Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Spotify's Great Reset: Is the Profitable Growth Sustainable?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're really getting into
- 0:03Spotify technology essay that's spot on the ticker now.
- 0:07Spotify for years was kind of the poster child for, well,
- 0:11growth at any cost, right? Amazing product, users
- 0:14everywhere, but always losing money.
- 0:16It felt like this incredible machine that just couldn't make
- 0:19a profit. Yeah, exactly.
- 0:20And that's, you know, that's why your typical valuing voucher
- 0:22just steered clear completely. I mean, look at the numbers.
- 0:25Historically, they were kind of scary.
- 0:27We're talking even now a PE ratio of like 156. 150. 6 and
- 0:32price to book around 18.7 when you see a P/E that high, I mean
- 0:36the market is basically betting on perfection for years and
- 0:39years. It's not valued well, so hope.
- 0:41So that's our mission today, isn't it, To figure out if that
- 0:44hope is viable. Now we're looking at this big
- 0:48shift, this transformation that really kicked off in 2023.
- 0:51It seems like they've gone from burning cash to actually
- 0:53generating quite a bit of free cash flow or FCF.
- 0:56The big questions are, is this new profitability real?
- 1:00Is it sustainable? And maybe most importantly for
- 1:04you, is there any margin of safety baked into the stock
- 1:06price right now? Let's let's unpack it.
- 1:09OK, so to really get the turn around, you first have to
- 1:12understand the, let's call it the crisis.
- 1:14They were in the old Spotify. It was it was a tough story,
- 1:17great product, totally dominant, but stuck in a really bad
- 1:21business model. The core problem structural it
- 1:24was all about the margin cap. Right.
- 1:25The margin cap, you mentioned that structural flaw.
- 1:27Can you walk us through that? How exactly were the big record
- 1:30label sort of locking them in? How much cash were they losing
- 1:33right off the top? Oh, it was brutal.
- 1:35Just brutal. Historically, their main cost,
- 1:38the cost of revenue, was mostly just royalty payments, and it
- 1:41went to basically three huge labels.
- 1:43And the key thing is that cost was variable.
- 1:46So it ate up something like 70 cents of every single dollar
- 1:49they made for music. $0.70. Wow.
- 1:53Yeah. And that just pinned their gross
- 1:54margin, you know, the profit before they paid salaries or
- 1:57marketing or anything else. It was stuck in this really
- 2:00tight, frustrating range, like maybe 13% some years, maybe
- 2:04hitting 27% if they were lucky between 2015 and 2022 roughly.
- 2:09So it almost didn't matter how many millions of users they
- 2:12added. The bigger they got, the more
- 2:13cash just flowed straight out the door to the labels.
- 2:16That structural problem basically capped their success.
- 2:19So to break free, they had to what?
- 2:20Change the whole game. They absolutely did.
- 2:23And that brings us right to 2023.
- 2:24Daniel Egg called it the Great Reset.
- 2:27Now part of that was, yeah, some pretty serious cough cutting,
- 2:30painful stuff. They're just had by a
- 2:32significant amount, 17%. But the really interesting part
- 2:35strategically wasn't just the cuts, it was the move towards a
- 2:39multi format strategy. Ah.
- 2:41Right, building the Spotify machine, as they call it, which
- 2:45means basically pushing hard into content that makes more
- 2:48money and isn't just traditional music.
- 2:50We're talking podcasts, audiobooks, video now too,
- 2:54increasingly. Exactly.
- 2:55And what's really key here is that these other formats, these
- 2:58non music things often have totally different cost
- 3:02structures. Think about say an exclusive
- 3:04podcast deal like the one with Joe Rogan.
- 3:06That's usually a fixed cost. Pay him a set amount, right?
- 3:09Doesn't matter if it's 10 million or 50 million people
- 3:11listen. Once you cover that fixed cost,
- 3:14basically every extra listener, every extra dollar of revenue
- 3:16from ads on that show drops almost entirely to the gross
- 3:20margin line, much higher margin potential.
- 3:22Got it. So that's how they could finally
- 3:24breakthrough that ceiling the music labels imposed if the
- 3:28overall revenue pie grows and more of that pie comes from
- 3:31these fixed cost things like podcasts, while the overall
- 3:34company profitability has to go up.
- 3:36And you can see it clear as day in the margin numbers post 2023.
- 3:41There's this sharp upward turn. Spotify's gross margin, on a
- 3:44trailing 12 months basis, recently hit 31.6%.
- 3:49That jump is the proof. It shows the structural shift
- 3:52isn't just talk, it's actually working.
- 3:54You see it in the economics. OK.
- 3:56So that shift really sets the stage for the latest earnings
- 3:58report. We looked at Q32025 and those
- 4:01numbers were, well, they were pretty stellar, weren't they?
- 4:03A big beat pretty much everywhere.
- 4:05Absolutely. Really Sustained momentum.
- 4:06Monthly active users MU's, they grew 11% year over year, hit
- 4:10713,000,007. 113,000,000 users, yeah.
