Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Did Richard III Murder the Princes in the Tower – Or Did the Tudors Frame Him?
Transcript
- 0:00But he tells us that this story comes from the Bishop of Bath
- 0:03and Wells, a man called Robert Stillington.
- 0:06He says that Stillington comes to Richard after the death of
- 0:09his brother Edward, and tells him that he had officiated at a
- 0:13wedding between Edward and Eleanor Butler.
- 0:15Eleanor Talbot, who's sorry, who got married and became Eleanor
- 0:18Butler, and before Edward had married Elizabeth Woodville.
- 0:22Therefore, the marriage is bigamous.
- 0:39Welcome back to the Jeremy Ryan Slate show.
- 0:40I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO and Co founder of
- 0:43Command Your Brand. We help our clients to appear on
- 0:46some of the top podcasts out there.
- 0:48You can check out our Brand Authority analysis of our
- 0:50Commander brand.com/analysis and reminder.
- 0:54You can find me all over the place.
- 0:56I'm at Jeremy Ryan Slate and I am very excited for the
- 0:59conversation we're going to have today.
- 1:01Because those of you out there that have followed me for a long
- 1:03time know that I am an ancient historian at heart and I love
- 1:07talking about ancient history. But I'm going to have a host on
- 1:11today from one of my favorite podcast, which is the Gone
- 1:13Medieval podcast, as I've gotten very into the Plantagenets, the
- 1:17tutors and and everything around it.
- 1:19So, Matt Lewis, thank you for hanging out with me today, Sir.
- 1:22Thank you very much for having me, Jeremy.
- 1:23That's a heck of an introduction.
- 1:25I I do have to say I stumbled on your show last year and I do not
- 1:29miss an episode because I've been very into medieval history.
- 1:33Oh, brilliant. Yeah.
- 1:33I mean, it's, you know, it's one of the great joys to be able to
- 1:37to produce something like that, to talk about medieval history
- 1:39for a living, to to talk to guests who, you know, are
- 1:41experts in their fields and have new research published and new
- 1:45books out. And to be able to, you know, I
- 1:47enjoy my time talking to them, which hopefully the audience
- 1:49does too. So for people that may not know
- 1:52you know much about you, could you tell us a little bit about
- 1:54your background and and what you do?
- 1:57Yeah, I actually not a historian by training.
- 2:01I did my degree in law and have ended up writing numerous non
- 2:07fiction history books. A couple of historical fiction
- 2:10novels thrown in there too. My main area of focus has always
- 2:14been the The Wars of the Roses and in particular Richard the
- 2:163rd and The Princess in the Tower and all of the
- 2:18controversies around all of that.
- 2:22And more recently, I have been lucky enough to be working for
- 2:25History Hits who operate a a network of podcasts.
- 2:29So God Medieval is one of those. Echoes of History is another one
- 2:32that I host to, which is tied into the Assassin's Creed
- 2:35franchise. And there's an ancient history
- 2:38one, as you mentioned, the you're into ancient history.
- 2:41There's one called The Ancients. And I discovered that recently
- 2:44from your crossover episode. It wasn't one I knew about.
- 2:48OK, well that you've got a massive back catalog there for
- 2:50you to go and enjoy. I think it's been going for a
- 2:52bit longer than God Medieval. So I may get to make
- 2:56documentaries with history hits. And I have also been previously
- 3:03chair of the Richard the Third Society.
- 3:05So that's how deep into Richard the third stuff I am.
- 3:09And I've written a a biography of him.
- 3:11I've written a book about the Princess and the tower amongst
- 3:13the the books that I've written. So I am fortunate enough to be
- 3:16able to call myself a full time historian now.
- 3:19So I guess when we look at Richard the 3rd and, and a lot
- 3:22of the world around him, you know, Shakespeare writes about
- 3:25Richard the 3rd and, and he's often given a, a reputation as
- 3:29kind of a, a bad guy in history. And it's, it's interesting
- 3:31because I just finished Dan Jones's book The War of the
- 3:34Roses. And, and I've been really into
- 3:37kind of that time period. And to me, if, if you look at it
- 3:40doesn't seem like Richard the third is, is really the guy that
- 3:43history makes him out to be. But how does history view
- 3:47Richard the 3rd and how should we view him?
- 3:49I think for a long time, I mean, I guess I would say as someone
- 3:52who's interested in Richard the 3rd and interested in
- 3:55reassessing his characters, you know, the aim is never to try
- 3:58and say that that this guy is a St.
- 4:00He never made any mistakes or did anything wrong.
- 4:03But to, to look at a reassessment of Richard the 3rd
- 4:07and his life and the things that he did.
- 4:10It's so, it's so weird in in many ways, I think that this is
- 4:14a guy who was king for just over 2 years.
- 4:16So a really, really short reign. And yet he has, you know, a
- 4:21worldwide society dedicated to, to examining and studying his
- 4:27life. And I, I think probably there
- 4:30wouldn't be as much interest in Richard the 3rd as there is if
- 4:32it wasn't for Shakespeare's play, You know, his, his
- 4:35absolute masterpiece. I love Shakespeare's Richard the
- 4:383rd. It's it's, it's a fascinating
- 4:41examination of the ultimate villain.
- 4:45And I think there's so many layers to it as well, because
- 4:47one of the things that always fascinates me about Richard the
- 4:49Third is that he's he's overtly, openly the bad guy.
- 4:53He tells the audience all the way through when he's going to
- 4:56kill someone, he's about to murder his wife.
- 4:58He's going to organise the death of his brother George.
- 5:00Now he's ordering the death of his nephews, all of those kinds
- 5:03of things. And yet we as an audience, we
- 5:05sit there and we watch him do all of this and we don't, we
- 5:09don't jump up on stage and stop him.
- 5:11And we find ourselves laughing along with the jokes, with the
- 5:13little asides that he makes, the, the funny comments that he
- 5:17makes to the audience. So we're laughing along with a
- 5:20guy who is a serial killer. And for me, the play asks as
- 5:23much about the audience and our reaction to that kind of thing,
- 5:27that idea that, you know, for, for evil to survive, all it
- 5:31requires is for good people to do nothing.
- 5:33And, and every performance of Richard the Third, you've got a
- 5:36bunch of good people in the audience watching this terrible,
- 5:38terrible person tell you he's about to murder everyone and we
- 5:41do nothing to stop it. So I think there's so much going
- 5:44on in the Richard the Third play beyond telling the story of
- 5:48Richard the 3rd. And that's part of the reason
- 5:51that play's been such a success. I think the thing that that
- 5:55causes the problem is really not Shakespeare's fault.
- 5:58And that's that people have tended to take it as history as
- 6:01as a non fiction historical documentary about what Richard
- 6:05the Third did. And if you ask people to to tell
- 6:08you something about Richard the Third, they will invariably tell
- 6:11you something that is in Shakespeare's play if they don't
- 6:13know too much about Richard the 3rd.
- 6:16So I think, you know, Ricardian's people who are
- 6:18interested in Richard the Third, I think we have to accept that
- 6:20Shakespeare's play is there. It's not going anywhere.
- 6:22And it's probably the reason that most of us are are actually
- 6:24interested in Richard the 3rd. It's that idea of being
- 6:27presented with this ultimate irredeemable villain.
- 6:32You know, he's a character who has absolutely no character
- 6:35development arc throughout the play.
- 6:36Richard the third, he starts off as an inveterate bad guy and he
- 6:40ends the play as an inveterate bad guy.
- 6:42There's no redemption. He hasn't learned anything.
