Latest / Surrounded / Amanda Seales vs 25 Black Conservatives
Transcript
- 0:00Black culture is toxic and let's not,
- 0:02let's get on the fact that there's no fathers in the black culture.
- 0:04Let's get,
- 0:05let's get,
- 0:05let's talk about that,
- 0:06stop,
- 0:06stop,
- 0:06stop.
- 0:07We all deserve a right to exist and I shouldn't have to earn my right
- 0:10to exist and that is what makes you think that you have to earn it.
- 0:12That's what I'm saying.
- 0:13I don't nation that is.
- 0:14You do have to earn it.
- 0:15You do,
- 0:16yes,
- 0:16you do.
- 0:16That is right.
- 0:17Criminalizing the poor.
- 0:18Well,
- 0:19here's what you all keep doing.
- 0:20You keep interrupting me when I'm talking and you don't
- 0:22want to hear the point that I'm gonna make,
- 0:24and yet you want me to respect your point,
- 0:26and that's not how a debate works.
- 0:28So I show you respect,
- 0:29give me the respect back.
- 0:31Oh,
- 0:31I knew I was gonna be surrounded by ignorance,
- 0:33but damn,
- 0:34let's go.
- 0:38From Jubilee Media,
- 0:39this is the Surrounded podcast,
- 0:41where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:44In the center today is Amanda Seales.
- 0:46She is a writer,
- 0:47producer,
- 0:48actress,
- 0:48and comedian,
- 0:49as well as a black liberal,
- 0:51and she will be facing 25 black conservatives.
- 0:54She will debate them one on one until
- 0:56they're voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 0:59Let's get into it.
- 1:00Greetings.
- 1:01I am Amanda Seales,
- 1:03widely known as
- 1:05a comedian,
- 1:05an actress,
- 1:06a disruptor,
- 1:07an annoying person on the Internet who always tells the truth,
- 1:10and I am now an artistic intellectual who commits myself
- 1:13to making art that educates
- 1:16and today
- 1:17I am surrounded
- 1:19by 20
- 1:20black
- 1:21conservatives.
- 1:22My first claim is it is undeniable that reparations are just and necessary.
- 1:37Alright,
- 1:38reparations fair?
- 1:40Necessary?
- 1:41My question would be,
- 1:42who's gonna get it?
- 1:44Why would they get it?
- 1:45And how long are we gonna sit here focusing on trying to get reparations?
- 1:49It's been how many years since slavery?
- 1:50150 years,
- 1:511865?
- 1:53Whenever there's a real thing that this country wants to do,
- 1:55they do it.
- 1:56Stop Asian hate.
- 1:58OK,
- 1:58there's a problem with the Asian hate.
- 2:00Let's draft a bill,
- 2:01sign it,
- 2:02and it's done.
- 2:03Anything that needs to be done,
- 2:04is done.
- 2:05With us,
- 2:06it's a carrot that dangle in front of us that they don't really wanna do.
- 2:09And it's not gonna help.
- 2:10We need education.
- 2:12Oh,
- 2:12it's not gonna help?
- 2:12No,
- 2:13it's not.
- 2:13We need education.
- 2:14Getting a check from the government is not gonna do that.
- 2:17And we need proper education.
- 2:19A lot of us go to these institutions
- 2:21where we're not really prepared,
- 2:22we're not really focused,
- 2:24and we don't get things that'll help us
- 2:26in the real world.
- 2:27So,
- 2:27if you want to help black people,
- 2:29a check from the government,
- 2:30from our tax dollars is gonna get raised because let's be clear,
- 2:34everybody in here is black,
- 2:35we all American,
- 2:36we gotta pay taxes.
- 2:37It'll go to that.
- 2:38So I don't really see how this is gonna help us at all.
- 2:41OK,
- 2:42um,
- 2:42well,
- 2:43first I'll start with It will help on even just a moral level.
- 2:46The reality is that the United States has become very comfortable
- 2:50with the fact that it does not consider black people equal,
- 2:52and it shows that in many ways that that I'm
- 2:55sure we will discuss over the course of today.
- 2:57But
- 2:57ultimately,
- 2:59there has not been a committed,
- 3:00concerted effort to shifting the mindset around
- 3:03the use of black people as a labor force in this nation
- 3:07back when it was slavery,
- 3:08now in the voice of In the use of slavery as slave labor in prisons.
- 3:13So
- 3:13on a basic cultural level,
- 3:15reparations are an act of repair.
- 3:17They are an effort to say,
- 3:19our bad,
- 3:20we see you now.
- 3:22We have seen that done with Japanese folks who were put in internment camps.
- 3:25We have seen that done with Jewish folks.
- 3:27We have seen that done even in the case of slave owners who received reparations.
- 3:32When it comes to the use of tax dollars to pay reparations,
- 3:35and this is gonna.
- 3:35Come up a lot today.
- 3:37It's a matter of values,
- 3:38right?
- 3:38For me,
- 3:39my value system circulates around the fact that I think that as a community,
- 3:43we should all be engaged in repair for our community.
- 3:46So I don't think there should be any
- 3:47problem with there being tax dollars spent at repairing
- 3:50consistent efforts that have been made to impede black people.
- 3:53So the reparations you're talking about are not just related to slavery.
- 3:57There's reparations that have been discussed all over this nation
- 3:59in different communities as it relates to a particular massacre.
- 4:02As it relates to redlining and the impediment of
- 4:05black people to earn wealth by having property,
- 4:07there's been impediments in in various ways that can be repaired,
- 4:11and I want to also just add
- 4:13there's reparations that are considered a cash payment from a government.
- 4:17There's also the version of reparations that shows up in how
- 4:21funds are applicated to specific groups of people.
- 4:25So
- 4:26there's multiple ways in which what you're stating.
- 4:28Cannot happen,
- 4:29could very well happen.
- 4:30OK,
- 4:30now,
- 4:31as far as the money going towards certain things is going to help us,
- 4:34look at Baltimore public schools.
- 4:36They get,
- 4:36I think,
- 4:36the 3rd most money per pupil in the US of A,
- 4:40like $15,000 per student,
- 4:41but yet
- 4:42the majority of the population that comes from that environment can't read.
- 4:45They're illiterate.
- 4:46So
- 4:47we're dumping money on the situation,
- 4:48yes,
- 4:49but yet we're not getting the results we should get from it.
- 4:52Money's not gonna help
- 4:53the thing.
- 4:54We need to just focus on what we need to focus on.
- 4:56As far as black people being
- 4:58the labor force of this country,
- 4:59what else are we doing?
- 5:00We got 25% of us
- 5:02on some kind of government assistance,
- 5:041 out of every 3 black men will go to jail.
- 5:06We gotta do something.
- 5:07We gotta work with our hands,
- 5:09work with tools,
- 5:09do something because we're not doing much of anything.
- 5:12And also,
- 5:12one more piece,
- 5:13one more piece here,
- 5:14reparations,
- 5:15again,
- 5:15always ain't going in front of us,
- 5:17never gonna happen
- 5:18as long as you've been living,
- 5:19as long as I've been living,
- 5:21as long as everybody's been living,
- 5:22they say we need it,
- 5:23we need it,
- 5:23we need it,
- 5:24and it never gets done.
- 5:25One more piece.
- 5:26You just said one more piece then you added on,
- 5:28I promise,
- 5:29wait,
- 5:29wait,
- 5:29wait,
- 5:29wait,
- 5:29wait,
- 5:29one more piece.
- 5:30I'm gonna land the plane.
- 5:31I'm,
- 5:32I'm gonna land the plane,
- 5:33I promise.
- 5:33Reparations
- 5:35is a thing,
- 5:35like I said,
- 5:36it's a carrot that dangle in front of us,
- 5:38they're never really gonna get it done.
- 5:40And if it was gonna get done,
- 5:41it would have already been done.
- 5:43It's just something that they're using to try and make us stay Democrat.
- 5:46That's what that's what I wanted to say.
- 5:49Democrats are not doing reparations either.
- 5:50This is this is nonpartisan.
- 5:52This is black partisan,
- 5:53baby.
- 5:54OK?
- 5:54This is,
- 5:54this is nonpartisan.
- 5:55Who do we vote for?
- 5:56Who do we vote for 93% of the time.
- 5:58There's no,
- 5:58there's no incentive to be,
- 6:00to be quite honest,
- 6:01you're not talking to a Democrat,
- 6:02you're talking to a radical.
- 6:04So let's let's let's land this.
- 6:06Plane very quickly.
- 6:07Wait.
- 6:07Let's land this plane quickly.
- 6:09You're talking to a radical,
- 6:10not a Democrat.
- 6:13And so let me tell you something now.
- 6:14I don't know what they told you,
- 6:16but if they told you that cutting me off is how I'm going to get clicks,
- 6:18stop it now,
- 6:19because that's,
- 6:20that's not how we're gonna,
- 6:21that's not how we're going to end.
- 6:23A debate does not require continuously cutting somebody off.
- 6:26OK.
- 6:27Now I do want to state this,
- 6:28you're stating things
- 6:30as it relates to how money is not fixing a problem
- 6:34without acknowledging the fact that the problem doesn't exist
- 6:36in a vacuum and that there are so many other
- 6:38factors that are determining how that money is getting
- 6:40spent to impede it from actually fixing a problem.
- 6:43You can put all the money into Baltimore public schools you want,
- 6:46but if you are also putting all this money into policing
- 6:49in communities that are Not getting resources,
- 6:53then you are also
- 6:54creating your own conundrum.
- 6:56The other part of this is that when you're saying they,
- 6:59you know,
- 6:59the they is a broad context.
- 7:02And the last part of this that I will say
- 7:05is that you keep saying
- 7:06they're dangling this in our face,
- 7:07they're dangling in this in our face.
- 7:08Slavery lasted for 400 years.
- 7:11It hasn't even been 400 years since slavery.
- 7:14So should we be only fighting for 25% of the time to get repaired?
- 7:19All right,
- 7:19I'm so sorry.
- 7:20You've been voted out by the majority.
- 7:22Please return to your seat.
- 7:23OK.
- 7:29My name is Matt Nuclear.
- 7:31Hello Matt Nuclear.
- 7:32Matt Nuclear.
- 7:32Yes,
- 7:32Matt Nuclear,
- 7:33give me a better handshake on that.
- 7:34Let's do it.
- 7:34I appreciate having this conversation with a beautiful,
- 7:36a beautiful black woman like yourself.
- 7:37This is nice,
- 7:38beautiful arena here.
- 7:39Um,
- 7:40I disagree that reparations are necessary.
- 7:42I think the most important thing that's necessary
- 7:44right now for the black community would be
- 7:45the stopping of violence,
- 7:46especially black on black violence.
- 7:48I don't see how reparations is going to solve anything.
- 7:50You can give
- 7:51everyone here like a $50,000 check,
- 7:53especially people that are in the streets who are
- 7:54committing violent crimes consistently,
- 7:56a $50,000 check.
- 7:57It's not going to fix anything.
- 7:58It's not going to increase the median household income in the next 10 years by
- 8:0110% or 20%.
- 8:02For example,
- 8:03we have the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882.
- 8:05We prevented Chinese people from
- 8:06Getting citizenship
- 8:07and even entering the country,
- 8:08we discriminate against them
- 8:10and
- 8:10basically put them under apartheid,
- 8:12even here in the United States.
- 8:13Yet they have the highest median household income.
- 8:15How is that possible?
- 8:16How come they don't complain
- 8:17and feel entitled consistently to beg for reparations and beg for
- 8:20this when they are killing each other 90% of the time,
- 8:22which is the rate that black people kill each other according to the FBI?
- 8:25Oh,
- 8:26young Matt,
- 8:27Y white people are the oppressors.
- 8:28I'm not sure where.
- 8:29Your education came from,
- 8:31but they lied to you.
- 8:32Stats don't lie though.
- 8:33Statistics lie all the time.
- 8:36So let's start there,
- 8:37particularly when the statistics are coming from
- 8:39the sources that gain from the statistics being shown a different way.
- 8:43So
- 8:43if you're gonna start your argument on stats don't lie,
- 8:46you've already lost the argument.
- 8:47They lie,
- 8:48they lie all the time.
- 8:49One,
- 8:51comparing Chinese people.
- 8:52Who are immigrants that made a choice to come to the United States
- 8:56and comparing the continued effort of black people to
- 9:00ground themselves in a nation that continues to
- 9:02make impediments for them to show and live and
- 9:04exist in their true citizenship is a false equivalency.
- 9:07I don't believe that happens at all.
- 9:08What a,
- 9:08what a,
- 9:09no one here is,
- 9:10are you acting right now?
- 9:11Do you really I'm telling the truth.
- 9:12There's no,
- 9:13there's no systemic racism that I've experienced here in America.
- 9:15Um,
- 9:16what system is racist?
- 9:17I think the only racism we've actually seen recently,
- 9:19systemic racism that we've seen,
- 9:20is the application of systemic racism against white people.
- 9:23The University of Western Washington,
- 9:24for example,
- 9:25has been trying to segregate
- 9:26dormitories using black-only dormitories because black
- 9:29people feel safer amongst each other,
- 9:31but they're more likely to kill each other
- 9:32than white people are are ever to kill them.
- 9:34That's just the truth.
- 9:36You have King Vaughn rapping about killing other black men.
- 9:38Why should I think that the white man is the oppressor?
- 9:40When black men are more likely to kill me.
- 9:43God,
- 9:43this is scary.
- 9:45You need to think about me as your mama.
- 9:46Do not talk to me in that fashion.
- 9:48So let's check that now.
- 9:50OK.
- 9:50So
- 9:51on a basic level,
- 9:52we have to understand that systemic racism
- 9:54is grounded in the realities that black people
- 9:56have not been considered an equal human being in this country since its onset.
- 10:00So there's simply no way
- 10:02to make the argument that there isn't systemic racism and we have seen.
- 10:06Very clear ways the system operate in an organically racist way.
- 10:10Do not cut me off.
- 10:12When we talk about systemic racism,
- 10:13we can start with even the fact that redlining,
- 10:16which was implemented to discriminate black communities,
- 10:19are you shaking your head that redlining doesn't exist?
- 10:21No,
- 10:21I,
- 10:21I'm saying I don't think it really existed at all.
- 10:23I mean,
- 10:23no,
- 10:23I don't think so at all.
- 10:25So it does exist
- 10:26and stating that it doesn't exist doesn't make it no longer exist.
- 10:30Redlining absolutely.
- 10:31Exists.
- 10:31It is not a,
- 10:33it is not something that's being made up.
- 10:35It's an empirical fact,
- 10:36and there are realities that exist because of redlining.
- 10:38We know that school systems are related to the way
- 10:41that property taxes are affecting the school systems.
- 10:44If a school system
- 10:46is not getting the same property value as the property taxes allow it,
- 10:49then it's not gonna have the same efficacy at allowing
- 10:52for students to be able to get what they deserve.
- 10:54When we talk about systemic racism,
- 10:56we have to ack.
- 10:56Knowledge that these private prisons are literally built based on
- 11:00the test scores of school students in 3rd grade.
- 11:03So if you are literally building prisons with the onset of,
- 11:07OK,
- 11:07if these people are not reaching a certain reading level,
- 11:10then we know that they're going to go down a
- 11:11prison industrial pipeline where we can use their free labor,
- 11:14then how is that not systemic?
- 11:16And if you,
- 11:16and if you want to stop them from entering prisons,
- 11:19how are you going to stop people from entering prisons if your goal,
- 11:21if your goal.
- 11:22Is to get them into prison.
- 11:23Sure,
- 11:23make them try to be more like Ben Carson than be like King Vaughn.
- 11:26That's very,
- 11:27very simple.
- 11:27So Ben Carson,
- 11:28Ben Carson,
- 11:29how does King Vaughn happen?
- 11:30King Vaughn reparation actually,
- 11:32no,
- 11:32let me land the plane.
- 11:33We're talking about reparations,
- 11:34and what you're doing is actually just trying
- 11:36to get this conversation off the facts.
- 11:37And the fact is reparations
- 11:40are just and necessary
- 11:41because on a basic level,
- 11:43black people built this country and the country continues to thrive
- 11:47off.
- 11:47Of the labor that black people put into this country,
- 11:49and it would behoove you,
- 11:51young man,
- 11:52to really understand
- 11:53the way that your ancestors put blood,
- 11:55sweat,
- 11:56and tears into this nation
- 11:57that is still living off of those blood,
- 11:59sweat,
- 11:59and tears.
