Latest / Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning / Gregory Cochran: 15 years after The 10,000 Year Explosion
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by the Albany Public Library
- 0:03Main Branch and the
- 0:04SPEAKER_02: generosity of listeners like you.
- 0:09SPEAKER_02: What is a podcast?
- 0:16SPEAKER_02: God Daddy, these people talk as much as you do.
- 0:26SPEAKER_02: Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning
- 0:29SPEAKER_00: Hey everybody,
- 0:29it's Razib with the Unsupervised Learning Podcast and I'm here
- 0:32today with a very
- 0:34SPEAKER_00: special guest,
- 0:36SPEAKER_00: Dr.
- 0:36SPEAKER_00: Gregory Cochran.
- 0:38He has a Twitter and he has a blog,
- 0:41West Hunt,
- 0:43and today we are gonna be talking about
- 0:46Well,
- 0:46natural selection in Western Eurasia,
- 0:49natural selection of the genome.
- 0:51SPEAKER_00: We will be talking first,
- 0:54SPEAKER_00: well,
- 0:54SPEAKER_00: we'll be talking simultaneously,
- 0:55SPEAKER_00: but really first we'll talk about Ali Akbar's paper,
- 0:58SPEAKER_00: Ancient DNA Reveals Pervasive Directional Selection
- 1:01SPEAKER_00: Special Eurasia.
- 1:02SPEAKER_00: We'll talk about that, but we are going to go back.
- 1:05This is a topic that I actually wanted to talk to Greg about
- 1:09for a couple years now.
- 1:11SPEAKER_00: I've talked about this.
- 1:12SPEAKER_00: I do a retrospective on 10,000-Year Explosion,
- 1:15SPEAKER_00: his book that he wrote in 2009,
- 1:16SPEAKER_00: published in 2009.
- 1:22Obviously the ideas are a little older and he co-wrote it with
- 1:26the late Henry
- 1:26Harpending and it also integrates some of Greg's ideas that
- 1:35were articulated in the
- 1:37SPEAKER_00: paper with John Hawks about accelerating evolution.
- 1:41SPEAKER_00: What year was that paper again?
- 1:43SPEAKER_00: 2007, I think.
- 1:45You've been on this recent acceleration of human adaptive
- 1:49evolution with Hawks,
- 1:53SPEAKER_00: Wang,
- 1:54SPEAKER_00: Cochran,
- 1:55SPEAKER_00: and Moises.
- 1:56SPEAKER_00: Yes, that was 2007 in PNAS.
- 1:57SPEAKER_00: So,
- 2:00SPEAKER_00: Anyway, that's the context.
- 2:02SPEAKER_00: I guess we should just start.
- 2:03SPEAKER_00: So the Reich Lab paper,
- 2:06SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:06SPEAKER_00: I've done a podcast about it,
- 2:08SPEAKER_00: and by the time this is published or posted,
- 2:11SPEAKER_00: you will have read my piece in the free press about the paper.
- 2:17SPEAKER_00: Although, you know...
- 2:19You're gonna hear a lot more technical detail in this
- 2:21conversation than in that
- 2:22SPEAKER_00: piece because,
- 2:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:23SPEAKER_00: the audience is different.
- 2:24SPEAKER_00: Anyway,
- 2:25so Ancient DNA Reveals Pervasive Directional Selection Across
- 2:28Western Eurasia,
- 2:28SPEAKER_00: published April 15th,
- 2:30SPEAKER_00: 2026.
- 2:30As most of you know,
- 2:32this has been a paper that was in the works for eight years.
- 2:36SPEAKER_00: and,
- 2:37SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:38SPEAKER_00: it's something we knew the right lab was gonna do because of,
- 2:42SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:42SPEAKER_00: there was,
- 2:43SPEAKER_00: when you download their data,
- 2:44SPEAKER_00: you sign an agreement that you don't,
- 2:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:48SPEAKER_00: publish original stuff on selection.
- 2:50SPEAKER_00: So they're clearly doing that.
- 2:51So it's the outcome of that made a huge press splash even
- 2:54though the preprint's
- 2:55SPEAKER_00: been out for a couple of years.
- 2:56SPEAKER_00: You know, this has been a conference presentation also for years.
- 3:00SPEAKER_00: You know, I heard about this paper
- 3:04SPEAKER_00: from people in Rasmus Nielsen's lab in 2020.
- 3:07SPEAKER_00: Not the paper, but the research.
- 3:09SPEAKER_00: And at that point,
- 3:10SPEAKER_00: they were already joking that it was,
- 3:15SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 3:15SPEAKER_00: they'd been hearing about it for a couple of years.
- 3:17SPEAKER_00: So yeah, that makes sense.
- 3:18SPEAKER_00: because I think Akabari said eight years have been working on it.
- 3:20SPEAKER_00: So two years in, people are making fun of it for being late.
- 3:24SPEAKER_00: And now it's 2026, obviously, you know, six years after that.
