Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (9.30.24): Ralph Gebran, Managing Partner of Onramp MENA
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for joining us today. We're excited to bring you a
- 0:02brand new show from the On Ramp Media umbrella.
- 0:05Wake Up Call is a weekly show that will be streamed live on
- 0:08LinkedIn every Monday morning. To catch the premiere of each
- 0:11episode, follow On Ramps LinkedIn page and add Wake Up
- 0:14Call events to your calendar. After the live premiere on
- 0:17LinkedIn, we will distribute each episode across On Ramp
- 0:20Media's podcast channels and YouTube page.
- 0:23Wake Up Call aims to educate financial professionals on the
- 0:26merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis, how this asset
- 0:29represents both a threat to legacy financial service
- 0:31businesses and an opportunity to differentiate oneself and retain
- 0:35and attract new clients. Hosted by Mark Connors, Onramp's
- 0:39Head of Global Macro Strategy, and Rich Kerr, Onramp's
- 0:42President of Managed Wealth, this show seeks to provide
- 0:45financial professionals the wake up call they need, prompt them
- 0:48to have an open mind with respect to Bitcoin, rethink
- 0:51their prior assumptions, become more educated on the topic, and
- 0:54learn from others who are already farther down this path.
- 0:57Mark and Rich bring a combined 60 plus years of experience
- 1:00across traditional markets and financial services and will
- 1:03share their unique perspectives and how their peers and
- 1:05colleagues can approach the realm of Bitcoin.
- 1:08Wake Up Call will feature guest from various backgrounds and
- 1:10industries. Will also share their own
- 1:12journeys to Bitcoin and how others can get up to speed.
- 1:15Now time for the show. Well, good morning everyone and
- 1:19welcome to Monday's wake up call.
- 1:23Today we are joined by our Co host Mark Connors and then of
- 1:28course we have Ralph Gibran who is the managing partner of On
- 1:33Ramp. Mina And Ralph, we are delighted
- 1:37that you're joining us from the United Arab Emirates.
- 1:41So welcome back from your long travels to Canada and glad to
- 1:46have you today. But before we get kicked off, I
- 1:49think maybe we'll kick it over to Mark because there's been
- 1:52some really interesting developments that we'd like to
- 1:54kind of hear some of his early thoughts before we kind of dig
- 1:58into some of the interesting things that you're working on.
- 2:01Ralph. Yeah, it's a pleasure to be
- 2:03here. You bet Ralph, as as Rich said,
- 2:06we're very excited to hear what comes from your travels and just
- 2:10your home base there in in representing on ramp and Mina
- 2:17because today's, you know, headlines are global.
- 2:20We are definitely US focused for a good reason.
- 2:23Only 6% of population, but over 42% of the equity valuation and
- 2:29probably even higher when you look at bonds and all securities
- 2:32and assets. So but it's about China.
- 2:36So the Chinese equity market, the CSI 300 is up as much as 8
- 2:421/2 percent today unopened. Now the the AD Rs in the US
- 2:47steel trading China's close obviously up 25% Ralph and Rich
- 2:54on the week. Imagine if people woke up and
- 2:58said the S&P or the NASDAQ is up 25% in a week.
- 3:04I'm not sure that people would be happy.
- 3:06I mean, some people would be, I'd be a little nervous about
- 3:10how and why did the valuations or prices or earnings go up that
- 3:14much. And so that a little bit of a
- 3:17tease question, a little lead up for me to say we all know why it
- 3:21happened. We talked about a little bit in
- 3:23our roundup. China entered into a stimulus in
- 3:27a series of steps over the past week that we haven't seen since
- 3:3008. And you know, we're not fear
- 3:32mongers. We don't drop stuff to get
- 3:34clickbait that is relevant. One of the major reasons the EU
- 3:39global economy survived O 8 was because of the expansion of
- 3:42China as a trade partner. Their GDP grew from, I don't
- 3:47know, 1.3 trillion in O2 when they entered the WTO World Trade
- 3:52Organization to I think it's over 17 trillion.
- 3:55If I'm give or take a trillion, don't call me a liar for a
- 4:00trillion guys. But that's slowing.
- 4:04And in dollar terms there like flat over the past year, you
- 4:09know they're up 5% in yuan terms, but they have put in a
- 4:13couple 100 billion / 150 billion into the banking system to
- 4:18support it. They have all but ripped the
- 4:21need for the banks to have reserve ratios.
- 4:26You know, we all know that banks don't have your dollars.
- 4:28They keep 5 or 10% of them and lend the rest out.
- 4:32The amount that the banks in China are supposed to hold I
- 4:37think was cut in half. So there's a problem there.
- 4:41And they're trying to accelerate the economy by making it easier
- 4:45for banks, which is risky because now banks have less
- 4:46collateral. They're injecting money.
- 4:48And what they did also, which is very like O 8 in the US, is they
- 4:54took these short term loans that that people have with the
- 4:57government overnight and they pushed them out.
- 5:00They then made them medium term notes and if you remember in O 8
- 5:03when the whole front end commercial paper everything was
- 5:06collapsing because of these, you know, silly asset backed things
- 5:10that were not really that were vaporware with bad mortgages.
- 5:13The government said, OK, we will guarantee corporate debt out
- 5:17three years. That's what we did for the first
- 5:19time. They, you know, you had
- 5:21investment grade companies not able to issue debt.
- 5:24But the government said anything up to three years is like an
- 5:26agency. We'll we'll guarantee it just
- 5:28like a, a government agency, you know, implied full faith.
- 5:35That's what China did. That's why it's like O 8.
- 5:38Their system is in disrepair. So what are people doing?
- 5:43They're they're putting their money into equities.
- 5:45All this excess cash is a safe haven.
- 5:47That's all it is. It's a safe haven trade.
