Latest / On Scope: The Marketing Podcast / Winning the AI Creative Battle with Your Datasets
Transcript
- Speaker 1 (00:00): The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect those of the ANA or its members. On today's episode of On Scope, VidMob founder Alex Colemer explains why creative data may be the new frontier in marketing differentiation. And in the winner's circle, B2 award winner FIS gives its customers a scare by presenting them a world in which the brand doesn't exist. All that next, On Scope. It's a plane. Just kidding. This is On Scope, the marketing podcast brought to you by the ANA. I'm your host, Mike Burbridge. And with me as always, my personal Superman, the founder and producer of OnScope, Ryan Dinger. Ryan, how does the day find you? Speaker 2 (00:57): Dave finds me very well, Mike. The praise is getting higher every week. I mean, I don't know that we can get - Speaker 1 (01:02): You keep burning it, man. Speaker 2 (01:03): I don't know if we can get better than Superman, I'll be honest. Speaker 1 (01:05): There's only one way to find out. Speaker 2 (01:08): Fair enough, fair enough. How are you? How are you? Speaker 1 (01:10): I'm doing great, man. Just this past weekend, got to go home. I officiated my cousin's wedding. Sounds Speaker 2 (01:18): Quite lovely. Speaker 1 (01:18): Love is in the air. I'm just feeling I'm walking on sunshine right now. Speaker 2 (01:23): I love to hear that. Love is in the air, data powering, amazing creative is in the air. Speaker 1 (01:28): Yes. Speaker 2 (01:28): And another addition of one of our favorite segments. Isn't that right? Speaker 1 (01:32): Absolutely. Ryan, we're about to hear how the champions get their business done in a little segment we like to call The Winners Circle. Listeners, we are back in the Winners Circle. This is a segment where we shine the light on activations and campaigns that have been honored by the ANA Awards program for their just cut above the rest. Today we're talking about a B2 award winner. The B2 Awards honor and celebrate excellence in B2B marketing. Ryan, would you do the honors? Speaker 2 (02:15): I would be happy to, Mike, but not just any B2 Award winner. Speaker 1 (02:17): Oh my. Speaker 2 (02:18): The Best in Show B2 Award winner. Speaker 1 (02:20): Okay. Speaker 2 (02:21): This was the best of the best and it comes to us from FIS, a financial services brand. Here's the headline for the case study that our wonderful content team has produced based on this campaign, how FIS made financial disharmony impossible to ignore. And then from the case study, I'm going to read a little bit for you here, Mike. Speaker 1 (02:40): Please do. Speaker 2 (02:41): FIS powers the storage movement tracking and investment of trillions of dollars throughout the global economy. Yet despite its scale and importance, the company remained largely invisible because its technology operates behind the scenes. Many existing and prospective customers were unaware of the breadth of solutions available through FIS, limiting growth opportunities and reducing consideration among decision makers across industries. The company needed to reach audiences with highly diverse technology needs and convince them to think differently about FIS. Research highlighted a consistent theme, financial disharmony was costing organizations dearly. Leaders identified cyber threats, fraud, and regulatory complexities as major sources of operational tension while many organizations experienced the greatest friction during the "money in motion stage of financial operations." The strategy therefore focused on dramatizing business problems and positioning FIS as the force capable of restoring order. The central idea behind money and harmony, the name of the campaign, was simple. (03:39): Show a world where FIS did not exist. Because the company's technology worked quietly and effectively behind the scenes, many customers rarely considered its importance. The campaign exaggerated real business anxieties, including AI-powered fraud, cash flow disruption, and system fragmentation to help audiences understand the value FIS delivers every day. The resulting world of financial disharmony felt chaotic, fractured, and unpredictable. By contrasting this reality with the stability enabled by FIS, the company transformed harmony into something audiences actively wanted and a little taste of the content they put together for this effort. They produced three cinematic 30-second films focused on AI-driven fraud, cash flow disruption, and system fragmentation. They also developed a 15-second and six-second version of each for broader deployment. They activated the campaign across connected television, LinkedIn and YouTube, and they leveraged highly targeted awareness assets to increase lower funnel conversion performance. Mike, this is an amazing campaign, I want to say. Speaker 1 (04:37): Oh, you've got to check out these videos. You've got to go check out these videos. Speaker 2 (04:39): I don't want to make a joke of it, but the first thing that comes to mind for me - Speaker 1 (04:43): What is it? Speaker 2 (04:43): Is a classic Simpsons episode where Bart is in school and they're watching an educational video on the importance of zinc. And in said video, there is a gentleman who for some reason has wished to live in a world without zinc. You don't ever find out why but - Speaker 1 (04:57): It happens to the best of us. Speaker 2 (04:58): So he goes through this day and finds out how important zinc is to his existence. For example, he goes to start his car to drive over to his girlfriend's and learns that the car battery is made partly of zinc, so he can't start his car. And there's a guy there sort of leading him through why now suddenly he can't do all these things. He goes, "Oh okay, I can't drive over to