Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / International Family Law - Family Law Across the U.S. and India
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:02International Family Law Series. I'm Alphonse
- 0:05Provenziano, a family law practitioner based
- 0:08in Beverly Hills, California, and also a fellow
- 0:10of the International Academy of Family Lawyers.
- 0:13This episode will be joined by two Indian practitioners,
- 0:18Ranjit Malhotra and Rulani Deshmukh. And what
- 0:22the significance to us is in California in particular
- 0:26is that There is such a big diaspora of people
- 0:30from India in California. But when you're faced
- 0:33with a case involving India, and let's say the
- 0:36family has property, well, how do you value that
- 0:39property in India? What are the ways to deal
- 0:41with that? And this is a recurring theme that
- 0:43we see often. And there's differing attitudes
- 0:46on how a divorce will be enforced from California
- 0:49to India. And there's even differences among
- 0:51practitioners. and differences regionally within
- 0:54India, how they're going to treat our divorce
- 0:56decrees, not to mention the fact that there's
- 0:59significant challenges in enforcing child abduction
- 1:02orders. So when you have these Indian cases and
- 1:05you're faced with Indian cross -border issues,
- 1:09given the huge Indian population in California,
- 1:13these are two people that you really want. to
- 1:15know and to tell you a little bit about them.
- 1:17Ranjit Malhotra is a Chandigarh based advocate
- 1:20practicing before the Supreme Court of India
- 1:22and the Punjab and Haryana High Court with over
- 1:25three decades of experience in international
- 1:27family law. private international law and immigration.
- 1:31And he is a fellow also of the International
- 1:33Academy of Family Lawyers. And he was the first
- 1:36Indian lawyer awarded the Felix Scholarship to
- 1:38pursue his LLM at the University of London. He
- 1:42advises foreign lawyers and embassies on cross
- 1:44-border matters, provides expert testimony and
- 1:47oversees proceedings, and has authored nine books
- 1:50on Indian family law and legal issues for residents
- 1:52worldwide. And Rulani Deshmukh is, in addition
- 1:56to being a lovely person, is a Mumbai -based
- 1:59advocate with over four decades of practice in
- 2:02Indian family law appearing across all courts
- 2:05in India. And she's very modest, but she's a
- 2:07very well -known lawyer all throughout India
- 2:10and is a real pioneer in her field. And she's
- 2:13been involved in landmark judgments on maintenance,
- 2:16child abduction, relocation, and has spoken domestically
- 2:19and internationally on family law. wealth structuring
- 2:21and laws governing women. Their expertise together
- 2:26in cross -border family law disputes is something
- 2:30that will be absolutely essential for your understanding
- 2:33of when you're dealing with legal complexities
- 2:36facing the global Indian diaspora. Let's get
- 2:39to our episode. Really wonderful to be here with
- 2:44you, Ranjit and Rulani. And it's a wonderful
- 2:50thing because we're here in Barcelona, getting
- 2:53to meet in person to discuss Indian law and California
- 2:57law. And I just wanted to thank you both so much
- 2:59for being here. Thank you so much for having
- 3:02us over here. And I'm sure we're going to have
- 3:04a great conversation regarding the subject matter.
- 3:06Thank you so much. Appreciate it. It's such a
- 3:08pleasure. And I know you just came in. The people
- 3:12at home don't understand this, but it's about
- 3:141030 a .m. here in Barcelona before the International
- 3:17Academy of Family Lawyers. And you just got in
- 3:20from India at 8 a .m. And Ranjit, how long was
- 3:24your flight from India? I had a long journey
- 3:27from my home to Delhi was six hours by taxi.
- 3:31Then I took a connection from Delhi to Munich,
- 3:34eight and a half hours, two hours waiting. And
- 3:35then another two hours for me, door to door,
- 3:37it was only 26 hours. I've been doing this all
- 3:39my life. Only 26 hours. So I've been traveling
- 3:42for 35 years, right from, you can use it, Toronto,
- 3:44Vancouver to Sydney, Perth, here, there. I love
- 3:47it. And we are very grateful to you for setting
- 3:50up this podcast. And I was just thinking about
- 3:54it, three experts from three different cities.
- 3:55on a neutral soil. It's it's it's sort of the
- 4:01magic of the International Academy of Family
- 4:03Lawyers. And it's nice that the Beverly Hills
- 4:06Bar Association sponsors these podcasts that
- 4:09really the interesting thing we were talking
- 4:11about is there's such a huge diaspora of Indian
- 4:14citizens in the United States and particularly
- 4:17in California. They're drawn to California from
- 4:20the tech industry, engineering, science, medicine
- 4:23and law and bankers, everything. We have such
- 4:27a huge. uh, Indian community. And I think for
- 4:31a lot of practitioners, um, in California, they
- 4:34don't understand, well, look, I have this case
- 4:36where there's, there's a nexus in India. Um,
- 4:40and how do we, how do we deal with that? So I
- 4:42was kind of wanting to, we're hoping to do a
- 4:44deep dive so that California practitioners can
- 4:47know what there is to know about India and they'll
- 4:50have two great. people in different cities to
- 4:54talk about a little bit about these problems
- 4:56and if they need help in the future. Thank you,
- 4:58Alfonso. I mean, you're right. The legal baggage
- 5:01of the NRI community is huge and immense. I mean,
- 5:05I was just doing an expert report for one of
- 5:07these high -end professionals in the US. No,
- 5:09what happens is there are very complicated issues
- 5:12in so far, especially relating to the validity
- 5:14of managers. Then any divorce litigation starts,
- 5:17right? It's quite complicated. for you in your
- 5:21jurisdiction, like the marriage certificate is
- 5:24the last word. But now what happens is in our
- 5:26country if you have got married under the provisions
- 5:28of the Hindu Marriage Act 1995, which has like
- 5:32extra territorial application, right, it's like
- 5:34your personal law you carry in your pocket, it
- 5:36extends outside the territories of India. So
- 5:39now the core question which comes at the start
- 5:42of any bitterly contested divorce litigation,
- 5:46especially when Either of the spouses are highly
- 5:49qualified and their multi -jurisdictional assets
- 5:51is the validity of the marriage. See we have
- 5:54section 7 of the Hindu marriage act 1955. Now
- 5:58it prescribes the ceremonies of marriage. Now
- 6:01what happens is whether it's Northern India or
- 6:03Southern India. You see, in Northern India, you
- 6:06will have the seven steps around the sacred and
- 6:08the holy fire with the priest chanting the hymns.
- 6:11That is the validity of the marriage, right?
- 6:13See, traditionally in olden days, registration
- 6:15of marriage is not compulsory. You know, that
- 6:18the priest doing the ceremony and inviting everybody,
- 6:21family, extended family, friends, acquaintances,
- 6:23a few hundred or 500 people depending on your
- 6:25standing. That was considered to be the validity
- 6:27of the marriage. Now what happens is you go to
- 6:30southern India, right? They will have a different
- 6:33set of customs. People coming from Kerala, Andhra
- 6:35Pradesh. So these are ceremonies which are like
- 6:39akin to ceremonies of marriage. Now what happens
- 6:42is sometimes there may not be valid ceremonies
- 6:45of marriage. Nonetheless, you have a marriage
- 6:48registration certificate, right? So the foreign
- 6:53court judge He is in a maze. He says look here,
- 6:57here is this marriage certificate, but how are
- 7:00you now challenging or assailing the validity
- 7:02of the marriage per se as such. Now the answer
- 7:06to that question is under section 8 of the Hindu
- 7:11marriage act 1955, the marriage certificate is
- 7:16neither conclusive proof nor of the date of marriage
- 7:19nor of the ceremonies of marriage because it
- 7:22is only a declaration. before a public authority,
- 7:25it's an administrative function. The parties
- 7:28to the marriage themselves are responsible for
- 7:31the contents of the marriage certificate. They
- 7:33have to give evidence like marriage photographs,
- 7:37wedding invitation cards, their ID cards and
- 7:41witnesses from both sides of the families. Sometimes
- 7:44it is manipulated. issues become very important
- 7:47issues. Sometimes there have been cases in addition
- 7:50to tending expert evidence the courts have gone
- 7:53so far even sort of examining the priest who
- 7:57stated who have performed the ceremonies of marriage.
