Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Are All Signs Pointing To Michigan Steeling Itself For Significant NCAA Violations?
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:06here as sometimes with Mark Givler. Mark, how's it going. It's been
- 0:12an interesting few days, really, been gearing up with the recruiting stuff for
- 0:16this huge weekend with Penn State. It's Ohio State's biggest visitor list, and
- 0:21all of a sudden, we've got national college football bombshells dropping. Yeah,
- 0:26we've we thought we'd jump on and get into this Michigan thing. NCAA and
- 0:31CIA investigating Michigan football for alleged rule violations related to sign stealing, perhaps some
- 0:40on site scouting of opponents, which is also illegal or at least against the
- 0:46rules. And we'd been hearing for a little while that there's there's been some
- 0:51rumblings that something is going on at Michigan, and we're I'll assume this is
- 0:55it, although with the Jim Jim Harbaugh's program at this point, you don't
- 1:00want to assume that things are over in terms of what else they could come
- 1:03up with. But already being investigated by the NCAA for numerous violations, including
- 1:10essentially lying or not being forthcoming, with the NCAA already having served a three
- 1:15game imposed suspension from the school itself and still waiting to hear more from the
- 1:21NCAAA. And now this comes down, Mark, what was your first thought
- 1:26why this broke? I had a few. It's hard to limited to one.
- 1:32I think the first thing though, that kind of came to my head
- 1:34like not another thing here, like just like, you've already been suspended this
- 1:42year by your school. It's very obvious the way his contracts has been handled,
- 1:47his contract situation has been handled over the years, and the rumors of
- 1:49him kind of flirting with the NFL over the years, very obvious that there
- 1:53are people at Michigan that don't see idi with Jim Harball, that maybe don't
- 1:59get along very well with Jim Harbaugh. It seems like there's a lot of
- 2:01disconnect between the administration there and Jim Harball. So that was kind of my
- 2:08first thing was can he afford another scandal here? Well? I mean and
- 2:16games, what are you doing that? Like? What is the punishment now
- 2:20if this has found out to be true? Well, and there's still probably
- 2:23more suspension to come from the previous stuff, because there was sort of an
- 2:29agreed upon four game suspension and then Harbaugh and the NCAA backed out of that.
- 2:34So the NCAA apparently wasn't even happy with a four game suspension. So
- 2:37why would anybody think they're gonna be okay with the three that Michigan gave them.
- 2:40And now you've got this coming down, You wonder in terms of we've
- 2:46seen the NCAA when they get angry, they can and if you're purposefully you
- 2:51lie to them, or you're just flaunting and going around the rules or not
- 2:57adhering to them, then they can hand down some harsher penalties. But with
- 3:04the way that Jim Harbaugh reacted to the four game suspension and then not even
- 3:09I don't even know that he agreed with the three, but it seemed like
- 3:12once all this stuff was happening, that just meant he's gone after this year,
- 3:15like he is going to go to the NFL. And then I know
- 3:17there was a one of the sites that covers Michigan has been talking in the
- 3:23last couple of weeks about there could be an extension coming for Jim Harbaugh in
- 3:27the coming weeks. It may may not be, but could and with this,
- 3:31like, doesn't that have to even if that portion was true of an
- 3:37extension coming for Jim Harbaugh like with this if this is true, and it
- 3:43sure sounds like the Big ten is taking it seriously and the NCAA is taking
- 3:46it seriously, And I'll be interested to see how many loopholes that people have
- 3:51to climb through to say that it's all up above board. But it's it's
- 3:58It would be difficult for me to believe that men would give him an extension,
- 4:00knowing what you just said that there are some people that he's that have
- 4:03grown tired of him. It seems like he's grown tired of a lot of
- 4:08people there as well, and he's been trying to leave four years. So
- 4:14it sure seems to me like this was this is not an exit plan,
- 4:17but he's okay with this being an exit plan. It would seem so on
- 4:24the surface that that's what's going on here. You know. Then again,
- 4:28I think we all thought he might be gone at the end of last year,
- 4:30and I think we know why he wasn't. The previous couple of years,
- 4:32there weren't really NFL teams weren't knocking down his door, you know,
- 4:35coming off of two and four COVID year or whatever. So it's going to
- 4:41be interesting to see kind of what his options might be with the NFL.
