Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Safety Before Insight: How to go Deeper in Your Meditation Practice
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Hoss. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It's Thursday, November 20th, 2025 at 7:35 PM Pacific Time.
- 0:26And I was thinking today that we would talk about a topic which
- 0:33is safety before insight. How do you go deeper into your
- 0:37meditation practice? And I'm including and of course
- 0:43all the attachment work in that. How do you safely approach
- 0:48insight work into liberation? And I think part of the
- 0:54preliminaries for that is doing the attachment work mainly the
- 1:00way that we approach that is by teaching a meta Vipassana
- 1:05approach so that an integrated practice of the heart.
- 1:10The heart practices sort of short form for that loving
- 1:14kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy, and equanimity
- 1:18practice in combination with insight practice.
- 1:25And then using that platform as a preliminary practice to
- 1:32develop mentalizing and emotional regulation skills.
- 1:36And then using that platform to jump into ideal parent figure
- 1:45protocol as part of the preliminary practices so that
- 1:48you can resolve the attachment conditioning.
- 1:52That then frees you up to be the awesome explorer that you need
- 1:57to be in order to get into the, the, the deeper investigations
- 2:03that are offered by inside practice.
- 2:06That makes sense. You know, when I first started
- 2:11practicing in this way, I don't know what would that be 35 years
- 2:18ago or something, I had the problem that comes up with
- 2:24people quite often, which is I would start the insight
- 2:27practice, I would start the Vipassana practice.
- 2:30But then I would wander into the, the, the shadow realms of
- 2:35my psyche and be completely horrified by clicking on the
- 2:39lights and immediately clicked them off again.
- 2:41And the way I would do that was by stopping meditating.
- 2:45That was the the choice that I really had.
- 2:49I remember valiantly. At least that's how it appeared
- 2:54to me, valiantly going to my first weekend retreat and
- 2:59halfway through Saturday, wanting to leave desperately.
- 3:07I've made it through the the couple of hours of sitting on
- 3:11Friday evening and then after three or four hours of sitting
- 3:17in the morning, I was definitely ready to get the hell out of
- 3:19there. And so I went and I told the
- 3:22teacher that I was going to leave and I spent 20 minutes
- 3:27talking to him and I felt fine again.
- 3:28And so I was able to stay for the rest of the retreat.
- 3:32In hindsight, reflecting back on it, the disengagement in the way
- 3:38that the positive treats are often offered, which is a silent
- 3:43meditation retreat. The detachment and what I
- 3:47experienced as a rejection of people not using the normal eye
- 3:53contact and you know, acknowledgement of politeness
- 3:59triggered in me a sense of being rejected and that became painful
- 4:04and, and a 20 minute conversation with the teacher of
- 4:08course re regulated me. Once I was re regulated, I could
- 4:12then continue on with the true retreat.
- 4:17The Friday evening, of course, we were still talking.
- 4:23It was only Saturday that was silent and then Sunday was
- 4:27silent. But it only lasted until lunch,
- 4:30which was how I could get through to the whole thing.
- 4:33And then I felt amazingly accomplished at having stayed
- 4:40through the hardship of my first weekend apostan retreat.
- 4:46But I did understand that there was a risk on attending retreats
- 4:52that the, the dysregulated states were really intense.
- 4:57And what, what should I do about that?
- 5:03And then of course, at that time, the modeling of the silent
- 5:09retreat was all over the the only option really in in the
- 5:14world that I was in. I also at that time didn't last
- 5:26very long in meditation groups. I would come into the group, I
- 5:32would be initially intoxicated with the relationships and the
- 5:36kindness of people and I I would be interested in the the
- 5:42meditation. I remember taking a a classic
- 5:48eight week beginners or introductory to meditation class
- 5:54and driving down to Venice and for the 7:30 class and it lasted
- 6:02an hour and then going home and attempting to sit at home.
- 6:08And I would sit down and I would take my stiff posture and I
- 6:14would sit as long as I could barely stand it.
- 6:20And I would open my eyes and three minutes would have gone.
- 6:28And then I would say, that's ridiculous.
- 6:29I should be able to sit longer than 3 minutes.
- 6:31And I would close my eyes and I would stiffen my posture and I
- 6:34would sit as long as I possibly could.
- 6:38I would open my eyes and two more minutes would have gone by.
- 6:47Very chaotic by very, I think we used to call it monkey mind
- 6:52rolling around and so going on the retreats and having that
- 7:03difficult time and and doing what any self respecting
- 7:07survivalist would do on a retreat, which was to routinely
- 7:11violate the silence restriction of the retreat and have
- 7:15clandestine conversations with people all over the place.
- 7:18Because I just couldn't stand the, the lack of reassurance
- 7:27that I was actually OK. And I, I have a painful body.