- 6:45He's just a vehicle for for villainy.
- 6:49And it's such an interesting play, but it has led to this
- 6:53kind of backlash more recently. So the, the rich of the Third
- 6:57Society celebrated its 100th anniversary last year.
- 7:01So there's been a, a more recent backlash against the idea that
- 7:04he was such a bad guy. And, and that for me, that tends
- 7:08to be backed up an awful lot by the the research and the study
- 7:11that tells us so much about his life.
- 7:14And it becomes really, really hard to reconcile the man that
- 7:19you can see at work throughout the 1470s and the 1480s with
- 7:25this idea of the irredeemable villain of Shakespeare.
- 7:29So I guess when we look at it, I, I kind of want to back out a
- 7:32little bit just to give an idea to people, the stage we're on,
- 7:34the time period once we've, we've talked about Margaret
- 7:36Ofanju on the show before. So we have an idea of, you know,
- 7:41that part of the, the War of the Roses.
- 7:43But I guess how does Richard fit into this and and what is really
- 7:46his his role in royal succession?
- 7:49Yeah. So I mean, if you've done
- 7:51Margaret of Anjou, so we've got there Henry the sixth wife and
- 7:55queen. So her her great rival, I think.
- 7:59And I think the rivalry is more between Margaret and Richard
- 8:02Duke of York than it is between Henry the 6th and Richard Duke
- 8:05of York. They're the two that are really
- 8:07vying to be the the power behind Henry's throne while Henry is so
- 8:12weak. So Richard Duke of York is is
- 8:15Richard the Third's father. So obviously they've got the
- 8:17same name because everyone has to have the same name just to
- 8:19make it ultra confusing. History is very confusing from
- 8:23that perspective, especially in this era where everyone's an
- 8:26Edward and everyone's a Richard. Yet they have such a small baby
- 8:30book. In the Wars of the Roses,
- 8:31everyone is a Richard and Edward or a Henry, and all of the girls
- 8:34are a Margaret or an Elizabeth as a rule.
- 8:37And it becomes really tricky to keep track of of who everybody
- 8:39is. So Margaret's great enemy really
- 8:43is Richard, Duke of York. And he ultimately at the end of
- 8:48the 1450s and in 1460 falls out spectacularly with Henry the
- 8:536th. There's, there's a whole lot to
- 8:56say about that relationship too, I think.
- 8:58But in 1460 he effectively lays claim to Henry's throne, I think
- 9:04in an act of of self preservation, something that
- 9:07he's avoided trying to do for for 10 years by that point.
- 9:11But he is declared heir to Henry's throne.
- 9:13So they they don't depose Henry at that point.
- 9:16They make Richard, Duke of York, his heir.
- 9:19And within a couple of months of this being put through
- 9:22Parliament, York is killed at Wakefield by the the the end of
- 9:261460. So York becoming heir has has
- 9:30suddenly put Richard, ah, Richard, Richard the third in
- 9:34the line of, of succession. He's got at this point three
- 9:37older brothers. One of them actually dies
- 9:39alongside their father at Wakefield.
- 9:43So he has two more older brothers, Edward and George.
- 9:46Edward becomes a king in 1461 as the first kind of Yorkist king
- 9:51of England. And then he's he's 18 years old
- 9:54at that point. He's unmarried, doesn't have any
- 9:56children. So George is his heir.
- 9:58And Richard is now next in line to the throne.
- 10:00So all of a sudden, at the age of what is he at this point nine
- 10:05years old, he's second in line to the throne.
- 10:08And this this comes hot on the heels of of a few years of real
- 10:11tumult for Richard as well. So before he's reached the age
- 10:14of 10, he's witnessed the sacking of of Ludlow.
- 10:17The town is ransacked by Henry's army while Richard is is in the
- 10:22castle. And the castle we're told in
- 10:25some sources, is robbed to the bare walls.
- 10:27So he's witnessed all of this. He's been a prisoner.
- 10:29So he's placed in the household of his aunt, his mother's
- 10:32sister. When his father is declared A
- 10:34traitor, the whole family are dispossessed of everything.
- 10:38So, you know, he's now kind of at rock bottom at the age of of
- 10:42eight. He is eventually when their
- 10:45father is killed at Wakefield. The situation has got so
- 10:48desperate in London that their mother, Cecily Neville, puts
- 10:53George and Richard in a boat and sails has them sailed out into
- 10:56the Thames and a cross with a handful of servants across the
- 10:59Channel to Burgundy. And they end up sort of at the a
- 11:03property of the Duke of Burgundy, but he keeps them away
- 11:06from court because he's not quite sure what to do with these
- 11:07boys. He doesn't know what's going to
- 11:08happen in England. Are they, are they valuable
- 11:12connections to the, the English throne?
- 11:14Or are they dangerous traitors that people are going to come
- 11:16looking for? And so they're sort of left in
- 11:19limbo for several months until their older brother Edward takes
- 11:23the throne and has them brought back to England for his
- 11:26coronation. And a few months after the
- 11:29coronation, Richard has created Duke of Gloucester and as I say,
- 11:31is, is now second in line to the throne of England.
- 11:34So he's been through an awful lot before he's even reached the
- 11:38age of 10. And he, you know, it's hard to
- 11:42imagine that those things didn't leave a, a mark on a small boy,
- 11:46that sense of, of insecurity, of how precarious life could be,
- 11:50how quickly and easily it could all be turned upside down.
- 11:54And then it could be turned over again.
- 11:56You know, he's, he's constantly being flipped all the way
- 11:59through the early Wars of the Roses.
- 12:01It's, it's really interesting as well because I know even in the
- 12:04background, you know, once Edward becomes king, we also
- 12:07have Margaret Beaufort who has the idea that her, her son Henry
- 12:10Tudor could be the next king. So it's you really do seem to
- 12:14feel very insecure in power in this moment in time.
- 12:18Yeah, I mean, Margaret Beaufort is an interesting 1.
- 12:21So she I would, I would disagree with the notion that she
- 12:24believed her son Henry was always destined to be king.
- 12:27I think that is something that that comes to the fore at the
- 12:29end of 1483. I think she sees an opportunity
- 12:32in all of the the chaos that breaks out in 1483.
- 12:38But nevertheless, she is a die hard devoted Lancastrian who
- 12:44doesn't really like the House of York.
- 12:46She, she becomes reconciled to the fact that Edward the 4th is
- 12:49king. You know, he, he's on the throne
- 12:50for, for 10 years and then he gets kicked off for, for about 6
- 12:54months and, and sent into exile, driven into exile in Burgundy.
- 12:58And Richard goes with him again. So a second spell of exile on
- 13:01the continent for, for Richard. And then they come back and, and
- 13:05you know, Henry is killed, his only son in heir is killed.
- 13:10Margaret is captured and eventually ransomed back to
- 13:14France. Margaret of Anjou, sorry.
- 13:17And so I think Margaret of both, Margaret Beaufort kind of
- 13:19realizes that she has to just exist in this this New Yorkist
- 13:23world. But she is very quick to move
- 13:25against the House of York when things begin to to go off the
- 13:29rails for them. And it's interesting too,
- 13:31because I know I guess going a little bit further down the road
- 13:33here when Edward the 4th dies. And I, I've always wondered how
- 13:37would history be different if Edward the 4th lives a little
- 13:40bit longer? Because it does seem like there
- 13:43was a bit more security. I know there's these, these
- 13:47rebel attacks every once in a while, but there is overall more
- 13:49security during the time of his rule.
- 13:51And, and how would things have changed?
