Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Unnecessary Mastectomy Damages and Rape Shield Laws
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan, barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Morning Michael, how are we doing?
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: I'm doing great.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Some interesting things on the agenda today.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: I'm reading here a jury award for misdiagnosing breast cancer being reduced on appeal.
- 0:17Adam Stirling: How does all that work?
- 0:19Michael Mulligan: Well, not well if you're the person who went through all of this oh, indeed.
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: And Well, not well if you're the person who went through all of this oh, indeed.
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: And so the background of it is this it was a woman who was diagnosed with having breast cancer and, as a result of that diagnosis, opted to have a full mastectomy, and after that was done, the breast tissue that was removed was examined and it was determined she did not have any sign of cancer, and that's what led to the lawsuit.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: Now, the first thing to mention is this Doctors are not infallible, and we don't require them to be infallible, right?
- 1:02Michael Mulligan: Not every mistake or error by a doctor is going to lead to a successful claim for damages.
- 1:07Michael Mulligan: The first part of it is that you would need to successfully sue a doctor.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: You would need to establish, first of all, that they fell below the standard of care of a reasonable doctor in the circumstances.
- 1:20Michael Mulligan: Right, so the standard is not perfection.
- 1:21Michael Mulligan: The standard is reasonable doctor, right, yes, right, so the standard is not perfection.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: The standard is reasonable doctor, right, yes.
- 1:26Michael Mulligan: And then, if the doctor falls below the standard of reasonable doctor, then the next issue is going to be would the person have gone ahead with the procedure regardless of the mistake, right?
- 1:39Michael Mulligan: And whether somebody would proceed or not is going to depend, of course, on the circumstances and there's going to be, for example, much closer scrutiny as to whether somebody would have gone ahead or not with a completely optional procedure, right, some cosmetic surgery or something.
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: If you don't tell somebody of the risk and they go ahead without that information, he may well conclude that person would not have proceeded had they been told.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: That person would not have proceeded had they been told.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: On the other hand, if something is life-saving, it may be that a person would choose to proceed regardless of not being told of all the risks.
- 2:11Michael Mulligan: So that's sort of the background of it.
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: This case was interesting because it was a jury trial.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: It was one of the interesting elements of it and what recently came down was an appeal from the jury verdict, and so the case proceeded with a jury trial and the jury concluded that indeed, in this case, the doctor had breached their standard of care that being the standard of a reasonably prudent doctor, right.
- 2:38Michael Mulligan: And furthermore concluded that, as a result of that breach, the patient in this case made the decision to proceed with this full mastectomy.
- 2:50Michael Mulligan: And what the essence of that is that the woman, what was communicated to her, was that she had an aggressive form of cancer and led to believe that if the cancer was not removed, you know, as soon as possible, it was a matter of life and death.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: And so, on the basis of that, she's okay, go ahead, right.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: And the evidence at the trial from other doctors who were experts in the area was that that really was not what should have been communicated.
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: There was a lower degree of certainty and there should have been other things done as part of the surgery rather than proceeding to the complete mastectomy without doing more.
- 3:31Michael Mulligan: So that's what the jury found.
- 3:34Michael Mulligan: And then that led to the issue of damages, which was really the central issue on this appeal, and this is going to be a theme of the cases we're talking about today.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: It's a theme of things that juries are not told about, and one of the things and this is a civil jury, of course, not a criminal case, but one of the things this I think would be interesting for people one of the things that a judge provides is not allowed to provide instructions to a jury about, and lawyers are not allowed to provide instructions to a jury about, and lawyers are not allowed to provide instructions to the jury about, is how much and how they should calculate non-pecuniary damages.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: So pecuniary damages would be things like you know lost wages or you know the cost of your medical equipment, things like that.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: Non-pecuniary damages could be things like pain and suffering.
- 4:24Michael Mulligan: Right, what did you?
- 4:25Michael Mulligan: You know what was the impact in your life in terms of you know this happening to you?
- 4:29Michael Mulligan: And well, we can't solve everything with money.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: The idea would be to provide some amount of money and some compensation for right this happening.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And on that point, with that kind of award, juries are given virtually no help.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: They're not told.
- 4:48Michael Mulligan: Well, this is the range you might consider, or this is what has happened in other cases, and that comes from a BC Court of Appeal decision back in 2002.
- 4:56Michael Mulligan: Comes from a BC Court of Appeal decision back in 2002.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: And the idea there by the majority of the Court of Appeal on that occasion it's the law in BC is that they didn't want to fetter the discretion of juries.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: They wanted juries to sort of bring their common sense and community values and figure out what would be an appropriate reward for this.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: What happened to you right, and in this case you know, the mastectomy wouldn't have probably caused a lot of missed work, maybe some, a lot of.