- 7:59And I think that's something that we a lot of
- 8:01times in California don't appreciate. California
- 8:04in terms of getting married you just go you get
- 8:06your marriage license and then you have to have
- 8:09an official officiant do the marriage and then
- 8:12which can usually be a priest or a judge or a
- 8:16minister but what's very different and it's something
- 8:19that's very rare for people in the US to understand
- 8:21is this concept of personal status laws and and
- 8:26that different religions are treated differently
- 8:29in terms of the formation of the marriage and
- 8:32Mulani maybe you could Tell us a little bit about
- 8:33that. So it's a very peculiar setup as far as
- 8:38the Indian marriages are concerned. Please appreciate
- 8:41that our marriages or our Hindu law or the other
- 8:45laws have their origin in the unquotified law,
- 8:49which has come through customs, usages, et cetera.
- 8:51Only in 1955 was the codification done, where
- 8:56all these things which were happening otherwise
- 8:58without a statute were now put into a statute
- 9:02to give it that statutory recognition. And in
- 9:05India, it's a multicultural, multi -religious
- 9:08country. So we have Hindus, we have Muslims,
- 9:12we have Parsis, we have Jews, we have Christians.
- 9:17Fortunately, unfortunately, I don't know what
- 9:19to say that, but there's no similarity or one
- 9:23forum where things happen. So a person, your
- 9:26religion is something that takes you for your
- 9:30marriages, for your inheritance, for the other
- 9:32subsequent thing. So hence, now there is to be
- 9:35honest, now there is a move that's been happening
- 9:38in India where they're trying to have a uniform
- 9:41civil code, which means all these civil issues
- 9:44relating to marriage, inheritance, succession,
- 9:48etc. could come under one statute so that there
- 9:51is no difference. But that will take some time.
- 9:54As we speak, we are still governed by the personal
- 9:56laws. And that is why the personal status is
- 10:00something which is very unique and very exceptional
- 10:03as far as the Indian marriages are concerned.
- 10:06And that is where I think as we progress in our
- 10:09conversation, we'll be able to share as to how
- 10:12is it that is affecting I mean to decide jurisdictional
- 10:16issues, to decide what is the domicile of the
- 10:19parties, to decide which is the appropriate forum
- 10:22before this it could go. So all those things
- 10:25are a little interlinked and as you may be having
- 10:27a lot of issues, we also have similar cases of
- 10:31parties married in India but residing in the
- 10:34US. You know, it's a California or whatever the
- 10:37case may be. Well, and that's an interesting
- 10:39thing because how do we determine if we're looking
- 10:44at a case, the first question is client comes
- 10:45into our office, let's say, and let's say one
- 10:48spouse is in India, the other spouse is in California.
- 10:54How in India do we look at, well, when do they
- 10:58get jurisdiction? Let's assume they're both...
- 11:00Indian nationals, but maybe one lives in California
- 11:04and the other spouse has gone back to India.
- 11:07How would we look at a jurisdictional problem
- 11:09in that sense? Here I might chime in, please.
- 11:12Now what happens is, if the parties have got
- 11:15married in India, right, and their marriage has
- 11:18been registered in India, right, they have a
- 11:21choice to get divorced in India in case things
- 11:25run sour, provided they agree or acquiesce. That
- 11:29is one aspect. Now, I also must chip in when
- 11:32it comes to the validity of the marriage. There
- 11:34is another very important legislation called
- 11:36the Special Marriage Act 1954. Now, the Special
- 11:40Marriage Act 1954, it comes into play when two
- 11:45persons marry, principally people of two different
- 11:48religions, right? Say it's like one American
- 11:52Christian and an Indian person. So what will
- 11:56happen is, now there are two avenues under this
- 11:59legislation. One is that you Solomonize a marriage
- 12:04before the marriage officer in your competent
- 12:07jurisdiction. You go to the office of the marriage
- 12:10officer, you submit in your paperwork, both parties
- 12:13have to be present. It can't be like proxy de
- 12:16facto. You lodge in your papers, then you put
- 12:21in a public notice. in one of the regional papers,
- 12:24local papers and a public notice in the said
- 12:27office inviting objections from members of the
- 12:30public if they have any potential objections.
- 12:33then what happens is you come back after 30 days,
- 12:36assuming there are no objections. You know, sometimes
- 12:38there is friction with the families when you
- 12:41find a person of Indian origin, he or she is
- 12:44marrying somebody outside their religion. Things
- 12:47have changed, India has become very cost -reportant,
- 12:49but still there is friction sometimes and unpleasantness.
- 12:54If everything is fine, after 30 days, you go
- 12:57back to the marriage officer, you get your marriage
- 12:59certificate. advising a lot number of Schengen
- 13:03member states on their settlement applications,
- 13:06they are very touchy on one aspect and rightly
- 13:09so that under the provisions of the Special Marriage
- 13:12Act 1954, one of the parties must have resided
- 13:15in that jurisdiction for a period of 30 days
- 13:18at a stretch. It is just that you just can fly
- 13:21in both of you and just try to have your marriage
- 13:24registered, right? Oh, interesting. Married,
- 13:27Solomonized. In India. Now, this is one aspect.
- 13:31The second aspect is, this is a grey area. There
- 13:33is a lot of confusion. A lot of people get it
- 13:35wrong and it leads to big time trouble. The second
- 13:39avenue is, you can have your marriage registered
- 13:43as celebrated in other forms, validly, according
- 13:48to your personal law. In that case, there is
- 13:51a separate column, separate provision in the
- 13:54set certificate saying that so and so got married
- 13:58as per Hindu law or as per their valid personal
- 14:01law, it could be Muslim law, it could be Christian
- 14:03law on so and so date and they have been living
- 14:06as husband and wife from so and so date and point
- 14:09of time and that marriage is registered under
- 14:13the provisions of the Special Marriage Act 1954
- 14:15in contradistinction to pure Solomonization.
- 14:21When you're looking at a divorce case in India,
- 14:24given the different personal statuses of people,
- 14:27their different religions, they could be Hindu,
- 14:30Muslim, Jewish, Christian, is it something where
- 14:34you're always having to first take a look, do
- 14:36we have a valid marriage? Because it's not very
- 14:39clear. That's the starting point. Interesting.
- 14:40Because you see what happens. And you see that
- 14:42too. Yes, so that's a very important point that
- 14:45you have to see whether the validity of the marriage
- 14:47and I'll give you some examples which are real
- 14:50life examples that if a Hindu wants to get married
- 14:53to a non -Hindu who's a Christian. So obviously
- 14:55as Ranjit said that it has to be under the Special
- 14:58Marriage Act which is a secular act, it doesn't
- 15:01consider any religion. as the primary concern.
- 15:05So if this is the thing, then that's a best case
- 15:09option. But some people want to get married under
- 15:12the Hindu law. I am a Hindu but my partner is
- 15:17not a Hindu but I want to get it done. So there
- 15:19is a provision wherein the partner gets converted
- 15:23to Hinduism. So there is a ceremony which is
- 15:26a very nominal ceremony which is called conversion.
- 15:30So say if my partner is a Christian he gets converted
- 15:33into a Hindu prior to the marriage and post that
- 15:37conversion we get married as per the Hindu rights.
- 15:40So then we continue to be governed by the Hindu
- 15:43Marriage Act. Now the question that arises is
- 15:47what you are saying is that what happens, I think
- 15:50you started off by saying, what happens is one
- 15:53of the spouses is in California and the other
- 15:56spouse comes to India. So how would you advise
- 15:59your clients that what is the law and what is
- 16:03it? The difference that I see is as per States
- 16:09in the US and some of them which because I have
- 16:11worked on it is a 60 day 90 day or six months
- 16:16Residents gives the person a jurisdiction to
- 16:19do that. I know that about the East Coast Boston
- 16:21For example, if you're residing there for six
- 16:24months irrespective of the fact where you got
- 16:26married irrespective of the fact where your spouse
- 16:29is you could file that and that that's a court
- 16:31of competent jurisdiction Now we get cases where
- 16:35people do get divorces in that manner Indian
- 16:39courts do not accept that. That is not considered
- 16:42to be a valid divorce because the parties have
- 16:45got married, I'm saying for the sake of argument
- 16:47under the Hindu Marriage Act. So that divorce
- 16:49has to be taken and now you will ask me is there
- 16:52any particular section in the statute which says
- 16:55that this should not be done? The answer to that
- 16:58question is no. It is by judicial interpretation.