- 13:53But Edward dies and we have the idea that his son Edward the 5th
- 13:57is supposed to be the next ruler.
- 13:59But I believe Richard the third is basically Lord protector at
- 14:04this point in time. So I guess when we're looking at
- 14:06this, what happens in this time period and, and, and why is
- 14:10Richard blamed for what happens to his nephews?
- 14:13Well, I mean, this is the $1,000,000 question.
- 14:15This is the where it gets really, really complicated.
- 14:18So Edward the 4th dies in early April 1483.
- 14:22And this is utterly unexpected. He's 40 years old.
- 14:26He is, you know, he's 6 foot 4. He's a, a beast of a man.
- 14:30He's never been defeated on the battlefields of the Wars of the
- 14:33Roses. And not many people can say that
- 14:34throughout this period. Nobody is expecting him to die
- 14:40his heir. He has 2 two sons and and
- 14:43several daughters. His heir is the 12 year old who
- 14:47is immediately proclaimed Edward the 5th.
- 14:50He's been Prince of Wales and on the death of his father he is
- 14:54automatically, instantly proclaimed king and that's why
- 14:57he gets his regular number even though he doesn't make it to a
- 15:00coronation. So we're we're told that in a
- 15:04late addition to his will which the document doesn't survive.
- 15:07So we're relying on sources that tell us about this.
- 15:10Edward added a late codicil to his will, an addition at the end
- 15:14of it just before he died, which I think can only be because he
- 15:17realized that there was going to be chaos when he had gone.
- 15:22And he he definitely doesn't see that chaos coming from his
- 15:24brother Richard. There are two factions at his
- 15:27court, 1 led by the family of his wife Elizabeth Woodville,
- 15:31and the other led by what we might call Edward the force best
- 15:34mate his his drinking and partying by the Lord Hastings.
- 15:40And we're we're told in the sources that in the immediate
- 15:43aftermath of Edward's death, those two factions have men,
- 15:47armed men in the streets of London on the brink of violence.
- 15:51And so at this point Richard is based in the north of England,
- 15:54the far north of England. He's kind of living at Midland
- 15:56Castle in Yorkshire. So there is trouble in London in
- 16:01the aftermath of Edward the 4th death before Richard is anywhere
- 16:04near London. So this idea that he is the
- 16:06cause of trouble is something that we we need to be very wary
- 16:10of. Edward is very clearly seen
- 16:12Richard as the solution to the problem that I think he knows is
- 16:15coming. So we're told that this late
- 16:17codicil to his will appoints his brother as Lord Protector.
- 16:21And Lord Protector is a very, very specific function in 15th
- 16:26century England. It was a post that was created
- 16:29after the death of Henry the 5th when his heir, Henry the sixth
- 16:32was, was a nine month old baby. Lord Protector specifically
- 16:38gives the post holder control of internal and external security.
- 16:44So it makes him kind of, you know, head of the police, head
- 16:46of the army, if there was an equivalent of those things in
- 16:48the medieval world. It doesn't give him control of
- 16:51the government. It doesn't give him control of
- 16:54the person of the new king. So Richard is not the protector
- 16:58of his nephews. He's a protector for his
- 17:02nephew's government. The government will be run by a
- 17:04council in which Richard is envisaged as a senior member,
- 17:08but not necessarily the leader and definitely not running the
- 17:13government exclusively. He's doing it alongside the
- 17:16council and the person of Edward the 5th is, is still being cared
- 17:22for by his maternal uncle, sorry, Anthony Woodville, who is
- 17:26Earl Rivers. And he's been raised at Ludlow,
- 17:30which is on the Welsh borders, not too far away from where I'm
- 17:32sitting right now. And he's been there since the
- 17:36age of 2. So he spent 10 years kind of
- 17:38being prepared to be the next king.
- 17:41But undoubtedly Edward the 4th would have expected to have
- 17:44lived longer and allowed his son to be better prepared and to be
- 17:47an adult who could take control of this situation himself.
- 17:51The the imminent early death that is facing him in April 1483
- 17:55clearly drives him to see his brother Richard as the solution
- 17:59who can come South, get a grip of these these two factions that
- 18:03are causing problems or which he knows are going to cause
- 18:05problems when he's gone. And and he sees Richard, I think
- 18:10as the person who will smooth the succession of his his son
- 18:15Edward the 5th. Now, you know, hindsight will
- 18:17tell us that that doesn't happen.
- 18:20And it's easy then to start to conflate things and say, you
- 18:22know, Richard had this great scheme all along to to depose
- 18:25his nephew and take the throne for himself.
- 18:27But it is, it is way, way more complicated than that.
- 18:31And, and it's it's so tricky because the evidence is so
- 18:34lacking that you, depending on what you already think of
- 18:37Richard the third, I think you can see a scenario in which he,
- 18:41he stumbles his way through this, making mess after mess
- 18:45after mess until he backs himself into a corner and has no
- 18:47option but to take the throne for himself.
- 18:50I think the idea that he is scheming all along is is really,
- 18:54really difficult to back up with any kind of evidence.
- 18:57It's been the long held one. It's the one that Tudor
- 18:59chroniclers will try to propagate that as soon as Edward
- 19:02the 4th is dead, Richard is planning how he can make himself
- 19:05king. And that simply doesn't really
- 19:07stack up to to any evidence, doesn't hold up to any evidence.
- 19:12But there is also a version of Richard which is is much less,
- 19:18you know, there's there's a danger, I think sometimes in
- 19:20connecting dots with hindsight that aren't necessarily, you
- 19:24know, events that sequentially follow on from one another.
- 19:27They can be discreet individual moments of crisis.
- 19:31And I think those individual moments of crisis come really
- 19:35thick and fast in 1483. And they end in a situation in
- 19:38which, I mean, we we could get into the rights and wrongs and,
- 19:42and what may or may not have happened.
- 19:44But the legal outcome is that the children of Edward the 4th,
- 19:48his two sons and all of his daughters are declared
- 19:51illegitimate on the grounds of bigamy that his marriage to his
- 19:54Queen Elizabeth Woodville was, was bigamous because he was
- 19:59already married to someone else. The lady that is named is
- 20:01Eleanor Talbot. And illegitimate children can't
- 20:06succeed to the throne of England.
- 20:09There is another person who who might be considered heir and
- 20:12that is so that the brother between Edward and Richard who
- 20:15we mentioned earlier, George, he's he's dead by this point,
- 20:18actually executed by Edward, but he has a son.
- 20:22He was also called Edward, of course, Edward, Earl of Warwick.
- 20:26He could arguably be considered to have a the next best claim to
- 20:30the throne of England, but he is actually legally barred from the
- 20:34succession by the the attained of a treason that is passed
- 20:37against his father. It removes George and all of his
- 20:39children from the line of succession.
- 20:41So the conclusion is that Richard is the next available
- 20:44legitimate Yorkist heir to the throne and is offered the crown
- 20:51in in late June 1483, accept it and on the 6th of July 1483 is
- 20:57crowned as King Richard the third.
- 21:00If that that's kind of the the bare bones of the legal
- 21:02situation. The real question is how genuine
- 21:04was that bigamy story? Where did that?
- 21:06Well, that's the. Question I have is, I guess when
- 21:09we look at that, do we know where the bigamy story came
- 21:12from? Like, like and, and, and at that
- 21:14same point, because it's serving someone's purpose, right?
- 21:17And I, I, I guess who would have, who would have come up
- 21:19with that idea? I mean, again, another
- 21:22$1,000,000 question, if we can answer these, we're going to get
- 21:25rich today, Jeremy. Well, well, I guess the the The
- 21:27thing is, Matt, is I like medieval history.