- 7:33And so that pridefulness of wanting to sit on the cushion
- 7:38and be in the, in the, in the perfect meditation posture
- 7:42really is not something my body's ever been capable of
- 7:45doing. The the first few years of just
- 7:51mainly sitting in pain and just so distracted by the pain, not
- 7:56being able to do anything else. Finally accepting the
- 8:03humiliation that I was one of the people that would have to
- 8:06sit in a chair and began to sit in a chair.
- 8:14I, I think of myself very fondly though in Do you know those
- 8:20Chinese bags? They're quite large and they're
- 8:25used for laundry. I had two of these big things
- 8:28that were like 3 by 4 feet stuffed with all the different
- 8:32pillows and cushions that I used back jacks, everything I could
- 8:36possibly do to sit on the floor in Lotus Full Lotus was the the
- 8:47ultimate visual image of what I needed to be doing.
- 8:51And finally retiring my 2 bags of cushions and just sitting in
- 8:55the chair, so much better in terms of the quality of the
- 8:59meditation. But that the first few years
- 9:03just working with the pain of the body, which I I failed to
- 9:08recognize, was an astonishing amount of pain in comparison to
- 9:13people who had good backs and could sit easily.
- 9:19And then began to have those those first experiences of
- 9:27deeper meditation states, usually coming from
- 9:29concentration. It turns out pain is a great
- 9:32object of meditation 'cause it really narrows your focus.
- 9:36And if you can sit with it, it you get into concentrated
- 9:41states. When I was at my first
- 9:48meditation class, the the teacher asked, why did we come
- 9:55to the meditation class? And another thing I enjoy about
- 10:00myself is I, I have this sort of, maybe you'd call it a
- 10:05willful naivete, but I, I just in a, in a sort of bubbly,
- 10:12cheerful way, said, I want to be enlightened.
- 10:16And it, it produced a roar of laughter in the class, but it
- 10:19was not a kind laughter. It was a you idiot.
- 10:25Nobody could be enlightened in the, in the way that we practice
- 10:30meditation here. And that was quite disturbing to
- 10:33me as a, a concept. I thought, if I'm going to take
- 10:38on this practice, I should be able to get to enlightenment.
- 10:42But why would I practice if that weren't actually the case?
- 10:47So I kept looking for teachers and stumbled upon the concept of
- 10:57Dharma orphan. A Dharma orphan is somebody who
- 11:01is practicing the Dharma mainly through books because they don't
- 11:05have a teacher and they they don't have a community.
- 11:08And I and I understood that the relational difficulty I had that
- 11:13made it impossible to really connect in a stable way to
- 11:18people in a regular way was also affecting me in my ability to
- 11:27connect into a meditation community.
- 11:31And it was evident in that cycle of brushing into a community but
- 11:36getting really enthusiastic about it, the relationships not
- 11:40going very well, and withdrawing from the community to another
- 11:45stretch of a Dharma orphan hood. And then recognizing that I
- 11:50wasn't able to make progress on my own without help of some
- 11:56kind. And then being too chagrin to
- 11:59return to the community that I left and searching out new
- 12:04communities. So at a point where I I was lost
- 12:09at who where to go and who to talk to, a book came.
- 12:14A book called Buddhism in America came out, which was
- 12:17essentially like a whole earth catalog of Buddhist meditation
- 12:21teachers and centers. And I went and each place put in
- 12:27a, a, a 1/4, like 1/4 page blurb of what their teaching was or
- 12:33what their center was like. And I went through the book and
- 12:37read all the ads and then landed on of Abbas and a support
- 12:43International, which was Shinzen Young's group.
- 12:50And being my usual paranoid self, I went to their retreat,
- 12:55their day long retreats. And he grilled all of the
- 13:00students to see whether or not he was actually a a good teacher
- 13:04who wasn't in the habit of violating the trust of his
- 13:07students. And I got really good feedback
- 13:11over the course of about six months and then started to
- 13:15attend retreats. He was a retreat teacher, still
- 13:20isn't. In fact, right.
- 13:22Right now, the last retreat that he's teaching is happening.
- 13:27It's a long stretch. And he was astonishingly kind,
- 13:32which is also what I needed. The the the cruelty of my
- 13:38childhood resulted in just an outrageously unrealistic bar of
- 13:48the kindness that I expected from people.
- 13:51And if they weren't able to reach that impossible height, I
- 13:54I didn't think I could be in relationship to them.
- 13:57And and he was able to manage that was which was quite
- 14:00astonishing. And that was long before the the
- 14:08full grid. See here feel structure that
- 14:11he's created now that he teaches that's that really does inform
- 14:15you so quickly easily how to access meditative states.
- 14:21And there was a a community of people around that were were
- 14:25also kind and I was, I think terribly lonely at the time.
- 14:30One of the things about having attachment disturbances is that
- 14:34you don't form relationships that are particularly intimate
- 14:38or particularly reliable. And so you're alone a lot.
