Latest / Automotive State of The Union / FTC Compliance Fallout with Ted Smith of FLADA
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, good morning. It's Tuesday, March 17th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mountsier coming up to us from a sound booth.
- 0:09We also have Ted Smith on the show today, Florida Association of Dealers- Here I go... the presidente You already want to know Talk about a little FTC stuff.
- 0:17Who I is, what I do There's, there's a couple things going on, Kyle. Have you heard? They start to trip on me and my crew There's some stuff floating around. I'm up in Canada.
- 0:22I'm trying to scope out a BYD, but they, I haven't found one yet. [laughs] So they're not here yet, you know? [laughs] Yeah, they, that you know about. That you know about. That I know about. We'll see. Yeah.
- 0:32Uh, I mean, it is an interesting season in automotive.
- 0:34It ebbs and flows and, like, all of a sudden we're having FTC conversations, we're having international import conversations, both with vehicles coming into the country and, like, Nissan and Toyota export- or, uh, Nissan and Honda exporting vehicles back to Japan.
- 0:49It's just like the Wild West this week it feels like. It's a Wild West. I love it. I, I... One, thank you for the content, auto industry. Yeah. [laughs] We appreciate it, right?
- 0:58Uh, but two, it's super exciting because, again, you think about when the public eye faces auto, there's, there's a general lift.
- 1:07And, and whether or not there's, like, semi-bad PR or amazing PR or just consideration of auto on platforms that d- aren't just about auto, that, like, pins people to, "I, maybe I should think about a car right now."
- 1:23Um, it just, like- That's right... it's what you pay attention to- It's also tax season... you do. Yeah. It's tax season. It's tax season. I can't- Let's go... I can't open this right now, but- I- Uh-oh. What'd you get?
- 1:32No, I got- What'd you get? I got mail for you. What is that? Mail for me? From RevDojo. Oh. No name. We'll open this another time. Just wanna let you know. I know who that is. Right. That's my boy Kyle Disher. Yep.
- 1:46Yeah, it doesn't have his name on it, but we'll- Yeah. I mean, do we open it now? What do we do? I think I know what it is. Uh, what do you think it is? Open it. Okay. I think it's really dope. Go for it. Try it.
- 1:55Uh-oh, we've never had- Let's see. If- We've never had a knife on the show before... if, if I've seen some things on the LinkedIn, if I've seen some stuff on the LinkedIn, I think, I feel like I know what it might be.
- 2:04Let's see. Well, you have to say- Let's see. What do we get?... what you think it is before I show it. No. I'm not gonna read the note. Hate mail. Don't read the note. More hate mail for Kyle.
- 2:15It's K- Kyle Dish- Kyle to Kyle. You never want that. Whoa. Is it a billboard? Oh- Is it a billboard?... it's so cool. It's a billboard, isn't it?
- 2:22Dude, if I knew it was this, I would've opened it before I waited for you. How cool is that? Oh, oh, it's broken. Oh, no. I can fix it. It's just hot glue. Hold on. Say it ain't so. Here we go. Ready? Ta-da.
- 2:34There it comes. [laughs] It's so dope. So cool. It's a billboard. It's a billboard. All right. You gotta do some billboard advertising every now and then. Hold on. Hold on.
- 2:44Uh, is this gonna re- You know, I really was just about to draw a mustache on this, like- [laughs]... you know, draw some glasses and a mustache, but I don't wanna ruin that nice gift.
- 2:52And if it doesn't wipe off- What a perfect thing... I'll feel bad. [laughs] I know. I would've been, "Well, thanks, Kyle Disher." Thanks, Kyle Disher. To, uh, Kyle Mountsier. Now there's no more mystery box- Dreams...
- 2:59in my office. I should close this knife before I hurt myself. Done. Uh, we do have a sponsor of today's show, and, uh, it's our friends at Hey Green Light. So energetic. Love these guys.
- 3:09Here's a fun dealership exercise: listen to five recorded sales calls in a row. By call three, you'll hear it. It's a long pause. The- Oh, no... "So what questions do you have for me?" moment.
- 3:22Uh, Wingman from Hey Green Light fixes that with live real-time prompts during calls so your team knows exactly what to say next.
- 3:29Better conversations, more appointments, and fewer awkward silences, which is good for everybody. If you want more consistent performance without hiring more people, check out Hey Green Light, H-E-Y Green Light.com.
