Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / No Longer Atheist: an analysis of Ayaan Hirsi Ali
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I am
- 0:57quite sure that at this moment there are a pologists, send evangelicals, and
- 1:02even armchair Christians who are kind of smirking the atheists lost one of their own.
- 1:10I An Hersey, Ali for so long, a public, front line
- 1:15proud atheist, has just said she is a Christian, and if you're not
- 1:22familiar with her, I am going to give you some background quickly before I
- 1:26speak to Jonathan MS Pierce. He's a columnist and philosopher and a friend who
- 1:32has written publicly about all of this, and I thought he would be great
- 1:36to weigh in for the final part of the broadcast. So let's set up
- 1:41all of this with a little bit of backstory. Ian Hersey Ali. She
- 1:45was born in Mogadishu back in nineteen sixty nine. Her dad was a political
- 1:51activist. He was part of the Somali Revolution that was protesting Communist government.
- 1:56For that, they put him in prison. He escaped and the family escaped
- 2:00Somalia in nineteen seventy seven. Iane was only eight years old at the time.
- 2:07The family, then settled in Kenya, had a pretty good life.
- 2:12Ianne went to a Muslim school which was increasingly influenced by Saudi Arabian a Saudi
- 2:19Arabia has a pretty strict, hobbyist version of Islam, and that's what they
- 2:23were teaching more and more in Ian's school. And she was a Muslim,
- 2:28a devout Muslim, a true believer. She prayed and read the Koran and
- 2:32wore the hijab and everything. So we skipped forward from her schooling to her
- 2:38adulthood. This is nineteen ninety two. Ian claims she was arranged to be
- 2:46married against her will. She wanted nothing to do with this, but she
- 2:53was worried about the consequences. She specifically worried about an honor killing. She
- 3:00would be executed for disobeying her family, her culture and Allah, and so
- 3:06she begged for political asylum in the Netherlands, which they did grants. Now
- 3:12her family came forward and said, this is all a bunch of crap.
- 3:15She was never in danger. She lived a great life, kept in touch
- 3:21with her family even after she had moved to the Netherlands, and she herself
- 3:27had to admit years later that she had made up a bunch of information she
- 3:30gave to the Dutch government. She lied about her name, she lied about
- 3:36her birth date and some of the circumstances. But Ian Hersili insists that there
- 3:42was an arranged marriage and she was trying to escape it. Iron very intelligence
- 3:49and well educated. She speaks six languages, got a degree in political science
- 3:55back in two thousand and one. And then nine eleven happened, and this
- 4:01rattled her Islamic cage. She said, for really the first time, it
- 4:06was nine to eleven that caused her to see more clearly the Islamic language of
- 4:13jihad, the radicals justifying mass murder, and as a human being, she
- 4:18could not reconcilent, and so she began to reverse engineer and deconstruct Islam.
- 4:26She went back to the Qoran for a more objective reading, and by two
- 4:30thousand and two she had totally renounced her Muslim faith and said I am an
- 4:35atheist, and then began her activism, mostly against Islam and its oppression of
- 4:44women. She dared to talk about those verses in the Koran where Mohammed married
- 4:48a six year old and raped her when she was nine. She rightly said
- 4:54Mohammed would be considered a pedophile by any standard today, and and for saying
- 5:00that publicly, she got death threats. One of her associates in activism was
- 5:06executed. Two thousand and four. She was working with a film director,
- 5:12a guy named Theo van go She helped to write and voice a documentary called
- 5:18Submission that talked about the horrible treatment of women under Islamic regimes. And that
- 5:25year two thousand and four, Theo van Goh was walking outside a man came
- 5:30and shot and stabbed and nearly beheaded him. His dead body, found in
- 5:36the street, had a note pinned to it with a knife. That note
- 5:41was written to Ian Hersey Ali. It was a death threat. She went
- 5:46into hiding. Two thousand and six, she moved to the United States.
- 5:51She got her green card in two thousand and seven became a citizen in twenty
- 5:57thirteen. She founded the a Ha Foundation. This is a nonprofit created to
- 6:03protect women and girls in the United States against Islamic oppression and other human rights
- 6:11abuses, and she remained a professing atheist. She wrote several books, including
- 6:17two thousand and six, she wrote Infidel Nomad, published in twenty ten.
- 6:23Three years ago, she released Pray, Immigration, Islam, and the Erosion
- 6:30of Women's Rights. She has written for The Daily Beast, The New York
- 6:33Post, The Spectator, and other publications. Ion heir See Ali has been
- 6:40fiercely critical of the West for trying to distance Islam from radical Islam. She
- 6:47says, there's really no difference. They're all part of this same machine that
- 6:51has softened a little bit. She used to say, you can't reform Islam,
- 6:58but these days reform seems to be more of that conversation, let's moderate
- 7:01the religion where we can. Politically, this woman has been a mess.
- 7:08Ayan Heirsi Ali supported Trump. She declared that he did, in fact have
- 7:13the legal right to implement his Muslim ban for the entire country. She wanted
- 7:19extreme vetting her words, extreme vetting of Muslim migrants and the targeting of a
- 7:28single religion in this country for investigation. She dismissed the Women's March on Washington
- 7:34back in twenty seventeen and called American feminists idiotic women consumed with the trivial.
- 7:43She gave a speech called Wokism and how to counter it. She calls woke
- 7:48an ideological stew of identity politics, group think, social justice, critical race
- 7:57theory, and the practice of canceling any one who fails to tow the woke
- 8:01line. She supported Brett Kavanaugh for Supreme Court. She has often come after
- 8:09the left, those wokeists for being enemies of free speech. She has compared
- 8:15the woke to Islamist. She said wokeness is the return of white supremacy.