- 14:43I found that to be one of the harder parts of life and the
- 14:49community, even though it was a retreat community and a a silent
- 14:55retreat community, you know how it is with the silent retreat
- 14:57community. You could sit 4 retreats a year,
- 15:00You could spend two months sitting next to somebody, but
- 15:03you, you never have a full conversation because you're in
- 15:07silence. And so some, there was some
- 15:10local community that formed. And I'm, I'm talking about
- 15:19safety in community and safety in, in practice so that you can
- 15:25allow yourself that space. I think of it as a creative
- 15:30space or an exploration space might be a way to talk about it,
- 15:35but you open a space that you can then turn your attention
- 15:42inward and begin a process of exploration.
- 15:46But that ability to open that space and be unguarded comes
- 15:53from the perception of safety in the community.
- 15:57If you don't have that or safety with the teacher, if you don't
- 16:01have that, then there's too much attention to being protective of
- 16:07yourself to really allow that space to open up.
- 16:14Once that space opens up, then you have to go into the Dragon's
- 16:20den. It depends.
- 16:21Maybe. Maybe you you have a lion's den
- 16:25or maybe yours is filled with puppies, but mine was definitely
- 16:33a Dragon's dead. The what we're really poking at
- 16:40and, and as we begin to explore the nature of how we create
- 16:45reality, that's really what we're talking about, right?
- 16:48The conditioned response to the sensory impulses that we take in
- 16:55through our sense gates that we then define and assign meaning
- 16:59to. But in order to explore the
- 17:02meaning that you're giving to reality, you have to explore the
- 17:05conditioning, which is the source of the meaning that you
- 17:08give to what's happening. And a lot of us with poor
- 17:16attachment conditioning are, are looking at harsh circumstances
- 17:21and, and there's a lot of defense against the reality of
- 17:25what happened to us in order for us to preserve a navigatable
- 17:31world. And that doesn't hold up too
- 17:34well if you're really diving into insight practice.
- 17:42And so that was the the condition of that period of
- 17:45practice, diving in to these retreats and coming into into
- 17:53contact with the material that I was preventing myself from
- 17:57knowing about myself and then withdrawing from contact with
- 18:04it, mainly by stopping meditating.
- 18:08And so that characteristic of, you know, intense practice,
- 18:12intense practice, consistent practice, consistent practice,
- 18:15horror, complete collapse of the practice and waiting for some
- 18:22process of integration and sound familiar?
- 18:26I don't know, seems to be a pretty common way of practicing.
- 18:34I did recognize one of the things I recognized about myself
- 18:37as I wasn't particularly feeling, wasn't particularly
- 18:41compassionate, and in fact had almost no training in in empathy
- 18:50or compassion. And it was startling to
- 18:57recognize this. I was, my cousin was visiting me
- 19:08in New York. So this is during that first
- 19:12early period of practice. And we were walking through one
- 19:21of the, the lobbies of the skyscraper, which was, you know,
- 19:23one of these corporate cathedrals of black granite and
- 19:27Chrome and glass. And for dramatic effect, they
- 19:33had a two-story escalator come down into the center of, of the
- 19:37lobby. And as we were walking through
- 19:39the lobby, which was otherwise empty and, you know, the echoing
- 19:43sound, she was wearing heels. And I, I remember very
- 19:46distinctly the sound of the, the, the heels on the, the
- 19:50granite. A guy who was probably my age
- 19:52now tripped at the top of the escalator and started rolling
- 19:55down the escalator. My mind said wow that's a cool
- 20:01visual. As he was rolling down the
- 20:04escalator. My cousin on the other hand ran
- 20:07across the lobby, turned off the escalator, took the escalator 2
- 20:12steps at a time and caught the guy in the middle and I was
- 20:18thinking wow that was a really great thing to do.
- 20:22I wonder how she thought of doing it.
- 20:25Because it had never occurred to me that that would be something
- 20:28that you would do. And so when she got back, you
- 20:35know, then the security came and carried him off and all the
- 20:38rest. He was injured.
- 20:45She came back and I and I said to her, how did you think to do
- 20:50that? I mean, how did you know how to
- 20:52turn off the escalator? And she said, I didn't think
- 20:56about it, I just did it. And so I had this very
- 21:03interesting recognition of how differently we were conditioned
- 21:09in the world that her mind would automatically propel her across
- 21:12the lobby. And she would take that risk
- 21:15without even thinking about it. She would figure out how to turn
- 21:18off the escalator. There was of course an emergency
- 21:21switch that she just hit on the way up, but would have thought
- 21:27to do that. It certainly wouldn't have
- 21:28occurred to me. That was the thing I knew and
- 21:31kept track of that as this is a deficit that I need to fix in
- 21:36some way. Well, I don't know if you ever
- 21:40tried to fix it. It's not so easy, but as I was
- 21:46practicing in by this, I moved to LA.
- 21:53The The Art of Loving Kindness came out of Sharon Salzberg
- 21:55book, I think it was 94 or something like that.
- 22:00And so I started to practice it. Not much happened.
