Latest / Film And Whiskey / 12 Angry Men (1957) / Very Old Barton 80 Proof Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1957, director Sidney Lumet and star Henry Fonda gave the
- 0:04world a jury room drama that has never been topped and still asks
- 0:08the pertinent question, Is it possible?
- 0:11In 2023, we returned to a fan favorite brand at their lowest
- 0:16proof point. The film is 12 Angry Men.
- 0:20The whiskey is very old. Barton, 80.
- 0:22Proof. We'll review them both.
- 0:24This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:43Music. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:48podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:50glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:53I'm Brad Gee. And this week we are watching
- 0:56for the second time Brad 12 Angry Men director Sidney
- 1:00Lumet's debut feature from 1957. I think it's actually my third
- 1:04time watching the film, Bob. Oh, is it?
- 1:07First time was yeah, first time was for season 1 and I'm like
- 1:1190% sure I've watched it at some point in the intervening years.
- 1:16Oh, so you hadn't seen it prior to us watching it the first
- 1:19time? I don't believe so.
- 1:21Wow, that's shocking. Yeah.
- 1:22I thought this was one of those movies that like, if you didn't
- 1:25see it outside of school, then you saw it inside of school, you
- 1:28know what I mean? It just feels like everyone has
- 1:30seen it at some point. As they should, as.
- 1:33They absolutely should. Yeah.
- 1:34Part of the reason that I said that this is Sydney Lumet's
- 1:37debut feature is what, A debut feature, man.
- 1:41Oh, dude, yeah. When you talk about like best
- 1:43first films for a director, this has got to be up here.
- 1:48Oh my God. I know a lot of people would put
- 1:49Reservoir Dogs up there. We were a little bit cooler on
- 1:53it. I I don't know of many better
- 1:55first film introductions than 12 Angry Men.
- 1:59I mean, it's this and Tommy Wiseau's The Room.
- 2:02Right, obviously. Yeah, I thought, yeah, for sure.
- 2:04Well, hey, as we get into talking about 12 Angry Men, we
- 2:07do want to remind everybody out there that you can subscribe to
- 2:10us on Patreon where you get a ton of bonus perks.
- 2:13We do special episodes just for our Patreon members.
- 2:16We have uncut, longer episodes for our patrons as well.
- 2:20You can find allofthisextracontent@patreon.com/film.
- 2:25Whiskey, Brad. I don't know that we need to
- 2:28beat around the Bush too much here.
- 2:29We've talked about this movie once.
- 2:31We're revisiting it. 10 out of 10 Great episode I.
- 2:34Was going to say if anything it's gone even higher in my
- 2:37estimation on 2nd watch. Yeah, yeah, it's interesting.
- 2:41We we don't give 10 out of 10 super often, but probably more
- 2:45often than some film critics might hand them out.
- 2:48And at this point, I feel like I need to have like a inner
- 2:53ranking system of like once you hit 10 out of 10, I give you
- 2:57like a gold medal 10 or a silver middle 10 or, or a bronze medal
- 3:0110. I I don't know, we need to mix
- 3:02it up, I think. You know, we were talking one
- 3:05time with a friend of show, Patrick Williams, and he told us
- 3:08that he doesn't give a 10 out of 10 or A5 out of five on
- 3:11Letterboxed on 1st viewing. And I've kind of started to
- 3:15drift that way a little bit in the last couple years.
- 3:17Like, there's been a few movies that just absolutely gob smacked
- 3:21me. And I'll give him a 10 and then
- 3:22go back five years later and be like, oh, OK, I was kind of a
- 3:26prisoner of the moment, you know?
- 3:28And I feel like now I try to air on the side of, like, this might
- 3:32be a 10. And I'm going to rank it as like
- 3:34a nine until I can revisit it and determine for sure if it's a
- 3:3710. And this is one of those movies
- 3:39that every time I watch it, I don't even go into it thinking
- 3:43like, oh, I wonder if this is going to hold up.
- 3:45It's like you put it on and you are so immediately engrossed in
- 3:50the movie that at multiple points I was like, oh, this is a
- 3:5310 out of 10. Like there's just, there's
- 3:55nothing that that changes it for me.
- 3:58Even just the opening shot is outside the courtroom, it slowly
- 4:02pans up and ends on like a saying about justice at the top
- 4:07of this, you know, courthouse. And then the camera cuts, you're
- 4:10inside the courthouse looking up at the top at another quote
- 4:13about justice and it slowly pans down as you see people entering
- 4:18the courthouse. Then it pan like turns to the
- 4:20side and follows like 4 different people slowly into the
- 4:24courtroom and I'm like the like the cinematography in this is.
- 4:30Incredible. You know what?
- 4:31Like, let's, let's start there. Actually, no, let's not start
- 4:34there. Let's start with our favorite
- 4:36segment, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 4:39movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 4:43ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 4:46Brad explains. Brad explains is America's
- 4:49favorite segment this is where Brad breaks down the plot of the
- 4:52movie that he has just seen often for the first time.
- 4:56This is Brad's apparently third time watching 12 Angry Men.
- 5:00Brad, I don't really know that there's.
- 5:03I feel like you should change what you say from often for the
- 5:05first time to often for the. Second time for the second time.
- 5:08Just for this season. I was going to say, I don't know
- 5:11if it's even possible to fill out a full 60 seconds explaining
- 5:15the plot of this movie because like a short one sentence
- 5:18synopsis pretty much covers exactly what this movie's about.
- 5:23But we give you a minute, so if you want to pat it out with just
- 5:26personal opinions on things, you feel free, man.
- 5:29You have one minute on the clock to completely spoil this movie
- 5:33and everything that happens inside of it and go.
- 5:37Do do you want me to, like, tell you about what I had for dinner
- 5:39last night? Do you have a personal opinion
- 5:41about it? It was delicious.
- 5:43There you go, I made AI made a lemon chicken orzo with with
- 5:46bacon and oh man, it was incredible.
- 5:50You guys do lemon chicken orzo quite often, don't you?
- 5:54I. Would say it's like at least
- 5:55once a month. OK, nice type of meal.
- 5:57All right. How many?
- 5:58How much time do I have left? Like 35 seconds.
- 6:01OK, so 12 Angry Men is a film about a jury trying to decide if
- 6:05a boy is innocent. One juror is convinced that
- 6:10there is a shadow of a doubt, the rest of them are not, and he
- 6:14has to prove them all wrong. There you go, that's it.
- 6:18I like how you asked for how much time you had left and then
- 6:21spent 4 seconds. Well, let me tell you a little
- 6:24more about my lemon chicken or so Bob.
- 6:27All right, so important context to add to your, Brad explains.
- 6:30It's not just that they're deciding if a boy is innocent.
- 6:33I mean, they are, but it's a murder trial.
- 6:35This boy is on trial for his life.
- 6:37He's going to get sent to the electric chair if found guilty,
- 6:41and they're determining whether or not he murdered his own
- 6:43father. The boy grew up in what is
- 6:46referred to many times as the slums and the jurors.
- 6:50He's just a dirty Italian, Bob. He's.
- 6:51Truly man, I'm surprised we didn't hear some very
- 6:54insensitive epithets thrown his way.
- 6:57I was going to say for 1950s they do a very good job of being
- 7:02racist without being overtly like like using.
- 7:06Actual slurs, right? I was going to say it's, it's
- 7:08overt. It's just like, you know, I
- 7:12don't know what's, what's the word, I was going to say polite
- 7:15racism, but it's not that either.
- 7:19You know, that polite version of racism that nobody minds?
- 7:25All right, so anyway, all of the jurors, or most of the jurors I
- 7:27should say, bring their own personal baggage into the room
- 7:30with them, and one by one they are convinced that the boy may
- 7:35or may not be innocent. And Brad, this is just a really
- 7:39good movie. Yeah, yeah, this movie is
- 7:42incredible. I think it comes from the fact
- 7:45that this might be Drum roll, Please.
- 7:48The best script we've ever had on the.
- 7:51Podcast. It is a perfectly structured
- 7:53script and. And not just for the dialogue
- 7:56and the flow and and all of those things which work
- 7:59incredibly well. I don't know if I've ever seen a
- 8:02script with at least I would say like 9 of the 12 jurors have
- 8:09incredibly well fleshed out histories and character quirks.
- 8:16And like, you know, there's one or two of them that don't quite
- 8:20get as much screen time. But overall, almost every single
- 8:24character in this film is deep and rich and intriguing.
- 8:29And I like, I want to know more about them.
- 8:31And then you put their performances on top of that.
- 8:34I like this movie is incredible Bob.
- 8:37Yeah, just from a structural standpoint, let's talk about
- 8:39this script a little bit because one of the things it does so
- 8:42brilliantly is every time there is some sort of a blow up or a
- 8:47vote or a new piece of evidence is introduced and you can tell
- 8:50it kind of shakes that room to its core.
