Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Does Not Have Presidential Immunity
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: For the purpose of this criminal case, former President Trump
- 0:13Speaker 2: has become citizen Trump. That's what the DC's Circuit Court
- 0:17Speaker 2: of Appeals wrote as it moved Donald Trump one step
- 0:21Speaker 2: closer to standing trial for trying to overturn the twenty
- 0:24Speaker 2: twenty election. In a decisive, unanimous ruling, the three judge
- 0:29Speaker 2: panel found that Trump can't claim that the office of
- 0:33Speaker 2: the presidency protects him from criminal prosecution. The judges wrote,
- 0:38Speaker 2: we cannot accept that the Office of the Presidency places
- 0:42Speaker 2: its former occupants above the law for all time. Thereafter,
- 0:46Speaker 2: the judges had made their skepticism of Trump's immunity claims
- 0:50Speaker 2: clear during the oral arguments last month. Here's Judge Karen
- 0:54Speaker 2: Lacraft Henderson.
- 0:56Speaker 1: I think it's paradoxical to say that his constitutional duty
- 1:02Speaker 1: to take care that the laws be faithfully executed allows
- 1:07Speaker 1: him to violate criminal laws.
- 1:12Speaker 2: And in the opinion, the judges repeatedly used Trump's words
- 1:15Speaker 2: and positions against him, for example, pointing to Trump's position
- 1:19Speaker 2: during his impeachment that he could still be criminally charged,
- 1:23Speaker 2: something Judge Florence panpointed out during the arguments.
- 1:27Speaker 3: You took the position or your client did during the
- 1:31Speaker 3: impeachment proceedings that there would be an option for criminal
- 1:35Speaker 3: prosecution later, and it's in the congressional record, and I
- 1:38Speaker 3: guess the question is what has changed or why have
- 1:41Speaker 3: you changed your position.
- 1:42Speaker 2: The court put the ruling on hold for Trump to
- 1:45Speaker 2: appeal to the Supreme Court, but only until Monday. Joining
- 1:49Speaker 2: me is former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth, a professor at
- 1:53Speaker 2: Cardozo Law School. The court said, our analysis is guided
- 1:57Speaker 2: by the Constitution, federal statutes, and his as well as
- 2:00Speaker 2: concerns of public policy. What's your impression broadly of the opinion?
- 2:07Speaker 4: My opinion broadly is that it is a resounding rejection
- 2:10Speaker 4: of Trump's claim of immunity from criminal prosecution, and that
- 2:14Speaker 4: it's an extremely thorough well written and well reasoned opinion
- 2:18Speaker 4: that is unanimous issued on behalf of a panel that
- 2:21Speaker 4: included one judge appointed by a Republican president, all speaking
- 2:25Speaker 4: in one calm but clear voice, holding that a former
- 2:29Speaker 4: president is not above the law.
- 2:31Speaker 2: They address all of Trump's arguments for immunity and shoot
- 2:35Speaker 2: them down one by one, starting with his argument that
- 2:39Speaker 2: separation of power's doctrine immunizes him.
- 2:43Speaker 4: The Court took that argument seriously and addressed it thoroughly,
- 2:47Speaker 4: but found that there was no problem in separation of
- 2:51Speaker 4: powers concerns with a former president being held criminally responsible
- 2:57Speaker 4: for actions taken while in office that were in violation
- 3:00Speaker 4: of federal criminal laws passed by the United States Congress.
- 3:05Speaker 4: And it cited precedents in which presidential actions had been
- 3:09Speaker 4: subject to judicial review, including former President truman seizure of
- 3:13Speaker 4: the steel mills, and the Court said it did not
- 3:16Speaker 4: find that separation of powers concerns prevented the Court from
- 3:20Speaker 4: exercising oversight through the adjudication of the criminal laws over
- 3:24Speaker 4: acts committed by a former president while in office that
- 3:28Speaker 4: in fact were violations of criminal law.
- 3:30Speaker 2: As you mentioned, there was a measured tone, but I
- 3:33Speaker 2: thought that the tone was a little less measured when
- 3:36Speaker 2: they had concerns about quote at bottom, former President Trump's
- 3:41Speaker 2: stance would collapse our system of separated powers by placing
- 3:45Speaker 2: the president beyond the reach of all three branches. At
- 3:49Speaker 2: different points, I just thought that they raised some heightened concerns.
- 3:53Speaker 4: They certainly raised concerns, and there were a number of
- 3:57Speaker 4: really striking portions of the opinion that in a sense
- 4:01Speaker 4: in a very measured way, I thought, expressed a sense
- 4:04Speaker 4: of outrage over the implications of the former president's arguments.
- 4:08Speaker 4: So you just read one portion of it. There's another
- 4:10Speaker 4: portion where the court said, it would be a striking
- 4:13Speaker 4: paradox if the president, who alone is vested with the
- 4:16Speaker 4: constitutional duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed,
- 4:21Speaker 4: were the sole officer capable of defying those laws with impunity.
- 4:25Speaker 4: So there are a number of statements like that that
- 4:27Speaker 4: are just really strong rejections of the notion that a
- 4:32Speaker 4: former president would be immune from prosecution and from his
- 4:36Speaker 4: actions being reviewed by the court.
