Latest / Unexplained : True Tales of Unexplained Mysteries with Bestselling Author Steph Young / Guest Dan Mitchell and I discuss Hunted in the Woods - the true story of Heath and David
Transcript
- 0:00There's a lot to unpack with this story. There's so much to it,
- 0:04and unpacking it is the challenge Heath Bullard and David Smith are. We're not
- 0:11in communication with them. They pretty much refuse to have any part of this.
- 0:17So, you know, the most that we have is Heath Bullard statement
- 0:22about what happened up till the time they got to the rest stop. So
- 0:27I'm going to read Heath Bullard statement of what happened on August ninth through the
- 0:31twelfth of nineteen ninety four. Okay, Heath Bullard statement to us. He
- 0:36says, Hi, my name is Heath Bullard, and I went through hell
- 0:39and back within the states of Tennessee and Arkansas. No one believes anything I
- 0:44say about the events of August ninth, tenth, eleventh, and twelfth of
- 0:47nineteen ninety four. Here's my story. Please note that I cannot speak for
- 0:52my friend David Smith, who accompanied me during these events. I must state
- 0:57that David Smith, my friend, did not come back as the same person
- 1:00as before the following events. To date, I have not sat down and
- 1:06discussed the things that happened to us on this fateful trip. I lived in
- 1:11Pennsylvania and in nineteen ninety four, I was an education major at Cuttstown University
- 1:15in Cutsdown, Pennsylvania. I was in my last semester and studied Native American
- 1:22history and had signed up to student teach in Arizona on the Cayanta Indian Reservation.
- 1:27In August nineteen ninety four, my best friend, David Smith, and
- 1:32myself arranged to drive cross country in my vehicle, a Chevy S ten pickup.
- 1:38We thought it would be cool to have a road trip together. While
- 1:42we were wrong, Our intentions were to leave August ninth, nineteen ninety four,
- 1:48and take I eighty one to I forty to Arizona, where I would
- 1:53begin my student teaching. David was going to hang out with me on the
- 1:57reservation, and then we would fly back to Pennsylvania. I'm sorry, let
- 2:02me correct that David would fly back to Pennsylvania. Okay. During this time,
- 2:07I was married and owned a house in Pennsylvania. I was twenty three
- 2:13and had a three point eight grade average. I was not a problem child,
- 2:16nor was David. We were just everyday American kids. We were best
- 2:22of friends and we told each other everything. I trusted him with my life.
- 2:27This is important to know because after what I am about to stay in
- 2:30this paper, we only spoke about maybe fifteen times after the atrocities that happened
- 2:35to us. On August ninth, we left from Pennsylvania and began our trip
- 2:40to Arizona. David and I packed our belongings in plastic bags. I had
- 2:46almost all of my clothes and a computer in those bags so that if it
- 2:51rained, nothing would get wet. The back of my truck was packed with
- 2:54bags. We left later in the afternoon to avoid traffic on I eighty one.
- 3:00We drove straight through, entering Tennessee early morning and getting on I forty.
- 3:07We stopped at a pancake house right before Nashville to get something to eat.
- 3:12The drive from Knoxville to Nashville was awesome. It seemed like we were
- 3:15going down the mountains forever. It was foggy going down the mountains. I
- 3:21was amazed at the tractor trailers just flying past us, as if the fog
- 3:24didn't bother them. It was getting light out and my contact lenses were getting
- 3:29dry, so we pulled into some type of center before Memphis. It was
- 3:34daylight. I put my contact solution in and we took off. I was
- 3:38tired, but we wanted to get into Arkansas before resting. We were nearing
- 3:43Memphis and I started I stated to David we must be getting near Mississippi because
- 3:51there was a stink of rotting plants. As we were driving toward Memphis,
- 3:54a van kept pulling up aside alongside of us and then pulling behind for miles
- 4:00on the interstate. It was a conversion van that was kind of big in
- 4:03the late nineteen eighties and early nineties. The van had tinted windows, but
- 4:09at one point it pulled aside us and with the light with the lighting of
- 4:15the sun, I saw the side window and saw a guy in the back
- 4:18of the van talking on what I believed it was a Cbee radio and pointing
- 4:21at us. I pointed it out to David. David told me to pull
- 4:26into the next rest stop. I pulled into the next rest stop and about
- 4:30eight cars pulled in behind us, but the van did not. I thought,
- 4:34well, that was nothing. We got out of the truck and I
- 4:38noticed a Tennessee Valley Authority white pickup truck pull alongside us. The logo was
- 4:44on the side of the truck. The older white male just kept staring at
- 4:47us. I said to David that this doesn't seem right. As we looked
- 4:51around, we saw many of the cars that followed us into the rest stop.
- 4:57David started to become concerned and I was free out. I stated to
- 5:00David, let's just use the restroom. I went into the men's room and
- 5:04began to use the urinal. I looked to the right of me and noticed
- 5:08that the guy from the Tennessee Valley Authority watching my genital area. As I
- 5:13was relieving myself, I was totally thinking, what the hell, that's wrong,
- 5:17That's just wrong. He was looking at my dick. I said,
- 5:21Dave, we have to get the fuck out of here. That guy was
- 5:25looking at my dick. We went out of the restroom and out of my
- 5:30truck, and we walked to the truck. As we walked to the truck,
- 5:33we noticed six people just staring at us. Dave and I both said,
- 5:38what the fuck? I said to Dave, since I saw the TVA
- 5:42guy looking at me, piss that maybe they think we were drug runners because
- 5:46we are from Pennsylvania and got all those garbage bags in a truck. I
- 5:49thought maybe they were thinking I was dumping drugs. That's why he was watching
- 5:54me piss. Okay, So that's Heath Bullard statement. It's basically a page
- 5:59in a quarter. And you know, we had reached out to him numerous
- 6:05times and he really wasn't interested in telling us anymore after this. This was
- 6:11it. So the only thing we got one more reply after that, and
- 6:17he said that after he got back from there, he spent five days locked
- 6:24inside his bathroom with a gun. When I read that, I thought that
- 6:29he meant he was thinking about killing himself. But actually you said, what
- 6:34was your opinion? My opinion was that he was likely terrified that this cult
- 6:41was going to track him down to his home because you know, there was
- 6:46a lot of issues where you know, they crashed into this field in Henning,
- 6:49Tennessee, and he had I'm sure he had his computer there, he
- 6:54had his wallet, and they are all this personal information, so they very
- 6:57easily could have tracked him down, whoever this group was. And you know,
- 7:00just for the record, we don't necessarily believe this is even a cult,
- 7:04or that this is like a Satanic cult or a which cult or a
- 7:10COVID or anything like that. It's genuinely unknown. But I think that he
- 7:16thought was that at this point, I have just been put in this very
- 7:21traumatic situation, very traumatic events, and I need to hide, and I'm
- 7:29going to hide with a gun. I'm going to lock myself in the bathroom
- 7:30because that's how bad the situation really is. Which makes me ask who would
- 7:36be powerful enough to have the nerve to go to another state and kick someone's
- 7:42door in and not be worried about being caught. Yeah, and it's probably
- 7:46going to be the same kind of people that would have a convoy of twenty
- 7:49to thirty people chasing it down Interstate forty and basically stalking you for three days.
- 7:57And you know, it's to me that whoever this is, they're very
- 8:03They were very organized on this event. You know, it was very well
- 8:07planned. I mean it's pretty pretty high level of organization. I would say.