- 3:28SPEAKER_00: So it's finally out.
- 3:29SPEAKER_00: And, you know, it's a pretty good paper.
- 3:31SPEAKER_00: It's pretty comprehensive.
- 3:32SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 3:33SPEAKER_00: Introduces new methods and all that stuff.
- 3:35SPEAKER_00: So I've been talking about this.
- 3:37SPEAKER_00: I think you guys have heard my piece.
- 3:41Greg,
- 3:42well,
- 3:43you,
- 3:43both you and John Hawks actually have been talking about this.
- 3:46SPEAKER_00: And I will probably link to, maybe I'll
- 3:48I'll talk to John separately but I'll link to his essay or his
- 3:51post on hisSubstack
- 3:51but tell me what you think how you're feeling about this paper
- 3:55and then the context
- 3:56of like the work that it didn't or did cite also I should say
- 3:59the guest on this
- 4:01SPEAKER_00: podcast David Piefer who has a
- 4:03SPEAKER_00: Substack that I've linked to,
- 4:04SPEAKER_00: and I think many of you have read,
- 4:06SPEAKER_00: has also been complaining that they did not cite prior work,
- 4:09SPEAKER_00: did not cite his work,
- 4:11his work with Emil Kierkegaard and others on directional
- 4:14selection using somewhat
- 4:15SPEAKER_00: different methods,
- 4:16SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 4:16SPEAKER_00: coarser,
- 4:17SPEAKER_00: less robust methods,
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: but whatever,
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: it is what it is.
- 4:20So there's that kind of media scientific ethics controversy
- 4:23that's going on.
- 4:23SPEAKER_00: So with that, Greg, take it away.
- 4:26SPEAKER_00: It's definitely an interesting paper,
- 4:29but I think one of the interesting points is that there were
- 4:35other ways of knowing
- 4:36SPEAKER_01: some of the conclusions,
- 4:39which is one reason I came to somewhat similar conclusions
- 4:42quite a while ago.
- 4:44SPEAKER_01: And those ways seem to be invisible to a lot of people in human genetics.
- 4:52well I mean so what do you mean what sort of ways are you
- 4:54talking about I mean I
- 4:55SPEAKER_00: kind of know but like let's articulate for the listener well here's a
- 5:00SPEAKER_01: Here's a particular example.
- 5:03SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 5:03maybe the strongest selection they found was basically a lot of
- 5:10selection on
- 5:11SPEAKER_01: pathogen defenses in this paper.
- 5:15SPEAKER_01: Things like,
- 5:17think of it as some are specific things against specific
- 5:21infectious diseases
- 5:22SPEAKER_01: probably,
- 5:23but others you would say sort of a general upregulation of the
- 5:26immune system,
- 5:29SPEAKER_01: making things
- 5:30SPEAKER_01: Turning the Volume Up on Immune Defenses.
- 5:34And I would say that it was possible to know that that had
- 5:40happened in places like
- 5:42SPEAKER_01: Europe some time ago.
- 5:45SPEAKER_01: Let's say 50 years, at least.
- 5:48SPEAKER_01: It was easy to know that.
- 5:51SPEAKER_01: But I don't think most people in human genetics did know it.
- 5:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: so the context is I think with human genetics,
- 5:58SPEAKER_00: we're talking about this,
- 5:59SPEAKER_00: a lot of people in human genetics,
- 6:01they come out of medical genetics and they're studying probands
- 6:04and they're
- 6:05SPEAKER_00: studying pedigrees.
- 6:06SPEAKER_00: They're not thinking about selection.
- 6:07SPEAKER_00: They're thinking about how do you identify a genetic locus for a disease?
- 6:11SPEAKER_00: So that is, if you go to the American Society of Human Genetics meetings,
- 6:14SPEAKER_00: American Society of Human Genetics is half MDs, half geneticists.
- 6:17So the medical aspect of genetics is really,
- 6:20really dominant in human genetics historically.
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: And the evolutionary aspect has not been as dominant.
- 6:25Evolutionary geneticists have tended to work in drosophila and
- 6:27stuff like that.
- 6:28SPEAKER_00: So drosophila geneticists or animal breeders,
- 6:31SPEAKER_00: breeders,
- 6:32SPEAKER_00: agricultural geneticists,
- 6:32SPEAKER_00: quantitative geneticists,
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: they also understand selection,
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: right?
- 6:35SPEAKER_00: But human geneticists tend not to.
- 6:38SPEAKER_01: That's certainly part of it.
- 6:39But part of what I'm talking about is something you would have
- 6:42thought the medical
- 6:44SPEAKER_01: types would know.
- 6:46SPEAKER_01: Like a simple example.
- 6:50Like when the Spaniards show up in the New World,
- 6:54Indians start dying like flies.