- 4:39Speaker 2: They also took on policy considerations that he'd raised. Trump's
- 4:44Speaker 2: lawyer had said, and Trump himself has said this on
- 4:47Speaker 2: the road, that if presidents didn't have immunity, it would
- 4:51Speaker 2: risk chilling their actions, and that presidence would be routinely
- 4:56Speaker 2: indicted after they left office.
- 4:58Speaker 4: Yes, the court did into account those policy considerations and
- 5:03Speaker 4: said that not only was there no historical precedent for
- 5:09Speaker 4: immunity from criminal prosecution of the kind that former President
- 5:13Speaker 4: Trump thought, but that these policy considerations did not weigh
- 5:18Speaker 4: in favor of recognizing such immunity. For the first time.
- 5:22Speaker 4: In this case, they said that it has always been
- 5:26Speaker 4: understood that former presidents could be subject to criminal prosecution
- 5:30Speaker 4: when they left office. For example, that's why former President
- 5:34Speaker 4: Ford pardoned former President Nixon. They cited the example of
- 5:38Speaker 4: former President Bill Clinton, who entered into an agreement with
- 5:41Speaker 4: the special counsel who had been investigating him with various sanctions,
- 5:44Speaker 4: including forfeiting his law license, in part to settle the
- 5:49Speaker 4: prospect of a future criminal prosecution. And then, most importantly,
- 5:52Speaker 4: they cited statements by attorneys for former President Trump during
- 5:57Speaker 4: his impeachment trial his second impeachment trial, they argued that
- 6:01Speaker 4: impeachment was not the proper remedy, but rather the possibility
- 6:05Speaker 4: of a criminal prosecution would be the proper remedy. And
- 6:08Speaker 4: so they said these examples that point toward an understanding
- 6:12Speaker 4: that former presidents could be subject to criminal prosecution when
- 6:16Speaker 4: they left office for acts taken while president, and that
- 6:20Speaker 4: there was no suggestion in the historical record that that
- 6:24Speaker 4: prospect had chilled presidents while they were in office from
- 6:29Speaker 4: exercising their duties without too much concern. And in fact,
- 6:33Speaker 4: there was a quote from the district court opinion that
- 6:35Speaker 4: they reiterated in the appellate opinion that I just thought
- 6:38Speaker 4: was very telling. The District Court had said, every president
- 6:41Speaker 4: will face difficult decisions, whether to intentionally commit a federal
- 6:45Speaker 4: crime should not be one of them. And the DC
- 6:48Speaker 4: Circuit quoted that language, saying, basically, they don't think that
- 6:52Speaker 4: they're holding that there is no immunity from criminal prosecution
- 6:56Speaker 4: is going to actually chill presidents in the exercise.
- 6:59Speaker 2: Of their duties. They sort of turned the argument around
- 7:02Speaker 2: against Trump. During the oral arguments, Trump's lawyer spent seemed
- 7:07Speaker 2: like most of the time on the impeachment clause and
- 7:11Speaker 2: this argument that Donald Trump would first have to have
- 7:15Speaker 2: been convicted by the Senate in order to then be
- 7:21Speaker 2: tried criminally after he left office.
- 7:24Speaker 5: So, as the Lascimenta points out very clearly, then the founders,
- 7:28Speaker 5: the framers actually in the Constitution Convention clearly contemplated that
- 7:32Speaker 5: that sequence that I've described would be mandatory. He would
- 7:35Speaker 5: have to be impeached and convicted first of them.
- 7:37Speaker 2: And they took that on and they said, the strongest
- 7:40Speaker 2: evidence against Trump's claim of immunity is found in the
- 7:43Speaker 2: words of the Constitution's impeachment clause.
- 7:47Speaker 4: They did treat thoroughly this argument that he could not
- 7:51Speaker 4: be prosecuted criminally because he had not been convicted in
- 7:54Speaker 4: the Senate relying on the impeachment clause. They addressed it
- 7:58Speaker 4: thoroughly and said that they rejected it, that they thought
- 8:01Speaker 4: it was a strained reading of the clause that he offered,
- 8:05Speaker 4: and that although the clause makes clear that a president
- 8:09Speaker 4: can be criminally prosecuted after being impeached and convicted, that
- 8:15Speaker 4: the negative implication that Trump was arguing from that clause
- 8:18Speaker 4: that he could only be criminally prosecuted if he had
- 8:20Speaker 4: been convicted in the Senate following impeachment simply did not follow.
- 8:25Speaker 2: So in the opinion, you had the legal arguments based
- 8:30Speaker 2: on precedent and history and the Constitution, and then there
- 8:34Speaker 2: were the sort of logical, sensible arguments, and one here
- 8:39Speaker 2: was that, you know, the founders knew how to grant
- 8:42Speaker 2: immunity if they wanted to, and they didn't want to hear.
- 8:46Speaker 6: Yes, absolutely.
- 8:47Speaker 4: They cited to other portions of the Constitution that were
- 8:50Speaker 4: explicit about granted immunity, for example, with respect to the
- 8:53Speaker 4: speaking debate clause and making clear that there would be
- 8:55Speaker 4: immunity there for actions in the course of speech and debate.