- 8:20None other than Christian propaganda mill prager U called ien here cl a champion of
- 8:30free speech and enemy of wokeness. Now, many of us on the left
- 8:37have said that she has made some very problematic and overly simplistic statements and she
- 8:43doesn't like to be criticized for it. So she is claiming that we are
- 8:48just intolerant. We are the intolerant, anti free speech woke, and if
- 8:54I can speak for myself, I used to be a big fan of I
- 8:58Her. I read Infidel and loved it. I really appreciated her fierce criticisms
- 9:07of Islam, even at the risk of her own life. But in recent
- 9:11years she's become so frustrating because she seems to want to reduce complex human rights
- 9:16issues down to bumper stickers. I mean the Women's March. She saw it
- 9:22as the acting out of entitled women who just don't want to do the dishes,
- 9:28or they want to fight with her husbands about who does the dishes.
- 9:31That was what she said. But I saw the march as a public statement
- 9:35of protest and empowerment. Trump had just been inaugurated. He had proudly talked
- 9:43about grabbing a woman by the pussy. He was a sexist pig. He
- 9:46was declaring war on reproductive rights and aligning himself with bigoted evangelical Christian nationalists.
- 9:54And these millions of women had been marching nationwide, not just on Washington,
- 10:00marching in solidarity with women with protections for all human rights. Why in the
- 10:05world would I n Hersey Ali call these protesters spoiled brats, just squabbling over
- 10:13the unimportant, and that kind of thing really started to distance me from her.
- 10:18She's trying to meme complex human rights conversations and the world just doesn't work
- 10:26that way. Then this month, November thirteenth, twenty twenty three, din
- 10:33hersey Li publishes this article titled why I Am Now a Christian and the piece
- 10:43is just jaw droppingly bad, poorly reasoned, pathetically defended, and of course
- 10:50the Christian world is gobbling this thing up like it's candy. Now, I
- 10:56don't know what else to do before I talk to Jonathan pierceon I don't know
- 11:00what else to do but to read her article in its entirety so we can
- 11:05talk about it now. I am estimating this to be between a fifteen and
- 11:13eighteen minute read, and I don't want to interrupt it, so let me
- 11:16take a short break here and I will come back and read for you.
- 11:22I am Hersey Ali's reasons why she is no longer an atheist and she is
- 11:26now a Christian, and we're going to comment on that next. I am
- 11:35Hersyli. In the headlines all around the world this past week, a former
- 11:41frontline atheist activist who now says she has become a Christian. She is a
- 11:46former Muslim now a former atheist found her from Jesus. But why why would
- 11:54this happen? Well, she has I'm going to call him reasons. I'm
- 11:58gonna call them reasons. They're bad reasons. And I want to read for
- 12:03you her reasons by reading the articles she posted. I'll be back with philosopher
- 12:09columnist Jonathan MS Peers to discuss after I read this statement ion hersy ali as
- 12:18published on Unheard You nherd dot com why I Am now a Christian? Atheism
- 12:26can't equip us for civilizational war. In two thousand and two, I discovered
- 12:35a nineteen twenty seven lecture by Bertrand Russell entitled Why I Am Not a Christian?
- 12:41It did not cross my mind as I read it that one day,
- 12:45nearly a century after he delivered it to the South London branch of the National
- 12:50Secular Society, I would be compelled to write an essay with precisely the opposite
- 12:56title. The year before, had publicly condemned the terrorist attacks of the nineteen
- 13:03men who had hijacked passenger jets and crash them into the Twin Towers in New
- 13:09York. They had done it in the name of my religion Islam. I
- 13:13was a Muslim then, although not a practicing one. If I truly condemned
- 13:18their actions, then where did that leave me? The underlying principle that justified
- 13:26the attacks was religious, after all, the idea of jihad or holy war
- 13:31against the infidels. Was it possible for me, as for many members of
- 13:37the Muslim community, simply to distance myself from the action and its horrific results.
- 13:45At the time, there were many eminent leaders in the West, politicians,
- 13:48scholars, journalists, and other experts who insisted that the terrorists were motivated
- 13:54by reasons other than the ones they and their leader of Tama bin Laden had
- 14:01articulated so clearly, so Islam had an alibi. This excuse making was not
- 14:09only condescending towards Muslims, it also gave many Westerners a chance to retreat into
- 14:16denial. Blaming the errors of US foreign policy was easier than contemplating the possibility
- 14:24that we were confronted with a religious war. We've seen a similar tendency in
- 14:28the past five weeks, as millions of people sympathetic to the plight of Gossans
- 14:35seek to rationalize the October seventh terrorist attacks as a justified response to the policies
- 14:43of the Israeli government. When I read Russell's lecture, I found my cognitive
- 14:48dissonance easing. It was a relief to adopt an attitude of skepticism toward religious
- 14:54doctrine, discard my faith in God, and declare that no such an ena
- 15:00entity existed. Best of all, I could reject the existence of hell and
- 15:05the danger of everlasting punishment. Russell's assertion that religion is based primarily on fear
- 15:13resonated with me. I had lived for too long in terror of all the
- 15:18gruesome punishments that awaited me. While I had abandoned all the rational reasons for
- 15:24believing in God, that irrational fear of hell fire still lingered. Russell's conclusion
- 15:31thus came as something of a relief. When I die, I shall rot
- 15:39to understand why I became an atheist twenty years ago, you first need to
- 15:43understand the kind of Muslim I had been. I was a teenager when the
- 15:48Muslim Brotherhood penetrated my community in Nairobi, Kenya, in nineteen eighty five.
- 15:54I don't think I had even understood religious practice before the coming of the Brotherhood.
- 16:00I had endured the rituals of ablutions, prayers and fasting as tedious and
- 16:07pointless. The preachers of the Muslim Brotherhood changed this. They articulated a direction,
- 16:15the straight path, a purpose to work towards admission into Allah's paradise after
- 16:22death, a method, the Prophet's instruction manual, abdues and don'ts, the
- 16:27Halal and the Haram. As a detailed supplement to the Quran. The Hadith
- 16:33spelled out how to put himTo practice the difference between right and wrong, good
- 16:38and evil, God and the devil. The Brotherhood preachers left nothing to the
- 16:45imagination. They gave us a choice. Strive to live by the Prophet's manual
- 16:51and reap the glorious rewards and the hereafter on this earth. Meanwhile, the
- 16:56greatest achievement possible to die as a martyr for the sake of Allah. The
- 17:03alternative indulging in the pleasures of the world was to earn Allah's wrath and be
- 17:11condemned to an eternal life in hell fire. Some of the worldly pleasures they
- 17:17were decrying, including reading novels, listening to music, dancing, and going
- 17:22to the cinema, all of which I was ashamed to admit that I adored.