- 6:57SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 6:58SPEAKER_01: Diseases that were,
- 6:59SPEAKER_01: let's say,
- 6:59serious in Europe are much more serious and much more deadly in
- 7:05affecting people in
- 7:07SPEAKER_01: the Americas and in other isolated populations.
- 7:10And that isn't a secret,
- 7:12and it's kind of a medical story,
- 7:14but apparently nobody knew it.
- 7:16SPEAKER_01: Or at least the people involved in this sort of thing didn't know it,
- 7:19SPEAKER_01: and I don't think you could make them know it.
- 7:27SPEAKER_01: It's a strange story, but it's spectacular.
- 7:31I mean,
- 7:31it shows up as a historical factor,
- 7:35but they act as if it is not true.
- 7:38SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 7:38to the point where if you have a certain place in medicine
- 7:41where people are taking
- 7:42SPEAKER_01: account of some such difference,
- 7:45SPEAKER_01: they're all people trying to make sure you don't.
- 7:49yeah yeah so there's medicine you know human genetics like you
- 7:54know people are
- 7:55ignoring this stuff so I mean obviously well someone like Nick
- 7:59Patterson I'm just
- 8:00going to name some people you know so the authors you know
- 8:04Aliak Barry Annabelle
- 8:05SPEAKER_00: Perry Alice Barton
- 8:07SPEAKER_00: I mean, Nick Patterson knows about selection, right?
- 8:22SPEAKER_00: There are people in this list we don't know about selection, though.
- 8:26But in terms of the literature review and the introduction,
- 8:28it's very genomics-focused.
- 8:30SPEAKER_00: It's very paleogenomics-focused.
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: It's basically how can paleogenomics tell us about selection.
- 8:36SPEAKER_00: If this was,
- 8:37SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: if Ali Akbar is going to write a book,
- 8:39SPEAKER_00: which I don't think he is,
- 8:40SPEAKER_00: but if he was going to write a book,
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: though,
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: I don't think he would write it just about this paper,
- 8:44SPEAKER_00: right?
- 8:45SPEAKER_00: It would be a more thorough introduction.
- 8:48um I don't know I haven't met the guy uh I'd like to sometime I
- 8:52mean I've talked to
- 8:53some of these other people not to that not to uh Alec Berry uh
- 8:57I know that uh uh
- 9:01SPEAKER_01: It's as if,
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 9:03there's just whole areas of relevant knowledge that are never
- 9:08referred to,
- 9:09SPEAKER_01: never.
- 9:10Well,
- 9:11for example,
- 9:13like they use PRS scores for,
- 9:16say,
- 9:17IQ,
- 9:18but they never use IQ.
- 9:21SPEAKER_01: Except in that sense.
- 9:22SPEAKER_01: I mean, people have actually given IQ tests to people.
- 9:26SPEAKER_01: We kind of had to do that in order to get things like PRS scores.
- 9:31But everything in that kind of work has been really
- 9:39energetically ignored.
- 9:42Scores that people actually get in different parts of the
- 9:46world,
- 9:46things like that.
- 9:50The only thing I've ever seen anybody do in this kind of
- 9:54genetics is deny that it exists.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 9:58SPEAKER_00: so PRS,
- 9:59SPEAKER_00: Polygenic Risk Score,
- 10:00SPEAKER_00: just to be clear,
- 10:01that basically means that you look at the genes and you tote up
- 10:05what the predicted
- 10:06SPEAKER_00: phenotype is based just on the genes instead of measuring them,
- 10:09SPEAKER_00: right?
- 10:10SPEAKER_01: Of course,
- 10:12somebody had to have done lots of tests and then do statistical
- 10:18checks to see how
- 10:19SPEAKER_01: the genes affected those test results.
- 10:21SPEAKER_01: I mean, here we have PRS scores, but there are no IQ tests.
- 10:26SPEAKER_01: or there are no test results.
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: And if they exist, they have to be ignored.
- 10:31SPEAKER_01: I mean, completely.
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: It's weird.
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: But I mean,
- 10:39SPEAKER_01: to the extent that how much of the things that are the results,
- 10:44SPEAKER_01: and I'm not talking about genetic details because for the most part,
- 10:47SPEAKER_01: we did not know those,
- 10:48SPEAKER_01: although we know a few of them perhaps.
- 10:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 10:50SPEAKER_01: But the general trends were already known.
- 10:56SPEAKER_01: If you thought about it for three minutes,
- 11:00SPEAKER_01: you would have come to a similar conclusion on a lot of it.
- 11:04SPEAKER_01: I think that's interesting.
- 11:07I don't think it's the only interesting question,
- 11:09but I think it's interesting to me.
- 11:12SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 11:12SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 11:12SPEAKER_00: so what do you think real quickly,
- 11:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:14some people like Sasha Gusev and earlier Graham Coop back when
- 11:16the preprint was
- 11:18SPEAKER_00: new,
- 11:18SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:19have talked about they don't believe in the robustness of the
- 11:22methods to control
- 11:23SPEAKER_00: for,
- 11:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:25SPEAKER_00: various things.