- 8:53Then there's always like a lull. There's always a calm after the
- 8:56storm and before the next storm. And it's in those moments that
- 8:59they do a really good job of introducing character quirks.
- 9:02So for example, like one of the jurors, I think it's juror #2
- 9:06he's a really stuck up, stuffy, like stockbroker guy.
- 9:10And that's three. That's three.
- 9:12Yeah. Oh, OK.
- 9:14And because number 2 is Lee J Cobb.
- 9:16Oh, OK. I thought he was three.
- 9:17OK, Anyway, so the the stockbroker guy, it's in one of
- 9:21these walls and someone sits next to him and everyone's
- 9:24remarking on how hot it is in this room because it's the 50s
- 9:26and they don't have air conditioning in this room.
- 9:29And someone asks him, don't you ever sweat?
- 9:31And he just goes, no, I don't. And it comes back later in the
- 9:35script. You know, he, he kind of gets
- 9:37put on his heels a little bit and you see this one drop of
- 9:39sweat start dripping down his brow and you're like, they got
- 9:43him. And so just just structurally,
- 9:47it's, it's so brilliant because it gives itself room to breathe
- 9:51and it gives the audience time to catch its breath.
- 9:53But it's not simply doing that just for the sake of having ebbs
- 9:56and flows. It uses the ebbs like as well as
- 10:00it uses the flows to establish character and pay offs for later
- 10:04on in the movie. Yeah, for.
- 10:06Well, First off, I have to tell you something, Bob.
- 10:08I was wrong and you were right. Hey, Lee J Lee J Cobb was juror
- 10:14#3, and juror #2 was played by John Fiedler.
- 10:20Yes. Just just in case anybody needed
- 10:22to know that. John Fiedler.
- 10:24Fun fact, Brad, I hope this is not one of your two facts and a
- 10:27falsehood. Did you recognize his voice from
- 10:29anywhere? I did.
- 10:32I'm the whole movie. It was him and the the baseball
- 10:36guy at the end of the table. I think number six or seven.
- 10:39Yep, Yep. His voice.
- 10:41I was like, I have heard his voice before, but I can't place
- 10:44it. Well, we will.
- 10:46I think maybe we should go around the juror table and kind
- 10:49of talk about each one. But before we, no, you know, let
- 10:52me just finish my thought on, on juror #2 John Fiedler, the voice
- 10:57of Piglet in Winnie the Pooh. Really.
- 11:01And as soon, as, as soon as you think about it, you're like, Oh
- 11:04yeah, that's Piglet. That's 100% Piglet.
- 11:06Can we talk for a second how incredible the original Disney
- 11:11Winnie the Pooh movie is? It's very good.
- 11:13It's so good. It's got that like classic kids
- 11:17movie acid trip in the middle of it, which, you know, obviously
- 11:21makes the movie what it is. But man, oh man, Piglet, who
- 11:26would have known? All right, so let's start at the
- 11:28head of the table. Juror number one of the foreman
- 11:30is played by a great character actor named Martin Balsam, who
- 11:34we have seen in a couple other movies for this podcast, Brad,
- 11:37most notably in Psycho. He is the detective in Psycho
- 11:41that gets stabbed. Right in the forehead.
- 11:43Falls backwards down the steps. Yeah, I remember that vividly.
- 11:47The thing about this movie is, you know, Henry Fonda and Lee J
- 11:53Cobb are, I guess ostensibly the stars of this movie.
- 11:57And if you're breaking down, you know, who gets the most words
- 12:00spoken versus who gets the least words spoken.
- 12:02They they definitely are the two biggest roles.
- 12:05But something that really stood out to me on this watch, Brad,
- 12:07is how evenly spread out everything is in this script.
- 12:12And so I don't have a lot to say about each actor, but I think it
- 12:16says a lot in itself that every single one of them essentially
- 12:20holds down 112th of this movie. And I don't really know that
- 12:24there is a a weak link in the cast.
- 12:27Everything works really well for me.
- 12:29I, I would mostly agree with you, I think that the older
- 12:33gentleman juror #9 I believe I, I struggle with him.
- 12:40He like, of all the jurors, he's the one that feels most like
- 12:45somebody who is hamming it up because he knows he's on camera
- 12:49and, and there's just a few moments where he's overacting
- 12:53and, and just really beyond his scope.
- 12:56I feel like, but other than, other than him and, and here's
- 12:59the thing, I actually still love his character.
- 13:02I think that the way he interacts with everyone is
- 13:04funny. I think he also gets kind of
- 13:08not, not screwed over, but I, I don't think the camera does him
- 13:12any favors because there's like three shots early in the film
- 13:15where every other shot has been, there's been some close-ups.
- 13:19But then they, they get up into his face like they're trying to
- 13:23like zoom in on a family sitting on his nose, like they are right
- 13:28up in his business and he's just got this goofy like look on his
- 13:32face. And I, and so I, I think those
- 13:35are a few small moments that I'm kind of like, OK, like this
- 13:38movie's not perfect. But even all that being said, I
- 13:44love the older gentleman. I, I don't even know what his,
- 13:47what his name is, the actor. His name is Joseph Sweeney, and
- 13:51we can get back to him when we get around the table.
- 13:53But let's let's go back to OK. So jury #1 Martin Balsam.
- 13:56Very good. I have no no real notes on him,
- 13:59Do you? He's one of the two or three
- 14:01that I'm like, he's there. Yeah, they don't flush him out
- 14:04very well for sure. They give him a little monologue
- 14:07about like being a high school football coach, and you think
- 14:10that story's going somewhere. And then it just doesn't.
- 14:13Like his story just ends with. And then it rained and I'm like,
- 14:15oh cool, thank you for. That's the the mom's cancer.
- 14:19The mom's cancer from the room. They just needed to insert like
- 14:23I too have seen rain before. Yeah, he's, he's playing the,
- 14:28you know, the famous archetype character guy who has seen rain.
- 14:32Yes, obviously it's a trope. Look it up on what's What's that
- 14:35website that has all the tropes? I think TV Tropes, I think it's,
- 14:39yeah, TV Tropes. All right, so John Fiedler is
- 14:42juror #2 he's another one that I think kind of gets the short end
- 14:45of the stick. He's just a very small, mousy
- 14:47guy who gets bullied a lot, but he has a a great couple zingers.
- 14:52Like when the racist guy is like, you know, where's all
- 14:55those cough drops? And he's like, they're all gone
- 14:58friend because the guy keeps calling everybody friend.
- 15:01So like he has his moments. But I think, again, for me, he's
- 15:04probably one of the, you know, the three or so that aren't
- 15:07fleshed out enough. Oh, I my brain got confused.
- 15:10I was thinking that you were talking about the banker who is
- 15:13sitting to Lee J Cops left. That's I think that's why I was
- 15:17thinking Lee J was #2 Anyways, John Fiedler is great.
- 15:23We can move on to Lee Lee Cobb. Lee J Cobb is a great actor.
- 15:29He is known for being the heavy and movies like this.
- 15:31He is one of the great on screen screamers because it's
- 15:35believable, like the man is channeling deep rage and I.
- 15:40Was going to say, I feel like Jack Nicholson probably bit off
- 15:44a lot of Lee J Cobb in his performances.
- 15:48There is just such passion and vigor.
- 15:54And when he rips up his son's picture at the end of it, Oh my
- 15:59gosh, dude. What an emotional wallop.
- 16:01Yeah, who knew that this was going to be a father son drama
- 16:04by the end of it? They all are, Brad.
- 16:06They all are. Every single one.
- 16:10So the thing about Lee J Cobb's character is, you know, he is
- 16:13the last one at the end of the film, spoiler alert, to vote not
- 16:17guilty. And it's really brilliantly set
- 16:19up and we'll talk about why, but his is the most personal reason.
- 16:23His is it's not logic based, but it's kind of hidden behind
- 16:28logic. And so as you watch the last
- 16:30three or four people kind of convert, you know, it becomes
- 16:32like the really racist guy and then the guy who is the most
- 16:36logical. And then it's Lee J Cobb because
- 16:39his is the closest to home. He had a falling out with his
- 16:42own son. And he is clearly bringing the
- 16:45guilt that he feels about it into the deliberation room with
- 16:48him. And you're right, man, when when
- 16:51he rips up that picture at the end of the movie and you just
- 16:53see him kind of like whimper, he goes like, and then you hear him
- 16:58cry into his own arm like, no, no.
- 17:02You know, it's one of those things that at the end of the
- 17:04day, despite all of the walls that he's built up with his son,
- 17:08it's the fact that he refuses at the end of the day to completely
- 17:13give up on his son and his relationship with his son and
- 17:16his love for his son. And that's the only reason that
- 17:19he comes back around and says not guilty.