- 21:29I'm not anywhere near as informed as you are, so my
- 21:31questions aren't as informed. No, no, no.
- 21:34I mean, it's, it's absolutely the the spot on question to be
- 21:37asking the the tricky bit is that we don't have the evidence
- 21:42to reach a definitive conclusion.
- 21:44So again, we're left looking at what are the options for the
- 21:49emergence of this story. We're only given a source for
- 21:52the story in one account. And this comes from Philippe de
- 21:55Camin, who is a Burgundian, who by this point is working at the
- 21:59French court. So he's a continental
- 22:02chronicler. I mean, he's pretty well
- 22:04informed, but he tells us that this story comes from the Bishop
- 22:08of Bath and Wells, a man called Robert Stillington.
- 22:12He says that Stillington comes to Richard after the death of
- 22:15his brother Edward and tells him that he had officiated at a
- 22:18wedding between Edward and Elena Butler.
- 22:21Elena Talbot who sorry who got married and became Elena Butler
- 22:26and before Edward had married Elizabeth Woodville.
- 22:28Therefore the marriage is bigamous.
- 22:33Whether it comes from Stillington we don't know.
- 22:35Kameen is the only source that gives him as a name.
- 22:39We know that Richard, by this point is in, is coming into
- 22:41contact with a lawyer named William Catesby, who has worked
- 22:47for the Talbot family. So he's worked for Eleanor
- 22:49Talbot's. Which by the way, Catesby in in
- 22:53English history is a very interesting name as well, a few
- 22:57100 years down the road. But anyway.
- 22:59Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's, it's an ancestor
- 23:01of his who will be the, the Robert Catesby who gets caught
- 23:04up in the well, he's the leader of the the Gunpowder Plot in
- 23:071605 and is is killed at Holbeach house in a big shoot
- 23:11out, which again, is not far away from where I live.
- 23:15So yeah, William Catesby is connected to the Talbot family.
- 23:20He could be a source for the story.
- 23:23He was previously working for Lord Hastings.
- 23:26Richard has Lord Hastings executed on the 13th of June on
- 23:29a charge of treason and Kate speak sort of moves into into
- 23:33Richard's circle. Then he's a potential source for
- 23:37the story. But again, I I see kind of three
- 23:40options with the the bigamy story.
- 23:43Either it's a lie that Richard invents as an excuse, a
- 23:47mechanism to take the throne for himself to move all of Edward
- 23:50the force children neatly out of the way, knowing that he can
- 23:53bypass the Earl of Warwick because of the attainder and
- 23:56this will make him king. The second option is that this
- 24:00is a story that is fabricated by somebody else and and sold to
- 24:05Richard so that maybe he believes it.
- 24:08Maybe he wants to believe it if it makes him king.
- 24:10It's hard to say, but there are reasons why people might want to
- 24:14sell this story to Richard. So nobody wants a 12 year old
- 24:17child on the throne of England. They've just endured the
- 24:20kingship of Henry the Sixth who became king at nine months old
- 24:24and turned out to be an absolute disaster.
- 24:27There is also the fact that France is is becoming incredibly
- 24:31aggressive. They're attacking shipping in
- 24:32the Channel. They're threatening the South
- 24:34Coast of England. They've stopped paying a pension
- 24:37to England that was a result of a treaty in 1475.
- 24:41So there are aggressive moves coming from across the Channel.
- 24:45And again, you don't want a 12 year old on the throne when
- 24:48you're about to come under attack from France.
- 24:52Edward the 5th remaining in power would also mean that his
- 24:55mother's family, the Woodville's would remain at the very centre
- 24:57of power. And they are incredibly
- 24:59unpopular in the country. So Lord Hastings, for example,
- 25:04you know, the the other one that was at the head of the faction
- 25:06after the death of Edward the 4th, he says that if the
- 25:08Woodville's are allowed to remain in power, he will go
- 25:10across to Calais, which is still an English possession at this
- 25:13point. And he will barricade himself in
- 25:15at Calais and, and launch attacks across the Channel to
- 25:19remove the Woodville. So that's how unliked they are.
- 25:23So there are reasons why people might want to to sidestep Edward
- 25:27the 5th's kingship, particularly in this moment.
- 25:32But I think the problem that Richard is going to face when he
- 25:34does become king is that there are also lots of people who who
- 25:37need Edward the 5th to become king.
- 25:39They've invested 12 years in preparing for his kingship in in
- 25:44placing, you know, their sons in his household, in building
- 25:47connections and ties that will serve them well while he's king.
- 25:50And as soon as Edward the 5th doesn't become king, all of that
- 25:52work is for nothing. You know, it all goes up in
- 25:55flames. So that causes a severe problem
- 25:57for another group of people. And the third option with the
- 26:01bigamy story is simply that it's true.
- 26:03It's the one that people tend to laugh at and think, you know,
- 26:05it's just just too convenient. My argument is always that I
- 26:09think this is is potentially the least convenient thing that
- 26:12happens for Richard. I mean, look, people for the
- 26:14last 500 years have called him a liar and a cheat.
- 26:17It's not convenient for him. It creates a crisis on top of
- 26:22several other crises that he's having to deal with.
- 26:27He has, he's sworn an oath of allegiance to his nephew Edward
- 26:30the 5th. He's caused other men throughout
- 26:32the the north of England and in London as soon as he arrived to
- 26:36swear oaths of allegiance to Edward the 5th.
- 26:38That's a really dangerous thing to then try to, to unpick, to
- 26:41undo. So it's not convenient, I don't
- 26:44think for Richard that the bigamy story emerges.
- 26:49And so again, I think where you fall on those kind of three
- 26:52options will probably depend on on what you think of Richard at
- 26:56the outset of this story. The one interesting thing that I
- 26:59will say, so we lack evidence to to examine, to think about the
- 27:05validity of the the bigamy story.
- 27:08But we have sources that tell us that in 1483 that evidence was
- 27:12presented. It was presented to the
- 27:14authorities of London and it was presented to people who had
- 27:19arrived in London for a session of Parliament.
- 27:21So Parliament isn't sitting at the moment.
- 27:23So I can't say that you know, the document that the evidence
- 27:25is presented to Parliament, but it's presented to to those
- 27:28people that would make up a sitting of Parliament.
- 27:31And we're told that they examine that evidence and they believe
- 27:35that that evidence proves bigamy and they declare Edward the
- 27:38Fourth children illegitimate. Now we can't look at that
- 27:41evidence because it hasn't survived.
- 27:44But what we do know is that people in 1483 who saw that
- 27:47evidence believed it. So I think it's really tricky
- 27:50for us to turn around without the benefit of being able to see
- 27:53that evidence and say, well, they are all stupid and they
- 27:56clearly fell for a trick. I think the the reason that the
- 27:59evidence probably doesn't survive is because when Richard
- 28:03when Richard loses his life at Bosworth and loses the throne
- 28:07and is succeeded by Henry Tudor, Henry the 7th, he then marries
- 28:12the oldest daughter of Edward the 4th Elizabeth of York.
- 28:16She has been made illegitimate by all of this, this process of
- 28:21illegitimizing her brothers and he he needs her to no longer be
- 28:25illegitimate for him to marry her.