- 8:13Well, it's also kind of surreal as well, because in his letter
- 8:18he mentioned seeing these tractor trailers floating past him, and the bit we don't
- 8:22really quite understand is where this happened, because his letters talking about him then
- 8:31seeing this fan tailing him and pulling in, and we don't quite know where
- 8:37these tractor trailers came foremost started trailing in. That's yeah, and that's that's
- 8:41what's so strange about it too, because it's, you know, I think
- 8:46that they're right because their their thought was that they were chosen on the interstate
- 8:50because they had out of state license plates, which would make sense. I
- 8:54mean, you're, you're, you're a long way away from home. You
- 8:58don't really have anybody that you can go to, you know, chances are
- 9:03I mean, I can't imagine that they would have had any kind of cell
- 9:05phone. I mean, this was nineteen ninety four. I mean they were
- 9:09around, but you know, two, you know, twenty something year old
- 9:11kids are definitely, you know, probably not going to have that in the
- 9:16vehicle with them. So it's I think it was just a real good target
- 9:20of opportunity. And I think that it's it's almost like this group had this
- 9:26conversion van that was kind of out there scouting people first, and you know,
- 9:31they were they were communicating obviously through Cebe radio. You know, in
- 9:37that time, obviously before cell phones. This is the sort of way that
- 9:41people communicated on Cebe radios, and you know, especially truck drivers. And
- 9:46the fact that you know, he's talking that there were track or trailers involved
- 9:50in this convoy and that they were all communicating that way and kind of organizing
- 9:56corraling these guys to a certain area. I mean, it's a very high
- 10:00level of organization, and it cannot be that this was the first time,
- 10:05whoever these people were, that they did something like this. Well, they
- 10:09were obviously so scared on the highway because when they got boxed in it trying
- 10:13to cross into Texas and they said that a car wouldn't let them enter and
- 10:18they were forced back onto the I forty. So they literally did a full
- 10:24three sixty and turned around and went for about six hours along that highway rather
- 10:28than trying to take any other exits off because they must have been too scared
- 10:31to take any side roads in case they got into more trouble. You know,
- 10:35they felt it was safer to be on the highway. Yeah, they
- 10:37did. And that's devotion too, because if I mean, if you really
- 10:39think about that and driving that long, I mean, this whole thing was
- 10:46like it was a five hundred mile trip. Five hundred mile trip. They
- 10:50got completely turned around on Interstate forty. I mean they were almost into Texas
- 10:54before they got turned around, and that's a long way. I mean,
- 10:58it's a really long drive and it's a lot of devotion on the people following
- 11:03you to travel out that far. And I mean the thing is is that
- 11:07it if there were vehicles involved in this as well, I mean that means
- 11:11people were at some point getting off of the interstate, refueling, getting back
- 11:18on, and the whole time people are in communication and doing this. So
- 11:24it's it's just it seems so far fetched that, you know, when they
- 11:30ran into the sheriff in Prescott, Arkansas, the deputy to them, he
- 11:35said that Heath and David pointed out these cars or trucks or events that he
- 11:39said was following them, and the sheriff said, what ghosts? What ghosts
- 11:43of following you? And then he said they're just local people when they pointed
- 11:48out the cars. Yeah. And that's the thing too, is that one
- 11:50thing that they had also mentioned is that these were the people that were in
- 11:56this convoy had Texas plates, Arkansas plates, and Tennessee plates. Okay,
- 12:01so it could be, you know, it's not necessarily that it was.
- 12:05Whoever this group is is concentrated to where they ran them off the road in
- 12:09and around Henning and Covington, Tennessee. This could be something beyond that,
- 12:15and when you take into account the many disappearances and many strange things that have
- 12:20happened a long eye forty, it really does make you wonder that is there
- 12:24some kind of organized stocking going on and something to look into, which in
- 12:31which we have is a lot of the cases from the nineteen nineties and even
- 12:35late nineteen eighties, and there's there's quite a few of them. Yeah,
- 12:39there's a strange one about a student that went missing from Memphis University, which
- 12:43will cover. There's a young couple that went missing. There's quite a few
- 12:46men that went missing, and we have and right now I know on a
- 12:52nightfall and strange town site. I'm kind of updating things there as well,
- 12:56because there's two missing men and tipped in in Lauderdale County, which is kind
- 13:01of where Heath and David crash landed that are missing right now. In these
- 13:05were cases like one was from June twenty nineteen, the others from August twenty
- 13:11nineteen, and these managers disappeared without a trace. One of them's truck was
- 13:15found in the Mississippi River, which is absolute vanishings. There's another strange one
- 13:20actually from a few years ago, and the search for the man, they
- 13:22came across a grave and inside the grave was buried pigs bodies, which kind
- 13:26of reminded me of the sheep and the pigs. They were kind of rolling
- 13:30in the blood and on the blanket. Even though I was thinking too he
- 13:33lost his contact lenses, okay, but yet he was able to read the
- 13:37mail and to know the address of where he was at. That's really bizarre,
- 13:43and that's one thing that I was thinking to it. He's completely blind
- 13:46where he can't see that it's a cop standing in front of him, yet
- 13:50he can read the address of where he's at, and that that's kind of
- 13:54an anomaly in that story. Why would Heath say he thought it was a
- 14:01DEA when all he had were belongings in the back of his truck. So
- 14:05why would that make you think that the DEA were following you? Well,
- 14:09he's he's thicking it because they're on a major interstate. They have out of
- 14:13state plates, and there's all these plastic bags. So his initial thought as
- 14:20well, who else could it be a religious cult chasing after us? I
- 14:22mean, your first thought's going to be, well, I have undercover cops
- 14:26DEA and they're following us because they think that we're maybe running drugs down the
- 14:31interstate. So that probably the first thought in his mind seeing the van that
- 14:39was kind of scouting them first. And it's kind of a bit nebulous,
- 14:43but we think the tractor trailers were around at that time as well. We
- 14:46just don't know exactly from the newspaper accounts and from his letter. So they
- 14:50pull in to this rest stop, mile marker seventy two restop on I eighty
- 14:58just east of Memphis. Know that it has an actual name aside from you
- 15:03know, just some weird name like Tina Turner, Isaac Hayes something or other.
- 15:09That's that's the weird designations they give to rest stops in Tennessee apparently.
- 15:15And so at this point he phones his lawyer, right, I mean,
- 15:20in the UK, we don't really have lawyers on tap necessarily, but he
- 15:24phones. He must have used a public phone in that time. So he
- 15:26phones his lawyer and tells him what's happening, and the lawyer says, confront
- 15:31them, and he says, you guys are illegally following me, and they
- 15:35kind of laugh at him. They just kind of ask him, well,
- 15:37what are you talking about? So they had they had no idea. And
- 15:41I think one of Heath's statements too just and this would have been just in
- 15:45an email and not in the actual document statement that we have, is that
- 15:50they were pretending to work on a vehicle while they were at this rest stop.
- 15:56So they were they were kind of like looking at everybody, and and
- 16:00you know, they had this one crowd of you know, between six to
- 16:02ten people kind of trailing them into this rest stop and kind of walking around
- 16:07watching them. And he kind of perceived right away, well, you know,
- 16:10these guys must be they must be watching me. And it's interesting because
- 16:15he said that the actual van that was initially following them didn't pull into that
- 16:18restaurant. It did not set eight cars pull in. The van doesn't,
- 16:22but then attemps value authority van pulls in instead, right, And from the
- 16:26sounds of what he was writing about this TVA van in his statement was that
- 16:34the older gentleman in this van, and maybe this is just what I took
- 16:38from it, is the one that was kind of almost seemed to be the
- 16:44real intimidator for him. He had a real I think he was real spooked
- 16:49by this guy. And I think it was the same thing for David.
- 16:52Whoever this guy was who was kind of watching him at the urinal apparently had
- 16:59you know, some kind of you know it just he invoked this fear in
- 17:04both of them. That's that's what I got out of that statement. But
- 17:07it's kind of weird because so he watched him when he was at the Urnyl,
- 17:11but he took from this to me and he was saying, if I
- 17:15was on drugs, but you can't see if someone's on drugs by watching them
- 17:18at a urrhino, can you. You can't can And it's a weird I
- 17:21mean, and it's a really weird thought that he would have had that too,
- 17:25that you know, yeah, he was checking for drugs while he's taking
- 17:30a piss. It just seems really, it just seems really bizarre way to
- 17:33think of things. And what I get from that is there's more of an
- 17:38underlying tone that it was some kind of weirdly uncomfortably sexual exactly. And that's
- 17:44sort of what I took from that as well, is that and I think
- 17:48that that's what really spooked both of them, because I as much as I
- 17:52think that they first believed that these were dea people that were following them along
- 17:59in State forty. I think that once they got to that rest stop,
- 18:03I really believe that the mood of that sort of changed. And I think
- 18:07that had also changed when you know, he talked to them after getting off
- 18:11the phone with his lawyer, which is weird in itself because at twenty three
- 18:17year old with a lawyer on call seems really I don't know, it seems
- 18:22a little strange to me, I guess, and that was they're not and
- 18:26that was I mean, it could be a family acquaintance as well, and
- 18:30I you know, I thought of that as I thought of that too.
