Latest / The Vegan Report / Money Saves Animals. With Liz Wheeler & Alice Müller Coleman | Ep. 87
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan
- 0:02and today an exclusive window into a high stakes
- 0:06world at the heart of the animal rights movement.
- 0:09Hear from the fundraisers, driving the dollars
- 0:13that fuel the fight for animals. Those conversations
- 0:17are very common among professional animal advocates,
- 0:21yet always behind closed doors. That is, until
- 0:25now. To discuss this topic, I have with me Alice
- 0:29Mueller -Coleman, Development Manager for Balanced,
- 0:33and Liz Wheeler, Philanthropy Managers for Philanlytics.
- 0:37Among other things, we talked about the dangers
- 0:40of toxic work environments. What power do funders
- 0:45hold over animal organizations? And why are sanctuaries
- 0:50the ugly duckling of fundraising? Balance and
- 0:54Phoneletics are two amazing organizations that
- 0:57deserve your support. Visit the episode notes
- 1:01to connect with them. Lastly, don't forget to
- 1:05show some love for this podcast. Follow the show,
- 1:08share this episode, leave a five -star review.
- 1:12Every gesture of support counts. Thank you. Liz,
- 1:18Alice, welcome to the show. Thank you so much
- 1:21for being here. Um, I guess to get us started,
- 1:26uh, an icebreaker question, maybe, uh, one of
- 1:31my favorite question to ask is who is your vegan
- 1:34hero and why? Alice, do you have somebody on
- 1:37the top of your head? No, and I'm embarrassed
- 1:40to say it. I do. So I'll go. So, I mean, for
- 1:48some folks who know me, I'm Canadian. I don't
- 1:52say A that much, so hopefully it won't catch
- 1:54me up in the podcast, but it might start coming
- 1:57out a little twangy. My vegan hero is Camille
- 2:01Labchuk. So she's the executive director of an
- 2:04organization called Animal Justice here in Canada.
- 2:06and a huge reason why I went vegan. My journey
- 2:12in veganism, I was vegetarian for like 12 years.
- 2:15And it really wasn't until I started listening
- 2:17to the Animal Justice podcast that she was hosting,
- 2:20where I started to learn more about the inherent
- 2:24cruelty of the systems of dairy and eggs. And
- 2:28so yeah, she she's definitely one of the driving
- 2:31forces behind the trajectory of my life now.
- 2:36Wonderful. That is so beautiful. Fellow Canadian.
- 2:39I love that. My husband's actually in Vancouver
- 2:43right now, so he's there championing your team
- 2:46as well. I can't choose one person. I think when
- 2:51you've worked in this field long enough, I know
- 2:54thousands of really wonderful humans, some more
- 2:59than others, and I feel like I love so many people
- 3:04in different ways. I, you know, on top of mine,
- 3:07I'm thinking like, Chef Tara Panzone from Pura
- 3:10Vida. She's like bringing her culinary experience
- 3:13and making her grandma's dishes yet veganized.
- 3:17And I'm thinking about Matcha, who sells like
- 3:21French pastries at the farmers markets. And I'm
- 3:24thinking of Jean Bauer. And I'm thinking of our
- 3:26executive director, Audrey Lawson Sanchez. And
- 3:28I can't choose one. I just can't. It's also a
- 3:35good answer. So both of you are fundraising for
- 3:39different organizations. I would love if you
- 3:42could tell us a bit more about analytics and
- 3:46also balance. Yeah, I mean, so Faunalytics, I'm
- 3:50new -ish to the team. I've been with them for
- 3:52about three and a half years, which I consider
- 3:55new for like the 25 -year history that the organization
- 3:58has. We're an organization that conducts and
- 4:01shares research and data for animal advocates.
- 4:04So we have three key programs. One is our original
- 4:07research. So we will conduct studies, meta -analysis.
- 4:13and reports that help fill gaps in animal advocates'
- 4:17knowledge. It can be anything from what is effective
- 4:21tactics and messaging to more niche areas. We
- 4:25did a study with, mentioning Gene Bauer -Alice,
- 4:28we did a study with Farm Sanctuary in 2021 that
- 4:31looked at a sanctuary tours effectiveness. We
- 4:35also have a research library. So there are over
- 4:396 ,000 research study summaries, infographics,
- 4:43blog posts, and that's all free access for anybody
- 4:47who wants to go online and is looking for any
- 4:49kind of information. You can sort it by region.
- 4:52You can sort it by keywords. You can actually
- 4:54sort by species if you want, by tag. So if you're
- 4:57looking for fundraising, there's a bunch of fundraising
- 4:59articles on there too. And then third is our
- 5:02research support program. So that's where we
- 5:04help advocates actually take that research that
- 5:07they've just learned and how to actually put
- 5:09it into practice. So any individual advocates
- 5:12or organizations can come to us and and ask questions
- 5:15about how to apply that researcher data and or
- 5:17also like how to conduct a really effective survey.
- 5:20We do that too. So that's about Phonilytics.
- 5:23Wonderful. And I recently covered one of your
- 5:27study with one of your affiliated researcher
- 5:31Bjorn are protest helping animals or hurting
- 5:35them, something like that. So go check this episode.
- 5:38It's truly interesting. What about you, Alice?
- 5:42Yeah, so I'm the development manager over at
- 5:45Balanced and Balanced was started in 2017 by
- 5:50Audrey Lawson Sanchez, as I mentioned before.
- 5:52She's a mother and former educator, and she recognized
- 5:55that something needed to be done about school
- 5:57food. And so we are a public health and nutrition
- 6:01security advocacy organization that works on
- 6:05institutional diet change, primarily in K through
- 6:0812 schools. One thing I didn't know is 75 % of
- 6:12all K through 12 schools are self -op, so there's
- 6:16a need for a lot of hands -on support. And so
- 6:18we do that in our various programmatic areas.
- 6:22One is community -led advocacy. providing resources
- 6:27and assistance to the community members that
- 6:29want to see change where they eat. Second is
- 6:32institutional support. They're the ones that
- 6:35are really working side by side with the food
- 6:38service teams and doing a lot of exciting things
- 6:41through our plant -based cohort, which is a six
- 6:44month program, really getting into the nitty
- 6:46gritty. And then we have a nutrition research
- 6:49and policy team as well. So our Our team is working
- 6:55on a data analysis project right now, which is
- 6:58looking to find the fiber content of school meals.
- 7:03That's also great work. Please connect with Pheneletics
- 7:07Unbalanced. Link in the episode notes. Okay.
- 7:13Fundraising. I feel like this is one of the topics
- 7:18that goes really like under the radar of most
- 7:23people, like they don't think about fundraising,
- 7:26they don't think about the fundraisers. We're
- 7:28like this, you know, truly part of the behind
- 7:33the scenes team. So let me start with this. How
- 7:37did you become a fundraiser? How did you fall
- 7:41into this, this job? Maybe you Liz? Gosh, yeah.
- 7:46Okay, I'm very, very lucky. I started my career
- 7:50with animals about 15 years ago, I started working.
- 7:54Well, I was volunteering actually at my local
- 7:56Humane Society. And through volunteering there,
- 7:59I was able to get a job in their foster department,
- 8:04which is actually like more animal care. It's
- 8:06working with the animals doing things like subcu
- 8:08fluids and vaccines and very hands on. But To
- 8:13my luck, the Humane Society is actually a unionized
- 8:16environment and it was a contract position. So
- 8:18in order to stay in with the organization, I
- 8:21had to apply for whatever jobs would come up
- 8:23and there was one in the development department.