- 12:00And let me also add,
- 12:01there are reparations and then there is remunerations.
- 12:03Do you know the difference?
- 12:05Yes,
- 12:05but can I finish one point that I wanted to say?
- 12:06Ben Carson,
- 12:07Ben Carson's cousins were killed at a very young.
- 12:09I'm so sorry you've been voted out by the majority.
- 12:11Please return to your seat.
- 12:13I hope some of y'all are acting.
- 12:15I really do.
- 12:16I,
- 12:16I really,
- 12:17we in LA,
- 12:18we in LA and I,
- 12:19I hope some people in here are acting.
- 12:27Oh,
- 12:28what's that on your chain?
- 12:29Uh,
- 12:29this is a coin from Israel.
- 12:32Lord have mercy.
- 12:33Yes,
- 12:33you got to go.
- 12:35That's a choice that you are making for yourself.
- 12:37Yes.
- 12:38Uh,
- 12:38the thing with the whole reparations thing,
- 12:41and
- 12:41I don't know,
- 12:41we're probably close to the same age,
- 12:43so maybe you can't call me.
- 12:44How old are you?
- 12:45I'm 32.
- 12:46I'm 44.
- 12:470 really?
- 12:48Oh,
- 12:48you look young.
- 12:49Thank you.
- 12:49That's what water and keeping stress out of your life will do.
- 12:52Really?
- 12:53Liberal positions are real stressful.
- 12:55By the way,
- 12:55I wouldn't know.
- 12:56I'm not a liberal.
- 12:57Carry on.
- 12:58Well,
- 12:58most liberal,
- 12:59most of it's a liberal position because conservatives believe in hard work.
- 13:03We believe in
- 13:04going to work and working for what you got,
- 13:08not asking for handouts
- 13:10from people
- 13:11who never had slaves.
- 13:13Some of the people that you're asking for money
- 13:16from,
- 13:17never had slaves.
- 13:18And let's talk about the fact there were also black people
- 13:21that had
- 13:22Slaves.
- 13:23So if you want to talk about that,
- 13:25how is that fair?
- 13:27If I'm a white person and my family fall on the side of the union,
- 13:31why should I have to pay for slaves
- 13:34when this whole country was never all racist.
- 13:37Half of the founding,
- 13:38some of the founding fathers were
- 13:40abolitionists and they believed they hated slavery
- 13:42and they actually put things in the Declaration of Independence
- 13:45and things too because they believed that there'll be a future
- 13:48where there would be a black.
- 13:49President one day or that there would be people in leadership that were black.
- 13:52There was people in the North who helped
- 13:55with the Underground Railroad and fought in the uh
- 13:57fought with the Union.
- 13:59So why is that fair
- 14:00for people who never had slaves,
- 14:03who fought against slavery to have to pay
- 14:05for people
- 14:06that,
- 14:07that,
- 14:07that,
- 14:07that,
- 14:08that had slaves?
- 14:09One,
- 14:10from my understanding,
- 14:11you are more interested in preserving the fairness of those who didn't have slaves.
- 14:16than the fairness of those who are the descendants of slaves.
- 14:20That that
- 14:20that is,
- 14:21that is priority to you than finding a fair way
- 14:24to accommodate those who have been the descendant of slaves.
- 14:26Well,
- 14:26our ancestors wasn't asking for handouts,
- 14:28they were asking for,
- 14:29they were asking for equal opportunity
- 14:31and we have equal opportunity in this country.
- 14:34We had a black president,
- 14:35just in case you didn't know.
- 14:36We had a black president and we had a black vice president.
- 14:40I mean,
- 14:40I think she was black,
- 14:41they said she was black.
- 14:42I don't know.
- 14:44So
- 14:44we had a,
- 14:45we had a black president and you know who voted for that black man?
- 14:49White people.
- 14:51Because you can't win a popular election in this country without white people.
- 14:54So Barack Obama is the product of white people.
- 14:58So,
- 14:58so let's,
- 14:59let's get off this thing where,
- 15:01oh,
- 15:01America is so racist.
- 15:03What's making America so racist is people that,
- 15:06that continue to talk about racism
- 15:08and continue to focus on racism
- 15:11instead of focusing on unity and Bringing our country forward.
- 15:14People that have this liberal mindset are infecting our communities,
- 15:18black people and making us victims and not victors.
- 15:21I refuse to embrace a victim mentality because that's not what
- 15:25our grandparents and Harriet Tubman and those people fought for.
- 15:28They fought for
- 15:30Harriet Tubman's name in vain,
- 15:32baby,
- 15:32please Lord's name in vain
- 15:35Lord's name.
- 15:36Harriet Tubman was literally,
- 15:39literally.
- 15:41Saving her family and others from slavery.
- 15:46You know who helped her?
- 15:47White people.
- 15:47You know who helped her?
- 15:48They were on the Underground Railroad come on in,
- 15:51you know who helped her?
- 15:52Come on in.
- 15:52No,
- 15:53you know who helped her?
- 15:55People,
- 15:56people who benefit from white supremacy.
- 15:58One of the things that,
- 15:59one of the lie.
- 16:01No,
- 16:01sir,
- 16:01that's simply not true.
- 16:03If that were not the case,
- 16:05then we wouldn't see
- 16:06the continued effort of colonialism
- 16:09and white people.
- 16:10Placing themselves in positions of power when they do not have the power?
- 16:15Because
- 16:15their culture,
- 16:17black culture is toxic.
- 16:18The the black culture is toxic.
- 16:21We have produced a culture
- 16:22that is toxic and let's not,
- 16:24let's get on the fact that there's no fathers in the black culture.
- 16:26Let's get,
- 16:27let's get,
- 16:27let's talk about that.
- 16:28Let's talk about that,
- 16:29stop,
- 16:29stop,
- 16:29stop.
- 16:30This,
- 16:31none of this is going to work if y'all are just going to sit here and make up shit.
- 16:34It's not gonna work.
- 16:35No,
- 16:35it's a debate,
- 16:36it has to be in facts.
- 16:38You are literally not.
- 16:40I am not putting off emotional liberalism.
- 16:41You're putting off unfounded lies based in conservatism.
- 16:46Remember they did the misinformation thing all summer
- 16:49where everything conservative,
- 16:50they said a chain around your neck of an apartheid nation that actively wants to harm
- 16:57black people and not non-Jewish people.
- 17:00But let me bring it back,
- 17:01let me bring it back.
- 17:03Let me bring it that was not happening in the context that
- 17:05you're saying and they were selling their own bring it back.
- 17:08Still sell their own people today too,
- 17:10but I don't know.
- 17:11We're selling our own people.
- 17:12I don't know if I'm gonna probably won't with me.
- 17:14I won't because your ignorance is so
- 17:16overwhelming liberals y'all start when y'all defeated.
- 17:20You won't have an argument because you keep cutting me off.
- 17:23that's fine if they don't You won't even,
- 17:25you won't,
- 17:25you didn't make your point.
- 17:27You haven't made your point.
- 17:28And let me just tell you about your point.
- 17:30You started off saying
- 17:32we believe in hard work
- 17:34and we believe in being compensated.
- 17:38Reparations is not hard work,
- 17:39it's stealing.
- 17:39It's Robin Hood.
- 17:41You said you believe in hard work
- 17:43and you believe in being compensated for hard work.
- 17:46Were slaves compensated for their work?
- 17:48They weren't compensated for their work,
- 17:50but why should people who are sitting at home playing video games,
- 17:54smoking marijuana,
- 17:55are you sitting at home playing a video game?
- 17:57Are you sitting at home playing a video game?
- 17:59Am I sitting at home playing a video game?
- 18:01No.
- 18:02And I don't know what,
- 18:03I don't know who these people are that you're
- 18:04talking about because the majority of the black community
- 18:07is not sitting at home playing video games.
- 18:09Where are you getting that statistic?
- 18:11Where are you getting that statistic?
- 18:12Pause,
- 18:13pause.
- 18:13You've been voted out by the majority,
- 18:15please return to your seat.
- 18:16I knew I was going to be surrounded by ignorance,
- 18:17but damn,
- 18:18let's go.
- 18:24Hello,
- 18:25my hands wet from the,
- 18:26from the bottom.
- 18:26My hands are sweaty because I'm nervous.
- 18:28We both got sweaty hands,
- 18:29OK.
- 18:30So I just wanted clarity because I think it'd be helpful.
- 18:33You said radical.
- 18:34I wanted just clarity on that and then also with the reparations,
- 18:36you said it's not just money,
- 18:37it's other things.
- 18:38I just want to know like what do you see as like the
- 18:40grand picture of what would help,
- 18:42the grand picture of what would help of reparations,
- 18:43like what does that look like to you?
- 18:45Oh,
- 18:45great,
- 18:46um,
- 18:46reparations,
- 18:47what reparations looks like to me is
- 18:48a combination of reparations and remunerations,
- 18:50and reparations are about repair for damages that have been caused based on harm.
- 18:55Remuneration.
- 18:56Is a monetary response
- 18:58to work that has not been paid for.
- 19:01So if you come and paint my house and I don't pay you,
- 19:03you can take me to court
- 19:05and get remunerations for the work that you have done.
- 19:08So we're actually
- 19:10owed both in this nation as black people,
- 19:13and there are incredibly
- 19:15just clear cut records that show the buying and selling and purchasing of slaves,
- 19:20the work that was done,
- 19:21also the intellectual property that was sold.
- 19:23from slaves,
- 19:23right,
- 19:24because there was so much inventing that was happening
- 19:26and there is also quite a bit of
- 19:29other reparations that are being discussed as it relates to property being stolen,
- 19:33as it relates to,
- 19:34again,
- 19:35redlining and the inability for black people to get loans,
- 19:38etc.
- 19:38and these impediments being solely based on
- 19:40their race as far as like discrimination.
- 19:42Yes,
- 19:43like they're being solely based on their race,
- 19:44and not being about anything other than you're black,
- 19:46so you can't,
- 19:47right?
- 19:47And so when it's very clear cut like that.
- 19:49There are very distinctive responses to that
- 19:52that can be done through a cash payment
- 19:54as well as
- 19:55through measures that are being done to create funds for creating
- 20:00resources and responses like housing,
- 20:04uh,
- 20:04like access to food,
- 20:07access to education,
- 20:08etc.
- 20:09that certain communities have not had access to
- 20:11because of the fallout from these things.
- 20:13And I just had a quick question for clarifying.
- 20:15With the funds,
- 20:17I'm wondering where do you think those should come from,
- 20:19like the actual money,
- 20:20like is that we're raising money,
- 20:21is it taxes?
- 20:22Like what does that look like?
- 20:23Well,
- 20:23I think what they've been doing with these
- 20:25different reparations committees is they're looking at,
- 20:27all right,
- 20:28well how much
- 20:30has this
- 20:31city or how much has this town or how much has this country
- 20:34gained
- 20:36from
- 20:36the estimated amount that was stolen from these people,
- 20:40right?
- 20:41So they're looking at like.
- 20:42What is this wage amount,
- 20:43for instance,
- 20:43like if you look at
- 20:45during that time,
- 20:46OK,
- 20:46what was the wage amount that
- 20:47a hired worker would get for the same work,
- 20:50all right,
- 20:50and so we're looking at how was that wage
- 20:53not provided and what is that pool that is being created and then we're looking at,
- 20:57all right,
- 20:58where can that wage come from
- 21:00in terms of how has that wage been applied.
- 21:02So there are spaces
- 21:04where this is very clear.
- 21:05I think the and I think the last thing that you asked about was the difference.
- 21:08Between liberal and radical.
- 21:10Ultimately,
- 21:11the concept of liberalism is really just not Republican,
- 21:14right?
- 21:14I mean,
- 21:15that's essentially what it's become.
- 21:16I would disagree with that,
- 21:17but I understand that's your stance.
- 21:19There's a very generic concept of what liberalism is in the sense that
- 21:22it's simply saying that I am a part of the bipartisan mind frame,
- 21:25but I am not a Republican.
- 21:26It's,
- 21:27it's a mindset.
- 21:28It doesn't always show up in action,
- 21:29but it's a mindset that says,
- 21:30you know,
- 21:31I don't support extremes in certain ways or,
- 21:34you know,
- 21:34I want the government.
- 21:35To to show,
- 21:36show up in certain ways,
- 21:37you know,
- 21:37I know
- 21:38there's a conservative point of view that says there should be less government,
- 21:40but even though it just says that,
- 21:42the action is very different.
- 21:43The radical mind state
- 21:45simply
- 21:46is living opposite to
- 21:48our colonizers,
- 21:49which
- 21:50is an imperialist,
- 21:51capitalist mind state,
- 21:52and radical blacks do not believe that that is any way for us to have liberation.
- 21:56Thank you for explaining that and thank you for being very
- 21:59respectful.
- 21:59We were told to be respectful.
- 22:01We're not,
- 22:02we're not your enemies.
- 22:04My next claim is that black on black crime
- 22:06is a result of underinvestment and over policing.
- 22:15So you say that black on black crime
- 22:16is due to underfunding and over policing essentially.
- 22:20Uh,
- 22:20I actually don't necessarily disagree with one of those.
- 22:23Um,
- 22:24I think that however,
- 22:25the government,
- 22:25who do you think should be responsible for
- 22:28the funding piece of the black community?
- 22:29Should that be something that the government should step into or should
- 22:31that be something that we as black people need to handle ourselves?
- 22:34Uh,
- 22:34Doctor Jordan Peterson and.
- 22:36Uh,
- 22:36even Thomas Sowell and several others have stated one thing,
- 22:38that poverty and crime,
- 22:40there's a positive correlation.
- 22:41There's also a positive correlation in the black community
- 22:43of absentee fatherism being one of the root causes
- 22:46leading into criminality.
- 22:47Black male black males that grew up without a father
- 22:49are
- 22:5010 times more likely to engage in criminal activity.
- 22:53And so I think one of the,
- 22:53can I put a pin right there and ask you a question?
- 22:55Ask me whatever you like.
- 22:56What is the root cause
- 22:58of there being
- 22:59fathers present.
- 23:00Bad decision making on the part of the fathers.
- 23:02We live in a patriarchal system,
- 23:03like it or not,
- 23:04men have dominated the socioeconomic,
- 23:05economic,
- 23:06and political power of this country and the world since our existence.
- 23:09So our bad decision making,
- 23:11especially when we focus on the black community,
- 23:13is the root cause of of fatherlessness.
- 23:16Not marrying the women we decide to lay down and have children with,
- 23:19not being careful with the seeds that we plant in women.
- 23:21A woman can get pregnant
- 23:22without a man planting his seed inside of her.
- 23:24So therefore,
- 23:25so it's marriage.
- 23:26Well,
- 23:26that's a,
- 23:27that's a part of it.
- 23:28That that's marriage is a part of it.
- 23:30But the true
- 23:31piece that I'm looking at is connectedness between familial units.
- 23:34The black community was at its economically strongest while being at its poorest
- 23:38during the,
- 23:39uh,
- 23:39segregation era.
- 23:40Prior to 1968,
- 23:41Dr.
- 23:41Martin Luther King in his last speech said that we have an annual income.
- 23:44Of more than $30 billion a year,
- 23:45which is more than all of the exports of Canada and more
- 23:48or more than all of the exports of the United
- 23:50States and more than the national budget of Canada.
- 23:52That was when we were economically at our poorest.
- 23:54Yet
- 23:5485% of our black children were growing up
- 23:57with a father in the home.
- 23:58There was less black on black crime.
- 24:00There was less,
- 24:01uh,
- 24:01disenfranchised.
- 24:02Why was there less black on black crime?
- 24:04Because we needed to live together.
- 24:05We had,
- 24:05we had to stick by each other.
- 24:07What was there also less of?
- 24:09I'm not sure where you're leading.
- 24:09That's a leading question.
- 24:12I don't like you don't like this.
- 24:12I don't like leading questions,
- 24:13no,
- 24:14I like direct stuff.
- 24:15So essentially,
- 24:17when we were living in our own communities,
- 24:18we were also policing our own communities.
- 24:21So we were not being
- 24:23used as statistics in the same way to determine
- 24:27how resources were provided to our own communities.
- 24:29When we were going
- 24:30to the government saying,
- 24:31hey,
- 24:32we deserve because we are supposed to be separate,
- 24:35but Equal.
- 24:36We weren't saying,
- 24:37hey,
- 24:37we want to be with y'all.
- 24:38We were essentially saying we want what you are stating we deserve.
- 24:42And that is what all of the efforts of the civil rights movement has been.