- 17:01of the cases that have started way back in 1975,
- 17:05some of the landmark cases which are there, which
- 17:08has laid down the law. And this law says that
- 17:11the parties who are married under the Hindu Marriage
- 17:14Act have to get divorced under the Hindu Marriage
- 17:16Act. unless both the parties voluntarily submit
- 17:20to another jurisdiction. There could be a situation
- 17:23where two people are in California, they're married
- 17:25under the Hindu Marriage Act, and you would have
- 17:28jurisdiction and they could do that. A consent
- 17:31divorce is accepted, but if it's at one... You
- 17:34know, either one -sided divorce that is granted
- 17:36by the court could be challenged by the court.
- 17:38See, that's a very interesting thing because
- 17:40in California we have this ability to have what
- 17:43we call a status -only divorce. So the parties
- 17:46could... just agree to get divorced. And then
- 17:49that's a that's an agreement that their marriage
- 17:51is they're no longer married. But then then you
- 17:55can reserve all your issues of property division,
- 17:59alimony, spousal support, child support, custody
- 18:02for another determination. So that is an interesting
- 18:05nuance that that a lot of practitioners in California
- 18:09wouldn't understand that if you if you're Hindus
- 18:14and your there sounds like if there's an objection.
- 18:17in one person's maybe in India, but the other
- 18:19person's in California, and you're saying, look,
- 18:22I'm gonna go forward in California, I'm gonna
- 18:24go forward with this divorce in California, and
- 18:26the other person objects to it, they may not,
- 18:29you could do your divorce in California theoretically,
- 18:31and then have an unenforceable judgment in India,
- 18:35is that what you have seen? Yes, exactly, that's
- 18:37what it is, that the Indian courts most of the
- 18:39time do not recognize, because there are... case
- 18:43laws, that is what the judicial precedents have
- 18:45been, and there are certain sections of the Civil
- 18:47Procedure Code which says what is a foreign judgment
- 18:51and which is that foreign judgment which can
- 18:54be executed in the Indian courts or valid under
- 18:57the Indian law. So these two things have to be
- 19:00sort of, you know, got together for the courts
- 19:02to determine the validity of probably a divorce
- 19:05which you may get into in the California court
- 19:08but may not be acceptable or Well, and I have
- 19:13an interesting question for you. So if you're
- 19:17Muslims, let's say, and you're from India, is
- 19:20it the same treatment? Do you have to get divorced
- 19:23under any particular Muslim code in India, or
- 19:26is it more focused for Hindus? So Muslim law
- 19:29or the Islamic law, they do not have a structured
- 19:33statute. They are governed by the Sharia law,
- 19:35but more by the religious thing. So a woman has
- 19:39an option. for going for divorce in the court
- 19:43under which she has been treated cruelly or whatever
- 19:46her grounds may have been. But a husband to divorce
- 19:50his wife has to go as per his personal law of
- 19:54pronouncing talaq. Talaq is a divorce. And there
- 19:58are certain guidelines which now the courts have
- 20:00let down as to what could be constituting a valid
- 20:04talaq or a divorce. But that is not from the
- 20:08court. It is by legal notices and pronouncement
- 20:13before the religious heads. I'm kind of curious
- 20:16too, in the sense of that kind of consideration,
- 20:23is property treated differently based on your
- 20:26religion or is it the same way? Okay, before
- 20:30we proceed further, I have three... points to
- 20:34chip in supplemental to a very important issue.
- 20:38Then I'll come to the other two issues. One is
- 20:41she raised a very valid point about the law of
- 20:43conversion. Now you see what happens is traditionally
- 20:46what the law of conversion means is that before
- 20:49the priest is actually if it's like it's a Christian
- 20:51person wanting to get married to a let's say
- 20:54a very common scenario European husband lady
- 21:01from Delhi or anywhere down south, Bombay, Kerala.
- 21:06Right? Both are highly qualified. They come from
- 21:09well -known families. They have a grand ceremony
- 21:11in the Taj, in Delhi, the works, the big fat
- 21:14Indian wedding, 500 people for five days. That
- 21:16we all want to go to. I've always wanted to be
- 21:18at one of those Indian weddings. Right. It's
- 21:20very exhausting. But now what happens is, right,
- 21:24so that wedding is done with big pomp and show
- 21:26to announce the whole world. Right. They get
- 21:29married. They get a priest. They have no clue
- 21:31about conversion. Right. When they apply for
- 21:35the lady's visa at the Schengen member state
- 21:38or any other place, the validity of the marriage
- 21:42certificate comes under the jeweler's focus,
- 21:45right? The embassy is short, short going to say,
- 21:47we do a lot of advice work for Schengen member
- 21:49states. They will immediately attack the validity
- 21:53of the marriage. They'll say, where was the conversion?
- 21:56I mean. the family, you don't blame them, they
- 21:59will have no clue about conversion. Generally
- 22:01what happens is the priest solemnizing the wedding,
- 22:04if he's told about the conversion, what he does
- 22:07is just before the marriage or after they've
- 22:09wrapped up and the family tells the priest, look
- 22:12here, can you give us a certificate that you
- 22:14solemnize the wedding because we now have to
- 22:16go to the office of the registrar of marriages
- 22:18or the marriage officer as the case may be. So
- 22:21generally the priest will just scribble a few
- 22:23lines saying, Mark, Zuckerman, God converted
- 22:27to Hinduism. Now, now, now. That may be accepted,
- 22:31that may not be accepted, right? The embassy,
- 22:34the Schengen member state generally is well within
- 22:38their powers to question you. Are you a devout
- 22:42Hindu? What do you do to practice Hindu law,
- 22:45right? Or Hindu religion, not Hindu law, Hindu
- 22:47religion. Now, we have a very important document
- 22:50which is Report number 235 of the Law Commission
- 22:55of India. I have often referred it to in all
- 22:58my expert reports and legal opinions. It's the
- 23:01best consolidated, documented document analyzing
- 23:06the entire law on conversion and reconversion.
- 23:11Now, the second part. Is the impact then, and
- 23:14a lot of people in... in California, they might
- 23:18not pick up on this nuance. The Schengen area
- 23:20obviously is the EU where you can travel freely.
- 23:25And and so I'm kind of curious if if the parties
- 23:28get married, let's say, and you can't necessarily
- 23:32the embassy says, well, we're questioning if
- 23:35you really converted. Is that a way then to deny
- 23:38that it's a valid marriage? You see, you you.
- 23:41Oh, interesting. Right. You see, what generally
- 23:43happens is the way out is. Well, that marriage
- 23:47was done for pomp and show, right? So the way
- 23:49out is you... Do a new marriage. You do Solomonizer
- 23:53marriage under the provisions of the Special
- 23:55Marriage Act 1954, right? That is a convenient
- 23:58way out. Because you see, if you go back to the
- 24:00Office of the Register of Marriages for annulling
- 24:03that... marriage, that's another story. Now the
- 24:06second point which I wanted to raise or which
- 24:08Bananali raised a very, very valid point that
- 24:10the foreign court judgments, the divorce decrees
- 24:13of the judgment, that has to be in consonance
- 24:16with... are provisions of the civil procedure
- 24:18court. That's principally section 13 and section
- 24:2044 and then we have a list of reciprocating territories
- 24:24under 44A and there's a list drawn up by the
- 24:27government of India. So you know basically the
- 24:29law is, settle law is, it should not violate
- 24:31the principles of natural justice, it should
- 24:34not be opposed to the public policy, should be
- 24:38in consonance with laws of India. Now what happens
- 24:40is, as Banalini pointed out, sometimes what happens
- 24:44is the husband goes to a particular county or
- 24:47the jurisdiction, say it's California, England,
- 24:49or Canada, he files for divorce proceedings.
- 24:52And then what he does is he tries to effect service
- 24:55under the hate process, which doesn't work because
- 24:58it has to be rooted to the government authorities,
- 25:00right? And that takes one hell of a lot of time.