- 11:26What do you think about that,
- 11:27like in terms of the population structure or whatever?
- 11:28I think you should take those two guys and have them teach an
- 11:33AP calculus course to
- 11:35SPEAKER_01: some pure-blooded Australian aborigines.
- 11:40SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 11:41SPEAKER_00: There we go.
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: For the next five years.
- 11:44SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 11:45SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 11:45SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 11:46SPEAKER_00: That's fair enough.
- 11:47SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 11:48SPEAKER_00: All right.
- 11:49SPEAKER_00: So,
- 11:50SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:51SPEAKER_00: what do you think about,
- 11:52SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 11:52SPEAKER_00: David's complaints that they're not citing people?
- 11:55SPEAKER_00: I mean, I think you have that complaint, too, probably to some extent.
- 11:58SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 12:02SPEAKER_01: You know, in a better world, people might cite things.
- 12:05SPEAKER_01: It's up to them.
- 12:06SPEAKER_01: I don't expect much.
- 12:09SPEAKER_01: I could go on, but I don't expect much.
- 12:12I also know that they are sort of,
- 12:15to some extent,
- 12:16navigating political currents and so forth.
- 12:20And naturally,
- 12:23that's just the most fascinating and wonderful thing to me in
- 12:25the world.
- 12:25And I certainly spend all my time trying to think of how to do
- 12:29similar things.
- 12:32I mean,
- 12:32it's probably necessary if you want to run a big lab and get
- 12:36money.
- 12:37SPEAKER_01: But it ends up with you saying things like,
- 12:40SPEAKER_01: well,
- 12:40SPEAKER_01: it's,
- 12:42SPEAKER_01: I am paraphrasing,
- 12:43SPEAKER_01: check me for accuracy,
- 12:45SPEAKER_01: in Reich's book when he was talking about,
- 12:48SPEAKER_01: well,
- 12:48SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 12:49SPEAKER_01: we're going to find that populations are different,
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: even in things like psychological stuff,
- 12:54SPEAKER_01: and it's foolish to pretend that isn't so,
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: but they'll probably be the opposite differences of what we think.
- 13:03SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, you know what I said, right?
- 13:06SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:08SPEAKER_01: Well, that's bullshit.
- 13:11SPEAKER_01: And as such, it sort of offends me.
- 13:14SPEAKER_01: By the way, will there be surprises?
- 13:16SPEAKER_01: Oh, yeah.
- 13:19SPEAKER_01: Will we end up that,
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: like if Group X consistently shows a certain difference that,
- 13:26SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 13:26a detailed genetic investigation will show it's really in the
- 13:29opposite direction?
- 13:30SPEAKER_01: Well, it hasn't happened yet.
- 13:33SPEAKER_01: And it's inherently kind of improbable that
- 13:36But,
- 13:37you know,
- 13:37when you deliberately lie,
- 13:39that's kind of going to be an improbable statement.
- 13:41SPEAKER_01: And of course, that was a deliberate lie on Reich's part.
- 13:46I think I understand why,
- 13:49but I think there's no other way to characterize it.
- 13:53SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 13:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
- 13:55SPEAKER_01: I mean, what do you think?
- 13:56SPEAKER_01: How likely is it going to be that,
- 13:58SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 13:58SPEAKER_01: the people with the greatest genetic potential for height are,
- 14:02SPEAKER_01: let's say,
- 14:03SPEAKER_01: the pygmies?
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: I don't think so.
- 14:08SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 14:09SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 14:09SPEAKER_00: so with pygmies,
- 14:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 14:10SPEAKER_00: with the height stuff,
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: though,
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: at least,
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 14:11SPEAKER_00: that is,
- 14:12SPEAKER_00: like,
- 14:12SPEAKER_00: resolved in terms of,
- 14:13SPEAKER_00: like,
- 14:13SPEAKER_00: the more,
- 14:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 14:14SPEAKER_00: there have been admixture analyses where,
- 14:15SPEAKER_00: like,
- 14:15SPEAKER_00: the more pygmy ancestry someone has,
- 14:18SPEAKER_00: the shorter they are,
- 14:19SPEAKER_00: you know.
- 14:19SPEAKER_01: I was impressed with Bantu ancestry because there is a mixture.
- 14:22SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: There is a mixture.
- 14:24SPEAKER_00: Yeah, sure.
- 14:25So you're explicitly correcting for,
- 14:26I mean,
- 14:27it's basically,
- 14:27like,
- 14:28you know,
- 14:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so we know the pygmies are short.
- 14:31Some people have said stupid things like,
- 14:33oh,
- 14:33the pygmies are short because they're oppressed.
- 14:37SPEAKER_00: There have been anthropologists that have said things like that.
- 14:39SPEAKER_00: Oh, they're short because they're marginalized.
- 14:41SPEAKER_00: Well, no, no, no.