- 24:45It's literally just been to say,
- 24:47you said when we got out of the Civil War
- 24:50that we would be considered citizens and all all
- 24:52citizens should be getting equal access to these things.
- 24:55However,
- 24:56you are actively allowing the Klan
- 24:58to harm us.
- 24:59You're actively allowing who's killed more black people,
- 25:02the Klan or us?
- 25:03I would like to continue my statement.
- 25:05I let you speak uninterrupted.
- 25:06When we talk about this concept of
- 25:09who is harming us,
- 25:10we are really
- 25:12making a false claim when it comes to black on
- 25:14black crime as if there isn't white on white crime.
- 25:16There's also this unnecessary
- 25:18effort to try and pathologize
- 25:20black on black crime in a way that you don't try to pathologize white on white crime.
- 25:24There are white people killing each other
- 25:26every single day.
- 25:27Now they may be on jet skis
- 25:29in the pictures after they shoot up their whole family,
- 25:31but nonetheless,
- 25:32there are white people killing.
- 25:33Each other every single day.
- 25:34Now,
- 25:34much of the reason why you may see more numbers in
- 25:36terms of black on black crime are for two reasons.
- 25:38One,
- 25:38the statistics be lying all the time.
- 25:40We have seen this.
- 25:41We have seen this in a real way.
- 25:42So in New Jersey,
- 25:44so in New Jersey,
- 25:44what numbers can be trusted because with the previous
- 25:46speaker I'm about to tell you right now,
- 25:48OK,
- 25:48so your sources you can't such numbers.
- 25:50No,
- 25:50I'm literally about to give you an example of numbers not being able to be trusted.
- 25:53OK,
- 25:53talk to me.
- 25:53That's what I was doing.
- 25:55So,
- 25:55OK,
- 25:56then,
- 25:56then listen.
- 25:58So listen,
- 25:58in New Jersey,
- 26:00they had a statistic that was created by.
- 26:01The police department that said look at
- 26:03how many black people are committing crimes.
- 26:06Look at how crazy this number is.
- 26:07These black people are so exorbitantly violent.
- 26:09Look at this.
- 26:10And then
- 26:11people went
- 26:12and actually matched the names that they were booking
- 26:16with the faces of the actual people incarcerated,
- 26:19and it was proven
- 26:21that they were lying.
- 26:22So that's one,
- 26:22OK,
- 26:22so that's one instance.
- 26:23Hold on,
- 26:23no,
- 26:23no,
- 26:24you're talking to somebody that works as a
- 26:25police dispatcher when I'm not making content.
- 26:26So here's the thing.
- 26:27So no,
- 26:28no,
- 26:28no,
- 26:28you see,
- 26:29well,
- 26:29the truth is you're about to see the truth.
- 26:30Just give me a second.
- 26:31Like Trump said,
- 26:31just give me a second.
- 26:32I'm,
- 26:32I'm gonna do the weave,
- 26:33but give me a minute.
- 26:34Well,
- 26:34here's what you all keep doing.
- 26:35You keep interrupting me when I'm talking,
- 26:37and you don't want to hear the point that I'm gonna make,
- 26:39and yet you want me to respect your point,
- 26:41and that's not how a debate works.
- 26:43So if you want me to keep getting louder,
- 26:45I will do it.
- 26:46But ultimately,
- 26:46if I show you respect,
- 26:48give me the respect back.
- 26:49I let you talk.
- 26:50I let you make your points.
- 26:51I am countering your points,
- 26:53and my points are just as valid as yours,
- 26:54even though you got a pocket square
- 26:56and a Church of Christ,
- 26:57uh,
- 26:57pin on your chest.
- 26:58It's not a Church of Christ.
- 26:59It's a cross,
- 27:00same difference.
- 27:01You got an American flag and you think you know something because you're a cop.
- 27:03And ultimately,
- 27:04and
- 27:05ultimately it's it's a cab all day over here,
- 27:07so let me make that clear.
- 27:08But let me also add to my point.
- 27:11My point is
- 27:12that you can sit here
- 27:14and blame black people on black people all day long
- 27:17and not acknowledge that we are forced into,
- 27:20you're coming to interrupt me again.
- 27:23All right,
- 27:23that is flags,
- 27:24so I'm going to ask you to return to your seat.
- 27:26It's a waste of my time.
- 27:28Y'all just want to be seen.
- 27:30I don't need to be seen.
- 27:36How are you?
- 27:37I'm Jasmine the pretty.
- 27:39Say less outfit.
- 27:40Thank you.
- 27:41So this is my thing,
- 27:42um,
- 27:42I think the premise of your question was black on black crime.
- 27:45So I think I'm coming from a place,
- 27:47um,
- 27:47and I guess my issue is,
- 27:49is having had my biological father murdered by a black man,
- 27:52having had my cousin shot in the head by a black man.
- 27:54We can talk numbers and statistics and what the people are
- 27:57doing and what the white man is doing and all that,
- 27:59but at the end of the day,
- 28:00I see when my family lives on the south side of Chicago and I think you and I both can.
- 28:04attest to this,
- 28:05and I'm not saying that they're not other factors,
- 28:07but we know that we kill each other at a disproportionate rate than any other race.
- 28:11Now,
- 28:11why we do that and why 60 to 9000 black men are gonna be homicided
- 28:15or killed or whatever by the end of the year annually by other black men,
- 28:19whereas the likelihood of a black man being killed by
- 28:21a white police officer is less than 150 per year,
- 28:24we know that we kill each other at a higher rate.
- 28:26So I'm not debating that they're not factors at play,
- 28:29but because I've lived the experience as a black woman
- 28:31losing my father to be murdered by a black.
- 28:32man walking down the street,
- 28:34no,
- 28:34no worries,
- 28:35thank you,
- 28:35but walking down the street in in inner cities and different things,
- 28:38knowing that it's more likely that my own brother will rob
- 28:41and rape me than a white man or a white officer,
- 28:43we got to be real.
- 28:44What's your proximity to white men
- 28:45in the South Side of Chicago?
- 28:47Are there even white men around to rob and rape
- 28:48you at the same rate that there are black men?
- 28:50There are white men around at the same rate.
- 28:52There wasn't a lot of black people in there,
- 28:53but then that doesn't justify the fact that we're destroying each other.
- 28:56So even if we get the like,
- 28:57we can agree on that,
- 28:58OK,
- 28:58because I feel like a lot of times liberals will argue like well I'm not.
- 29:02I am alive.
- 29:02I'm not a liberal.
- 29:03OK,
- 29:03well,
- 29:03I will say that people that sometimes
- 29:05have your stance that are against conservatives,
- 29:07maybe,
- 29:07they have this claim that they're making it up,
- 29:09they're making up the numbers.
- 29:10We know that we do that to each other,
- 29:11so I want to get to the root of the issue.
- 29:13Why are we killing each other?
- 29:14I think the root of the issue is we've lost
- 29:16our values and we've lost our resilience as black people.
- 29:19We sit there and we talk about what the white man
- 29:21did and we talk about slavery and everything like that,
- 29:22but we have no self-accountability and say,
- 29:24you know what,
- 29:25at the end of the day,
- 29:25that is my black grandmother,
- 29:26that is my black sister,
- 29:27you are my black sister and you know that.
- 29:29A black man is more likely to rob you or commit some type of crime against you,
- 29:32and that's what we need to get down to the
- 29:34issue of and like you were talking about earlier,
- 29:35like,
- 29:35hey,
- 29:36well what's going on,
- 29:37you know,
- 29:37what do you think the answer is to one of the brothers that were speaking?
- 29:39I think it's the breakdown of the family.
- 29:41I think like he said,
- 29:42because of our poor choices and what happens is,
- 29:44is we look at domestic violence,
- 29:45for example,
- 29:46when domestic violence,
- 29:47women or men are even attacked,
- 29:48what is the first thing we say?
- 29:50It's like,
- 29:50you know what,
- 29:50it's not your what,
- 29:51it's not your fault.
- 29:52So that's what we do,
- 29:53we hold on to this narrative that,
- 29:54well,
- 29:55it's not our fault and the issues in our community,
- 29:56they're not our fault and then the white man needs to.
- 29:58Give us something,
- 29:58an old white lady down the street is looking at me and I don't know why she
- 30:00got braids in her hair and we focus on
- 30:02all these other stupid things that don't matter.
- 30:04We don't get to the root of the fact that we're
- 30:05killing each other at a higher rate than any other race.
- 30:07It is self-hatred amongst us,
- 30:09I believe that we can do that,
- 30:11that we,
- 30:11my,
- 30:11my cousin,
- 30:12my mom's cousin,
- 30:13excuse me,
- 30:14going,
- 30:14coming from the church parking lot and guess who
- 30:15stuck her up and robbed her at gunpoint?
- 30:17A black man.
- 30:18I need you to get to the point.
- 30:19Like,
- 30:19my point is,
- 30:20is that,
- 30:21you know,
- 30:21and I'm not trying to be funny unless unless like you said,
- 30:23we're going to keep it respectful,
- 30:24but
- 30:24but you're you're monopolizing the whole conversation.
- 30:26I'm not trying,
- 30:26OK,
- 30:27I'm gonna let you speak,
- 30:27but let's not get the attitudes and stuff because you're my sister and I respect you,
- 30:30so I don't have an attitude.
- 30:31I'm being direct to you,
- 30:32but you're literally not speaking this and you're
- 30:34not going to do that with me either.
- 30:35So you're stating your point
- 30:36and you've been stating your point for quite some time,
- 30:38so you have a reason for me to respond.
- 30:40Yeah,
- 30:40would you allow me to respond,
- 30:41so that's a better response.
- 30:42Go ahead.
- 30:43The response that I have for you is that
- 30:46everything you're saying does not exist in a vacuum.
- 30:48I actually agree with you
- 30:49in that yes,
- 30:50there has been an incredible denigration
- 30:52of black worth and black pride in this nation.
- 30:55I think it's also very important to acknowledge
- 30:57what has contributed to that and to state
- 30:59that it is only black people that have contributed to that is a false flag.
- 31:04So we have to admit that.
- 31:05So in order to have this conversation around
- 31:08how we got here,
- 31:09you can't say,
- 31:10oh well,
- 31:10we're caring about the white woman getting braids
- 31:12and that doesn't matter and this thing.
- 31:13All of that attaches.
- 31:15All of that is actually a very big part of the lack of worth of black people.
- 31:18I'll ask you,
- 31:19do you think we're resilient?
- 31:20What does resilience mean to you?
- 31:22Do you think we have to be perpetual victims?
- 31:23Or do you think that black people are
- 31:24re think that those are two different conversations.
- 31:26I think they're because I think that the,
- 31:28the concept of black people being victims
- 31:30is really trying to not provide accountability
- 31:33to where the root problem for the actual cause is.
- 31:35And if we keep saying that somebody is a victim and that that doesn't
- 31:38mean that the other person should have to have to actually have accountability,
- 31:42then what are we really doing?
- 31:43You can do both.
- 31:44You can be a victim
- 31:46and be resilient.
- 31:47How do we do both if you stay in the victimhood?
- 31:49That's my question.
- 31:49But your statement about black people staying.
- 31:51In the victim place is also your point of view.
- 31:55We continue to rise above it by 1,
- 31:57pouring into our communities with mutual aid,
- 31:59but 2,
- 32:00by simultaneously
- 32:02making sure that we are challenging the systems that are in place to impede us.
- 32:06We have so many opportunities where we are
- 32:07trying to do mutual aid and those things get
- 32:10disrupted by folks who want to have capitalist gain,
- 32:13by folks who want privatization.
- 32:15We used to have all these mom and pop businesses in our communities.
- 32:18That's 3 million black millionaires in America.
- 32:20Right now,
- 32:21you are an intelligent black woman that is successful.
- 32:23No one's stopping me from doing anything.
- 32:24I'm an intelligent black woman that graduated efforts have
- 32:26tried to stop me from doing what I do.
- 32:29We are not all equal in our capabilities
- 32:32and we are not all equal in our ability to be invested in by others.
- 32:35We are not all equal in our trauma.
- 32:38We can't say we because it is a false
- 32:41equivalency.
- 32:42We keep trying to,
- 32:43we keep trying,
- 32:44but we keep trying to cause I'm so sorry,
- 32:46I'm so sorry you've been voted out.
- 32:53First,
- 32:54I want to say,
- 32:54I wanna kind of
- 32:55get rid of this like right left ordeal.
- 32:58I really want to talk about just like
- 32:59our own personal views and what we've experienced,
- 33:01what we've seen.
- 33:02Um,
- 33:03and when it comes to your claim,
- 33:05uh,
- 33:06about black on black crime,
- 33:07I really do believe,
- 33:08and I think a lot of people here do believe,
- 33:10especially based off of,
- 33:11uh,
- 33:12personal experiences and everything,
- 33:13that it is just lack of accountability.
- 33:15In the black community,
- 33:16we need to start taking responsibility for our actions
- 33:19and stop pointing our fingers at other people and the white man,
- 33:23because to be honest,
- 33:24at the same time
- 33:26because you got Clean your own house before you go complain
- 33:29because if you're you're dirtying my house,
- 33:32if you keep pouring shit into my house
- 33:34and I'm cleaning it,
- 33:36why can't I do both?
- 33:37Why can't I clean my house and bar the windows from you shitting on my house?
- 33:40It begins with responsibility within us.
- 33:43If we're like,
- 33:43OK,
- 33:44oh,
- 33:44the white person's doing this to me,
- 33:45the white person's not,
- 33:46we're not going to ever come to the core of the issue.
- 33:49We need to take responsibility just the white person.
- 33:51And because now we have seen very many races,
- 33:54people of very many backgrounds that are actively participating in the effort
- 33:57to keep a working class down.
- 33:59Like that isn't,
- 34:00that is abs absolutely the fact.
- 34:02It's not just white people,
- 34:03so I don't,
- 34:04I don't attend to that,
- 34:05but I will say
- 34:06the reality of
- 34:07there being systems in place
- 34:09is real.
- 34:10Over policing is a real thing.
- 34:12You know what's also been really real is the effort
- 34:14of violence.
- 34:15Interruption commu in,
- 34:16in certain communities,
- 34:17right?
- 34:18So we've seen this in Detroit,
- 34:19we've seen this in New York,
- 34:21we've seen this in Baltimore
- 34:22where there are communities that have said what we're gonna do is we're gonna be
- 34:25like a neighborhood watch for our community so that before the popo even come,
- 34:29before 12 even rolls up in here,
- 34:31we're gonna actually put ourselves in between
- 34:33the conflict and calm it down
- 34:35and that has been incredibly effective,
- 34:38but you know what,
- 34:39it's not funded.
- 34:40It's not funded and you would think that like
- 34:42city councils and mayors and governors would say,
- 34:45shit,
- 34:46you know what,
- 34:46this is going to save us so much money because why taxpayers keep having
- 34:49to pay for the fault of these police officers and even though we say,
- 34:52well,
- 34:52only certain people,
- 34:53only a certain number of people have died,
- 34:55that doesn't dispel the fact that a large amount more black
- 34:59people are imprisoned than any other group in this nation,
- 35:02and that is not by accident.
- 35:04Again.
- 35:04I started with accountability
- 35:06and it just seemed like.
- 35:08I mean,
- 35:09I don't disagree with you.
- 35:10Because here's the thing,
- 35:11look at,
- 35:11look at our media,
- 35:12look at,
- 35:12look at rap.
- 35:13Look at what we're glorifying.
- 35:14We're glorifying violence.
- 35:17We're the black the black community.
- 35:20Controls
- 35:21the distribution of these sources of media and who
- 35:24takes it in controls and who takes it in.
- 35:26Listen,
- 35:26if you're OK,
- 35:27so let me,
- 35:27let me put it in this context.
- 35:29If I have a company,
- 35:31right,
- 35:31and you guys are my employees
- 35:33and I determine what you get to eat every day.
- 35:36That's also going to determine
- 35:37how you exist in this company,
- 35:40right?
- 35:40Like if you come to work and I say the only thing you can eat
- 35:43is processed foods and fried foods
- 35:46and you're not going to get to have the best vegetables,
- 35:48etc.
- 35:49What's that going to affect?
- 35:51Your health,
- 35:51it's gonna affect your ability to operate,
- 35:54etc.
- 35:55This is how the United States operates.
- 35:58There's a lot of us that don't want to admit.
- 36:00That as much as accountable as we want to be,
- 36:03all of our brains also don't operate the same way.
- 36:05Some of us are much more apt to be indoctrinated than others.