- 22:05I think when you begin to practice a loving kindness,
- 22:10depending on what the instructions are, you, if you're
- 22:13on the dismissing side of things, which I was, there's a
- 22:16suppression of emotion. So you don't have a lot of
- 22:18access to it. And so even in the, the wet meta
- 22:22practices where you're attempting to generate these
- 22:25positive emotional states, I didn't feel that much, It was
- 22:29hard to get something to happen. And I, I remember practicing and
- 22:37going through all the exercises. I was really affected by that,
- 22:42that the perception that there would be such, such a profound
- 22:45deficit of character as I saw it.
- 22:48And, and for a few months, I think I went slowly through the
- 22:56book practicing. And then I was on the telephone
- 23:02with someone. I was talking to them and they
- 23:04were describing something that that happened to them.
- 23:06And I suddenly had this compassionate response, this
- 23:12loving kindness response, which was fully embodied emotion.
- 23:15It was mind blowing. And I, I literally sat down
- 23:21where I was standing because it was so different than what my
- 23:27normal experience of, of life was so quite transformative.
- 23:36When I discovered that there was a combined practice of
- 23:40metavipasana, I was immediately drawn to it.
- 23:43One of the things that you can do in a combined practice of
- 23:46meta Vipassana is you can use the Vipassana side to explore
- 23:53the, the loving kindness side. Although I didn't find so much
- 23:57available to me in terms of instruction around the
- 24:00combination of the two. It was always segregated
- 24:06practice of loving kindness and segregated practice of
- 24:10Vipassana. When I started to teach
- 24:14meditation, we initially taught Vipassana only silent meditation
- 24:20style retreats in that typical way.
- 24:25And what you notice on the the teacher side of retreats is that
- 24:30that first two or three days of the retreat, you have a lot of
- 24:33people that are having a lot of problems with the the
- 24:37disconnection and the reassurance that they're used
- 24:40to. And a lot of people want to
- 24:42leave the retreat in the early part of their treat because
- 24:45they're having trouble emotionally regulating
- 24:48themselves in silence. I'm not sure why it's such a
- 24:54standard practice in the Vipassana world to have silent
- 24:59retreats. When I began to inquire as to
- 25:02why we were doing that, it wasn't adequately explained.
- 25:05It was modeled on Asian monastic models of practice.
- 25:11But you know, we were so far away from any realistic monastic
- 25:16practice on retreat or any cultural, the, the cultural
- 25:21responses in Asia not being relevant here really mainly that
- 25:27in the beginning, of course in the East the identification is
- 25:32with the family unit, but it's not that way in the West.
- 25:35We are solidly identified with ourselves and have some
- 25:41identification with the family system.
- 25:42But for a lot of us, particularly the people who find
- 25:45their way into meditation circles aren't, aren't so
- 25:50connected there. So those early practices of
- 25:54silence and those early practices of disconnection,
- 25:57which are really in the East, meant to point you to yourself
- 26:01outside of the context of the family union.
- 26:05I think for a lot of us in the West become alienating practices
- 26:09where we feel too separate, too disconnected.
- 26:16And the inside practice going in and discovering these aspects of
- 26:24ourselves that we have defended so valiantly.
- 26:28There's that word to get valiantly defended against
- 26:31knowing anything about ourselves because our opinion of ourselves
- 26:35is so low. And then recoiling in horror and
- 26:45rushing away from the practice until of course, the suffering
- 26:49returns. And then returning to the
- 26:52practice because we need to do something about the suffering
- 26:55that sort of swing back and forth.
- 27:00When I got interested in this Medeva positive way of
- 27:05practicing and and went out to Miramar and studied with the
- 27:11said indica, in particular the metajana form, which is these
- 27:16entering into these high concentration states using the
- 27:21view or the mindset of loving kindness as the object of
- 27:29meditation. It really solidified the idea
- 27:32that we should be entering into retreat practice with the a few
- 27:40days at the beginning or after retreat is what we used to do
- 27:44would be loving kindness practice.
- 27:48So you really settle into this relationship with yourself,
- 27:50which is this kindness to itself, this compassionate in
- 27:55the way that we can have self compassion toward ourselves in
- 28:00opening to these aspects of ourselves that are hard to hold.
- 28:06We really found that there was no distress in the first few
- 28:10days of the retreat. There was no disconnection in
- 28:13the first few days of the retreat.
- 28:16Then people settled into these positive experiences of
- 28:20themselves, which then allowed them to open the inside side and
- 28:24explore conditioning without that, without the trouble that
- 28:31we we often had. So I think that from the safety
- 28:35perspective that that model of meteviposity where we spend a
- 28:43few days settling into an open kind relationship with ourselves
- 28:50as a a wonderful prerequisite than to pushing into the inside
- 28:57side. I do think also in, in that
- 29:03experience it, it became evident that a lot of us have attachment
- 29:10conditioning which we need to repair.
