Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Capital Rules and Risk Management for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, I'm Mark Treichel, and you are listening to With Flying
- 0:03Colors, the podcast where I interview subject matter experts.
- 0:08to provide credit union leaders with tips on how you can achieve success with NCUA
- 0:13and pass your exam with flying colors.
- 0:17Today, I'm joined by Steve Farr to talk about credit union capital.
- 0:21Steve, before we jump in for folks who are just meeting you for the first time,
- 0:25could you share a little bit about who you are And your career experience with NCUA.
- 0:30Thanks, Mark.
- 0:31Yeah, I look forward to being able to talk about capital and credit unions
- 0:35because it is a subject I spent a great deal of time on my history with NCUA.
- 0:40They started as an examiner clear back in 1987, spent most of my career as a
- 0:46problem case officer and as a problem case officer, I had the opportunity to work
- 0:50in conservatorships, number of workouts.
- 0:54liquidations, assisted mergers.
- 0:57So it got well rounded and worked throughout the nation on those.
- 1:00Then around the year 2000, I went into the central office where I worked on
- 1:06assisted mergers throughout the regions.
- 1:08I'd help them with the plans that they put together on that.
- 1:11Prepared a number of supervision letters that many of you credit unions
- 1:15have probably read was involved in the corporate resolution as many of us were
- 1:20that were in the office at that time.
- 1:22I always referred to that that age to me very, very much the capital rulemaking.
- 1:28I started on that.
- 1:29In . So that had a long incubation period.
- 1:32I worked on a number of postmortems, which is always kinda interesting
- 1:35looking at the, uh, failures at NCOA because I worked to solve these
- 1:39problem credit unions and postmortems.
- 1:41I was always associated with failures in NCOA, but hopefully in a good way, . I
- 1:46spent time as the vice president of the CLF, and one of the things that I did is.
- 1:52Responsibility is vice president of CLF is we're looking at how much capital
- 1:57should the CLF hole because we wanted to be able to return as much as we
- 2:01could back to the memberships, but still hold their responsible amount.
- 2:04So that helped me to do a calculation of which I was asking credit unions to do.
- 2:10So hopefully we'll benefit from that experience as we move into this subject.
- 2:14Great, Steve.
- 2:15I wrote a few things down that made me chuckle and smile, but
- 2:17yeah, the corporate resolution.
- 2:18I remember when you were the guy at NCUA who had to work with the CPAs
- 2:23about how NCUA needed to allow for that on NCUA's books and records.
- 2:28And that's when you taught me about what Monte Carlo simulation was.
- 2:31I think he used as some of the backdrop there.
- 2:34Yeah.
- 2:34Those were interesting times.
- 2:36And as you mentioned that you talked about being VP of the CLF, that might
- 2:39be something we could do a podcast on separately, cause that's not a lot of
- 2:42people who understand the CLF probably.
- 2:45And you've left the agency, Owen Cole, who used to be the president recently
- 2:49retired, and that might be a topic that we could talk about later, but yeah.
- 2:53And see, so you and I have known each other for over 30 years.
- 2:57I believe we met.
- 2:58Enter around San Francisco at one of those NCOA training classes,
- 3:02and we may have gone out and had dinner and maybe a beer or two.
- 3:05And then we worked very closely.
- 3:07You were very modest about being a PCO for a long time.
- 3:10You were, if not the best problem solver at NCOA in those years,
- 3:15you were number one or number two.
- 3:16And you taught me a lot about my new job when I came out
- 3:19there to be your supervisor, the director of special actions.
- 3:22So those were good times.
- 3:24It doesn't seem like that was so long ago, we learned a lot back then.
- 3:28Also you spoke to the fact that you Took a heavy interest in this and were
- 3:33involved in it in 2014 on the failures that you were Involved with where credit
- 3:37unions cost the insurance fund money.
- 3:39And so having you involved in that with your background You were really the
- 3:43right hand guy for the E& I director back in 2014 and all that when these
- 3:48rules were coming out One of the things that I talk about with clients
- 3:51is inside baseball, different things about NCOA, and there's things that,
- 3:55I think about how this came about that probably nobody other than maybe Larry
- 3:58Fazio can remember from back in the day.