- 18:33But I think after that, you know, after he confronted this group of
- 18:38guys sort of working or looking at this vehicle at the rest stop, I
- 18:44think that's when the tone changed immediately. I think that they I think that
- 18:48they knew at that point this was not DA, that there was something much
- 18:53more frightening about these people. And you're right, I really do believe,
- 18:59and I hate to use the term, but this had I think that this
- 19:03sort of communicated a real deliverance sort of feel to these guys, and that's
- 19:08why they got you know, they got out of there as quickly as they
- 19:11could, and they continued heading west on I forty. So now is where
- 19:18things get strange. It's it's you know, they finally get in their vehicle,
- 19:21they leave, and they're still being followed onto I forty by this group
- 19:26of people that they encountered at the rest stop. Obviously. Well, to
- 19:30be honest, we were tall me about calling this podcast to detective or deliverance,
- 19:34because it's always reminded us of both. Yeah, And in fact,
- 19:37the lawyer that I spoke to who represented David actually said to me on the
- 19:41phone, have you seen the TV show True Detective? And he actually had
- 19:45that vibe about the whole thing as well. Okay, so they drive on
- 19:49to Prescott, Arkansas, and they must have actually gone into the sheriff's office
- 19:53there because the newspaper reports say that they followed up after the story and the
- 19:59shrift in them being in the office. So again they're feeling uncomfortable because they
- 20:03say that there are all these vehicles that have pulled in to Prescott with them.
- 20:07The sheriff says to them, show me the ghosts of following you and
- 20:11then says these are local people. So then they carry on again on the
- 20:15ifot get to Texas and they're boxed in, they say, by tractor trailers
- 20:18and one car that prevents them from leaving to cross over into the state,
- 20:22and they're forced back exactly the same way they came. And then they say
- 20:26that they stop on the highway itself and they pop the berm or pop the
- 20:30hood and pretend that they've got car trouble, and a highway trooper comes along
- 20:34and literally laughs at them and says, I can't help you and drives off,
- 20:40which which seems really strange as well, because you know, if you're
- 20:44you're a highway patrolman or a sheriff's deputy and somebody starts saying that, usually
- 20:48you're going to investigate it a little bit further, you know, asking for
- 20:52IDs, and you know, asking are you okay if you used any drugs?
- 20:56And in both cases were where they had encountered law enforcement in Arkansas,
- 21:03both cases, they laughed them off both cases. And what's interesting about that
- 21:11too, is that it really does make you understand why Heath and David believed
- 21:17that the law enforcement was involved. And I don't deny that for a second
- 21:21that there was maybe some kind of knowing. It's just we have not been
- 21:25able to furnish any proof of that as of yet. Well. In fact,
- 21:30Sheriff Yoakum, who was the sheriff of the actual area where they run
- 21:33off when they go into the field, said just tell them that it's ten
- 21:37bucks a day to get their car back, and laughed again. So it's
- 21:41just really kind of strange that they were laughed at all the time, because
- 21:44it's not normal. It's not the normal reaction to be laughed at by the
- 21:48cops every time you stop and talk to them. No, it really isn't.
- 21:52And that's why I'm saying, is that it was. It's really easy
- 21:55to dismiss this when you read this, when you read this story in the
- 22:00newspapers and in the morning call. It's because the police just dismiss it so
- 22:06outright. They're just, you know, they make a mockery of it at
- 22:11every step. You can call it a mystery of aptin, an enigma.
- 22:15But he was laughing all the time, he said it. Yeah, And
- 22:18that's the thing. And it just seems that the attitude that they had in
- 22:22the face of all of this. And you know, if somebody today and
- 22:29I guess, and I can't speak for the mid nineteen nineties how the police
- 22:33would have looked at this, But I don't think it would be that much
- 22:36different that if you have somebody saying things it's on like paranoid delusions, you're
- 22:41going to investigate that a little further rather than just saying, Okay, you
- 22:44can go back to wherever it is you came from. On this major US
- 22:48interstate, it makes no sense. One of the newspaper Oscars actually said of
- 22:52the story that they get the award for being the most bizarre story of nineteen
- 22:56ninety four. It's very very easy. There are some very comical elements to
- 23:02this story, so it's very hard to take a lot of it entirely seriously
- 23:06in some respects, but you would be most likely writ in thinking that these
- 23:08boys were on drugs or they had been drinking as they were driving. But
- 23:12well, as David later gets taken to a hospital after his ordeal, he
- 23:17is drug tested and he has no drugs or alcohol in his body. So
- 23:21we know that David said after his experiences that he did used to have a
- 23:26drinking problem, but he had not drunk for several years prior to this trip,
- 23:30So we know that neither of them took drink or drugs. I believe
- 23:32it was. He said that he had been taking caffeine pills. They had
- 23:36driven through the night, so they set off late afternoon, drove through the
- 23:38night, and arrived in the early morning. Yes, so they were very
- 23:42tired, but they didn't have a history of mental problems correct to have made
- 23:48this story up. And in fact, as we progress through the story,
- 23:52they really had nothing to gain by making this story up, because they in
- 23:55fact went to the newspapers about it because they were worried that if this could
- 23:59happen to them, up into others, these people could end up going missing,
- 24:03and that's why they were so willing to be interviewed. But for David
- 24:06to be sectioned into a mental health unit on his return and his family to
- 24:11be dragged into this, they had nothing to gain by making this story up,
- 24:15and certainly if they had made it up, they could have backtracked and
- 24:18withdrawn from it. The only thing we're not going to say that this was
- 24:23a satanic cult or a witch cult or anything of that nature, because there's
- 24:30no proof that that that's the case. One thing I would say is that
- 24:36those Morning Call articles may well have saved both of them in some way,
- 24:41because the only thing that I'm willing to agree one hundred percent on with this
- 24:48story is that the people in that convoy were very dangerous, and that plays
- 24:53out as they re enter Tennessee after being turned around in Arkan. So they
- 25:00drove clean across the state of Arkansas again headed east and back into Tennessee.
- 25:07So that's you know, almost five hundred miles, so actually maybe over five
- 25:15hundred miles. And to me, the part in where they're in Tennessee in
- 25:22this and I'll kind of explain why I feel this way that Tennessee, for
- 25:27whatever reason, especially near Henning and Covington, seems to be almost the home
- 25:34base of whoever this group was. I think that it was probably around this
- 25:38area where you know, these guys first saw Heath and David's pickup truck.
- 25:45And I think that it was a big, you know, a big organized,
- 25:48concerted effort to get them back there. And it just as outrageous as
- 25:53that sounds, I mean, that is what all the evidence points to,
- 25:57is that they were chased, re routed back to where they came from for
- 26:03five hundred miles, toyed with on the interstate and all really, you know,
- 26:07late into the night and they are entering again back into Tennessee where they're
- 26:14starting to run out of gas. Well, we have uncovered a few interesting
- 26:18characters, haven't we in that area? We really have. And of course
- 26:22the Morning Call when they reported on it, did say this comes hot on
- 26:26the heels of the West Memphis three case, which really is not that far
- 26:30from where they first run into trouble. Not to say that there's any relation
- 26:34to it at all, but it's also interesting that there could be a lot
- 26:37going on in that area itself, which is what we're looking into. And
- 26:41it's funny because it's you know, you can say and it is rumor and
- 26:45I think around you know, the time of the West Memphis three when all
- 26:48that was going on, it was rumors of weird little cults and everything in
- 26:53that area. So it's you know, I don't know that it's related,
- 26:57and it's something that we've looked into, but it's sure is a very big
- 27:03coincidence that you know, it's it's Covington in West Memphis are as close together
- 27:08as they are, Yeah, exactly, And we know that West Memphis three
- 27:12is extremely controversial and really it's a fifty to fifty. Yeah, really,
- 27:18we understand that. But going through a lot of the documents in that case,
- 27:22it is interesting to know that there's a witness, for example, who
- 27:26talks about a cult who lived on the other side of Covington. So Memphis
- 27:30is sort of south of it Covington, So it sounds like they're a lot
- 27:34further apart than they are because in fact, they're only about forty minutes away.