- 29:18And that actually the repairing of that attachment conditioning
- 29:22opens up our capacity to explore in a way that we we have been in
- 29:27some ways restricted at. And that that capacity to
- 29:31explore is essential to the to the deep investigations that are
- 29:37open in the meditation pass. I'm I've said this part of the
- 29:48story quite a lot. So you may have heard it before,
- 29:50but 25 years ago, Shinzen asked his senior students at the time
- 29:57to begin to teach as a a way of, of paying back his having taught
- 30:04us. And so I started to teach, there
- 30:09was a, a place in Santa Monica called called the Santa Monica
- 30:14Zen Center. And I initially began to teach
- 30:20Shinzen's material. And I was attempting to teach it
- 30:25in great fidelity to the way that he taught it.
- 30:30But the feedback that I got from people was if we wanted to sit
- 30:36with Shinzen, we'd just go sit with Shinzen.
- 30:39We want to sit with you. But we don't want you to give us
- 30:43your impression of Shinzen. We want an authentic expression
- 30:47of you and your understanding of what's going on.
- 30:55And in particular, one of the students said, you used to be
- 30:59the angriest person I had ever met, and you're not angry
- 31:02anymore. I would really be useful to be
- 31:04if you could tell me how you did that.
- 31:09And so I began to teach a class called overcoming Anger.
- 31:15And and that that went pretty well and I taught it a few times
- 31:23and and then somebody came up to me and said, you know, anger
- 31:28really isn't my issue. Fear is my issue.
- 31:31Could you talk teach a class on fear?
- 31:34And so I started to teach a class called Overcoming Fear.
- 31:38In addition to my class of Overcoming anger.
- 31:42I would alternate them. And then somebody came and said
- 31:47anger and fear aren't my issues, sadness is my issue.
- 31:49Could you teach a class on sadness?
- 31:51So I started to teach a class called Overcoming Sadness, which
- 31:54I would alternate with Overcoming Anger and Overcoming
- 31:57Fear 8 week classes. And then somebody came up to me
- 32:02and said, you know, anger, fear and sadness is not my issue.
- 32:04Shame is my issue. Could you teach a class on
- 32:07shame? And then the light bulb went off
- 32:09above my head and I thought, I know I'll teach a class called
- 32:13overcoming difficult emotions. And so I started to teach a
- 32:18class called overcoming emotions.
- 32:21And actually it was a big class because everybody came to it
- 32:24instead of just the the slices of their emotional pie.
- 32:29And then a student came up to me and said, you know, George, it
- 32:32isn't the difficult emotions that are the problem in my life.
- 32:35It's the relationships that cause the difficult emotions
- 32:38that are the problem in my life. At which point I thought I will
- 32:43begin to teach about attachment because my personal practice had
- 32:49been working with my attachment conditioning.
- 32:53How did I end up with an interest in teaching attachment
- 32:57conditioning in the late 90s in Los Angeles?
- 33:00Might be a question. And a friend of mine worked at
- 33:03the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA and recorded a lecture
- 33:11that Alan Shore had given on disorganized attachment, which
- 33:16she then copied to ACD, which she gave me.
- 33:19She said, essentially, this reminds me of you, you should
- 33:24listen to it. And so I popped the CD of Alan
- 33:28Shore talking about disorganized attachment.
- 33:30And in 10 minutes, he described the whole cycle of my life,
- 33:34which repeated itself over and over again, which was some, a
- 33:38lot of beginnings, some of them even brilliant, a few middles,
- 33:43but no finishes. And then he described the origin
- 33:48of that cycle, which was embedded in attachment theory.
- 33:51And I thought, this is it. This is the the, this is the
- 33:55actual model that explains everything to me in a way that
- 34:00seems clear. And so I ran around looking for
- 34:05some kind of psychotherapy, which was attachment focused.
- 34:10I can tell you that 30 years ago in Los Angeles, there was not a
- 34:17single therapist who was offering attachment focus
- 34:22therapy and almost no one who had heard of it as a concept.
- 34:27So it was just emerging in in the zeitgeist.
- 34:33But I thought listening to it and and getting what material I
- 34:37could read on it. If you've not read Alan Shorts
- 34:41it, it is dry and dense, hard to read.
- 34:46It was an act of will that got me through those books, and I
- 34:55like to read difficult things. I began to suspect that
- 35:02attachment conditioning would be susceptible to meditation
- 35:06practice. And so I began to develop these
- 35:08meditation strategies that I thought I could use to rack my
- 35:13attachment conditioning because I wanted to have connection to
- 35:19people that felt reliable and close.
- 35:23I wanted to feel safe in in revealing myself, which was
- 35:27always hard to do. And I was tired of being so
- 35:33alone in the world. You know, when you have I, I had
- 35:40complexly disorganized attachment.
- 35:42It really feels a lot of the time like you, you have your
- 35:45nose pressed against the glass and you're looking into a room
- 35:49of people that are connecting and, and engaging each other
- 35:53and, and having fun and enjoying each other.
- 35:55And you can't crack the code of it.
- 35:58So you would know how to do it for yourself.