- 3:41Hey Green Light. That's just fun. [laughs] We do, do jingles. Oh, that's a good- We doing live jingles, Kyle? I just came up with a campaign. I just came up with the jingle- Hey Green Light... and the live campaign.
- 3:49No, that's just Green Giant. Like, that's just- That's true... Green Giant. That's just another- Okay... thing that you just made, Hey Green Light. [laughs] Unbelievable. Oh, SoDo, right?
- 3:58Like you do with every- People gotta come to a SoDo Con. Did you know that, Paul? They should come to a SoDo Con. They should. They should get their tickets. Yeah. Tickets are streaming in.
- 4:05People are buying their, getting their, uh, their rooms. You don't wanna be late on the hotel rooms. That's true. Get those today, SoDoCon.com. Come to the AutoIndustry.ai summit.
- 4:15And other than that, we gotta get into a show. We're, we're doing a lot of stuff. Ted, Ted's back here. He's been drinking coffee and Red Bull for the last 20 minutes. He's super fired up, ready to get in here.
- 4:23[laughs] So let's bring Ted Smith into the show this morning. Ted, make sure he gets in. Nathan's trying so hard. I see his concentrated face back there. Ted, good morning. Hey, guys. Good morning.
- 4:36Um, do, do you have anyone else in your office that's as energetic as we are, first thing, that is still alive? I, I try not to. Um, I try to calm things down a touch. You know, you guys are over the top.
- 4:48[laughs] But I love you. You, you smile a lot. You're wearing those wonderful hats. I mean, I wanna be like you. Oh, well, thank you so much. Aw, what a, what a joy. [laughs] We...
- 4:58Well, thanks for joining us on the show today, because there's obviously a lot of talk going around across, uh, dealer associations, NADA, dealer to dealer, uh, 20 groups about what happened in the FTC sending out these letters to these 97 dealers.
- 5:13Um, Don Hall of VADA, we've read the email he sent to everybody, um, and I'm gonna read some points from it, but we would love to get, uh, your feedback and just, you know, how you're instructing dealers and some things that you can share with us.
- 5:25So, uh, Don Hall, g- another good friend of all of ours at the Virginia Auto Dealer Association, responded to Friday's warning letters with a detailed compliance roadmap trying to help, uh, dealers navigate the situation and, and step up, um, to do what they're tr- already trying to do.
- 5:41From VADA's compliance roadmap: "The core rule is simple. The advertised price must be the total price every consumer pays, processing fees and freight included. State law does not matter.
- 5:53The FTC Act overrules it."Goes on to say, "There's no such thing as an internet price or a geographic price. If it's advertised, it must be available to every customer, every time.
- 6:05No disclaimer can fix a non-compliant price." So they went on and they, they encourage dealers to audit their ads.
- 6:13Um, but you know, you obviously have a lot of dealers under, under your guidance, and so what are you saying to your dealers, and, and, you know, what can you tell us about how the situation's washing out for you?
- 6:23Well, you know, I s- I saw Don's memo as well. I've constructed my own for my members, and we're sending that out along with our roadmap. We have an advertising guide here in Florida we prepared.
- 6:34Because, uh, guys, this is not a new subject. This has been going on for several years at the state level, where some attorneys ge- attorney generals have gotten active looking at ads and talking to dealers.
- 6:46And, uh, my own attorney general called me a, a couple of years ago and said, "Hey, we should look at the marketplace." And they did so really because of what they were seeing with some independent dealer advertising.
- 6:58Mm. And when they brought those people in for some questions, they said, "Well, you shouldn't be thinking just about us. Look at what the new car dealers are doing."
- 7:06And, and look, why don't we focus on what the real problem is with this? And it's a great one.
- 7:12You guys were sort of tiptoeing around it when you were on your show a little bit earlier by talking about the dynamics of our marketplace. What's wonderful about our marketplace is we are intensely competitive.
- 7:24You don't have this conversation if it's a direct sale from OEM to consumer problem. Why is that? Ah. There's no competition. No competition. Yeah. 'Cause there's no competitive pricing [laughs] going on.
- 7:36You know, you... The price of the Tesla is the price of the Tesla, whether it's in New York or Los Angeles or, or Tallahassee, Florida. The Tesla price is the price.
- 7:44The wonderful thing about our industry is we have intense price competition. So let's focus on that. That's what causes sometimes certain dealers get outside the box in how they might display pricing.