- 27:38Yeah, it is, it's close, and that's why I'm saying it's
- 27:41a very it's a very strange coincidence. I don't put anything on it at
- 27:45this point, and it's just something that has to be investigated further. And
- 27:52I think the biggest the biggest thing to me is that this dangerous group of
- 27:57individuals exists. They maybe behind many, many, numerous missing cases, missing
- 28:03persons cases, and many of which are in that area even to this day.
- 28:08But don't forget the other thing that he said in his email to you
- 28:12when he was reluctant to send you any more information other than that one page
- 28:15document, was he was so reluctant it was taking us weeks, wasn't it
- 28:19to get any kind of response? And one of the replies he sent you
- 28:23was saying to you, listen, man, you're one of them, are
- 28:27Yeah, he kind of thought that I was one of them, because it
- 28:30was it was getting very difficult to communicate with him and get responses from him
- 28:36after many, many, many weeks of trying highly suspicious, but he was
- 28:41implication there is that. Twenty five years later, he's still very fearful,
- 28:45but he also still thinks this group exists. He does, and I would
- 28:51assume, and I wouldn't even have to assume that David Smith also is of
- 28:56that opinion. And clearly this was very traumatic event for both of them,
- 29:03to the point where you know, and I completely understand that they don't want
- 29:07to discuss it. They don't want to go any further into it or have
- 29:11to re rehash that because it was a very Yeah, it was devastating,
- 29:17and to go home to people mocking you and not believing you is I can't
- 29:22even imagine, and that that for me would probably be the most difficult part
- 29:26of it, because you know what you saw, you know what you had
- 29:30been through, and as traumatic as it was, and you know it would
- 29:36have a lot of negative effects in both of these men's lives for many,
- 29:41many years. To come. At least that's what I was told by Heath,
- 29:44So you know, it's it's rough. If he's saying now he's recalling
- 29:51it, it's very strange that it could be a made up story. If
- 29:55you're still willing to say that it happened twenty five years later, you know,
- 29:57you've got a family and you're still fearful of it, or I thought
- 30:00you were not replied or just said that's just nonsense that was put in the
- 30:04paper. Yeah, exactly. And when they get into and that's it,
- 30:10I'll say too, is that the reason for this level of trauma is because
- 30:15of what happened as they got toward I believe it's Highway fifty one in Tennessee.
- 30:25When they crossed back into Tennessee. They were running out of gas from
- 30:30being on the run pretty much late afternoon into the evening. So they're driving
- 30:36and they're no longer on Interstate forty. They're on a small probably like a
- 30:40county highway, and they're running out of gas looking for a gas station,
- 30:47and they end up out in rural Hending, Tennessee, where they get run
- 30:52off of the road. And that's where details get really strange, because the
- 31:00rolled that they're on where they were being followed by this large convoy. I
- 31:04mean, obviously they're off the interstate now. Well, the interesting thing is
- 31:10that Keith says in his letter that there's no mention of these tractor trailers and
- 31:15convoy at this point, so we don't know if the convoy was still with
- 31:18them. But he said his opinion was that he believed they were unmarked police
- 31:25cars, two of them, two of that. So his version is that
- 31:27they were chased into this field by two unmarked cars that he thought looked like
- 31:33cop cars. They got stuck in the mud, so they basically just got
- 31:36out of the truck and they fled, leaving all their belongings behind. So
- 31:40we don't know where the convoy was at this point, but they caught up
- 31:44with them immediately once they were in the woods, so that both the boys
- 31:47run off into the woods. Heath can't swim, so he can't go into
- 31:51the water. David just jumps in the water and there their separation begins.
- 32:01They got stuck in the mud, so they basically just got out of the
- 32:05truck and they fled, leaving all their belongings behind. So we don't know
- 32:08where the convoy was at this point, but they caught up with them immediately
- 32:13once they were in the woods, so that both the boys run off into
- 32:15the woods. Heath can't swim, so he can't go into the water.
- 32:20David just jumps in the water and there their separation begins. That was That's
- 32:25the strange thing too, because it's and it's one of those unanswered questions to
- 32:30the story in general, is that you have they're chased off the road by
- 32:35two vehicles, but yet when they make a run for it, and from
- 32:38the point where they crashed the vehicle till the it's basically a swamp I think
- 32:45they call it the bottoms, and it's right along the Hatchie River. It's
- 32:49about a one mile run, so I mean, these guys get out of
- 32:52their vehicle, they run a mile. But by the time they're out there
- 32:57in along the swamps in the next to the actually river, this group of
- 33:00people seem to already be there. Yeah, they're already inside of this area
- 33:07and they're stocking them. Because Heath manages to get out of there the next
- 33:12day, but David's there from the ninth until he is put into hospital on
- 33:16the twelfth, so he's in there for three nights, and during that time,
- 33:22these people are constantly there in the woods. If you look at what
- 33:25he described his experience to the newspaper, if you look at the breakdown,
- 33:30they're pretty much there constantly, which is really strange. So heath He says
- 33:36that he spent the night in the woods and he hid, and then the
- 33:40next morning his words were, he walked for miles and miles and miles,
- 33:45and he gets to a farm where a woman comes to the door and she
- 33:50allows him to shower and change clothes. He calls his grandfather. The grandfather
- 33:53wires Western Union money to the woman. She drives and goes and picks the
- 33:59money up, and then she asks her friends to drive him to the airport.
- 34:02So he gets back to Pennsylvania, and then he hides for five nights
- 34:06in the bathroom with a gun. But David is it looks like in the
- 34:09swamp for three nights. So on the first night he hides in the water
- 34:14under the brush, and he said that he had been shot at with paint
- 34:17pellets. Now, interestingly, the lawyer, mister Lossak that we spoke to,
- 34:22confirmed that when David was taken to hospital, the nurse records say that
- 34:28he had paint marks on his body. So David says that he's been shot
- 34:31at with paint pellets. He's hearing bird calls communicating with each other, so
- 34:37the people have followed them into the woods, into the swamp and are kind
- 34:40of trying to round him up by communicating with each other. Then the next
- 34:45morning, David says, so he's spent the whole night in the water.
- 34:47Basically, in the next morning, he said, he gets out of the
- 34:51water and they start shooting at him again. So basically, these people stayed
- 34:53there and they never left, right, They stayed in there hunting or waiting
- 34:59for him. And that's yeah, and that's what what it what it reads
- 35:04like as well, because he gives a pretty solid, uh description of events,
- 35:10and I mean there are a lot of other things that happened in there
- 35:14as well, because I mean even at at one point, I think this
- 35:16was the second night or the second day that he was there, he encounters
- 35:22a a father with his son, and you know, he has his son
- 35:29point a rifle at David and wants the son to shoot him. Now,
- 35:32whether this was a real rifle, whether it was a paint rifle, whether
- 35:37it was a BB gun. I mean, nobody knows, but I mean
- 35:39one thing is certain is that whoever these people were in those swamps along the
- 35:45Hatchie were stalking him pure terror. And it's also that they're playing with him
- 35:51because obviously they know this well. I'm presuming they they the swamps in the
- 35:54woods better than he does. That morning, so he spent the first night
- 35:58in the water, and it's next morning. He says that he runs for
- 36:00about two miles, finds another swamp, goes in. There's still people shooting
- 36:06paint pellets at him. He said he saw about ten different people running through
- 36:08the woods. He gets back in the water in the swamp, hides again,
- 36:13then he's out, Then he's running again, then he's chased, then
- 36:15he's circled using bird calls, and then he says about this man and the
- 36:19little boy, and the little boy refuses to shoot him and starts crying.