- 36:03And I wanted to get through the door, but when the, the students
- 36:09said, you know, it's not the, the difficult emotions that are
- 36:13the problem for me. It's the relationships that I
- 36:17can't figure out and I can't manage.
- 36:19I said, all right, I'll teach it.
- 36:23I'll teach these techniques that I've been developing for myself
- 36:27and see if that's helpful to people.
- 36:29And so I started to teach a class called the Meaningful
- 36:32Life. I think, Hesh, did you, you came
- 36:36to that one long, long ago. I had the idea that it was going
- 36:43to take some effort to change your attachment strategy.
- 36:46So I made the classes 10 months long instead of eight weeks.
- 36:52I thought a 10 month class, I'll teach all of this stuff, I'll
- 36:56teach these techniques and at the end of the class everyone
- 36:58will have secure attachment and and it'll be fantastic.
- 37:02Well, that didn't pan out really.
- 37:08I noticed after teaching the class for five years that while
- 37:13it was very helpful to people, didn't have that big of an
- 37:18effect on people's attachment. It had a big effect on their
- 37:21awareness and they could see the patterns that they were engaging
- 37:24in that they weren't free of the the patterns.
- 37:28So we looked around for what we might use to help that and I
- 37:36came across Dan Brown's work and and in dialogue with him
- 37:42understood that the addition of ideal parent figure protocol
- 37:46would be useful. Christian.
- 37:50George, that's the, that's the worst thing you can, you could
- 37:52have done to those people. You gave them all the awareness.
- 37:54Without the I'm still suffering. Anyway, I worked with Dan for
- 38:13several years in integrating the ideal parent figure into the
- 38:16work. And one of the things about
- 38:19ideal parent figure, which I really appreciate, and this is
- 38:23again, coming back to this idea of safety, is that it's a non
- 38:30direct trauma reprocessing approach.
- 38:34I had a lot of trauma in, in my life and in the 90's the, the
- 38:39main idea of trauma was a kind of direct trauma reprocessing
- 38:47approach, a kind of exposure therapy, but lighter than direct
- 38:52exposure therapy. And I went for four sessions a
- 38:58week. So I go from 3:00 to 5:00 on
- 39:03Tuesday and from 9:00 to 11:00 on a Wednesday.
- 39:07So we could open it up and I could get through the night and
- 39:10then we could close it up at the end of the, the second day.
- 39:14But it, it really didn't close up so well and I didn't function
- 39:20so well and, and was really a long three years of, of a cycle
- 39:27that not much else happened except for the, the trauma
- 39:31reprocessing. And I was when I began to do the
- 39:36ideal parent figure stuff, the indirect trauma reprocessing
- 39:42approach did not interrupt the flow of my week the way that the
- 39:47other did. And I ended up being able to
- 39:51process the stuff that was unprocessible, unprocessable in
- 39:55the other approach. And it was very clear to me that
- 39:59that that even though it was the standard of treatment at the
- 40:02time was it was not a good approach for dealing with it.
- 40:06And that the the indirect approach is much better, much
- 40:11safer. And so it fit really well into
- 40:15this, this frame of safe practice, if you will.
- 40:26Until couple of years, 2 1/2 years of doing ideal parent
- 40:30figure, I went from complexly disorganized, which was, which
- 40:37was what my first AAI was to earn secure in in my second AAI,
- 40:44which was a wonderful thing. But the main thing about that is
- 40:49that it it, it completely transforms this process of
- 40:54making conceptual reality from what you perceive the the
- 41:00paranoia and the fearfulness of a a disorganized person was
- 41:04relieved. I often talk about writing my
- 41:10book, The Lower Manhattan Dormitory Effect, which took 12
- 41:14years to write, mainly because it was so anxiety producing to
- 41:21work on it. So I'd work on it as much as I
- 41:23could, and then the anxiety would get too great and then I
- 41:26would stop working on it. The pattern of engagement of
- 41:30disorganized people, right? Rush in work, work feverishly as
- 41:35hard as you can because you know the window is going to be short.
- 41:37Trying to get as much to happen as possible.
- 41:40Get into the middle where it gets troubling and then just
- 41:43having to bail because it the anxiety is so great, you can't
- 41:47bear it finishing it and then following the earning of
- 41:55security writing the next book punch outs in two years because
- 42:00there was no anxiety about it. And also now working on the book
- 42:04I'm working on now, there's no anxiety about the writing of the
- 42:09book. So that that space that I was
- 42:11talking about that opens where you can play, where you can
- 42:16create. Is there that sense of that
- 42:20attachment container that then protects that childlike play
- 42:27that then has to happen so that you can engage in finding the
- 42:33meaning that you need to find in in in life?
- 42:36There it is, which comes from that security.
- 42:42Hence our collection of strategies that we talked about
- 42:47in order to do the preliminary practice of resolving the
- 42:52unresolved childhood conflicts in your conditioning so that you
- 42:58can successfully come into this place where that space for a
- 43:06creative play opens and you can discover what you need to know.