- 25:03It may not be successful. It goes through so
- 25:05many channels. And by the time the representatives
- 25:07actually show up, there is so much bitterness
- 25:10at the... at the side of the wife's family, generally
- 25:15the wife is at the receiving end, right? Unfortunately,
- 25:19so because the issue comes, you know, with regard
- 25:21to dowry and other stuff, it's, you know, sort
- 25:23of a slur on the family name. I mean, people
- 25:26feel very bad and bitter. We have, you know,
- 25:28so many of these holiday wives, abandoned wives,
- 25:32which the numbers swell up in thousands in Punjab
- 25:34in northern India, where it's a big, you know,
- 25:37status thing for one member of the family to
- 25:40be married abroad. Right. So. or if they are
- 25:43not able to effect the service to the Hague process
- 25:46then what happens is they engage private lawyers
- 25:49or investigators or detectives to get an affidavit
- 25:52of service or an affidavit of attempted service
- 25:54and the wife is or the spouse in India is slammed
- 25:58with a divorce, judgment and a decree. And you
- 26:01know often the spouse at the Indian end does
- 26:04not have the means and resources. to engage a
- 26:07council say in California or whatever, right?
- 26:10And under Indian law, representation should mean
- 26:13representation by council of the spouse whose
- 26:17resident India married to a foreign spouse, an
- 26:21overseas spouse, right? So they will not accept
- 26:25the fact that the spouse residing in India was
- 26:29served summons. that will not constitute proper
- 26:32representation in court. So what happens is sometimes,
- 26:34you know, five years pass down the line and the
- 26:37spouse who's abroad, he says, now, well, it's
- 26:39time to get remarried. Let me go back home. He
- 26:42lands at New Delhi Airport and the police arrest
- 26:44him. because what happens is there is a lookout
- 26:46notice for him. He thought, I mean, life is paradise,
- 26:50it's bliss, it's all sorted out. So people at
- 26:53the Indian end, you know, generally they also
- 26:55end up complaining to the Human Rights Commission,
- 26:57to the Ministry of External Affairs, they have
- 26:59a portal for NRI grievances, which is called
- 27:02the non -residents Indian, as you know. Right?
- 27:06So there are a lot of dimensions to it. I mean,
- 27:08it's very risky, sitting pretty thinking that
- 27:10you've slammed... Why would the police arrest
- 27:14the person? You see, what happens is there are
- 27:16dowry issues, right? Because often it so happens,
- 27:19say we are having a scenario of a husband and
- 27:20a wife, right? Say wife is from Punjab or Northern
- 27:22India or maybe Maharashtra, right? She has been
- 27:26slammed with a divorce judgment or a decree wherein
- 27:29she was never represented. All she could do was,
- 27:31you know... to send some representations to the
- 27:34court, right? And because she was not represented
- 27:36by council, she did not have the opportunity
- 27:39to put her own version. You know, family honour
- 27:41is at stake, there have been dowry issues, right?
- 27:46So they keep on complaining, you know, and as
- 27:48you know, ultimately the long arm of law catches
- 27:51you at the end of the day. It takes time. So
- 27:54the police comes in, because in certain parts...
- 27:57primarily as Ranjit has said in the northern
- 28:00part of India and maybe less a little down south
- 28:03when you go. The issue of dowry, I don't know
- 28:07how much you or the lawyers are aware of. Dowry
- 28:13is a concept wherein the girl's parents are forced,
- 28:18coerced, emotionally blackmailed to give the
- 28:21husband or the husband's family members you know,
- 28:26things in terms of gold, things in terms of cash,
- 28:29things in terms of properties, to all those things,
- 28:32because, and the concept is because the girl
- 28:35is going to come and stay with us, and I'm the
- 28:37husband and he's going to stay with us. you have
- 28:40to compensate us, and that compensation is called
- 28:43dowry. Now this is a complete abuse of what the
- 28:47situation is. It's a token amount that you have
- 28:50to give, say a hundred dollar bill, okay, in
- 28:53your words, is all that you need to give because
- 28:55that's what the custom is. But that custom has
- 28:58been so misused and abused. So if a girl's family
- 29:02is subjected to this, which is illegal demands,
- 29:06or monetary demands from the husband and his
- 29:10family, then the wife has an option under the
- 29:12law to file a police complaint against him, his
- 29:16parents, or whoever the family members are, and
- 29:19that would come under the criminal proceedings
- 29:21and not under the civil proceeding. And that
- 29:24is why in extreme cases, There could be a case
- 29:27of arrest warrant or something. So that's the
- 29:30case that we are talking about. That's so interesting.
- 29:33So husband gets a default judgment in California,
- 29:36keeps the dowry and returns to India. Thinking
- 29:40it's all over. Thinking it's done with, but it's
- 29:43not. And so I guess the sad moral of the story
- 29:46in those situations are if you can maybe divide
- 29:50up your US assets, but then you've got huge legal
- 29:53problems in India. Yes, so what happens? That's
- 29:57the trap for people advising clients in the US.
- 30:00So what happens is I'll tell you a very typical
- 30:02case. And I'm being very honest over here. If
- 30:05I'm representing a husband who probably had lived
- 30:07in California for some time and the wife has
- 30:11come back or she's staying there. But it mattered
- 30:13under the Hindu Marriage Act, and they were married
- 30:15in Bombay for the sake of argument. We advise
- 30:19him to file here, to grab the jurisdiction here.
- 30:22The reason, in India. In India, yeah. The reason
- 30:25being, I want to safeguard the equitable and
- 30:30the community property which you have in the
- 30:33US, in the California jurisdiction, where all
- 30:36marital assets minus the debts are divided equally.
- 30:40That's what I understand. In California. In California,
- 30:42yes. And most of the western US, but not. Yes.
- 30:44And somewhat, to a certain extent, you'll have
- 30:46that in the East Coast, but it's dealt with,
- 30:48called Equitable Principles of Common Law. Yes.
- 30:51that in New York State because I've done a couple
- 30:53of matters there. So if I have to protect his
- 30:55assets and not be subjected to the equitable
- 30:58distribution and be guided by the Indian law,
- 31:02because in Indian law we do not have this equitable
- 31:05and proportionate distribution of the assets
- 31:06or marital income which is there. It is only
- 31:09based on the needs of the woman, her maintenance,
- 31:12her residence, and her lifestyle that they have
- 31:14led as a couple for over a period of time. So
- 31:17there's a huge difference between 50 % going
- 31:19to the wife and the wife getting amount from
- 31:22here. So we advise, run, run, run. Is it gender
- 31:25focused? Yes. And that's so different from...
- 31:28No, it's gender -focused, which is in the interest
- 31:31of the husband. But we have wives, I'm giving
- 31:34the other flip side, who are otherwise either
- 31:37residents there or at some point of time were
- 31:40residing there, which gives them jurisdiction
- 31:42to file. They file it over there. I'm doing three
- 31:44cases right now where the wives have threatened
- 31:47or they're filed over there while the parties
- 31:49were married in India and all three husbands
- 31:52are... I mean those cases, their husbands are
- 31:55my clients, and we have advised them that let's
- 31:59file it here before she grabs the jurisdiction.
- 32:02Otherwise you have these cross -jurisdictional
- 32:04issues. Wow. And how does that prevent it? How
- 32:07does that prevent the cross -jurisdiction? Because
- 32:08if I file it here, and the wife files it in India,
- 32:12and the wife files it there, I can challenge
- 32:14the jurisdiction. And I will say that, listen,
- 32:17we are Indians. We may be even US citizens. But
- 32:19we are born Hindus. And we got married under
- 32:23the Hindu Marriage Act. We continue to be Hindus.
- 32:25So we are governed by this law. And there is
- 32:27a competent court of India, whether it's Mumbai
- 32:30or any other place, which is going to decide
- 32:33these issues. We're talking about the Indian
- 32:36courts. We're talking about the courts which
- 32:38also consider the rights of the wife, the rights
- 32:40of the children, the maintenance, the residence,
- 32:43etc. They may not consider equitable and proportionate
- 32:46distribution, but they are going to consider
- 32:48that. So we are going to say... Why are you going
- 32:51there if I'm for the husband? Come to India,
- 32:53you can get whatever it is. The wife feels she
- 32:56may not get a proper share here, and she wants
- 32:59to go there. So this conflict is always... If
- 33:02you are the moneyed spouse, let's say you're
- 33:04the person who has the assets, do you... We understand
- 33:08California and much of the US, even though it
- 33:11doesn't say it's that way, but definitely California
- 33:13Western states, it's a 50 -50 marital division,
- 33:17but then premarital property, separate property.
- 33:19Post -separation, separate property, 100%. Where
- 33:22do you think about filing in that consideration?