- 28:27So the Act of Parliament that makes Edward the 4th bigamy kind
- 28:31of legal and his children illegitimate is is stricken from
- 28:36the the records without being read in Parliament, which is
- 28:38highly unusual. Henry orders all the copies of
- 28:41it to be returned to be burned. The only copies that survive are
- 28:45one that remains on the the Parliament role in the Tower of
- 28:48London and one that is hidden in a library at Crowland Abbey,
- 28:52which should have been returned. Someone took a big risk to hide
- 28:55that. If Henry is destroying all of
- 28:59those copies of Titulus Regius of the the Act of Parliament
- 29:03that talks about the bigamy, he's got to have destroyed the
- 29:06evidence that went along with it that was shown to people and
- 29:10which was accepted as proving the bigamy because he can't have
- 29:13that evidence lying around. You know, if that evidence was
- 29:15so weak that it it was laughable, surely Henry would
- 29:19have shown it to everybody and said, look, you know, what kind
- 29:21of a fool is going to believe any of this nonsense?
- 29:24The fact that he doesn't do that suggests to me that there was
- 29:27pretty strong evidence out there.
- 29:29So when people are are, I think people are sometimes too quick
- 29:32to laugh off the idea that the bigamy story just might be true.
- 29:35Well, the thing I, I've always wondered is because as, as I've
- 29:38mentioned, like my life obsession is the Roman Empire,
- 29:40right? And if I, and if I look at what
- 29:42Augustus does when he becomes the first emperor, well, he
- 29:45starts paying for literature to be written.
- 29:48He's handling decency laws. He's handling laws around who
- 29:51can marry and how can marry and try to try to make people
- 29:53procreate. So when someone is trying to
- 29:56establish something new, they often try to handle things from
- 29:59the past to make it like their new thing is legitimate.
- 30:02And you have to look at Henry Tudor and wonder, you know, even
- 30:04the Tudor rose, right? A lot of what he did is to
- 30:07legitimize a guy that they're kind of like, you're really far
- 30:11away from being legitimate. How did you get here?
- 30:14Absolutely. And the Tudor Rose is so
- 30:15interesting because the we think of the Wars of the Roses as the
- 30:19red rose of Lancaster and the White Rose of York.
- 30:22And whilst the White Rose is a badge that the House of York
- 30:24used, the House of Lancaster never used a red rose as a
- 30:27badge. Henry Tudor literally invents
- 30:30this as a piece of PR, you know, as a logo.
- 30:33It's perfect. It's it's used today by
- 30:36organisations all over the place.
- 30:37You see it on the side of historic buildings still today.
- 30:39So more than 500 years later, it's still successful PR, but
- 30:47Henry is is reinventing himself as the the man who ends the Wars
- 30:52of the Roses. He very much doesn't because
- 30:55there is a battle in Stoke in 1487.
- 30:58He faces pretenders throughout the the 1480s and 1490s.
- 31:04He faces threats into the next century.
- 31:06And his son Henry the eighth will face threats as well from
- 31:08from Yorkist families, from particularly the the de la Pole
- 31:12family. So 1485 is not the end of the
- 31:16Wars of the Roses. What we've been sold is an
- 31:19absolutely incredible piece of PR by Henry Tudor that says, you
- 31:23know, Bosworth bang done, I've finished it.
- 31:28It's it's, it's Lord Stanley crowns him and we're we're ready
- 31:31to go. So it it is kind of a really
- 31:33interesting thing to look at. But I guess looking at as well,
- 31:36you know, we talked about succession and one of the the
- 31:39things that's talked about very often is, well, what happens to
- 31:42the boys in the tower And we speaking about Edward's Edward
- 31:46the fourth children at this point in time.
- 31:48Now I know we don't know a ton about what actually happened to
- 31:51them and some of those views are modern license.
- 31:53They are. There's a lot of research
- 31:56projects going on this too, which are quite interesting that
- 31:58that viewpoint may be changing. But I guess from your view, what
- 32:02happened to the boys in the Tower and what do we know about
- 32:04it? We know for certain very little.
- 32:08So again you kind of get 2 polar opposite versions of what might
- 32:11have happened to the Princess. The generally accepted story is
- 32:15that they were murdered in probably the, the autumn, late
- 32:18autumn of 1483, perhaps around late September, October 1483.
- 32:23But there is no recorded date for the last time that they're
- 32:25sighted. They're, they're seen playing in
- 32:28the grounds of the tower throughout the summer of 1483
- 32:31and eventually seen less and less in, in the grounds of the
- 32:34tower. And that seems to come to an end
- 32:37towards let's say maybe late September, early October 1483.
- 32:42So the, the prevailing wisdom, I guess has been that they were
- 32:46killed before the end of 1483 and most likely on the orders of
- 32:49their uncle Richard the third, who perceived them as a threat.
- 32:54People quite often say that Richard killed them so that he
- 32:56could become king. That simply factually incorrect
- 32:59because he's king from the end of June 1483.
- 33:01So if they're still alive in September, October, he's not
- 33:03killing them to become king because he already is king.
- 33:07If he's removing them, it's because they are potentially a
- 33:10threat to his throne. He's he's had them declared
- 33:15illegitimate, but that could be reversed in parliament as easily
- 33:18as it's been put in place. You know, we see attained As for
- 33:20treason being done and reversed all the way through the walls of
- 33:23the Roses. So I, I don't necessarily think
- 33:26that they cease being a threat to Richard.
- 33:28I do think they are a problem that he's going to have to deal
- 33:31with. The question is whether you see
- 33:32Richard as a man who's kind of first response to a crisis is to
- 33:35think the only way out of this is to murder some children.
- 33:38A 12 year old and a nine year old.
- 33:40My 2 nephews, I'm just going to kill them.
- 33:42Yeah. And you can't see that anywhere
- 33:45else in his in his make up in his career.
- 33:49If this is a man who we have tons and tons and tons of
- 33:52evidence of him favouring the the lot of the common man
- 33:57against those higher up the social scale than them.
- 34:00A man who is genuinely concerned for equity and and law, a man
- 34:05who who doesn't, you know, murder people without due
- 34:09process of the law. We could talk about Lord
- 34:12Hastings. I think he undergoes a a
- 34:14perfunctory trial under a court martial, which Richard has the
- 34:18power to do as constable of England and is executed for
- 34:20treason. The other option is that Richard
- 34:25recognizes that his nephews are a potential threat, that there
- 34:28are people in the country, as I mentioned before, who are going
- 34:30to want Edward the 5th to be king because they've put all of
- 34:33their eggs in an Edward the 5th shaped basket for a very, very
- 34:35long time by this point. He recognizes that, but his his
- 34:40first choice isn't murder. It's perhaps to try and and hide
- 34:44the boys. So there is a a kind of
- 34:49blueprint that he might be looking at here that is part of
- 34:51his own family history. So his great uncle was a man
- 34:54named Edmund Mortimer the 5th early of March.
- 34:57And Edmund and his little brother were small children.
- 35:00I think they're sort of eight and and six in 1399 when Henry
- 35:05the 4th deposes Richard the Second.
- 35:08Now Henry the 4th is not by most measures the rightful heir of
- 35:13Richard the Second. There are lots of people who
- 35:15would have considered the mortem as the Mortimer family LED at
- 35:18this point by Edmund who is just a small boy unable to press his
- 35:21own claim. And what Henry the 4th does with
- 35:24those two boys who are very real threats to his throne.
- 35:26There is a there is a an attempt to abduct them and take them to
- 35:29Wales and have Edmund crowned king, which Henry manages to to
- 35:33foil and get the boys back. But they are a very real threat
- 35:36to to Henry the 4th throne. What he doesn't do is kill them.
- 35:40What he does is initially he keeps them in a fairly open
- 35:44loose custody at Windsor Castle. Everybody knows where they are.