- 17:29The most striking quality of the Moslem brotherhood was their ability to transform me
- 17:34and my fellow teenagers from passive believers into activists almost overnight. We didn't just
- 17:42say things or pray for things. We did things. As girls, we
- 17:48donned the burka and swore off Western fashion and makeup. The boys cultivated their
- 17:53facial hair to the greatest extent possible. They wore the white dress like tall
- 18:00worn in Arab countries, or had their trousers shortened above their ankle bones.
- 18:06We operated in groups and volunteered our services in charity to the poor, the
- 18:11old, the disabled, and the weak. We urged fellow Muslims to pray
- 18:17and demanded that non Muslims convert to Islam. During Islamic study sessions, we
- 18:25shared with the preacher in charge of the session our worries, For instance,
- 18:29what should we do about the friends we loved and felt loyal to, but
- 18:33who refused to accept our dawa, our invitation to the faith. In response,
- 18:40we were reminded repeatedly about the clarity of the prophet's instructions. We were
- 18:45told in no uncertain terms that we could not be loyal to Allah and Mohammed,
- 18:52while also maintaining friendships and loyalty toward the unbelievers. If they explicitly rejected
- 19:00our summons to Islam, we were to hate and curse them. Here a
- 19:06special hatred was reserved for one subset of unbeliever, the Jew. We cursed
- 19:12the Jews multiple times a day and expressed horror, disgust, and anger at
- 19:18the litany of offenses he had allegedly committed. The Jew had betrayed our prophet,
- 19:26he had occupied the Holy Mosque in Jerusalem. He continued to spread corruption
- 19:30of the heart, mind and soul. You can see why to someone who
- 19:36had been through such a religious schooling, atheism seemed so appealing. Bertrand Russell
- 19:41offered a simple, zero cost escape from an unbearable life of self denial and
- 19:48harassment of other people. For him, there was no credible case for the
- 19:53existence of God. Religion, Russell argued, was rooted in fear. He
- 20:00said, fear is the basis of the whole thing. Fear of the mysterious,
- 20:04fear of defeat, fear of death. As an atheist, I thought
- 20:11I would lose that fear. I also found an entirely new circle of friends
- 20:17as different from the preachers of the Muslim Brotherhood as one could imagine. The
- 20:22more time I spent with them, people such as Christopher Hitchins and Richard Dawkins,
- 20:27the more confident I felt that I had made the right choice. For
- 20:30the atheists were clever. They were also a great deal of fun. So
- 20:37what changed? Why do I call myself a Christian now? Part of the
- 20:44answer is global Western civilization is under threat from three different but related forces.
- 20:52The resurgence of great power authoritarianism and expansionism in the forms of the Chinese Communist
- 21:00Party in Vladimir Putin's Russia. The rise of global Islamism, which threatens to
- 21:06mobilize a vast population against the West. And the viral spread of woke ideology,
- 21:14which is eating into the moral fiber of the next generation. We endeavor
- 21:19to fend off these threats with modern secular tools, military, economic, diplomatic,
- 21:27and technological efforts to defeat, bribe, persuade of peace, or surveil.
- 21:33And yet with every round of conflict we find ourselves losing ground. We're
- 21:40either running out of money, with our national debt in the tens of trillions
- 21:44of dollars, or we are losing our lead in the technological race with China.
- 21:49But we can't fight off these formidable forces unless we can answer the question
- 21:56what is it that unites us? The response that God is dead seems insufficient,
- 22:03so too does the attempt to find solace in the rules based, liberal
- 22:10international order. The only credible answer, I believe lies in our desire to
- 22:15uphold the legacy of the Judeo Christian tradition. That legacy consists of an elaborate
- 22:23set of ideas and institutions designed to safeguard human life, freedom, and dignity,
- 22:32from the nation state and the rule of law to the institutions of science,
- 22:36health, and learning. As Tom Holland has shown in his marvelous book
- 22:41Dominion, all sorts of apparently secular freedoms, of the market of conscience and
- 22:48of the press find their roots in Christianity. And so I have come to
- 22:55realize that Russell and my atheist friends failed to see the wood for the trees.
- 23:02The wood is the civilization built on the Judeo Christian tradition. It is
- 23:08the story of the West warts and all Russell's critique of those contradictions and Christian
- 23:15doctrine is serious, but it is also too narrow in scope. For instance,
- 23:22he gave his lecture in a room full of former or at least doubting
- 23:26Christians and a Christian country. Think about how unique that was nearly a century
- 23:33ago, and how rare it still is in non Western civilizations. Could a
- 23:37Muslim philosopher stand before any audience in a Muslim country then or now and deliver
- 23:44a lecture with the title why I Am Not a Muslim? In fact,
- 23:48a book with that title exists, written by an ex Muslim, but the
- 23:55author published it in America under the pseudonym Iven Warwick. It would have been
- 24:02too dangerous to do otherwise. To me, this freedom of conscience and speech
- 24:07is perhaps the greatest benefit of Western civilization. It does not come naturally to
- 24:14man. It is the product of centuries of debate within Jewish and Christian communities.