- 8:26So I got really, really lucky in that way that
- 8:30things just kind of aligned. And so I took a
- 8:33job in the development department. department
- 8:34just entering donations because I inevitably
- 8:37wanted to go back to the foster department, but
- 8:39then I ended up falling in love with the fundraising.
- 8:42So started there and then started working at
- 8:45an organization formerly known as the Canadian
- 8:48Federation of Humane Societies, now known as
- 8:51Humane Canada, and then eventually made my way
- 8:54to Phonolitics today. But yeah, I've been working
- 8:56on fundraising for like 10 years. It just feels
- 8:58like what I've done my whole life. I know 10
- 9:01years is like nothing in comparison to a lot
- 9:03of seasoned fundraisers. But yeah, unfortunately,
- 9:07my journey is not very exciting. I kind of had
- 9:09it easy because I just got a job with the Humane
- 9:11Society. And then they were like, do you want
- 9:13to enter in donations? And I was like, yeah.
- 9:15But that's an interesting reaction to fundraising,
- 9:18because when I talk about fundraising to people,
- 9:22I see, you know, in their eyes, fear, I see boredom,
- 9:26I see, you know, a mix of emotions that you know,
- 9:31fall far away from the spectrum of falling in
- 9:34love. So I guess quick follow up question, what
- 9:39made you fall in love? I think it's just like
- 9:43the idea that I could do one of the things that
- 9:46I'm most passionate about, which is really like,
- 9:48at the end of the day, I see fundraising is connecting
- 9:50people who love animals with animals. And so
- 9:54that can come in. Like such a variety of different
- 9:57ways when you're fundraising and it's definitely
- 9:59not a boring job. I think once people like get
- 10:02into the day to day of it, people from my experience
- 10:05are like wary of it because of the whole idea
- 10:07of having to ask for money but I think a lot
- 10:11of fundraisers who get into it realize it's really
- 10:13not about that. It's about building relationships.
- 10:15And I'm a very social person. I'd love to connect
- 10:18with people. I'm also very nosy. So I just like
- 10:20to know more about people and like what they
- 10:22have going on and like what their hobbies and
- 10:24interests are. So it's a really good mix for
- 10:28my personality type. Yeah, I hope that answered
- 10:32it. Those are indeed fitting qualities for the
- 10:36fundraising profession. Okay, Alice, what about
- 10:40you? What was your journey into fundraising?
- 10:44Totally, I was thinking about it before the call
- 10:46a little bit. And I just kind of had a flashback
- 10:49of being a kid and doing door to door lemonade
- 10:54sales. I wasn't even going to like have a table.
- 10:56I just went door to door. And then I started
- 10:59a little dog -walking business when I was 12.
- 11:02And I remember I came home from my freshman year
- 11:05of college and my dad said, you need to get a
- 11:08job. So I went on Craigslist and called Greenpeace,
- 11:13got an interview for the next day, and I started
- 11:15canvassing on and off for multiple years. And
- 11:18so my start was asking people for their credit
- 11:22card information on the sidewalk. And, you know,
- 11:25if you can do that, you can kind of do anything.
- 11:27It's perfect for college kids. I feel like it
- 11:29really gets you out of your comfort zone, and
- 11:32you have to navigate a lot of real -time responses.
- 11:35And then the way that I've found myself into
- 11:37the animal rights space is I started as Milo
- 11:43Runkle's executive assistant at Mercy for Animals.
- 11:47I remember I participated in putting together
- 11:51the staff retreats and each department would
- 11:54put on a little skit. And the fundraising team
- 11:57just had the best skit. And it's so silly, but
- 12:00I was just like seeing them up there and they
- 12:02were all fun and personable. They were relationship
- 12:06builders. They're still some of my good friends
- 12:09today. And I think when you think of it from
- 12:13a relationship perspective, like you were saying,
- 12:16Liz, I mean, you're building relationships and
- 12:19hyping up other people. It's pretty great. You
- 12:23know, it's a harder thing to do to sell yourself.
- 12:25You're selling people who are doing great things
- 12:26and you believe in what their work is. Like,
- 12:29I don't know, I feel very lucky to have landed
- 12:32in and feel very lucky to have landed at Balanced
- 12:35in particular. What a rough start. Like this
- 12:39is one of the worst jobs out there having to
- 12:43ask people for money, like in the streets. Did
- 12:49you have any coping mechanism? What was the feeling
- 12:52like at the end of the day? Did you need a drink?
- 12:56I mean, I was 18, so sheer ignorance, I think.
- 13:01I was just like, oh, this is what it means to
- 13:02work. You know? And the people were fun, too.
- 13:08I mean, you're just like, you care about polar
- 13:09bears, right? And then you talk about... chimpanzees
- 13:12or orangutans or the rainforest and get silly
- 13:15with it. So yeah, it was a, there was a lot of
- 13:18weirdness and it was a really good experience.
- 13:24Okay. So fundraising is all about, you know,
- 13:30like Liz said, creating, building those relationships
- 13:33and strengthening them. So how do you convince
- 13:39someone? of making a donation. How people come
- 13:45to make a donation to a cause. What's that psychology
- 13:51that, you know, brings us to express generosity?
- 13:55Alice, do you want to go first? I mean, I think
- 13:58it's like, you know, we all have this vision
- 14:00of the type of world we want to live in. And
- 14:04there are going to be things that Me like matter
- 14:09more to me or you Ryan or you Liz or to the random
- 14:12person down the street and It you know, we all
- 14:16have that vision, right? so whether it is a world
- 14:19where animals are treated with kindness and compassion
- 14:21or People want to make sure that people don't
- 14:26go hungry or they want to combat climate change,
- 14:31or any sort of these avenues. There are things
- 14:34that people believe in, and it's an investment
- 14:36in the future that you want to see, or direct
- 14:39response to things that are happening that have
- 14:41a shorter life cycle in many ways. And so I think
- 14:44it's just the psychology is you're investing
- 14:48in the world that you want to live in. Yeah,
- 14:50I love that. I would echo everything that Alice
- 14:53just said. I think the approach that I tried
- 14:55to take to it is not seeing it as like asking
- 14:59something of somebody, but providing them an
- 15:02opportunity to fulfill what they want to do already.
- 15:05So we know people are very, very charitable,
- 15:07but a lot of the times when people make a donation
- 15:10to our organization, they already are involved
- 15:13in the space. They're already animal advocates,
- 15:15maybe they've used our services in the past,
- 15:17or they know somebody who's benefited from them.
- 15:20And so our job is less about convincing people
- 15:23to donate, like they've already made up their
- 15:24mind, they're going to donate somewhere, they
- 15:26want to support our movement, they want to see
- 15:28it progress. So it's just trying to communicate
- 15:32with them how we can help them achieve their
- 15:34mission and figure out if we're a good fit for
- 15:35them. I know it can take years to like get somebody
- 15:40to commit to a gift, but that doesn't mean that
- 15:42they're not interested. It just means that you
- 15:44haven't figured out the psychology around like
- 15:48what, what is their motivation for giving? Like
- 15:50what legacy do they want to give? Even if it's
- 15:53like a $5 monthly donation to me, like when I'm
- 15:55donating to organizations, it's because I want
- 15:58to see like progress in my lifetime. I want to
- 16:01see animal cruelty. like slow down, I would love
- 16:03to see it end. But you know, that's rose colored
- 16:07glasses on but I always just try and treat it
- 16:10like we can help people achieve what they want.
