Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.34 Peatlands, Carbon, and the Public Inquiry with Alessandra Accogli & Elena Aitova
Transcript
- 0:00Paul, hello and welcome to the Save Our Sperrins podcast,
- 0:08voices from the frontline. This podcast comes from the sperm
- 0:12mountains in Northern Ireland. It's a place shaped by land, by
- 0:17community and by long memory, and it's now living with growing
- 0:22pressure from mining and large scale upland development.
- 0:27That pressure isn't unique to here.
- 0:30Across the world, a so called energy transition is driving
- 0:35ever more extraction. There's growing demand for critical
- 0:39minerals and rare earth metals, and that demand is landing on
- 0:44local communities, asking them to live with the long term
- 0:48impacts of toxic mining. Season one looked at why the sperm
- 0:53mountains matter through the voices of the people who live
- 0:56here and know this place well. Season Two keeps those local
- 1:01voices at the centre, while also stepping back a bit. In season
- 1:06two, we look at extractivism more broadly, how it's been
- 1:10justified, how it is fundamental to a system of accelerated
- 1:14growth, plundering evermore from a finite planet designed only to
- 1:19feed predatory capitalism creating untold and
- 1:23unprecedented misery simply to support the bottom line of a
- 1:27balance sheet in some distant, glass walled boardroom far from
- 1:32the ground that we stand on. Thanks for listening, and let's
- 1:37begin. My guests today are Alexandra okoli and Elena itova.
- 1:44Alexandra works in environmental and climate law, with particular
- 1:48focus on how peatlands are treated within planning and
- 1:52climate policy. She authored a report on the Delray and gold
- 1:57mining application that looked closely at how peatland
- 2:00extraction sat alongside stated climate commitments and where
- 2:05there were gaps and inconsistencies between policy
- 2:08language and what was actually being proposed. On the ground
- 2:14her work sits in the difficult space where climate targets,
- 2:18legal obligations and real places collide looking at how
- 2:23effective policy protection is when there is unrelenting
- 2:26pressure for development and growth. Elena aytova is a PhD
- 2:32researcher working on greenhouse gas emissions from the Irish
- 2:36raised bogs. Her scientific work focuses on measuring carbon
- 2:41emissions directly and the impact of rewetting and
- 2:44restoring degraded peatlands. She also drafted the peatland
- 2:49rebuttal for save our sperms, bringing that scientific
- 2:52understanding into the planning process and helping translate
- 2:56measurements and monitoring into evidence that could be used
- 3:00publicly and legally.
- 3:02Hello, Alessandra and Elena, you are very welcome to the podcast.
- 3:07Alexandra, could you tell us a little about yourself and your
- 3:10work, and then, Elena, I'll come to you after that. Yes, yes, I
- 3:16can do that. And so I'm based in Dublin, so I'm currently in
- 3:21Dublin, and I've been living in Dublin for five years. So I
- 3:25actually came to Ireland from Italy. I'm originally Italian,
- 3:30and I came to Ireland for to start my PhD, so to do my PhD in
- 3:35law at the UCD Sutherland School of Law and and so that kept me
- 3:41busy for the past four years. And then after that, I started
- 3:47working in DCU as a post doctoral researcher and
- 3:51currently also teaching assistant lecturer, yeah, so
- 3:55that's me now. So I'm working in DCU and mainly working on
- 3:59climate change law and policy and human rights law as well.
- 4:04Those are my fields for research and work. So yeah, so that's me
- 4:08in a nutshell. Basically,
- 4:12what attracted you into that work? Yeah, that's a good
- 4:14question. So before actually coming to Ireland, I wasn't in
- 4:19Italy, I was in Belgium. So I did my undergraduate studies in
- 4:24Italy, but then I moved to Belgium for to continue kind of
- 4:28with work and also study. So in Belgium, I first was working
- 4:35with an NGO, but then I just felt I needed to go back to
- 4:39studying. And I did two masters there, and one of these was on
- 4:43political science and then public international law.
- 4:46Actually these two, when I was studying there as part of, you
- 4:52know, as well as working, I just became really interested in the
- 4:57cause of climate change. It was so that.
- 5:00Have been 2018, 2019, and I think just the debate on climate
- 5:05change was really interesting at the time. It was still it was
- 5:09still uncertain. So there was still voices kind of questioning
- 5:13whether, you know, the science was was consensual, or whether
- 5:18there was enough science. But then there were also people and
- 5:21scholars and researchers, as well as activists and other
- 5:25organisations kind of calling for action. And so I just, I
- 5:29just was intrigued by how the law could have been made better.
- 5:35What was the problem? What why? What was lacking in the law, or
- 5:40what was the role of the law in addressing climate change? So
- 5:43that's how I got to be wanting to kind of dig into that, and
- 5:47that's how I felt. I really wanted to do research. And then,
- 5:51yeah, that then I started the PhD.