- 7:58Our role as a trade association is to educate them on what the laws say, what the practice should be for, uh, y- you know, good pricing programs, transparent pricing for customers.
- 8:11But the difficulty is, and if you look at what the FTC just said, they basically, what was writing beneath some of the conversation was, they're not just looking at these things because they're concerned about consumers.
- 8:24They're concerned about those dealers that might not be doing it right impacting the ability of the other dealers to survive in the marketplace. Ah. Mm. That's a good point.
- 8:33Yeah, because, because when the consumer loses trust at some level, it's not just the, it's not just the bad dealers that, that, or, or the ones that maybe aren't, you know, following the letter of the law, but it's the good ones that get pulled down too.
- 8:47And I think that's what your encouragement is, is like, "Hey, look, this is a rising tide lifts all ships. Let's be good for our consumers. We wanna maintain price competitiveness.
- 8:56We wanna m- maintain optionality in the market.
- 8:59So let's be good for our consumers and price appropriately so that they can make quality, educated decisions to buy at the place that has the inventory and the price point that makes most sense for them."
- 9:08And if we can do that as an industry, it's better for everyone, right? That's, that's right.
- 9:13And the way we market today digitally has caused some of the difficulties that consumers are having in the marketplace, because there's a displayed price.
- 9:23There are certain things that are really close to that price, such as the dealer fee. Mm-hmm. In Florida, our attorney general has said, it's okay to not in...
- 9:32Even though the law says that dealer fee has to be in the price, they're saying it's okay if it's nearby, if it's in proximity to the big, bold price, because any person with any degree of brains can go, "$18,000 plus $500-" Right...
- 9:46is $18,500." [laughs] Right. Right. Right.
- 9:49And but there are other, sometimes other disclosures being made which a dealer might feel is transparent, but someone else may feel, "Oh, you shouldn't have to read on and find out about other things," discounts that are available to some, not available to others.
- 10:05So it is not, it is a complex process, as you guys well know. It is. Yeah, absolutely. I love how you brought up the beauty of the industry in the sense that when there is competition, the consumer wins. That's right.
- 10:17When there's a lack of competition, the consumer loses every time. Like, the, I... There's, I mean, wouldn't it be great if we had competition for a lot of things that we get direct, like power and energy, right?
- 10:27[laughs] Like, all these things that there's no competition. We're just at the mercy of it. So I love how you brought that into the conversation because, um, you know, as...
- 10:35We, we spend a lot of time on the internet, so, you know, sometimes you get, uh, down the rabbit hole in, like, a Twitter thread or something and, or Reddit, and you start to see how consumers are, you know, talking about their dealership experience, and some liked it, some didn't like it.
- 10:47But the reality is not many people are thinking or putting that bit of levity into the conversation. Like, isn't it great that we actually have options? Absolutely. We've never had a world otherwise, I guess. Absolutely.
- 11:00And, and, you know, you can talk all day long about direct to consumer versus the franchise system. I've always been an advocate. That's why I work [laughs] in this business. It's, it's not just a job.
- 11:10It's a belief system for me that competition is much better than single price with no competition. Because w- the minute you set that price, you've included a level of profit in it that the consumer can't get inside of.
- 11:24Yeah. Competition provides something completely different than that. I mean- Mm...
- 11:28and, and this, you know, this issue's being res- dealers are responding to what's going on in, in this constantly because the market rises and fall. You know, there's so much going on competitively. What do dealers want?
- 11:42They want every consumer to come, look at their website and come to their store. So that's what makes this difficult.
- 11:48There's, there's the people that are operating properly, and there's a few that don't, and, and when that happens, um, it makes it sometimes difficult, but it is directly a result of a competitive pricing system.
- 12:02And, and I think what we're seeing now is some dealers saying, "Well, I'm g- you know, I'm seeing dealers advertise that their..."...
- 12:10pricing is transparent and challenging their customers, their prospective customers when they're shopping to make sure you n- you're- you're aware of what's going on in the industry.
- 12:21Come to my store because I'm, I'm giving you transparent pricing. I'm gonna treat you properly when you visit. Oh.
- 12:27Well, Ted, as always, thank you for being out there, uh, bringing a lot of levity to the situation, advocating for the industry, making sure we're following the regulations and serving the customers well.
- 12:38Uh, we hope you have a great day doing that for your dealers out there, and we hope to see you soon. Thanks, guys. As always, great being with you. Man, I love, I love it.