- 5:49It's a debasement trade. So that's China just stepping
- 5:53back to more update. I mean, upbeat things that are
- 5:55out there. We know that BlackRock put out
- 5:58a, a piece last week, maybe the middle of the month, 9 pages,
- 6:04just like the Satoshi white paper.
- 6:06I don't know if that was a wink to, to the white paper, but it
- 6:10was on, on bitcoins unique qualities.
- 6:12And you know, given the fact that CPI is supposedly going
- 6:18lower, it's not because we know that the, that the rental part,
- 6:24you know, the shelter, etcetera, is still up five to 7%.
- 6:26So people are living a costly environment, even though the
- 6:29government's saying no CPI is 2 1/2.
- 6:33Everyone's life is more expensive, Rich and Ralph.
- 6:36I don't know in in where if you're feeling any type of
- 6:40increase in rents or standard cost of living where you are or
- 6:47is are the Emirates in a 2% environment rate?
- 6:52Well, no, in general, across the board globally, things have
- 6:57gotten more expensive. Now the ironic part when they
- 7:01say prices are going down, they fail to tell people that CPI is
- 7:07a percentage increase. So when CPI goes down, it
- 7:11doesn't mean prices are going down, it means the rate of
- 7:13increase of those prices is slowing down.
- 7:16South life is getting more expensive.
- 7:18You would need to see a negative number to actually see price go
- 7:21down. So as a metric, as you
- 7:24mentioned, you know, they take out conveniently everything that
- 7:28you need to actually sustain yourself, especially shelter,
- 7:33housing. And then, you know, numbers go
- 7:35down. Great.
- 7:36Everyone celebrates. And well, not everyone, only
- 7:39those that are issuing those numbers.
- 7:42But yeah, Mark, in general, everywhere the UAE has witnessed
- 7:47over the last two years a tremendous rise in property
- 7:52prices and in rental prices. Now, one of the advantages here
- 7:57though, is there's no income tax.
- 8:00So we actually keep all the profits you make, which allows
- 8:03you to have a better real return, right?
- 8:07Because they don't take taxes from your gain.
- 8:08So you end up with more than what you you originally would
- 8:12have in the US or in Canada, for example.
- 8:15But yeah, I would tend to agree with that.
- 8:17In general, life across the board is getting more expensive.
- 8:21But what's unique about the UAE, for example, is their debt to
- 8:25GDP ratio, which is nowhere near as high as the one in the US
- 8:29You're talking about 35 percent, 40% on average, maybe even a bit
- 8:35less. So they are much more
- 8:37constrained in terms of their fiscal and monetary policies.
- 8:44OK, so the costs are going higher, but they have a
- 8:50structural advantage versus taxes here where we know they're
- 8:55popping up like like weeds on your front lawn.
- 8:58Their new taxes. It's like, no, your tax rate in
- 9:00your property is fine, but now we have a new assessment.
- 9:03Whenever you go mail a letter, try to get your, you know, house
- 9:07reappraised. So there are there are new taxes
- 9:09in the US that are coming in to grab value, making the house not
- 9:13as good as, say a Bitcoin investment trying rich.
- 9:19I'm just scooting through what we had talked about before here
- 9:22and on any more news as far as as far as to the to the
- 9:29audience. And I think, you know, the only
- 9:31other thing maybe just look at is unemployment and then I'll
- 9:35kick it back to you. It's coming out Friday.
- 9:39I think it's going to be a non starter.
- 9:42The Fed is going to take any, if you see a revision lower, which
- 9:47they hope on, on, on claims, you know, that there were less
- 9:52claims and or more claims and less unemployment for previous
- 9:55months like that big August 817,001 year revision.
- 10:00Like talk about a bank error not in your favor.
- 10:03Like who does that type of miss? You know, that's why people
- 10:06aren't trusting the data. But unemployment will be there.
- 10:09And I think the, the, the reason this call focuses on the money
- 10:16printing in the debasement is because we think we're at a
- 10:19pretty big inflection point. The Fed for the first time in
- 10:24two years has gone into now or M2 is now growing again.
- 10:29So for two years we went into a tightening by the Fed that
- 10:34brought M2 down to the lowest levels in retracement that we've
- 10:38seen since 19341937 period when the Fed was again trying to
- 10:43figure out how the heck to deal with with a very unique period
- 10:46like we have now. But now we're going higher.
- 10:49That's why we think that asset prices are again going to be
- 10:52going higher. Why we think what Ralph's going
- 10:56to bring today to the forefront about why how Bitcoin can help
- 11:00absorb some of that loss of buying power.
- 11:04And so rich back to you. That's the news.
- 11:07Everything points to, you know, number go up on Bitcoin because
- 11:12there's only one tool the Fed and everyone has and that's
- 11:15printing to deal with all the issues.
- 11:18There's so much going on these days and and, you know, we won't
- 11:22talk about everything, but, you know, there's some there's some
- 11:25cool things that are happening in the world and even over here
- 11:29in the states, Ralph, you know, Louisiana, I believe, became the
- 11:33first state to to officially announce that they would accept
- 11:39Bitcoin for state services. And so that was kind of a cool
- 11:43little nugget in my mind and worth just kind of flagging.
- 11:47You know, the adoption of Bitcoin is starting to kind of
- 11:50become more ubiquitous. And so I always try to pay
- 11:53attention to, you know, those types of elements.
- 11:57But that being said, one of the big reasons why we have you here
- 12:02today 1, you know, because as Mark said, you know, you bring
- 12:07them a global perspective, right?
- 12:09Often times we're thinking about things in a very myopic way and
- 12:13what's happening in the United States.
- 12:15Everything's about the United States and we kind of get stuck
- 12:18in that framework and we like to break that because I think
- 12:21there's some really interesting things happening all around the
- 12:24world with Bitcoin. And you're kind of in a unique
- 12:28space, right, being over in the Emirates and, and, you know,
- 12:33having a perspective of, of how that is affecting the Middle
- 12:37East or North Africa areas. And, and so maybe you can share
- 12:42a little bit about your business and what you're focused on.