- 5:55And
- 5:57Which part do you find the most interesting, the point of view
- 6:01of the role of the law,
- 6:04or the arguments about climate change, which, which?
- 6:09Which attracts you most, you know, which speaks to you most?
- 6:13Or is that a fair question? But perhaps it's equal. And I think
- 6:16I just brought the two aspects together because of my
- 6:19backgrounds, the my background would have been in law. So I
- 6:22think in addressing, in thinking about climate change, I would
- 6:26bring my own kind of perspective as a legal scholar. Now, well,
- 6:31at the time, I was just a law student, but yeah, so I think I
- 6:36just, you know, I used the lens that I knew the most, so the
- 6:41legal kind of lens to see whether the law could when you
- 6:46know how the law addressed the problem in the first place, and
- 6:49maybe how it could be made better, or whether there was an
- 6:53issue with the legal response to climate change. So I think I
- 6:56just brought them together myself because of my background.
- 7:00Yeah, okay, okay. And finally, sort of little question this,
- 7:06as you were growing up, had you much awareness, or when you were
- 7:09a younger woman, had you were you aware of climate change,
- 7:13that, as we call it, climate emergency at the stage, or has
- 7:17that more become more prevalent for you? No, I think it has
- 7:21become really prevalent. When I moved to Belgium, I think there
- 7:25was much more awareness. It just as a question of time. It was,
- 7:30it was a different time. But also, I come from a small place
- 7:35and small village in the south of Italy, I just don't think,
- 7:38even now, that the awareness that I have here in Ireland, in
- 7:42Dublin is a bit different. And then back home there is,
- 7:47obviously, there is much more awareness even there. But I
- 7:49don't know if it's just a question of being being related
- 7:53or linked to certain institutions and the work I do
- 7:56and all of that. But no, I think, I think I grew up with
- 8:00that awareness later on, I didn't, yeah, I didn't remember
- 8:05growing up with the awareness of climate change. No, okay, okay,
- 8:10so let's move it on a little bit. Can you explain to the
- 8:15listener how peatlands are protected by law in the Republic
- 8:20of Ireland? Just a general overview. You don't have to go
- 8:22into huge details. Yeah, yes, for sure. So what i Yeah, but
- 8:29what I say all the time when I ask, and what I'm asked this
- 8:32question, is the idea that maybe you know the first thing is that
- 8:36we need to understand that there isn't just maybe one law, one
- 8:39legal instrument, that is applicable to peatlands, but
- 8:42it's kind of a constellation. So I did this kind of in my
- 8:45research, this mapping of different laws that apply to
- 8:49peatlands. And first of all, the main one would be the main legal
- 8:56instrument would be the EU Habitats Directive, because that
- 9:00provides for designation of protected areas in the Republic
- 9:05of Ireland. And then so these these areas are designated. And
- 9:09the goal is to kind of preserve these natural features so that
- 9:15they can, you know, we can enjoy them for present and the future.
- 9:19And then another important piece of legislation is the
- 9:22environmental impact assessment directive, which basically
- 9:26provides for an assessment of the, you know, significant
- 9:32impacts that a specific project or plan can have on the
- 9:35environment. So as you can imagine, then, especially the
- 9:40Habitats Directive, with the designation of protected areas
- 9:42has created this divide between designated and non designated
- 9:48peatlands, and then the level of protection is different as well,
- 9:52because designated peatlands would have a stronger level of
- 9:55protection. It basically the main implication of this is
- 9:59limited.
- 10:00In land use activities that can happen on the land then. And
- 10:04just to keep in mind that obviously these laws were
- 10:08adopted with, you know, they didn't have the idea of
- 10:13peatlands as carbon sinks in mind. So peatlands as essential
- 10:18for mitigating climate change, they were mainly the goal of
- 10:21those laws was mainly to protect biodiversity and protect
- 10:26peatlands as natural habitats. And then more recently,
- 10:30peatlands have begun to be seen as important carbon sinks, so as
- 10:36storing, as absorbing and storing carbon, and so as
- 10:39essential also for climate mitigation, and that's that led
- 10:43to another system of protection, with targets to be achieved, and
- 10:47restoration targets and climate targets as well. So I can go in
- 10:52detail into that, if you want me to, but that's kind of a bit an
- 10:56overview on a general level. And
- 11:00do you feel
- 11:03in relation to the law
- 11:05that the peatlands are adequately protected right now?
- 11:09Or have you an opinion on that?
- 11:12It's a good question.