- 17:22It's a really touching and beautiful moment.
- 17:25Well you can tell that he is so incredibly angry with his son
- 17:29that he wants to murder their relationship and when it comes
- 17:33down to it, he can't. And like that like dude, what a
- 17:39script all. Right.
- 17:41Let's talk really quickly about Lee J Cobb, though, because he
- 17:44is, like I said, one of the great screamers on screen, one
- 17:47of the great big tough guys. And I have never seen a more
- 17:51seamless transition than this of like, he handed the baton off to
- 17:56George C Scott and then George C Scott took it and ran with it in
- 17:59movies like Doctor Strangelove. And it's so funny because their
- 18:03names are so similar that you can almost confuse them for Lee
- 18:06J Cobb, George C Scott, they play the exact same type of
- 18:09character. You know, this movie actually
- 18:11gets remade in the late 90s as an HBO drama.
- 18:14And the Lee J Cobb character is played by George C Scott in that
- 18:18movie. So it's like they share this
- 18:20kind of spiritual DNA with each other.
- 18:23And and I think sometimes, like we forget about guys like Lee J
- 18:28Cobb because they're always the bad guy.
- 18:30They're always the heavy. But what always stands out to me
- 18:34is how believable he makes his characters.
- 18:38I'm going to be honest with you, I I don't remember who George C
- 18:41Scott is. He's the guy from Strangelove
- 18:44that was like the gum chewing. Like not the general, but the
- 18:48guy that was talking about the Ruskies.
- 18:51Yes, yes, yes, Buck, I think his name was.
- 18:54I think so. Yeah.
- 18:55OK, that that clicks for me. Yes.
- 18:57Lee J Cobb and George C Scott are wildly similar at Yeah.
- 19:03I'm not helping you in your point, Bob, because I don't know
- 19:05of him and anything other than Doctor Strangelove or how I
- 19:09learned to stop worrying and love the bomb.
- 19:11So. Well, there you go.
- 19:12There you go. And we will leave Mr. Cobb alone
- 19:17now and move on to EG Marshall juror #4.
- 19:20He is the guy who is the stuck up stockbroker and I think he
- 19:25does a really good job. But once again, it's like,
- 19:28that's just who he is, you know what I mean?
- 19:30Yeah, 100%. I, I think that throughout the
- 19:34film, the nuance I love for him is how he is staunchly on the
- 19:39guilty side, but he doesn't want to be identified with the crazy
- 19:44people on the guilty side. And I, I think that in that
- 19:47character, you've, it's easy to find yourself in there in a
- 19:52modern world where it feels like everyone and like, I'm talking
- 19:57about our current culture at this point, it feels like
- 19:59everyone wants to stereotype everyone else into like, you're
- 20:03a crazy right wing person or you're a crazy left wing person.
- 20:07And as with everybody, whether you're left wing or right wing,
- 20:11you have your reasons for being over there, but you don't want
- 20:14to get lumped in with all the, you know, wild, crazy people on
- 20:18your side. The Fringe.
- 20:20Yeah, exactly. And like, I think you can see
- 20:23that in his character. And the nuance there comes out a
- 20:27little later in the film. But it made me appreciate his
- 20:30character and his acting a lot more.
- 20:32There's a great moment after Lee J Cobb has one of his first big
- 20:36blow UPS and he's kind of off to the side.
- 20:38I think it's when the the jury split 6/6 and the stockbroker
- 20:43comes over to get some water and he's like, I Can you believe,
- 20:46you know, I'm sorry, I got a little flustered, but he's just
- 20:49trying to bait me. I can tell he's just trying to
- 20:50bait me. And he doesn't even make eye
- 20:52contact and just says, well, he certainly did a good job.
- 20:59But they use his character so well because especially at the
- 21:02end of the movie when it's like they're the last two, Lee J Cobb
- 21:06and him, they actually framed the shots where Lee J Cobb is
- 21:10sitting behind him in the shot. And he's basically telling Henry
- 21:15Fonda, like, look, you've made some really compelling points.
- 21:17Here are the things that I'm still hung up on.
- 21:20And it's a great visual representation of what Lee J
- 21:22Cobb has been doing the whole movie because every time he
- 21:25needs to reiterate facts or, you know, he needs something in his
- 21:30corner, he taps that guy on the shoulder and says, hey, you tell
- 21:34him. You tell him exactly, you know,
- 21:35And then he'll say something. And he goes, yeah, that's the
- 21:37thing that I believe, too. And it's just a great picture of
- 21:40how he's hiding behind the logic without actually using it.
- 21:44You know, yeah, 100%. And I, I think it also serves to
- 21:49be, you know, this is in the mid to late 50s.
- 21:53We've just come off a period with lots of dictators.
- 21:56I, I think that Lee J Cobb kind of serves to represent a Hitler,
- 22:01Mussolini, Stalin type of personality that there's not a
- 22:05lot of facts behind what they're saying, but man, oh man, are
- 22:08they loud and persuasive and brash.
- 22:12But when you actually sit back and and you're a little more
- 22:14cool headed about it and ask questions it, you know, people
- 22:18kind of fall away from them eventually.
- 22:21All right, juror #5 is played by Jack Klugman, who goes on to
- 22:24have a really successful career, especially in television.
- 22:27He is the original Oscar in The Odd Couple TV show.
- 22:32I'm pretty sure he's an Emmy winner.
- 22:33I think he's absolutely great in this movie, man.
- 22:36He, he plays the kid from a rough neighborhood who is still
- 22:39very sensitive to that topic, and he plays it so, so well.
- 22:43Like, they don't give him a ton of lines, but you can see his
- 22:48discomfort as people talk about kids from the slums until he
- 22:51finally speaks up. And what this movie does so
- 22:55well, both from, like, Henry Fonda and the Old Man and Jack
- 22:58Klugman, is these people are very polite until it's time for
- 23:02them to take their kind of principled stand.
- 23:04And they're not always pushy with it.
- 23:06But when it's their turn to speak, they say, no, no, no.
- 23:09Listen, I need you to understand this.
- 23:11There's something about my own experience that you need to hear
- 23:15because you're clearly not factoring that in right now, and
- 23:18his character is a great example of that.
- 23:21Yeah. And I I think that what Jack
- 23:23does so incredibly well, it is that moment where he and Lee J
- 23:29Cobb get into it because Cobb thinks that he's changed his
- 23:33vote. And and then you get the 1st, a
- 23:36close up of the old man saying that he was the one who did it.
- 23:39But it. But it's moments like that where
- 23:41you can tell this man is conflicted.
- 23:44This man is struggling with what he believes, and he's willing to
- 23:49listen to arguments on both sides.
- 23:52And in the midst of all that you can, you can feel the inner
- 23:56turmoil of like this kids just like me.
- 24:00And I, you know, his guilty vote might not just be against the
- 24:04kid, it might be against himself as well.
- 24:06And like the fact that you can read all of that from his facial
- 24:09expressions and the way he delivers his lines.
- 24:12I think Klugman. Klugman is incredible here.
- 24:14Jared number six is played by Edward Binz.
- 24:17He is also a pretty underdeveloped character.
- 24:20And yet I will say he gives one of my favorite performances of
- 24:22anybody at the table. He does a really good job of
- 24:25embodying like the blue collar worker.
- 24:28I think he they say that he's a painter, like he's a contracted
- 24:30painter and he does a great job of sticking up for like the old
- 24:35man. I just really wish there was
- 24:37more of his character in this movie because I believe Brad,
- 24:41he's the one that goes in the bathroom with Henry Fonda and
- 24:44had that great line where the stakes of the movie shift
- 24:48dramatically because, you know, Henry Fonda is is doing his
- 24:52principled thing and turning people's opinions.
- 24:54And I think it's like a nine to three vote at that point.
- 24:57And he just, he asked Henry Fonda the question, like, hey,
- 25:01suppose you convince us all that this kid is innocent and he
- 25:04really did murder his father. And then he just walks out.
- 25:07And it's the first time that possibility has been introduced.
- 25:11Yeah. So they use his character really
- 25:12well. But the performance I thought
- 25:14was just excellent, man. Yeah.
- 25:16And, and I think that he and, and Klugman are like the
- 25:20examples of how this film, you know, doesn't give all of the
- 25:24jurors an equal chance. And yet because of their acting
- 25:29performances, they raise those two characters to a level that
- 25:33the script might not naturally give them.
- 25:37And so it, it is this pairing of like, yes, they have some, some
- 25:41good lines to help them establish character, but it,
- 25:44there's so many scenes where they're saying nothing, but
- 25:46they're, you know, just off center from the camera and you
- 25:49can feel the energy radiating off of them that I, I, I just
- 25:54think, man, like they got the perfect cast for this film.