- 12:45And then we can kind of transition into the heart of
- 12:47this, which I, I think we want to focus on a, a paper.
- 12:51I don't want to call it a rebuttal because I think in many
- 12:54respects you really agree largely with the, with the, the
- 12:59core themes of what BlackRock had produced in their nine page
- 13:03paper. But you're going to be producing
- 13:06a, a document or a paper that that is an addendum, you know,
- 13:11to maybe cover on the things that BlackRock neglected to talk
- 13:14about. And so we'll hit on those two
- 13:16major areas, But maybe let's just kind of start with what
- 13:19what it what are you seeing over in in your side of the world?
- 13:24And, and how Bitcoin is, is, you know, advancing not just from a,
- 13:30you know, an investment standpoint, but you know, what,
- 13:34what, what's intriguing you over there in the Emirates?
- 13:39Yeah. So the Emirates and the general
- 13:43GCC area is quite unique. So when it comes to Bitcoin
- 13:48adoption, we are extremely early.
- 13:52What's positive is that the vast majority of people here are
- 13:56crypto owners or crypto savvy, so there is a very high level of
- 14:01sophistication when it comes to understanding the technical
- 14:05aspects of Bitcoin, but where it is lacking is the monetary
- 14:10aspects of Bitcoin. Now, the governments in certain
- 14:14GCC countries have been extremely forward-looking and
- 14:19have adapted regulatory frameworks to facilitate the
- 14:24flourishing of this new industry.
- 14:26So we are one of the few, if not only Bitcoin only advisory and
- 14:33educational platforms within the region.
- 14:35And we're looking to import some products from the US as well.
- 14:38We can touch on that later, such as multi institution custody.
- 14:42We feel that a product like that would align extremely well with
- 14:46the cultural aspect of the MENA region.
- 14:48So it has the highest concentration of Muslims within
- 14:52the region. And I don't know if you watch
- 14:54our podcast, The New Frontier with my Co host Harris Irfan,
- 14:58He's the expert with regards to Islamic finance.
- 15:01And the way he breaks it down is that Bitcoin is the hardest
- 15:05money and that, you know, Muslims should look into Bitcoin
- 15:09as the best form and the most halal form of money that there
- 15:15is. Just from a moral point of view,
- 15:18ethical point of view, it's worth just looking into Bitcoin.
- 15:21The market here when it comes to understanding the monetary
- 15:25properties of Bitcoin is still in its infancy.
- 15:28And that's why we're here. We're here to breakthrough the
- 15:31noise to showcase Bitcoin as not just a ethical asset but also a
- 15:37incredibly useful asset to own within your portfolio.
- 15:42Overall adoption of Bitcoin is present, especially in the
- 15:48developed countries here like the UAE.
- 15:52However, in certain other countries, Bitcoin is used more
- 15:56as a lifeline, I would say because some of these countries
- 16:02have witnessed hyperinflation, unofficial bank capital
- 16:06controls, and the only way to actually move capital within
- 16:10these countries is through some form of digital asset.
- 16:14Now there is a ongoing debate between Bitcoin and certain
- 16:19stable coins and the only reason why is because when you are in
- 16:24an environment, whether a conflict environment or a total
- 16:27economic collapse, it's more about a high time preference
- 16:31mindset. So you're looking to survive.
- 16:33And so the volatility of Bitcoin, even though we view it
- 16:36as a positive thing and as a feature for the individuals in
- 16:40such areas, it is a bit more nuanced.
- 16:43So you can't just say just use Bitcoin.
- 16:45They need, you know, some form of stability for day-to-day
- 16:48purchases, for day-to-day needs. So that's just a holistic lens
- 16:53of the region. So there's a bit of everything,
- 16:55developed countries, non developed countries, countries
- 16:57under conflict, countries suffering from economic turmoil.
- 17:01And it's funny because you see Bitcoins variety of use cases
- 17:07all within the GCC or the overall MENA region.
- 17:11For example, in Nigeria, a country suffering from
- 17:14hyperinflation, Bitcoin is the most used cryptocurrency.
- 17:19The people there rejected the central bank digital currency,
- 17:23the Nero, in favor of Bitcoin. And one of the reasons is
- 17:27because it's decentralized, it empowers them, and it allows
- 17:31them to move capital, you know, extremely fast and relatively
- 17:35cheap prices. Yeah, that's a that's an
- 17:42incredible recap of, you know, everything that's going on in in
- 17:46your side of the world. And we appreciate kind of a lens
- 17:49into that. You know, I I teased at the
- 17:53beginning, Ralph, that you have this, you know, report that's
- 17:59being released. It's a it's going to be released
- 18:02here in the United States, I think later today, if I'm not
- 18:07mistaken, which I think is, is outstanding.
- 18:09And everybody can get access to that.
- 18:12And we'll be, you know, sending that out through it out
- 18:15LinkedIn, so you can see that or you can visit on ramp Bitcoin
- 18:18and be able to get that report. But it's really a, a, a
- 18:24beautiful report in many respects because I think it it,
- 18:28it highlights the agreements that you that we have with the
- 18:32BlackRock 9 page report that Mark was referencing.
- 18:35It's called BlackRock, a unique diversifier and in which they
- 18:40kind of go over four major themes is as to why it's a
- 18:45unique diversifier and why people should, you know,
- 18:48potentially explore including Bitcoin into their portfolios.
- 18:54But you also kind of take it a little a step further and, and,
- 18:57and talk about the unique nature of Bitcoin and, and, and what's
- 19:02missing in the report. But maybe we could start just
- 19:06kind of highlighting or talking at the three of us with the
- 19:09audience about the things that stood out to us inside of the
- 19:13Black Rock report that that we do agree with that we do find
- 19:17interesting. So, you know, I kind of push,
- 19:20push that to you, Ralph, maybe to 1st, you know, kick us off.