- 8:59Speaker 4: By members of Congress, And so if the framers knew
- 9:03Speaker 4: how to be explicit about grants of immunity, it follows
- 9:05Speaker 4: that if they didn't explicitly grant it to presidents in
- 9:08Speaker 4: this context, that it doesn't exist.
- 9:10Speaker 2: Is there any part of this opinion that you think
- 9:14Speaker 2: is weak or subject to attack on appeal?
- 9:19Speaker 4: It is a really sorrow opinion, and I think that
- 9:25Speaker 4: the fact that the Court took its time to write
- 9:28Speaker 4: this and to speak in one voice clearly was time
- 9:32Speaker 4: well used to write such a sorrow opinion. I do
- 9:35Speaker 4: not see any weak points in this opinion. I thought
- 9:39Speaker 4: it was interesting that the court wrote in a footnote
- 9:42Speaker 4: that it was not addressing the situation of a criminal
- 9:45Speaker 4: prosecution by a state prosecutor for ax undertaken in office,
- 9:50Speaker 4: and nor was it addressing the prospect of immunity of
- 9:54Speaker 4: a sitting president from criminal prosecution. So in a sense,
- 9:58Speaker 4: it's very much narrowly tailored to the situation before the court.
- 10:03Speaker 2: And where did Trump's arguments about official acts go?
- 10:07Speaker 4: I thought it was really interesting that the DC Circuit
- 10:10Speaker 4: held categorically that there was no immunity from criminal prosecution
- 10:16Speaker 4: for a former president, even for official acts at the
- 10:20Speaker 4: oral argument, and given the briefing, much of which was
- 10:23Speaker 4: dedicated to whether these were official acts of the president,
- 10:27Speaker 4: I thought it was possible that the court would say,
- 10:31Speaker 4: we're not going to deal with the categorical question because
- 10:34Speaker 4: we're going to find that there is no immunity here
- 10:38Speaker 4: because these were not official acts. In other words, they
- 10:40Speaker 4: might have said, arguendos, we're going to apply the framework
- 10:44Speaker 4: for immunity from the civil context to the criminal context,
- 10:49Speaker 4: which is what Trump invited them to do, that we
- 10:52Speaker 4: would find that even within that framework, these actions by
- 10:56Speaker 4: Trump fall outside of his official acts. Have written an
- 11:00Speaker 4: opinion along those lines, but they didn't, and I think
- 11:04Speaker 4: that that is significant. It's a really sort of resounding
- 11:07Speaker 4: rejection of the idea that there could be immunity from
- 11:11Speaker 4: criminal prosecution even for official acts. The Court didn't really
- 11:16Speaker 4: discuss whether or not these were official acts in the
- 11:19Speaker 4: body of its opinion. They dropped a footnote where they said,
- 11:23Speaker 4: even if we were to apply that framework, which asks
- 11:27Speaker 4: whether the actions were within the outer perimeter of the
- 11:31Speaker 4: presence responsibilities, which is the civil suit immunity framework, they said,
- 11:36Speaker 4: we are doubtful that these most of these acts is
- 11:39Speaker 4: alleged to the indictment would constitute official acts, and they
- 11:43Speaker 4: cited to their recent's opinion in the Blastingham case, which
- 11:46Speaker 4: was the civil suit against Trump and others involved in
- 11:49Speaker 4: the January sixth riot, where the court did apply the
- 11:52Speaker 4: civil immunity framework and found that most of the actions
- 11:56Speaker 4: as alleged in those civil complaints outside the outer perimeter
- 12:02Speaker 4: of official actions. And so although the court didn't squarely
- 12:05Speaker 4: address that question in this opinion, because it didn't need to,
- 12:09Speaker 4: given that it said categorically there is no immunity from
- 12:12Speaker 4: criminal prosecution, I thought it was interesting that it did
- 12:16Speaker 4: drop that footnote essentially expressing doubt that these would be
- 12:20Speaker 4: deemed to be official acts.
- 12:22Speaker 2: Didn't the judges also throw cold water on any claims
- 12:26Speaker 2: that the counting of the ballots, that part of the
- 12:28Speaker 2: electoral process has anything to do with the president.
- 12:32Speaker 6: They did.
- 12:33Speaker 7: They talked about how these were not actually acts that
- 12:37Speaker 7: were within the president's duty, that these were not matters
- 12:42Speaker 7: entrusted to him, and to the extented he claims that
- 12:46Speaker 7: his actions were an effort to see that the laws
- 12:49Speaker 7: were faithfully executed, that that essentially was a disingenuous argument
- 12:53Speaker 7: here because he had no role to play with respect
- 12:57Speaker 7: to the administration of the state elections and the county
- 13:02Speaker 7: of the electoral votes, and that, in fact, what he
- 13:05Speaker 7: did was an effort, as alleged, it's an effort to
- 13:09Speaker 7: actually undermine the working of the laws that do govern
- 13:14Speaker 7: the election of the president. It's a one other sort
- 13:18Speaker 7: of notable quote from the opinion in that regard is
- 13:21Speaker 7: the court said former President Trump's alleged efforts to remain
- 13:25Speaker 7: in power despite losing the twenty twenty election were, if proven,
- 13:29Speaker 7: an unprecedented assault on the structure of our government. He
- 13:33Speaker 7: allegedly injected himself into a process in which the president
- 13:37Speaker 7: has no role the counting and certifying of the Electoral
- 13:40Speaker 7: College votes, thereby undermining constitutionally established procedures and the will.