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: It would just be, man, that is terrible and very upsetting and so on, that you would go through that kind of surgery unnecessarily.
- 5:27Michael Mulligan: And so in this case, without being told what amount could be awarded or what the range could be, the jury awarded the woman $400,000.
- 5:36Michael Mulligan: Now, you know, I must say when you listen to this, well, it's a substantial amount of money.
- 5:41Michael Mulligan: But I doubt there are very many people if you said, look, I'll pay you, you know, $400,000 to go through this process.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: Most people, what are you kidding, right?
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: You know you, look, you compare that to somebody said I'm going to provide you with a very substantial down, I can provide you with a very substantial down payment on a home if you undergo this.
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: You probably say well, that's probably not compensation for this.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: But here's the context In Canada and this comes from the Supreme Court of Canada back in 1978, there were a series of cases three of them, given the name, referred to as the Trilogy, and the Supreme Court of Canada in that Trilogy of Cases and the Supreme Court of Canada in that trilogy of cases, limited the amount of money somebody could receive in non-pecuniary damages for pain and suffering, and it was just a policy decision.
- 6:26Michael Mulligan: It was a policy decision intended to limit things like the cost of insurance and the Supreme Court of Canada capped that in 1978 at $100,000.
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: And that is a departure from the general proposition which in a civil case, if you're negligent and you cause some harm to somebody, the general proposition would be try to put the person back in the position they would have been in.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: But for what you did right and on the pain and suffering front, that would equate to well, as far as money can do it, what might be a reasonable amount to try to put the person back in a position they would have been in.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: And that $100,000 cap in 1978, that would be for somebody who was the most possibly injured person.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: So that would be somebody who became a quadriplegic, for example, as a result of an accident.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: That was the cap, and that's an important thing to keep in mind when we talk about sort of oh, weren't people getting giant amounts of money for pain and suffering?
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: Not in Canada.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: That amount was increased for inflation over time and it's now a bit over $400,000, but that's it, that's the most, and everything is to be scaled down from there.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: And so it's not like in Canada people were, for the car accident context in British Columbia, getting enormous, out of control payouts for pain and suffering.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: If you're, if you had the most catastrophic of injuries impacting you for the longest period of time, forever, that's all you're entitled to, that's the most.
- 7:56Michael Mulligan: And so, in that context, the Court of Appeal well, they pointed out that jury verdicts with respect to non-pecuniary damages are entitled to deference, and more deference even than when a judge determines it that the Court of appeal will interfere with awards of that kind if the court of appeal finds that.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: You know, those are just completely inappropriate right Now.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: What is completely inappropriate in terms of and the language is slightly different than that, the language they use is wholly disproportionate or shockingly unreasonable.
- 8:35Michael Mulligan: Now I must say, if somebody said to me okay, the jury's found the doctor was negligent, caused you to have a mastectomy, complete removal of your breast.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure that I would find it wholly disproportionate or shockingly unreasonable that the person received that amount of compensation.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: But I suppose reasonable people can disagree and the Court of Appeal disagrees with my assessment of that.
- 8:58Michael Mulligan: And so they found that that award was that wholly disproportionate and shockingly unreasonable, and the context they used to assess that is that trilogy, which is still the law.
- 9:09Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada, or the Court of Appeal, said well, you know, the maximum you can possibly get for the most extraordinary sort of impact on somebody's life is $400,000, roughly that's roughly the inflation adjusted value of $100,000 from, you know, 1978.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: And so because of that we've adopted in Canada as the absolute ceiling, it reduced the award for this woman to $250,000.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: And so that's what she'll receive as a result of this jury verdict.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: The other interesting context, of course, for all of this right in BC, this is a topic that's been getting lots of discussion lately and maybe an election issue is no fault.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: So with ICBC, no fault.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: The amount is not.
- 9:58Michael Mulligan: The maximum amount is not, you know, for the most catastrophically injured person $400,000, it's zero.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: And that's one of the things which, about no fault I think, many people look at it.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: It just doesn't sound right, you know, when you have somebody whose life is completely changed, to say, well, we're going to give you a portion of what your salary would have been, and you know crutches and wheelchairs and so on.
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: You know, I don't think that that's really in accordance with what most people would think is fair and reasonable.
- 10:32Michael Mulligan: And one of the things about the law is that, generally this is why the you know, that whole concept of let's give juries lots of discretion came into play.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: What is the community standard?