- 33:24Here I'll chip in. What I have seen, especially
- 33:27from US, the new generation of super smart. Highly
- 33:32qualified young professionals, techies, bankers,
- 33:35software engineers. For sure, people working
- 33:37in the tech industry, coming to California, working
- 33:41in all sorts of companies there. You will be
- 33:44surprised, Afonso. They do massive research on
- 33:48forum shopping. They will ask you very pinpointed
- 33:52questions, right? They will ring up. people like
- 33:54Menalri, us, head, dad, right? So they know what
- 33:58they're doing, right? See, basically, if you
- 34:00are smart, you know what you do is you nudge
- 34:03everything to India. Because what happens is,
- 34:06like the golden handshake, which you would get
- 34:09in California, you would not get in India. I
- 34:12mean, not exactly the same way. But today, I
- 34:15mean, just to take this forward, Ranjith is absolutely
- 34:18right. It's not going to be 50%. That's not the
- 34:21law of the land. The law of the land is 25 %
- 34:24which goes to the wife. Interesting. And because
- 34:28the husband has the responsibilities of the children
- 34:30also. So then he solely picks up the responsibilities
- 34:34of the children. So today, the wife gets 25%,
- 34:37if $100 is what the net worth is, around 25 %
- 34:40to 30%. I'm not saying exactly 24 hours, in which
- 34:44all her rights are taken care of. While the wife
- 34:47feels if I go to the US, of course. But the other
- 34:51problem is, which the wives don't understand,
- 34:53is that in India, all assets of the husband are
- 34:57concerned. prior to marriage, ancestral, gifted
- 35:01assets, all is in the pool when the court is
- 35:04going to decide. So it's not exactly not favorable,
- 35:08but in a very simple manner, not exactly a straight
- 35:13cut. It takes time. So there are some procedural
- 35:16delays. That's so interesting. So now there are
- 35:18four upshots over here, right? Now what happens
- 35:21is, number one, if the divorce proceedings are
- 35:25instituted in India, one, It is very difficult
- 35:29to prove the foreign assets of the husband in
- 35:32St. California or U .S., right? Then the big
- 35:35question is, does the judge or the court have
- 35:41jurisdiction over the foreign assets of the husband
- 35:44in St. U .S.? Territorial jurisdiction. Territorial
- 35:46jurisdiction. Now, number two, delay. you can
- 35:50drag it on. Typical scenarios, you challenge
- 35:52the validity of the marriage ceremony. I did
- 35:56an expert opinion a couple of years ago. A highly
- 36:00qualified gentleman, loaded with money, operating
- 36:03from the UAE, with assets everywhere, married
- 36:07children, settled in New York and England, questioning
- 36:10the validity of the marriage. There were three
- 36:12councils in the picture. One from UAE, Dubai,
- 36:17UAE, England, myself in India. I said, look here,
- 36:20you possibly cannot seal the validity of the
- 36:23marriage ceremony. What had happened was, say
- 36:25like 20 years ago, he got married in Delhi, the
- 36:27priest was still around. Sometimes they go to
- 36:30the extent of... We have to go to the extent
- 36:31of questioning the priest. Did you solemnize
- 36:34the marriage? Wow. And who remembers that after
- 36:3720 years? Yeah. You see, the person in this particular
- 36:40case... Right. Yeah, you got a very valid point.
- 36:42In this particular case, the priest was around,
- 36:45the husband confessed that the temple is near
- 36:49the house of his mother -in -law, right? The
- 36:52priest can be approached. He said, he was trying
- 36:54to just question something, but there was an
- 36:57overwhelming catalogue of evidence in so far
- 37:00relating to the ceremonies of marriage. He just
- 37:02wanted to take advantage of the situation that
- 37:05the marriage was registered. I said, you will
- 37:07not succeed. You will not succeed at all because
- 37:10there were heavy stakes. So now two issues, as
- 37:12I told you, one is... How long did that take,
- 37:16that case go from start to finish? How many years
- 37:18did it take? No, no, they just, you see, they
- 37:21just contacted me on the issue of the validity
- 37:24of the marriage. The solicitors in England, the
- 37:28council in UAE and myself here in India, and
- 37:31they had their matrimonial home was also in England.
- 37:35I mean, rich people have houses in so many cities
- 37:37and jurisdictions. and his English solicitors
- 37:40advised him. He says, the moment I advise you
- 37:44not to travel to England, the moment you land
- 37:45at Heathrow, there will be some agent waiting
- 37:48outside to serve you proceedings. So I said,
- 37:52this cannot be taken forward. I am sorry. I cannot
- 37:55do an expert report. Now two issues I've addressed.
- 37:58One is of delay, territorial jurisdiction over
- 38:02foreign assets. So these are two significant
- 38:06points. Then the issue of the validity of the
- 38:10marriage, we have addressed. There were two more
- 38:12points which have now sort of got drowned in
- 38:14the conversation you're having. And I think that's
- 38:17the fascinating thing, talking about all this
- 38:18stuff, is when you start peeling the onion layers
- 38:21away, you see the complexity that's involved.
- 38:24And I think that that's the challenge for a lot
- 38:26of US practitioners. And we will have a lot of
- 38:30people that are, let's say they're of Indian
- 38:33ancestry. and they may have just emigrated, but
- 38:36they're US citizens now, but then they have issues
- 38:39where, let's say, they are getting through a
- 38:42divorce right now in California, but they have
- 38:46property in India. And that's always a very challenging
- 38:49thing. Yeah, I'll come back to my third point.
- 38:51It's about property. What happens is, you've
- 38:54done your research very well. I admire you. Sitting
- 38:56from a desk in California, you've got a very
- 38:58good picture of what happens on the ground. You
- 39:00see, what happens is, once you're loaded, right?
- 39:03You know, as you know, in India, when it comes
- 39:06to divorce proceedings, the extended family has
- 39:08a very large hand, especially the parents. Say
- 39:11you've got nine properties, and whereby the husband
- 39:15had some properties on his name, suddenly you
- 39:17will find that the properties get transferred
- 39:19within the family. They will project an image
- 39:22as if he's got nothing. I remember a case from
- 39:27our jurisdiction 30 years ago, both very powerful
- 39:30parties. The judge started the judgment with
- 39:33an opening paragraph that both the parties have
- 39:37put up massive concerted efforts to conceal their
- 39:42assets. Like I did a expert report. in a case
- 39:47relating to Goa, both the parties were resident
- 39:49in England. They had massive assets in Goa, Hong
- 39:53Kong, South Africa. And then it came to the disclosure.
- 39:57Goa, India, on the southwestern coast. It has
- 40:00a separate civil court. I mean, it's a different
- 40:03area of law. It used to be part of Portugal a
- 40:05long time ago. They have a separate civil court.
- 40:07And they have a uniform civil court there. Oh,
- 40:10really? Oh, interesting. But very limited, documented,
- 40:13reported case law. I mean, getting information
- 40:15is sort of a huge task. So what had happened
- 40:19was I had to do some legal reports. And then
- 40:22I... used a local firm of lawyers from Guam,
- 40:25Bombay to invest, to discover and investigate
- 40:28his assets from a big business family with headquarters
- 40:30in Goa, big name in Goa, right? And suddenly
- 40:33they found some properties. We got certified
- 40:35copies of the title deeds. I gave it to the solicitors
- 40:38in England, which led to a strikeout, eventually.
- 40:42Really? Right. You see, now what happens is one
- 40:44very more important aspect is - How was that
- 40:46a strikeout? Just out of curiosity. Because you
- 40:47see, they did not disclose their properties in
- 40:50Goa. before the proceedings going on in the High
- 40:53Court of London. Now you see what happens is,
- 40:56especially from Northern India. Sometimes you
- 40:58find whereby people have been married for 20,
- 41:0130 years, they assail the validity of the marriage.
- 41:04And these instructing solicitors will tell you,
- 41:07look here, we've got some copies of some land
- 41:11revenue records. Can you please investigate?
- 41:14Now, the problem is in olden times, all these
- 41:17records were not computerized or digitized. So
- 41:19you have to depute a team of local lawyers or
- 41:21send lawyers from your office. Go and do an inspection.
- 41:25But it does not stop there. The best way is,
- 41:28whether it's Northern India, Delhi, Bombay, whatever,
- 41:31or Goa, the best thing to do is now these days
- 41:33you can get information under the provisions
- 41:35of the Right to Information Act, or you apply
- 41:38for the certified copies of the title deeds.