- 4:14And premium subscribers reached 281,000,000.
- 4:17Total revenue came in at 4.3 billion.
- 4:19Just solid numbers all around and the.
- 4:21Profit number was huge, operating income 582,000,000,
- 4:25way above what even Spotify themselves guided for.
- 4:28Now, normally see a beat like that, the stock just rockets up.
- 4:30But here's where it gets kind of weird, right?
- 4:33The stock actually dropped 2% after they announced this.
- 4:35What's going on there? It's it's classic Wall Street,
- 4:38isn't that you can have a fantastic quarter now, but if
- 4:40you even hint that the next quarter might be slightly less
- 4:42explosive, the market just freaks out a little.
- 4:47And that's what happened. The market zoned in completely
- 4:49on what they called lukewarm guidance for Q42025.
- 4:53South all those great results kind of got ignored because the
- 4:56forecast wasn't quite as sky high as analysts wanted.
- 4:59Pretty much Spotify guided for about 8 million new premium
- 5:03subscribers in the fourth quarter.
- 5:05Wall Street models were looking for more like 10.1 million.
- 5:09So the read through there is maybe those aggressive price
- 5:12increases they rolled out globally are starting to hit a
- 5:14bit of a ceiling. They might be facing a trade off
- 5:17now and keep pushing prices up for more revenue per user or
- 5:20ease off a bit to keep that really explosive subscriber
- 5:23growth going that investors got used to.
- 5:25And Speaking of that profit beat, we need to talk about
- 5:27something else. You flagged this accounting
- 5:29detail, the social charges, because that muddies the water a
- 5:32bit on how good the profit really was.
- 5:34Right. This is super important if you
- 5:36want to understand the sustainable level of profit.
- 5:39That 582,000,000 operating income looks amazing, yes, but
- 5:43when you dig in about 41 million of that beat, maybe 40% of the
- 5:50upside. Surprise came from something
- 5:51called lower social charges, and these aren't operational.
- 5:55They're basically payroll taxes linked to stock compensation.
- 5:58OK, hang on. Why would payroll taxes suddenly
- 6:01drop like that? How does that work?
- 6:03It's tied mainly to stock options.
- 6:05In the stock price, the company has to estimate how much tax
- 6:08liability they might have related to the stock comp they
- 6:10give employees. So if the stock price has been
- 6:12running really hot, their estimated future tax bill goes
- 6:15up. If the stock price cools off or
- 6:17dips like it might have done leading into that quarter, their
- 6:20estimated liability goes down. When that estimate drops
- 6:23unexpectedly, it flows through the PNL and looks like extra
- 6:25profit. But it's not really from selling
- 6:27more subscriptions or ads. It's more of a a non recurring
- 6:31accounting adjustment. Interesting.
- 6:32So it puts a bit of an asterisk next to that big headline profit
- 6:36number doesn't totally negate the underlying improvement, but
- 6:39it's, you know, context. OK, moving on a bit, even with
- 6:43these operational gains, we still need to think about
- 6:46Spotify's position, its Moat against some huge competitors
- 6:50like Apple, Amazon. What makes Spotify defensible?
- 6:53Well, the scale itself is a big one.
- 6:55They're the global leader. Market share somewhere between
- 6:58say 31% and 37%, depending who you ask.
- 7:01That's huge. But I think their most powerful
- 7:03weapon, the thing Apple Music just can't easily copy, is that
- 7:07freemium funnel. The free tier.
- 7:09Exactly, that free version isn't just some side thing, it's their
- 7:11main customer acquisition tool. It's low cost, brings people in,
- 7:15and they convert over 60% of their premium subscribers
- 7:18directly from free users. And the data they have, I mean,
- 7:21713 million users, the algorithms they build for things
- 7:25like Discover Weekly, the AIDJ, that whole viral Rapt campaign
- 7:29every year, that creates massive switching costs, right?
- 7:32You leave Spotify, you lose all that personalization that's
- 7:35sticky. The Moat is definitely strong,
- 7:36yeah, no question. But you know, even the strongest
- 7:39castles face threats from the outside, and we can't just look
- 7:42at the good stuff. There are still some big kind of
- 7:45permanent headwinds that structurally limit how high
- 7:48their profits can ultimately go. You mean the labels?
- 7:52That power dynamic is still there, isn't it?
- 7:54The big three record labels. Absolutely.
- 7:56It's the elephant in the room. It's an oligopoly.
- 7:59That concentration gives the suppliers, the labels, huge
- 8:02bargaining power. It fundamentally puts a cap on
- 8:05long term profit potential, especially from the core music
- 8:08streaming side. Because of those, you know,
- 8:10roughly 70% royalty payouts. And that ties into the
- 8:13competition issue too, doesn't it?
- 8:15Spotify is just an audio company basically, right?
- 8:18They're up against giants Apple, Amazon and Google.
- 8:22Who, frankly, don't need to make money on music.
- 8:25For them, music streaming can just be a loss leader.