- 11:16The problem essentially with the law, especially in relation to
- 11:21my experience with the Republic of Ireland, is the lack of
- 11:26enforcement. So even if the law was there in terms of the
- 11:30designation, designation of protected areas, the enforcement
- 11:34has been lacking in a sense that, you know, still, let's
- 11:38say, land use activities that weren't supposed to happen. You
- 11:42know, continue to happen. You know, in terms of, I especially
- 11:46looked at pit extractions, both from an industrial and domestic
- 11:49perspective. So they continue to happen and and it's been
- 11:53difficult to to to lead to the cessation of those activities.
- 11:59And sometimes, you know, the problem is also related to how
- 12:03the law has been implemented. You know, with lack of, maybe
- 12:06involvement and consultation of, you know, people felt they have
- 12:10been kind of left behind in that kind of application of the EU
- 12:14law to the national level. So there is also an element of, you
- 12:19know, how things are done in terms of implementing the law,
- 12:22but I would say that
- 12:25it's mainly a kind of a lack of enforcement and and taking
- 12:29different considerations into account when you implement the
- 12:34law. So not just the fact that you're trying to protect the
- 12:37ecosystem as natural habitat, but also maybe considering what
- 12:42was, what was there before doing that. So, you know, obviously
- 12:46there were people involved and people interacting with the
- 12:48ecosystem, so it's important, and that's kind of the approach
- 12:52and the I try to promote in the research, to consider this
- 12:55ecosystem as holistic space. And so also the response has to be a
- 13:00bit more realistic and consider different interests at stake.
- 13:05Yeah, I often notice there's quite a bit of resistance to
- 13:08traditional methods of removing traditional methods of
- 13:13harvesting turf in the bog. There are some people who want
- 13:18to continue it because they see it as a traditional rice, and I
- 13:22suppose, when they were foot and turf, using a spade as a
- 13:25completely different animal from using tractor and cutting, as we
- 13:30used to call it, maggot turf, you know, the big, long rules
- 13:33that is, there still much resistance around the country to
- 13:38the removal, you know, to removal of that right to cut
- 13:41turf. Do some people are some people still allowed to cut it,
- 13:45and do they have to cut it by hand? Or where does that do, you
- 13:49know, perhaps you don't know about that, yeah, like it's, I
- 13:52think there is still resistance in terms of, yeah, domestic turf
- 13:57cashing. Certainly,
- 14:00the the practice has changed, as you were pointing out that it's
- 14:03not is no longer just hand cashing practices, but more like
- 14:09being cut by machinery, oftentimes by contractors on
- 14:13behalf of of the people with the tarberry rights, with the right
- 14:18cut turf. But then you know, still, still, it is considered
- 14:22pretty much
- 14:24a traditional activities or a cultural practice in terms of,
- 14:28then, you know, the stocking and the drying of the peach is done,
- 14:33seen in a kind of a traditional way. So what I've done, I did
- 14:36look into this, the domestic the dimension of catching turf for
- 14:42domestic purposes, so for household fuel in my research,
- 14:47and I did so I used, and I don't know if that's of interest, but
- 14:51I did use, I did try to see if this cultural practice can fall
- 14:57within the scope of the of a human right to.
- 15:00Or to take part in cultural life under international law.
- 15:05Basically, what I came down to is that, you know, I kind of
- 15:09devised this different criteria that can be applied to see
- 15:13whether that's the case. So there is a collective dimension,
- 15:15this place based dimension, the temporal dimension, and there's
- 15:20collective meaning dimension. And you know, the breaking point
- 15:24for me was precisely the purpose for which the caching is done,
- 15:28so whether it is for domestic use or whether it is for
- 15:32commercial so selling the teeth on our
- 15:37big scale, and often associated with black market and, you know,
- 15:41with the use of of the, you know, this black economy
- 15:45sometimes. So, you know, that's where kind of it was, the
- 15:47breaking point of where it didn't really match. Then with
- 15:51the cultural understanding of the practice the Republic of
- 15:55Ireland as well. It's not so much about cutting beat for
- 16:01heating the houses. Now it's about cutting peat for
- 16:05horticulture. Oh, yeah, yeah. Kind of getting bigger and
- 16:09bigger issue, and bigger proportion of peat are cut for
- 16:12this rather than for the houses. And it's interesting to look on
- 16:18this issue from completely different direction
- 16:22all the houses. So it's not about cutting pit it's about
- 16:26keeping warm in winter. And this could be done in different ways.
- 16:31So we can tackle this problem from different direction.