- 25:58Yeah, man, let's breeze through these last few.
- 26:00And I guess we could even hold off on talking about Henry Fonda
- 26:02for a bit, if you want. Jack Worden is juror #7.
- 26:06He plays guy who wants to go to baseball game and he plays him
- 26:10very well. I do think that there are times
- 26:13where his like the accent he's trying to do and the kind of
- 26:16dumb guy thing he's trying to do get a little distracting.
- 26:20Like he gets cornered by the the European watchmaker and he's
- 26:24like, no, no, you have to tell me why you think he's not
- 26:27guilty. And he goes, I don't, I don't
- 26:31think he's guilty. It's just the way he says it.
- 26:35It's like very Yogi Bear sounding, you know what I mean?
- 26:38And it's fine. But I think that his is probably
- 26:42one of my less favorite performances here.
- 26:45Bob, all I care about at this point is why do I recognize his
- 26:48voice? I don't know why.
- 26:52Oh. I, I thought earlier when I said
- 26:54it, you said we'd get to him later.
- 26:56I thought you had like an answer like, oh, he was Eeyore in in
- 26:59the Winnie the Pooh poofie. No, I mean, he was a a really
- 27:03well respected character actor. He was in a lot of TV shows and
- 27:06a lot of movies, but I don't, I'm looking at a bunch of TV
- 27:10shows that he was on and I don't know if you've watched any of
- 27:12them so. Oh man, yeah, that that's tough.
- 27:16He is somebody that 100%. I recognize his voice.
- 27:20I'm going to have to get on on the old Google after this and
- 27:24see if I can figure it out. All right, we'll skip Fonda for
- 27:27now. Juror #9 the old man we've kind
- 27:30of already touched on. I think the performance is
- 27:32better than you do, and I think they do a really good job.
- 27:36You know, Lumet likes to use these extreme close-ups in these
- 27:39moments where people are being the most confrontational and
- 27:42also the most vulnerable. And the first time they cut to
- 27:46one of those type of close-ups is when the old man is having
- 27:49his confessional about the other old man who had testified and
- 27:54basically accusing that guy of just wanting attention.
- 27:57And not in a bad way, but just because when you're old and
- 27:59lonely, that's what you're looking for.
- 28:02And you don't realize as he's building his argument that he's
- 28:05talking about himself. And you get that great
- 28:07realization a moment later. But yeah, for a guy who has the
- 28:11camera 3 inches from his face for a lot of his performance,
- 28:15like, yeah, I, I think he does pretty good, man.
- 28:18Yeah, I I think overall his character is well written.
- 28:22I think that his performance is like the only like B minus
- 28:26performance in the film. And that's totally fine.
- 28:29Like it still works. My least favorite performance
- 28:31here is juror #10 Ed Begley, who I actually think is a really
- 28:35good actor. His son, Ed Ed Begley Junior is
- 28:38really popular actor that you would probably recognize from
- 28:41some things. Brad, he is.
- 28:44He's good and his character is necessary.
- 28:47He's just the overt racist in the group.
- 28:50But it's like when he stands up and gives his big impassioned
- 28:53plea at the end of the movie that like none of these people
- 28:56are any good. And everyone 1 by 1 gets up and
- 28:59turns their back on him silently.
- 29:02And then he the realization sets in and he goes off in the corner
- 29:05and never says anything again. That's the most strained moment
- 29:11of the movie for me. Like it no one really is acting
- 29:14like they would in real life in that moment.
- 29:16And it just feels more like, oh, this is my visual representation
- 29:21of how we end racism. Do you know what I mean?
- 29:23I just like, no one interrupts him.
- 29:25No one's like, ah, this guy. They just all silently move away
- 29:29and like it looks cool, but it just, it was the one moment that
- 29:33didn't feel real for me. Yeah, no, I, I that was like
- 29:36kind of a note that I took while I was watching it.
- 29:39There. There's something about that
- 29:41where you can feel Lumet's voice stronger than at any other point
- 29:46in the movie. Does that make sense?
- 29:49Like, like through the camera work, through the blocking of
- 29:52where the actors are walking, you're like, oh, I get it,
- 29:55Lumet. We're just, we're just all
- 29:57turning our backs on racism now. Go America and, and, and I don't
- 30:04know, that sounds weird to say because we're all against
- 30:07racism. It's bad.
- 30:08We all should turn our backs on it.
- 30:10But there there was something about it that felt preachy
- 30:13compared to the rest of the film.
- 30:15I do appreciate, though, that it's like it's the most drastic
- 30:19reaction of the group because everyone else has their little
- 30:22personal peccadillo's, you know, like, yeah, like the holes get
- 30:27poked in them and they get kind of turned.
- 30:30And then I think the argument like, mad.
- 30:32What's that? Just like the father.
- 30:34Yeah, exactly. And I think that the point
- 30:38Lumet's trying to make here is this guy doesn't really have a
- 30:42personal reason and other than he just doesn't like these kind
- 30:46of people. It's like there's there's no,
- 30:49he's formed an opinion and he just hates people.
- 30:53And I think it gets to the point sometimes where there is just no
- 30:56humanity to appeal to the way you can with the Lee J Cobb.
- 31:00And so at that point, the only thing you could do is just tell
- 31:02him to shut up and sit down, which is what the stockbroker
- 31:05does. Yeah, yeah.
- 31:07I will say that's another moment where like if all the turning
- 31:11around and, you know, turning their backs to him is kind of a
- 31:14little bit cheesy. The the way the stockbroker
- 31:17delivers that line is so cutting.
- 31:20And like, man, he cuts him straight out at the knees and
- 31:23he's done for the rest of the movie.
- 31:25And I that that's probably the one part of that scene that I'm
- 31:28like, yeah, you get him. All right, we have two more
- 31:31jurors, and then we'll take a break.
- 31:32George Voskovac plays juror #11 the European watchmaker.
- 31:37He's pretty good. He's also one of those ones that
- 31:40it's like, oh, we're going to use this character as a way for
- 31:43us to talk about the goodness of America.
- 31:45Like he stands up and, and does the whole like, what are the
- 31:49things that I, I longed for in the old country?
- 31:51And it's OK, man. Like we get it.
- 31:54Democracy is great, you know. Also, I think you have to be
- 31:57Eastern European to call it the old country.
- 32:00I don't know if you're allowed to do that from France.
- 32:02Oh, OK, well, there you go. France.
- 32:05France, very famously not an old country.
- 32:07Yeah, yeah, exactly. I, I like him a lot.
- 32:13I think he does a good job with what he's asked to do.
- 32:17I think one of the funniest lines of the movie is when he he
- 32:20corrects the racist guy's speech.
- 32:24That man. Because like the the French guy
- 32:28does not speak for like the first 80% of the movie pretty
- 32:31much except for that one line and it's in that one line.
- 32:36I just about lost it. So he has some good moments for
- 32:39sure. Juror #12 is a slick ad
- 32:42executive played by Robert Weber and Brad.
- 32:45I think you. I think you mispronounced
- 32:47beautiful as slick. He's a good looking man.
- 32:50He's well built, incredible. He's got that Mad Men suit and
- 32:53and hairdo going as well. The funny thing about him is
- 32:56that he looks like, I don't know Rock Hudson, you know, but he
- 33:02he's trying to behave like Jack Lemmon.
- 33:05And the whole performance I was like, Oh, Jack Lemmon was too
- 33:10famous to be guy as juror #2 in this movie.
- 33:13So then they're like, Hey, you do a good Jack Lemmon.
- 33:17And I think it like it works. And he he is the like fast
- 33:20talking ad executive. But it just felt like if if I
- 33:25had had that movie on in the background and not been watching
- 33:27it and just listening to his voice, it sounded like he was
- 33:30trying to do a Jack Lemmon impression to me.
- 33:33Yeah, a little bit. I think that he feels the least
- 33:37real of all the characters, but at the same time I think that
- 33:42his, you know, script wise, his character does add a lot to the
- 33:47room. I think that the acting
- 33:50performance is just fine. It's solid if anything.
- 33:53Man, it's really hard when you have 12 main characters to get
- 33:57through anything else on a podcast, Brad?
- 33:58We haven't talked about Henry Fonda and we haven't talked
- 34:01about Lumet and the movie making part of this.
- 34:04I think it's time for us to hit pause.
- 34:06We'll come back and touch on Fonda and then we'll talk a
- 34:08little bit about what makes this movie so great.
- 34:11What do you say we drink this whiskey?
- 34:13You want to touch Henry Fonda? He he touched me deep in my
- 34:17soul. Let's get to it, Bob.