- 4:01So I'm really looking forward to chatting with you about this.
- 4:04So before we start talking about capitals, what would you say the
- 4:08purpose of regulatory capital is?
- 4:10What can we glean from the purpose of regulatory capital
- 4:13that will lead this discussion?
- 4:15It always helps to start with why regulatory capital,
- 4:19and it's really consistent.
- 4:20Same with how any business would want capital, but for banks
- 4:24and credit unions, the same.
- 4:25It's there to absorb those losses, but because we have deposits of which the
- 4:30public man puts into the institutions, we need to have public confidence
- 4:34and they look at the capital ratios.
- 4:37It restricts excessive growth.
- 4:40Because if you're limited to certain capital ratios, you can't grow
- 4:44exponentially very quickly, which would be putting risk into your balance sheet.
- 4:49And I was near and dear to how I thought my main responsibility
- 4:54was protect the insurance fund.
- 4:57Like they talk about people that play at the NFL, their
- 5:00symbol is protect the shield.
- 5:01And mine was always, we need to protect the fund.
- 5:04And capital is a big protector of the insurance funds.
- 5:08But beyond that, we really expect credit unions to go beyond the regulatory capital
- 5:13requirement and hold the appropriate capital based on their unique risk, and
- 5:18they need to have the ability to identify, measure, monitor and control those risks.
- 5:22So we'll cover that part of the capital a little bit later, but adequate capital.
- 5:29For safety and soundness purposes is the key part for
- 5:32undercapitalized credit unions.
- 5:34They result in failures And those failures result in losses to the insurance fund
- 5:39Probably the most recent one that people will be aware of is the losses are
- 5:42incurred from concentrations of credit in credit union medallion loans If we go back
- 5:48in history, we've had failures a long time ago based on mortgage servicing assets
- 5:54and Investments in properties in Florida by credit unions in the upper Midwest.
- 6:01So that's what, capital saves insurance fund in the
- 6:04institution from failing itself.
- 6:05But then there's that risk of over capitalization.
- 6:09And that's the one that can really start to bother me personally.
- 6:12And I know Bob Fenner at NCO used to really be upset about.
- 6:16When the credit union had too much capital and people would look at that
- 6:20and try to say, how can I turn this into personal gain for myself or for my group?
- 6:26When people would convert the credit union charter to something of which they were
- 6:30in a position to gain on that and take the funds that really were the membership,
- 6:35those are always really disheartening.
- 6:37So as I caution credit unions against, you don't want to be over capitalized
- 6:41because you want to be returning as much as you can back to the membership.
- 6:45So that's the purpose.
- 6:46Sure.
- 6:47Both regulatory capital and capital.
- 6:49And by having above average capital, whether that's to associate to
- 6:53mitigate your risks, and you're, we're going to get into that.
- 6:56The other thing, when you have the extra capital, it's free money.
- 6:58And while they're not paying high rates on anything right now to attract money,
- 7:03it does help subsidize loan rates.
- 7:05As well as things like that.
- 7:07Next, I think we're going to talk a little bit about the net worth ratio when PCA and
- 7:11things like that and when that came into play, but I'm reminded of a story back
- 7:15before we had PCA and you and I were PCOs and we could allow credit unions to go
- 7:20below the certain levels that PCA created.
- 7:23I remember you telling me a story.
- 7:25About one of your credit unions that you had that had very low capital and had
- 7:30some challenges tied to that, but they were reborn like the Phoenix because
- 7:33of the great efforts they put forward.
- 7:35And it was one of those situations that I enjoyed the most was when you had a credit
- 7:40union that you were able to work real closely with, to deal with the problem,
- 7:45and it almost became like a partnership of working to be reborn, like the Phoenix.
- 7:50And as if I recall, there was a credit union that liked how much you helped them
- 7:55in that process that you might be the only NCUA retiree that has a boardroom
- 8:00that is named after you because of all the work you did at that credit union.
- 8:05Am I remembering that right?
- 8:07Yeah, it's funny because we always talked about.