- 24:21It was these debates that advanced science and reason, diminished cruelty, suppressed
- 24:27superstitions, and built institutions to order and protect life while guaranteeing freedom to as
- 24:36many people as possible. Unlike Islam, Christianity outgrew its dogmatic stage. Sorry
- 24:44I'm about to choke I'm trying to choke this back. Christianity outgrew its dogmatic
- 24:52stage. It became increasingly clear that Christ's teaching implied not only a circumscribed role
- 24:59for or religion as something separate from politics. It also implied compassion for the
- 25:06sinner and humility for the believer. Yet I would not be truthful if I
- 25:11attributed my embrace of Christianity solely to the realization that atheism is too weak and
- 25:19divisive a doctrine to fortify us against our menacing foes. I have also turned
- 25:26to Christianity because I ultimately found life without any spiritual solace, unendurable, indeed
- 25:36very nearly self destructive. Atheism failed to answer a simple question, what is
- 25:42the meaning and purpose of life? Russell and other atheist activists believe that with
- 25:48the rejection of God we would enter an age of reason and intelligent humanism.
- 25:55But the God hold the void left by the retreat of the Church has merely
- 26:00been filled by a jumble of irrational quasi religious dogma. The result is a
- 26:07world where modern cults prey on the dislocated masses, offering them spurious reasons for
- 26:15being and action, mostly by engaging in virtue signaling theater on behalf of a
- 26:21victimized minority or our supposedly doomed planet. The line often attributed to G.
- 26:29K. Chesterson has turned into a prophecy quote. When men choose not to
- 26:33believe in God, they do not thereafter believe in nothing. They then become
- 26:38capable of believing in anything in this nihilistic vacuum. The challenge before us becomes
- 26:47civilizational. We can't withstand China, Russia and Iran if we can't explain to
- 26:52our populations why it matters that we do. We can't fight woke ideology if
- 27:00we can't defend the civilization that it is determined to destroy, and we can't
- 27:06counter Islamism with purely secular tools. To win the hearts and minds of Muslims
- 27:12here in the West, we have to offer them something more than videos on
- 27:17TikTok. The lesson I learned from my years with the Muslim Brotherhood was the
- 27:23power of a unifying story embedded in the foundational texts of Islam to attract,
- 27:30engage, and mobilize the Muslim masses. Unless we offer something as meaningful,
- 27:37I fear the erosion of our civilization will continue and fortunately there is no need
- 27:44to look for some new age concoction of medication and mindfulness. Christianity has it
- 27:52all. That is why I no longer consider myself a Muslim apostate, but
- 27:57elapsed a theist. Of course, I still have a great deal to learn
- 28:03about Christianity. I discover a little more at church each Sunday. But I
- 28:08have recognized in my own long journey through a wilderness of fear and self doubt,
- 28:15that there is a better way to manage the challenges of existence than either
- 28:21Islam or unbelief had to offer. And I have to remark quickly about that
- 28:26line in the last paragraph, certainly, where she says I have a lot
- 28:30to learn about Christianity, meaning I don't know very much about it, but
- 28:34somehow she knows it's true. In just a second, I want to speak
- 28:41to a gentleman who wrote a column commenting on her column. He's a fellow
- 28:45activist, humanist, philosopher. His name is Jonathan ms. Piers. He's
- 28:51going to give us his take next. I wanted to talk about all of
- 29:02this with a friends, a philosopher, author, columnist, and I guess
- 29:07some people would consider pain in the ass because he's always stirring the pot out
- 29:11there. Jonathan MS Pierce a brother. Good to have you, Hey,
- 29:15thanks for contacting me, Seth. Always good to talk about these sorts of
- 29:18things, And this one sort of came out of the blue. I guess.
- 29:22I just finished giving a profile of Ian Hersey Ali and her background,
- 29:27and I used to be a big fan. You know. I loved Infidel
- 29:30when I read it and appreciated her fearce stand against Islam, and I aligned
- 29:37with her a little bit in that I don't think you can fully separate Muslims
- 29:41from Islam. I myself have become frustrated that this sort of silent culture of
- 29:48people who hold to the Koran have not been more vocal in the wake of
- 29:53Islamic terrorism blah blah blah. But I've also come to realize that just like
- 29:59Christians, many many, I think even most Muslims have sort of fashioned of
- 30:03faith in their own image. They're lovely people who may have some bad ideas,
- 30:07but it's unfair to align them with the g Hardists, you know.
- 30:11And there's any of that resonate with you, man hugely, Like my goodness,
- 30:17I could digress for a very long time here, So I have actually
- 30:19presented before on Islam being an inherently theologically violent religion and one, as you
- 30:26say, must differentiate between Islam and Muslims here. But when you look at
- 30:30the text of the Quran, and when you look at the Hideth particularly,
- 30:34these are texts that do not sit very well with someone who's a secular humanist.
- 30:38In fact, I read the Koran and felt somewhat dehumanized. Now,
- 30:42I've written on this before and presented on this, and i've been it's probably
- 30:48been the most pushback I've ever had with anything I've said from fellow liberals.
- 30:53Now, I'm a lefty liberal, but I will not shy away from saying
- 30:56what I think are the truths here. Now, let me guess carlon Islamopholt.
- 31:03Not quite, but you could see it going on the way to that
- 31:06like fellow people. But because you're you're picking on a group of people that
- 31:10some assume are some kind of oppressed minority, or because there are a minority
- 31:14in certain sections of certain societies around the world, they're therefore kind of ring
- 31:18fenced from criticism. But of course, you know that's irrelevant to the truth
- 31:23of what I'm saying Now, I then came to a realization that what I
- 31:27was saying, however true it might be, might not aid social cohesion.
- 31:33So I started stepping back from saying that, not because I didn't find what
- 31:36I was saying had value in terms of its truth, but because it could
- 31:40be divisive and could be used by people who were genuinely Islamophobic to try and
- 31:45sew division and discord, and you know, have a go at Muslims on
- 31:51account and the being Muslims, not on account of like theological wranglings over whether
- 31:55these texts are inherently violent or not. So if you walk into the room,
- 31:59you don't with Muhammad was a pedophile. You don't lead with that,
- 32:04even though it's there, right, even though we it's you and I.