- 43:15And it's very intuitive. It's very fluid.
- 43:21And then if you want to, you can turn your attention to the deep
- 43:25meditation insights that are available and really run a long
- 43:31way down that path as well, which I think is also a good
- 43:37idea. In fact, actually, probably the
- 43:40idea behind all of this is to get to the place where you can
- 43:44see yourself and the world and how you make it in each moment
- 43:49so that you can make it in a way that actually is who you are.
- 43:54And so it's this the freedom to become who it is that you are,
- 44:01Christian. George, I'm curious this this
- 44:04might be a long longer answer, but I'm I'm curious because you
- 44:09had been meditating so long before you did the attachment
- 44:11work, what kind of effect you saw doing the attachment work
- 44:17haddock on your meditation practice?
- 44:22I would say that the early part of the meditation practice was
- 44:29really just a practical way of managing anxiety.
- 44:38That's what it was. And there was a in some sense
- 44:47also a helplessness that came from it because I could see very
- 44:50clearly the patterns of reaction that I had, but I couldn't
- 44:54inhibit or stop them. I could correct.
- 44:57I could repair quicker. I could see that often I could
- 45:04see the distortion in my thinking and not make a fatal
- 45:09acts action in a relationship. But I didn't stop having them
- 45:18and I didn't have a sense of safety really.
- 45:21I I was always as disorganized people do it do preparing to be
- 45:29abandoned and having to get on alone.
- 45:34I never really counted on anybody in that way.
- 45:41With the advent of the the ideal parent figure and then the shift
- 45:47in that perception, the sense of people's reliability no longer
- 45:55became frightening. I just relied on them, which is
- 46:01the change and in that relying on them.
- 46:05And you know, as you well know, nobody is perfect.
- 46:11So there's even that space for people to be imperfect opened
- 46:16this space. I I don't know what to call it a
- 46:23space this the, the, the place where the undefended mind can
- 46:30creatively puzzle things. And in that then opening really
- 46:38for the such a strong sense of the sacredness of everything
- 46:44that was completely absent from the earlier practice.
- 46:49And then really wandering around most of the time with his
- 46:56astonishment at the, the sacredness of life and the
- 47:01astonishment at to the beauty of the people that I encounter as I
- 47:07go along, which was also pretty much absent earlier, which I
- 47:15also don't think would have been available had I not been able
- 47:19to, to pursue the attachment work.
- 47:24After the trauma reprocessing that I did in the
- 47:28psychotherapeutic setting, I was able to stabilize and keep a
- 47:36job. For instance, the first time
- 47:39really I was able to keep a job. Now this would put me in my
- 47:43early 50s. I was finally able to keep a job
- 47:47that didn't blow up because the relationships I got soured.
- 47:53But it was a job way below what I might have been capable of
- 47:57doing had I started out early or if I had been able to develop
- 48:01myself a career wise. And when you start out in your
- 48:0750s, being employable, what you're really noticing is that
- 48:12everybody your age is winding up their employment.
- 48:16They're not striving to make their way.
- 48:21And so I had that sense of it. You know, I, I had a sales shop
- 48:33and I, I was in home sales. You're driving around.
- 48:37And so in order to entertain myself with that, I bought an
- 48:41old camera and I threw it in my trunk, an old 4 by 5 phone
- 48:45camera. And I, I would take pictures in
- 48:48different places that I went because I found, well, still
- 48:56being quite harsh with myself, I demanded of myself that I do
- 49:00something because I, I, I thought that my, my station
- 49:05where I had managed to get to was, was not valuable.
- 49:11There's a lot of still a lot of driven ISM and I, and the goal
- 49:16that I had set for myself with was that I would make 6 pictures
- 49:20a month. I would finish six photographs a
- 49:23month, which was actually really hard to do.
- 49:28So it gives you a level of where I was at the anyway, I'm my
- 49:41mother was a photographer and I some of my earliest memories are
- 49:45really hanging out in the dark room with mom.
- 49:50And I loved that. And so it was when you know, you
- 49:54make meaning, of course. So you're attaching this memory
- 49:57thread to this activity that you have now.
- 49:59And it, it is the thing that is happening now, but it's also one
- 50:03of the versions of my mother that actually was valuable to
- 50:08me. And so there's that merging of
- 50:10it, which means the, the, the activity of the present moment
- 50:15has that richness of your whole life in it, which is actually
- 50:19part of the way that things become meaningful.
- 50:22They're resonant of it. I think you play the violin,
- 50:27don't you? It probably has that richness of
- 50:31meaning from the the the time that you've engaged in.
- 50:37It it also has the the sort of traumatic introjection of
- 50:43getting it from my mom and then finding later finding the
- 50:47meaning of it as. An which is, yeah, essentially
- 50:51what the photography for me was that similar salvaging of
- 50:56something in the early, early life that you can carry through
- 51:02as meaning part of it. Also, I think it is coming to
- 51:10terms with what wasn't developed that perhaps there was the
- 51:16potential for but didn't happen because of the the conditions of
- 51:21childhood. I think as long as we hold on to
- 51:23that and fail to grieve it, there's this devaluing of what
- 51:29what is actually available to us now that we could do because it
- 51:34isn't the what might have been. You know, we can idealize the
- 51:38shit out of what might have been.