- 16:35Provide people grants for upgrading their houses
- 16:41accessible other sources I am to keep warm in winter. And again,
- 16:48like I like asking people, when they see them, what would they
- 16:51do? How they do? And I have people I live in, in the houses
- 16:56where they don't have any other option, for example, but then
- 17:00they would love to change to something less labour intensive,
- 17:05younger generation. So my perspective, it's maybe it's not
- 17:10as big issue anymore, because I'm sure
- 17:15our generation would love to use less labour and then in their
- 17:21houses and go through different routes again, like retrofitting
- 17:24the houses, but then we still left with the issues of
- 17:28horticulture,
- 17:31which is huge in the Republic of Ireland. Yeah, would have been
- 17:36involved in the horticultural industry back many years ago,
- 17:40and I was often involved in nurseries which were based
- 17:44around the bog of Allen there, you know. So I do know that
- 17:47tonnes and tonnes and tonnes of peat dusters was being used for
- 17:51horticultural products. I actually thought that had
- 17:53stopped that they were buying in peat from abroad, somebody
- 17:58else's feet to do the same thing. But maybe I'm wrong. Is
- 18:02that correct
- 18:04or, yeah, that's another, yeah, that's what they were
- 18:07reinforcement. Yeah, that was they were complaining about as
- 18:10well. Because, you know, if we're, if we're restricting the
- 18:15use of the indigenous
- 18:18piece that we have, but we're anyway, exporting it from
- 18:21abroad. What's the what's the difference? That was the kind of
- 18:24a point of debate as well. Yeah,
- 18:28Elena, you were involved in drafting the rebuttal for save
- 18:31our sperms and and your own scientific work focuses on
- 18:36measuring carbon, carbon emissions from Irish raised bogs
- 18:40and on peak land restoration monitoring,
- 18:44in your opinion, looking at the amount of peak land that will be
- 18:48impacted by the planned gold mine.
- 18:54What have you to say about this?
- 18:58Do you repeat the question and what exactly trying to say? What
- 19:04kind of impact on pigment? Yes, for the work that they're there
- 19:11that will require the removal of the piece and then that they
- 19:14will replace it after they have done all their work. You know.
- 19:19What are your thoughts about this?
- 19:22So the it's just kind of simple things to remember is when peat
- 19:29is wet, that it does not release any emissions. So anytime that
- 19:36peatlands has gone to outfit the air carbon, molecules of carbon
- 19:41that in pit, they connects to the oxygen, and that what goes
- 19:46into
- 19:48two so imagine, like the work they do, they have to drain
- 19:53peatlands, first, I presume, to dig it up, and then lots of pit
- 19:58is connected.
- 20:00Has access to the oxygen while the transfer it, while they put
- 20:04it to the new place.
- 20:06Yeah, so it's all, we're all losing carbon at every stage,
- 20:12and then peatlands in not is not uniform, so it's not peatland
- 20:18the same pit as have like three a three metre depth, all the
- 20:23peat we have at the surface. It has different carbon content. It
- 20:27has different properties. So it's kind of complicated when we
- 20:33move peat from one place to another place.
- 20:38So we literally don't have any evidence or any monitoring of
- 20:43what's happening, so science cannot say at the moment what
- 20:49exactly is going to happen and how to happen. But again, like
- 20:55remember, wet bit, no emissions, dry bit, we have emissions.
- 21:01And is it possible? I know you said because it's changeable, or
- 21:04it's variable, and there are no models existing. But is it, is
- 21:08it possible to say like
- 21:10one cubic metre of dry piece equals X number of emissions?
- 21:16Is that? Does that figure exist out there? Or,
- 21:22yeah, so we can have a look. We have some numbers from land use.
- 21:27So when peatland is on the land, it's a mid certain amount of a
- 21:33CO two. And then we have numbers for peat, usually it's extracted
- 21:39for horticulture or for burning. So that's we can add up as well
- 21:45those numbers, there are methodologies existed in the
- 21:49national inventory report in the Republic of Ireland, so we
- 21:52actually can calculate, once we know how much bit
- 21:58was taken and the era of the land it was taken from? Yes, it
- 22:03is possible to get the number, okay. And so another question I
- 22:10have So my understanding of of peat is that it acts like a
- 22:14giant sponge.
- 22:18What is it? Sphagnum moss, it absorbs how many times its own
- 22:22weight in water? Or
- 22:25can do we know that? I know it absorbs a lot of moisture, yeah,
- 22:30and we often, when I came to OMA first, back in 1985 86 it was
- 22:36very heavy rain in October, November, and
- 22:41the straw river burst its banks and almost flooded up to the top
- 22:45of the first floor windows from the amount of water that was
- 22:48coming down, almost in kind of a they call it the Virgin plain.