- 34:27All right, so today, Brad, we are revisiting a brand that we
- 34:29haven't even talked about since I think season 1, maybe 2, and
- 34:33that is very Old Barton. Now to give just the briefest of
- 34:38histories here, this is a whiskey that I had like when I
- 34:41first got on whiskey Instagram. People were always like, you can
- 34:45only find it in Kentucky, and it's really cheap and it's
- 34:47really good for the price. Don't sleep on Very Old Barton.
- 34:51And so I made a trip to Kentucky.
- 34:52I bought a bunch of whiskey for our podcast.
- 34:54And I was like, it's the one that people on Instagram know.
- 34:58And we hadn't really established yet that like our podcast was
- 35:01going to be about whiskeys people can buy everywhere.
- 35:04And so it became pretty immediately apparent, like Very
- 35:07Old Barton might be known by people who visit Kentucky, but
- 35:11not by anyone outside of that. And I feel like I kind of
- 35:15pigeonholed us into trying all of them because there's 4 proof
- 35:17points of Very Old Barton and we ended up trying them all.
- 35:22And fun fact, you can get this in the state of Ohio now.
- 35:25Oh, that's. True.
- 35:26I think, yeah, the 80 proof for sure.
- 35:28Can you buy all four variants in Ohio?
- 35:31I don't I I think it's just the 80 proof.
- 35:33OK, so they'd make an 80 proof and 86 proof, a 90 proof and a
- 35:38bottled and bond version. And the bottled and bond is 75%
- 35:43corn, 15% rye, 10% barley. I don't think there's any reason
- 35:47to believe that this is a different mash bill.
- 35:49So we're dealing with a a high ish rye bourbon.
- 35:53It's aged according to the label on the back of this small
- 35:56plastic bottle for 36 months, Brad.
- 35:59So it's a three-year bourbon. I've been thinking about this
- 36:02lately. You know, like, first of all, I
- 36:04respect that they put that it's a three-year bourbon on here.
- 36:07Like a lot of places wouldn't even do that and I respect that
- 36:10at least. Yeah, but I was going to ask you
- 36:13like, what do you think is the age of a bourbon where you start
- 36:18being like? I'll drink that.
- 36:22Like you don't have to give the caveat anymore.
- 36:24Like oh it's good for a two year bourbon.
- 36:26Like when do you drop the four NX year?
- 36:30I think that once a whiskey hits four years, I kind of stop
- 36:35worrying about the age, like worrying in the sense of like,
- 36:40like I still want to know the age if it's a six year and
- 36:42eight-year or 12 year. But I, I stopped worrying in the
- 36:45sense of like, oh, is that going to be any good?
- 36:49Like once you hit four years, I assume that it has aged long
- 36:52enough to get the character necessary to make me pull my
- 36:56wallet out. I think honestly though, as
- 36:58like, if we can transition into the nose on this bourbon, man,
- 37:01at three years and at 80 proof, I'm pretty shocked at how
- 37:05pleasant this smells. Yeah, it, it's not bad.
- 37:10I got like some caramel, some peanuts, some ethanol.
- 37:14And then the longer I sat with it, the overwhelming, like, I
- 37:18could not get this out of my head.
- 37:20I think this smells like apple juice, Bob.
- 37:22Oh interesting. See I'm getting a completely
- 37:24different fruit, but I'm getting banana on this like a lot.
- 37:27I'm like fresh baked banana bread and I have a friend that
- 37:31makes this bread this like almost like a banana cake, but
- 37:34it's like a banana bread that has like a, a brown sugar kind
- 37:37of Maple frosting on it. And I'm getting a ton of that
- 37:40here. I get the banana, I get the
- 37:41brown sugar. I do think that like if you
- 37:44really go in for the nose, there are some notes that are like,
- 37:48oh, this smells a little bit cheap.
- 37:50Like there's there's a little bit of like wet paper for me on
- 37:53this as well, but it's almost like it's covered up by these
- 37:56syrupy sweet Roma's on top of that.
- 38:00So it kind of masks the fact that this is like a $10 whiskey
- 38:04and I'm cool with that. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2 on
- 38:06the nose. Have you ever Have you ever
- 38:09taken a banana that's like, you're like, oh, I'm on the edge
- 38:14of whether or not I could eat this.
- 38:16And there's enough black spots on it that I'm a little nervous.
- 38:19I think that's what that's what this smells like for me.
- 38:23Like, I'm with you. It has a banana smell, but it's
- 38:25a it's like a little too sweet over a little bit like, yeah,
- 38:29over ripe banana. The note that all whiskey
- 38:32producers. Are going for?
- 38:34Yeah, exactly. I personally gave this a 4 1/2
- 38:39on on the nose. Out of 10.
- 38:43Yes. No Bob, I actually decided to
- 38:45switch it up this week. I'm scoring everything out of a
- 38:4777.75 is my Max. Wow, I thought this was way
- 38:52better than a four and a half. I'm going to give it a sip.
- 38:54Why don't you tell us what you're tasting notes are?
- 38:57The taste is decent. I think that there's vanilla,
- 39:01there's some like just like almost a generic like heavy
- 39:03whipping cream. There's apple peel.
- 39:07I don't really get much caramel and the, the fruitiness that I
- 39:13experienced on the nose, that apple juice overripe banana kind
- 39:18of just turns into what, what would you say the the tasting
- 39:23note is on like an overripe banana?
- 39:26Like like, I don't, I don't want to call it, you know?
- 39:30Yeah, it's hard because when when a banana is too green, it's
- 39:32kind of sour, and when a banana is too ripe, it's kind of sour.
- 39:35But they're different. They're very different.
- 39:37Yeah, exactly. So I'm like, I don't know if
- 39:39like sickly sweet is the right word, but it's like, it's like
- 39:44the wrong kind of sweet. I I think it's a decent palette.
- 39:49I'll give it a 5 1/2 out of 10 here.
- 39:51I'm wondering if if part of the reason that our notes are about
- 39:54to be different is because of the different nosing notes we
- 39:57picked up. So I had that like overly sweet
- 40:00Maple, brown sugar and banana. And so I was expecting a really
- 40:04sweet palate and I was disappointed in how not sweet
- 40:08the palate was based on what I was expecting, right?
- 40:11So like, it's really oaky. And then for me, the rye and the
- 40:15malt took over. Like it gets really, really
- 40:18almost like a toasted oak kind of flavor, but then.
- 40:22It almost like sapped the like it was almost tannic for me and
- 40:26I think I'm the malt in the rye had a lot to do with that.
- 40:30I wouldn't call it bitter, but it's definitely unsweet and at
- 40:3480 proof it was a little bit aggressive too.
- 40:36I don't know if I would say that it was like alcohol forward.
- 40:39It packed a punch. Like I actually think this would
- 40:41go really well in a cocktail because it stands up so well,
- 40:46but it was just not what I was expecting on the flavor.
- 40:48I'm going to give it just a 5 1/2.
- 40:51Yeah. And as I got into the finish,
- 40:52it, it doesn't finish well. It it kind of sours for me.
- 40:56There's a little bit of a leathery like essence of leather
- 41:02type of feel. O day leather.
- 41:04O day leather, it's kind of oaky on the end.
- 41:08It gets a little bittery sour. I'll come back down to a 4 1/2
- 41:12on the finish. Yeah.
- 41:14I mean, I just don't think it's anything to write home about.
- 41:16I would give it a six, but I don't know that I'm even that
- 41:19positive about it. I'm just very neutral.
- 41:21So I think another 5 1/2 is in order here.
- 41:24And that takes us to balance where, you know, Brad, we, we
- 41:28try to be objective about our first four categories and then
- 41:32if it's a cheap whiskey that is OK, we kind of reward it in the
- 41:37value category. I don't think this is a really
- 41:42well balanced whiskey. Like, I mean it, it's well
- 41:44balanced in that it's like just very mediocre across the board.
- 41:49I guess I'll give it a six on balance.
- 41:52Where are you sitting on it? I'm actually at the same point.
- 41:55And I think for me it's not the fact that it's mediocre with
- 41:59like crazy different notes throughout, it's the fact that
- 42:02like the flavors remain pretty consistent and steady throughout
- 42:07there. There's nothing that like
- 42:09overpowers you on the nose and then disappears on the taste.
- 42:12And like all the flavors kind of are present.
- 42:15They're there. They they stay the same and I
- 42:18think that's fine. So yeah, 6 out of 10.
- 42:21All right. And that takes us to value,
- 42:23Brad, since this is sold in Ohio now, what is the price on a
- 42:26750ML bottle? This will set you back 21
- 42:32dollars. What?
- 42:34The 80 proof? Yes Sir.
- 42:36Oh, that's crazy. Now, I don't think I've ever
- 42:39done this before. I can tell you for a fact that
- 42:44it was not nearly that expensive when I visited Kentucky just a
- 42:47few months ago to pick up these samples for us.