- 16:13I'm asking this because it feels more and more
- 16:17aliens to alien to our societies. you know, to
- 16:23make a donation without expecting anything in
- 16:26return. Everything is so transactional nowadays.
- 16:30You always expect something in return. So witnessing
- 16:34people just donating for the sake of donating
- 16:38is an intriguing behavior. Yeah, so I was really
- 16:47lucky. I got to go to the Association of Fundraising
- 16:50Professionals conference earlier in the year
- 16:52and it was really eye -opening. I mean, we know
- 16:55that the animal protection space, I'm just going
- 16:58to reference it as animal protection, animal
- 17:00welfare rights protection all under the same
- 17:02umbrella. But like the farmed animal protection
- 17:05movement specifically is so like we are dealing
- 17:09with a very small pot of money compared to like
- 17:13charitable giving. There is billions upon hundreds
- 17:16of billions of dollars in charitable giving.
- 17:19Farmed animal production gets about like 200
- 17:21to 250 million of that. So we're already dealing
- 17:24with like such a small piece of the pie, but
- 17:26we're also lucky in that sense that people who
- 17:29are in our movement are so dedicated, are so
- 17:32passionate about believing in this cause, that
- 17:35it's really just about figuring out like what
- 17:37their motivation is. And I bring this back to
- 17:39AFP is because i was one of the only people there
- 17:42from like an animal protection organization i
- 17:45think there were like 10 of us in a sea of 3000
- 17:47attendees um but there was one presentation um
- 17:52by uh I can't remember the person's name from
- 17:55giving Tuesday and they were talking about donors
- 17:57motivation. It was like they either donate because
- 18:00of like affinity. So they're connected to the
- 18:02organization. They have a history of philanthropy.
- 18:05So it's like what they're known their families
- 18:08known to do what is expected of them or they
- 18:11have connections. So they have somebody who's
- 18:13benefited from what you do. That's more like
- 18:15applicable in like hospital settings, for example,
- 18:18or capacity. They've won the lottery. They have
- 18:22sold a business and they have this ability to
- 18:24give generously so they do it because they can.
- 18:28So for us, we try and figure out which of those
- 18:31they kind of fall into because then you can steward
- 18:34them and kind of guide them and talk to them
- 18:38based on what their motivation is. So I found
- 18:41that that's been incredibly helpful. But yeah,
- 18:43for any fundraisers who are listening to this,
- 18:44AFP is incredible. And like there is just so
- 18:48much information and there's a lot of data driven
- 18:50information. Bing, Bing, Bing politics. I'm very
- 18:55data driven. So I like to know like, okay, where
- 18:57are the numbers? What what's showing this? Yeah,
- 19:00I was really lucky a number of years ago, I think
- 19:02it was my first year working in development.
- 19:05My entire team went to AFP in New Orleans. And
- 19:08that was like such a great team building experience
- 19:10as well as an opportunity just to like hone skills,
- 19:14especially as a newer fundraiser back at that
- 19:16time. Yeah, I love AFP. I've been a member for
- 19:20years, but I never went to their conferences.
- 19:26Okay, so who is that donor? Can you draw a profile
- 19:30of the typical donor to the animal cause? Do
- 19:36we have more female donors or male donors? What's
- 19:40the age range? Is there something about their
- 19:45personality that makes them more inclined to
- 19:47give to the animal cause? Think so. I feel like
- 19:52Liz is gonna have the data handled no pressure
- 19:55Liz but in from like a more emotional stance
- 19:59on it like I feel like There is a huge range
- 20:04you have your effective altruists that want to
- 20:06rely on the data and they want to see the number
- 20:07of lives that are impacted and they are more
- 20:10motivated by the hard figures and then you have
- 20:13the individuals that want to save the life that
- 20:17is in front of them. Those are perhaps people
- 20:19who want to fund sanctuaries, who want to, you
- 20:22know, foster and adopt animals, focus on TNR
- 20:25programs or things that are more maybe companion
- 20:27animal or sanctuary related. And then in terms
- 20:31of like our donors, I feel like a lot of them
- 20:35fall, especially now as we have grown our institutional
- 20:38support program, where they want to see the number
- 20:41of meals impacted. We talk a lot about fiber.
- 20:47Our whole thing is focused on fiber. And how
- 20:50do you get more fiber on plates? It's plants.
- 20:53You need plants for fiber. It's the only thing
- 20:56that has it. And 97 % of Americans are deficient
- 21:00in it. Our donors are typically those that care
- 21:05about the number of meals impacted, also wanting
- 21:09to see kids having access to healthier options.
- 21:14And that might be different than those that fund
- 21:16other organizations. And that's why I think it's
- 21:19so wonderful that there are so many different
- 21:21organizations that cover the spectrum and we
- 21:24really need all of them. And what's great is
- 21:28behind the scenes, a lot of us are working together.
- 21:31That's so interesting. Let me raise this point.
- 21:38Many times, strategically speaking, you can inspire
- 21:42donations by addressing connected issues to your
- 21:49cause. So you mentioned children. That is a way
- 21:53in for donors who might not care about animals,
- 21:57but might care about children and children nutrition.
- 22:03Um, do you feel like this is, um, a good way
- 22:09of approaching, you know, donors? Because I've
- 22:12had this conversation with one sanctuary owner
- 22:15and vegan activists who told me, um, I'm all
- 22:20about veganism. I'm all about the cause. I want,
- 22:23you know, uh, talk about connected issues, although
- 22:27I could. because I feel this betrays the, you
- 22:32know, core values of my organization. What do
- 22:36you make of that? Oh, gosh. Okay, I have so much
- 22:39to say about this question. So while Alice was
- 22:43talking, I did pull up so there is a study that
- 22:48well, it's a follow up study. So we have a reference,
- 22:51I'll give it to you. It's called people who support
- 22:53animal causes and who gives more. So we did look
- 22:56at charity donor behavior. This is from 2019,
- 23:01so take it with a grain of salt. We are now six
- 23:04years later. But yeah, as far as demographics
- 23:07go, people giving to animal causes as important
- 23:13or seeing animal causes as important are going
- 23:16to skew female, less religious, more liberal.
- 23:21do you tend to have these like everyday animal
- 23:24related behaviors so normally having a companion
- 23:27animal and then when you're looking at monetary
- 23:29donations specifically you're going to be looking
- 23:31at demographics of those who have a higher income
- 23:34their animal related behaviors they're probably
- 23:37going to follow a vegan diet especially when
- 23:39you're looking at farmed animal protection organizations
- 23:42they may have animal appreciation related hobbies
- 23:46they're We do have sections looking at donation
- 23:50methods as well. I'm not gonna go through the
- 23:52whole thing, but that's just kind of like a sneak
- 23:54peek. So yeah, we definitely have looked at this.
- 23:56As far as like what language to use, I will say,
- 24:02don't say vegans. It's the easiest and most accessible
- 24:06way. It doesn't mean that your mission is changing.