- 22:52It's in a kind of a low area surrounded by hills, all of
- 22:56which have got Upland. You know, they've got peach bogs on top,
- 23:01removing vast quantities of peat like this surely must have an
- 23:06impact on the lower hydrology and downstream hydrology. Have
- 23:11you anything? Any comments either of you would like to say
- 23:14about that? Or,
- 23:16yeah, definitely every, every time we
- 23:20do something with the peat won't disturb them. Cutting drains,
- 23:25like pretty much if you remove peat, is cutting the big,
- 23:28massive drain. So and what happens is that this kind of
- 23:35sponge qualities, kind of cut in half, and you have this open,
- 23:40open sponge. So all those, all these features with valid
- 23:45peatlands for like, absorb water after the heavy rain,
- 23:51kind of loses it and kind of goes to the opposite so now,
- 23:55right, taking in all this heavy rainfall and heavy water and
- 24:01release it slowly afterwards,
- 24:05because it's it's been cut, all this water just goes through
- 24:10straight away. And because it's dry, Pit is dry, we lose soil
- 24:16stability. We talking about erosion. So all this water
- 24:20taking the pit with it, and that's what you see. This brown
- 24:27water dissolved organic carbon, blue, losing carbon, blue,
- 24:31losing soil. And of course, it's affect a lot water quality. So
- 24:36it's literally the opposite process. Peatlands could act as
- 24:42artificial water treatment plant, pretty much drained when
- 24:48they disturbed its opposite. They actually pollute water,
- 24:55right? Another important thing to remember about uplands area.
- 25:00Is it's landslides.
- 25:02It's when peat is dry,
- 25:05especially in the summer, the soil can crack, and once the
- 25:10heavy water goes into those cracks, they can make pittance
- 25:15move.
- 25:16So that's why we can see those news about landslides.
- 25:22That's really interesting, because where the proposed mine
- 25:26tailings heap is to be built is in a townland called sheshkun
- 25:31seul and that means moving ground. It's actually
- 25:37to be put on top of a townland that's called Moving ground. And
- 25:43this, this, these waste tailings from the mine. In the planning
- 25:50application,
- 25:52it is to be 17 and a half stories high on top of a
- 25:57mountain, on top of a moving bog, in your in your knowledge
- 26:01of bugs and bug movements. What would you say about this?
- 26:09Yeah, again, like you have to be very careful with this, and it's
- 26:12really hard to predict its mountains areas. So it's not
- 26:16flat ground and it's speed laying on the bedrocks,
- 26:22somewhere it's deeper, somewhere it's more shallow. So it's
- 26:26really hard to predict how like removing parts of it going to
- 26:31affect other areas, especially with such high slope. And it is
- 26:37getting a problem, as we can see, like we can hear a news of
- 26:41landslides happening here and there,
- 26:44and then I would say about wildfires as well. With the dry
- 26:49bit in the summer, we in Ireland, we weren't affected
- 26:53this so much so far, but it's happening more and more every
- 26:57year. We can see that, especially uplands areas where
- 27:01Heather is dominant, we need to remember about this as well,
- 27:07and that will
- 27:09further
- 27:11worsen the problem. It will make bead drier, make it crack. And
- 27:16then with the climate change, we get more extreme weather events.
- 27:22So we're talking about storms and stuff, and the combination
- 27:26of this, too, leads to all this soil instability and erosion and
- 27:32to those slippage landslide Yeah, I remember some years ago
- 27:38the Glen Elly Valley, that was after very heavy rain, there was
- 27:41quite a large landslide down on down onto the road. You know,
- 27:45there was number of farmers affected by it. And then, of
- 27:49course, over in guwabara and Donegal, they had a major
- 27:52landslide there as well.
- 27:54So all these and the impact of wildfires as well, that's
- 28:00actually one thing that's that's I hadn't thought of, to be quite
- 28:04honest, and they are so prevalent now wildfires said,
- 28:08yeah, that's and the peak gets burning. It's very hard to put
- 28:12out when it's called Zombie fires, even when you don't see
- 28:17fire on the top, yeah, it is still kept underneath the soil
- 28:22at the bottom of the pit. And once it's the weather is dry
- 28:26again, it just goes back up. And about the line slides, I
- 28:31wouldn't know much research been done in it. It's not exactly my
- 28:37area. Yeah, in it's quite new topic. So that will be hard to
- 28:44estimate, to find evidence,
- 28:47to do the assessment of what's going to happen with the land,
- 28:51what will happen with the area where the pit will be removed,
- 28:55right? We don't have enough evidence to see what's going to
- 28:59happen with the pit when they put any in the new place, how?
- 29:03How it's going to affect carbon emissions? We don't have
- 29:07evidence either. Let me come back to Alessandra in relation
- 29:12to the law. What would better protection look like? Yeah. So
- 29:19what I found in my, let's say, mapping of the different laws
- 29:24that apply to peatlands, and, you know, just, you know, having
- 29:28a look at what the current response is, is, what you find
- 29:32is that the law is often fragmented. So it's, you know,
- 29:37it looks so if it's you know, as I was saying, like you know, the
- 29:40legal instruments that, at the moment, better protect peatlands
- 29:44are were thought of to in order to protect biodiversity. And you
- 29:49know the natural habitat in terms of wildlife, and you know,
- 29:53just keeping the biodiversity alive. And then you have climate
- 29:56law, which is quite you know, it has this.