my girlfriend's. I better give her a call and let her know." He goes to the phone and the rotary style phone was made with zinc, and so the phone doesn't work. Speaker 1 (05:28): Oh my. Speaker 2 (05:29): And then it finally ends with him attempting to darkly take his own life and is unable to do so because the trigger mechanism within the gun he's using is also made from zinc. The episode ends with him or the sequence ends with him awaking from a bad dream in which he was imagining a world that he could no longer live in because he didn't have zinc. Comes to find out zinc is still plentiful and he can still start his car and use the telephone and fire a firearm should he so desire to do so. I mean, you can see the similarities between what this campaign is doing or what this campaign did and this weird zinc example that I have, can't you? Speaker 1 (06:11): Yeah. It's always fascinating to see what's going on up there every once in a while. Another reference might be It's a Wonderful Life. Speaker 2 (06:22): Ah, yes. That's fair. Speaker 1 (06:24): The practically universally known holiday classic. That is fair. But yours too. Speaker 2 (06:31): Thank you. Thank you. Speaker 1 (06:32): So a couple of things I really, really like about this campaign, and I will admit that this first part is speculative on my part, but I'm seeing the final product and I'm getting my intuition from all of the talks I've had with hundreds of brilliant marketers over the years that this didn't feel like they started with, we need something big and bold. What can we do? No, it's what is the message we want to convey? Life without us would all of a sudden show you how important we are to your everyday thing. And I love that you brought it up in the case study copy, shout out to the ANA content team, that a lot of B2B organizations, if they do their job extremely well, they are essentially invisible. That's so tough. Speaker 2 (07:29): Yeah, it's a really fascinating take because like you said, especially for an organization like FIS, you don't want to be seen. Speaker 1 (07:37): Exactly. Speaker 2 (07:38): If you're working the way you're intended to, people aren't thinking about you at all and that's exactly what you need to be. But that's a very interesting challenge because then people don't realize how valuable you are. So it's really interesting insight. And as Mike said earlier, if you have a chance, I would check out these videos because the commercials are hilarious. My favorite part is they've personified all of these different security risks, fraud that can happen. And it's these almost like comic book style villains running around the office doing this thing. I particularly liked the guy, he's stolen an entire data server rack. He's running down. He's running through the hall, wheeling it away. Speaker 1 (08:22): Oh Speaker 2 (08:22): My goodness. Sort of representing the data hacker and data privacy. All the different types of fraudsters are represented. It's very interesting. It is cinematic as the case study said. Speaker 1 (08:31): Yeah, absolutely. But they started from the idea, the story, the message they tried to convey, and then they went and they really went for it. I was thinking about that and kind of mulling over those cartoonish villains that you could even get this great idea, go, "I want to go cinematic. I want to go beyond something that a company usually does," but stop there and have people looking at their computers and freaking out to bring it. If you're going to go for it, especially as a B2B brand, if you're out here already, push the envelope. And these characters really adding an extra level of entertainment, I just think that it was a exquisite campaign from end to end, truly. Speaker 2 (09:16): Yeah. I mean, you look at the creative, it's easy to see why it won an award. But of course, Mike, having great creative doesn't necessarily mean that the campaign is going to do what it's meant to. And particularly for ANA award programs, you've got to show results if you're going to win one of these awards. And so let's take a look at the results of this campaign, shall we? Quite impressive. Speaker 1 (09:37): Oh, move that needle, baby. Speaker 2 (09:39): So through this campaign dubbed Money in Harmony, FIS was able to increase demand generation effectiveness by 57%. They generated $26 million in attributable annual contract value. They delivered a 700% return on investment from a $6 million media investment. They achieved a 212% lift in brand awareness, generated a 116% increase in favorability and produced click-through rates that exceeded expectations by two to three times a 700% ROI on a $6 million media investment. If you're hurting for budget and you go in and show that number - Speaker 1 (10:19): You show these numbers. Speaker 2 (10:20): We broke back 700% on your six million you gave us. Speaker 1 (10:23): Yes. Speaker 2 (10:24): Let me tell you something. The CFO is going to probably give you a kiss. I actually think that, I mean, if that's within the guidelines of your organization. Speaker 1 (10:34): As long as HR approves. Speaker 2 (10:36): Exactly. I'm not saying they want to do anything outside the organizational bylaws, but they're going to be quite happy is really my point. Speaker 1 (10:41): Absolutely. Speaker 2 (10:42): They went on to say, "Beyond the metrics, the campaign repositioned FIS within the FinTech category. By rejecting conventional B2B advertising and visualizing a world defined by financial disharmony, the company established a distinctive brand platform capable of supporting future growth while proving that bold creative storytelling could deliver measurable business performance." I mean, I will say yes, indeed. Speaker 1 (11:04): Yes. And honestly, this is a perfect example of the age old axiom of B2B brands