- 36:07That's a fact.
- 36:08There is a 1% of people
- 36:10that knows this.
- 36:11There's a whole show called Mad Men that's about advertising,
- 36:14etc.
- 36:15and if we don't acknowledge
- 36:16multiple things at the same time,
- 36:19then we simply cannot
- 36:20stop it.
- 36:21We can be as accountable as we want to be.
- 36:23And I hope,
- 36:24I hope that if you're right,
- 36:26because I hope you're right,
- 36:27I wish that it was a situation where if black people could just be accountable,
- 36:30then nothing else would matter.
- 36:32But unfortunately that hasn't been the case because we have seen
- 36:34when we have black
- 36:36hot black Wall Street in Tulsa and we have black Wall Street in Durham,
- 36:39that when we actually do hold our own and build our own communities,
- 36:42they will still come and run it down.
- 36:44Boss,
- 36:45you've been voted out.
- 36:46Please return to your seat.
- 36:56So,
- 36:56um,
- 36:56I have two claims I want to settle.
- 36:58Um,
- 36:58so I'm originally from New Orleans,
- 37:00right,
- 37:00and I've seen black on black crime my whole life,
- 37:03right?
- 37:03Um,
- 37:04it's,
- 37:05I don't believe it has nothing to do with the police,
- 37:07um,
- 37:07it's more with the community,
- 37:09because there's a lot of pride that's in that city,
- 37:12where to the point where this person ain't telling me nothing.
- 37:15I'm gonna kill him,
- 37:15I'm gonna take him out.
- 37:16It's that simple in New Orleans.
- 37:18Now in Cali it's probably the same way,
- 37:20but
- 37:20I feel like every,
- 37:21every state is different.
- 37:23You probably,
- 37:23your,
- 37:23the way how your belief is might be right,
- 37:25right,
- 37:26but in New Orleans,
- 37:27it's a little different.
- 37:28Also,
- 37:29my,
- 37:29my second claim is this,
- 37:30we
- 37:31um
- 37:31proclaim so much about Black Lives Matter,
- 37:33but when it comes down to a white person killing a black person,
- 37:36it's a big deal.
- 37:37It it just don't make
- 37:39no sense to me.
- 37:39Do you know what the statement Black Lives Matter is actually stating?
- 37:42Well,
- 37:42like,
- 37:42you know,
- 37:43it started off from George Floyd.
- 37:45Start off from Mike Brown.
- 37:46Mike Brown.
- 37:47So Black Lives Matter is really simply just stating
- 37:50that when black people are murdered by the police,
- 37:53that
- 37:53our lives should matter,
- 37:55um,
- 37:55and that oftentimes it is not.
- 37:58It is oftentimes presented as we deserved it
- 38:01or we must have done something
- 38:04to cause it
- 38:05and that our lives are disposable.
- 38:07We also don't ever see true justice
- 38:09on the same level as others when the police incur
- 38:13violence against black people.
- 38:14So Black Lives Matter is a statement asserting
- 38:17that our lives.
- 38:18worth justice,
- 38:19our lives are worth preservation,
- 38:21and we have seen in
- 38:22innumerable instances a level of restraint
- 38:26operated between the police and people of other races that
- 38:29they do not seem to carry with black people.
- 38:31So that's what Black Lives Matter means.
- 38:32It doesn't mean that anyone else's life doesn't matter.
- 38:34It means that ours matter just as much as their lives.
- 38:37That's good that you cleared it out for people.
- 38:40I appreciate you.
- 38:41Now,
- 38:41as it comes to New Orleans,
- 38:42tell me this.
- 38:43Well,
- 38:43first of all,
- 38:43it was,
- 38:44uh,
- 38:44I think it's the senator of Louisiana who literally
- 38:47made a,
- 38:48a campaign ad,
- 38:49uh,
- 38:49Kennedy it was,
- 38:50that said,
- 38:51uh,
- 38:51do you want Louisiana to be run by crackheads?
- 38:54Like he said that like straight up bunch of them,
- 38:57yeah,
- 38:57yeah,
- 38:57yeah.
- 38:58So here's my question about New Orleans.
- 38:59Would you say
- 39:00that New Orleans gets that particular areas of New Orleans?
- 39:04For instance,
- 39:05like the 9th War,
- 39:05yeah,
- 39:06the 9th War is crazy,
- 39:07but
- 39:08I'm just saying it,
- 39:09would you say,
- 39:10would you say that funding and attention is is,
- 39:12uh,
- 39:13dispersed equally across New Orleans
- 39:15in terms of resources,
- 39:17because I know that from living through
- 39:18Katrina that that is absolutely not the case.
- 39:20No,
- 39:20yeah,
- 39:21I agree with you in that case,
- 39:22um,
- 39:24everybody's not equal when it comes down to resources for sure.
- 39:26I agree with you.
- 39:27Here's the thing I want to just.
- 39:29Part is that I think that we have a very
- 39:32distorted version of
- 39:34what resiliency and what restorative practice is because
- 39:38we live in a time where we're seeing so many things happen so fast.
- 39:42So like we've seen technology like advance so fast,
- 39:45right?
- 39:45Like we have seen just our lives shift so fast
- 39:48that I think that we forget that as humans,
- 39:51our ability
- 39:52to recalibrate.
- 39:54To heal from trauma
- 39:56is simply not
- 39:58the same
- 39:58as the things that we are watching in technology and so
- 40:02we cannot just casually think that people just get over things.
- 40:06Katrina,
- 40:07people in New Orleans are still reeling from Katrina.
- 40:10That's true,
- 40:11that's true.
- 40:12So when we talk about
- 40:13the amount of crime and violence that is still explicit
- 40:16that is still living and and happening explicitly in Katrina.
- 40:19We have to also talk about the amount of trauma,
- 40:21the amount of drug use,
- 40:23the amount of policing,
- 40:25the amount of all of these things that physically harm people across the world,
- 40:28not just in the United States,
- 40:29across the world in
- 40:31communities that are not being served and how those communities
- 40:34never get the chance to quote unquote pull themselves up by the bootstraps.
- 40:37Yeah,
- 40:37I agree.
- 40:38I I personally agree,
- 40:39yeah,
- 40:40yeah,
- 40:40I agree,
- 40:40yeah,
- 40:41for sure,
- 40:41yeah,
- 40:41of course,
- 40:42yeah.
- 40:42Thanks,
- 40:42Josh.
- 40:45My next claim is systemic racism isn't a theory,
- 40:48it's our lived reality backed by data and history.
- 40:56Hello
- 40:57hello John.
- 40:58John Samuel.
- 40:59Hello John Samuel,
- 41:00first name,
- 41:00first name.
- 41:00All right,
- 41:01blame my parents.
- 41:04Um,
- 41:04I want to listen to you first.
- 41:06Why do you feel that?
- 41:06Um,
- 41:07why do you feel that way?
- 41:08Why John came to John went to debate training before he came here,
- 41:11OK.
- 41:12Um,
- 41:12ultimately,
- 41:13I feel that way because it's simply just
- 41:15facts.
- 41:15It's in the books and that's why there have been laws to
- 41:19challenge it.
- 41:20Uh,
- 41:20there have been innumerable instances where
- 41:24actual systems were created specifically for the
- 41:27impediment of black people to advance.
- 41:29We have also seen numerable instances where
- 41:32there were things created for black people to advance
- 41:35and they were taken back under the auspices of,
- 41:37we don't want them to advance.
- 41:38Ultimately,
- 41:39systemic racism.
- 41:40Exists in our institutions on a government level,
- 41:43in our institutions,
- 41:45whether it's prisons or schools,
- 41:47and it is undeniable
- 41:49because they are actively trying to reinstate it
- 41:52right now.
- 41:53Can you give me an example of one of those
- 41:54systems that you believe um perpetuates that cycle of racism?
- 41:58Redlining?
- 41:59OK.
- 42:00And how does that,
- 42:00like,
- 42:01you know,
- 42:01can you elaborate and like how is that affecting the black community?
- 42:04Do you know what redlining is?
- 42:05I,
- 42:05I know a little bit.
- 42:06I'm not,
- 42:06I'm not an expert.
- 42:07Redlining was a system.
- 42:09That was created to determine property values and that said black people
- 42:13can only live in certain neighborhoods and not in other neighborhoods,
- 42:15and the redlining lowered the property values of those
- 42:18black neighborhoods by stating that they were more savage,
- 42:21that they were more dangerous,
- 42:23etc.
- 42:24Thus,
- 42:24they were not able to own property that was on a
- 42:28level of par
- 42:29to their white counterparts.
- 42:31There were also many efforts at just simply not
- 42:33allowing black people to get loans for property,
- 42:36putting them in predatory scenarios where
- 42:38They were being
- 42:40essentially unable to own land,
- 42:42and that inability to own land,
- 42:44but still having to pay out
- 42:46a mortgage,
- 42:46if you will,
- 42:47or a rent,
- 42:48continued to put black people in a conundrum of not being able
- 42:51to excel at the same economic rate as their white counterparts.
- 42:54What I'm hearing from you,
- 42:55if,
- 42:55if,
- 42:56if I'm hearing correctly,
- 42:57is it,
- 42:58it feels like in the United States that for a while we've kind of
- 43:01established these systems at their foundation and they've continued on
- 43:04and they've
- 43:05continually just oppressed black.
- 43:07People and we haven't dismantled them and we haven't
- 43:08done much so they continue to complete the cycle.
- 43:11Is that,
- 43:11is that what I'm hearing correctly?
- 43:12Well,
- 43:12in many of these systems they have been dismantled maybe in name,
- 43:16but because this country has never dismantled the culture of racism,
- 43:20they end up still living in practice.
- 43:22So we see that,
- 43:23for instance,
- 43:23in the way that uh the appraisal system works.
- 43:28Now we saw like there was an entire documentary on
- 43:31how appraisals have been also very racist home appraisals,
- 43:34right?
- 43:34So your ability to Sell your house for the value that it deserves.
- 43:37There were a number of homes,
- 43:38particularly in Marin County,
- 43:40California,
- 43:40where
- 43:41black people
- 43:42had one appraisal
- 43:43when they had their blackness up,
- 43:45so they had their dashikis hanging,
- 43:47you know,
- 43:47and they had their,
- 43:49right,
- 43:49they had their,
- 43:50their black Good Times poster,
- 43:52but then when they removed all those items and put up white people and
- 43:56a dog in the house and then had their white friends come and pose
- 43:59as the owners of the home,
- 44:00the appraisal
- 44:01was significantly higher,
- 44:03and we have seen that in a number.
- 44:04of instances.
- 44:05Now,
- 44:05of course that is just Marin County,
- 44:06but there are a number of other scenarios where this has been relayed,
- 44:10and that's why there were certain efforts by the Democratic Party to say,
- 44:14OK,
- 44:14well,
- 44:14we're gonna try and step in for this.
- 44:15I actually,
- 44:16um,
- 44:16remember that case and I,
- 44:17I watched it with the family and I thought that was just
- 44:20really just terrible.
- 44:22But
- 44:22the problem I guess I have with systemic racism is,
- 44:25I guess for somebody like me,
- 44:26where my family comes from the deep South,
- 44:28you probably don't even know it,
- 44:29Aliceville,
- 44:29Alabama,
- 44:30um,
- 44:31that's where my grandparents are from.
- 44:33And my grandpa came,
- 44:34if you saw the house that he grew up in,
- 44:37it,
- 44:37I'm not trying to be funny,
- 44:38it looked like a,
- 44:39a slave house.
- 44:39It was just,
- 44:40they grew up in poverty.
- 44:42And the fact that he was able to go from that
- 44:45and get the highest rank enlisted in the United States Navy
- 44:49amidst,
- 44:49you know,
- 44:50all these,
- 44:50you know,
- 44:51systems,
- 44:52um,
- 44:52so to speak,
- 44:53and he was able to buy his own house out in San Diego,
- 44:56he was able to,
- 44:57you know,
- 44:57pass on these things to his son,
- 44:59my dad,
- 45:00that,
- 45:00um,
- 45:01and his grandchildren,
- 45:02you know,
- 45:02now I'm able to get an education.
- 45:04I was able to get my undergrad,
- 45:05my master's,
- 45:06that,
- 45:07you know,
- 45:08the great,
- 45:08great.
- 45:09Grandson of enslaved peoples can now say that,
- 45:12you know,
- 45:12educated and can even run for Congress,
- 45:15you know,
- 45:15I,
- 45:15I don't see how
- 45:17these systems are still in place as they were before because before
- 45:20I would say you do have a little bit of a um
- 45:23a foothold,
- 45:23you do have some um validity there,
- 45:26but I just think these days when we call it systemic racism,
- 45:29really what we're calling it is those people
- 45:31who may still be in those institutions,
- 45:33those individual people who.
- 45:35May actually be racist and hold some racist
- 45:37ideals who are continuing to perpetuate this.
- 45:40I believe it's,
- 45:40it's,
- 45:41it's those people.
- 45:42So in,
- 45:42in all reality,
- 45:43the problem is not the systemic racism,
- 45:45the problem is us.
- 45:46The problem starts with with us,
- 45:48with those people
- 45:50who,
- 45:50um,
- 45:50are perpetuating these,
- 45:51you know,
- 45:52kind of,
- 45:52you know,
- 45:53racist ideals.
- 45:54And so I feel like just to attack these systems
- 45:57is just,
- 45:58it's nonsensical.
- 45:59Who's running the system,
- 46:00like which system you're talking about.
- 46:01Whether it's the prison industrial,
- 46:02whether it's the prison industrial complex,
- 46:04we're seeing this now with,
- 46:05uh,
- 46:06with immigration and ICE,
- 46:07we're seeing this also with the effort at not making schools available,
- 46:12uh,
- 46:13for equal level of schooling available with the voucher systems that are
- 46:16now allowing tax dollars to allow people to go to segregated schools.
- 46:20Who is,
- 46:21who is controlling those systems?
- 46:22So for instance,
- 46:22in Tennessee,
- 46:23right,
- 46:23so in Tennessee
- 46:25you have a Senate and a House of Representative.
- 46:28that is largely controlled
- 46:31by white Republicans
- 46:33and that have actively said we are not going
- 46:36to consider what the people want in our constituencies.
- 46:39We are going to simply just do what we want to do to the point where they have removed.
- 46:42So it's only in those states that have largely white
- 46:45legislators or largely white people are controlling the systems.
- 46:48I just,
- 46:48I don't,
- 46:49I'm not trying to push all right guys,
- 46:50I'm so sorry you have been voted out.
- 46:52Please return to your seat.
- 46:53Thank you.
- 46:59Oh Lord.
- 47:01So to go back to your claim,
- 47:03you basically said something about Tennessee and how they've said
- 47:06what exactly you said they
- 47:07are not in favor of what their people said,
- 47:09or yeah,
- 47:10Tennessee has actively said,
- 47:11you know,
- 47:11we're not really listening to our constituency.
- 47:13We're not even going to allow them in
- 47:15the gallery when we're voting on certain issues.
- 47:17So for instance,
- 47:17like when it comes to like guns in the classroom,
- 47:20like the,
- 47:20the constituency very loudly said.
- 47:22We do not want guns in the classroom.
- 47:23And they were like,
- 47:24Well,
- 47:24we don't care.
- 47:24We're going to do it anyway.
- 47:26We've also seen them actively silence
- 47:28members of the House of Representatives who are black and
- 47:31not silence someone who is doing the exact same action,
- 47:34who is a white woman,
- 47:35Gloria.
- 47:36Shout out to the Justins.
- 47:37You are right,
- 47:37actually,
- 47:38on this aspect.
- 47:39I did actually remember,
- 47:40I did actually remember a time where two black Democrats,
- 47:43I believe,
- 47:43were actually not allowed to speak.
- 47:45And that was interesting,
- 47:46and I found that really like insane
- 47:48considering they're representatives of the state.
- 47:51So no,
- 47:51I totally can get where you're coming from,
- 47:53but I don't think that's an institutionalized problem where it's a law per se.
- 47:56I think it's more so a personal vendetta in a way.
- 47:59What's the difference if you are a
- 48:01lawmaker and you're exacting your personal ability,
- 48:04your personal.
- 48:04Choice through
- 48:06through impediment of law change.
- 48:08So if we're going to go based on systemic racism,
- 48:10it has to be institutionalized,
- 48:12which means it has to be written into law,
- 48:13made,
- 48:14made public.
- 48:15When it comes to that aspect,
- 48:16that's not necessarily made public by law,
- 48:18that's made public by choice and actual discrimination by person.