- 4:46And the one thing I'll say right away, they're not going to care about
- 4:47this. This the NFL. The NFL is not going to care like this
- 4:53is not like they don't care about recruiting violations. They don't. They'll they'll
- 4:58gently maybe tell him, don't go Little Belichick once you get here, but
- 5:01they're not going to not offer him a job because of NCAA violations. It's
- 5:06just not gonna be a thing. So so from there it's kind of interesting,
- 5:11like what's what's he gonna have available to him? And I think the
- 5:14point you raise is interesting this happened. This is one of the other things
- 5:16that was flowing through my mind was they were just talking about an extension coming
- 5:21out like any day now, like any week now. This was going to
- 5:26be announced, some extension for Harball. And I don't know how if you're
- 5:32Michigan, kind of like what you have to put into an extension offer if
- 5:36you offer him an extension now at all, you don't know if he's gonna
- 5:40be your coach not not because of the NFL. Like that's whatever. There's
- 5:43there's always stuff in the contract for that, but you don't know, like,
- 5:46are we going to sign him to some like ten million dollars a year
- 5:49contract and he's not going to get an NFL offer or he's not gonna you
- 5:55know, go to the NFL, and then we're gonna get hit with you
- 5:59know, sanctions and we're gonna get hit with suspensions for Jim Harbaugh. And
- 6:04then what it just creates a mess where you don't know if the contract extension
- 6:11you're going to sign now could be totally like could blow up in your face,
- 6:15laugh out, like the Mel Tucker extension that took like twelve months to
- 6:17blow up Michigan State's face. This could blow up in your face like instantly
- 6:21if this goes sideways for them, well, and I imagine at this point,
- 6:28if there is an extension, the lawyers are going back over it and
- 6:30to add some NCAA violation stuff, and then if it gets too accusatory or
- 6:38too like, you shouldn't be putting this stuff into a contract about me.
- 6:41I'm Jim Harbaugh, I'm clean cut. Like if as all of these clauses
- 6:45in it, then it might be something that he's like, I don't that's
- 6:47an insult to me. Because I'm Jim Harbaugh and I do things above board.
- 6:50And it's like, well, the evidence has shown that the NCAA disagrees,
- 6:55so or at least other people disagree, and they've brought the NCAAA in.
- 7:00That's another interesting thing because Greg Ciano is mentioned during the halftime the interview
- 7:08of the Michigan game, Rutgers head coach Greg Ciano said there's some some things
- 7:12going on that they need to they need to just he was being I don't
- 7:16I don't remember the exact words, but just like there's some things that that
- 7:19are going on that he's not happy with. And it was an odd conversation
- 7:24at the time. Now it makes a lot more sense. And my thing
- 7:29is if you are going to steal signs from Rutgers, like if you have
- 7:32to steal signs from Rutgers, it's one of these things that you lie little,
- 7:35lie big, Like if you'll steal signs from Rutgers, you'll steal signs
- 7:39from anybody, and you'll do who knows, who knows what else. And
- 7:44so the Yahoo story that came out said there are two teams that went to
- 7:46the Big Ten about this. So I'm gonna assume Rutgers was one the other
- 7:50three Big Ten teams they played with Nebraska, Minnesota, and Indiana. And
- 7:58if you're stealing signs against those offenses and defenses, that's pretty pitiful because you
- 8:05should be You're Michigan, you should be good enough to do it with without
- 8:09those things. And that was that was maybe my first thought is you've got
- 8:13to steal signs in a Big Ten? It's crazy. But how long has
- 8:20this been going on? I mean, do we know that this is just
- 8:24like it sounds like they're trying to get to the bottom of that, Like
- 8:26do we know that these allegations are you know, just relevant for this season?
- 8:31Have did they like I mean it's part of their allegations for the other
- 8:37stuff or like hosting visitors I think during COVID and and how we're having informiscible
- 8:41contact during COVID. Did they just like go into COVID and then be like,
- 8:46Okay, we're just gonna, you know, do whatever we want now.