- 13:45Speaker 4: Of the Congress.
- 13:46Speaker 2: Jessica, you're going to stay with me. Coming up, we're
- 13:48Speaker 2: going to discuss whether the Supreme Court will take this
- 13:52Speaker 2: case on appeal. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 13:56Speaker 2: In a unanimous ruling, the DC Court of Appeals has
- 13:59Speaker 2: found that Donald Trump cannot claim that the office of
- 14:02Speaker 2: the presidency protects him from prosecution. Quote. Former President Trump
- 14:07Speaker 2: has become citizen Trump with all the defenses of any
- 14:11Speaker 2: other criminal defendant, but any executive immunity that may have
- 14:15Speaker 2: protected him while he served as president no longer protects
- 14:19Speaker 2: him against this prosecution. This decision moves Trump closer to
- 14:24Speaker 2: standing trial for trying to overturn the twenty twenty election,
- 14:28Speaker 2: but it may not be the last word. The court
- 14:31Speaker 2: put the ruling against Trump on hold until February twelfth
- 14:35Speaker 2: for him to appeal to the U. S. Supreme Court.
- 14:38Speaker 2: He might also ask the full d C. Circuit to
- 14:41Speaker 2: rehear the case. Neither court is required to take up
- 14:44Speaker 2: his appeal. I've been talking to former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth,
- 14:49Speaker 2: a professor at Cardozo Law School. The court gave Trump
- 14:53Speaker 2: until Monday only to appeal to the Supreme Court to
- 14:58Speaker 2: have this case on hold. Do you think they were
- 15:00Speaker 2: looking at his strategy of delayed delay delay.
- 15:04Speaker 4: I can't speak to what was in the judge's vines
- 15:08Speaker 4: in their decision about the timing here. It is notable
- 15:12Speaker 4: that they gave him a short time frame in which
- 15:14Speaker 4: to appeal to the US Supreme Court before they would
- 15:18Speaker 4: issue the mandate. I think it speaks to the urgency
- 15:21Speaker 4: of the matters involved in this case, and you see
- 15:24Speaker 4: that sense of the significance of this case throughout the
- 15:28Speaker 4: Court's opinion when it talks about how the alleged conduct
- 15:33Speaker 4: was an effort to overturn the results of a democratic
- 15:38Speaker 4: election and the public's interest in the enforcement of criminal laws.
- 15:42Speaker 4: So I think that those substantive aspects of the case
- 15:47Speaker 4: may carry over to the court sense of what is
- 15:49Speaker 4: an appropriate time frame in which to allow resort to
- 15:53Speaker 4: further appellate review before the case goes forward in the
- 15:57Speaker 4: district Court.
- 15:58Speaker 2: Does that order the way it's it's raised mean that
- 16:01Speaker 2: if Trump decides to appeal on Bank to the DC
- 16:06Speaker 2: Circuit that the order won't be stayed.
- 16:10Speaker 1: Yes.
- 16:11Speaker 4: So the order makes clear that although Trump could file
- 16:15Speaker 4: a petition for rehearing in Bank from the full DC Circuit,
- 16:19Speaker 4: that motion would not stay the mandate. The only thing
- 16:24Speaker 4: that will stay the mandate beyond Monday would be Trump
- 16:27Speaker 4: filing an application for a stay from the United States
- 16:31Speaker 4: Supreme Court. And as I read the DC Circuit order,
- 16:35Speaker 4: its mandate will be stayed tending the US Supreme Court's
- 16:39Speaker 4: resolution of a motion by Trump for a stay. So,
- 16:43Speaker 4: if the Supreme Court considers an application by Trump for
- 16:47Speaker 4: a stay and rejects it. Then the case goes back
- 16:50Speaker 4: to the trial court, even if the US Supreme Court
- 16:54Speaker 4: subsequently grants circiora.
- 16:57Speaker 2: No one knows whether the Supreme Court will take the
- 16:59Speaker 2: case or not, but they already have a couple of
- 17:03Speaker 2: Trump cases on the docket, including this Thursday, the case
- 17:07Speaker 2: over Colorado barring him from the ballot. What would be
- 17:11Speaker 2: your guess as to whether they'll take the case or not.
- 17:14Speaker 4: This is such a well reasoned and thoughtful opinion that
- 17:18Speaker 4: I think they are very compelling reasons why the Court
- 17:22Speaker 4: wouldn't take this case. There's no circuit split on this issue,
- 17:26Speaker 4: and they certainly have their plateful with other really important
- 17:31Speaker 4: cases that they need to decide, including the ballot access question.
- 17:35Speaker 4: On the other hand, this is an enormously significant issue
- 17:40Speaker 4: whether a former president is entitled to immunity from criminal prosecution.
- 17:44Speaker 4: One could imagine the Justice is saying this is an
- 17:46Speaker 4: issue on which we should open. But on the other hand,
- 17:49Speaker 4: unless there are enough justices who think that the DC's
- 17:52Speaker 4: circuit opinion is wrong, then I could also see them
- 17:55Speaker 4: letting the DC opinion be the final word on this subject.