- 24:09It's just the language that you're using. If
- 24:12you fill out a grant application and you don't
- 24:14mention vegan, but at the end of the day, your
- 24:16work is pushing forward the shared mission of
- 24:19ending animal suffering, does it really matter
- 24:22if you use that language? No, because you're
- 24:24still achieving your mission. So I would just
- 24:26say, especially when you're looking at collaborating
- 24:29with other either social justice causes, trying
- 24:32to do cross cross sector funding with like education
- 24:37or environment. Yeah, just don't say vegan plant
- 24:41based. You don't even really say plant -based
- 24:47all that much, though our cohort is the plant
- 24:49-based cohort. We talk about fiber -rich, healthy,
- 24:55plant -forward, fiber -forward. we don't use
- 24:58the word vegan. And I don't think it dilutes
- 25:01your work at all, because at the end of the day,
- 25:04if you're alienating people by using specific
- 25:07language, and so they're not willing to meet
- 25:09you at the table or to like take on different
- 25:11behavioral issues or giving, then you're basically
- 25:20disservicing yourself and in turn the animals.
- 25:24I mean, there's Some are going to care about
- 25:27the environment. And if you have the ability
- 25:30and the metrics to frame it that way, you're
- 25:34being completely honest in the way that you're
- 25:36approaching it. And it just so happens to benefit
- 25:38animals. Liz, the study you referenced, I will
- 25:45add that to the episode links, please send the
- 25:48study my way. What about trends? Is the world
- 25:54getting more generous or less generous? Is the
- 25:59donation pot shrinking or increasing for the
- 26:06animal cause? Do you see any trends? I think
- 26:10that once more Liz is going to have the data.
- 26:14I think that from what I understand, individual
- 26:17giving is down and like, I mean, we all feel
- 26:20it with inflation and just like how far the dollar
- 26:24or whatever currency you use goes. And that is
- 26:29a real thing. That doesn't mean people aren't
- 26:31giving. I think we focus on the subscription
- 26:37model of recurring and monthly giving. We have
- 26:40become a subscription economy in many ways. So
- 26:42that is one avenue. I think our revenue is growing,
- 26:49but that is because we have shifted our focus.
- 26:53And, you know, we primarily work with our major
- 26:56funders and grants and the family foundations.
- 27:00Yeah. So, yep, I came prepared. I have the data.
- 27:04But before I jump into that, I do want to say
- 27:06for anybody listening who's a fundraiser with
- 27:10another organization, the struggle is real for
- 27:12all of us. We're all feeling hurt right now.
- 27:152025 is... benchmark year, but not in a good
- 27:19way. And it's not abnormal for us to be struggling.
- 27:24So there is community here for other fundraisers.
- 27:28I would be remiss not to give a shout out to
- 27:30the Hive fundraising community calls. They're
- 27:32a really great place to connect with other fundraisers.
- 27:36We have calls every month. Every other month,
- 27:39it's just a community led discussion where fundraisers
- 27:42get to bring up. problems that they're having.
- 27:44The calls aren't recorded, so it's a safe space
- 27:46to kind of bounce ideas off of one another. And
- 27:49then on the other months, we have experts come
- 27:52and talk to us and do Q &As. We had Megan from
- 27:55Greenbaum Foundation, and she did a great presentation
- 27:57on doing pitches to funders. So definitely check
- 28:01that out. But yeah, as far as the numbers go,
- 28:04yeah, we're seeing a decline in donations. Part
- 28:09of it has to do with inflation. it's really hard
- 28:14to find data specifically to animal protection
- 28:17and even harder for farm animal protection. We
- 28:21usually reference the GivingUSA annual report.
- 28:25So the most recent data that I have access to
- 28:28is from 2023. I do know that they just released
- 28:30their 2024 report, but we haven't gotten our
- 28:33fingers on that yet. But as far as like 2023,
- 28:37there was a decline in money towards animals
- 28:40in the environment. We're kind of lumped together.
- 28:42by 8 .9%. So there is a decline, we know that.
- 28:46But of that 3 % of the giving pot, only 1 % really
- 28:50goes towards animals. So it's hard to know how
- 28:53much of that eight per night. 8 .9 % is attributed
- 28:56to environment versus animals. It's nearly impossible
- 28:59to say. Stray Dog Institute did conduct a renewed
- 29:04state of the sector report that was just published,
- 29:08which I'm really excited about. I think it shows
- 29:11that there's between 200 and 250 million in funding.
- 29:16So the 2021 report was 200 million, so it really
- 29:19hasn't increased that much, which is not great.
- 29:24But compared to the giving sector in total, there
- 29:30was a 3 .4 % decline compared to 2021. So that's
- 29:37a loss of quite a few billions. So yeah, we're
- 29:42all struggling. If your fundraising is struggling,
- 29:51then your entire organization and its impact,
- 29:54its reach will be reduced. That's the hard reality.
- 30:00And that also highlights the importance of fundraising,
- 30:04of the work we're doing. OK, so I guess this
- 30:09ties well with my next question, which is how
- 30:13much power do we have as fundraisers in the organization?
- 30:18more than that, how much power do funders have
- 30:23over organizations? Alice? Yeah, that's a really
- 30:28good question. I mean, I think every organization
- 30:31will have a different answer on this because
- 30:33I know like when it comes to balance, like We
- 30:36do not change our strategy based on a funding
- 30:40opportunity. We really have our vision for a
- 30:44reason. And we are very nimble as a smaller organization
- 30:47when things do change. For example, the administration.
- 30:52And we realized that it wasn't going to be impactful
- 30:56to continue doubling down on our USDA component
- 30:59of our focus on fiber initiative. So we changed
- 31:03our strategy. That wasn't thunder directed though.
- 31:07And while we will of course take feedback, we
- 31:11won't change our strategy based on. what they
- 31:15say. As for working within the confines of the
- 31:18organization, I work really closely with our
- 31:21executive director. I mean, once more, we are
- 31:23a smaller organization, so I am the sole development
- 31:26person. And so I talk to her most days, whether
- 31:30it's just a Slack message or otherwise, but we
- 31:34work very closely and she keeps me very much
- 31:36in the loop because we can't do our jobs without
- 31:39each other and in turn the program's teams. Yeah,
- 31:43that's a sign of good health, organizational
- 31:46health. Liz? Yeah, I mean, I'll just ditto exactly
- 31:51what Alice said. I think I always see like my
- 31:55role as fundraising, like I'm one person in a
- 31:5812 person team. And yes, I'm the only one who
- 32:00has philanthropy in their title, but everyone
- 32:03in our organization is a fundraiser of sorts.