- 30:00Kind of almost kind of carbon tunnel vision. So we need to
- 30:03reduce emissions. We need to so
- 30:07it needs to be more integrated. It needs to be it to consider
- 30:12because pitons aren't and bitlands are a great example of
- 30:15the interconnection as well. Because they're not just carbon
- 30:19things. They're not just natural habitats. They're not they are
- 30:22like all of these things together, including lived in
- 30:25environments and environments with which people have
- 30:28interacted. So that's what I kind of come down to, that the
- 30:32law needs to be more integrated. Needs to consider the potential
- 30:36also clashes between these different objectives, for
- 30:40instance, and Elena maybe might jump in on this. But like there
- 30:44has been, also, there have been concerns around the building of,
- 30:50for instance, wind farms on peatlands. And so, you know, you
- 30:53build, you have wind farms that obviously try to aim, try to
- 30:58achieve a certain climate goal, which is reducing, moving away
- 31:01from fossil fuels and having renewable energy, but then at
- 31:05the same time, you're building it on a on a bog, on a on a
- 31:08peatland site that you know is supposed to store, act as a
- 31:11carbon sink and have carbon stored. So you know, you have a
- 31:15clash of different objectives, and also just the idea that
- 31:19beside these different climate or environmental objectives that
- 31:23have to be considered together, but also the fact, as I said, of
- 31:27the human aspect, the human dimension and social and
- 31:30cultural dimension of peatlands. So in my research, I so I, as I
- 31:36said, I mean between climate and environmental law and human
- 31:39rights law. So I do try to consider the human rights as
- 31:44well at stake in the process of managing peatlands. So and you
- 31:49know, try to have a balanced approach where you consider,
- 31:53yes, of course, you need to prioritise at certain points the
- 31:56protection or the conservation of peatlands, and you need to
- 31:59make these difficult choices, but still considering that, you
- 32:03know, they have been human shaped spaces as well. And so in
- 32:09a in maybe either adopting the law or implementing the law,
- 32:13taking into account the human interest that ended, so the
- 32:17human rights of people that have been maybe impacted in the
- 32:21process of protection as well. So I think, I think this
- 32:24holistic approach to the problem is really necessary, and that's
- 32:28what I try to promote in the research last year. Well, much
- 32:32legislation, it was mainly what, what I hear, what's, what's
- 32:36happening, but, yeah, I do see that often
- 32:42it's one sided chat to some groups, and there is a lack of
- 32:49different, even opposition, stakeholders to come together
- 32:55and been able to chat. There is no instruments to bring them, to
- 33:01bring them together, and sometimes they even consider to
- 33:06be a position. It's like people who wants to restore beetlands
- 33:10and farmers for turf cutter who want to cut turf. And somehow
- 33:15they looked at being on different sides. But then they
- 33:20all come from the same community, and all they want is
- 33:23that community being good and living their best life with them
- 33:31in the area. So this kind of the lack of dialogue, and instead
- 33:36with kind of crushing them together while they aiming for
- 33:41the same goal. So that's maybe where we lack the instrument on
- 33:47how to open the conversation. Okay, do you believe by bringing
- 33:52all the different sides together, that, and I'm not
- 33:55talking about the gold mine per se, but in just in relation to
- 33:59looking after the peat bogs in the Republic of Ireland that
- 34:03there is, there is a road forward. There's that will
- 34:06everyone.
- 34:08Everyone feels heard.
- 34:11I feel that they heard in different places, but not in one
- 34:17physically, not in one room. It's hard to bring people, and I
- 34:21think it's mainly about social aspect, I'd say, rather than
- 34:27maybe legislation here, just people being able to talk to
- 34:31each other, and then how they present it in the media as well.
- 34:38And people open readiness to have a to have a talk, because
- 34:43once you see people in the same room, suddenly there is a
- 34:48dialogue. Yeah,
- 34:51that would be nice to see. And maybe in in your case, I'm as
- 34:58well. Just.
- 35:00That people to people a different opinion, physically in
- 35:03the same place, and see how, how it will work.
- 35:09Yeah,
- 35:10I hear what you're saying when people realise that they're
- 35:13working towards a common concern, and the common concern
- 35:16is, perhaps to make living or looking after their children, or
- 35:20just to have a reasonable, a reasonable life lifestyle.