need to think more like B2C brands, but they can't lose the essence of what they're trying to do. I think this is so perfectly... The combination of head in the clouds, but grounded in exactly what your business reality is, how can you take that creativity? How can you make it a moment of surprise and delight? Speaker 2 (11:32): No doubt. Speaker 1 (11:33): I mean, absolutely ticking all the boxes. And as you said, this is the best in show. B2 award winner for 2026 FIS. Here are your flowers. Take your bow. You have earned it, friends. Speaker 2 (11:52): Indeed. And if you listener are intrigued, let's say, and want to learn more about the B2 Award winner this year. Speaker 1 (11:58): I'm sure you do. Speaker 2 (11:59): We've got a ton of case studies available for you. You can find out more about this campaign, including reading the entire case study, which features a robust breakdown of the reverse funnel thinking deployed by FIS. Speaker 1 (12:09): I love that. Speaker 2 (12:10): You can visit us to learn more and find this case study at www.ana.net/b2casestudies. And while there you'll be able to read case studies from the more than 80 2026 B2 Award winners. Speaker 1 (12:23): Amazing. That is www.ana.net/b2casestudies. Another fantastic addition of the Winners Circle. I really love this new segment that we're doing here in season two. We are at the OnScope Podcast are all about action. Let's get out there and make change. So I'm loving this opportunity to dive into campaigns that move the needle and have an award to show for it. Speaking of moving the needle, there has been conversations for decades around how creative is the most powerful part of the entire marketing function. Well, in this age of AI, creative is under attack and we as an industry must act to preserve it. With that in mind, we have today's guest, Alex Colemer, the founder and executive chairman of VidMob, the creative data company. As an engineer and background, Alex has made a career living at the intersection of technology, design, and customer entertainment. VidMob's AI-based software improves creative and media performance by helping brands and agencies derive their own custom creative best practices and ensure that those learnings are applied across all flighted media. (13:45): Today, Alex joins the pod to discuss how marketers can survive the upcoming wave of infinite creative by harnessing their brand's proprietary creative data. My conversation with Alex is up next. Listeners, I don't really have to give you a whole lot of background around the AI saga that the marketing industry has been experiencing for years now. There've been a lot of promises of accelerating and enhancing creativity, but I have to ask if we're all using the same genie's lamp, how different is this world going to really look like if we don't do something about it? And so we needed to get somebody who could answer that question. So please help me welcome to ANA Studios, Alex Colemer, founder and executive chairman at VidMob. Alex, thanks for joining us today, my friend. Speaker 3 (14:41): It is entirely my pleasure. Thanks for having me. Speaker 1 (14:43): Oh my goodness. So like I said, I want to set this up. For every pitch that comes in, let's say for every 10 pitches that come into OnScope, 9.98 of them are around AI, but typically it's just what's coming next? How can you get faster? What is this? And what I really appreciate is when somebody comes to us with a story about how do we actually build a foundation, how do we act responsibly, strategically, mindfully to really not get lost in the hype and make sure that this technology we're investing in actually works for us. Now, you and I have had a couple of chats before and you've argued that AI models themselves are becoming commodities. I happen to agree with that strongly. So if every marketer has access to essentially the same intelligence, the same pattern recognition, the same generative capabilities, where does competitive advantage come from in 2026? Speaker 3 (15:45): It's a great question. I guess I feel like I should say just right up front, saying that something is a commodity doesn't in any way say that it's not important or valuable or useful or revolutionary or all the above. So when I say that models are commodities, it's in no way denigrating the utility or value of AI. But what it is saying is that if the goal of marketing is to win share, to out compete your competitor, to do something better than the other people in the space, then if you are using the same thing as a single competitor or more likely all of your competitors, then whether it's 1X is good this week or 2X is good next week or 10X is... It doesn't really matter. And so the question then is how do marketers in that frame get to winning? And our argument, and I don't think this is all that revolutionary, is that what you put into these systems is at least as valuable as the systems themselves. Speaker 1 (16:50): That's a great point. And I think part of the reason why it may be a little hard to swallow for some people that their AI has become a commodity is that the interface can make it feel like the answer you are getting is yours and nobody else's when that's really not the case and we've actually seen that met out in practice before. So I like that we've kind of set that standard of just because you've had a good chat with the AI doesn't mean you have something singular. What it really is doing is allowing what you already are at scale. And that actually brings up something that you brought up earlier, a term infinite creative. And I've got a kind of idea about this, but I'd love for you to break it down. What is infinite creative? Why do you think it will soon overwhelm the modern marketing workflow? Speaker 3 (17:47): Well, I think it stems from how easy it is