- 32:07We have to have the hard discussions about those types of things. And if
- 32:10I say that, there are some even some liberals, my fellow lefties who
- 32:15says Seth is an islamophobe. And I always try to differentiate between Islam,
- 32:20which is a truth claim and ideology a dogma, and Muslims. I think
- 32:24there's a difference between anti Muslim bigotry and Islamophobia. I myself struggle. I
- 32:30think Islamophobia is a bullshit term. I don't know, would you agree disagree
- 32:34with that? Well, yes, so it's an interest. I once call
- 32:37myself rationally Islamophobic, which was like, which is a moron because it's an
- 32:43irrational fear. But it's the idea that you know, I look at Muslims
- 32:46and I say, right, if you my thesis is if you are like
- 32:51scare quotes true Muslim, and we can talk about the provenance of Islam or
- 32:57the Holy Text, competitive provenance of the Bible, real difference, because if
- 33:00this is a direct word of God as dictated through the archangel Gabriel or whatever,
- 33:06then it is I guess, easier to get a true Islam than it
- 33:09is to get a true Christianity, if you like, which is why I
- 33:13think there's such a vast array of Christianities around the world, because it's the
- 33:16Word, is the inspired word of God, not the direct word of God,
- 33:21and you can interpret it how you like and so on and so forth,
- 33:23whereas with the Quran, it's literally the word of God and it's supposed
- 33:28to be in Arabic et cetera, et cetera, and so you can get
- 33:30this idea. I think that we can approximate more easily a truer version of
- 33:36Islam. Now what that then means is that you can go up to Muslims
- 33:39who are kind of peace loving liberal Muslims like myself, more really like myself,
- 33:44and say, actually, you're wrong about your faith. You should be
- 33:46more violent, and of course that's not what you want to do. So
- 33:50it's this weird paradigm where the Muslims I associate better with are the ones I
- 33:54think have a less correct version of their faith. Do you see what I
- 33:58mean? Well, I think ultimately the umbrella point would be it's not enough
- 34:02to be correct if we want to be effective. I used to be the
- 34:06guy coming out of the faith where I would walk into the room with a
- 34:08big T shirt and placards and I'd be pounding my gavel and I was just
- 34:12afraid train and I came to the conclusion that I did more damage than good
- 34:19if I was trying to engage in conversation, you know, create discourse,
- 34:23change minds, even my own, that kind of thing. We're setting all
- 34:28this up because we're talking about Iane hersy Ali. Your article on her caught
- 34:32my attention. Now I have read her statement for the audience. So let's
- 34:38get into your analysis. What do you think? Well, first of all,
- 34:43she wrote it in a publication it's called Unheard, which is sort of
- 34:47center right, right leaning, often anti woke, quasi religious website, as
- 34:53in it does have connections to Christianity and so on and so forth, And
- 34:59that's interesting and in and of itself, like the choice of where to say
- 35:02this and then what she said in that article as to why she has embraced
- 35:09Christianity or why she labels herself as Christian now was kind of devoid of any
- 35:15decent rational analysis. Basically, it's not a positive, I guess, rational
- 35:21argument for Christianity based on evidence. It's much more about, like I don't
- 35:25want to be dismissive here, but much more about the feels. It's like,
- 35:29oh, you be dismissive, That's what I call it, Like you
- 35:30didn't see her say here are the proofs I have discovered for the existence of
- 35:36God. It was more about, you know, some people treated me shitty
- 35:39and I'm frustrated and I kind of missed the warm fuzzies and that kind of
- 35:45There was a lot of that in there, would you agree, absolutely?
- 35:46So? A lot of it was to do with unlacking a meaning and purpose
- 35:52in life. I'm missing something, and I think Christianity can give that to
- 35:58me. Rather than you know, I king from the basis, the rational
- 36:01basis of Christianity as evidentually justified as looking at the Bible and saying, well,
- 36:07this theologically makes sense. It's more like, oh, I'm just I
- 36:09have this hole in my life that I think can only be filled by something
- 36:13like Christianity. And I always think that that is just not interacting with something
- 36:19like a positive vision of secular humanism, but really get to grips with,
- 36:23you know, understanding meaning and purpose and understanding these big philosophical ideas and getting
- 36:30to grips with them, rather than going, oh no, I'm missing that.
- 36:32Therefore, jumping into Christianity was one of the things I took from it.
- 36:37I noticed that she had the step into Judeo Christianity and how it has
- 36:42helped to build civilized society and it's provided all these things. And of course
- 36:47you and I are like, have you opened a history book as to how
- 36:51Christianity was spread? I mean, yeah, you'll find examples of structure and
- 36:55civilization that have been heavily influenced and you'll find examples of destruction and oppression,
- 37:01and you know, the slaughter of indigenous peoples and torture and rape and all
- 37:07those other things in the name of Christianity. I mean, she sounds like
- 37:12Mike Johnson, the new US Speaker of the House, when she talks about
- 37:15Judeo Christian civilization, and it's almost to forget what the Greeks and Romans did?
- 37:21You know what the Romans ever done for us? I think it's just,
- 37:23yeah, it gets me, And it's very similar to that conversation you
- 37:27often hear from Christians who say, look at all the scientists throughout history,
- 37:30and Christianity is responsible for science. No humans were responsible for science, And
- 37:36it just so happens the default religion of those humans in most of these places
- 37:39was Christianity, and therefore you are it's a correlation fallacy, isn't it So?
- 37:45The idea that Christianity is responsible for these things, as you rightfully point
- 37:49out, is a problem. But a lot of what she says was also
- 37:52I think I think politics was a vehicle by which she got into Christianity.
- 37:57By just by reading what she is saying, a few things caught my eye
- 38:00were quite like this part of the answer is global. So the answers to
- 38:04why she changed and became a Christian, part of the answer is global.
- 38:07Western civilization is under threat from three different but related forces. The resurgence of
- 38:12great power authoritarianism and expansionism in the forms of the Chinese Communist Party in Vladimir
- 38:16Putin's Russia. The rise of global Islamism, which threatens to mobilize a vast
- 38:22population against the West. And a viral spread of woke ideology which is eating
- 38:25into the moral fiber of the next generation. As soon as someone places like
- 38:30anti woke or wokeism at the center of their issues with the world, it
- 38:36sets alarm belts going for me because I think it's such an ill defined term
- 38:39and it tells me more about them and where they are than anything else.