- 41:41Once you get the certified copies of the title
- 41:44deeds, then you should advise the instructing
- 41:48solicitors or the attorneys in the US. as the
- 41:50case may be, please, now we need a local value
- 41:53to assess the value or the price of the land.
- 41:56Now, what has happened is the real estate has
- 41:58shot up like anything. And in California, we
- 42:00have something that all the divorce lawyers like
- 42:03to use, although it's not admissible in court,
- 42:05which is Zillow, which you may have heard of,
- 42:07may have not of, you can type in an address and
- 42:10it'll give you a printout. It'll say, OK, this
- 42:12house in Santa Monica is worth a million dollars.
- 42:15And obviously, India is a very different system
- 42:17of property valuation, and there's listed rates,
- 42:21right? But tell us a little bit about it. How
- 42:23do you deal with those properties? How do you
- 42:25value them? The properties have a ready reckoner,
- 42:28which is the registrar, which is kept with the
- 42:30authorities, which has a value of the property,
- 42:33say, 50 lakhs Indian rupees. But the actual market
- 42:37transactions that have taken place could be 70
- 42:41lakhs. or maybe three times the problem. Yeah,
- 42:43I'm just saying, I'm just saying more conservatively.
- 42:46The law is you cannot sell below the ready -recognized
- 42:51value. Circle rate, which you mentioned. I was
- 42:53so impressed. You know the meaning of the importance
- 42:55of the phrase circle rate. That's a big thing.
- 42:58Right well, and that's that's the official rate
- 43:01That is the rate earmarked by the revenue authorities
- 43:07on the basis of sale transactions in in that
- 43:10locality basically people use it for Legitimate
- 43:14tax playing which we call tax fill So what happens
- 43:17if you are buying a property say which is worth
- 43:19the circle rate is hundred thousand dollars.
- 43:21So the white component or the bank transfer has
- 43:25to be of that circle rate. Otherwise, the tax
- 43:28man will get after you, right? Interesting. If
- 43:30it's below it. If it's below X. Right. Right.
- 43:33But then the properties can sell for more than
- 43:34that. Yeah, yeah, they sell more than that. You
- 43:36see, normally what happens is I've seen, I mean,
- 43:39having handled litigation in the Daddy High Court
- 43:42and other places, property -related litigation
- 43:46to second, third generation of NRIs. Now, I mean,
- 43:5160, 40, 70, 30 is the norm, like 30 % is the
- 43:55white component or 70%. You know, like in olden
- 43:58days, we had suitcase bankers for people staying
- 44:01abroad. Right? Exactly. I mean, what would happen?
- 44:04I have seen wealth managers, presidents in...
- 44:08high -end private banks, they would keep a track
- 44:11of all their ultra high -net -worth clients in
- 44:14England. Supposing they moved a bank, they went
- 44:16from, let's say, one foreign bank to another
- 44:19foreign bank, they made it a point to keep their
- 44:22old clientele in the loop, even if they change
- 44:24their job four times. So what happened in olden
- 44:27days, this is all history. If you had such property
- 44:29transactions, you were staying abroad, you sold
- 44:32a property, I mean, the client would get in some
- 44:34suitcase bankers. They said, OK, you take care
- 44:36of this. But now things have changed. The tax
- 44:40man is very strict. The Reserve Bank of India
- 44:42is very strict. Your tax compliances are very
- 44:46strict. You are under the scanner. You have a
- 44:48form AS26. It's like, you know, you get your
- 44:51entire life history on the website of the income
- 44:54tax department. Gone are the days of failing.
- 44:56Is it something, you know, what a lot of times
- 45:00we'll rely on in the US? So if we have Let's
- 45:03say, for example, we have a divorce going on,
- 45:05and in California, we can deal with your worldwide
- 45:09assets. It doesn't necessarily mean, for example,
- 45:12that we'll be able to go to India and divide
- 45:14up a house or a property. But we'll say, look,
- 45:17this property is worth the equivalent of 500
- 45:21,000 US dollars. And because we can't get to
- 45:24it, and let's say it's in the husband's name
- 45:26or the wife's name, 50 % of that is community
- 45:29property, so 250 ,000 U .S. is community property.
- 45:32We'll take that from a U .S. asset and give it
- 45:35to the husband or the wife. If you're the U .S.-based
- 45:41attorney or the California -based attorney, do
- 45:44we contact you, Ranjit, or you, Murani, and see,
- 45:48hey, do we... How do we deal with this particular
- 45:52issue? Can you give us an opinion? Do we have
- 45:55to talk to an appraiser? How do we get to that?
- 45:58I tell you, I've done a lot of expert reports
- 46:00in such scenarios. See, what happens is, our
- 46:04Indian courts are not, you're coming to the first
- 46:07part of the proposition, our Indian courts are
- 46:09not equipped to handle assets of one of the parties
- 46:13which are worldwide, which are outside the territories
- 46:16of India. Now, how do you handle a situation
- 46:19whereby there is a property say Delhi, Bombay
- 46:22or any part of the country to assess its value.
- 46:25First, what happens is you get a certified copy
- 46:27of the title deed, right? The second step is
- 46:30you get a valuation done from a government approved
- 46:33value from that jurisdiction. The third step
- 46:37is you give a legal opinion or an expert report
- 46:42on the title of the property saying, look here,
- 46:47these are certified copies. from the government
- 46:49authorities, which constitute evidence of the
- 46:52title of the property, right? Then the question
- 46:55comes is our inheritance law, right? What is
- 46:59valid under the joint family properties? And
- 47:05then what is valid under properties acquired
- 47:08from the... Ancestral? Ancestral or the self
- 47:16-generated income. So these factors then come
- 47:21into play and then you have to see, then there's
- 47:25another dimension under the provisions of the
- 47:29Hindu Succession Act and the Indian Succession
- 47:32Act of 1925. You have to see what law applies
- 47:36to the movable assets, immovable assets within
- 47:40the territories of India and outside the territories
- 47:42of India. Wow. And is that what you've seen,
- 47:44MD, too? Yeah. And that's sort of the interesting
- 47:48thing for us is we kind of talked about it a
- 47:51little bit. But I'm kind of curious, before we
- 47:54go too deep into that, let's say, for example,
- 47:58you have that cross -border case where it's California
- 48:01versus India. And we want to go forward with
- 48:04the case in California. Let's say I represent
- 48:07the wife, and she's going to get more of a windfall
- 48:10in California. Husband wants to keep the case
- 48:12in India. We have this concept, and I know you're
- 48:16familiar with it from your studies of inconvenient
- 48:19form or form non -convenience. Can you initiate
- 48:23a form non -convenience? So form non -convenience.
- 48:26could be initiated only, but the principle behind
- 48:30which the jurisdiction is decided is the law
- 48:33of the land. So if I am representing the husband,
- 48:37and I am saying that we are Hindus, we got married
- 48:39under this act, and the Hindu law is such, if
- 48:42you see the section, that it travels beyond the
- 48:45territories to which the parties are residing.
- 48:48So it doesn't mean that they have to be within
- 48:50the country. Even if they're residing otherwise,
- 48:53the law travels with them. It's like a crab on
- 48:55the back. That goes with them. So that's the
- 49:01way... It becomes a monster, ultimately. That's
- 49:04how powerful this particular concept is. From
- 49:07India. I'm talking from the Indian point of view.
- 49:10So this is where it is. So I would say that my
- 49:13court in India, if I were to represent the husband,
- 49:16would be the valid court because this is where
- 49:17we've got married. Of course. The wife would
- 49:20say, because I would get a windfall, that that's
- 49:22no justification. In my understanding I would
- 49:25oppose you sorry to say that if you were her
- 49:27attorney that is it's not about your windfall
- 49:30gain It is you have to get your Maintenance or
- 49:34your distribution of the assets etc as for the
- 49:36law under which you got married now We have this
- 49:38concept and I'm kind of curious Let's say in
- 49:41this scenario The vast majority of the assets
- 49:45are in, California husband goes back to India
- 49:49And let's say there's some assets, but just maybe
- 49:52some family properties, but they came and they
- 49:54made it big in the US, right? But then he realizes,
- 49:58I'm gonna get a better determination in India
- 50:02because the wife is gonna get less property,
- 50:04it's just gonna get to meet her needs. So I wanna
- 50:07go to India, I wanna file in India. Let's say
- 50:1010 % of the assets are in India, 90 % are in
- 50:14California. Will an Indian court say, yeah, you
- 50:17know, it makes more sense to do this case in
- 50:19California, or will they keep it in India? No,
- 50:23it is not determined by the jurisdiction in which
- 50:27the property or the assets is situated. Right.