- 8:50I mean it just did they come out of that COVID year like at
- 8:54two and four like, oh yeah, we gotta we gotta start changing things
- 8:56around here, because I don't think they just want to. Why would they
- 9:00have just started this year. Yeah, and I'm I guarantee all of the
- 9:05teams they've faced are going to go back and look and try to do the
- 9:09math on how many plays, Like how did you know that play we have?
- 9:13We hadn't shown that at all, and yet you called the right play.
- 9:16It's like playing techmo ball when you only have four plays to choose from
- 9:20it. So it's easier to hit on the right play when you're picking against
- 9:24an opponent. But for you to size up somebody and they do something that
- 9:28they haven't shown before and you you do you know, or they've only shown
- 9:31it a couple of times and you're there to match it. I think everybody's
- 9:35going to go back and try to I don't know if it's gonna be this
- 9:37season, although I guess maybe that's what interns and everybody else is for,
- 9:41like go go try to see and just take a look at what has happened
- 9:46in the past, and you know, I don't know. They say COVID
- 9:48gave people, gives people. One of the things is brain fog. Maybe
- 9:52it gave Michigan brain fog. Regarding NCAA rules, although there are also not
- 10:01there are there are no rules about stealing signs organically, like with your eyeballs
- 10:07and relaying them with the to the person next to you, but there are
- 10:09rules about doing it via electronic equipment and then relaying it to players via electronic
- 10:16equipment. So my thing is the only way this would be legal is if
- 10:22the person stealing the signs allegedly then tells the players. But I don't think
- 10:30whoever is the guy is down on the field stealing signs also relaying them to
- 10:35the player. There's gonna be somebody. I assume there would theoretically be somebody
- 10:39upstairs who is relaying it to it and they're not doing it by shouting,
- 10:41like they're using electronic equipment to speak to somebody. So like, I think
- 10:46all of that falls under electronic equipment. So I don't know how you really
- 10:50get away with it, right, And like that's the thing. The NCAA
- 10:56would not be getting involved in putting out this notice about allegations and alerting the
- 11:01big ten at schools. This would not be happening if the allegations were that
- 11:05Michigan had a coach on the sidelines who just by watching throughout the game was
- 11:11like picking up on signals you know that may be frowned upon, but it's
- 11:16not really in the rule book. So clearly these allegations are referring to like
- 11:24spygate type stuff of just their recording stuff and like sending other people, sending
- 11:28staffers to future opponents games and shooting their signs that you know, Nebraska's playing
- 11:37Minnesota or whatever, going to that game and shooting side. I mean,
- 11:41so that would be that would be next level crazy. But that's that's what
- 11:46the allegations are. That's what they're hinting at. These things don't happen because
- 11:50you know, you're support staff guy on the sideline thinks he's caught up on
- 11:56something across the field. There it's something has happened here with with recording equipment.
- 12:00And so this could get really interesting as all of this unfolds and as
- 12:05people are interviewed, and Jim Harbaugh is gonna have no incentive to come forward
- 12:13with anything other than denial, because especially if he is planning on this being
- 12:20his last hurrah at Michigan, there is no reason for him to come forward
- 12:24with anything or talk to the NCAAA or whatever. I do think it's interesting
- 12:30that the NCAA rule book has says that any attempt to record and relay this
- 12:35information is prohibited, but it doesn't have a penalty or a punishment. I
- 12:41don't know if that's because they just assume, like, well, nobody's actually
- 12:45gonna do this, you know, or it's one of these things where it's
- 12:48so it's so beneath the level of trust that you have for administrators coaches that
- 12:56like, we don't need to set up a penalty for this. It's just
- 12:58we're gonna say it's against the rules and people will follow it. And you
- 13:03know, I'm seeing other people on Twitter college football people saying, well,
- 13:07that's just scouting, and this is next level scouting. This is this is
- 13:13like you said, NFL kind of scouting that gets you cost you a first
- 13:18round pick if you get caught. So I don't know what it would cost
- 13:22Michigan. I do know that if all of this is found out and it's
- 13:26all true, and I don't think it just ends with two opponents, And
- 13:31I would be shocked if it just started this year, like pretty amazing that
- 13:35you get caught the first year you're doing it or the first game, because
- 13:39I refuse to believe that they were trying to steal signs allegedly against Bowling Green
- 13:48or UNLV or East Carolina this year, Like that would be unless unless you're
- 13:54practicing it for the Big ten. Bowling Green's a short drive from in orbit
- 14:00on' that's not too much on the company card. No, but like during
- 14:07a game, like, are you putting that much effort? Is it like
- 14:09a drive run for the Big ten? Like you you're up in the booth
- 14:11of theular, Hey can we get away with this? Let's try this.