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: That's kind of why we have juries.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: That's an important part of why we have juries, right, it's sort of, well, let's get some, you know, disinterested people from the community and have them sort out what would be fair here, and so that's been eliminated completely, and so that's been eliminated completely.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: The other thing to be said about all of this in terms of not telling juries what they can do, just kind of leaving them to do whatever they think is appropriate, not letting lawyers say anything about it or judges say anything about it, is what happens in practice is one of two things Either a jury awards somebody a very low amount of money, which is then defended as well.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: I guess they didn't think they were that hurt, right, or they didn't think it was a big deal.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: But if they give the person a larger amount of money, then there's an appeal, like in this case, and what gets pointed to is this Supreme Court of Canada case that limits it and says, well, that could be the most then, and I guess we better reduce that, and so so well, there's lip service to.
- 11:38Michael Mulligan: You know, giving discretion to juries and letting them make decisions without interfering with that and so on.
- 11:43Michael Mulligan: When they come up with an amount of money that uh winds up getting, uh is inconsistent with what the judiciary has determined.
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: Uh should be a cap for policy reasons, it just gets reduced on appeal, and so that's the outcome for this woman.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: That's the amount that she will receive.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, that gets paid for by the Canadian Medical Protective Association.
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: It's a doctor's captive insurance company, and the other thing to know about that is that in British Columbia, by fits and starts, what's happened is the provincial government pays all of the insurance fees for doctors, and so there's no longer any particular financial disincentive for doctors if they are negligent.
- 12:29Michael Mulligan: I mean there may be some professional repercussion, but, unlike other insurance products, if somebody has a high rate of claims, if you're constantly fouling up, your insurance rates go up, and so that produces, of course, an incentive to don't screw up.
- 12:45Michael Mulligan: You know, maybe go do that extra remedial course or whatever, but for policy reasons in BC, we now, with the public, pay all of the insurance costs for doctors, and that includes the cost of litigating these things.
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: And so, as a result of that, despite what happened to this woman and the major impact it had on her, what is going to happen is that the public will effectively pay her $250,000 as a result of what the jury found to be negligence on the part of her doctor, causing her to opt to have a complete mastectomy of her right breast.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: And so that's the state of affairs, that's what juries aren't told, and that's what happened in this case, and it's got important bearings for people to think about.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: Those other things like should there be that cap, and is it appropriate now that, as a result of no fault, all of that is gone altogether?
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: So that's the recent case Jury verdict to what the Court of Appeal did with now that, as a result of no fault, all of that is gone altogether.
- 13:41Michael Mulligan: So that's the recent case jury verdict and what the Court of Appeal did with it Very interesting.
- 13:43Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 13:45Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues on CFAX 1070.
- 13:48Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers up next.
- 13:51Adam Stirling: Not permitted cross-examination.
- 13:54Adam Stirling: This is obviously about a sensitive issue as well.
- 13:58Adam Stirling: Set this up for us.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: It is.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: It's a case out of BC and it's a decision from the Supreme Court of Canada and it's a decision that just came out and it's a very interesting fact pattern.
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: And it's a decision that just came out and it's a very interesting fact pattern and it addresses how a section of the criminal code that's sometimes referred to as a rape shield provision should be applied.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: And the way that works, or this particular part of that works, is that the presumption in a sexual assault criminal case is that a complainant couldn't be cross-examined about prior consensual sexual activity to establish either that it's more likely the person consented to what is the subject matter of the charge or that they are less worthy of belief.
- 14:44Michael Mulligan: Those are referred to as twin myth reasoning and, on the face of it, in most cases that would make sense.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: The fact that somebody might be promiscuous or might have engaged in other consensual activity really has nothing to do with.
- 14:56Michael Mulligan: Well, what happened on this occasion?
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: Right, they're separate things and certainly doesn't mean that the person's not somebody who should be believed.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: That's again, doesn't make any sense.
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: So that's why we have that section and there is provision no-transcript.
- 15:32Michael Mulligan: And so this was an interesting fact pattern in that it was a case involving an allegation made by a wife against her husband of sexual assault, and the reason that those general provisions were particularly interesting here is that her version of events at the trial was that the marriage had broken down a couple of months prior to the date of the allegation, and she claimed the marriage had broken down completely and that her husband was staying in the basement and that she was just assaulted one morning sexually.