- 51:44If you could bring it down to just, there may have been
- 51:49potential and maybe a possibility there, but because
- 51:52it was not pursued, it is it isn't what happened.
- 51:56And we do really have to inhabit this eternity of the present
- 52:00moment and gather up what what is here now and make this
- 52:04meaningful life out of what what it is that we have to make it
- 52:08out of, not what was lost, which is already lost or what we
- 52:15didn't do. And that also is, if you can
- 52:21manage it, greatly relieving really lightning of things and
- 52:27rich leads to a richness of life.
- 52:36You know, the old childhood song, Nobody likes me, Everybody
- 52:42hates me. I'm going to go eat worms.
- 52:44Do you know that one? But if I can't have the
- 52:52idealized version, I'm not going to take anything, which leads to
- 52:58just a an endless deprivation, right?
- 53:01It's lost already. No need to pay attention to
- 53:05what's here, what's available now Take that, make make rich
- 53:12and beautiful life from that and it and it will be enough.
- 53:19Doesn't have to be what it might have been and to move in this
- 53:27practice. And, and you know, if, if
- 53:29you're, if you work with people, I think it's important to have a
- 53:33meditation teacher, a person to help you through all of this.
- 53:39If you particularly if you have attachment work to do or some
- 53:44kind of traumatic experiences early.
- 53:46It's hard to avoid people that are sensitive to the safety of
- 53:50this and, and have an understanding of it and a
- 53:53pathway that they can just describe to you that that will
- 53:58take you there in, in a container that allows that
- 54:06freedom of having to constantly attend to the environment so
- 54:10that you can turn inward and allow that creative space to
- 54:15open up so that you can gauge solving those conflicts.
- 54:23Anyway, what do you say we do a little practice.
- 54:26So what would you like to do? Loving kindness, the Pasana IPF
- 54:39loving kindness. All right.
- 54:45You know, me, I'm, I'm very intimidated by the ideal parent
- 54:49now. So I get through it a little bit
- 54:51more. So I go for loving kindness.
- 54:54All right, two for loving kindness.
- 54:57What else? Going once, going twice.
- 55:03I want IPF but I'll I'll go with the flower.
- 55:07Soul to love and kindness. Go ahead and settle in.
- 55:14OK, Let go of the meditation. How's that?
- 55:36So let's see here next week we're, we're doing our monthly
- 55:55lunchtime meet, which is on Tuesday the 25th from 1:00 till
- 56:042:15. Actually this I'm talking about
- 56:17the using ideal parent figure protocol in a professional
- 56:27setting. On Friday the 28th, the day
- 56:31after Thanksgiving, we're having Kaleidoscope, our monthly
- 56:35gathering at 11 AM until 12:30. And then let's see here, our
- 56:58monthly meeting in December. Our monthly lunch meeting in
- 57:01December is on the 16th of December and then Kaleidoscope
- 57:08is on the 26th of December, the day after Christmas.
- 57:15And then starting on the week of the 29th of December through the
- 57:192nd of January, we're having a virtual retreat.
- 57:25Take a look at that. And then on the 10th of January
- 57:30next year, we're starting a meditation and attachment level
- 57:34one class. So that's essentially what's
- 57:37coming up. Thanksgiving, Christmas and New
- 57:41Year's are on Thursday, so we won't be meeting for I love you.
- 57:47Keep going on those days. But I do hope that you have a
- 57:52good holiday experience. Well, it's not a holiday in
- 57:58Canada. I will be eating Turkey.
- 58:06Yeah. Or Tofurky.
- 58:16Exactly. Yeah.
- 58:20No, it won't be. So we'll miss you.
- 58:22Yeah. Well, Thanksgiving to you all.
- 58:28Have a good. Thanksgiving.
- 58:30You've already had yours. Yeah, it's true.
- 58:33And it's only another month till Christmas Turkey so.
- 58:37I. Or tofurkey.
- 58:45Everybody all right, I really appreciate your practice.
- 58:48Ioffer the teaching freely, but I do hope if you're resourced,
- 58:51if you can, you'll make a donation.
- 58:53There's a link on the website that helps support me and also
- 58:56the work meta group is doing hash.
- 59:02Yeah. I wanted to ask about the lunch.
- 59:05Lunch meet. Is that, is that in person?
- 59:07No, no. No, no, it's virtual.
- 59:09Everything is virtual. OK.
- 59:12And is that like an open thing like the like like this class?
- 59:17No, you have to register for it. OK.
- 59:21All right. I'll look for it on the site.
- 59:22OK, good. All right, everybody, good to
- 59:26see you. See you soon.
- 59:28Well, a couple of weeks, bye.