- 36:23Then he says that he runs off the man. The boy's father shoots at
- 36:28him, and he gets back in the water. And now he grabs two
- 36:31logs, put one either side of his head and floats down it. And
- 36:35then a man in a motor boat offers to help and Again, we're not
- 36:37saying that there's any time with the West Memphith three, but it is interesting
- 36:40to note that there is a peripheral figure in the West Memphith three case where
- 36:45he was goading one boy to attack another one with a knife. And there
- 36:49was also a witness statement of a man who is in prison who mentions using
- 36:54a motor boat to travel these rivers. So again I'm not saying that they're
- 36:58connected, but it's just you can see kind of how these things overlap in
- 37:02some respects. Sometimes, yeah, they do, they clearly do. Anyway,
- 37:07So the logs get caught that he's floating down the river rawn and then
- 37:12he says he goes back on land. He spends another night hiding under the
- 37:15brush. The next morning he jumps in the creek again nearly drowns, and
- 37:19the people who were chasing him they use a tree branch and they pull him
- 37:22out with a tree branch. And here he says that they were playing with
- 37:25him. So again it's like at some points they just let him do what
- 37:30he was doing. They just kind of let him, Well, you can
- 37:32sleep there for the night. We'll be back, you know, and we'll
- 37:36get you in the morning, they were quite relaxed about knowing that they were
- 37:38confident they could get him. Yeah, exactly. You know, it's funny
- 37:43because it almost comes off like the story The Most Dangerous Game, where you
- 37:50have people that are hunting humans out in some isolated spot and it's going,
- 38:00But this is worse. I mean, this is not just straight up hunting
- 38:04a human being or an animal. I mean they're just toying with the person
- 38:08and you know, evoking as much terror as they can in this guy.
- 38:14Yeah, because I've said to you, haven't I why did they use paint
- 38:15pellets? Whyouldn't they just shoot him? And he said, well, it's
- 38:19they really just wanted to scare him constantly, just to prevoct terror. Yeah,
- 38:22And it makes you wonder how many other times this has happened to people
- 38:29where it's it's the same thing out around that Hatchie River and the kind of
- 38:32things that go on over there, because an organized group that seemed to really
- 38:37know their way around that area and to kind of know where he is at
- 38:45every moment, and it's it's it's kind of a because at that point when
- 38:51they put him out by the tree branch, David says to the newspaper that
- 38:54he thinks they laid him down on the bank and he went to sleep or
- 38:58he passed out, so they just leave him there to go to sleep for
- 39:01a while. You know, they're so relaxed knowing that they can get him.
- 39:05Yeah, exactly, And I think that. And I'm not sure exactly
- 39:08when this happened, but the strangest part of this chase between this group and
- 39:15David kind of ends in this this ritual blood sacrifice where all of a sudden,
- 39:22there's this large woolen blanket and this group of people kind of encircles David
- 39:30while they sacrifice animals on the blanket and roll around in the animal blood.
- 39:38And I can only imagine they must be in some kind of a frenzy at
- 39:43this point. And you know, it almost comes off as a strange kind
- 39:49of initiation going on here. And I don't know if it was, you
- 39:53know, with the kids having a father telling his son to shoot this guy
- 39:58in the swamp and the animal sacrifice. I mean, it sounds so completely
- 40:04outlandish to anybody, To any casual observer looking at this story and reading it,
- 40:09they're going to just say, well, you know, the guy's exhausted,
- 40:14he has, uh, yeah, he doesn't have his contact lenses.
- 40:20I mean at this point, he even sees three decapitated heads, human heads
- 40:24sitting in a tree or hanging from a tree. And it almost kind of
- 40:30gives you this sort of voodoo ish kind of feeling to it because it's you
- 40:37know, rolling around and blood in a frenzy, human heads hanging from a
- 40:40tree. It's very you know, very primal, almost love crafty in in
- 40:45a way, and you know it's it's not something that you're going to hear
- 40:53a lot of in reality. I mean a lot of this gets into you
- 40:59know, the whole Satanic panic. This is the kind of things you know,
- 41:01these super sensationalized stories from the eighties where you know, mothers were offering
- 41:08their babies up in sacrifice, or they were skinning babies alive. These just
- 41:14outlandish stories that you know are very likely not true, and that's what this
- 41:22kind of plays into. It sort of plays into that mythology in a way,
- 41:27and it's very it's just it just really walks the line of fiction and
- 41:35reality. Because when we talk to the lawyer, I mean he had seen
- 41:40David's tattered clothes and that there were paintball stains on it. So I mean,
- 41:49without a doubt he was being shot at in those swamps, so that
- 41:52you know, that's already been established. And the wounds like, because when
- 41:55you get hit with those things, I mean it's it's there's enough to leave
- 42:00a welt on you. So I mean every time he was getting hit,
- 42:02it was leaving a rash, and there was residue of paint inside of those
- 42:07rashes. That much has already been been verified. And you know that's established
- 42:14as facts in this whole case. And do you remember in the newspaper it
- 42:17said that when he got to the hospital, one of the nurses there said
- 42:22to him that they sacrificed members of their own family. But why would she
- 42:27say something like that, right? And that's that's the other thing too,
- 42:30is that. And it's the same thing with the nurse that said that,
- 42:34And it's also with the same woman that helped Heath get out of town right
- 42:38away, is that she hid him in the house. Yeah. So most
- 42:43people, if somebody's running around saying people are after them, your first thing
- 42:47would be to think, I'm going to call the cops, get the cops
- 42:50here. Yes, but she did the opposite she hit him and smuggled him
- 42:54out to get out of the state. It's like she knew something was going
- 42:58on. She did, we may know who this is, right, Yeah.
- 43:02And that's the thing too, is that it's it's one of it's it's
- 43:07really bizarre because that is your first inclination is you're going to call the police,
- 43:12You're going to get them help. But yeah, she does exactly the
- 43:15opposite, which to me when I first read the story, indicated to me
- 43:19right away, Okay, there's something weird in Covington. There's something very strange
- 43:23in Covington, Tennessee, because people are not doing what normal people do.
- 43:29Like, you have somebody that's raving in front of your house, you're going
- 43:31to call the police. She brings him into the house, gives him a
- 43:37shower, gives him clothes, gives him something to eat and I'm talking about
- 43:40heath here, and basically sneaks him to the airport. And then the same
- 43:47woman goes to the hospital where Dave has been taken. He leaves it for
- 43:52as well. It's the same woman. Yep. So she helped both of
- 43:57them get out of Yeah, both of them get out of Covington and get
- 44:00them back home. Well, you just wouldn't do that. You wouldn't,
- 44:04because he says that he ripped the ivy out of his arm. She came
- 44:07and collected him and they telled it. That's the exact opposite to what most
- 44:12people would do. Most people would say, you're a complete stranger. I
- 44:15know you need help, so you'd be better off in the hospital and with
- 44:17the police coming to see you, right, And she, instead of doing
- 44:22that, almost seemed to understand and realize that there was some kind of an
- 44:28element out there that was a very serious threat to them, which made her
- 44:31not call the police. So, you know, I wonder how much you
- 44:37know, both of these guys knew or were told from this particular individual who
- 44:44got them out of there that led them to believe that this was a cult
- 44:47and that there were police involved, because clearly the town, I mean,
- 44:52this woman did not she didn't call the police, So to me, that
- 44:58indicates that she has knowing of something. And there's way more to this story
- 45:04than a couple guys that are mentally exhausted, starving and basically hallucinating. I
- 45:13just I don't believe that. I never believe that, even from the first
- 45:16time I read this story. And I mean when we say cult, but
- 45:21we might say colt. But it's also basically a group. So we're looking
- 45:24into whether it could be a group of people that go hunting together who have
- 45:29this kind of weird interest in doing things like this. So it's not necessarily,
- 45:32like you said, some kind of satanic thing. But it may be
- 45:35that there's a weird family there that have been doing this for generations and it's
- 45:39just grown into something that's normal to them, right, And that's that's sort
- 45:45of where I'm where I lean and where i've I've I've been on this since
- 45:49the beginning. I don't I don't think that this is, you know,
- 45:54a Satanic cult per se. I think it's more along the lines that,
- 45:59yes, this is some kind of a family that very large lives out in
- 46:04that area. It's it's spread out, and this is something that for whatever
- 46:07reason, that they're into and that they do. And I mean I guess
- 46:10in that I guess in that regard. I mean, technically you could call
- 46:15it a cult by the truest meaning of that word, but I don't think
- 46:20that it's necessarily a cult based on any you know, sort of religion or
- 46:27philosophy or anything of that nature. To me, it just sounds like these
- 46:31are very criminal people, very degenerate people that are probably into just weird things,
- 46:39yeah, like kind of being statistic and taunting somebody or you know,
- 46:44getting a kind of thrill out of how you play with people, right.