- 14:43SPEAKER_00: The pygmies
- 14:43SPEAKER_00: that are taller have more Bantu ancestry and vice versa, right?
- 14:47And mixture studies are a way to look at some of these
- 14:51differences in which you
- 14:54don't have the same concerns about portability of PRS scores
- 14:58and so forth.
- 14:59SPEAKER_01: And they're fairly often done for medical purposes.
- 15:05SPEAKER_01: And they're occasionally done for forbidden purposes.
- 15:09SPEAKER_01: But when they do,
- 15:10SPEAKER_01: they all come up with the answer that,
- 15:12SPEAKER_01: oh yeah,
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: well,
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:13you're between these two groups and the closer you are to one
- 15:17in your admixture,
- 15:18SPEAKER_01: on the whole,
- 15:19SPEAKER_01: the closer you are to the phenotype.
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: So,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 15:27SPEAKER_01: and a fair amount is known about that,
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: but,
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:29I don't get the impression that that's ever mentioned in any of
- 15:33this sort of work
- 15:35SPEAKER_01: either.
- 15:35SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 15:36SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 15:37SPEAKER_01: But it's simpler to do than to do,
- 15:41SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:41SPEAKER_01: the various sorts of corrections and check,
- 15:44SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:44SPEAKER_01: trying to look for selection itself and not,
- 15:47SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:48SPEAKER_01: not add mixtures of different groups,
- 15:49SPEAKER_01: although those differences,
- 15:51SPEAKER_01: too,
- 15:52SPEAKER_01: were generated by selection because,
- 15:54SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 15:54essentially everybody outside of Africa has common ancestry
- 15:59generally no later than
- 16:01SPEAKER_01: about 50,000 years ago.
- 16:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 16:05SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's the latest.
- 16:06SPEAKER_01: and sometimes a lot more recently.
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: So,
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 16:10SPEAKER_01: one of the players in this study,
- 16:12SPEAKER_01: one of the groups,
- 16:13SPEAKER_01: we have basically three groups making up the ancestors of Europeans.
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: We have the early farmers from the Middle East, EEF.
- 16:24SPEAKER_01: We have the steppe peoples, the Indo-Europeans.
- 16:28SPEAKER_01: But before that, we had
- 16:30SPEAKER_01: Hunter-Gatherers occupying Europe.
- 16:33But those hunter-gatherers are not people who have been in
- 16:36Europe for 50,000 or
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: 40,000 or 30,000 years.
- 16:39They're largely descended from groups in probably Anatolia more
- 16:46like 15,000 years
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: ago,
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: not a major source.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: So, for example, the time to the last common ancestry of the
- 16:59SPEAKER_01: Hunter-Gatherers and the farmers coming in is not a really long time.
- 17:05I mean,
- 17:07they seem to have common roots maybe 6,000 years earlier,
- 17:11something like that.
- 17:14SPEAKER_01: So it's interesting.
- 17:16SPEAKER_01: Why are they different?
- 17:18SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 17:19Well,
- 17:19I mean,
- 17:20one thing we know is that the farmers have basal Eurasian,
- 17:23right?
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 17:27SPEAKER_00: which the Mesolithic populations,
- 17:30SPEAKER_00: they didn't have it or they had it at much lower levels if they had it,
- 17:32SPEAKER_00: right?
- 17:32SPEAKER_00: So that is interesting.
- 17:34SPEAKER_00: But basically the Mesolithic,
- 17:36SPEAKER_00: so the Villabruna Cluster that you're talking about,
- 17:37SPEAKER_00: the Villabruna Cluster,
- 17:39It seems to have emerged from the Balkans slash Anatolia at
- 17:43some point in the
- 17:44SPEAKER_00: Pleistocene,
- 17:45SPEAKER_00: at some point after the last glacial maximum.
- 17:47SPEAKER_00: So there were people in that region that didn't have basal Eurasian,
- 17:51SPEAKER_00: but there were other people in Anatolia.
- 17:54There's a sample out of the Caucasus like 30,000 years ago or
- 17:58something like 20 or
- 17:59SPEAKER_00: maybe like 20-some thousand years ago.
- 18:01SPEAKER_00: The Duna, I think is what it's called.
- 18:02SPEAKER_00: There's a preprint.
- 18:04SPEAKER_00: The paper never got published.
- 18:05SPEAKER_00: It was basically...
- 18:06SPEAKER_00: All the info and the data was just moved into other papers,
- 18:09SPEAKER_00: but it shows that that individual had basal Eurasian ancestry,
- 18:12SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 18:13SPEAKER_00: 25,
- 18:13SPEAKER_00: 30,000 years ago in the Middle East,
- 18:16SPEAKER_00: so,
- 18:17SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 18:17SPEAKER_00: they were,
- 18:18SPEAKER_00: it seems like they were absorbed earlier in an Apache way into different
- 18:21SPEAKER_00: populations,
- 18:22SPEAKER_00: but
- 18:22SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so these are the European populations that you have.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: I think one of the fascinating things,
- 18:26SPEAKER_00: and I haven't gotten into this,
- 18:29is they partitioned the results also in some of their charts
- 18:36between Mesolithic
- 18:37SPEAKER_00: foragers,
- 18:38SPEAKER_00: Neolithic farmers,
- 18:39SPEAKER_00: and Yamnaya step pastoralists.