- 35:47They're eventually abducted from Windsor Castle.
- 35:49As I mentioned, an effort is made to to make Edmund King
- 35:52Henry gets them back. And from that point onwards,
- 35:55their location is kept much more of a secret.
- 35:58So they are moved more often and it's not broadcast where they
- 36:03are anymore. And then as soon as Henry the
- 36:064th dies in 1413, so 14 years later, his son becomes Henry the
- 36:12Fifth. And one of the first things
- 36:13Henry the Fifth does is release the 21 year old Edmund, who is
- 36:18fifth, early of March. An incredibly wealthy and
- 36:20powerful nobleman, possibly the the richest nobleman in the
- 36:23country at this point. He releases Edmund and his
- 36:28brother Roger. Roger dies a few years later.
- 36:31Edmund goes on to serve the House of Lancaster until 1425,
- 36:34when he died. And as I mentioned, he's he's
- 36:37Richard, the third great uncle. So this is part of Richard's
- 36:40family story as well as a blueprint in your near living
- 36:47memory for some people of what you might do if you're a king
- 36:52whose claim to the throne is challenged.
- 36:55And when you have two children who some people might think have
- 36:58a better claim to the throne or they might prefer as king, and
- 37:00it doesn't involve murdering your own nephews, the sons of a
- 37:05brother who you've served faithfully for, for 15 years by
- 37:09this point. And and, you know, just
- 37:13murdering children, It's it's. Yeah, it is just a horrible
- 37:17thing. The reason the story of the
- 37:18Princess in the Tower sticks in people's minds is because it's
- 37:21so horrific and it stands out. And I think those are the
- 37:25reasons that Richard would have wanted to avoid doing that.
- 37:28You know, maybe he would have reached a point when those boys
- 37:30were of of adult age where he'd felt like he couldn't, he
- 37:34couldn't contain the threat that they posed and he could deal
- 37:36with them as adults. But I don't see him as someone
- 37:40who, you know, sits on his throne and thinks, do you know
- 37:43what? I'm going to have to kill some
- 37:45children. I think you can't you can't find
- 37:48that Richard in his story up until that point.
- 37:52And that doesn't mean that, you know, in a crisis, he didn't
- 37:54snap and, and do it absolutely can't tell you that he
- 37:57definitely didn't do it. So the interesting research that
- 38:00that's been going on recently is by a group called the Missing
- 38:03Princess project. And, and this is, I mean, aside
- 38:06from what they might find, what they have found and what they
- 38:09might find going forward, is it an absolutely fantastic project?
- 38:13So this is, is kind of citizen researchers going into their
- 38:15local archives across the UK and across the continent and looking
- 38:19through documents. And, and I've spoken to, to
- 38:22researchers on that project who have talked about, you know,
- 38:25slipping their fingers under the seal of a document that hasn't
- 38:27been open for over 500 years. No one has read this stuff.
- 38:30It's not catalogued anywhere. No one knows what it says.
- 38:33And it's that moment of, you know, you open it and it's, is
- 38:36this going to tell me what happened to the Princess in the
- 38:38Tower or is it some boring financial document that doesn't
- 38:41mean anything? And they found a couple of
- 38:44really interesting things. So 1 is a document that that
- 38:47claims to be a life story of Richard, Duke of York, the
- 38:51younger of the Princess in the Tower.
- 38:53And this is a story dictated by the person that history
- 38:56remembers as Perkin Warbeck, who threatens Henry the 7th in the
- 39:001490s, claiming to be the younger of the Princess in the
- 39:02Tower. The one of the other key
- 39:04documents they found is a receipt for some weapons for the
- 39:07the 1487 invasion of England that led to the Battle of Stoke
- 39:10that I mentioned earlier. And this talks about that
- 39:13invasion being in favour of Edward the 5th, whereas history
- 39:17normally talks about it being in favour of Edward, Earl of
- 39:20Warwick and led by an impostor by the name of, of Lambert
- 39:24Simmel. So again, you know, I think with
- 39:27Lambert Simmel and Perkin Warbeck, we have to look at
- 39:29Henry the 7th as this kind of master of PR and spin.
- 39:33And he's, he sold us a story for hundreds and hundreds and
- 39:36hundreds of years. And I simply don't think that
- 39:38it's true. So I I wrote a.
- 39:40Book I'm trying to remember if I was on your show or on history
- 39:42hit too that I that I heard them talking about in some of these
- 39:46sources. The way Richard the 5th is
- 39:48written about they they would have mentions his name
- 39:51differently if he had passed. Is that correct?
- 39:54Yeah, so there are, there are a number of documents.
- 39:57I mean, again, if we think the Prince and the tower are dead,
- 39:59we, we never have any recorded masses said for the souls of
- 40:03those boys. We never have a public
- 40:06accusation of murder, particularly against Richard or
- 40:09against anybody else made by their mother, who outlives
- 40:13Richard the Third by seven years.
- 40:15By any of their sisters, who all live into the 16th century and
- 40:18never, ever say that their brothers are dead and that Uncle
- 40:21Richard killed them. And perhaps most strikingly, we
- 40:24never have an accusation against Richard the 3rd for killing the
- 40:26Princess in the Tower from Henry the 7th, the person who has the
- 40:29most to gain from accusing his predecessor of killing children.
- 40:33He simply doesn't say it. And there are references that
- 40:37talk about the boys. There's documents that are
- 40:40written up in 1484 that talk about Edward the 5th and they
- 40:43don't refer to him as the late Edward the 5th or, you know, of
- 40:48blessed memory and things like that.
- 40:49In the same way that they talk about his father immediately
- 40:51after his death. So the way that they are,
- 40:55they're not mentioned very often.
- 40:56Absolutely. But when they are mentioned,
- 40:58they're not mentioned as as the poor deceased Princess in the
- 41:01Tower. It's just perfunctory mentions
- 41:04to to Edward, a former king of England or, or you know, he's,
- 41:09he's sometimes called Edward Bastard or Lord Bastard or Lord
- 41:13Edward and, and things like that.
- 41:14So you get this array of ways in which they're referred to, but
- 41:16never as deceased. And so you add up all of those
- 41:20things that, you know, no recorded masses, no accusations
- 41:24from the immediate family ever made public against Richard the
- 41:27Third, mentioning them as if they're still alive.
- 41:31And and you have to start to wonder, you know, we're often
- 41:34told that everybody believed they were dead by the end of
- 41:361483. I simply don't think that that's
- 41:38true. So when we look at Richard's
- 41:41rule, you know, he mentioned he, he ruled for a little over 2
- 41:45years. Like it wasn't a long reign.
- 41:48What was that time period like for him?
- 41:50And, and I guess even in that, what sort of things was he
- 41:55dealing with? I mean, it was an incredibly
- 41:59fraught couple of years. So he faces his first rebellion
- 42:02in October 1483. So what four months, three, 3
- 42:061/2 months, four months after becoming king, he's facing a a
- 42:09major armed rebellion led by the Duke of Buckingham, who is a man
- 42:13who had been at Richard's side and had helped him to secure his
- 42:18position on the throne. And the questions around that
- 42:21are often, you know, what is bucking him up to?
- 42:23Has he has he murdered the Princess?
- 42:25Buckingham is one of the other suspects, if you believe the
- 42:27Princess in the tower have been killed.
- 42:29Has he murdered them and fallen out with Richard as a result?
- 42:32Has he found out that Richard's killed them and and so is so
- 42:35disgusted that he turns against against Richard for this?