to create something. We have, I think, two forces now that are leading to an explosion of content by orders of magnitude. The first is GenAI, and we can sort of debate where that is in its progress and whether it's game ready and all this. I think it is in certain cases it is in others. Then the other is influencer or creator content. I think they're kind of almost like two sides of the same cloth. Now with all these synthetic influencers, they actually are the same cloth. But anyway, you slice it, marketers are generally going from having sort of a relatively small number of pieces of content that embodied their brand and their ethos and their value system and where the way that people connected with that product to a world now where they might have thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of pieces of content, and they may not actually have any idea what's in some or most of that content. (18:45): And so this is the world of infinite creative where in a sense, value is shifting from being able to make something, which for all of our lives has been an incredibly powerful skill, to now coupling that with the knowledge of what to make to drive a specific outcome. And then how do you get those million pieces of content to act in concert to drive some sort of desired response? And that I think is where things are really interesting. And right now I think you see a lot of people just sort of thinking, "Hey, the answer is actually, I'll just make a bunch of stuff. I'll throw it out there and the algorithms are just going to figure it out." And that's great. I read Nasim Teleb's Fooled by Randomist and the whole idea of giving a million monkeys a typewriter and one of them will write the Iliad. (19:33): Sure, I buy that. But if I'm a brand, I don't want 999,000 people to write what the other monkeys wrote. Speaker 1 (19:42): Yeah. And which monkey and how can you make them do it again? Speaker 3 (19:45): Exactly. Speaker 1 (19:45): Honestly, if you've got a million pieces of content out there tracking and knowing this kind of feels almost like the early days of the Walled Gardens. "Well, I gave this platform the money, got my ROI. What? I'm taking the long weekend. "It's like," Okay, what worked? What didn't? How can you replicate it? Speaker 3 (20:05): "And there's downstream consequences. Actually, I love the fact that you talk about the early days of the Wald Gardens because my previous business, I helped start and build a game publisher. And that ecosystem, I think there's a lot of parallels there between that and the influencer side now where there was a period where the conventional wisdom was just make tons and tons of stuff and throw it at the algorithm. And so if you remember that period where literally as a category, the game industry was spending a hundred plus billion dollars on what was then Facebook and elsewhere. And all the ads looked the same. It was all side scrollers, gameplay, arena battles. And guess what? It did drive the app installs they cared about. It did nothing else. Speaker 1 (20:47): Yeah. Speaker 3 (20:47): And a few years later, I'm not sure what value came from that. And so here we are now basically replaying that exact same thing where there's a million people in their bathrooms putting on lipstick or whatever, and you can't tell whether it's for this brand or that brand or that brand. It's driving performance, but is it helping in things that are going to still matter three years from now? I'm not sure. Speaker 1 (21:09): That's a great point. I'd love to kind of actually dive into that a little deeper. What are the implications now for brand versus performance marketing? It's been a pretty interesting conversation in the last couple of years of is there a way to blend? You need to hit the balance. Now that we're in the world of infinite creative, what are the implications when marketers think about brand versus performance? Speaker 3 (21:34): I think we over rotate it towards performance and we're starting to see a correction. I don't think it's going to shift all the way back because performance matters, but I'm on the board of the MMA's media and data committee. The MMA does lots of really interesting research and one of the things they measured was the impact of brand marketing on performance and the idea that these things actually, they are not at odds, they act in concert. And brand marketing today has a multiplicative effect on performance marketing three, six, and 12 months down the road. I think as we head into this world of infinite creative, let's just say you're walking, for analogy, say you're walking down the street, there's a trillion things out there. (22:23): Your brain, to protect itself, will evolve to learn how to tune it all out. We will become really good at not seeing unremarkable stuff. And so what's going to stand out is story and narrative and memorable content that probably is laddering up to some sort of brand ethos. I think what's going to happen is it's not like there's going to be all your chips on one bucket, all chips on the other, but I do think we're going to end up back much closer to the middle than we are now where we're frankly pretty over rotated towards performance. Speaker 1 (23:02): No, I completely agree with you. And yeah, it's going to happen. Your kind of box check marketing is going to become the margins of every website on the internet. Our brains just know not to go there. So that's an incredible insight into that because it's typically not thought about in the same breath as the kind of confluence of content, but geez, it's inextricably linked. Speaker 3 (23:30): Yeah, and it gets back to your question earlier about AI, right? I feel like AI gets tarnished when it shouldn't necessarily... We can use it with very little information, very little prompting and