- 19:23You know, what were some of the things that stood out to you?
- 19:27Yeah. So I'll just start off by saying
- 19:30the way I view this report isn't really a rebuttal, but I would
- 19:35view it as kind of like the fine print footnotes in your
- 19:39insurance contract. So the part that most people
- 19:42don't read. So that's that's just how I view
- 19:44it. I'll just put it that put it out
- 19:46that way. Now, what was fascinating to me
- 19:50when I read this report, it sounded like it came from a
- 19:54native Bitcoiner. A lot of the points that we
- 19:57truly believe in Bitcoin being uncorrelated to traditional
- 20:01assets, being decentralized, you know, being a solid store of
- 20:05value, All these things, you know, are table stakes for your
- 20:09average Bitcoiner. But what was really fascinating
- 20:12for me, and the part that I found the most interesting, is
- 20:16when BlackRock basically called out all other asset managers and
- 20:22basically told them that you have to look at Bitcoin through
- 20:25a different lens. Your previous models, especially
- 20:29the risk models themselves, don't typically apply or can't
- 20:33really be applied to this nascent and new asset.
- 20:38So that for me was the most interesting part about the
- 20:40report, because all the other stuff are pretty clear.
- 20:43But for an institution like BlackRock to come out and say
- 20:45that analyzing and studying Bitcoins risk the traditional
- 20:50way doesn't work. So it's a paradigm shift.
- 20:54So the models that were used beforehand to, you know, analyze
- 20:59risk for equity, stock, real estate, whatever they may be,
- 21:04cannot be applied to Bitcoin, and new ways of looking at
- 21:08Bitcoin should be developed. So that was the part that was
- 21:11most fascinating to me, to be honest.
- 21:13So, Ralph, when when you jumped, when you saw that, Thanks for
- 21:17Let me jump in here, Rich, was that something, how do you think
- 21:23the audience will take that? Because it's hard to say, you
- 21:28know, this time is different. That's kind of, you know, the
- 21:32the road to investment Hells paved with that statement.
- 21:35People would say. So when they said that, what
- 21:39were some of the attributes that that you said?
- 21:41Yeah, I I agree and I've seen it.
- 21:44How did they relay that? It's a regime ship and you can't
- 21:47use old models. Yeah.
- 21:50So I think they didn't say it bluntly.
- 21:53They just hinted at, you know, a paradigm shift in the way we
- 21:56review Bitcoin. But I think what they were
- 21:59trying to say and there's something I agree with.
- 22:02So Bitcoin in some form of ways is a risk off asset, especially
- 22:08when you look at the world and the way it's headed.
- 22:11There are uprisings everywhere. There are issues politically,
- 22:17geopolitically everywhere, all around the world and everything
- 22:21is interconnected to the current monetary system, which is the US
- 22:25dollar base system. Now, why is Bitcoin risk off?
- 22:29Even though some people would think of risk as, you know, just
- 22:31price action, But there are a variety of risk dimensions.
- 22:36And this is really prevalent in areas such as the West and
- 22:40Europe where people view the world in a more stable lens.
- 22:45But if you grew up in a more, you know, unstable environment,
- 22:50which is really 90% of the world, I mean, in terms of
- 22:54percentage of population, the West is just a fraction of the
- 22:59actual world population. So most people live under, you
- 23:03know, less stable situation. So they view the world in a in a
- 23:08different fashion. Now, when you look at Bitcoin
- 23:12from different risk dimensions, one of them in particular that
- 23:16makes it a risk off you is that is outside of the US dollar
- 23:20monetary system. Whether there are a variety of
- 23:23free floating fiats. At the end of the day, the
- 23:27system is based on the US dollar as the reserve asset of the
- 23:32world and is based on the Petro dollar to fuel the economies all
- 23:37over the world. So there is a very high level of
- 23:40interconnectedness across all asset classes.
- 23:44It doesn't matter. So they're all connected.
- 23:46Your house in Canada might be affected by an interest rate
- 23:49shift in the US because of the interest rate differential.
- 23:53So countries have to compete on interest rates to make sure
- 23:56their exports and imports are in line.
- 23:58So there's full integration there.
- 24:01So Bitcoin is a risk off because it for the first time ever, you
- 24:05can actually disconnect from that system and basically hide a
- 24:10portion of your wealth outside of it.
- 24:12It cannot be manipulated, it cannot be controlled, and most
- 24:15importantly, it cannot be debased.
- 24:18So sure, price volatility for some people is a problem, but
- 24:23the end goal is to not sell the Bitcoin, is to hold it for the
- 24:27long term to store your wealth. And if history has shown us is
- 24:33that it's been very successful at doing that.
- 24:35And the reality is when you have an asset that is not
- 24:38interconnected to the world, well, some people would go to
- 24:42gold, right? But gold is the bearer asset,
- 24:45which is like Bitcoin. And what people would do to
- 24:48disconnect it from the world, they actually buy the physical
- 24:51bars and hide them in their backyard or somewhere that no
- 24:53one knows about. But the reality is, you know
- 24:57gold is problematic in a world where you know there might be a
- 25:02war, or you might have to leave, or you might have to evacuate
- 25:05real fast. Well gold's hedge goes to 0
- 25:10because you cannot actually move it across borders using it to
- 25:17purchase stuff. If you have gold bars, first of
- 25:19all, how are you going to break them into pieces?
- 25:21Second of all, if people know you have a gold bar in a
- 25:23war-torn country or in a hyperinflating country, then
- 25:26you're literally putting a target on your back.
- 25:29So Bitcoin alleviates all these risks.
- 25:32So it is really a risk off asset for a risk on world.
- 25:37At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 25:40asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 25:44right. There are shortcomings with
- 25:46keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 25:49up your own self custody arrangement.