- 17:59Speaker 2: So is everything here because the federal election case was
- 18:04Speaker 2: on for March fourth, but then the judge had to
- 18:07Speaker 2: take it off the calendar. If the Supreme Court decides
- 18:11Speaker 2: not to take the case, how fast could the trial
- 18:14Speaker 2: be put back on the calendar and move forward.
- 18:18Speaker 4: Well, the Trial court has indicated that she will give
- 18:21Speaker 4: the former president additional time to respond to motions that
- 18:26Speaker 4: were filed by the special counsel to file any additional
- 18:29Speaker 4: motions on his own behalf time that but for the
- 18:34Speaker 4: stay of the trial court proceedings, he would have had
- 18:37Speaker 4: to work on these motions in this last month or so.
- 18:40Speaker 4: So she's going to give him that time. That means
- 18:43Speaker 4: we're probably looking at some time at the earliest in
- 18:47Speaker 4: late summer, perhaps late July, early August, for a trial date.
- 18:52Speaker 4: But we really don't know what's going to happen. I mean,
- 18:55Speaker 4: if the US Supreme Court were to take the case
- 18:57Speaker 4: in grant to stay, that would mean that things would
- 19:00Speaker 4: remain frozen. We really don't know, But we do see
- 19:03Speaker 4: coming from the Trial Court in DC, Judge Chutkin every
- 19:07Speaker 4: effort to move the case along as expeditiously as possible.
- 19:10Speaker 4: So I think we may have a better sense by
- 19:12Speaker 4: next week, by Monday, when and if Trump files an
- 19:15Speaker 4: application in the US Supreme Court for a stay. Whether
- 19:18Speaker 4: that's going to happen, I expect it will, and then
- 19:21Speaker 4: I would imagine within a week or so after that,
- 19:23Speaker 4: perhaps we would have some indication from the US Supreme
- 19:25Speaker 4: Court about how quickly they're going to move, and if
- 19:28Speaker 4: they're not going to take the case at all, then
- 19:30Speaker 4: these things may start proceeding even more quickly in the
- 19:32Speaker 4: trial court.
- 19:34Speaker 2: So I know that what they say here, or as
- 19:36Speaker 2: they said it has no application to what's happening in Georgia.
- 19:41Speaker 2: But Trump did make a similar argument in Georgia, and
- 19:46Speaker 2: I'm wondering if the courts there might look to what
- 19:49Speaker 2: this court has said.
- 19:50Speaker 4: I think the courts there will look to what this
- 19:53Speaker 4: court has said as persuasive authority. Certainly, the analysis about
- 19:58Speaker 4: the functional considerations about what impact would a holding that
- 20:03Speaker 4: a case, a criminal case could go forward have on
- 20:06Speaker 4: a president's ability to conduct their official duties without too
- 20:10Speaker 4: much concern. I think that would be persuasive to state
- 20:13Speaker 4: courts considering whether immunity should apply from a state prosecution.
- 20:18Speaker 4: But I do think that some of the language might
- 20:22Speaker 4: cut the other way, in the sense that one of
- 20:25Speaker 4: the things that the Court says about why federal criminal
- 20:28Speaker 4: prosecutions don't pose as great a concern as the prospect
- 20:32Speaker 4: of civil lawsuits is. They said, well, essentially, there are
- 20:35Speaker 4: so many private parties who might file civil lawsuits against
- 20:39Speaker 4: a former president, and that prospect is significant enough for
- 20:43Speaker 4: us to be concerned about not granting immunity. Those are
- 20:46Speaker 4: statements that the US Supreme Court had made in the
- 20:50Speaker 4: Fitzgerald's case, where it did recognize immunity from civil lawsuits
- 20:54Speaker 4: for presidents for actions taken in the course of their
- 20:58Speaker 4: official duties. DC Circuit said, well, we don't think those
- 21:01Speaker 4: considerations apply with the same force with respect to federal
- 21:06Speaker 4: criminal prosecutions, because prosecutors are subject to a number of
- 21:11Speaker 4: constraints before they can bring criminal charges, including a code
- 21:15Speaker 4: of ethics and also having to present their cases to
- 21:18Speaker 4: a grand jury composed of ordinary citizens before the case
- 21:21Speaker 4: can proceed. So much of that language I think works
- 21:25Speaker 4: in the same way with respect to date criminal prosecutions.
- 21:30Speaker 4: Prosecutors in the States also are subject to codes of
- 21:33Speaker 4: ethics before they can bring charges. They also generally have
- 21:36Speaker 4: to present them before a grand jury. But on the
- 21:39Speaker 4: other hand, there are many more state prosecutors in a
- 21:42Speaker 4: sense than there are federal prosecutors who are all encompassed
- 21:45Speaker 4: within the Department of Justice. So I could see that
- 21:48Speaker 4: discussion parts of it being used to help establish immunity
- 21:52Speaker 4: from state prosecution, and parts of it being used to
- 21:55Speaker 4: establish it there is no immunity from state prosecutions. And
- 21:59Speaker 4: then of course there's a whole issue of the supremacy
- 22:01Speaker 4: clause on how that would work in the context of
- 22:03Speaker 4: state prosecutions of a former president. That wasn't a consideration
- 22:07Speaker 4: in this case because it is a federal prosecution of
- 22:10Speaker 4: a former president.