- 14:13I it's fully agreed first before we try it. Against Nebraska, Brent Venables
- 14:18was accused of stealing signs and everybody it was just understood that it was happening.
- 14:24And I remember, I think it was the twenty twenty season. Then
- 14:28Ohio State took steps to make sure that it didn't happen, or tried to
- 14:31make sure that it didn't happen, and they lit Clemson's defense up. And
- 14:37the year before things weren't as great for Io State. In twenty twenty against
- 14:41Clemson, they lit them up because they protected themselves. And I'm not saying
- 14:45the Michigan State's gonna light Michigan up this week, but it is just interesting
- 14:48that I do wonder how long they've been doing it allegedly, if they're doing
- 14:54it at all, mark if it's even happening. I wonder how long it
- 14:56has even been happening allegedly before the here, because it wouldn't seem strange to
- 15:01get caught the very first time you do it. And you know, as
- 15:05I start some of the stuff you don't really process until you're talking about it,
- 15:11like we are. We don't even really process everything. And as I'm
- 15:13as we're talking this through, I'm like, Okay, what's worse for Michigan
- 15:18here if they just started it and got caught, or if they've been doing
- 15:22it for years. You know, if they've been doing it for three years,
- 15:24let's say, and got caught, I think it's if they just started
- 15:28it because and here's why the NCAA investigation has been ongoing. So if you're
- 15:33in the middle of an NCAA investigation and one thing you do is like,
- 15:35we're going to start illegally filming our opponents, Like if you started already,
- 15:41it's kind of like, oh, you know, it's in the past,
- 15:43Like you know, you were doing all these different things wrong that the NCAA
- 15:46doesn't like. And so they'll they'll hit you for it. But like if
- 15:50you were alerted that you were being investigated by the NCAA and then one of
- 15:54your responses to that investigation was to then start illegally filming opponents, they're going
- 16:00to throw the book at you. The NCAAA is kind of toothless these days,
- 16:06but there's still there's right we're in that point where they can get it
- 16:10under the gun and get somebody before this all goes to hell in a few
- 16:14the next few years. As far as the governing bodies of college football,
- 16:17and if there's one thing I know about the NCAAA just come around and covering
- 16:19the Jim Tressole thing. If they don't like you, if they suspect that
- 16:23you've lied to them, if they suspect that you're cheating and get and have
- 16:27routinely been able to get away with it, they will throw the book at
- 16:30you if they can, even if it's not a big deal or it's not
- 16:36the worst thing we've ever seen. And that's really what got Trestle in trouble
- 16:40was the lying about it with they had they had them dead to rights on
- 16:42the email and again talking to people at the time, I was kind of
- 16:47asking like, is this really like a big deal? And obviously now is
- 16:49to look back on it, given what we've kind of seen, it's kind
- 16:52of not. But the NCAA, there were people at the NCAA who were
- 16:56still there when Tressell was being investigated what he was at Ohio State, who
- 17:00investigated him when he was at Young Sound State, the whole ray Issic situation
- 17:04at Young Sound State, which will be a totally different pot I'm not going
- 17:07to just google that if if you you know, I'm not going to derail
- 17:11this. But but he basically got away with that. There were some things
- 17:15at Young Sound State the nca feels he got away with and they couldn't wait
- 17:18to get him is basically what I was told by a few people who know
- 17:22a lot of people at the NCAA and the enforcement officers and stuff there.