- 42:50In fact, I got us these 200ML tiny little bottles.
- 42:54They were $3 a piece. Like I'm pretty sure this bottle
- 42:58in a 750 was either 1199 or 1299.
- 43:02Yeah. So I don't really know, like I
- 43:04don't know how to score this, Brad, because I'm, I'm grateful
- 43:07that Ohio picked it up, but I was planning to score it out
- 43:11based on Kentucky prices because I thought it was only available
- 43:13there. Yeah.
- 43:14I mean, looking online, I see a lot of prices in the 13 to
- 43:20$16.00 range. So I think it'd be fair to call
- 43:23this a $15 whiskey. All right cool so it's right in
- 43:26line with like a benchmark. I think benchmark is better than
- 43:30this like I think this smells better than benchmark.
- 43:33I think benchmarks better at 15 bucks.
- 43:37There are only a few whiskeys you can actually buy so like
- 43:44it's not the best one in the category though so I think I'm
- 43:46automatically going to dock it a few.
- 43:48I'll give it a 7 out of 10 on value because it's not
- 43:51unpalatable and you can't really get any cheaper for a bottle of
- 43:54whiskey. Yeah, I'll, I'll give it a 7 1/2
- 43:58as well. I think that this is a really
- 44:00solid expression at 1516 dollars.
- 44:04I think that even at 80 proof the the flavors remain solid
- 44:08throughout. It does have a little bit of pop
- 44:10of flavor on the palate and if you're going to spend $15 on
- 44:14whiskey, like you might as well spend it here.
- 44:17So I I think it's a solid value. Bob, I am coming out to a 28 out
- 44:22of 50. Where are you at?
- 44:24Brad, I'm at a 31 1/2 out of 50, which kind of feels high from
- 44:28being honest, but like that value score really boosted it.
- 44:31So we are at just a 59.5 out of 100 or a 29.75 out of 50.
- 44:39I think that's a pretty fair score.
- 44:41Like, yeah, this is a an extremely mediocre whiskey that
- 44:46is boosted by the fact that it's like 14 bucks.
- 44:50Yeah, 100%. If this cost, as you said, if it
- 44:53cost $2122, I think it would fall off pretty quickly.
- 44:58But at $15 like you can't make the argument that this needs to
- 45:02compete with Rebel 100 like it it is a genuine lower price
- 45:06category. I think it does its job pretty
- 45:08pretty admirably. All right.
- 45:10Now the real question is, which juror do you think this most
- 45:15appeals to? I think the baseball juror #7II,
- 45:21I just think that this is his go to drink.
- 45:24Well, as long as it's not like the, you know, raging racist
- 45:27guy, I think that it's kind of just pick, take your pick, and
- 45:31then you're OK. We, we don't want to put that on
- 45:33any of our, our whiskey brands, Bob.
- 45:35No, especially not this one. All right, man, let's get back
- 45:38into talking about 12 angry men. What do you say?
- 45:41Let's get to it. All right, everybody, That was
- 45:47very old Barton 80 proof, a whiskey that cost little money
- 45:53and will probably make little impact on your life.
- 45:56And that's OK, Sometimes you know it.
- 45:58Is yeah, sometimes you just need a whiskey that is unremarkable.
- 46:02You you can't appreciate the great whiskey.
- 46:05Without having a baseline, yeah. Yeah, if you don't have very old
- 46:08Barton 80. When I was a kid, every once in
- 46:10a while my mom would take us to see a movie and it would be a
- 46:13movie that usually like a movie I didn't pick, but it was like
- 46:16the kids movie that was out at the time and it was mediocre.
- 46:21And we would leave and the the thing my mom would say as we
- 46:23walked out to the car was that was cute.
- 46:27And cute was like, you know, it was fine.
- 46:29Even like 7 year old Bob knew what she meant.
- 46:32Yeah, You know, like, it wasn't great, but we had an OK time.
- 46:35And then, you know, this, this whiskey was cute.
- 46:38Yeah. And that's OK.
- 46:38About being you. Need those exactly.
- 46:42Well, you know what else brings us together, Bob, and has never
- 46:44once caused a riff in our relationship?
- 46:46Is it 2 facts and a falsehood? 2 facts and a falsehood baby.
- 46:51Brad is going to try to stump you.
- 46:53Ball 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 46:592 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 47:03the podcast where Brad presents three items to me as fact about
- 47:07the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie, and I
- 47:10have to figure out which one that is.
- 47:13Brad, there are so many directions you can go with your
- 47:15facts and falsehoods today. There's twelve people to keep
- 47:18track of, there's a great screenplay, there's a great
- 47:22director, and to be honest with you, I finished watching this
- 47:25movie like 8 minutes before we started recording.
- 47:28So I have not done any research and I am very vulnerable to
- 47:32losing today. So with that.
- 47:34As you are every day, Bob fact #1 as juror #8 is pacing the
- 47:41distance. Henry Fonda, juror #7 makes fun
- 47:44of the way he is pacing by whistling.
- 47:46The tune he whistles is called Dance of the Cuckoos, which was
- 47:49the theme song for Laurel and Hardy.
- 47:53Fact #2 at the time of this recording, Bob, this is the
- 47:56shortest movie in the IMDb top ten as well as the only one in
- 48:00the top ten to be under 2 hours in length.
- 48:03It is also the only movie in the top 30 to be under 100 minutes
- 48:08in length. The next film to have a 2 digit
- 48:11runtime is actually I'm. I'm going to make you guess what
- 48:15do you what do you think the next film is?
- 48:17We have watched it on the podcast, I'll give you that.
- 48:20I don't know. Is it a chaplain?
- 48:22Hey, good job dude. Is it really?
- 48:25Yeah, it is. Well, what is it?
- 48:27Well, you have to guess the you. You guessed the director.
- 48:29Modern Times. No City lights City.
- 48:32Lights all right? That number 35, good job.
- 48:34Though, man. Well, thank you.
- 48:36Yeah, but what if that's a falsehood though?
- 48:38Wait a minute. What if that ends up being a
- 48:39falsehood? You can't tell me.
- 48:40Good job if I guessed something you made-up.
- 48:44I I'm hey man, maybe it is modern times fact number three.
- 48:50Of all the jurors in this film, Edward Bin's juror number six is
- 48:54the only one still alive at 102 years of age.
- 48:59He was born in 1921 in Philadelphia, PA.
- 49:04I don't know, man. All right, I'm just going to
- 49:07assume number 2 is true just for the time being, because you, you
- 49:10said good job and I want to believe that.
- 49:12I guess something that's true #3 sounds like wild 102 years old
- 49:20and number one was what was #1 again.
- 49:24As as Henry Fonda is pacing. Oh yeah, out of there.
- 49:28He's whistling the Laurel and Hardy themes.
- 49:31There's a couple moments in this movie where they make pop
- 49:33culture references, like Lee J Cobb calls somebody The Boy in
- 49:37the Gray Flannel suit. There was a movie called The Man
- 49:40in the Gray Flannel Suit, so I assumed that that tune was
- 49:45something that people knew. I don't know if that's what it
- 49:47is. So it it could be a falsehood,
- 49:50Brad, I'm going to just go with my gut and say that number 3 is
- 49:55the falsehood, but I have absolutely no basis for that.
- 50:00Bob, your gut has steered you in the correct direction.
- 50:04That is the falsehood. Man, that's kind of sad though,
- 50:07because I he's dead, you know? Yes, yes, all of them.
- 50:12I have I. Have never unknowingly cheered
- 50:16at someone's death like that before.
- 50:18I got you. Yeah, As I was watching the
- 50:25film, I was looking at facts about it, and the final juror
- 50:29actually passed away in 2012. OK.
- 50:32And who was that? Right now I don't remember.
- 50:35What if it was the old man? What if he?
- 50:38Lived like 172. I was going to say, like
- 50:41Speaking of Chaplin films, I remember the when we watched, I
- 50:45believe it was Gold Rush, the they had what they think to be
- 50:50the oldest man on film ever in that movie because there was a
- 50:55guy in the movie who was born in like 1837 and the movie came out
- 51:00in like 1928. That's crazy.
- 51:04Yeah. All right, Brad, let's get into
- 51:06talking about Henry Fonda a little bit.
- 51:08I don't know that there's too much that needs to be said that
- 51:11hasn't already been said. The great thing about Fonda in
- 51:14this movie and kind of Fonda's personality overall, he reminds
- 51:19me of, like, I think I've had this conversation with you
- 51:22before, too. One of my favorite working
- 51:24actors is Matt Damon because Matt Damon is never showy.
- 51:30He's just not a showbodie actor. And you know, I, I'm thinking
- 51:34about movies that he made, like he made one, I don't know if
- 51:37you've seen it, Brad. It's called Air.