- 12:48Just leave it, leave it to somebody to say, "Wait a minute. Let's go down to the basic root." The reason we even have to- Let's talk through this, yes...
- 12:55work through this is because we have a good thing, which is competition. Yeah. And that's something I haven't heard as, as a part of the conversation yet. Yeah.
- 13:02I, I, like, the, the, the reality of our complicated marketplace- Mm-hmm... has to be front and center.
- 13:09And I think that that's a conversation that, that Ted and others in his position are bringing to the dealer, bringing to the consumer, and pr- bringing to the regulators.
- 13:19And I think that all sides need to understand the competitive marketplace, um, what that allows consumers to have. And then even the, the difficulty of in, uh, uh, how OEMs, uh, bring down incentives, right?
- 13:32Because this universal pricing just isn't a possibility. If you've got someone shopping for a vehicle from Virginia in Florida, typically their rebates are gonna be based on where they register the car- That's right...
- 13:43not where they buy the car. So that totally changes the capability of a dealer to advertise price points based on a certain location. So you have to be zip aware, um, when pricing these things.
- 13:53And these are dynamics that a l- a lot of regulators don't really understand, and the difference between what the OEM, the dealer, uh, and the consumer can see. Um, I'm kinda going back and forth.
- 14:03Do we talk about the, the next story, or do we just, like, jam on this for another minute or two? 'Cause we, you know, we had a guest today, so we're going a little long. What do you think? Yeah.
- 14:12W- let's just jam on this because I, I think that this is, this is what dealers should, should be talking through, is they should be not just taking, like, do not just take a GPT recap of this thing. Talk to your ADA.
- 14:26Talk to your, uh, to, to your legal team. Look at your VDPs, the way they're structured, your SRPs, the way they're structured.
- 14:32Um, but more importantly, go to your advertising because your advertising is the place where, where historically we've done a, um, less than, less than powerful job at being, um, at being, like, the most forthright that we possibly can.
- 14:47Um, you know, we shove these disclaimers. We don't wanna get to the place in healthcare where the entire- Commercial's a disclaimer... the whole commercial- No, no, no... is a disclaimer.
- 14:55[laughs] We don't wanna be there. May cause injury or death. So how can we- Yeah... right, how can we promote the things that we need to get right there front and center to the customer at the right, right place?
- 15:05And then, hey, look, if you've made a living advertising on price and it's not been forthright, move to brand. Don't try and, like, figure out how to be- It's all right. It's only gonna get harder... yeah, yeah.
- 15:17It's only gonna get harder. Just move to brand. Like, figure out how to advertise and, and talk about your brand as opposed to your price points.
- 15:23That actually makes this whole conversation easier, uh, 'cause you don't have people inquiring on price as much when you talk about brand more.
- 15:30You know, one of the things we're huge advocates for, and I think is more needed than ever, is this alignment that you were talking about.
- 15:36You were talking about compliance, but also with the marketing team, with the ownership, especially the larger groups you get.
- 15:43What is that coordinated voice that moves forward, that talks about why you're getting the car here? And price advertising matters, for sure, but if it's the only thing, you're gonna put yourself in the trick bag.
- 15:53I also, you know, you think about the larger a group gets, the more difficult it is because, uh, like you were saying, they're cross-regions. And I bet a lot of the confusion comes from that as well, right?
- 16:02And here, here's the bottom line. And I think, um, [smacks lips] I think it was Tom Klein, our friend, who said this. It's, it's general best practice.
- 16:11When you can show diligence in trying to uphold and follow the law, even if you miss one or something gets flagged- Yes...
- 16:20when you come back and you can show internal records, you can show meetings, you can show memos, you can show that the culture is around prioritizing compliance, that's when the little slip-ups get corrected and you keep moving forward.
- 16:33However, if you- Yes...
- 16:33have a culture that is hiding things and it is no evidence of you having these conversations or being on with your compliance and legal experts or working with your ATAE, if you don't have any of that, that's when it's most likely you're gonna get the hammer dropped.
- 16:47So whatever it is, I think anyone listening to this today can do something to improve, period. That's all we're asking. [upbeat music] There you go. I don't know. That was a fun Tuesday episode. What a Tuesday.
- 16:58What did we love about this episode? It's gonna be a Tuesday today. Whatever it is, we hope you go out there, talk to your people, talk to your customers. Go and make a difference.
- 17:04And go to asotokon.com to get your tickets and join us. And hey... [upbeat music]