Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / #20 No Excuse for Sin: A Biblical Take on the Lindsay Clancy Case
Transcript
- 0:15For too long, our culture has embraced and believed the lies of feminism,
- 0:19distorting God's design for women and leaving us burdened and unsatisfied.
- 0:24This podcast exists to confront the lies shaping our culture and boldly proclaim the truth of the gospel.
- 0:30True freedom is only found in Christ. So join us as we bring the truth of the
- 0:34gospel to light in our culture.
- 0:38Welcome back to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Today, we are hitting a hard and heavy topic.
- 0:44We are discussing the Lindsay Clancy trial and the response that we have seen to it.
- 0:48How should we as Christians respond to a situation like this,
- 0:52and what does the Bible have to say on it?
- 0:55For many, this case and its complexities scare people off.
- 0:59The minute you mention mental health, there seems to be an underlying assumption
- 1:03that all bets are suddenly off the table, and unless you are a psychologist,
- 1:07you are not allowed to comment or say anything about this.
- 1:11However, when we come at this with the backing of Scripture,
- 1:14the Bible says in 2 Peter 1.3, His divine power has granted to us all things
- 1:20that pertain to life and godliness.
- 1:23The truth of God's word is not insufficient to tackle a situation even like this.
- 1:29To hint that we as Christians cannot comment on what has happened,
- 1:33or have no standing doing so, actually undermines the sufficiency and power
- 1:38of God's word and actually who God is.
- 1:41So let's remember that as we come to this heavy and very dark situation.
- 1:47I want to start by saying that there is no excuse for sin. Anger is no excuse
- 1:51for sin and a mental health crisis is no excuse for sin.
- 1:55On the final judgment date, there will be no justification for our sin.
- 1:59We will stand before a completely holy and perfect God to give an account for our actions.
- 2:05Only solution and help available is through Jesus Christ's death on the cross.
- 2:10The Bible is sufficient, and we as Christians must stand on the truth of God's
- 2:15word, even when we are alone, and particularly when evil glares us in the face
- 2:21so prolifically. Now there are two deeply troubling aspects to this case.
- 2:25The first is the obvious brutal murder of three helpless children,
- 2:29having their lives taken from them by the one purpose to protect,
- 2:33care, and nurture them. their mother.
- 2:37The second is the stark evil that we have witnessed by women around the world
- 2:42in their response to this trial and making Lindsay out to be the victim
- 2:46and the problem being an external mental health crisis that Lindsay had no ability to control.
- 2:52There's a lot that could be said about this case and a lot of details that could be gone into.
- 2:56And for a deep dive into the facts, the drugs, the diagnoses,
- 3:00et cetera, I would direct you to Ali Beth Stuckey's episodes on that.
- 3:04What I want to focus on here are the two responses that women have had to this
- 3:08whole situation and apply God's word to them.
- 3:12The first is a response from women identifying with Lindsay with the mentality
- 3:16of, I can imagine being postpartum, sleep deprived, depressed,
- 3:20and desperately overwhelmed, and I don't want a society pretending this couldn't happen to me.
- 3:25The second is the argument that it was the medical system that had failed her.
- 3:29Therefore, Lindsay is a victim in all this and should not be held morally responsible.
- 3:33Both of these statements and responses carry significant consequences to them,
- 3:38and we need to confront them and apply the truth of God's word to them.
- 3:42So let's deal with his first argument. The justification and solidarity of women
- 3:47around the world has been framed in the manner that Lindsay Clancy was having
- 3:51a mental health crisis and therefore is the victim in this scenario.
- 3:57This is how one Australian woman has put it. Carly Grubb, who is a perinatal
- 4:01mental health and baby sleep advocate, said, The prelude to what ultimately
- 4:06led to filicide is something I can relate to.
- 4:09Mental health crises can happen to anyone. Even you, sitting over there,
- 4:14full of ill-placed confidence and disdain.
- 4:17Now, I'm a mother of three, with a fourth on the way. I am well aware of the
- 4:21insanity that can come with sleep deprivation.
- 4:24We had our first child when we were alone in Sydney with no family.
- 4:27My husband worked long hours, and our daughter slept for 45 minutes to one hour
- 4:31since basically for the first year of her life, or longer.