- 22:11Speaker 2: So now we'll be keeping our eye on the calendar
- 22:13Speaker 2: until Monday to see what happens with the appeal. Thanks
- 22:17Speaker 2: so much, Jessica. That's Professor Jessica Roth of Cardozo Law School,
- 22:22Speaker 2: coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. The Pennsylvania
- 22:26Speaker 2: Supreme Court has made a ruling in a case over
- 22:29Speaker 2: the use of Medicaid dollars to cover the cost of abortions,
- 22:33Speaker 2: and the reasoning in that ruling signals a possible new
- 22:36Speaker 2: path for reasserting abortion rights. I'm June Gross when you're
- 22:40Speaker 2: listening to Bloomberg. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ordered a
- 22:44Speaker 2: lower court to reconsider a challenge to the states decades
- 22:48Speaker 2: old ban on using medicaid funds for abortions except in
- 22:52Speaker 2: cases of rape or incest. But the State Supreme Court's
- 22:56Speaker 2: reasoning has far wider implications. A law school professor Jessica
- 23:01Speaker 2: Levinson has written in a column for MSNBC, the majority
- 23:05Speaker 2: opinion signals a possible new path for reasserting abortion rights,
- 23:10Speaker 2: as well as thoroughly rebutting the Supreme Court's Dobb's decision,
- 23:14Speaker 2: which overturned Roe v. Wade, and Professor Levinson joins me, Now, Jessica,
- 23:19Speaker 2: in order to put this in context, where you have
- 23:22Speaker 2: to go back to the Roe v. Wade decision in
- 23:24Speaker 2: nineteen seventy three, explain how the court used the Fourteenth Amendment. There. Rov.
- 23:30Speaker 6: Wade is the Supreme Court deciding what is included in
- 23:34Speaker 6: the word liberty in the Fourteenth Amendment, what is constitutionally protected,
- 23:39Speaker 6: And leading up to Roe v. Wade, what the Supreme
- 23:42Speaker 6: Court had concluded is that broadly, there is this right
- 23:46Speaker 6: to privacy that's included in that word liberty. That broadly
- 23:50Speaker 6: that includes, for instance, the right to obtain contraception. But
- 23:55Speaker 6: the question in Roe v. Wade was does the word
- 23:58Speaker 6: liberty include the right to obtain an abortion? And back
- 24:03Speaker 6: in that case, the court answered in the affirmative, they said, yes,
- 24:06Speaker 6: it's not written anywhere in the Constitution, but we find
- 24:11Speaker 6: these unwritten rights and we conclude that they are included
- 24:16Speaker 6: in this word liberty. That the drafters of the fourteenth
- 24:19Speaker 6: Amendment knew that we were going to have to fill
- 24:22Speaker 6: in meaning to that word. And one of the things
- 24:24Speaker 6: that must mean is the right not just to contraception,
- 24:28Speaker 6: but also to an abortion.
- 24:30Speaker 2: And you right that Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the attorney Ruth
- 24:34Speaker 2: Bader Ginsburg, would have chosen a different legal theory.
- 24:39Speaker 6: That's right, in part because I think Justice Ginsberg knew
- 24:43Speaker 6: that a decision like Dobbs could come down, and I
- 24:47Speaker 6: think her feeling was instead of locating the right to
- 24:50Speaker 6: obtain an abortion in the due process clause of the
- 24:54Speaker 6: fourteenth Amendment, instead of saying it's an unwritten right that's
- 24:58Speaker 6: included in the word liberty, let's instead look to a
- 25:01Speaker 6: different part of the fourteenth Amendment. Let's list to the
- 25:04Speaker 6: equal Protection clause, and let's look at how abortions obviously
- 25:10Speaker 6: and the right to obtain an abortion disproportionately falls along
- 25:15Speaker 6: gender lines. It is women and now trans men who
- 25:20Speaker 6: can obtain abortions, And what she thought is that it's
- 25:25Speaker 6: much cleaner to look at this as an equal protection
- 25:28Speaker 6: clause analysis. Obviously, if you limit abortions, that is something
- 25:33Speaker 6: that will have an impact on women in a very
- 25:36Speaker 6: different way than it will impact men. And I think
- 25:39Speaker 6: she was worried about writing rights into the Constitution that
- 25:44Speaker 6: weren't written and therefore could potentially be overturned by a
- 25:49Speaker 6: future court.
- 25:50Speaker 2: Is that why she was a critic of Roe.
- 25:53Speaker 6: I think that Jessice Ginsberg was a critic of Roe
- 25:56Speaker 6: in part because she thought that this was cleaner and
- 26:00Speaker 6: more legally elegant not to ever put words in her
- 26:04Speaker 6: mouth as an equal protection cause analysis saying this is
- 26:07Speaker 6: really amounts to gender discrimination when you limit or ban abortions.
- 26:11Speaker 6: I think part of it was that Justice Ginsberg was
- 26:15Speaker 6: somebody who, when she looked at women's rights, understood that
- 26:18Speaker 6: we needed to move incrementally. And I think some of
- 26:22Speaker 6: her writing and some of her speeches indicate that she
- 26:25Speaker 6: thought maybe we needed to move more slowly when it
- 26:29Speaker 6: comes to finding a constitutional right to obtain an abortion.