- 8:09Credit unions were building a lot of crazy looking buildings back then and
- 8:13when they finally had gotten Situated where they could build a the building that
- 8:18they needed Of course, we built a really square efficient building and that's nice
- 8:22because a few of those credit unions I did Workouts in when they were actually
- 8:26in negative retained earnings positions.
- 8:29Many of them are still around a few have been merged into other entities
- 8:34or Because they took on other ones, but there's a few of them that they're still
- 8:38around today I do take a lot of pride in those absolutely No, that's, I can think
- 8:43of some where I did the same and it's, that's when everything's working perfectly
- 8:46from the regulatory side and the credit union side and really good cooperation.
- 8:50And that's fun to see.
- 8:51And it's fun to participate in.
- 8:52All right.
- 8:52So net worth ratio, why don't you speak to the net worth ratio as it
- 8:56relates to credit union capital?
- 8:59This starts NCUA's history with capital, there really only dates
- 9:02back to the year 2000, there was different capital regulations that
- 9:06were in effect before the year 2000.
- 9:08It was like, I thought about looking it up, but it's not going to go there.
- 9:11It was too long ago.
- 9:13So it was real novel though when credit union started to have to do
- 9:17the net worth ratio, it was very controversial and everybody, a lot
- 9:21of people are really upset about it.
- 9:22But it was based on and required from the prompt corrective action
- 9:28regulation that went into effect and that we had to put this measure that
- 9:31was consistent with what the banks had.
- 9:34So we ended up with just using a simple leverage ratio and call
- 9:38it the net worth ratio because.
- 9:40It has in its numerator, mostly GAAP retained earnings type items in capital,
- 9:47but it has the unique item dealing with mergers and that we take pre acquisition
- 9:53retained earnings and count that part of capital available to observe losses.
- 9:58Which really isn't quite that way, but so it has this kind of unique numerator and
- 10:04then the denominator is just simply being assets and when we wrote the regulation,
- 10:09we allowed a lot of definitions of assets so that if you were growing rapidly,
- 10:13you wouldn't have a fall short term fall in your net worth ratio, because you
- 10:17could use averaging to bring it down.
- 10:19But in the end, credit unions, Took to that pretty well.
- 10:23We had very few that were initially impacted by it.
- 10:26But if we go back and look at this measure, it was 7 percent or
- 10:29greater to be well capitalized.
- 10:31Now, recall that the bank similar major on their tier 1 ratio is 5%.
- 10:37So going back to what was the reason for the 2 percent difference?
- 10:401 percent was due to the NSU SIF and that that's still on the books of
- 10:46the credit unions versus for banks.
- 10:48They've expensed all of that money that's in their insurance fund.
- 10:52The other 1 percent was really there because Credit unions
- 10:55rather limited ability to raise capital, except through earnings.
- 10:59With now this increased use and availability of secondary capital,
- 11:03that's probably somewhat mitigated.
- 11:06And I haven't heard a lot of discussion on that, but we started
- 11:09with the net worth ratio and that was the initial measure and.
- 11:13been in effect since 2000 and now we're going to move forward to what really
- 11:18were the changes that start January 1st.
- 11:21Got it.
- 11:22And so if I'm interpreting you right, so the 1 percent buffer for the NCUSAF, I
- 11:28get that, and the other 1 percent because credit unions couldn't raise capital, as
- 11:33you referred to, limited income credit unions can get secondary capital, and then
- 11:36under risk based net worth, there's some opportunities for other credit unions.
- 11:40It sounds like.
- 11:41If you were still at NCUA, you would be open to maybe well capitalized being able
- 11:46to be a little bit less that or at least re evaluating that one percent buffer
- 11:51potentially for all credit unions or for low income or am I over interpreting that?
- 11:57You might be over interpreting that, but I will make a comment
- 12:00on that when we talk about the complex credit union leverage ratio.
- 12:04Okay, great.
- 12:05Then let's talk about the new complex credit union leverage ratio.
- 12:09This final rule was approved by the NCB board in December, just absolutely
- 12:14this past December, providing a simplified measure of capital
- 12:17adequacy for complex credit unions went into effect on January 1st.