- 4:36I put immense pressure on myself postpartum, was depleted nutritionally as most
- 4:41women are after birth, and it was an incredibly difficult time.
- 4:45Whether you call this postpartum depression, postpartum depletion,
- 4:49or just the stark reality of entering motherhood and being weaned off a sinful
- 4:52and selfish nature, doesn't really matter. It was a difficult time.
- 4:56Now our second born had reflux, wouldn't sleep lying down for more than 20 minutes
- 5:01for the first two months of his life.
- 5:03That is a long two months.
- 5:05And I am well aware of the difficulty of sleep deprivation paired with recovering
- 5:10from intense birth and what that brings.
- 5:13Now this isn't a valid argument but anyone who says that you haven't experienced
- 5:17this so you can't comment that could be shut down right there.
- 5:20The problem with the argument that says that this was a mental health crisis
- 5:24and therefore Lindsay is not liable is that this absolves the responsibility
- 5:28from anyone doing anything if it is therefore claimed as a mental health crisis.
- 5:34I'll say again, mental health crises are no excuse for sin.
- 5:38On the final judgment day, there will be no justification for our sin.
- 5:42We will stand before a completely holy and perfect God to give an account for our actions.
- 5:48There is only one solution to the problem of sin that we all face.
- 5:52Now, I do want to unpack this comment of women being able to relate to the prelude
- 5:57of filicide and therefore abdicate responsibility from Lindsay.
- 6:02Yes, these women are exactly right. We all struggle with sinful thoughts.
- 6:06We are sinful by nature. Psalm 51.5 Our hearts are deceitfully wicked.
- 6:10Mark 7 And we are all in the world struggling against the spiritual forces of
- 6:15evil in the heavenly realms.
- 6:17Ephesians 6.12 There is not a human alive who has not or will not struggle with
- 6:22temptations and thoughts to sin, which are pure evil.
- 6:26We are all on a level playing field here.
- 6:29However, this is not where it ends. Just because we all face temptations to
- 6:32sin or evil thoughts across our mind does not ever justify our actions in taking
- 6:38the next step, and this is where our moral responsibility comes in.
- 6:43Despite the temptation that Adam and Eve faced, God held them both morally responsible
- 6:49for the sin they committed, and they had to suffer the consequences for their actions.
- 6:542 Corinthians 5.10 For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ,
- 6:59so that each one may receive what is done for what he did in the body, whether good or evil.
- 7:05Romans 14.12 So then each of us will give an account of himself to God.
- 7:10Revelation 20.12 And I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne.
- 7:16The books were opened, and then another book was opened, which is the book of life.
- 7:21And the dead were judged by what was written in the books according to what they had done.
- 7:27Now, God didn't leave Adam and Eve without hope, and we will get to that hope.
- 7:31However, they both and we all have to continually face the consequences to their sin.
- 7:37God will hold each of us accountable for our lives here on earth.
- 7:40But he also promises that there is a way of escape when temptation comes.
- 7:441 Corinthians 10.13 says, No temptation has overtaken you that is not common to man.
- 7:50God is faithful, and he will not let you be tempted beyond your ability.
- 7:54But with the temptation, he will also provide a way of escape,
- 7:58that you may be able to endure it.
- 7:59The issue when we frame this as a mental health crisis that happened to Lindsay,
- 8:04rather than from within her, is that we are negating any moral responsibility
- 8:09she has to other humans, to her little children, and ultimately to God.
- 8:14The truth of the gospel is that our greatest problem is sin.
- 8:17We have all sinned, fallen short of God's glory, Romans 3.
- 8:21We all struggle against sin, but we are not helpless. There is hope for the
- 8:26sinner, hope that is found nowhere else in this world.
- 8:30All throughout Jesus' life and through Scripture, he is telling us that through
- 8:34him we can actually say no to sin and not be enslaved to it.
- 8:39To his disciples, he says in Matthew 26, Watch and pray that you may not enter into temptation.
- 8:47The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.
- 8:50Romans 13.14 Put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh to gratify its desires.
- 8:581 Peter 5.8-9 Be sober-minded, be watchful. Your adversary the devil prowls
- 9:04around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour.
