15:31Yes, in Most states. That's true.
- 15:33There are some states. As I mentioned, like New York
- 15:36that have issued guidelines saying that the insurance
- 15:39companies can't do this and there are limits and what they
- 15:41can do with the data. But again, those guidelines are
- 15:44dependent upon the insurance department stepping up and doing
- 15:47their job and what the insurance department.
- 15:50They could change their minds and say those guidelines are no
- 15:52longer in effect in some states like California again, there are
- 15:56stronger consumer protections and that's where a telematics.
- 15:59G RI the best for consumers because the factors that they
- 16:03can use our limited. But in most States yet, it's
- 16:06kind of like a wild west. There aren't a lot of
- 16:09restrictions. There isn't a lot of privacy
- 16:11protections. The companies all claimed, like
- 16:14they have big disclaimers on their website, saying we are not
- 16:16going to take your data and sell it, but I don't really trust
- 16:20them. And frankly, neither should you.
- 16:22So, what about hackers anything digital can be?
- 16:24Compromised, are you at all concerned that this device in
- 16:27your car, on your app? Could be compromised, and
- 16:29Somehow things. Bad could happen.
- 16:31Yes, these devices are quite vulnerable to hackers.
- 16:34There aren't a lot of safeguards.
- 16:35There aren't a lot of protections.
- 16:37Again, the companies I assure you that there are protections.
- 16:41We have been pushing among other things for much stronger,
- 16:43regulation of telematics at the state level.
- 16:46And one of the things that we want is for states to require
- 16:49that there be strong protections against hackers and strong
- 16:52privacy protections for Consumer data in these programs.
- 16:56Well, it sounds like telematics is a free-for-all right now that
- 16:58needs to be Like it and we're going to talk to you about that
- 17:01coming up. Next, this is consumer pedia.
- 17:03Powered by checkbook, dot-org consumer PDF, fast facts, the
- 17:09average auto insurance policy cost about $140 a month or
- 17:13Seventeen hundred dollars a year.
- 17:15Auto insurance is required in every state except New
- 17:18Hampshire. There are three main types of
- 17:20Auto Insurance liability coverage, protects you, if you
- 17:23cause damage to others and or their stuff Collision coverage
- 17:27covers your car. If you hit another car, Person
- 17:30or non moving object, like a tree or garage.
- 17:32Comprehensive is optional coverage that protects against
- 17:35damage caused to your vehicle that was not caused by an
- 17:38accident. Such as vandalism, windshield
- 17:41damage fire or weather. So, based on all the concerns
- 17:46we've been discussing consumer Federation.
- 17:48Of America would like to see some rules of the road, so to
- 17:51speak and acted and some states, as you mentioned, New York,
- 17:54California washing of already done that.
- 17:56Are you looking for some kind of Federal Regulation, or are you
- 17:59looking for the states to all agree on something, or where do
- 18:01we go with this? And what are you looking for?
- 18:03Well, insurance is mostly regulated at the state level.
- 18:06You have the 50 State Insurance departments, plus the District
- 18:10of Columbia Insurance Department.
- 18:12Federal Regulation, would be good, but realistically, It's
- 18:15probably not going to happen anytime soon and getting a 50
- 18:19states. Plus the District of Columbia to
- 18:20all agree. On something is like herding
- 18:22cats, but we're pushing for regulation at the state level.
- 18:26We've organized, with a bunch of consumer groups in a whole bunch
- 18:29of different areas. This is a very complicated
- 18:31subject, but there are some basic ground rules that would
- 18:34benefit consumers and help. A lot of people.
- 18:36First telemachus needs to be voluntary for consumers.
- 18:39That shouldn't be required, consumers.
- 18:41Should decide whether to enroll in this program or whether they
- 18:44don't want, To enroll in this program, consumers and
- 18:47Regulators need to know all the points and the factor is
- 18:50collected in telematics by insurers.
- 18:52Like, whether it's, how much you travel, what time of day you
- 18:56travel your speed, and they should also know how much weight
- 19:00each factor has like for instance, if your premium in the
- 19:03tell Max program is 20% of that is based on speed that should be
- 19:07a known and it should be publicly available in language
- 19:10that the average consumer can understand.
- 19:12We also think that Regulators should have very strong
- 19:15Standards for the information that's collected and used only
- 19:19data, that's directly related to Insurance risk, should be
- 19:21allowed the insurers need to provide good justification for
- 19:25every factor that they're using. So the Department's can clearly
- 19:28understand this and if needed, the Department's can bring in
- 19:32outside experts. Also, these programs should be
- 19:35tested for disparate impact, to make sure that they don't
- 19:38unfairly discriminated against African Americans or other
- 19:41people. And so they don't perpetuate
- 19:43systemic racism or or biases against racial or ethnic groups
- 19:48and the companies should be required to test their programs
- 19:51for this bias. And if they find it, they should
- 19:54be required to correct it very quickly or face serious, serious
- 19:58consequences. And we also think that there
- 20:00should be restrictions on this information to ensure that
- 20:03telematics actually benefits consumers and lowers your
- 20:06premiums instead of raising them.
- 20:08There are a couple of the companies that say our data will
- 20:11only be used to lower your premium instead of increasing
- 20:13it. That's an encouraging.
- 20:15First Step, but again, we don't trust the companies.
- 20:17When they say that we think that telematics should be required to
- 20:20help consumers. And these are some good first
- 20:24steps to try and ensure that these programs actually lower
- 20:26your premium instead of increasing it.
- 20:28Michael it sounds like telematics is the future.
- 20:31So we better get some rules of the road in place.