- 25:51On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 25:54Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 25:57minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 26:00remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 26:04inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 26:06well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 26:09for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 26:12for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 26:15setup. For more information, check us
- 26:17out at on rampbitcoin.com. I think that's spot on on that
- 26:22on that and I agree that BlackRock allude to the fact
- 26:26that, you know, you may want to have something that's outside
- 26:29the system. Jeez, like that's a big
- 26:32statement and and it's something Brian Kubelis, our chief of
- 26:36strategy, was chatting with us before the call.
- 26:37And he's like, hey, Mark, remember, you know, that's
- 26:39something that Zoltan, you know, wrote about in March of 22.
- 26:43I think just how we're going into a commodity market.
- 26:46Russia's sick of being on the SWIFT system.
- 26:48They're, you know, having their assets taken.
- 26:51There are charges to it. You know, banks charge 4%
- 26:55unbalanced just to move money around and and he said we're
- 26:58going to go to a commodity base and Bitcoin may be part of it.
- 27:01So it is there in the system. But rich, you know, this is a
- 27:05call for advisors. Does that message, which we
- 27:08think is happening, BlackRock is giving you more than a wink that
- 27:12this is an attribute that you should consider?
- 27:15Is that one of the things that advisors are considering or are
- 27:19they still looking at from just an investment opportunity?
- 27:23Yeah, I, I think we're early, Mark, you know, in, in
- 27:26conversations with advisors, they're, they're, they're really
- 27:29just gathering the education, right?
- 27:32And, and, and distilling, you know, their point of view around
- 27:36what is Bitcoin And, and you know, to the black rocks point,
- 27:40right, BlackRock was trying to nudge the advisor community
- 27:44saying, Hey, you, you really need to be paying attention to
- 27:46this. And, and you know, you knew, you
- 27:49need to consider changing your framework on the way that you're
- 27:52thinking about it. And and so, you know, this
- 27:55report that BlackRock produced, I really loved it in many
- 28:00respects, right? Because, you know, to Ralph's
- 28:02earlier point, it speaks to the things that we've been trying to
- 28:05talk, you know, to our friends and family and clients and you
- 28:10know, everybody about for a very long time.
- 28:12And it does a really nice job of, of framing, you know, why
- 28:17it's a why it's a risk off asset.
- 28:20You know, there's a, there's a beautiful chart and inside of
- 28:23the report or a table maybe is a better way to say it.
- 28:27That really describes, you know, S&P 500 gold Bitcoin, you know,
- 28:35all up against, you know, the, the, the most frequent or the
- 28:39most recent geopolitical events and how it responded in a 10 day
- 28:44move, you know, 10 day return basis and then a sixty day
- 28:47return basis. And, and how important, you
- 28:51know, or, or how relevant Bitcoin became, especially as a
- 28:5560 day, you know, event horizon, I guess, you know, post the
- 29:01event, right. So US, Iran escalation, Bitcoin
- 29:04was up 20%. You know, 60 days after COVID
- 29:08outbreak of March 11th, 2020, Bitcoin was up 21% Gold only
- 29:15three, S&P 500 only two, right. So, you know, if you, if you
- 29:21keep going down and they cover off on, you know, the 2020 US
- 29:26election challenges, they cover the Russia and Ukraine invasion,
- 29:34they cover the US regional banking crisis.
- 29:37So they, they do a nice job of outlining how well Bitcoin
- 29:40performed and it and it really is a risk off asset in those
- 29:46scenarios. But I think to Blackrock's
- 29:48point, they're saying, Hey, you got to change those models.
- 29:51What they didn't say, I guess in, in in some regards and and
- 29:55Ralph really drove, drove this point home was, you know, if
- 30:00you're willing to change your model, right for risk on risk
- 30:05off you, you can't cherry pick what, what what you're going to
- 30:10do. It's not just that you're
- 30:12changing the model, but you also have to evaluate how the, you
- 30:16know, how the asset is held as well.
- 30:18And so, you know, I kick it over to you, Ralph, you know, to kind
- 30:22of, you know, just highlight, you know, that that missing
- 30:26element in what Bitcoin or what BlackRock, excuse me, was
- 30:31articulating. Yeah, for sure.
- 30:34So that was the funnest part about the report because there's
- 30:38like this big elephant in the room that's not discussed
- 30:41throughout, which is something we're used to in the traditional
- 30:45finance world. I mean, when you buy stocks or
- 30:50bonds, you never really ask who's the custodian.
- 30:54You never take a look at the custodian holistically and then
- 30:57study the custodian to make sure that you know there's no risk
- 31:00there. Because in stocks, bonds or
- 31:04whatever, even if the custodian were to go down, at the end of
- 31:08the day, they're just holding a digital record that says, Rich
- 31:12Mark, you own X amount of shares of XYZ.
- 31:17If the custodian were to go down, I mean, they could
- 31:20recreate that digital record relatively easy.
- 31:24And there's no concerns there on your platform.
- 31:27You're just going to see your, your stock.
- 31:30It doesn't matter what the custodian, you know, is doing in
- 31:32the background. But with Bitcoin, it introduces
- 31:36a new layer to asset management, which is the custody aspect,
- 31:40because before Bitcoin, you couldn't really decide how you
- 31:44wanted to custody your equity, your stock.
- 31:47So the paradigm shift isn't just a digital asset that's hard
- 31:52capped at 21 million, a hard form of money, but also it opens
- 31:57up this whole new industry or field, which is the custody
- 32:01aspect. Because Bitcoin, unlike almost
- 32:04anything else, can be held in a vast variety of ways.