- 38:43And it's like, ah, the viral spread of wok ideologies. So when
- 38:46you start looking into her positioning, it's very much a political thing as much
- 38:52as anything. And I think once you start getting down that rabbit hole of
- 38:54that way of thinking, it's possibly not too surprise that you can see someone
- 39:00jump from like an ardent atheism into Christianity, because there's almost like the horseshoe
- 39:06theory of politics, where you got the extreme left and the extreme right actually
- 39:08quite close to each other. And you can see her sort of light that
- 39:12jumping from just one position to the other as a result of her political leanings.
- 39:17I don't know that that was kind of what I got out of a
- 39:20lot of what she was saying. The word work is such a freaking heart
- 39:23button, and I will be the first to admit I have seen my fellow
- 39:28liberals who have just you know, they've gone off the deep end. I
- 39:31get it. But I've also, more than that, really seen how the
- 39:36word work has been weaponized by the right to attack basic human decency, empathy,
- 39:44equality. We watch Ron Desantistine in Florida, we watch Ryan Walters in
- 39:49my home state. You know, we see the theocrats, the Christian nationalists,
- 39:53and work seems to be their new buzzword. You ask them to define
- 39:57it, good luck with that. It just seems to be any thing that
- 40:00raises their delicate, privileged sensibilities. Talk about work from your perspective, sir,
- 40:07I completely agree with you. I wrote an article on this for Only
- 40:09Guy. Somewhat recently. I was asked to actually by a humanist magazine,
- 40:14who the editor was trying to get different opinions of woke, and he himself
- 40:17was fairly anti woke and wanted me to present the other side. And my
- 40:21position is that it's just such an ill defined term. It basically just is
- 40:25a modern iteration of the term libtard, like it really is that. I
- 40:31guess you know that sounds simplistic and unnuanced, but that's how I see.
- 40:36It's like anything, as you say, anything that I don't like in my
- 40:38political positioning is therefore woke, and it's just really ill defined. But another
- 40:45quote from her in her piece is this, which talks to both that and
- 40:47the idea that she's lacking this sense of meaning and purpose. So she says,
- 40:52in this nihilistic vacuum, the challenge before us becomes civilizational. We can't
- 40:59withstand China, Russia and Iran if we can't explain to our populations why it
- 41:02matters that we do. We can't fight woke ideology if we can't defend the
- 41:07civilization that it is determined to destroy, as if like wokism is going to
- 41:12destroy an entire civilization. This is like moral panic anyway, just to continue
- 41:16a little bit and we can't counter Islamism with purely secular tools. To win
- 41:22the hearts and minds of Muslims here in the West, we have to offer
- 41:25them something more than the videos on TikTok as. If like philosophical secular humanism
- 41:31is just like trashy videos on TikTok as, If we can't take down the
- 41:37theological foundations of Islam with philosophical endeavor, I just really beggars believes claims.
- 41:45Yeah, I've just noticed that it seems to be the word they use whenever
- 41:50they encounter any sort of progressive idea, the idea of collectivist values, equality
- 41:58advocacy. And I spoke year about the Women's March in twenty seventeen as we
- 42:02saw millions of people, women and men actually supporting women who were marching in
- 42:08protest after the Trump inauguration, and they legitimately feared that there was a war
- 42:15on women on reproductive health. There was a sexist, misogynist predator who'd been
- 42:21elected to the most powerful chair in the United States. And so they rightfully
- 42:25and admirably went out and said no, no, we will not be ignored.
- 42:29I in here CLI is like, ah, what a bunch of spoiled,
- 42:31rotten, privileged American women. They're all, you know, they just
- 42:36think that men want to keep them barefoot and pregnant. That was not the
- 42:39position being argued, that was not the statement being made. And I found
- 42:44myself just shouting at the screen when I read the articles, like what the
- 42:46hell I am? Right? Yeah, and which is interesting because she has
- 42:50actually campaigned an awful lot for feminist ideals within the context, particularly of Islam,
- 42:55and so yeah, that's doubly frustrating in that respect. It's a very
- 43:01tongue in cheek comment at the end of my article wrote, well, then
- 43:06she damn well needs to shut up and not be heard from again. The
- 43:08required role for a Christian woman. I mean, he obviously doesn't doesn't mean
- 43:12that should be quiet, but I do not permit a woman to teach.
- 43:19You're going to go two Timothy on an exactly, and so you know,
- 43:22you jump. I don't know it, but sometimes I think when people leave
- 43:28a religion, and admittedly there was a lot there's been a long time since
- 43:31she left Islam to where she is now. But sometimes when I've got a
- 43:36very good friend who is ostensibly left Christianity but he still has that hole in
- 43:42him that was filled by Christianity that he feels cannot be filled by atheism or
- 43:46secular humanism. So he's gone back to some kind of weird deism. But
- 43:52I see that similar thing in many people who come from this staunch kind of
- 43:55religiosity and then can't find the sort so things that they were psychologically brought up
- 44:02with, and so they are searching, possibly for the rest of their lives
- 44:07for that thing to fill that hole. And I think that's what's happened here.
- 44:09So there's in other words, there's a lot of psychology going on here
- 44:14and not an awful lot of rational thought. I had an awkward time with
- 44:17my autobiography, De Converted. Dear friend Teresa McBain left the Methodist Church she
- 44:23was a Methodist minister, and realized she did not buy it. And I
- 44:29asked her to write the forward for De Converted, and she was so kind
- 44:32to do so, and and you know, she went through a series of
- 44:36struggles. I think she had a hard time sort of finding her place in
- 44:39the movement post religion, and I I'm guessing here, I'm watching from my
- 44:46perch over here outside her life. But I got the vibe that she missed
- 44:52the sense of belonging and security and community. All of a sudden, she
- 44:58says, no, I'm going back to the church. I was wrong.