- 46:46And I mean, the other thing too, to keep in mind is that
- 46:50the people that were chasing them were it was black people, white people,
- 46:54men, women, children, it was it was no specific group of people
- 47:00going after them. And you know, the one thing that's that's kind of
- 47:04important and plays into this as well is the fact that when David had escaped
- 47:09this group, that for the last time and he was finally escaped, because
- 47:15you know, we don't know if he was captured two times and let go
- 47:17three times in like, oh, we don't know all the details of this.
- 47:21And we also don't know exactly what happened to him, because something so
- 47:24bad happened that he had to go to a mental hospital and all he kept
- 47:29saying was I'm going to kill myself. When they extradited him back, he
- 47:32just kept saying, I will kill myself rather than go back there. And
- 47:36he was hitting his head against walls trying to cope with it mentally and having
- 47:40priests visit him. So, whatever it was, we don't know what happened
- 47:45in the swamp, but something happened well we and we know that that it's
- 47:50probably much worse than what the Morning Call had reported. We have some ideas
- 47:54on what we believe likely happened to David when he was out there, and
- 47:59it is much more than just what the reports were saying. And there's a
- 48:07real strange element to this because this group of people, as they were chasing
- 48:10David, David noticed that they had some strange insignias that they were wearing on
- 48:16on their clothes, and one was the letter A with a circle around it
- 48:22and then beneath that it was kind of like the likeness of a witch.
- 48:29And some of the people in this group were apparently wearing this symbol, whatever
- 48:34it was. And he also said, which is really strange, that at
- 48:37one point when he was running, he got to a church, didn't he
- 48:40and the church had lighted poles outside and he said, the same emblem was
- 48:46on these poles. Yes, Yes, we hid out in the church for
- 48:50a while. Yes, and we've re exiled rain something we for a long
- 48:52time trying to work out this insignia, which could be. At one point
- 48:55we said it could be literally the A for the air symbol which is used
- 49:00in witchcraft or spellcasting as the element of air. Or it could be as
- 49:05simple as being a company logo that they were wearing, sure right, or
- 49:08the Tennessee Valley Authority logo which has an A on it and which under the
- 49:15right circumstances, it's pretty scary look. And if you're on the receiving pastiness,
- 49:21it's a black and white logo. And if you just look at it
- 49:23with the knowledge of this story, you can see crescent moons, you can
- 49:27see what looks like a witch's cradle, you can see what could be like
- 49:30a burning man wicker symbol. We're looking at it knowing the story, but
- 49:35also for David looking at it maybe in the twilight, and he's absolutely terrified.
- 49:40It actually does look quite sinister. Yeah, but you know, again,
- 49:44it could be entirely unrelated. We don't know. Very true, very
- 49:47true. And the thing is is that we've pretty much located the church that
- 49:52he is claiming that had these posts and everything on it, So I mean
- 49:58that has been located, but it's it's just what the media had said it
- 50:06was. It's a it's a predominantly black church. That seems pretty normal,
- 50:10pretty run of the mill for any church in that area of Tennessee. So
- 50:15there's a lot of questions with that. And you know, one thing to
- 50:19keep in mind is that this church is about a mile away from where Heath
- 50:24broke into the house to call his fiance. Well Sheriff Yeacum confirmed that there
- 50:31was a church there and he said it was, in his ways, predominantly
- 50:36a black congregation. But also interesting was he said colts. Well, there's
- 50:40been a little talk of colts, you know, here and there, which
- 50:45is a weird thing to say, really because you would probably would have just
- 50:46said, well, that's ridiculous, although he of course was laughing at the
- 50:50story at the whole time. He also confirmed in his opinion that the only
- 50:53vehicle that got into that field was Heath and David's vehicle, and he said,
- 50:58well, there were no other tracks in the field. It was not
- 51:00even possible to get a truck in there. When it came to the newspapers
- 51:06trying to investigate the story twenty five years ago, they were really getting the
- 51:08run around because they went to all the different jurisdictions, because really across several
- 51:14counties, so there were several sheriffs involved, but each one at that time
- 51:19was saying, well, the other one's investigating it, and then the office
- 51:22for the FBI was saying, well, actually, eventually they said, well,
- 51:24no, it's going to be the local Tipton County the criminal investigator,
- 51:29the chief criminal investigator for the area. He did take it seriously, but
- 51:32he wanted Heath and Davey to come back and point out the areas that it
- 51:36happened. But ultimately it seemed that nobody at all investigated and really just passed
- 51:42it from one to the other. Although then they did a secret indictment.
- 51:45Is that quite a common thing done? Or I would say no. And
- 51:52the reason I would say that is because all the evidence that they had that
- 51:54these guys, I should say what David Lawyer said, you know, all
- 52:00the evidence that they had for the fact that these guys were chased and run
- 52:05off the road. It seems really strange to me that they would or that
- 52:09David would get indicted and brought back. I mean, there's something weird about
- 52:15that as well. And I'm not extremely familiar with how all of that works,
- 52:20but it's it's bizarre to me because clearly these guys were the victims of
- 52:24something. And I mean, to me, the indictment is, well,
- 52:30David ended up breaking into a sheriff deputy's house, Yeah, because he was
- 52:37completely exhausted. He was, you know, I would say, on the
- 52:43verge of complete collapse, and he needed food. He hadn't drink any water,
- 52:47and the water that he was drinking was pretty much swamp water. And
- 52:51at some point, and I should say that he only believed that he was
- 52:55hallucinating after the event happened and with this ritual animal sacrifice. This wasn't you
- 53:02know, it wasn't the first night he was in there that he started drinking
- 53:06swamp water and was seeing things. And the level of his hallucination wasn't that
- 53:13he was, you know, seeing phantoms chasing him. It was just that
- 53:15he was would fall asleep and he would think that he was at home.
- 53:20That was kind of the level of what his hallucination was. So, you
- 53:27know, it's it's kind of a it's a weird story because you have to
- 53:34kind of divide everything and divide the times and figure out the timeline. And
- 53:39clearly the majority of all of these events happened when these guys were completely lucid,
- 53:45well fed, hydrated, And it only got to its worst point where
- 53:52David claimed he was hallucinating when he was already passed this. Yeah, so
- 54:00it wasn't until much later that just happened. So you can't easily dismiss this
- 54:05whole thing as being now they were just hallucinating. They were on the road
- 54:07a lot. I mean a lot of times when you're driving on a road
- 54:10trip, I mean you're you're kind of taking sleep breaks. I mean,
- 54:13I know you don't get the greatest amount of sleep when you do it.
- 54:15But young guys, early twenties, they can pull off a long distance road
- 54:22trip without you know, becoming mentally exhausted and hallucinating. So you know,
- 54:28that idea right there is just it's that's insane to even believe that. And
- 54:32the fact that these guys were completely dismissed as they were is just it's such
- 54:37a tragedy. Such a tragedy. I mean, we could say, well,
- 54:40whether really human heads hanging in the trees, but then think about what
- 54:44else could you mistake that for? Maybe pigs heads? Right? And if
- 54:49there is work to make you think that you were seeing human heads in trees.