- 32:08It's a spectrum and you can choose what you're comfortable
- 32:11with between 100% relying on yourself to 100% relying on a
- 32:18third party like a custodian, which is what the ETFs are
- 32:23doing. So the ETFs, almost 80 to 85% of
- 32:27the US ETFs are currently custody by one single entity,
- 32:31just Coinbase. And you know, when they talk
- 32:34about risk models, how can you not factor in the huge
- 32:40concentration of Bitcoin under one single entity?
- 32:45Just take a look at what happened with Mt Gox.
- 32:49When Mt Gox went down, it took ten years of litigation before
- 32:53the owners of the Bitcoin received back their Bitcoin.
- 32:57And they only received, you know, 8070.
- 33:01I don't know how much it is they, it was a haircut, right?
- 33:03They couldn't fulfill the entire 100%.
- 33:07Most recently FTXI Mean FTX said it had around 100,000 Bitcoin on
- 33:12the balance sheet when it went bankrupt.
- 33:15It turned out they had zero. And so you can't just recreate a
- 33:18digital record saying you have this much Bitcoin.
- 33:21Oops. Right, Right, Ralph.
- 33:23Oops, exactly like oops. And people were like, what?
- 33:28So what happened? It took two years for these, you
- 33:33know, investors to get back some of that value.
- 33:37And they got it not in Bitcoin. They got it in U.S. dollars, and
- 33:42they got it when Bitcoin was close to its low last cycle,
- 33:45meaning they've lost 3X to gains on those holding.
- 33:50So what's common in this little story is that in centralized
- 33:55custody, you always end up with less Bitcoin.
- 33:59And that's what history has shown Between Block Fi, Celsius,
- 34:03anyone who promises that they can hold your Bitcoin forever
- 34:07and extremely comfortably is not being 100% genuine because the
- 34:11entity at the end of the day involves other humans.
- 34:15There's mismanagement, there's mischievous activity, there's
- 34:18fraud, there's hacks, and these are all single points of
- 34:21failure. So that's something that
- 34:23BlackRock doesn't mention and doesn't factor into its
- 34:27analysis. Because when you point a light
- 34:32at the custody, you realize as more and more Bitcoin are found
- 34:37under one entity, well, the risk is actually higher than what
- 34:41they're saying. So I'll stop there and see what
- 34:44you guys think of that. But that's that's that's one of
- 34:48the little footnotes that they forgot to mention.
- 34:51Yeah. So in in other words, you can
- 34:53model the risk of the asset, but you also have to model the risk
- 34:58of how the asset is held. Exactly.
- 35:01You got it. That's spot on.
- 35:03Yeah. And they, and as you mentioned
- 35:05earlier, Ralph or maybe it was Rich, one of the highlights of
- 35:11the report is that they talk about the risk off the safe
- 35:15haven nature of it is from that it is outside the system.
- 35:19So they bring it to the table. They just don't put the food in
- 35:22front of you on the discussion of custody and how it should be
- 35:28in the asset because as you said, Bitcoin has rails that
- 35:35have never existed before. If you, you can own gold to safe
- 35:39haven, but you can't move gold on the, on the same rail system
- 35:44that the little that the, you know, the Gremlins did
- 35:47underneath, you know, Harry Potter's castle when they held
- 35:51all the gold down there, it was on the rails.
- 35:54Bitcoin has a rail system. It's the first one to have that.
- 35:57And you know, I guess that is maybe report #2 for BlackRock,
- 36:03maybe that'll come out later. But we don't have to wait for
- 36:05that. It sounds like sounds like
- 36:06you're going to have one coming out.
- 36:09This week, yeah. So on our side of the world,
- 36:14it's coming out tomorrow. And I believe in the US it's
- 36:16coming out later today during your time it's evening here.
- 36:20But yeah, that point, Mark, just to to develop a little bit more
- 36:24on that. So what I found interesting is
- 36:28that all these positives are attributed to Bitcoin and the
- 36:34BlackRock report, which is great.
- 36:36It sheds light, it brings in a lot of traditional finance
- 36:39player to better understand Bitcoin.
- 36:42The only problem with that, you know, they even mentioned
- 36:45decentralized, but that decentralization means nothing
- 36:50if the entire Bitcoin are centralized within the
- 36:53custodian. And on top of that, a lot of
- 36:57the, you know, like you said, risk off components of Bitcoin,
- 37:01which are what make it fascinating and provided with
- 37:04such utility, especially in certain areas in the world,
- 37:07like, you know, the ability to be extremely mobile, the ability
- 37:12to be, you know, 100% against the basement.
- 37:17That's problematic with the ETF because you cannot check whether
- 37:23they're using that Bitcoin for other purposes.
- 37:26Recently, Black Rock enforced or amended an agreement with
- 37:31Coinbase so that they would settle on chain transactions
- 37:34within 12 hours. You must think, why?
- 37:37What happened? You know, and it's kind of funny
- 37:41as well. Every time the Bitcoin price
- 37:43goes up, Coinbase acts like a circuit breaker.
- 37:47The platform stops working altogether.
- 37:49You can't withdraw, you can't buy, you can't do anything.
- 37:52So you start to question the integrity of the Castilian.
- 37:55I mean, Coinbase, when you really look at it, it hasn't
- 37:58been around for more than, I don't know, 12 years Maybe
- 38:02that's being generous compared to, for example, BNY Mellon,
- 38:06which is getting an exemption to custody Bitcoin.
- 38:08So you start to question why are they making exemptions?
- 38:12Why is a 200 year old institution now getting into the
- 38:15Bitcoin custody business? But the problem is you're still
- 38:19using the same model for an asset that you know is
- 38:22considered a paradigm shift in the way you hold it.
- 38:25So even that, you know, personally, I think will not
- 38:30work because at the end of the day, there's only 21 million of
- 38:33them. If BNY Mellon acts irresponsibly
- 38:36with the Bitcoin, you're going to have the same situation with
- 38:38FDX. You're going to have to, you
- 38:39know, go through litigation and then pay your the owners some
- 38:43form of Fiat currency, which by the time you get it has lost
- 38:46purchasing power or the price of Bitcoin, you know, has ran away
- 38:50and you're just stuck with a fraction of what you would have
- 38:53had have you held it correctly. So the way I view it, we need to
- 38:58decentralize custody. It is a decentralized asset and
- 39:02that custody needs to be decentralized.