- 48:21So I can give you an example in Tennessee.
- 48:23So for instance,
- 48:24uh,
- 48:24in Tennessee we can say that they are put into law
- 48:28that now tax dollars,
- 48:30people's,
- 48:31the public's tax dollars will be supporting
- 48:33voucher systems.
- 48:34The voucher systems for the schools allow
- 48:37parents
- 48:37to choose whatever school they want their child to go to
- 48:40using taxpayer money,
- 48:42and
- 48:43these schools can be private schools,
- 48:45and private schools are not in any way limited from creating
- 48:49systems of segregation,
- 48:50and this is.
- 48:51Actually how segregation,
- 48:52segregated schools was carried out previous to Brown versus Board of Education.
- 48:57So
- 48:58this is a systemic example.
- 48:59Um,
- 49:00we also can acknowledge that systemic examples come from
- 49:03not always it being written into law,
- 49:05and I think that is a real straw man argument for
- 49:09the way that a lot of color blind racism explained is,
- 49:11is,
- 49:11is carried out in the United States.
- 49:13And what happens when we do that is we ignore
- 49:16the fact that the most of the people making the laws.
- 49:19are not going to put their racism on the books.
- 49:21That's true.
- 49:22Obviously they're not going to put it on the books,
- 49:23but when it comes to the Civil Rights Acts of 1964,
- 49:26then you also want to talk about the one in 1968.
- 49:29They did actually give more fair housing equality.
- 49:32That was,
- 49:32yeah,
- 49:32that's true.
- 49:33But you see,
- 49:33that's the thing,
- 49:34it's like if we,
- 49:35we,
- 49:35so that's the,
- 49:36that's the difficult part of not changing a culture.
- 49:38You can change the law all day,
- 49:40but as Martin Luther King Jr.
- 49:41as the Doctor Reverend Martin Luther King Jr.
- 49:43talks about in his final book,
- 49:44he says,
- 49:44I I feel like I integrated my people into a burning house,
- 49:48because he understood America to be a place of morality.
- 49:50Well,
- 49:50when it came back to even back in the 1960s,
- 49:53like
- 49:54Lyndon B.
- 49:55Johnson actually proposed many
- 49:57systems in place where he actually want people still got lynched.
- 50:00Well,
- 50:01that's,
- 50:01I mean,
- 50:02I can't really like say that's a systemic problem.
- 50:04That's definitely a personal heart problem.
- 50:06Those are more people's individual choices against someone else.
- 50:09But when it came down to that's in place does not.
- 50:11In incarcerate those people or create any repercussions for those actions,
- 50:14then it is systemic.
- 50:15Because when you don't allow for there to
- 50:17be repercussions for harmful behaviors of the people,
- 50:20you are literally saying our system is OK with this.
- 50:23So that's what Black Lives Matter is about,
- 50:24right?
- 50:25Saying like,
- 50:26OK,
- 50:26if police are going to act in this way,
- 50:29well,
- 50:29there should at least be fair repercussions across all people that they're doing
- 50:34this to and they're not carrying out those repercussions for black people.
- 50:37Why?
- 50:38And so the system is supporting
- 50:41this personal point of view that you're talking
- 50:43about and that's what makes it also systemic,
- 50:45along with the fact that we know for a fact that the
- 50:48number of black people incarcerated is greater per capita than white people.
- 50:52We know that black people are having longer
- 50:54sentences for the same crimes than white people.
- 50:56That's not
- 50:57me making that up,
- 50:57like that is actual data,
- 50:59so systemic is real.
- 51:00Pause,
- 51:01you've been voted out by the majority,
- 51:02please return to your seat.
- 51:09Come on.
- 51:09Alright,
- 51:10how you doing,
- 51:10Amanda?
- 51:10I'm Ryan.
- 51:11Nice to meet you,
- 51:12thanks for being here.
- 51:13Alright,
- 51:13well,
- 51:13uh,
- 51:14what I would say is,
- 51:15as far as,
- 51:15uh,
- 51:16systematic racism,
- 51:16right?
- 51:17Um,
- 51:18I,
- 51:18I think most of us would agree that at the very least it has occurred in this country,
- 51:22uh,
- 51:22right,
- 51:22you know,
- 51:22we've had slavery,
- 51:23we've had Jim Crow segregation,
- 51:24all these different things.
- 51:25I think my argument would be that right now,
- 51:27um,
- 51:28in modern America,
- 51:28I don't think at the very least,
- 51:30it's not as prevalent as it has been to where it could stop us from being successful,
- 51:35OK?
- 51:35I would say that,
- 51:36uh,
- 51:36it's not a thing anymore where it needs to be talked
- 51:38about so much and so much attention focused on it.
- 51:41Um,
- 51:41I don't think that currently there is systematic racism in
- 51:44a way that it's gonna be harmful to us.
- 51:47You know,
- 51:47like I said,
- 51:48to stop us.
- 51:48If anything,
- 51:49really,
- 51:49I think institutions such as
- 51:52things with DEI,
- 51:53what do you think DEI is?
- 51:54Basically,
- 51:55I think that is,
- 51:56it's in a way it's racism against other races
- 51:59outside of blacks.
- 52:00And so,
- 52:01um,
- 52:01where did you get that concept of it from?
- 52:03I've researched a lot of things.
- 52:04I've looked at different clips from both sides of the argument,
- 52:06things like that.
- 52:06But
- 52:07basically my point is I think that as far as systematic racism,
- 52:10I think that there's evidence from the other side in that
- 52:12there's different things that are pushing black people up in ways that are not fair.
- 52:16And different things like that,
- 52:18uh,
- 52:18because I think that we should be merit-based.
- 52:20I think that should always be merit-based,
- 52:21and where we're in,
- 52:22you know,
- 52:23uh,
- 52:23when there's jobs and different things like that,
- 52:25um,
- 52:26race should not be
- 52:27something that's considered.
- 52:28And so,
- 52:29uh,
- 52:29I think that let's say that there are ways right now where
- 52:33where systematic racism is still alive.
- 52:35Um,
- 52:35again,
- 52:36it's not holding us back to a point where we can still be successful.
- 52:38We've,
- 52:39we've seen so many examples,
- 52:41uh,
- 52:41you know,
- 52:41today in modern times where,
- 52:43uh,
- 52:43uh,
- 52:43black Americans can,
- 52:45you know,
- 52:45there's no opportunities that I
- 52:46have that a white person,
- 52:48uh,
- 52:48or that a white person has that I don't have that I believe that all opportunities.
- 52:52Can you,
- 52:53can you,
- 52:53can you actually say that?
- 52:55I,
- 52:55I,
- 52:55I would say that I have every opportunity in this country to be successful,
- 52:58to do what I want to do,
- 52:59and to stand on business that every other race has,
- 53:02uh,
- 53:02absolutely,
- 53:02and,
- 53:03and and again,
- 53:04even if I don't have the same support,
- 53:06I can,
- 53:06I,
- 53:06I can do what I gotta do the same.
- 53:08I,
- 53:08I probably have more,
- 53:09I can have more support than others.
- 53:11I,
- 53:11I have excellent community support,
- 53:12absolutely for you.
- 53:13Sure,
- 53:14sure,
- 53:14yeah,
- 53:14yeah,
- 53:15I,
- 53:15I.
- 53:16Did you grow up in a lower income,
- 53:17middle income,
- 53:18high,
- 53:18high income community?
- 53:19Uh,
- 53:19it was middle income,
- 53:20yeah.
- 53:21So again,
- 53:22I think that even those who grew up in,
- 53:23in,
- 53:23in,
- 53:23uh,
- 53:24very needy situations,
- 53:25right,
- 53:25um,
- 53:25they may not have,
- 53:26uh,
- 53:26been dealt a great,
- 53:28uh,
- 53:28hand of cards,
- 53:29but they still,
- 53:30they,
- 53:30they can still,
- 53:31you know,
- 53:31I,
- 53:31I think it comes down to accountability.
- 53:33Uh,
- 53:34you can still play your,
- 53:35play your hand and play your cards,
- 53:36uh,
- 53:36strategically in a way where you can still be successful.
- 53:38You can still do your thing,
- 53:39um,
- 53:40and you can wind up on top,
- 53:41and there's nothing stopping us from doing that.
- 53:43Would you say that low income white people and low
- 53:44income black people are The same ability to excel.
- 53:48I,
- 53:48I would say they have the same ability to excel.
- 53:49OK,
- 53:50so I'm going to start countering from that point then.
- 53:52So
- 53:52ultimately,
- 53:53we know that our low income communities are not given the same access to resources
- 53:57on a myriad of levels.
- 53:58They don't even have the same air quality,
- 54:00OK.
- 54:01Uh,
- 54:01we know that low income communities in general
- 54:03are also
- 54:04going to be much more policed than other communities.
- 54:07We know that policing as it exists in the United States came from slave catching.
- 54:11So even the tradition of of policing comes from
- 54:15protecting.
- 54:15Property not protecting people,
- 54:17OK,
- 54:17so let's start there.
- 54:18When we talk about low income like the working class black people in this nation,
- 54:22we know that they have never been considered ever,
- 54:24whether they were slaves or not,
- 54:26they just weren't considered.
- 54:27And we also know,
- 54:28as our brother Isaiah pointed out that there are
- 54:30still people in very powerful positions that hold very personal
- 54:33positions as it relates to racism
- 54:36and so in that way they are impediments to someone moving forward.
- 54:40When we talk about DEI,
- 54:41the concept of DEI is not about lowering a standard,
- 54:45it's about.
- 54:45About widening the options.
- 54:47So we live in a nation that a lot of,
- 54:49I feel like a lot of y'all are looking at the United States
- 54:52as a long history of something.
- 54:55We have a short history,
- 54:57all right.
- 54:57For 400 years there was slavery,
- 54:59black people were not even considered whole humans,
- 55:01we were 3/5 human.
- 55:03After the Civil War,
- 55:04during Reconstruction,
- 55:06black people were then subjected to the Black Clause.
- 55:08The black laws were specifically for black people.
- 55:11The black laws incarcerated black people at such an exorbitant rate.
- 55:15That they were able to get another
- 55:17slave labor force through the 13th Amendment because
- 55:20you had black people that were serving entire
- 55:23life,
- 55:24like months-long,
- 55:25years-long cases,
- 55:26I mean years-long sentences
- 55:27for jaywalking.
- 55:29So
- 55:29when we look at these things,
- 55:30we act as if,
- 55:31well,
- 55:31why can't we just get over that.
- 55:33That's 2 generations previous,
- 55:34OK.
- 55:35So if a father
- 55:36In the 19 in the early 1900s,
- 55:38was incarcerated for two years.
- 55:40How do you think that would impede
- 55:42their family from being able
- 55:44to grow,
- 55:44right?
- 55:44Now you're,
- 55:45you're affecting the ability for their children to have two parents in the home.
- 55:48You also now have a mother who's like incredibly
- 55:50stressed and may have to always be working,
- 55:52so she's not even able to parent,
- 55:53etc.
- 55:54We also know that there is a continued effort in this nation
- 55:57to not Have black people know the history
- 56:00of this nation.
- 56:00Like our good sis here was talking about like we have resilience,
- 56:03but this nation actively works systemically
- 56:06to keep that from us,
- 56:07right?
- 56:07We look in Florida at the laws that they are passing
- 56:10to not allow education about our past and we know
- 56:13that if we don't know where we came from,
- 56:14how can we know where we're going?
- 56:16All right,
- 56:16I'm so sorry.
- 56:17I'm sorry.
- 56:17That's,
- 56:18that's flags.
- 56:24Hi,
- 56:25hi,
- 56:25hi again.
- 56:26um,
- 56:27we cool now?
- 56:27We,
- 56:27we good,
- 56:28we good.
- 56:28I think we.
- 56:30I think we're on the same,
- 56:32we're we're kind of looking at the same side of the same coin,
- 56:33and I think because I think we both want
- 56:36the betterment of the black community and I think we're
- 56:38maybe coming from it from different ways and so I do
- 56:41respect your position to what you were saying as well,
- 56:43that there are certain things and powers at play,
- 56:45and I've experienced racism firsthand.
- 56:46A lot of conservatives may try to act like,
- 56:48oh,
- 56:48there's no racism in America,
- 56:50I absolutely believe there is racism in America,
- 56:52I believe racist people exist.
- 56:53I just don't think that the systems as they stand today
- 56:56are inherently racist because I've seen too many black people overcome.
- 56:59And I just feel like a lot of times what's
- 57:01left out of the dialogue is self-accountability and like self-will.
- 57:04We talked about how we were 3/5 of a person,
- 57:07but now we are 100% I guess according to the law or whatever,
- 57:10a person,
- 57:11and I feel like at the end of the day if you wanted to walk out here right now and decide,
- 57:14you know what,
- 57:14I wanna change my career,
- 57:15I wanna do that,
- 57:16you can.
- 57:17And that's why so many people and Nigerians
- 57:19come here and Indians come here and so many
- 57:20people who are not white who are supposed
- 57:22to be discriminated against because they're not white,
- 57:24they come here and they become doctors and lawyers.
- 57:26Why?
- 57:27Because to your point.
- 57:28There's community.
- 57:29There's a sense of pride about,
- 57:30you know what,
- 57:30I got to go honor my parents back in Nigeria.
- 57:32I'm heart Nigerian.
- 57:33I have to go honor my parents.
- 57:34I have to go honor my elders.
- 57:35They're not twerking and shaking booty.
- 57:37They're getting they're literally twerking and shaking and booty.
- 57:39The Nigerians I know ain't doing it.
- 57:41If they are.
- 57:43They're doctors twerking and shaking booty,
- 57:44so maybe they can shake because they got the money to back it up.
- 57:47But do you see what you're saying?
- 57:48But do you see what I'm saying though?
- 57:49We have to be honest,
- 57:50Amanda.
- 57:51When Indias fellow,
- 57:52as a fellow daughter of an immigrant,
- 57:53right,
- 57:54so my mother's from Grenada,
- 57:55my mother did come here
- 57:56and was a.
- 57:57Able to work and was able to get green cards for folks.
- 57:59So shout out to my mom.
- 58:00There's a very big difference in growing up somewhere
- 58:04and coming from a place where you are the majority
- 58:06and where your people are running the show
- 58:09than being somewhere where your people have been subjugated the entire time your
- 58:13people have been your mama came here and she wasn't the majority,
- 58:15so how did she succeed?
- 58:16She succeeded because she came here with the
- 58:19fortitude of coming from a place resilience.
- 58:22No,
- 58:23but you'll let me,
- 58:23let me say what I'm saying.
- 58:24I'll unpack.
- 58:25If we don't.
- 58:25Knowledge,
- 58:26divide and conquer in the United States.
- 58:29We are having a pointless conversation.
- 58:31We have to acknowledge that there is a concerted
- 58:34effort at divide and conquer in the United States.
- 58:36We're literally
- 58:37watching it happen right now with an effort to divide and conquer
- 58:40and have black people fighting immigrants and have
- 58:42black people saying that immigrants don't matter.
- 58:45So fighting white people.
- 58:46White people is not the point.
- 58:48The concept of white people is about people who are
- 58:50upholding a supremacy of whiteness versus people who understand.
- 58:54That there should be an egalitarianism.
- 58:56There should be an equality are becoming the new white supremacists.
- 58:59We are,
- 58:59we've been putting them on a pedestal.
- 59:00We are.
- 59:01We feel like we can't do anything.
- 59:02No,
- 59:02it's not that we're putting them,
- 59:03it's not that we're putting them on a pedestal.
- 59:05It's that we are joining them
- 59:07and instead weaponizing our blackness against our people.
- 59:10When we do what you're saying,
- 59:11we are saying
- 59:13I am better
- 59:14because I can,
- 59:15I figured it out and so you're the problem because you didn't figure it out,
- 59:18what about if I believe that the American dream is I have a right to that as well.
- 59:21Is that me joining white people or is that me saying,
- 59:23you know.
- 59:23I want.
- 59:24The American dream for me,
- 59:25because it may look different from other people.
- 59:27Some people it's a boss shit.
- 59:28For me,
- 59:28I want my kids to grow up in a wonderful neighborhood.
- 59:30I want them to go to college.
- 59:31I want
- 59:32um to have a 401k.
- 59:34I want to do this,
- 59:34I want to do that.
- 59:35So I feel like a lot of times in the black community,
- 59:36we associate anything that's right or that's
- 59:38just or that's striving forward with whiteness.