- 45:00I now believe in God, but I couldn't shake the idea that she had
- 45:04remained a drift, and that drift spoke to her missing her tribe, missing
- 45:09the sense of security and belonging. And when I was reading Ian's article,
- 45:14I thought she's talking about how much she missed the feeling of being in a
- 45:20group that was consolidated and structured and even had power, weaponized power against Islam.
- 45:27They are more tooled up than the atheists to fight the Islamic tide.
- 45:31You catch that, well, yeah, there's almost a historical kind of reference
- 45:36in terms of like Crusades and such like. But I do I'm really with
- 45:39you then, that there is this idea that atheism isn't a worldview per se,
- 45:45and trying to collectively appeal to atheists like herding cats. It's so difficult
- 45:52because you have this whole gammut of different philosophical and political opinions within it atheism.
- 45:58Because atheism does very little as a term. It's like it's a proposition.
- 46:01I'm a strong atheist. So it's like it's a proposition that I do
- 46:05not believe in God. But that's all it does. I don't believe in
- 46:07God, so everything else I've got to work out for myself and for someone
- 46:12that you know is used to having a lot of thought done for them,
- 46:15and for someone that is used to being in a social environment that supports them,
- 46:20a kind of familial or social environment that churches or mosques provide. Atheism
- 46:25doesn't do that. Now, I'm not saying that's definitely what's happened with hercy
- 46:29Ellie, because I think she's been out of that environment for a long time.
- 46:31For a lot of people, I think they generally struggle with that.
- 46:35And this is why movements like the Sunday Assembly and things like that do have
- 46:38a place. I think there is a need for bringing like minded people together
- 46:43in social environments that means that you have that supporting environment that can help you
- 46:50get through your daily travails and hopefully do that in a secular way. Well,
- 46:54she says, if we can't find off these formidable for its or column
- 47:00ors of evil or whatever, unless we can answer the question what is it
- 47:04that unites us? The responses that God is dead, seems insufficient, it
- 47:10almost seems tactical. Now we can be a formidable force against our foes.
- 47:17But all this then talks to is the idea that God is merely functional.
- 47:22Again, it goes back to the not rationally justified as a position, but
- 47:25psychologically justified as a need. I need God in order to feel that I've
- 47:31got the right tools, or to feel that I've got something to I guess
- 47:36hide behind or be driven by something. It's that psychological need. I mean
- 47:39I at the end of my article I said, I can't help but think
- 47:43she's singularly failed to interact with the positive philosophy of secular humanism. She's missing
- 47:47all this in her kind of atheistic I guess lack of worldview, just in
- 47:52her atheism that she wanted to find that or she thought she could only find
- 47:59that in Christianity. Well, actually, did you try really hard to find
- 48:02out within secular humanism? What was your interaction with humanism as a worldview?
- 48:07I mean, some people will class humanism as a religion. I know that's
- 48:12debatable and controversial, but in kind of technical times in the UK, for
- 48:15example, in terms of education religious education, we not humanism can be seen
- 48:21as a religion. Well, how much have you interacted with that worldview?
- 48:24Talking here with columnist and philosopher Jonathan MS Peers, she got a couple extra
- 48:30minutes because I just want to keep spitbowing here and talking about some stuff in
- 48:35the article. I didn't wait for your answer either, because I really don't
- 48:37care. I'm going to keep you anyway. That's I am just using and
- 48:45abusing you. In the article, she said atheism is too weak and divisive
- 48:50a doctrine to fortify us against our menacing foes. I'm a frontline atheist activist
- 48:58of a decade and a half. A doctrine are thethism? Is she talking
- 49:04about? This is the whole point, like it, I mean, like
- 49:07we've been saying, it's not a doctrine. To make it a doctrine,
- 49:10you have to then pad it out with an awful lot of other philosophy.
- 49:15I mean, that's what secular humanism is. You know, you start with
- 49:17God doesn't exist, okay, now what, and you construct a worldview from
- 49:22there on in and that may or may not become a doctrine. But you
- 49:27can't, on the one hand, say that there is kind of no doctrine
- 49:30it and it's nihilistic, and then say the doctrine's weak. I mean she's
- 49:34playing around with his ideas of doctrine when really there isn't a doctrine at all.
- 49:38And when it comes to things like meaning and purpose, it's subjective.
- 49:42You have to make it for yourself and don't expect that to be thrust on
- 49:45you by third party like God. And even if you believe in God.
- 49:50So hate to break this to you here, sy Ali, but if you
- 49:52are going to Christianity expecting meaning and purpose, what you're wanting is some someone
- 49:59else, some third identity, either the Christians around you or God, to
- 50:01thrust their own meaning and purpose on you. You're still going to have to
- 50:06interpret that yourself. It's still a subjective process, but it's so much nobler
- 50:10to create your own meaning and purpose. She just gift wrapped to the Evangelicals
- 50:17their claim that atheism is just another religion. Yeah, I mean, I
- 50:23think, as you say, she's handed a lot of arguments to the Evangelicals
- 50:28on a plate. Here is saying exactly the sort of things they're going to
- 50:30be gleefully hearing. I mean, one has to say in certain lights atheism
- 50:37is nihilistic because atheism doesn't tell you anything other than God doesn't exist. Right,
- 50:42So if you think that's all atheism is, which is all it is,
- 50:45but it's therefore necessarily not everything else. Again you have to construct everything
- 50:51else. So you can interpret that as been nihilistic. There is nothing else
- 50:54there. Well, yeah, definitionally there is nothing else there, But that
- 50:59doesn't mean that if if you are an atheist, you have you know,
- 51:01you are nihilistic because you create all this other philosophy around it, and you
- 51:06can live a wonderfully fulfilled life without God. You know, good without God
- 51:10is the badge that many humanists might pin to their lapel. You know,
- 51:15we can be good and we can have these really fulfilling, wonderful communities of
- 51:21non believers who are brought together partly by their non belief but partly by shared
- 51:24understanding of how the universe works and how we can create really vibrant communities.
- 51:30All right, let's just I don't know, let's just render an opinion,
- 51:36and you know, we're just speaking subjectively. I feel like she got burned.