- 20:33Now, before, for instance, insurance companies, say you've
- 20:36got to do this or something like that.
- 20:38Yeah. Well that's more accurate to say
- 20:40that the insurance companies are trying to make it the future.
- 20:43They have been pushing these programs for any years when you
- 20:46go online to a bunch of their websites and go through the
- 20:49process of getting an auto insurance quote, the default
- 20:51option is to participate in the telematics program.
- 20:54So they're trying, I think to sign up a lot of people
- 20:56automatically and to make it so you actually have to decide not
- 20:59to be in the telematics program consumers, have actually been
- 21:02quite skeptical about these programs, they've gradually
- 21:04grown but a lot of people are put off by the idea of Big
- 21:07Brother riding shotgun with you of an insurance company.
- 21:10Tracking all your driving behavior and knowing quite
- 21:13frankly, a pretty big amount. About you and they're also
- 21:17concerned about what the insurance company will do with
- 21:19that information. So a lot of people are still not
- 21:22using telematics there have actually been some polls where
- 21:25most Americans say they're skeptical about telematics and
- 21:28won't participate in these programs.
- 21:30And of, the people who'd will participate in these programs.
- 21:32A lot of them say we would only enroll in this.
- 21:35If say it lowers our premium by a certain amount, if it's really
- 21:38worth it. And I think frankly that's a
- 21:40good mindset to have. Consumers should go into this
- 21:42with an open mind. They should also be aware of all
- 21:44the pit. Falls that these programs aren't
- 21:46well-regulated. They could save you money, but
- 21:49they could also increase your premium and to be careful and do
- 21:52your research to me. Michael, the scariest part of
- 21:55all, this is a decisions are going to be made by algorithms.
- 21:59I don't trust algorithms, I don't know what they're doing.
- 22:02You can't appeal an algorithm, we all know the problems when
- 22:04somebody gets kicked off of Amazon or one of the social
- 22:07media platforms based on an algorithm and you got to try to
- 22:10deal with that. To me, that's the scariest part
- 22:12of this whole thing that algorithms are going to be
- 22:14deciding how much I For insurance.
- 22:16Yeah, it's a serious problem and one of the things that we have
- 22:19been advocating for is that algorithms and insurance
- 22:22programs and tell Max programs need to be extremely
- 22:25transparent. We have been fighting to say
- 22:28that Regulators elected officials and ordinary consumers
- 22:31should see how these algorithms were, what goes into the
- 22:34calculations, and how that affects your insurance, premium
- 22:37all the components and like the factors that should be
- 22:40identified and again, so should the weight given to them, but
- 22:43the insurance company is basically.
- 22:45We don't want that. I'm not sure whether it's
- 22:46through greed or simple stubbornness or something else.
- 22:50But they have fought transparency at every turn.
- 22:53We don't think that's right. We think consumers should know,
- 22:56what goes into tell Max programs, how algorithms work
- 22:59and it will benefit everybody in the long run because if it's an
- 23:03algorithms workings are transparent, it will usually be
- 23:05fairly obvious to see if there is serious unfair discrimination
- 23:09and you can correct. It very, very interesting stuff.
- 23:12Michael the long as advocacy associate at the consumer
- 23:14Federation. America, their campaign for
- 23:16Fair, auto insurance Michael. Thank you for spending so much
- 23:19time with us today and drive safely.
- 23:21Thanks you too. Before we go check book, wanted
- 23:23to find out what the insurance industry had to say about the
- 23:26types of issues consumer. Advocates are concerned about in
- 23:29response to our questions. We received a statement from the
- 23:32insurance information Institute, a trade group that represents
- 23:35the industry vice president of media relations.
- 23:38Loretta water said the continuous monitoring provided
- 23:41by telematics can help ensure as more accurately gauge their
- 23:44risk. Feedback and provides can help
- 23:46change bad driving habits or encourage good one.
- 23:49She said Waters acknowledged that tracking mileage and Driver
- 23:52Behavior has raised privacy concerns and as a result some
- 23:55states have enacted legislation requiring disclosure of tracking
- 23:59practices and devices despite privacy issues.
- 24:02She said usage based insurance is gaining in popularity as
- 24:05customers become more comfortable with allowing their
- 24:08driving to be monitored in order to save money.
- 24:10Many insurers are beginning to offer it as an option.
- 24:13She said and new companies or entities In the marketplace.
- 24:16Well, that's it for this episode of consumer PDF.
- 24:18You can subscribe to us on Apple or Google podcasts Spotify,
- 24:22Stitcher, or wherever you listen to your podcast.
- 24:25That way you won't miss an episode.
- 24:27Remember we release new ones, every other Thursday, another
- 24:30way you can support this show is to follow us on consumer, pedia
- 24:34on Facebook and Instagram and at my consumer pedia on Twitter,
- 24:38I'm her Weiss bomb. Thanks for listening consumer,
- 24:41pedia is a public service of checkbook.
- 24:43Dot-org, where are you now? Nonprofit that helps you save
- 24:46money and make smarter choices. You can count on, checkbook to
- 24:49help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 24:53ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 24:55If you live in or around these Seven Cities Navin, join
- 24:58checkbook, yet check us out Boston.
- 25:01Chicago Philadelphia Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis st.
- 25:06Paul and Washington, d.c. to get your free 30-day subscription.
- 25:10Go to check book. Dot org, slash consumer pedia if
- 25:13you like what you've heard, we hope.
- 25:15You'll become a supporter by using the link at the bottom of
- 25:17the show notes to make a small contribution each month consumer
- 25:21pedia, empowering consumers to save money and make smarter
- 25:25choices.