- 32:05They're going to hate me for saying this, so
- 32:07I apologize in advance. But they're representatives
- 32:10of our organization, and every conversation that
- 32:12they have with an advocate that helps them, that
- 32:15then can be used for our case for support of,
- 32:19oh, yes, we helped this organization. And so
- 32:21it really is like a team effort. And my role
- 32:25is only made easier by the incredible work that
- 32:28the rest of our team does. can say like without
- 32:32a doubt that we would be completely lost and
- 32:35like without the incredible team that we have
- 32:39like all of analytics success is because of every
- 32:42single person in our organization and our leadership
- 32:45is just spectacular. While it's like a one -person
- 32:49development team, Brooke who is our executive
- 32:52director is there alongside me every step of
- 32:55the way and we're just very very lucky. to have
- 33:00this strong team that we have. One thing that
- 33:04I'll also mention is we will create a fundraising
- 33:08plan every single year that changes based on
- 33:12what our previous year's revenue is. So this
- 33:15allows us to look at all of our tactics. Like,
- 33:19what are we doing with individual donors? What
- 33:21are we doing with grants? Maybe one year it was
- 33:24really, really fruitful for grants, but we always
- 33:26want to be diversifying our revenue stream. So
- 33:30just because one year we had a really great year
- 33:31with a bit grants doesn't mean that we're going
- 33:33to all of a sudden jump ship and ignore our individual
- 33:36donors. So kind of figuring out which areas are
- 33:42most promising, what are maybe new possibilities
- 33:44that we haven't looked into before. I remember
- 33:47the first time that I met Alice, I'm pretty sure
- 33:49I was asking her like, what do you do with your
- 33:51Bequest program? Because we don't really have
- 33:53one. So how can we grow this? So definitely also
- 33:56like leaning into your fellow fundraisers and
- 33:58figuring out what's going well for them and not
- 34:01being afraid to ask stupid questions. That's
- 34:04like the number one thing I've learned is just
- 34:07lean into your ignorance of what you don't know
- 34:10and always be willing to just learn new new things
- 34:13because you will that's I think how fundraising
- 34:16plans and how your development and your revenue
- 34:20can grow is by like constantly learning and constantly
- 34:23trying to like figure out that missing piece
- 34:27and the one way that I describe fundraising to
- 34:30a lot of like my friends and family I'm like
- 34:32just imagine me in like a full velcro suit and
- 34:35I'm just like throwing myself at the wall and
- 34:37like one arm is like has 12 velcro strips strips
- 34:42because I know all of the data but then this
- 34:44one I have no idea what I'm doing so we're just
- 34:45gonna see where I land um and it's a lot of trial
- 34:48and error um because of the lack of data in our
- 34:52area for fundraising. Yeah, I know that our organization
- 34:57has like a fail fast mentality and I love it
- 35:00because Like it allows us to try things and if
- 35:03it doesn't work. It's not like an issue You know,
- 35:08for example my first year at balance I worked
- 35:12on a wellness challenge that was a month -long
- 35:16challenge, and I wanted it to be really, really
- 35:18inclusive. So it was everything from make a plant
- 35:22-based meal, to take a walk, to swimming laps,
- 35:26so that everyone could do something. And it was
- 35:32a lot of work to bring in just a few thousand
- 35:34dollars and so like taking into consideration
- 35:37like how much work is it going to be could I
- 35:39be doing something else because if I can put
- 35:41in a grant application that is worth like you
- 35:43know five or six figures and be successful versus
- 35:47taking a whole month to raise three four five
- 35:50grand which one am I going to be going to do
- 35:53the next year because you know it's it's really
- 35:56working smarter. and hard, but not harder, and
- 36:00focusing on the lower hanging fruit. We didn't
- 36:04have a comms person. How are we going to have
- 36:07a strong individual giving team when we didn't
- 36:11have people who knew who we were? So now we do,
- 36:16and Chris is great, and we're very lucky. Oh
- 36:19my god, Alice, I love that you mentioned that
- 36:21because in my head I'm just thinking like, we
- 36:23did the exact, or I did the exact same thing
- 36:26when I first came into Faunalytics. I was like,
- 36:28hey, like, I was so ready, so amped, and I was
- 36:30like, we're gonna do this donor -centered event,
- 36:33we're gonna call it Data Days of Summer, it's
- 36:35gonna be like a fundraising online event, it's
- 36:37gonna be so great, it's gonna be a benefit. It
- 36:40sucked. Like, no offense to anybody who contributed
- 36:43to it, but it was just like... our donors don't
- 36:45want to be thanked that way. And it took me doing
- 36:49it to realize, okay, this is not the right strategy.
- 36:51And so now we have Fauna Connections, which is
- 36:54a research symposium, and that is so much more
- 36:56aligned with Faunalytics mission. And we don't
- 36:59need to be like thanking our donors, they come
- 37:01to it and they see the good work that we're doing.
- 37:03And that's how they get their appreciation. So
- 37:05I just absolutely love Alice that you shared,
- 37:08like failing fast, because yeah, totally did
- 37:10the exact same thing when I started. Oh, yeah.
- 37:13And just because you can put on an event doesn't
- 37:15mean you should. Yes. Yeah. Well, this is a great
- 37:21moment to talk about stress, the stress that
- 37:25this job brings. I don't know if you can relate,
- 37:30but I often think of myself as the only one in
- 37:34the organization who's actually bringing money
- 37:37in. And so I have to justify my salary. And I'm
- 37:43always thinking about how much of a good fundraiser
- 37:49I am in terms of how much of a good investment
- 37:53I am for my organization. So what do you make
- 37:59of that pressure to be productive, to bring that
- 38:03money, to keep your organization basically alive?
- 38:11I've been in that position before. Luckily, when
- 38:14I came to Faunalytics, I felt like I was just
- 38:16like walking into like Willy Wonka's Chocolate
- 38:18Factory. I was like, wait, you have all of these
- 38:20amazing things in place? Like what? They like,
- 38:23I was just like, this, this is amazing. I think
- 38:26it really starts with leadership honestly like
- 38:29I hate using this like term like culture of an
- 38:32organization because it's been misused and like
- 38:35put against employees so often it's like oh this
- 38:37is our culture blah blah blah but truly like
- 38:40I think if you have good leadership that's willing
- 38:43to um kind of like practice what they preach
- 38:47and like take their vacation time off and like
- 38:51set good boundaries and like allow sick days
- 38:53to be used for mental health. Like when I came
- 38:56into Faunalytics, it was like a no -brainer.
- 38:58It was like your sick days can be used for mental
- 39:00health if you want to just take like a self -care
- 39:02day with your sick day like that it is for you
- 39:05to use. And to me that was like that just took
- 39:08off so much pressure of like worrying like oh
- 39:10my gosh like if I'm sick if this like grant deadline
- 39:13comes up it's like very much a collaborative
- 39:15work environment and I think I would like push
- 39:18back a little and say like the onus is really
- 39:19on the organization to set up those things to
- 39:22ensure that employees can thrive. Employees have
- 39:27a responsibility to show up. work every day and
- 39:30to put their best foot forward and to do the
- 39:32best work that they can but that's only possible
- 39:34when there are structures in place that allow
- 39:36people to thrive and not feel like they are dying
- 39:39every time they come to work and let they're
- 39:41just like a number or a machine because we're
- 39:43not and we work in an area where arguably we
- 39:46are facing a lot of really like traumatizing
- 39:50content sometimes like I can't tell you how many
- 39:52times like I scroll through like graphic imagery
- 39:54of animals um and it's like just having a good
- 39:59organization and good leadership that's willing
- 40:01to back you up really makes a difference. So
- 40:03I would say like, from my conversations with
- 40:05other fundraisers, there are great organizations
- 40:07out there. So if you're being treated in a way
- 40:09that makes you feel like a machine, find another
- 40:11job because you will be appreciated. There are
- 40:15people that will appreciate you. Oh my God, a
- 40:18hundred percent. I am like so passionate about
- 40:23culture actually and about organizational health.
- 40:28Because, you know, echoing what you're saying,
- 40:30Liz, like if you do not have really kind, compassionate
- 40:35and effective leaders at the top who work, you
- 40:39know, work from like a place of once more compassion,
- 40:43like there doesn't need to be any ego. Audrey
- 40:46is the best leader. She is so highly competent.