- 12:22The first measurement of this will take place in March.
- 12:26It's modeled after the community bank leverage ratio, which was implemented
- 12:29by FDIC in November of 2019.
- 12:33So credit unions that satisfy eligibility do not need to calculate.
- 12:38The risk based capital ratio, which we'll talk about in a little bit by
- 12:42maintaining a higher net worth ratio, about 690 credit unions with assets
- 12:47over 500 million, which makes them into the definition of complex and of able
- 12:52to use the credit union in a complex credit union leverage ratio, but they
- 12:57have an average net worth ratio of 10.
- 12:5916%.
- 13:01So on average, everybody has a 1 percent buffer above the amount needed.
- 13:06And the really, the only thing you get there is.
- 13:08They wouldn't have to compute the risk based capital.
- 13:12The minimum is set at 9%.
- 13:14Same as it is for the banks.
- 13:15So basically, it's the net worth ratio 9 percent same net worth ratio, the
- 13:197 percent to be well capitalized.
- 13:22So that 2 percent difference that there used to be between FDIC measures and NCLE
- 13:29measures on the simple leverage ratio.
- 13:31Is essentially gone.
- 13:33It goes away under the complex credit, Under the complex credit, okay, you'd
- 13:37be a little bit remiss to say It's exactly comparable because it's really
- 13:40not the kareans did get a benefit.
- 13:43It just really probably wasn't worth the amount of People that had comments
- 13:48about a negative about bringing that up again at this point in time I think nine
- 13:52percent is a pretty fair measure for leverage Of just basically pure equity
- 13:59for the most part amount available to cover losses so that this measure is
- 14:03good because it's still 4 percent above the amount needed to be well capitalized
- 14:09so it does create a significant buffer above the net worth ratio.
- 14:15And so Steve if someone's at 9.
- 14:184%.
- 14:18So they're billion dollars, so they're over the 500 million threshold.
- 14:22They're at 9.
- 14:245%.
- 14:24Thanks a lot.
- 14:25net worth ratio.
- 14:26The advantage they have with this new regulation is that because
- 14:32they're over the nine and a half percent, they're well capitalized.
- 14:36And so they don't need to do all those other calculations tied to how much
- 14:42they have in member business loans, how much they have in real estate loans.
- 14:45While they can do the calculation, the one that NCUA Now we'll grade
- 14:49them on is being over the 9%.
- 14:52Am I summarizing that right?
- 14:54That's correct.
- 14:55As long as you are a qualifying institution that you don't have a
- 14:58significant off balance sheet exposures or greater than 2 percent of assets
- 15:04basically and tied up in goodwill, which generally isn't available to cover losses.
- 15:09So there are.
- 15:10Just the four qualifying criteria.
- 15:12Okay.
- 15:13You reminded me of someone who's still at NCUA.
- 15:15When I would restate something and get it mostly right, but off a touch, and
- 15:19they would clarify it, they would start by saying, that's roughly correct.
- 15:23And that always made me smile.
- 15:24So adding those caveats to what I said, make that accurate.
- 15:27Okay.
- 15:28Got it.
- 15:28Anything else on the complex credit union leverage ratio?
- 15:32No, it is fairly straightforward.
- 15:35Very good.
- 15:36Very good.
- 15:37Let's speak to risk based capital.
- 15:40This is another one that just comes into effect.
- 15:42First measurement of be on the call report that's been drafted in is out
- 15:47there for credit unions to look at starting with the measurement in March.
- 15:50I'd say, don't be afraid of this ratio because even though very few credit
- 15:56unions is, we're talking about the complex credit unions, and ones that
- 16:01aren't going to use the leverage ratio to not have to compute risk based capital.
- 16:07It is a valid measure that takes into account the uniqueness of your assets.
- 16:13So when we put together those risk weights, they're pretty much the same
- 16:17as in the other banking agencies.
- 16:19We did manage to get some things in there dealing with concentrations
- 16:24of assets because those would have led to credit union failures.
- 16:27So there are.
- 16:29Additional risk higher risk weights when you get above higher levels of real estate
- 16:34loans and especially commercial loans.