- 51:40She feels burned by liberals and conservative culture is more Christian culture. I
- 51:47feel like part of this is a retreat and to a safer place where she
- 51:51doesn't have to deal with analysis, commentary, criticism, even condemnation when she
- 51:58says, dumb shit, I don't know, what do you think? I'd
- 52:01agree? And I think that here it's almost as if anti woke politics is
- 52:10more important. It drives her more than whether she believes in God or not.
- 52:15That is secondary, Whereas I wouldn't be placing these things against each other.
- 52:20They're just I don't believe in God and I had these political beliefs,
- 52:23and those two aren't necessarily connected. But for her, as you've kind of
- 52:28intimated before, like she sees the only way to battle anti woke ideology is
- 52:32to jump into a Christian worldview or a religious worldview. And you can understand
- 52:37that because it is the Christian nationalists in the US that are consistently banging on
- 52:43about this same idea that you see that so often every time you turn on
- 52:47Fox News. When Tucker Carlson was on there, it was all like anti
- 52:52white, anti whit blah blah blah. But together with that comes the it's
- 52:55almost you know, one without the other is rare. Together comes this Christian
- 53:00worldview, this Christian nationalism as well, and it's all wrapped up with each
- 53:06other, and so that therefore it doesn't surprise me that I think she made
- 53:09what is in the end a relatively small jump, because really her move was
- 53:15a political one rather than a move from atheism to theism. Think any of
- 53:19this is going to really matter. I mean, every BlueMoon or so,
- 53:22we'll see somebody who has been a frontline atheist or has been someone in the
- 53:27public eye, and I don't know, they do something odd, or they're
- 53:30caught in a scandal or you know, some thing shit goes down and everybody's
- 53:36like aha. But at the end of the day, I feel like that
- 53:38I'm not sure it's all that consequential. We're speaking about it because it is
- 53:43newsworthy, and I think people want to know, Hey, what the hell
- 53:45happened and what's your take? But when the dust settles, does it really
- 53:51diminish us? I think because she was like a fringe new atheist mover and
- 53:55shaker, it's quite newsworthy. It's almost like a Kitchens on his deathbed goes,
- 54:00no, he didn't actually, And but she mixed in that crowd a
- 54:05little bit. And so therefore that's pretty newsworthy. But as you say,
- 54:08once in a blue moon tells you everything you need to know. Occasionally this
- 54:13will happen. What you need to do is look at the data. So
- 54:15what does the data say about conversions versus deconversions? Does it more often happen
- 54:21that we have deconversions? Well, I think the data is pretty solid for
- 54:24that. We are seeing a pretty continuous trend away from religious belief. And
- 54:29also I think if it correct me if I'm wrong, I don't if you
- 54:31know, but I think the data also supports that if you deconvert, you're
- 54:35more likely to stay deconverted than if you convert. So I think there's also
- 54:39a long term commitment to atheism or non belief that's more robust than the commitment
- 54:45to theism. But I may be incorrect on that. No, I think
- 54:49your data is correct. I'll have to look up the ccation. But the
- 54:52ratios of a past age is that they stay a past it it it's not
- 54:55like people are leaving a religion and rushing back. If we see the trends
- 55:00of ex religious people leaving church, the rising seculars or nuns, I think
- 55:07the data bears that out. And I think it's striking. So you know,
- 55:10you will find an outlier, and a very public outlier. But I
- 55:14think the trend is actually in the reverse. People are like, this sucks,
- 55:17it's just stupid. I don't buy it, it's damaging. I'm out,
- 55:21and they don't go back once they taste freedom, you know what I'm
- 55:24saying. So there's probably an awful lot of other data as well that doesn't
- 55:28get announced. So when people convert to religion, and I'm speculating here,
- 55:34but I guess people are quite open about that. It's like, oh,
- 55:36I found God again. Oh brilliant, Right, I'm going to tell people
- 55:38about this. You get rather evangelical. But when people who are potentially quite
- 55:42famous, or maybe people who are ensconced within a social and familial networks that
- 55:47are overtly religious, then there's going to be an awful lot of people that
- 55:51leave religion without telling anyone that they've left religion and keep it very personal to
- 55:54themselves. I mean, you will know this from the conversion accounts that people
- 55:58I'm sure have given you over time, that actually there's going to be an
- 56:00awful lot of data that doesn't reflect accurately the sheer number of people who are
- 56:06no longer believers. They're just not prepared to tell other people. Jonathan ms
- 56:09Peiris, Thanks for an impromptu conversation. I just sort of ambushed you because
- 56:14I saw the article and I wanted to jump on this while the story was
- 56:16had any final thoughts about Iane heresy Ali your article the culture before we sign
- 56:22off. Yeah, it's just it's always interesting to look at the intersection of
- 56:25politics and religious belief or non belief, and I think here we have another
- 56:30example where I think the religious belief is probably piggybacking on the back of political
- 56:38belief, and it's that's really what's driving things here. And of course the
- 56:42psychology of you know, needs and desires and meaning and purpose and a lot
- 56:47of that which has its links to religion. But I just think she was
- 56:52philosophically fairly naive and what she was claiming. I'll put your article as a
- 56:57link in the description box. Thanks for signing in and and the sounding off
- 57:00being great to talk to you again, brother, Appreciate you mate. You
- 57:05know, I never want to fall into the no true Scotsman trap, right,
- 57:08Well, she wasn't a true atheist, That's not what I'm saying.
- 57:10I don't think that's what anybody's saying. We just wanted to analyze her quote
- 57:15unquote reasonings given her history and try to figure out what the hell is going
- 57:21on. Anyway, interesting conversation. I've got a self professed sweary historian joining
- 57:28me next week. If you haven't read the work of James Fell, buckle
- 57:30up. This guy's hysterical and he's a hell of a storyteller with a new
- 57:36book called On This Day in History. Shit went down? Oh yeah,
- 57:40we had to talk. He's next week. See you then. Follow The
- 57:44Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 57:49products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist
- 57:53pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log
- 57:59onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.