- 42:40My my strong suspicion is that Buckingham has his head turned
- 42:44by Margaret Beaufort and and the the faction that she is building
- 42:50and Margaret Beaufort is his aunt and I think that he's
- 42:53encouraged to claim the throne. He has perhaps the the next best
- 42:57Lancastrian claim still in existence.
- 43:01He is perhaps next in line to the throne after Richard the 3rd
- 43:06and his his son Edward of Midland.
- 43:09So I think the the October 1483 rebellion is about putting
- 43:12Buckingham on the throne and undoubtedly I think Margaret is
- 43:14looking to bring her son Henry Tudor back from from exile as
- 43:17part of this. But I don't think at this point
- 43:19she envisages him being king. That comes a little later after
- 43:23the failure of that uprising. So Edward Richard the Third has
- 43:27a stroke of luck in that the weather is absolutely terrible
- 43:30when this uprising breaks out. Some people go a little bit too
- 43:33early and the plot is uncovered. It rains a lot along the Welsh
- 43:37border, so Buckingham can't bring his armies out of Wales.
- 43:41And he, Richard manages to to quash this rebellion.
- 43:43Buckingham is caught and he's beheaded.
- 43:46And it's only after this that Henry Tudor starts to be talked
- 43:49about as a potential claimant to the throne.
- 43:51And so then the the story of the rest of Richard's reign is
- 43:55largely about him trying to get his hands on Henry Tudor, who
- 43:59you know, is, is the last threat to his throne that is beyond his
- 44:03control. Edward the 4th have been trying
- 44:05to get his hands on Henry Tudor for years and years too.
- 44:07So he's just continuing his brother's policy and trying to
- 44:09do this. There are there are other one of
- 44:13the most interesting things about Richard the third reign, I
- 44:15think, is the one Parliament that he holds in early 1484.
- 44:19It's been held up for for centuries, even by people who
- 44:22aren't fans of Richard the Third who think he's a terrible,
- 44:24terrible person. His parliament has been held up
- 44:27as as one of the most, I think someone described it as one of
- 44:30the most meritorious since the reign of Henry the Third.
- 44:33And the reign of Henry the third was when Parliament first
- 44:35emerged. So you're talking about, you
- 44:37know, one of the best parliaments ever potentially.
- 44:40And and they were wrapped up in in this parliament.
- 44:42There are lots of reforms to bail.
- 44:45And again, it, it continues Richard's interest in the lot of
- 44:49the, the common man against those with more political power
- 44:52in society than they have, which is, is what he'd been interested
- 44:56in as Duke of Gloucester in the North.
- 44:58I mean, his reforms to bail kind of equate to the emergence of
- 45:00the idea of being innocent until you're proven guilty.
- 45:02It's, it's that kind of important, the stuff that he's
- 45:05doing lots of work around property, land sales and things
- 45:11like that and weights and measures, all sorts of stuff.
- 45:15Alongside that, he also has the to the, there's perhaps the, the
- 45:19interest in his, his parliament, which, you know, it's a
- 45:22parliament that's hard to reconcile with the guy who kills
- 45:24children. To be honest.
- 45:26He's got the political problems of a rebellion in October 1483
- 45:30and of, of Henry Tudor still being on the loose on the
- 45:33continent in, in Brittany and later in France.
- 45:37And then he also suffers a good deal of personal tragedy too.
- 45:40So in the spring of 1484, his only legitimate son, he has an
- 45:46illegitimate son and daughter from believed to be from before
- 45:48he was married. His only legitimate son, the
- 45:51Prince of Wales. He's also called Edward, Edward
- 45:54of Midland. He passes away, unfortunately,
- 45:56at the age of maybe about 7 or 8.
- 46:00And so Richard and his wife Anne, face that kind of personal
- 46:03tragedy at the beginning of 1485.
- 46:07Anne also passes away. It's believed that she she died
- 46:11of consumption, which is the medieval term for tuberculosis.
- 46:16It it seems like that's a phrase you hear a lot in medieval
- 46:19history. By the way, I guess there's a
- 46:20side note that there seems to be a lot of people suffering from
- 46:23tuberculosis, which is quite interesting.
- 46:25Yeah, I mean, you know, it's so highly contagious and they
- 46:27simply can't treat it. So there's there's no way around
- 46:30it. Anne's sister had actually died
- 46:32of of tuberculosis of consumption several years
- 46:34earlier as well. So in in the immediate aftermath
- 46:39of that tragedy, this is a woman who's been his wife by this
- 46:42point for 14 years, something like that.
- 46:45They'd worked incredibly closely together.
- 46:46They'd just been both devastated by the loss of their their son.
- 46:50And sources talk about them being inconsolable when their
- 46:53son had died. And in the immediate aftermath
- 46:55of that, Richard faces accusations both that he had
- 46:58murdered his wife, that he poisoned Nan, and also that he's
- 47:02planning to marry his own niece, Elizabeth of York.
- 47:05So the the oldest daughter of Edward the 4th.
- 47:08And there's simply no evidence to back either of those stories
- 47:10up. They are contemporary though.
- 47:12I mean, Richard stands in the in the centre of London and issues
- 47:15a public denial of any intention to to marry his niece.
- 47:19That's how serious it is for him.
- 47:21And and that's, I think by this point, that's a really good
- 47:24indication of just how weak Richard's position has become.
- 47:27The fact that he is forced to to make this public declaration.
- 47:31What seems to actually have been going on is that when his wife
- 47:35died, Richard, you know, he's, he now needs a, a new heir, he
- 47:38needs a son. So he looks to to be planning to
- 47:42marry again either to a Spanish or a Portuguese Princess.
- 47:45And the interesting things about the Spanish and the Portuguese
- 47:47princesses at this point is both of those royal families are
- 47:50packed with Lancastrian blood. So John have Gaunt had married
- 47:53two of his daughters, 1 into the Portuguese royal family and one
- 47:56to the Spanish. So here is Richard, you know,
- 47:58trying to reconcile the red and white roses in in 1485 in a way
- 48:04that Henry Tudor will later claim that he is done.
- 48:07He seems to Richard seems to agree on a match with a Princess
- 48:11from Portugal named Joanna. And as part of that agreement,
- 48:15there is also a marriage arranged between Elizabeth of
- 48:18York and Manuel, who is the Duke of Beho and will later become
- 48:22King Manuel, the first of of Portugal.
- 48:25So that that arrangement is being played out.
- 48:28And clearly someone is kind of twisting that story to suggest
- 48:32that Richard is planning to marry his own niece.
- 48:34So rather than a marriage for Richard and a marriage for his
- 48:36niece, someone is is bending that against Richard to turn it
- 48:41into a story that he's planning to marry his own niece.
- 48:43And you know, I strongly suspect Margaret Beaufort and her
- 48:45faction are behind well. That that's always been my
- 48:47question on Richard is if you look at how Richard the third is
- 48:50treated in history, you also look at when Shakespeare is
- 48:53writing, he's writing during the Tudor reign and, and into a bit
- 48:58of James the first's reign as well.
- 49:00See, you have to wonder. A lot of these things just seem
- 49:03to serve Henry the 7th, right. Like to, to, to kind of make it
- 49:06look like, you know, he's bringing peace or in some ways
- 49:09or he's handling some bad king. It just seems like it's really,
- 49:12really convenient for him, if that makes sense.
- 49:15Yeah, I and I said, you know, I think, excuse me.
- 49:19As I said before, I think his great PR victory is convincing
- 49:24us all that he ended the Wars of the Roses when he demonstrably
- 49:27didn't of having the the White Rose and the red rose and
- 49:31smashing them together to create the Tudor rose.