- 54:52If you weren't, you know, why would you think, Oh,
- 54:54I can see three human heads there right, and they're just hanging from a
- 54:58tree. And I don't know. I don't know how they were hanging or
- 55:01how they were suspending human heads, but I can I can tell you that
- 55:06I don't think I would make the mistake between a sheep's head and a human
- 55:09head. And I mean, granted, the truth is that David lost his
- 55:15contacts at one point and was not able to see very well. But at
- 55:19the same time, you have to remember that he broke into a sheriff deputies
- 55:24home and he was able to read the mail the address on this Holmes mail
- 55:31to you know, call his fiance to let her know here, I'm at
- 55:36this house in Covington, Tennessee. Please send help. We don't know if
- 55:40he's short or longsighted, so you could read mail. Might that's true,
- 55:45But even so, let's say, for argument's sake, it wasn't a human
- 55:50head. It was a pig's head. But what else could look like that
- 55:54if you are short sighted, that you could mistake it for could have well
- 55:59been like a pig's head. I mean, if they're if they're hacking up
- 56:04animals and rolling around in the blood, I mean, clearly, you know,
- 56:08these are people that have some familiarity with with you know, cutting up
- 56:15animals and things like that. So I mean, it very well could have
- 56:19been a pig's head or something. But you know, I guess it all
- 56:22really depends on how far away these heads were to him that he would have
- 56:25been able to see them or not so unpresumably not far away, right,
- 56:31because he also said to the newspapers that the words were that he observed numerous
- 56:37rituals, so presumably it was all going on in this He said that they
- 56:40circled him like it was an arena, so presumably it was all quite up
- 56:45close. Yeah, And that's that's why I'm saying, is that you tie
- 56:50that situation into the situation with these insignias being in the church, and it
- 56:58really does have a true detective to feel to it that you know, there
- 57:01is some kind of a strange group in that area that is hunting people down,
- 57:07kidnapping people, terrorizing people, stalking them on the interstate to get them
- 57:13back toward Tennessee. But it just, you know, it seems like such
- 57:20hard work to do that. It's a lot of effort and a lot of
- 57:22time and a lot of money to have crossed from one state to the next
- 57:27state, and to go for hundreds of miles to do this unheard of.
- 57:32And that's why I think people that would look at this story and read this
- 57:36story, especially how it's laid out in the Morning Call, and just a
- 57:38big joke they make out of it, it's just foolishness. I mean,
- 57:44there's just so much evidence that proves that this did happen to these guys,
- 57:50and you know, it sounds outrageous. It sounds outrageous because really it's it's
- 57:55something that would happen in a nightmare. It doesn't seem like something that would
- 58:00happen very often in real life, if at all much. And if you
- 58:06weren't a fit young man and they did it to you, these two guys
- 58:10were in the pack of fitness to be able to get out of it.
- 58:15But what if you had been an elderly couple, right, yeah, elderly,
- 58:21a child, I mean, anybody, And you know, that's that's
- 58:24the thing. And I almost wonder if maybe the point was not to follow
- 58:30them as much as they did to maybe even take them at that rest stop
- 58:35and something went wrong there, or they got away too quickly, or you
- 58:38know, they just something unexpected came up when they got there. But to
- 58:45me, I really do believe that the point was not to terrorize them.
- 58:51I do believe the point was they were going to kill these guys. You
- 58:53don't You don't spend that much time chasing somebody down with somebody in a swamp,
- 59:02ritually slaughtering animals in front of them, you know, having an eight
- 59:07year old point of rifle at them. If you're just going to say,
- 59:09oh, yeah, we were just joking around. We're going to send you
- 59:13back home after we're done toying with you, I mean, it makes it
- 59:16makes no logical sense at all. I believe that whoever this group was,
- 59:22it was and it's and the fact that they had these insignias, you know,
- 59:27emblazoned on a church in that area, seems to indicate to me that
- 59:32this is an organized group that was doing things. I don't know if this
- 59:37is early human trafficking or this group was involved in things like that, but
- 59:44you know, a lot of a lot of these criminal organizations are into some
- 59:46really weird sort of things. And I think the scary thing for us as
- 59:52well though, is that he'th's saying to you, are you one of them?
- 59:55And with him being so scared that people were going to come and kick
- 59:59his all down? Really, is it going to be this little local group
- 1:00:04who are real hooligans, fair enough, but are they going to go all
- 1:00:07the way to Pennsylvania and kick your door in? Or is it somebody who's
- 1:00:10more of an authority figure that's going to turn up and with them thinking these
- 1:00:15guys are dea So the weird thing is, I know you've said at one
- 1:00:19point it's almost like the Finder's cult were actually it was run by intelligence or
- 1:00:22it was run by parts of some kind of secret government. So that's a
- 1:00:27scary bit. Could possibly be organized and these are the local yocals that are
- 1:00:31used to carry out the terrorizing, but there's other people pulling the strings.
- 1:00:37Yeah, And that's that's one worry that I have always had about this too,
- 1:00:40is is go on public with a thing like this. I mean,
- 1:00:43let's just say that this is some kind of sanctioned, sanctioned organization like the
- 1:00:49Finders clearly was, you know, and they were doing similar things where they
- 1:00:52were having these kids sacrifice animals, and you know, and they had polaroid
- 1:00:58pictures of this, and you know, it was really strange. Yes,
- 1:01:02it was really strange things. And that's why there's elements of that in here.
- 1:01:07And you know, if you have twenty thirty people running around in the
- 1:01:12bottoms and terrorizing people, it seems pretty unlikely to me that nobody's going to
- 1:01:20hear it and nobody's going to realize, hey, there's something weird going on
- 1:01:23over there. And which is why I say that that, you know,
- 1:01:28the Covington Henning area strikes me as a very strange kind of place, you
- 1:01:34know, And what really backs that is is the fact that this Missus Dixon
- 1:01:37who got Heathen David out of Tennessee, seemed very aware that there was a
- 1:01:46real threat and that she had to protect them from this very real threat.
- 1:01:52So you know, the question is is what was the threat? Who are
- 1:01:55these people? What are they doing? I mean, are they still operate
- 1:02:00rating? You know, it's just there's a lot of unanswered questions to this
- 1:02:05story. Yeah, and is it literally it's just a very bad area.
- 1:02:09The guys on the highway happened to live there, they happened to be on
- 1:02:14the highway. They herded them back to their area, and it's some intergenerational
- 1:02:20family doing it. Or is it that this is the area that they choose
- 1:02:23to use and it's been organized by more orchestrated set up. So yeah,
- 1:02:32and that may well be. And that's why, you know, locating this
- 1:02:36church and some of the other things that we've found, which will be going
- 1:02:42over you know, in later episodes, is kind of compelling that there really
- 1:02:47is more going on here. And you know, we really, we genuinely
- 1:02:53do not know, at least not yet whether this group is still functioning in
- 1:02:59that area or if there's even any remnants of it. But generally that part
- 1:03:04of Tennessee is very poor, so a lot of the people are very it's
- 1:03:09poverty stricken. A lot of these people are very hard up. It's a
- 1:03:16rough place to live. David in the hospital. The one thing about David
- 1:03:22is that when he's in the hospital, he comes into contact with a nurse
- 1:03:27there that tells him, or he must have told the story to her that
- 1:03:30I was chased around in the bottoms by this crazy cult that was following us
- 1:03:36along Interstate forty. And then she says to him that cults sometimes sacrifice their
- 1:03:44own children, okay, which is a really bizarre thing for a nurse to
- 1:03:50say to a patient who has just been through this kind of a traumatic thing.
- 1:03:55Well, the interesting thing is that when they morning Cole tried to find
- 1:04:00out more information, the hospital said he had never been there, right,
- 1:04:05although we know we know from David's lawyer when he was charged with the break
- 1:04:12in, that the hospital record showed that he had the pat pellet marks on
- 1:04:16his body, so obviously he was there, but the hospital denied, and
- 1:04:21in fact, the Morning Call phoned all the hospitals in the area and they
- 1:04:25all denied having had him, which is strange because even the sheriff had said
- 1:04:30that he was he was in the hospital, but they I don't think they
- 1:04:33said I think it was a Tipton Baptist Hospital or something like that. I
- 1:04:38thought they named it. And it's just to me that part also sort of
- 1:04:43lends credence to the idea that there's something really strange about that region, in
- 1:04:47particular, because if you have a nurse that's saying these things, and you
- 1:04:54know, granted, I know that it's you know, still nineteen ninety four,
- 1:04:58you know, and at times a bit different, but it's still a
- 1:05:02very out there and strange thing to say to a patient who has just been
- 1:05:09through that. So that's why I say it's these details that the Morning Call
- 1:05:15did document that kind of make this very interesting and it gives you a little
- 1:05:21bit more information about what has happened and what's going on with these guys.