- 9:08Resist him, firm in your faith, knowing that the same kinds of suffering are
- 9:12being experienced by your brotherhood throughout the world.
- 9:15There is a real struggle against sin, but there is not a hopelessness towards sin.
- 9:20The problem of sin is that we are all totally wicked, depraved and sinful by nature.
- 9:26But the hope of the gospel is that we do not have to be enslaved to this.
- 9:30There is hope found through Jesus Christ in what he did on the cross.
- 9:34Now the second argument that is being projected is that the medical system or
- 9:38her friends and families failed her and therefore Lindsay is a victim in all
- 9:42of this and should not be held morally responsible.
- 9:46This sort of defense comes in the form of statements such as,
- 9:50there were a lot of warning signs that Lindsay was saying she was daily thinking
- 9:53of harming herself and her kids.
- 9:56Why didn't her family rally around her and give her the love and care that she needed?
- 10:01If she had been hospitalised and given the correct care, this wouldn't have happened.
- 10:06Now the inverse of this argument is then that if someone is having thoughts
- 10:10of harming their children, has let others know and is not hospitalised,
- 10:14then commits murder, they are not responsible for doing so.
- 10:18It becomes the fault of their friends, their family, the church or the hospital system.
- 10:23This is an absurd notion, but it is the logical conclusion of when we refuse to call evil, evil.
- 10:31James McPherson, a journalist, writer and former pastor, put this well when
- 10:35he said, Cora, aged five, Dawson, aged three, and little eight-month Callan
- 10:40were strangled to death by their mum.
- 10:43And yet this perverse display of compassion finds perfectly sane women rooting
- 10:48for the woman who killed them.
- 10:50This is what happens when a civilization loses the vocabulary of evil.
- 10:55We stop asking who did what, and start asking what social forces made them do it.
- 11:01The perpetrator becomes a patient, then a victim.
- 11:05Then, if the political conditions are right, an icon.
- 11:09And once evil has been sufficiently contextualized, there is nothing left to condemn.
- 11:15Or as Kosti Hint has stated, if every sin can ultimately be explained away by
- 11:19identifying psychological or external influences,
- 11:23eventually nobody is truly guilty of anything, and once guilt disappears,
- 11:27so does the meaning of forgiveness and so does the need for the gospel.
- 11:32These arguments, abdicating responsibility from Lindsay and placing it upon
- 11:36a mental health crisis happening to her, the fault of the medical system, is pure evil.
- 11:43But it is the logical conclusion when you follow the feminist logic and worldview.
- 11:49Feminism rejects God. It rejects his design, his authority.
- 11:53And quoting Kosti Hinn, when people reject God, Paul says, their thinking becomes
- 11:58futile, their hearts are darkened, and eventually they exchange the truth of God for a lie.
- 12:05Creation gets turned upside down. Freedom becomes bondage, children become burdens.
- 12:11Motherhood becomes oppression, murder becomes healthcare, and perpetrators become symbols of victimhood.
- 12:18Feminism's fundamental claim
- 12:20of autonomous self-definition collides with Christianity at the foundation,
- 12:25because it rejects God's created boundaries and seizes the right to define good,
- 12:31freedom, and fulfillment for yourself. End quote.
- 12:34And so you see the premise of feminism that rejects God's authority and design
- 12:38is starting to play out and show itself in a very evil and sinister way within our society.
- 12:45What started out as women's rights, freeing women from the so-called burden
- 12:49of children and managing the home, is now resulting in women around the world
- 12:54justifying the brutal murder of children aged 5, 3 and 8 months old,
- 12:59due to a mental health crisis that was brought on by having children.
- 13:03It is so important for us, particularly as women, to see the link here between
- 13:07the initial lie of Satan that children are a burden and God's design for women
- 13:12to have children and raise them is not good.
- 13:15It has now led to the explicit justification of murdering an innocent five-year-old,
- 13:21three-year-old, and eight-month-old baby, absolutely helpless against their mother's anger and sin.
- 13:28It doesn't get much more evil than this. And in the face of this evil,
- 13:31we can be left to think this is a hopeless situation and Satan has won here.
- 13:37But that is only the case if we forget the gospel. So let's remind ourselves of this now.