- 17:25They could not wait to be able to catch him on something. And so
- 17:30if you're horrible, if you're Michigan right now, if you just started doing
- 17:34this after their investigation already started into you, you are you are asking for
- 17:41it, you really are. The Yeah, the NCAA is not going to
- 17:45be certainly not happy with this, and I do wonder we talked about lack
- 17:52of institutional control when the institution is controlling all of the all in terms of
- 18:00the alleged violations, like this isn't a head coach not knowing something is happening
- 18:06and he can just plead the ignorance to the plausible deniability like I didn't know,
- 18:11But the NCAA can still hit him for lack of institutional control. These
- 18:15all sound like head coaching things, Like the initial stuff with the NCAA was
- 18:18head coaching. If this is true, the scouting and all of the advanced
- 18:22scouting and whatever, and the science dealing that's coming from the head coach,
- 18:26I would think as well. So that's that's that lack of institutional control,
- 18:30unless the institution is Michigan not controlling Jim Harbaugh. This is a level of
- 18:37disregard, perhaps possibly allegedly for all of the rules. And then what happens
- 18:45if there's like a show cause penalty handed down to Jim Harbaugh. Now you
- 18:49can still coach, you can still hire coaches with the show cause, but
- 18:52you're restricted in a bunch of different things, and it's almost kind of like
- 18:56a probation thing where you're checking in with your nca A officer every six months
- 19:00or you know, like you have to check in. And it sounds like
- 19:04just the type of thing Harball wants to do exactly. And that's why it
- 19:08just keeps coming back to the fact that it sure feels like especially if JJ
- 19:12McCarthy's headed for the NFL, and I don't know that he is, but
- 19:15if a bunch of Michigan players are headed for the NFL, I'm gonna be
- 19:19terribly unsurprised if Jim Harbaugh was joining them or trying to. I think he
- 19:26would love nothing more than to win a championship this year and then go to
- 19:32the NFL and just give all of college football the middle finger on the way
- 19:34out and be like, you can vacate it if you want. I want
- 19:37it. You know I'm not giving it back like I'm going off to the
- 19:40NFL like you know, dari to vacate it. I really think that would
- 19:45probably be his ultimate dream here in this situation. But we'll see the other
- 19:52thing. I'd love the Michigan States for spots. I kind of rolled my
- 19:55eyes at this because I do think if Michigan was sending people to like opponents
- 19:59game like in some like disguise and like shooting the sidelines everything like that's pretty
- 20:06serious to me. But like, at the same time, Michigan State statement
- 20:08was kind of hilarious to me. The you know, Michigan State consider or
- 20:14maybe it wasn't their statement. Bill reported that Michigan State considered not playing the
- 20:18game out of a concern for players safety. But I'm just like, no,
- 20:23you considered taking the way out, easy way out of a fifty point
- 20:27beating and putting it on Michigan, very similar to what Michigan did against Ohio
- 20:34State a few years ago. So that was all very funny and ironic to
- 20:37me. Yeah, they learned it from watching Michigan. It's the old I
- 20:41learned it from watching you Dad. I learned it from watching you big brother.
- 20:45That's sort of what that was. So I'm gonna be fascinated to see
- 20:49how all of this turns out. Any prediction, Mark, do you think
- 20:52this becomes? Is this a not I apologize for using this phrase, a
- 20:57nothing burger and the the previous NCAA infraction and investigation also involves some burgers.
- 21:03Any thoughts on how this ends up? I mean, I think it ends
- 21:08up with Jim Harball leaving Michigan one way or the other, and you know
- 21:12the way the NCAA moves and all this stuff tends to move, I would
- 21:18generally be surprised if we heard anything before like march on from the NCAAA.
- 21:23At least I would be surprised. But you know, I probably no sooner
- 21:26than that because I think this. I think this sends Horball to the NFL.
- 21:30And you know, he's done enough on the field. You know,
- 21:36we can make all the jokes we want about you know, spying and everything
- 21:38else, but he's done enough on the field these last couple of years.