- 26:32Speaker 6: Not because she personally didn't believe in that or didn't
- 26:36Speaker 6: believe that it was legally correct, but that she worried
- 26:39Speaker 6: about the court and a gap between the court and
- 26:42Speaker 6: public opinion.
- 26:44Speaker 2: And now we have the Pennsylvania Supreme Court tell us
- 26:48Speaker 2: about the decision on the state law banning the use
- 26:52Speaker 2: of medicaid funds for abortions.
- 26:55Speaker 6: So this is a case that's fascinating where we see
- 26:59Speaker 6: now the question largely about abortion rights is going back
- 27:04Speaker 6: to states, and in this case, the state Supreme Court.
- 27:07Speaker 6: And this is a state Supreme Court that isn't looking
- 27:11Speaker 6: directly at that state's equal protection clause, but is instead
- 27:15Speaker 6: looking at that state's equal rights amendments. Now, I think
- 27:19Speaker 6: that's worth noting, but it's also worth noting that the court,
- 27:23Speaker 6: in my view, kind of got very close to talking
- 27:27Speaker 6: directly about that state constitution in the equal protection clause.
- 27:32Speaker 6: But essentially, I read that State Supreme Court decision as saying,
- 27:38Speaker 6: when we look at restrictions on abortions in this case,
- 27:42Speaker 6: you cannot use government funds to obtain an abortion, we
- 27:46Speaker 6: have to acknowledge that the impact is falling on gender lines.
- 27:51Speaker 6: The court also acknowledge that you are treating certain women
- 27:55Speaker 6: women who want to end a pregnancy as different from
- 27:59Speaker 6: those who want to care continue a pregnancy, where the
- 28:01Speaker 6: women who want an end of pregnancy get no funding
- 28:05Speaker 6: from the government, but those who want to continue and
- 28:07Speaker 6: carry a child to term do get funding from the government.
- 28:11Speaker 6: So they saw different places where the government is treating
- 28:17Speaker 6: arguably similarly situated people differently, and that is what gives
- 28:21Speaker 6: rise to this the quality question.
- 28:24Speaker 2: And you think it's a much cleaner argument, Well, I think.
- 28:28Speaker 6: The argument when it comes to substance who due process
- 28:32Speaker 6: on the federal level is obviously done for now. The
- 28:35Speaker 6: Supreme Court said indabbs in no uncertain terms that there
- 28:41Speaker 6: is no constitutionally protected rights to an abortion under the
- 28:44Speaker 6: federal constitution. Now, there are some states that could look
- 28:48Speaker 6: at their states to process clauses and decide that abortion
- 28:54Speaker 6: is protected. But I think the equality argument does have
- 28:59Speaker 6: a lot of a peace you'll legally speaking, now there's
- 29:01Speaker 6: still questions that you need to look at. You still
- 29:04Speaker 6: need to look at how different state if and when
- 29:07Speaker 6: they have equal rights amendments the specific wording. You still
- 29:11Speaker 6: have to look at the equal protection clause state by
- 29:14Speaker 6: state in those states constitutions and figure out if in fact,
- 29:19Speaker 6: we're going to say a restriction on abortion amount to
- 29:24Speaker 6: gender based discrimination. So it's not that we're absolutely there,
- 29:29Speaker 6: it's that there's a new framework that at least the
- 29:32Speaker 6: Pennsylvania Supreme Court is looking at. And then I think
- 29:36Speaker 6: offers hope for those who do want legal protections for
- 29:40Speaker 6: women in their ability to obtain abortions.
- 29:43Speaker 2: This could work in some of the states. Could it
- 29:46Speaker 2: work federally as well?
- 29:48Speaker 6: So I believe it could work federally if we want
- 29:51Speaker 6: to change our paradigm. And again, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court
- 29:54Speaker 6: looking at the state Equal Rights Amendment, But if we
- 29:56Speaker 6: want to make this conversation broader, and if we want
- 29:59Speaker 6: to look at restrictions on abortions as discrimination based on gender,
- 30:05Speaker 6: then that is a conversation that we can have under
- 30:08Speaker 6: the Equal Rights Amendment. Now, it would take the Supreme
- 30:11Speaker 6: Court using a different strategy and espousing a different task
- 30:16Speaker 6: than it otherwise has. This is not a theory that
- 30:20Speaker 6: the Supreme Court has ever previously espoused. But I think
- 30:24Speaker 6: that you could say, again, because the vast majority of
- 30:28Speaker 6: people who speak an abortion are women. There are some transmen,
- 30:33Speaker 6: but we're talking about disparate impact here. Then if you're
- 30:37Speaker 6: looking at the Court's current jurisprudence. What you need to
- 30:41Speaker 6: ask is about discriminatory intent. That's a difficult threshold, But
- 30:46Speaker 6: I think that this is a legal framework that could
- 30:49Speaker 6: be employed on the federal level.
- 30:52Speaker 2: How would that work on the ground. You'd have to
- 30:53Speaker 2: have a case where someone challenges an abortion restriction based
- 30:59Speaker 2: on the equal protection.