- 18:42SPEAKER_00: So you see sometimes,
- 18:43SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 18:44SPEAKER_00: with intelligence,
- 18:46it goes up with the Neolithic and then it drops back with that
- 18:49Yamnaya before going
- 18:50SPEAKER_00: back up,
- 18:50SPEAKER_00: right?
- 18:51SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 18:51SPEAKER_01: And what I think is going on,
- 18:54SPEAKER_01: although I think I'd put it as a pretty likely explanation,
- 19:01SPEAKER_01: is that a lot of this has to do with how long you've been farming.
- 19:05Now,
- 19:05with the EEF coming in,
- 19:10they had already been farming for a while before.
- 19:13SPEAKER_01: They were farmers when they came to Europe,
- 19:15but they had been farming for several thousand years before
- 19:18that in the Middle
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: East.
- 19:20SPEAKER_01: Not enormous,
- 19:22SPEAKER_01: less than 10,
- 19:23SPEAKER_01: but perhaps as much as 4,000 or 5,000 years in the beginnings of farming.
- 19:29Whereas,
- 19:29for example,
- 19:30it looks a lot like the Indo-Europeans were pretty close
- 19:36They really had probably not done more than about a very small
- 19:41amount of farming.
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: They're basically a bunch of hunter-gatherers and fishermen,
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: more specifically,
- 19:48SPEAKER_01: that ended up becoming pastoralists.
- 19:53SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 19:54SPEAKER_01: Which is, by the way, somehow—
- 19:57SPEAKER_01: I think it's somehow an easier thing for people to switch to.
- 20:01SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 20:02SPEAKER_00: This was true with Australian Aborigines.
- 20:03SPEAKER_00: They got involved in becoming shepherds pretty easily.
- 20:07I would say something like that was probably true of the Turks
- 20:10and Mongols as well.
- 20:12SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 20:13SPEAKER_01: They went straight from perhaps from being hunters to being herdsmen.
- 20:22SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well, they went from hunters to herdsmen.
- 20:23SPEAKER_00: They also had some millet farming going on,
- 20:26SPEAKER_00: but what we know about the Mongols,
- 20:28SPEAKER_00: like Genghis Khan,
- 20:29SPEAKER_00: his life,
- 20:30SPEAKER_00: there was a period where he was a forager.
- 20:32SPEAKER_00: They used to call, I think, the Merkids tribe did a lot of foraging.
- 20:37They called them rat eaters,
- 20:38probably just because they hunted so many,
- 20:40I guess,
- 20:41rodents.
- 20:41SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 20:43SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
- 20:44SPEAKER_00: so that's definitely interesting to see in the data,
- 20:47SPEAKER_00: and I think you would have anticipated.
- 20:50SPEAKER_00: Actually,
- 20:51SPEAKER_00: I want to ask you real quick,
- 20:52SPEAKER_00: and then we'll go to 10,000 a year,
- 20:54SPEAKER_00: because I want to talk about it chapter by chapter.
- 20:56SPEAKER_00: There's not that many chapters, but we've got like seven chapters.
- 20:59SPEAKER_00: So...
- 21:03SPEAKER_00: Daveed Peefer's complaints.
- 21:06SPEAKER_00: I know that you said that people don't cite.
- 21:08SPEAKER_00: That just happens.
- 21:09SPEAKER_00: Do you think he's got some legitimate complaints?
- 21:11SPEAKER_00: Some people don't cite,
- 21:13SPEAKER_01: but in some areas you don't have the political,
- 21:17SPEAKER_01: oh,
- 21:19SPEAKER_01: we don't want to cite those naughty people problems.
- 21:22SPEAKER_01: Although there's more to it than that because,
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: for example,
- 21:27when Hawks and I wrote that paper saying that it was very
- 21:30likely that we had mixed
- 21:31with Neanderthals and some of the alleles would probably be
- 21:36advantageous and would
- 21:37SPEAKER_01: have been selected,
- 21:40SPEAKER_01: we got very few sites from people you would have thought would have.
- 21:43I think there is—and I don't think that one was politically
- 21:48very sensitive.
- 21:49SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 21:51I think there's just a lot of people who don't cite if you're
- 21:55not part of the right club.
- 21:59SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 21:59SPEAKER_01: and there's other things which are sort of alien to me,
- 22:02SPEAKER_01: but they're probably the way things are,
- 22:04SPEAKER_01: which is in biology,
- 22:08SPEAKER_01: most of biology,
- 22:10SPEAKER_01: predictions of things are not considered even meaningful.