- 13:43Now to address the initial statement of Carly Grapp and agreed with by women
- 13:46who are standing in solidarity with Lindsay that the prelude to what ultimately
- 13:51led to filicide is something I can relate to, mental health crises can happen to anyone.
- 13:57These women are admitting their evil wickedness unknowingly and sinful state that they are in.
- 14:02But the next comment that mental health crises can happen to anyone what these
- 14:07women are really saying is horrifically murdering your three helpless children
- 14:11can happen to anyone due to no fault of your own,
- 14:15This is where the evil is played out, and as Doug Wilson puts it,
- 14:20these women are displaying psychotic empathy,
- 14:23because empathising with a murderer so as to absolve responsibility from them,
- 14:28and at the same time have your own sin justified in the process, is psychotic.
- 14:34If this same argument is applied to a different situation, feminists would be
- 14:38the last people to support it.
- 14:41Like the argument for the pedophile who abuses children, what if his defense
- 14:45is that he is suffering from a mental health crisis?
- 14:48Does that then abdicate responsibility from him?
- 14:52No, he deserves to be locked away and pay the penalty for his actions.
- 14:56Or how about the man who perpetually commits domestic violence?
- 15:00Look at his life, he is stressed at work, he's underpaid, he's struggling with
- 15:04his mental health, and so he beats his wife as an outlet.
- 15:08Are his actions justified? Would we accept men standing in solidarity with him
- 15:13around the world if he was on trial?
- 15:15No, he deserves to be locked away for the crime that he has committed.
- 15:20The same applies to Lindsay. Lindsay is a human created by God who struggles
- 15:25against sin, has broken God's law, and ultimately rebelled against God's design
- 15:29for her to protect, care, and nurture her children,
- 15:33instead murdering them in a horrifically premeditated manner,
- 15:37has broken the laws of her country and needs to be locked away for a long time,
- 15:42if not for life, for the crimes that she has committed.
- 15:45And whilst the consequences for her actions have pretty much written off her
- 15:49life here on earth, there is actually hope for her.
- 15:52And there's hope for you too, only through the gospel of Jesus Christ.
- 15:57Treating this as a mental health crisis that happened to Lindsay actually undermines the gospel.
- 16:04It does this in the way that we all need to be brought face to face with the
- 16:08reality and wicked and evil nature of ourselves.
- 16:12It is only then that when we have faced the reality of our depravity can we
- 16:16hear and appreciate and accept the good news of the gospel,
- 16:20that it was Jesus Christ who took the divine penalty for our sin,
- 16:25so that we can be reconciled to our Creator and not be controlled or enslaved to sin.
- 16:31This sin is dark and evil, but it is not too dark for God.
- 16:36The only hope for Lindsay and for women around the world is realizing their
- 16:40utter depravity and the evilness of their nature, coming before God in repentance.
- 16:46Now that won't change things for the consequences that she has to face here
- 16:50on earth, but it will change her eternal destiny if she humbles herself before
- 16:54the God who created her and brings her sin into the light rather than running
- 16:58from it in the name of a mental health crisis.
- 17:01And so to close, mental health crises are no excuse for sin.
- 17:06On the final judgment day, there will be no justification for our sin.
- 17:10We will stand before a completely holy and perfect God to give an account for our actions.
- 17:16There is only one solution to the problem of sins that we face,
- 17:20and it is in Jesus Christ.
- 17:22Now, I don't usually do this on my podcast episodes, but I think we need to
- 17:27today. I'm going to close in prayer.
- 17:29Dear Lord God, we bring before you this horrific situation and the horrific
- 17:34evil that it has brought out in our culture.
- 17:37And we ask for your mercy upon us. We ask for your mercy and forgiveness to us for...
- 17:45Committing heinous crimes against you for justifying our sin before you.
- 17:50And we pray that you would step in, that you would bring the hope of the gospel
- 17:55to light in this situation,
- 17:58that you might be able to redeem this situation for your glory,
- 18:01to show people the evilness of their sin to turn to you.
- 18:07And we even pray for Lindsay in this. As hard as it is to see after what she
- 18:12has committed, Lord we are all sinners before you and so we ask for your grace
- 18:16and we ask for the truth of the gospel to shine forth in his,
- 18:21we pray this in the mighty name of Jesus Christ Amen.