say, Hey, make a bunch of stuff and it'll do that. It'll be unremarkable. It'll be sloppy and it'll basically get ignored. But there are incredible artists, human artists using AI to make massively brand resonant, thoughtful pieces. So I think that ultimately we're sort of heading into this world where it's all going to be about how you use these systems to get to the thing you're trying and being really clear about what it is you're trying to accomplish. Speaker 1 (24:15): The drum I've been beating for, it feels like a half decade now is AI is a tool. How you use it and the degree to which you master its use is all that's going to affect the outcome. Speaker 3 (24:30): And this is where creative data gets really useful because it may not have been possible 10, 15 years ago to get into really fine-grained understanding of creative performance. It was just too much signal to watch to be able to manually tabulate the hundred thousand creative decisions that happen in a 10-second or 30-second ad. Speaker 1 (24:53): Yes. Oh my God. Yeah. Speaker 3 (24:54): And so what we did was we built systems to look at which ad is working and how well it is working. Those are known at this point. We have lots of measurement to be able to couple those things, but forever why something worked was kind of an unknown. Now, it's much easier to be able to take any piece of content and break it down into the many, many decisions that make up that sort of creative embodiment. And when you take that and compare it to the multiplicity of performance signals that people care about, whether they're media performance, brand performance, sales performance, whatever it might be, you actually can get to an understanding of what drives performance for particular audiences or outcomes. And so that then becomes the fuel that you can put into an AI system and provide the very specific recommendations. So hey, I'm going to be on this platform in this format targeting this particular audience. (25:52): What should that ad be? And how do I take this concept I have and make it sing the loudest it can sing? Speaker 1 (25:58): Love that. Love that. Listeners, stick around because when we come back, we're going even deeper on creative data and how brands can start to identify and organize that data for the creative data era that is to come. Stick around. No going to want to miss it. Ryan? Speaker 2 (26:19): Yeah, Mike? Speaker 1 (26:20): The following question has been brought to you by OnScope, The Marketing Podcast. How's it going, buddy? Speaker 2 (26:27): I'm doing great. Why are you talking like that? Speaker 1 (26:29): The following response has been brought to you by OnScope, The Marketing Podcast. Ryan, I had this idea that to generate some additional revenue for the pod, that I was going to sponsor this conversation. Speaker 2 (26:43): You're going to sponsor the conversation that we're having right now? Speaker 1 (26:49): Yes, yes. Generally, yes. Speaker 2 (26:51): I got to tell you, Mike, I think that might actually be illegal. I think that might be fraud. Speaker 1 (26:57): Huh. Well, I don't really have anything to talk about right now, Ryan. Anything going on in your world? Speaker 2 (27:06): You know what I'd love to talk about? Speaker 1 (27:07): What would you like to talk about? Speaker 2 (27:08): Sponsorship and partnership opportunities via the A&A. Speaker 1 (27:12): Are they legal? Speaker 2 (27:13): They are very legal. Speaker 1 (27:14): Oh, then let's go crazy. Speaker 2 (27:16): Not only are they legal, they're valuable because you, dear listener, when you sponsor an A&A event, you're not just reaching marketers, you're reaching the decision makers. Discussions that shape the industry started A&A events, whether it be a networking opportunity, a coffee break, or in one-on-one meetings. Speaker 1 (27:32): Yeah, absolutely. And A&A sponsorship is not just about hanging up a logo and calling it a day. Our national industry conferences are just electric spaces for convening marketing leaders, the people you want to get in front of, and spurring meaningful conversations, making new relationships. Real things are happening. You can be in the middle of it all with an A&A sponsorship. Speaker 2 (28:00): You might actually be the one joining the conversations that move marketing forward, and I can't think of anything more valuable when you're looking for a sponsorship opportunity than being the ones who are pushing innovation, who are pushing our industry into the future. Speaker 1 (28:13): Truly, this is your opportunity to be the straw that stirs the drink. Speaker 2 (28:18): You want to learn how to do that? Then you got to visit us at ana.net/sponsorship. Speaker 1 (28:23): That's right. Go over to ana.net/sponsorship, and let's begin a beautiful friendship. Speaker 2 (28:31): And now, back to our show. Speaker 1 (28:36): Listeners, we are back. This is On Scope: The Marketing Podcast. My guest today, Alex Colemer, founder and executive chairman at VidMob. Alex, before the break, we were chopping it up a bit about proprietary creative data, and actually in a previous conversation, you've gone as far to say that this might become as important to marketers as identity data was in the CDP era, which is quite a statement that felt like it was almost the holy grail back in the day. A little bit for me personally, but let's clarify what exactly counts as proprietary creative data, and what does a company need to start capturing today that most brands are currently throwing away or ignoring at the very least? Speaker 3 (29:27): Yeah, it's a really important question, and maybe a little bit of background first. I think the way I think about it is, we've spent the last 15 years or so as an industry focusing on media optimization and improvements in targeting and segmentation and