- 51:38It's about like the air, the creation of the Air Jordan shoe.
- 51:41And he plays Sonny Vaccaro in that movie.
- 51:44He is the most unassuming. Like for a guy that had a big
- 51:47personality in real life, Damon is so good at just taking what
- 51:51other actors give him and working with it.
- 51:54And I don't feel like he gets recognized enough because he
- 51:56doesn't give these big Oscar E performances.
- 51:59And I think Fonda's the same way.
- 52:01Like, yes, he has the biggest part in this movie, but so much
- 52:04of this performance is him just kind of sitting back silently
- 52:08and watching the world burn around him and, like, bidding
- 52:11his time and waiting to jump in and say what he needs to say.
- 52:15But it never once feels stagey or like he's trying to hog the
- 52:20spotlight. Yeah, I think he has a talent
- 52:23for giving the soft smile when somebody kind of turns his way
- 52:29and and he does it in such a way that you feel included, like you
- 52:35matter. And I think that's why this
- 52:38movie stands up so well is because it's, it's a master
- 52:42class in like, like, I, I have to imagine that if somebody
- 52:46wrote a movie that wanted to illustrate Carnegie's, you know,
- 52:51how to win friends and influence people, what movie would better
- 52:56illustrate that than this film? Like, he has this talent for
- 53:00being charming and yet firm and, and the way he wins people over
- 53:06by using their own emotions, using their own logic, not
- 53:10against them, but just to question what they're doing.
- 53:14I like I just I I think that Fonda takes what is written on
- 53:18this on the script, which is great, and raises it to the next
- 53:22level. So the screenplay was written by
- 53:24Reginald Rose and it was originally developed as a
- 53:28teleplay like it was ATV movie before those were really a
- 53:31thing. And then it was developed into a
- 53:33full length movie. And I think to go back to the
- 53:36script again with Reginald Rose, one of the great things that he
- 53:40does is he lets people's logic defeat themselves.
- 53:44And he doesn't always have to under score that with people
- 53:47saying aha or gotcha. Like there's a great moment, I
- 53:51don't know, like midway through the movie, probably when they're
- 53:54arguing about, you know, whether the old man could have walked so
- 53:58far, whatever. And Lee J Cobb says he was an
- 54:02old man. How could he be sure about
- 54:04anything? And as soon as he says that, you
- 54:06can see Lee J Cobb go, damn it, they shouldn't have said that.
- 54:10Like, I know what I just said. And everybody behind him just
- 54:13kind of gives a little smirk because they all know what he
- 54:15just did, too. But no one acknowledges it.
- 54:18It's just kind of like in a boxing match and you're kind of
- 54:20tallying up hits like it who's landing punches?
- 54:24Because we all know at the end of the day, like, we're going to
- 54:27tally them all up in the the final summation of things.
- 54:30But Fonda's performance kind of demonstrates that better than I
- 54:35think anybody else's. He's not always pouncing on
- 54:37people and he's letting their own words come back to kind of
- 54:41cook them at the end of the movie.
- 54:43Yeah, and, and he continually does not commit himself to his
- 54:46position so hard that it would push anyone away from what he
- 54:51believes. Like he's continually
- 54:53backpedaling. And, you know, they pointed out
- 54:56in the film, like when he goes into the bathroom, I, I don't
- 54:59remember if it's juror number six or if it's one of the later
- 55:03ones. But you know, somebody says to
- 55:06him, like, have you ever heard of the Soft Cell?
- 55:08Because, boy, you're the master at it.
- 55:11And and like, it's true. He has an ability to say, look,
- 55:15I'm not saying he is 100% innocent.
- 55:18I'm just saying there's a shadow of a doubt, you know, is it, is
- 55:21it possible that this alternates, you know, theory
- 55:25could be viable instead of just what the prosecution gave us?
- 55:31All right, before we dive into Lumet, I do just want to take
- 55:34one more 2nd and talk about how good this script is because
- 55:36like, the first note that I took was about the way that the movie
- 55:40just kind of logically unfolds. I don't even know if logically
- 55:43is the word, but realistically, because Fonda does his whole
- 55:47thing where he's like, I'm the only one.
- 55:49I think that there I have a doubt and it's possible.
- 55:52And everyone's like, you know, But then immediately people
- 55:57start pointing out little things that they noticed too.
- 56:01And after the first couple, you get people that are starting to
- 56:06feel personally offended by it, like, well, how dare you accuse
- 56:10me of this? And then someone saying I'm not
- 56:11accusing you of anything. And but I love that the way that
- 56:15it unfolds is that before anyone changes their mind, everyone
- 56:19gets offended first. And so there's always, there's
- 56:21already like these little riffs. And I think that's it's such a
- 56:25good demonstration of how this would actually happen in real
- 56:27life. Like no one would just be like,
- 56:29oh, you know what, you're right. I'm going to change my vote.
- 56:33They they each have to personally push past their own,
- 56:37I don't know, pride, vanity, thought process.
- 56:41And because of all that, like the the first, I don't know, 20
- 56:44minutes of debate between all these people.
- 56:47Is this kind of personal like, well, I didn't say that.
- 56:51Why are you putting words in my mouth for?
- 56:53And it just makes for. It's awkward to get through, but
- 56:56it's exactly how that would really happen.
- 56:58Well, and they also set you up for like, the social politeness
- 57:02factor of like, yeah, there's these big personalities in the
- 57:05room that just want to get this over with.
- 57:07And I don't want to be the guy that, like, goes against the big
- 57:11public voice in the room. But as soon as they do the blind
- 57:15vote, it's fascinating to me that the old man doesn't change
- 57:19his opinion because he thinks the boy is not guilty.
- 57:22He does it because he has respect for Henry Fonda.
- 57:26And I think that even that is like a fascinating pushed by the
- 57:30script to say, like, people do things for reasons that do not
- 57:35have any relevance to, to what's going on in front of them.
- 57:38Like people are not always logical.
- 57:40Like they're there to determine the guilt of this boy.
- 57:43And he just voted not guilty based on nothing about the case
- 57:47and 100% on the fact that he's like, man, this guy's all by
- 57:51himself. I think I'm going to vote for
- 57:52him because he's he's, you know, committed.
- 57:55Well, and that's like the really great thing about this too, is I
- 57:57don't know that Henry Fonda really proves the the boy's
- 58:00innocence. And he doesn't have to, right?
- 58:02He says at the beginning, like, that's the burden of the
- 58:04prosecution. And if they didn't prove his
- 58:06guilt, then you have to vote not guilty, right?
- 58:10And I think in our very first episode on this, Brad, I kind of
- 58:12said, like, I think if you're just talking probabilistically,
- 58:16like it, it does seem like a ton of coincidences had to add up to
- 58:21get this kid off. And so maybe, maybe the
- 58:24probability is that he he did kill his dad.
- 58:27But I think it's such a good example of how I don't know what
- 58:34am I trying to say. I think what you're trying to
- 58:36say is it's a beautiful example of social maneuvering.
- 58:42And I think that at the end of the day, if the jury had to
- 58:46reveal like the content of their deliberation, I think that their
- 58:50verdict would have gotten thrown out.
- 58:53Like that? Like what you mean sneaking in a
- 58:55knife as? A.
- 58:56Counter evidence is not going to be allowed.
- 58:59Yeah. You know, I think that there's a
- 59:01lot of conjecture here, especially from the old man who
- 59:05literally like, isn't saying like, here's some facts and a
- 59:09reasonable thing based off of it.
- 59:10He's just kind of like this guy's old and I think he wants
- 59:14attention and, and everybody's like, I don't know about that.
- 59:18And he's like, Nah, I know about it.
- 59:20And, and everybody's just like, OK, there's enough that goes on
- 59:24that I'm like, I once again, this is an example of a movie
- 59:29that you're not looking for it to be a fully accurate
- 59:34description of the American legal system.
- 59:37You're looking at it and, and, and counting it as one of, you
- 59:41know, the top 20 greatest movies of all time simply for the fact
- 59:45that you get to watch these people just bounce off of each
- 59:49other and run into each other. And it's something that I've
- 59:52said in running events for a long time in my personal life,
- 59:56that anytime you add a person into the room, right?
- 1:00:00Whether it's, you know, adding a Co worker into a into an e-mail
- 1:00:04thread to have a conversation about something.
- 1:00:06Whether it's adding 10 more people under your guest list for
- 1:00:09your wedding. Like anytime you add a person
- 1:00:12into the room, you are adding. Their childhood, their first
- 1:00:16girlfriend that dumped them, their experience with people of
- 1:00:20a different race, their experience with religion and
- 1:00:23church. And you're adding all this
- 1:00:26massive ball of, of human experiences of sadness and joy
- 1:00:32and anger and disappointment and prejudice and, and all these
- 1:00:35things. And I don't know if I've ever
- 1:00:37seen a movie illustrate that better than 12 Angry Men.