- 8:28Something to make their phones better, or their smart speakers
- 8:30stickier, or to sell Prime subscriptions they can afford to
- 8:33subsidized music to booth their main businesses.
- 8:35Spotify doesn't have that luxury.
- 8:37And one last risk, we have to mention governance, that dual
- 8:41class share structure. Yeah, that's a big one for some
- 8:44investors. The founders, Daniel Aik and
- 8:47Martin Lorenzen have super voting shares.
- 8:50It means they effectively control the company.
- 8:52Public shareholders very little say so.
- 8:55Investing in Spotify is really a bet on EEK and Lorenzen's vision
- 8:58and execution. You don't have much recourse if
- 9:01you disagree. OK.
- 9:02So let's pull it all together with the financials.
- 9:04We look back at the 10 year picture and you really see that
- 9:06inflection point you talked about earlier, the free cash
- 9:09flow before 2024, it was well all over the place, often
- 9:13negative. Yeah, volatile is putting it
- 9:14mildly, but since 2024 it's just shot up almost vertical growth.
- 9:19TTMFCF trailing 12 months is now a really solid $3.4 billion.
- 9:24That gives them an XCF margin of 18.8%.
- 9:27That's the proof the transition is done.
- 9:29They are definitely a cash generating company now.
- 9:31You see it in the returns to TTM.
- 9:33Return on equity Roe is 22.6%. Return on invested capital ROIC
- 9:38is 28.1%. Strong numbers.
- 9:40Really strong performance, but then we pull out our traditional
- 9:42deep value checklist and Spotify it.
- 9:45It doesn't fare so well there, does it?
- 9:46No, not at all. It is absolutely not a
- 9:48traditional deep value stock. Feels completely on evaluation
- 9:52discipline, PE of 156, PB of nearly nineteen way off.
- 9:57Feels on historical consistency too, because, you know, net
- 10:00losses for most of its public life.
- 10:02OK, but where does it pass? It definitely passes on balance
- 10:05sheet safety. Debt to equity is low .29,
- 10:08current ratio is healthy at 1.61, rock solid there and it
- 10:12passes obviously on recent cash generation as we just discussed.
- 10:15All right, so that brings us to the bottom line valuation.
- 10:18We ran the numbers using a discounted cash flow model.
- 10:21ADCF tried to figure out what the company is actually worth
- 10:24based on future cash flows. We used a nominal case assuming
- 10:27FCF grows about 12.8% a year, which is basically what analysts
- 10:30are expecting. What did the math show?
- 10:33Well, the math gives us an intrinsic value for Spotify's
- 10:36equity of around $139.8 billion. And the market cap right now?
- 10:40The market cap is sitting at $145.5 billion.
- 10:43So they're trading almost exactly at the value implied by
- 10:46consensus growth expectations. No discount.
- 10:49The market has basically priced in all the good news, maybe even
- 10:51priced in perfection for the next decade.
- 10:53That's the conclusion. There's virtually no margin of
- 10:56safety at this current price. None.
- 10:59If you're a value investor and you demand that cushion, that
- 11:0230% margin of safety, let's say you'd need the price to drop
- 11:06significantly. You'd need the market cap to be
- 11:08down around $97.9 billion or less before you think about
- 11:12buying. That's a pretty clear verdict,
- 11:14although it's interesting management seems to disagree
- 11:17that the stock is perfectly priced or overvalued.
- 11:20We saw a big shift in how they're using their cash this
- 11:22year. Yeah.
- 11:23That's a really important signal.
- 11:24The share buyer buybacks, they bought back 0 shares in 2024,
- 11:28but this year, 2025 year to date, $410 million spent
- 11:32repurchasing their own stock. That's management saying we
- 11:35think our stock is cheap and we're confident enough in our
- 11:38cash generation to start buying it back.
- 11:40It's a definite vote of confidence from inside the
- 11:42company. OK, so let's try and summarize
- 11:43the insight here. Spotify, they've pulled off a
- 11:47really impressive, really difficult turn around, gone from
- 11:49just chasing growth to actually delivering profitable growth
- 11:52that was driven by some serious cost discipline and this smart
- 11:56pivot to non music content. The question isn't really if
- 12:00they succeeded in changing the business, it's whether the
- 12:03market has already seen that success, recognized it and fully
- 12:06priced it into the stock. And our analysis suggests, yeah,
- 12:09pretty much. Which leaves us with maybe one
- 12:12final provocative thought for you, the listener to chew on.
- 12:15It's about leadership. Daniel Eek, the guy who drove
- 12:17this whole 2023 reset. He's moving to executive
- 12:20chairman in January 2026. Two internal veterans are
- 12:24stepping up as Co CEOs. The question is, given how much
- 12:27the recent success seems tied to Eeks intense top down focus on
- 12:31discipline of margins, can a Co CEO structure keep that same
- 12:34level of intensity, especially against those big structural
- 12:37risks, the labels, the competition that haven't gone
- 12:39away? How that management transition
- 12:41plays out could really determine if Spotify can actually break
- 12:44above the consensus growth already baked into the price.
- 12:47Something to watch.