- 59:41So when you say that we're working with that it's whiteness,
- 59:42it's capitalism,
- 59:44and I think that's what we have to understand the difference of.
- 59:46The concept of capitalism always is grounded in exploitation.
- 59:49So we're sitting here benefiting from capitalism
- 59:51and you know that because you would.
- 59:52I Understand that we are benefiting.
- 59:53I understand that we are benefiting from capitalism,
- 59:55but I also understand that we would have other people and a
- 59:58vast majority of people benefit if we were not solely capitalists.
- 1:00:02That is what it means to be a black radical.
- 1:00:03It's to understand that I can benefit
- 1:00:06as well as others.
- 1:00:07Amanda,
- 1:00:07what is your solution then?
- 1:00:08Because we know that capitalism benefits us and people
- 1:00:10are coming is what I continue to say.
- 1:00:12We need to have coalition building across cultural differences,
- 1:00:15across ethnicities,
- 1:00:16across classes.
- 1:00:18We with white people.
- 1:00:18I've never said it didn't,
- 1:00:20but this obsession.
- 1:00:21This obsession with white people fails to acknowledge the fact
- 1:00:23that there are people who benefit from white supremacy.
- 1:00:27Let me finish my point.
- 1:00:29There are people who benefit from white supremacy
- 1:00:31that do not identify themselves as white.
- 1:00:33They don't consider that to be the naming the most
- 1:00:36important element of their identity because they understand that at
- 1:00:38the end of the day we need to see each other as humans that all deserve a right to exist.
- 1:00:44We all deserve a right to exist,
- 1:00:45and I shouldn't have to earn my right to exist,
- 1:00:47and that is what capitalism does that you have to earn it.
- 1:00:49That's.
- 1:00:50is what this nation is.
- 1:00:51You do have to earn it.
- 1:00:52You do.
- 1:00:53Yes,
- 1:00:53you do.
- 1:00:53That is why we are criminalizing the poor.
- 1:00:55We are criminalizing the poor on a regular basis.
- 1:00:58It's how so?
- 1:00:59Because we're not even allowing for a wage to
- 1:01:01happen to allow people to get out of poverty.
- 1:01:03We are seeing inflation grow.
- 1:01:04We both have people in our family that have done it,
- 1:01:06so we can't.
- 1:01:06No,
- 1:01:06we have not had people that have done it.
- 1:01:08My mother came to America
- 1:01:09with an entire nursing degree.
- 1:01:11I can't say,
- 1:01:12oh well,
- 1:01:13my mother did it.
- 1:01:13Why can't you?
- 1:01:14Because my mother was pregnant at 19 from the South Side
- 1:01:16of Chicago with no degree and still made for your mom.
- 1:01:19But this is the thing,
- 1:01:20your mom is,
- 1:01:21I'm not,
- 1:01:21it's not the question isn't whether or not some people can do it.
- 1:01:24The question and the reality is that it is not available to everyone in an equal way.
- 1:01:28That's unfortunate,
- 1:01:29Amanda,
- 1:01:29but you know we live in a broken society.
- 1:01:31I went to Nigeria,
- 1:01:32so they're having the same problems,
- 1:01:33and it's a bunch of black people that are running Nigeria society.
- 1:01:36But it's the same thing in Nigeria.
- 1:01:37Nigeria is a broken society,
- 1:01:39whereas Burkina Faso is not.
- 1:01:40Burkina Faso is not.
- 1:01:43My final claim is black conservatism fails to meet the needs of the working class.
- 1:01:53A dog,
- 1:01:53OK,
- 1:01:54talk to me.
- 1:01:55So I think black conservatives,
- 1:01:56we're the ones who really want the best for working people.
- 1:02:00I think we're the ones,
- 1:02:01like a lot of the liberals,
- 1:02:02a lot of the leftists,
- 1:02:02they want us to do things like office work,
- 1:02:05they want us to go reparations,
- 1:02:07try to get things from the government and get handouts.
- 1:02:10We say,
- 1:02:10hey,
- 1:02:11go out there and work,
- 1:02:12go out there and get these jobs that are available,
- 1:02:14work with your hands,
- 1:02:16do skilled trades.
- 1:02:17That's what a lot of us talk about,
- 1:02:19skilled trades.
- 1:02:20So,
- 1:02:21working class,
- 1:02:21that's Really
- 1:02:22a black conservative thing in my humble opinion.
- 1:02:24I would beg to disagree.
- 1:02:26Um,
- 1:02:27I think that that would be true if black conservatism also created
- 1:02:32pathways for people to get those jobs and also to be
- 1:02:35able to challenge the corporations that are using their labor,
- 1:02:38that are stealing from them and not impeding them from having a union.
- 1:02:42So for instance,
- 1:02:43like in the South,
- 1:02:44right,
- 1:02:44uh,
- 1:02:44I just left North Carolina where I met with the USSW,
- 1:02:47the Union of Southern Service Workers.
- 1:02:49This is an unofficial union
- 1:02:50of individuals.
- 1:02:51who work at places like Waffle House,
- 1:02:53at Food Lion,
- 1:02:54etc.
- 1:02:55and their unofficial union is unofficial because
- 1:02:58the conservatives in that state will not
- 1:03:01allow for them to be official
- 1:03:03officialized,
- 1:03:04legit,
- 1:03:05legitimized.
- 1:03:07It will not allow for them to be legitimized
- 1:03:09because then they would be able to push back
- 1:03:12legitimately
- 1:03:14on the corporations to get fair wages,
- 1:03:15right?
- 1:03:16So like someone was telling me in this
- 1:03:17organization that she was in Baltimore getting 1525.
- 1:03:20as a minimum wage and then when she moved
- 1:03:23just one state away,
- 1:03:24she was now only getting 725 for minimum wage,
- 1:03:27but the cost of living was the same for her.
- 1:03:29So when we talk about,
- 1:03:30you know,
- 1:03:30the effort of saying go out and get these jobs and get these trades,
- 1:03:33etc.
- 1:03:34I think that that is valid,
- 1:03:35but I think that the impediments by leveling up corporations and
- 1:03:39by pouring into the effort of corporations to keep billionaires billionaires,
- 1:03:43as black conservatives,
- 1:03:44you are actually cutting off the ability for those people to excel.
- 1:03:48OK,
- 1:03:48I understand your point,
- 1:03:49but
- 1:03:49A lot of us are more about being self-sufficient.
- 1:03:52So,
- 1:03:53the South,
- 1:03:53a friend of mine down there,
- 1:03:54King Randall,
- 1:03:55has a school for boys.
- 1:03:56He's what,
- 1:03:5722 years old,
- 1:03:58he has a bunch of kids living with him,
- 1:03:59he's teaching them
- 1:04:00physical skills they can do,
- 1:04:01OK.
- 1:04:02Being being a mechanic,
- 1:04:03working on your car,
- 1:04:05working on your house,
- 1:04:06doing things with your hands,
- 1:04:07so you don't gotta worry about corporations.
- 1:04:09You could be your own man,
- 1:04:10you could be your own woman.
- 1:04:11And also,
- 1:04:12didn't you also say earlier that you're against unions,
- 1:04:15but are you for them now.
- 1:04:16Oh,
- 1:04:16so you're you're for unions.
- 1:04:18So And unions keep black folks out,
- 1:04:20you're for that as well,
- 1:04:21because that's traditionally what they've done,
- 1:04:23keep black folks out,
- 1:04:24correct?
- 1:04:24Obviously I am not for that.
- 1:04:26The reality is that unions
- 1:04:28have definitely in the beginning kept black folks out and the
- 1:04:31reason why they were keeping black folks out is because after
- 1:04:34the Civil War,
- 1:04:35when there was reconstruction,
- 1:04:36you had all these black people that had been used with free labor and they had skills,
- 1:04:40right?
- 1:04:40Whether they were a blacksmith or a carpenter or whatever.
- 1:04:43However,
- 1:04:43they could not get jobs because the white people
- 1:04:45who now had to fend for themselves.
- 1:04:48If you will,
- 1:04:48because they didn't have slaves,
- 1:04:50they had to go and learn all these trades.
- 1:04:51And so they actively kept black people out of those jobs.
- 1:04:55And then what they would do is that when they would as a union
- 1:04:58say we're going on strike,
- 1:04:59the black people would be like,
- 1:05:00well,
- 1:05:01we'll work
- 1:05:02because they won't let us in their union anyway.
- 1:05:04And then when they would go and actually get those
- 1:05:06jobs that were that the people were on strike for,
- 1:05:08they would hang them,
- 1:05:09they would lynch them.
- 1:05:10So yes,
- 1:05:10these are real things that have taken place,
- 1:05:12but we keep having these conversations where
- 1:05:14we acknowledge the past when it's convenient
- 1:05:17and then we Only stay in the present when it's convenient.
- 1:05:19So you can't simultaneously say,
- 1:05:21well,
- 1:05:21everybody's fine now and there's no systemic racism at the same time as stating
- 1:05:26that
- 1:05:26there are unions that are racist and unions that aren't racist.
- 1:05:30Ultimately,
- 1:05:31there is racism in the United States,
- 1:05:32it is deeply embedded.
- 1:05:33We have seen it in a myriad of examples even just yesterday or today,
- 1:05:38and black conservatives are working against
- 1:05:41the working class because they are actively placing their vision,
- 1:05:44their ideology of black excellence.
- 1:05:47In economics solely.
- 1:05:49And and in individual economics,
- 1:05:51and I think that's really the big difference of what we're talking about right now.
- 1:05:53You're talking about every man for themselves,
- 1:05:55every man for themselves,
- 1:05:56no,
- 1:05:56I don't say that.
- 1:05:57I say,
- 1:05:58I say that we have to be individualist people,
- 1:06:00as black people,
- 1:06:00but still get all of us
- 1:06:02on the same page.
- 1:06:03My friends at school,
- 1:06:04he's not just looking out for himself,
- 1:06:05he's looking for all these kids as well,
- 1:06:07so it's like,
- 1:06:07OK,
- 1:06:08I bring myself up and then bring everybody else up
- 1:06:11rather than relying upon the corporations and white people to lift this up.
- 1:06:14That's where we come from as black conservatives.
- 1:06:16The difference between relying on
- 1:06:17and acknowledging that there are impediments of,
- 1:06:20and I want to acknowledge the reality that we keep seeming to bump up against,
- 1:06:24which is that everybody has equal ability and they don't.
- 1:06:27Everybody doesn't have the same impediments.
- 1:06:29So for instance,
- 1:06:30I
- 1:06:31grew up with a single parent,
- 1:06:32not because
- 1:06:34I grew up with a single parent,
- 1:06:35not because,
- 1:06:36um,
- 1:06:36my father was some
- 1:06:38deadbeat that didn't have,
- 1:06:39my father has a
- 1:06:40MD from Harvard.
- 1:06:41My father has an MBA from Tufts.
- 1:06:43My dad,
- 1:06:44my dad was a firefighter,
- 1:06:45so.
- 1:06:45Working class conservative.
- 1:06:46He just didn't want to be a parent.
- 1:06:47So when we talk about this whole idea of like,
- 1:06:49oh,
- 1:06:50the blacks that,
- 1:06:51that are,
- 1:06:51you know,
- 1:06:51not doing the thing,
- 1:06:52it's not about
- 1:06:54necessarily whether what class you're in,
- 1:06:55it's literally just about we live in a nation
- 1:06:58that gives the option of,
- 1:07:00I don't want to be a parent,
- 1:07:02we live in a nation that gives the option of,
- 1:07:04I don't need to be in cooperation with our community
- 1:07:07and as far as I'm concerned,
- 1:07:09black conservatives do not address the needs of the working class which
- 1:07:12are fair access to Sources which are equal access to getting jobs,
- 1:07:17which are equal pay
- 1:07:19to the same access as others and we don't
- 1:07:22equal to other states even
- 1:07:23like there's no reality where
- 1:07:26you can say that the same amount of white people
- 1:07:27are working low wage jobs per capita as black people.
- 1:07:30A lot of the reason is because
- 1:07:31there's such a disparate incarceration of black people
- 1:07:34that it impedes their ability to get higher level
- 1:07:38education as well as higher level
- 1:07:39employment because we know about disenfranchisement.
- 1:07:42All right,
- 1:07:43there you go.
- 1:07:47Hi,
- 1:07:48nice to meet you.
- 1:07:49I'm Leila.
- 1:07:50I would actually argue that the black working class is failing themselves.
- 1:07:54Wouldn't you agree that.
- 1:07:56You know,
- 1:07:56in order to get a job,
- 1:07:57in order to qualify for a certain position and and education system at a job,
- 1:08:01wouldn't you argue that it should be based off
- 1:08:03of qualifications and not your race or identity?
- 1:08:06I've never argued that.
- 1:08:07I've never argued that's I know that you were saying
- 1:08:09that you would argue that it should be equal,
- 1:08:12right?
- 1:08:12So you're saying that there should be black Americans
- 1:08:15in education systems in jobs,
- 1:08:17but
- 1:08:17wouldn't you argue that they should be qualified for those positions
- 1:08:20and not just placed there because of their skin color?
- 1:08:22I've never disapproved that.
- 1:08:24OK,
- 1:08:24so
- 1:08:25let's say what DEI.
- 1:08:26Do you know that?
- 1:08:27Well,
- 1:08:27I'm not talking about DEI right now.
- 1:08:28Well,
- 1:08:29because you're suggesting that I suggested that somebody
- 1:08:31should get a job just because they're black,
- 1:08:33and I've never asserted anything like that.
- 1:08:35I mean,
- 1:08:35I understand that you may not say that exactly,
- 1:08:38but a lot of I didn't say that are,
- 1:08:39you know,
- 1:08:40they're pointing to that.
- 1:08:41No,
- 1:08:41it's not pointing to that.
- 1:08:42And so that is that I,
- 1:08:43I need to clear this up because it's a really important point.
- 1:08:46We live in a nation
- 1:08:47that has actively
- 1:08:49pedestaled white people.
- 1:08:51Can we all agree on that,
- 1:08:52that we in the past in the past,
- 1:08:54in the past,
- 1:08:54not currently in the past,
- 1:08:55but not.
- 1:08:55So,
- 1:08:56OK,
- 1:08:56fair,
- 1:08:56fair,
- 1:08:57fair.
- 1:08:57OK,
- 1:08:58so how many black people are part of this administration's cabinet?
- 1:09:01I'm not sure.
- 1:09:02Can you tell me?
- 1:09:02Can you fill me in?
- 1:09:030.
- 1:09:06Who?
- 1:09:06Who?
- 1:09:07So
- 1:09:08it seems like there may be a couple of the cabinet.
- 1:09:10I don't know.
- 1:09:11Scott Turner.
- 1:09:12OK,
- 1:09:13OK,
- 1:09:13so,
- 1:09:13so we got 2.
- 1:09:14So we got,
- 1:09:15we got 2,
- 1:09:15we got 2,
- 1:09:16we got 2.
- 1:09:17So back to your point,
- 1:09:18DEI
- 1:09:19is about expanding,
- 1:09:22not lowering credibility.
- 1:09:24So if we have a
- 1:09:25System
- 1:09:26that has very actively said
- 1:09:28these particular people are the best people simply because of their race,
- 1:09:32DEI said,
- 1:09:33or their gender,
- 1:09:35because DEI
- 1:09:36mostly
- 1:09:37leveled up white women.
- 1:09:39OK,
- 1:09:39so it would be incorrect if it's,
- 1:09:41you know,
- 1:09:42if we're pointing toward
- 1:09:43this,
- 1:09:44you know,
- 1:09:44a majority of race is qualified because of the skin,
- 1:09:47the base of their skin.
- 1:09:48Yeah,
- 1:09:48whether they're white,
- 1:09:49black,
- 1:09:50I mean,
- 1:09:50race is fake.
- 1:09:51Now I do want to touch on a point that
- 1:09:52you did mention earlier that you would argue that.
- 1:09:55You know,
- 1:09:55black people have less opportunities in America.
- 1:09:57I do not agree with that.
- 1:09:58I have not had,
- 1:10:00you know,
- 1:10:00first of all,
- 1:10:01you're a woman
- 1:10:02and so are you,
- 1:10:03and you're doing great.
- 1:10:05Yes,
- 1:10:05and so colorism really does serve us.
- 1:10:07I do want to say,
- 1:10:08why do you think that is though?
- 1:10:10Why do you think that?
- 1:10:10Do you think it's just based off the color of our skin or do
- 1:10:13you think it's based off of the reputation that black people make for themselves?