- 16:11Michael Mulligan: That was the basis of it.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: The trouble is that she had, when she spoke to the police, initially told them that in fact the evening before they had engaged in consensual activity on the basis that he asked.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: Nicely, that was her statement to the police, and so the man's lawyer wanted to ask her about that, to suggest that her story about the relationship having completely broken down was false and that it's inconsistent with what she told the police.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: The judge at trial that application was made before the trial said no, and so the man's lawyer was not allowed to ask about it.
- 16:50Michael Mulligan: The lawyer asked again at the trial after the woman testified about her claim about what happened here, about the relationship being completely broken down, and again he was told.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: The lawyer was told no.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: The man was then convicted.
- 17:04Michael Mulligan: There was an appeal to the bc court of appeal and the judges in the court of appeal split.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: It was three judges and they split two to one.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: One of the judges said and the judges in the Court of Appeal split it was three judges and they split two to one.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: One of the judges said no, the judge was wrong there.
- 17:15Michael Mulligan: This evidence was not being led to show the person was more likely to be consented or less worthy of belief.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: The lawyer wanted to ask questions to show that the woman's evidence about the nature of the relationship was false, at least inconsistent with what she had told the police at the time.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Now, when there's a split like that in the court of appeal, that judge is in the minority and a person has a right to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, and so that's where the case went.
- 17:41Michael Mulligan: The man's appeal was again unsuccessful on a split decision from the Supreme Court of Canada decision from the Supreme Court of Canada finding the majority there 7-2, found that the judge was correct in not allowing the wife to be asked about the previous consensual activity, and so the conviction was upheld, which is, I think, an interesting thing for many people to know that when trials like this sort take place, what a jury is being told is often a subset of what in fact went on, trying to avoid inappropriate reasoning, but it does lead to sometimes, when you look at it, sort of a decision about this being made on a fact pattern that is clearly not the whole picture as to what was going on over that period of time.
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: The other thing which is interesting about this case is that when there's an application made, as there was in this case, to allow defense counsel to ask about prior sexual activity, there is a mandatory section of the criminal code that requires a judge to ban publication of the hearing about that.
- 18:51Michael Mulligan: And there was such a publication ban in this case.
- 18:55Michael Mulligan: And so then, when the case went to the appeal, the court of appeal held the whole hearing in secret so the public couldn't know about it, and then and ban publication of information about what happened.
- 19:07Michael Mulligan: And then that was renewed at the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: One of the issues was should there be?
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: The Crown asked for again a complete ban on publication so that there could be no information about the other sexual activity.
- 19:20Michael Mulligan: The Supreme Court of Canada found that that section that deals with mandatory bans on publication does not apply to appeals, and instead the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada have their own jurisdiction to restrict what could be published if that's necessary.
- 19:36Michael Mulligan: And so they found here that it was not necessary to completely ban all of it, that the appeal earlier one should not have been conducted in secret, and instead it was sufficient to ban publication of details of the sexual activity the evening before, in accordance with what the wife told the police.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: And so there's a ban on publication of the nature of that sexual activity.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: But otherwise this could be reported upon and people can know about the decision and read the decision and find out what's going on in the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court of Canada.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: That certainly, to my mind, is appropriate.
- 20:17Michael Mulligan: We do not want to have, and there's a strong presumption against secret hearings, particularly on important topics like this, that people should be aware of.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: Because there's no doubt there's going to be probably some head scratching about what is the appropriate balance to be struck here.
- 20:33Michael Mulligan: Clearly the judges don't all agree about it.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: Both the Court of Appeal and in the Supreme Court of Canada there was division about, you know, is it appropriate to prohibit questions being asked about that activity, and here the reason, at least when I read it, didn't appear to be to suggest the person's because of the sexual activity less worthy of belief.
- 20:58Michael Mulligan: The stated reason was to show that the narrative about it was not consistent with what the complainant told the police.
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: But because of that section in the ruling, nothing could be asked about it.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: And so it's just like that example of with the juries not being told about.
- 21:17Michael Mulligan: You know how should you figure out the award for pain and suffering on pecuniary damages?
- 21:22Michael Mulligan: The judge telling them nothing.
- 21:27Michael Mulligan: You know the lawyers telling them nothing.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: It's another example of you know, we've made this decision to limit the information that can be provided to a jury in a criminal case, and reasonable people clearly here reasonable judges disagreed about whether that outcome resulted in an unfair trial for this man, but the majority concluded that this was acceptable, and so, despite various judges coming to an opposite conclusion, the conviction stands.
- 22:02Michael Mulligan: And so that's Section 276, and another example of what we just don't let juries know about.
- 22:08Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday here on the program.
- 22:14Adam Stirling: Thanks so much as always.
- 22:15Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 22:17Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:17Adam Stirling: Talk to you next week.