- 40:50She could do so many of our jobs. And she trusts
- 40:54us so much. She gives us so much autonomy. She's
- 40:57there as a person to brainstorm solutions when
- 41:01needed. I mean, I live in LA. So fortunately,
- 41:07we weren't. as impacted as some but like we temporarily
- 41:10left our homes during the fires and during that
- 41:13time we had a huge grant deadline and Audrey
- 41:16really stepped in. It's like having a compassionate
- 41:19and effective leader is amazing and hiring the
- 41:22right people though that's like the second step.
- 41:26I mean Not to go off on too much of a tangent,
- 41:29but our hiring process, I've never been a part
- 41:32of an organization that does it quite this way.
- 41:34And so every time someone new comes on board,
- 41:37there's this infusion of really good energy.
- 41:41And I've started putting in our grant applications
- 41:44how we have 100 % retention. People don't leave.
- 41:48And I think that speaks volumes. And yes, if
- 41:52you're not being taken care of and treated as
- 41:54a human first, leave, find another place, because
- 41:59there are great organizations that have wonderful
- 42:02people at every level. And everyone who's doing
- 42:06this type of work deserves that. And I can't
- 42:09remember the original question, but I do really,
- 42:12really. It's a big issue for me to make sure
- 42:16that really good people are taken care of. Yeah,
- 42:20I also recall you saying something about, like,
- 42:22making sure that you're, like, getting that grant
- 42:24that, like, justifies, like, your worth. Yeah.
- 42:27I will mention Phonelytics has a study that looks
- 42:30at compensation in the farmed animal advocacy
- 42:33sector. So we surveyed... a bunch of organizations,
- 42:38the number 27 organizations I think, and we're
- 42:42able to pull salary groups across all participating
- 42:45organizations. So this is publicly available
- 42:47data. So if you want to be able to request a
- 42:51raise to make sure you're being fairly compensated,
- 42:54we have this information for you. And not you
- 42:56specifically. Anybody who's listening is what
- 42:58I'm trying to allude to. No, no. I think that's
- 43:01great. Because also, if people are being compensated
- 43:04and they have the appropriate benefits to have
- 43:08a work -life balance, then they stay. If people
- 43:10stay, they have all the institutional knowledge.
- 43:13If they have the institutional knowledge, they'll
- 43:15be able to do the work faster and better than
- 43:18bringing on someone new, not saying that there
- 43:20aren't any job seekers that really would do great,
- 43:22because I know a few of them. Yeah, take care
- 43:27of the people. And yeah, I feel very lucky because
- 43:31I don't feel like I'm in a position where I have
- 43:32to prove my worth. And I think that is indicative
- 43:34of the organization that I'm at, because it really
- 43:37is like a human first mentality. And also like,
- 43:42and this hasn't always been the case in places
- 43:45that I have worked, we have like such sustainable
- 43:49growth strategy and such like financial responsibility
- 43:54that if like, if we had a really bad fundraising
- 43:59year this year, no one's going to lose their
- 44:01jobs. And having that safety net because of leadership
- 44:04and our board, that means that I can sleep at
- 44:07night if there's like an emergency going on in
- 44:10my own life. Not to say that I want any more
- 44:14fires in Los Angeles. Come on people. Those are
- 44:19incredibly, um, great points to note and memorize.
- 44:27I would add, yes, it is important to get great
- 44:31compensation, but be careful. There are jobs
- 44:36with great salary offers, but the culture is
- 44:40not that good, and you really need to prioritize
- 44:45the culture versus the salary. you won't win
- 44:51with you know, just the salary. You only have
- 44:54one body and one mind. Yeah, you can always make
- 44:58more money later or from you know, another better
- 45:03offer elsewhere. But yeah, so be careful about
- 45:07the also, I'm such a better fundraiser, getting
- 45:13to like fundraise for an organization that I
- 45:15believe in where I truly am proud of all of my
- 45:18coworkers and what they do. I am so impressed
- 45:21by each and every one of them. And I can't do
- 45:25their jobs. They can't do my job. I can't do
- 45:26their job, truly. More so if they don't want
- 45:30to do my job. They could probably do it. But
- 45:35at the end of the day, if you are working for
- 45:40a mission that you believe in, and in an organization
- 45:42that does have healthy culture, fundraising is
- 45:46so much easier. Yeah. Okay, let me ask something
- 45:53else. This time related to impact. And I've been
- 46:00playing with this idea that often the focus in
- 46:05our movement is to convert people to a vegan
- 46:11lifestyle or a healthy fiber -rich lifestyle,
- 46:16whatever terms we use. But there are people who
- 46:21just won't do it for a number of reasons, many
- 46:27of them being valid reasons. If you're struggling
- 46:30with an eating disorder, I don't think you should
- 46:33be the target of people wanting you to become
- 46:37vegan. Um, in any case, so what about alternatives
- 46:43to advance the movement? And of course, for me,
- 46:48the answer to that is donations. Uh, if you cannot,
- 46:53uh, become vegan, um, you can still become a
- 46:58donor for the cause and you're going to still,
- 47:01you know, make a huge impact with your gift.
- 47:05What do you make of that idea? I think that's
- 47:08a really interesting idea. I feel like I've used
- 47:12it as an argument in a very different subject
- 47:16matter, where I've suggested to non -vegan business
- 47:20owners that they have a vegan business. I'm like,
- 47:22OK, if you don't want it, but if your business
- 47:24is vegan, you're still doing wonderful good in
- 47:26this world. And I love the utopian vision of
- 47:31everyone being vegan. That would be amazing.
- 47:34My husband's not vegan. We are going to have
- 47:38vegan babies one day, but he's not vegan and
- 47:41maybe he'll never go vegan. And, you know, honestly,
- 47:45sometimes he walks in a room and he's better
- 47:47equipped to get someone to try a vegan product
- 47:50because he's not vegan and they don't want to
- 47:53listen to the vegan. Yeah, this world is complex
- 47:57beyond our grasp. And yeah, I definitely understand
- 48:03the struggle of living with people who are not
- 48:05vegan. Liz? Yeah, gosh, all this makes me think
- 48:10up is I like in my head is stuck as when I went
- 48:14to the Animal and Vegan Advocacy Summit, gosh,
- 48:17this was like three years ago now. I think it
- 48:18was like the first year or something. Steven
- 48:21from Connect for Animals did a lightning presentation
- 48:25on social contagion theory. And that has just
- 48:28really stuck with me. It's like the idea that,
- 48:31you know, sometimes we're in this silo, this
- 48:35like tunnel vision of veganism right because
- 48:37everybody around us is vegan like our co -workers
- 48:40are the people in our movement are but there's
- 48:43an entire world where people really like do not
- 48:46vibe with us um and i have just kept this in
- 48:51my mind as i moved out to the rural countryside
- 48:53and it's like nobody here is there's like no
- 48:55restaurants with vegan options and so Am I gonna
- 48:59turn any of those people away from donating to
- 49:01my sanctuary? Absolutely not. That would be ludicrous
- 49:04because we know that vegans aren't the majority
- 49:07of the population. We're already dealing with
- 49:09such a small pot of money. Do we really want
- 49:11to restrict ourselves more? And I wouldn't even
- 49:14say it's about like morals, like only accepting
- 49:16money from vegans because that's not gonna advance
- 49:19our mission. And so like, as long as you have
- 49:22a proper, I would say like gift acceptance policy,
- 49:26I would definitely not include not including
- 49:28donations from from non -vegans or like vegetarians
- 49:31or flexitarians or reducitarians or omnivores
- 49:35like there's just so much good we can do and
- 49:38everybody is at a different step in their journey.