- 50:30our laws are based on the law under which you
- 50:33get married. You could have assets in India,
- 50:36you could have it in, you know, Kuala Lumpur,
- 50:38you could have it anywhere part of the world.
- 50:40That could be considered. We cannot get it into
- 50:43it, but that would give the courts a little bit
- 50:45of an idea that this person who's projecting
- 50:48to have only X amount is really his net worth
- 50:51is much more than that. But that exactly will
- 50:54not be distributed because, as Ranjit said, they
- 50:58lack territorial jurisdiction. But they do get
- 51:01the optics about the standard of living or the
- 51:03wealth of the person concerned. So it is not
- 51:06determined by where the assets are located. It
- 51:09is determined under the law by the law under
- 51:13which they have got married. Now, here's an interesting
- 51:15question, too. Let's say the children are in
- 51:18California with the wife, the husbands in India
- 51:22by himself. Would India still assume jurisdiction
- 51:27over the children, or would they give way to
- 51:31the US court for that? If it's only a custody
- 51:33petition that is to be filed, then that will
- 51:36have to be entertained by that court where the
- 51:38children are residing. So they may have been
- 51:40born in India, then they may have gone to the
- 51:42US, and they have lived there, and the courts
- 51:44in the US may have jurisdiction. But if I'm filing
- 51:47for a divorce on behalf of the husband, In that,
- 51:51I can make a prayer for the custody of the children,
- 51:54though the children are not residing in the territories
- 51:57of India or wherever the case may be. But this
- 52:02is a very interesting thing. I think Ranjit will
- 52:04be able to put a little more light on that. Before
- 52:06we move on to the issues of child custody, I
- 52:09wanted to chip in on one very important aspect,
- 52:11right, coming to jurisdiction. We now have a
- 52:14jurisprudence developing on anti -injunction
- 52:18suits, right? Sometimes where there are the inconvenient
- 52:21jurisdictions, you will find either of the spouses
- 52:24going in for anti -injunction suits and Menali
- 52:26ma 'am will also sort of supplement on that.
- 52:28Now coming to you see child custody issues, they
- 52:32look. the issue is with regard to the habitual
- 52:34residence of the child. And as you know, we are
- 52:36not a party to the Hague Convention on Civil
- 52:39Aspects of International Abduction. A lot of
- 52:40people don't know that's an important point that
- 52:42India is not a signatory. And so if you're dealing
- 52:46with those issues, it's going to be very challenging.
- 52:47And even for you to serve petition from the California
- 52:51court to one of the clients who was in India,
- 52:54you will have to go through the Hague process.
- 52:57But I can serve the petition through the court,
- 53:01which is from their website. now because of his
- 53:03email or from the desk of the lawyer and that
- 53:06would be construed as a valid notice or... An
- 53:09email service is valid for a petition. Yes. See,
- 53:12we don't have that in California. We have it.
- 53:14This also goes from not only the lawyer's desk,
- 53:17it goes from the court's website. So for example,
- 53:19there's a family court in Mumbai. Okay, from
- 53:22the website of that court, the service is done...
- 53:26on behalf of the, say, husband to the wife who
- 53:29is not residing in Mumbai, but is residing in
- 53:32the US. Does everyone have to have a registered
- 53:34email in India? Yes. Every petition we write,
- 53:37sorry, we file, we have to give the name, age,
- 53:39et cetera, which is the person details, then
- 53:42the mobile number, because everybody has a mobile
- 53:45today, and the email. So those become the identification.
- 53:48The lawyer is filing the petition. In some jurisdictions,
- 53:50you would have to give your enrollment number,
- 53:51your license number. Yeah, yeah. No, but she's
- 53:53talking about the parties, so they have to give
- 53:55that. and that is presumed to be and you know
- 53:57something very interesting and this is how you
- 53:59guys are ahead of us because in the US I still
- 54:02have to if I I have to hand you this document
- 54:05and that service and that is and you know if
- 54:08you if you do an email service on an unrepresented
- 54:12person. But it has to be from the court's website.
- 54:13Right. In addition to personal service from the
- 54:16lawyers. Right. Because that is a recognized
- 54:18website which will give the sort of you know
- 54:21to the court that they have received it. But
- 54:24tell us, Ranji, in terms of dealing with custody,
- 54:26because I know this, we may run out of time,
- 54:29but this is gonna be so important to people.
- 54:32Since it is not a signatory to the hate convention,
- 54:36and let's say the kids are, parent, the marriage
- 54:39dissolves, parent leaves California, let's say
- 54:43it's the mom, takes the three kids with her.
- 54:46And father now wants to get the children back.
- 54:49What's his process? See, what happens is a typical
- 54:51scenario is where the divorce litigation is underway.
- 54:54What happens is either of the spouses says, look
- 54:56here, the grandfather is on his deathbed. And
- 55:00he wants to, he loves his grandchildren. He wants
- 55:03to see that. You've seen this before. It happens
- 55:05all the time, right? And he wants, this last
- 55:08wish, he wants to see his grandchildren before
- 55:10he dies. So you move on up, either sometimes
- 55:13people just whisk the children, right, to India.
- 55:17I mean, like in England, all this is very developed.
- 55:19You've got Reunite. We've been very, very closely
- 55:20associated with the Reunite. In fact, one of
- 55:24the ladies who was actively involved in setting
- 55:27up Reunite, she was our client. back in 1984,
- 55:301985, then she set up this initiative with Anne
- 55:35-Marie principally. I mean, we all miss her so
- 55:38much. I mean, she did some sterling work and
- 55:40I did a lot of expert reports and some of my
- 55:42reports were cited in her reported cases. So
- 55:46what happens is either the child is clandestinely
- 55:49or surreptitiously brought to India, right? And
- 55:52then what happens is to be not so kind to the
- 55:57other spouse, the erring spouse, what he or she
- 56:00does is she files like a custody application
- 56:04in the family court or the court of the competent
- 56:07jurisdiction. Now, this trial is like a Rolls
- 56:12Royce trial. I mean, it takes one hell of a lot
- 56:15of amount of time, right? And the Indian court
- 56:17gets seized of the jurisdiction. Other option
- 56:22is what happens is, the agreed spouse may get
- 56:27a foreign court order, right? But now the law
- 56:29is very clear, the foreign court custody order
- 56:32is one of the factors that will be taken into
- 56:36consideration, right? That will not be the sole
- 56:39motivating pole star or guiding determining factor
- 56:46to... assess the claim of the award of the custody
- 56:50to either of the spouses. In fact, to be very
- 56:53honest with you, with the current day jurisprudence
- 56:57and the concern of the Supreme Court, Honorable
- 57:01Supreme Court of India and high courts across
- 57:03the country, flashing a foreign court custody
- 57:06order is... counterproductive. The Indian courts
- 57:10feel that you are undermining their authority.
- 57:13They would look at the entire circumstances around,
- 57:16right? And then what happens is, you see - So
- 57:19you have to get a second go then in India to
- 57:21get the kids. Absolutely. Now, if I may develop
- 57:22this further, you see, what happens is, what
- 57:29happens is, we have the, you see, initiate custody
- 57:36proceedings right because we do not have any
- 57:39child custody law per se right and there is no
- 57:42separate criminal legislation recognizing child
- 57:45custody or to put it child abduction as a separate
- 57:48criminal offense. So the only option you are
- 57:51left with is either to file a writ of habeas
- 57:54corpus in the high court where the child is or
- 57:58a petition directly under Article 32 before the
- 58:01Honourable Supreme Court of India. But now you
- 58:03see what happens is we have law in both the directions.