- 35:24That's what everyone wants for for themselves, you know, and
- 35:28but I think as all of us human beings, we may, we need to make
- 35:34room for everyone around that. But there's, there is
- 35:39an overall thrusting argument, and it's it all comes back to
- 35:44our economic system, and instead of going for growth, we need to
- 35:48go for degrowth, which is,
- 35:51it's almost like a bad word or a bad concept, because it's
- 35:56impossible to keep our lifestyles going in the style
- 35:59that we're accustomed and not impact on on our mountains, on
- 36:03our rivers, on our lakes, you know, for it's then, but the
- 36:07things that are essential for for us, for our lives, the air
- 36:11we breathe, the water we drink, and the earth that supports us
- 36:14has been, has been thrashed for a slightly higher standard of
- 36:19life. And however that shows up because we need more of this,
- 36:22more of that to to support it, you know. But what comes down to
- 36:27it is really understanding this is important. Our fresh water is
- 36:31important, our air is important, and can not contaminating the
- 36:36earth so and that's a grown up conversation we all need to
- 36:40have,
- 36:42and then our laws, then need to support that grown up
- 36:45conversation. This just made me think of right to health
- 36:49environment, which is something that, yeah, I highly support as
- 36:54a you know, it's so the right to health environment is not, for
- 36:58instance, currently recognised in in the European Convention of
- 37:02Human Rights, or in Ireland, there has been development to
- 37:04that. But it's precisely this idea that we link a human right,
- 37:09which is normally, you know, whether you are impacted in your
- 37:12own physical or state or mental state, with the fact that we
- 37:17actually heavily rely on on the environment. So there have been
- 37:22calls at the international level, and then it's also
- 37:25development at judicial levels in the Republic of Ireland
- 37:29especially. But still, we're not there. But it's highly important
- 37:32as a right to establish that connection between us, human
- 37:36beings and the environment. So we need the environment to be
- 37:39healthy, because then we can be healthy as well. Not not just to
- 37:43always think of the environment as something instrumental that
- 37:46we need to get something from, but it at least it establishes
- 37:50common understanding also how much we rely on it, and now how
- 37:55interconnected we are to it. Actually, in couple of weeks,
- 37:59we're going to have the visit of the Special Rapporteur on the
- 38:02Right to health environment, so the EU, United Nations Special
- 38:05Rapporteur to Ireland. So that's going to be a good conversation
- 38:10to have as well. Yeah, we sent in the report to her. We noticed
- 38:14going on, but I know we're up in the north, but what happens a
- 38:18lot? What's happening is impacting trans boundaries, so
- 38:22perhaps she will consider us, and I think we'd like to go down
- 38:25and meet her, if that's possible, but we'll see what
- 38:27happens. Just on that some years back from ananoma District
- 38:32Council passed the rights for nature bill and within the
- 38:35Council, as did Jerry and straban, and the rights of
- 38:40nature is, yeah, well, if we are pay, if we uphold it,
- 38:45it's it, it would be a fantastic thing, because it would give us
- 38:49what we need, which to respect, what is essential for life, for
- 38:53human life, really, but it's sort of been done and dusted and
- 38:59hung back in the cupboard again.
- 39:01You know it doesn't, it doesn't have any punch at the minute.
- 39:05Have you any comments? I don't know if any the Councils down in
- 39:09the Republic have passed the rights for nature Bill within
- 39:12their council area, or not aware of whether it's been done at
- 39:15council level, but I know, for instance, that in 2022 there was
- 39:20a citizens assembly on biodiversity laws in Ireland,
- 39:23and one of the recommendations of the assembly was the
- 39:26recognition of both the right to a healthy environment and rights
- 39:30of nature within the constitution. So that was the, I
- 39:34think, the most recent development in terms of our
- 39:37people. Also, you know, you know people in Ireland, think of, or
- 39:42the Republic anyway, think of, you know, how important rights
- 39:45of nature are, and then it hasn't been really followed up
- 39:50since. Or, you know, the response, I think, if I remember
- 39:54correctly, was that, you know, it's been discussed. Because
- 39:56obviously it's not something that you can do from, you know,
- 39:59to.
- 40:00Recognise something in the Constitution. It's not something
- 40:02that you can do from, you know, just very quickly. You know,
- 40:06there has to be a process in place. So, you know, it's, it's
- 40:09in progress, apparently. But yeah, so certainly it reflected
- 40:14like a call even from people to to recognise rights of nature
- 40:19also in the Republic. Yeah. Yeah, be nice to see it
- 40:23happening.