- 1:10:18What reputation are black people making for themselves?
- 1:10:20What would you argue?
- 1:10:20Because I mean when I look at who makes a reputation for black people,
- 1:10:23let's look at music for example.
- 1:10:25We already had this conversation with somebody else.
- 1:10:26Well,
- 1:10:26we're going to have it again.
- 1:10:27Most of the people that,
- 1:10:28oh,
- 1:10:29are we?
- 1:10:29Most of the people,
- 1:10:30I'm going to shut it down right now and let you know
- 1:10:32that the reality is that when you come to black music,
- 1:10:35for you to say most of the people,
- 1:10:36you've already lost the argument.
- 1:10:37There is no most of the people with black people
- 1:10:39because you haven't heard of all of black music.
- 1:10:42So let's start there of the music that is,
- 1:10:43let's say
- 1:10:44maybe exalted are shown by the media,
- 1:10:47right,
- 1:10:47and it controlsiles,
- 1:10:49it defiles black Americans,
- 1:10:51but who's putting it out there?
- 1:10:52We are black people,
- 1:10:53we're the ones.
- 1:10:55the distribution systems that are putting them out there
- 1:10:56are owned by white peoples who listens to them?
- 1:10:58Because I can,
- 1:10:59I can bet you most of my friends,
- 1:11:00my black friends that are not conservative,
- 1:11:02they listen to that music that defiles their bodies,
- 1:11:04you know that talks about black on black crime and everybody else.
- 1:11:08But if we don't acknowledge that they are not in the same way pursuing white voices,
- 1:11:13talking about the same thing,
- 1:11:14even though they are,
- 1:11:15we simply like to start at the branches of a tree and not at the root.
- 1:11:19We have to understand that the media is king,
- 1:11:21OK?
- 1:11:22Media is king and media does not.
- 1:11:24It does not favor conservatism.
- 1:11:25I can tell you that right now.
- 1:11:27I mean,
- 1:11:27look at the protests right now in Los Angeles.
- 1:11:29Depending on who is in office,
- 1:11:31media does favor them.
- 1:11:32I mean,
- 1:11:32we have Trump in office right now as never is not favoring Trump.
- 1:11:35Media is absolutely not favoring Trump in certain spaces because
- 1:11:40Trump is also not favoring that particular type of media,
- 1:11:43but it depends on the day,
- 1:11:44and we have to acknowledge that regardless of whether you talk conservatism or not,
- 1:11:47media has never favored black people
- 1:11:49at any point.
- 1:11:50All right guys,
- 1:11:50that's time.
- 1:11:51You've been voted out.
- 1:11:52Thank you at any point.
- 1:11:53Thank you.
- 1:12:00I'm back.
- 1:12:03So let's talk about facts.
- 1:12:04I just want to move back to systemic
- 1:12:05racism because you mentioned systemic racism earlier.
- 1:12:07I just want to look at three applications of systemic racism
- 1:12:10against white people and against East Asians as well.
- 1:12:12So for example,
- 1:12:13we have the National College Attainment Network,
- 1:12:15um,
- 1:12:15which defines affirmative action or even
- 1:12:18race conscious admissions
- 1:12:19as taking race as one of the factors in whether or not you're gonna admit a student,
- 1:12:22and we noticed that when race conscious admissions was out of it,
- 1:12:25black enrollment dropped 64%.
- 1:12:27At UC Berkeley,
- 1:12:28and that is an that is an act of systemic racism,
- 1:12:30trying to
- 1:12:31see,
- 1:12:31look at people's races and allow them into colleges whether
- 1:12:33or not they're of a set race is racism,
- 1:12:35and it's race conscious
- 1:12:36and Martin Luther King's most famous quote is that he
- 1:12:39doesn't want his children to be judged based on race,
- 1:12:40but by the content of their character and
- 1:12:42the content of people's characters also includes,
- 1:12:44includes merit.
- 1:12:45We have another example of systemic racism.
- 1:12:47Burgess Owens.
- 1:12:48He's a representative out of Utah.
- 1:12:49He's a black Republican representative.
- 1:12:51He called out.
- 1:12:52The MIT president
- 1:12:53for having black-only dormitories.
- 1:12:55I mean,
- 1:12:55what does that mean?
- 1:12:56Why are we trying to segregate each other and say that black people feel safer
- 1:12:59amongst black people when the truth is they're actually
- 1:13:01more in danger when they're around black people,
- 1:13:03and that's unfortunate.
- 1:13:04It's sad that I'm saying this,
- 1:13:05but it's the case,
- 1:13:05and I have to say it because
- 1:13:06it's true,
- 1:13:07OK?
- 1:13:07Black people are killing each other at a,
- 1:13:09at a vast crazy rate.
- 1:13:10Black men rapping about it.
- 1:13:11It's savagery,
- 1:13:12it's barbaric,
- 1:13:13and people,
- 1:13:14we shouldn't be doing it as a people.
- 1:13:15We should try to get more Ben Carson's.
- 1:13:16Carson's cousins
- 1:13:18were murdered when he was younger,
- 1:13:19but his mother came to him and gave him a
- 1:13:20book and told Ben Carson to read and studied to,
- 1:13:23to not be like his cousins,
- 1:13:24and Ben Carson
- 1:13:26separated two twins at the back of the head,
- 1:13:27and he's known as one of the best
- 1:13:29pronowned neurologists or neuroscientists that we've ever seen,
- 1:13:31right?
- 1:13:32Ben Carson said that slaves were immigrants.
- 1:13:34Well,
- 1:13:35they were,
- 1:13:36but they were brought here to the United States,
- 1:13:37and many of them were slaves,
- 1:13:38and we know that to be a fact.
- 1:13:39What is the difference between someone being
- 1:13:41An immigrant and being a stolen person,
- 1:13:43I mean,
- 1:13:43I understand that many people were stolen here,
- 1:13:45but 90% of historians agree that slavery would have not
- 1:13:47been possible if black slave owners within Africa didn't,
- 1:13:50didn't sell off their people.
- 1:13:51White people didn't show up and just start stealing people.
- 1:13:53They didn't do that.
- 1:13:53That's not how that works,
- 1:13:54literally did that,
- 1:13:55but they didn't.
- 1:13:56They worked with black owners and black,
- 1:13:57the Arabs did the same thing.
- 1:13:59It's funny Arabs did that as well,
- 1:14:00and I think it's very important,
- 1:14:02and I think it's important to note
- 1:14:03that there is an oversimplification.
- 1:14:06Of history as well as of black people in Africa.
- 1:14:10There's a failure to acknowledge that in Africa,
- 1:14:12black people did not consider themselves black people.
- 1:14:14That was a racial distinction that was solely created by white oppressors
- 1:14:18to
- 1:14:18to legitimize slavery.
- 1:14:20Arab oppressors actually,
- 1:14:21because the Arabs did it in the 70th century.
- 1:14:22They were the first ones.
- 1:14:23They did not name it under blackness.
- 1:14:25They simply just decided we're going to go and have enslavers.
- 1:14:27This was a decision
- 1:14:29that was actualized and then tried to be pushed forward through eugenics.
- 1:14:33Literally there.
- 1:14:34An executive order that was passed a few months
- 1:14:36ago that said that Donald Trump wants to now control
- 1:14:39the museums because he wants to take back control
- 1:14:43of the narrative around race and in one of these museums that they cited
- 1:14:47was that there was a display that speaks about race not as a biological thing,
- 1:14:51but as something that has just been created as a social construct,
- 1:14:54and he stated
- 1:14:55that that is an incorrect expression of race,
- 1:14:57that race is biological,
- 1:14:58but it is biological.
- 1:14:59Like,
- 1:14:59let,
- 1:14:59let's look at our phenotypical traits,
- 1:15:01the nose differences,
- 1:15:02the hair.
- 1:15:03Texture,
- 1:15:03it's a,
- 1:15:04it's a biological thing.
- 1:15:05Sure,
- 1:15:05there's a,
- 1:15:06there's a,
- 1:15:06there's a social concept,
- 1:15:07but there's biological differences.
- 1:15:09You're very convicted in your lack of information around these things.
- 1:15:14Race
- 1:15:15and ethnicity are two different things,
- 1:15:16OK.
- 1:15:17Ethnicity is where you're from.
- 1:15:19Race is literally something that was created
- 1:15:21to put people into categories of caste,
- 1:15:24to put people into categories of oppression.
- 1:15:26Race is not something that you are.
- 1:15:28Race is something that was bestowed and put upon you racism,
- 1:15:31not race.
- 1:15:32No,
- 1:15:32race is literally something that was created and put upon you,
- 1:15:35and I want you to listen to me as somebody who has studied this,
- 1:15:38who has a master's in African American studies from the
- 1:15:40Institute for Research in African American Studies at Columbia University.
- 1:15:43I want you to understand very clearly that race is not something that is biological.
- 1:15:48There is literally
- 1:15:49no,
- 1:15:49there is no,
- 1:15:51there is many differences that are equated to ours that has nothing to do with race,
- 1:15:55that has nothing to do with.
- 1:15:56So if you have a black parent and you have a white parent
- 1:15:59and now you come.
- 1:16:00Out looking white.
- 1:16:01How is that a biological proof of your race?
- 1:16:03There's no most of them.
- 1:16:04Stop,
- 1:16:05stop,
- 1:16:05stop.
- 1:16:06There's no most of them.
- 1:16:07You do not have anything to you're mix that race too.
- 1:16:09I am not mixed race.
- 1:16:10My mother is black and my father is black.
- 1:16:12Well,
- 1:16:12my father is also considered black,
- 1:16:14but he's very much,
- 1:16:15uh,
- 1:16:15has a lot of European DNA and,
- 1:16:16you know what I think?
- 1:16:17I think that you are at a phase of your learning where you are a contrarian,
- 1:16:21and I look forward to seeing your development because I have a feeling that you're
- 1:16:25actually going to flip the script eventually because
- 1:16:26you are somebody that definitely is grounded.
- 1:16:29In wanting to learn
- 1:16:30facts and wanting to learn the truths of things,
- 1:16:33however,
- 1:16:33you're currently still stuck in an indoctrinated
- 1:16:35space that is tricking you into thinking
- 1:16:37that you are something that you are not.
- 1:16:39You
- 1:16:39are a black person
- 1:16:41who is literally having to receive the results of racism,
- 1:16:44but ultimately you are of an ethnicity that has thrived in spite of it,
- 1:16:49and that is where we really exist from and that
- 1:16:51is where our resilience comes from in the spite,
- 1:16:54in spite of systemic racism.
- 1:16:56I think our resilience.
- 1:16:57is,
- 1:16:57is happening now,
- 1:16:58I think.
- 1:16:59Growing,
- 1:16:59understanding the real problems,
- 1:17:01not going out and trying to protest against
- 1:17:03you guys don't ever do this.
- 1:17:04Uh,
- 1:17:04KTS you guys don't ever do that.
- 1:17:07KTS is you guys,
- 1:17:08members of the black community that don't
- 1:17:09want to hold accountable people accountable,
- 1:17:11especially black people.
- 1:17:12So KTSJ was shot 60 times outside of
- 1:17:14Cook County,
- 1:17:14Chicago.
- 1:17:15How many BLM members came out?
- 1:17:16You guys,
- 1:17:16you earlier said BLM is about referring to me as you guys.
- 1:17:19OK,
- 1:17:19that's fine.
- 1:17:20So for example,
- 1:17:21we had
- 1:17:22a
- 1:17:22really good example of this where it's not a police because I,
- 1:17:24I remember you said from.
- 1:17:26Where am I from?
- 1:17:26What do you mean by that?
- 1:17:27Like,
- 1:17:27what state am I from?
- 1:17:27Where was I born?
- 1:17:28Where do you live right now?
- 1:17:29Well,
- 1:17:29I live in Florida.
- 1:17:30I was born in Angola though.
- 1:17:32I was born in sub-Saharan Africa.
- 1:17:33OK.
- 1:17:34Where did you grow up for most of your time?
- 1:17:35Um,
- 1:17:36in Maine.
- 1:17:36I,
- 1:17:37I lived in North America,
- 1:17:37Maine,
- 1:17:38yes.
- 1:17:38And what is the population of black people in the town that you're from?
- 1:17:42Uh,
- 1:17:42it's really extremely low,
- 1:17:43but I grew up around black people,
- 1:17:44and there was a black community where I lived.
- 1:17:46And that black community that you lived in,
- 1:17:48did they teach you about black history in the in the United States?
- 1:17:51Like,
- 1:17:51are your parents,
- 1:17:52are your parents black American?
- 1:17:53Yeah,
- 1:17:53my,
- 1:17:54my mom.
- 1:17:54Black.
- 1:17:55My father was black.
- 1:17:55No,
- 1:17:55I'm asking,
- 1:17:56are they,
- 1:17:57were they born in the United States,
- 1:17:58because I wasn't born there.
- 1:17:59Oh,
- 1:17:59so you guys are all from Angola.
- 1:18:01Yes,
- 1:18:01but again,
- 1:18:02I,
- 1:18:02I like I told you earlier,
- 1:18:03right,
- 1:18:04um,
- 1:18:04in terms of
- 1:18:05people like KTSJ,
- 1:18:06they were shot.
- 1:18:07BLM doesn't come out for them,
- 1:18:08and I remember you earlier said,
- 1:18:10hold on,
- 1:18:10can I please finish?
- 1:18:10Can I please finish?
- 1:18:11You earlier said that BLM is worried about police,
- 1:18:13but when Daniel Penny choked out the man that
- 1:18:15we all know was causing violence on that subway,
- 1:18:18uh,
- 1:18:18train,
- 1:18:18or was not causing violence.
- 1:18:19He was,
- 1:18:20he was threatening causing disruption is not causing violence.
- 1:18:22He was threatening people.
- 1:18:23Causing disruption is not causing violence there,
- 1:18:24and the people there helped him also,
- 1:18:26and we know that we helped them.
- 1:18:27I don't know what that has to do with BLM.
- 1:18:28Random people on a train is not Black Lives Matter.
- 1:18:31BLM showed up for that.
- 1:18:33They showed up for what?
- 1:18:33BLM showed up threatening white people,
- 1:18:35saying that they were gonna go get white people.
- 1:18:36Now BLM protested BLM New York.
- 1:18:38BLM protested.
- 1:18:39Where did you get that from?
- 1:18:40You see,
- 1:18:41your,
- 1:18:41your,
- 1:18:41your,
- 1:18:42no,
- 1:18:42your sources are not,
- 1:18:43you're not able to cite your sources.
- 1:18:45Please go sit down.
- 1:18:46Yeah,
- 1:18:46that's the truth.
- 1:18:47It's not the truth.
- 1:18:48It's not the truth.
- 1:18:49It's not that.
- 1:18:49Nothing you say is actually the truth.
- 1:18:52Nothing,
- 1:18:52you're not even American.
- 1:18:54You're not even a black American
- 1:18:56as the daughter of an immigrant,
- 1:18:58it is imperative
- 1:18:59that black people from other places understand the disparate difference
- 1:19:04that they exist
- 1:19:05from black people in the United States.
- 1:19:07It is not
- 1:19:08the same
- 1:19:09period and ultimately the best effort that we can do.
- 1:19:13As a diaspora is to lead in understanding,
- 1:19:17not in judgment.
- 1:19:18So when I am talking to somebody from Sudan,
- 1:19:21from the Congo,
- 1:19:22from Angola,
- 1:19:23I am listening to understand their experience,
- 1:19:25not to undermine it,
- 1:19:26and I refuse to allow anybody
- 1:19:28from Grenada,
- 1:19:29from Angola,
- 1:19:30from any other place to come and try to undermine the experience of black Americans.
- 1:19:35Amanda will now choose someone from the circle to
- 1:19:37debate again based on a claim of their choice.
- 1:19:40Who feels passionately about something that they want to talk to me about?
- 1:19:44I choose John Samuel because I like his facial hair and dashiki pairing.
- 1:19:49I feel like he's going to sing a mean R&B.
- 1:19:53Which one?
- 1:19:54My claim is that black people as a community
- 1:19:57need to walk away from the Democratic Party and progressivism
- 1:20:00completely.
- 1:20:01I'm saying this from a very unique perspective.
- 1:20:03I'm not trying to shot myself or anything
- 1:20:05this is really just my experience.
- 1:20:07Um,
- 1:20:08currently I'm running for Congress,
- 1:20:09right?
- 1:20:10And one of the biggest hurdles I have,
- 1:20:13um,
- 1:20:13in doing that
- 1:20:14is the black community.