- 58:06There are some judges which say how can you have
- 58:10an illegal custody of your own child. Now the
- 58:13crux, the issue, then what happens is sometimes
- 58:16where the divorce litigation is underway and
- 58:19it is sort of making headway, right? The court
- 58:22calls for an expert report, right? Or a single
- 58:24joint expert report. We do a lot of these reports
- 58:26from England for the family division of the High
- 58:28Court of London and courts in the US. The key
- 58:33question is, the Honorable Court, either in US,
- 58:36England or Canada, especially US, would want
- 58:39to know, well, can you give us an iron? glad
- 58:43guarantee that the child or the children will
- 58:47come back if sent to India. The answer is a big
- 58:50no. Big no. If any good honest counsel will advise
- 58:55you. Unless mirrored. Unless mirrored here if
- 59:00you'd mirror it and especially if you had a court
- 59:02order the same high court and the Supreme Court
- 59:05and if you did mirror this order then there is
- 59:09a very high chance and there's an exceptional
- 59:11circumstances but in most of the cases to be
- 59:14honest in my experience and opinion that yes,
- 59:18they do consider this because this is by choice
- 59:21by their own agreement that they have agreed
- 59:24and we have mirrored it in the two different
- 59:26things. So we normally suggest that even if you
- 59:29get to arrangements of custody and visitation
- 59:32in a particular court and the children are likely
- 59:34to be in some other thing, the other spouse who
- 59:37probably most of the time is a non -custodial
- 59:39parent should have an option to exercise his
- 59:43or her rights in that particular jurisdiction.
- 59:48You can't just randomly go and ask the court
- 59:50that please do this. They can only do it when
- 59:52there's a court order of that particular court
- 59:54which has given that. So this The mirroring of
- 59:57the orders is now sort of very, very predominantly
- 1:00:02done in these cross -border... And that's such
- 1:00:04an important aspect for California attorneys
- 1:00:06to know because under California law and California's
- 1:00:10interpretation of international move away cases,
- 1:00:14you have to have certainty that the... Children
- 1:00:17are gonna if they go to India that India would
- 1:00:20enforce the orders or that the children be returnable
- 1:00:24So it seems that if you're going to do a relocation
- 1:00:27case involving the US or California and India
- 1:00:31The only way to really ensure that is to have
- 1:00:34mirror orders in two courts, in the High Court
- 1:00:36and the Supreme Court. In the High Court and
- 1:00:37the Supreme Court, these are more executable
- 1:00:39ones, sometimes in the trial courts on an honest
- 1:00:42basis. It takes time and years and years to get
- 1:00:46these things done. Though courts today, at least
- 1:00:48in these urban metros, are pretty proactive and
- 1:00:52understand the situation. But yes, we have seen
- 1:00:56a lot of cases and even Supreme Courts have,
- 1:00:59as Ranjit has said in some cases, they have come
- 1:01:01down heavily. which is that foreign court which
- 1:01:06thinks that they can decide about the children,
- 1:01:07we can also decide about it because the parameters
- 1:01:11are different. In the U .S., as I understand,
- 1:01:14and please correct me if I'm wrong, the custody
- 1:01:16cases, it's always a joint custody between the
- 1:01:19father and the mother. Am I right? No. Unless
- 1:01:21exceptional circumstances. Oh yeah, there's so
- 1:01:23many. For example, the biggest thing in California
- 1:01:28is if there's domestic violence, there's a presumption
- 1:01:31against the perpetrator of domestic violence.
- 1:01:34that they don't get joint custody. Generally
- 1:01:36speaking, it is true that the courts are gonna
- 1:01:38come in and that's maybe their thought process,
- 1:01:41but it's not automatic even. So you're close
- 1:01:46to it, but it's not 100%. Domestic violence could
- 1:01:49be exceptions. In cases where there are incompatibility
- 1:01:52between the parties, and they want to separate,
- 1:01:55and they're not coming to anything. I think in
- 1:01:57most of the cases, in the cases that I have done,
- 1:01:59and of course your experience and authority in
- 1:02:01that field is much more. seen that it's a joint
- 1:02:04custody and the joint decisions are taken the
- 1:02:08parenting time is shared between say Monday to
- 1:02:10Friday with the mother or father and things like
- 1:02:13that because I'll tell you why we are now adopting
- 1:02:16that in our individual cases and we are saying
- 1:02:18that this is a better way to let the child be
- 1:02:21with both the parents because the fight is between
- 1:02:23the husband and the wife we don't want to drag
- 1:02:26the children into this we don't want to deprive
- 1:02:28the child of the other non -custodial unless
- 1:02:30there are exceptional cases as you said alcohol
- 1:02:33or domestic violence or drugs or something which
- 1:02:36really you know sort of negates all this but
- 1:02:38we and me as a practitioner feel I feel that
- 1:02:42the kids need both the parents The proportionate
- 1:02:46time could be different. The physical care could
- 1:02:49be different. The physical day -to -day care
- 1:02:51could be taken by the mother. But it is not that
- 1:02:54the parent or the other parent has just come
- 1:02:56like a visiting father, like a Sunday daddy,
- 1:02:59just give some Santa Claus, do stuff and go.
- 1:03:01Has to be an involved parent because we have
- 1:03:04seen a lot of cases where the child, if has been
- 1:03:07deliberately kept away from the father or the
- 1:03:10mother as the case, maybe. We've seen them that
- 1:03:13they had serious, severe psychological issues
- 1:03:15when they grew up as a child. So we want to stop
- 1:03:18that. And I am, in my own very, very limited,
- 1:03:23and not that I have much of reach, but in my
- 1:03:25limited capacity, in my case, is trying to reach
- 1:03:28a situation where both the parents, to a large
- 1:03:31extent, get, if not 50 % and equal, proportionately
- 1:03:36equal. positive shift or the larger canvas of
- 1:03:46jurisprudence. We have now had some four very
- 1:03:48good developments. Rights of the child, voice
- 1:03:52of the child, like there was a Hague conference
- 1:03:56organized by Merlin Freeman in London on looking
- 1:04:00at the voice of the child. Rights of the child,
- 1:04:03voice of the child is taking a very positive
- 1:04:08shift. in the jurisprudence in this area of law,
- 1:04:11right? And as Birali Ma 'am said, now the Indian
- 1:04:16courts frown upon parental alienation syndrome.
- 1:04:22Often the erring spouse, he or she will antagonize
- 1:04:27the minor child, sort of try to brainwash him
- 1:04:30against the left behind spouse. So this is the
- 1:04:33third, this is the... Third aspect, right? And
- 1:04:37the fourth aspect, important aspect is now is
- 1:04:40visitation, right? But sometimes there is a lot
- 1:04:44of trouble and bad blood, like the court orders,
- 1:04:48you will meet the child in a shopping mall or
- 1:04:50here or there. the wife plays or the husband,
- 1:04:53one spouse may sort of try to play difficult,
- 1:04:56cut the custody, access, may not show up, don't
- 1:04:59respond to emails, saying the child is not well.
- 1:05:02So these are four very important issues which
- 1:05:05are looking at the rights of the child. I mean,
- 1:05:09sometimes the court rightly so, they are not
- 1:05:12very happy when the erring spouses are flagging
- 1:05:16their own rights. So this has been a very positive
- 1:05:19shift. in jurisprudence in the last five years.
- 1:05:22And one more issue coming to mirror orders. I
- 1:05:24mean, five years ago, until five years ago, there
- 1:05:27would be a specific query by instructing attorneys
- 1:05:30or solicitors. Do you have the concept of mirror
- 1:05:33orders statutorily recognized in your jurisdiction?
- 1:05:37The answer is a no. But now, you have judgments
- 1:05:40of the Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court,
- 1:05:42and in one of our lead cases, the concept of
- 1:05:46mirror order jurisprudence as... carved out by
- 1:05:49the Delhi High Court was affirmed by the Honorable
- 1:05:51Supreme Court of India. I can give you the citation
- 1:05:53later on. It's one of our reported cases. That's
- 1:05:56amazing. Well, Ranjit and MD, I just want to
- 1:05:59thank you so much. This has been such a great
- 1:06:02conversation and it's so nice to be able to have
- 1:06:05it here in person rather than via Zoom. Absolutely.
- 1:06:10We could have sat here all day. We could have.
- 1:06:13And I think this is going to be such a great
- 1:06:15resource for practitioners and to know both of
- 1:06:18you are available for questions on Indian cases.
- 1:06:22They're going to come up and there's just such
- 1:06:24a huge community in California. Yes. So thank
- 1:06:26you both for your time and heartfelt thanks from
- 1:06:30the Beverly Hills. Thank you for organizing this
- 1:06:32equally. Thank you for organizing this, taking
- 1:06:34this.