addressability, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. In a lot of ways, that is the bedrock of digital marketing. That is all based on an identity data spine. Yes. So it's like if you understand Who the audience is, you can enable all these amazing things. And it has been amazing. It's led to what's now close to a trillion dollars a year in annual spending across digital marketing. But when you think about this in the terms of S-curves and technology, we are reaching the maturity point in that S-curve. And it's not me that's saying that, it's Google, it's Meta, it's anyone that's in the space realizing, "Hey, after relentlessly optimizing this thing across tens of thousands of companies and incredible technologists, we've kind of done it. (30:33): And we might be able to squeeze a point or two of improvement out there, but there's not that much left." Now, at the same time, through all this time, every CMO has been saying that creative is 50 to 70% of results. I've never had a single person argue that, right? So we've been spending all of our time optimizing this 30% piece. And so what we've sort of seen, and I think now Google's in market saying creative is the last frontier, Metasys creative is new targeting. The world is moving to this idea that creative is chapter two. If media optimization was chapter one, creative optimization is chapter two. Media optimization was enabled by identity data, creative optimization will be enabled by creative data. And so the question then is like, well, what is creative data? And I think really simply what it is, is a structured understanding of what drives creative performance specifically for you. (31:31): And so that is the space that we live in. VidMob is the creative data company. It's our five hour energy. Put it right on the tin, what you do. Speaker 1 (31:42): Hell yeah. Well, and I think there's just so much more potential here for knowing what your creative superpowers are because in the identity wars, race, whatever you want to call it, there was a ceiling shared by everybody. And quite frankly, we got to a place where I think you were right. I think we were just kind of nitpicking around the margins. Well, we could personalize this little, I think they like blue better than... You know what I mean? They were just making these tiny little things and we got... Yeah, I think that you made a great point of focusing in on the 30 while evangelizing with no action the 70. Speaker 3 (32:21): Yeah. And so the question then is who has it and how do you get it? And so I think that there is a world where the big platforms are saying, Hey, we have this PMax or AdvantagePlus or these end-to-end Speaker 2 (32:36): AI Speaker 3 (32:36): Systems. We're just going to do it all. Just tell us what you care about and it's all going to happen. And so they have some version of it there, but for a marketer, it's a fauceting bargain there where you're Speaker 2 (32:49): Losing Speaker 3 (32:50): The ability to understand how to communicate with your customer. And I think that's a very dangerous place to be. And so part of what we're doing with the folks that we work with is helping them build that understanding on their own, own that understanding and the underlying data so that they understand how to communicate effectively and can make that transportable across platforms or channels or whatever. And then where things have gotten really interesting all of a sudden is I think about this, it's like there's some technologies where the advancement of AI and models puts the business at risk. And then there are others where the advancement of AIs and models makes the things way more interesting. And what we've seen is that this creative data has always been incredibly valuable, but it's been sort of hard to get to insights. You need data scientists and data analysts, and then you need to connect it into these human workflows. (33:42): Well, now it's like you just basically use the MCP, you connect it to cloud or agents you're building or anything and say, "Hey, answer this question and it will, or put it in a Speaker 2 (33:55): Chart. Speaker 3 (33:56): Remind me at the end of this week, every asset that's decayed by more than 20%, tell me what to do and how much..." On and on and on. And so this is a case where basically the advancement of models and capabilities and data processing is just a massive accelerant on a data asset. Speaker 1 (34:13): Yeah. And I mean, this is one of the rare places where I'm like speed, speed, speed, speed. In so many other instances, I'm talking about pumping the brakes and being more mindful, but getting these creative insights in time to make the meaningful adjustments when this is all still relevant data, that is the name of the game right now. Speaker 3 (34:35): Totally. And it's Speaker 1 (34:36): So Speaker 3 (34:36): Cool. I mean, what's interesting Speaker 1 (34:37): Is that Speaker 3 (34:37): Even though it has the word creative in it, it Speaker 1 (34:41): Is Speaker 3 (34:41): Also very applicable in media. So what we sort of see is that ultimately through this process, we're able to predict the performance of an asset against whatever KPS someone cares about. So we just released work we did with Kroger a few months ago, and there we basically found that we were able to build a model that was 81% accurate of performance for what they cared about, which was e-commerce. So they're able to score every asset and see its likelihood of performance. And what they found was the difference between high and low scoring assets on Google was almost 6X, and I bet it was like 3X. Still are. Speaker 1 (35:18): We're out of the margins. Speaker 3 (35:20): And so how would you run your business differently if you actually understood ahead of time how an asset was likely to perform in an impression