- 16:36As I say, even if you're not going to end up having to calculate the
- 16:42risk based net worth requirement.
- 16:43I would want to be aware of it because it is a nice and another measurement tool.
- 16:47The credit unions would have available to themselves to see where they stand
- 16:52in capital under a risk weighted basis.
- 16:55Sure.
- 16:56And so it's a tool that gives them some context compared to other measurements.
- 17:00And then theoretically, another reason to pay attention to it would be like
- 17:04with COVID unexpected growth, the capital ratio, going back to what you
- 17:08said at the beginning, part of the reason to have capital restrictions.
- 17:12Is to prevent excessive growth.
- 17:14Over the last couple of years, a lot of credit unions experienced
- 17:17excessive growth that they really could do nothing about race for zero.
- 17:20And it was just funneling in because of the world that we lived in.
- 17:23And that could drop you down below the 9 percent net worth ratio.
- 17:28And then all of a sudden, six months ago, you weren't being measured
- 17:32on it, but now you are, which is a reason to continue to watch it.
- 17:35Yeah, that's a very good point.
- 17:37The other one coming into that is.
- 17:39If credit unions have had a lot of this share growth that's come in on a risk
- 17:44based capital basis, where are they putting Those assets and predominantly
- 17:49if you're unable to put it in loans, you're probably putting it into lower risk
- 17:53weighted assets So you might find that risk based capital Ratio isn't fluctuating
- 18:00as much because the risk weighted assets Aren't changing as rapidly because
- 18:05they're being put into lower risk assets.
- 18:08That makes sense.
- 18:09And the other thing I like about the risk based capital is that the
- 18:14numerator is really purely gap and it has the deductions that work on these
- 18:21items inside the balance sheet are not going to be available to cover losses.
- 18:25So it's a more precise measure of what is available to cover
- 18:30losses in the event of failure.
- 18:33And so an example of what's excluded in the numerator, would that be the
- 18:37merger and acquisition category or what it's not in there because if you do a
- 18:43combination or merger and you have a gain on that transaction in which you
- 18:49are not having to record additional goodwill that goes directly into equity.
- 18:53So we don't have that.
- 18:54Non gap item that just sits there and could become problems at some point
- 19:00in time, but so far so good on that.
- 19:02It hasn't raised a lot of problems with it.
- 19:04The calculations takes into account goodwill intangibles, and it also
- 19:07takes into account the end to SF deposit and that we do reduce it
- 19:11from the numerator and denominator.
- 19:13So then that measure is more comparable against the other banking agencies,
- 19:18which is the risk based capital threshold for well capitalized of 10%.
- 19:23You and I talked about management of capital.
- 19:25You want to speak to what management of capital does and is?
- 19:28Yeah, because there's the regulatory requirement for
- 19:31capital that sets the minimum.
- 19:34Now, institutions, large and small need to be able to discuss with their examiner.
- 19:41What their capital goal is and why it's where it is.
- 19:44So in order to get there, you'd have to have probably some measurement
- 19:49beyond regulatory capital approaches.
- 19:52There are many ways to do it out there.
- 19:55The economic capital is one measure of doing it.
- 19:59And that is the.
- 20:00Calculation I did for doing the CLF and they looked at all of our assets
- 20:04and you figure what's the probability of default and with the investments
- 20:09to see if I could do very low and then that loss given default and then the
- 20:14amount of the exposure you have it.
- 20:15It's not a real complicated transaction, but it is another way of looking at
- 20:19your balance sheet and then identifying those risk items that are in there.
- 20:24What you can always look at for a tool is those credit unions
- 20:27over 10 billion in assets.
- 20:28They have another regulatory requirement to basically to do this.
- 20:33They have the requirement for stress testing and they have the
- 20:36requirement for a capital plan.
- 20:39And if you look at the elements of those.
- 20:42Not all of them would be something that you'd have to use for the credit union
- 20:45that you're particularly in because you don't have the complexity of the
- 20:49larger ones, but that does provide some reference as to what items of
- 20:55that appear to be appropriate for your credit union and that you could use.