- 22:17in physics it's very much different and by the way I will say
- 22:23clearly better
- 22:26Not Just Different Biology Tends To Not Much Believe In Theory
- 22:31Even When It Has A
- 22:33Correct Theory Which Is It's A Mistake There's Not Much
- 22:39Positive To Be Said About
- 22:40It But They Don't So Maybe That's Part Of It Maybe A
- 22:47Theoretical Prediction Isn't
- 22:49SPEAKER_01: Considered I Mean I Don't Think It's Considered To Be Anything At All
- 22:55SPEAKER_01: I certainly have had certain people say,
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: well,
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 22:58you predicted X and it was true and you predicted Y and it was
- 23:01true and you
- 23:02SPEAKER_01: predicted Z and it was true,
- 23:04SPEAKER_01: but those are all just coincidences.
- 23:08So I guess the first thing I want to talk about is Chapter 2,
- 23:12The Neanderthal Within.
- 23:14SPEAKER_00: And this came out in 2009.
- 23:16SPEAKER_00: I don't know if you could have timed it better,
- 23:19SPEAKER_00: because the Neanderthal Introgression Admixture Paper,
- 23:22SPEAKER_00: I think it was in Science,
- 23:24SPEAKER_00: came out in the spring of 2010,
- 23:27SPEAKER_00: which basically established two
- 23:29SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 23:30there were still people that were talking about ancient
- 23:33population structure and
- 23:34SPEAKER_00: other things,
- 23:35but basically established to most people's certainty that there
- 23:38was Neanderthal
- 23:38SPEAKER_00: admixture.
- 23:40SPEAKER_00: You had been writing,
- 23:41SPEAKER_00: actually,
- 23:42you had been writing and talking about this along with John for
- 23:47actually many years
- 23:48SPEAKER_00: before 2009.
- 23:49SPEAKER_01: Well, several years.
- 23:51SPEAKER_00: I mean, probably no more than 10, less, a little less than 10.
- 23:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 23:58SPEAKER_01: something like that.
- 23:59SPEAKER_01: But we were not the only people who ever said that it was likely.
- 24:04There was certainly a current of thought going back a long time
- 24:07saying it probably
- 24:09SPEAKER_01: would have happened,
- 24:10SPEAKER_01: although there were probably more people.
- 24:13SPEAKER_01: Certainly the majority of people in human genetics said the opposite.
- 24:17SPEAKER_01: But we weren't the first people to ever say it.
- 24:22SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's fair.
- 24:26This is a prediction that was conformed almost immediately,
- 24:32pretty soon afterwards.
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: So the key I will say is there were people
- 24:37Jeff Wall and others besides you and John and Henry Harpending
- 24:44who had written
- 24:44SPEAKER_00: about this sort of stuff in the likelihood using genomic data.
- 24:47But I think Magnus Nordberg showed how the early mitochondrial
- 24:52work that showed
- 24:53Neanderthals were an outgroup could not actually refute the
- 24:57proposition of
- 24:58admixture because it's a single locus and all these things
- 25:02you're expecting a
- 25:03SPEAKER_00: certain level of drift.
- 25:04There's a lot of theoretical reasons why,
- 25:06you know,
- 25:06admixture was possible.
- 25:08SPEAKER_00: And I want to reiterate for the listener,
- 25:10SPEAKER_00: the reason that we know that it,
- 25:11SPEAKER_00: or we think it likely happened is,
- 25:12SPEAKER_00: well,
- 25:12SPEAKER_00: we actually got that Neanderthal genome.
- 25:14SPEAKER_00: And it just turns out,
- 25:15SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 25:16SPEAKER_00: Eurasians or non-Africans,
- 25:18SPEAKER_00: their genome resembles Neanderthals more than African genomes resemble
- 25:22SPEAKER_00: Neanderthals.
- 25:22SPEAKER_00: And like,
- 25:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 25:23one of the number one ways that that could be is they got
- 25:26Neanderthal ancestry
- 25:27SPEAKER_00: about a couple of percent,
- 25:29SPEAKER_00: a couple of percent.
- 25:30SPEAKER_00: Although in...
- 25:33Like Patterson's calculations,
- 25:34it was only about 40 standard deviations more likely.
- 25:40But go ahead,
- 25:40yeah,
- 25:41that there had been such a mixture into people outside Africa.
- 25:47SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that was a fun moment.
- 25:50SPEAKER_01: I can tell you one fun thing that happened in 2010.
- 25:55SPEAKER_01: There was a conference in Albuquerque.