- 49:43If people didn't take my money before I went
- 49:45vegan like that would be really awful because
- 49:47that would really not be good for them. I just,
- 49:51yeah, I think we just have to meet people where
- 49:52they are and kind of reach out to them with these
- 49:58steps. It really, it's been proven to work. Different
- 50:02strokes for different folks, right? Totally.
- 50:05And I think, you know, our donor base and our
- 50:10supporters and even our participants are not
- 50:14necessarily vegan or plant based, but they want
- 50:18healthier options and those just once more so
- 50:21happened to be plants and so by like for us we
- 50:24focus on the nutrient interventions as it's something
- 50:27that people don't argue against you know we're
- 50:30showing them the evidence based science and we're
- 50:33saying like you know we need to focus on low
- 50:36cholesterol and lower saturated fats and lower
- 50:38sodium and this that and the other thing and
- 50:42this is how you do it and we provide the solutions
- 50:45for that and Children are consuming more plants.
- 50:50It's a win -win for everyone. I mean, even a
- 50:53lot of our work on the policy front in the last
- 50:55few years has been working in response to upon
- 50:58request legislature that's like legislation that
- 51:02passed in Illinois where there was a lot of that
- 51:05passed that said if a student requests a plant
- 51:07-based school lunch that the school is required
- 51:09to provide it. And so we co -founded the Plant
- 51:13-Based School Lunch Collaborative and More Plants
- 51:14on Plates Illinois, where we worked with a philanthropy
- 51:19organization and a marketing firm to get the
- 51:22word out and to make the resources easily accessible
- 51:25so that students could request plant -based school
- 51:28lunches through the programs and the infrastructure
- 51:30that was already in place. Were all those people
- 51:33vegan? Probably not. And so we need to work together.
- 51:37I mean, my non -vegan friends go to vegan restaurants
- 51:39all the time. They buy Miyoko's butter. They
- 51:42get the plant -based meat alternatives. They
- 51:44drink oat milk and soy milk, you know, baby steps.
- 51:50Why do you think people don't consider fundraising
- 51:55as a valid form or more popular form of activism?
- 52:00Like, people go and protest and go on, you know,
- 52:05to all sorts of things in the name of animals.
- 52:08But fundraising is always at the bottom of the
- 52:10list, if not, you know, not even on the list.
- 52:16So why aren't people thinking about fundraising
- 52:19as a valid way to do activism? I think people
- 52:23are afraid to ask for help in general. Like I
- 52:26just feel like that's applicable across like
- 52:29just humanity. It's like the idea of being vulnerable
- 52:33and saying like I need you for something. But
- 52:36like I mentioned before, I don't really see it
- 52:38as asking. I see it as like a collaboration,
- 52:41a connection, a relationship. And so we don't
- 52:44really take that approach. But I can definitely
- 52:46see like people just not feeling comfortable
- 52:48asking. We've seen that like peer -to -peer giving
- 52:51is a really big struggle for our organization.
- 52:55trying to convince people to fundraise on behalf
- 52:58of our organization, and I think it's just because
- 52:59people are uncomfortable having to make that
- 53:01ask. There's so much going on in the world that
- 53:05it can feel really privileged to say, like, will
- 53:08you donate to animals? And so, I mean, I don't
- 53:13think everybody has to, is the thing, right?
- 53:16It's, I wish everybody did, but I think people
- 53:21should really focus on what they're most passionate
- 53:25about. And then that will show through your activism.
- 53:29So if you are like a very much on the grounds
- 53:33person and you want to protest your heart's content,
- 53:37do that, do it effectively. Read our research
- 53:40on what the most effective ways are. But as long
- 53:43as you're putting your all into everything and
- 53:46trying to make sure that you're, you know, doing
- 53:49it with the most effective strategies, tactics.
- 53:53I don't think that everybody should have to fundraise
- 53:55if they don't want to. I really like that. I
- 54:00really like that approach, Liz. I think also
- 54:03it's like giving within your means and I think
- 54:05the last number of years have just been collectively
- 54:08really hard. You know, we've survived a global
- 54:11pandemic. There's numerous political issues across
- 54:15numerous countries going on. There there is just
- 54:20like so much happening that and the news cycle
- 54:23just goes so fast now So I think there's probably
- 54:27like a collective compassion fatigue as well
- 54:29And so people are just tuning out there's so
- 54:32much like our inboxes are flooded every single
- 54:36day and so a lot of people are just our capacity
- 54:39and you know and that has like Changed our approach
- 54:43even to giving Tuesday where you know we we limit
- 54:47the amount of emails not we're not you know we
- 54:49are participating we are sending out emails but
- 54:53we're not going to be sending out eight or ten
- 54:55emails. People are getting emails from everyone.
- 55:00You know we we we I think we just really like
- 55:04focus on the human human first component more
- 55:07than anything else and we are all on the receiving
- 55:09end of that. And yeah, I agree. We all have our
- 55:14own special gifts and talents and interests and
- 55:18flavors. And if that is protesting, if that is
- 55:22working in the movement, you are fundraising.
- 55:26You are giving. You are donating by giving your
- 55:28time, volunteering. You know, direct rescue,
- 55:33there's so many different things that are so
- 55:35valid. And if you can give on top of that, if
- 55:38you have the capacity, fantastic. Should you
- 55:41donate and go hungry? No. Last question. Sanctuaries.
- 55:50It feels like sanctuaries are just struggling
- 55:55for money. um as someone you know struggling
- 56:00for air and drawing like this is the image i
- 56:04get every time i come across you know different
- 56:07sanctuaries um what do you make of that why are
- 56:13sanctuaries the ugly duck of the movement and
- 56:17not getting much love from funders what's happening
- 56:21here oh boy so i don't know if you knew this
- 56:24about me but i have a sanctuary a chicken microsanctuary.
- 56:29So I have this really unique experience of working
- 56:32for both what I would say is like an international
- 56:34organization. We conduct research that reaches
- 56:37and is translated into many languages across
- 56:40the world. And then I have a very micro chicken
- 56:44sanctuary with 22 rescue chickens. So I see like
- 56:47two completely opposite, not opposites, but they
- 56:49mesh well, sides of the movement. I think in
- 56:54my opinion, the sanctuaries hardest thing to
- 57:00overcome is legitimacy in the movement. I think
- 57:05there isn't really a good network right now of
- 57:09sanctuaries and it's something that I've been
- 57:11working very hard on trying to help fix. You'll
- 57:15see things like sanctuary meetups at the Animal
- 57:17and Vegan Advocacy Summit. You'll see things
- 57:20like the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries,
- 57:23GFAS, which does accreditation, but isn't always
- 57:26realistic for all sanctuaries. And there isn't
- 57:29really a collective or a network where all the
- 57:32sanctuaries gather together to share resources
- 57:35or data or research. Like I mentioned at the
- 57:39beginning of the podcast, Fauna Lake did do a
- 57:42study with farm sanctuary, but that was in 2021.