- 21:41I think to re energize NFL franchises about him, I think would be a
- 21:47fair way to put it. And so we know there's gonna be NFL jobs
- 21:51available. They fire coaches all the time, so they're gonna be they go,
- 21:56they go right through them. I know a couple should be fired right
- 21:57now. But I think he's gonna jump on an opportunity. And I think
- 22:00it's one of those deals now where it's like I think before it was like
- 22:03I want the right opportunity, I want the right quarterback or the right draft
- 22:07picks or whatever it was. Now I think it becomes just get me out
- 22:11of here, Just get me out of here. And I don't I just
- 22:15I don't see between yet another investigation and just the seemingly building whatever you know,
- 22:22emotions between Jim Harball and the administration of Michigan. And it doesn't Michigan
- 22:29have to distance themselves from him now or cause, because if you're Michigan and
- 22:33this stuff turns out to be true, you're gonna want to you need you
- 22:37need to have a scapegoat, and it has to be horrible. It can't
- 22:41be a lower level guy at this point because these things, as you pointed
- 22:44out earlier, these things are things that there's no way the head coach would
- 22:48not know. So if you're Michigan, don't you have to kind of save
- 22:52yourselves a little bit here and be like, well, you know, you
- 22:56don't have to fire him. You can just kind of let him go to
- 22:59the NFL. I think there's a way out of this from Michigan where they
- 23:00can be like, well, he just left, you know, And but
- 23:03don't you have to kind of distance yourself so that any punishment that comes down,
- 23:07like if Horrball leaves, that any punishment that comes down maybe is lighter
- 23:11on you because horrball is now gone. Well, if you re light on
- 23:18Harbosch at the NCAA, be light on you. And if you just let
- 23:21him go without It's almost one of these things where they have to orchestrate the
- 23:26departure to make themselves look like they've they were hard on crime, and so
- 23:32whatever that entails, if this all comes to be and comes to pass.
- 23:37You know, Ohio State said goodbye to Jim Tressel, and Jim Trussel won
- 23:41a national championship and beat Michigan nine times or whatever I say. It had
- 23:45urban Meyer on online too, though, Well there is Michigan line too.
- 23:51It's coming to save Michigan. Urban Meyer is available. Would that be something?
- 24:00Well? No, next video, will will will Hire be the next
- 24:03head coach at Michigan. No, that's the other thing is who, And
- 24:10Michigan State has that same question to answer, sort of a bunch of schools.
- 24:14I do wonder if if they do find this out and how far back
- 24:18it goes. Maybe maybe Ryan Day moves to one to zero against Jim Harbaugh
- 24:23again until they play in November. But Mark ain't got anything else before we
- 24:29head out of here. No, just check us out bucke huddle dot com.
- 24:33This is a huge game, obviously top ten matchup, I think,
- 24:38I mean, certainly, the loser of this game it stings their playoff chances.
- 24:44The winner of this game is like in a really strong position to make
- 24:48the playoff even though both have Michigan. Still you still you're going to be
- 24:52the top You're the winner. This game is going to make itself basically the
- 24:56top wild card if there is one. Now there may not be, but
- 25:00the winner of this game is essentially going to establish itself as the top one
- 25:03loss team if they you know, if they stumble down the stretch. So
- 25:08I think there are huge implications here beyond just the Big ten championship. There's
- 25:12recruiting implications here, huge visitor lists, So we're previewing that over on the
- 25:15website. I think we'll have a recruiting podcast out here before the game on
- 25:21Friday morning detailing some of the big visitors. So check all that stuff out.
- 25:25That's all I got now. But this boy just a random Thursday afternoon
- 25:30and here we go. Yeah, it was a Thursday news dump instead of
- 25:34a Friday news deup. That's how you know it didn't come from Michigan or
- 25:37else. They want to save it for Friday at five pm, so that
- 25:41will do it from here. So I want to thank you all for tuning
- 25:44in. As always, reminder to check us out at bucke huddle dot com.
- 25:45Become a member if you haven't yet, go ahead and like and subscribe
- 25:48on YouTube if that's where you're watching us, now, hit the bell to
- 25:52be notified. And if you are listening this to the Via podcast platform,
- 25:55go ahead and give us a five star rating in review if you would like.
- 25:56So thank you all for tuning in. We'll talk to you guys later