- 1:20:16It's because they expect us to be in this box,
- 1:20:20the box would be,
- 1:20:21OK,
- 1:20:22you're,
- 1:20:22you're black,
- 1:20:23so you gotta be a Democrat,
- 1:20:25you gotta think this way.
- 1:20:26You have to have this view on this matter.
- 1:20:28Think what way?
- 1:20:29Like,
- 1:20:29I really wanna understand.
- 1:20:31So let's take immigration.
- 1:20:32That's a,
- 1:20:32that's a hot button issue right now,
- 1:20:34especially in Los Angeles.
- 1:20:36My view is that Yi should.
- 1:20:38Here the legal way
- 1:20:39and that if you don't come here the legal way,
- 1:20:41you are subject to the laws of the country,
- 1:20:44but I also feel that if you're anyone would disagree with that,
- 1:20:47yeah,
- 1:20:47yeah,
- 1:20:48what I'm just saying is that a lot of people,
- 1:20:49especially where I'm from,
- 1:20:50I'm from San Diego,
- 1:20:51would like to put black conservatives in this box.
- 1:20:54And the reason why I say specifically in my claim
- 1:20:57that black people need to walk away from the
- 1:20:59Democratic Party is because every single election cycle,
- 1:21:02all they do is use as their tokens,
- 1:21:04they use us as.
- 1:21:05Their
- 1:21:06kind of election tools.
- 1:21:07They use us as these campaign posters.
- 1:21:10They tell us to come to their rallies,
- 1:21:11they tell us to sing on their stages.
- 1:21:13They tell us to do all these things and they forget about us 3 other years,
- 1:21:16and they remember us 4 years later.
- 1:21:18Every single cycle,
- 1:21:19it happens again and again.
- 1:21:20And I,
- 1:21:21and I'm,
- 1:21:21I'm one of the people like I,
- 1:21:23I really appreciate you because it seems like you have a
- 1:21:25love for the black community and you have a love for,
- 1:21:27uh,
- 1:21:27for people,
- 1:21:28and I appreciate that
- 1:21:29and I do too,
- 1:21:30because I don't express that in the same way,
- 1:21:32uh,
- 1:21:32as let's say as a.
- 1:21:33Black person who's a member of the Democratic Party.
- 1:21:35I get called Uncle Tom.
- 1:21:36I get called coon.
- 1:21:38I get called a racist.
- 1:21:39I hate myself.
- 1:21:40I love myself and I love our people.
- 1:21:43I love everything about us.
- 1:21:44We have done so much for this country.
- 1:21:46We built this table that everyone is seated at.
- 1:21:49We deserve rights.
- 1:21:51We deserve all these things.
- 1:21:52However,
- 1:21:53what I don't like more than that,
- 1:21:54more than anything is being used,
- 1:21:56is being used by politicians,
- 1:21:58being used by governments as some type of puppet.
- 1:22:01To say,
- 1:22:01here's my black person that's voting for me.
- 1:22:04I don't like that,
- 1:22:05and that makes me sad no matter you're Democrat,
- 1:22:06Independent,
- 1:22:07Green Party,
- 1:22:08whatever.
- 1:22:08Yes,
- 1:22:09yeah,
- 1:22:09sorry.
- 1:22:09I completely agree.
- 1:22:11I completely agree.
- 1:22:11I would add to that
- 1:22:13that it's no different with the Conservative Party,
- 1:22:15that there is 100% a use of black people
- 1:22:18to weaponize a concerted effort
- 1:22:22to
- 1:22:23literally quote unquote make America great again.
- 1:22:25The concept of Make America Great Again did not start with Donald Trump.
- 1:22:28It started.
- 1:22:29Started with Ronald Reagan and it happened right after the civil rights movement.
- 1:22:33There was a very strong visceral response by white people
- 1:22:37after the civil rights movement,
- 1:22:38after the Voting Rights Act of 1965,
- 1:22:40the Civil Rights Act of 1964,
- 1:22:42the Housing Fair Housing Act of 1969,
- 1:22:45the Economic Opportunity Act of 1965.
- 1:22:48These were all efforts that were put in place
- 1:22:50on a federal level to say,
- 1:22:51OK,
- 1:22:52fine,
- 1:22:52fine,
- 1:22:53here,
- 1:22:53***,
- 1:22:53damn,
- 1:22:53we're gonna give you a little bit of something to get your weight up.
- 1:22:56After that.
- 1:22:57There was an
- 1:22:58active effort made by conservatives because that's also when we
- 1:23:01saw the flip between the Democratic and Republican parties.
- 1:23:04That is,
- 1:23:05there was a flip.
- 1:23:06That's actively what happened.
- 1:23:07There was a flip.
- 1:23:09And we saw Reconstruction Democrat
- 1:23:10Democratic Party has been the party of slavery,
- 1:23:12the party of racism.
- 1:23:13There was a flip because the Democratic,
- 1:23:15the Democrats were more aligned with making
- 1:23:18the civil rights concessions than the Republicans.
- 1:23:20That's the flip.
- 1:23:21Ultimately though,
- 1:23:22the flip is what people are misappropriating.
- 1:23:25Because
- 1:23:25the flip isn't a 180,
- 1:23:27OK.
- 1:23:28The flip is literally just we was this and now we this,
- 1:23:30and that is not the same as we are for black people.
- 1:23:33The Democratic Party is not for black people,
- 1:23:36nor is the Republican Party.
- 1:23:37Any nation
- 1:23:39that has a bipartisan system that doesn't even allow for its own people to
- 1:23:44determine who are going to be the candidates for president isn't for its people
- 1:23:47in general,
- 1:23:49beyond blackness.
- 1:23:50So it's imperative that we begin to truly understand.
- 1:23:52And the systems that work in this government
- 1:23:55that not only hinder us as black people,
- 1:23:57but they hinder anyone
- 1:23:59who wants to see change because they are ultimately working together.
- 1:24:02Now,
- 1:24:02do we see one party activating
- 1:24:04higher levels of discrimination than others?
- 1:24:07Yes.
- 1:24:07Do we see one party that is more violent per se
- 1:24:11than others?
- 1:24:11Yes,
- 1:24:12and we can say this on many different levels,
- 1:24:14but when it comes to like enacting genocide or destabilizing other nations,
- 1:24:18we know that that happens on an American.
- 1:24:21regardless,
- 1:24:21OK,
- 1:24:22I completely agree
- 1:24:23that
- 1:24:24the idea that you have to act a certain way
- 1:24:27as a black person
- 1:24:28is really problematic because
- 1:24:30the Democrats and the Republicans,
- 1:24:32neither of them actually care about black people.
- 1:24:34And when we talk about conservatism or we talk about being a liberal,
- 1:24:38neither of these aspects were grounded in how do we
- 1:24:42help
- 1:24:43to repair
- 1:24:44the harm that we have caused an entire Group of people
- 1:24:49who made it possible for us to even have a constitution,
- 1:24:53so you can sit here and show me whatever you want.
- 1:24:55No,
- 1:24:55no,
- 1:24:55no.
- 1:24:56The only reason why I was gonna show you this is because you,
- 1:24:58because even with that Constitution,
- 1:24:59we weren't even
- 1:25:00humans
- 1:25:01when they wrote it.
- 1:25:02So that was another fact check I wanted to,
- 1:25:04um,
- 1:25:05kind of fact check before,
- 1:25:06but I couldn't say anything,
- 1:25:07but
- 1:25:07the 3/5 compromise had nothing to do with
- 1:25:10you're 3/5 of a person.
- 1:25:11The 3/5 compromise had to do with representation in Congress.
- 1:25:14So there's a little note here.
- 1:25:15The 3/5 compromise
- 1:25:17said that the Southern slaveholders needed to be represented fairly in Congress,
- 1:25:22and because there were so many more slaves than actual white people in the South,
- 1:25:27they were allowed to count their slaves as representation,
- 1:25:30even though those slaves did not have the ability to vote.
- 1:25:32If,
- 1:25:33if,
- 1:25:33if we were at that time,
- 1:25:34let's say the 3/5 compromise never happened,
- 1:25:37we were a whole person as,
- 1:25:38as in light of the government,
- 1:25:39right?
- 1:25:40If that happened,
- 1:25:41then this America would not be the America.
- 1:25:43That you know today,
- 1:25:44because what it was is if it was,
- 1:25:46we were counted as defending no,
- 1:25:48no,
- 1:25:48no,
- 1:25:48listen,
- 1:25:48can you listen,
- 1:25:49can you listen?
- 1:25:50No,
- 1:25:50listen for a second,
- 1:25:51because I don't want you to get mischaracized what I'm saying,
- 1:25:53OK?
- 1:25:54Slavery was wrong.
- 1:25:55It was absolutely disgusting and immoral thing.
- 1:25:57Um,
- 1:25:58I have nothing
- 1:25:59good to say about that.
- 1:26:00But the 3/5 compromise,
- 1:26:02if you counted a person who was a slave as a whole person at that time,
- 1:26:07most of the slaves were held in the,
- 1:26:08uh,
- 1:26:09south of the Mason-Dixon
- 1:26:10Library.
- 1:26:11So what would happen is they would have more
- 1:26:13representation in Congress and thus those laws that were,
- 1:26:17um,
- 1:26:17you know,
- 1:26:18by the abolitionists,
- 1:26:19those would have been,
- 1:26:20those would have been gone,
- 1:26:21OK.
- 1:26:22So that would have gave the South more power
- 1:26:25to do the things that they couldn't do.
- 1:26:26So that's why they said the 3/5 compromise because then if it's 3/5 compromise,
- 1:26:31they don't get that power.
- 1:26:32But of course they're people,
- 1:26:34so they have to say something and that's where this
- 1:26:36came into play because if it wasn't for that.
- 1:26:38This country would have looked a lot differently.
- 1:26:41So you're suggesting that it was OK for slaves' bodies to not only be used for labor,
- 1:26:46but also used to empower those who are harming them to be,
- 1:26:49to be fairly represented in government.
- 1:26:51I think it's absolutely they should have been used,
- 1:26:53period.
- 1:26:54I think so then we,
- 1:26:55so then we agree on that.
- 1:26:56So we agree on that.
- 1:26:57It was,
- 1:26:57it was absolutely abhorrent.
- 1:26:58There's no excuse for it.
- 1:27:00There's no justification for it.
- 1:27:01Where's the argument?
- 1:27:02Because ultimately when there was an opportunity
- 1:27:05in reconstruction
- 1:27:06for there to be equality.
- 1:27:08And humans considered in a real way and protected.
- 1:27:11Democrats torched it.
- 1:27:13Andrew Johnson,
- 1:27:14yes,
- 1:27:15as well as
- 1:27:16the Supreme Court.
- 1:27:17That's actually more important what we need to,
- 1:27:18we have to acknowledge the Supreme Court torched it.
- 1:27:20The Supreme Court
- 1:27:21has actively throughout this entire existence of this nation
- 1:27:25been at the forefront of impeding any advancement,
- 1:27:28and it ends up sending us back over and over
- 1:27:30and over again because it doesn't have term limits,
- 1:27:33because it is,
- 1:27:33it doesn't have term limits,
- 1:27:35you know,
- 1:27:36it's not,
- 1:27:36it's not.
- 1:27:37Elected,
- 1:27:37it's appointed
- 1:27:38and ultimately they have made it abundantly clear that
- 1:27:42they pick and choose when it's the states that
- 1:27:43are going to have rights and when they're going
- 1:27:45to be in a federal position of of precedence.
- 1:27:47Well,
- 1:27:47that has to do with the supremacy Clause.
- 1:27:49So the supremacy clause is when a federal law is in conflict with the state's law.
- 1:27:53The federal law will override,
- 1:27:54for example,
- 1:27:55in California,
- 1:27:56weed is legal,
- 1:27:56right?
- 1:27:58But,
- 1:27:58federally,
- 1:27:59it's not.
- 1:27:59So they can come down here and they could say,
- 1:28:01hey,
- 1:28:02we're going to raid all these places,
- 1:28:03and they would be a completely in line with the law.
- 1:28:05And so this is how segregation.
- 1:28:06And discrimination ended up existing even after the civil rights laws of the 13th,
- 1:28:1114th,
- 1:28:11and 15th Amendment were passed because Congress said
- 1:28:14we need to protect black people and the
- 1:28:15Supreme Court said we actually are not going to give you the right to do so.
- 1:28:19For what it's worth,
- 1:28:19I think we can do this back and forth all day,
- 1:28:21but at the end of the day,
- 1:28:22I will completely agree with you.
- 1:28:23Black people need to let the Democrats go.
- 1:28:25I think black people need to let
- 1:28:27both of these parties go and figure out a way to move forward together in our own
- 1:28:31nation.
- 1:28:32You know what?
- 1:28:32I can actually get,
- 1:28:33get on with that because,
- 1:28:34you know,
- 1:28:35I don't believe that all.
- 1:28:36Republicans are,
- 1:28:36you know,
- 1:28:37good and not using us as well.
- 1:28:39I agree with that,
- 1:28:39you know,
- 1:28:40I agree with that,
- 1:28:41and I'm for,
- 1:28:42I'm for,
- 1:28:42I'm for no matter what
- 1:28:44color of skin you are or black,
- 1:28:46whatever it is,
- 1:28:47think for yourself.
- 1:28:48If you think for yourself and you do your own
- 1:28:49research and you want to be a liberal radical,
- 1:28:51go for it.
- 1:28:52If you want to think for yourself and be a Green Party,
- 1:28:54go
- 1:28:54for it.
- 1:28:55If you want,
- 1:28:55if you want to be liberal and be Republican,
- 1:28:57then go for it.
- 1:28:58It's OK.
- 1:29:00No,
- 1:29:00I'm down for that.
- 1:29:01Think for ourselves.
- 1:29:02Let's do it.
- 1:29:03Let's do it.
- 1:29:06Appreciate you.
- 1:29:09I appreciate you coming on the show and and
- 1:29:11debating with Amanda.
- 1:29:12I could see that there was a care for the community and there was
- 1:29:15a care for wanting to uplift us rather than treat us like a monolith,
- 1:29:20and that's what I'm all about.
- 1:29:21Regardless if you're a Democrat,
- 1:29:23Green Party,
- 1:29:24Republican,
- 1:29:24like,
- 1:29:25I just think that
- 1:29:26people are far more complex than we give them credit.
- 1:29:29There is an active effort of folks on
- 1:29:31any side of the aisle that want to see the elevation of black people
- 1:29:35to be able to come together and have real conversations
- 1:29:39that are grounded,
- 1:29:40not in stats,
- 1:29:41and this is gonna sound real woo woo,
- 1:29:43but
- 1:29:44it's what it is,
- 1:29:45that are grounded in love.
- 1:29:47And I hope that whatever anyone took away from this conversation
- 1:29:49is the reality that I really do love black people.
- 1:29:52I love people
- 1:29:53and I love the ability
- 1:29:55to exist on this earth
- 1:29:57and have access to joy.
- 1:29:58I think sometimes things got a little bit heated and
- 1:30:00that's OK because emotions get the best of us,
- 1:30:02but I think overall she did pretty well
- 1:30:04for her position.
- 1:30:05I don't agree with her for the most part,
- 1:30:07but I think she did.
- 1:30:08Just kind of seeing this dynamic that this is really what happens a lot of times
- 1:30:11when we look at discourse we look at it online so everybody's typing and typing,
- 1:30:15but this is what real discourse looks like when
- 1:30:17you have to really sit in front of someone
- 1:30:18and unpack your arguments you can see the pressure that that
- 1:30:21causes and how you have to really kind of have your
- 1:30:23thoughts together and how heated and emotional it can get so
- 1:30:26I think the fact that you guys.
- 1:30:27You know,
- 1:30:28created this space for us to be able to do that is awesome.
- 1:30:30Whether it was productive or not,
- 1:30:32we'll only see hopefully some of the things that,
- 1:30:34you know,
- 1:30:34we said stick with Amanda.
- 1:30:36She was using some of my,
- 1:30:37my quotes,
- 1:30:37you know,
- 1:30:38about like resilience and everything,
- 1:30:39and I was like,
- 1:30:39OK,
- 1:30:40so I'm planting a little bit of seeds there.
- 1:30:41And then of course there were times where when she was right,
- 1:30:43she was right and I was like,
- 1:30:44you know what,
- 1:30:45she has a point.
- 1:30:45So I think it's pretty productive if you allow it to be.
- 1:30:49Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:30:51your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:30:54And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:30:56subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.