against a particular audience in this channel or format? And that's all new capability, new optimization. Speaker 1 (35:37): Yeah. I love that because I think, I don't want to say this too harshly to our marketers, but I think the term experiment sometimes gets used as cloud coverage for I'm not quite sure why this is working. So we're testing, we're learning. Sometimes you want to have those learnings, apply them and then refine them. That does feel like kind of a chapter too. So as we're talking, this kind of paradox is forming in my head that I think is kind of interesting. To build a proprietary creative intelligence system, you want to be you, you want to learn what works for you, but presumably you want to be able to tap into the larger creative world. What might be out there that's untapped that I don't know might be working, that might work for me. Where does proprietary advantage end and shared industry intelligence begin? Speaker 3 (36:37): Yeah, it's a good question. I think ultimately what we see is it's basically a ladder of value where folks start with basically what are generically published platform best practices. Google ABCDs or Meta Brilliant Basics or things like that. Those do lead to some lift, but once you all have your logo in the first three seconds, it's not going to do much more. And then there are category specifics, so maybe pharma or CPG or e-commerce, things like that. And then ultimately you get into custom by brand or platform or whatever. Importantly, none of these things are static. So what was working this summer in TikTok? I bet you $5 is not going to be working in next spring. And so the question is how do you make sure that the systems you have are built so that they understand when the culture has moved and something that you've now mandated as the thing is actually now damaging your performance. (37:43): And so a lot of the systemry we're building is around that. It's making sure that you're sort of flagged when something is outdated and then the models get updated. And so you always have the most predictive signal there. Speaker 1 (37:53): Got you. Speaker 3 (37:54): And that is what would be proprietary for a particular brand. Speaker 1 (37:58): Absolutely. So there is a layer of just general, this is the algo has definitely changed and so we're making this high level of recommendation and through your platforms, this is what it would likely look like for you. This would be our best recommendation or the numbers say. Speaker 3 (38:14): Absolutely. And they're going to be very different for things that you might think are relatively similar. So they're going to be snack foods that they're basically the same thing, but you have a different relationship with that brand or that brand character. It makes you feel differently. So the things and the way you want to see it presented are going to be different. Same, I think about Uber and Lyft, very similar businesses, but very different brand relationships. And so how they show up and their respective best practices are probably going to be pretty different. Speaker 1 (38:43): Yeah. And you said it perfectly earlier, the hundreds of thousands of decisions that are made in a 10 second piece of content, our brains are specifically wired not to let all hundred thousand pieces of data hit our minds. So really the only, we're going to need help in identifying it down to that minuscule level. Speaker 3 (39:04): Yeah. And so we tell stories to ourselves to make... Historically, we would've done an AB test and we would've had one ad with a dog and one ad with a cat and the dog one wins. And so we're like, okay, the insight is dogs are better. Speaker 1 (39:15): B cat. Yeah. Speaker 3 (39:16): But when you zoom out and look at it, maybe it's actually like the sunset was a particular color that was very nostalgic for a large portion of the audience. It had literally nothing to do with it. So I think that what we see is it's the ability to, through things that you can only do with large scale technology, to move away from these kind of very finite AB type things that frankly oftentimes led to the wrong insight. Speaker 1 (39:42): Yeah. Well, there's a reason why Don Draper had to go in and do theater at the end of every time they come up with a pitch because it's basically his best guess and he was going through... We won't get into it, but there was always this idea of make a guess and present it as confidently as you possibly can. Speaker 3 (40:03): And damn, was he good at it? Speaker 1 (40:04): Yeah. But yes, when we can do more, why not do more? This has been such a cool conversation. I really don't get to talk about AI in this manner. It's usually about trying to get the horses back in the barn or this, that, and the other thing, but it is an inevitable part of our lives and we've really got to be looking at it as how do we control it? How do we put our spin on it? And that sounds a lot like what Vitmob is helping its clients do. So very cool stuff. Speaker 3 (40:34): Yeah. No, I mean it's incredibly powerful and it can be used to great benefit. And I think maybe most importantly for me personally is it's not at odds with creativity.This is something that actually can and should let creativity flourish. And when you provide it with additional information, you can do so in a way that hopefully will drive even better results. Speaker 1 (40:56): Very well said. Listeners, I know you're smarter about creative data and AI than you were when this episode began, but this is the moment when we turn marketers into masters. We give them something to go out into the world with after this episode is complete. In a little segment we like to call the CTA. Are you ready? Speaker 3 (41:27): The tension is palpable, but I am. Speaker 1 (41:30): I knew you were. I knew you were. Alex, how