- 49:33When you know, the red rose is just an invented badge that he's
- 49:35created so that he can create the Tudor rose.
- 49:38I think one of the other things that Henry has to do, you know,
- 49:43in August 1485, at the Battle of Bosworth, he has invaded England
- 49:46and killed God's anointed king. He needs Richard to be Richard,
- 49:52to be the the darkest character that he can possibly be, because
- 49:56he needs a way to excuse the fact that he did that.
- 49:58He needs to be saving England from a monster.
- 50:01If he's going to be the good guy, then he has to have beaten
- 50:03the bad guy, which means Richard has to be the bad guy.
- 50:06The early Tudor security relies utterly on a belief that the
- 50:10Princess in the Tower can't come back and threaten Henry anymore,
- 50:14and that Richard was so evil that he deserved to be deposed
- 50:18and that Henry has done the country a favour by doing it.
- 50:21And so Tudor security relies utterly on on darkening the name
- 50:27of Richard the 3rd and blaming him for for all kinds of stuff.
- 50:31And you this idea of him as a tyrant who would go so far as to
- 50:34murder children only serves the Tudor regime.
- 50:38It it isn't backed up by any facts or any evidence that we
- 50:41have. He, he rules in a way that is
- 50:43almost diametrically opposed to the way a tyrant would rule.
- 50:47And I find it really hard to believe that he would have
- 50:49murdered the Princess in the Tower as a kind of first
- 50:51reaction to the crises that he found himself in in 1483.
- 50:56Those things only suit Henry Tudor.
- 50:58You know, he sold us this idea that he ended the Wars of the
- 51:01Roses. He sold us the Tudor rose.
- 51:03I think he sold us the bad reputation of Richard the 3rd
- 51:06and the murder of the Princess in the Tower too.
- 51:08Well, I think we're definitely in agreement on that because
- 51:10it's. It's the more I read about Henry
- 51:12Tudor, the more suspect I I see. And also, as I said, when you
- 51:16look at when Shakespeare's writing, a lot of the culture
- 51:18that we're dealing with is still for the most part being written
- 51:22during the Tudor reign. So why would you want to make
- 51:23The Tudors look bad? And I think there's also we
- 51:26forget that. Shakespeare is writing, so I
- 51:28think there's a I'll try and be as brief as I can with this
- 51:30because it's it's a long story. I think there's a really
- 51:33interesting bit of context to Shakespeare's Rich to the third
- 51:36to we often forget that that he's writing a play for
- 51:40entertainment in the middle of the the 1590s.
- 51:43He's writing Richard the 3rd and so much of, of what we expect to
- 51:48see in in theatre then and perhaps on TV and things like
- 51:52now. It, it has to speak to people in
- 51:55the moment. You know, it has to be something
- 51:56that they connect with in their everyday lives for it to be
- 52:01entertaining and watchable and meaningful for them.
- 52:04And you can interpret, there is a, a way of interpreting Richard
- 52:06the Third that is, is utterly contemporary to the 1590s.
- 52:10So in the 1590s we've got an ageing Elizabeth the First who
- 52:13is very clearly never going to have a son.
- 52:15She's never going to have an heir, which leaves the question
- 52:18of what's going to come next. We know that the Cecil family,
- 52:23so William Cecil and his son Robert are, are planning for the
- 52:28succession of James the 6th of Scotland, who will become James
- 52:32the first of England, who is a Protestant.
- 52:35There are plenty in the country who would rather have a Catholic
- 52:38monarch back on the throne. And, you know, there is a school
- 52:42of thought that says Shakespeare was maybe a recalcitrant
- 52:44Catholic. Certainly lots of his patrons
- 52:46were recalcitrant Catholics who may have favoured a Catholic
- 52:51succession. So when I talked earlier about,
- 52:54you know, we as an audience, we watched Richard the Third, you
- 52:57know, lurching around the stage telling us he's going to commit
- 52:59all of these diabolical acts. And we laugh along with him and
- 53:01we let him get away with it. To a contemporary audience, I
- 53:05think they would have understood that they were watching late
- 53:08Tudor politics playing out. Someone is planning and plotting
- 53:12the succession in plain sight of the king of Scotland, of a
- 53:16Protestant monarch. And everybody is just letting
- 53:18them get away with it. And one, one of the most
- 53:20interesting things about this is that when we think of
- 53:22Shakespeare's Richard the Third, we think about the guy with
- 53:27forward curvature of the spine, which is is cruelly called the
- 53:30hunchback. So Shakespeare calls him a bunch
- 53:32back and yes, we know that Richard had scoliosis now, so
- 53:35that sideways curvature of the spine, but it's a very different
- 53:38look from that forward curvature of the spine caused by kyphosis.
- 53:43And we know that he he kind of limps and he talks about having
- 53:46a withered arm and all of this kind of thing.
- 53:48And the most interesting thing I think about this is that Robert
- 53:50Cecil, so William Cecil's son, Robert Cecil, who becomes Earl
- 53:53of Salisbury and James the 1st and 6th is documented to to have
- 53:59suffered with kyphosis. He had forward curvature of the
- 54:03spying that Shakespeare gives to his Richard the 3rd.
- 54:06And he's described, as you know, an I'll formed imp in in sources
- 54:10from people who who met him and he's described as scheming and
- 54:15all of those kinds of things. And the descriptions fit
- 54:17Shakespeare's Richard the third absolutely perfectly.
- 54:20So I think you can interpret that play as actually being a, a
- 54:24reference to modern politics, kind of using history as a way
- 54:27of packaging that up. So that that Richard the Third
- 54:31in the 1590s, I think an audience watching Shakespeare's
- 54:34Richard the Third would have watched his characters come onto
- 54:36the stage and would have been elbowing each other going, it's
- 54:38Robert Cecil. It's Robert Cecil.
- 54:41And you're going to watch him plot evil things in plain sight
- 54:45and you're going to let him get away with it.
- 54:47You know, it's funny. I did not know that Robert
- 54:49Cecil. By the way, I'm watching the the
- 54:51HBO series Gunpowder right now and I was wondering why the
- 54:55character they have playing Robert Cecil is kind of walking
- 54:57like this. So I guess that makes sense to
- 54:59me. Well, Matt, I've.
- 55:02Really enjoyed this conversation.
- 55:04And I'm so grateful to you giving me some time because as I
- 55:06said, I've really enjoyed listening to your show, and I
- 55:09continue not to miss a new episode.
- 55:11So for people watching, how can they connect with you and how
- 55:13can they find out more about what you're doing?
- 55:15Yeah, so you can find Dom Medieval.
- 55:19Podcast, wherever you get your podcasts from and echoes of
- 55:21history that I also do is is kind of the the history that's
- 55:24behind the Assassin's Creed games.
- 55:27I am on Instagram at Matt Lewis. History I am on, I want to say
- 55:32Twitter X. It's always going to be Twitter
- 55:34really, isn't it? I have a hard time
- 55:36differentiating myself. Yeah, yeah.
- 55:39So. I'm, I'm, you know, fairly
- 55:41active on social media on Facebook as well.
- 55:45So you can find me kind of almost anywhere if you if you
- 55:47want to find me and hear me waffling about medieval history
- 55:49a bit more awesome. Well, Matt Lewis, thank you so
- 55:51much for hanging out with me today.
- 55:52For those of you watching, reminder to like this video,
- 55:55leave us a comment and smash that subscribe button.
- 55:57If you want to learn more of history's mysteries.
- 56:00Have a good one everyone.