- 39:04We need to erase what we've are accustomed to, which is OK.
- 39:10We need a huge vault, a bank where we put everything in it
- 39:14and just we surrounded with security guards.
- 39:16And then we pray for the, you know, for the best with Bitcoin,
- 39:20you can alleviate first of all, the cost and the risk by using
- 39:24something called multi institution custody, which is on
- 39:27the cutting edge of custody models.
- 39:30So we mentioned earlier on one extreme of owning Bitcoin is
- 39:35self custody where if done properly is extremely secure.
- 39:39However, there's an inherent risk and it is yourself.
- 39:43So you bear the entire risk. Your counterparty is yourself on
- 39:48the far right, you have these third party custodians like
- 39:51Coinbase, potentially BNY Mellon.
- 39:54So in this situation, what you're doing, you're putting
- 39:57100% trust in an entity that just sees you as a number on
- 40:02their screen. And in the middle you have
- 40:05something called multi institution custody.
- 40:07I know you guys talk a lot about it, but multi institution
- 40:11custody, just for those who are not very familiar with it,
- 40:13basically is a middle ground where you don't.
- 40:17Have any responsibility and nor are you putting all the
- 40:21responsibility on one single entity.
- 40:23The counterparty risk is spread out across 3 separate entities.
- 40:27And if you want to take it further, you can even
- 40:30geographically distribute these entities and reduce geopolitical
- 40:33risk. And in the world where
- 40:35geopolitical tensions are rising, that might be the most
- 40:40ideal way to hold Bitcoin. And I personally believe that's
- 40:43how you scale Bitcoin adoption to the institutions.
- 40:45And they might be late to understand that, but personally,
- 40:50I think it's coming. Yeah, I agree, I agree.
- 40:55And and it remains on on the Bitcoin rails, right.
- 40:58And it, you know, and and that's one of the interesting things,
- 41:01you know, with the ETF is look, government, I don't know anybody
- 41:07that would disagree with this statement.
- 41:09You know, I know it's an interesting time and we're very
- 41:13polarized, certainly over here in the United States.
- 41:16But that being said, you know, there is a level of hostility by
- 41:22the government towards the people and you know, you have to
- 41:27look at that with an honest lens.
- 41:30And, and so, you know, the portability of Bitcoin, it
- 41:33empowers the individual in many respects, right?
- 41:36You can, if you don't like the terms of, you know, how you're
- 41:39being treated by your government or whatever, you can take your
- 41:43assets and, and, you know, move them to other economies.
- 41:48That being said, it, you know, you can't do the same thing with
- 41:53an ETF, right, that you lose some of those beautiful benefits
- 41:58of, of, you know, the Bitcoin design and how it's architected.
- 42:02And, and so in many respects, I think, you know, that's a that's
- 42:07an important thing. But with multi institutional
- 42:10custody, your, your Bitcoin is on chain.
- 42:12You can see that and every custodian, right, that you know,
- 42:17is in a quorum, you know, has a, a trust minimized nature, right?
- 42:24They, they, they play one specific role and that one
- 42:28specific role is to safeguard that key and based off of your
- 42:33instructions to turn that key right, that doesn't move the
- 42:37assets right. And that's the, the beauty of of
- 42:40multi sig, you know, structure, which is native to Bitcoin.
- 42:45And and so it is kind of a cutting edge technology and
- 42:49solution that that makes it that much more empowering for the
- 42:54individual and and better to secure ultimately their holdings
- 42:59over a long period of time and minimize that single party
- 43:01failure of the counterparty risks that you described.
- 43:05Yeah, and, and pulling on the whole looking the whole
- 43:09custodian thing, it remember a friend of mine bought his first
- 43:15house NE when you're in the Northeast, Ralph, you need a
- 43:18snow blower because you're not going to get your car out.
- 43:21So he did the right thing. He bought a house, got his
- 43:23family there, bought the snow blower, did that, that's great.
- 43:26But he didn't do the third thing, which he forgot because
- 43:28it snowed and he couldn't get his car out because there was
- 43:32snow in the driveway. He forgot to put gas in the snow
- 43:35blower. So he did two out of three
- 43:38things. Well, and that is reminds me
- 43:42when you were kicking through Bitcoins like you got to know
- 43:45Bitcoin, not crypto. Good for you.
- 43:46It's one you got to buy Bitcoin Bitcoin and then you got to
- 43:52custody it, right. So you need three out of three.
- 43:55You can't do the meatloaf. Two out of three ain't bad.
- 43:58Two out of three is bad. Unfortunately, in Bitcoin, you
- 44:01got to do all three. And, you know, just like back to
- 44:05the, you know, this story about my friend, whenever we do
- 44:08something new and we haven't done it, you're going to have
- 44:11to, you should really need speak to someone who's done it before
- 44:14because you're going to miss something.
- 44:16And like all those folks who left their coins on the
- 44:18exchanges, think of that. They were in Bitcoin early.
- 44:22They bought it, they did the right thing.
- 44:24Everyone thought they were, you know, an idiot in their
- 44:27community. Maybe I'm telling my own story.
- 44:29You know, rich, I don't know about you living around.
- 44:30If your neighbors think that you being in Bitcoin is, you know,
- 44:34is something that they can't comprehend, it's changing.
- 44:38But the point is they did the work, but they didn't play the
- 44:41long game by custody and correctly.
- 44:44And that's something that being in, you know, in the investment
- 44:47world, we're just not wired for, you know, I'm 35 years doing,
- 44:52you know, stocks, bonds markets, as you said, Ralph, just stick
- 44:56them in Bony. They take care of it.