- 20:59I think the hard thing is, like I say, when I always go to a
- 21:03credit, and they go, well, our board set a net worth ratio of 9%.
- 21:07Then my answer is like, why?
- 21:09Well, what was the peer average for credit unions in our state of our size?
- 21:14It's like very good, but your assets are exactly the same as theirs.
- 21:20The environment you're operating in, is that the same?
- 21:24I look at it like I like to do the SWOT analysis.
- 21:27Strengths, weaknesses, strengths, weaknesses.
- 21:28Opportunities and threats.
- 21:30I think that that is always another way of okay, this is why we would believe that we
- 21:35are safe holding closer to the regulatory minimum amount of capital versus that
- 21:41it's okay for accrediting to be aggressive and to be out there and do risk because
- 21:46it might be what their membership needs.
- 21:50But you can do that, but you just need to be able to hold appropriate capital
- 21:55for what you're doing and use of these tools like economic capital and
- 21:59stress testing and capital sensitivity testing, reverse stress testing.
- 22:06All provide value, but you need to be able to have those and be able to understand
- 22:11what it is that you are getting, because you can't just assign it off to a 3rd
- 22:15party and say that's all great and good.
- 22:16But just tell us what that means.
- 22:18You need to have at least some people on staff that are very comfortable with
- 22:21that discussion to the examiner says near the regulatory minimum is good for us.
- 22:27where we decide that we need to bump it up x percentage point because
- 22:30right now we're taking on these risks.
- 22:32The other thing you need to look at the future because merger and
- 22:36acquisition opportunities are generally going to result in at least a short
- 22:42term decrease in your regulatory capital measures as you can see.
- 22:46So if that's in your future, You need to take that into account.
- 22:52So there's lots of items that take place in there.
- 22:54What we've looked for is that credit unions have done analysis
- 22:58and additional work, so they're really comfortable for why that
- 23:01capital goal is their capital goal.
- 23:04This is a great topic.
- 23:05And as you're talking, I'm getting a lot of things that run through my head.
- 23:09Steve, if you think back on the consulting work, you and I have done it for some
- 23:12of my clients over the last year, this topic has been there more than others.
- 23:17The fact that, okay, NCOA is questioning.
- 23:20Their capital regime, if you will, and wanting them to better explain
- 23:25why, if they're just over well capitalized, why that makes sense.
- 23:29How that relates to where they've been and some of the tools you've mentioned
- 23:33here are things that we've suggested to some of the clients we've had.
- 23:36But if you find yourself having capital type questions, reach out to me and I'll
- 23:42explain how to reach out to me later.
- 23:43But this is something that Steve and I would love to try and assist a credit
- 23:46union with to walk through some of this.
- 23:48And then two other things that you said that I want to touch on, as you said, look
- 23:53to what credit unions over 10 billion.
- 23:55are asked to do, and I can imagine credit unions out there
- 23:59hearing that have a heavy side.
- 24:00Like I'm 400 million.
- 24:02I'm not 10 billion.
- 24:03I can't afford to do that.
- 24:05I'm a billion.
- 24:06I'm 25 million.
- 24:08Of course, somebody who is at nine billion certainly has to be getting ready to
- 24:12transfer over from regional control to the Office of National Exam and supervision.
- 24:16And so there's this You know, into a comes out with something.
- 24:20And one of the things that can happen is it's expected at a higher level and then
- 24:24it can start to bleed into lower levels.
- 24:27And you're not saying to let it bleed.
- 24:29You're just saying, look to it, understand it, take from it.
- 24:32What might make sense.
- 24:34And as you read through what larger institutions are asked to do, you might
- 24:38have an aha moment that says, okay, that makes sense for me as it relates to you.
- 24:42The part of the country I'm in and the risks that I could have while I do that
- 24:47SWOT analysis and you can raise the bar of what you're doing capital wise
- 24:52without really having to comply with the rule, anything you want to add to that?
- 24:55Yeah, that's a really good point to make.
- 24:58And we don't want to make great unions go too far.
- 25:02But as you do additional calculations of how much capital
- 25:06you think you should have, It's all related to your risk tolerance.