- 57:45So again, it's getting older now. Personally,
- 57:50I do think that sanctuaries are very effective,
- 57:52not just because I have one, but because I've
- 57:55taken time to look through the research and data
- 57:58that shows that positive solution -focused messaging
- 58:01is more effective than graphic imageries. Sanctuaries
- 58:05can... kind of bypass this like moral disengagement
- 58:08because they're not triggering guilt they're
- 58:10like creating a connection they're like fostering
- 58:13empathy and I think like sanctuaries do a really
- 58:17good job at shifting social norms I think the
- 58:19biggest issue is that sanctuaries don't see that
- 58:21they're doing this they're so focused on the
- 58:23individual animals that they're rescuing that
- 58:26they have a hard time because of capacity because
- 58:29they're so overburdened a lot of them are just
- 58:30volunteer run like ours is myself and my partner,
- 58:33we don't take a dime from it. All of our team
- 58:35is volunteer. It's all stuff that we just do.
- 58:40But yeah, I think that they have a really, really
- 58:41hard time being able to like take a step back
- 58:44from that animal care, having the capacity to
- 58:46do so and say like, okay, well, how are we influencing
- 58:48people online? How are we influencing people
- 58:51who come for tours? And so my hope is that over
- 58:55the next few years that there'll be more collaboration.
- 58:59And this will be something that we'll look at
- 59:01more. That is so tender and from the heart. I
- 59:08mean, it's so interesting because I feel like
- 59:12this has been a shift even just in the time that
- 59:15I've been part of the movement. And I feel like
- 59:24Since people have been able to accumulate some
- 59:26of this data, they've kind of shifted away from
- 59:30funding sanctuaries in many ways. And I totally
- 59:34understand wanting to spare as many animals as
- 59:38possible. I think that is a very valid approach.
- 59:42and at the same time like each animal at a sanctuary
- 59:46has the ability to be an ambassador for their
- 59:49species and honestly deserves to have a life
- 59:52that feels and you know feels good and make sure
- 59:55that they're well taken care of and well fed
- 59:57and nurtured and loved and you know there's there's
- 1:00:01so much goodness that can come from that too
- 1:00:03it really is a both and and so that's why i you
- 1:00:07know i think focusing on there's the donor that's
- 1:00:10going to be motivated by the sanctuary experience
- 1:00:13and story and what it means in this, in this
- 1:00:16space. And then there's going to be the folks
- 1:00:18that, you know, have a totally different psychology
- 1:00:20and giving approach. And that is okay. But I
- 1:00:26think there's room for both and it would be a
- 1:00:31huge disservice to not promote sanctuaries and
- 1:00:35the people who are running them because they
- 1:00:37are so hard working. And I can only imagine how
- 1:00:42the effects of inflation and the cost of living
- 1:00:46has changed things. Because if I'm feeling it
- 1:00:49when I'm going to the grocery store, I can only
- 1:00:51imagine when it comes to animal feed and supplies
- 1:00:54and supply chain issues or veterinary care. Because
- 1:00:58if I can feel that with my dogs, how much it
- 1:01:01costs for them, how much is it on a grander scale?
- 1:01:05So I can see where the day to day is really hard
- 1:01:07and really expensive. And I feel like there's
- 1:01:11still a lot of value there. And so just finding
- 1:01:13the right people who get to experience that,
- 1:01:17because I mean, It really is a gift to the animals
- 1:01:21and to the humans. Everyone. Yeah, if you're
- 1:01:27a sanctuary owner like Liz, take note of Alice
- 1:01:32and Liz answers because you have your case of
- 1:01:35support right there. I could go on with questions.
- 1:01:39There is so much to cover with fundraising. By
- 1:01:42the way, do we all have like birds? birds creatures
- 1:01:48artwork on our background I'm trying to see like
- 1:01:55what my back I'm trying to remember what my background
- 1:01:57I think it's like fruit coffee and like butterflies
- 1:01:59and flowers rooster somewhere wait yeah there's
- 1:02:04a little chicken yeah I went for this one okay
- 1:02:16so did you want to add something before I stop
- 1:02:19the recording Yeah, I mean, so I would just say
- 1:02:22like, for any fundraisers that are listening
- 1:02:25to this, yeah, join our Hive fundraising community
- 1:02:28calls for any donors who are listening to this.
- 1:02:32consider donating to politics and balanced, of
- 1:02:36course. And then also just if you're an advocate
- 1:02:40who's just like curious about fundraising, Animal
- 1:02:43Advocacy Careers is absolutely amazing and it
- 1:02:45has a great course where you can learn more about
- 1:02:46fundraising. You can always reach out to me.
- 1:02:50I'll provide my email so people can connect with
- 1:02:53us. And then, yeah, if anybody is just listening
- 1:02:55to this just for general I was going to say shits
- 1:02:59and giggles, you might have to cut that out.
- 1:03:01But if they're just listening for fun, then feel
- 1:03:06free to use Phonelytics office hours anytime
- 1:03:08you need any advocacy help. Thank you, Liz. Alice?
- 1:03:13I love that. I mean, let's see. I'm trying to
- 1:03:19think. Honestly, I think just having these types
- 1:03:21of conversations more regularly, I think it really,
- 1:03:25one, it provides an opportunity for connection
- 1:03:29and collaboration. I get a lot more energy when
- 1:03:32I'm talking to really wonderful people about
- 1:03:34the good work that they're doing. is inspiring.
- 1:03:38And I am very grateful for the in -person opportunities
- 1:03:41that we do have allotted to us, whether it's
- 1:03:43at Eva, Reducetarian. I'm really excited to go
- 1:03:46to Reducetarian in October. I'm really excited
- 1:03:49to go to Clem. Yes, exactly. I love conferences.
- 1:03:53It is weird. I lose my voice, my throat hurts,
- 1:03:57and I'm happy. And I'm so drained at the end
- 1:03:59of it, but I can't sleep. And then, you know,
- 1:04:03I think like, We just need to have more human
- 1:04:08time talking with each other, with our fellow
- 1:04:12organizations, with funders, and continue to
- 1:04:17have these conversations. And yes, donate to
- 1:04:20Phonelytics, donate to Balanced. that the organizations
- 1:04:24that you give to see who's working together behind
- 1:04:26the scenes. One thing I will add, too, I think
- 1:04:30we were touching on it earlier on about the metrics
- 1:04:33that organizations have been providing. And one
- 1:04:37thing that we did, I feel like this is not for
- 1:04:40a tail end of a conversation, but one thing that
- 1:04:43we did that I thought was really great is during
- 1:04:46the pandemic when data was really hard to produce
- 1:04:49or we said that we were transparent and we said,
- 1:04:53you know what, we can't tell you the numbers
- 1:04:55right now, because we have no idea how to measure
- 1:04:58them at this juncture. But once we figure that
- 1:05:01out, we'll keep you in the loop. So being honest,
- 1:05:05being transparent, maintaining relationships,
- 1:05:08and we just got to continue to cheerlead for
- 1:05:10each other. I love it. Liz, Alice, Phenoletics
- 1:05:15and Balance are really lucky to have you. You
- 1:05:20are, of course, you're experts and truly true
- 1:05:24professionals. So yeah, really lucky to have
- 1:05:27you. And thank you. Thank you so much for having
- 1:05:31answered my questions and shared your insights
- 1:05:34and knowledge with everyone. Thank you everyone
- 1:05:39for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:05:42podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:05:45more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:05:49so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:05:52for a new episode.