do brands using off the shelf AI start their journey to owning a proprietary creative source? Speaker 3 (41:42): I love this question because I think one of the things that we're most focused on is preserving flexibility. I think the thing that everyone is afraid of now in their respective AI journey is making a wrong decision because we all can see that literally every two weeks there's a new best thing. The paralyzing fear would be like, what if I align on something today and Friday it's out of date because it will be. I think that is a conversation that we have all the time. It gets this idea that we believe that by owning and building this data asset, it actually maximizes your flexibility because then you're not locked in on the model or the tool or whatever. It can be applied to anything. The way to go is, and I don't think this needs to be a pitch for VidMob, there are a handful of creative data platforms that can do this, but the essential thing is how do you start building structured understanding of your creative? (42:45): In our case, we have literally hundreds of models that we've built that we run every asset against that then enables us to break it down. We've built a proprietary taxonomy, which we call the creative aperture, which gets to an understanding of not just is there a pencil in the third second, but what's the benefit messaging and narrative arc and all these things that are actually important to marketers. Once you have that and you have the performance data, then you have this thing. Now that can be applied via MCP and connectors. I mean, it literally takes two seconds to go into cloud and be like, "Enable VidMob MCP." And then you're off the races. And it's sort of the same on the GenAI side where our view is that there are going to be, this is a million flowers blooming scenario. There's going to be lots and lots of tools. (43:32): There are going to be some that are really good at animation, some that are really good at clay motion, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And what you're going to want to bring is effectively a recommendation system into them so that when you say, "Make me an ad to drive ad to carts and TikTok," it actually gets also the information to make sure that the thing it makes drives that result. So for me, this is find a system that is good at building rich. It can't just be doing some tags.That's not enough. Speaker 1 (44:02): Yes. Yes. Give me three titles for - Speaker 3 (44:05): Yeah. I think about this, let's just put it in the audience data frame. Let's say there's two companies that have audience data. One has your email address, that's it. And the other has email address and geographic location and spending habits and media channel. Those are both audience data. It's just one's a lot more useful than the other. And so it's the same with creative data. Do your diligence, get involved and figure out is this company going to build really rich, robust credit data that's actually going to give me a meaningful signal? Then once you have it, make sure that it has outbound connectors because all these things in a silo, they're useless. They need to be connected to the AI system. They need to be able to partner with other data sources and providers, other measurement channels. The more data flows in and out, the better. (44:51): And then it's about kind of playing and getting in there. I'm sure 99% of people listen to this are on that journey and it's a wild and awesome journey. Speaker 1 (45:04): Yeah, man. Art is limitation. And wouldn't you love your limitations to be set by breaking your creative down to a subatomic level and getting in there to what's really working? Speaker 3 (45:14): Yeah. But the results, the impact is massive. I mean, I talked about the 6X improvement. We have customers who have had 100 million plus improvement in their overall media effectiveness annually as a result of this. And again, it shouldn't be surprising, right? If we actually do believe that creative is 50 to 70% of results, then it's a really big deal. Speaker 1 (45:39): Yes. Speaker 3 (45:40): And we just as an industry haven't behaved that way. And I'm glad to see that I think that's changing. Speaker 1 (45:47): Yeah. Well, you know what? That is the reason this show exists is to beat the drum for marketers to literally put their money where their mouth is and let's start acting on the things we've been talking about for decades. Speaker 3 (45:59): Absolutely. Speaker 1 (45:59): Alex, this was such a pleasure. We are so grateful to have you as a guest on Scope. Speaker 3 (46:06): Thank you. Speaker 1 (46:09): I can barely believe it, but here we are at the end of another episode of On Scope, The Marketing Podcast. A huge thanks to our guest today, VidMob founder Alex Colemer. In this age of AI where a lot of the conversations are around, oh look, it can take over the creativity and just put content out every five seconds. It was nice to have a talk about how your proprietary creative data is going to be more and more and more valuable in the coming years. What we like to do here at On Scope is really heighten and put some pressure on conversations that we've been going around and around about in this industry. If you really think creative is the most important part of advertising, it's time to put your money where your mouth is. As a reminder, if you have a future topic or guest that you'd like to see on an episode of On Scope, go ahead and shoot us a note. (47:06): We'd love to hear from you. That email address is onscope@ana.net. And now, as always, here is your moment of marketing meditation. Take a nice deep breath, relax those shoulders, and consider the following from Maya Angelou. You can't use up creativity. The more you use, the more you have. Think on that and we'll see you next week.