- 25:10So if you're, low risk tolerance, credit union operating fairly well below the
- 25:1610 billion requirement, we shouldn't be asking for a lot and you don't need a lot.
- 25:20But if you're have a fairly healthy risk appetite, You're in the market for
- 25:25some merger and acquisition activity.
- 25:27Certainly you want to be moving your process and sophistication up.
- 25:33Makes sense.
- 25:33And then you talked about one other thing you mentioned under this last discussion
- 25:37was having assistance from a third party.
- 25:39And so there's a lot of good third parties out there that can assist in
- 25:42a lot of different things from ALM, NEV, capital planning and everything.
- 25:47But the point I want to reiterate that you are making is N.
- 25:51C.
- 25:51U.
- 25:51A.
- 25:51Wants to make sure that while you have that third party that you own
- 25:55it, that whatever suggestions they might have, maybe they come back and
- 25:59they say, we suggest these 10 things and you evaluated internally say
- 26:02seven of these make sense for us.
- 26:04And the words I think you said were somebody within the walls of
- 26:07the credit union that understands that and then can speak to N.
- 26:10C.
- 26:10U.
- 26:10A.
- 26:11With that language so that N.
- 26:12C.
- 26:12U.
- 26:13A.
- 26:13understands that the credit union didn't just farm it out.
- 26:15They actually get it exactly.
- 26:17Yeah, exactly.
- 26:19You brought up the stuff about the corporate resolution.
- 26:21Yes, the accounting for the reserve on that was extremely complicated.
- 26:25And we did use third parties.
- 26:27These third parties had a lot of initials after their names.
- 26:30And I did have to spend a great deal of time sitting down with them and
- 26:34saying, Okay, this is how you say we do explain it to me again, so that I
- 26:39could make sure that I could explain it.
- 26:41And number one, that I understood it and agreed with it.
- 26:45I couldn't.
- 26:46Yeah, you were, that's a great comparison.
- 26:48You were that guy at NCA who understood that and then explained it to the board,
- 26:52explain it to Maryanne Woodson, the chief financial officer and the CPAs who had
- 26:57to buy into the concept of Yeah, yeah.
- 26:59We had our own people doing our audit, like the NCA audit, and they had to.
- 27:04Be in the room with them and be able to confidently explain to them how
- 27:08that calculation worked and why we were comfortable with the results.
- 27:13Very good.
- 27:13One last thing on this topic.
- 27:15I know Steve, you and I had helped a couple of credit unions with
- 27:19net worth restoration plans.
- 27:21That's something you're fantastic at with that.
- 27:23I've got some experience with as well, and we were able to help
- 27:27those credit unions achieve success.
- 27:28Maybe at some juncture, that's not a lot of credit unions have to
- 27:31do it when they do have to do it.
- 27:32It can be a heavy lift to get approval.
- 27:35And that's something we'll talk about down the road.
- 27:37I know you and I have some other topics we're going to be
- 27:39talking about in future episodes.
- 27:42So this was great.
- 27:43I want to thank you for being my guest here today on the podcast.
- 27:47And in closing, I want to mention that.
- 27:50I do listen to a lot of podcasts.
- 27:51I enjoy podcasts myself and a lot of different topics.
- 27:55And one of my favorite podcasts at the end of episodes, they will
- 27:59tack on questions that came up from previous podcasts, so no doubt.
- 28:05There might've been something that Steve said here, or that I said that triggered
- 28:09a follow up question that you might have.
- 28:11And if you do have such questions about what we talked about today, I'd like
- 28:15you to reach out and let me know so that we can address those questions
- 28:19that maybe provide some clarification or a follow up podcast on this topic.
- 28:23And then lastly, if you'd like to talk to me about how Steve and
- 28:27I can assist you and your credit union, you can reach out to me at my
- 28:31email, which is cu exam solutions.
- 28:35So the letters see you exam solutions at mark trickle.
- 28:39com or via my website, which is www.
- 28:43marktreichel.
- 28:45com.
- 28:46All right, everybody.
- 28:47That's it for today.
- 28:48I'm Mark Treichel, and I hope you will join me again next
- 28:51time for with flying colors.