- 1:00:42Yeah, I mean, if it hadn't been for each of the people in that
- 1:00:45room like this kids going to the electric chair, that's just, you
- 1:00:48know, if it was 12 ad men like juror #12, they would have said,
- 1:00:53let's throw it out on the scoop and see if the cat licks it up.
- 1:00:55And then it would have been, it would have been done.
- 1:00:58Let's let's throw it the other direction.
- 1:00:59What if it was 12 angry women? Is.
- 1:01:04Is he going to the electric chair?
- 1:01:05I don't. Know man, I'm not going to go
- 1:01:06there but all right, Brad, real quick, let's talk about Lumet
- 1:01:11because again this is his first movie.
- 1:01:13We talked in our our first episode on this about how this
- 1:01:16movie is famous for how many different camera setups he has
- 1:01:19and how there's I think there's like over 100 setups and he
- 1:01:22never returns to a shot once. He does it once.
- 1:01:25And I think I mean 6 Bob, what is it?
- 1:01:28356. That's crazy.
- 1:01:30That's so many shots. But it works really well to the
- 1:01:34point where there they had such a low budget for this film that
- 1:01:38there were certain lighting setups that worked for multiple
- 1:01:42of those 356 shots. And so they would film, you
- 1:01:47know, shot #72 of, you know, early in the film and then shot
- 1:01:52number 85 and then shot number 97.
- 1:01:55And so, like, there might be weeks in between, you know, the
- 1:02:00actual next line in the film. Because when they were actually
- 1:02:04performing it. Like, that's crazy.
- 1:02:06Isn't that that's mind. Boggling.
- 1:02:08Can you imagine having to keep track of all that?
- 1:02:10That's what dude, that's what I'm saying, man.
- 1:02:12They didn't have Google Spreadsheets.
- 1:02:13They couldn't share it with everybody on the team and be
- 1:02:16like, all right, we're moving, moving on.
- 1:02:18We need this lighting set up. One, OK, so two things that I
- 1:02:21noticed AI think the obvious 1 is like the the camera gets much
- 1:02:26closer to people as the movie goes on.
- 1:02:27It gets more much more claustrophobic because it's
- 1:02:30getting more personal in the thematic content, right?
- 1:02:33Like, you know, Lee J Cobb is having his own stuff challenged,
- 1:02:39and so the cameras pushing in closer and closer on his face.
- 1:02:42But the thing that I really noticed this time is that I was
- 1:02:46expecting all these different shots.
- 1:02:47I wasn't expecting how many wonders there were in this
- 1:02:50movie. Like, there's a ton, especially
- 1:02:52in the early going where it's like extended shots.
- 1:02:56And he's getting 345 shots out of each of those.
- 1:02:59Yeah, 100%. There's, he has a talent with
- 1:03:02the camera that I don't think you see in a lot of first time
- 1:03:05directors. And granted, he was a television
- 1:03:07director for a long time, like, like this isn't his first time
- 1:03:10behind a camera. But man, oh man, the, the camera
- 1:03:14movement in this not, not just like panning from one side to
- 1:03:18the other, but the, the little short dollies.
- 1:03:20And when, when Henry Fonda is limping across the floor and it
- 1:03:25follows him down the room. And even just the blocking of
- 1:03:29the racist juror being like slowly backed off by Henry
- 1:03:33Fonda's limping is incredible. But the way the camera stays
- 1:03:36close to his feet and then as he turns, it slowly pans up as it
- 1:03:40moves backwards into his face, it's just, it's just incredible.
- 1:03:45Bob all. Right, man.
- 1:03:46I think it's time for us to get to our final segment of the day,
- 1:03:50which we call let's make it a double.
- 1:03:52We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 1:03:55the film and Whiskey show. Let's have another film with
- 1:03:58this one, even if it's struggling.
- 1:04:00It's the final segment of the day.
- 1:04:01Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:04:04part of the podcast where we pick another movie to pair up
- 1:04:07with this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:04:10Brad, I've been thinking about this a lot.
- 1:04:12And I mean, you could go a lot of different directions.
- 1:04:15You could go courtroom drama with it.
- 1:04:19Man, I don't know. I like, I want to be deep and
- 1:04:23and do a really good pairing, but I can't get the Lee J Cobb,
- 1:04:26George C Scott thing out of my head.
- 1:04:28So right now I'm just going to say pair it with Doctor
- 1:04:30Strangelove and watch two guys scream for three hours.
- 1:04:34What's, what's that movie, Bob? I didn't recognize the title.
- 1:04:36Oh, that's Doctor Strangelove, or how I learned to stop
- 1:04:40worrying and love the bomb. Oh, what a movie.
- 1:04:43Man, That's that was a good one. I'm going to go the opposite
- 1:04:48direction of you in terms of title length.
- 1:04:52I'm going to go with a one word title.
- 1:04:55I think that watching this and then watching Network would be
- 1:04:59an incredible evening of cinema. Lumet and great scripts.
- 1:05:04Yeah, that, that's what I'm saying, man.
- 1:05:07Like, I was trying to think of other, like pair it with another
- 1:05:09courtroom drama, you know, To Kill a Mockingbird would be the
- 1:05:12obvious choice. But I think that just sitting
- 1:05:15down for, you know, network is what, 2 1/2 hours?
- 1:05:19Maybe not even that long, yeah. Yeah, and then watching this for
- 1:05:2390 minutes, I think that'd be a heck of a night, man.
- 1:05:26Brad, we have done I think three 1957 movies on this podcast and
- 1:05:32they are all bangers now, like this movie Bridge on the River,
- 1:05:36Kwai and and Paths of Glory. Yeah.
- 1:05:40So you could just bring it up by year and do a triple feature and
- 1:05:43that would be awesome. That would be awesome.
- 1:05:46Another fun fact I gleaned in my research of the film, this movie
- 1:05:50was nominated for three Oscars and lost to Bridge on the River
- 1:05:54Kwai for all three of them. It was just kind of a
- 1:05:57steamroller that year, man. Yeah, it really was.
- 1:06:00And like, I'll say this, Bridge on the River Kwai is an
- 1:06:04incredible movie. I absolutely love it. 12 Angry
- 1:06:08Men Is is perfect, Bob. It is.
- 1:06:10Perfect. And it's, you know, it's hard
- 1:06:12because like, listen, I I'm a prisoner of the moment sometimes
- 1:06:15and bridge on the river Kwai is one of those movies that like, I
- 1:06:18don't really blame the Oscars for not rewarding this tiny
- 1:06:22movie that flopped and rewarding Bridge on the River Kwai
- 1:06:25instead. It's not like that's a bad
- 1:06:27movie, but like this, this is a perfect movie, Brad.
- 1:06:31And and I think to tip my final score here, it is like a 10
- 1:06:35plus. It's a it's a 10 out of 10 and
- 1:06:37then some because I can't think of a single thing about this
- 1:06:41movie that I would really change.
- 1:06:43Do I think every single word spoken is perfect?
- 1:06:47No, but I don't know that I would cut a second out of this
- 1:06:51movie or add anything else to it.
- 1:06:53Yeah, like there's no such thing as a perfect movie, Bob, but
- 1:06:58this is a perfect movie. You know what I mean?
- 1:07:02Like like that. There's just nothing that I
- 1:07:05think you could change about this and make it enhanced or
- 1:07:09better. I think that what happened is
- 1:07:11the best version that we could have gotten of this film and I
- 1:07:15I'm giving it a 10 out of 10. All right, so it's a 10 out of
- 1:07:1910 from both of us. I'm not really surprised, Brad,
- 1:07:21but I think it deserves to be restated again.
- 1:07:24If you've never seen 12 Angry Men, you are missing out.
- 1:07:27And it is like 94 minutes long or something like that.
- 1:07:30It's a quick watch it, it's AI mean it breezes by.
- 1:07:34I can't recommend it highly enough.
- 1:07:36But we want to know what you think of 12 Angry Men.
- 1:07:39So reach out to us on all of our social medias.
- 1:07:41You can find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok,
- 1:07:45YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or you can join the angry
- 1:07:50conversation over on our Discord.
- 1:07:52You can find a link to our Discord at the end of every
- 1:07:54single one of our show notes. Next week we'll be back
- 1:07:57revisiting a Gene Kelly masterpiece, an American in
- 1:08:01Paris. From the most angry man to the
- 1:08:04least angry man. We're we're going to go sing and
- 1:08:08dance in France for a little. While the old country, if he's
- 1:08:11the old country. So join us for that one next
- 1:08:14week, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:08:17I'm Brad Gee. And we'll see you next time.