- 31:01Speaker 6: Argument exactly, and then that case has to move up
- 31:06Speaker 6: the system. The Supreme Court has to decide to take
- 31:09Speaker 6: that case, which I frankly think is not likely. The
- 31:13Speaker 6: Supreme Court in Dobbs already said basically, now we're done,
- 31:17Speaker 6: We're not deciding more abortion cases, and of course that
- 31:20Speaker 6: is not true at all. The Court is looking at
- 31:24Speaker 6: midf for Priston, but they're also looking at a case
- 31:26Speaker 6: dealing with whether or not there's a federal statute that
- 31:29Speaker 6: requires people to obtain be able to obtain free emergency
- 31:34Speaker 6: treatment in emergency rooms, whether or not that applies to
- 31:37Speaker 6: women seeking abortions. So they're certainly not out of this question.
- 31:41Speaker 2: The Pennsylvania Supreme Court also attacked Justice Alito's reasoning in
- 31:46Speaker 2: the Dobbs decision.
- 31:48Speaker 6: Yes, what we saw from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court was
- 31:51Speaker 6: a strong rebuke of the US Supreme Court's majority opinion
- 31:57Speaker 6: in Dobbs, and what they really reminded us of, and
- 32:03Speaker 6: this was specifically in a concurrence as well, is that
- 32:06Speaker 6: when you're looking at history, there are often different lenses
- 32:10Speaker 6: through which you can look at history. And part of
- 32:13Speaker 6: the problem I think in grounding constitutional rights based on
- 32:18Speaker 6: the time that either the Constitution was ratified or an
- 32:22Speaker 6: amendment was ratified, is that that was often a time
- 32:26Speaker 6: in society where we had gross inequality. So looking at,
- 32:32Speaker 6: for instance, the fourteenth Amendment and when that was added
- 32:35Speaker 6: to the Constitution and asking at that moment whether or
- 32:40Speaker 6: not abortions were legal, I think is problematic because it
- 32:46Speaker 6: has the effect of kind entrenching inequality. It has the
- 32:51Speaker 6: effect of saying, let's locate this right at a time
- 32:54Speaker 6: when women, frankly were second class citizens, women couldn't vote.
- 32:59Speaker 6: I believe at the time spousal rape laws were rare,
- 33:04Speaker 6: or at the very least not the majority. I think
- 33:07Speaker 6: the answer is quite rare. But women were not full
- 33:10Speaker 6: participants in society, And so there's a problem when you
- 33:14Speaker 6: locate rights at a time when our society looked very different.
- 33:18Speaker 2: How do we get to this point where constitutional interpretation
- 33:22Speaker 2: means relying on tradition and history, going back to a
- 33:26Speaker 2: time when society was so different. I mean, look at
- 33:28Speaker 2: the Second Amendment cases where they're comparing modern weapons to weapons,
- 33:33Speaker 2: you know, back in the eighteen hundreds.
- 33:35Speaker 6: Well, I think people who are originalists or constructionists, what
- 33:39Speaker 6: they would say is I'm a judge, not a lawmaker,
- 33:43Speaker 6: and I'm interpreting what provisions of the Constitution mean, and
- 33:48Speaker 6: it's not up to me to say what I think
- 33:51Speaker 6: is wise or unwise. I don't make policy. I just
- 33:55Speaker 6: apply the facts of cases to existing laws, and I
- 33:59Speaker 6: helped to inter for those laws. And I think proponents
- 34:03Speaker 6: of originalism would say it's the only way to make
- 34:06Speaker 6: sure that we don't have judicial activism, that we just
- 34:10Speaker 6: need to look at the time that the Second Amendment
- 34:13Speaker 6: was ratified or the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified and figure
- 34:16Speaker 6: out what was allowed and or prohibited at that time. Now,
- 34:23Speaker 6: obviously those who are proponents of originalism, I'm sure would
- 34:26Speaker 6: say much more than I just said, But it is
- 34:30Speaker 6: certainly a judicial philosophy that I think has now been
- 34:34Speaker 6: espoused by a majority of the Supreme Court. And again,
- 34:37Speaker 6: what people what supporters would say is I'm not somebody
- 34:40Speaker 6: who's elected. I'm the furthest away as a judge from
- 34:44Speaker 6: we the people, and so I shouldn't be acting as
- 34:47Speaker 6: a super legislator. I should be acting as somebody in chief,
- 34:52Speaker 6: Justice Roberts Words, who just calls balls and strikes. And
- 34:55Speaker 6: the only way I can do that is just looking
- 34:57Speaker 6: at the plain language of these when they were adopted.
- 35:02Speaker 2: I remember when the late Justice Antonin Scalia and Justice
- 35:06Speaker 2: Stephen Breyer used to debate Originalism versus the living Constitution,
- 35:12Speaker 2: and it appears the living Constitution has lost. Thanks so much, Jessica.
- 35:16Speaker 2: That's Professor Jessica Levinson of Loyola Law School. And that's
- 35:20Speaker 2: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm
- 35:23Speaker 2: June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. And that's it
- 35:26Speaker 2: for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you
- 35:29Speaker 2: can always get the latest legal news by subscribing and
- 35:32Speaker 2: listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 35:36Speaker 2: Bloomberg dot com, Slash podcast, Slash Law. I'm June Grosso,
- 35:40Speaker 2: and this is Bloomberg