- 1:05:28And I mean they covered it for what felt like weeks. There's a plethora
- 1:05:32of accounts that they reported on, isn't there. So they did an amazing
- 1:05:38job with documenting it all, right, right, I mean when these guys
- 1:05:44and that's the thing too, is that when these guys got home, I
- 1:05:46mean they both isolated themselves completely. You know, David probably more so where
- 1:05:54he was just losing his mind over this. I mean he was falling apart.
- 1:05:59He was reading the Bible kind of I guess, you know, he
- 1:06:02was his relationship with his fiance was was quite strained, and he came back
- 1:06:08from this not the same person that he was. Yeah, and his mother
- 1:06:14tried to get him to tell her what had happened to him, and he
- 1:06:17just would not tell her. So what what could it be that is so
- 1:06:21bad that you just couldn't tell anyone, right, And that that's why,
- 1:06:27that's why I think that the amount of terror that they were inflicting on David
- 1:06:32was far worse than what the Morning Call was saying. And I mean,
- 1:06:40you keep in mind, he was he was there for a few days.
- 1:06:42It wasn't just you know, a few hours and he's out. I mean,
- 1:06:45Heath made a very quick escape out of there, and you know,
- 1:06:49only you know his the biggest thing for him was what happened at that at
- 1:06:56that rest stop. You know, that's the most interaction he had with them,
- 1:06:59aside from from hiding. And you know, another thing that he had
- 1:07:02said is that they were out there with with flashlights that night, you know,
- 1:07:06looking for them. So I mean, it's it's there out there with
- 1:07:10they came prepared, whoever they were, they came prepared. They were out
- 1:07:13there with flashlights, they were communicating with each other using bird calls. You
- 1:07:17know, they had paint pellets. This to me was like a like a
- 1:07:21chartered hunting trip sort of thing. And maybe that's you know, one group
- 1:07:29of these guys is just kind of herds them into one specific area, and
- 1:07:33there was another group that was out there doing the hunting and terrorizing, And
- 1:07:42you know there's because we tried to get a description from hethe about this fan
- 1:07:46when it all began. What were they wearing, what did the men look
- 1:07:50like, do they look military types or what? Who were they? But
- 1:07:55he just wouldn't tell us. He wouldn't, he didn't, he wouldn't say.
- 1:07:58Combined with him saying to you or you one of them kind of seems
- 1:08:01to be like it's a bigger thing than we've run through the ideas. Was
- 1:08:06it travelers, was it carnival people, you know, just playing with them?
- 1:08:11But what happened to them in the swamp doesn't match with vans and cars
- 1:08:16on the highway who look like the Dea. That's the insynchronicity of it,
- 1:08:23which makes it all the more weirder it is. And you know, that's
- 1:08:27what I was seeing, is that the amount of tracking they had on these
- 1:08:31guys from the time they spotted them on the interstate just before Memphis and till
- 1:08:40the very end. I mean, they just they had eyes on them.
- 1:08:44And I interestingly, do you remember when we first started looking into this and
- 1:08:47you said, you know, these guys, I reckon they must have been
- 1:08:50communicating by Cebee radio and then we got his letter like two years afterwards,
- 1:08:56didn't we saying to you, oh yeah, well it was by CEBE radio.
- 1:08:59Yah, yeah yeah. And that's that's why I was saying, is
- 1:09:01that it's it's it's very organized, it's very organized. How how they carried
- 1:09:06it out, how they uh pushed them back where they wanted them. I
- 1:09:12mean, it was just it was done just like clockwork really because there were
- 1:09:17clearly people waiting in that swamp, and it was the people in the swamp
- 1:09:21that were hunting them down and doing all of these things, you know,
- 1:09:27and and and some of the questions we have is where did this convoy drop
- 1:09:31off and these two cop cars pick up? Because a lot of were they
- 1:09:39and they could have just been So that's that's a lot of the strange sort
- 1:09:47of details of the story that that are hard to hard to figure out exactly
- 1:09:54what happened. And you know, who knows who this group is or if
- 1:10:00it's you know, it was one group did one part of this, another
- 1:10:04group did another part. But I think it was completely by mistake that David
- 1:10:11ended up getting away. I think that Heath getting away was one thing,
- 1:10:15and the level of fearlessness in this group that. I mean, they must
- 1:10:20have known early on that they lost Heath, that he was already gone,
- 1:10:26they weren't going to find him, and yet they continued on. It didn't
- 1:10:30stop them at all for days. And I mean, it wasn't like the
- 1:10:32police were out there looking. And that's what I'm saying is that it gives
- 1:10:36a lot of credence to what Yeah, it gives a lot of credence to
- 1:10:41what these two were saying that they believe that the police were involved in some
- 1:10:44way with this. So and it's a very good point. It didn't stop
- 1:10:50when one of them escaped, you know, so then David got out as
- 1:10:55well, and I don't know, I mean maybe you know, previous victims
- 1:10:59of this just weren't as able bodied as David and Heath were, and that's
- 1:11:03why, you know, they just they weren't able to catch these guys and
- 1:11:09do whatever it was they were going to do. Because that was Heath's exact
- 1:11:14comment, wasn't it that when he reached well to both of us, he
- 1:11:17said, you know, I want to tell you everything because we were the
- 1:11:21lucky ones. And so he believed they weren't supposed to get out of their
- 1:11:25alive didn't. He he did, he did. And that's why I was
- 1:11:28I was saying early on that this was not the intent of this group to
- 1:11:34just let them go, and they wanted to do some some serious damage to
- 1:11:41these guys. And if the police were going to take them seriously, which
- 1:11:45you would imagine they would if you go to the police with a story that
- 1:11:48you've just been hunted, why did they have no fear about the police coming
- 1:11:55to the swamps to look for them and stop them, right, That's that's
- 1:12:00that's a very good point, and that's that's what makes this story so enigmatic
- 1:12:05because the cops don't seem to care. Yet there's all this evidence pointing that
- 1:12:12this is a true story, that all of this really happened. So,
- 1:12:16you know, it might be a very tight knit group down there where they're
- 1:12:20just kind of they're looking out for their own and that's just how they are.
- 1:12:28It's just how they operate, and and they have been very successful at
- 1:12:30getting away with it, and they maybe, you know, we're too confident
- 1:12:34in their ability to not let people get away and this is what happened,
- 1:12:41you know, But it's it really does almost come off like like some kind
- 1:12:44of a movie where it's you know, these guys are and everyone's involved.
- 1:12:50Everyone's involved in and for whatever reason it's even a church, a church of
- 1:12:58all places, is somehow associated with it and carried those insignias and was a
- 1:13:05part of this group, and you know it does it's it's unanswered questions and
- 1:13:14the strangeness of the story itself that really makes it. Uh, it just
- 1:13:17makes it very compelling. Yeah, you just made such a good point about
- 1:13:23the fact that one of them got away and they didn't care. They just
- 1:13:26carried on for another two or three nights. They didn't care. Now that's
- 1:13:30not normal. So that does speak of some kind of open secret about everybody
- 1:13:33knowing and just like carry on everyone. Oh. Perfect. Yeah, that's
- 1:13:36a good word for it, because it is. To me, that's what
- 1:13:40I see it as. It's it's a it's an open secret and nobody but
- 1:13:47nobody but but but nobody but the locals seem to be aware of it,
- 1:13:53and they're clearly aware of it. Yeah. And if they and if they
- 1:13:57weren't worried that that that Heath might well, I mean that whoa, I
- 1:14:01don't know how fat well, No, we know that he didn't go to
- 1:14:03the police when the woman rescued him, because I presume he'd had enough of
- 1:14:06the police by that point. But they were not worried that one had escaped
- 1:14:11and at any second the police could come marching into that swamp searching for him.
- 1:14:15I mean, did they even I mean, think about that, for
- 1:14:18three days he's out there, or three days