- 40:25People often smile, and I bring it up and say, that'll never
- 40:27happen, you know. But I I often say, Well, there was a time in
- 40:32the world when people thought it would be impossible to eradicate
- 40:35slavery, or it would be or there was a time in the world when
- 40:39women didn't have the vote, like it did happen in many parts of
- 40:43the world, and I think it's because of a different
- 40:45conception. But in the United States, in Australia, in
- 40:49Ecuador. So Latin America, many places have the rights of nature
- 40:53for rivers, or, depending on what the concern was, forest
- 40:58rights and all of that. And I think we have a very different
- 41:01conception in Europe, much more anthropocentric. So we tend to
- 41:06be much more individualistic, but and put the human first,
- 41:10but, yeah, with distance, or, you know, we're influenced, and
- 41:16there is cross fertilisation between across countries. So
- 41:19there is hope. We just we can live in hope actually, which
- 41:23brings me perfectly to my next question.
- 41:28Either you can answer it on both of you, I'd like to answer, what
- 41:31gives you hope in the work that you do?
- 41:34I think it's people. Yeah, once you see people, once you see
- 41:38their enthusiasm, once you see, see that we all share the same
- 41:43ideas, the same goal, the similar vision, it's so
- 41:47inspiring. I think it's people, yeah, no, yeah. And we kind of
- 41:51want to bring up, I mean, I agree. I mean, maybe not
- 41:54everyone shares the same ideas, because we know that our people
- 41:57are very different ideas, but and so it's the, I think the
- 42:00challenge is bringing those people into the conversation so
- 42:04not to become too polarised in as a society. So try and kind of
- 42:12bridge the the gaps and kind of bring everyone in the
- 42:15conversation. But you know, I think I a great aspect of the
- 42:19research that we both are doing is precisely this kind of
- 42:23connection. So we we met through this early career researchers
- 42:28network and of peatland researchers. So we kind of
- 42:32realised there were different people working on peatlands from
- 42:36different disciplines. And so we became, well, Elena was the main
- 42:40person behind us to create this network of people, and we meet
- 42:43now, even though maybe some of us have finished their PhDs, are
- 42:47doing maybe something slightly different, but we still kind of
- 42:50are in touch. And we meet every now and then and we and it's
- 42:53always events that are that have some relation to peatland. So we
- 42:56go to an art exhibition or installation, or we go to art
- 43:01performance or to the museum to see the bug bodies, but it
- 43:05created connection. And I think connections in this world are so
- 43:09important, and I think for me, that's the main hope, and that's
- 43:13why I love this job so much, because you try to do something
- 43:18good, and at the same time, you're connected to people who
- 43:21are doing the same, and you share the same kind of hopes or
- 43:24concerns, and you know you still, and even though there's
- 43:27so much, there's
- 43:29there's so much to be concerned about, where you still kind of
- 43:32keep going, and I think the connections you have really
- 43:35helped. So I think we need to foster those connections. Yeah,
- 43:39that's I agree with you.
- 43:43We found in the campaign, the more we collaborated and the
- 43:49more we had solidarity across the world, across the earth,
- 43:53that the more it came back to us, and the wider and wider the
- 43:56ripples are created. And it's that cross pollination of ideas
- 44:01and people, and stops us speaking into our own echo
- 44:05chamber,
- 44:07you know? And that's what gives that's what gives me hope. And I
- 44:11was speaking to folk like you, so normally, just surrounded
- 44:14with the folk in the campaign, and then now I speak to people
- 44:19outside it, and it's so wonderful that, you know, there
- 44:22are people, lots of other people, up to great stuff in the
- 44:25world, you know, and that's what gives me hope, really, it's,
- 44:30it's a joy.
- 44:32So I think maybe we leave it on that note. It was a lovely
- 44:36conversation with both of you, and I want to thank you for your
- 44:40sport, support of save our spurns in the past, and for
- 44:44coming on here in the podcast, and I look forward to meeting
- 44:47you maybe at the public inquiry in the near future. So thank you
- 44:52both. Thank you so much for inviting us. Yeah, thank you.
- 44:56It's been wonderful conversation. I agree, and that
- 44:59conversation.
- 45:00And we heard how science policy and legal thinking can sit
- 45:03together in academia and at the same time show up in the world
- 45:07of a public inquiry. It's been a heavy conversation at times, but
- 45:10also hoped for one, because it shows what rigour and care can
- 45:15look like when people take climate change seriously. Thanks
- 45:19so much to Elena and Alexandra for their time and for the work
- 45:23they continue to do. If this conversation matters to you, if
- 45:28you think it's worth keeping alive, you can help by following
- 45:31the sperms podcast, wherever you get your podcasts, or by sharing
- 45:36this episode with someone else who might listen. You'll also
- 45:40find the podcast and all the usual platforms and on the don't
- 45:44minus.com website, we'll be back again soon with another voice,
- 45:49another perspective, and the same questions we keep returning
- 45:52to. Thanks for taking the time to listen for the air we
- 45:56breathe, water we drink, and the earth that supports us, we hold
- 46:00the line. You.