- 44:58It's not the case here. As, as we say often inside of
- 45:04our company circles, you know, the risk of Bitcoin price going
- 45:08to 0 isn't the risk, it's that your Bitcoin position holdings
- 45:16go to zero and it's, and that just amplifies the custodial
- 45:20implications. And I don't know that the
- 45:22broader community has really got their understanding of where the
- 45:26real zero risk comes from. It's how it's held.
- 45:31It's it's either your own error because you're not, you know,
- 45:36comfortable with, you know, the technology of, you know,
- 45:40securing it correctly, or you lose your pass phrase or, or
- 45:45somebody you know, you know, comes in and and forces a threat
- 45:51upon you and you know, whatever right?
- 45:53Or the, OR the flip side, which is, you know what Ralph did such
- 45:57a nice job of describing, you know, the malfeasance or human
- 46:02error or whatever it might be in terms of, you know, the
- 46:06custodial risk of, of a single exchange or custody.
- 46:11So yeah. Yeah.
- 46:14And just to add to that real fast.
- 46:16So when you get, like you said, you nailed it, rich.
- 46:21Price exposure is one thing, but price exposure, Even if Bitcoin
- 46:25did 1000% it means nothing if you don't probably secure a
- 46:29Bitcoin. And I don't want people to get
- 46:32me wrong. I mean self custody is good.
- 46:36You can have a variety of flavors of custody, but each has
- 46:41its purpose. If you're looking for long term
- 46:44gains, you really want to alleviate yourself from holding
- 46:48that responsibility. You have people, and people need
- 46:51to humble themselves as well. Because you have people who are
- 46:53developers who've worked in tech their entire life, and all it
- 46:57takes is one mistake and their whole OPSEC goes to 0 and
- 47:02they've lost the Bitcoin. It's not, as you know, simple as
- 47:07you think it is. You might have spent 100 hours
- 47:09learning about it, but at the end of the day, you're human and
- 47:12and you know, one misplaced key or you know, something were to
- 47:16happen in natural disaster and something were to happen to your
- 47:20keys or whatever it is. I mean, at the end of the day,
- 47:23we need to diversify our custody.
- 47:26And if you're looking for institutions visors, you know,
- 47:30hide out with individuals, it's unrealistic to expect them to,
- 47:34you know, manage a 12 to 24 seed phrase or, you know, using a
- 47:40plastic device. I mean, especially that type of
- 47:44audience, they're looking for some form of white glove
- 47:46service. They don't want to deal with the
- 47:48technicalities. They want to know that they
- 47:50actually own it and they have control over it if they choose
- 47:53to move it. And they'd rather still trust
- 47:57institutions. But the key here is not one
- 48:01institution, but to spread out that trust across 3
- 48:04institutions. Hence, it's a step forward in
- 48:08the way we custody because we are reducing the risk of custody
- 48:13by, you know, almost three times.
- 48:17And that, that trust piece is important, right?
- 48:19It's defining specific and limited roles of the custodian,
- 48:25right? And, and, and I, and I emphasize
- 48:27that because it's not the delegation of, of total control,
- 48:35very, very different things. And I think that you need to
- 48:38kind of, you know, do your work. If you're listening to this and
- 48:42understand the, I guess the beauty of, of multi sig and in
- 48:48more importantly, trust minimization and just defining
- 48:53limited roles that that are being played by a custodial
- 48:57partner inside of a larger quorum.
- 49:01That being said, we're kind of coming to the the close of our
- 49:08conversation today and we'll let everybody get on with their work
- 49:11weeks. But I have to say, Ralph, I
- 49:14really love the piece that you that you penned.
- 49:18Like you said earlier, it's not a rebuttal in many respects.
- 49:21We agree wholeheartedly with with much of the content in
- 49:25which BlackRock is brought forward.
- 49:27In fact, we're grateful that they did.
- 49:30That being said, it's an addendum.
- 49:33It, you know, it's, it's, I guess as we said, you can model
- 49:38the risk of the asset, but you, but you can't cherry pick it.
- 49:41You have to model, you have to model the risk of how the asset
- 49:46is actually held as well. And so that being said, we're
- 49:51really looking forward to the release of that report.
- 49:54And if people are interested, regardless of where you are, you
- 49:59know, if you're in the United States, you can go to on
- 50:01rampbitcoin.com. But if, if you're looking
- 50:05forward to that piece, please make sure that you see in, in
- 50:09the MENA region of the world, please make sure that you see
- 50:14Ralph's LinkedIn feed when he produces his report, I believe
- 50:17tomorrow. So, Ralph, we're grateful that
- 50:21you took time this evening away from family to join us.
- 50:26I think it's probably closing in on what, eight, 9:00 at night?
- 50:30I don't know. Yeah, it's almost 8, but 8.
- 50:32Almost eight, yeah. So there's no, you know.
- 50:35There's always time for Bitcoin. Yeah, there you go.
- 50:38There you go. Well, we're grateful to have you
- 50:40and, and, you know, gain your insights, you know, of Bitcoin
- 50:46and, and you know, speak about some of the work that you're
- 50:50doing. And, and so thank you so much
- 50:53for for taking the time this evening and, and joining us and
- 50:57for the rest of you in the audience, we wish you all a, a
- 51:00very productive week. And if there's any way that we
- 51:03can help you in your efforts, you know, don't hesitate to
- 51:06reach out to any one of the three of us.
- 51:09So thank you. Thank you for having me guys.
- 51:12Yeah, Ralph, pleasure having you.
- 51:15Thanks guys. You bet.
- 51:16Take care guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 51:19week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 51:21valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 51:24rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 51:26All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 51:28notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 51:31reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 51:33entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 51:36investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 51:39your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 51:42Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 51:46one of our private Client advisors.