- 25:57which is one of the very few times of conferences I go to and
- 26:01not even then half
- 26:02the time but John and I were there and there were people it
- 26:08started leaking because
- 26:10there were people reviewing the paper this was slightly before
- 26:13the publication in
- 26:14SPEAKER_02: Nature and it's fair to say we were enjoying ourselves yeah I will say
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: Okay,
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: so,
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: and this was the one that a lot,
- 26:28but a lot of people also did say that of the various things
- 26:30that you're seeing in
- 26:31SPEAKER_00: 10,000-year explosion,
- 26:32SPEAKER_00: this was the one that got like the most assent,
- 26:34SPEAKER_00: though,
- 26:35SPEAKER_00: in terms of like,
- 26:35SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 26:36SPEAKER_00: that's quite likely,
- 26:36SPEAKER_00: right?
- 26:37SPEAKER_01: Well, had it already been done...
- 26:40SPEAKER_01: In terms of people saying it was likely,
- 26:42SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 26:43a lot of people said it was likely after they already knew it
- 26:45had happened.
- 26:47SPEAKER_01: That's good, actually.
- 26:49But I know the general sorts of things that people in human
- 26:54genetics were saying,
- 26:55SPEAKER_01: and they were kind,
- 26:57SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 26:57SPEAKER_01: who mostly did not think it.
- 27:01SPEAKER_01: And I thought they were rather silly.
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: But
- 27:04SPEAKER_01: But I could expand on that a little bit.
- 27:07I can also tell you why we thought it was clear that it was
- 27:10extremely likely it
- 27:11SPEAKER_01: would have happened.
- 27:13SPEAKER_01: And it wasn't that complicated an argument.
- 27:15SPEAKER_01: I mean, basically, I would say the key part was saying that...
- 27:20We have a lot of information on how long two mammal populations
- 27:27need to split
- 27:28SPEAKER_01: before typically you start having serious fertility problems.
- 27:32SPEAKER_01: Sister species that had a common ancestry.
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 27:37How big does X have to be before it's fairly difficult to have
- 27:43offspring?
- 27:44SPEAKER_01: And the answer, I mean, and this is something that it varies.
- 27:47SPEAKER_01: I mean, there's some animals that will surprise you.
- 27:50They've separated longer than you think,
- 27:52but it's about,
- 27:54roughly speaking,
- 27:552 million years.
- 27:57SPEAKER_01: And it was pretty clear that Neanderthals had not,
- 28:01SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 28:01SPEAKER_01: from the fossil record,
- 28:03SPEAKER_01: that Neanderthals had not split that long ago.
- 28:06SPEAKER_01: More like, you know, 600,000, 800,000, something like that.
- 28:12SPEAKER_01: So I said, what are the odds that there'll be mutual fertility?
- 28:17SPEAKER_01: They said, I don't know, 90%.
- 28:20SPEAKER_01: You know, very likely.
- 28:23SPEAKER_01: But then there were the funny parts of it.
- 28:25Since I saw various people say humans wouldn't have done
- 28:29anything that disgusting.
- 28:31SPEAKER_01: I love those people.
- 28:33SPEAKER_01: I would like to hear them talk more because they're funny.
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: So there were people saying,
- 28:40SPEAKER_01: well,
- 28:40SPEAKER_01: Neanderthals look too different and they were weird,
- 28:42SPEAKER_01: so people wouldn't have had sex with them.
- 28:44SPEAKER_01: And I remember thinking...
- 28:46SPEAKER_01: You don't get out much, do you?
- 28:49SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 28:49SPEAKER_01: You've never been in a bar at one o'clock in the morning.
- 28:53SPEAKER_01: You've never even been drunk.
- 28:57SPEAKER_01: So I thought those people were fun.
- 29:03SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 29:03SPEAKER_01: there were other people who had various comments such as,
- 29:08SPEAKER_01: well,
- 29:08SPEAKER_01: I remember a certain Nobel Prize winner who would say,
- 29:11SPEAKER_01: well,
- 29:12SPEAKER_01: even if there was a little bit of admixture,
- 29:15SPEAKER_01: it probably wouldn't have been genetically significant.
- 29:18SPEAKER_01: That was Svante Pabo.
- 29:20SPEAKER_01: But that's because that was wrong,
- 29:22SPEAKER_01: but that's because he doesn't know any population genetics at all.
- 29:26SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 29:28SPEAKER_01: even,
- 29:28SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 29:28if you had a 1% admixture that gives enormous numbers of
- 29:32opportunities for
- 29:34SPEAKER_01: favorable,
- 29:35that means many copies of each favorable gene have been
- 29:37injected into the other
- 29:38SPEAKER_01: group.
- 29:40SPEAKER_01: There's a fair chance,
- 29:41SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 29:42SPEAKER_01: if they really are favorable,
- 29:43SPEAKER_01: they have a reasonable chance of spreading,
- 29:45SPEAKER_01: a computable chance.
- 29:47SPEAKER_01: You know, this was something figured out by Haldane.
- 29:50SPEAKER_01: It's sort of like Haldane back in 1927.
- 29:53SPEAKER_01: It's kind of like
- 29:56It's very similar to the chance of a favorable new mutation
- 29:59happening spontaneously.